[This question paper contains 10 printed pages.

7970 Your Roll No. . ............ .

J1lT.lCfiT Jlj911 Jf/ Ct; ............. .

LL.B./II Term ES

Paper - LB - 201 LAW OF EVIDENCE

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : 100

~ .. 3 FJTTt ~ . 100

(Write your Roll No. on the top immediately

on receipt of this question paper.)

(W JTR"-~ ~ fitrrff tft ~w ~ ~ ~

~ W JffFfT 3fj911 Jf/Ctl ~ I)

Note :- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

~:..: w JrR"- ~ CfiT 3rT( ~ <lT fff;:ift ~ % ~

# ~; ~ ~ 0rlif" CfiT 7flt""lflf % "ift "iRf ~I

Answer any 5 questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

.., ~ ffl ~ 3rT( ~I

CfiM

~m~atcn~~-~

P.T.O.
7970 2

1. Under what provisions of the Indian Evidence Act,

1872 are the following relevant :-

(a) 'X' is charged with the murder of 'Y' in Bangalore.

'X' shows a railway ticket of the train he boarded
a day before the murder was committed and also
the bills payed by him at the hotel in Delhi where
he stayed for four days.

(b) The question is whether 'A' robbed 'B'. The fact

that after 'B' was robbed, 'C' said in A's presence
__ " the police are coming to look for the man
who robbed 'B' and immediately afterwards 'A'
ran away.

(c) The question is whether 'M' robbed 'N'. The facts

that, shortly before the robbery, 'N' went to a
fair with mciney in his possession and that he
showed it, or mentioned that he had it, to third
persons.

(d) 'A' sues 'B' for including 'C' to break a contract :..
of service made by him with 'A'. 'C', on leaving
A's service says to A __ , I am leaving you
because 'B' has made a better offer to me."
(20)

~ ~ ~. 1872 cfi fcfi;r~ cfi 3lUR' Plk1f(;JI{qd

~.s:.
"' 5.
7970 3

(Cfi} 'X' 1R ~"it 'Y' <fit ~ CfiT 3ffiN ~ t I X~

"0 ~ ~ iVfic en) ~ Cf6 ~ ~ ~ <fit "Tf ~

~ ~ fu;:r ~ "ijqR s;arr ~ ~ ~ -it ~ ~ -it

Cf6 'tffi ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1ITU 3{qf fcm lT'q

~Cfil~tl

("{<f) lAR t ~ 'A' ~ 'B' cnT W fW:rr I -a-~ t fc6 B ~

~~~GITG 'C' ~A cfit~-it'Cfi5T ~- ~~~
~ ~

~ 31TG+Tt <fit mlm -it an "f"~ t ~ 'B' CfiT WI ~"

~ ~ ~ GITG 'A' Cffi"i it ~ <r:rr I

(<r} lAR t ~ 'M' ~ 'N' en) WI ~I -a-~ t' fc6 ~

it ~ ~ 'N' u;rofu ~ ~ ~ <r:rr ~ ~ ~
~ 3{""~ ~ en) mcw:rr af4CIT ~ fc6 ~ -qm

tR t I

(~) 'A'~ 'B' 1R 'C' CfiT ~ 1ITU 'A'~~ <fit "Tf itqr
<fit~ cnT ~~~coB~~
. ~
CI1G ~I

'C' ~ 'A' <fit itqr ~ 1R 'A' it Cfi5T - ~~~ arrqCfi)

~ ~. w i ~
~ 'B' ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~
mr
t I"

2. 'A' agreed to supply 'B' with only one packet of

explosive, enough for the purpose of blowing up a
railway bridge. 'B' along with 'C' utilised the

P.T.O.
7970 4

explosive for the purpose of blowing the bridge. The

attempt proved unsuccessful. Next day 'B' sent a
letter to 'A' describing the unsuccessful attempt and
asked if, he could supply some more explosive. The
said letter, before it could reach 'A' was intercepted
during the post and handed over to the )'olice. A, B,
C, were tried for the conspiracy to blow up the
railway bridge.

Whether Prosecution can be allowed to prove the

aforesaid letter written by 'B' to 'A' to prove the
charge of conspiracy against 'A' ? Discuss with
reference to the relevant case law. (20)

'A' ~ ~ "' ~
. cfi- ~ ~ fcl%'\ccti <fiT ~ ~ ~

B "CflT ~ <fiB cfi" ~ wlT mlTm I 'B' ~ 'C' cfi- ~

~ ~ cfi- ~ ~ A%'\ccti <fiT~ M 1 w:mr 3R!lflR
"' . "'
~ 83lT I wR ~ 'B' ~ ~ w:mT <fiT quA- Cfi"& ~
~ ~ 'l:fm fcfi CfliT cw; "C.fi£9 ~ Fc\%1 cCfl
'A' "CflT ~ 1p.:f
"' "'
t
~ CR ~ I '3m 1p.:f 'A' cfi- "!ffiT ~ -ij- ~ t't SfCfi
cfi- ~ ~ CR fu<:u lTm ~ ~ "CflT ~ ~ lTm I

A, B, C <fiT ~ -p;r "CflT ~ cfi- ~ ~ ~ fcrtmuT fcfim

lTm I

CfliT ~ "CflT 'A' cfi- ~ ~ <fiT ~ ~ <fiB

cfi" ~ 'B' am 'A' "CflT ~ ~ ~ 1p.:f "CflT ~ CfiB
"'
ett ~ ~ ~ ~ t ? ~ f.1oF:r fctlU cfi- m ~
fcfcftR ~I
7970 5

3. 'X' is accused of murdering his uncle 'Y' and his

Cousins 'Z' and 'T' with a knife. After committing
the murder he kept the dead bodies on the railway
track and went to the police station and lodged a FIR
and signed the same. The same day police recovered
the dead bodies and the knife from the house of X,
when pointed out by the accused 'X'. There is no
eyewitness or direct evidence of the crime but the
medical report confirmed the wounds caused by a
sharp weapon.

Can 'X' be convicted on the basis of this confessional

statement? Decide with the help of law and
cases. (20)

'X' 1R ~ ~
"'
m "ilfttT 'Y' ~ m ~ ~- 'Z'
~m 'T' Ch'T ~ coB CfiT ~ WIT ~ I ~ coB ~ ~
~ricnr~tcn'IR-m~ ~~~~~
~ 'R1lrt fA<CF.tl~ ~ ~ 1R ~&R "fcm I ~ ~ ~

~ricnr ~~ ~ x~~~Cl"Gf x~m~

~cnr~~m1 ~ ~CfiTm~-marr
"'
<:rr ~&T ~ ..rnT ~ 1 ~ Rl~ffil 'R1lrt ~ ~ ~ am
~ -me£ Ch'T ~ Ch'T I

<FIT X~ ~q:;auf'Attl ~ ~ 3TTUR "«R ~ fcti<:rr ~ ~

t 7 fctltr ~ ~ Ch'T W1'ffiT ~ fcl~~=qtt ~I

P.T.O.
7970 6

4. (a) ~What is the test laid down by the judiciary for the
reliability of a dying declaration.

(b) 'A', the deceased wife was married to 'B' in

Jan, 2014. The couple lived together peacefully
but six months after marriage, disputes arose
between them. 'A' complained to her parents on
several occasions about harassment to her by the
husband and in-laws through letters. On 30th
March, 2015, 'A' was admitted to the hospital with
80% burns. The police and the Magistrate was
informed. The statement of 'A' was recorded by
the Magistrate in the presence of police and the
doctor on the duty. 'A' became unconscious before
he could answer the last question- "What move
you want to say?" A died the same day. 'A' had
made her husband, sister in-law and mother-in-
law responsible for burning her as per her
statement made to the magistrate.

Can the accused persons be convicted on the basis '""

of uncorroborated dying declaration alone ? Discuss
with relevant case law. (20)

(en) ~CScti18lcti ~ ctt fcll!crijoilllctl ~ ;:qrll418lctil &m ~

"Wa:fUT qm ~ ?

(\Cf) ~ ~ 'A' CfiT 'B' cfi ~ fcrcrT6 ~. 2014 -ij s3IT

~I '15 ~ ~ llilf2144cti
.,_ \60T ~ 1R fcrcrT6 cfi m-
7970 7

~~~~~~it11m1 'A'~m~
1R ~ cfi ~ 3flH ~- flrnr en) ~ -qfu ~ ~­
~ am ~ 'i1fR- ~ ~ cfiT ~ICflllld cfiT ~ I 30 lfT'it,
2015 cnT 'A' cnT 80% \ffi¥1" cfi ~ ~ ~ ~ fcnlrr
11m I ~am +!~~C: cnT ~~~11m I ~ ~
~ 1R *rro ~ cfit ~ ~ +!~~c: ~ 'A' CfiT

~ ~ fcnlrr ~I

~ ~ - II alTtf 3ft\ CfliT ~ ~ t ?- CfiT "3"W

~~"¥'A' mit"lf{ I 'A' cfit~~~it"lf{ I

+!~~c:
cnT ~ ~ ~ ~ cfi 31¥R A ~ ~
~ cfi ~ 3flH -qfu, -.,.,q altt ~ cnT J fHGI~ iiRl<n I

CfliT ~ ~ en) ~ 3lTZ" ~~Cfli~Cfl ~ cfi

3Ut1R 1R ~ fcnlrr ~ ~ t I ~ f.toTl!" fctfU

·~~~

5. (a) X's daughter 'Y' was married to 'Z'. During April

2012, 'Y' was residing with her parents at Cochin.
'Z' wrote three letters to 'Y' from Bombay, which
contained defamatory imputations about 'X'. As a
result 'X' filed a complaint against 'Z' charging
him offence of defarmation. 'Z' raised the
objection that the three letters which formed the
sole basis of the complaint were inadmissible in
evidence.
P.T.O.
7970 8

Is the objection of 'Z' sustainable ? Decide with

the help of case law.

(b) A falsely makes B to believe that A is the owner

of a property and sells it to B. Subsequently A
inherits the same property on the death of his
father. Whether A will be precluded to contend
that he was not the owner of property at the time
of sale ? Discuss. (20)

("Cfl) 'X' ctt ~ 'Y' CfiT ~ 'Z' cfi 'ij"M salT~ I $ 2012

cfi ~ 'Y' ~ +{ffif- ftRrr cfi 'tffif ~ ~ \5 W mI

'Z' ~ ~ ~ 'Y' en) 'ffi;r 'tP-i ~ ~ 'X' cfi ~
~ "l1"'161HCflRCfl ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ q({uu+H<tt4 X
~ ~ 'tR "li"'161H cfi ;wmu CfiT 3lTir1 ~ ~ 'Z' cfi
~ ~ ~ Cfi( ft<rr I Z ~ 3lT4ffi ~ fcfi ~ 'ffi;r

'tp.f -me<l ~ ~ ~ ftRCflT ~ CfiT ~ 31IUR ~

7fliT ~ I

q:m z ctt 3lT4ffi ~ t ? ~ fcrtU ctt ~ ~

~H~'tlll ~I

(((f) 'A', 'B' cnT ~ ~ ~ t fcfi A~ CfiT ~

t cnT ~ tffi t I ~ ~ 'A' ~ ftRrr ctt

~ Cf6' 'B'
~ cfi ~ ~ ~ cnT fcRRffi ~ TIT ~ t I Cfm
'A' <:f6' ~ ~ ~ wuftr irm fcfl Cf6' ~ cfi wm
~Cfif~..,.m~~~~l
7970 9
.
6. (a) Explain what is conclusive proof and how its
evidentiary value is different from that of other
kinds of presumption.

(b) A Hindu women was married toM in June, 2000.

She was divorced by her husband on 21st Nov.,
2002. After divorce she married another man 'T'
on March, 2003 and gave birth to a daughter on
24th Aug., 2003.

'T' challenges the legitimacy of the daughter born.

Will he succeed ? Decide. (20)

(Cfi) ~ ~ Pl:i"cMCfi ~ CfliT t ~~~~

~ WiiR ~ WiiR ctt ~an ~ ~ t ?

((<f) ~ ~ ;ffif cnT ~. 2000 ~ M cfi" ~ ~ ~3IT ~I

21 ~. 2002 q;l~-qfct~~~~~ I~

cfi" GlTG ~ ~ 2oo3 ~ ~ ~ 'T' ~ ~ Cfi( m

~ 24 Wffif, 2003 q;l ~ ~ ~ q;l ~ ~ I

'T' ~ ~ ~ ctT wfuRrr q;l 3ITR Cfi«<T t I <FIT Cf5

~ 617fT ? fclf.:l:i~ll ~ I

7. "An accomplice is unworthy of credit unless

corroborated in material particulars."

Explain it with reference to relevant statutory

provisions and case law on this aspect. (20)
P.T.O.
7970 10

~~~- 3f1R1Ut ~ w.n fucfm cfi" ;wWq mm t ~ w.n ~

~ffl,~m· ~ .~ ~~ i~ -g 1" ~ ~ ~m ~
~m Rul<i ~ cfi ~ -mgcr ~ ~ 1

8. Write short notes on any two of the following:

(a) Hostile Witness

(b) Relevancy of Admissions

(c) Res-Gestae (20)

(200)
This question paper contains 8+3 printed pages]

Your Roll No . ...................................... .

7930

LL.B./II Term E

Paper LB-20 I : LAW OF EVIDENCE

Time : 3 flours Maximum Marks : I 00

(lf'rite your Roll Xo. on tire top immaliote(r on receipt of tillS question paper.)

Note Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but .the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

R:Ufofl :- ~ >r-R-l:f?f CfiT ~ ~ m ~ fcnm ~ cqp;rr

it ~; ~ ~m ~ CfiT lil'U:Jli ~ -m m
~I

Attelllpt any Fil'e questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

~~m~~~~
~m m· ~ ~ Bl1R %1

I. Attempt briefly any .fimr of the following :

Differentiate between : 20

(a) 'Fact' and 'Fact in Issue'

P.T.O.
 ( 2 7930

(b) Adversarial and Inquisitorial system

(c) 'Facts which should be proved' and 'Facts which need

·not be proved'

(d) 'Witness' and 'Hostile witness'

(e) 'Factum Probandum' and '•Factum Probans'

· (jj 'Oral' and 'Documentary evidence'.

f~Yf<"lf~d if 'B ~ ~ ~ ~ "ti~ if fuft8rQ:

~~am~~:

(a) '(fv:f I am ' fct<"W~JCf) (fv:f I

(b) ~rctCfl"'Miq am 6ijjli);jjCfllq ~

(c) '<r~ ~ ~ m ~~ 3fR: '<r~ ~ ~

~ \ifRT 61 I'~ ){q Cf) -;@ ~I

<d) ' waft 3fR: ' '~~ waft

I
1

(e) 'Factum Probandum' 3fR: 'Factum Probans'

 ( 3 7930

2. Discuss the provisions of law under which the following are

relevant 20

(i) In a charge of murder by domestic help of an elderly

couple. evidence is given that they had received money

from their son in U.S.A.

(ii) X is prosecuted for, rioting in Calcutta on 30.11.2012.

He produces a railway ticket travelling froni Mumbai to

Delhi on 30.11.2012.

(iii) The question is whether A murdered B. Marks on the

ground, produced by a struggle at or near the place

where the murder was committed.

(iv) X is accused of receiving stolen propet1)' knowing it

to be stolen. He offers to prove that he refused to sell

it below their value ..

P.T.O.
 ( 4 ) 7930
'
fcW:T <fi ·~ CfiT ~ ~ ~ ~ Pt~f(1f~ct

(t) ~ ~ Bt?I4Ch 'IDU ~ ~ qft .~ ~

\iiA <fi a:ntrq ii m~ Wn l'f1.U ~ fcfl ~ ~

(it) X ~ 30-11-2012 Clll Ch(1Ch'dl ii ~ ·~ %n I

~ ~ l'f1.U ~I ~ 30-11-2012 Clll ~

11{ "l['( ~ 'tJrn ~ ~ qft ~ ~. ~ 'IDU

\iflfR 1R "Wt ~ ~I

(iv) x~~~fcfl~~~~t

~ ~ ~ ~ Clll "ffi CfiT 31f~ ~I ~

~ ~ ~ qft q~(Cf)~f Cfi«<T t fq;- ~ ~

~ q;-q ~ 1R ~ ~ lfU Cli{ fG<:n' ~ I

 ( 5 7930

3. (a) Conspiracy is based on the principle of Agency.

Comment.

(b) A wrote a letter to B to supply poison for

contamination of groundwater to create nuisance for

residents of village X. He did not receive any

information from B, he then wrote to C about the

same. He meanwhile received the poison from B after

writing to C and was caught. He contaminated 1he

water from the poison received from B before being

caught where the prosecution produced the letters and

the substance in a trial against A, B and C. Discuss

the relevancy of the two letters and the poison under

Section I0 of the Evidence Act.

(a) ~ ~ ~ ~· 1R WlTfuf %1 ~

~I

P.T.O.
 (· 6 ) 7930

(b) A ~ X~ ~ f1qlfflifi %g ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~-\jffi ~ ~ %TI fqq ~ ~ ~

~ B qj) ~ fu@TI ~ B if ~ ~ -;;tl
tlrffil ~ ~ ~ ~ if C qj) fu&T1 ~

~ C qj) ·fffi§R ~ ~ ~ B if fcrGr ~

Tf<lT <tm ~ ~ Tr<lf'l ~ ~ ~ if ~

s if >ffqf ~ m if \jffi qj) ~ q){ m

flm lR. 31f~· ~ A, B alR C cfi ~ 1:f?r

<tm ~ ~ Fcfqj{OI '"'41llli!lll ii ~ q){ mI

ma;<:r 31f~ Cfft 'tlm 1o cfi 3Rf1fu ~ "tJ?it
<tm fcl1sr Cfft ~ q)f ~ ~1

4. (a) A sues B for a loan of Rs. 50,000 which B denies. ·

B makes a statement before X that he ha,s taken a

loan from A, though X was not pres~nt when the

transaction took place between A and B. State the

relevancy of the statement of B to X apd the Rule

of Evidence. 20
 ( 7 ) 7930

(b)
.
Mr. Justice Sir John Beaumont, while hearing an appeal

wrote. ··sec. 17 is not artistically worded provides an

exception to the prohibitions imposed by the preceding

sections and enables certain statements made by a person

in police custody to be proved." Discuss.

(a) A 50.000 m ·cfi ~ '* ~ B 1R Cfre: ~

t" ~ B ~ 'Cfi«<T %I B, X '* "ff''lR ·~

~tfcfi~Ait~mt~x~

'Wl<l, ~ A '0~ B '* ~ ffi-~ g31f ~' dYf~

1@ ~ l B '* cnl
X ~ ~. 'WlR cnl ~

afu: m~ '* f.:r:r:l cnT ~ ~1

(h) ~ ~ m \liR ~ ~ tJ:Cfl ~ cn1

~ q;-fcr 'W1<l fu&r, "Cfi(11c-4Cfi ~ it !ll~~<&

1@ ~ ··~ 27 ~ muan &RT ~ ~m

cnT ~ ~mr ~ % ·afu: ~ fumm
.q 'Q.Cfi ~ &RT ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ mf<irn
~ .q ~ ~ %1" ~ ~I

P.T.O.
 8 7930

..
5. (a) Elucidate on the precautionary measures when dying

declarations can be made the sole basis of conviction. 20

(b) · Sarla was married in 20 II and was subject to torture

by her in-laws. She kept telling her maid about it and

then finally wrote a. letter to her. parents narrating the

same and 3 months later she died the prosecution produces

the letter as a dying declaration. Comment.

(a) ~ '"j~CfllfC1Cfl Cfi~ 'Cfll ~b!fflfc& CfiT ~ 3TI~

~ ~ ~% ~ ~~:u;flq<Cfl ~ Cfft 'fcRwr

'&JT'&1l ~I

(b) ~ 'Cfll ~ 2011 -B ~3TI 2lT am: ~ ~

"flTH-"f!'W mu ~ fcf;<:n ll71T 1 ~ ~ ~

. -q 311111 ~ 'Cfll 'arnrffi ~ m a2ll aiffir: ~

~ \l111Cfl Rl ~ SQ: .3l'R 1Tim-ftRrr 'Cfll 't1?T Wmn

a~ oR 11m ~ ~ ~ 'Cfll '9l1:(f QT ~ I aTI~

'3CRf 't1?T 'Cfll 10jf1Cfllf~Cfl Cfi2R ~ ~ -q ~ CfiUIT

%1~~1
 7930

6. "An accomplice is un.worthy of credit unless he is corroborated

with material particulars."

Critically analyze the above statement. 20

''w-:wrom fcp~qfl'11t:~ctl cfi ~ (fCfi :wiTn:r t ~ (fCfi

~ fq ~ lfr;c4f 'B oB ~ -;:ytf fcfi<:rr \lfrcfr %I "

~ Cf)~ Cflf B'llc.•il't'.l11c''ICfl fc:tl(@lqul ~I

7. (a) Discuss the principle of Estoppel and the exception

applicable to it. 20

(b) A newspaper stated that those opening industrial . units

in Himachal Pradesh will be exempted from corporate taX:

for a period of 4 years. X after seeking contirmation

from the Government department about the exemption,

set up a medicinal unit. However. the state Govt. withdrew

its policy of exemption 6 months later. X now seeks

Estoppel against the withdrawaL. Advise X.

P.T.O.
 ( 10 ) 7930

(a) m~ ~ ~ om ~ 1R ffi1L ~ <:frn:T .~

qiT ~ ~~

(b) ~ · BG(;:m:-'Pr it ~ 2:IT· fcn f~'"li'<'R1 ~ it

~ 3{\cilfllqi ~ • wt ~ -:qn: . qq CfiT

·~~ ~ ·~ f.;rrq Cfi\ ft ~ ~ ~fl X

~ ~ ~ ~ it ~ fer~ ft ~ CfiR ~

~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ CfiT I lJ1T\ ~ wcnn:

~ 6 "'1m <ifie: 311FiT ~ ~..m -;:ftfu qrcm ~

"ffit X ~ cwrnT cfi ~ ~ ~ ~I X·

cit~ ~I

8. Write short notes on any two of the following 20

(a) Who is competent to testify ?

(b) DNA testing for presumption of legitimacy.

(c) Communications between a lawyer and his client.

 ( II ) 7930

~I

7930 II 3000
. This question paper contains 16 printed pages]

Your Roll No ................ .

7931

LL.B./II Term E

Paper LB-202: FAMILY LAW --H

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : l 00

(Write your Roll No. on the top immediately on receipt of this question paper.)

_ Note :'- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi; but

the same medium should be used throughout the paper.

~ ~-~ "cfiT -am:~ err~~ v:cn ~

-B ~; ~ ~m- ~ tfiT l=lT~ v:cn m. ~

~

Attempt any Five questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

~ ~ m cf; -am:~~

~ m cF; ~ "ftl1R i1

P.T.O.
 ( 2 ) 7931

Answer any four of the following : 4x5=20

I.

(z) Mention any jive features of Mitakshara Coparcenary.

(ii) Discuss the validity of gifts made .during Marz-ul-Maut .

. (iii) Can a junior coparcen~r act as Karta ?

(iv) Explain the 'Rule in Hanuman Prasad Pandey's ·

~ Case'.

(v) [)iscuss the effect of deletion of Section 24 of the Hindu

Succession Act, 1956 ..

(i) fl:rnTa.R fi~~(~Cfll CfiT ~ ~ fct~ttst(llaTI .Cfil

~~I

(ii) ~-~-~ cfi ~ ~ ~ ~ qft ~

CflT ~~I
 ( 3 ) 7931

(iii) ct<n ·cnW ~ ff~~rP-'ICflCflfiT ~ ~ "# cnr:f ~

.~ ~?

(iv) '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "# ~' Cfft ~

~I

(v) ~ '3Wrf~ an~, 1956 Cfft ·mu 24 ~

~ \llR ~ qf{ou&~ 'Cfl1 ~ ~ 1

2. Manoj has the following properties in · which his daughter

claimed a share by way ofpartition. Discuss the maintainability

of her claim made in 2007 : 20

(i) .A house which he got under a will executed by his

maternal grandfather.

(ii) · A land which he purchased out of his savings from

earnings.

(iii) A house which he got after the death of his father

as class I heir.

(iv) A land which he received on partition from his

father.

P.T.O.
 ( 4 ) . 7931

~. ~ "tT"Rl f1k1f(1f~<1 w=qf"tllli "% ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ &m am ~ cn1 l1Trr cn1 1 · 2oo7 it

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cnl 4itSJofl;q<11 Cfil. fq~'q1 .

~:

(i) "Q!fi ~ ~ ~ "1'RT &m f1 t>qlfG<1 fcR;r· ~ 3RI1'"ffi

~ fi:R;rr ?.lT I

{it) "Q!fi ~ ~· ~ am am -B ~ ~ ~

cnll

(iii) "Q!fi ~ ~ ~ am f1mT cn1 ~ ~ ~ "51"2Ft

~ ~~ ~ ~ it fi:R;rr I

(iv) "Q!fi ~ . ~ ~ ~ f1rcn 'if ~ · 1R 1lwft 1.

3. (1) Pannalal, the Karta of Hindu Joint Family, sold a portion

of the Joint Family property to perform the marriage

of his daughter who is aged 17 years. He also sold

 ( 5 ) 7931

four items of the mortgaged property to redeem the

remaining four items of the property out of which one

is a residential house. His brothers challenged both the

alienations. Discuss the validity of the alienations in

the light of decided cases.

(ii) Can a minor coparcener file a suit for partition ? Is

it different from a suit filed by a major coparcener ?

2xJ0=20

P.T.O.
 6 ) 7931

· 4. Govind, a Mitakshara Hindu died as an undivided coparcener

in January 2015, survived by his widow W), a son (S 1), a

son and a daught~r of predeceased son (S 2S and S2D) a

daughter (D), his own mother (M), a brother (Br) and a sister

.
(Sis). Ascertain the shares of heirs in the coparcenary property
-

if the family is domiciled_ in 20

(a) Chennai

(b) Nagpur.
 ( 7 7931

~ fi:Rrr~;R ~ Cfft ~' 2015 ~ affif~ f!Q<;If4Cfl

·~ ~ -q ~ m~~ ~ 31\R w 3N1T rcr~

(W), 1J!'fi :pf (S 1), ~ :pf CfiT ~ "3(1 <l~ v;cFl ~

( S2S am S2 D), v;cFi ~ D., ~ 3N-ft l1RIT (M), ~ ·

~ (Br) am v;cFl ~ .(Sis) I ~ -:jcffi. ~ (a) ~ 1

(b) ~ -q an~ mm f\Q<;If4Chl -w:qfu -q ~

errftBl ~ WlR. 31f~f1f:(l:q(1 ~I

- 5. (l) 'A' a Hindu, died intestate in 2010 survived by his

widow (W), father and mother (F and M), a brother

and a sister (Br and Sis), a son (S 1) who had converted

to Islam, an illegitimate son (S 2) and an unmarrie~

daughter of a predeceased daughter who had converted

to Christianity and married a Christian (DD). Identify

the heirs who are entitled to a share and how

much ?
P.T.Q.
 ( 8 ) '7931

(ii) Sheela died in 2011 survived by the following persons.

Her illegitimate daughter (D), a legitimate son through

her first husband '(SH 1) and her husband (H 2) whom

she married after the death of her first husband. At

the time of her c:leath she had the following properties :

A house inherited from her mother, a plot of land -

inherited from her first husband and anoth~r plot of.

land gifted to her by her father. Who will succ,eed to

her property and in what shares ? 2x10=20

(1) ~ f1~\:il~ell ~ A 'qft 2010 ~ ~ m~I

~ am -qw w:RT fcr'EfCfl' cw), ftrnr· aW: lffi'IT

(F alR M), ~ ~ (f~ ~ ~ (Br afu: Sis),

~ ~ 'tl"'f~f{cj ~ ·~ (S 1), ~ -31~ ~

 ( 9 7931

(S 2) am ~ ~ ~ qft, 'llT ~ ~ -B

t:t4i~Ra m~ ~ o~ ~ ~ cfi" m~ fqqlf(ia

~~ 3ifqqlf(i<1 ~ (DD) I &f cnfuiT qft ~

~ 'llT WlR m am fc8Frr m m cfi" ~

~ ?

(il) m am w f.iyf(1f<§Jct o;qfctctlJ1 CfiT ~

2011 -B ~ CfiT ~ m~ =

~ a1~ ~ (D), am ~ -qfu ~ "5W<f

~ .~ ~ (SH 1) am 6WfiT Wd (H 2) ~

m~ ~ am ~· -qfu qft ~ cfi" ~

~ fc.fi7:rr ~ I ~ ~ cfi" ~ ~ 1:Jffi

Pt40Wi f(1 fuil a ft u:t Rl 4i ~if; ~ l1Tm ~ fcromf "B

f1:R;rr ~ "%, ~ ~ -qfu ~ fcrmm -B f1:R;rr

P.T.O.
 ( \0 ) 7931

~ ~m am: ~· fi:rnT ~ ~ ~ -q 1lR1T .

~ 3Fl ~ I ~ w:qfu cfi cnT-1-cnT-1 TI~

~ ~-m cfi mfu1 mil ?

6. (i) A Sunni Muslim. died survived_ by his parents [M and F],

his widow (W~, one daughter (D)- and a son (S).

Ascertain their shares if the property is worth rupees

seventy two lakhs.

(ii) A Sunni female died survived by her mother, father,

brother and husband. Ascertain the shares of eligible

heirs if the property is worth rupees .sixty lakhs.

2xl0=20

(i) ~ ~ ~ 3l1R ~ 3l1R -rm:rr~ fi:rnT (M

alR F) ~ fcrw.n (W),- ~ ~ (D) alR ~

·. ~ (S) ~ ~ cit· 1nl:{f m~I ~ Wilfu

~ffi'{§T~~Cfilmm~~q)J

3lf~f1!?'i'.l~ ~I
 ( II 7931

(ii) ~ ~ ~ am -qm a1tRT l1ffiT, ftrm, ~

am 1:Jfu cn1 ~ ~ cn1 :srfl{l m~, ~

~ ~ 6o. "fm§f ~ ~ cn1 mm11Bf

crrfu:Tf ~ ~ CfiT 31fcqf1~il4 ~I

7. (l) A Muslim executed a will giving Rs. 30,000; Rs. 60,000

and Rs. 90,000 to X, Y and Z respectively. His total

property on the date of his death was Rs. 2, 70,000.

Discuss · who would get how much under Sunni and

Shia law.

(ii) . A Muslim executed a will giving Rs. 30,000 each to

X, Y and Z. His total property was Rs. 90,000. Discuss

who would get how much under Sunni and Shia

law. 2xi0=20

P.T.O.
 ( 12 ) 7931

( 1) ~ ~ ~ X, Yam 'z Cfil ~: 30,000 ~.

60,000 ~. am 90,000 ~. ~ ~ ~ fcK;r f1&qlfc:a

2, 70,000 ~. li~ CfiT ~ I fclcf-:q.:r Cfll f\ll lJ> I

~ 3W ~ fciT~ ~ 3Rflfu fChf!Cfll CFIT-CFIT

fBWrr ?

(ii) ~ ~ ~ X, Y afu: Z 'B "# ~ Cfil 30,000 ~.

~ ~ ~ fcK;r f16q 1Ra CfiT 1 ~ ~ "fi1J1fu

9o,ooo ~. ~ CfiT 2ft , ~ am· ~ M~ ~

3Rflfu fChfiCfll fcficRT fBWrr, ~. ~ I

8. (t) Abdul declared his intention to his friends to gift his

house and agricultural lands to his minor granddaughter

784 12 8500
 13 )· 7931

[daughter's daughter] who. had been under his care and

protectiOR from her childhood and communicated the

same .to her father. Abdul continued to manage the

properties till his death. His brother challenged the

validity of the gift on the ground that there was no

acceptance from the guardian of the donee and there

. was no delivery of possession. On behalf .of the donee

it was argued that where the donor and the donee were

residing in the same premises which had been gifted,

delivery of possession was not required. Examine the

validity of the gift in the light of decided cases.

P.T.O.
 ( 14 ) 7931

(ii) Husband gifted a property to his minor wife through

a registered deed and handed over the document to

the mother of his wife who had been taking care of

her daughter and son-in-law and the gift was accepted

by her. After the death of the husband, the wife also

died .. The husband's brother claimed his share in the

property according to law of inheritance denying the

validity· of the gift on the ground that it was not

accepted by the guardian. Examine the validity of the

gift in the light of decided cases. 2x10=20

 ( 15 ) 7931

f1:Rrr en) .qr ~ "GT 9.ft 1 ~ ~ ~ m- ~

~'lW'T 3fR m:~ # m 9.ft 1 ~ 31lRt ~

~ ~ w:qfu cnr ~ Cfi«fT m ~1 ~

~ -q ~ an~ 1R ~ fi;rffi§1 CfiT ~~- en)

ann M ~ fen ~ -cK ma.rcn &m ~

.qr '%1 M ll<1f ~ I a:nzyrr q:ft ~ ~ ~

"GT ~ 9.ft fen ~ ~ am a:nzyrr m:rr ~

# w w ~ -m ~ # m ll<1f ~. ~ ~

-cK ~ CfiT ~ -~~ ~ 9.ft 1 fctf1~:qa cKm

en) ~ # ~- ~- ~ ·GA CfiT M~

CfiT ~-~1
P.T.O.
 ( 16 ) 7931

- (.ii) -qfu ~ <f\3\'R.}iiCI fcrffi9r IDU. ~ ~ 'tWf\' -

em -~ GR -q ~ eft .3lR. a11Rt 'tWft Gfl1 llTffi

em, ~ ~ l5fi (l~ ~ Gfl1 ~~ Cf){

W 2ft, t!:B'II~\31 Wtf ~ (l~ GR CfiT stfct!I~OI

~ ~ ~ -~1 -qfu Gfl1 ~ ~ ~ ~­

Cfil {<pfql'("i ~ m 7]<:IT 1 -qfu ~ ~ ~ ~ 3TI~

1R GR Gfl1 M~ em ~- ~ ~~ ·

fcrf~ ~ ~ ~ -q 3ltA -oo CfiT GJCfT

fcfl<:rr fen GR CfiT Sl fct!l t? 01 ma:rcfl -wu ~ fcfl<:rr

7]<:IT ~ 1 fqf.1R't'.IC1 cR:n ·em ~ -q ~ ~

~ Gfl1 MWlPmT em ~ ~ 1

7931 16
[This question paper contains 8 printed pages.]

7971 Your Roll No.

J1TflCilT Jfj¢fi Jfl<ii ............. .

LL.B./II Term ES

Paper LB- 202 - FAMILY LAW- II

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : I 00

i
?Pill: 3 erut ~ .. 100

(Write your Roll No. on the top immediately

on receipt of this question paper.)

(w TAR"-~ <t ~ tft d>W ~ w f.fufftrr

~ W J1TRT JtFh Jflifi ~ I)

Note :- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

~:- w TAR"-~ CfiT 3rT( ~ "llT ft;:;ft fit#t f?7ll 'RTTW

~ ..,. ~ ~ ~ CfiT 7f/t<[lf f?7l/ "ifT fiRr ~I

Attempt any five questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

qm
"'
'tlfir m c:t 3rT( ~ ,

~ m c:t 3fcn ~ -t·,

P.T.O.
7971 2

1. (a) What are the primary differences between the

separate property and the coparcenary property
held by a coparcener under Hindu law ?

(b) 'The Hindu Succession Act, 19 56 has made a

substantial difference in determining the character
of property in the hands of the son, inherited by
him from his father vis-a-vis grandson from the
position as understood under the classical Hindu
law.' Comment.

(c.n) ~ fctfu <t 3Rf1fu fi6GI!llcti am tm ~ ~ aft\

f!Mifllcfil ~ cfi- ~ Cfm ~ ~ i' ?

((q) ~~~ ~·, 1956 ~~cfi~~F

ct mm ~ ~ m ~ fcRR:m ~ ~ "f{~ <tT ~

<t 3FWRUf ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3RR "ffi ~ t \ill ~

Cfcll~$61 ~ fctfU cfi' 3R'Ilfu ~ ~ ~ I' ~

~I

2. (a) Who can be a karta of the Hindu Joint Family? Is

this position open to a female Hindu?

(b) A Mitakshara coparcenary consists of Ram, the

karta and his two sons, Sonu and Manu. The family
lives in Delhi. They have extensive coparcenary
property near Hastinapur, about 70 miles away
7971 3

from Delhi. Ram sells the land to Sohan and utilises

the sale proceeds for the marriage of his 16 years
old daughter and for purchasing a residential flat
in South Delhi.

Sonu and Monu challenge the sale. Decide. Also

discuss the rights and remedies of Sohan if
transaction is effected.

(en) ~ ~ ~ CfiT com~ it~ t? Cfm 1:16 "GG

fto:G~cfi~~t?
"' "'

(~) ~ Wffiw ti6GI~ct11 "WI" \ill com t ~~err F ~

-am.wr~~~t~~~~~t~~
"'
-qrn ~ ~ ~ 70 ~ ~ 6~'11~( cfi f.tcnc ~

ti6GI~cn9 ~ t I "WI" ~ ~ ctTI ~ ctTI ~ ftm ~

~ -· 3lf1T1f CfiT ~ 3llRT 16 • ~ cfi fctcmr tg
-am ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Sfi'T CfiB tg fcfim 1

'€\;r -am oft;; ~ ~ 1R 3TTWr fcttrr I fclf.i!l'il£1 ~ I

"' "'
~ ~ Wr-~ ~ it "ij'ffilf t it~ cfi ~

~ ~ CfiT fcfm ~ I

3. X, a male Hindu, dies in Delhi as an undivided member

of Mitakshara coparcenary in 2014. He is survived

P.T.O.
7971 4

by his parents M and F, his sister Sis, one son SI and

one daughter DI. His another son S2 and daughter D 2
predeceased him survived by their son and daughter
S S, S 2D and D 2S, D 2D. DI has two children D 1D and
2
DIS and SI has a wife S 1W, and two children S 1D
and S 1S. S 1S is married and has a wife SISW, a son
slss and a daughter SISD.

Determine the share of each and every member in

the family. ·

Would your answer be different if the family was

domiciled in Chennai ?

~ ~~ X cfit 2014 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~6~tfll419 ~

~~~m~~mllf1~am~m

omrr-~ M 3fu: F, m.GWol Sis,~ 'T-'f SI 3fu: ~ ~

DI ~ t I~ 3P-l 'T-'f S2 3fu: ~ D2 cfit ~ ~ ~
mllf ~ am~ am 'T-'f ~ ~ S2S, S2D 3fu: D2S,
D2D ~ ~ 1 D 1 ~ ~ ~ D 1D 3lk D 1S t ~ S1 cfit
~ ~ S 1W 3lk ~ ~ S 1D 3lk SIS ~I S 1S ~

~~~ sisw, ~ F S1SS 3lk ~ ~ S1SD t 1

~~~~~~en)~~~

<Jffl" ~ ~ ~ ~ 1ffirr "ffi qm 3WfCfiT ~ ~

mcrr ?
7971 5

4. X, a male Hindu dies intestate leaving behind his

separate property. He is survived by his widow W.
He also had four children Sl' S2, D 1 and 0 2 • S 1 after
conversion to Islam got married to a Muslim girl SW
and died during the lifetime of X after begetting a son
SS. D 1 got married to a Christian man under the
Special Marriage Act 1954. S2 who had fallen into
bad company murdered X's brother over a property
dispute. Discuss who would inherit his property and
what would be their shares.

~~~ x m1~~~ Pl4ff1~d1 ~CfiT

~it\ifRITt I~ 3flH1fu} ~fcrucrr W~t I~
m -ar~ ~ t- Sl' S2, D 1 aW D2 1 ~ ~ tiJJT~Itl m
~ ~ S1 .;r ~ ~ sw ~ ~ fctcrr6 Cfi{ ~ 31tt
~ tP-f SS cnT \JPf ~ ~ ~ X ~ ~CI"1CfiiA ~ ~
"'
m
~ cnT ~ it 7l<lT I 0 1 .;r fcrifq fctcrr6 ~, 1954 ~

~~~~~~Cfi{~ S2,\ill~~
11? 7l<TI, .;r ~ fclcnG lR X~ mf cfit ~ Cfi{ ~ I ~
~ ~ ~ <fi' "Cf1"fm cnr.r itlT 3itt ~ ~ <FIT
WI"?

5. A, a Hindu female inherited some prope'rty from her

husband H from whom she had a daughter D. Later
she started living with H 2 from whom she had three
children SP S 2, D 1• S 1 died during her lifetime leaving

P.T.O.
7971 6

behind a widow S 1W. She also had her parents living

with her. She dies intestate in 2014. Discuss who
gets her property and what would be their shares.

~~~ A~~-qfu H.~~~~ D~

~ ~. it ~ ~ fcRmo ~ liT{ ~ I ~ ~ ~ H2 ~
-m~ wu ~ co( ~ ~ ~ -aH ~ Sl' S2, D 1 ~
~ I S I ~ lfuJ 3l1Rt fclucrr S I W ~ ~ \JllC('1Cfll<:1
~ tt ~ CfiT ~ m- lJliT 1 ~ Offi1T- fitrr ~ 7fflt ~ ~
~ ~ I ~ 2014 ~ f.f~ ~ if <f{ I ~~
~ ~ mcnT 3fu: fcficR m ~ ~ 7

6. X, a Muslim, dies leaving behind the parents M and

F, two widows W 1 and W 2 , two sons S 1 and S2 , two
daughters D 1 and D 2 and a widow, a son and daughter
of a predeceased son S 3W, S 3 S and S3D. Discuss
who will get the property and what would be their
shares in Sunni and Shia laws.

What would be your answer if X was a female ?

~ ~ X m lfuJ Offi1T- f1taT M 3fu: F, mfcrucrr W 1

3fu: W2, if "T-f S1 3ik S2 , if ~ D 1 cr~ D2 3ik ~
T.f S3w ctt ~ fcrucrr, ~ T.f cr~ ~ ~ s3 s 3ik S3D
~ ~ q:;) ~ it lJliT I ~ ~ ~ 3ik WIT
~ ~ wqfu fcfi;r- fcfi;r "Cfl) ~ ~ ~ ~ Cf<IT ~ 7

~ x CfiTt w m-at m 3W1cfiT Cf<IT ~ mcrr ?

7971 7
7. (i) Discuss the rules relating to abatement of
legacies under Sunni and Shia laws.

(ii) Examine the validity of the following gifts under

Muslim law:

(a) Rahim is suffering from cancer. When he

comes to know about it, he makes a gift of
all his property in favour of his wife. Two
months later he dies.

(b) Habib makes a gift of his house to his

nephew, Imran who is staying with him.
There is no delivery of possession of house
but rent receipts are issued in the name of
Imran.

(i) ~ ~ fir<:rr fctfUm cfi 3Rr<fu ~ ~ ~ ~

~ f.:t<:riT CfiT ~ ~ I

(ii) ~ fcilir cfi ~ ~yiftf&d GAY ctt ~

ctl \1fl':tT ~ :

(en) m ~ CfiT M ~I~~~ "q"ffi ~ "dGf

~ m ~~ ctiT ~ ~ c€t m;r~

~ ft<:rrl m~~~~ mllfl

P.T.O.
7971 8

(\<f) ~ ~ ;wR ~ ~ cnl", ~~ '"ijN ~

t, 3{q;{f W GR Cfi\ K<:!f I W cfi ~ <tT cn1"l

~~ fcli'IT lT'lT ~ ~ q\1 ~ ~

cfiowr~~~t1

8. Discuss the effect of deletion of sub section(2) of

section 4 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956 by the
Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 2005. Discuss
also the case law, if any.

~ ~ (tfirru;r) ~. 2005 IDU ~ ~

~ ~, 1956 <h'1 um 4 <h'1 "3"Cfum (2 ) cfit "iRW
\ifR cfi ~ <tT ~ ~ I

(200)
[This question paper contains 6 printed pages.]

7972 Your Roll No.

LL.B./II Term ES

Paper LB - 203 - CRIMINAL LAW- II

(General Principles and Criminal Procedure)

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : 100

(Write your Roll No. on the top immediately

on receipt of this question paper.)

Note :- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

~: - w rrR"- ~ CfiT TrT( J7'irofr "llT ~ fit?it VCfi ~

~· ~; ~ '?11ft ~· CfiT 7flt7[1f VCfi "if ifrrr • I

Attempt five questions in all, selecting

at least one question from Part-B.
All questions carry equal marks.

S1T1T- B ~ Cfi7f ~ Cfi7f VCfi !lR ~ ~

cwr ~ m· ~ TrT( ~1
~ ffl ~ Jicn. "W1Ff "ff I

P.T.O.
7972 2

PART-A

~-A

1. "There is a presumption that mens rea is an essential

ingredient in a statutory offence, but this presumption
is likely to be displaced either by the words of the
Statute creating the offence or by the subject matter
with which it deals." Explain this statement and
discuss the relevance of mens rea while affxing
liability in strict liability offences. Cite relevant cases
in support of your answer.

/1~ "31ruR1JfT t fcfi ~OR':~~ ~ ~ ~

~ 'tfCcfi t ~~~ cn1 '3Cffi ~ cn1 ~

~~~cfi~imr3NCIT~~-~gro~ ~
fcnl::tr \jl'f ~ ~ 'lffl' ~ cn«1t t1" ~ ~ cfit aman
~~~~cn-R~~~~~~
~+A':~ cfit ~ ~~~I 3l1H '3m
cfit ~ ~ ~ cfim CfiT 5Cffi1T ~I

2. (a) What are the limitations to the exercise of the

right of private defence of person and property?

(b) 'A' under the influence of madness attempts to

kill 'X' and his wife 'Y'. If 'X' causes harm to
'A' while protecting himself or his wife, would
he be entitled to plead the right of private
defence? Discuss.
7972 3

(en) -mR 3itt ~ cfiT ~ ~ cfi- 3lfucfiR cfi- m

cfiT Cfm qfM'IJ~Il{. ~?

(~) I A' qJ4J<"Jq'1 cfi- 3RR ~ 'X' 3itt ~ f l 'y' en)

~ CfiT ~ infflr tr ~ m en) ~ 31tAT f l
en)~~ 'X' I A' en) e-m:r ~ t 'ffi q:m em-
~ ~ CfiT ~ m- CfiT ~ imr? ~
~I

3. (a) Explain the followi~g maxims with the help of

relevant cases

Ignorantia facit doth excusat and ignorantia

juris non excusat

(b) Explain the law relating to intoxication as a

defence to criminal charge as laid down in the
IPC, 1860.

(en) ~ q: cfiT ~ ~ ~~~Rcl€1 ~ cfiT ~

~ :-~cfil ~~m~t~f<tlU
ct1 ~~I

(~) ~ * ~. 1860 ~ ~~ ~ 3ltRlU

cfi- m ~ cfi- ~ ~· ~ ~ f<tlU cfiT 'Ci!:fR&IT
~I

P.T.O.
7972 4

4. What is the difference between common intention and

Common object?

Five frien<:ls A, B, C, D and E with a common objective

to rob a petrol pump go there in a car, and they are
all armed with guns and knives. While A and B try to
empty the cash box, C and D threaten the people
there by firing shots in the air and E keeps the engine
of their car running so that they may be able to escape
fast. While trying to run away they face stiff
resistance from the guard who is finally shot dead by
B. A month later all five of these persons are
apprehended from different places and charged with
the offences of murder and other related offences
with the help of Section 149 IPC. Decide.
~ ~ 3ft\~~~it:q~~t?

~~Cfi)~~~~-ij-~~ A,B,C,D
E~ CfiR ~em~ ~I~~ "tffiT ~ ~ ~
3ft\
"' "'
~I ~ A~ B ~~liiiiCffl CfiT ~ ~ CfiT Vlmf ~ t
c 3ft\ n 6C1T ~ ~ ~ em ~ &~Pcre4i CfiT ·~ ~ ~
"'
~ E~ CfiR CfiT ~ ~ wrar t f i ~ f i ~
"'
~ ~I ~ CfiT Vlmf ~ ~ ~ l'lfi ~ ~ ~
CfiT ~ Cfi'V'IT ~
. t
~ 3Rffi: B 1lRl 11C
"' ~ -;m: ~
\liffiT -~I ~ ~ GUG ~ ~ ~ cnT 3ffi1T- 3ffi1T ~

-ij- ~ ~ ~ \liffiT t ~ ..-uo ~o ~o cfiT uro 14 9 cfiT

~ -ij- ~ 1R ~ ~ ~ ~ iWRftiT CfiT 3lffiq
~ \liffiT t1 MPt~w~ ~~
7972 5

5. What is the difference between Preparation and an

Attempt to commit a crime? Discuss the liability of
'A' in the following circumstances:

'A' gives medicine to a woman to procure abortion

but it turns out that-

(a) The woman was not pregnant

(b) The dosage of medicine was insufficient to cause

abortion.

~ ~ en) CfiB cfit ~ ~ 1J<ITtr q1 Gltt:r qm ~

t? ~kiRIR'cld ~~A q1 ~ Cfi'r Fcl~~il/04 ~:

'A' fcm1t ~ CfiT ~ CfiB q1 fB'q ~ ~ t 1R «<r 'q'[tiT

~ t fct-
('Cfi) ~ ~ o:fflY ~

(\Cf) ~ ~ q1 ~ ~ cfit ~ ~ ~I

6. Write short notes on any two of following

(a) Difference between legal and medical insanity

(b) First information report

(c) Debate regarding Constitutional validity of Section

309 IPC

~~R!Rcld ~ ~· fct;tf ~ 1R ~ ~ ~:

(Cfi} fctlU"Cfi ~ filfcl:iffil~ ~ q1 ~ ~I

P.T.O.
7972 6

(\Cf) ~~ ~ Rtiltl

(ll) ~o G'o -«o cfit um 309 cfit ~ ~mrr ~

~I

PART-B

~-B

7. What are the considerations before Court while

granting bail in case of non-bailable offences?

What are the grounds on which bail may be cancelled?

Explain

~- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "*¥ ~ ~ ;::ql£11(1£1
CfiT fcfi;r ~ 'q\ fcft;m: Cfi(.IT ~ t?
~ cnt.:r -ij- ~ t= ~ 'q\ ~ ~ m- ~ t? ~
~I

8. Discuss the following

(a) Basic features of a Fair Trial

(b) Plea Bargaining

(\<f) ~ ~ (Plea Bargaining)

(200)
[This question paper contains 10 printed pages.]

7932 Your Roll No.

LL.B. I II Term E.

Paper LB-203 LAW OF CRIMES

Time: 3 Hours Maximum Marks : I 00

(Write your Roll No. on the top immediately

on receipt of this question paper.)

Note :- Answers may be written eit~er in English or in Hindi,·

but the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

ftaroft: - ~ r;rTr{- r:p;r CfiT 'JF(( 3iUufr <IT ~ Fct-m % ~

7{' ~; ~ N -:mit' CfiT "1f/t7[1f % it iFrr 'tlTf3v I

Attempt any Five questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

C§M ~ ffl ci' JfT( ~I

m:ft ffl ci' Jicn 'WfF/'. -/1

1. (a) What are the essentials of the 'First Information

Report' and how it carries greater evidentiary
value than the statements of the witnesses
recorded by the police during investigation.
(10)

P.T.O.
7932 2

(b) Discuss whet~er a police officer is bound to

register a FIR when a cognizable offence is made
. out or he has an option, discretion or latitude of
conducting some kind of preliminary enquiry before
registering the FIR. What is the remedy that is
available to the victim in case of refusal of a
police officer to register the FIR. (10)

("Cfi') I~ ~ fttfrt' ~ ~ "ffi'q q<:JT t ~ ~

·.~~~~~~iiRT~~~
·~~~m~t?

(~) ~~<F~Tm~ ~m arquu5H~

~ ~ ~ fttiTt <~f{)<@cl ~ ~ ~ ~ t
3f4CIT m- 1:fRT <if{ ~' ~ t <:[]' Wllf ~
fttiTt ~ <~f{)tta ~ ~ ~ ~ m ctT ~
~~ ctT f<:l=t:i§·c:al t 1~ ~ fttiTt cnr <~f{)tta

~~~ ~~~~~~-cnTCFIT
'3'IW ~ t?

2. (a) W's father in law, aged 72 yrs and who has

suffered heart attack once; mother in law, aged
65 yrs and a patient of asthma and brother-in-law
'
aged 15 yrs and an outstanding shooter are
7932 3
arrested for assault (a: bailable offence) and
murder (a non bailable offence) of W .. Al,l the
accused apply for bail. They belong .to a highly
connected family of bureaucrats. c~.n. they be
released on bail. What factors ·should be
considered while disposing of their bail applications.
(1 0)

(b) M, a former minister, pleads that he has heen

falsely implicated in case of receiving 'kickbacks'.
M, apprehending his arrest moves an application
for anticipatory bail. Describe the factors which
should be kept in mind while considering the
application of M for anticipatory bail. (1 0)

("Cfi) w <fi" 72 c:rrl <hl" arrg <fi" ~, m 1fCfi <iiR @GZr ~

it ~ t, 65 c:rrl Chl" arrg cit ~ ~ ~ Chl" -wiT .g

~ 15 c:rrl Chl" arrg CfiT ~, ~ 1fCfi ~ ~ t, cit
w lR ~ (lfCO ~ armu) ~ ~ (~-~
armu) cfi" fuq ~ fct<:rr lTliT t 1 ~ ~ ~

\JI1fRd" ~ ~ ~ c@"
~
.g I ~ ~ ~ ~ «<R- ~

CllB ~Cfl(!ill?l cfi" ~ ~ t I qm ~ \JI1fRd" lR f@ M

~ ~ t ?~ \JI1fRd" Chl" ~ CfiT Fr:!cH ~
~ fcn;r ~ lR fcftm: fct<:rr ~ ~ ?

P.T.O.
793'2 4

(~) lcf ~ M ~ CfmiT t fcfi "3WfiT ~ 'AA ~ ~

.~: ~ ~ ~ ~ fct"llT <r:rr t I ;w:Rt ITR'hil() <tT
· 611~(Cfllq~l Cf5 Slc:til~ld ~ ~ 31\ill W CfiBT t I

Sl~l~ld
. ~ .Jrr M <tl 31\ill 1R fcRm: fcm \Tiffi wr:i
-m CfiRCfiT CfiT vk.r ~ wu ~ • ~ • ~ 1
3. (a) Explain the difference between cognizable and non
cognizable offences. Describe the procedure and
powers of a police officer while investigating
cognizable offences. (1 0)

(b) Z, an accused made a confession before a

magistrate, who gave him no warning of the
consequences of making a confessional statement.
The magistrate made no notes b_ut listened to the
accused with great attention. Later, the magistrate
dictated, to the best of his recollection, a
confessional statement to his steno and put his
signature to the typed statement.

Can the accused be convicted on the basis of

such a confessional statement alone. Describe the
procedure for recording of the confessional
statement admissible in the trial. (10)
 7932 5

(en) ~ 3TR ~ 3mTUT cfi- ~ ~ CfiT ~ ~ 1

~~Clif~~~~~<tt~
~ ~ CfiT cr$r ~ I

(\Cf) ~ Z ~ ~~* cfi" ~ ~~~tfd <tT I ~~~C: ~

~ ij\•cfltRI CJffiT ~ ~ cfi- ~ <tt ~ ~ o:@
~ 1 ~~~c: ~ ~ ~ o:@ ~ 1:R ~ ~ ~
en) ~ ~IPf'l.clCfl WIT I GUG ~ Jf~~c: ~ ~ ~

l!IGGI!id ~ <ti~'tfu ~ ~ <fir ~ ~ CfiT ~

~ ~ iFcfia" ~ 1:R ~ 1ffilTm Cfi{ ~I

CfliT ~ CfiT ~ ~ifcflrt~Rl ~ cfi- m 1:R ~

~ ~ Wfim ~? fcfcrRuT ~ ~ ij·~'!lfd ~ cfi'

RCflJfl41 ~ ~ CfiT cr$r ~ I

4. (a) Describe in detail, with the help of judicial

decisions, the basic features of a fair trial as given
under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
(10)

(b) "Regulating the nature of interaction between the

accused and the police authorities is at the crux
of a developed criminal justice system." Elucidate
while highlighting the provisions of arrest and

P.T.O.
7932 6
the safeguards afforded to the arrested persons,
in the light of recent judicial. and legislative
developments. (1 0)

(en)~~~. 1973 ~ ~ 4'4tstih'1 ~~~

~~an cnr (l~ttil< <rJR"·~ ~PHi~~· cfit
~~~~

(\Cf) II~ 3fu: ~ ~ ~ ~ 3Rf:fsli<:rr cfi ~

cnT ~Fl4J1"1 ~Cfllftd ~ ~ ~ cnT ~ t I" 6m

cfi" ~· 3ik ~ l:lc"11SfiJ1 <iT ~ ~ ~ ~

!1'1(~1{1 cfi" ~ 3ik ~ ~ cfit ~ lW ~

'IR wtim ~ ~ WfRIT ~I

5. (a) What is the justification and applicability of the

concept of 'Plea Bargaining' in the Indian context.
Is it different from compounding of offences ?
(10)

(b) Explain the essentials of a judgement delivered in

a criminal court with the help of the relevant
provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973. (1 0)
7932 7

(Cfi) 'qffif cfi m ~ I~ am:il Pi~ 1 ctt

1
fl.Cf) <"'"~ '11 CfiT ~ 3fu:
3iji'!Lfl\i4dl CFn t 7 CFn ~ aMTW cfi ~ ~ ~ it
~t?

((Cf) ~ ~ ·~. 1973 cfi ~ ~ ctt ~ it

~ ;::[li~IM~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cfi ~ ~ cR ~

~I

6. (a) Critically evaluate the role of the Criminal Court

and the prosecutor in the withdraw! of prosecution
in the light of the decided case of Abdul Karim v.
State of Karnataka (2000) 8 SCC 710. (1 0)

(b) Discuss the inherent powers of the High Court

in relation to quashing of FIR and review of
judgement. (1 0)
i
I

(Cfi) ~ Cfif#r 'GRT1f fiT' Jifrfi Cfl rtfc: Cfl ( 2 0 0 0 ) 8 ~ -m -m

710 cfi FclPifli!d ~ c8 ~~ ~ ~ ~ cnW
~ ~ ;::[li~IM~ 3fu: ~ ctt, ~ CfiT ~~

Jl("ll(Cfl'1 ~ I
"'

((Cf) WFf ~ Wt c8 3r1ffif Cfi'H 3fu: ~ cfi ~'114Ml Cfl'1

cfi GfR ~ ~ ;::[lllliM~ ctt 3i'"'df.li%d ~ CfiT ~

~I
P.T.O.
7932 8

7. (a) Explain 'taking cognizance of an offence by a

Magistrate'. When and how a Magistrate takes
cognizance of an offence. (1 0)

(b) What is meant by 'framing of charge' ? Explain

the contents of a charge. What is the effect of
'Error in Framing Charge'? (10)

(Cfl) . +~Rif(c: &m fcnm m Cfi1 ~ fc;r:rr \ilR'T- ~ ~

~I m +!fu:tf(c f<nm 3lWU Cfi1 ~ ~ Jfu: ~

>!CFiR ~ ~ ?

c~) ,~ Cf<:r <fiR' Cfi1 <fliT ~ ~ ? ~ ctt ~

cnT ~ ~ I I~ Cf<:r <fiR ~ ~' Cfi1 <fliT ~

"'

8. (a) X, rescues Y, an undertrial from Tihar Jail and

m so doing causes grievous hurt to W, the
warden of Tihar Jail. X is tried and convicted for
unlawfully rescuing an undertrial from the legal
. custodY.. Subsequently he is tried for causing
grievous hurt to W. X argues that the subsequent
trial can not proceed in view of the previous
conviction.
7932 9

Examine the argument of X, dearly bringing out

the law under S-300 of the. Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973. ( 10)

(b) Write short notes on any two of the following:-

,

(i) Cancellation of bail.

(ii) Powers of a police officer to conduct a search

without warrant.
i
(iii) Difference between ! 'Discharge' and
'Acquittal'. (5x2=10)

("en) x~~ Y CfiT ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cfi cnt.=r ~ CfiT w ~ Cfilftf

cfiT I X CfiT fcrt:rRuT fcfi<:rr ~ t ~ ·~ fctlUcfi ~

~ fcfim ~ CfiT fctlU fcl{ioacl~l ~

...,. -AA ~..., ~

mr ~ t 1 ~ ~ '3WfiT w Cfili w ~ Cfilftf ~

i

~..., fcrt:rRuT ~ .t I X ~ ~ t fct ~ J'P!lffl~ cfiT

~

~ ~ q!i't:llclClffi fcrt:rRuT ~ ~ \1fT ~ I

I
I
I
i
~ ~ ~. 1973 c8 urn ; 300 cfi ~ fctlU
CfiT ~ ~ ~ "Wfim ~ 'Bffi ~: X c8 ~ c8 ~

~I

P.T.O.
7932 10

(i) ~ CfiT ~I

(ii) cm'c W-IT m;rm ~ cfi ~ ~ ~ cfiT

~I

(3000)
This question paper contains 8+4 printed pages]

Your Roll No ................ .

7935

LL.B./II Term E

Paper IV: CRI!"'INAL LAW-II (OC) (General Principles and

.
Criminal Procedure)

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : I 00

(Write your Roll No. on/he top immediately on receipt of !his ques/ion paper.)

Note :- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi; but

the same medium should be used throughout the paper.

~ ~- '1?J CfiT '3m ~ c:rr ~ fcfim ~ 'q]1iiT

"# ~; ~ "B'lfl' ~ CfiT l1T&ftl ~ m- m;;r

~
Attempt Five questions and at

least one question from Part II.

All questions carry equal marks.

'1WT II 'B Cfill-'B-Cfill ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~
"'
m
cfi '3m~~
t~m ~ cfi ~ 'BllR ~ 1

P.T.O.
 2 ) 7935

Part I

(~ 1)

1. Attempt briefly any four of the following

(a) Distinguish between legal insanity and medical

- insanity.

(b) Voluntary drunkenness is no excuse, while involuntary

drunkenness is an excuss. Comment.

(c) Enumerate briefly the rights of an accused or arrested

person.

(d) When can an FIR be lodged ? State its essentials.

(e) Plea bargaining undermines the rights of victims as well

as the accused. Do you agree ? Give reasons.

F11=1F<1f@(1 if ~ fcf;;@ ~ ~ ma;rcq ~ ~ _

(a) fcrf~ ·~ aTR fqfCflffiChllf '3'"'411<:11 ~ irq

~~~'
 ( .3 7935

. (b) ~~ R--0Cfl 11mff ~ ~ %TI ~ %~ &!~ f-iijCf)

11mff ~ %I Ruluft ~I

(c) an~ 7:JT rl<'h11{ ~ ~ an~ C8 m~

~~I

(d) >r~ ~ ftqli ~ ~ Cfft ~ ~ %?

~ &IICl~l!Cfl ~- C8 ~ ~I

(e) cffi <sm~f.:jll ~ ~ ('f~ an~.~ an~

C8 WB ~ %I cp:rr 31r1 ~ %? CfiRUT

~~I

2. 'A statutory crime may or may not contain an express

definition of the necessary state of mind. In order to determine

whether or not mens rea, is an essentia.l element of the offence

it is necessary to look at the object and terms of the statute.'

Explain this statement with .the help of decided cases.

P.T.O.
 ( 4 ) . ·7935

~~ 3ltm~ . ~~Cl~Wh l=R:'W.lfu Cfll ~ 'G'ft:~

31'iifcf~ ·~· m %·711 ~ ~ m %1 <:fQ 3lCrmfuf

m cfi fu'Q: cp:rr 31rmf'l:fc:n 11-1:~ 311m~ cnr 311Cl~'4Cfl

~ ~ 31~ ~, Cfi11:1 cfi ~ ~m ~q;Jt 'R

UTR t-=rr 311Cl~'4Cfl %1'

fctf1~'qd cfi'B1 · Cfll Btl""ldl it ~ Cfl~ Cfll ~

~I

3. (a) 'A' hit 'B' with a hockey stick on head, whereby 'B'

took out a knife and gave a single blow on the chest

of 'A' which caused his death. Did 'B' exceed his rigbt

of private defence ?

(b) Anil confronted Ravi for not returning Rupees One Lakh

which Ravi had taken from him. He pushed Ravi, who

retaliated by picking up a stone and hit Ani! on his

 ( 5 ) 7935

_ forehead with it. Ani! took out his pen knife and

gave few blows with it. Ravi died on the way to the

hospital. Ani! pleaded right of private defence. Will he

succeed ?

(a) 'A' ~ 'B' ~ fW 1R QfcnT ft?:Cfi 'B ~ fc8n .

P.T.O.
 ( 6 7935

4. (a) Shiv, a security guard, was returning home late at night

when he was pushed from behind, but he could not

see anyone. As he walked further, ~he was pushed again.

r

He instantly fired from his gun thinking it to be a ghost.

The bullet hit Vijay a rag-picker who was playing this

trick on Shiv to scare him. Vijay died one day thereafteL

Shiv pleaded mistake of fact. Decide, citing relevant case

law.

(b) Is 'Irresistible impulse' as a defence 111 IPC is

permissible ? Explain.
 ( 7 ) 7935

(a) W&n 1lTi ftrq ~ "UG ciT m~ ~ 2lr ~

~ w it ~ K<:rr 1"flfT ~ CfQ" ~

qi) ~ ~ 1WITI ~ -m CfQ" 3Wt ~ ~ :rr:

~ K<:rr 1"flfT I ~ n=r 'Iff ~ ~ ~

"3B . 1R ~. ~ it l:fil"ll1: ~ K<:rr I ~

~ Cf) 011 f"'? ;q 1 ~ qi) \iff , ~ l5lT ftrq qi) m

~ f<?r'Q ~ m21 7:ffi ~ ~ ~ 2l"fl ~

~ ~ "0llG: ~ ctT ~ m~ 1 ftrq ~

Cf~ ~ CfiT 31f~ fcnllT I ~ f.fuP:r fuf~

CfiT ~ ~ ~ fqf.W"'1ll ~I

(b) Cfll1 ~ ~ ~ 'B ~&n ~ ~ 'B

':mffirov::r 31'fcM '· 3=1j)l""lR14ln~ t" ? ~ ~ 1

5. A, B, C, D and E with a common object to take away ATM

Machine went to HDFC Bank ATM. A, B, C and D entered

the ATM kiosk and started detaching the machine from the

P.T.O.
 ( 8 ) 7935

floor. E stood at a distance to warm them of any impending

danger. As they were about to take away the ATM machine,

..
a man came there to withdraw money, but he was assaulted

by. A, B, C and D. He died afterwards. A, B, C, D and E

were tried for the offence of murder and other offence read

with settion 149 !PC. Decide.

A, . B, C aW D ~.it.~. ~. if ~ ~ aW &@t

m~ ~ qft iJcliCFfl ~ cfi ~ ~ ·lR ~

m'T<n 1 . ~ m ~ ~.it.~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

cnm 2l, ~ cxiTcRr ~ f~Cfil(1~ ~ ~ ~ an

'T<nl ~ ~ ~ ~ m~I A, B, C, D aW
 9 7935

E CfiT ~ cf;" ~'tl aW 'tlm 149 "1f.r;:.B. ~ BT2l

~ 3F1 ~'tl cf;" ~ fq ~-w:ol ~ -rr:n 1 FC1F1~~'4

~I

6. (a) Rakesh and his mother Sheela stopped giving food to

Rakesh's wife Sarita. They starved her for a long time,

However she escaped and was taken care of by an

NGO. What offence, if any, has been committed by

Rakesh and Sheela ? Decide.

(b) Sonu entered Raju's house to kill him. He ~ntered R~u's

bedroom and fired at his bed, thinking that Raju was

sleeping. However, Raju was not there and had put

pillows therein to give an impression that he was

sleeping. Can· some be held guilty of attempt to murder

Raju ? Decide.

P.T.O.
 ( 10 ) 7935

~ ~ ~ ~&T it ~ 3fu: <:JQ ~ ~

~ ~ 11{ ~ mr ~ ~ ~ m t1
 .( II 7935

Part II.

(~ 11)

7. (a) Discuss the legal principles evolved by courts in

granting bail in respect of non-bailable offences ..

(b) A, an eminent politician, was alleged to have accepted

money and favoured a particular company while

awarding contract for mineral extraction from forest

area. 'A', apprehending arrest, moves an application·

for anticipatory bail under section ·438 CrPC. Will he

succeed ?

P.T.O.
 ( I2 ) 7935

(b) ~ ~ {1\llflfdii!· A CR ~ 'B' ~ HCflR1~

~~~~'tR~~cr~fcfim

~ ~ c6 m21 -qm m c6 ~

~~~ fcn<;rr 'l<:n . ~ I A ~ fl I{'"Rll{ m 'Cfll

~ 'B' 'tTm 438-~ ~ ~ c6 3Rf1fu
Slf41f.<ld ~ ~ 31\lll Wflt %I CF1T ~ ~

W1T ? .

8. (a) Discuss the procedure and power of the police to _

investigate cognisable cases.

(b) ·State briefly the salient features of 'fair trial'.

(a) ~ cfiBf ct ~ ~ ~ 'Cfll ~ Cf~

~ Cf1T ~~I

(b) '~ fcl't:II{OI' 'Cfll ~ fCJ0ISIC11aTI 'Cfll m~ ~

~I

7935 . 12 300
[This question paper contains 7 printed pages.]

7973 Your Roll No.

JITfFI1T Jfj}li Jff'q:; 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

LL.B./II Term ES

Paper LB-204 : PROPERTY LAW

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : 100

"ff1fZ{ : 3 F:JTit T:fUlfcn· 100
"' 0

(Write your Roll No. on the top· immediately

on receipt of this question paper.)

(w JrR"- rr-r ~ ~ -m· ~ ~ "JW Rufftrr

Fl"Fr W JfTRT 31j¢1i Jf/'q:; fWtr:w I)

Note :- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

ftalu7t: - w JrR"- rr-r cnr "3fT{ Jiit1!t <IT ffi";=ift M vcn ~

.;r· ~ ~ N ~ CfiT Jflt7Pf VCfi "ift flRr • I

Attempt five questions in all including

Question Number 1 which is compulsory.
All questions carry equal marks.

a#rcnzf JrR" ~ 1 ~

CfiM ~ Jl"Rl' ~ "JrT( ~I

~m~Jfcn~t1

P.T.O.
7973 2

1. Explain any four of the following :

(a) Animo Attestandi

(b) Profits a prendre

(c) Meaning of Transfer of Property under section 5

of the TPA

(d) Distinguish between Vested and Contingent

Interest

(e) Registration as Constructive Notice (20)

(Cfi) Animo Attestandi

(~) Profits a prendre

(lf) ~ aRRUT ~ cfiT tTRT 5 cfi- 3lUR' ~ aRRUT

CfiT ;wl I

2. Explain the Doctrine of Fixtures and determine the

character of the following properties :
 7973 3

(i) Diesel oil engine fixed to the earth with the

help of nuts and bolts on the cemented
foundation for the purposes of running a touring
talkies.

(ii) ATM machine fixed to the earth and wall by

the bank in a tenanted premises. (20)

I flfiCffliH I cfi ~ cfiT cx:ma:rr ~ ~ f.iyfi¥JRCid ij+qfftqf

cfi ~ CfiT 3lCruT(Uf ~ :

(i) ~ ~ crctfii.f ~ cfi ~ ~ ~ qrffi ~

1R 1VRT-~ cfiT ~ -ij- ~it ~ ~ ~
.~I

. (ii) ~ 1R ~ trRm: it~ 'IDU ~ "d'~ ~it~

"lf ~it~~ I

· 3. Explain and distinguish between Spes Successions and

Doctrine of feeding the grant by Estoppel.

A mother of a minor son B; transferred property in

favour of C on her behalf and on behalf of B. The
son B after getting majority challenged the said transfer
and court held that the transfer upto the extent of

P.T.O.
7973 4

share of B is void. Thereafter before the B could

take the possession he dies in a road accident and
A being legal heir of B inherited the same property.
Now C sues A for transfer of same property to
him under section 43. Decide whether C would
succeed? (20)

~~<'fiR 3ft<: ·~ G 7JFC ~~I ~ ~

ctt CZfRCZIT ~ 3fu: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I

CfiT C ~ llel ~ 3RRUT Cfi\ fttrr I ~ mlifA" ~ GITG ~

B ~ "3Tii 3RRll1 en) ~ fcfi<:rr ~ rl"ll£11&1£1 ~ ~

M fcfi B ~ in:R ctt ~ ~ 3Rf{UT ~ t I M"l~"41d,

~mfcfi s~-R~~~~~~m
1ft 3ft<: B CfiT fctltrcn ~ ~ ~ ~ A en) qtl ~

fcRma ~ f1tR lT{ 1 ~ c uro 43 ~ ~ ~ ~ cn1

~ ~cnB~~ A TRCfTG~~ I ~f.i~"4£1 ~
q:qr c~mm?

4. Explain the Rule against Pe{petuity. What is the

procedure prescribed under Transfer of Property Act
1882 to transfer property for the benefit of unborn
person? (20)
7973 5

liii~Ciddl cfi" ~ ~ cnt ~~I 31iiffif ~ cfi" W

~ wqfu en) aRrftr cnB cfi" ~ wqfu aRRUT ~.

188 2 cfi" 3R11fu CfliT ~ t 7

5. (a) Explain the Doctrine of Lis Pendens.

(b) A files a suit against B for possession of property.

But the plaint is returned by the court after
preliminary finding that the court does not
have pecuniary jurisdiction. Before A could file
the same before the proper court B gifted the
property to C. Whether the gift deed is hit by lis
pendens ? (20)

('(Cf) A wqfu cfi" ~ ~ B cfi" ~ CfiCl" ~ Cfi«''T t I

~ o::!Olllll&~ll am~~~ cfi" ~ ~ <utffi

~ ~ 'ijfffif t ~ o::!Olllll&lll cfi" -qrn ~ ~ o:rtT
t I~ m ~ A~ o::!Olllll&lll cfi" ~ ~ ~
CO"{ ~ B ~ wqfu CfiT qr;r C cnt CO"{ ~ I CfliT '3m"

qr;r f<tffiq ~ CfiCl" cfi" ~ ~ ~ ~ I

6. (a) Define Mortgage and discuss various kinds of

mortgages contemplated under section 58 of the
Transfer of property Act, 1882. ·

P.T.O.
7973 6

(b) A creates Anomalous Mortgage of property in

favour of B for a period of 99 years with the
condition that the entire amount along with interest
would be payable at the time of redemption and
property can be redeemed within 6 months after
the completion of the term. Whether these
conditions of the mortgage amounts to Clog on
equity of Redemption? Decide. (20)

(en) ~UCI'i cit~~ 3ft\~ aRRUT ~.

1882 <tt urn sa cfi" ~ ~ ~ ~ cfi" ~
<fiT~~~

(~) A ~ W cfi" ~ 99 Cf1t cfiT ~ cfi"· ~ B cfi" llaT

~ ~ <fiT ~ "fcffi&lur ~UCI) ~ Cfi«lT t fct ~

cfi" ~ iS£11\JI~~d Wffif mt ~ inTI "d"~ ~tH cfi" ~

~cfi" ~ 6 ~cfi" ~~~<tt~~

t I <fliT ~UCI'i <t't ~ ~ ~ <t't mRIT 1R GllUT cfi" ~

t' ? ~R!!"44 ~ I

7. A group of Delhi Government employees acquire land

for Co-operative Group Housing Society. The rules
of the Society provides that no flat of the society can
be sold to any non Delhi Government Employee.
Decide whether such condition is valid as per legal
provisions and decided cases. (20)
7973 7

~ mCfiR cfi Cfl4-ill~· cfi ~ ~ ~ ~ ~11_~Cfl

~ Jl~1~t) ~ ~ CfiT awR fcfim I~ cfi ~ ~

mcruFf t fct «<~l~tl cfi ~ ~ ~ 'Cfl) ~ mCfiR cfi
~ 'ij- ~ ~ 'Cfll ~ o:rtJ tm iiiT ~ t I f4Ft~'illl
~ q<:{f ~~ fctlUCfl' ~ ~ f4Ptffl:ild cfim cfi ~
~t1

8. (a) What are the essentials of a valid gift under the

provisions of TP A ?

(b) Define and distinguish between actual and

constructive Notice with the help of illustrations.
(20)

(en) ~ 3R'RUT ~ cfi "3'1""~ cfi 3Rnfu ~u GFr cfi

~ m:q q<:{f .g ?

c~) ~ ctT mw:rdT -ij- cm:~f4Cfl afu: 3ll""lf1:l Cfl ~ cfi ~

<ilG~~~~~~I

(200)
This question paper contains 8 printed pages]

Your Roll No ..................................... ..

7933

LL.B,/11 Term E

Paper LB-204-PROPERTY LAW

Time : 3 Hours Maximum Marks : 100

(Write yoitr Roll Xo. on the top immediately on receipt of this quesiion paper.)

Note:- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but the same medium should be used throughout the

paper.

~ ~-;-~ CfiT ~ ~ tiT ~ 00 1ZCfi 'qTli!l

-B. ~; ~ "B.~ ~ CfiT l1T~ 1ZCfi m~

~I

Attempt any Five questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

~ -qfu m cfi.~ ~
r
Nmcfi~~%

P.T.O.
 .< 2 ) 7933

1. (a) "There is no comprehensive definition of the expression

'immov~ble property' in the T.P. Act, 1882. Each can has

to be decided on its own merit."

Discuss with the help of decided cases. 10

"~ 3RRUT an~ , 1882. .~ ~~ "Wiffir'

an~ Clft ~ ~ crfb:rrlSIT ~ <n ~ t 1

~ ~ q;) ~ :rr-~ "lR fqf1G.l'Cid CfiB"T·~

(b) Discuss giving reasons whether the following are

movable or immovable properties : 10

(I) A right to· work· mines and carry the coal for

2 years.

(ii) Oil engine attached to land by mortgagLis of

land.

(iii) A right to graze cattle over the land for one

year.

(iv) A right to grow and appropriate grass for six

months.
 (3 ) 7933

Cf;Ttur ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ cp:rr F1101F0f@o

~· '81011f'd4i ~ <:IT ~ '81011f'd4i :

(t) G)~~~~~~·3tR~

~ \5fA CfiT 3lf~

(ii) ~ ~ ~~ &m ~ ~ ~ 7l<:JT ~

~I

(iii) ~ 1R ~ Cf!Sf tg ~ "'i'.R'R CfiT an~

(iv) ~ l:lrn ~ qffif errn -m <fm ~ fqf.14'Jf"1o

~ CfiT 3lf~ I

2. (a) "A person buying property in a municipal area must be

deemed to be aware that municipal taxes are a charge on

a property, that there is a possibility of such taxes being

in arrear~ and that it is his duty to enquire about such

arrears, if he fails to do so he would always be deemed

to have notice of such taxes." Naval Kishore Vs. Agra

Muncipility 1943 ALJ 53. How far do you agree with the

above statement ? 15

P.T.O.
 (4 ) 7933

"Djf1fftq(1 ~ -q "B'P1fu ~ ~ cnR .arfcR:r Cfil

~ \llHCflR ~~~fcnWJ1fu"Y1: afifBY<1

Cfiit Cfil "!I~ WRIT %", ~ Cfiit "Cfll "Dfu ~ .~

"@r Cfi1 -fi~ ~ Cf2ll -Q:B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

-q·~ CfiBT ~ ~ t ~ ~ -Q:m ~

.·-q ·~ "ffiiT ~ m~ ~ ~ fcn ~

-Q:B Cfiit Cfi1 ~ ~ 1'' ~ mTR ·GAlli awm

•PI<Yifc:1Cfll 1943 ALJ 53 I 3Wf ~ en~ 'i\'

c:nm (fCf) ~ %?

(b) What are the cond,itions subject to which a registered

instrument operates as a constructive notice ? 5

~ ~ ~ %~ 3lUf~ <f~~l~d funsrn

3il~f'"lCfl ~ ~ ~ -q cnr<f ~ %?

3. "Section 6(a) of the T.P. Act; 1882 enacts a rule ofsubstantive

law while Sec. 43 enacts a rule of estoppel which is one of

evidence."
 (5) 7933·

.
Elucidate the above statement in the light
.
of the decided

case Jumma Masjid Mercara Vs. Kodaimanidra Deviah, AfR

1962 S.C. 847. 20

""BP1fu ~ 31f~, .1882 Cfi1 't1m 6(a) "ll"Z1

fcnoq Cfi1 ~ 31f~f14filii Cfi«ft t ~ qm 43

~ CfiT f.:r:r:r an~f.l 4 Flio Cfltd1 t ~ ~ -ma?l t ,,

Mercara Vs. Kodaimanidra Deviah, AIR 1.962 S.C. 847 CfiT

4. "The effect of the doctrine of Lis Pendens as embodied in Section

52 of the TP Act, 1882 is not to annual all voluntary transfers

affected by the parties to the suit. but only to. render it sub-

servient to the right of the parties thereto under the degree or

order which may be made in that suit."

Discuss with the help ·of decided cases. 20

"-wx:rfu 3RRUT a:rr~, 1882 cn1 'tlm s2 ii ~~

CJI<;ct>IC1l1 ~- ~ ~ CfiT qftullq ~ ~ "'l~

P.T.O.
 (6 ) 7933

~ t ~ ~ ~ fum al~ ~ cfi, \liT ~ -q

m \liT ~ t al'tfA ~ -q~ cfi an~ CfiT

imrul'~Tcfl ~ t I"

5. "Restrictions repayment to the interest created are alway_s void."

· Comment.

Are the following conditions imposed by the transferror against

the transferee valid ?

(i) The transferee cannot transfer the property outside ·

the family. 10

(ii) The transferee still not sublet the lawn on rent which has

been transferred absolutely to him." 10

'~ fucf cfi ~Rlih.,_<1 ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I" fc:u:ruft

~I

CFIT 3RRCfi mu 3Rffuft cfi ~ an~ f11=1f<1f<Sld

~ fclf~ ~ ?

(i) 3Rffuft -qftcm ~ ~ -w:qfu CfiT a:fffitf ~ cnl:

~tl
 (7) 7933

(ii) 3Rffuft ~ ~ ffi ~m·4fuCfl ~ -B a:ffifu:r fcfi<:rr

lp;JT ""3B "31=[- ~ 'R 1@ ~ I

6. Briefly discuss the following :

(a) Principles involved in validity effecting a transfer in

favour an unborn person. 10

(b) Rule against perpetuity. 10

F114f<?lf«H1 cnr m~ ~ ~

(a) "fcfim ~ ~ cfi "'la.l -q 3RRUT ~ ~~ ~

-q Cfll4ff.<:lct ~ -q ~ ~ ~

(b) ~II~ cld(11 cfi ~ f.p;p::r I

7. What· is a elog on equity of Redemption ?

_X executes a mortgage in favour of Y, providing on the deed

.that X would be entitled to redeem the property only within

six months after 85 years failing which he would lose the right

of.redemption. Discuss the validity of such a condition. 20

~ Cfft ~ mm cp:rr mat t ?

X ~ y cfi "'la.l -q ~ ~~ f.1!>YIRct fcfi<:rr ~ ~

"it >r]"q~ 2lT fcn X ""BPlfu ~ ~ 85 "CflSI1 cfi ~ "$

P.T.O.
 (8) 7933

"Gm ~ ~ ~ enG. Cf1T .~ ~ ~ ~

~m~~cnT31f~~m~ ~~

~ Cfft w~ Cf1T ~ ~ 1

8. Write short notes on any two of the following : 20

(1) Amino Attestandi

(ii) Sec. 5 of the T.P. Act of 1882

(iii) Revocation of gifts.

(i) Amino Attestandi

(ii) w:qfu ~ 31f~, 1882 qfr 'l:lm 5

7933 8 2,800.
 This question paper contains 7 printed pages]

Your Roll No ................ .

7934

LL.B./II Term E

Paper LB-205-PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW-I

Time : 3 Hours ~ ·Maximum Marks : I00

fWnie your Roll No. on the top"immediately on receipt of this question paper.)

Note : - Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

.·
but the same medium should be used throughout the

paper.

· R:114on :-~ ~-~ CfiT "3'tR ~

..
:m -~ fcfim ~ ~
'

-q ~; ~ "B~ 6WT CfiT lll~:lfll ~ m- ~

~I

Attempt any Five questions.

All questions carry equaL marks.

~ ~>r.R ~I

rim~~ WlR ~~

I. (a) Explain the basis of international law with the help of

jurisprudential .theories. 10

P.T.O,
 ( 2 ) 7934

(b) "There is no general rule that the individual cannot

be a 'subject of international. law' and in partic.ular

contexts he appears as a legal person on the international

plane." Do you agree with this view of Ian

Brownlie ? Critically comment on the status of

individuals as a subject of International law. 10

 ( 3 ) 7934

2 What do you understand by "evidence of a general practice

accepted as law" in relation to international custom ? Discuss

how international courts have decided on the validity of

international custom with the help of cases.

3HHf~l4 ~ "ct ~ ~ "fc:W:l "ct ~ ~ ~

m't"IRUT 4R41c.1 ct mltlr" ~ 3Wfcf)T cp:rr m~

%? ~ qft ~ ~ ~ ~ 3H1<f~l4

rlll41(14f ~ 3i~<f~l4 ~ Cfl1 M~ iR ~

m Fotf~:rt:~4 fcfi<:rr % ?

3. (a) What are general principles of law recognized by civilized

nations ? Discuss how the principles of 'res judicata'

and 'estoppel' have been applied by the international

court of justice in different cases. 10

(b) Briefly comment on consular privileges and

immunities. 10

P.T.O.
 ( 4 ) 7934

~I

4. (a) What is the basis of state responsibility ? Explain how

the principle of state responsibility was applied

in Nicaragua case (Nicaragua Vs. USA, ICJ Rep. 1986

p. 14). 10

(b) Explain the d_ifferent forms of reparation by referring to

the ILC Draft Code on Responsibility. of States for

Internationally Wrongful Acts, 200 I .. 10-

 ..
( 5 ) 7934

( 31) ~ 3'd(<!JflffCI CfiT cp:ff ~'l:lR "% ? ~ ~

RctiHPJ>.m ~~ ( F1cnHPJ>an ~ 'i:"TJ:B·~·

~.m.~. h" 1986 p 14) if ~ 3'd<GlflffCI ~

~ q:;l fcR1 m "ffill fc8n lFIT ~ 1

(~) 3i~Hf~lll ~if~ 31f~, 2001 %TIM

~ a'd<Gif71CC~1CR 3Tit.~.m. ~ m cn1 ~

~ ~ ~If1'{fct ~ fcrf'l.A ~. Cfil .~

~I

5. Explain the relevance of Blackstonian doctrine while deciding

the relationship between international faw and municipal law.

What is the practice of applicability of International treaty law

and customary law in India ? Elucidate your answer with the

help of cases. 20

31~Hf~lll fcrf~ 3ffi ~f1fflq<1 fcrf~ cfi: ~ ~

CfiT fqf1f:<'l:l(l ~ ~ ~Cf?'Rlf141 ffl<&l"ff . Cfil

· "~Jrfif1rcnctl Cfil ~ ~ 1 'B"mf if. ~"ff{f~14

m~ fcrf~ 3fu: ~ fcrf~ Cfil 31j)$1Y)<:ffi(ll Cfi1 cp:ff

qf<qr2l "% ? 311R mR qft m qft ~ -B fcmG

~~I

P.T.O.
 ( 6 ) 7934

6. Explain the extent of territorial sea and contiguous zone and -

the rights enjoyed by the states in these areas~ Explain how

is straight baseline system applied to measure territorial waters

with the help of Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries case. 20

~~ ~ am ~ P$r qft ~ am ~
l$0 -# ~ &ro an'tl~ an~ Cfi1 ~ ~ 1
~ •uaf\il~"1 Ni~1:ih1 ~ cn1 ~ ~ ~~
~ ~ +wR .~ ~ $ ~fl<:11~1 fm:c:tr Cfi1 .~
)lqiR "<:1rl f<fi<rr \iiTffi t- . ?
7. (a) Briefly comment on the influence cast upon the

UNCLOS, 1982 by the North Sea Continental Shelf

cases on delimitation of adjacent and opposite maritime

boundaries. lO

(b) Comment on extra territorial jurisdiction of State. 10

<a:r) fl'l1q~ am ~ qft fllljF~Cfl ~an ~ qf<'8l'l1

en: "1M m Cflic.1~o:c<:1 ~ ~ &ro ~v;r.m.

~.m.~., 1982 en: ~ ~ "Srmc~ en: m~

fccquft ~I

C~) . ~ ~ 3ifuRCRt ~~ ~ en: R:o:ruTt

~I
 ( 7 ) 7934

· 8. What are the three generation human rights ? Discuss in detail

the implementation of the human rights recognised by the

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966 and

the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural

Rights, 1966. 20

(fR ~ liRC1 aTitfcfiR q:<:rr ~ ? $c:<~~l1(1 CfiT~~;:c:

3lR fufcR1 "tis qTffifc:Cfi("l ~~ 1966 afu: ~;:c:<~~l1(1

CfiT~~;:c: 3lR ~Cf>"H"If"!Cfi, ~ "tis <:6~<(1 ~~ 1966

IDU '"il'""lldiSIICCI liRCf aTI~ ~ Cfil4foq41 Cfi1 ~fct«ll<

fcrh:.R ~I

7934 7 3,100
[This question paper contains 4 printed pages.]

7974 Your Roll No.

J1TTFfiT Jlj¢fi Jf/ 'en ............. .

LL.B./II Term ES

Paper LB- 205 - PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW- I

Time: 3 Hours Maximum Marks : 100

tf7{ll : 3 r:rut ~ . 100

(Write your Roll No. on the top immediately

on receipt of this question paper.)

(~ rnrr- rrn- cfi" (it(;ffi- "it ~ ~ w Frufftrr

~ W J1fRT Jfpi Jf/Cn ~I)

Note :- Answers may be written either in English or in Hindi;

but the same medium should be used throughout the
paper.

~: - ~ rnrr- rrn- w 'JrT( aWiifr 'IT fff;:#t M VC'fl ~

~ ~; ~ ~ 3rTif CfiT 7flt7flf VC'fi
."it 'iFfr ~ I

Attempt five questions.

All questions carry equal marks.

~ .qro m ct 'JrT( ~1
rim ct afffi ~ ~~
P.T.O.
7974 2

1. Can Article 38 of the Statute of ICJ (International

Court of Justice) be regarded as a complete statement
of the sources of international law ? Discuss in detail.
(20)

CfliT 3l"*HT~ll "'lllll1<1ll ctt ~ ~ ~ 38 en) 3l"ff~I~ll

fctlU ~ m- ~ 1fUl
"'
fctcRuT ~ -m ~ ~ ~ ~ t ?

2. (a) Discuss the Constitutional provisions on treaty

making and its implementation in India.

(b) Discuss the role of Indian judiciary in the

effectuation of international legal obligations.
(10x2=20)

(en)~~ mu cnR 3fu: ~ w:ffi;r ~ ~ ~ ~

~Cj)f~~l

(~) 3RRYt{lll ~ ~arr ~ Cflltll""''ll'1 ~ ~ "'llrt~qrR\q:;r

ctl~C!1T~~I
"'

3. (a) Is individual the subject of international law?

Explain.

(b) Does UN possess a legal personality in international

law? Discuss with special reference to the
Reparation for Injuries Case ( 1949).
(10x2=20)

(en) CfliT ~ 3l"f!U~ll fctlU C!1T ~ t ?~ ~r

7974 3

(~) CfliT 31"*Rl'{)ll fctfU ~ ~ ~ ~ oqRfi~ mta" t ?

~WR:~~ (1949) ct~~~~
~I

4. What is Continental Shelf? Discuss the rules

applicable in the delimitation of continental shelf
between opposite and adjacent states. (20)

JJ61~<llll ~ CfliT ~ .g ? ~ 3ltt ~ ~ ct ~

JJ6i~<llll ~ ct qf«f!JJ"1 1R ~ ~ Cfi"R ~ CfiT ~
~I

5. (a) What are the Constituent elements of international

responsibility ? Explain the different forms of
reparation.

(b) Discuss the straight baseline method for the

measurement of the breadth of territorial sea.
(1 0X2=2Q)

{Cfi) ;ji"*i<T'{)ll \h'1<GI!ll~ ct ~ m:cT CfliT t ? ~· ct

~w'cnl~~~

(~) ~~ ~ cfit ~ ct lWFf ~ * ~~('11~"1 ~

CfiT~~I

6. Examine the role, functions and powers of the UN

Human Rights Council. (20)

P.T.O.
7974 4

~~ l{RCf 3rlUcnR -crrn cfiT ~ ~ ~ ~

cfil~~l

7. (a) Distinguish between extradition and asylum.

(b) Comment on Diplomatic immunities. (10x2=20)

8. Answer any two of the following :

(a) Sanctions determine the effectiveness of

international law. Comment.

(b) The ships of all states enjoy a right of innocent

passage in the territorial waters of coastal states.
Comment.

(c) Exclusive Economic Zone. (1QX2=2Q)

Pl~R!Rc:la ~ ~ ~ en cfi ~ ~:
(Cfi} 3i'"~Hlt<{)4 fctfU cfiT ~ qiT ~ ~ ~ ~ I

~~I

(\Cf) ~ M cfi lffif ~ M cfi ~~ ~ ~ RGlisr

+rnf cfi ~ CfiT ~ ~ ~ I fta:rolt ~ I

(<r} ~ ~ et;r I
(200)