AB105 Organizational Behavior and Design

Semester 1, AY 2010-2011

Case Critical Thinking Rubric

Name: _____________________ Seminar Group Number: _________________

(1) Identifies and summarizes the key information from the case situation

Unsatisfactory Very good

Does not identify and summarize the key Comprehensive identification and summary of key
information, is confused or represents the information from the case, including its implicit aspects.
information inaccurately.

Unsatisfactory Very good

(2) Integrates facts, knowledge of appropriate organizational concepts, and insights in analyzing the
situation

Unsatisfactory Very good

Fails to identify appropriate case facts to support Identifies appropriate case facts to support the case situation
the case situation analysis using organizational analysis and integrates the facts and knowledge with insights
behavior concepts into the situation

Unsatisfactory Very good

(3) Identifies the influence of the context on the issue.

Unsatisfactory Very good

Does not examine the effects of contexts, e.g., Comprehensive examination of the effects of context on the
cultural, and political on the case situation analysis case situation analysis

Unsatisfactory Very good

(4) Provides logically derived recommendations for action in the situation

Unsatisfactory Very Good

Failed to provide any recommendations that are Provides recommendations that are selected based on prior
logically derived from prior evaluation of issue. evaluation of situation including contextual issues as well as
the trade-offs in implementation of those actions

Unsatisfactory Very good

Overall Grade =