Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FOREWORD..................................................................................................................................................ix
X
1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................. 1
i
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
17 CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................93
18 REFERENCES ...................................................................................................................................95
iii ii
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2-1: Effects of Delayed Maintenance........................................................................ 4
Figure 7-6 : Bridge Rating for all roads on the CRN ........................................................ 53
iv
iii
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
LIST OF TABLES
Table 3-1: Maintenance Challenges and Rating .................................................................. 8
Table 6-1: Shared Network Responsibility ....................................................................... 11
Table 6-2: Condition Rating Criteria for Paved Roads .................................................... 13
Table 6-3: Proposed IRI Condition Criteria ..................................................................... 13
Table 7-1: Network Prioritization .................................................................................... 16
Table 7-2: Short to medium term targets for rehabilitation (ZNS) ................................. 18
Table 7-3: Short to medium term primary feeder roads maintenance strategies ........... 20
Table 7-4: Primary Feeder Roads Network by Region .................................................... 25
Table 7-5: Primary Feeder Roads Network by Region .................................................... 25
Table 7-6: OPRC Roll out strategies ................................................................................ 26
Table 7-7: Short to Medium term Funding Requirements for Maintenance and
Rehabilitation of Primary Feeder Roads (ZNS) ........................................................ 28
Table 7-8: Short to Medium Target Kilometers for Maintenance and Rehabilitation of
Primary Feeder Roads (ZNS) ................................................................................... 29
Table 7-9: Long term Funding Requirements for rehabilitation of Primary Feeder Roads
– OPRC ..................................................................................................................... 30
Table 7-10: Long term Target Kilometers for rehabilitation and maintenance of Primary
Feeder Roads – OPRC ............................................................................................. 32
Table 7-11: Long term Target Kilometers for rehabilitation and maintenance of Primary
Feeder Roads – OPRC Cont’d ................................................................................. 33
Table 7-12: Urban Road Network on the CRN .............................................................. 34
Table 7-13: Implementation Strategy for the Urban Roads Network ............................. 39
Table 7-14: Funding Requirements for the rehab of paved urban roads ......................... 42
Table 7-15: Long term Funding Requirements for Maintenance of Paved Urban Roads. 43
Table 7-16: Long term Funding Requirements for Maintenance of Paved Urban Roads
Cont’d ....................................................................................................................... 44
Table 7-17: Long term Funding Requirements for Maintenance of Paved Urban Roads
Cont’d ....................................................................................................................... 45
Table 7-18: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban
roads ......................................................................................................................... 46
Table 7-19: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban
roads Cont’d ............................................................................................................. 47
Table 7-20: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban
roads Cont’d ............................................................................................................. 48
Table 7-21: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban
roads Cont’d ............................................................................................................. 49
Table 7-22: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory ........................................ 50
Table 7-23: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory on District Roads by
Province .................................................................................................................... 51
iv
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-24: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory on PFR by Province........ 52
Table 7-25: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory on the Urban Roads by
Province .................................................................................................................... 52
Table 7-26: Ratings Descriptions ...................................................................................... 53
Table 7-27: Ratings Descriptions ...................................................................................... 53
Table 7-28: Summary of structures on the CRN ............................................................. 55
Table 8-1: Emergency Preparedness Strategy .................................................................. 64
Table 8-2: Emergency Response Strategy......................................................................... 67
Table 8-3: Response Category.......................................................................................... 68
Table 10-1: Frequency of Inspections on the CRN .......................................................... 72
Table 12-1: Projected Local Resource Revenues (ZMW’million) .................................... 76
Table 12-2: Projected Road Sector Cash-flows 2015 to 2024 (High Case Scenario)
(ZMW’million) .......................................................................................................... 78
Table 12-3: Resource Mobilization Strategies .................................................................. 79
Table 12-4: Risk Mitigation Strategies .............................................................................. 81
Table 13-1: Research and Development Strategies.......................................................... 87
Table 14-1: Research and Development Strategies.......................................................... 89
Table 15-1: Maintenance Management Monitoring Framework ...................................... 90
vi
v
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
ABBREVIATIONS
AM Asset Management
vii
vi
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
ZA Zambia Army
viii
vii
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
VISION
The vision of the RDA is to be the leading Road Authority in Africa that is providing a
world class Road Network in Zambia. Provision of this world class road network
involves the improvement of the riding quality and safety of the network as well as
increasing its structural strength.
MISSION
The Strategic Mission of the RDA is to provide a World Class Road Network that
supports socio-economic growth in Zambia.
ix
viii
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
FOREWORD
It is well known that a well-maintained and efficient road network is an essential pre-
condition to economic development. There is a strong correlation between kilometers
travelled and the gross national income. Roads play a critical role to industry,
agriculture, and commerce by providing a means of transportation of goods and
services. Ever since independence in 1964, considerable amounts of funds have been
invested in the construction and improvement of the road network. It is safe to
conclude that roads are essentially big business and a catalyst to economic development
which should be managed efficiently and effectively.
For a very long time now, the road sector has been preoccupied with the construction
and upgrading of roads with very little emphasis being given to maintenance. The cost of
not carrying out timely maintenance on the network is ultimately borne by the Road
Users. A study has revealed that for every dollar that a country fails to spend on
maintenance results in three dollars being spent by road users in increased vehicle
operating costs as a result of the poor road conditions (Gwilliam and Shalizi, 1996). The
resulting impact on the economy is increased costs on industry and commerce. In order
therefore to ensure sustainability of road transport network, it is essential that
maintenance becomes the number one priority alongside other developmental
programmes. Road network development can only be effective if it ensures that there is
a continuing capability to support the development, a contribution to the general quality
of life and the equitable sharing of benefits to various sections of communities.
This Road Maintenance Strategy is designed to create a clear pathway for the provision
of road maintenance activities on the Core Road Network (CRN). The RMS is geared
towards ensuring that there is timely implementation and improved quality of
maintenance on the CRN, which will enhance the life span of roads and related
infrastructure. This will have the added benefit of reducing the vehicle operating costs to
the road users and also contribute to general job creation in the road sector. More so,
it will contribute to increasing the capacity of the local contracting industry.
Willie Nsanda
ROAD DEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD CHAIRMAN
x
ix
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The development of this Road Maintenance Strategy was achieved with the involvement
and participation of the following key staff listed below.
Lastly, I wish to thank the Road Development Agency Senior Management Staff for the
invaluable input that they made in the formulation of this Road Maintenance Strategy.
xi
x
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Road Maintenance Strategy is aimed at setting a pathway for the provision of
maintenance activities on the Core Road Network (CRN). This will in turn create an
atmosphere that will ensure that the roads are properly maintained thus promoting
economic growth and development. Road Maintenance has consistently remained a
challenge despite the formulation of Road Sector Programmes such as the Road Sector
Investment Programmes (Phase I and II) of 1998 and 2003. The Road Sector has for a
long time since independence being pre-occupied with major construction and upgrading
works on the network at the expense of the much needed road maintenance. This road
Maintenance Strategy is based on maintenance activities relevant to the Zambian
environment and is tailored for execution of maintenance works by either in-house
units, by contracts based on unit rates or by Output and Performance-Based Road
Contracts (OPRC).
Condition Assessment
Through a systematic method of road and bridge data inventory and data collection, the
RDA will have up- to- date information for decision making on maintenance priorities
for both roads and bridges including minor and major culverts. Furthermore, the RDA
will ensure that regular inspections for defects are conducted on the CRN whose
intervals will be guided through the road and bridge hierarchy. The RDA recognizes the
importance of data to the decision making process. Network Level inventory and
condition data will be outsourced while scheduled inspections will be conducted in-
house.
The programming of maintenance activities on the Trunk Main and District Roads will
be based on the Zambia Highway Management System (ZHMS). The Bridge Management
System (BMS) will be used to prioritize bridge maintenance activities. The RDA will
employ a multi-criteria system for the prioritization of the lower order roads such as
the Primary Feeder Roads. The maintenance of the Urban Roads will be under the sole
charge of the respective Local Road Authorities (LRAs) under the Ministry of Local
Government and Housing (MLGH).
Emergency Planning
The RMS has also adopted a more proactive approach to dealing with emergencies
through the development of comprehensive Emergency Preparedness and Response
strategies. Emergencies will be addressed based on the determined level of risk. The
xii
xi
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Emergency Response Strategy has assigned a reaction time for each level of risk on the
CRN to the Road Users.
Asset Management
Strict adherence to Asset Management principles will go a long way to ensuring that
resources for maintenance are applied optimally to realize value from the Road Assets.
The approach to Asset Management will improve on stewardship and accountability;
communication and relationships with service users; risk management and financial
efficiency.
Performance Management
The RDA will develop Maintenance Manuals based on best practice to ensure that
maintenance is carried out timely and to the best quality.
The RMS has defined the required service levels on the different classes of roads based
on the traffic composition. These Service Levels will guide on how long defects on the
CRN can be tolerated and when best to effect remedial measures.
Resources are critical to the carrying out of maintenance activities on the CRN. It is
therefore essential that funds earmarked for maintenance are used solely for that
purpose. The RMS therefore impresses on need to use the Road Fund to finance all
maintenance activities while Capital Investments Funds can be used to carry out Capital
Projects.
xiii
xii
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Risk Management
Risk Management will assist the RDA to identify and deal with the risks that threaten
our plans and impact upon the continuation of service delivery. The risk assessment will
cover Risk identification, Risk evaluation and Risk impact.
xiv
xiii
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
1 INTRODUCTION
For the purpose of management of the public roads network, the RDA has delegated
some responsibility to Local Road Authorities in line with Section20 (1) (2) (3) and
Section 73 (1) of the Public Roads Act No. 12 of 2002 which states as follows:
(1) The Minister may, on the recommendation of the Agency, by statutory order, appoint
any person or institution as a road authority in respect of any public road
(2) The road authority appointed under subsection (1) shall be responsible for the
construction, care and maintenance of the roads specified in the statutory order.
(3) All expenses incurred in the construction, care and maintenance of roads, for which the
road authority appointed under subsection (1) is responsible, shall be paid under the
Fund.
Following the nationalization of the copper mines in 1972, there was a sharp economic
decline that led to the inadequate resources being available for road maintenance. Thus
due to inadequate maintenance, most of the roads had deteriorated sharply by the late
1
1
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
due to inadequate maintenance, most of the roads had deteriorated sharply by the late
1980s. Coupled with ever dwindling revenue for the country caused by low copper and
high fuel prices and depreciation of the Kwacha (Raballand and Whitworth, 2012), it
became increasingly difficult for Government to finance the repair of the road network
from its annual budgets.
A road condition survey conducted in 1995 on 8,800 km of Trunk, Main and District
(TMD) roads revealed that only 20 per cent were in ‘good’ condition (World Bank,
1997), 29 per cent ‘fair’ and 51 per cent ‘poor’. In addition, 90 per cent of feeder roads
were in ‘poor’ condition. A recent road condition survey of 2013 on 40,454 km of the
Core Road Network (CRN) revealed that 72 per cent of Primary Feeder Roads (PFR)
was still in poor condition while the composite condition of the TMD network has seen
some slight improvements with 56 per cent good, 21.5 per cent fair and 22.5 per cent
poor (RDA Condition Report, 2013). This improvement is largely due to major
rehabilitation and reconstruction works in the past decade. There is still a need for
more emphasis on maintenance of the existing road network to cut down on the high
cost of major rehabilitation and maintenance works. This will be best achieved through
the development of a comprehensive Road Maintenance Strategy (RMS) that will ensure
that there is timely execution of maintenance activities on the road network.
2
2
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Postponing road maintenance is not a favorable option as it will result in high costs to
the road users. A study has revealed that for every one (01) dollar that a country fails to
spend on road maintenance results in three (03) dollars being spent by road users in
increased VOCs as a result of the poor road conditions (Gwilliam and Shalizi, 1996). The
longer that maintenance is delayed, the more costly it becomes to restore the road to
good condition. The repair costs can rise to six (06) times maintenance costs after three
(03) years of neglect and to eighteen (18) times after five (05) years of neglect. A study
has shown that in Sub-Saharan Africa, for every kilometer of road rehabilitated, an
3
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
estimated three (03) kilometers of roads fall into disrepair, leading to a net deterioration
in the total road network (World Bank, 2003). The situation is similar in many other
developing countries. It is thus imperative that adequate and timely road maintenance is
undertaken. Figure 2-1 shows the effects of delayed maintenance on the road network.
In the Zambian situation, there has been an over emphasis on new construction and/or
reconstruction of roads over maintenance. This situation has led to a steady increase in
the backlog of road repairs and a loss of development impact. One major example is the
T002 from Serenje to Nakonde which has not received timely maintenance hence the
deterioration to alarming levels especially for the section between Chinsali and Nakonde
towns. Zambia cannot afford to allow its major regional trunk routes to deteriorate to
such levels. Poor road condition can act as a deterrent to economic development by
increasing the transport costs as well as slowing the progress of regional integration.
4
4
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
climate and the environment. Eventually the end of a pavement design life will be reached
and there is a need for pavement renewal. This is normally a relatively expensive activity
and should therefore be postponed for as long as possible by carrying out effective and
timely maintenance.
With this in mind, this Road Maintenance Strategy (2015-2024) has been produced to set
a clear pathway for the provision of Road Maintenance services within Zambia. This is in
line with RDA’s statutory mandate (Public Roads Act, 2002), Vision and Mission as
contained in the RDA Strategic Plan (2012-2016).
5
5
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
3 SITUATION ANALYSIS
500.00
400.00
300.00
200.00 156.00 154.40
100.00 67.40
-
.2012 .2013 .2014
From Figure 3-1 above, it can be seen that in 2012, only 22 per cent of the maintenance
budget requirements were met while as little as 9 per cent and 21 percent were met for
the years 2013 and 2014 respectively. As a result of these financing gaps, in 2012 only
8,786.90km of the targeted 18,342.53km of maintenance was achieved (RSAWP, 2013).
6
6
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
There has been an over emphasis in carrying out new construction and upgrade works
at the expense of carrying out timely routine and periodic maintenance. This situation
has left the bulk of the CRN unattended to. The worst affected network has been the
PFR network which has not seen any significant improvement in condition and
passability.
The budgetary allocations for maintenance are way below the required maintenance
needs. Section 3.1 above clearly describes the financing gap for maintenance for the
period between 2012 and 2014.
The protracted procurement process has negatively affected the timely implementation
of maintenance activities on the road network. In addition, the statutory requirement for
the review of contract documentation by the office of the Attorney General has also
contributed to delayed implementation of projects. Delays in the clearing of these
contracts can even take up to 3 or 4 months.
This refers to inadequate capacity (in terms of low staffing levels in regions, tools such as
maintenance manuals and cycle maintenance equipment) to effectively carry out
maintenance on force account and also monitoring routine and periodic maintenance
activities on the CRN.
The Road sector has of late witnessed dwindling quality of services offered by
Consultants especially in supervision services and defective designs which have resulted
in cost overruns, delayed maintenance due to time extensions and inadequate
monitoring of Contractors.
The current pool of local contractors lack technical capacity in carrying out some
maintenance works. This has also resulted in delayed project implementation, cost
overruns and general poor quality of work.
7
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
These factors were ranked to determine their weighting on road maintenance in Zambia.
Table 3-1presents the ratings and weighting of the maintenance challenges:
These ratings were then mapped on a Spider Web Chart as shown in Figure 3-2below:
0
Over emphasis on up-grades Poor Quality of Consultants’
and construction High Service Medium
8
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The primary goal of this RDA Road Maintenance Strategy (RMS) is to ensure that the
Core Road Network is in a maintainable state for sustainable economic growth and
development.
1. To ensure that 100 per cent of the paved TMD is in good condition by 2024;
2. To ensure greater than 80 per cent of the unpaved TMD is in good condition by
2024;
3. To ensure that greater than 90 per cent of the paved Urban Roads is in good
condition by 2024;
4. To ensure that greater than 80 per cent of the unpaved Urban Roads is in good
condition by 2024;
5. To ensure that greater than 80 per cent of the Primary Feeder Roads is in good
condition by 2024;
6. Ensuring that the Road User Charges are dedicated to road maintenance by
2018;
7. Application of the Output and Performance Based Road Contract system for
road maintenance by 2016; and
8. To create 15,000 new job opportunities annually through the Road Maintenance
Strategy by 2020.
9
9
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Network Definition
Emergency Planning
Road Maintenance Strategy
Asset Management
Performance Management
Risk Management
10
10
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
6 Network Definition
The RDA is mandated by the Public Roads Act of 2002 to provide care and maintenance for
the entire Public Roads Network as defined under Part II Section 4. However, owing to the
vast size of the network, and limited resources, the RDA has concentrated its efforts on a
1
Road classes according to Road Act 2002
2
Road length assessed in the WB-supported Road sector Investment Programme (RoadSIP) II
3
Road lengths included in the Primary Feeder Roads
4
Estimate of unclassified road network ranges between 7,000 and 10,000. The upper limit has been used in the
above estimate.
11
11
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
rationalized network of 40,454km deemed as the Core Road Network (CRN). The CRN is
defined under the Road SIP II bankable document as the “the barest minimum network which
when improved will spur economic development and contribute to poverty reduction". Consequently,
the RDA has been allocating resources through its Annual Work Plans (AWPs) to the CRN in
order to achieve the main objectives of Road SIP II.
The resources for the AWPs arise from local and external sources. The local resources
comprise the Road Fund (Fuel Levy and Other Road User Charges), Toll Fees and direct
Government funding from the Treasury.
The CRN is in varying levels of condition. The condition is based on a rating criterion that is
used in the Zambia Highway Management System (ZHMS). Condition is reported in terms of
good, fair and poor based on an International Roughness Index (IRI) which is a measure of the
ride quality. The paved road condition is given in Table 6-2.
12
12
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
According to a road network condition survey conducted on the CRN in 2013 (RDA
Condition Report, 2013), 85 per cent of the paved TMD network was in good condition while
13 per cent and 2 per cent were in fair and poor condition respectively. Similarly for the
unpaved TMD network, 12 per cent was in good condition while 70 per cent and 18 per cent
was in fair and poor condition respectively.
About 72 per cent of the unpaved Primary Feeder Roads were in poor condition with only 18
and 10 per cent in fair and good condition respectively. The Urban roads on the other hand
recorded 49 per cent in good condition while 32 and 19 per cent was in poor and fair
conditions respectively. Figure 6-1 shows the summary of the CRN condition as of 2013.
Good
85% Fair
70%
13
13
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Poor Fair
72% 19%
Good Fair Poor Good Fair Poor
The data collected on the network during the visual surveys is grouped into the following
categories:
14
14
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Condition Surveys
--
Road condition data includes the capture of the visual condition rating data at 500m
intervals for all roads. The condition guidelines are described in Annex 3 of the Data
Collection Procedures Manual for the CRN (DCPM, 2013). Condition data IS collected
using the ROMDAS key code programmable keyboard.
15
15
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road classification;
Traffic volumes; and
Social economic factors – access to schools, hospitals and public facilities etc
The priority ranking for maintenance on the CRN will be as shown in Table 7-1:
The annual allocation of the Road Fund for road maintenance will be distributed as outlined in
Table 7.1.
Routine maintenance activities on the TMD network will be based on three (03) year
Performance Based Contracts (PBC). The criterion for the selection of roads for routine
maintenance will be based on road condition data as analyzed and assessed by the RDA
Planning and Design directorate. All TMDs in good and fair condition will be placed on routine
maintenance (RoadSIP II, 2003). In addition, all newly constructed and rehabilitated roads will
be placed on routine maintenance after completion. The criteria for good and fair for paved
and unpaved TMDs is fully described in Chapter 6, Section 6.3.1, Table 6-2 and Table 6-3
respectively. These contracts will be administered by the Regional Managers.
16
16
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
The Primary Feeder Roads Network in Zambia plays a critical role to farming communities in
rural areas by providing access to transportation for the movement of farm produce from
farms sites to marketing centres. They also feed into the Trunk, Main and District Roads
Network. Agriculture is an important part of the livelihoods of many poor people, and it is
frequently argued that agricultural growth is a fundamental pre-requisite for widespread
poverty reduction. Furthermore, the contribution of agriculture to GDP is higher today, than
what it was at independence in 1964. Investment into the improvement of Primary Feeder
Roads can have an impact on poverty through various channels. It can contribute to increased
agricultural productivity, which in turn directly increases farm incomes and helps reduce rural
poverty. Thus improved provision of rural feeder roads can lead to lower transaction and
farm production costs, while facilitating trading of cash crops and fostering long-run economic
growth that contribute to the expansion of the economy.
Over the years, the condition of the Primary Feeder Roads (PFR) has deteriorated
significantly. According to the 2013 Road Network Condition Survey Report about 72 per
cent of the PFR were in poor condition with only 28 per cent in good and fair condition. In
2011, 77 percent of the network was in poor condition. The survey results of 2013 also
showed that only 74.4 per cent of this network is passable by a 2-wheel drive vehicle while
the remaining 25 percent is impassable for the most part of the year. This condition is a
deterrent to the movement of goods and services on these roads thus negatively impacting
agriculture and tourism activities. The PFR network is in dire need of road rehabilitation and
maintenance to guarantee a high degree of passability throughout the year to contribute to
economic development and poverty reduction.
The Government of Zambia is seeking to increase the efficiency and effectiveness with which
the management and maintenance of the PFR network. This is further motivated by the
recognition that the road network constitutes the single largest asset owned by the
Government, and that a less-than-optimal system for the management and maintenance of
17
17
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
that asset generally results in huge losses for the national economy. This occurs not only in
the form of road deterioration and massive reductions in road asset value, but even more so
in the form of increased vehicle operation costs (VOCs) which have to be borne by road
users and which reduce the competitiveness of any given country in an increasingly global
economy.
This Road Maintenance Strategy Paper has proposed two main measures to deal with the
poor state of the PFR Network. The strategies comprise short to medium and long term
measures.
Inorder to address the immediate maintenance needs requirements on the PFR network, the
RDA will employ services of the Zambia National Service (ZNS) for the rehabilitation of PFR
in poor condition. The RDA will appoint ZNS as a Local Road Authority (LRA) on the PFR in
accordance with the Public Roads Act No. 12 of 2002 Section 20 (1) (2) (3) and Section 73
(1). In facilitating the services of ZNS, RDA will enter into Memorandum of Understanding
(MoU) with ZNS which will see the purchase and handover of major road equipment through
the 2015 Road Sector Annual Work Plan (RSAWP) by RDA to ZNS. It is estimated that the
short to medium term rehabilitation works by ZNS will cost US$918million while the
maintenance works will cost US$628 million. The programme will cover a total of
9,991km from the total of 15,386km.The remaining network will be covered under the
long term approach which will be discussed in detail in Section 7.33.
The targeted kilometers for rehabilitation and maintenance in the short to medium term is
given in Table 7-2below:
18
18
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
2. Signing of a MOU between RDA and ZNS by March 20, 2015 for the period between
2015 and 2018;
3. ZNS to develop comprehensive short to medium term plan for the rehabilitation and
maintenance of 15,330km of the PFR Network by April 20, 2015; and
4. Allocate resources for purchase of maintenance equipment for use by ZNS on PFR
Network in 2015 RSAWP by October 10, 2014.
The details on how these strategies will be achieved are outlined in Table 7-3.
19
19
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-3: Short to medium term primary feeder roads maintenance strategies
No. Strategies Lead From To Department Supporting How
Agency Responsible Institution
1 Appoint ZNS as a RDA/ZNS 2015 2018 Planning & Design NRFA Appointment to be done in
Road Authority by accordance with the Public Roads
November 30, Act of 2002
2014 for the
period between
2015 and 2018
2 MOU between RDA 2015 2018 Planning & Ministry of Planning & Design and Maintenance
RDA and ZNS by Design/Maintenance/ Justice Departments to develop MOU by
February 27, 2015 Legal January 16, 2015
for the period Legal Department to review MOU
between 2015 and by January 23, 2015
2018 Board Approval of the MOU by
February 6, 2015
Attorney General‘s office to review
and approve MOU by February 20,
2015
3 ZNS to develop ZNS/RDA 2015 2018 Planning & RRU/MLGH/ RDA/RRU/MLGH/RTSA / to review
comprehensive Design/Maintenance RTSA and approve the plan by ZNS by
short to medium March 31, 2015.
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
20
20
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
21
21
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
7.3.3 Long Term Strategy-Output and Performance Based Road Contracts (OPRC)
The long- term approach for addressing maintenance needs of the PFR Network is the use of
the Output and Performance Based Road Contracts (OPRC) System. The RDA future
collaboration with the World Bank going forward from the year 2015 is largely focused on a
sustainable maintenance regime for the PFR Network through the use of the OPRC system.
The RDA with funding support from the World Bank intends to roll out the OPRC system on
the PFR Network commencing in the year 2016. This roll out will be preceded by a detailed
design and packaging of the entire PFR Network in 2015.
The OPRC is a concept designed to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of road
maintenance operations. It is designed to ensure that the physical condition of the roads
under contract is adequate for the need of road users, over the entire period of the contract,
which is normally several years. This type of contract significantly expands the role of the
private sector, from the simple execution of works to the management and conservation of
the road assets. This approach will avoid a premature deterioration of road assets in general,
and ensure that road users are accorded a level of service, which is adequate for their needs
and at the same time keeping costs down for providing those service levels.
The RDA has implemented similar contracts in two (02) phases. The first phase or the ‗first
generation‘ took place on a large scale (countrywide) from 2006 to 2010 covering3,372km of
unpaved Main and District Roads. The European Union (EU) had supported the National Road
Fund Agency (NRFA) through a sector budget support facility totalling just over €70 million
released over a 5-year period. The support was targeted at clearing backlog periodic
maintenance on the road network. A total of 11 works contracts were entered into from
2006 to 2010 and work was carried out in all of the then 9 Provinces of Zambia (RDA:1,
2014).
22
22
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
The works packages were supervised by different Consultants and the Supervision costs were
low at an average of 3.5% of works cost. The average costs were estimated at US$12,400 per
km for rehabilitation and US$2,240 per km per year for maintenance however there were
large variations in the rates between contracts. It was clear that there was a lack of familiarity
with the new concept of OPRC, they were poorly designed, and there was an initial lack of
supervision and little emphasis on maintenance. Despite this, they were a source of steady
employment, the administration costs were low and an impact monitoring exercise carried
out by ASCO in 2009/2010 concluded that despite the obvious weaknesses there was a high
and beneficial impact amongst local communities.
A more detailed analysis of the problems and issues associated with the ‘first generation
OPRCs’ is as follows:
Poor preparation – The projects were prepared hurriedly with little or no survey
prior to preparation of the bidding documents. As a result, there were inaccuracies in
the bidding documents, which contributed to a lack of understanding and confusion.
Many of the project roads required almost complete reconstruction, which was not
catered for adequately in the documents and led to the failure of at least one contract.
Packaging – There was a wide variation in the lengths of roads chosen and also a
wide geographical dispersion of the roads. The provision for supervision was the same
for each package irrespective of the length of roads. Clearly there is a lesson to be
learnt regarding the optimal packaging of these contracts in future.
Prequalification – The Contractors were not prequalified but tendering was
restricted to firms in Category 3 of National Council for Construction (NCC) or
above. In practice there were different approaches to sub-contracting and the use of
Contractor/Consultant joint ventures.
Pricing – The projects were not balanced in that the majority of the funds were paid
on the improvement works and insufficient funds were left for maintenance. In
addition due consideration was not paid to gravel haulage which is obviously a large
item of cost and some Contractors experienced high costs due to material shortages
in the vicinity.
Supervision Arrangements – It was certainly not ideal that the Contractors were
appointed before the Consultants and there were different interpretations regarding
the scope of their services and no guidance was given on setting up standard
monitoring procedures between the contracts. The amount of input in terms of man-
days was extremely limited in the Consultancy contracts especially considering the
large distances to be covered.
Traffic Volume and Composition – There was no consideration given to the
monitoring of the traffic volume and its composition, which could have been quite
easily built-in to the contracts. Instead a separate monitoring contract was carried out.
Specifications - The adopted performance specifications were limited and
emphasized travel speed as the primary indicator of road quality. Little consideration
was given to road defects such as rutting and corrugations. The target speeds were
23
23
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
quite low and could be achieved even if the roads were in poor condition. Target road
widths were not achieved in many cases. Lack of definition is clear from the wide
variation in interpretation between contracts.
Sustainability – It was considered that the average estimated maintenance cost of
US$2,400 per km per year was unsustainable for the National Road Fund Agency
(NRFA) and that further experience of the OPRC approach was required before
valued judgments on value for money can be made. It was considered that annual
maintenance costs would reduce as roads are brought into a stable condition and
Contractors become familiar with OPRC contract.
In 2006, a grant agreement was signed between the World Bank (WB) and the Government
of the Republic of Zambia (GRZ) for the Agricultural Development Support Programme
(ADSP), which aimed to promote agricultural development through various activities including
the improvement to road infrastructure in targeted districts. The Rural Road Improvement
Facility (RRIF) has been a major component of the ADSP and its objective was to ensure
agricultural development through year-round market access. The maintenance aspect was
built into the project design through the use of long-term OPRC contracts. The project was
managed by the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives and the RDA was the implementing
agency of the RRIF component.
In 2007, Consultants were appointed to carry out a comprehensive design for OPRC
contracts. Lesson learnt from the EU contracts were incorporated into the designs for the
OPRC contracts under ADSP. The Districts chosen for the interventions were
Chipata/Katete (one contract) and Lundazi in Eastern Province, Chongwe in Lusaka Province
and Choma in Southern Province. The Works were packaged into 4 Contracts, each with
150 to 300kms of road and the roads were chosen on the basis of selection by the district
authorities and subsequent survey (including video survey) of the roads.
The long term strategy is to roll out the OPRC on the PFR Network covering a total of
15,386km countrywide. The objectives of the OPRC Strategy are to ensure:
1. The PFR network is kept in a maintainable condition;
2. To improve accessibility to outlying areas and thereby stimulating agricultural
development; and
3. Jobs are created in rural areas in accordance with Government’s policy on
industrialization and job creation.
24
24
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
The PFR network will be divided into three (03) main regions as shown in Table 7-4 Table
7-4:for the purpose of the roll out.
The prioritization of the Primary Feeder Roads in the allotted regions will be based on a
detailed feasibility study and design which will be carried out independently by Consultants
commencing in Year 1 (2015). The component strategies are detailed in Table 7-6.
The OPRC Roll out programme is estimated at US$3.8 billion comprising US$1.15 billion
for rehabilitation and US$2.65 billion for maintenance for the period from 2015 to 2024.
The programme will cover the entire network of the PFR network of 15,386km. Detailed
costs are given in Table 7-9.
25
25
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
3 Roll out the OPRC contracts RDA 2016 2020 Construction World Procure Contractors by June
on the PFR Network and Bank/LRAs 30, 2016
Rehabilitation/
Maintenance/P
lanning &
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Design
26
26
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015
2014 - 2014
2024
27
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-7: Short to Medium term Funding Requirements for Maintenance and Rehabilitation of Primary Feeder Roads (ZNS)
2015 2016 2017 2018 Grand Total
Province Rehabilitation Maintenance Rehabilitation Maintenance Rehabilitation Maintenance Rehabilitation Maintenance Rehabilitation Maintenance
Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000
Central 33,062.74 2,241.08 23,143.92 13,261.99 16,531.37 18,772.45 9,847.69 24,282.90 82,585.71 58,558.42
Copperbelt 14,587.80 524.71 10,211.46 5,387.31 7,293.90 7,818.61 4,344.96 10,249.91 36,438.12 23,980.53
Eastern 47,574.59 3,125.43 33,302.22 18,983.62 23,787.30 26,912.72 14,170.03 34,841.82 118,834.13 83,863.59
Luapula 26,515.51 82.06 18,560.85 8,920.56 13,257.75 13,339.81 7,897.61 17,759.07 66,231.72 40,101.51
Lusaka 7,818.76 763.09 5,473.13 3,369.35 3,909.38 4,672.47 2,328.81 5,975.60 19,530.08 14,780.51
Muchinga 28,672.28 2,539.79 20,070.59 12,097.22 14,336.14 16,875.93 8,540.00 21,654.64 71,619.01 53,167.59
Northern 39,123.04 1,555.57 27,386.12 14,596.58 19,561.52 21,117.09 11,652.74 27,637.60 97,723.42 64,906.84
Northwestern 49,192.24 1,474.26 34,434.57 17,871.67 24,596.12 26,070.38 14,651.84 34,269.09 122,874.77 79,685.40
Southern 26,153.36 3,996.57 18,307.35 12,714.36 13,076.68 17,073.25 7,789.74 21,432.14 65,327.13 55,216.33
Western 46,792.56 450.24 32,754.79 16,047.76 23,396.28 23,846.52 13,937.10 31,645.28 116,880.73 71,989.79
Equipment 15,847.86 - - - - - - - -
Total 335,340.73 16,752.80 223,645.01 123,250.42 159,746.43 176,499.23 95,160.52 229,748.05 798,044.83 546,250.50
Supervision Costs 16,767.04 837.64 11,182.25 6,162.52 7,987.32 8,824.96 4,758.03 11,487.40 39,902.24 27,312.53
Operational Cost 33,534.07 1,675.28 22,364.50 12,325.04 15,974.64 17,649.92 9,516.05 22,974.80 79,804.48 54,625.05
Grand Total 385,641.84 19,265.72 257,191.76 141,737.99 183,708.40 202,974.12 109,434.59 264,210.25 917,751.55 628,188.08
28
28
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-8: Short to Medium Target Kilometers for Maintenance and Rehabilitation of Primary Feeder Roads (ZNS)
2015 2016 2017 2018 Grand Total
Province Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce
Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km
Central 414 84 290 498 207 705 123 912 1034 912
Copperbelt 183 20 128 202 91 294 54 385 456 385
Eastern 596 117 417 713 298 1011 177 1309 1488 1309
Luapula 332 3 232 335 166 501 99 667 829 667
Lusaka 98 29 69 127 49 176 29 224 245 224
Muchinga 359 95 251 454 179 634 107 813 897 813
Northern 490 58 343 548 245 793 146 1038 1223 1038
Northwestern 616 55 431 671 308 979 183 1287 1538 1287
Southern 327 150 229 478 164 641 98 805 818 805
Western 586 17 410 603 293 896 174 1189 1463 1189
Grand Total 4000 629 2800 4629 2000 6629 1191 8629 9991 8629
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
29
29
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-9: Long term Funding Requirements for rehabilitation of Primary Feeder Roads – OPRC
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce
Province
Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost
US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000
Central 14,169.74 - 23,616.24 4,723.25 28,091.16 12,595.33 9,192.84 42,899.90 7,354.27 42,899.90
Copperbelt 6,251.92 - 10,419.86 2,083.97 10,405.30 5,557.26 3,956.58 18,464.03 3,165.26 18,464.03
Eastern 20,389.11 - 33,981.85 6,796.37 39,995.30 18,123.65 13,206.47 61,630.17 10,565.17 61,630.17
Luapula 11,363.79 - 18,939.65 3,787.93 15,177.44 10,101.15 7,004.88 32,689.45 5,603.90 32,689.45
Lusaka 3,350.90 - 5,584.83 1,116.97 7,642.14 2,978.57 2,223.90 10,378.19 1,779.12 10,378.19
Muchinga 12,288.12 - 20,480.20 4,096.04 26,916.50 10,922.77 8,099.88 37,799.46 6,479.91 37,799.46
Northern 16,767.02 - 27,945.03 5,589.01 28,541.80 14,904.01 10,642.94 49,667.04 8,514.35 49,667.04
Northwestern 21,082.39 - 35,137.31 7,027.46 33,823.36 18,739.90 13,278.92 61,968.30 10,623.14 61,968.30
Southern 11,208.58 - 18,680.97 3,736.19 31,751.43 9,963.18 7,748.27 36,158.61 6,198.62 36,158.61
Western 20,053.95 - 33,423.26 6,684.65 28,092.95 17,825.74 12,427.13 57,993.28 9,941.71 57,993.28
Total 136,925.52 - 228,209.19 45,641.84 250,437.39 121,711.57 87,781.81 409,648.43 70,225.45 409,648.43
Supervision
6,846.28 - 11,410.46 2,282.09 12,521.87 6,085.58 4,389.09 20,482.42 3,511.27 20,482.42
Costs
Operational
13,692.55 - 22,820.92 4,564.18 25,043.74 12,171.16 8,778.18 40,964.84 7,022.54 40,964.84
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Cost
Grand Total 157,464.34 - 262,440.57 52,488.11 288,003.00 139,968.30 100,949.08 471,095.70 80,759.26 471,095.70
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
30
30
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Long term Funding Requirements for rehabilitation of Primary Feeder Roads – OPRC cont’d
2021 2022 2023 2024 Grand Total
Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce
Province
Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost
Cost US$'000 Cost US$'000
US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000 US$'000
Central 7,354.27 42,899.90 7,354.27 42,899.90 7,354.27 42,899.90 7,354.27 42,899.90 111,841.33 274,718.01
Copperbelt 3,165.26 18,464.03 3,165.26 18,464.03 3,165.26 18,464.03 3,165.26 18,464.03 46,859.96 118,425.38
Eastern 10,565.17 61,630.17 10,565.17 61,630.17 10,565.17 61,630.17 10,565.17 61,630.17 160,398.60 394,701.07
Luapula 5,603.90 32,689.45 5,603.90 32,689.45 5,603.90 32,689.45 5,603.90 32,689.45 80,505.28 210,025.75
Lusaka 1,779.12 10,378.19 1,779.12 10,378.19 1,779.12 10,378.19 1,779.12 10,378.19 27,697.36 66,364.70
Muchinga 6,479.91 37,799.46 6,479.91 37,799.46 6,479.91 37,799.46 6,479.91 37,799.46 100,184.24 241,815.58
Northern 8,514.35 49,667.04 8,514.35 49,667.04 8,514.35 49,667.04 8,514.35 49,667.04 126,468.52 318,495.24
Northwestern 10,623.14 61,968.30 10,623.14 61,968.30 10,623.14 61,968.30 10,623.14 61,968.30 156,437.67 397,577.19
Southern 6,198.62 36,158.61 6,198.62 36,158.61 6,198.62 36,158.61 6,198.62 36,158.61 100,382.34 230,651.01
Western 9,941.71 57,993.28 9,941.71 57,993.28 9,941.71 57,993.28 9,941.71 57,993.28 143,705.82 372,470.07
Total 70,225.45 409,648.43 70,225.45 409,648.43 70,225.45 409,648.43 70,225.45 409,648.43 1,054,481.13 2,625,243.99
Supervision
3,511.27 20,482.42 3,511.27 20,482.42 3,511.27 20,482.42 3,511.27 20,482.42 52,724.06 131,262.20
Costs
Operational
7,022.54 40,964.84 7,022.54 40,964.84 7,022.54 40,964.84 7,022.54 40,964.84 105,448.11 262,524.40
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Cost
Grand Total 80,759.26 471,095.70 80,759.26 471,095.70 80,759.26 471,095.70 80,759.26 471,095.70 1,212,653.30 3,019,030.59
31
31
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-10: Long term Target Kilometers for rehabilitation and maintenance of Primary Feeder Roads – OPRC
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Province Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce
Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km
Central 124.18 - 206.97 124.18 246.19 331.15 80.57 1,611.30 - 1,611.30
Copperbelt 54.79 - 91.32 54.79 91.19 146.11 34.68 693.50 27.74 693.50
Eastern 178.69 - 297.81 178.69 350.51 476.50 115.74 2,314.80 92.59 2,314.80
Luapula 99.59 - 165.98 99.59 133.01 265.58 61.39 1,227.80 49.11 1,227.80
Lusaka 29.37 - 48.94 29.37 66.97 78.31 19.49 389.80 15.59 389.80
Muchinga 107.69 - 179.49 107.69 235.89 287.18 70.99 1,419.73 56.79 1,419.73
Northern 146.94 - 244.91 146.94 250.14 391.85 93.27 1,865.47 74.62 1,865.47
Northwestern 184.76 - 307.94 184.76 296.42 492.70 116.38 2,327.50 93.10 2,327.50
Southern 98.23 - 163.72 98.23 278.27 261.95 67.91 1,358.10 54.32 1,358.10
Western 175.75 - 292.92 175.75 246.20 468.67 108.91 2,178.20 87.13 2,178.20
Grand 1,200.00 - 2,000.00 1,200.00 2,194.81 3,200.00 769.31 15,386.20 551.00 15,386.20
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
32
32
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-11: Long term Target Kilometers for rehabilitation and maintenance of Primary Feeder Roads – OPRC Cont’d
2021 2022 2023 2024 Grand Total
Province Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce Rehab Mtce
Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km Km
Central 64.45 1,611.30 64.45 1,611.30 64.45 1,611.30 64.45 1,611.30 851.26 1,611.30
Copperbelt 27.74 693.50 27.74 693.50 27.74 693.50 27.74 693.50 382.94 693.50
Eastern 92.59 2,314.80 92.59 2,314.80 92.59 2,314.80 92.59 2,314.80 1,313.12 2,314.80
Luapula 49.11 1,227.80 49.11 1,227.80 49.11 1,227.80 49.11 1,227.80 656.43 1,227.80
Lusaka 15.59 389.80 15.59 389.80 15.59 389.80 15.59 389.80 227.14 389.80
Muchinga 56.79 1,419.73 56.79 1,419.73 56.79 1,419.73 56.79 1,419.73 821.21 1,419.73
Northern 74.62 1,865.47 74.62 1,865.47 74.62 1,865.47 74.62 1,865.47 1,033.74 1,865.47
Northwestern 93.10 2,327.50 93.10 2,327.50 93.10 2,327.50 93.10 2,327.50 1,277.90 2,327.50
Southern 54.32 1,358.10 54.32 1,358.10 54.32 1,358.10 54.32 1,358.10 825.42 1,358.10
Western 87.13 2,178.20 87.13 2,178.20 87.13 2,178.20 87.13 2,178.20 1,172.29 2,178.20
Grand total 615.45 15,386.20 615.45 15,386.20 615.45 15,386.20 615.45 15,386.20 8,561.46 15,386.20
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
33
33
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
There has been a remarkable improvement in the condition of the paved urban road network
from 15 per cent good, 16 per cent fair and 69 per cent poor in 2009 to 49 per cent good, 19
per cent fair and 32 per cent poor in 2013 (RDA Condition Report, 2013). Figure 7-1 shows
the trend in condition of the paved urban road network. The improvement in the condition of
the urban road network can be attributed to the accelerated urban road rehabilitation
programmes that have been implemented on the urban road network from 2009 to date by
the RDA. However, there is still an increased need to preserve the investment that has been
made on the urban road network.
80
70
60
Condition (%)
50
40
30
20
10
0
2009 2011 2013
The composition of the Urban Roads on the CRN is given in Table 7-12
Table 7-12: Urban Road Network on the CRN
Province Length (Km)
Lusaka 1,663.50
Western 149.30
Northwestern 228.38
Copperbelt 2,118.40
Central 229.79
Southern 325.50
Luapula 201.04
Northern/ Muchinga 185.44
Eastern 192.38
Total 5,293.73
34
34
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
The planning, maintenance and management of the urban roads was delegated to Local
Authorities (City, Municipal and District Councils) in 2006, which fall under the Ministry of
Local Government and Housing (MLGH). The then Ministry of Works and Supply (MWS) had
signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Ministry of Local Government and
Housing (MLGH) in 2006 for the planning, maintenance and coordination of both Urban and
Feeder Roads in the Country. The MoU had spelt out the working relationships for RDA,
MLGH and the LRAs. This MoU has not been entirely effective ever since it was signed. The
following challenges have been experienced:
In addition to the challenges listed above, the financial capacities of these local road
authorities are also very limited and cannot fully support the construction, rehabilitation and
maintenance of roads under their jurisdiction. Councils collect revenue from rates and other
sources, but this income is barely sufficient to pay wages and salaries of their workers. This
situation has caused most of the urban roads to deteriorate to levels where most have not
been maintained for some considerable time.
MLGH, in an effort to compliment limited capacity of the Local Road Authorities, appointed
10 principal engineers to assist in the planning and execution of maintenance activities in the
respective regions. The RDA also has senior engineers in all the 10 provinces that are
responsible for coordinating activities for the Local Road Authorities. The organization
structure for the management of the urban roads is given in Figure 7-2.
35
35
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
RDA
MLGH
REGIONAL PRINCIPAL
MANAGERS ENGINEER-DHID
The lack of adequate funding for maintenance has also been supplemented through provisions
in the RDA Annual Work Plans (AWPs). Though, there have been these measures to address
the limited institutional capacity in funding and skills, there still remain a challenge in the
coordination of planning and maintenance activities for the urban road network. This lack of
institutional capacity by the Local Road Authorities has resulted in the RDA undertaking
maintenance activities on urban roads despite the delegated authority that has been granted.
The lack of adequate maintenance on urban roads has continued to escalate VOCs and the
cost of road transport related services. This has also contributed to the increased cost of
production. In addition to the input and VOCs; there are the added costs of accidents and
travel time. All these factors have a negative impact on the nations GDP.
There is currently no formal rational system for the prioritization of urban roads for
maintenance. There are no decision support systems to support how funds are been
distributed for maintenance of the urban roads on the CRN. Under this Road Maintenance
Strategy, a multi criteria approach for prioritization of maintenance activities on the urban
roads network will be used based on the following:
1. Road Condition;
2. Ranking of Town/City:
a) Cities
b) Provincial headquarters
36
36
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
c) Municipalities
d) Districts
3. Traffic volumes;
4. Access to social amenities;
5. Economic activities/potential;
6. Resource envelopes; and
7. Political input.
There currently a total of 103 Councils out of which 72 have been appointed as Local Road
Authorities. There is need to capacitate the LRAs with decision support systems that will
incorporate the multi-criteria approach highlighted above to assist in the prioritization
process. The decision support systems will assist in the development of short, medium and
long term maintenance plans. Figure 7-3 shows how the prioritization process will be
actualized in this Road Maintenance Strategy.
RDA Reviews
Consolidates the
Short, Medium and MLGH
Long Term Plans
Priority List
All roads that are in good and fair condition will be placed on routine maintenance in order to
preserve the investments into the road asset. The urban roads network will be split into
37
37
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
zones. The Local Road Authorities will spearhead the process of zoning the roads. A system
of area maintenance contracts will be used on the zones. The area maintenance contracts will
employ a performance based approach similar to the OPRC system. The Urban Roads
Maintenance activities will be managed and coordinated by Local Road Authorities in
collaboration with the RDA as shown in Figure 7-4.
LOCAL ROAD
AUTHORITY
ZONE -2 ZONE -N
ZONE -1
38
38
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
2 Enhancement of MTWSC/ML 2015 2024 Planning & EU Sector Training of Local Road
capacity of Local GH/RDA Design Budget Authorities
Road Authorities Support Production of Manuals and
through short and standards for maintenance
Improvement of working
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
39
39
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
recruitment of
personnel
3 Zoning of Urban RDA/MLGH Maintenance/Pla MLGH/NRFA Procure Consultant for
areas for area /LRAs nning & Design zoning and packaging of
maintenance maintenance contracts by
contracts June 30, 2015
Procuring of Supervision
Consultants by March 30,
2016
Procuring of Works
Contractors by March
30,2016
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
40
40
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015
2014 - 2014
2024
42
41
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-14: Funding Requirements for the rehab of paved urban roads
Total Rehab Cost (ZMW mn)
Total Rehab
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Rehab
Poor
cost per
No. Province Condition
km
(km)
(US$'000)
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
Length (km)
Length (km)
Length (km)
Length (km)
Length (km)
Length (km)
Length (km)
42
42
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-15: Long term Funding Requirements for Maintenance of Paved Urban Roads
2015 2016 2017 2018
Periodic Routine Periodic Routine Periodic Routine Periodic Routine
No. Province
Length Cost Cost Length Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost
Length (km) Length (km)
(km) (US$'000) (US$'000) (km) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000)
1 Central 17.40 1,516.45 596.21 83.72 - 2,093.12 139.72 - 3,493.12 139.72 - 3,493.12
Copperbe
2 183.59 16,001.88 7,442.19 572.11 - 14,302.65 662.94 - 16,573.49 753.77 - 18,844.32
lt
3 Eastern 20.06 1,748.81 22.50 34.96 - 874.09 34.96 - 874.09 34.96 - 874.09
4 Luapula 9.15 797.57 92.96 63.87 - 1,596.72 63.87 - 1,596.72 63.87 - 1,596.72
5 Lusaka 102.00 8,890.73 10,896.82 539.87 - 13,496.84 539.87 - 13,496.84 539.87 - 13,496.84
6 Muchinga 6.76 589.57 25.00 9.76 - 244.10 9.76 - 244.10 9.76 - 244.10
7 Northern 13.44 1,171.56 180.83 74.67 - 1,866.85 74.67 - 1,866.85 74.67 - 1,866.85
Northwes
8 9.24 805.14 177.54 19.34 - 483.46 19.34 - 483.46 19.34 - 483.46
tern
9 Southern 82.55 7,195.63 1,927.34 185.40 - 4,634.90 211.14 - 5,278.62 211.14 - 5,278.62
10 Western 10.25 893.68 478.25 33.38 - 834.57 33.38 - 834.57 33.38 - 834.57
Total Works 454.45 39,611.02 21,839.63 1,617.09 - 40,427.30 1,789.67 - 44,741.86 1,880.51 - 47,012.69
Supervision
1,980.55 1,091.98 - 2,021.37 - 2,237.09 - 2,350.63
Cost (5%)
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Grand Total 454.45 41,591.57 22,931.61 1,617.09 - 42,448.67 1,789.67 - 46,978.95 1,880.51 - 49,363.32
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
43
43
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-16: Long term Funding Requirements for Maintenance of Paved Urban Roads Cont’d
2019 2020 2021
Periodic Routine Periodic Routine Periodic Routine
No. Province
Length Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost
Length (km) Length (km)
(km) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000) (US$'000)
Grand Total 1,971.34 90,209.94 25,873.85 1,158.68 90,209.94 28,258.22 2,200.24 - 57,756.42
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
44
44
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-17: Long term Funding Requirements for Maintenance of Paved Urban Roads Cont’d
2022 2023 2024 Total Maintenance
Periodic Routine Periodic Routine Periodic Routine Routine Periodic
No. Province
Overall Overall
Length Cost Cost Length Cost Cost Length Cost Cost Length
(km) (US$'000) (US$'000) (km) (US$'000) (US$'000) (km) (US$'000) (US$'000)
Cost Cost
(km)
(US$) (US$)
1 Central 126 - 3,155 126 - 3,155 126 - 3,155 126 25,789 13,695
2 Copperbelt 1,026 - 25,651 1,026 - 25,651 1,026 - 25,651 1,026 183,152 89,620
3 Eastern 35 - 868 35 - 868 35 - 868 35 6,991 4,796
4 Luapula 17 - 414 17 - 414 17 - 414 17 8,137 6,365
5 Lusaka 650 - 16,238 650 - 16,238 650 - 16,238 650 129,836 55,948
6 Muchinga 11 - 273 11 - 273 11 - 273 11 2,092 1,441
7 Northern 75 - 1,877 75 - 1,877 75 - 1,877 75 15,156 7,680
8 Northwestern 18 - 459 18 - 459 18 - 459 18 3,945 2,491
9 Southern 211 - 5,279 211 - 5,279 211 - 5,279 211 43,513 25,600
10 Western 32 - 793 32 - 793 32 - 793 32 6,987 3,803
Total Works 2,200 - 55,006 2,200 - 55,006 2,200 - 55,006 2,200 425,600 211,439
Supervision Cost
- 2,750 - 2,750 - 2,750 21,280 10,572
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
(5%)
Grand Total 2,200 - 57,756 2,200 - 57,756 2,200 - 57,756 2,200 446,880 222,011
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
45
45
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-18: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban roads
2015 2016 2017
Routine Upgrade Routine Upgrade Routine Upgrade
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
1 Central 46.93 1,220.13 - 46.93 76.95 1,220.13 38,475.62 76.95 100.42 1,923.78 50,207.62
2 Copperbelt 168.33 4,376.50 - 168.33 94.17 4,376.50 47,086.39 94.17 178.34 2,354.32 89,168.14
3 Eastern 38.30 995.92 - 17.48 46.84 454.43 23,418.23 46.84 65.99 1,170.91 32,994.41
4 Luapula 11.43 297.07 - 11.43 35.88 297.07 17,940.98 35.88 41.59 897.05 20,797.41
5 Lusaka 105.81 2,751.02 - 97.39 81.45 2,532.21 40,723.44 81.45 134.35 2,036.17 67,175.54
6 Muchinga 27.04 703.08 - 16.93 36.62 440.30 18,311.17 36.62 50.14 915.56 25,071.59
7 Northern 24.77 644.07 - 16.42 24.87 426.84 12,433.33 24.87 37.25 621.67 18,626.33
8 Northwestern 25.07 651.76 - 22.62 33.06 588.14 16,530.82 33.06 45.60 826.54 22,797.72
9 Southern 256.12 6,659.22 - 256.12 63.55 6,659.22 31,776.63 63.55 191.62 1,588.83 95,807.63
10 Western 33.23 863.98 - 31.13 18.85 809.35 9,425.78 18.85 35.47 471.29 17,733.28
Total Works 737.03 19,162.76 - 684.78 512.24 17,804.20 256,122.40 512.24 880.76 12,806.12 440,379.67
Supervision Cost (5%) 958.14 - 890.21 12,806.12 640.31 22,018.98
Grand Total 737.03 20,120.89 - 684.78 512.24 18,694.41 268,928.51 512.24 880.76 13,446.43 462,398.65
Source: RDA Estimates, 2014
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
46
46
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-19: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban roads Cont’d
2018 2019 2020
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
1 Central
177.37 100.42 1,923.78 50,207.62 277.78 6,944.54 - 277.78 6,944.54 -
2 Copperbelt
272.51 178.34 2,354.32 89,168.14 450.85 11,271.13 47,086.39 545.02 13,625.45 47,086.39
3 Eastern
112.83 65.99 1,170.91 32,994.41 178.81 4,470.35 - 178.81 4,470.35 -
4 Luapula
77.48 41.59 897.05 20,797.41 119.07 2,976.79 - 119.07 2,976.79 -
5 Lusaka
215.80 134.35 2,036.17 67,175.54 350.15 8,753.73 40,723.44 431.60 10,789.90 40,723.44
6 Muchinga
86.77 50.14 915.56 25,071.59 136.91 3,422.72 - 136.91 3,422.72 -
7 Northern
62.12 37.25 621.67 18,626.33 99.37 2,484.30 - 99.37 2,484.30 -
8 Northwestern
78.66 45.60 826.54 22,797.72 124.25 3,106.31 - 124.25 3,106.31 -
9 Southern
255.17 191.62 1,588.83 95,807.63 446.78 11,169.59 31,776.63 510.34 12,758.43 31,776.63
10 Western
54.32 35.47 471.29 17,733.28 89.78 2,244.62 - 89.78 2,244.62 -
Total Works
1,393.00 880.76 12,806.12 440,379.67 2,273.76 56,844.09 119,586.46 2,512.94 62,823.41 119,586.46
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
47
47
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-20: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban roads Cont’d
No. Province 2021 2022 2023
Routine Upgrade Routine Upgrade Routine Upgrade
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
(US$'000)
48
48
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 7-21: Funding Requirements for the upgrades and maintenance unpaved urban roads Cont’d
2024 Grand Total
Routine Upgrade Routine Upgrading
No. Province Length Length
RM (km) UPG(km) Cost Cost Length Cost Length
Cost US$'000
(US$'000) (US$'000) (km) US$'000 (km)
49
49
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Bridges are an integral part of the existing CRN. However, many of Zambia’s bridges are also
in excess of forty years old and it has become common, in recent years, for areas of the
country to become inaccessible due to bridge failures in rural areas. These failures may occur
as a result of structural failure, failure of approach embankments and/or structural damage
arising from high floods. In addition, some bridges in the CRN may be of inadequate width or
load capacity. Many of the country’s large and small culverts have been constructed using
corrugated metal sheeting which have either deteriorated or been vandalized, resulting in
structural failure. The cost of reconstructing these structures as well as providing temporary
bridges has been considerable.
The RDA is primarily responsible for the planning, maintenance and management of all bridges
on the CRN. The RDA in 2011 carried out inventory and condition survey for all bridges
including culverts on the entire public roads network. In addition to carrying the detailed
inventory and condition surveys, the RDA also developed a Bridge Management System (BMS)
to assist in prioritizing maintenance activities on all bridge infrastructures.
According to the Inventory and Condition Survey conducted of all bridges and major culverts
on the CRN of 2011 a total of 3,775 structures were identified (BMS, 2011). The data for
all structures is now installed in a new Bridge Management System which has been
developed exclusively for the RDA . Table shows the summary of all the structures that
were identified on the CRN by road class.
Table 7-22: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory
Road Type Length (km) Length % No of km/Structure
Surveyed (km) Complete Structures
Trunk 3,115.57 3104.05 99.63 551 5.63
Main 3,701.06 3592.34 97.06 421 8.53
District 12,106.81 6961.77 57.50 816 8.53
Feeder 15,318.11 8152.06 53.22 567 14.40
Urban 5,596.89 0 - - -
Total 39,838.44 21,810.21 54.75 2,355 9.27
Figure 7-5 shows the map of all the bridge and major culvert structures that were surveyed in
2011.
50
50
Road Maintenance Strategy,
Road Maintenance Strategy,2014 - 2024
2015-2024
Bridge and major culvert structures on the District roads are shown in Table 7-23 below:
Table 7-23: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory on District Roads by Province
Province Total Length Length % No of km/structure
complete Complete Structures
Lusaka 599.24 568.08 94.80 114.00 4.98
Copperbelt 502.10 475.68 94.74 27.00 17.62
Luapula 1,243.60 1,182.30 95.07 144.00 8.21
Central 2,460.18 2,361.69 96.00 132.00 17.89
Southern 2,173.11 2,142.53 98.59 237.00 9.04
Western 921.67 643.04 69.77 47.00 13.68
Northern/Muchinga 1,717.47 1,664.33 96.91 167.00 9.97
Northwestern 1,054.97 910.06 86.26 58.00 15.69
Eastern 1,423.10 1,209.48 84.99 133.00 9.09
Total 12,095.44 11,157.19 0.92 1,059.00 10.54
Source: BMS Final Report, 2011
51
51
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Bridge and major culvert structures on the Primary Feeder Roads are shown in Table 7-24
below:
Table 7-24: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory on PFR by Province
Total Length % Structures km/structure
Length Complete Complete
Lusaka 389.86 389.86 100.00 17.00 22.93
Copperbelt 687.99 687.99 100.00 31.00 22.19
Luapula 1,227.82 996.58 81.17 62.00 16.07
Central 1,426.93 1,388.85 97.33 92.00 15.10
Southern 1,434.59 1,106.52 77.13 38.00 29.12
Western 2,178.15 1,498.89 68.82 35.00 42.83
Northern/Muchinga 3,443.09 3,246.29 94.28 250.00 12.99
Northwestern 2,214.88 1,854.39 83.72 80.00 23.18
Bridge and major culvert structures on the Urban Roads network are shown in Table 7-25
below:
Table 7-25: Summary of Bridge and Major culverts inventory on the Urban Roads by Province
Province Total Length % Structures km/structure
Length Complete Complete
52
52
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The Bridge Management Database uses ratings that range from 0 to 9 and the definitions for
each rating are shown in Table 3.1.
140
120
100
No. of Bridges
80
60
40
20
0
0&1 2&3 4&5 6 7 to 9
Rating Category
53
53
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The following graphs show the baseline individual ratings for bridges on all types of road class
covered based on inventory and condition data collected in 2011.
Figure 7-7 : Ratings for Trunk, Main District & Feeder Roads
54
54
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
7.5.4 Prioritization
Bridge Maintenance interventions shall be programmed and prioritized using the BMS Data.
Inventory and condition data will be collected on an annual basis and used to update the BMS.
The RDA will be implementing an extensive bridge repair and rehabilitation programme
covering a total of 144 bridges across the country commencing in 2015. Table 7-28
summarizes the number of structures that will undergo rehabilitation works by Province.
55
55
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
1 Optimal use of the BMS to prioritize RDA/MLGH Planning & N/A Produce priority list for
BMS activities by November 30, Design/ medium to long term plan
2014 Maintenance for bridge maintenance by
July 31, 2015
Conduct training for use of
BMS by February 27, 2015
Update the BMS System on
an annual basis
2 Expand the scope of the BMS RDA/MLGH Planning & N/A Single Source a Consultant
system to include cost component Design/Mainten to expand the scope of the
for prioritization ance BMS system to include cost
component for prioritization
by June 30, 2015.
3 Create accessibility on none core RDA Planning & MLGH Undertake Community
road network
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
56
56
Road Maintenance Strategy,
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
2015-2024
The Government of the Republic of Zambia has embarked on a very ambitious programme of
transforming the country from a landlocked into a land linked country. This development is
expected to result into the reduction of travelling time from one place to another and is likely
to pose a challenge to the safe mobility of the people. As a way of addressing the potential
problems as the result of massive investment in Road Infrastructure, the 2011-2020 United
Nations Decade of Action for Road Safety has identified safer roads and mobility as one of the
key components in reducing the high levels of road carnage. Safer roads and mobility entails
that appropriate consideration be given to pedestrian facilities and other vulnerable road
users such as cyclists in road infrastructure development and maintenance,
Safety treatments to the road and roadside have a major influence in preventing crashes or
minimizing the consequences of a crash. Road safety improvements derive from two broad
categories of infrastructure investment:
• Investment in new road construction and major upgrades. This activity is primarily
associated with mobility and economic performance benefits, with safety being an
ancillary benefit.
Compared with many other African countries, Zambia has a relatively considerable road
network and a relatively small population. This places limits on the level of expenditure on
infrastructure and infrastructure safety per kilometer of network, and on the proportion of
highways that are likely to ever be converted to dual carriageway. It is therefore important to
maximize the safety benefit of the overall investment in the nation‘s road infrastructure.
Infrastructure treatments can assist in making it obvious how the function of the road
changes. For example, vulnerable road users such as cyclists can be assisted by
implementing traffic calming measures on roads to slow cars down. On higher speed roads,
separation of cyclists from motorised vehicles is desirable. Cycle lanes are one option but
physical separation is more effective and likely to encourage greater cycling activity. Likewise,
in residential streets where limited vehicle access is needed, pedestrians benefit from lower
57
57
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
61
58
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
a right turn lane at an intersection, edge lining on the shoulder of the road, and installation of
barrier systems (a good per cent of serious casualties involving errant vehicles).
Head on crashes are usually as of result of poor overtaking decisions but more often as a
result of drivers straying over the centerline due to inattention, fatigue or losing control of
the vehicle for some other reason. A variety of proven treatments will be undertaken on
standard two – lane or one – lane undivided roads to create more secure separation:
Addition of barriers in the median and on the side of the road, with some provision of
overtaking opportunities.
59
59
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Rumble strips — will be installed at certain locations which will alert motorists that
they are approaching intersections and rail level crossings.
Ensure that Safe System principles are applied to all new road projects, including road
upgrades.
Modify infrastructure funding guidelines and agreements to increase the safety benefits
resulting from expenditure on roads by allocating 5% of road maintenance resources
to road safety and allocate sufficient financial and human resources to improve road
safety in line with the resolution of the United Nations Decade of Action for Road
Safety and the Africa Road Safety Action Plan adopted by the Africa Union Heads of
States in February 2012.
Address safety issues for vulnerable road users, for example: safety
improvements on popular motorcycle routes; infrastructure improvements for
bicyclists, older road users, people accessing public transport and pedestrians.
Address safety on key arterial routes, prioritised by crash history. Road Safety
Inspections to be undertaken and findings implemented.
60
60
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
61
61
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
In Zambia the common emergencies in the road sector are basically washaways of drainage
structures such as culverts, vented drifts and minor bridges. These emergencies normally
occur during the rainy season as a result of flash floods.
62
62
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
63
63
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
2 Increased Contingency RDA/NRFA 2015 2024 Planning/Maint NRFA RDA to ensure that adequate
Funds with ring fenced enance funds are provided for in the
seed funds for RSAWP for maintenance
emergencies NRFA to ensure that
adequate funds are available
for maintenance
Seed Funds will be kept in the
RDA HQ Account
3 Speedy Access to RDA October 2024 Maintenance NRFA RDA HQ to transfer required
Contingency Funds by Regional 31,2014 Dept./Finance funds to the Regional Office
Implementing Regions Office within 24 hours from
approval.
4 Preparation of Emergency RDA November 2024 Maintenance LRAs/DMMU Draft a template for
Plans Regional 28, 2014 emergency plans by
Office November 28, 2014
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Distribute templates to
regional
offices by December 1, 2014
5 Reviewing & Updating RDA 2015 2024 Maintenance LRAs/DMMU Review Emergency Plans
Emergency Plans Regional every year
64
64
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Office
6 Framework and Supply RDA – November 2024 Regional NRFA RDA to procure in advance
Contracts in the 10 Planning & 2014 Offices/ contractors by October of
Regions Design Maintenance every year in all 10 provinces
Dept./Procure that will be instructed to carry
ment out works during emergencies
7 Material Stockpiling and RDA November 2024 Maintenance/R DMMU/NRFA Stockpile material to be
Equipment in readiness for 2014 egions procured by November of
emergencies – bitumen every year before onset of
(standing contract), rainy season.
prefabricated culverts,
bailey bridges and many
others
8 Establishing processes for RDA June 2015 June Monitoring & DMMU/LRA/NRFA Conduct debriefs on
lessons learned including 2024 Evaluation/Mai /Provincial and emergency activities on a
conducting debriefs and ntenance/Audi District semi-annual basis
reviews of other t/Public Administration
emergency events or Relations
exercises that are relevant
to the RDA
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
65
65
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 8-2 is the RDA Emergency Response Strategy (ERS) that shows the reaction time
for various activities undertaken to respond to emergencies whilst Table 8-3 shows the
category of responses. The ERS is fully described in the Draft 2014 RDA Road
Maintenance Manual.
Figure 8-1 shows the emergency response flow chart through either Force Account or
Framework Contract approach. The RDA will maintain to a limited extent Force
Account works for emergencies while at the same time use Framework and Supply
Contracts to deal with all major emergency works in the regions.
66
66
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
67
67
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Notes:
68
68
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Incident Reported
[Emergency Call Service
Centre]
Regional Manager’s
Office; Initial
Assessment/Report/ Cost
Estimate
Fast Tracked
Procurement
Activate Framework
Force Account Contracts
Implementation of
Emergency Works
69
69
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
9 Asset Management
The data that will be needed to support the RDA Asset Management process will include
the following:
Road network – Logical and physical referencing, item inventory, routes etc;
Traffic- Volume, loading, congestion levels etc;
Structures – Pavements, Bridges, drainage structures, condition etc;
Equipment – road furniture, control equipment etc;
Accidents – type, victims, contributory factors etc; and
Finance and resources – costs budgets, personnel, materials, equipment etc.
Under this Road Maintenance Strategy, the road infrastructure asset management will
be enhanced through the following:
70
70
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The RDA Draft Road Maintenance Manual describes in detail the Asset Management
approach that has been adopted from best practice (ISO55000).
71
71
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
10 Performance Management
The Regional Manager shall be responsible for the performance management of routine
maintenance activities which are being executed by contracting out or by Force Account.
The performance management shall be carried out through regular inspections (a
minimum of two inspections per month per contract). The inspections shall be carried out
to ensure that works are carried out in line with specified provisions in the contract.
Table 10-1 below shows the frequency of inspections to be carried out on the CRN
according to Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT). These inspections will be carried out
to check routine maintenance activities and general monitoring of the CRN for obstacles.
An inspectorate team will carry out the inspections in accordance with the frequency set
in Table 10-1 below:
Table 10-1: Frequency of Inspections on the CRN
No. AADT Frequency of Inspections
1 >3,000 Once every 24 hours
2 1,000<AADT≤3,000 Once every 48 hours
3 500<AADT≤1,000 Once every week
4 ≤500 Every fortnight
In addition there shall be Toll free lines established for the members of the public to
report any incidence on the whole CRN. The RDA toll free lines will be operated on a 24
hour service. Each region will have a Customer Service Center Hot Line for incident
72
72
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
reporting. The incident reporting and response flow chart is summarized in Figure 8-1
under Section 8.
To reduce emergencies on the road network, a road inspection team will be established
at Regional level. This inspection team will be conducting regular inspections of the road
network. The inspections will include road Patrols.
73
73
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The RDA is developing a Road Maintenance Manual that will act as a guide for best
practice for maintenance activities on the CRN. The Road Maintenance Manual will be
completed by the first quarter of 2015. The manual will assign responsibilities to
respective departments within the RDA to ensure effective implementation of
maintenance activities. The RDA Maintenance Manual will make reference to best
practices in the SADC region and other relevant papers.
74
74
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The main funding sources for road maintenance are derived from the Road Fund and the
newly introduced road tolling funds. Despite the increase in financing to the road sector over
the years, there has been very little attention given to maintenance activities and
programmes. Maintenance activities cover only about 20 percent of the 2014 RSAWP while
major capital investment projects account for about 50 per cent of the budget. The pre-
occupation over the years has mostly been with new constructions and up-grades at the
expense of road maintenance. This has resulted in some of the roads outliving their design
life. The best case example is the Serenje to Nakonde Road which has deteriorated to
alarming levels. It is therefore imperative to make maintenance a number one priority
alongside other developmental programmes. Timely application of maintenance on the road
network will prevent the necessity to carrying out major rehabilitation works which are
about three to four times more expensive than the maintenance costs.
75
75
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
The RDA recognizes the need and importance of timely execution of maintenance activities
on the public roads network to prevent the roads from deteriorating to rehabilitation levels
earlier than expected. Furthermore, the RDA in this road maintenance strategy aims at
making maintenance the number one priority alongside other developmental programmes.
This will entail increasing the budgetary allocation for road maintenance activities to the
equivalent of about US$721 million per annum in order to bring the CRN into a maintainable
condition for the next five years commencing 2015 (RDA Needs Report, 2012).
In addition, the road fund should be used to solely finance all maintenance activities on the
CRN while construction and upgrade projects can be financed from capital investment funds
which should be directly sourced from the Treasury and other financiers such as the
Cooperating Partners (CPs) and Multilateral Development Banks.
Additional resources for maintenance shall be sourced from the Road Tolling programme.
The RDA commenced the Road Tolling Programme on November 1, 2013. The Programme
is designed to provide additional revenues for road maintenance as is defined by the Road
Tolling Act No.14 of 2011 and SI No. 73 of 2013. The RDA will commence the construction
of Toll Plazas at nine (09) designated locations on the CRN out of the approved twenty-six
(26) to broaden the maintenance revenue base in the fourth quarter of 2014. It is anticipated
that an average of ZMW 1.1billion (US$180 million) will be collected on an annual basis from
the Road Tolling Programme. The overall annual projected road maintenance funding for the
period between 2015 and 2024is given in Table 12-1.
Table 12-1: Projected Local Resource Revenues (ZMW‘million)
Grand
Type 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
Total
Fuel Levy 379 511 630 750 825 908 998 1,098 1,208 1,329 8,637
ORUC 569 769 947 1,127 1,240 1,364 1,501 1,651 1,816 1,997 12,982
Others 19 26 32 38 42 46 51 56 62 68 440
Tolls 452 611 752 895 985 1,083 1,192 1,311 1,442 1,586 10,310
Road Fund 1,420 1,917 2,362 2,811 3,092 3,402 3,742 4,116 4,528 4,980 32,369
GRZ 1,780 2,404 2,963 3,526 3,879 4,267 4,693 5,163 5,679 6,247 40,601
Grand Total 3,200 4,321 5,326 6,337 6,971 7,668 8,435 9,279 10,206 11,227 72,971
Source: 2014 Core Circular (MTEF) and RDA projected estimates
76
76
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Table 12-2 shows the projected cash-flow expenditure on the entire CRN for the period
between 2015 and 2024. These cash-flow projections of expenditure are based on ongoing
commitments and planned activities by all relevant road sector agencies. A total of ZMW71.2
billion in local resources is projected to be spent on both capital investments and
maintenance projects. The major capital investment programme in line with the Revised Sixth
National Development Plan (SNDP) is the Link Zambia 8000 Programme. It is projected that
a total of ZMW24 billion will be spent on upgrading to bituminous standard of various roads
under the Link Zambia 8000 Programme between 2015 and 2024. Furthermore, a total of
ZMW21 billion of local resources are projected to be spent on maintenance activities during
the period between 2015 and 2024.
77
77
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Table 12-2: Projected Road Sector Cash-flows 2015 to 2024 (High Case Scenario) (ZMW’million)
Intervention/Agency 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Grand Total
Axle Load Control 16.6 41.9 46.6 47.8 46.1 87.3 89.7 98.9 145.2 150.0 770.0
Bridges 66.5 159.4 218.3 266.5 257.2 121.7 259.7 286.5 434.9 339.5 2,410.2
Carried Forward IPCs 1,149.9 - - - - - - - 232.9 - 1,382.8
Emergency 24.9 59.8 81.9 99.9 96.4 45.6 46.9 51.8 100.5 - 607.8
Link Zambia 8000 Programme 329.3 974.2 1,387.7 1,861.8 2,764.1 3,329.0 4,247.2 4,473.5 4,426.5 879.8 24,673.2
Feasibility Studies and Designs 44.0 111.6 - - - - - - 30.6 - 186.2
Pave Zambia 12.5 67.0 40.9 50.0 48.2 22.8 23.5 75.4 58.0 26.2 424.4
Periodic Maintenance 439.3 753.9 1,117.3 1,146.4 1,198.4 1,134.3 1,166.2 1,286.3 1,178.7 7,732.1 17,152.9
Routine Maintenance 93.3 223.4 306.0 373.6 360.5 341.2 350.8 387.0 618.2 859.1 3,913.1
Project Monitoring/Procurement/Capital Expenditure 178.7 166.8 169.1 148.0 137.0 131.9 139.2 156.4 298.8 158.8 1,684.6
Construction and Rehabilitation 482.0 889.0 788.5 935.8 768.4 1,673.1 1,236.8 1,742.6 8,516.1
Tolling Programme 41.6 58.6 93.1 95.5 23.0 43.6 116.6 49.5 103.4 75.0 700.0
RTSA 80.7 148.3 188.1 215.9 224.0 219.0 225.2 248.4 399.5 328.0 2,277.0
MLGH 221.6 632.2 843.3 1,044.6 994.3 466.3 479.3 362.9 698.3 208.4 5,951.2
NCC 4.2 7.5 9.3 11.5 12.0 11.4 11.8 13.1 21.0 17.0 118.9
NRFA 15.0 27.6 35.4 40.1 41.5 41.0 42.2 46.5 74.7 61.0 425.0
Grand Total 3,200.0 4,321.3 5,325.6 6,337.4 6,971.1 7,668.3 8,435.1 9,278.6 8,821.1 10,834.8 71,193.2
Source: RDA/NRFA Projected Road Sector Cash-flows, 2014 (2014-2024)
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
78
78
RoadRoad
Maintenance
Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Strategy, 2015-2024
The Human Capital and Administration department in liaison with other departments shall play a
critical role in identifying the skills gaps. This shall include
Development of training programmes to cover:
o On the job training – planned project attachment of RDA Engineers;
o Short-term training programmes – customized training programmes designed to
address specific skills gaps; and
o Long term training.
Recruitment of Staff
79
79
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Risk Management is a systematic approach to identifying and dealing with the risks that
threaten our plans and impact upon the continuation of service delivery. The following
outlines risk management framework whose purpose is to define in a controlled way how
risks will be handled.
The following are the risks that have been identified in the effective implementation of this
Road Maintenance strategy:
80
80
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
81
81
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
9 Lack of appropriate decision Medium Use of appropriate decision Planning and 2015
support systems for support systems by both the RDA Design
maintenance prioritization and LRAs LRAs
on the CRN
10 Lack of clear distinction High Clearly distinguish Road Fund MoF 2015
between GRZ Treasury from GRZ capital investment for NRFA
Revenues and Road Fund maintenance planning purposes
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
82
82
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
16 Over emphasis on up-grades High Sensitization on the importance of Planning and First
and construction maintenance to all relevant Design quarter of
stakeholders Public 2015
Deliberate policy to prioritize Relations
maintenance MTWSC
through
83
83
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
16 Over emphasis on up-grades High Sensitization on the importance of Planning and First
and construction maintenance to all relevant Design quarter of
stakeholders Public 2015
Deliberate policy to prioritize Relations
maintenance MTWSC
through
83
83
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
84
84
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
13.1 Definition
Research and Development refers to discovering new knowledge about products, processes,
and services, and then applying that knowledge to create new and improved products,
processes, and services that meet market needs. The current investment in the road
infrastructure development requires efficient tools for planning, design, construction, quality
control and management which can be achieved through the development of innovative
technology. The need for the development of innovative technology prompted the RDA to
create a Research and Development Unit. The Unit is expected to advance scientific and
technical knowledge of the sector through scientific research and apply that knowledge to the
extent necessary to provide a well maintained cost effective road network.
To establish formal collaborative links with local universities and other international
transport research institutions for knowledge exchange and capacity building by 2015;
To implement and operationalize the Materials Databank by 2017;
To have fully equipped and accredited state of the art Laboratory by 2018;
Formulate a research Policy for the R&D Unit by 2015
Create synergies with Consultants & Contractors and Private Institutions
Develop a strategy to enhance quality control on road construction projects in order
to reduce on maintenance costs associated with poor quality works or use of
inappropriate construction methods by 2016
85
85
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
materials is of great importance. The uncertainty regarding the location, nature, quality and
cost of road construction materials in various parts of the country has led to uncertainty in
design and even higher construction costs usually due to contract variations.
It is for this reason that embarking on this project of this nature is essential in order to have
updated information on the availability and quality of construction materials for the entire road
network. The Materials Databank strategy is to focus on Trunk, Main and District Roads
(TMDs) and shall cover approximately 19,000 Km of this network.
The implementation of the materials databank is in two phases. Phase I comprises the Design
and Implementation of the Materials Database, which is essentially software design and
development. Phase II of the project is the geotechnical and environmental investigation for
the identification of construction material sources.
The main objectives of this project for the two phases are:
It is envisaged that this project when fully implemented will help to reduce costs related to
planning, procurement, design and construction of roads as general information regarding
available and quality of materials will be readily available and accessible. The cost reduction
could be achieved because there will be certainty of material available, quality and quantity.
This will ensure reduction of uncertainty during tender and also optimized designs for use of
locally available materials. Consequently, this will greatly reduce variations that result from
design change due to unavailability of ‘suitable materials’ which results increased cost of road
construction resulting from hauling of required materials over long distances.
Table 13-1 shows the strategies under the Research and Development Unit intended to aid
the effective and efficient implementation of maintenance activities on the CRN.
86
86
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
4 Formulate a research Policy RDA 1st 4th Planning & Design RDA Board
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
87
87
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
There is a general inadequacy of contractors being able to carry out specific maintenance
interventions such as asphalt overlays, single and double surface dressing among other
maintenance interventions according to the Vendor Rating System Report of 2013. This lack of
capacity by the general pool of contractors has resulted in the following:
Poor quality of works;
Time and cost overruns;
Termination of Contracts; and
Premature failure of pavements and structures
The RDA has developed the following strategies to address the challenges outlined above:
Accreditation of all Road Contractors through NCC in accordance with the various
road maintenance intervention techniques by 2015;
Adoption of this new accreditation in the evaluation criteria for all future award of
contracts by 2015; and
Provide financial support to NCC for training and subsequent accreditation of small
scale contractors in various road maintenance interventions by 2015.
Table 13-2 shows how the above mentioned strategies will be achieved.
88
88
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
89
89
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Investment in the network is not the only factor affecting condition. Changes in the level of
heavy vehicle traffic and in vehicle overload may have a significant effect on condition so it is
necessary to monitor these factors.
Table 13-1 contains road network maintenance management indicators that will provide a
good overview of how well RDA is performing in terms of its network management.
In selecting these indicators consideration has been given to the relative ease of annual data
collection and their direct relationship to the sustainability of road infrastructure.
Table 15-1: Maintenance Management Monitoring Framework
No. Core Measures Disaggregation (See note) Performance Indicators
90
90
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
91
91
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
16 Major Assumptions
92
92
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
17 CONCLUSION
The development of this Road Maintenance Strategy was necessitated by the need to
embrace a shift in focus from high emphasis on construction and rehabilitation to
maintenance. Road Maintenance in Zambia has consistently remained a challenge despite
the formulation of Road Sector Investment Programmes that were implemented
between 1998 and 2013 (RoadSIP I and II). The Road Sector has for a long time since
independence been pre-occupied with major construction and upgrading works on the
road network at the expense of the much needed road maintenance. This Road
Maintenance Strategy is thus designed to set a clear pathway for the provision of road
maintenance activities on the CRN. The Strategy also demonstrates how the RDA
understands the needs of the Road Users as well as the statutory obligations provided in
the Public Roads Act of 2002. The Strategy further outlines how the RDA intends to
achieve its vision of being the leading Road Authority in Africa through the provision of
a world class road network.
Maintenance prioritization on the TMD network will employ the use of decision support
systems such as the ZHMS and HDM-IV in view of the limited local resource envelope.
The 10 year plan will see the entire TMD network been kept in a maintainable condition
by 2024. A total of ZMW21 billion from local resources has been earmarked to be
spent for maintenance (periodic and routine) on the TMD network over the 10 year
implementation period of this Road Maintenance Strategy.
The RDA plans to roll out the 4th generation OPRCs on the PFR network in 2016. It is
projected that PFR network will be in a maintainable condition by end of 2019. In
addition, the RDA has planned to appoint the ZNS as local road authority to assist in
the short to medium term management of the PFR network. Bringing the PFR network
into a maintainable condition by 2019 will act as a catalyst for social and economic
growth by boosting agriculture and trade through increased mobility and accessibility.
Similarly, the RDA plans to work closely with the Local Road Authorities in
implementing long term area maintenance contracts on urban roads. This approach is
designed to ensure that all urban roads are in a maintainable condition by 2024. Under
this approach, there will be a systematic upgrading of all unpaved urban roads to
bituminous standard up until the end of the 10 year implementation period.
The RDA is committed to ensuring that it provides for adequate and timely periodic and
routine maintenance of the CRN by improving the operational efficiency and
effectiveness of critical departments associated with road maintenance. In addition, the
93
93
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
RMS has also adopted a more proactive approach to dealing with emergencies through
comprehensive emergency preparedness and response strategies. Adherence to Asset
Management principles will go a long way to ensuring that resources for maintenance
are applied optimally to realize value from assets. The approach to asset management
will improve on stewardship and accountability; communication and relationships with
service users; risk management and financial efficiency. Efficient and effective execution
of preventive and corrective maintenance will be achieved through Performance
Management. The development of Road Maintenance Manuals will further guide best
practice in the application of maintenance activities on the CRN.
94
94
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
18 REFERENCES
2014 Core Circular (MTEF) and RDA projected estimates
BMS., (2011). Final Report: Inventory and Condition Surveys of Bridges and Major
Culvert Structures on the Core Road Network, Road Development Agency, Zambia.
DCPM., (2013). Data Collection and Procedures Manual, 2013. Road Development
Agency (RDA) Lusaka, Zambia.
Gaël Raballand and Alan Whitworth, (2012). The Crisis in the Zambian Road Sector:
ZIPAR Working Paper No. 5. [Online]. Available from:
http://www.zipar.org.zm/documents/The%20Crisis%20in%20the%20Zambian%20Road.pd
f [Accessed on 12 July 2014].
Gwilliam, K. M. and Shalizi, Z. M., (1996). Road Funds, User Charges and Taxes.
Transport Division Discussion Paper No. 18930. The World Bank Washington
Hicks, R.G, S.P Seeds and DG Peshkin., (2000). Selecting a Preventative Maintenance
Treatment for Flexible Pavement Preservation, Washington DC
Public Roads Act No. 12 of 2002, Republic of Zambia, Section 20 (1) (2) (3) and Section
73 (1). Government Printers, Lusaka.
RDA Consultants’ and Contractors’ Vendor Rating System Policy and Procedures
Manual 2013
RDA., (2009). The Road Development Agency Road Network Reclassification Study
Final Report. RDA Lusaka Zambia
RDA., (2012). The Road Development Agency Maintenance Needs Report on the Core
Road Network.
RDA., (2013). The Road Development Agency Road Network Condition Report of
2013.
95
95
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2015-2024
Road Maintenance Strategy, 2014 - 2024
RDA:1., (2014). Final Technical Report: Detailed Engineering Assessment, Conceptual Design
and Environmental and Social Assessment Studies for the Improvement to Climate Resilient
Standards of Selected Strategic Roads in the Kafue Sub-basin. Road Development Agency,
Lusaka, Zambia.
RDA:II., (2014). Draft 2014 RDA Maintenance Procedures Manual. Road Development
Agency Lusaka, Zambia.
RSAWP., (2013). The 2013 Road Sector Annual Work Plan. Road Development Agency
Lusaka Zambia.
TRN-4., (2005). Why road maintenance is important and how to get it done. [Online].
Available from: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTTRANSPORT/Resources/336291-
1227561426235/5611053-1231943010251/TRN4_Road_Maintenance.pdf [Accessed on
12 July 2014]
World Bank (1997). Staff Appraisal Report: Republic of Zambia - Project to Support a
Road Sector Investment Program, Report No. 16539-ZA. Washington, DC cited in
“ZIPAR Working Paper No. 5: The Crisis in the Zambian Road Sector”
World Bank Rural Transport Thematic Group. 2003. Rural Transport in Multi Sectoral
and Community Driven Projects. World Bank, Washington, DC. Cited in TRN-4, 2005.
96
96