Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1) Facultad de Ingeniería Mecánica y Aeroespacial de la Universidad Nacional de Seúl, Seúl 151-744, Corea
2) Instituto de la maquinaria avanzada y Diseño, Universidad Nacional de Seúl, Seúl 151-744, Corea
RESUMEN - A vehicle rollover is a critical accident that could have many causes. This paper describes a novel vision-based system for measuring vehicle
roof deformation due to a rollover accident. A vision-based measurement system offers an overall view of structural deformation simply at low cost. Our
measurement system was constructed using a Kinect camera from Microsoft, a battery, and a remote-controlled recording computer. Color images and
distance maps can be obtained using two sensors embedded in the Kinect along with customized software, and the distance from the camera lens to a
specific object can be calculated with a simple equation. To test our proposed approach, actual vehicle rollover experiments were conducted and the
resulting roof deformations were compared to those indicated by our system. Moreover, cross-sectional image of Apillar was analyzed to calculate bending
moment of inertia. From the research results, it was able to show that deformation errors were within 13 mm, and roof deformation was correlated with
vehicle type, or vehicle curb weight.
KEY WORDS : Depth map, Microsoft Kinect, Roof deformation, Vehicle rollover, Vision-based measurement
1. INTRODUCTION al., 2010; Yim et al., 2011). Active suspension or active anti-roll bars are
other approaches to this problem (Yim et al., 2011; Lee, 2002). In some
Over 8000 fatal vehicle rollover accidents occur every year in the US cases, individual control modules have been combined and integrated to
(National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) in the United improve dynamic stability (Lee, 2002).
States, 2011). Even though rollovers constitute only a small portion of all
the accidents that occur, it is clear that they must be more dangerous The other main branch of research attempts to protect passengers
than other types of accidents. A vehicle that rolls over onto its roof often from injury when an accident does occur. This includes reinforcing the
causes serious injury or death to its passengers, and frequently suffers automobile body (Ko et al., 2009) or using airbag control to prevent
jammed doors that make the escape of passengers difficult. For critical injury.
example, in 2009 in the United States, rollovers accounted for only 2.4% In addition, Europe (United Nations Economic Commission for Europe
of all automobile crashes, but resulted in 21.4% of all fatal crashes and (UNECE), 1995) and the US (NHTSA, 1999) regulate the structure of
buses to ensure a minimum headspace in case of rollover accidents to
help ensure the safety of passengers.
35.4% of all occupants deaths, as shown in Figure 1 (NHTSA, 2011).
Similarly in 2010, rollovers accounted for only 3% of the total number of The safety of vehicle structures is tested by five methods: complete
automobile accidents, but caused one third of all fatalities (NHTSA, vehicle rollover tests, body section rollover tests, body section tests with
2012). quasi-static loads, component testing based on quasi-static calculations,
One effective way of reducing fatalities and serious injuries in vehicle and complete vehicle
crashes is to protect passengers from the negative effects of a rollover.
Several approaches to this have been studied.
667
668 H.-S. YOON, K.-T. LEE and S.-H. AHN
rollover tests based on computer simulation. vision-based measurement system. Kinect was designed to capture the
Concerns about vehicle structure emerged in the 1990s due to trends motion of players gaming on an Xbox 360 gaming console. It has two
toward lightweight and streamlined vehicle bodies. Testing the safety of complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS) sensors, one for
vehicle structures is increasingly important as manufacturers aim for capturing red/ green/blue (RGB) color images, and the other for depth
better efficiency by decreasing fuel consumption and increasing the measurement. The main reason for choosing Kinect in this study was
aerodynamic nature of their vehicles. because it provides the required data at reasonable cost. Various kinds
of measurement systems can be constructed using the optical and
One method of rollover analysis for verifying structural safety is infrared sensors in Kinect. Kinect applications can be created using the
computer-aided engineering (CAE), which is frequently used because of Kinect software developer’s kit (SDK), and Kinect offers stable and
its ease and low cost. Researchers have used computer simulations repeatable results.
(Kim et al.,
2006) with finite element methods to analyze the crash impact and
rollover dynamics of full vehicle bodies as well as cross-sectional Several research projects have used the Kinect camera due to its
portions (Friedman and Hutchinson, attractive features and ready accessibility. Kinect has been studied for
2008). Several analyses have shown good agreement with actual test use as a wearable haptic motion sensor (Frati and Prattichizzo, 2011), as
results, and have contributed to the optimization of vehicle structures a physical rehabilitation system (Chang et al., 2011), and even as an
(Liang and Le, 2010a, 2010b). altitude controller for an aerial vehicle (Stowers et al., 2011). In addition,
Nonetheless, a vehicle rollover experiment is the most intuitive and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Media Lab (2011) attempted
effective method of identifying structural weak points. Even though much to control a web browser with threedimensional motion. Table 1 shows
CAE research has taken place, most countries still perform a new-car hardware specifications of Kinect camera. In this study, color and depth
assessment program test for all car models, and many studies have images captured by the Kinect camera were used for the first time to
been made of actual vehicle rollovers. Experiments are usually study the deformation of vehicle structures during rollover accidents.
performed using special test fixtures that suddenly roll a vehicle over,
cause an impact to occur on its roof, or even push a vehicle in a lateral
direction along inclined rails. Structural deformation is observed visually
(Friedman et al., An open source Kinect driver and SDK from Code
This study proposes a novel vision-based measurement system for Depth sensor range 1.2–3.5 m
vehicle rollover experiments. Vision systems have been studied and Data streams
improved since the mid-1980s, and have proven to have several benefits
640 × 480 32-bit color at 30 frame/s
such as low cost and system simplicity compared to traditional methods
(Kim and Lee, 2006). Moreover, a vision-based inspection system can
easily detect the deformation of large, threedimensional structures
(Chung et al., 2011), is not limited by the number of sensors, and can
easily observe how the structure deforms. Therefore, the objective of this
research was to construct a simple and low-cost vision-based
measurement system, and then conduct rollover experiments to test it.
2. CONSTRUCTION OF VISION-BASED
MEASUREMENT SYSTEM FOR ROOF
DEFORMATION
Figure 3. Calibration results for depth and distance, and the resulting
approximation.
In general, the relationship between the Kinect depth value and the
actual distance was nonlinear, and the values were fitted to a logarithm
model so that the distance could be determined using an exponential
model. Figure 6. Vehicle rollover experimental method.
670 H.-S. YOON, K.-T. LEE and S.-H. AHN
3. RESULTS
Figure 7. Sequential images of vehicle structure deformation at the Figure 10. Definition of roof deformed distance and front head space: head
moment of rollover and final deformation of the A-pillar: color (left) and clearance = headroom - average height of seated passengers.
depth (right) images.
MEASUREMENT OF ROOF DEFORMATION CAUSED BY VEHICLE ROLLOVER 671
J xx = ∫ y A d
2
(2)
A
Because most vehicle engines are in the front, the vehicles tended to
land front first. Therefore, the amount of roof deformation (2–15 cm) was
a function of the bending strength of the A-pillar and the vehicle curb
weight. For similar A-pillar cross-sections, deformation increased with the
vehicle curb weight.
3.2. Analysis of Bending Moment of Inertia of A-pillar In order to analyze Figure 14. Results of calculated bending moment of inertia in terms of
roof deformation, deformation was curb weight.
672 H.-S. YOON, K.-T. LEE and S.-H. AHN
To extend types of data being measured, the Figure 17. Vertical forces applied on upper neck load cell in neck
measurement system was constructed again with a dummy inside. Only assembly of the dummy under rollover.
dummy head and neck assembly (Hybrid III 50th male haed and neck
assembly, Humanetics Innovative Solutions, USA) was mounted on a
mannequin to focus on head and neck damage, and that assembly Figure 17 shows results of vertical forces applied on upper neck load
model was installed inside the vehicle. 3 loadcells and 3 accelerometers cell measured by dummy neck assembly. Constructed vision based
were installed in the head and neck respectively, and 1 angular measurement system could provide information of structural deformation
accelerometer was installed between head and neck. with the dummy. Vehicle designer also could observe inside behavior
under rollover event.
Figure 15 shows hardware configurations including dummy model Moreover detecting area of the vision system could be easily
inside, and Figure 16 shows screen image after rollover has occurred. As expanded by increasing number of Kinect sensor. In the experiment, only
shown in the figure, inside behavior of vehicle was clearly observed. A-pillar deformation was observed mainly due to limitation in horizontal
field of view. However with more cameras, B-pillar deformation also
could be observed as well as A-pillar. It is expected that vehicle designer
could consider both A-pillar and B-pillar deformation, and dummy
information using the suggested measurement system.
4. CONCLUSION
simple geometry information about the vehicle. The results produced by ing Cong. and Exposition (IMECE2008-68751), Boston,
the system agreed closely with the measured data. Massachusetts, USA, 31 October - 6 November 2008, 1 − 9.
Puesto que el motor se encuentra usualy en la parte delantera de un vehículo, Kim, H.-S. and Lee, B.-R. (2006). Real-time pipe fault
se espera que el momento rotacional de inercia de la columna A a ser el factor más detection system using computer vision. Int. J. Precision Engineering
importante que afecta a la deformación techo. Los vehículos con varios pesos and Manufacturing 7, 1, 30 − 34.
bordillo y diferentes tipos de A-pilar secciones transversales se ensayaron en Kim, M. H., Oh, J. H., Lee, J. H. and Jeon, M. C. (2006).
accidentes de vuelco simulados. Con el fin de reducir los daños causados por Development of rollover criteria based on simple physical model of
accidentes de vuelco, estructura del vehículo debe ser diseñado teniendo en cuenta rollover event. Int. J. Automotive Technology 7, 1, 51 − 60.
la flexión del pilar A y el aclaramiento de la cabeza de los pasajeros.
Ko, H.-Y., Shin, K.-B., Jeon, K.-W. and Cho, S.-H. (2009).
A study on the crashworthiness and rollover characteristics of
La investigación futura implicará experimentos adicionales con este sistema para low-floor bus made of sandwich composites. J. Mechanical Science
observar el efecto de la estructura del vehículo. Nuestro sistema basado en la visión and Technology 23,
se utiliza para medir fácilmente el proceso de deformación del techo durante los 10, 2686 − 2693.
vuelcos, opcionalmente relleno instalada, y los resultados dará lugar a sugerencias Lee, A. Y. (2002). Coordinated control of steering and anti-
para mejorar las estructuras de vehículos. roll bars to alter vehicle rollover tendencies. J. Dynamic Systems,
Measurement, and Control, 124, 127 − 132.
Liang, C. and Le, G. (2010). Analysis of bus rollover
RECONOCIMIENTO - Este trabajo fue apoyado por el proyecto Cerebro protection under legislated standards using LS-DYNA software
Corea 21 en la Universidad Nacional de Seúl, y el Programa de Innovación simulation techniques. Int. J. Automotive Technology 11, 4, 495 − 506.
Tecnológica (subvención No. 10036459, Desarrollo del centro
para apoyar la industria y QoLT
Liang, C. and Le, G. (2010). Optimization of bus rollover
infraestructuras), financiado por el MKE / KEIT, el gobierno de Corea. Los autores
strength by consideration of the energy absorption ability. Int. J.
agradecen al Prof. Sang Mook-Lee de la Universidad Nacional de Seúl por su guía en
Automotive Technology 11, 2, 173 − 185.
esta investigación.
Media Laboratory of Massachusetts Institute of
Technology (MIT) (2011). Kinected Conf., [ online] Available at:
Referencias
<http://kinectedconference.media.mit.edu/
Brumbelow, ML y Teoh, ER (2009). la fuerza del techo > [Accessed 28 September 2011].
Chang, Y.-J., Chen, S.-F. y Huang, J.-D. (2011). UNA <http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj131033. aspx> [Accessed 19
Chen, B. y Peng, H. (2001). a base de diferencial-frenado Safety Standards and Regulations No.
Chung, B.-M., So, B.-S. and Lee, S. H. (2011). Flexible (2011). Occupants of Passenger Vehicles Killed by Vehicle Type and
vision inspection for seat frame of automobile using slit beam. Int. J. Rollover Occurrence, 2009, [ online] Available at:
12, 4, 605 − 612. [Accessed 19 September 2012]. National Highway Traffic Safety
(Driver and SDK). [ online] Available at: <http:// (2012). Rollover Characteristics-Fatalities, [ online] Available
Prattichizzo, D. (2011). Using Kinect for hand Shoppers/Rollover/Fatalities> [Accessed 19 September 2012].
Friedman, D., Nash, C. E. and Bish, J. (2007). Observa- Occurrence, 2009, [ online] Available at:
tions from repeatable dynamic rollover tests. Int. J. Crashworthiness 12, <http://www-fars.nhtsa.dot.gov/Vehicles/Vehicles AllVehicles.aspx >
existing repeatable vehicle rollover dynamic physical testing methods. Rollover crash tests - The influence of roof strength on injury
Pro. ASME Int. Mechanical Engineer- mechanics. SAE Paper No. 851734, 1483 − 1508.
674 H.-S. YOON, K.-T. LEE and S.-H. AHN