Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Key Words: kernicterus, bilirubin induced neurologic dysfunction, neonatal hyperbilirubinemia, newborn jaundice
Summary
Kernicterus, one of the most easily preventable causes of brain injury from severe neonatal jaundice, has re-emerged in
the United States and other nations with well developed healthcare systems as a public and societal health concern.
Kernicterus, in its usually recognized form, causes devastating disabilities including athetoid cerebral palsy (CP) and
speech and hearing impairment. It represents the severe manifestation of bilirubin induced neurologic dysfunction
(BIND) syndrome. This condition not only ranks amongst the highest cost per new case (according to the Center of
Disease Control’s Financial Burden of Disability study in 1992), but also results in profound and uncompromising grief
for the family and loss to siblings of healthy, talkative playmates. And for the child with kernicterus (usually remarkably
intelligent, but trapped in an uncontrollable body), grief and frustration are enormous. In 2001 national healthcare
organizations, including Centers for Disease Control (CDC), the Joint Commission for the Accreditation of Healthcare
Organizations (JACHO) and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) issued alerts to all accredited hospitals and
public health professionals in the United States and affiliated organizations that all healthy infants are at potential risk of
kernicterus if their newborn jaundice is unmonitored and inadequately treated. Evidentiary analysis of 125 cases, from an
informal Pilot Kernicterus Registry, documents that unmonitored or inadequately treated severe hyperbilirubinemia
results in kernicterus in otherwise healthy term and near term infants. On the basis of this empirical evidence, the lapses
in care and root causes have been associated with the occurrence of kernicterus in these infants. The re-emergence of
kernicterus in the United States is the result of interacting phenomena including a) early hospital discharge (before extent
of jaundice is known and signs of impending brain damage have appeared); b) lack of adequate concern for the risks of
severe jaundice in healthy term and near term newborns; c) an increase in breast feeding without adequate instruction,
monitoring and support; d) medical care cost constraints leading to early discharge with loss of supervision; e) paucity
of educational materials to enable parents to participate in safeguarding their newborns; and f) limitations within the
healthcare systems to provide continuity of care. The current resources for clinical interventions that can drastically and
efficiently reduce the increased bilirubin load, intensive phototherapy and exchange transfusions, are available for use in
those infants with excessive hyperbilirubinemia. However, these interventions leave a very narrow margin of safety for
babies who have rapid or unrecognized increases in their bilirubin load. Because most babies are discharged before the
hyperbilirubinemia reaches its peak during the first week of life, preventive and system-based strategies offer a safer,
kinder and gentler means to prevent BIND including kernicterus.
12
Kernicterus: A Preventable Neonatal Brain Injury
1998).7 In addition, among 111,009 infants in the KPMCP barrier acts as a pump through ATP-dependent export by
database, 11 (0.01%) developed total serum bilirubin transporter molecules to remove Bf from the brain and
(TSB) levels ≥30mg/dL (when measured), and none maintain the concentration gradient of bilirubin from
apparently developed kernicterus.8 On the other hand, a plasma to CSF has yet to be determined, though ATP-
Danish population-based study reports 6 cases of dependent export by transporter molecules has been
kernicterus over a duration of 5 years for an estimated suggested.17-19
incidence of 1:38,000 well-babies cared for in Danish
nurseries.9 Another important determinant of toxicity is neuronal
susceptibility. Shapiro et al examined cerebella of
Pediatricians who have managed babies with neonatal jaundiced Gunn rats made toxic at various developmental
hyperbilirubinemia that progress to acute or chronic ages and found that neurons undergoing differentiation at
bilirubin encephalopathy often feel stigmatized and are the time of exposure were the most susceptible to cell
disinclined to report, discuss, review or publish their death, while those that were slightly more or less mature
experience. Thus, the scope of the true incidences of overt showed only transient changes or seemed to be much less
kernicterus as well as possible “subtle” neurological sensitive.19 This supported the presence of a critical or
deficits cannot be ascertained without an innovative and sensitive period when elevated bilirubin could be most
non-adversarial investigative approach. There is a societal toxic to neuronal development.
expectation to provide a universally available safe
birthing experience that includes a safe experience with Bilirubin can cause neuronal necrosis, and there is now
newborn jaundice. Thus, kernicterus (or a TSB level >30 good evidence in vitro that it induces apoptosis, which
mg/dL) is now considered a “never-event” by the public supports in vivo observations in older literature showing
health community.10-14 neuroanatomical changes consistent with apoptosis.
Evidence also suggests that bilirubin interferes with
This review focuses on the clinical definitions of BIND, intracellular calcium homeostasis by altering function and
its relationship with hyperbilirubinemia, bilirubin/albumin expression of calcium/calmodulin kinase II, by selectively
ratio and with a specific focus on G6PD deficiency- decreasing calcium binding proteins in susceptible
related neonatal hyperbilirubinemia. In addition, the brainstem areas and increasing intracellular calcium in
article briefly addresses the role of a systems strategy for cultured neurons, and by sensitizing the cell to other
a safer experience with newborn jaundice and the injuries or triggering apoptosis. Bilirubin may also kill
potential role of chemoprevention. cells by causing neuronal hyperexcitability perhaps via
excitatory amino acid neurotoxicity, or it may have other
A. Bilirubin Induced Neurologic Dysfunction membrane of neurotransmitter effects. Finally, it may act
by interfering with mitochondrial respiration and energy
1. Determinants of Neuronal Injury by Bilirubin production, perhaps as an oxidant injury.20-23
The risk of neuronal injury by bilirubin is primarily
determined by the concentration of unbound or “free” Overall, it is hypothesized that bilirubin damages brain
unconjugated bilirubin (Bf) and hydrogen ion (pH) in tissue cells via necrosis and apoptosis, either alone or in
blood. Bf can be measured indirectly or estimated by combination, in a neuro-anatomical distribution
calculating the molar ratio of total serum bilirubin (TSB) dependant on the amount, duration, and the
to albumin. Bilirubin enters brain tissue as Bf when the developmental timing of exposure of sensitive brain tissue
blood binding capacity is exceeded, or when other to free bilirubin. With this perspective, the neuro-
displacing substances, such as sulphonamides, compete anatomical and clinical expression of injury is likely to be
for bilirubin binding sites on albumin.15 Other important complex with different patterns of damage and a range of
risk factors for kernicterus relate to neuronal clinical expression. Different patterns of expression may
susceptibility, including gestational age, infection or relate to 1) the amount of, and duration of exposure to
sepsis, and hemolysis, especially Rh disease. Sepsis or free bilirubin (high level, short duration exposure not
other neonatal inflammatory conditions and prematurity necessarily the same as lower level, long duration
may decrease the bilirubin binding affinity of albumin. exposure), 2) the susceptibility of the developing CNS, 3)
the relative amount of necrosis vs. apoptosis produced,
Even though a "safe" level of bilirubin has not yet been and 4) whether surviving neurons will be functionally
determined, most of the circulatory bilirubin is bound to normal or more susceptible to other stressors either at the
albumin which acts as a “neuro-protective”. The blood- time of hyperbilirubinemia or afterwards.
brain-barrier has long been considered to play a role in
protection of the brain from bilirubin toxicity, and its
disruption produces diffuse yellow staining but not the 2. Neuropathology of Kernicterus
specific pattern of kernicterus.16 Whether the blood brain Kernicterus causes selective yellow staining in the basal
13
J. Arab Neonatal Forum 2005; 2: 12-24
ganglia, especially the globus pallidus and subthalamic Table I: Root Causes for Reemergence of Kernicterus
[adapted from JCAHO Sentinel Alert (11) and Johnson et al (5)]
nucleus. Brainstem nuclei, especially the auditory
(cochlear nucleus, inferior colliculus, superior olivary System Failure Major Root Causes for Reemergence of
complex), oculomotor and vestibular nuclei are especially Kernicterus
vulnerable. Other vulnerable areas include the cerebellum, Institutional Early hospital discharge (before extent of
Purkinje cells, and the hippocampus (especially the CA2 jaundice is known and signs of impending
brain damage have appeared)
sector). The basal ganglia are associated with the Structural limitations within the
movement disorders of dystonia, athetosis and healthcare systems to deal with continuity
choreoathetosis. Abnormalities of the auditory brainstem of mother-infant care after birthing.
nuclei are associated with deafness, hearing loss, and a Providers Lack of adequate concern for the risks of
severe jaundice in healthy term and near
recently described entity known as auditory neuropathy. term newborns
Abnormalities of the brainstem oculomotor nuclei are Medical care cost constraints with early
associated with strabismus and gaze palsies, especially discharge and limited access to healthcare
paresis of upgaze.1-3 In the auditory system, bilirubin does during the first week after birth
Family and Societal A lauded increase in breast feeding but
not appear to affect either inner or outer hair cells, but unsupported by optimal lactation
appears to be toxic to cell bodies of the auditory nerve in counseling to instruct, monitor and guide.
the spiral ganglia. Brainstem auditory nuclei and not the Paucity of educational materials to enable
pathways are particularly susceptible.24,25 The optimum parents to participate in safeguarding their
newborns
means of assessment is neuro-physiological since this
component of the auditory system cannot be imaged. Table II: Bilirubin-induced neurological dysfunction (BIND)
Neuro-physiological assessment involves the evaluation Score (adapted from Johnson et al (31)
of the mechanical structure of the inner ear by otoacoustic
emissions (OAE), and the outer hair cells (inner ear) by Severity Score Mental Date/ Date/ Date/
Status Time Time Time
cochlear microphonic responses (CM). In infants with None 0 Normal
kernicterus, these are both normal. Sensori-neural Mild 1 Sleepy, poor
assessment requires the testing of auditory brainstem feeding
response (ABR) or brainstem auditory evoked potential Moderate 2 Lethargic,
Irritable
(BAEP). In bilirubin-related injury, it is absent or
Severe 3 Semicoma,
abnormal and reflects damage to the auditory nerve (wave Seizures
I) as well as the auditory brainstem nuclei (waves III and Coma
V). Severity Score Muscle Tone
None 0 Normal
Mild 1 Neck
The basal ganglia lesions can be imaged with magnetic Stiffness,
resonance imaging (MRI), the signature of which is Mild hyper-
bilateral damage of the globus pallidus. The subthalamic /hypotonia
nuclei can sometimes be seen and are characteristically Moderate 2 Arching
neck,
affected. Disordered outputs from the basal ganglia are retrocolis,
possibly responsible for the dyskinetic movements. The Arching
MRI evidence of kernicterus is distinct from that of trunk
hypoxia-ischemia; in the latter, the thalamus, cortex and Severe 3 Bowing of
trunk
peri-ventricular white matter are involved; while, the Opisthotonus
caudate nuclei and putamen are not affected in Severity Score Cry pattern
kernicterus.26 None 0 Normal
Mild 1 High pitched
Moderate 2 Shrill
Severe 3 Inconsolable
3. Clinical Definitions of Bilirubin Induced Neurologic Total Bind Score
Dysfunction Nurse/MD signature
Kernicterus has usually referred to the post-mortem Score of 7 to 9: represent severe acute bilirubin encephalopathy;
evidence of icteric (yellow) staining of the basal ganglia urgent interventions are recommended to possibly minimize further
and lesions of the extra-pyramidal nervous system. The brain injury.
Pilot Registry has offered formal clinical definitions of Scores of 4 to 6: Represent moderate acute bilirubin encephalopathy
BIND and Kernicterus (Table I). The spectrum of acute and is likely to be reversible with urgent bilirubin reduction.
and chronic manifestations of BIND varies from the acute Scores of 1 to 3: Represent mild acute bilirubin encephalopathy and
are usually reversible with urgent bilirubin reduction strategies. An
stage bilirubin encephalopathy to those of chronic abnormal ABR or “referred” automated ABR would indicative of
sequelae such as isolated auditory neuropathy ( a form of BIND would be suggestive of moderate to severe ABE
14
Kernicterus: A Preventable Neonatal Brain Injury
Classification Clinical
Classic Kernicterus Have ? 3 classic signs of kernicterus including : 1) Auditory (AN, hearing loss), 2)Motor
(hyperkinetic dystonia or athetosis, choreoathetosis, “athetoid” CP, 3) oculomotor disorder
esp. impairment of upgaze, 4) dental enamel dysplasia.
Mixed kernicterus Auditory predominant: moderate of severe AN ± hearing loss with mild motor symptoms
or (hypotonia, mildly delayed walking, slightly abnormal muscle tone), normal or slightly
Location BIND abnormal GP (Signals) or MRI
Isolated Kernicterus Has signs and symptoms limited to only one system, either the auditory or motor system.
or BIND Most cases of isolated kernicterus have turned out to be not strictly isolated, but have findings
in another system on close examination
Moderate AN with absent or persistent abnormal ABR, Moderate hyperkinetic dystonia/ “athetoid”
Severity Mild/moderate hearing loss, may fluctuate; CP; ambulates with or without assistance with
speech delayed or absent athetoid/ choreoathetoid gait
Severe AN with absent ABR, severe-to-profound Severe dystonia/hyperkinetic CP; unable to
hearing loss/ deafness ambulate, feed self, sign, speak; often with episodic
severe hyper-tonial/spasticity, cramps
Timing Symptoms
Acute First few days or weeks of life, at the time of In infants: lethargy, variable hypotonia ±
Time unconjugated bilirubin neurotoxicity, hypertonia, high pitched cry, arching,
usually with excessive hyperbilirubinaemia retrocollis- opisthotonus, impaired upgaze,
but may have low bilirubin with displacers. fever, seizures, death
Rarely may occur in older children and
adults, eg with Crigler-Najjar syndrome or
severe hepatic failure, but always with acute
unconjugated bilirubin neurotoxicity.
Subacute In the days or weeks after bilirubin Similar to acute, but also may have feeding
neurotoxicity, eg after treatment with and sleep disorders
exchange transfusion or phototherapy the
natural decline in bilirubin
Chronic Months, years, decades Classical clinical kernicterus (movement
Disorder, auditory, oculomotor, dental) or
Subtle kernicterus/BIND
All four abnormal signs are present and /or abnormal MRI
Moderate Abnormal Any two of three of these abnormal are present If unavailable
sensorineural hearing loss), and chronic bilirubin The actual incidence of ABE is not known because (a)
encephalopathy of both neuromotor and auditory damage there have been no longitudinal surveillance studies of the
(kernicterus). Though not yet proven, some experts condition, (b) there is limited awareness and recognition
believe that there may be more neurological of this diagnosis in healthy babies and (c) the diagnosis is
manifestations of BIND including subtle basal ganglia usually not coded on discharge summaries (Table II).
and central processing disorders.27-29 The effect of even However, recent case reports and registries suggest that
moderate increases in TSB levels on early development kernicterus has re-emerged as a public health problem
remains a source of controversy, especially because some after years of near extinction.6,11-14 The introduction in the
clinical manifestations are reversible upon reduction of 1960’s of Rhogam to prevent Rh sensitization and
the TSB concentration. Figure 1: The Magnetic resonance image shows post-icteric
bilateral and increased T-2 weighted signals from the globus
a. Acute Bilirubin Encephalopathy (ABE)
15
J. Arab Neonatal Forum 2005; 2: 12-24
pallidus in an year old infant who previously manifested acute hypertonia and retrocolis, which increase in severity and
bilirubin encephalopathy
are usually accompanied by a shrill cry, an unexplained
irritability alternate with increasing lethargy. Advanced
signs are marked by cessation of feeding, bicycling
movements, inconsolable irritability and crying, possible
seizures, fever and coma. These are late findings and
ominous predictors of the likelihood of severe kernicteric
sequelae, even with intensive treatment. Acute stage
mortality is due to respiratory failure and progressive
coma or intractable seizures. Rate of progression of
clinical signs depends on the rate of bilirubin rise,
duration of hyperbilirubinemia, host-susceptibility and
presence of co-morbidities.
16
Kernicterus: A Preventable Neonatal Brain Injury
The only prospective study that has shown an toxicity and level of unbound bilirubin in excessively
association between TSB levels and occurrence of ABE jaundiced babies. The integrity of binding (below the
is that reported by Mollison and Cutbush in a 1954 1:1 molar ratio) is compromised in a newborn because
follow-up report of babies with hyperbilirubinemia and newborn albumin has a poor binding ability compared
hypoalbuminemia due to Rh hemolytic disease.37 These to adult albumin. It is further compromised if a)
data are from over four decades ago and the sample size albumin binding affinity is markedly decreased with
is small (n=60) and applicable to babies with severe concurrent prematurity, sickness or acidosis; b) protein
hemolytic disease. However, an incremental bound drugs compete for albumin binding sites. It is
relationship of kernicterus to increasing levels of TSB further compromised for postnatal age < 72 hours, and
>19 mg/dl is apparent. Currently most US nurseries if the serum albumin level is lower than expected. In
discharge babies without screening for hemolysis other severely hyperbilirubinemic but otherwise healthy
than Rh disease. Though hemolysis screening could be newborns (TSB levels >95th percentile and over 72
helpful, babies with pre-discharge high-risk hours age) the bilirubin to albumin ratio is a useful tool
hyperbilirubinemia (>75th percentile for age in hours) to define one’s “worry” and potential risk for BIND.39,40
are as likely to have impaired bilirubin clearance due to
confounding genetic polymorphisms in the glucuronyl For practical purposes, the B: A ratio can be expressed
transferase gene and / or delayed maturation of the in terms of mg of bilirubin to grams of albumin. A
otherwise normal glucuronyl transferase enzyme bilirubin to albumin ratio of 7.0 in mg to grams
system. In the Pilot Kernicterus Registry,5 the causes corresponds to a bilirubin to albumin molar ratio of
for kernicterus were attributed to three equivalent 0.80. Exposure to bilirubin/albumin ratios of >7.0 (mg
categories (one-third each): hemolytic disorders (mostly to gram) carry a clear risk of irreversible neurotoxicity,
ABO isoimmunization), G6PD deficiency (associated especially if such exposure is prolonged. Available
with both hemolysis and impaired bilirubin clinical and experimental data suggests that B: A ratios
conjugation) and idiopathic causes (presumably due to of >5.3 and <7.0 mg/g (molar ratios of bilirubin to
delayed or impaired function of the glucuronyl albumin >0.63 and <0.80) are generally associated with
transferase enzyme system) coupled with breast-feeding reversible abnormalities of auditory brainstem
and inadequate nutritional intake. In such newborns responses.41-45 In a term newborn with subtle signs of
with TSB levels >75th percentile a rate of TSB rise BIND these B: A ratio values can be reassuring as long
>0.20 mg/dl/hr will exceed the peak rate of rise as the bilirubin load is vigorously reduced and signs of
observed at the 95th percentile track on the bilirubin progression are closely monitored.
nomogram and increase the bilirubin load.38 At these
rates of rise, the bilirubin load will increase to severe
hyperbilirubinemia and risk for BIND. D. G-6-PD deficiency, Neonatal Hyperbilirubinemia
and Kernicterus
C. Relationship of Bilirubin to Albumin and Risk of G-6-PD deficiency is one of the commonest enzyme
ABE deficiencies in humans and can present with hemolytic
Albumin concentration is a powerful neuro-protective crises in children and adults (favism) who ingest fava
agent as well as a major determinant of both bilirubin beans or have exposure to stress of oxidants, drugs,
Figure 2: An infant with early onset hyperbilirubinemia that was progressive, unresponsive to intensive
phototherapy. Following an exchange transfusion, the infant has had a normal neurologic outcome. Serial TSB
levels are plotted on an hour-specific bilirubin nomogram (38)
C a s e : M a le I n f a n t w ith G -6 -P D D e fic ie n c y
E x c h a n ge T ra n s fu s io n
30
Serum Bilirubin (mg/dl)
J a un dic e n ot e d
20
9 5 t h pe rc e n ti le
7 5 th p e rc e n ti le
4 0 t h p e rc e nt il e
10
In te n s ive p h o t o t h er ap y
17
J. Arab Neonatal Forum 2005; 2: 12-24
infections and other chemical triggers.46 G-6-PD hyperbilirubinemia may not be completely amenable to
deficiency is also associated with neonatal prediction of hyperbilirubinemia or prevention of
hyperbilirubinemia though favism is unusual in infants. kernicterus.53,54
The association with severe neonatal
hyperbilirubinemia with its potentially devastating 2. Gradual onset jaundice with progressive neonatal
complication of kernicterus was made in Greece soon hyperbilirubinaemia. In contradistinction to the above,
after recognition of G-6-PD deficiency as an entity and significantly more G-6-PD deficient neonates develop
has subsequently been reported from many geographic hyperbilirubinemia compared with controls. Gradual
areas in which G-6-PD deficiency is found.47 The onset jaundice with progressive neonatal
incidence of neonatal hyperbilirubinemia has repeatedly hyperbilirubinemia can be severe and is associated with
been shown to be several-fold greater in G-6-PD a slower increase in TSB concentrations than in those
deficient populations than in the G-6-PD normal with acute hemolysis. With intensive, modern day
population.48,49 However, this incidence is not constant phototherapy exchange transfusion is rarely necessary
and varies in different communities and geographic with this variant of the hyperbilirubinemia. As these
areas and is related to numerous mutations. Functional babies are usually treated aggressively, the natural
severe mutations may cause hemolysis in the absence of history of the hyperbilirubinemia and consequently the
stress. Different mutations are characteristic of Asian, potential of extreme hyperbilirubinemia and the risk of
African, Southern Europe populations. Gourley linked kernicterus are unknown in this subgroup. There is
neonatal jaundice with Gilbert syndrome. Neonates some evidence that this form of jaundice has its origins
with the GS polymorphism have an increased rate of in utero: TSB values sampled immediately after birth
TSB rise in the first two days after birth and a were higher than in controls and correlated with both
predisposition to prolonged or severe neonatal third day TSB values as well as with those who
hyperbilirubinemia in infants with G-6-PD deficiency subsequently developed hyperbilirubinemia, defined as
or co-inherited with hematological abnormalities: a) TSB value >15.0 mg/dL. Also, blood
beta-thalassemia, b) hereditary spherocytosis and carboxyhemoglobin and end tidal carbon monoxide and
certain forms of ABO incompatibility.50,51 Kaplan et al representative of hemolysis, were higher in G-6-PD
have observed that infants with G-6-PD deficiency do deficient neonates than in controls shortly after birth.
not have an increased incidence of hyperbilirubinemia The pathogenesis of hyperbilirubinemia in G-6-PD
(compared to G-6-PD normals) unless they also carry deficient neonates appears to be different from G-6-PD
the UGT1A1 promoter polymorphism. Homozygotes normal counterparts, greater emphasis being laid on the
have significantly higher TSB levels than role of bilirubin conjugation defects. Also important in
hemizygotes.52 understanding of the pathogenesis hyperbilirubinemia is
the concept that the TSB at any point in time represents
Two clinical manifestations of G-6-PD deficiency and bilirubin production on the one hand, and its
neonatal hyperbilirubinemia are described in clinical elimination from the body, on the other. As long as
practice: 1) severe jaundice resulting from acute equilibrium between these processes is maintained,
hemolysis, similar to favism; 2) jaundice and TSB concentrations should not exceed the physiologic
hyperbilirubinemia of more gradual but progressive range. However, should bilirubin production exceed
onset. The frequency of either manifestation is not well the body’s capacity to eliminate it, hyperbilirubinemia
documented. may develop. Severe hemolysis is not essential to the
mechanism of hyperbilirubinemia: moderately
1. Acute and severe jaundice accompanied by sudden- increased heme catabolism in the face of diminished
onset of hemolysis is unusual in neonates. In some bilirubin conjugation may be sufficient to tip the
cases a known trigger of hemolysis can be identified balance. Because increased hemolysis does not appear
and results in rapidly rising serum total bilirubin (TSB) to play a major role in the patho-physiology of
levels. Maternal ingestion of fava beans can cause hyperbilirubinemia, diminished bilirubin conjugation
severe intrauterine hemolysis presumably by has been emphasized by some as an important factor
transplacental transmission of the fava metabolites. In [see Figure 2]. The current literature suggests that
other cases transmission of metabolites to the nursing insufficiency of bilirubin conjugation is the mechanism
infant via breast milk has been suggested. However, of neonatal hyperbilirubinemia in infants with G-6-PD
severe hemolytic episodes can occur even when all deficiency.55-57
known offenders are scrupulously avoided. It is possible
that as yet unidentifiable chemical offenders may be
included in the vast array of cleaning or other Pre-discharge hour-specific bilirubin screening can
household materials available. Beutler has emphasized identify many G-6-PD deficient neonates at high risk
infection as a possible inducer of hemolysis. These for developing hyperbilirubinemia and facilitate
severe hemolytic episodes [with clinical evidence of discharge and follow-up planning. Of those G-6-PD
hemolysis] can be unpredictable and there is frequently deficient neonates with pre-discharge TSB value <50th
no warning that acute hemolysis is about to occur. This percentile on the hour-specific nomogram, the
form of G-6-PD deficiency associated neonatal incidence of developing a TSB >15.0 mg/dL was very
18
Kernicterus: A Preventable Neonatal Brain Injury
low, but increased progressively as pre-discharge TSB lactation failure leading to adverse hyperbilirubinemia
values increased from the 50th to >90th percentile. outcomes or the incidence of lactation disruption
Additional population-based data are needed to better associated with management of hyperbilirubinemia.
describe and understand the predictive role of pre-
discharge hyperbilirubinemia as well as the natural 3. Undue reliance on visual assessment of jaundice.
history of hyperbilirubinemia in both homozygous and The AAP guideline cautions on the reliance of visual
heterozygous neonates with G-6-PD deficiency.58 estimation of jaundice. However, the inaccuracy of
visual assessment of jaundice may not be widely
E. A systems-approach for a safer management of appreciated.
newborn jaundice
The rationale to update “bilirubin guidelines” such as 4. Persistent hyperbilirubinemia. The incidence of
the 1994 AAP guidelines59 are based on new data persistent indirect hyperbilirubinemia (age >2 weeks),
related to newborn safety, that jaundice is an unreliable especially in breastfed infants, and its possible sequelae
indicator for severity of hyperbilirubinemia, the are not known. In addition, clinical distinction of benign
predictive abilities of pre-discharge screening for persistent jaundice from cholestasis is often difficult.
subsequent severe hyperbilirubinemia is weak and there Cholestasis, which occurs in approximately 1:2500 live
is a need for lowered bilirubin level thresholds for births, can be a manifestation of more than 70 different
interventions.60-62 These studies have provided an diseases, biliary atresia being the most common.67,68
opportunity for restructuring to a more physician Factors contributing to delayed referral of infants with
friendly instrument and enhancing its acceptance for biliary atresia include lack of follow-up of neonatal
wider implementation. The purpose of the guidelines is jaundice and misdiagnosis of breast milk jaundice.
to ensure that clear criteria for patient safety, family Early diagnosis of biliary atresia is crucial for a
centeredness, and precise, practical, user-friendly, successful surgical outcome but has no linkage with
preventive approaches and for timely interventions, are kernicterus. It is to be noted the 2004 AAP guidelines
met.63 Barriers to seamless transition from birth to home strongly recommends that a clinician should not
have been recognized to compound the risk for subtract the direct bilirubin value from the total serum
hyperbilirubinemia.64-66 Four clinical entities that add to bilirubin value for clinical decisions, especially for
inefficient continuity of care include 1) early discharge administration of phototherapy or exchange
(<72 hours age) without timely follow-up, 2) inadequate transfusion.69
lactation support, 3) undue reliance on the visual
assessment of jaundice to initiate evaluation, and 4) Since clear evidence for a course of action has been
lack of data to define persistence of jaundice, including absent, we have recommended an approach that
the potential for unrecognized cholestatic jaundice. guarantees patient safety pending the “gathering” of
evidence. Structural changes that would facilitate such a
1. Early discharge and multiple providers at multiple system-based approach should include a) pre-discharge
sites (problems with “hand-off”). Early discharge bilirubin management; b) follow-up bilirubin
shifted the locus of care from the hospital to home and management; and, c) lactational support and nutritional
created a need for post discharge observation, a change management. Currently there are two major pre-
in venue for patient and family education, and gaps in discharge screening strategies that are amenable to a
communication. Furthermore, follow-up appointments system-based approach: i) pre-discharge total serum
after hospital discharge are often scheduled after the bilirubin screening and ii) a scoring system based on
anticipated peak of serum bilirubin concentration. clinical risk factors. With either approach there should
Systems are limited to facilitate sharing of clinical data be no room for error and a wide margin of safety to
among multiple clinical providers at multiple sites such prevent the need for a “crash cart” approach for babies
as between the birth hospital and the paediatric office. with excessive hyperbilirubinemia. On the basis of
New parents may have difficulty arranging for a available evidence, we should screen all babies for
clinician to check their child after discharge. Flawed hyperbilirubinemia for targeted follow-up that is based
interactions between many different parties perpetuate on an hour-specific TSB measured for risk assessment.
the problems. To ensure a safe first week after birth for In addition, we should provide focused universal
all newborns requires broad changes in the processes of education with an emphasis on supporting adequate
care. lactational nutrition to decrease severe
hyperbilirubinemia and thus prevent kernicterus.70
2. Inefficient lactation counseling. A clinical diagnosis
of jaundice may lead to disruption of breastfeeding F. Role of Chemoprevention
rather than implementation of steps that would enhance Chemoprevention of hyperbilirubinemia by
breast milk intake. Although breast milk is the most pharmacological agents to effectively reduce adverse
appropriate feeding for newborns, exclusive breast bilirubin loads has been studied for several years and
feeding, especially if it is not going well, is a major risk recently reviewed by Dennery.71 The proven available
factor for hyperbilirubinemia. However, no quantitative options for pharmacotherapy include drug-induced
data are available to document either the incidence of acceleration of bilirubin excretion (such as use of
19
J. Arab Neonatal Forum 2005; 2: 12-24
Phenobarbital) and alteration of bilirubin production by investigated and evaluated in infants at risk for severe
synthetic heme analogues that act as competitive hyperbilirubinemia.
inhibitors for heme catabolism (such as tin
mesoporphyrin). In view of patient safety concerns Other strategies that warrant further investigations and
from unmonitored adverse effects related to severe clinical trials are use of agents that interrupt the entero-
hyperbilirubinemia, the role of chemoprevention in hepatic circulation and bilirubin accumulation from the
infants at risk for severe hyperbilirubinemia is being continued action of beta-glucuronidase.
investigated. Phenobarbital increases hepatic clearance Chemoprevention with use of casein supplements75 or
and excretion, and may be administered prenatally.71,72 other agents such as L-aspartic acid could decrease
It is effective when administered 1 week prior to intestinal reabsorption of bilirubin and may have a
delivery and when given to newborn infants. However, potential clinical role.76
this intervention has limited or no clinical effect when
administered to infants <32 weeks of gestation and has G. Global Perspective of Jaundice and Kernicterus.
now been shown to be ineffective when given prior to Kernicterus is still thought of by many as a condition
12 hours of age. The adverse effects of this therapy are that occurs primarily in underdeveloped countries. As
of concern. These are sedation, risk of hemorrhagic the JCAHO root cause list suggests, the safety net
disease, and potential for addiction. This drug has a protecting newborns has significant deficits. Most
slow onset of effect (usually several days) and a long families learn about potential problems related to
duration of action (one to two weeks) after its newborn care during childbirth education classes.
discontinuation. In addition, its confounding effects on Unfortunately, the lack of concern about jaundice
other hormones and concerns of drug safety have among health care providers has led to a major lacuna
limited the clinical value of phenobarbital as a in childbirth education curricula.77 The teaching and
chemopreventive agent for newborn jaundice. discussion of jaundice, impact of early discharge, and
breast-feeding have been minimal or non-existent. The
Newer chemopreventive strategies have included role of family and community in prevention of BIND
investigations of a number of synthetic heme analogues and Kernicterus is an integral component of any public
that are protoporphyrin derivatives of tin, zinc, health strategy.78 Since this condition is not yet a
manganese, chromium, and cobalt.73 Overall, “notifiable” disease, there is an urgent need for a
metalloporphyrins (MePs) reduce bilirubin production, tightening of the “safety net” and reaching all families
can be phototoxic and may increase transcription of and health-care workers to supplement existing
HO-1, the inducible HO isozyme. Effective information and expedite change in current practices for
development of this class of compounds has been in the assessing and effectively treating hyperbilirubinemia.
direction of products that are less phototoxic and are Kernicterus is frequent and less preventable in countries
stronger inhibitors of heme oxygenase. A number of with poor access to healthcare (for example: South
MePs have been evaluated experimentally with Asia, and Africa), those with high-risk populations
variations of the pertinent metal (such as tin, zinc, (Middle-East, as well as North African and South
chromium) and porphyrin (protoporphyrin, African nations) and countries who are rapidly
mesoporphyrin, bisglycol porphyrin, etc). Our improving their healthcare systems to contemporary
understanding of the molecular basis of heme standards (Eastern Europe and Latin America).
oxygenase inhibition is evolving as new heme
oxygenase isoenzymes are characterized in different In conclusion, Kernicterus ranks as a major cause for
organs. The significance of prolonged and potent, long- infant mortality and morbidity in developing countries
lasting inhibition of heme oxygenase needs to be but not considered as serious as birth asphyxia, sepsis,
differentiated from a single, acute and transient malnutrition and prematurity. However, it is the only
inhibition. The inherent appeal of naturally occurring neonatal condition for which safe, inexpensive and
molecules, such as zinc, has been questioned by the effective clinical strategies are easily available. Cost-
finding of deleterious effects on rabbit bone marrow effective bilirubin reduction strategies such as
erythroid and myeloid cells and by lethal consequences promotion of breast feeding, universal availability of
of chromium mesoporphyrin injection in animals. Thus safe and effective phototherapy as well as
far, the stannic porphyrins, in particular tin chemoprevention need to be targeted to infants at risk
protoporphyrin and tin mesoporphyrin have been while ensuring patient safety and universal access.
extensively investigated and found to be safe and Global eradication of kernicterus, through a national
effective in preclinical studies. With the successful public health agenda, is feasible and practical. It is
completion of nearly two decades of extensive clinical essential to a society that aspires for every family and
pharmacological and toxicological studies, as recently their newborn to have a safer experience with newborn
summarized by Kappas,74 stannate, an effective MeP, jaundice.
has demonstrated its therapeutic ability to safely reduce
bilirubin production through competitive inhibition of Acknowledgement: Preliminary paper presented at the
heme-oxygenase, the rate-limiting enzyme in heme “Hot Topics in Newborn Care”, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia,
catabolic sequence. Its chemopreventive role is being February, 2005 (Convener: Dr. Mai-Seoud).
20
Kernicterus: A Preventable Neonatal Brain Injury
21
J. Arab Neonatal Forum 2005; 2: 12-24
22
Kernicterus: A Preventable Neonatal Brain Injury
62. Brown AK, Johnson L. Loss of concern about 69. Esbjorner E. Albumin binding properties in relation
jaundice and the reemergence of kernicterus in full- to bilirubin and albumin concentrations during the
term infants in the era of managed care. Chapter In: first week of life. Acta Paediatr Scand 1991;
The Year Book of Neonatal and Perinatal Medicine, 80:400-405.
Fanaroff AA, Klaus MH (eds). Mosby Yearbook, 70. Bhutani VK, Johnson LH, Keren R. Diagnosis and
Philadelphia, pp xvii-xxviii,1996. management of hyperbilirubinemia in the term
63. American Academy of Pediatrics. Subcommittee on neonate: for a safer first week.
Hyperbilirubinemia, Maisels MJ, Baltz RD, Bhutani Pediatr Clin North Am 2004;51(4):843-861.
VK, Newman TB, Palmer H, Rosenfeld W, et al. 71. Dennery PA, Seidman D, Stevenson DK. Neonatal
Clinical Practice Guideline: Management of Hyperbilirubinemia. N Engl J Med 2001;334:581.
Hyperbilirubinemia in the Newborn Infant ≥35 72. Arya VB, Agarwal R, Paul VK, Deorari AK.
Weeks of Gestation. Pediatrics (in press, July 2004). Efficacy of Oral Phenobarbitone in Term “At Risk”
http://www.aap.org/jaundice guidelines.htm Neonates in Decreasing Neonatal
64. Palmer RH, Clanton M, Ezhuthachan S, Newman C, Hyperbilirubinemia: A Randomized Double-
Maisels J, Plsek P, Salem-Schatz S. Applying the blinded, Placebo Controlled Trial. Indian Pediatr
"10 simple rules" of the institute of medicine to 2004;41(4):327-332.
management of hyperbilirubinemia in newborns. 73. Alexander D. A method for interdicting the
Pediatrics 2003;112:1388-1393. development of severe jaundice in newborns by
65. Lannon C, Stark AR. Closing the gap between inhibiting the production of bilirubin. Pediatrics
guidelines and practice: ensuring safe and healthy 2004;113:135.
beginnings. Pediatrics 2004;114(2):494-496. 74. Kappas A. A method for interdicting the
66. Salem-Schatz S, Peterson LE, Palmer RH, Clanton development of severe jaundice in newborns by
SM, Ezhuthachan S, Luttrell RC, Newman C, inhibiting the production of bilirubin. Pediatrics
Westbury R. Barriers to first-week follow-up of 2004;113:119-123.
newborns: findings from parent and clinician focus 75. Gourley GR, Kreamer B, Cohnen M, Kosorok MR.
groups. Jt Comm J Qual Saf 2004;30(11):593-601. Neonatal jaundice and diet. Arch Pediatr Adolesc
67. Watkins JB. Neonatal Cholestasis: Developmental Med 1999;153(2):184-188.
Aspects and Current Concepts. Semin Liver Dis 76. Kreamer BL, Siegel FL, Gourley GR. A novel
1993;13(3):276-288. inhibitor of beta-glucuronidase: L-aspartic acid.
68. Gourley GR. Neonatal Jaundice and Disorders of Pediatr Res 2001; 50:460-466.
Bilirubin Metabolism. Suchy FJ, Sokol, RJ, and 77. Bhutani VK, Johnson LH. Newborn jaundice and
Balistreri WF. Liver Disease in Children. 2nd ed. kernicterus--health and societal perspectives.
Philadelphia, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Indian J Pediatr 2003;70:407-416.
2000, pp.275-314. 78. Sheridan SE. Parents of Infants and Children with
Kernicterus. J Perinatol 2005;25(4):227-228.
_____________________________________
23