HOME LAW NOTES + PH ELECTIONS + CASE DIGESTS + TRAVEL GAMES +

TOYS

LAW TECH WORLD

Law, Technology and the World

2014 CASE DIGEST: GMA NETWORK V. COMELEC

Published by admin on December 20, 2015 | Leave a response

GMA NETWORK, INC., Petitioner,

vs.

COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, Respondent.

G.R. No. 205357 September 2, 2014

PONENTE: Peralta

TOPIC: Freedom of expression, of speech and of the press, airtime limits

FACTS:

The five (5) petitions before the Court put in issue the alleged unconstitutionality
of Section 9 (a) of COMELEC Resolution No. 9615 limiting the broadcast and radio
advertisements of candidates and political parties for national election positions to an
aggregate total of one hundred twenty (120) minutes and one hundred eighty (180)
minutes, respectively. They contend that such restrictive regulation on allowable
broadcast time violates freedom of the press, impairs the people’s right to suffrage as

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 1 of 7
 well as their right to information relative to the exercise of their right to choose who to
elect during the forth coming elections

Section 9 (a) provides for an “aggregate total” airtime instead of the previous
“per station” airtime for political campaigns or advertisements, and also required prior
COMELEC approval for candidates’ television and radio guestings and appearances.

ISSUE:

Whether or not Section 9 (a) of COMELEC Resolution No. 9615 on airtime

limits violates freedom of expression, of speech and of the press.

HELD:

YES. The Court held that the assailed rule on “aggregate-based” airtime limits
is unreasonable and arbitrary as it unduly restricts and constrains the ability of
candidates and political parties to reach out and communicate with the people. Here,
the adverted reason for imposing the “aggregate-based” airtime limits – leveling the
playing field – does not constitute a compelling state interest which would justify such a
substantial restriction on the freedom of candidates and political parties to
communicate their ideas, philosophies, platforms and programs of government. And,
this is specially so in the absence of a clear-cut basis for the imposition of such a
prohibitive measure.

It is also particularly unreasonable and whimsical to adopt the aggregate-based

time limits on broadcast time when we consider that the Philippines is not only
composed of so many islands. There are also a lot of languages and dialects spoken
among the citizens across the country. Accordingly, for a national candidate to really
reach out to as many of the electorates as possible, then it might also be necessary that
he conveys his message through his advertisements in languages and dialects that the
people may more readily understand and relate to. To add all of these airtimes in
different dialects would greatly hamper the ability of such candidate to express himself
– a form of suppression of his political speech.

Amendments Freedoms

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 2 of 7
 RELATED ARTICLES:

2016 Elections: Binay, No. 1 in TV Ads Spending

Political Law Bar Exam Answers: Bill of Attainder

Case Digest: NICOLAS-LEWIS v COMELEC

2015 Case Digest: Diocese of Bacolod v. COMELEC

Case Digest: BIENVENIDO A. CERBO, JR., et al. v. THE COMMISSION ON

ELECTIONS, et al. 516 SCRA 51 (2007)

Case Digest: KABATAAN PARTY-LIST REPRESENTATIVE PALATINO, et

al. v. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 3 of 7
 Share this:

Posted in Case Digest, Political Law

LEAVE A REPLY

Comment

Name * Email *

Website

POST COMMENT

PREVIOUS NEXT

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 4 of 7
 SEARCH

Law Tech World

541 likes

Like Page

Be the first of your friends to like this

POPULAR POSTS

Pokemon Revolution: How to Get to Giovanni in Silph Co Maze (25,348)

Pokemon Revolution: Eevee Mission at Game Corner Guide (15,070)
2014 Case Digest: Arigo v. Swift (8,334)
Pokemon Revolution: How to Get to Articuno in Seafoam Island (7,835)
2015 Case Digest: Diocese of Bacolod v. COMELEC (6,956)
2017 Case Digest: Estipona v. Lobrigo and People (5,687)
2014 Case Digest: Sameer Overseas Placement Agency… (5,553)
2015 Case Digest: Kalaw v. Fernandez (MR) (5,261)
Pokemon Revolution: Cinnabar Mansion Guide (4,910)
Case Digest: PCGG V SANDIGANBAYAN (4,509)

This work by Law Tech World is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License.

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 5 of 7
 Live Traffic Feed
A visitor from Buting, Rizal
viewed "Case Digest: LA BUGAL
B’LAAN TRIBAL
ASSOCIATION INC., et. al. v.
VICTOR O. RAMOS, Secretary
Department of Environment and
Natural
A visitorResources;
from UnitedHORACIO
States
RAMOS, Director, Mines
viewed "Pokemon Revolution: and
Geosciences
How to Get toBureau (MGB-
Articuno in
DENR);
Seafoam
A RUBEN
Island"
visitor from TORRES,
3 mins ago
Philippines viewed
Executive Secretary;
"Case Digest: LA BUGAL and WMC
(PH"
B’LAAN1 min ago
TRIBAL
ASSOCIATION INC., et. al. v.
VICTOR O. RAMOS, Secretary
Department of Environment and
Natural
A visitorResources; HORACIO
from Liberty, Leyte
RAMOS, Director, Mines
viewed "Case Digest: LA BUGALand
Geosciences
B’LAAN TRIBAL Bureau (MGB-
DENR); RUBENINC.,
ASSOCIATION TORRES,
et. al. v.
Executive Secretary; and
VICTOR O. RAMOS, Secretary WMC
(PH" 6 minsof
Department ago
Environment and
Natural
A visitorResources; HORACIO
from Liberty, Leyte
RAMOS,
viewed "2014 Case Digest:and
Director, Mines CBK
Geosciences Bureau (MGB-
Power Company Limited v. CIR"
A visitor RUBEN
DENR); from Quezon City
TORRES,
10 mins ago
viewed
Executive"Case Digest:and
Secretary; DE WMC
MESA
V. ACERO"
(PH" 8 mins 15 mins ago
A visitor fromago
Taytay, Rizal
viewed "Obligations and

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 6 of 7
 viewed "Obligations and
Contracts MCQs – Set 1" 17 mins
A visitor from Caloocan viewed
ago
"2015 Case Digest: Diocese of
Bacolod v. COMELEC" 18 mins
A visitor from Buting, Rizal
ago
viewed "Case Digest:
FELICIANO ESGUERRA, et al.
v. visitor
A VIRGINIA fromTRINIDAD,
Banjarmasin,et al."
21 mins agoSelatan viewed
Kalimantan
"Pokemon Revolution: How to
Get HM01
Real-time view · Get– Cut" 23 mins ago
Feedjit

Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2018 Law Tech World.

Powered by WordPress and Live Wire.

http://lawtechworld.com/blog/blog/2015/12/2014-case-digest-gma-network-v-comelec/ 17/02/2018, 12A31 AM

Page 7 of 7