Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
3, JULY 2003
I. INTRODUCTION
Fig. 1. Typical schematic of a power distribution system compensated by a
Similarly, let and be the input reactive power from If the voltage sag is so severe that (11) cannot be satisfied,
the source and load reactive power, respectively, then then the optimum value of can still be calculated by setting
(5) . At this operating point, the DVR is supplying
minimum real power to the external system to keep p.u.
This is considered next.
(6) Case 2—Optimal Operation When : As ,
use (4) and set . This means that
Denote the reactive power supplied by the DVR as , then
(7)
(8) i.e., (12)
Therefore, the results of cases 1 and 2 can be combined to
From (4) and (8), it is apparent that the control of real and determine an optimum adjustment strategy for any given dis-
reactive power exchange between the DVR and distribution turbance as follows:
system is possible with the adjustment of the phase angle for If
given , , , and .
Fig. 6. Real power supplied by the DVR Vs three-phase voltage sag Fig. 9. DVR injected voltage magnitude for a three-phase balanced sag.
magnitude.
Fig. 7. Real power supplied by the DVR Vs two-phase voltage sag magnitude.
healthy phases in case of single-phase sag, is higher than en-
ergy supply by the source under two-phase or three-phase sag
situations.
Figs. 9 and 10 show the respective voltage injection require-
ment for in-phase boosting and the PAC techniques under three-
phase and single-phase sags, respectively. Fig. 9 shows that a
significantly higher injection voltage is required for the PAC
technique at lower sags compared with the in-phase boosting
method. This difference between the voltage injection require-
ments of the two methods diminishes with the increase in sag
magnitude. The injection voltage increases much more steeply
with the sag depth over the range where no real power is in-
jected because the load voltage boost has to be supported by an
increase in the reactive power injected from the DVR. The real
power injection, once it comes into play, offsets somewhat the
Fig. 8. Real power supplied by the DVR Vs single phase voltage sag reactive power support, and thus, the increase in the injection
magnitude. voltage magnitude becomes less significant.
the DVR needs to supply less power than that based on in-phase IV. DVR CONTROL
boosting technique. As the sag level increases, however, the
amount of energy saving reduces correspondingly. Similar ob- Having considered the energy aspect of the DVR design, at-
servation can also be seen from Figs. 7 and 8: the DVR can be tention will now be directed toward the dynamic performance
operated in the PAC mode without supplying real power to the of the restorer.
system for two-phase sag of up to 0.3 p.u. and for single phase
sag, of up to 0.6 p.u. It is evident from Fig. 8 that the energy A. Multiloop Control System
saving from the proposed method is significantly higher for the With the rapid advances in microelectronics, real-time dig-
case of single-phase sags compared to that of two-phase and ital control of custom power devices using cost-effective dig-
three-phase sags. This can be attributed to the fact that the ex- ital-signal-processor (DSP)-based hardware system has become
tent at which the energy supply by the source, which has two a viable proposition. The DSP hardware architecture enables
VILATHGAMUWA et al.: VOLTAGE SAG COMPENSATION WITH ENERGY OPTIMIZED DYNAMIC VOLTAGE RESTORER 933
Fig. 11. Block diagram representation of the DVR system with the multiloop feedback controller.
most of its instructions to be executed in a single instruction propriately, the load voltage can also be controlled in the event
cycle and complex control algorithms to be processed at a faster of load changes. This control feature, together with the outer
rate compared to single-chip microprocessors. In the light of this voltage feedback loop described earlier, can be readily incor-
development, a multiloop control structure for the DVR is now porated into the DVR control scheme. This is shown in Fig. 11
proposed whereby the resulting load voltage is regulated to track where it is shown that the DVR load-side voltage is compared
a sinusoidal reference. The design of such a control scheme is with the load voltage reference value, the error is multiplied by
necessary as it has been shown that the consequence of using the voltage error feedback gain and the product is fed to the
the existing DVR open-loop control can result in poor system second stage as a reference for the filter capacitor current .
damping following a voltage sag [8]. This virtual capacitor current reference is then compared with
The fidelity of the DVR output voltage depends on the the actual capacitor current and the error is multiplied with the
accuracy and dynamic behavior of the pulse width modulated current error gain to form the inner current feedback loop.
(PWM) voltage synthesis scheme and the control system The output signal of this loop is subsequently fed to the PWM
adopted. The general requirement of such control scheme is to generator of the inverter. As the inherent delay in the feedback
obtain an ac waveform with low total harmonic distortion and control system could result in excessive overshoot or under-
good dynamic response characteristics against supply and load shoot in the injected voltage following a sudden change in , a
disturbances. Usually, the control voltage of the DVR is derived feed-forward control signal has also been added to the inverter
by comparing the supply voltage against a reference waveform. input voltage signal in order to provide instantaneous response
Although system stability is guaranteed when adopting this to the change in . The design criterion and the detailed anal-
method, it has been shown that the stability margin can be ysis of the resulting control scheme are described in [8].
inadequate and the damping of the output voltage can be very
poor due to the presence of the switching harmonic filter [8]. B. Determination of Supply Voltage Parameters
Poor damping results in sustained voltage oscillations in the The reference waveform referred to earlier is generated by a
distribution line which could have serious repercussions on sen- digital phase locked loop (PLL) in the following way. The PLL
sitive loads and equipment, such as the adjustable speed-drives. tracks the supply voltage continuously but upon the initiation of
The supply voltage oscillations result in current surge into the a sag, the tracking process is frozen and the PLL subsequently
dc-link capacitor which holds the rectified dc voltage supply uses a look-up table to generate the reference waveform. In this
to the drives’ inverter. The excessive charging of the dc-link way, the desired phase advancement in the injected voltage can
capacitor may cause nuisance tripping. Another disadvantage of be realized. Parameters of the incoming voltages, which include
using such an open-loop control scheme is that the steady-state supply voltage amplitude and phase angle, need to be estimated
load voltage may not be compensated to the desired value accurately in real-time so as to obtain the actual advance angle
owing to voltage drop across the transformer series impedance for a particular disturbance. In this regard, an estimation method
and the filter. This becomes particularly important if the load is based on Kalman Filtering technique has been implemented [8].
nonlinear as nonsinusoidal currents drawn by such a load can The authors are unaware of any previous application of Kalman
distort the load voltage. It is therefore also essential to include filtering for dynamic voltage restoration purposes.
in the DVR control scheme the feature of being able to correct
the load voltage toward a desirable reference value.
V. EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATIONS
Current mode control techniques are usually applied to power
electronic circuits wherein an inner current loop is employed A detailed experimental investigation of the DVR system was
within an outer voltage loop in the closed-loop regulation of carried out in the laboratory in order to verify the effectiveness
power converters. It can be seen from Fig. 3 that the rate of of the proposed design. The experimental set-up and the pa-
change of the DVR output voltage is proportional to the cur- rameters selected for the study are based on an assumed 22-kV
rent of the filter capacitor. If this current can be regulated ap- distribution system delivering a load of 4 MVA, such as that
934 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 18, NO. 3, JULY 2003
TABLE I
ACTUAL SYSTEM 22-kV AND 4-MVA ASSUMED, SCALED-MODEL VALUES ARE
DETERMINED BY MAINTAINING THE SAME BASE IMPEDANCE OF 121
Fig. 14. Load-voltage response for two-phase 40% sag for an inductive load
under multiloop control (in-phase mode), (time: 20 ms/div).
PWM switching signals for the voltage source inverter are gen-
erated by a commercially available DSP controller board [7].
The source and load voltages as well as the filter capacitor cur-
rents are measured by transducers and are fed to the A/D con-
verters in the DSP card for real-time control. The sampling fre-
quency of the control system is set at 10 kHz.
Typical experimental results on supply voltage estimation are
Fig. 12. Hardware prototype configuration of the DVR. discussed first. In this experiment, a 40% single-phase sag is
generated (nominal voltage is 100 V). Using the Kalman fil-
shown in Fig. 1. The filter inductor and capacitor values have tering algorithm, the amplitude of the voltage is calculated in
been determined for this particular application by assuming that real-time. After extracting the amplitude and phase angle the
switching harmonics above 5 kHz are attenuated by at least required phase advance angle for the PAC is calculated using
40 dB. (13). The results of the estimation of supply parameters are
Table I shows the parameters of the scaled-down DVR system shown in Fig. 13. It can be seen that in less than half-cycle, the
used in the laboratory tests. The hardware configuration of the algorithm is able to detect the actual supply voltage parameters
prototype DVR is shown in Fig. 12. A three-phase low voltage and produce the optimal . Fig. 13 also shows the reference
programmable power source supplies the R-L load through a voltage waveforms generated by the PLL which can be used in
bank of series injection transformers. The injection transformer conjunction with in-phase injection or PAC techniques. In the
primary windings are connected to the PWM voltage source in- second plot, the reference phase voltage is advanced gradually
verter via the LC low-pass filter. The voltage source inverter at the beginning of the sag once has been determined while
consists of six insulated gate bipolar transistor (IGBT) switches it is gradually retarded to the normal value once the sag ceases.
with antiparalleled diodes connected across each switch. The Various types of sags are experimented under the proposed mul-
dc-link of the inverter is fed by a separate power supply. The tiloop control. Figs. 14 and 15 show the load voltage response
VILATHGAMUWA et al.: VOLTAGE SAG COMPENSATION WITH ENERGY OPTIMIZED DYNAMIC VOLTAGE RESTORER 935
Fig. 15. Load-voltage response for single-phase 40% sag for an inductive load
under multiloop control (in-phase mode), (time: 20 ms/div).
Fig. 18. Load-voltage response for single-phase 40% sag for an inductive load
under open-loop control (in-phase mode), (time: 20 ms/div).
Fig. 19. Real power supplied by the DVR under (a) PAC and (b) in-phase
Fig. 16. Load-voltage response for two-phase 40% sag for an inductive load modes of operation (time: 20 ms/div).
under multiloop control (PAC mode), (time: 20 ms/div).
phase deviation. It shows that under in-phase control mode, the
power injection is around 72 W while for the PAC mode it is
about 52 W, for a load of 247 VA, 0.77 lagging power factor. The
corresponding values based on the results of Section III-B are 76
W and 42 W, respectively. This discrepancy may be attributed to
measurement errors and possible deviations in load impedance
and filter reactances. Nevertheless, this shows the PAC mode
is attractive over in-phase control mode with regards to energy
saving.
VI. CONCLUSIONS
A new phase advanced multiloop control scheme has been
proposed for the dynamic voltage restorer. A Kalman filter is
used to determine the supply voltage parameters such that the
Fig. 17. Load-voltage response for single-phase 40% sag for an inductive load control scheme can be realized in real time. Through analysis,
under multiloop control (PAC mode), (time: 20 ms/div). simulation, and experimental measurements, it is shown that
the proposed scheme is superior compared to the conventional
under L-L and single-phase sags when in-phase control method in-phase injection technique in terms of energy saving and dy-
was implemented. Figs. 16 and 17 show the corresponding re- namic performance. Such characteristics are highly desirable as
sults under PAC scheme. Fig. 18 shows the waveform of the the design is seen to result in a more economical restorer which
load voltage for a single-phase sag under open-loop control with can improve the ride-through capability of sensitive loads and
in-phase boosting. It is noted that, in general, the degree of industrial processes.
damping has increased significantly with the multiloop control
scheme compared to that under the open-loop scheme. REFERENCES
Fig. 19 shows the real power injected by the DVR under PAC [1] T. Jauch, A. Kara, M. Rahmani, and D. Westermann, “Power quality
and in-phase control mode for a three-phase 40% sag without ensured by dynamic voltage correction,” ABB Rev., vol. 4, 1998.
936 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 18, NO. 3, JULY 2003
[2] N. H. Woodley, L. Morgan, and A. Sundaram, “Experience with an in- A. A. D. Ranjith Perera received the B.Sc. degree in electrical engineering
verter-based dynamic voltage restorer,” IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, from the University of Moratuwa, Sri Lanka, in 1993, and the M.Eng. degree
vol. 14, pp. 1181–1186, July 1999. from Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, in 2000.
[3] N. A. Samra, C. Neft, A. Sundaram, and W. Malcolm, “The distribu- Currently, he is an Application Engineer with SP Systems Pte. Ltd., Singa-
tion system dynamic voltage restorer and its applications at industrial pore. He was also an Electrical Engineer and Project Manager with Lanka Trans-
facilities with sensitive loads,” in Proc. Power Conversion Intell. Mo- formers Ltd., Sri Lanka. His research interest is in power electronics and control.
tion Power Quality, Long Beach, CA, Sept. 1995.
[4] T. Wunderlin, P. Dahler, D. Amhof, and H. Gruning, “Power supply
quality improvement with a dynamic voltage restorer,” in Proc. Int.
Conf. Energy Manage. Power Delivery, vol. 2, 1998, pp. 518–525.
[5] S. S. Choi, B. H. Li, and D. M. Vilathgamuwa, “Dynamic voltage S. S. Choi received the B.E. and Ph.D. degrees from the University of Canter-
restoration with minimum energy injection,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., bury, New Zealand, in 1973 and 1976, respectively.
vol. 15, pp. 51–57, Feb. 2000. Currently, he is a Professor in the School of Electrical and Electronic Engi-
[6] S. W. Middlekauff and E. R. Collinges Jr., “System and customer impact: neering at Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. He was also with the
Consideration for series custom power devices,” IEEE Trans. Power De- New Zealand Electricity Department at the National University of Singapore,
livery, vol. 13, pp. 278–282, Jan. 1998. and the State Energy Commission of Western Australia, Perth. His research in-
[7] “dSPACE DS1103 DSP Controller Board, dSPACE GmbH,”, Paderborn, terests include power system analysis, control, FACTS, and power quality.
Germany.
[8] A. A. D. R. Perera, “Development of Controllers for the Dynamic
Voltage Restorer,” M.Eng., Nanyang Tech. Univ., Singapore, 2000.