Unhealthy appetite for food porn

Silverman, Gary . FT.com ; London (Sep 18, 2008).

ProQuest document link

FULL TEXT
The first thing I noticed was her voice, so sticky, sweet and southern it poured out of her like syrup. "Smear it,
baby," she cooed to the woman with her. "Just smear it."

It was early on a Sunday afternoon. I had turned on the television without knowing where I was going and found
myself facing two women who seemed to have only one thing on their minds.

They were holding it in between them. Long and cylindrical, it was a loaf of bread - big enough for a peasant family
sitting down to dinner - that they proceeded to slice in half so they could gleefully smear the insides with gobs of
garlic butter.

I got my bearings. I realised I was watching the Food Network. But it wasn't the Food Network that I had grown to
know and love since the late 1990s, when I turned to its earnest chefs as a relief from cultural sludge that
dominates so much of US television.

This was the Food Network gone wild. The programme I was watching was called "Paula's Best Dishes" and the
woman giving the orders, Paula Deen, was cooking with a guest, Cheryl Day, proprietor of a Savannah, Georgia,
bakery called Back in the Day that is known for its way with butter cream.

"We bring out the worst in each other," Paula told Cheryl as they played with their buttery loaf. "Or the best."

I think Paula had it right the first time. Unwilling to live by garlic bread alone, she reached for a tray of lasagna that
had apparently been made earlier in the show, cut off two ample mounds of the baked pasta and inserted them
between slices of the garlic bread.

Splitting the entire loaf between them, she and Cheryl raised their massive lasagna sandwiches to their mouths
and dug in, squealing in delight until Paula brought the festivities to an end by saying they would return after a
commercial break - to sample Cheryl's cupcakes.

At this point, I think I should say something about myself. When it comes to other people's pleasures, I have long
tried to live up to the words of Jesus: Judge not, lest ye be judged.

But the sight of those women diving into all those calories left me unable to hold my tongue. It struck me as
obscene - an incitement to obesity in a country where so many people are eating themselves to death. I would call
it "food porn".

I use the term advisedly. The armchair deconstructionist in me can't help but note the formal similarities between
food shows and traditional cinematic presentations of sexual activities. In both genres, the viewer is offered a

PDF GENERATED BY SEARCH.PROQUEST.COM Page 1 of 3

titillating peek into a traditionally domestic sphere - in one case, the bedroom; in the other, the kitchen. The stars
do lots of oohing and aahing, and the camera work alternates between a fixed wide shot and close-ups of selected
objects of desire.

What makes something obscene in either area will always be a matter for debate. But I think we can agree that
there is material that does harm and material that doesn't. In the sexual realm, people try to get at this difference
by distinguishing pornography from erotica, and I think we make similar distinctions when it comes to cooking on
television.

For an example of food "erotica", we need look no further than domestic goddess Nigella Lawson, the star of
"Nigella Bites", a UK cooking programme known on both sides of the Atlantic (and shown on the Food Network).
The show clearly appeals to the senses, but it ultimately presents food and its star in a healthy light. Her food
helps Nigella connect with other people. She is shown cooking for friends and family and passing on the culinary
wisdom of her elders.
By contrast, the subject of Paula's Best Dishes seems to be the pleasures of overeating, as opposed to the
pleasures of eating. The two women are depicted as losing themselves in food - their faces obscured by the
enormity of their lasagna sandwiches. The image ultimately desensitises its audience.

This show is by no means the only one of its kind with The Food Network seeming to serving up ever greater
portions of high-calorie programming. When I started watching a decade ago, I remember seeing all the food
groups - particularly on shows such as "Iron Chef," a Japanese cooking competition that required the contestants
to quickly prepare several dishes based on a single ingredient and became a cult classic in the process.

Today the network still has a wide variety of shows including A Cooks Tour in which Tony Bourdain travels the
world to find exotic foods and Healthy Appetite that focuses on lighter recipes and is presented by Ellie Krieger.
But these appear to be in a minority. A perusal of a recent Saturday night Food Network schedule revealed it to be
more focused on fat and sugar, featuring programmes devoted to such subjects as fast-food drive-ins, colas,
Krispy Kreme doughnuts, potato chips, movie snacks and vending machines.

It isn't hard to guess what the Food Network is trying to do. Networks of all stripes are threatened by relentless
audience fragmentation as the number of entertainment options grows. One common response is to lock in a
niche audience - and Food Network seems be targeting people who spend Saturday nights thinking about colas,
doughnuts, potato chips and movie snacks.

I would submit that these people are also likely to be spending Saturday nights consuming colas, doughnuts,
potato chips, and movie snacks, and I can't see how the Food Network is doing them much good by presenting
paean after paean to foods that could kill them.

One would think that a television network would want to keep its audience alive as long as possible - if only for
business reasons. But the rise of food porn is reminder that corporate television executives aren't paid to think that
far ahead.

More articles on television round the world

Credit: By Gary Silverman

PDF GENERATED BY SEARCH.PROQUEST.COM Page 2 of 3

DETAILS

People: Deen, Paula Day, Cheryl

Publication title: FT.com; London

Publication year: 2008

Publication date: Sep 18, 2008

Publisher: The Financial Times Limited

Place of publication: London

Country of publication: United Kingdom, London

Publication subject: Business And Economics

Source type: Trade Journals

Language of publication: English

Document type: News

ProQuest document ID: 229213977

Document URL: https://search.proquest.com/docview/22921397 7?accountid=145163

Copyright: (Copyright Financial Times Ltd. 2008. All rights reserved.)

Last updated: 2017-11-08

Database: ProQuest Central

Database copyright  2019 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Terms and Conditions Contact ProQuest

PDF GENERATED BY SEARCH.PROQUEST.COM Page 3 of 3