Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
of customer
experience…
a look ahead
to 2020
Celebrating 20 years
of the Global CX
Benchmarking Report
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Contents
1. Foreword 3
7. Next steps 22
2
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
1. Foreword
Over the last 20 years, ensuring that ‘the customer is king’ has become
more significant than ever.
Meanwhile, the challenges facing businesses have game-changing Artificial Intelligence (AI) aren’t only
been exacerbated by growing cost pressures, siloed advancing customer expectations but require CX
behaviours, and the need to deliver tangible value. journeys to be continuously re-engineered.
Disruptive innovators have become the ‘prophets
of the new land’, and exceptional customer The goalposts are changing. What worked before
experience (CX) is an undisputed differentiator in won’t necessarily meet your needs for the future.
the battleground of today’s digital world. At face value, contact resolution rates are worse
today than they were 20 years ago. But, today, we’re
The last 20 years of CX benchmarking results trace not just measuring whether first contact resolution
a profound acceleration of the rate of change in occurred or not. We’re trying to understand whether
customer behaviour, and their expectations are the agent added value in terms of the opportunity
frequently out-pacing boardroom decision making the interaction presented.
and organisational execution.
Organisations often tend to interpret this service
The world has formed a digital skin. Digital evolution as an urgent and ongoing need to
technologies are enabling information exchange implement new technologies.
at unprecedented speeds. Social media, alongside
the always-on capability of ever-smarter devices, However, as the Dimension Data Global CX
have completely reinvented user attitudes and Benchmarking Report has proven in over 20 years of
consumer behaviours. research, successful CX is less about technology, and
more about adopting new business strategies and
Changing channel choices need to be balanced customer-centric attitudes.
against effective deployments and necessitates
alignment between solution design and user needs. Today the CX landscape is complex and
sophisticated, both in design and in its impact
Many established business processes weren’t on the business. Its role is often misunderstood.
designed for, and struggle to understand, the Frequently, it’s underplayed.
digital revolution. Adaptability and innovation are
key. To thrive, organisations must recognise that In this commentary, we’ll explore some of the
exceptional CX is vital. changes, challenges – and opportunities – that
you can adopt to make CX a source of competitive
Successful CX demands agile organisations that can advantage and improved customer loyalty and
operate in a fast-changing mobile, online, social, profitability… and help you to prepare your
and automated era. CX reputations and mistakes are business as we look ahead to 2020 and beyond.
highly visible and the introduction of robotics and
Rob Allman
Group Senior Vice President, CX at Dimension Data
Rob is a global practitioner and thought leader in CX. For over 20 years, he’s enabled
organisations to transform and grow the value of their customer relationships.
3
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
4
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Transformation of CX
Telephone-primed CX Digital-primed CX
In the digital age, we’re seeing a return to the idea These characteristics are based on an understanding
that the customer is the most essential part of the that customer expectation and opportunity shifts go
business; that he or she is the origin and driver of hand in hand with the evolution of technologies and
business value, whether that’s defined as profit fresh thinking from disruptive innovators. It’s clear
or performance. Organisations committing their now that the ways in which we work, live, and play
entire existence to delivering a superior customer will merge and increasingly be managed seamlessly
experience are not only prospering, they’re via aggregated data across multiple organisations.
gaining market share. They’ve already changed There’s an explosive growth of voice user interface
their customer experience irrevocably. They’re devices in connecting organisations’ services, our
setting the bar for customer experience, even for personal preferences, and the mechanics of our
organisations that aren’t their direct competitors, day to day life. Automated personal concierge
or in the same market. capabilities represent a significant shift in how we
engage with organisations. More and more, people
One of the seminal findings of the 2017 Global CX are favouring organisations with the ability to
Benchmarking Report was that once customers provide smart, integrated services.
are exposed to exceptional experience by one
organisation, they apply that yardstick to all other The security of personal data is now paramount.
organisations with which they interact. It must be an integral part of the new corporate
culture, as the value of such data increases
Today, you’re not being compared to your peers; exponentially and people and governments become
you’re being compared to the best overall. You’re emphatic about related rights and legislation.
not competing with your peers; you’re competing
with whoever has found the shortest digital route to In 2017, the Global CX Benchmarking Report found
the customer’s sweet spot. that companies that have fully embraced digital
technology, and put the customer front and centre of
A constant we’ve observed – and predict will remain all their operations, are experiencing extraordinary
ever present – is that achievement of the pinnacle of growth and profitability. In their case, the customer
CX is not a once-off, unique event. It’s possible only is the source – not a by-product – of their success.
through a culture-defining set of characteristics.
5
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
6
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
• Organisations committing to transforming their CX • Some 36% don’t have a single manager
and leveraging new digital capabilities, alongside exclusively responsible for CX. Of those who do,
a human touch that’s available when necessary, just 36% are at board level.
are demonstrating huge value. A staggering 91.6%
can evidence increased customer loyalty, while • Alarmingly, this lack of executive ownership of
84.4% report increased company profit/revenue CX comes at a time of unprecedented change, an
and 78.9% also experience a reduction in costs. unequivocal need for digital transformation in
business, and an urgent need to evolve business
• Hardly surprising, then, that 81.4% of boardrooms services at the pace at which digital is advancing
recognise CX as a competitive differentiator. in our personal lives. The chart below indicates
the immediate evolution – and expansion areas –
of CX leading up to 2020.
Figure 2: Digital transformation of CX in the next two years
Customer interaction levels are forecast to rise by 62% in the next two years.
71% anticipate increases to fully automated contact volumes, while 56% expect transaction via telephone to fall.
Overall interactions
62.3 21.8 9.0 6.9
(spanning all channels) will...
7
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
4. How to create a
CX-centric business strategy
There’s a tendency to misinterpret
the evolution of CX as the need
to simply implement new
technologies. Rather, it’s a need to
adopt new business strategies.
8
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
CX is core to digital transformation. Digitally-relevant forces. This will mean changing the organisation –
businesses are focusing on aligning system user not just once but whenever the market shifts.
experiences, both internally and externally, to drive
positive disruption. This means not only changing You may already have some of the components
the CX with a new application or with improved needed to put in place these modern day
customer service but re-arranging the entire fundamentals. Recent history indicates, however,
organisation to become more agile and responsive that you’ll need to make adjustments to enable
to customer needs. At face value, contact resolution them to properly serve your CX ambition.
rates are worse today than they were 20 years ago.
But, today, we’re not just measuring whether first
contact resolution occurred or not. We’re trying to New skills
understand whether the agent added value in terms As channel choices expand, so too does the role and
of the opportunity the interaction presented. associated skill profile of the supporting customer
Beyond today’s appreciation that customers are advisor. Ten years ago, just 18% of agents were
more demanding, better able to compare services, skilled across different contact channels. Today
and ahead of most organisations in their use of almost one third (32.5%) are. Recruitment strategies
technology, is your CX creating a differentiator are having to change. People skilled at voice
for the company and, by default, promoting the interaction are not necessarily equally skilled at web
company’s value proposition? chat, and vice versa.
9
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
CX
Transformation
al Cust
omer analytics Di
sic g
Reduce costs
y
ita
Ph
Ma
l
rk
et
es Understand
in
l
Sa
As
Wo
s
rkfo
ce
ist
Omnic
rvi
ed
rce optimisatio
Grow revenues
Self-se
-ser
Todays
expected CX Integrate
hannel CX
vice
Pro
Dis
active service
vic
n
Automate
tri
ut
er
S Improve
b
io
n experience
re
Fu
nt
m
lfi
ce
en ct
l
t Robotics & AI
nta
Co Optimise
Digitise business
Clearly, for CX to deliver the desired consistent results By 2017, staff productivity ranked just sixth, as
for both customers and the organisation, a common executive commitment to CX increased and
CX strategy must be used by every department. It also analytics showed a picture of customers and agents
means applying to digital options the management that didn’t match up with early contact centre ideas
basics used on live agent or telephone channels. about productivity.
10
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
‘Proof of value
is an emerging
measure that will
become critical in
CX transformation
measurement and
investment.’
11
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
12
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Figure 4: How to create a customer experience-centric business strategy: understand, integrate, automate, and optimise
Customer analytics
Why customer analytics is key:
translation of customer personalisation and provide better service; increase productivity revenue growth,
strategy to customer differentiation increase brand and reduce cost repeat business, and
engagement advocacy and reduce customer retention
customer effort
Analytics is the single most CX-empowering tool expectations. Fewer than half of organisations
organisations have at their disposal today. surveyed (48.1%) have customer analytic systems
in place. Just 18.6% believe their analytic systems
This is because of three critical, accelerating CX meet their future needs. This disparity indicates why
trends: personalisation, robotics, and automation. well-equipped organisations operating towards a
clear strategy are performing at levels up to 10 times
Personalisation is impossible without the ability
better than the average benchmark.
to harness and understand mass data. Without
access to information, automation, and robotics In 2008, 25.3% of organisations were fully
are disabled. cooperating on processes at an organisation-wide
level. Some 24% had formal mechanisms to share
A decade ago, 72.7% of organisations had a
intelligence. These capabilities are now down
centralised system to collate data and generate
to 18% and 15.1% respectively. Poor design is
management information reports. Some 49%
becoming the top hindrance to digital success.
could track and view customer interaction journeys.
Expansion of the scope of CX responsibilities Collaboration on intelligence is regressing when it
combined with the ever-widening spread of should be progressing. Without a shared consistency
channels creates complexity. Digital expansion on the collection and analytics of data, it’s
has actually seen tracking capability decline. impossible for an organisation to deliver effective
Full visibility of the end to end journey is now and truly personalised experiences. There’s plenty
at just 38.3%. This needs to change. of data available, but you must be able to interpret it
Despite last year’s Benchmarking Report and translate it to actionable insights.
showing that the focus on big data has grown by
75%, business intelligence capability is below
13
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Omnichannel CX
Why omnichannel CX is important:
realigns and offers experience- provides better reduces customer drives new revenues
derives value
integrates your centric customer service, increases effort through
from holistic data
business to deliver a engagement that is brand advocacy relevance and
capture
better experience context-appropriate choice
and relevant
Omnichannel was first mentioned in the 2013 The evolution of multiple communication
Benchmarking Report. It has since established touchpoints has now been enabled by the
itself as the number one technology trend being application of valuable data and dynamic algorithm-
progressed by CX teams. based intelligence. Some 79.8% of organisations are
aiming to have most, if not all, channels connected
Yet the term is often misunderstood. Omnichannel’s by the end of 2019.
value isn’t limited to the connection of all channels.
It actually lies in the understanding and facilitation A decade back, some 69% of CX technology systems
of relevant real time data that reciprocally adds were part of the enterprise architecture in some
value to the customer’s experience and the form – versus 76.4% today. That said, in 2013,
organisation’s ability to be more productive and 58.8% of operations enjoyed more than a limited
grow the value of the relationship. The appropriate involvement in the design of new CX technology
connection of channels provides context – and systems. Today it’s just 49.6%.
content – relevant to the experience to customers.
By definition when it comes to omnichannel,
involvement of the entire organisation is the only
way to achieve the desired CX outcomes.
‘Approximately 59% of
organisations say their
channels are managed
in silos (with different
management agendas).’
14
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Robotics and AI
Why robotics and AI are important:
transformed customer reduction in agent increased brand increase sales and consistent
journey and operations cost and increase in perception and CX services resolution application of CX
productivity through ease of use through evaluation and strategy
knowledge capabilities
Despite the fact that the world has formed a digital Automation versus robotics
skin, levels of digital uptake by organisations have
slowed, affected by poor design, deployment, and The explosion of new IoD consumer devices
marketing. Customer demand for digital remains underpinned by voice user interfaces (e.g. Amazon’s
high, but solutions fall short of customer needs. Echo), combined with increasing consumer
use of messaging as a means of engaging with
This in spite of the fact that phone volumes have organisations, means that we are primed for
dropped by 17% since 2015, and CX robotics has exponential change in the way organisations engage
reached its tipping point, and process automation, with customers. It also means that the elements that
AI, IoT, and IoD are creating a new reality. The form CX will change fundamentally.
appetite for apps and social is rising as AI and IoD
focus intensifies. Automation is one way of enabling an organisation
to keep pace with user shifts and demands.
In this context, the automation of customer service However, errant use of automation can harm rather
is perhaps the most crucial evolution in CX today. than help the cause of CX. It can escalate frustration
to the point of disillusionment, resulting in loss of a
The effective use of automation and self-service has vast wealth of opportunity.
redefined leading organisations’ value propositions
and created a leader/laggard dynamic. Simply And, while the introduction of robotics and AI in
layering automation over legacy process and tandem with a human touch is critical for growing
dysfunctional organisational structures is not an CX at this juncture, bear in mind that the outward
effective response to disruptive digital entrants. focus of robotics and AI is well documented.
Instead, organisations must think in terms of factors
such as the re-emergence of voice user interfaces, By contrast, the automation of tasks that increase
now being enabled via the IoD (think Amazon Echo, productivity of customer advisors offers the
Apple’s Suri etc.) that make it possible to simplify, opportunity for profound inwardly focused
serve, and enrich customer lifestyles. efficiency gains, in tandem with increased employee
engagement. Inherently this will enhance CX. It also
constitutes lower risk for the organisation than a
fully cognitive self-service bot, for instance, because
it uses advances in technology to create pragmatic
value for both customers and organisations.
15
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Taken in isolation, these additional demands make because they were digital. However, by 2013, 66.4%
the organisational CX landscape more complex and of organisations believed self-service systems were
costly. In fact, the use of digital channels to deliver causing significant customer dissatisfaction.
superior CX solutions is a highly effective way of
reducing cost and increasing productivity. Now, the top factor cited as hindering customer
usage of new channels is customer awareness and
In 2013, just 36.4% of organisations considered functionality. Far from proactively driving customers
digital as a way to reduce cost. Today, 52.2% use to digital offerings, organisations aren’t marketing or
assisted service digital channels to reduce costs, and effectively researching CX needs on new channels.
56.3% see automated solutions as an additional cost
savings opportunity. In 2013, the split of actual interactions was 66% for
telephone, 17% for assisted-service, and 17% for
However, digital solutions do need to be designed, automated channels. Progress has been made, with
managed, and maintained efficiently – and then the split reshaping to 54.7% (telephone), 25.2%
measured to ensure that they’re driving the correct (assisted service), and 20.1% (automated). However,
outcomes. Currently, just 44.3% of organisations the progress remains less than the desired position of
use return on investment as a key commercial 39.8%, 36.5% and 23.7% respectively.
consideration in assessing new technology. It’s
resulting in most organisations failing to measure While delivery on the digital vision has fallen short of
costs per transaction on the vast majority of channels expectations, the attempts made so far have taught
they offer. us valuable lessons about uptake, and how to ensure
that solutions meet customer needs.
As has often been the case over the past 20 years,
the evolution of the cost savings belief has been What we need to do now is apply the learnings to
circular. A decade ago, in 2008, 15.8% were using AI and robotics, as the speed of transition is set to
financial incentives to drive customers to lower intensify. Organisations that stall may not survive.
cost channels. They came at a lower cost precisely
Phone contacts dropped 17% from 2015, but the actual split of interactions fall way short of the desired model.
Digital uptake levels are losing momentum, as they are affected by poor deployments and unsatisfactory design and marketing.
16
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Workflow based Platform specific End-to-end AFTEs Configurable AFTEs Cognitive AFTEs (AiFTE)
Platform based
If used appropriately, robotics and AI will reducing cost. Automated processes provide a
exponentially increase both CX and an huge productivity gain by allowing customer
organisation’s productivity. They have a dual – advisors to focus on their customers rather than
inside out and outside in – impact on CX. systems. Automation capability and intelligence
can also build up effectively, trained to be match
Advances in automation have combined fit for customer-facing, AI-based self-service.
machine-based learning, AI, and natural language
processing to offer powerful, highly intelligent The cultural, man versus machine challenge
‘automated agents’. But, be aware, robotics and is profound. Managing change and concepts
AI deployed in a static way will not reflect the such as automation anxiety for both customers
ever changing world. We need to constantly use and employees is crucial to ensuring that digital
‘bots’ to understand the effectiveness of customer is an appropriate servant to your CX strategy
journeys and opportunities, while being aware of and that highly effective CX is harmonised
‘bot mortality’. with the productivity benefits, cost, and growth
of automation.
Automation in general and the advances in
automation offered by robotics finally gives The guiding star for this effort must be defining
organisations an all in one ability to differentiate the experience you want your customers to have.
their services and add value to customers while
17
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
The most intractable challenge of the digital era, Emerging technologies are creating a platform for
and the CX that it makes possible, appears to be the unprecedented efficiency opportunities, both in
difficulty of bridging a strategic desire to evolve and business and customer effort, but resources need
address a siloed management operating model that new skills to support the re-shaped environment.
inherently hinders digital and workforce optimisation. These skills are not being provided for.
Efficiency levels are further impeded by the absence One very effective way of resolving these issues is to
or inconsistent use of core support technologies. view efficiency as a CX enabler.
In spite of the fact that complexity levels are
growing and cost pressures are returning, many If you’re serving the customer effectively, you’ll
organisations are operating without knowledge and automatically be highly productive. By definition,
workforce management systems. Agent analytics you’ll be adapting your operating models to meet
and a surge in e-learning techniques have emerged future needs, reducing wasted effort that’s costly and
as 2017’s top optimisation priorities. Employee skills frustrating for employees and customers. You’ll be
and experience are now at a premium. using technology enablers to accelerate workforce
optimisation. All of which will provide a significant
Yet, because of increased complexity in the return on investment in digital transformation.
workplace, agent absenteeism is twice that of
management – and has doubled since our first
report 20 years ago. If we don’t gauge engagement
levels properly, the roles imposed on agents
may become untenable and the industry will
hemorrhage experienced, high performing agents.
18
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Engaged employees =
productive employees Looking back over 20 years
In 2013, the top methods for promoting employee Average CX team sizes have remained the
•
engagement were clear goals and process alongside same for the last two decades. The 1998
proactive communications. Yet today, and five years benchmark was 12 agents to one manager.
down the line, just 45% of organisations say that The 2008 benchmark was also 12. Today
employee engagement levels are at a promoter we’re at 13.
level, and rating 8/10 or better.
• Two decades ago, just 69% of agents
Budget level brands and the public sector report enjoyed permanent contracts; by 2013
the lowest engagement levels. Our understandings 87% did. Most recent results have levelled
around role performance are also diminishing. Back out to 82.5%.
in 2008, 69.2% of organisations had agent analytics.
Disappointingly, this has dropped to 53.8%. Induction training allocations averaged
•
18.7 days as recently as 2013; despite
Measurement and data collection tools are often increasing role complexity, allowances
available. They’re just not being applied effectively. have since dropped by 17% to 15.6%.
In 2013, just 27.2% of organisations were tracking
volume forecasts across all CX channels. Today, 72.5% • Two decades ago, agents were receiving
will endeavour to forecast telephone volume, but only 22 days’ vacation per annum, and 16 days
36% will do the same for assisted service volumes. of development training. Again, we see a
There’s little business logic behind this approach. drop to today: 20.5 days vacation and 9.6
days formal development training.
Critical to growing the value of CX and harnessing
the value of engaged people are current and • L
ength of service was as much of
targeted operating models that demonstrate a clear a problem twenty years ago as it is
understanding of the need to harmonise self-service, today. Back then, the average tenure
automation, and the value of the customer advisor. for agents was just 29.3 months. In 2017,
it was 28.7 months.
• A
gent attrition was the same level in 1998
as it is today (19.9%). It surged to 27.5% in
2013 before settling again.
19
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
20
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Establishment of trust for customers is the leading driver of CX, followed by the matching of
service experiences to brand values. Change comes at a cost and the commercials will always
linger at front of mind. But customer-centric strategies need to see beyond that. The value that
can be derived and opportunity that can be gained is evidenced by those who have committed
to transform. Their returns on investment being powerfully evidenced by customer spend
increases, improved loyalty, and operational cost savings.
Think about CX as a value enabler. Delivered effectively, CX will grow the value of your
business rather than the business having to fund CX. Take full advantage of the digital
revolution. Reshape your business model by powering personalisation, automation,
and connected customer journeys with intelligence from analytics.
Most importantly, don’t hesitate. Disruptors have already given your customers’ expectations of
all organisations that you can’t meet with your old strategies, business models, or technologies.
New disruptors in the industry are proving that strategy is the real enabler of profitability,
performance, and sustainability. Commitment to CX, using digital tools, is what actually positions
you to transform your organisation into a 21st century brand.
21
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
7. Next steps
22
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report
Dimension Data has over 30 years of experience in helping our clients navigate the challenges we’ve outlined
in this paper. We offer a range of consulting, advisory, and benchmarking services to help set you up for
success. Some of our offerings include:
https://www.dimensiondata.com/
en/expertise/customer-experience
Customer Experience Omnichannel Comparative
Maturity Model Optimisation Workshop Benchmarking Services
Look out for the 2019 Report, due to be published in January 2019
23
The evolution of customer experience (CX)… a look ahead to 2020
Celebrating 20 years of the Global CX Benchmarking Report