Paper Review Form for ISMM 2018

Please return before Friday, 15 November 2018

Reviewer’s Agung Imaduddin

Name
Reviewer’s agungi@gmail.com
Email
Reviewer’s
Signature

Paper
Number 57

Paper Title Optical Properties of ZnO Nanorods derived from Chemical

Bath Deposition Process with Different Seeds Solution
Concentration
Author
Name(s) L Suhaimi1, A.H. Yuwono1 and C Hudaya2

Paper Evaluation

Exceptional Good Average Poor Very Poor None

Relevance to Scope V

Paper organization V

Originality of presented work V

Theoretical basis for the paper V

Empirical basis for the paper V

Discussion of related work V

Writing and expression V

Reviewers Overall Rating

3 Strong accept
2 Accept
1 Weak accept V
0 Borderline paper
-1 Should not be Accepted
-2 Reject
Confidential Comments to Program Committee
This paper is accepted with major revision.

Comments to be sent to the Author

--- Please include detailed comments to the author, describing if any shortcomings of the paper
and recommending changes of these will address these shortcomings. This field is required

Need to clarify the purpose of the research in the abstract and contents of the paper.
It should be explained why the optical property measurement method can answer the research objectives.
The XRD graph is too small, it needs to be revised.
Graph 4 is not clear, it needs to be revised. The x axis is unreadable
When we see the results, the higher the concentration, the better ZnO is formed, is there any limit for the best
concentration?
On page 5, the last paragraph, what is meant by the phrase "Samples with a concentration of 0.05 M optical
transmittance spectrum, the transmittance obtained is very low". (According to the graph, c curve is the highest
transmission curve).

***************************************************************************