Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 75

Pamantasan ng Cabuyao

Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 0

WEB-BASED WATER QUALITY DATA PROFILING BUOY


NETWORK USING LORAWAN TECHNOLOGY

A Design Project Proposal Presented to the


College of Engineering
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao

In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree


Bachelor of Science in Electronics Engineering

By
Del Valle, Kenneth Ian D.
Hede, Roselle G.
Sonio, Mark John Paul M.

March 2019
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 1

Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION

Introduction

Human overpopulation imposes the biggest risk with the environment silently

worsening the forces behind global warming, environmental pollution, habitat loss,

the sixth mass extinction, intensive farming practices and the consumption of limited

natural resources, such as fresh water, arable land and fossil fuels at speeds faster

than their rate of regeneration. Collective consumption exceeds what our planet can

renew by over 70 percent as mentioned by the Global Footprint Network, a non-

profit research group that counts the planet’s bio-capacity.

With all this natural resources we are consuming, freshwater is the most

fundamental finite resource with no substitute for most uses. Considering that saline

water in oceans, seas and saline groundwater sums up to about 97 percent of all the

water on earth while the remaining 2.5-2.75 percent is left with freshwater which is

subdivided to 2 percent frozen in glaciers, polar caps and snow, 0.5 percent goes to

the groundwater and moisture yet we are consuming freshwater at least 10 times
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 2

faster. Water is a pre-requisite for life and is present in most organisms, including

humans. It is involved in all processes and cycle of life and affects each of us directly

and indirectly. As United Nations Water states, the earth’s surface, at around 75

percent, primarily consists of bodies of water. With this, it plays a vital role in climate

and the progress of life on this planet.

As water is as utmost importance as food, communities grow around bodies

of water and with them arises the problem of pollution. They live along the coast of

lakes or rivers and infect the water quality and eventually lead to water pollution.

Water pollution is the contamination of bodies and sources of water and usually as a

result of human activities such as overpopulation. These bodies of water comprise of

rivers, lakes, seas or oceans while pollutant/contaminants are introduced into the

environment. The causes of water pollution include chemicals from industrial plants

illegally being dumped into a system and household wastes directly thrown into a

tributary. As a result, water pollution is now the leading cause of death worldwide

due to water-borne diseases according to the World Health Organization.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 3

Background of the Study

The country has more than enough of surface and ground water supply but

the untreated domestic wastes and industrial wastewater are directly discarded into

bodies and systems of water eventually damaging them. Pasig River is one of the

world’s most polluted river system according to the Asian Water Development

Outlook (2007) and a main tributary to the Laguna Lake (Laguna de Bay) by the

Marikina River and Manggahan Floodway. With this, the Laguna Lake is in severe

environmental risk. As the largest inland freshwater lake in the Philippines, Laguna

de Bay serves as a temporary reservoir during flooding in Marikina River and a

sanctuary for endemic freshwater fishes.

The City of Cabuyao is directly situated alongside the Laguna de Bay which

exposes the communities and inhabitants to imminent danger as pollution brings

great threat to the public health and the quality of life of the residents.

As a solution to this matter, the researchers create a profiling buoy network

that allows the government and concerned individuals to monitor strategic points in

the Cabuyao River system for the water quality data and record it for further study.

This study can vastly help and aid the government and nearby industries in
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 4

monitoring the water quality along the river system. The network can coordinate and

send the information to a main station that records the data for monitoring.

As the two buoy are placed along the river system and remotely send

information, the LoRaWAN technology can be the most efficient and practical mode

of data transmission.

This proposed solution can be a great help in improving the optimal health

and quality of living to the citizens of the City of Cabuyao residing along the

Cabuyao River and Laguna Lake. This would give them knowledge and to raise the

awareness and understanding of the importance and present state of these water

resources.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 5

Statement of the Problem

The goal of this is to design and implement a system that can assess, monitor

and respond accordingly to the current water quality data and send/record to a main

station.

Specifically, this study aims to answer the following questions:

1. How can the device test pH level, turbidity, total dissolved solids, water

temperature, air temperature and humidity?

2. How can profiling specific water quality data by means of two buoys be

developed?

3. How can each buoy transmit data to the main system?

4. How can the information and results reach the general public?
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 6

Conceptual Framework

• Quality measurement for each parameter (pH, turbidity,


total dissolve solids, water temperature, air humidity and
INPUT temperature)

• Sensors acquire data connected to a microcontroller


• Data are analyzed with specific parameters
PROCESS • Results go into a main station

• Display the analyzed data and results in the main station and
through the web
OUTPUT

Figure 1. Conceptual Framework of Web-based Water Quality Data Profiling

Buoy Network using LoRaWAN Technology

Water quality data for each parameter is used as the input. Meanwhile, the

process shows the analysis of the data through sensors of different water quality

connected to a microcontroller which analyze and assess the data collected as safe,

alarming or dangerous. The figures collected by each buoy are then sent to the main
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 7

station over LoRaWAN for comparison. Analyzed data are then displayed to the

main station and available through the web.

Design Objectives

The objective of this study is to design and implement two buoys that can

monitor, record and send the data to a station to implement the necessary actions to

take with the results acquired and profile physical parameters.

The study is designed to:

1. Develop a device that can acquire pH level, turbidity, total dissolved solids,

water temperature, air temperature and humidity data;

2. Develop two buoys which can hold the sensors intact;

3. Determine the threshold for each water quality data being measured;

4. Determine the method of communication and data transmission of each buoy

to a main station;

5. Develop a system that allows the information to be available for the public.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 8

Assumptions

During the course of the study, the researchers assume that:

1. The profiling buoy network will take water quality data at an interval of 24

hours.

2. The system will record data from each buoy and measure the difference of

changes in each parameter.

3. The recorded data will be sent using LoRaWAN to the main station and

uploaded to the web.

4. The data collected will be available to the web for anyone to access for

referencing.

5. Each buoy is anchored to the riverbed or with any heavy object to maintain its

position and integrity in location during the collection of data.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 9

Scope and Limitations

The buoy network and system is constricted and limited only to the following:

Scope:

1. Each buoy will assess water quality data in pH, turbidity, total dissolved

solids, water temperature, air temperature and humidity.

2. The collected data will be used to determine if thresholds were reached

and note the day of sampling as safe, alarming or dangerous in any of the

parameter accordingly.

3. The device has solar panels situated on top supplying the power needs

and charges an emergency battery for use during lean season.

4. The buoys are waterproof and can withstand heavy shaking of waves or

extreme weather conditions.

5. The system can provide graphical interpretation of the data for faster

analysis.

6. The data collected will be available through the web.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 10

7. The data in the web can only be accessed with a specific number of users.

Limitations:

1. The buoys may tumble upon collision with heavy objects.

2. The LoRa Gateway has a limited range and in an urban setting, the range

will be 2- to 3-km-wide coverage as this depends on the radio-line-of-sight.

3. LoRa nodes can only send data specifically for alarms, triggering, and

monitoring purposes as LoRa can only transmit at extremely low speeds.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 11

Significance of the Study

The study can be of great help to the local government, industry practitioners

and future researchers.

City of Cabuyao

The outcome of this study may provide as a basis to determine enough

knowledge of an individual about knowing the quality and profile of water systems

that may contribute significant part in bringing improvements to the community.

Engineering Discipline

The information gathered in this study may increase their knowledge about

the water quality that may benefit their existing projects which may lead them to

solve problems effectively and efficiently.

Future Researchers

The findings of the study may serve as a good source of accurate and

relevant information if they are conducting similar study. It may also help them to

attain more ideas and details for certain purposes.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 12

Definition of Terms

Defined below are the terms used in the study for better understanding:

Buoy Network. Interconnected system of buoys that are working with each

other comparing the data collected.

Buoy. A floating device which gathers data with the sensors attached to it

and used for research purposes.

Gateway. A network node that connects two networks using different

protocols together.

Internet of Things (IoT). The interconnection of computing devices

embedded in everyday objects enabling them to transmit and receive data.

LoRa. Enables long range transmissions with low power consumption and

serves as the digital wireless communication device for transmitting and receiving

data from the buoys.

LoRaWAN. A media access protocol for wide area networks that is designed

to allow low-powered devices to communicate over long-range wireless connection.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 13

pH. pH is the measure of the acidity or alkalinity of water of a solution of a

water. The pH scale ranges from 0 to 14. Pure water is said to be neutral, with a pH

of 7. Water with a pH below 7.0 is considered acidic while pH level greater than 7.0

is considered basic or alkaline.

Physico-chemical parameters. Pertaining to both physical and chemical

properties, changes and reactions.

Salinity. The saltiness or amount of salt dissolved in a body of water.

Sensors. Devices that detect, monitor or collect data for a specific use by

measuring the necessary samples.

Temperature. Measure of hot and cold readings in a specific environment with

standards set at 0°C as the freezing point of water and 100°C as the boiling point.

Total Dissolved Solids. Refers to the measure of any minerals, salts or

metals dissolved in water.

Water Pollution. The presence of water pollutants or contaminants in bodies

and sources of water that destroys the quality of life of organisms within and along

and produce harmful environmental effects.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 14

Chapter 2
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

This chapter presents a review of related literature and studies from various

sources each relevant to the present study.

Foreign Literature

According to the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs

(UNDESA), declining water quality has become a global issue of concern as the

natural hydrological cycle has been majorly altered by overpopulation, industrial and

agricultural development and expansion and climate change. Without human

intervention and influences, water quality would be determine by natural processes

such as weathering of bedrock minerals, by the atmospheric processes of

evapotranspiration, deposition of dust and salt by the wind and by biological

processes within the aquatic environment that can affect the composition of water.

As stated by Gorde & Jadhav (2013), the indiscriminate use of chemical

fertilizers and pesticides and the rapid industrialization are causing extreme and
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 15

varied pollution in aquatic environment which leads to the deterioration of water

quality and depletion of aquatic biota. Human population suffers from water borne

diseases due to use of contaminated water. Storm water runoff and discharge of

sewage into bodies of water are few of the common causes where foreign

substances and nutrients enter the aquatic ecosystems resulting in their death.

To determine the pollution in a body of water, combined physical and

chemical characteristics of water samples compared with water quality guidelines

and standards will define if the pollution thresholds were reached. Checking the

water quality such as temperature, pH, turbidity, salinity and so on at a regular time

interval is necessary to assess the condition of water bodies and nearby areas.

Canadian Council of Ministers of Environment Water Quality Index

(CCMEWQI) is a tool for evaluation of complex water quality data for a more

convenient guide to a general audience of concern. The index has three elements:

the scope, which the number of parameters not meeting the set water quality

guidelines; the frequency, which is the number of times these guidelines are not met;

and the amplitude, which is the amount by which the guidelines are not met. The

index has values from 0 to 100, which is from worst to best water quality,

respectively. Once the water quality is measured, it is categorized into five


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 16

descriptive classification: Excellent (95-100) – water quality is close to natural levels;

Good (80-94) – water quality rarely far from natural levels: Fair (65-79) – conditions

sometimes depart from natural levels; Marginal (45-64) – water quality is often far

from natural levels; and Poor (0-44) – water quality is usually far from natural levels

(Canadian Council of Ministers of Environment, 2017).

For data transmission and reception, LoRa Alliance indicated that LoRaWAN

specifications offer flawless interoperability among “smart things” without using

complex installations performing Internet of Things (IoT) applications. It targets the

key requirements of the IoT such as safe full duplex communication, mobility and

localization services that are not addressed by other technologies. LoRa Technology

can only transmit in low data rates such as from quality sensors (Tomas, 2017).

Local Literature

A part of the United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund

(UNICEF) Water, Sanitation and Hygiene program in the Philippines noted that 30

million Filipinos have problem with access to adequate sanitation facilities which
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 17

eventually pollutes nearby bodies of water. This leads to nine million Filipinos relying

on unsafe water supplies.

Meanwhile out of 101 million Filipinos, 19 million Filipinos lack access to

improved sanitation according to water.org. Filipinos consider water and sanitation

access a matter of safety, pride, progress and convenience, in addition to the health

considerations. While those without an access to sanitary toilet facility directly dump

into water bodies over time will pollute them (Department of Environment and

Natural Resources).

According to the Water Environment Partnership in Asia (Philippines

Environment Monitor, n.d.), the National Capital Region (NCR), Central Luzon,

Southern Luzon and Central Visayas are the four urban critical regions in terms of

water quality and quantity. Monitored data by the government also indicated that

over a third or 36 percent of the country’s river systems are classified as sources of

public water supply. Despite this, untreated wastewaters are directly dumped into

rivers or its tributaries making water unfit for drinking and recreational use threatens

biodiversity and eventually deteriorates overall quality of life.

Furthermore, as recorded by United Nations Environment (Cox, 2017),

Laguna Lake, the country’s largest lake, supplies a third of Metro Manila’s 16 million
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 18

people with a third of their fish and houses agriculture, recreation, power generation,

and so on. This placed the lake in peril as pollution from untreated water sewage

and industrial waste reached extreme levels.

According to UN Environment, Laguna de Bay’s main problem is the

excessive nutrients due to fertilizer runoff, livestock runoff and wastewater. An

excessive nutrient from human activities is risky to bodies of water for it takes away

the balance in the ecosystem. Increase in nutrients leads to eutrophication that

speeds up growth of algae, water hyacinth and other species. Because of that, they

block sunlight preventing survival of other species. Consequently, when algae die,

their decomposition leaches the surrounding water of oxygen resulting to shortage of

oxygen that kills fishes and eventually declaring the water body a dead zone (UN

Environment, 2018).

Also, siltation has vastly affected the average depth of Laguna Lake from 10

meters in the 1980s to 2.5 to 3 meters now (Inquirer.net, 2014). With this, light to

moderate flooding can be easily felt over the coastal areas and neighboring

communities.

Moreover, during the Typhoon Ondoy’s unusual downpour, rampaging quick

floodwater kept lakeshore towns and cities in the provinces of Laguna, Rizal and
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 19

Metro Manila flooded for months. The water level in the lake rose to 13.9 m (average

normal level is 10m) which prompted government officials to identify key issue with

the lake. According to Laguna Lake Development Authority (LLDA), the government

body in charge of the rehabilitation and preservation of the lake identified that

sedimentation annual rate rose from 1.03 cm/year (1938) to 1.20 cm/year (1997)

which means the lake could become shallower by another meter in the next century

due to pollution, siltation, overcrowding of fish pens, and so on. (Cinco, 2016).

To compensate this water quality issues, a law was signed to protect,

preserve and revive the quality of water bodies. It is the Republic Act (R.A.) No.

9275 entitled “An Act Providing for a Comprehensive Water Quality Management

and for Other Purposes”, which is known as the Philippine Clean Water Act of 2004

(CWA) signed by the former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo on March 22, 2004

and took effect on May 6, 2004. The Implementing Rules and Regulation (IRR) of

this act was contained in the Department of Environment and Natural Resources

(DENR) Administrative Order (A.O.) No. 2005-10.

The law covers water quality management in all bodies of water in the

country. Its primary purpose is to monitor and control pollution from land-based

sources that stream down the water bodies. Any person, firm or institution showing
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 20

disobedience to this act shall be enforced under its civil liability and penal provisions

(Philippine Clean Water Act of 2004, 2004).

Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) has released

new set of water quality guidelines and effluent standards under DENR

Administrative Order (DAO) 2016-08 under compliance to with section 19e and 19f

of Republic Act (R.A.) 9275, also known as the “ Philippine Clean Water Act of

2004”.

Under new DAO, each type of water body has its set water quality rules. For

water body classification and usage of Freshwater, four categories are set: Class

AA- Public Water Supply Class I; Class A- Public Water Supply Class II; Class B-

Recreational Water Class I; Class C- Recreational Water Class II; and Class D-

Navigable Waters. Meanwhile, for the classification and usage of Marine Waters,

four levels are also obtained: Class SA- Protected Waters and Fishery Water Class

I; Class SB- Fishery Water Class II, Tourist Zones and Recreational Water Class I;

Class SC- Fishery Water Class III, Recreational Water Class II and Marshy and/or

mangrove areas declared as fish and wildlife sanctuaries; and Class SD- Navigable

Waters.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 21

For treated water discharge into bodies of water, effluent quality parameters

are set for each industry which is based on the most significant pollutant that the

industry will discharge in the environment (DENR, 2016).

Since the country is an archipelago, a LoRa (Long Range) transmission will

be efficient and practical. LoRa, as e-Gizmo (e-Gizmo Mechatronix Central, 2018)

has stated, provides ultra-long range speed spectrum communication and high

interference immunity while minimizing current consumption and able to perform

long range data transmission, and data comparison from different stations. As

compared with the traditional modulation technology, LoRa has a high sensitivity and

solves the traditional cannot take into account the distance, interference and power

consumption.

In addition, Packetworx, a Philippine Internet of Things (IoT) startup company

gives away IoT devices that can be attached to any devices making this “smart”

because the user is capable of controlling it remotely using smartphones and

computers. Also, the company also introduced the LoRaWAN (Long Range Wide

Access Network) technology that includes system of sensor to be provided for Local

Government Units and non-commercial users. LoRaWAN operates Packetnet,

Packetworx’s own network by long range, low power data transmission which may
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 22

eventually be utilized for transmission of temperature, air quality, and weather

updates to the community (Gonzales, 2018).

In correspondence to Internet of Things (IoT) and LoRAWAN’s introduction in

the Philippines, Pasig River Rehabilitation Council (PRRC) has teamed up with

Cypher Odin, a homegrown blockchain company to rehabilitate the river which

connects Laguna de Bay to Manila Bay. The company will install Internet of Things

(IoT) devices along the river to monitor the developments real-time. It will also be

used to track water quality data and tide levels (Acuña, 2018) .

Foreign Studies

In order to understand the water quality of Friveni Lake, physico-chemical

parameters were studied and analyzed for a period of one year. Various physico-

chemical parameters, such as water temperature, air temperature, humidity,

conductivity, etc., were studied and found that the water quality varied with summer

and winter seasons. During this time, the quality of lake water is best for drinking

purposes compared to other seasons (Khan, 2012).


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 23

A study was conducted in Cuyahoga River located in Northern Ohio, USA. It

was named as Crooked River Project which aims to monitor water quality of the

river. The study discussed the effects of various water quality parameters in river

such as Dissolved Oxygen, pH, Turbidity and Temperature.

Inadequacy of dissolved oxygen gas is unhealthy for rivers. Aquatic

organisms need enough of this element to support their lives. However, extremely

high level of dissolved oxygen may lead cultural eutrophication, a process where

plant growth, especially algal blooms, is uncontrolled, and may cause death of

animals due to lack of oxygen.

Turbidity is a condition where level of water transparency is decreased due to

suspended solids in the water, including silts, clays, sewages and industrial wastes.

Those particles increase water temperature by absorbing heat from sunlight which

results to lower dissolved oxygen level harmful to aquatic life.

Meanwhile, temperature affects metabolism and growth rates of aquatic

organism, photosynthesis and dissolved oxygen levels, such that higher temperature

speeds up growth and death of plants, which in turn, requires oxygen for

decomposition. Additionally, it impacts aquatic organisms’ sensitivity to diseases and

toxic particles (Fister, et al., Cuyahoga River Water Quality Monitoring Program).
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 24

A related research was also conducted at Kelani River Basin in Sri Lanka,

where most of rural water supply is from groundwater through the use of wells. The

river is the second largest catch basin in the country resulting to high possibility of

water contamination as industrial, agricultural, livestock and even household waste

are stream directly into it. To assess water quality of river, the researchers utilized

the Canadian Council of Ministers of Environment Water Quality Index (CCMEWQI).

The tool was created to measure ground water quality for household and

industrial uses aided with specific guidelines which is used by most countries

worldwide. Standard methods for evaluation of water quality parameters such as

Water temperature, pH, Dissolved Oxygen (DO), Total Dissolved Solids (TDS),

Electrical Conductivity (EC), salinity, Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), Faecal

Coliform (FC), and so on were done through the use of specified devices. In

conclusion, the average index values and their ranks for drinking were evaluated as

poor (33) where water quality for irrigation and livestock were marked as poor (37)

and excellent (100) respectively (Mahagamage & Manage, 2014).

Additionally, a research has been conducted in three lakes in India and

collected water samples tested and analyzed for pH, turbidity, total alkalinity, sulfate

(as SO42-), chloride (C1-) and some heavy metals as these parameters determine
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 25

drinking water quality of a lake or any body of water (Chandra, Singh, & Tomar,

2012).

On the other hand, scientists at the University of Maine deployed an ocean-

observing buoy at the mouth of Damariscotta River to aid researchers in

understanding how various types and scales of aqua-culture can fit into Maine’s

multi-use working water-front. This buoy is a part of a project that assist the aqua-

culture sector to have an environmentally and economically sustainable production

way maintained (Healy, 2015).

To monitor water quality of Fraser River Estuary, Canada, (Ethier & Bedard,

2008) utilized a moored buoy platform modified to include multi-parameter water

quality sensors. A Three Meter Oceanographic-Data-Acquisition-System (ODAS)

buoy, which is capable of withstanding river flood due to heavy rains and snow

melting conditions. The buoy has also the capacity to support considerable sampling

and parameter sensors to be used. Continuous monitoring and twice a week

sampling was simultaneously done with contaminates testing.

Olsson & Finnson (2017) evaluated how the LoRaWAN protocols can be

used for the purpose of transmitting weather data from a single IoT Weather Station.

LoRaWAN is evaluated as a long-range wireless transmission protocol with respect


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 26

to its usability for weather stations placed in the Gothenburg Archipelago. They

provided a range extending protocol for LoRaWAN suitable for weather

stations/node network in the same area. The range extending protocol allow devices

outside of a central gateway’s range to do a hop to the nearest node/station that

forwards the message to the central gateway. LoRa and LoRaWAN based range

extending protocol will potentially reduce the number of gateways necessary for a

network and ultimately minimize network costs.

Liu, et al. (2018), carried out a water quality monitoring project at Dong Lake

in National Dong Hwa University, Taiwan through Internet of Things (IoT). Various

parameters are tested to the river such as temperature, turbidity, conductivity, and

pH. Consequently, wireless transmission was used to send data to the database.

The wireless communication medium utilized was Low-Power Wide-Area Network

(LPWAN)- Long Range Wide Area Network (LoRaWAN) which has the capability of

long-range data transmission.

LoRa technology, which is mainly developed for Internet of Things (IoT), is a

system of data collection that uses Distributed Measurement System (DMS). Using

experimental research method, which focuses on evaluation of time-related

performance indicators, it was concluded that a low-cost transceiver has the


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 27

capacity to transmit data frames for less than 3 µs; and provide long-term stability for

commercially available nodes and packet forwarders (Ferrari, Rizzi, Flammini, &

Sisinni, 2017).

Local Studies

According to Matinico-Perez (2014), the beneficial usage of water depends on

its quality. They used the Water Quality Index (WQI) developed by the Canadian

Council of Ministers of the Environment (CCME) in the major rivers of Palawan

Province. The WQI used is based on physico-chemical and microbiological

parameters vis-à-vis freshwater quality standards issued by the Department of

Environment and Natural Resources. They would rely on the water quality index as a

decision tool and basis for decision-making activities and environmental planning

related to water resource protection and management.

Likewise, Cada (2017) stated that the analysis of physico-chemical

parameters in fish and waters of Candaba, Pampanga showed that there is a

desirable need to analyze the pond water at regular intervals as alkaline water is
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 28

good for fish farming and higher level of water conductivity implies a good level of

nutrients whole water temperature was fairly high.

Tamayo-Zafaralla (2002) reported that the most glaring evidence of the

stressed ecological state of the lake is the declining fishery productivity. This loss

stems from various deleterious factors happening throughout the lake and all its river

tributaries. The problems seen collectively showed that Laguna de Bay is an

extremely stressed and polluted aquatic ecosystem urgently needing rehabilitation.

Niugan River, in addition, which is one of the tributaries of Cabuyao River,

has been a subject to River Health Status Model (Baltazar, 2012). The model is

made up of two component factors: Response Parameters – measurement of

current condition of the river using 15 water quality indicators such as pH, cadmium,

dissolved oxygen, air and water temperature difference, conductivity, and so on; and

Pressure Parameters – physical factors affecting the river condition such as land

use, infrastructure and riparian vegetation.

Response parameters values were obtained through on-site measurements

while the Pressure parameters were derived from a map using ArcMap10, a

Geographic Information System (GIS) software. A calculator-like device is also

created to perform a more efficient input and sensitivity measurement. The interface
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 29

recorded a score of 37.07, corresponding to ‘poor’ river health. It was also learned

that health score was greatly affected by the combination of water quality indicators

and not by the number of it. Thus, it needs to collect data sets from other river to

perform comparison and consequently achieve a dynamic results.

A system of water quality parameter sensors was also designed and develop

for Lake Palakpakin in San Pablo City, Laguna which has 1 km diameter and depth

of 7 m. The system measures and sends data acquired on dissolved oxygen,

conductivity and temperature in the lake at 0.5 and 2.5 m depths for a time interval

of 30 minutes. Collected data are sent via SMS to main server and displayed on web

which can be accessed by concerned audience. Aerator utilization is also done

which operates during night time and early morning that turns on via drop call

(Solpico, et al., 2014).

Consequently, as acknowledged by Abadilla (2015), the continuously

increasing decimals for steady supply and access to potable water comes with

urbanization and that water governance has to cope with, both for the immediate

and long term. A strengthened local government mechanism is important for

integrating efforts, coordinating ad managing integrated water resources and related


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 30

water operations in the area and driving the different sectors and agencies involved

to treat water resource in an integrated manner.

Relevance to the Present Study

The mentioned literature and studies will help the researchers in conducting

their studies. The literatures explained many factors to consider in studying the

water quality data. Other literatures give some methods of sampling certain water

quality and the materials needed to do so. Other literatures provide guidelines and

thresholds in measuring water quality depending on the pollutants itself and on its

surroundings. Aside from the literature, the studies also provide information about

past researches related to the current research in terms of data gathering and

processing, research methodology and the technologies used. This information will

be a great help to the researchers in improving the study.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 31

Chapter 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

The research methodology is the building block of the definite process of a

study. It includes the activities of the researchers in their research proceedings. It

denotes set of methods or procedures and the assumptions in a particular study.

This chapter provides broad details of the project/research; its design, project

development, progress of the project, and instruments and techniques to be used.

This section includes the data gathering procedures, operating and testing

procedures, evaluation procedures and criteria used by the researchers for the

study.

Project/ Research Design

The research design is the general strategic plan of the research study. It

specifies the type of research study and the type of research method to undertake to

effectively address the research study’s objectives and problems.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 32

The descriptive method of research involves data collection from a present

condition of a phenomena without changing it in any way. This enables the situation

to describe the existing status with respect to the variables. The subject is being

observed, analyzed and evaluated in a completely inherent and unchanged natural

environment. However, the results from a descriptive research cannot be used to

discover a definitive answer to disprove a hypothesis.

The Web-Based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy Network using LoRaWAN

Technology utilizes the aforementioned method. The project aims to profile current

water quality parameters in parts of Cabuyao river. It compares results gathered

from two buoys and sends the result to a main station. The buoy stations form a

communication network over LoRaWAN enabling the transmission and reception of

acquired data. When set thresholds are exceeded, alarms are triggered as the

warning signal. However, it does not determine the cause and effect of the

accumulated water quality. These aspects rely on the evaluation of concerned

professionals and government agencies.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 33

Project Development

The project development comprises the discussion of the system’s structure.

The project construction is instrumental in obtaining the objectives of the design

project. It will be used to ensure that the construction would comply with the plan

acquired. In the event that a problem would arise, this approach could facilitate the

isolation process for troubleshooting and would result in the eventual resolution of

the issue.

The procedures that the proponents follow in the prototype construction are

as follows:

1. Planning of the Project

1.1. Identify the possible location to be monitored in Cabuyao River.

1.2. Plan strategic way/s in measuring water parameters accurately.

1.3. Use a microcontroller that would analyze the data measured by the

waterproof sensors and add a wireless module for the transmission of

data.

1.4. Create a procedure or manual on how the device works.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 34

1.5. Design the schematic diagram of the Web-Based Water Quality Data

Profiling Buoy Network using LoRaWAN.Technology

1.6. Create a list of possible equipment or components needed in the

project.

1.7. Make a time table on the construction of the prototype for the on-time

progress.

2. Construction of the Project

2.1. Check the compatibility of each component including the way they

work, calibrations and the identification of the parameters to be

measured.
Table 1. Gantt Chart of Web-based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy Network using
LoRaWAN Technology
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao

35
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 36

Table 2. Sensors to be used with each parameter.

PARAMETER METHOD OF ANALYSIS


Water Temperature Waterproof Digital Temperature Sensor
pH pH Sensor E-201-C
Turbidity Analog Turbidity Sensor Module
Total Dissolved Solids Analog TDS Sensor
DHT22 Temperature and Humidity
Air (Surface) Temperature & Humidity*
Sensor

*Air temperature and relative humidity parameters are measured also as the

surface temperature rises, less gas molecules will dissolve in water and may affect

the pH outputs (Sallam & Elsayed, 2018).

The results are compared on the water quality standards for fresh surface

waters such as lakes, rivers, reservoirs and so on bases on the Department of

Environment and Natural Resources Administrative Order No. 34, series of 1990.

2.2. Connect and transmit data from sensor to microcontroller where an

Arduino language is used.

2.3. Construct a program in the microcontroller that analyzes the water

parameters measured by the sensors.

2.4. Create a buoy that serves as the floater of the installed sensors.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 37

2.5. Install a solar panel appropriate to the power consumption of the

sensors and microcontroller in the buoy.

2.6. Use a wireless module for the transmission of the water parameters to

the main station.

2.7. Construct a main station for the reception of the transmitted data in

every buoy station.

2.8. Set a criterion in order to classify the gathered data into the level of

the water quality.

2.9. Create a daily and weekly graphical interpretation of the transmitted

data.

3. Testing

3.1. Hardware Testing

3.1.1. Test each component for compatibility in the design project.

3.1.2. Make a test for the calibration of the device after assembling the

whole unit.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 38

3.1.3. Test the device by measuring the received data.

3.1.4. Test the prototype from time to time to check its efficiency and

reliability.

3.2. Software Testing

3.2.1. Test the software provided by the developer.

3.2.2. Test the constructed program if it is working properly.

4. Evaluation

4.1. Relevance

4.1.1. This design project aims to provide the information that can

alleviate the conditions of the river in the City of Cabuyao.

4.1.2. The data collected are forwarded to a partner agency that takes

necessary actions.

4.2. Effectiveness

4.2.1. The sensors have a high percentage of accuracy and thus

maximizes the success of data acquisition.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 39

Table 3. Accuracy of each sensor reading.

SENSOR ACCURACY (%)


Water Temperature Sensor ±0.5°C over much of the range
DHT22 Temperature and Humidity Humidity: 0-100% with 2-5% accuracy
Sensor Temperature: -40 - 80°C ±.5°C
accuracy
pH meter sensor ±0.1pH 25°C
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) Meter ±10% (25°C)
Analog Sensor

4.3. Reliability

4.3.1. The buoy network and the LoRaWAN system must transmit and

receive data to its gateway to ensure reliability.

5. Documentation

5.1. The documents of this design project can be used to aid the future

proponents in understanding the deeper technical side, aspects and

theories involved.

6. Implementation

6.1. The proposed project can be implemented to the river channels in the

City of Cabuyao and to raise the awareness to future recipients and


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 40

people of the whole Philippines, which can help the youth gain interest

in the application of this technology.

Operation Procedures

The researchers come up with the following step by step procedure for the

design project development.

1. Buoys placed in strategic points have sensors detecting pH level, turbidity,

total dissolved solids, water temperature, air temperature and humidity.

2. The sensors submerged/exposed automatically measure the water

parameters every 24 hours.

3. As the water parameters have been measured, the data collected are sent by

each member buoy of the network to the main station.

4. The main station compares the measurements gathered in every buoy.

5. The measurements are then analyzed individually using the water quality

index.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 41

6. The acquired data are then uploaded to the web.

7. The water quality index and the data of gathered water parameters are

displayed in the web.

8. This webpage with the graphical interpretation is only available for a limited

number of users.

Testing Procedures

To test the functionality of the devices, the following procedures may be

conducted as follows:

1. Each component is tested depending on what is the standard testing.

2. pH Sensor

2.1. pH level reading displays on the main station

2.2. pH level is transmitted to the main station via LoRa protocol.

2.3. pH sensor is calibrated by using solutions with a fixed amount level of pH


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 42

range.

2.4. pH sensor is also calibrated by comparing its output to the existing simple

pH meter sensor in the market.

3. Turbidity Sensor

3.1. Turbidity level reading displays on the main station

3.2. Turbidity level is transmitted to the main station via LoRa protocol.

3.3. The turbidity sensor is calibrated by using different kinds of water

and based its value given by the device specifications.

4. Water Temperature Sensor

4.1. Water temperature level reading displays on the main station

4.2. Water temperature level is transmitted to the main station via LoRa

protocol.

4.3. Water temperature sensor is calibrated by applying water with different

temperature conditions.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 43

4.4. Water temperature sensor is also calibrated by comparing its output to a

thermometer.

5. Total Dissolved Solids Sensor

5.1. TDS level reading displays on the main station

5.2. TDS level is transmitted to the main station via LoRa protocol.

5.3. TDS sensor is calibrated by using a solution that approximates the

conductivity for the water to be monitored.

6. Air Temperature and Humidity Sensor

6.1. Air temperature and humidity level reading displays on the main station

6.2. Air temperature and humidity level is transmitted to the main station via

LoRa protocol.

6.3. The Air temperature and humidity sensor is tested by using it in different

kinds of weather conditions.

7. Lora Module for Communication


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 44

7.1. LoRa Sends and receives any data and views it on the main station.

7.2. LoRa is tested by changing the spreading factor and cote rate to know

how fast the transmitted data can be received.

7.3. LoRa is placed in different locations to test its long range transmission

and reception capabilities.

8. Solar Panel

8.1. Solar Panel is tested by measuring its power and voltage output

appropriate to the power consumption needs of each buoy of the network.

8.2. The solar panel is placed on the top of the buoy to test what time it can

generate its most efficient power rating.

9. Acquired data of each sensors will then be compared with a manually

collected data to verify accuracy.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 45

Figure 2. Operational Flow Chart of Web-Based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy

Network using LoRaWAN Technology


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 46

Operational Flow Chart of Web-Based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy Network

using LoRaWAN Technology


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 47

Figure 2 shows the operational procedure of the Web-based Water Quality

Data Profiling Buoy Network using LoRaWAN. The sensors gather the water quality

data and check the turbidity, temperature, pH level and the total dissolved solids in

the water and the humidity and temperature of the air. The air temperature and

humidity should be measured first before the pH level. As the surface temperature

rises, less gas molecules will dissolve in water and may affect the pH outputs.

Whenever a measurement fails, the device tries to read it again.

The values acquired by the sensors for water parameters are computed by

the microcontroller given a standard formula in solving the water quality. The largest

WQI is considered. The WQI is classified to its effect to the health of the river.

Values are ranging from 100 being the safest to 0 being the most hazardous state.

The classified water quality together with the air temperature and humidity readings

from each buoy of the network are sent to the main station and then to the database

for further analysis. The current and previous data between the two buoy are

compared. After the data have been recorded, this will be posted to the web for the

awareness of the citizen.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 48

Figure 3. Block Diagram of Web-Based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy Network

using LoRaWAN Technology


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 49

Evaluation Procedure

The following procedure shows the step by step functionality of the Web-

Based Water Data Profiling Buoy Network using LoRaWAN.

1. Test the wireless module by sending a message and check if it receives the

message.

2. Compare the data for the evaluation of accurate reading of the

microcontroller.

3. After comparison, calibrate the sensors by programming the microcontroller.

4. Check the output of the sensors through the analyzed data by the

microcontroller by sending the data to see if it reads the data.

5. Check if the microcontroller senses the condition and sends an information

to the main station by using separate water samples with different water

parameters.

6. Evaluate the buoy network by using a separate water sample and see if it

senses the water sample automatically after detection.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 50

Evaluation Criteria

The following criteria are used to assess the functionality of the design

project:

1. The system shall be considered functional if the conditions presented are

satisfied.

2. The system is activated depending upon the specifies schedule.

3. The data on the main station must correctly show the data gathered from the

buoy networks.

4. The different sensors (Humidity, air and water temperature, pH, dissolved

solids and turbidity) correctly gather different stimuli and will be fed to the

microcontroller to be processed and thereafter send the data.

5. Turbidity is measured in Nephelometric Turbidity Units (NTU). Surface water

is usually between 1-50 NTU but it can become higher than this due to heavy

rain according to the US Geology Survey. The turbidity sensor only measures

the transparency of the river. This is used to monitor the average turbidity

level of the Cabuyao river.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 51

6. The criteria of water parameters are based on the guidelines provided by

DAO 2016-08.

Table 4. Water Quality Guidelines for Primary Parameter

Water Body Classification


Parameter Unit
AA A B C
pH 6.5 - 8.5 6.5 - 8.5 6.5 -8.5 6.5 - 9.0
Temperature °C 26 – 30 26 - 30 26 – 30 25 - 31
Total Suspended Solids mg/L 25 50 65 80

Note: From “Water Quality Guidelines and General Effluent Standards of

2016”. The classification of water parameters is Class C. These are the criteria of

the microcontroller on the probes output.

7. The device bases its response to this criteria of pH level:

Table 5. Acceptable pH levels of rivers

pH Level Effect
<4.0 Too Acidic
4.0 – 6.5 Slightly Acidic
6.5 – 8.5 Neutral
8.5 – 10.0 Slightly Alkaline
>10.0 Too Alkaline
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 52

Note: The normal pH level of river is between 6.5 to 8.5. Signs of aquatic life

can be found at pH values from 4-10. Any value less than 4 or greater than 10 can

cause fish kill in the rivers.

Instruments and Techniques Used

The technique in writing a thesis is determined by the capability of the

researchers in the establishment of obtained information in every chapter. The

researchers also have to present the materials which have been used to give a

reader an actual standpoint.

Library Researches

The researchers include some relevant documents practical to the

development of water data profiling buoy network which describes the water quality

particulars in Cabuyao river. The researchers utilize the materials offered by the

library such as books, journals, articles and theses. Additional references are found

in the internet which is of foreign and local pieces.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 53

Flowchart and Block Diagram

The researchers include an operational flowchart and block diagram to

illustrate the sequence of operations to be performed from the buoy network to the

accessibility of the gathered water quality data on the web.

Gantt Chart

The researchers use Gantt chart to organize the amount of work needed to

be done in a certain period of time creating the buoy network in relation to the

amount planned to those periods.

Mathematical Method

In calculating the Water Quality index, The Weighted Arithmetic Index method

is used. The quality rating scale of each parameter (Qi) was calculated bu using this

expression:

Quality rating, Qi = 100 [(Vn-Vi)/(Vs-Vi)]

Where, Vn = actual amount of nth parameter

Vi = the ideal value of this parameter

Vs =recommended WHO standard of the corresponding parameter.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 54

Relatively weight (Wi) was calculated by a value inversely proportional to the


recommended standard (Si) of the corresponding parameter

Wi = 1/Si

The overall WQI was calculated by using this equation:

Water Quality Index = ∑(𝑄𝑖)𝑊𝑖/ ∑ 𝑊𝑖

The WQI ranges have been defined as:

 90-100 : Excellent

 70-90 : Good

 50-70 : Moderate

 25-50 : Bad

 0-25 : Very Bad


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 55

Chapter 4

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

This chapter embraces the technical information used in the design project. It

includes the construction of the prototype and the test evaluation needed in aiming

the objective of the design project and the materials to be used.

This section centers on the project and research design, description of the

study procedure, project development, operation and testing procedures, evaluation

procedures and evaluation criteria.

Project Technical Description

Web-Based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy Network using LoRaWAN

Technology is designed for the surveillance of the condition or quality of Cabuyao

River as a tributary to Laguna Lake. The main function of the device is to measure

the parameters of the water in the river and the lake and to determine if these

parameters were in normal or critical level in accordance to DAO and international

standards. The parameters being tested are pH, total dissolved solids, turbidity,
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 56

water temperature, air temperature and humidity. The pH sensor measures the pH

level of the water may it be base or alkaline while the TDS sensor processes the

concentration of the dissolved solid particles. The turbidity sensor identifies the level

of cloudiness of the water and the temperature sensor measures as stated. Humidity

and temperature sensor is also placed to measure relative humidity and temperature

of the air as this may affect the water quality readings. Using LoRa technology, the

collected water quality data were sent to a LoRa Gateway and then to the web after

measuring the parameters.

Project Structure

The technical features of the design are listed below:

1. The entire network is made up of sensors (pH, total dissolved solids, turbidity,

water temperature, and air temperature and humidity sensors). The sensors

were intended to gather the measurement of water parameters of the river to

be processed on a microcontroller.

2. PacketDock Duino is used as a microcontroller that has the capability to

process and interpret the output signal of the sensors and execute the
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 57

program written on it. This microcontroller is a LoRaWAN enabled Arduino

board which may transmit and receive data.

3. Sensors are placed inside a buoy (floatation device) that also houses the

battery and a solar panel. Solar panels are used as the main power source of

each buoy which also charges the Li-ion battery during night time or lean

seasons also an obstruction light (OB Light) is also placed atop each buoy.

4. Anchors are connected to the buoy then submerged in the bottom of the river

to hold and fix the location of the buoy.

5. The data transmitted with the PacketDock Duino is sent to an indoor gateway,

packetCELL INDOOR.

6. Then, the The Things Industries, a private network owned by PacketWorx, will

act as a serial monitor that enables the user to see if a ping or data is

received or not.

7. All the data can be viewed using the PacketView with widgets for each

parameter.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 58

Project Organization

Figure 4. Project Organization of Web- Based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy

Network using LoRaWAN Technology.

Figure 4 shows the project organization of Web-Based Water Quality Data

Profiling Buoy Network using LoRaWAN Technology. It displays the part of each

member in the development of the design project. The roles of the three proponents

are providing the research and documentation of the study as well as the design

layout and the fabrication of the whole system. Engr. Soriano provides the

techniques on how to easily understand the dynamics of this project.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 59

Device Limitation and Capabilities

The following are the limitations and capabilities of the Web-Based Water

Quality Data Profiling using LoRaWAN Technology that is made and observed by

the researchers:

Capabilities

1. The prototype operates when partially submerged in water.

2. The Buoy sends the data to the LoRaWAN Gateway using the PacketDock

Duino.

3. The LoRa Gateway will connect and sends the data of each buoy through the

“The Things Industries’ network server.

4. The PacketView Application server is where all the data has been displayed

for the users.

5. The system’s basis for the water quality classification is according to the

guidelines of DAO and international standards.

6. This prototype can send data up to 2km distance to the LoRa Gateway.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 60

Limitations

1. The prototype floats above the water and is on a fixed location using a steel

chain and an anchor.

2. The device is powered using the generated DC supply from the solar panels

placed on the top of each buoy.

Project Evaluation

This part is a systematic and objective assessment of design project. It shows

the achievement of set evaluation for the effective development of the prototype.

The following are the achieved results based on the set evaluation criteria:

Relevance

a. This project aims to provide and help the City of Cabuyao especially

CENRO, the agency that has a great concern to the environment for it

to have a fixed monitoring network in classifying water quality

b. This project aims to be the first prototype in Laguna that will use

LoRaWAN technology in transmitting and receiving the data of the

quality of the water.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 61

2. Effectiveness

a. This design project achieves its goal to identify the classification of

water in Cabuyao River.

b. It provides a system which determines the classification of the quality

of the water in Cabuyao by the collected data and provide an analysis.

3. Reliability

a. Accuracy and consistency readings from time to time.

b. Durability of the materials use in this project.

4. Safety

a. The programs are safe as it is only accessed by authorized personnel.

b. The data being transmitted is secured in a private network.

c. The connections of the device inside the buoy are safe as it is potted

and is anchored in the riverbed.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 62

Test Procedures

In order to test the functionality of the devices, the following procedures are

conducted as follows:

1. Each component is tested depending on what is the standard test procedure.

Table 6. Test conducted on each sensor, problems encountered and

solutions

Date Component Assessment Problem Solution


Encountered
December 22, pH sensor Functionality of Calibration Calibration
2018 the sensor resulting to Solution to
Error Readings reference values
December 22, DHT22 Functionality of None None
2018 the sensor
December 22, TDS Sensor Functionality of None None
2018 the sensor
December 22, Turbidity Sensor Functionality of None None
2018 the sensor
December 22, Water Functionality of None None
2018 Temperature the sensor
Sensor

Table 6 shows the problems encountered by the proponents with each sensor

and the corresponding solution.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 63

2. In all sensors (water temperature, pH, total dissolved solids, turbidity, air

temperature and humidity), the level of the readings display in the application

server and transmitted to the LoRa Gateway and network server wirelessly

through microcontroller with built in LoRa module.

Table 7. LoRaWAN Data Transmission with respect to distance

Problem

Distance Encountered Solution

1m None None

Connect a patch

10m Incorrect data antenna

50m Cannot receive Connect a patch

data antenna

Based on the results on Table 7, the data transmission using the LoRaWAN

Module must be with its patch antenna to further enhance its range and immunity to

noise and interference.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 64

3. The transmission of PacketDock Duino to the indoor gateway must send

without errors.

Study/ Testing Area

The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) classified

Laguna Lake as a Class C body of water. This type of water body is suited for

fisheries, recreational activities, and industrial water supply.

3 months of water quality data (December 2018 – February 2019) were

gathered from two sampling locations listed in Table 8.

Table 8. Coordinates of buoy sites in Laguna Lake, Philippines

Location

Sampling Point Latitude Longitude

Cabuyao Fish Port

Marinig 14.2806° N 121.1486° E

Butong, Cabuyao 14.2660° N 121.1311° E.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 65

The sites were specifically chosen to represent the water quality of Laguna

Lake and Cabuyao River. The two sampling sites effectively showed variations in

water quality data in relation to the area’s characteristics, hydrologic patterns,

weather conditions and land use attributes.

Testing Results

Table 9. Results of Testing (average results of two locations)

Table 9 results showed that the mean data collected from the two locations

were relatively fair except for pH levels that are having spikes in values and have
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 66

been attributed to sewages thrown directly to the river or the lake meanwhile the

single reading of the water temperature that exceeded the threshold value may have

been due to a sudden change in weather climate.


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 67

Chapter 5

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

This chapter presents the summary, conclusions and recommendation of the

design project titled “Web-based Water Quality Data Profiling Buoy Network using

LoRaWAN Technology.

Summary of Findings

This design project emphasizes the importance of water quality to the

community, bodies of water, and marine species. To support this objective, a water

quality data profiling network— two distant stationed system that measures different

water quality parameter such as total dissolved solids, pH, turbidity, water

temperature are developed. Ambient parameters are also added which includes

temperature and humidity. Data gathered are compared and assessed to monitor

water quality and identify the status. The evaluation are displayed in software

console specifically PacketView accessible by general public.

The implementation of this design scheme may improve present condition of

water bodies. Communities and agencies concerned with marine life will be able to
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 68

analyze the root causes of the issue and determine what action must be undertaken

and the technical efforts that need to be worked on.

The project, as a whole, was effectively planned and tested. The components

including sensors such as pH, turbidity, total dissolved solids, water temperature,

ambient temperature and humidity and the communication medium used which is

LoRaWAN technology have proven their functionality and reliability.

Conclusions

1. The water quality parameter sensors such as pH, turbidity, total dissolved

solids, water temperature, ambient temperature and humidity were installed in

two stationed buoys. The sensors’ probes were submerged to gather data

every four hours.

2. Two buoys containing the water quality parameters sensors were installed in

two locations: Cabuyao River and Laguna lake tributaries anchored at depths

of 1 meter and 2 meters, respectively. The system will classify the status of

the water body through Water Quality Index by Canadian Council of Ministers

of the Environment (CCME).


Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 69

3. LoRaWAN technology was used for transmission and reception of data.

PacketDuino module, were sensors are pinned, processes the transmission

of data. The values gathered will be received by PacketWorx Indoor Gateway

which will route the data to the The Things Industries.

4. The resulting information will be displayed in PacketView Dashboard which

can be viewed by the general public using end user equipment such as

mobile phones and computers connected to the internet.

Recommendations

1. The system can utilize Bluetooth wireless technology to get immediate

water quality parameter levels over short distances.

2. Water level monitoring system can be added to the buoys which will

inform the government for possible floods.

3. Water turbines can be used as an auxiliary power source of the buoys

in times of rains where solar cells cannot collect energy.

4. The system may require a need for safety precautions such as an

alarm system and locks which may disable the device upon force entry

or breach of data.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 70

5. A sleep mode which will conserve the battery/power during no data

transmission.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 71

Bibliography

Journal

Chandra, S., Singh, A., & Tomar, P. (2012). Assessment of Water Quality Values in
Porur Lake Chennai, Hussain Sugar Hyderabad and Vihar Lake Mumbai,
India. Chem Sci Trans.

News Articles

Acuña, O. (2018, September 25). Philippines to use blockchain and IoT devices to
clean up Pasig River. Retrieved from https://coinrivet.com/philippines-to-use-
blockchain-and-iot-devices-to-clean-up-pasig-river/

Cinco, M. (2016). Pollution, squatting, industries hasten death of Laguna de Bay.


Philippine Daily Inquirer.

Gonzales, G. (2018, August 8). Startup Packetworx fostering internet-of-things


community in PH. Retrieved from
https://www.rappler.com/technology/features/209139-packetworx-internet-of-
things-philippines

Published/Unpublished Theses

Baltazar, D. E. (2012). A River Health Status Model using Water Quality,


Macroinvertebrates, and Land Use for Niyugan River, Cabuyao City, Laguna,
Philippines. XII, 106.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 72

Ethier, A., & Bedard, J. (2008). Development of a Real-Time Water Quality Buoy for
the Fraser River Estuary. doi: 10.1109/OCEANS.2007.4449424

Ferrari, P., Rizzi, M., Flammini, A., & Sisinni, E. (2017, September 13). Evaluation of
the IoT LoRaWAN Solution for Distributed Measurements Applications.
66(12), 3340-3349. Retrieved from
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8036410

Fister, A., Gombas, J., DeBrosse, S., Tag, M., Magbag, D., & Kosmider, J. (n.d.).
Cuyahoga River Water Quality Monitoring Program. Retrieved from
https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/fenlewis/Waterquality.html

Gorde, S., & Jadhav, M. (2013). Assesment of Water Quality Parameters: A Review.
Pune.

Liu, Y.-T., Lin, B.-Y., Yue, X.-F., Cai, Z.-X., Yang, Z.-X., Yuan, S.-Y., & Lu, J.-L.
(2018). A Solar-Powered Long Range Real-Time Water Quality Monitoring
System by LoRaWAN. 1-2. doi:10.1109/WOCC.2018.8373792

Mahagamage, M., & Manage, S. C. (2014). Assessment of Water Quality Index for
Groundwater in the Kelani River Basin, Sri Lanka. International Journal of
Agriculture and Environmental Research.

Martinico-Perez, M., Hara, J., & Cabrestante Jr., M. (2017). Evaluation of Water
Quality of Major Rivers in Palawan, Philippines using Physico-Chemical
Parameters and Water Quality Index. Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.

Solpico, D. B., Libatique, N. C., Tangonan, G. L., Cabacungan, P. M., Girardot, G.,
Macaraig, R., . . . Teran, A. (2014, September 20). Solar-Powered Field
Server and Aerator Development for Lake Palakpakin. Retrieved from
https://www.fujipress.jp/jaciii/jc/jacii001800050755/

Tamayo-Zafaralla, M., Santos, R., Orozco, R., & Elegado, G. (2013). The Ecological
Status of Lake Laguna de Bay, Philippines. Aquatic Ecosystem Health and
Management.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 73

Government Documents

Affairs, U. N. (2015). Water for Life. United Nations.

Canadian Council of Ministers of Environment. (2017). CCME Water Quality Index


User's Manual. Canadian Water Quality Guidelines for the Protection of
Acquatic Life.

Department of Environment and Natural Resources. (n.d.). Clean Water Act and
Provisions. Manila, Philippines: DENR-EMB.

Department of Environment and Natural Resouces (DENR). (2016, May 24). Water
Quality Guidelines and General Effluent Standards of 2016. Retrieved from
http://server2.denr.gov.ph/uploads/rmdd/dao-2016-08.pdf

Republic Act (R.A.) No. 9275. (2004, March 22). Retrieved September 25, 2018,
from https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2004/ra_9275_2004.html

United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. (2015). Water for Life.

United Nations International Children's Emergency Fund. (n.d.). Water, Sanitation


and Hygiene. Retrieved from UNICEF: www.unicef.org/wash/

United Nations Environment. (2018, April 10). Paralysed Growth: Lake Under Siege.
Retrieved from https://www.unenvironment.org/news-and-
stories/story/paralysed-growth-lake-under-siege
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
Laguna, Philippines 4025

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING 74

Internet Researches

Cox, C. (2017). Battling Pollution in the Philippine's Largest Lake. Retrieved from UN
Environment: www.unenvironment.org

e-Gizmo Mechatronix Central. (2018). e-Gizmo Mechatronix Central. Retrieved from


e-Gizmo: www.e-gizmo.net/index

Philippines Environment Monitor. (n.d.). Philippines: State of Water Environmental


Issues. Retrieved from Water Environment Partnership in Asia: www.wepa-
db.net/policies

Tomas, J. P. (2017). What is LoRaWAN and what are the main benefits of this
Technology? Retrieved from Enterprise IoT Insights: enterpriseiotinsights.com

Вам также может понравиться