30 July 2019

Our Ref.: 8715/00077/TL/DW/FT/fl

Your Ref.: ---

China State Construction Engineering (Hong Kong) Limited

P.O. Box No. 258, Tung Chung Post Office
Tung Chung

For the attention of Mr. Samuel Tse

Dear Sir

C17W03 - SKY BRIDGE CONNECTING TERMINAL 1 WITH NORTH SATELLITE

CONCOURSE
AIR-CONDITIONING INSTALLATION - COMMENT ON MATERIAL SUBMISSION
(G.I. SHEET DUCTWORK & ACCESSORIES, INSULATION FOR PIPEWORK, INSULATION FOR
DUCTWORK, INSULATION FOR REFRIGERANT PIPE, FIRE SEALANT, PIPE SUPPORT, CABLE
CONTAINMENT AND ACCESSORIES & G.I. CONDUIT AND ACCESSORIES)

With reference to the China State's submission, we would like to advise our comment as follow:-

Item Reference Rev. Description Brand of Comment

Origin
1. CSHK/CDR/C 0 G.I. Sheet Yieh Phui / - No adverse comment on brand and
AI/2019/0359 Ductwork & Taiwan origin.
Accessories - The page order is not correct.
- The material submission have not
included accessories. Please clarify.
- Please clarify the non-compliance
of GMWS Section 70.3.1.
- Please sure that it is not applied on
kitchen exhaust ductwork.
- Please clarift the the thickness of
GI sheet.
- Samples shall be submitted for
comment.
- Resubmission is required.
..../P.2
Page 2

30 July 2019

Our Ref.: 8715/00077/TL/DW/FT/fl

Your Ref.: ---
China State Construction Engineering (Hong Kong) Limited

Item Reference Rev. Description Brand of Comment

Origin
2. CSHK/CDR/C 0 Insulation Armaflex/ - No adverse comment on brand and
AI/2019/0398 for pipework Phenotherm / origin.
UK / PRC - Please clarify the appplied type of
pipe.
- Please submit and comply relavant
BEC 2018 requirement.
- Please provide table to indicate the
minimum thickness of insulation of
different size of pipe on difficult
conditions (eg. outdoor, conditioned
space and unconditioned space) under
their own material properties
(thermal conductivity and line
temperature, etc)
- Please highlight the catalogue to
comply GWMS Secion 73.2.1 (e)(iv)
material performance.
- Samples shall be submitted for
comment.
- Two catalogue are submitted. Please
clarify and submit separately.
- Please clarify the non-compliace of
GWMS Secion 73.4.4 Table 73.4.
- Resubmission is required
3. CSHK/CDR/C 0 Insulation Armaflex/ - Rejected
AI/2019/0402 for Phenotherm / - The submission content is for pipe
Ductwork UK / PRC insulation, not applicable on
ductwork insulation.
- Resubmission is required.
..../P.3
Page 3

30 July 2019

Our Ref.: 8715/00077/TL/DW/FT/fl

Your Ref.: ---
China State Construction Engineering (Hong Kong) Limited

Item Reference Rev. Description Brand of Comment

Origin
4. CSHK/CDR/C 0 Insulation Armaflex/ UK - No adverse comment on brand and
AI/2019/0403 for / PRC origin.
Refrigerant - Please submit and comply relavant
Pipe BEC 2018 requirement.
- Please provide table to indicate the
minimum thickness of insulation of
different size of pipe on difficult
conditions (eg. outdoor, conditioned
space and unconditioned space)
under their own material properties
(thermal conductivity and line
temperature, etc)
- Please highlight the catalogue to
comply 73.2.1 (e)(iv) material
performance.
- Samples shall be submitted for
comment.
- Resubmission is required
5. CSHK/CDR/C 0 Fire Sealant Hilti / UK - No adverse comment on brand and
AI/2019/0406 origin.
- Please submit and comply GMWS
Section 70.4.1(e), 70.4.9(b)&(c)
and 70.6.13.
- Job reference 2015-2018 shall be
provided.
- Resubmission is required
6. CSHK/CDR/C 0 Pipe Support OPS / PRC - No adverse comment on brand and
AI/2019/0407 origin.
- Please submit and comply GMWS
Section 72.3.4 (a) and 72.5.3 and
73.2.1(e) and 73.4.4.
- Please clarify the density will be
adopted.
- Resubmission is required
..../P.4
Page 4

30 July 2019

Our Ref.: 8715/00077/TL/DW/FT/fl

Your Ref.: ---
China State Construction Engineering (Hong Kong) Limited

Item Reference Rev. Description Brand of Comment

Origin
7. CSHK/CDR/C 0 Cable Lik Hung / - No adverse comment on brand and
AI/2019/0444 Containment PRC origin.
and - Please clarify GMWS section 49.3.1
Accessories (f) for cable tray: For cable tray with
nominal width of 450mm or above,
the angle shall be 30°or 60°.
- Please provide BS 4678 or equivalent
certificate for cable tray.
- Resubmission is required.
8. CSHK/CDR/C 0 G.I. Conduit HN-MES / - Technically acceptable subject to
AI/2019/0445 and Tianjin, P.R.C fully compliance with technical
Accessories specification.

Please note that the checking of sub-contractor’s submission does not absolve the sub-contractor of their
responsibility to co-ordinate their work with other sub-contractors and direct contractors of main
contract and comply with the design intent and requirement of the contract documentation.

Thank you for your attention.

Yours faithfully

Tony Lau
Project Manager

Encl.

cc : YWL - Ms. Boonfei Chew / Mr. TB Lau (w/e by e-mail)

China State - Ms. Ella Lee / Mr. Charles Tse / Mr. Samuel Tse (w/e by e-mail)