Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Page 1 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
(3) QUALIFYING AGGRAVATING
CIRCUMSTANCE
- if present in the commission of the
crime, will change the nature of the
crime
Controlling rule:
Offender could not have committed the
crime if he were not a public officer.
Insult to authorities:
2. That the crime be committed in contempt
or with insult to the public authorities.
Page 2 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
2. That he who is thus engaged in the
exercise of said functions is not the person
against whom the crime is committed
Page 3 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
- victim must be a female while offender is
3. SEX - male or female, not gender male
- offender committed the crime with insult
to or in disregard of the respect due to the
victim on account of her sex
Page 4 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
- when the owner of the dwelling gave
sufficient and immediate provocation
4. That the act be committed with (1) abuse PEOPLE vs CALISO YES. Aggravating circumstance of grave abuse
of confidence, or (2) obvious ungratefulness
of confidence was present since the appellant
(1) Abuse of confidence: was a domestic servant of the family.
1. The offended party had trusted the
"Grave abuse of trust and confidence" offender Dwelling disregarded as both victim and
appellant were living in the same house.
2. The offender abused such trust by
committing a crime against offended party Treachery cannot be considered as it is
inherent in the crime of murder by means of
poisoning.
3. The abuse of confidence facilitated the
commission of the crime
PEOPLE vs LORA YES. 3 aggravating circumstances:
Page 5 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
1. Palace or in the presence of the
5. That the crime be committed in the palace President - inside Malacanang Palace
of the Chief Executive or in his presence, or (president may or may not be present)
where public authorities are engaged in the
discharge of their duties, or in a place
dedicated to religious worship
Page 6 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
Based on the time and place of the Nights are from sunset to sunrise. (Art. 13,
commission of the crime and means Civil Code)
and ways employed.
When aggravating:
3 common tests by Supreme Court:
(1) Objective Test - when night time
facilitates the commission of the offense.
E.g. rape, robbery, thef
2. commission of a crime in an
uninhabited place
Page 7 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
- uninhabited place is any place where
there are no access at all or where the
houses are far from each other or is any
place where no reasonable help may be
expected
- The basis of this aggravating - But for other crimes it may be considered
circumstance has reference to the time as ordinary aggravating.
of the commission of the crime.
-The crime is committed on the (fireman who commits robbery in a
occasion of a calamity or misfortune. burned house)
Page 8 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
2. That the accused availed himself of
It is based on the means and ways of their aid or relied upon them when the
committing the crime. crime was committed
Page 9 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
Page 10 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
- penalty must be imposed in its maximum
period. A special aggravating circumstance,
cannot be off-set by mitigating.
- extraordinary aggravating
- additional imposition of penalty
Page 11 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
13. That the act be committed with evident NO. The lapse of thirty minutes between the
PEOPLE vs ZETA
premeditation determination to commit a crime (to shoot
Ramon) and the execution (shot to death
Ramon) thereof is insufficient for a full
meditation on the consequences of the act.
- a specific ordinary aggravating 2. An act manifestly indicating that the
circumstance that can only be applied accused clung to that determination
to specific crimes
3. A lapse of time between the
determination and the execution sufficient
to allow the accused to reflect upon the
consequences of the act
Page 12 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
FRAUD - direct inducement by insidious
words or machinations to induce the
victim to act in a manner which would
enable the offender to carry out his design
Page 13 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
(2) The offender consciously adopted the
manner of attack to make the victim
- there is treachery when the offender defenseless
commits any of the crimes against the
person, employing means, methods, or
forms in the execution thereof which
tend directly and specially to insure its
execution, without risk to himself
arising from the defense which the
offended party might make
18. The crime be committed afer an unlawful There is unlawful entry when an entrance
is effected by a way not intended for the
entry (Escalamiento) purpose
Page 14 of 15
ARTICLE REQUISITES/ ELEMENTS CASE RULING
(entry through window and committed
crime; door is the usual entry)
19. That as a means to the commission of a Breaking of a wall, roof, floor etc. as a
crime, a wall, roof, floor, door, or window be means to commit a crime.
broken.
Page 15 of 15