Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
APPROVED BY :
EUROESTUDIOS S.L
CONSULTING ENGINEERING In Association with
SERVICES (INDIA) PVT. LTD.
INFINITY IT LAGOON, 10TH & 11TH
FLOOR, PLOT NO.-E2-2/1, BLOCK GEOCONSULT INDIA HOLTEC CONSULTING
HINDUSTAN EP&GP, SALT LAKE ELECTRONIC PVT. LTD. PVT LTD. RODIC CONSULTANTS PVT. LTD.
CONSTRUCTION CO. LTD. COMPLEX, SECTOR - V,
KOLKATA- 700 091
PLOT 473, INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HOLTEC CENTRE, A BLOCK, 4TH FLOOR, TOWER-A, DLF CYBER
LAL BAHADUR SHASTRI MARG UDYOG BIHAR, SECTOR 19, SUSHANT LOK, GURGAON GREENS, DLF CYBER CITY, GURGAON-
VIKHROLI (WEST), MUMBAI 400 083 PHASE V, 122016 GURGAON, 122001, HARYANA, INDIA 122002, HARYANA
INDIA
APPROVED BY :
EUROESTUDIOS S.L
CONSULTING ENGINEERING In Association with
SERVICES (INDIA) PVT. LTD.
INFINITY IT LAGOON, 10TH & 11TH
FLOOR, PLOT NO.-E2-2/1, BLOCK GEOCONSULT INDIA HOLTEC CONSULTING
HINDUSTAN EP&GP, SALT LAKE ELECTRONIC PVT. LTD. PVT LTD. RODIC CONSULTANTS PVT. LTD.
CONSTRUCTION CO. LTD. COMPLEX, SECTOR - V,
KOLKATA- 700 091
PLOT 473, INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HOLTEC CENTRE, A BLOCK, 4TH FLOOR, TOWER-A, DLF CYBER
LAL BAHADUR SHASTRI MARG
UDYOG BIHAR, SECTOR 19, SUSHANT LOK, GURGAON GREENS, DLF CYBER CITY, GURGAON-
VIKHROLI (WEST), MUMBAI 400 083 PHASE V, 122016 GURGAON, 122001, HARYANA, INDIA 122002, HARYANA
INDIA
Design Basis
1 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1.0 Detailed design of 1x30.0m c/c span integral bridge at ch. 155+087 .481km for South Bound
Carriageway of Ramban- Banihal section of NH-1A
1.1 Basis
Basic design criteria have been prepared with a view to satisfy all the relevant technical
requirements specified in the contract.
1.3 Material :
a) Grades of concrete are as follows:
i) Foundation :M40
ii) Substructure :M40
iii) Superstructure :M40
iv) crash barrier :M40
v) Retaining wall :M35
b) Grade of Reinforcement :Fe-500
c) Prestressing steel :12.7mm dia low relaxation strand of
UTS 1862 Mpa confirming to IS:14268
1.4 LOADS :
a) Unit Weight of Materials :
i) Unit weight of PSC super structure = 25.0 KN/m3
ii) Unit weight of RCC substructure & foundation = 25.0 KN/m3
iii) Unit weight of Structural steel = 78.5 KN/m3
iv) Unit weight of Wearing course = 22.0 KN/m3
v) Unit weight of Earth = 19.0 KN/m3
f) Impact (IL)
Impact factor of live load has been calculated as per IRC: 6-2014
Impact Factor for class-A = 4.5/(6+L)
i) Snow load
Snow load shall be calculated as per clause no. 221 of IRC:6-2014.
a) 0.25m ht of snow load to be added over 70R wheeled loading
b) 0.5m ht of snow load to be added over 70R tracked loading
2 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
r) Buoyancy (Gb)
Buoyancy as per clause no. 213 of IRC:6-2014 for water at HFL shall not be applicable for the above bridge
as the proposed integral bridge is away from the stream.
3 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
4 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1.5 Arrangement
PSC superstructure of span 30.0m c/c over RCC abutments on RCC open foundation have been proposed.
For two lane bridge with footpath, total width of carriageway is 9.0m and total width of deck slab
(incl. two nos. crash barrier & one railing) is 12.0m. 4nos. PSC girders are integrated with abutment.
1.6 Analysis
The longitudinal & transverse analysis of integral bridge has been done by Staad pro for Seismic load, DL,
SIDL, live load, secondary effect of prestress, support settlement, temperature earth pressure creep &
shrinkage etc.
Dead load analyses, prestressing forces & loss and stress calculation have been done by excel spreadsheet
prepared in-house. Design of abutment & its foundations have been done by excel spreadsheet.
1.7 Construction Methodology
Foundation
Before casting of RCC open foundation for abutment A1 & A2, foundation trench shall be excavated with
proper shoring to avoid collapse or slip circle failure. Open foundation with sliding key shall be placed on firm
rock bed. If any unsuitable material on foundation level or any loose pockets are observed on foundation
level, the same shall be removed /replaced by the PCC M15. RCC cast-in-situ foundation for both abutments
shall be laid over 100thk PCC M15 levelling course.
Substructure
RCC cast-in-situ abutment shall be cast over open foundation. The precast PSC 4nos. girders shall be placed
on PCC levelled plinth over abutment wall. Backfilling behind abutment shall be done after complete integration
of substructure & superstructure.
Superstructure
Stage-1 :- All 4 nos. Precast girders shall be cast over abutment with proper staging or casting yard.
Stage-2 :- After 5 days casting of Girder, first stage cables shall be stressed as per given force & elongation.
Stage-3 :- Second stage cables shall be stressed after 28 days of casting of precast girder.
Stage-4 :- All Precast girders shall be placed/erected on PCC levelled plinth over abutment wall.
Stage-5 :- Deck slab & X-Girder shall be monolithically cast after erecting necessary shuttering from precast
girder at 60 days except at top of abutment portion.
Stage-6 :- After 30 days casting of Deck Slab i.e. after 90 days casting of Precast Girder, top of abutment
cap shall be cast for jointing of superstructure & substructure after removing of all shuttering.
Stage-7 :- After 28/30 days jointing of superstructure & substructure i.e. after 120 days casting of
Precast Girder, SIDL shall be laid.
5 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Design Data
6 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
2.0 Design Data for Simply Supported Prestressed I-Girder of span 30.0m - Curved span
2.1 Geometric details
C/C distance of abutments = 30.00 m Effective girder span = 28.50 m
Deck slab overhang over pier = 0.75 m Girder overhang at either end = 0.25 m
Note - Overhangs are measured from the centreline of bearing. Angle for span, θ = 0.27 radian
Average Radius of curvature R = 110.00 m Design velocity of vehicle = 60 kmph
Actual length of girder, LG4 = 29.788 m Actual length of girder, LG3 = 29.296 m
Actual length of girder, LG2 = 28.803 m Actual length of girder, LG1 = 28.310 m
7 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Elevation
8 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
12.610
0.5 1.500 0.50 9.610 0.50
65 thk w/c
0.225 1.250
0.2
0.1
0.2
0.75 0.25
1.265 3.000 3.000 3.000 2.253 to 1.811
to 1.789 Section X-X
Center of Symmetry
0.225
0.2
0.10 0.30
1.75 1.75
2.00 1.775 1.525
0.20
0.25
0.75 28.50
30.00
0.250
Section Y-Y
X
3.00
13.144 Girder-LG2
3.00
Girder-LG3
3.00
Cross Girder
Girder-LG4
1.50 2.253
X
0.750 28.50
30.00
Plan
9 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
10 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.2 1 1
0.1 2 2
0.475
D= 1.775 3
0.2 4 4
0.25 5 5
0.225 0.3
0.75
0.2 1 1
0.053 2 2
0.25
D= 1.775 3
0.75
11 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Calculation of Sectional properties of main girder & cross girder for STAAD Analysis
2.8.3 Sectional properties of Composite Precast Girder & Deck Slab : At Mid Span
As per cl. No. 7.6.1.2 of IRC 112-2011, the width of compression flange of beams with solid webs
beff = ∑ beff,i +bw for T-Beam beff,i = 0.2bi+0.1l0
bw = Width of web = 0.3 m lo = effetive span = 28.50 m
bi = Spacing of girder = 3 m
be = 3.000 m for T-Beam 3.000 m for L-Beam
3.000
1.25
Y
1 0.225
0.2 2 2
0.1 3 3
0.475
D= 1.775 Z 4 Z
0.2 5 5
0.25 6 6
0.225 0.3
0.75
Y
Flexural Stiffness about major axis X-X:
CG from
Id. No. bi di N A A x d'i A x ( d'i )2 I xx(i) Ixx(i)+A(d'i)2
Bottom (d'i)
(m) (m) (Nos.) (m2) (m) (m3) (m4) (m4) (m4)
1 3.000 0.225 1 0.6750 1.888 1.27406 2.40479 0.002848 2.40764
2 0.475 0.200 2 0.1900 1.675 0.31825 0.53307 0.000633 0.53370
3 0.475 0.100 2 0.0475 1.542 0.07323 0.11289 0.000026 0.11292
4 0.300 1.775 1 0.5325 0.888 0.47259 0.41943 0.139809 0.55924
5 0.225 0.200 2 0.0450 0.317 0.01425 0.00451 0.000100 0.00461
6 0.225 0.250 2 0.1125 0.125 0.01406 0.00176 0.000586 0.00234
Total A = 1.6025 Total Axd'i = 2.1664 Total ICG(i)+ A ( d'i )2 = 3.6205
Total A = 1.603 m2
Total CG from bottom CG = =A/Axd'i = 1.352 m
Total Moment of Inertia about CG =ICG(i) + A ( d'i )2 -Ax CG^2 = 0.692 m4
3
Z Top of slab =I/(D+d-CG) = 1.067 m
3
Z bot of slab = 1.635 m
Zbottom of beam =I/CG = 0.512 m3
Perimeter in contact with air u = = 10.473 m
Flexural Stiffness about major axis Y-Y:
CG from
Id. No. bi di N A A x d'i A x ( d'i )2 I CG(i) ICG(i)+A(d'i)2
Centre (d'i)
(m) (m) (Nos.) (m2) (m) (m3) (m4) (m4) (m4)
1 0.225 3.000 1 0.6750 0.000 0.00000 0.00000 0.506250 0.50625
2 0.200 0.475 2 0.1900 0.388 0.00000 0.02853 0.003572 0.03210
3 0.100 0.475 2 0.0475 0.308 0.00000 0.00452 0.000595 0.00511
4 1.775 0.300 1 0.5325 0.000 0.00000 0.00000 0.003994 0.00399
5 0.200 0.225 2 0.0450 0.225 0.00000 0.00228 0.000127 0.00240
6 0.250 0.225 2 0.1125 0.263 0.00000 0.00775 0.000475 0.00823
Total Area = 1.6025 Total Axd'i = 0.00000 Total I = 0.55809
Total Moment of Inertia about CG = 0.558 m4
Torsional Stiffness : 3.000
Id. No. d b d/b k J0 = kb3d 1 0.225
(m) (m) (m4) 1.0917 2 0.300
1 3.0000 0.2250 13.333 0.333 0.01138
2 1.0917 0.3000 3.639 0.275 0.00809
3 1.025
3 1.0250 0.3000 3.417 0.271 0.00749 0.3
4 0.6500 0.4500 1.444 0.190 0.01128
Total torsional stiffness 0.03824 4 0.450
0.6500
12 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
2.8.4 Sectional properties of Composite Precast Girder & Deck Slab : At Support
3.000
1.25
Y
1 0.225
0.2 2 2
0.053 3 3
0.25
D= 1.775 X 4 X
0.75
Y
Flexural Stiffness about major axis X-X:
CG from
Id. No. bi di N A A x d'i A x ( d'i )2 I CG(i) ICG(i)+A(d'i)2
Bottom (d'i)
(m) (m) (Nos.) (m2) (m) (m3) (m4) (m4) (m4)
1 3.0000 0.225 1 0.6750 1.8875 1.27406 2.40479 0.002848 2.40764
2 0.2500 0.200 2 0.1000 1.675 0.16750 0.28056 0.000333 0.28090
3 0.2500 0.053 2 0.0132 1.557 0.02049 0.03192 0.000002 0.03192
4 0.750 1.775 1 1.3313 0.888 1.18148 1.04857 0.349522 1.39809
Total A = 2.1194 Total Axd'i = 2.6435 Total ICG(i)+ A ( d'i )2 = 4.1185
Total A = 2.119 m2
Total CG from bottom CG = =A/Axd'i = 1.247 m
Total Moment of Inertia about CG =ICG(i) + A ( d'i )2 -Ax CG^2 = 0.821 m4
Z Top of slab =I/(D+d-CG) = 1.091 m3
Z Top of girder 1.556 m3
Zbottom of girder =I/CG = 0.658 m3
Flexural Stiffness about major axis Y-Y:
CG from
Id. No. bi di N A A x d'i A x ( d'i )2 I CG(i) ICG(i)+A(d'i)2
Centre (d'i)
(m) (m) (Nos.) (m2) (m) (m3) (m4) (m4) (m4)
1 0.225 3.000 1 0.6750 0.000 0.00000 0.00000 0.506250 0.50625
2 0.200 0.250 2 0.1000 0.500 0.00000 0.02500 0.000521 0.02552
3 0.053 0.250 2 0.0132 0.833 0.00000 0.00914 0.000046 0.00918
4 1.775 0.750 1 1.3313 0.000 0.00000 0.00000 0.062402 0.06240
Total Area = 2.1194 Total Axd'i = 0.00000 Total I = 0.60336
Total Moment of Inertia about CG = 0.603 m4
Torsional Stiffness : 3.000
Id. No. d b d/b k J0 = kb3d 1 0.225
(m) (m) (m4) 1.1979 2 0.253
1 3.0000 0.2250 13.333 0.333 0.01138
2 1.1979 0.2526 4.742 0.288 0.00557 3
1.522
3 1.5224 0.7500 2.030 0.230 0.14792 0.75
Total torsional stiffness 0.16487
2.8.5.
2.8.5 Sectional properties of Composite Precast Girder & Deck Slab : At flared Portion
3.000
1.25
Y
1 0.225
0.2 2 2
0.076 3 3
0.3625
D= 1.775 X 4 X
0.100 5 5
0.25 6 6
0.1125 0.525
0.75
Y
13 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
2.8.6.
2.8.6 Sectional Properties of intermeaiate Cross Girder Member
3.563
1 0.225
2 1.525
0.30
14 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
15 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Load Calculation
16 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Avg. Dist. from LG4 = 2.130 m 0.105 m at support Moment= 0.79 kN-m at support
1.848 m 0.387 m at span Moment= 2.90 kN-m at span
Outer girder LG1, support 1.890 m Width = 2.890 m =2.890x0.1x22 = 6.36 kN/m
CG from girder = -0.055 m Moment = -= 0.35 kN-m
Outer girder LG1, span 1.570 m Width = 2.570 m =2.570x0.1x22 = 5.65 kN/m
CG from girder = -0.215 m Moment = -= 1.22 kN-m
Inner girder LG2 = 3.0 m = 6.600 kN/m 0 m
Inner girder LG3 = 3.0 m = 6.600 kN/m 0 m
Outer girder LG4 = 2.500 m = 5.500 kN/m 0.25 m
Outer girder LG4, support 2.130 m Width = 1.130 m =1.130x0.1x22 = 2.49 kN/m
CG from girder = 0.935 m Moment = = 2.32 kN-m
Outer girder LG4, span 1.848 m Width = 0.848 m =0.848x0.1x22 = 1.86 kN/m
CG from girder = 1.076 m Moment = = 2.01 kN-m
17 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
(For slab bridge, CD =1.1, For Single beam/Box girder, CD =1.5 for b/d<=2.0, CD =1.3 for b/d>=6.0 and inbetween interpolated CD to be considered)
G = Gust Factor (If Span<=150, G=2, Otherwise Wind tunnel testing required) = 2.0
CL = Lift coefficient = 0.75
18 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
19 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.84
2.06 2.9
0.84
0.914 0.914 0.914 0.914 0.914
4.57
3.656
Live Load Position in Plan
12.61
0.5 1.500 0.50 9.61 0.50
2.9
0.84 0.84 1.2
13.4
20 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
18.80
12.61
0.5 1.500 0.50 9.61 0.50
21 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
F
1025 300 h= 2000 mm
200 G 525
100 H
150 I h3 =0.3h<0.15m = 150mm
2.1
750
Equivalent Beam Section Temperature Rise
E= Elastic Modulus of Concrete at service Condition = 3.3E+04 N/mm2
α = Coefficient of thermal coefficient of concrete = 1.2E-05 /0C
CG = 1352 mm A= 1.603
Temperature Stress : = EαT = x xT Zt = 1.067 Ztb = 1.635
Zbb = 0.512
Force
Block Area Stress (σ) y (mm) Moment
(A x σ)
1 450000 4.26 1917.71 557.47 1069.07
2 225000 1.36 306.11 458.38 140.32
3 218750 0.56 122.55 306.42 37.55
4 112500 0.42 47.27 -1251.92 -59.18
2394 1188
Axial Tension = 2394 kN
Strain =F/(E*A) = 0.000045
Hogging Moment = 1188 kN-m
+ + =
Temperature Stresses :
Top of Slab : 6.92 - 1.494 = 5.43 - 1.11 = 4.32 N/mm2
Top of Beam : 1.12 - 1.49 -= 0.37 - 0.73 -= 1.10 N/mm2
Bottom of Beam: 0.84 - 1.49 -= 0.65 + 2.32 = 1.67 N/mm2
22 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
b) Temperature Fall
3000
10.6
225 A h1 =0.2h<0.25m = 250mm
25 B 1.69
175 C 1250 0.7 h2 =0.25h<0.25m = 250mm
75 D 775 0.210
25 E
F
975 300 h= 2000 mm
E= = 3.3E+04 N/mm2
α= = 1.2E-05 /0C
CG = 1352 mm A= 1.603
Temperature Stress : = EαT = x xT Zt = 1.067 Ztb = 1.635
Zbb = 0.512
Forcein top Slab as per cl. 218.5 to control
Hence sufficient amount Longitudinal reiforcement needs to provide
Block Area Stress (σ) y (mm) Moment
the thermal cracking. (A x σ)
1 675000.0 -2.46 -1659.77 508.40 -843.82
2 31250.0 -0.48 -14.94 408.86 -6.11
3 218750.0 -0.18 -39.83 519.88 -20.71
4 58125.0 -0.08 -4.88 423.08 -2.07
5 15000.0 -0.06 -0.96 -1318.58 1.27
105000.0 -0.19 -20.17 -1229.70 24.80
4 187500 -1.48 -277.60 -1194.26 331.53
-2018 -515
Axial compression = -2018 kN
Strain =F/(E*A) = -0.000038
Sagging Moment = -515 kN-m
-4.24 + 1.26 + 0.48 -2.50
-0.68 + 1.26 + 0.32 0.90
-0.28
-0.08
+ + =
-0.06
-0.32
-2.64 1.26 -1.01 -2.39
23 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
+ + =
24 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
25 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
3.10.2 Active earth Pressure on vertical wall at seismic case 0.000 kN/m2
26 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
3.10.3 Active earth Pressure on tranverse side wall at normal case 0.000 kN/m2
(As per clause no. 214 of ammendment no. 2 of IRC:6-2014, August 2014)
Active earth pressure coefficient at Normal case Ka
= Cos2(φ-α)
Cos α*Cos(α+δ)*[1+{Sin(φ+δ)*Sin(φ-β)/(Cos(α-δ)*Cos(δ+α))}1/2]2
2
27 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
28 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.475 0.2
0.1 0.053
0.2
0.25
0.225 0.225
0.75 2.250 0.75
Part of intermediate cross girder {1.25x(1.775-0.25)-(0.93-0.75x0.25)}x0.3x25 = 8.75 kN
= 8.75 kN
36.11 36.11
23.19
0.250 1.75 1.75 22.29 1.75 1.75 0.250
4.1.3 Dead Load Moment & Shear for Deck slab & X-girder
Unit weight of concrete = 25.000 kN/m3
Thickness of deck slab = 0.225 m2
Average width of deck slab at support = 3.445 m
Wt of Inner X-girder (1.75/2x(1.775-0.25))x0.3x25 = 10.008 kN
= 10.008
29 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
19.376
30 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
31 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
32 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
33 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
34 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
4.1.5 Summary of Bending Moment & Shear Force for outer girder
a) Bending Moment (kNm) 102 107 110 114 119 Staad Member no
Description At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Distance (m) 0.000 3.661 7.322 10.983 14.644
Precast girder only -1.1 1148.8 1941.7 2423.9 2595.3
Construction load -0.2 315.1 540.4 675.5 720.6
Deck slab & X-girder -0.6 926.6 1594.2 2002.1 2150.2
Total wt of deck slab = -1.7 2075.4 3536.0 4426.0 4745.6
SIDL (DL) from staad output -874.0 -68.9 264.0 376.4 354.0
SIDL (WC) from staad output -248.6 -33.6 76.7 151.6 196.7
Removal of shutter 485.1 63.2 -141.7 -265.4 -307.8
Earth pressure -231.0 -325.8 -377.9 -447.1 -535.8
Live load surcharge 446.8 295.3 -213.3 -103.5 64.8
Wind load (unloaded structure) -490.2 -46.6 212.5 265.8 334.1
Wind load (loaded structure) -243.6 -17.1 90.2 151.7 167.1
Differential settlement 772.3 534.3 -404.3 -229.2 41.1
Temperature rise -101.2 -97.7 -95.6 -92.8 -89.2
Temperature fall 56.5 55.4 54.7 53.7 52.3
Creep & shrinkage 296.3 310.3 -316.7 -324.3 -331.9
Footpath live load 391.4 41.2 109.5 176.5 175.5
Snow load -517.0 -65.4 107.4 286.7 331.9
Braking load 150.0 102.9 -77.3 -43.2 9.3
Live Load -1902.2 -421.2 708.5 1295.0 1417.8
Seismic in X- direction -1941.8 -1361.7 -1035.7 -586.4 -131.5
Seismic in Z- direction -390.5 -123.6 -101.8 -197.8 -238.7
Seismic in Y- direction -126.8 -25.2 -47.1 -85.8 -95.4
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. -99.7 -172.4 -212.5 -265.8 -334.1
Dynamic increment of LL Surcharge 281.8 186.3 -134.6 -65.3 40.8
Hyperstatic action At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Axial compresion 133.042 137.966 137.231 136.12 131.619
Moment -1096.2 -1097.5 -1096.3 -1094.5 -1091.9
The hyperstatic action is only considered for calculation of negative moment at support.
35 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
36 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
37 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.300
4
0.350
X X X 3
1.775 0.400
2
4 0.400
1 3 2 0.170 1 0.325
0.125
0.205 0.340 0.205
0.75 0.75
Section at Midspan Section at Support
0.25 14.644
Y
4.50
1 2 X 0.17
0.17
0.15 14.894
0.15
0.30 4
0.350 3
0.400 Z
2
0.400
1 0.170
0.125
0.33 0.25 3.000 4.50 3.00 4.144
.
Cable profile in Elevation
o
Vertical bending of Cable 1 =Tan-1{(0.325-0.125)/(0.25+3-0.15)} = 3.691
o
Vertical bending of Cable 2 =Tan-1{(0.325+0.4-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5-0.15)} = 4.514
o
Vertical bending of Cable 3 =Tan-1{(0.325+0.4+0.4-0.125-0.17-)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 5.389
o
Vertical bending of Cable 4 =Tan-1{(0.325+0.4+0.4+0.35-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 6.352
Radius for 1 to 3 = 20 m
Horizontal bending of Cable 1 2.781 o
Horizontal bending of Cable 2 2.781 o
Position of Cable
Cable Anchorage Location of vertical Bending
No. X Y Z X Y Z
1 0.000 0.000 0.325 3.100 0.000 0.125
2 0.000 0.000 0.725 7.600 -0.170 0.125
3 0.000 0.000 1.13 10.600 0.000 0.125
4 0.000 0.000 1.48 10.600 0.000 0.295
38 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 1 19 T13
Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ) Force after
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss
slip loss (kN)
(kN)
1 2732.90 2447.39
1-2 3.106 0.00 0.000 1.0062
2 2715.98 2464.32
2-3 4.503 4.622 0.081 1.0230
3 2654.97 2525.33
3-4 7.144 2.781 0.049 1.0228
4 2595.80 2584.50
Cable 2 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2440.75
1-2 3.110 0.00 0.000 1.0062
2 2715.96 2457.70
2-3 4.517 5.302 0.093 1.0251
3 2649.53 2524.13
3-4 7.144 2.781 0.049 1.0228
4 2590.48 2590.48
3.110 4.517 7.144
2732.90 2715.96
1 2 2649.53 2590.48
= 3
= 2583.18 4
2457.70 2524.13
2440.75 7.144
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2583.18 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 3 = 7.144 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.32 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.32 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.000 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = 29.542 m
Extension of cable = 113.38 mm
39 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 3 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2492.74
1-2 10.647 0.00 0.000 1.0215
2 2675.33 2550.32
2-3 4.144 5.389 0.094 1.0246
3 2611.15 2611.15
10.647 4.144
2732.90 2675.33
1 2 2611.15
= 3
= 2612.82
2550.32 4.036
2492.74
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2612.821 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 1 = 4.036 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.324 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.324 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.00 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = (10.647+4.144)x2 = 29.582 m
Extension of cable at each side = 114.58 mm
Cable 4 6 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 863.02 786.64
1-2 10.665 0.00 0.000 1.0216
2 844.81 804.85
2-3 4.144 6.352 0.111 1.0275
3 822.19 822.19
10.665 4.144
863.02 844.81
1 2 822.19
= 3
= 824.83
804.85 3.661
786.64 Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 824.8294 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 1 = 3.661 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 693.576 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 693.576 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 693.58-693.58 = 0.00 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = (10.665+4.144)x2 = 29.619 m
Extension of cable at each side = 114.67 mm
4.2.2 Summary of Cable Forces after Friction & Slip at different Points
Position Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Cable No 0.500 3.661 7.322 10.983 14.644
Cable 1 2450.12 2467.34 2521.43 2553.27 2584.50
Vert. angle 3.691 3.691 3.691 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 0.000 0.000
C.G. 0.293 0.125 0.125 0.125 0.125
Cable 2 2443.48 2460.70 2519.65 2555.30 2590.48
Vert. angle 4.514 4.514 4.514 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 2.781 0.000
C. G. 0.686 0.436 0.147 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Normal 4880.93 4915.29 5022.11 5105.56 5174.98
at first stage
CG of Cable 0.489 0.280 0.136 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Per.
350.05 352.52 360.21 0.00 0.00
Cable 3 2495.44 2512.54 2532.33 2552.13 2611.15
Vert. angle 5.389 5.389 5.389 5.389 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
C. G. 1.078 0.780 0.434 0.125 0.125
Cable 4 787.49 792.89 799.14 822.19 822.19
Vert. angle 6.352 6.352 6.352 6.352 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
C. G. 1.419 1.067 0.660 0.295 0.295
Total cable
forces Normal 3267.07 3289.45 3315.37 3358.00 3433.35
CG of Cable 1.160 0.849 0.488 0.166 0.166
Total cable
321.50 323.71 326.26 330.67 0.00
forces CG
Overall Per.of
Cable 0.758 0.508 0.276 0.141 0.141
% loss 9.8 % 9.1 % 7.6 % 6.4 % 5.0 %
40 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
41 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
4.3.1.2 Loss due to Relaxation of Steel (clause no. 6.3.6 of IRC 112-2011)
Total Relaxation Loss at service condition = 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Initial force after Friction, slip & ES loss (4770+2x(4804+4911+4994)+5064)/8 = 4906.50 kN
Percentage of Initial force = 0.703 UTS
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel = 2.56 % of initial force
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel 4906.5/2x2.56/100 = 62.74 kN/Cable
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing as per Table 6.2 of IRC 112-2011, = 37 % of Total Loss
5 - 28 days Loss 23 days 552 = 42.00 % of Total Loss
28 - 60 days Loss 32 days 768 = 21.00 % of Total Loss
60 - 90 days Loss 30 days = 0.00 % of Total Loss
90 - α days Loss = 200.0 % of Total Loss
i.e. 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing = 23.21 kN/Cable
5 - 28 days Loss = 26.35 kN/Cable
28 - 60 days Loss = 13.18 kN/Cable
60 - 90 days Loss = 0.00 kN/Cable
90-α days Loss = 125.49 kN/Cable
Total = 188.23 kN/Cable
188.228 6.89 %
42 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
43 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
4.3.3. Sustained Stress of precast girder at 60 days after Casting of Deck with X-Girder
Losses for first 3 cables:- Losses for last 1 cable:-
Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 13.18 kN/Cable Relaxation = 39.53 kN/Cable
Creep = 41.27 kN/Cable Creep = 41.27 kN/Cable
Total = 70.47 kN/Cable Total = 96.82 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 70.47 kN/Cable actual time dependent losses = 96.82 kN/Cable
Total Loss of 4 Cables = 268.33 kN Actual Loss of third Cables = 127.40 kN
Depth of Precast Girder = 1.775 m
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 0.928 m Area = 1.444 m
4 4
I= 0.354 m I= 0.412 m
CG = 0.962 m CG = 0.948 m
+ + =
< 20.00
Mpa
19.12 Mpa -0.89 Mpa -7.80 Mpa 10.44 Mpa Hence O.K.
Resultant Stress at 28 Stress due to loss between 28 Stress due to DL of Slab & Resultant Stress at 60
days to 60 days wt of shuttering days
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Precast Girder at 60 days of Casting of Girder
44 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 1.603 m Area = 2.119 m
4 4
I= 0.692 m I= 0.821 m
CG = 1.352 m CG = 1.247 m
Losses:- Shrinkage = 11.19 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 0.00 kN/Cable
Creep = 16.37 kN/Cable
Total = 27.56 kN/Cable
Total Loss = 91.39 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 91.39 kN
Total Stress
Stress due Loss of CG of Cables Stress due Moment due due to Total Stress at
Section
at 60 days Cables from soffit to loss to SIDL SIDL Stress cable CG
(Mpa) (kN) (m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab 0.00 0.00 -0.58 -0.59
Top of girder 2.46 -0.01 -637.43 -0.41 2.03
End -91.39 0.758 5.87
Bottom 7.87 -0.11 0.97 8.72
Top of slab 0.00 0.02 -0.04 -0.02
Top of girder 5.97 -0.01 -39.35 -0.02 5.93
L/8 -91.39 0.508 8.74
Bottom 9.99 -0.21 0.08 9.86
Top of slab 0.00 0.04 0.19 0.22
Top of girder 5.83 0.00 199.06 0.12 5.95
L/4 -91.39 0.276 9.23
Bottom 10.47 -0.25 -0.39 9.83
Top of slab 0.00 0.05 0.25 0.29
Top of girder 5.68 0.01 262.55 0.16 5.85
3L/8 -91.39 0.141 9.81
Bottom 10.94 -0.27 -0.51 10.16
Top of slab 0.00 0.05 0.23 0.27
Top of girder 6.40 0.01 242.86 0.15 6.56
L/2 -91.39 0.141 9.44
Bottom 10.44 -0.27 -0.47 9.69
Average stress at 90 days = (5.87+2x(8.74+9.23+9.81)+9.44)/8 = 8.86 Mpa
0.00 Mpa 0.05 0.23 Mpa 0.27 Mpa
6.40 0.01 Mpa 0.15 6.56 Mpa
Mpa Mpa
+ + =
45 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
+ =
Total Stress
Section Total Stress Stress due Stress due to at α days
without live Total Live Load 0.6 x Wind load to Live Load wind Load with live load
load (Mpa) Moment(kN-m) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -1.68 -1.20 -0.13 -3.01
Top of girder 1.09 -1305.46 -146.17 -0.84 -0.09 0.16
End
Bottom 8.96 1.98 0.22 11.17
Top of slab -0.91 -0.02 -0.01 -0.94
Top of girder 5.18 -22.98 -10.29 -0.01 -0.01 5.16
L/8
Bottom 10.13 0.04 0.02 10.20
Top of slab -0.42 0.39 0.05 0.02
Top of girder 5.37 417.84 54.14 0.26 0.03 5.66
L/4
Bottom 9.70 -0.82 -0.11 8.78
Top of slab -0.21 1.08 0.09 0.95
Top of girder 5.37 1148.31 91.03 0.70 0.06 6.12
3L/8
Bottom 9.80 -2.24 -0.18 7.37
Top of slab -0.22 1.34 0.09 1.21
Top of girder 6.07 1427.10 100.27 0.87 0.06 7.01
L/2
Bottom 9.32 -2.79 -0.20 6.34
46 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Composite Girder with SIDL & Live Load at α days
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 7.0 Mpa
Permissible Tensile stress in concrete at service = -1.41 Mpa > -3.0 Mpa
Tension reinforcement at top of support are provided
4.3.7 Summary of Stresses for Precast girder only
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder
Precast Girder Midspan Support Composite Girder Midspan Support
Area = 0.928 1.444 m2 Area = 1.603 2.119 m2
I= 0.354 0.412 m4 I= 0.692 0.821 m4
CG = 0.962 0.948 m CG = 1.352 1.247 m
Z Top of slab = 1.067 1.091 3
m
Z Top = 0.436 0.499 m3 Z Top = 1.635 1.556 m3
Zbottom = 0.368 0.435 m3 Zbottom = 0.512 0.658 m3
DL Moment
Moment due to
Stress Prestressing force & Loss
Section earth pr. Diff Prestress CG of cables Loss of pre. Loss of Axial Force Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa)
settle, creep, (kN) (m) Girder (kN) comp. girder & Moment (Mpa)
Top of slab snow (kN-m) -1.12 F=133.04 -1.10
Top of girder -0.79 1.30
End -1.73 -1224.1 8148.00 0.758 -691.23 -1609.71 -1096.24
Bottom 1.86 8.07
Top of slab 0.49 F=137.97 -0.85
Top of girder 5.08 -0.66
L/8 2075.43 518.8 8204.74 0.508 -691.23 -1609.71 -1097.48
Bottom -6.65 15.77
Top of slab -0.98 F=137.23 -0.49
Top of girder 7.47 -4.49
L/4 3535.95 -1046.7 8337.49 0.276 -691.23 -1609.71 -1096.29
Bottom -7.56 20.16
Top of slab -0.56 F=136.12 -0.29
Top of girder 9.79 -6.82
3L/8 4425.99 -592.7 8463.56 0.141 -691.23 -1609.71 -1094.52
Bottom -10.86 22.95
Top of slab -0.27 F=131.62 -0.28
Top of girder 10.72 -6.94
L/2 4745.56 -284.6 8608.32 0.141 -691.23 -1609.71 -1091.95
Bottom -12.33 23.43
Section SIDL Live load Wind load - loaded structure Temp (+ve) Temp (-ve)
Moment Stress Moment (kN- Stress Moment Stress Stress Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa) m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -1.03 -1.20 -0.13 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder -0.72 -0.84 -0.09 -1.10 0.90
End -1122.57 -1305.46 -146.17
Bottom 1.70 1.98 0.22 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab -0.10 -0.02 -0.01 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder -0.06 -0.01 -0.01 -1.10 0.90
L/8 -102.56 -22.98 -10.29
Bottom 0.20 0.04 0.02 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.32 0.39 0.05 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.21 0.26 0.03 -1.10 0.90
L/4 340.74 417.84 54.14
Bottom -0.67 -0.82 -0.11 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.49 1.08 0.09 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.32 0.70 0.06 -1.10 0.90
3L/8 527.96 1148.31 91.03
Bottom -1.03 -2.24 -0.18 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.52 1.34 0.09 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.34 0.87 0.06 -1.10 0.90
L/2 550.69 1427.10 100.27
Bottom -1.08 -2.79 -0.20 1.67 -2.39
47 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 1 1 0.75 0.75 1
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 1 1
Temp (+ve) 0.6
Temp (-ve)
48 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 5 (b) 5 (c ) 5 (d) 6 (a) 6 (b) 6 (c) 6 (c) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.75 -6.05 -5.84 0.07 0.27 -6.75 -6.54 0.27 -6.75
Top of girder -1.84 -0.79 -0.64 -2.22 -2.07 -0.22 -0.08 -0.08 -2.22
End
Bottom 13.82 11.72 11.38 14.33 13.99 10.27 9.93 14.33 9.93
Top of slab 2.20 -1.91 -1.89 3.91 3.93 -2.91 -2.89 3.93 -2.91
Top of girder 3.75 4.94 4.95 3.30 3.31 5.30 5.31 5.31 3.30
L/8
Bottom 8.79 6.39 6.35 9.48 9.44 5.42 5.38 9.48 5.38
Top of slab 1.87 -2.15 -2.21 3.57 3.50 -3.25 -3.31 3.57 -3.31
Top of girder 3.23 4.47 4.43 2.77 2.73 4.77 4.73 4.77 2.73
L/4
Bottom 10.10 7.54 7.67 10.84 10.97 6.78 6.92 10.97 6.78
Top of slab 3.34 -0.65 -0.74 4.90 4.80 -1.91 -2.01 4.90 -2.01
Top of girder 4.02 5.28 5.22 3.47 3.40 5.46 5.40 5.46 3.40
3L/8
Bottom 7.51 4.87 5.08 8.54 8.74 4.48 4.68 8.76 4.48
Top of slab 3.92 -0.07 -0.17 5.42 5.31 -1.40 -1.50 5.42 -1.50
Top of girder 5.02 6.29 6.22 4.43 4.36 6.43 6.36 6.43 4.36
L/2
Bottom 5.89 3.24 3.45 7.04 7.25 2.98 3.19 7.67 2.98
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -3.57 -3.37 -3.65 -3.45 -4.85 -4.64 -4.60 -4.40 -2.18
Top of girder -0.23 -0.09 -0.29 -0.14 -1.12 -0.98 -0.95 -0.81 -1.73
End
Bottom 12.79 12.45 12.92 12.58 14.90 14.56 14.50 14.16 15.77
Top of slab -0.56 -0.54 -0.57 -0.55 -0.59 -0.57 -0.59 -0.57 2.01
Top of girder 4.28 4.29 4.28 4.29 4.26 4.27 4.26 4.28 3.61
L/8
Bottom 10.93 10.89 10.94 10.90 10.99 10.95 10.99 10.95 11.98
Top of slab -1.14 -1.21 -1.11 -1.18 -0.72 -0.78 -0.80 -0.86 1.84
Top of girder 2.78 2.74 2.80 2.76 3.06 3.01 3.01 2.96 2.38
L/4
Bottom 13.82 13.95 13.75 13.89 12.94 13.07 13.10 13.23 14.00
Top of slab -0.28 -0.38 -0.23 -0.33 0.85 0.75 0.61 0.51 3.39
Top of girder 2.67 2.61 2.71 2.64 3.41 3.35 3.26 3.19 2.72
3L/8
Bottom 13.14 13.35 13.03 13.24 10.79 10.99 11.28 11.48 11.90
Top of slab 0.04 -0.06 0.10 -0.01 1.43 1.33 1.14 1.03 3.97
Top of girder 3.49 3.42 3.52 3.45 4.40 4.33 4.20 4.13 3.70
L/2
Bottom 12.14 12.36 12.03 12.24 9.24 9.45 9.86 10.07 10.36
49 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.97 -6.27 -6.06 -0.15 0.05 -6.97 -6.76 0.05 -6.97
Top of girder -1.58 -0.53 -0.38 -1.96 -1.81 0.04 0.18 0.18 -1.96
End
Bottom 15.43 13.34 13.00 15.94 15.60 11.89 11.54 15.94 11.54
Top of slab 2.03 -2.08 -2.06 3.74 3.76 -3.08 -3.06 3.76 -3.08
Top of girder 3.62 4.80 4.82 3.17 3.18 5.17 5.18 5.18 3.17
L/8
Bottom 11.94 9.54 9.50 12.63 12.59 8.58 8.54 12.63 8.54
Top of slab 1.78 -2.25 -2.31 3.47 3.40 -3.35 -3.41 3.47 -3.41
Top of girder 2.33 3.58 3.53 1.87 1.83 3.87 3.83 3.87 1.83
L/4
Bottom 14.13 11.57 11.70 14.87 15.01 10.82 10.95 15.01 10.82
Top of slab 3.29 -0.70 -0.80 4.84 4.74 -1.97 -2.07 4.84 -2.07
Top of girder 2.65 3.92 3.85 2.10 2.04 4.10 4.03 4.10 2.04
3L/8
Bottom 12.10 9.46 9.67 13.12 13.33 9.07 9.27 13.35 9.07
Top of slab 3.86 -0.12 -0.23 5.36 5.26 -1.46 -1.56 5.36 -1.56
Top of girder 3.63 4.90 4.83 3.04 2.97 5.04 4.97 5.04 2.97
L/2
Bottom 10.57 7.92 8.14 11.72 11.94 7.66 7.88 12.36 7.66
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 15.9 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = -2.12 Mpa < 2.98 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= -2.12 Mpa < 1.83 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
4.3.9 Load Combination for frequent Combination (SL2) - for prestressing member
1) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress
2) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+ wind load(lead) (unloaded structure)
3) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+wind load (accompany)
4) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+wind load (lead)
5) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+Temperature(accompany)
6) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+Temperature(lead)
a) Load combination
Load Case 1 (a) 1 (b) 2 (a) 2 (b) 3 (a) 3 (b) 4 (a) 4 (b) 5 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
50 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -3.57 -3.37 -3.65 -3.45 -4.54 -4.33 -3.89 -3.69 -2.31
Top of girder -0.23 -0.09 -0.29 -0.14 -0.91 -0.76 -0.45 -0.31 -1.41
End
Bottom 12.79 12.45 12.92 12.58 14.39 14.04 13.32 12.98 15.11
Top of slab -0.56 -0.54 -0.57 -0.55 -0.58 -0.56 -0.57 -0.55 1.58
Top of girder 4.28 4.29 4.28 4.29 4.27 4.28 4.27 4.29 3.72
L/8
Bottom 10.93 10.89 10.94 10.90 10.98 10.94 10.95 10.91 11.80
Top of slab -1.14 -1.21 -1.11 -1.18 -0.82 -0.89 -1.03 -1.10 1.31
Top of girder 2.78 2.74 2.80 2.76 2.99 2.95 2.85 2.81 2.42
L/4
Bottom 13.82 13.95 13.75 13.89 13.15 13.28 13.59 13.72 14.04
Top of slab -0.28 -0.38 -0.23 -0.33 0.57 0.47 -0.01 -0.11 2.69
Top of girder 2.67 2.61 2.71 2.64 3.23 3.16 2.85 2.78 2.65
3L/8
Bottom 13.14 13.35 13.03 13.24 11.37 11.57 12.58 12.79 12.29
Top of slab 0.04 -0.06 0.10 -0.01 1.09 0.99 0.36 0.26 3.20
Top of girder 3.49 3.42 3.52 3.45 4.17 4.10 3.70 3.63 3.59
L/2
Bottom 12.14 12.36 12.03 12.24 9.95 10.17 11.47 11.68 10.89
51 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -2.11 -5.72 -5.51 -1.22 -1.02 -5.31 -5.11 -1.02 -5.72
Top of girder -1.26 -0.41 -0.27 -1.06 -0.91 0.14 0.29 0.29 -1.41
End
Bottom 14.77 13.08 12.74 14.18 13.84 11.75 11.41 15.11 11.41
Top of slab 1.60 -1.83 -1.81 2.03 2.04 -2.06 -2.04 2.04 -2.06
Top of girder 3.73 4.72 4.73 3.62 3.63 4.82 4.83 4.83 3.62
L/8
Bottom 11.76 9.77 9.73 11.94 11.90 9.51 9.47 11.94 9.47
Top of slab 1.25 -2.10 -2.16 1.53 1.46 -2.56 -2.63 1.53 -2.63
Top of girder 2.38 3.42 3.38 2.17 2.13 3.37 3.33 3.42 2.13
L/4
Bottom 14.17 12.01 12.14 14.65 14.79 12.22 12.35 14.79 12.01
Top of slab 2.59 -0.72 -0.82 2.52 2.43 -1.56 -1.66 2.69 -1.66
Top of girder 2.59 3.65 3.59 2.16 2.09 3.35 3.29 3.65 2.09
3L/8
Bottom 12.50 10.26 10.47 13.69 13.90 11.26 11.46 13.90 10.26
Top of slab 3.10 -0.21 -0.31 2.90 2.79 -1.19 -1.29 3.20 -1.29
Top of girder 3.52 4.59 4.52 3.00 2.93 4.20 4.13 4.59 2.93
L/2
Bottom 11.10 8.86 9.07 12.59 12.80 10.15 10.37 12.80 8.86
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 15.1 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = 0.00 Mpa < 4.17 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= 0.00 Mpa < 2.09 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
4.4 Check for ultimate strength of girder in Flexure :-
Grade of concrete = M40 Modulus of elasticity of concrete E = 33346 MPa
Design yield strength fpd = 17.87 MPa Modulus of elasticity of steel = 195.00 Gpa
3000 0.00350 17.87
225 8754 kN
202.64
NA NA
2000 300
52 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
NA NA
2000
187.09
8022 kN
0.00350 17.87
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
750
Grade Concrete = M40 Grade of steel = Fe 500
Width of the section = 3000 mm Depth of the section = 2000 mm
Clear Cover = 40 mm Main dia of bar used = 25 mm
Dia of shear reinf. = 16 mm Effective depth, d = 1819 mm
R = Mu/bd2 = 0.779 MPa Negative Design Moment = 7737 kN-m
Mu,Lim/bd2 = 0.133xfck = 5.32 MPa Ast = 10007.9 mm2
Lower fractile tensile fctm = 2.12 MPa Where, pt = fck/(2*fy)*(1-sqrt(1-(4.598*R/fck))*100
Min. reinforcement 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 7094.1 mm2
Hence provide 25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf. Ast = 18451.6 mm2
25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf.
16 dia @ 113 c/c Slab Bottom reinf.
Bottom reinf. 14 Nos. 20 dia (50% of main reinforcement)
E of reinforcement = 200000 MPa Max strain in concrete = 0.0035
E of concrete = 33346 MPa Min strain in steel = 0.0042
Balanced neutral axis depth = 829.51 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 187.09 mm
Strain in steel = 0.0305 Stress in steel = 434.8 MPa
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 8022 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 8022 kN
Compressive force CG 77.83 mm Moment of resistance = 13968 kNm
> 7737 kNm Hence O.K.
Factor of safety = 13,968/7,737 = 1.81
53 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
vi) As per clause no 6.3.2 of IS-13920 :1993, Shear force due to ductile detailing shall be
Vua = Va D+L - 1.4(MuAh+MuBs)/L
D+L
Va = 1.2(D+L)/2 = 1470.13 kN
MuAh = -7736.86 kN
MuBs = -4230.85 kN
L = 27.79 m
Vua = 2073 kN
Maximum design shear at support > 2056 kN
54 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
ii) Shear Capacity of Uncracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
The shear resistance of the beam section uncracked in flexure is given below:-
VRd,c = ( I * bwc )/ S x √ (fctd2 + k1 σcp fctd)
Where, I = Moment of inertia bwc= Width of beam after deduction due to duct
S = First moment of area between cetroidal axis and extreme compression fibre about the centrodial axis.
fctd = design tensile strength of concrete = fctk/γm = 1.41 Mpa
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Prestress Force after all losses (kN) 5928.0 5984.8 6117.5 6243.6 6388.3
Effective width of the Web 750 300 300 300 300
Effective Depth of the Section (d) 1242 1492 1724 1859 1859
Stress due to Prestress (σcp) 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573
Design tensile strength of the Concrete (fctd) 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41
First moment of inertia about the CG (S) 2.45E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09
Transmission length factor, k1 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Moment of Inertia (I) (mm4) 8.2E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11
Design Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 666.7 315.7 315.7 315.7 315.7
iii) Summary of the Shear resistance of the Beam when shear reinforcement isn't required :
The maximum shear capacity of the Beam as cl.10.3.2 (5) of IRC 112-2010
VEd ≤ 0.50 bw d ν fcd where, ν = 0.60 [ 1 - fck/310]
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Distance from bearing in m 0.00 3.66 7.32 10.98 14.64
Distance modification factor β for Precast Beam 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Distance modification factor β for Composite 0.25 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Effective Shear for Precast Beam 2073.1 1596.1 1151.4 661.4 220.9
Effective Shear for Composite Section (kN) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective Shear due to prestressing force (kN) 493.8 498.5 509.2 260.5 0.0
Total Shear force for the Beam (kN) 1579.3 1097.7 642.2 400.9 220.9
Precast member Area (m2) 1.44 0.93 0.93 0.93 0.93
Zb (m3) 0.44 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.37
Composite member Area (m2) 2.12 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60
Zb (m3) 0.66 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51
Stress due to prestress at tensile fibre σ bpt (MPa) 2.4368 0.2627 -4.0436 -6.6401 -6.7608
Section at Maximum Bending Moment Uncracked Uncracked Cracked Cracked Cracked
Shear capacity of Beam Section (kN) 666.69 315.69 434.58 466.16 466.21
Maximum shear capacity of the Section (kN) 4349 2089 2414 2603 2603
Not Not
Whether shear reinforcement required or not Required Required Required
Required Required
55 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
56 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
57 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
A -0.00018
B 4 3.661 1.831 -0.00020 -0.00019 -0.001260275
C 3 3.661 5.492 -0.00020 -0.00020 -0.003999766
D 2 3.661 9.153 -0.00016 -0.00018 -0.006083804
E 1 3.661 12.814 -0.00015 -0.00016 -0.007481129
Total -0.018824974
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress + wt of precast Girder = = -19 mm
= - L/ 1556
58 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
(iii) Precast Girder - Prestress + wt of precast Girder +wt of deck slab at 60 days
Section At support Near L/8 At L/4 At 3L/8 At L/2
Distance 0.000 3.661 7.322 10.983 14.644
CG of all cables from bot.(m) 0.758 0.508 0.276 0.141 0.141
Loss 268.332 268.332 268.332 268.332 268.332
Moment due to prestressing losses 51.080 121.841 184.069 220.216 220.275
Moment due to Wt of Deck Slab -0.606 926.647 1594.204 2002.066 2150.233
Total moment due to prestress+DL 50.474 1048.488 1778.273 2222.282 2370.508
M/EI (1/m) 0.0000037 0.0000888 0.0001506 0.0001881 0.00020
3.7 3.661 3.661 3.661
A B C D E
0.000004 0.0000888 0.0001881
4 0.0001506 0.0002007
3 1
2
M/EI Diagram for Ist Stage Prestress after losses at 60 days
At Midspan
Average
Section Marked Distance CG from A M/EI Moment of M/EI about A Rotation
M/EI
A 0.0000037
B 4 3.661 1.831 0.0000888 0.0000462 0.000309733 0.00194
C 3 3.661 5.492 0.0001506 0.0001197 0.002405702
D 2 3.661 9.153 0.0001881 0.0001693 0.005674422
E 1 3.661 12.814 0.0002007 0.0001944 0.009120236
Total 0.017510093
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress losses + DL = = 17.510 mm
Total Deflection at 60 days =-33.152+17.510 = -15.641 mm
59 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
58 1 SPECTRUM IN X8.303
DIRECTION 0.068 0.529 8.32 0 0 0
2 SPECTRUM IN Z0.498
DIRECTION 0.683 1.584 1.796 0 0 0
3 SPECTRUM IN Y0.003
DIRECTION 0.284 0.019 0.285 0 0 0
4 DEAD LOAD 0.027 -1.692 0.002 1.692 0 0 0
5 SIDL (DL) 0 -1.298 0.01 1.298 0 0 0
6 SIDL(WC) -0.001 -0.544 0.001 0.544 0 0 0
7 REMOVAL OF SHUTTER
0.001 0.929 -0.011 0.929 0 0 0
8 EARTH PR ON ABUTMENT
1.458 2.634 0.224 3.019 0 0 0
9 LIVE LOAD SURCHARGE
2.304 0.176 0.147 2.315 0 0 0
10 DYNAMIC INCREMENT
1.159 OF EARTH
1.628 PR. 0.154 2.005 0 0 0
11 DYNAMIC INCREMENT
1.452 OF LL 0.11
SURCGARGE 0.093 1.459 0 0 0
12 UNLADEN WIND 0.101
LOAD -0.973 -0.166 0.992 0 0 0
13 LADEN WIND LOAD
0.093 -0.502 -0.151 0.532 0 0 0
14 DIFFERNTIAL SETTLEMENT
-2.551 -6.291 -0.134 6.79 0 0 0
15 TEMPERATURE -0.033
RISE 0.458 -0.189 0.496 0 0 0
16 TEMPERATURE0.016
FALL -0.267 0.095 0.283 0 0 0
17 CREEP SHRINKAGE
-0.037 DIFF SHRINKAGE
1.651 -0.239 1.669 0 0 0
18 FOOTPATH LIVE0.001
LOAD -0.587 0.007 0.587 0 0 0
19 SNOW LOAD FOR
-0.002
70R LL TRACK
-0.999 0.004 0.999 0 0 0
20 SNOW LOAD FOR
-0.001
LL 70R WHEEL
-0.57 0.003 0.57 0 0 0
21 BRAKING 0.604 0 0.03 0.604 0 0 0
504 COMBINATION0.001
LOAD CASE-1.263
504 0.02 1.263 0 0 0
60 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
61 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.475 0.2
0.1 0.053
0.2
0.25
0.225 0.225
0.75 2.250 0.75
Part of intermediate cross girder {1.25x(1.775-0.25)-(0.93-0.75x0.25)}x0.3x25 = 8.75 kN
= 8.75 kN
36.11 36.11
23.19
0.250 1.75 1.75 21.80 1.75 1.75 0.250
5.1.3 Dead Load Moment & Shear for Deck slab & X-girder
Unit weight of concrete = 25.000 kN/m3
Thickness of deck slab = 0.225 m2
Average width of deck slab at support = 3.000 m
Wt of Inner X-girder (1.75/2x(1.775-0.25))x0.3x25 = 10.008 kN
= 10.008
62 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
16.875
63 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
64 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
65 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
66 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
67 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
5.1.5 Summary of Bending Moment & Shear Force for outer girder
a) Bending Moment (kNm) 68 73 76 80 85 Staad Member no
Description At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Distance (m) 0.000 3.600 7.199 10.799 14.398
Precast girder only -1.1 1112.3 1879.1 2345.5 2511.4
Construction load -0.2 294.6 505.1 631.4 673.5
Deck slab & X-girder -0.5 782.7 1347.3 1693.3 1820.6
Total wt of deck slab = -1.7 1895.0 3226.4 4038.8 4332.1
SIDL (DL) from staad output -242.8 103.3 34.4 205.1 402.0
SIDL (WC) from staad output -352.2 49.8 103.2 185.8 202.5
Removal of shutter 457.9 -78.6 -126.3 -251.3 -296.3
Earth pressure -248.4 -333.5 -384.9 -453.5 -540.7
Live load surcharge 442.0 300.8 -218.0 -107.6 60.5
Wind load (unloaded structure) -465.8 -67.8 216.4 269.3 336.7
Wind load (loaded structure) -231.5 -28.1 80.9 146.3 168.1
Differential settlement 812.0 574.5 -435.2 -249.6 33.6
Temperature rise -100.4 -96.4 -94.4 -92.1 -89.4
Temperature fall 57.2 55.2 54.2 53.1 52.1
Creep & shrinkage 338.0 330.7 -327.5 -324.1 -322.5
Footpath live load 106.8 45.0 13.9 83.5 160.5
Snow load -520.0 -87.9 144.9 285.9 333.9
Braking load -149.5 -105.3 -79.4 -44.8 7.8
Live Load -1824.4 68.6 1020.0 1122.4 896.3
Seismic in X- direction -1939.7 -1388.3 -1055.4 -602.0 -111.4
Seismic in Z- direction -190.1 -98.6 -68.6 -87.5 -112.6
Seismic in Y- direction -136.9 -35.9 -49.5 -92.1 -119.9
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. -111.0 -176.7 -216.4 -269.3 -336.7
Dynamic increment of LL Surcharge 278.7 189.7 -137.5 -67.9 38.1
Hyperstatic action At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Axial compresion 157.085 169.875 173.642 176.66 178.329
Moment -1116.6 -1124.1 -1128.0 -1133.1 -1138.2
The hyperstatic action is only considered for calculation of negative moment at support.
68 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
69 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
70 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.300
4
0.350
X X X 3
1.775 0.400
2
4 0.400
1 3 2 0.170 1 0.325
0.125
0.205 0.340 0.205
0.75 0.75
Section at Midspan Section at Support
0.25 14.398
Y
4.50
1 2 X 0.17
0.17
0.15 14.648
0.15
0.30 4
0.350 3
0.400 Z
2
0.400
1 0.170
0.125
0.33 0.25 3.000 4.50 3.00 3.898
.
Cable profile in Elevation
o
Vertical bending of Cable 1 =Tan-1{(0.325-0.125)/(0.25+3-0.15)} = 3.691
o
Vertical bending of Cable 2 =Tan-1{(0.325+0.4-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5-0.15)} = 4.514
o
Vertical bending of Cable 3 =Tan-1{(0.325+0.4+0.4-0.125-0.17-)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 5.389
o
Vertical bending of Cable 4 =Tan-1{(0.325+0.4+0.4+0.35-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 6.352
Radius for 1 to 3 = 20 m
Horizontal bending of Cable 1 2.781 o
Horizontal bending of Cable 2 2.781 o
Position of Cable
Cable Anchorage Location of vertical Bending
No. X Y Z X Y Z
1 0.000 0.000 0.325 3.100 0.000 0.125
2 0.000 0.000 0.725 7.600 -0.170 0.125
3 0.000 0.000 1.13 10.600 0.000 0.125
4 0.000 0.000 1.48 10.600 0.000 0.295
71 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 1 19 T13
Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ) Force after
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss
slip loss (kN)
(kN)
1 2732.90 2446.81
1-2 3.106 0.00 0.000 1.0062
2 2715.98 2463.73
2-3 4.503 4.622 0.081 1.0230
3 2654.97 2524.74
3-4 6.898 2.781 0.049 1.0223
4 2597.08 2582.63
Cable 2 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2440.23
1-2 3.110 0.00 0.000 1.0062
2 2715.96 2457.18
2-3 4.517 5.302 0.093 1.0251
3 2649.53 2523.61
3-4 6.898 2.781 0.049 1.0223
4 2591.75 2591.75
3.110 4.517 6.898
2732.90 2715.96
1 2 2649.53 2591.75
= 3
= 2581.39 4
2457.18 2523.61
2440.23 6.898
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2581.39 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 3 = 6.898 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.32 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.32 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.000 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = 29.050 m
Extension of cable = 111.63 mm
72 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 3 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2492.04
1-2 10.647 0.00 0.000 1.0215
2 2675.33 2549.62
2-3 3.898 5.389 0.094 1.0241
3 2612.44 2612.44
10.647 3.898
2732.90 2675.33
1 2 2612.44
= 3
= 2612.47
2549.62 3.896
2492.04
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2612.472 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 1 = 3.896 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.324 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.324 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.00 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = (10.647+3.898)x2 = 29.090 m
Extension of cable at each side = 112.81 mm
Cable 4 6 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 863.02 786.42
1-2 10.665 0.00 0.000 1.0216
2 844.81 804.63
2-3 3.898 6.352 0.111 1.0270
3 822.60 822.60
10.665 3.898
863.02 844.81
1 2 822.60
= 3
= 824.72
804.63 3.525
786.42 Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 824.7205 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 1 = 3.525 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 693.576 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 693.576 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 693.58-693.58 = 0.00 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = (10.665+3.898)x2 = 29.127 m
Extension of cable at each side = 112.90 mm
5.2.2 Summary of Cable Forces after Friction & Slip at different Points
Position Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Cable No 0.500 3.600 7.199 10.799 14.398
Cable 1 2449.53 2466.42 2519.18 2551.50 2582.63
Vert. angle 3.691 3.691 3.691 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 0.000 0.000
C.G. 0.293 0.125 0.125 0.125 0.125
Cable 2 2442.96 2459.85 2517.32 2554.94 2591.75
Vert. angle 4.514 4.514 4.514 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 2.781 0.000
C. G. 0.686 0.441 0.157 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Normal 4879.83 4913.52 5017.55 5103.44 5174.39
at first stage
CG of Cable 0.489 0.283 0.141 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Per.
349.97 352.39 359.89 0.00 0.00
Cable 3 2494.74 2511.51 2530.97 2550.44 2612.44
Vert. angle 5.389 5.389 5.389 5.389 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
C. G. 1.078 0.785 0.446 0.125 0.125
Cable 4 787.27 792.57 798.71 822.60 822.60
Vert. angle 6.352 6.352 6.352 6.352 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
C. G. 1.419 1.074 0.674 0.295 0.295
Total cable
forces Normal 3266.16 3288.10 3313.59 3356.71 3435.04
CG of Cable 1.160 0.855 0.500 0.166 0.166
Total cable
321.41 323.57 326.08 330.55 0.00
forces CG
Overall Per.of
Cable 0.758 0.512 0.284 0.141 0.141
% loss 9.8 % 9.2 % 7.7 % 6.4 % 5.0 %
73 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
74 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
5.3.1.2 Loss due to Relaxation of Steel (clause no. 6.3.6 of IRC 112-2011)
Total Relaxation Loss at service condition = 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Initial force after Friction, slip & ES loss (4768+2x(4801+4905+4991)+5062)/8 = 4903.14 kN
Percentage of Initial force = 0.702 UTS
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel = 2.55 % of initial force
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel 4903.14/2x2.55/100 = 62.46 kN/Cable
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing as per Table 6.2 of IRC 112-2011, = 37 % of Total Loss
5 - 28 days Loss 23 days 552 = 42.00 % of Total Loss
28 - 60 days Loss 32 days 768 = 21.00 % of Total Loss
60 - 90 days Loss 30 days = 0.00 % of Total Loss
90 - α days Loss = 200.0 % of Total Loss
i.e. 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing = 23.11 kN/Cable
5 - 28 days Loss = 26.23 kN/Cable
28 - 60 days Loss = 13.12 kN/Cable
60 - 90 days Loss = 0.00 kN/Cable
90-α days Loss = 124.93 kN/Cable
Total = 187.39 kN/Cable
187.390 6.86 %
75 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
76 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
5.3.3. Sustained Stress of precast girder at 60 days after Casting of Deck with X-Girder
Losses for first 3 cables:- Losses for last 1 cable:-
Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 13.12 kN/Cable Relaxation = 39.35 kN/Cable
Creep = 41.41 kN/Cable Creep = 41.41 kN/Cable
Total = 70.55 kN/Cable Total = 96.79 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 70.55 kN/Cable actual time dependent losses = 96.79 kN/Cable
Total Loss of 4 Cables = 268.45 kN Actual Loss of third Cables = 127.35 kN
Depth of Precast Girder = 1.775 m
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 0.928 m Area = 1.444 m
4 4
I= 0.354 m I= 0.412 m
CG = 0.962 m CG = 0.948 m
+ + =
< 20.00
Mpa
19.35 Mpa -0.89 Mpa -6.77 Mpa 11.69 Mpa Hence O.K.
Resultant Stress at 28 Stress due to loss between 28 Stress due to DL of Slab & Resultant Stress at 60
days to 60 days wt of shuttering days
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Precast Girder at 60 days of Casting of Girder
77 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 1.603 m Area = 2.119 m
4 4
I= 0.692 m I= 0.821 m
CG = 1.352 m CG = 1.247 m
Losses:- Shrinkage = 11.19 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 0.00 kN/Cable
Creep = 17.36 kN/Cable
Total = 28.55 kN/Cable
Total Loss = 94.67 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 94.67 kN
Total Stress
Stress due Loss of CG of Cables Stress due Moment due due to Total Stress at
Section
at 60 days Cables from soffit to loss to SIDL SIDL Stress cable CG
(Mpa) (kN) (m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab 0.00 0.00 -0.13 -0.13
Top of girder 2.46 -0.01 -137.15 -0.09 2.35
End -94.67 0.758 5.56
Bottom 7.86 -0.12 0.21 7.95
Top of slab 0.00 0.02 0.07 0.09
Top of girder 5.57 -0.01 74.43 0.05 5.61
L/8 -94.67 0.512 8.80
Bottom 10.45 -0.21 -0.15 10.09
Top of slab 0.00 0.04 0.01 0.05
Top of girder 5.18 0.00 11.26 0.01 5.19
L/4 -94.67 0.284 10.02
Bottom 11.22 -0.26 -0.02 10.95
Top of slab 0.00 0.05 0.13 0.18
Top of girder 4.70 0.01 139.58 0.09 4.79
3L/8 -94.67 0.141 11.00
Bottom 12.10 -0.28 -0.27 11.54
Top of slab 0.00 0.05 0.29 0.34
Top of girder 5.34 0.01 308.12 0.19 5.54
L/2 -94.67 0.141 10.38
Bottom 11.69 -0.28 -0.60 10.80
Average stress at 90 days = (5.56+2x(8.8+10.02+11)+10.38)/8 = 9.45 Mpa
0.00 Mpa 0.05 0.29 Mpa 0.34 Mpa
5.34 0.01 Mpa 0.19 5.54 Mpa
Mpa Mpa
+ + =
78 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
+ =
Total Stress
Section Total Stress Stress due Stress due to at α days
without live Total Live Load 0.6 x Wind load to Live Load wind Load with live load
load (Mpa) Moment(kN-m) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -1.25 -1.40 -0.13 -2.78
Top of girder 1.38 -1532.02 -138.87 -0.98 -0.09 0.31
End
Bottom 8.18 2.33 0.21 10.72
Top of slab -0.84 0.25 -0.02 -0.61
Top of girder 4.82 264.07 -16.89 0.16 -0.01 4.97
L/8
Bottom 10.35 -0.52 0.03 9.87
Top of slab -0.65 0.68 0.05 0.08
Top of girder 4.56 722.68 48.54 0.44 0.03 5.03
L/4
Bottom 10.82 -1.41 -0.09 9.31
Top of slab -0.37 0.91 0.08 0.62
Top of girder 4.26 969.92 87.78 0.59 0.05 4.91
3L/8
Bottom 11.18 -1.90 -0.17 9.11
Top of slab -0.22 0.85 0.09 0.72
Top of girder 5.01 904.13 100.86 0.55 0.06 5.62
L/2
Bottom 10.44 -1.77 -0.20 8.48
79 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Composite Girder with SIDL & Live Load at α days
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 5.6 Mpa
Permissible Tensile stress in concrete at service = -1.41 Mpa > -2.8 Mpa
Tension reinforcement at top of support are provided
5.3.7 Summary of Stresses for Precast girder only
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder
Precast Girder Midspan Support Composite Girder Midspan Support
Area = 0.928 1.444 m2 Area = 1.603 2.119 m2
I= 0.354 0.412 m4 I= 0.692 0.821 m4
CG = 0.962 0.948 m CG = 1.352 1.247 m
Z Top of slab = 1.067 1.091 3
m
Z Top = 0.436 0.499 m3 Z Top = 1.635 1.556 m3
Zbottom = 0.368 0.435 m3 Zbottom = 0.512 0.658 m3
DL Moment
Moment due to
Stress Prestressing force & Loss
Section earth pr. Diff Prestress CG of cables Loss of pre. Loss of Moment due Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa)
settle, creep, (kN) (m) Girder (kN) comp. girder to (Mpa)
Top of slab snow (kN-m) -1.14 F=157.09 -1.14
Top of girder -0.80 1.27
End -1.66 -1242.4 8145.98 0.758 -692.30 -1639.67 -1116.62
Bottom 1.89 8.05
Top of slab 0.54 F=169.88 -0.89
Top of girder 4.70 -0.64
L/8 1895.00 571.7 8201.62 0.512 -692.30 -1639.67 -1124.07
Bottom -6.26 15.65
Top of slab -1.03 F=173.64 -0.55
Top of girder 6.73 -4.40
L/4 3226.42 -1096.1 8331.14 0.284 -692.30 -1639.67 -1127.96
Bottom -6.62 19.96
Top of slab -0.58 F=176.66 -0.34
Top of girder 8.89 -6.87
3L/8 4038.77 -621.2 8460.15 0.141 -692.30 -1639.67 -1133.08
Bottom -9.76 22.89
Top of slab -0.27 F=178.33 -0.34
Top of girder 9.76 -6.99
L/2 4332.06 -288.5 8609.42 0.141 -692.30 -1639.67 -1138.18
Bottom -11.20 23.40
Section SIDL Live load Wind load - loaded structure Temp (+ve) Temp (-ve)
Moment Stress Moment (kN- Stress Moment Stress Stress Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa) m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -0.55 -1.40 -0.13 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder -0.38 -0.98 -0.09 -1.10 0.90
End -595.07 -1532.02 -138.87
Bottom 0.90 2.33 0.21 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.14 0.25 -0.02 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.09 0.16 -0.01 -1.10 0.90
L/8 153.07 264.07 -16.89
Bottom -0.30 -0.52 0.03 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.13 0.68 0.05 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.08 0.44 0.03 -1.10 0.90
L/4 137.61 722.68 48.54
Bottom -0.27 -1.41 -0.09 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.37 0.91 0.08 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.24 0.59 0.05 -1.10 0.90
3L/8 390.88 969.92 87.78
Bottom -0.76 -1.90 -0.17 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.57 0.85 0.09 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.37 0.55 0.06 -1.10 0.90
L/2 604.43 904.13 100.86
Bottom -1.18 -1.77 -0.20 1.67 -2.39
80 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 1 1 0.75 0.75 1
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 1 1
Temp (+ve) 0.6
Temp (-ve)
81 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 5 (b) 5 (c ) 5 (d) 6 (a) 6 (b) 6 (c) 6 (c) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.52 -5.72 -5.61 0.45 0.56 -6.37 -6.26 0.56 -6.37
Top of girder -1.69 -0.57 -0.49 -1.96 -1.88 0.04 0.12 0.12 -1.96
End
Bottom 13.37 11.11 10.93 13.63 13.45 9.58 9.40 13.63 9.40
Top of slab 2.71 -1.35 -1.38 4.41 4.38 -2.41 -2.44 4.41 -2.44
Top of girder 3.72 4.94 4.92 3.26 3.24 5.26 5.24 5.26 3.24
L/8
Bottom 8.01 5.52 5.58 8.75 8.81 4.69 4.75 8.81 4.69
Top of slab 1.88 -2.19 -2.21 3.46 3.43 -3.36 -3.38 3.46 -3.38
Top of girder 2.64 3.85 3.84 2.10 2.09 4.10 4.08 4.10 2.09
L/4
Bottom 10.66 8.17 8.23 11.63 11.68 7.57 7.62 11.68 7.57
Top of slab 2.98 -1.04 -1.11 4.55 4.48 -2.26 -2.34 4.55 -2.34
Top of girder 2.88 4.13 4.08 2.34 2.29 4.34 4.29 4.34 2.29
3L/8
Bottom 9.19 6.60 6.75 10.18 10.33 6.12 6.27 10.33 6.12
Top of slab 3.43 -0.55 -0.66 5.05 4.94 -1.76 -1.87 5.05 -1.87
Top of girder 3.73 5.01 4.93 3.23 3.15 5.23 5.15 5.23 3.15
L/2
Bottom 7.91 5.24 5.47 8.78 9.02 4.72 4.96 9.02 4.72
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -3.04 -2.93 -3.12 -3.01 -4.52 -4.41 -4.22 -4.11 -1.86
Top of girder 0.13 0.21 0.08 0.16 -0.91 -0.83 -0.69 -0.62 -1.51
End
Bottom 11.83 11.65 11.96 11.78 14.28 14.10 13.79 13.61 15.16
Top of slab -0.27 -0.30 -0.28 -0.31 -0.04 -0.06 -0.10 -0.13 2.56
Top of girder 4.11 4.09 4.10 4.09 4.27 4.25 4.22 4.20 3.61
L/8
Bottom 10.60 10.66 10.62 10.68 10.10 10.16 10.24 10.30 11.08
Top of slab -1.47 -1.50 -1.45 -1.47 -0.77 -0.80 -0.92 -0.95 1.79
Top of girder 1.99 1.97 2.01 1.99 2.45 2.43 2.35 2.34 1.77
L/4
Bottom 15.01 15.06 14.95 15.01 13.54 13.59 13.86 13.91 14.60
Top of slab -0.51 -0.58 -0.46 -0.54 0.45 0.37 0.25 0.18 2.99
Top of girder 1.62 1.57 1.65 1.61 2.25 2.20 2.12 2.07 1.56
3L/8
Bottom 14.51 14.66 14.41 14.56 12.51 12.66 12.92 13.07 13.61
Top of slab 0.03 -0.08 0.09 -0.02 0.94 0.83 0.76 0.65 3.47
Top of girder 2.51 2.44 2.55 2.48 3.10 3.03 2.99 2.92 2.41
L/2
Bottom 13.12 13.35 13.00 13.24 11.23 11.47 11.60 11.83 12.35
82 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.75 -5.95 -5.84 0.22 0.33 -6.59 -6.49 0.33 -6.59
Top of girder -1.44 -0.31 -0.24 -1.71 -1.63 0.29 0.37 0.37 -1.71
End
Bottom 14.98 12.73 12.54 15.24 15.06 11.19 11.01 15.24 11.01
Top of slab 2.54 -1.53 -1.55 4.23 4.20 -2.59 -2.62 4.23 -2.62
Top of girder 3.59 4.81 4.79 3.13 3.11 5.13 5.11 5.13 3.11
L/8
Bottom 11.14 8.65 8.71 11.88 11.94 7.82 7.88 11.94 7.82
Top of slab 1.77 -2.30 -2.32 3.35 3.32 -3.47 -3.49 3.35 -3.49
Top of girder 1.76 2.97 2.96 1.22 1.21 3.22 3.20 3.22 1.21
L/4
Bottom 14.65 12.16 12.22 15.62 15.67 11.56 11.62 15.67 11.56
Top of slab 2.91 -1.10 -1.18 4.49 4.41 -2.33 -2.40 4.49 -2.40
Top of girder 1.51 2.75 2.71 0.97 0.92 2.97 2.92 2.97 0.92
3L/8
Bottom 13.77 11.18 11.33 14.76 14.91 10.70 10.85 14.91 10.70
Top of slab 3.36 -0.62 -0.73 4.99 4.87 -1.83 -1.94 4.99 -1.94
Top of girder 2.33 3.61 3.53 1.83 1.76 3.83 3.75 3.83 1.76
L/2
Bottom 12.59 9.92 10.15 13.46 13.70 9.40 9.64 13.70 9.40
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 15.7 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = -2.12 Mpa < 4.69 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= -2.12 Mpa < 0.92 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
5.3.9 Load Combination for frequent Combination (SL2) - for prestressing member
1) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress
2) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+ wind load(lead) (unloaded structure)
3) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+wind load (accompany)
4) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+wind load (lead)
5) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+Temperature(accompany)
6) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+Temperature(lead)
a) Load combination
Load Case 1 (a) 1 (b) 2 (a) 2 (b) 3 (a) 3 (b) 4 (a) 4 (b) 5 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
83 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -3.04 -2.93 -3.12 -3.01 -4.16 -4.05 -3.40 -3.29 -1.94
Top of girder 0.13 0.21 0.08 0.16 -0.65 -0.57 -0.12 -0.04 -1.16
End
Bottom 11.83 11.65 11.96 11.78 13.68 13.50 12.42 12.24 14.41
Top of slab -0.27 -0.30 -0.28 -0.31 -0.10 -0.12 -0.23 -0.26 2.07
Top of girder 4.11 4.09 4.10 4.09 4.23 4.21 4.14 4.12 3.68
L/8
Bottom 10.60 10.66 10.62 10.68 10.23 10.29 10.51 10.57 11.04
Top of slab -1.47 -1.50 -1.45 -1.47 -0.94 -0.97 -1.31 -1.34 1.19
Top of girder 1.99 1.97 2.01 1.99 2.34 2.32 2.10 2.08 1.77
L/4
Bottom 15.01 15.06 14.95 15.01 13.90 13.96 14.67 14.72 14.78
Top of slab -0.51 -0.58 -0.46 -0.54 0.21 0.14 -0.28 -0.35 2.33
Top of girder 1.62 1.57 1.65 1.61 2.09 2.05 1.77 1.73 1.52
3L/8
Bottom 14.51 14.66 14.41 14.56 13.00 13.15 14.03 14.18 13.92
Top of slab 0.03 -0.08 0.09 -0.02 0.72 0.60 0.26 0.15 2.83
Top of girder 2.51 2.44 2.55 2.48 2.96 2.89 2.66 2.59 2.38
L/2
Bottom 13.12 13.35 13.00 13.24 11.69 11.93 12.65 12.88 12.63
84 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.83 -5.35 -5.24 -0.73 -0.62 -4.82 -4.71 -0.62 -5.35
Top of girder -1.08 -0.16 -0.08 -0.72 -0.65 0.47 0.55 0.55 -1.16
End
Bottom 14.23 12.38 12.20 13.30 13.12 10.86 10.68 14.41 10.68
Top of slab 2.04 -1.34 -1.37 2.37 2.34 -1.72 -1.75 2.37 -1.75
Top of girder 3.66 4.68 4.66 3.48 3.46 4.68 4.66 4.68 3.46
L/8
Bottom 11.10 9.02 9.07 11.49 11.55 9.06 9.12 11.55 9.02
Top of slab 1.17 -2.22 -2.24 1.25 1.22 -2.84 -2.86 1.25 -2.86
Top of girder 1.76 2.77 2.75 1.42 1.40 2.62 2.60 2.77 1.40
L/4
Bottom 14.84 12.76 12.81 15.73 15.78 13.29 13.35 15.78 12.76
Top of slab 2.25 -1.08 -1.15 2.26 2.19 -1.83 -1.90 2.33 -1.90
Top of girder 1.47 2.52 2.47 1.08 1.03 2.28 2.23 2.52 1.03
3L/8
Bottom 14.07 11.89 12.05 15.13 15.28 12.70 12.85 15.28 11.89
Top of slab 2.71 -0.58 -0.69 2.79 2.68 -1.30 -1.41 2.83 -1.41
Top of girder 2.31 3.38 3.30 1.96 1.89 3.16 3.09 3.38 1.89
L/2
Bottom 12.86 10.60 10.83 13.77 14.00 11.33 11.57 14.00 10.60
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 15.8 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = 0.00 Mpa < 5.88 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= 0.00 Mpa < 1.03 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
5.4 Check for ultimate strength of girder in Flexure :-
Grade of concrete = M40 Modulus of elasticity of concrete E = 33346 MPa
Design yield strength fpd = 17.87 MPa Modulus of elasticity of steel = 195.00 Gpa
3000 0.00350 17.87
225 8754 kN
202.64
NA NA
2000 300
85 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
NA NA
2000
186.85
8012 kN
0.00350 17.87
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
750
Grade Concrete = M40 Grade of steel = Fe 500
Width of the section = 3000 mm Depth of the section = 2000 mm
Clear Cover = 40 mm Main dia of bar used = 25 mm
Dia of shear reinf. = 16 mm Effective depth, d = 1819 mm
R = Mu/bd2 = 0.710 MPa Negative Design Moment = 7052 kN-m
Mu,Lim/bd2 = 0.133xfck = 5.32 MPa Ast = 9102.1 mm2
Lower fractile tensile fctm = 2.12 MPa Where, pt = fck/(2*fy)*(1-sqrt(1-(4.598*R/fck))*100
Min. reinforcement 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 7094.1 mm2
Hence provide 25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf. Ast = 18427.9 mm2
25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf.
16 dia @ 113 c/c Slab Bottom reinf.
Bottom reinf. 14 Nos. 20 dia (50% of main reinforcement)
E of reinforcement = 200000 MPa Max strain in concrete = 0.0035
E of concrete = 33346 MPa Min strain in steel = 0.0042
Balanced neutral axis depth = 829.51 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 186.85 mm
Strain in steel = 0.0306 Stress in steel = 434.8 MPa
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 8012 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 8012 kN
Compressive force CG 77.73 mm Moment of resistance = 13951 kNm
> 7052 kNm Hence O.K.
Factor of safety = 13,951/7,052 = 1.98
86 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
vi) As per clause no 6.3.2 of IS-13920 :1993, Shear force due to ductile detailing shall be
Vua = Va D+L - 1.4(MuAh+MuBs)/L
D+L
Va = 1.2(D+L)/2 = 1559.28 kN
MuAh = -7051.57 kN
MuBs = -3726.84 kN
L = 27.30 m
Vua = 2112 kN
Maximum design shear at support > 2109 kN
87 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
ii) Shear Capacity of Uncracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
The shear resistance of the beam section uncracked in flexure is given below:-
VRd,c = ( I * bwc )/ S x √ (fctd2 + k1 σcp fctd)
Where, I = Moment of inertia bwc= Width of beam after deduction due to duct
S = First moment of area between cetroidal axis and extreme compression fibre about the centrodial axis.
fctd = design tensile strength of concrete = fctk/γm = 1.41 Mpa
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Prestress Force after all losses (kN) 5895.1 5950.8 6080.3 6209.3 6358.6
Effective width of the Web 750 300 300 300 300
Effective Depth of the Section (d) 1242 1488 1716 1859 1859
Stress due to Prestress (σcp) 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573
Design tensile strength of the Concrete (fctd) 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41
First moment of inertia about the CG (S) 2.45E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09
Transmission length factor, k1 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Moment of Inertia (I) (mm4) 8.2E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11
Design Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 666.7 315.7 315.7 315.7 315.7
iii) Summary of the Shear resistance of the Beam when shear reinforcement isn't required :
The maximum shear capacity of the Beam as cl.10.3.2 (5) of IRC 112-2010
VEd ≤ 0.50 bw d ν fcd where, ν = 0.60 [ 1 - fck/310]
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Distance from bearing in m 0.00 3.60 7.20 10.80 14.40
Distance modification factor β for Precast Beam 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Distance modification factor β for Composite 0.25 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Effective Shear for Precast Beam 2112.1 1506.3 1152.0 679.2 518.0
Effective Shear for Composite Section (kN) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective Shear due to prestressing force (kN) 491.1 495.7 506.1 259.2 0.0
Total Shear force for the Beam (kN) 1621.0 1010.6 645.9 419.9 518.0
Precast member Area (m2) 1.44 0.93 0.93 0.93 0.93
Zb (m3) 0.44 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.37
Composite member Area (m2) 2.12 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60
Zb (m3) 0.66 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51
Stress due to prestress at tensile fibre σ bpt (MPa) 2.4370 0.3344 -3.8953 -6.6367 -6.7612
Section at Maximum Bending Moment Uncracked Uncracked Cracked Cracked Cracked
Shear capacity of Beam Section (kN) 666.69 315.69 432.75 466.15 466.21
Maximum shear capacity of the Section (kN) 4349 2084 2403 2603 2603
Not
Whether shear reinforcement required or not Required Required Required Required
Required
88 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
89 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
90 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
A -0.00018
B 4 3.600 1.800 -0.00020 -0.00019 -0.001225
C 3 3.600 5.399 -0.00020 -0.00020 -0.003918608
D 2 3.600 8.999 -0.00017 -0.00019 -0.00604826
E 1 3.600 12.598 -0.00016 -0.00017 -0.007568682
Total -0.018760551
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress + wt of precast Girder = = -19 mm
= - L/ 1535
(iii) Precast Girder - Prestress + wt of precast Girder +wt of deck slab at 60 days
Section At support Near L/8 At L/4 At 3L/8 At L/2
Distance 0.000 3.600 7.199 10.799 14.398
CG of all cables from bot.(m) 0.758 0.512 0.284 0.141 0.141
Loss 268.450 268.450 268.450 268.450 268.450
Moment due to prestressing losses 51.104 120.855 182.063 220.308 220.370
Moment due to Wt of Deck Slab -0.527 782.722 1347.331 1693.302 1820.633
Total moment due to prestress+DL 50.576 903.577 1529.394 1913.610 2041.003
M/EI (1/m) 0.0000037 0.0000765 0.0001295 0.0001620 0.00017
91 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
92 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
93 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.475 0.2
0.1 0.053
0.2
0.25
0.225 0.225
0.75 2.250 0.75
Part of intermediate cross girder {1.25x(1.775-0.25)-(0.93-0.75x0.25)}x0.3x25 = 8.75 kN
= 8.75 kN
36.11 36.11
23.19
0.250 1.75 1.75 21.30 1.75 1.75 0.250
6.1.3 Dead Load Moment & Shear for Deck slab & X-girder
Unit weight of concrete = 25.000 kN/m3
Thickness of deck slab = 0.225 m2
Average width of deck slab at support = 3.000 m
Wt of Inner X-girder (1.75/2x(1.775-0.25))x0.3x25 = 10.008 kN
= 10.008
94 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
16.875
95 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
96 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
97 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
98 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
99 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
6.1.5 Summary of Bending Moment & Shear Force for outer girder
a) Bending Moment (kNm) 34 39 42 46 51 Staad Member no
Description At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Distance (m) 0.000 3.538 7.076 10.614 14.152
Precast girder only -1.1 1076.3 1817.4 2268.2 2428.8
Construction load -0.2 284.5 487.9 610.0 650.7
Deck slab & X-girder -0.5 756.4 1302.2 1636.7 1760.0
Total wt of deck slab = -1.7 1832.7 3119.5 3904.9 4188.8
SIDL (DL) from staad output -124.2 59.6 17.4 122.0 247.4
SIDL (WC) from staad output -403.2 85.0 101.8 209.7 243.3
Removal of shutter 437.8 -97.1 -109.7 -237.2 -285.3
Earth pressure -265.8 -342.5 -393.3 -460.9 -546.1
Live load surcharge 439.5 -309.6 -225.7 -113.4 57.2
Wind load (unloaded structure) -457.5 92.2 131.0 270.4 325.9
Wind load (loaded structure) -227.2 40.7 72.7 142.6 168.9
Differential settlement 857.4 -626.5 -477.0 -276.5 28.7
Temperature rise -85.9 -89.3 -90.7 -91.8 -92.4
Temperature fall 51.1 52.4 52.9 53.3 53.6
Creep & shrinkage 337.6 -332.1 -329.5 -326.9 -327.0
Footpath live load 19.0 -3.0 8.9 19.3 28.1
Snow load -523.6 119.0 129.1 285.3 349.3
Braking load 149.7 -108.9 -82.5 -47.1 -6.6
Live Load -1504.3 491.5 788.7 989.7 1080.3
Seismic in X- direction -1944.0 -1431.8 -1092.3 -629.2 -96.3
Seismic in Z- direction -154.0 -95.6 -70.0 -68.9 -91.0
Seismic in Y- direction -165.6 -51.5 -43.2 -110.6 -153.0
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. -122.0 -181.4 -220.8 -273.4 -339.6
Dynamic increment of LL Surcharge 277.2 -195.3 -142.4 -71.6 36.0
Hyperstatic action At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Axial compresion 32.159 33.983 35.747 37.124 39.381
Moment -947.6 -940.3 -935.6 -928.8 -920.0
The hyperstatic action is only considered for calculation of negative moment at support.
100 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
101 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
102 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.375
3
0.000
X X X
1.775 0.500
2
0.500
1 3 2 0.170 1 0.400
0.125
0.205 0.340 0.205
0.75 0.75
Section at Midspan Section at Support
0.25 14.152
Y
4.50
1 2 X 0.17
0.17
0.15 14.402
0.15
0.38 4
0.000 3
0.500 Z
2
0.500
1 0.170
0.125
0.40 0.25 3.000 4.50 3.00 3.652
.
Cable profile in Elevation
o
Vertical bending of Cable 1 =Tan-1{(0.4-0.125)/(0.25+3-0.15)} = 5.069
o
Vertical bending of Cable 2 =Tan-1{(0.4+0.5-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5-0.15)} = 5.823
o
Vertical bending of Cable 3 =Tan-1{(0.4+0.5+0.5-0.125-0.17-)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 6.859
o
Vertical bending of Cable 4 =Tan-1{(0.4+0.5+0.5+0-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 5.951
Radius for 1 to 3 = 20 m
Horizontal bending of Cable 1 2.781 o
Horizontal bending of Cable 2 2.781 o
Position of Cable
Cable Anchorage Location of vertical Bending
No. X Y Z X Y Z
1 0.000 0.000 0.400 3.100 0.000 0.125
2 0.000 0.000 0.900 7.600 -0.170 0.125
3 0.000 0.000 1.40 10.600 0.000 0.125
103 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 1 19 T13
Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ) Force after
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss
slip loss (kN)
(kN)
1 2732.90 2434.91
1-2 3.112 0.00 0.000 1.0062
2 2715.95 2451.87
2-3 4.503 5.782 0.101 1.0265
3 2645.81 2522.00
3-4 6.652 2.781 0.049 1.0218
4 2589.40 2578.42
Cable 2 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2428.61
1-2 3.116 0.00 0.000 1.0063
2 2715.93 2445.58
2-3 4.527 6.452 0.113 1.0286
3 2640.41 2521.10
3-4 6.652 2.781 0.049 1.0218
4 2584.11 2584.11
3.116 4.527 6.652
2732.90 2715.93
1 2 2640.41 2584.11
= 3
= 2577.40 4
2445.58 2521.10
2428.61 6.652
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2577.40 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 3 = 6.652 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.32 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.32 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.000 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = 28.588 m
Extension of cable = 109.78 mm
104 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 3 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2488.83
1-2 10.676 0.00 0.000 1.0216
2 2675.17 2546.57
2-3 3.652 6.859 0.120 1.0280
3 2602.20 2602.20
10.676 3.652
2732.90 2675.17
1 2 2602.20
= 3
= 2610.87
2546.57 3.218
2488.83
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2610.868 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 1 = 3.218 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.324 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.324 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.00 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = (10.676+3.6515)x2 = 28.656 m
Extension of cable at each side = 111.19 mm
6.2.2 Summary of Cable Forces after Friction & Slip at different Points
Position Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Cable No 0.500 3.538 7.076 10.614 14.152
Cable 1 2437.63 2454.19 2513.60 2547.43 2578.42
Vert. angle 5.069 5.069 5.069 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 0.000 0.000
C.G. 0.356 0.125 0.125 0.125 0.125
Cable 2 2431.33 2447.88 2511.64 2549.24 2584.11
Vert. angle 5.823 5.823 5.823 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 2.781 0.000
C. G. 0.849 0.539 0.178 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Normal 4846.88 4879.84 4996.56 5093.67 5162.53
at first stage
CG of Cable 0.602 0.332 0.152 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Per.
462.05 465.19 476.35 0.00 0.00
Cable 3 2491.54 2507.96 2527.10 2546.23 2602.20
Vert. angle 6.859 6.859 6.859 6.859 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
C. G. 1.340 0.974 0.549 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Normal 2473.70 2490.02 2509.01 2528.01 2602.20
CG of Cable 1.340 0.974 0.549 0.125 0.125
Total cable
297.54 299.51 301.79 304.08 0.00
forces CG
Overall Per.of
Cable 0.851 0.549 0.285 0.125 0.125
% loss 10.2 % 9.6 % 7.9 % 6.8 % 5.3 %
6.2.3 Length of Cables and Extension at each End
Total Length Extension at each End
Cable No
(m) (mm)
Cable 1 28.534 109.71
Cable 2 28.588 109.78
Cable 3 28.656 111.19
105 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
106 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
6.3.1.2 Loss due to Relaxation of Steel (clause no. 6.3.6 of IRC 112-2011)
Total Relaxation Loss at service condition = 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Initial force after Friction, slip & ES loss (4738+2x(4771+4888+4985)+5054)/8 = 4884.81 kN
Percentage of Initial force = 0.700 UTS
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel = 2.50 % of initial force
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel 4884.81/2x2.5/100 = 60.99 kN/Cable
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing as per Table 6.2 of IRC 112-2011, = 37 % of Total Loss
5 - 28 days Loss 23 days 552 = 42.00 % of Total Loss
28 - 60 days Loss 32 days 768 = 21.00 % of Total Loss
60 - 90 days Loss 30 days = 0.00 % of Total Loss
90 - α days Loss = 200.0 % of Total Loss
i.e. 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing = 22.57 kN/Cable
5 - 28 days Loss = 25.62 kN/Cable
28 - 60 days Loss = 12.81 kN/Cable
60 - 90 days Loss = 0.00 kN/Cable
90-α days Loss = 121.98 kN/Cable
Total = 182.97 kN/Cable
182.969 6.70 %
107 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
108 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
6.3.3. Sustained Stress of precast girder at 60 days after Casting of Deck with X-Girder
Losses for first 3 cables:- Losses for last 1 cable:-
Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 12.81 kN/Cable Relaxation = 38.42 kN/Cable
Creep = 36.10 kN/Cable Creep = 36.10 kN/Cable
Total = 64.93 kN/Cable Total = 90.54 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 64.93 kN/Cable actual time dependent losses = 90.54 kN/Cable
Total Loss of 4 Cables = 220.39 kN Actual Loss of third Cables = 90.54 kN
Depth of Precast Girder = 1.775 m
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 0.928 m Area = 1.444 m
4 4
I= 0.354 m I= 0.412 m
CG = 0.962 m CG = 0.948 m
+ + =
< 20.00
Mpa
17.41 Mpa -0.74 Mpa -6.55 Mpa 10.12 Mpa Hence O.K.
Resultant Stress at 28 Stress due to loss between 28 Stress due to DL of Slab & Resultant Stress at 60
days to 60 days wt of shuttering days
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Precast Girder at 60 days of Casting of Girder
Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 1.603 m Area = 2.119 m
4 4
I= 0.692 m I= 0.821 m
CG = 1.352 m CG = 1.247 m
109 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
+ + =
110 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
+ =
Total Stress
Section Total Stress Stress due Stress due to at α days
without live Total Live Load 0.6 x Wind load to Live Load wind Load with live load
load (Mpa) Moment(kN-m) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -1.08 -0.84 -0.12 -2.04
Top of girder 2.53 -915.14 -136.33 -0.59 -0.09 1.85
End
Bottom 6.14 1.39 0.21 7.74
Top of slab -0.68 0.07 0.02 -0.59
Top of girder 5.31 72.99 24.39 0.04 0.01 5.37
L/8
Bottom 8.47 -0.14 -0.05 8.28
Top of slab -0.46 0.45 0.04 0.03
Top of girder 4.78 480.51 43.59 0.29 0.03 5.10
L/4
Bottom 9.25 -0.94 -0.09 8.22
Top of slab -0.22 0.78 0.08 0.64
Top of girder 4.35 829.12 85.53 0.51 0.05 4.91
3L/8
Bottom 9.77 -1.62 -0.17 7.99
Top of slab -0.11 1.01 0.09 0.99
Top of girder 5.05 1073.69 101.37 0.66 0.06 5.76
L/2
Bottom 9.14 -2.10 -0.20 6.84
111 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Composite Girder with SIDL & Live Load at α days
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 5.8 Mpa
Permissible Tensile stress in concrete at service = -1.41 Mpa > -2.0 Mpa
Tension reinforcement at top of support are provided
6.3.7 Summary of Stresses for Precast girder only
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder
Precast Girder Midspan Support Composite Girder Midspan Support
Area = 0.928 1.444 m2 Area = 1.603 2.119 m2
I= 0.354 0.412 m4 I= 0.692 0.821 m4
CG = 0.962 0.948 m CG = 1.352 1.247 m
Z Top of slab = 1.067 1.091 3
m
Z Top = 0.436 0.499 m3 Z Top = 1.635 1.556 m3
Zbottom = 0.368 0.435 m3 Zbottom = 0.512 0.658 m3
DL Moment
Moment due to
Stress Prestressing force & Loss
Section earth pr. Diff Prestress CG of cables Loss of pre. Loss of Moment due Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa)
settle, creep, (kN) (m) Girder (kN) comp. girder to (Mpa)
Top of slab snow (kN-m) -1.20 F=32.16 -1.03
Top of girder -0.84 2.43
End -1.66 -1309.1 7320.59 0.851 -602.43 -1364.85 -947.56
Bottom 1.99 6.11
Top of slab -1.22 F=33.98 -0.73
Top of girder 3.41 0.10
L/8 1832.75 -1301.1 7369.86 0.549 -602.43 -1364.85 -940.34
Bottom -2.43 13.72
Top of slab -1.08 F=35.75 -0.39
Top of girder 6.46 -3.85
L/4 3119.54 -1149.0 7505.57 0.285 -602.43 -1364.85 -935.57
Bottom -6.23 18.25
Top of slab -0.62 F=37.12 -0.18
Top of girder 8.56 -6.33
3L/8 3904.88 -660.6 7621.68 0.125 -602.43 -1364.85 -928.79
Bottom -9.32 21.20
Top of slab -0.27 F=39.38 -0.17
Top of girder 9.43 -6.45
L/2 4188.78 -291.5 7764.73 0.125 -602.43 -1364.85 -920.01
Bottom -10.81 21.66
Section SIDL Live load Wind load - loaded structure Temp (+ve) Temp (-ve)
Moment Stress Moment (kN- Stress Moment Stress Stress Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa) m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -0.48 -0.84 -0.12 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder -0.34 -0.59 -0.09 -1.10 0.90
End -527.35 -915.14 -136.33
Bottom 0.80 1.39 0.21 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.14 0.07 0.02 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.09 0.04 0.01 -1.10 0.90
L/8 144.52 72.99 24.39
Bottom -0.28 -0.14 -0.05 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.11 0.45 0.04 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.07 0.29 0.03 -1.10 0.90
L/4 119.22 480.51 43.59
Bottom -0.23 -0.94 -0.09 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.31 0.78 0.08 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.20 0.51 0.05 -1.10 0.90
3L/8 331.76 829.12 85.53
Bottom -0.65 -1.62 -0.17 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.46 1.01 0.09 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.30 0.66 0.06 -1.10 0.90
L/2 490.70 1073.69 101.37
Bottom -0.96 -2.10 -0.20 1.67 -2.39
112 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 1 1 0.75 0.75 1
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 1 1
Temp (+ve) 0.6
Temp (-ve)
113 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 5 (b) 5 (c ) 5 (d) 6 (a) 6 (b) 6 (c) 6 (c) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -0.86 -5.05 -4.95 0.98 1.07 -5.84 -5.74 1.07 -5.84
Top of girder -0.25 0.88 0.95 -0.61 -0.54 1.39 1.46 1.46 -0.61
End
Bottom 10.68 8.41 8.25 11.16 11.00 7.10 6.94 11.16 6.94
Top of slab 0.92 -3.14 -3.17 2.66 2.63 -4.16 -4.19 2.66 -4.19
Top of girder 2.97 4.19 4.17 2.54 2.52 4.54 4.52 4.54 2.52
L/8
Bottom 10.49 7.99 8.05 11.13 11.19 7.07 7.13 11.19 7.07
Top of slab 1.73 -2.34 -2.36 3.36 3.34 -3.45 -3.47 3.36 -3.47
Top of girder 2.70 3.92 3.90 2.20 2.19 4.20 4.19 4.20 2.19
L/4
Bottom 10.03 7.55 7.60 10.89 10.93 6.83 6.88 10.93 6.83
Top of slab 2.90 -1.13 -1.19 4.49 4.43 -2.32 -2.38 4.49 -2.38
Top of girder 2.91 4.15 4.10 2.38 2.34 4.38 4.34 4.38 2.34
3L/8
Bottom 8.49 5.93 6.06 9.44 9.56 5.38 5.51 9.56 5.38
Top of slab 3.63 -0.37 -0.46 5.20 5.10 -1.62 -1.71 5.20 -1.71
Top of girder 3.92 5.18 5.12 3.38 3.32 5.38 5.32 5.38 3.32
L/2
Bottom 6.63 4.00 4.19 7.63 7.82 3.57 3.76 7.82 3.57
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -2.92 -2.82 -2.99 -2.89 -3.83 -3.73 -3.67 -3.57 -1.16
Top of girder 1.42 1.48 1.36 1.43 0.78 0.84 0.89 0.96 0.17
End
Bottom 9.67 9.51 9.79 9.63 11.18 11.02 10.92 10.76 12.06
Top of slab -1.86 -1.88 -1.84 -1.87 -1.77 -1.80 -1.78 -1.81 0.80
Top of girder 3.63 3.61 3.64 3.62 3.68 3.66 3.68 3.66 3.01
L/8
Bottom 12.31 12.37 12.28 12.34 12.14 12.20 12.16 12.22 13.17
Top of slab -1.37 -1.39 -1.34 -1.36 -0.89 -0.91 -0.99 -1.01 1.67
Top of girder 2.31 2.30 2.33 2.31 2.62 2.61 2.56 2.55 1.95
L/4
Bottom 13.57 13.62 13.52 13.57 12.58 12.63 12.78 12.83 13.63
Top of slab -0.44 -0.50 -0.39 -0.45 0.39 0.32 0.22 0.16 2.93
Top of girder 1.83 1.79 1.86 1.82 2.37 2.33 2.27 2.22 1.68
3L/8
Bottom 13.22 13.35 13.12 13.25 11.50 11.63 11.84 11.97 12.60
Top of slab 0.09 0.00 0.15 0.06 1.16 1.06 0.94 0.85 3.69
Top of girder 2.70 2.64 2.73 2.67 3.39 3.33 3.25 3.19 2.69
L/2
Bottom 11.86 12.06 11.74 11.94 9.65 9.84 10.09 10.28 10.77
114 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.07 -5.25 -5.16 0.77 0.87 -6.04 -5.95 0.87 -6.04
Top of girder 0.24 1.37 1.44 -0.12 -0.06 1.87 1.94 1.94 -0.12
End
Bottom 11.90 9.63 9.47 12.38 12.22 8.32 8.16 12.38 8.16
Top of slab 0.77 -3.29 -3.31 2.51 2.48 -4.30 -4.33 2.51 -4.33
Top of girder 2.99 4.21 4.19 2.56 2.54 4.56 4.54 4.56 2.54
L/8
Bottom 13.23 10.74 10.79 13.88 13.93 9.82 9.87 13.93 9.82
Top of slab 1.65 -2.42 -2.44 3.29 3.26 -3.53 -3.55 3.29 -3.55
Top of girder 1.93 3.15 3.13 1.43 1.42 3.43 3.42 3.43 1.42
L/4
Bottom 13.68 11.20 11.25 14.54 14.58 10.48 10.53 14.58 10.48
Top of slab 2.86 -1.16 -1.22 4.46 4.40 -2.36 -2.42 4.46 -2.42
Top of girder 1.64 2.88 2.84 1.11 1.07 3.11 3.07 3.11 1.07
3L/8
Bottom 12.73 10.17 10.30 13.67 13.80 9.62 9.75 13.80 9.62
Top of slab 3.60 -0.40 -0.49 5.16 5.07 -1.65 -1.74 5.16 -1.74
Top of girder 2.63 3.89 3.83 2.09 2.03 4.09 4.03 4.09 2.03
L/2
Bottom 10.96 8.33 8.52 11.96 12.15 7.90 8.09 12.15 7.90
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 14.6 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = -2.12 Mpa < 3.57 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= -2.12 Mpa < 1.07 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
6.3.9 Load Combination for frequent Combination (SL2) - for prestressing member
1) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress
2) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+ wind load(lead) (unloaded structure)
3) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+wind load (accompany)
4) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+wind load (lead)
5) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+Temperature(accompany)
6) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+Temperature(lead)
a) Load combination
Load Case 1 (a) 1 (b) 2 (a) 2 (b) 3 (a) 3 (b) 4 (a) 4 (b) 5 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
115 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -2.92 -2.82 -2.99 -2.89 -3.61 -3.51 -3.16 -3.06 -1.39
Top of girder 1.42 1.48 1.36 1.43 0.93 1.00 1.25 1.31 0.43
End
Bottom 9.67 9.51 9.79 9.63 10.82 10.66 10.07 9.91 11.55
Top of slab -1.86 -1.88 -1.84 -1.87 -1.79 -1.82 -1.83 -1.86 0.35
Top of girder 3.63 3.61 3.64 3.62 3.67 3.65 3.64 3.63 3.11
L/8
Bottom 12.31 12.37 12.28 12.34 12.18 12.24 12.26 12.31 13.04
Top of slab -1.37 -1.39 -1.34 -1.36 -1.01 -1.03 -1.25 -1.27 1.13
Top of girder 2.31 2.30 2.33 2.31 2.55 2.53 2.39 2.37 1.98
L/4
Bottom 13.57 13.62 13.52 13.57 12.83 12.87 13.33 13.38 13.70
Top of slab -0.44 -0.50 -0.39 -0.45 0.18 0.12 -0.24 -0.30 2.30
Top of girder 1.83 1.79 1.86 1.82 2.24 2.20 1.97 1.92 1.66
3L/8
Bottom 13.22 13.35 13.12 13.25 11.92 12.05 12.80 12.93 12.84
Top of slab 0.09 0.00 0.15 0.06 0.89 0.80 0.35 0.26 3.01
Top of girder 2.70 2.64 2.73 2.67 3.22 3.16 2.87 2.81 2.64
L/2
Bottom 11.86 12.06 11.74 11.94 10.19 10.38 11.33 11.52 11.12
116 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -1.29 -4.79 -4.70 -0.49 -0.40 -4.58 -4.49 -0.40 -4.79
Top of girder 0.49 1.43 1.49 0.64 0.71 1.84 1.91 1.91 0.43
End
Bottom 11.39 9.52 9.36 10.95 10.79 8.52 8.35 11.55 8.35
Top of slab 0.33 -3.05 -3.08 0.75 0.72 -3.34 -3.37 0.75 -3.37
Top of girder 3.09 4.11 4.09 2.98 2.96 4.17 4.16 4.17 2.96
L/8
Bottom 13.10 11.01 11.07 13.29 13.34 10.85 10.91 13.34 10.85
Top of slab 1.11 -2.28 -2.30 1.31 1.29 -2.78 -2.80 1.31 -2.80
Top of girder 1.97 2.98 2.97 1.71 1.70 2.91 2.90 2.98 1.70
L/4
Bottom 13.75 11.67 11.72 14.39 14.43 11.95 12.00 14.43 11.67
Top of slab 2.24 -1.11 -1.17 2.31 2.24 -1.78 -1.85 2.31 -1.85
Top of girder 1.62 2.66 2.62 1.27 1.23 2.47 2.43 2.66 1.23
3L/8
Bottom 12.97 10.81 10.94 13.90 14.03 11.46 11.59 14.03 10.81
Top of slab 2.91 -0.40 -0.49 2.88 2.79 -1.21 -1.30 3.01 -1.30
Top of girder 2.58 3.64 3.58 2.17 2.11 3.37 3.31 3.64 2.11
L/2
Bottom 11.32 9.10 9.29 12.45 12.64 10.01 10.20 12.64 9.10
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 14.4 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = 0.00 Mpa < 4.76 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= 0.00 Mpa < 1.23 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
6.4 Check for ultimate strength of girder in Flexure :-
Grade of concrete = M40 Modulus of elasticity of concrete E = 33346 MPa
Design yield strength fpd = 17.87 MPa Modulus of elasticity of steel = 195.00 Gpa
3000 0.00350 17.87
225 7920 kN
183.34
NA NA
2000 300
117 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
NA NA
2000
186.85
8012 kN
0.00350 17.87
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
750
Grade Concrete = M40 Grade of steel = Fe 500
Width of the section = 3000 mm Depth of the section = 2000 mm
Clear Cover = 40 mm Main dia of bar used = 25 mm
Dia of shear reinf. = 16 mm Effective depth, d = 1819 mm
R = Mu/bd2 = 0.694 MPa Negative Design Moment = 6890 kN-m
Mu,Lim/bd2 = 0.133xfck = 5.32 MPa Ast = 8889.2 mm2
Lower fractile tensile fctm = 2.12 MPa Where, pt = fck/(2*fy)*(1-sqrt(1-(4.598*R/fck))*100
Min. reinforcement 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 7094.1 mm2
Hence provide 25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf. Ast = 18427.9 mm2
25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf.
16 dia @ 113 c/c Slab Bottom reinf.
Bottom reinf. 14 Nos. 20 dia (50% of main reinforcement)
E of reinforcement = 200000 MPa Max strain in concrete = 0.0035
E of concrete = 33346 MPa Min strain in steel = 0.0042
Balanced neutral axis depth = 829.51 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 186.85 mm
Strain in steel = 0.0306 Stress in steel = 434.8 MPa
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 8012 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 8012 kN
Compressive force CG 77.73 mm Moment of resistance = 13951 kNm
> 6890 kNm Hence O.K.
Factor of safety = 13,951/6,890 = 2.02
118 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
vi) As per clause no 6.3.2 of IS-13920 :1993, Shear force due to ductile detailing shall be
Vua = Va D+L - 1.4(MuAh+MuBs)/L
D+L
Va = 1.2(D+L)/2 = 1407.13 kN
MuAh = -6890.07 kN
MuBs = -3561.52 kN
L = 26.80 m
Vua = 1953 kN
Maximum design shear at support > 1913 kN
119 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
ii) Shear Capacity of Uncracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
The shear resistance of the beam section uncracked in flexure is given below:-
VRd,c = ( I * bwc )/ S x √ (fctd2 + k1 σcp fctd)
Where, I = Moment of inertia bwc= Width of beam after deduction due to duct
S = First moment of area between cetroidal axis and extreme compression fibre about the centrodial axis.
fctd = design tensile strength of concrete = fctk/γm = 1.41 Mpa
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Prestress Force after all losses (kN) 5398.7 5448.0 5583.7 5699.8 5842.9
Effective width of the Web 750 300 300 300 300
Effective Depth of the Section (d) 1149 1451 1715 1875 1875
Stress due to Prestress (σcp) 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573
Design tensile strength of the Concrete (fctd) 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41
First moment of inertia about the CG (S) 2.45E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09
Transmission length factor, k1 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Moment of Inertia (I) (mm4) 8.2E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11
Design Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 666.7 315.7 315.7 315.7 315.7
iii) Summary of the Shear resistance of the Beam when shear reinforcement isn't required :
The maximum shear capacity of the Beam as cl.10.3.2 (5) of IRC 112-2010
VEd ≤ 0.50 bw d ν fcd where, ν = 0.60 [ 1 - fck/310]
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Distance from bearing in m 0.00 3.54 7.08 10.61 14.15
Distance modification factor β for Precast Beam 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Distance modification factor β for Composite 0.25 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Effective Shear for Precast Beam 1953.1 1397.7 1037.9 643.8 389.1
Effective Shear for Composite Section (kN) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective Shear due to prestressing force (kN) 540.6 545.7 559.7 219.5 0.0
Total Shear force for the Beam (kN) 1412.5 852.0 478.2 424.3 389.1
Precast member Area (m2) 1.44 0.93 0.93 0.93 0.93
Zb (m3) 0.44 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.37
Composite member Area (m2) 2.12 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60
Zb (m3) 0.66 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51
Stress due to prestress at tensile fibre σ bpt (MPa) 3.5525 0.9263 -3.5008 -6.2782 -6.3996
Section at Maximum Bending Moment Uncracked Uncracked Cracked Cracked Cracked
Shear capacity of Beam Section (kN) 666.69 315.69 432.60 470.00 470.01
Maximum shear capacity of the Section (kN) 4022 2032 2402 2626 2626
Not Not
Whether shear reinforcement required or not Required Required Required
Required Required
120 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
121 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
z = Lever arm
bi = the width of interface
VRdi = µσn + ρfyd[µsinα+cosα] <=0.5vfcd fck = M40
µ = friction for rough surface = 0.7 fyd = 500 Mpa
σn = the minimum co existing normal stress < 0.6fcd = 0.00 Mpa
ρ = As/Aj where As is the area of reinforcement, Aj is the interface area of the joint
ν1 = Coeff accounting stress in compression chord = 0.60
α = the angle of the reinforcement to the interface = 90.00 degree
fcd = αcc*fck/γm where, αcc =0.67 and γm = 1.5 = 17.87 Mpa
122 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
A -0.00013
B 4 3.538 1.769 -0.00018 -0.00016 -0.000980702
C 3 3.538 5.307 -0.00020 -0.00019 -0.003587581
D 2 3.538 8.845 -0.00018 -0.00019 -0.005939722
E 1 3.538 12.383 -0.00017 -0.00017 -0.007614851
Total -0.018122855
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress + wt of precast Girder = = -18 mm
= - L/ 1562
(iii) Precast Girder - Prestress + wt of precast Girder +wt of deck slab at 60 days
Section At support Near L/8 At L/4 At 3L/8 At L/2
Distance 0.000 3.538 7.076 10.614 14.152
CG of all cables from bot.(m) 0.851 0.549 0.285 0.125 0.125
Loss 220.393 220.393 220.393 220.393 220.393
Moment due to prestressing losses 21.354 91.080 149.325 184.489 184.500
Moment due to Wt of Deck Slab -0.527 756.435 1302.181 1636.709 1760.021
Total moment due to prestress+DL 20.826 847.516 1451.505 1821.198 1944.521
M/EI (1/m) 0.0000015 0.0000718 0.0001229 0.0001542 0.00016
3.5 3.538 3.538 3.538
A B C D E
0.000002 0.0000718 0.0001542
4 0.0001229 0.0001646
3 1
2
M/EI Diagram for Ist Stage Prestress after losses at 60 days
123 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
At Midspan
Average
Section Marked Distance CG from A M/EI Moment of M/EI about A Rotation
M/EI
A 0.0000015
B 4 3.538 1.769 0.0000718 0.0000366 0.000229263 0.00153
C 3 3.538 5.307 0.0001229 0.0000973 0.001827179
D 2 3.538 8.845 0.0001542 0.0001385 0.004335044
E 1 3.538 12.383 0.0001646 0.0001594 0.006983334
Total 0.01337482
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress losses + DL = = 13.375 mm
Total Deflection at 60 days =-27.647+13.375 = -14.272 mm
63 1 SPECTRUM IN X8.081
DIRECTION 0.061 0.529 8.098 0 0 0
2 SPECTRUM IN Z0.482
DIRECTION 0.211 1.584 1.669 0 0 0
3 SPECTRUM IN Y0.003
DIRECTION 0.366 0.019 0.367 0 0 0
4 DEAD LOAD 0.025 -1.581 0.002 1.581 0 0 0
5 SIDL (DL) -0.001 -0.449 0.01 0.45 0 0 0
6 SIDL(WC) -0.002 -0.715 0.001 0.715 0 0 0
7 REMOVAL OF SHUTTER
0.002 0.818 -0.011 0.819 0 0 0
8 EARTH PR ON ABUTMENT
1.361 2.555 0.224 2.904 0 0 0
9 LIVE LOAD SURCHARGE
2.236 0.162 0.147 2.247 0 0 0
10 DYNAMIC INCREMENT
1.093 OF EARTH
1.579 PR. 0.154 1.926 0 0 0
11 DYNAMIC INCREMENT
1.409 OF LL0.102
SURCGARGE 0.093 1.416 0 0 0
12 UNLADEN WIND 0.097
LOAD -0.909 -0.164 0.929 0 0 0
13 LADEN WIND LOAD
0.09 -0.471 -0.149 0.502 0 0 0
14 DIFFERNTIAL SETTLEMENT
-2.487 -6.448 -0.134 6.913 0 0 0.001
15 TEMPERATURE RISE 0 0.441 -0.189 0.48 0 0 0
16 TEMPERATURE -0.001
FALL -0.257 0.095 0.274 0 0 0
17 CREEP SHRINKAGE
0.016 DIFF SHRINKAGE
1.603 -0.24 1.621 0 0 0
18 FOOTPATH LIVE0.001
LOAD -0.073 0.007 0.073 0 0 0
19 SNOW LOAD FOR
-0.002
70R LL TRACK
-0.979 0.004 0.979 0 0 0
20 SNOW LOAD FOR
-0.001
LL 70R WHEEL
-0.471 0.003 0.471 0 0 0
21 BRAKING 0.588 -0.004 0.03 0.589 0 0 0
504 COMBINATION0.005
LOAD CASE-1.169
504 0.02 1.169 0 0 0
124 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
125 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.475 0.2
0.1 0.053
0.2
0.25
0.225 0.225
0.75 2.250 0.75
Part of intermediate cross girder {1.25x(1.775-0.25)-(0.93-0.75x0.25)}x0.3x25 = 8.75 kN
= 8.75 kN
36.11 36.11
23.19
0.250 1.75 1.75 20.81 1.75 1.75 0.250
7.1.3 Dead Load Moment & Shear for Deck slab & X-girder
Unit weight of concrete = 25.000 kN/m3
Thickness of deck slab = 0.225 m2
Average width of deck slab at support = 2.870 m
Wt of Inner X-girder (1.75/2x(1.775-0.25))x0.3x25 = 10.008 kN
= 10.008
126 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
16.143
127 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
128 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
129 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
130 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
131 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
7.1.5 Summary of Bending Moment & Shear Force for outer girder
a) Bending Moment (kNm) 1 5 8 12 17 Staad Member no
Description At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Distance (m) 0.000 3.476 6.953 10.429 13.905
Precast girder only -1.1 1041.0 1756.7 2192.2 2347.5
Construction load -0.2 272.0 466.4 583.0 621.9
Deck slab & X-girder -0.5 699.6 1204.7 1514.7 1629.7
Total wt of deck slab = -1.6 1740.6 2961.4 3706.9 3977.2
SIDL (DL) from staad output -300.5 34.2 106.5 133.5 73.1
SIDL (WC) from staad output -443.4 129.6 87.4 227.5 295.5
Removal of shutter 425.3 -117.9 -93.4 -224.7 -276.6
Earth pressure -287.6 -352.9 -401.4 -466.5 -549.0
Live load surcharge 445.4 -322.7 -235.7 -120.6 52.5
Wind load (unloaded structure) -481.4 120.3 123.1 268.6 317.4
Wind load (loaded structure) -239.4 54.9 68.7 141.6 163.7
Differential settlement 926.6 -690.5 -524.1 -304.8 34.4
Temperature rise -95.6 -93.8 -93.2 -92.9 -92.8
Temperature fall 53.7 53.4 -53.6 -54.0 -54.4
Creep & shrinkage 295.3 -309.7 -319.7 329.3 -344.9
Footpath live load 73.7 -37.2 11.4 31.3 57.7
Snow load -234.8 64.1 52.9 125.2 153.4
Braking load -142.1 -104.6 -77.1 -49.8 5.0
Live Load -2535.8 -1022.6 850.9 1535.4 1797.6
Seismic in X- direction -1975.9 -1496.1 -1148.8 -675.4 -77.8
Seismic in Z- direction -373.4 -159.4 -87.6 -181.4 -224.6
Seismic in Y- direction -250.4 -87.5 -57.2 -144.7 -178.6
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. -135.0 -186.7 -225.0 -276.1 -340.9
Dynamic increment of LL Surcharge 280.9 -203.6 -148.7 -76.1 33.0
Hyperstatic action At support Near L/8 Near L/4 Near 3L/8 At L/2
Axial compresion -103.326 -109.503 -112.325 -112.95 -114.68
Moment -975.1 -961.3 -953.1 -943.5 -932.5
The hyperstatic action is only considered for calculation of negative moment at support.
132 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
133 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
134 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.375
3
0.000
X X X
1.775 0.500
2
0.500
1 3 2 0.170 1 0.400
0.125
0.205 0.340 0.205
0.75 0.75
Section at Midspan Section at Support
0.25 13.905
Y
4.50
1 2 X 0.17
0.17
0.15 14.155
0.15
0.38 4
0.000 3
0.500 Z
2
0.500
1 0.170
0.125
0.40 0.25 3.000 4.50 3.00 3.405
.
Cable profile in Elevation
o
Vertical bending of Cable 1 =Tan-1{(0.4-0.125)/(0.25+3-0.15)} = 5.069
o
Vertical bending of Cable 2 =Tan-1{(0.4+0.5-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5-0.15)} = 5.823
o
Vertical bending of Cable 3 =Tan-1{(0.4+0.5+0.5-0.125-0.17-)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 6.859
o
Vertical bending of Cable 4 =Tan-1{(0.4+0.5+0.5+0-0.125-0.17)/(0.25+3+4.5+3-0.15)}= 5.951
Radius for 1 to 3 = 20 m
Horizontal bending of Cable 1 2.781 o
Horizontal bending of Cable 2 2.781 o
Position of Cable
Cable Anchorage Location of vertical Bending
No. X Y Z X Y Z
1 0.000 0.000 0.400 3.100 0.000 0.125
2 0.000 0.000 0.900 7.600 -0.170 0.125
3 0.000 0.000 1.40 10.600 0.000 0.125
135 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 1 19 T13
Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ) Force after
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss
slip loss (kN)
(kN)
1 2732.90 2434.31
1-2 3.112 0.00 0.000 1.0062
2 2715.95 2451.26
2-3 4.503 5.782 0.101 1.0265
3 2645.81 2521.40
3-4 6.405 2.781 0.049 1.0213
4 2590.67 2576.54
Cable 2 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2428.08
1-2 3.116 0.00 0.000 1.0063
2 2715.93 2445.06
2-3 4.527 6.452 0.113 1.0286
3 2640.41 2520.57
3-4 6.405 2.781 0.049 1.0213
4 2585.38 2585.38
3.116 4.527 6.405
2732.90 2715.93
1 2 2640.41 2585.38
= 3
= 2575.60 4
2445.06 2520.57
2428.08 6.405
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2575.60 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 3 = 6.405 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.32 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.32 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.000 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = 28.095 m
Extension of cable = 108.03 mm
136 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Cable 3 19 T13
Force after Force after
Length (l) in Deflection Angle (φ)
Node Link
meter Degree Radian e (µφ+kl) friction loss slip loss
(kN) (kN)
1 2732.90 2488.07
1-2 10.676 0.00 0.000 1.0216
2 2675.17 2545.80
2-3 3.405 6.859 0.120 1.0275
3 2603.49 2603.49
10.676 3.405
2732.90 2675.17
1 2 2603.49
= 3
= 2610.49
2545.80 3.073
2488.07
Force Diagram before & after Slip Loss
Assume Force of zero slip = 2610.485 kN
Point of Zero Slip from node 1 = 3.073 m
Area of Shaded Portion = ExAx∆L = 2196.324 kN-m
Area of Shaded Portion = 2196.324 kN-m
Diferance of these two forces = 2196.32-2196.32 = 0.00 kN-m
Hence O.K.
Length of Cable = (10.676+3.405)x2 = 28.163 m
Extension of cable at each side = 109.42 mm
7.2.2 Summary of Cable Forces after Friction & Slip at different Points
Position Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Cable No 0.500 3.476 6.953 10.429 13.905
Cable 1 2437.03 2453.25 2511.07 2545.62 2576.54
Vert. angle 5.069 5.069 5.069 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 0.000 0.000
C.G. 0.356 0.125 0.125 0.125 0.125
Cable 2 2430.81 2447.02 2509.06 2548.77 2585.38
Vert. angle 5.823 5.823 5.823 0.000 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 2.781 2.781 0.000
C. G. 0.849 0.546 0.191 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Normal 4845.76 4878.05 4991.48 5091.38 5161.92
at first stage
CG of Cable 0.602 0.335 0.158 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Per.
461.94 465.02 475.86 0.00 0.00
Cable 3 2490.77 2506.87 2525.66 2544.46 2603.49
Vert. angle 6.859 6.859 6.859 6.859 0.000
Hor. angle 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
C. G. 1.340 0.982 0.564 0.125 0.125
Total cable
forces Normal 2472.94 2488.92 2507.59 2526.25 2603.49
CG of Cable 1.340 0.982 0.564 0.125 0.125
Total cable
297.45 299.38 301.62 303.87 0.00
forces CG
Overall Per.of
Cable 0.851 0.553 0.294 0.125 0.125
% loss 10.2 % 9.7 % 8.0 % 6.8 % 5.3 %
7.2.3 Length of Cables and Extension at each End
Total Length Extension at each End
Cable No
(m) (mm)
Cable 1 28.041 107.96
Cable 2 28.095 108.03
Cable 3 28.163 109.42
137 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
138 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
7.3.1.2 Loss due to Relaxation of Steel (clause no. 6.3.6 of IRC 112-2011)
Total Relaxation Loss at service condition = 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Initial force after Friction, slip & ES loss (4736+2x(4768+4882+4982)+5052)/8 = 4881.43 kN
Percentage of Initial force = 0.699 UTS
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel = 2.49 % of initial force
Relaxation Loss at 1000hr. for low relaxation steel 4881.43/2x2.49/100 = 60.80 kN/Cable
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing as per Table 6.2 of IRC 112-2011, = 37 % of Total Loss
5 - 28 days Loss 23 days 552 = 42.00 % of Total Loss
28 - 60 days Loss 32 days 768 = 21.00 % of Total Loss
60 - 90 days Loss 30 days = 0.00 % of Total Loss
90 - α days Loss = 200.0 % of Total Loss
i.e. 3 x (1000 hr. value)
Immediate Loss i.e 1 hr. of stressing = 22.50 kN/Cable
5 - 28 days Loss = 25.54 kN/Cable
28 - 60 days Loss = 12.77 kN/Cable
60 - 90 days Loss = 0.00 kN/Cable
90-α days Loss = 121.60 kN/Cable
Total = 182.40 kN/Cable
182.399 6.67 %
139 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
140 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
7.3.3. Sustained Stress of precast girder at 60 days after Casting of Deck with X-Girder
Losses for first 3 cables:- Losses for last 1 cable:-
Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable Shrinkage = 16.02 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 12.77 kN/Cable Relaxation = 38.30 kN/Cable
Creep = 36.21 kN/Cable Creep = 36.21 kN/Cable
Total = 65.00 kN/Cable Total = 90.54 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 65.00 kN/Cable actual time dependent losses = 90.54 kN/Cable
Total Loss of 3 Cables = 220.54 kN Actual Loss of third Cables = 90.54 kN
Depth of Precast Girder = 1.775 m
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Precast Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 0.928 m Area = 1.444 m
4 4
I= 0.354 m I= 0.412 m
CG = 0.962 m CG = 0.948 m
+ + =
< 20.00
Mpa
17.63 Mpa -0.74 Mpa -6.12 Mpa 10.78 Mpa Hence O.K.
Resultant Stress at 28 Stress due to loss between 28 Stress due to DL of Slab & Resultant Stress at 60
days to 60 days wt of shuttering days
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Precast Girder at 60 days of Casting of Girder
141 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Midspan = Sectional Properties of Composite Girder at Support =
2 2
Area = 1.603 m Area = 2.119 m
4 4
I= 0.692 m I= 0.821 m
CG = 1.352 m CG = 1.247 m
Losses:- Shrinkage = 11.19 kN/Cable
Relaxation = 0.00 kN/Cable
Creep = 15.43 kN/Cable
Total = 26.62 kN/Cable
Total Loss = 79.86 kN/Cable
actual time dependent losses = 79.86 kN
Total Stress
Stress due Loss of CG of Cables Stress due Moment due due to Total Stress at
Section
at 60 days Cables from soffit to loss to SIDL SIDL Stress cable CG
(Mpa) (kN) (m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab 0.00 -0.01 -0.29 -0.30
Top of girder 3.44 -0.02 -318.62 -0.20 3.22
End -79.86 0.851 4.72
Bottom 5.71 -0.09 0.48 6.11
Top of slab 0.00 0.01 0.04 0.05
Top of girder 5.75 -0.01 46.00 0.03 5.76
L/8 -79.86 0.553 7.54
Bottom 8.60 -0.17 -0.09 8.34
Top of slab 0.00 0.03 0.09 0.12
Top of girder 4.95 0.00 100.59 0.06 5.02
L/4 -79.86 0.294 8.71
Bottom 9.85 -0.22 -0.20 9.44
Top of slab 0.00 0.04 0.13 0.17
Top of girder 4.12 0.01 136.35 0.08 4.21
3L/8 -79.86 0.125 10.16
Bottom 11.12 -0.24 -0.27 10.61
Top of slab 0.00 0.04 0.09 0.13
Top of girder 4.70 0.01 91.92 0.06 4.77
L/2 -79.86 0.125 9.96
Bottom 10.78 -0.24 -0.18 10.35
Average stress at 90 days = (4.72+2x(7.54+8.71+10.16)+9.96)/8 = 8.44 Mpa
0.00 Mpa 0.04 0.09 Mpa 0.13 Mpa
4.70 0.01 Mpa 0.06 4.77 Mpa
Mpa Mpa
+ + =
142 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
+ =
Total Stress
Section Total Stress Stress due Stress due to at α days
without live Total Live Load 0.6 x Wind load to Live Load wind Load with live load
load (Mpa) Moment(kN-m) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -1.25 -2.05 -0.13 -3.43
Top of girder 2.43 -2232.49 -143.62 -1.43 -0.09 0.90
End
Bottom 6.58 3.39 0.22 10.19
Top of slab -0.63 -1.36 0.03 -1.96
Top of girder 5.20 -1449.89 32.94 -0.89 0.02 4.33
L/8
Bottom 8.77 2.83 -0.06 11.54
Top of slab -0.32 0.50 0.04 0.22
Top of girder 4.63 538.10 41.22 0.33 0.03 4.98
L/4
Bottom 9.46 -1.05 -0.08 8.33
Top of slab -0.11 1.28 0.08 1.25
Top of girder 3.93 1365.01 84.95 0.84 0.05 4.82
3L/8
Bottom 10.37 -2.67 -0.17 7.53
Top of slab -0.14 1.69 0.09 1.64
Top of girder 4.50 1802.62 98.24 1.10 0.06 5.66
L/2
Bottom 10.09 -3.52 -0.19 6.37
143 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Diagram at Midspan of Composite Girder with SIDL & Live Load at α days
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 5.7 Mpa
Permissible Tensile stress in concrete at service = -1.41 Mpa > -3.4 Mpa
Tension reinforcement at top of support are provided
7.3.7 Summary of Stresses for Precast girder only
Sectional Properties of Precast Girder
Precast Girder Midspan Support Composite Girder Midspan Support
Area = 0.928 1.444 m2 Area = 1.603 2.119 m2
I= 0.354 0.412 m4 I= 0.692 0.821 m4
CG = 0.962 0.948 m CG = 1.352 1.247 m
Z Top of slab = 1.067 1.091 3
m
Z Top = 0.436 0.499 m3 Z Top = 1.635 1.556 m3
Zbottom = 0.368 0.435 m3 Zbottom = 0.512 0.658 m3
DL Moment
Moment due to
Stress Prestressing force & Loss
Section earth pr. Diff Prestress CG of cables Loss of pre. Loss of Moment due Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa)
settle, creep, (kN) (m) Girder (kN) comp. girder to (Mpa)
Top of slab snow (kN-m) -1.06 -F=103.33 -0.99
Top of girder -0.74 2.47
End -1.63 -1153.6 7318.71 0.851 -603.52 -1375.95 -975.13
Bottom 1.76 6.20
Top of slab -1.27 -F=109.50 -0.66
Top of girder 3.17 0.24
L/8 1740.61 -1353.2 7366.98 0.553 -603.52 -1375.95 -961.26
Bottom -2.08 13.74
Top of slab -1.12 -F=112.33 -0.32
Top of girder 6.06 -3.62
L/4 2961.41 -1196.7 7499.07 0.294 -603.52 -1375.95 -953.11
Bottom -5.70 18.18
Top of slab -0.19 -F=112.95 -0.09
Top of girder 8.38 -6.24
3L/8 3706.92 -203.2 7617.64 0.125 -603.52 -1375.95 -943.47
Bottom -9.67 21.27
Top of slab -0.48 -F=114.68 -0.08
Top of girder 8.81 -6.36
L/2 3977.16 -510.0 7765.41 0.125 -603.52 -1375.95 -932.54
Bottom -9.81 21.74
Section SIDL Live load Wind load - loaded structure Temp (+ve) Temp (-ve)
Moment Stress Moment (kN- Stress Moment Stress Stress Stress
(kN-m) (Mpa) m) (Mpa) (kN-m) (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa)
Top of slab -0.68 -2.05 -0.13 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder -0.48 -1.43 -0.09 -1.10 0.90
End -743.94 -2232.49 -143.62
Bottom 1.13 3.39 0.22 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.15 -1.36 0.03 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.10 -0.89 0.02 -1.10 0.90
L/8 163.86 -1449.89 32.94
Bottom -0.32 2.83 -0.06 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.18 0.50 0.04 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.12 0.33 0.03 -1.10 0.90
L/4 193.95 538.10 41.22
Bottom -0.38 -1.05 -0.08 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.34 1.28 0.08 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.22 0.84 0.05 -1.10 0.90
3L/8 361.02 1365.01 84.95
Bottom -0.71 -2.67 -0.17 1.67 -2.39
Top of slab 0.35 1.69 0.09 4.32 -2.50
Top of girder 0.23 1.10 0.06 -1.10 0.90
L/2 368.54 1802.62 98.24
Bottom -0.72 -3.52 -0.19 1.67 -2.39
144 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 1 1 0.75 0.75 1
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 1 1
Temp (+ve) 0.6
Temp (-ve)
145 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 5 (b) 5 (c ) 5 (d) 6 (a) 6 (b) 6 (c) 6 (c) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -2.09 -6.32 -6.18 0.01 0.15 -6.80 -6.67 0.15 -6.80
Top of girder -1.10 0.01 0.10 -1.27 -1.18 0.73 0.82 1.00 -1.27
End
Bottom 12.86 10.65 10.42 12.90 12.67 8.84 8.62 13.08 8.46
Top of slab -0.48 -4.54 -4.57 1.62 1.59 -5.20 -5.23 1.62 -5.23
Top of girder 1.94 3.16 3.14 1.74 1.72 3.74 3.72 3.74 1.72
L/8
Bottom 13.80 11.30 11.37 13.69 13.76 9.64 9.70 13.80 9.64
Top of slab 1.87 -2.18 -2.22 3.51 3.47 -3.31 -3.35 3.51 -3.35
Top of girder 2.59 3.81 3.79 2.09 2.07 4.09 4.07 4.09 2.07
L/4
Bottom 10.23 7.72 7.79 11.08 11.16 7.03 7.10 11.16 7.03
Top of slab 3.94 -0.09 -0.15 5.41 5.34 -1.41 -1.47 5.41 -1.47
Top of girder 3.16 4.40 4.36 2.55 2.51 4.55 4.51 4.55 2.51
3L/8
Bottom 7.10 4.52 4.66 8.29 8.43 4.23 4.37 8.76 4.23
Top of slab 4.08 0.05 -0.01 5.45 5.38 -1.37 -1.44 5.45 -1.44
Top of girder 3.76 5.00 4.96 3.09 3.04 5.09 5.04 5.09 3.04
L/2
Bottom 6.52 3.94 4.09 7.92 8.07 3.87 4.01 9.04 3.87
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -2.97 -2.83 -3.05 -2.91 -5.09 -4.96 -4.64 -4.50 -2.43
Top of girder 1.40 1.49 1.34 1.44 -0.09 0.00 0.23 0.32 -0.70
End
Bottom 9.93 9.70 10.06 9.83 13.45 13.22 12.69 12.46 14.32
Top of slab -1.81 -1.84 -1.79 -1.82 -3.15 -3.18 -2.80 -2.83 -0.58
Top of girder 3.55 3.53 3.57 3.55 2.68 2.66 2.91 2.89 2.01
L/8
Bottom 12.65 12.71 12.61 12.67 15.44 15.51 14.71 14.77 16.48
Top of slab -1.25 -1.29 -1.23 -1.27 -0.72 -0.76 -0.84 -0.87 1.84
Top of girder 2.22 2.20 2.24 2.21 2.57 2.54 2.49 2.47 1.89
L/4
Bottom 13.84 13.92 13.79 13.87 12.74 12.82 12.97 13.05 13.79
Top of slab 0.12 0.05 0.16 0.10 1.44 1.38 1.16 1.09 3.98
Top of girder 1.78 1.73 1.81 1.77 2.65 2.60 2.46 2.41 1.95
3L/8
Bottom 12.88 13.02 12.78 12.92 10.11 10.25 10.71 10.85 11.21
Top of slab -0.15 -0.22 -0.10 -0.16 1.59 1.52 1.21 1.14 4.13
Top of girder 2.09 2.04 2.12 2.08 3.23 3.18 2.97 2.93 2.53
L/2
Bottom 13.25 13.39 13.13 13.28 9.61 9.75 10.41 10.56 10.72
146 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -2.29 -6.52 -6.38 -0.19 -0.05 -7.00 -6.87 -0.05 -7.00
Top of girder -0.60 0.50 0.60 -0.78 -0.68 1.22 1.31 1.49 -0.78
End
Bottom 14.09 11.89 11.66 14.14 13.91 10.08 9.86 14.32 9.70
Top of slab -0.61 -4.67 -4.70 1.49 1.45 -5.33 -5.36 1.49 -5.36
Top of girder 1.99 3.21 3.19 1.79 1.77 3.79 3.77 3.79 1.77
L/8
Bottom 16.55 14.05 14.11 16.44 16.51 12.39 12.45 16.55 12.39
Top of slab 1.80 -2.25 -2.28 3.44 3.41 -3.37 -3.41 3.44 -3.41
Top of girder 1.87 3.09 3.07 1.37 1.34 3.37 3.34 3.37 1.34
L/4
Bottom 13.87 11.36 11.43 14.72 14.80 10.66 10.74 14.80 10.66
Top of slab 3.92 -0.10 -0.17 5.39 5.32 -1.42 -1.49 5.39 -1.49
Top of girder 1.91 3.15 3.11 1.31 1.26 3.30 3.26 3.30 1.26
3L/8
Bottom 11.35 8.77 8.91 12.54 12.68 8.49 8.63 13.02 8.49
Top of slab 4.06 0.04 -0.03 5.43 5.36 -1.38 -1.45 5.43 -1.45
Top of girder 2.49 3.73 3.68 1.81 1.77 3.81 3.77 3.81 1.77
L/2
Bottom 10.87 8.29 8.43 12.27 12.42 8.22 8.36 13.39 8.22
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 16.5 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = -2.12 Mpa < 3.87 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= -2.12 Mpa < 1.26 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
7.3.9 Load Combination for frequent Combination (SL2) - for prestressing member
1) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress
2) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+ wind load(lead) (unloaded structure)
3) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+wind load (accompany)
4) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+wind load (lead)
5) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(lead)+Temperature(accompany)
6) Dead load +SIDL+Prestress+Live load(accompany)+Temperature(lead)
a) Load combination
Load Case 1 (a) 1 (b) 2 (a) 2 (b) 3 (a) 3 (b) 4 (a) 4 (b) 5 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
Load Case 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
DL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
SIDL 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2 1 1.2
Prestress 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
Live load 0.75 0.75 0.2 0.2 0.75
Wind load 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6
Temp (+ve) 0.5
Temp (-ve)
147 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 7 (a) 7 (b) 8 (a) 8 (b) 9 (a) 9 (b) 10 (a) 10 (b) 11 (a)
Top of slab -2.97 -2.83 -3.05 -2.91 -4.57 -4.43 -3.46 -3.32 -2.35
Top of girder 1.40 1.49 1.34 1.44 0.27 0.37 1.05 1.15 -0.23
End
Bottom 9.93 9.70 10.06 9.83 12.58 12.36 10.74 10.51 13.31
Top of slab -1.81 -1.84 -1.79 -1.82 -2.82 -2.85 -2.06 -2.10 -0.67
Top of girder 3.55 3.53 3.57 3.55 2.90 2.88 3.39 3.37 2.34
L/8
Bottom 12.65 12.71 12.61 12.67 14.74 14.81 13.18 13.24 15.61
Top of slab -1.25 -1.29 -1.23 -1.27 -0.85 -0.89 -1.13 -1.16 1.28
Top of girder 2.22 2.20 2.24 2.21 2.48 2.46 2.30 2.28 1.92
L/4
Bottom 13.84 13.92 13.79 13.87 13.01 13.09 13.58 13.66 13.89
Top of slab 0.12 0.05 0.16 0.10 1.12 1.05 0.42 0.35 3.23
Top of girder 1.78 1.73 1.81 1.77 2.43 2.39 1.98 1.93 1.86
3L/8
Bottom 12.88 13.02 12.78 12.92 10.79 10.93 12.24 12.38 11.71
Top of slab -0.15 -0.22 -0.10 -0.16 1.16 1.09 0.24 0.17 3.27
Top of girder 2.09 2.04 2.12 2.08 2.94 2.90 2.34 2.30 2.36
L/2
Bottom 13.25 13.39 13.13 13.28 10.51 10.65 12.43 12.57 11.44
148 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Section 11 (b) 11 (c) 11 (d) 12 (a) 12 (b) 12 (c) 12 (d) Max comp.Max Tension
Top of slab -2.21 -5.75 -5.62 -0.79 -0.65 -4.88 -4.74 -0.65 -5.75
Top of girder -0.13 0.77 0.87 0.45 0.55 1.65 1.74 1.74 -0.23
End
Bottom 13.08 11.28 11.05 11.61 11.38 9.17 8.95 13.31 8.95
Top of slab -0.70 -4.08 -4.11 0.51 0.48 -3.58 -3.61 0.51 -4.11
Top of girder 2.32 3.34 3.32 2.72 2.70 3.92 3.90 3.92 2.32
L/8
Bottom 15.67 13.58 13.64 14.22 14.28 11.78 11.85 15.67 11.78
Top of slab 1.25 -2.12 -2.16 1.44 1.40 -2.65 -2.69 1.44 -2.69
Top of girder 1.89 2.92 2.89 1.63 1.60 2.83 2.80 2.92 1.60
L/4
Bottom 13.96 11.86 11.93 14.63 14.71 12.20 12.27 14.71 11.86
Top of slab 3.17 -0.17 -0.24 2.96 2.89 -1.13 -1.20 3.23 -1.20
Top of girder 1.81 2.85 2.81 1.29 1.24 2.48 2.44 2.85 1.24
3L/8
Bottom 11.85 9.68 9.82 13.34 13.48 10.91 11.05 13.48 9.68
Top of slab 3.21 -0.13 -0.20 2.78 2.71 -1.31 -1.38 3.27 -1.38
Top of girder 2.32 3.36 3.32 1.65 1.60 2.85 2.80 3.36 1.60
L/2
Bottom 11.58 9.41 9.55 13.54 13.69 11.11 11.25 13.69 9.41
Permissible compressive stress in concrete at service = 0.48 x fck = 19.20 Mpa > 15.7 Mpa
Permissible concreteTensile stress at bottom of girder at service = 0.00 Mpa < 5.06 Mpa Hence O.K.
Permissible concrete Tensile stress at top of girder at service= 0.00 Mpa < 1.24 Mpa Hence O.K.
except at support
7.4 Check for ultimate strength of girder in Flexure :-
Grade of concrete = M40 Modulus of elasticity of concrete E = 33346 MPa
Design yield strength fpd = 17.87 MPa Modulus of elasticity of steel = 195.00 Gpa
3000 0.00350 17.87
225 7920 kN
183.34
NA NA
2000 300
149 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
NA NA
2000
186.85
8012 kN
0.00350 17.87
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
750
Grade Concrete = M40 Grade of steel = Fe 500
Width of the section = 3000 mm Depth of the section = 2000 mm
Clear Cover = 40 mm Main dia of bar used = 25 mm
Dia of shear reinf. = 16 mm Effective depth, d = 1819 mm
R = Mu/bd2 = 0.777 MPa Negative Design Moment = 7713 kN-m
Mu,Lim/bd2 = 0.133xfck = 5.32 MPa Ast = 9976.8 mm2
Lower fractile tensile fctm = 2.12 MPa Where, pt = fck/(2*fy)*(1-sqrt(1-(4.598*R/fck))*100
Min. reinforcement 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 7094.1 mm2
Hence provide 25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf. Ast = 18427.9 mm2
25 dia @ 225 c/c Slab Top reinf.
16 dia @ 113 c/c Slab Bottom reinf.
Bottom reinf. 16 Nos. 25 dia (50% of main reinforcement)
E of reinforcement = 200000 MPa Max strain in concrete = 0.0035
E of concrete = 33346 MPa Min strain in steel = 0.0042
Balanced neutral axis depth = 829.51 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 186.85 mm
Strain in steel = 0.0306 Stress in steel = 434.8 MPa
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 8012 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 8012 kN
Compressive force CG 77.73 mm Moment of resistance = 13951 kNm
> 7713 kNm Hence O.K.
Factor of safety = 13,951/7,713 = 1.81
150 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
vi) As per clause no 6.3.2 of IS-13920 :1993, Shear force due to ductile detailing shall be
Vua = Va D+L - 1.4(MuAh+MuBs)/L
D+L
Va = 1.2(D+L)/2 = 1542.03 kN
MuAh = -7713.35 kN
MuBs = -3705.63 kN
L = 26.31 m
Vua = 2150 kN
Maximum design shear at support > 2063 kN
151 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
ii) Shear Capacity of Uncracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
The shear resistance of the beam section uncracked in flexure is given below:-
VRd,c = ( I * bwc )/ S x √ (fctd2 + k1 σcp fctd)
Where, I = Moment of inertia bwc= Width of beam after deduction due to duct
S = First moment of area between cetroidal axis and extreme compression fibre about the centrodial axis.
fctd = design tensile strength of concrete = fctk/γm = 1.41 Mpa
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Prestress Force after all losses (kN) 5384.8 5433.0 5565.1 5683.7 5831.5
Effective width of the Web 750 300 300 300 300
Effective Depth of the Section (d) 1149 1447 1706 1875 1875
Stress due to Prestress (σcp) 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573 3.573
Design tensile strength of the Concrete (fctd) 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41 1.41
First moment of inertia about the CG (S) 2.45E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09 1.75E+09
Transmission length factor, k1 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Moment of Inertia (I) (mm4) 8.2E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11 6.9E+11
Design Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 666.7 315.7 315.7 315.7 315.7
iii) Summary of the Shear resistance of the Beam when shear reinforcement isn't required :
The maximum shear capacity of the Beam as cl.10.3.2 (5) of IRC 112-2010
VEd ≤ 0.50 bw d ν fcd where, ν = 0.60 [ 1 - fck/310]
Description Support L/8 L/4 3L/8 L/2
Distance from bearing in m 0.00 3.48 6.95 10.43 13.91
Distance modification factor β for Precast Beam 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Distance modification factor β for Composite 0.25 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Effective Shear for Precast Beam 2149.7 1640.5 1321.2 809.0 578.0
Effective Shear for Composite Section (kN) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective Shear due to prestressing force (kN) 539.0 544.0 557.7 218.8 0.0
Total Shear force for the Beam (kN) 1610.6 1096.5 763.6 590.2 578.0
Precast member Area (m2) 1.44 0.93 0.93 0.93 0.93
Zb (m3) 0.44 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.37
Composite member Area (m2) 2.12 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60
Zb (m3) 0.66 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51
Stress due to prestress at tensile fibre σ bpt (MPa) 3.5520 1.0022 -3.3427 -6.2744 -6.3998
Section at Maximum Bending Moment Uncracked Uncracked Cracked Cracked Cracked
Shear capacity of Beam Section (kN) 666.69 315.69 430.44 470.00 470.01
Maximum shear capacity of the Section (kN) 4022 2026 2390 2626 2626
Whether shear reinforcement required or not Required Required Required Required Required
152 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
153 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
ρ = As/Aj where As is the area of reinforcement, Aj is the interface area of the joint
ν1 = Coeff accounting stress in compression chord = 0.60
α = the angle of the reinforcement to the interface = 90.00 degree
fcd = αcc*fck/γm where, αcc =0.67 and γm = 1.5 = 17.87 Mpa
154 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
A -0.00013
B 4 3.476 1.738 -0.00018 -0.00016 -0.00095196
C 3 3.476 5.214 -0.00020 -0.00019 -0.003500985
D 2 3.476 8.691 -0.00019 -0.00019 -0.005874165
E 1 3.476 12.167 -0.00018 -0.00018 -0.007656065
Total -0.017983175
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress + wt of precast Girder = = -18 mm
= - L/ 1546
(iii) Precast Girder - Prestress + wt of precast Girder +wt of deck slab at 60 days
Section At support Near L/8 At L/4 At 3L/8 At L/2
Distance 0.000 3.476 6.953 10.429 13.905
CG of all cables from bot.(m) 0.851 0.553 0.294 0.125 0.125
Loss 220.541 220.541 220.541 220.541 220.541
Moment due to prestressing losses 21.370 90.133 147.400 184.613 184.624
Moment due to Wt of Deck Slab -0.504 699.647 1204.726 1514.731 1629.662
Total moment due to prestress+DL 20.866 789.781 1352.126 1699.344 1814.286
M/EI (1/m) 0.0000015 0.0000669 0.0001145 0.0001439 0.00015
3.5 3.476 3.476 3.476
A B C D E
0.000002 0.0000669 0.0001439
4 0.0001145 0.0001536
3 1
2
M/EI Diagram for Ist Stage Prestress after losses at 60 days
155 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
At Midspan
Average
Section Marked Distance CG from A M/EI Moment of M/EI about A Rotation
M/EI
A 0.0000015
B 4 3.476 1.738 0.0000669 0.0000342 0.000206587 0.00140
C 3 3.476 5.214 0.0001145 0.0000907 0.001643523
D 2 3.476 8.691 0.0001439 0.0001292 0.003902411
E 1 3.476 12.167 0.0001536 0.0001487 0.00629083
Total 0.01204335
So, Midspan deflection due to Prestress losses + DL = = 12.043 mm
Total Deflection at 60 days =-27.087+12.043 = -15.043 mm
156 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
157 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
158 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
8.1.2 Summary of Bending Moment & Shear Force for outer girder
a) Bending Moment (kNm) Moment Shear
Staad Node no 62 63 62 63
Dead load = 10.2 -19.4 -3.1 3.1
SIDL (DL) from staad output 378.5 -331.5 15.6 -15.6
SIDL (WC) from staad output -36.9 32.1 -1.6 1.6
Removal of shutter 0.3 0.0 0.1 -0.1
Earth pressure -1.2 1.2 0.0 0.0
Live load surcharge 0.3 0.7 0.3 -0.3
Wind load (unloaded structure) 11.4 -14.3 -1.0 1.0
Wind load (loaded structure) 5.9 -7.4 -0.5 0.5
Differential settlement 1.2 0.5 0.6 -0.6
Temperature rise 0.4 0.1 0.2 -0.2
Temperature fall -0.6 0.4 -0.1 0.1
Creep & shrinkage 10.2 -11.0 -0.2 0.2
Footpath live load 108.1 -63.7 14.8 -14.8
Snow load 4.0 -2.6 0.5 -0.5
Braking load 0.1 0.2 0.1 -0.1
Live Load 333.9 -793.5 140.8 -140.9
Seismic in X- direction 37.4 -40.6 3.5 -3.5
Seismic in Y- direction 18.7 -30.7 6.8 -6.8
Seismic in Z- direction 26.3 -39.2 10.7 -10.7
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. -0.7 0.8 0.0 0.0
Dynamic increment of LL Surcharge 0.2 0.4 0.2 -0.2
159 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Moment Shear
1 1129.6 -1718.3 247.0 -247.1
2 (a) 483.5 -454.3 12.0 -12.0
2 (b) 373.3 -351.6 8.9 -8.9
3 (a) 1139.9 -1731.2 246.1 -246.3
3 (b) 1029.6 -1628.5 243.0 -243.2
4 (a) 992.0 -1439.8 191.1 -191.2
4 (b) 881.7 -1337.1 188.0 -188.1
5 (a) 1130.0 -1718.2 247.1 -247.3
5 (b) 1019.7 -1615.5 244.0 -244.2
6 (a) 975.5 -1418.2 192.8 -192.9
6 (b) 865.2 -1315.5 189.7 -189.8
7 (a) 631.5 -697.1 57.7 -57.8
7 (b) 611.9 -686.6 61.3 -61.3 (+)ve
7 (c) 619.9 -695.5 65.3 -65.3 value of
7 (d) 520.9 -594.0 54.6 -54.6 seismic
7 (e) 501.3 -583.5 58.2 -58.2 force
7 (f) 509.3 -592.4 62.2 -62.2
7 (a) 479.0 -512.2 31.5 -31.5
7 (b) 498.5 -522.6 27.9 -28.0 (-)ve
7 (c) 490.5 -513.8 23.9 -23.9 value of
7 (d) 368.3 -409.1 28.3 -28.4 seismic
7 (e) 387.9 -419.5 24.8 -24.8 force
7 (f) 379.9 -410.7 20.8 -20.8
Maximum 1139.9 -351.6 247.1 -8.9
Minimum 368.3 -1731.2 8.9 -247.3
1(a) 1 1 1.2 1
1(b) 1 1 1 1
2 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 1
3 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1 0.6
3 (b) 1 1 1 1 1 0.6
4 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 0.75 1
4 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.75 1
5 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1 0.6
5 (b) 1 1 1 1 1 0.6
6 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 0.75 1
6 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.75 1
Quasi-permanent (SL3)
1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (a) 1 1.2 1 1 0.5
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.5
160 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
161 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
162 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Balanced neutral axis depth = = 535.16 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 385.91 mm
Strain in steel = 0.00133 Stress in steel = 266.9 MPa
Comp. stress of concrete = 13.58 Mpa
Stress-strain diagram at Serviceability Limit State condition
0.00041 13.58
786.17
385.91
NA NA
786.17
0.00133
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok =
Total compressive force = 786.17 kN Total tensile force = 786.17 kN
Compressive force CG = 128.64 mm Moment of resistance = 1196.45 kNm
163 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
8.5.2. Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 111.20 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 5.998
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]=
248.8 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.039
fct,eff = = 2.12 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.00039
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000334
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 50 mm
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 25.0 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 277.7 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.108 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Inner Cross girder
Description At support Span
Stress in steel, σs 120.6 111.2
As 2945.2 2945.2
Actual NA 386 386
hc,eff 248.8 248.8
ρp,eff 0.039 0.039
εsm-εcm 0.00044 0.00039
φeq 25.0 25.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 277.7 277.7
Crack width, Wk 0.121 0.108
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
7.6. Side face reinforcement
Minimum main reinf. 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 643.70 mm2
Side face reinf. 0.1% bd = 495.15 mm2
Hence provide 7 Nos. 16 dia on each span Ast = 2814.9 mm2
164 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
165 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
300 2103 mm
2253 mm
166 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1.500 3 3 3 2.253
4.57
0.84 0.840
2.9
2.06
2.06
1.5
1.50 3 3 3 2.25
70R- Track Loading position over Deck for maximum moment
Centre to centre distance between X-gider b = 2.347 m
Span L = 3 m
Total Load = 700 kN
Impact Factor = 25 %
Dispersion of load along direction of movement
As per Annexure B-3 of IRC 112:2011 bef = α a(1-a/L)+b1
b/L = 0.78 α = 2.6
a1 = 1.5 m
Thickness of W/C = 65 mm Thick. of Deck slab = 225 mm
b1 =4.57+0.065x2 = 4.70 m
bef 1 = 6.650 m
=10/((0.86-0.05)x5.273x10) 1.22
0.234
0.86 0.86
2.79
1.93
Position of 70R Wheel bogie load
167 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1.93
1.5
1.50 3 3 3 1.50
70R- Track Loading position over Deck for maximum moment
Total Load = 400 kN
Impact Factor = 25 %
Dispersion of load along direction of movement
As per Annexure B-3 of IRC 112:2011 bef = α a(1-a/L)+b1
α = 2.6 a = 1.5 m
Thickness of W/C = 65 mm Thick. of Deck slab = 225 mm
b1 =0.234+0.065x2 = 0.364 m
bef = 2.314 m
> 1.220 m Overlaps.
Modified bef =2.314+1.22 = 3.534 m
1.2
0.250
0.5 0.50
2.3
1.8
Position of Class-A loading
1.50 3 3 3 1.50
70R- Track Loading position over Deck for maximum moment
Each Axle load = 114 kN
Impact Factor = 50 %
Dispersion of load along direction of movement
As per Annexure B-3 of IRC 112:2011 bef = α a(1-a/L)+b1
α = 2.6 For Ist Wheel a = 1.500 m
Thickness of W/C = 65 mm Thick. of Deck slab = 225 mm
b1 =0.250+0.065x2 = 0.380 m bef = 2.030 m
> 1.200 m Overlaps.
Modified bef1 = 3.230 m
168 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
169 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
48 0.0069 854 kN
1000 Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
170 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
395.33
0.00101
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok =
Total compressive force = 395.33 kN Total tensile force = 395.33 kN
Compressive force CG = 17.95 mm Moment of resistance = 62.88 kNm
171 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
9.5.2. Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 201.34 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 5.998
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 112.5 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.017
fct,eff = = 2.12 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.000671
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000604
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 40 mm
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 14.3 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 275.1 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.185 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Tranverse section of slab
Description End Inner
Span
support support
Stress in steel, σs 201.3 66.2 142.7
As 1963.5 1413.7 1413.7
Actual NA 54 47 47
hc,eff 112.5 112.5 112.5
ρp,eff 0.017 0.013 0.013
εsm-εcm 0.00067 0.00020 0.00043
φeq 14.3 12.0 12.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 275.1 298.3 298.3
Crack width, Wk 0.185 0.059 0.128
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
172 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Design of Column
173 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
174 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
175 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
176 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Stress
177 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Stress
178 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Minimum area of Shear reinf. reqd Asw/s (mm2/mm) 11.971 11.971 11.971
Area of shear reinforcement provided (mm) 6606.90 6606.90 6606.90
Spacing of stirrups provided (mm) 100.000 150.000 100.000
Area of shear reinf provided Asw/s (mm2/mm) 66.069 44.046 66.069
Angle of compression strut θ (degrees) 23.84 19.27 23.84
Shear resistance provided by reinf V RD,s (kN) 85070 71684 85070
Coeff accounting stress in comp chord αcw 1.000 1.000 1.000
Shear capacity of compression strut V RD,max (kN) 85070 71684 85070
Difference in shear resistance (kN) 0.0 0.0 0.0
Shear capacity of the Section (kN) 85070 71684 85070
Factor of Safety associated with failure 3.65 3.26 3.81
Longitudinal tensile force ∆Ftd (kN) 26373 31420 25261
Area of steel required for shear due stut & tie model 60658 72266 58100
179 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1(a) 1 1 1.2 1
1(b) 1 1 1 1
2 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 1
3 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1 0.8 0.6
3 (b) 1 1 1 1 1 0.8 0.6
4 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 0.75 0.8 1
4 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.75 0.8 1
5 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1 0.8 0.6
5 (b) 1 1 1 1 1 0.8 0.6
6 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 0.75 0.8 1
6 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.75 0.8 1
9.1.3.2 Load Combination for Quasi-permanent (SL3) - for RCC structure
1) Dead load +SIDL
2) Dead load +SIDL+Temperature(lead)
Wind on
DL, Support Wind on loaded
Load Case SIDL(WC) Earth pr. Earth pr. Live load unloaded Temperature
settle structure
structure
1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (a) 1 1.2 1 1 0.5
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.5
Rare Combination
Bottom support section Midspan section Top support section
Load Case V (kN) M (kN-m) V (kN) M (kN-m) V (kN) M (kN-m)
1(a) -14157.97 22694.34 -8056.90 24205.46 -3259.34 3264.73
1(b) -14093.70 22792.42 -8121.18 24280.98 -3323.61 3523.71
2 (a) -14587.51 22224.73 -7627.37 23626.43 -2829.81 1561.31
2 (b) -14523.24 22322.82 -7691.64 23701.95 -2894.08 1820.29
3 (a) -15931.39 31205.13 -9663.26 23952.84 -5120.13 4481.68
3 (b) -15867.12 31303.21 -9727.53 24028.35 -5184.40 4740.66
4 (a) -15583.37 30441.67 -9166.33 23931.18 -4559.59 4127.00
4 (b) -15519.10 30539.76 -9230.61 24006.70 -4623.87 4385.98
5 (a) -15799.25 32923.11 -9795.40 23868.28 -5252.27 6131.19
5 (b) -15734.97 33021.20 -9859.68 23943.80 -5316.54 6390.17
6 (a) -15363.13 33304.98 -9386.57 23790.25 -4779.83 6876.18
6 (b) -15298.86 33403.07 -9450.85 23865.77 -4844.11 7135.16
MaxV -15931.39 31205.1 -9859.68 23943.8 -5316.54 6390.2
MinV -14093.70 22792.4 -7627.37 23626.4 -2829.81 1561.3
MaxM -15298.86 33403.1 -8121.18 24281.0 -4844.11 7135.2
Quasi-permanent
1 -14160.55 22688.53 -8054.33 24199.56 -3256.77 3246.45
2 (a) -14160.35 24039.26 -8054.52 23967.51 -3256.96 4195.91
2 (b) -14093.51 24143.15 -8121.37 24048.93 -3323.81 4473.17
180 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Reinforcement at bottom
Bar Diameter (φ) = T 32 mm Number of bars = 117 Nos.
Bar Diameter (φ) = T 32 mm Number of bars = 59 Nos.
= T 25 mm = 58 Nos.
2 2
Reinforcement area (Ast) 94096.98 mm Reinforcement area (Ast) 75921.30 mm
2
Total Reinforcement area (A = 170018 mm Reinforcement % = 0.682
Min reinforcement % = 0.300 (Ok)
2
Cross-sectional area of uncracked section = 28157441 mm
4
Moment of inertia of uncracked section = 1.027E+13 mm
15931 31205 3.61 -2.47 Cracked section 667.8 10740533 519.79 1438.92
14094 22792 2.61 -1.61 Cracked section 723.8 11477647 505.95 1111.26
Bottom
15299 33403 3.63 -2.54 Cracked section 642.0 10401714 525.48 1657.89
support
section 14161 22689 2.60 -1.59 Cracked section 727.0 11518803 505.12 1097.11
14160 24039 2.72 -1.72 Cracked section 708.2 11271579 510.01 1187.64
14094 24143 2.73 -1.73 Cracked section 705.4 11234745 510.72 1202.35
9860 23944 2.56 -1.86 Cracked section 568.0 9211519 572.92 1855.53
7627 23626 2.45 -1.91 Cracked section 529.6 8705955 579.99 2517.59
Midspan 8121 24281 2.53 -1.95 Cracked section 534.4 8770088 579.17 2410.66
section 8054 24200 2.52 -1.95 Cracked section 533.7 8761030 579.29 2425.25
8055 23968 2.50 -1.93 Cracked section 535.1 8778917 579.06 2396.60
8121 24049 2.51 -1.93 Cracked section 535.8 8788024 578.94 2382.25
5317 6390 0.78 -0.40 Uncracked section 793.9 12180702 511.04 690.90
2830 1561 0.24 -0.04 Uncracked section 1522.6 21758754 216.41 335.32
Top support 4844 7135 0.83 -0.49 Uncracked section 702.2 10974661 539.51 933.45
section 3257 3246 0.42 -0.18 Uncracked section 910.2 13709251 470.55 526.28
3257 4196 0.50 -0.27 Uncracked section 759.1 11723595 522.25 766.04
3324 4473 0.53 -0.30 Uncracked section 739.2 11461419 528.46 817.34
181 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Maximum compressive stress = 5.64 Mpa < 19.20 Mpa Hence O.K.
Maximum tensile stress = 133.23 Mpa < 400.00 Mpa Hence O.K.
9.1.3.4 Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 82.99 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 5.998
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 257.5 mm
Ac,eff = 3384580 mm2 As/Ac,eff = 0.0140
fct,eff = = 1.29 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.00025
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000249
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 75.00 mm
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 32.0 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 643.0 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.160 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Bottom support section Midspan section Top support section
Description 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
Stress in steel, σs 74.3 82.1 83.0 133.0 131.3 131.5 7.4 13.5 15.0
As 94097.0 94097.0 94097.0 75921.3 75921.3 75921.3 75921.3 75921.3 75921.3
Diameter 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0
Actual NA 727 708 705 534 535 536 910 759 739
hc,eff 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5
Ac,eff 3384580 3384580 3384580 3384580 3384580 3384580 3384580 3384580 3384580
ρp,eff 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.022 0.022 0.022 0.022 0.022 0.022
εsm-εcm 0.00024 0.00027 0.00028 0.00050 0.00049 0.00049 0.00002 0.00004 0.00005
φeq 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 450.7 450.7 450.7 497.5 497.5 497.5 497.5 497.5 497.5
Crack width, Wk 0.106 0.124 0.126 0.250 0.245 0.246 0.011 0.020 0.022
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
182 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
9.2 Abutment A2
Formation Level = 890.548 m
Foundation bottom level = 870.548 m
Length of wall = 12.075 m
Width of wall = 2.000 m
Depth of superstructure = 2.000 m
Depth of Foundation at abutment base = 2.400 m
Height of wall = 15.600 m
183 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
2. Geometric details
[a] Dimension detail of column
Actual column length = 15.60 m Effective length multiplier = 1.50
Width of section = 12075 mm
Depth of section = 2000 mm Radius of gyration, i = 577.4 mm
Effective length of col l e = 23.40 m Slenderness ratio λ = 40.53
Reinforcement provided
Tension face At bottom 107 Nos. T 32 53.5 = 86055 mm2
At Top & middle 53 Nos. T 32 = 69132 mm2
54 Nos. T 25
Compression face 53 Nos. T 32 = 69132 mm2
54 Nos. T 25
Side side 12 Nos. T 25 = 5890 mm2
12 Nos. T 25 = 5890 mm2
Stiruups 16 T @ 100 c/c Total = 166968 mm2
12 T @ 100 c/c or = 150046 mm2
Ductile detailing for Seismic case, (although, this is applicable for seismic zone III, IV, V)
For rectangular Column
As per Clause No. 7.4 of IS 13920:1993, Ash = 0.18ShSDkxfck/fy[Ag/Ak-1.0)
Ash Area of tranverse Reinforcement = 201.1 mm2
D Larger Dimensionr of Column = 2000 mm
h Larger dimension of Core measured to the outside of the spiral = 308.3333 mm
fck = M40
fy = M500
184 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
185 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Stress
186 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Stress Stress
187 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
188 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1(a) 1 1 1.2 1
1(b) 1 1 1 1
2 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 1
3 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1 0.8 0.6
3 (b) 1 1 1 1 1 0.8 0.6
4 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 0.75 0.8 1
4 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.75 0.8 1
5 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 1 0.8 0.6
5 (b) 1 1 1 1 1 0.8 0.6
6 (a) 1 1 1.2 1 0.75 0.8 1
6 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.75 0.8 1
1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (a) 1 1.2 1 1 0.5
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.5
Rare Combination
Bottom support section Midspan section Top support section
Load Case V (kN) M (kN-m) V (kN) M (kN-m) V (kN) M (kN-m)
1(a) -13967.60 -13305.37 -7656.30 -23319.30 -2947.06 -955.98
1(b) -13903.69 -13399.81 -7720.21 -23394.56 -3010.97 -1211.08
2 (a) -14407.73 -12450.94 -7216.17 -22884.66 -2506.92 874.63
2 (b) -14343.82 -12545.39 -7280.08 -22959.93 -2570.83 619.53
3 (a) -13928.69 -19456.28 -7438.06 -21524.16 -2788.54 -1708.69
3 (b) -13864.78 -19550.72 -7501.97 -21599.43 -2852.44 -1963.80
4 (a) -14039.75 -18547.41 -7391.29 -21548.37 -2726.84 -1296.72
4 (b) -13975.84 -18641.85 -7455.20 -21623.64 -2790.74 -1551.82
5 (a) -13790.47 -21341.95 -7576.29 -21383.80 -2926.76 -3434.93
5 (b) -13726.56 -21436.40 -7640.20 -21459.07 -2990.66 -3690.03
6 (a) -13809.38 -21690.20 -7621.66 -21314.44 -2957.20 -4173.78
6 (b) -13745.47 -21784.64 -7685.57 -21389.71 -3021.11 -4428.88
MaxV -14407.73 -12450.9 -7720.21 -23394.6 -3021.11 -4428.9
MinV -13726.56 -21436.4 -7216.17 -22884.7 -2506.92 874.6
MaxM -14407.73 -12450.9 -7621.66 -21314.4 -2506.92 874.6
Quasi-permanent
1 -13970.12 -13298.69 -7653.78 -23314.47 -2944.53 -938.92
2 (a) -13970.31 -14608.30 -7653.59 -23101.33 -2944.34 -1888.50
2 (b) -13903.88 -14709.42 -7720.02 -23181.43 -3010.77 -2160.66
189 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
14408 12451 1.88 -0.76 Uncracked section 1070.1 14714440 391.70 472.48
13727 21436 2.69 -1.63 Cracked section 734.9 10666258 503.37 1058.30
Bottom
14408 12451 1.81 -0.70 Uncracked section 1070.1 14714440 391.70 472.48
support
section 13970 13299 1.88 -0.80 Uncracked section 993.5 13789152 420.12 531.81
13970 14608 2.01 -0.93 Uncracked section 928.5 13004440 443.12 602.54
13904 14709 2.02 -0.94 Uncracked section 921.1 12914385 445.69 612.25
7720 23395 2.65 -2.06 Cracked section 530.9 7999522 580.87 2449.43
7216 22885 2.58 -2.02 Cracked section 524.7 7925735 581.88 2589.42
Midspan 7622 21314 2.44 -1.85 Cracked section 542.5 8140532 578.83 2217.73
section 7654 23314 2.64 -2.05 Cracked section 530.1 7990850 580.99 2465.15
7654 23101 2.62 -2.03 Cracked section 531.4 8006124 580.78 2437.59
7720 23181 2.63 -2.03 Cracked section 532.1 8014843 580.65 2422.11
3021 4429 0.56 -0.33 Uncracked section 702.0 10066033 540.36 925.61
2507 875 0.18 0.01 Uncracked section 2033.1 26139166 -17.92 366.80
Top support 2507 875 0.18 0.01 Uncracked section 2033.1 26139166 -17.92 366.80
section 2945 939 0.21 0.02 Uncracked section 2116.9 27151451 -57.33 376.20
2944 1888 0.30 -0.08 Uncracked section 1339.4 17762454 297.26 344.14
3011 2161 0.33 -0.10 Uncracked section 1210.2 16203113 352.32 365.33
190 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Maximum compressive stress = 4.59 Mpa < 19.20 Mpa Hence O.K.
Maximum tensile stress = 141.56 Mpa < 400.00 Mpa Hence O.K.
9.2.3.4 Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 34.36 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 5.998
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 257.5 mm
Ac,eff = 3109313 mm2 As/Ac,eff = 0.0137
fct,eff = = 2.12 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.00010
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.0001031
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 75.00 mm
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 32.0 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 651.8 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.067 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Bottom support section Midspan section Top support section
Description 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
Stress in steel, σs 26.5 33.6 34.4 141.3 139.6 139.8 -0.3 1.7 2.7
As 86054.5 86054.5 86054.5 69132.3 69132.3 69132.3 69132.3 69132.3 69132.3
Diameter 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0
Actual NA 994 929 921 530 531 532 2117 1339 1210
hc,eff 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5 257.5
Ac,eff 3109313 3109313 3109313 3109313 3109313 3109313 3109313 3109313 3109313
ρp,eff 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.022 0.022 0.022 0.022 0.022 0.022
εsm-εcm 0.00008 0.00010 0.00010 0.00044 0.00043 0.00043 0.00000 0.00001 0.00001
φeq 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 451.6 451.6 451.6 499.7 499.7 499.7 499.7 499.7 499.7
Crack width, Wk 0.036 0.045 0.047 0.218 0.214 0.214 0.000 0.003 0.004
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
191 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
192 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
193 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Counterweight
Dead/Earth load calculation over foundation
Width of footing = 10.500 m Unit wt of concrete = 25 kN/m2
Length of footing = 13.144 m Unit wt of soil = 19 kN/m2
Depth of footing = 2.400 m Depth of footing at edge = 1.250 m
Thickness of wall = 2.000 m
Height of fill at back side = 18.560 m
Height of fill at front side = 5 m
194 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Normal Case
1 47986 2246 0 226 0 0.047 0.005 358 339 356 338 OK.
2 47005 -29363 0 -138 0 -0.625 -0.003 219 462 219 463 OK.
Wind case
5 46802 -9586 0 90 0 -0.205 0.002 300 379 299 379 OK.
6 48206 2009 0 207 0 0.042 0.004 358 342 357 340 OK.
7 47225 -29600 0 -158 0 -0.627 -0.003 219 464 220 465 OK.
Temp case
8 47986 5454 0 199 0 0.114 0.004 371 326 370 324 OK.
9 47006 -36089 0 -83 0 -0.768 -0.002 191 490 191 490 OK.
Seismic case
10 49170 51893 0 311 0 1.055 0.006 572 142 570 140 OK.
11 44381 -76978 0 -229 0 -1.734 -0.005 2 640 4 641 OK.
12 52774 12510 0 407 0 0.237 0.008 436 332 433 329 OK.
13 40777 -37596 0 -325 0 -0.922 -0.008 139 450 141 452 OK.
Max. base pressure Allowable base pressure
Maximum bearing capacity at Normal case = 462.6 kN/m2 = 550.0 kN/m2
Maximum bearing capacity at Wind case = 465.3 kN/m2 = 687.5 kN/m2
Maximum bearing capacity at Temperature case = 490.3 kN/m2 = 687.5 kN/m2
Maximum bearing capacity at Seismic case = 641.1 kN/m2 = 687.5 kN/m2
Maximum allowable bearing pressure for all cases = 512.8 kN/m2 = 550.0 kN/m2
Hence O.K.
195 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
196 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Counterweght
Dead/Earth load calculation over foundation
Width of footing = 10.500 m Unit wt of concrete = 25 kN/m2
Length of footing = 12.076 m Unit wt of soil = 19 kN/m2
Depth of footing = 2.400 m Depth of footing at edge = 1.250 m
Thickness of wall = 2.000 m
Height of fill at back side = 18.028 m
Height of fill at front side = 5 m
197 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Normal Case
1 45067.46 -9350.15 76.21 9350.46 0 0.70 3.4 > 1.50 OK.
2 42743.60 -9914.17 38.94 9914.25 0 0.70 3.0 > 1.50 OK.
Wind case
5 43839.14 -9678.15 178.36 9679.79 0 0.70 3.2 > 1.25 OK.
6 45298.22 -9263.30 172.18 9264.90 0 0.70 3.4 > 1.25 OK.
42974.36 -9827.33 134.91 9828.26 0 0.70 3.1 > 1.25 OK.
Temp case
7 45067.85 -9616.15 67.09 9616.38 0 0.70 3.3 > 1.25 OK.
8 42742.44 -9339.45 57.80 9339.63 0 0.70 3.2 > 1.25 OK.
Seismic case
9 46578.24 -17679.70 752.26 17695.70 0 0.70 1.8 > 1.25 OK.
10 40065.51 -1917.10 -643.26 2022.14 0 0.70 13.9 > 1.25 OK.
11 50000.46 -12287.72 1790.48 12417.48 0 0.70 2.8 > 1.25 OK.
12 36643.30 -7309.08 -1681.48 7500.00 0 0.70 3.4 > 1.25 OK.
However, 1000x750mm shear key has been provided for full length of abutment.
198 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Design of Footing
199 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
200 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Counterweght
Dead/Earth load calculation over foundation
Width of footing = 10.500 m Unit wt of concrete = 25 kN/m2
Length of footing = 13.144 m Unit wt of soil = 19 kN/m2
Depth of footing = 2.400 m Depth of footing at edge = 1.250 m
Thickness of wall = 2.000 m
Height of fill at back side = 18.560 m
Height of fill at front side = 5 m
201 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
A 10.50 X D
T
Y Y
Heel side Toe side
13.14
L
2.0
B C
2.40 AB CD 2.40
1.25
4.250 4.250
10.500
Wt.of base slab*1.35 81.0 kN/m2 123.2 kN/m2 Effective depth = 2.4*1000-75-25/2
Wt.of fill*1.5 476.1 kN/m2 128.3 kN/m2 = 2312.5 mm
Total downward load 557.1 kN/m2 251.4 kN/m2
11.1.1.4 Moment & Shear at X-X i.e. long direction
Avg design Avg design Avg design Avg design Moment
Moment Shear at dist Shear at dist d
base pr. along base pr. base pr. at base pr. at along Long -
Load Case along Long - d along Long- along Long-CD
long-AB along long- face wall-AB face wall- CD AB (kN-
CD (kN-m/m) AB (kN/m) (kN/m)
(kN/m2) CD (kN/m2) (kN/m2) (kN/m2) m/m)
1 -103 239 35 100 -6783.6 22886.5 -1827.2 5281.8
1 (a) 92 -54 33 5 8564.8 -4085.7 1996.0 -1035.1
2 (a) -43 153 36 74 -1941.9 14989.1 -628.8 3427.9
2 (b) 14 29 20 23 1865.6 3242.3 383.0 712.8
3 (a) -101 240 37 102 -6536.9 22980.2 -1772.3 5300.0
3 (b) 94 -54 34 6 8811.5 -3992.0 2050.8 -1016.9
4 (a) -87 220 37 95 -5456.3 21154.9 -1504.1 4872.0
4 (b) 75 -34 31 10 7199.3 -2264.7 1663.1 -604.5
5 (a) -115 251 33 103 -7820.1 23922.3 -2075.5 5530.0
5 (b) 117 -79 38 0 10738.0 -6257.1 2516.7 -1555.4
6 (a) -111 239 30 97 -7594.9 22725.1 -2009.4 5255.3
6 (b) 113 -76 36 0 10410.0 -6039.8 2439.5 -1501.9
7 (a) -395 554 -11 170 -31719.7 50599.0 -7836.7 11886.9
7 (b) 274 -298 43 -66 23418.4 -26156.4 5645.4 -6232.8
7 (c) -112 349 75 163 -5870.0 34049.1 -1759.6 7805.0
7 (d) 46 -145 -31 -68 2388.9 -14135.4 719.6 -3239.6
7 (e) -149 302 34 120 -10413.9 28642.3 -2723.7 6634.2
7 (f) 83 -98 10 -25 6932.8 -8728.5 1683.6 -2068.8
+ve means Upward pressure Maximum 23418.4 50599.0 5645.4 11886.9
Minimum -31719.7 -26156.4 -7836.7 -6232.8
0.0382 36769 kN
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
a) Support moment
Grade Concrete = M40 Grade of steel = Fe 500
Width of the section = 13144.0 mm Depth of the section = 2400 mm
Clear Cover = 75 mm Main dia of bar used = 25 mm
Dia of shear reinf. = 0 mm Effective depth, d 2312.5 = 2313 mm
R = Mu/bd2 = 0.720 MPa Design Moment = 50599 kN-m
Mu,Lim/bd2 = 0.133xfck = 5.32 MPa Ast = 51389.7 mm2
Lower fractile tensile fctm = 1.94 MPa Where, pt = fck/(2*fy)*(1-sqrt(1-(4.598*R/fck))*100
202 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Min. reinforcement 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 39514.2 mm2
Hence provide 32 dia @ 125 c/c Ast = 84568.3 mm2
0 dia @ 125 c/c > Hence O.K.
E of reinforcement = 200000 MPa Max strain in concrete = 0.0035
E of concrete = 32308 MPa Min strain in steel = 0.0042
Balanced neutral axis depth = 1054.6 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 194.26 mm
Strain in steel = 0.03816394 Stress in steel = 434.8 MPa
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 36769 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 36769 kN
Compressive force CG 80.81 mm Moment of resistance = 82056 kNm
> 50599 kNm Hence O.K.
Flexure Design
Heel side Toe side
Description
Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum
Moment 23418.4 -31719.7 50599.0 -26156.4
Width 13144 13144 13144 13144
Depth 2313 2313 2313 2313
R = Mu/bd2 0.33 -0.45 0.72 -0.37
pt 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Ast required for bending 622.2 -842.7 1344.2 -694.9
Ast required for shear 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Total Ast required 622.2 842.7 1344.2 694.9
1st layers 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia
Reinf provided 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c
2nd layers 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia
125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c
Ast provided 84568.3 51616.4 84568.3 51616.4
Actual NA 194 119 194 119
Strain in steel 0.0382 0.0648 0.0382 0.0648
Stress in steel 434.8 434.8 434.8 434.8
Total tension = 36769 22442 36769 22442
Total compression 36769 22442 36769 22442
Difference of force 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 80.8 49.3 80.8 49.3
Moment of resistance 82056 50790 82056 50790
Factor of Safety 3.5 1.6 1.6 1.9
Pt 0.0028 0.00170 0.0028 0.0017
203 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
204 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
T
Y
2.0
B C
X
2.40 AB CD 2.40
1.25
4.250 4.250
10.500
Wt.of base slab 60.0 kN/m2 45.6 kN/m2 Effective depth = 2.4*1000-75-32/2
Wt.of fill 352.6 kN/m2 95.0 kN/m2 = 2309 mm
Total downward load 412.6 kN/m2 140.6 kN/m2
Rare Combination
1(a) -39 158 41 41 -1436.2 9516.5
1(b) -9 134 49 49 1264.1 9174.6
2 (a) -30 159 46 46 -551.9 9983.0
2 (b) 0 135 54 54 2148.5 9641.0
3 (a) -72 217 45 45 -3889.3 12135.5
3 (b) 55 101 73 73 7221.7 9787.6
4 (a) -62 202 45 45 -3125.3 11571.6
4 (b) 40 109 68 68 5883.0 9725.1
5 (a) -81 224 42 42 -4744.8 12231.5
5 (b) 45 108 71 71 6366.2 9883.5
6 (a) -78 215 41 41 -4551.0 11731.5
6 (b) 24 122 64 64 4457.3 9885.1
Maximum 7221.7 12231.5
Minimum -4744.8 9174.6
Quasi-permanent Combination
1 -39 158 41 41 -1430.6 9517.7
2 (a) -45 165 40 40 -2006.4 9680.3
2 (b) -43 168 42 42 -1733.2 10021.4
+ve means upward pressure Maximum -1430.6 10021.4
Minimum -2006.4 9517.7
205 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.00010 1.64
533 5729.07
NA NA
67.74
0.00034
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok =
Total compressive force = 5729.1 kN Total tensile force = 5729.1 kN
Compressive force CG = 177.5 mm Moment of resistance = 12231.5 kNm
Rare Combination Quasi-permanent Combination
Heel side Toe side Heel side Toe side
Description Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum
h or D 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400
b 13144 13144 13144 13144 13144 13144 13144 13144
d 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313
Moment 7221.66 -4744.77 12231.52 0.00 -1430.62 -2006.41 10021.41 0.10
Reinf provided 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia
125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c
0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia
125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 0 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 0 c/c
Ast provided 84568.3 84568.3 51616.4 0.0 84568.3 84568.3 51616.4 0.0
Stress in concrete 1.0 0.6 2.0 -0.2 0.3 1.6
Actual NA 533 533 428 533 533 428
Stress in steel 40.0 26.3 109.2 -7.9 11.1 89.5
Total ultimate tensile force = 3383 2222 5637 -670 940 4619
Total ultimate compressive force3383 2222 5637 -670 940 4619
Difference of force 0 0 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 177.5 177.5 142.7 177.5 177.5 142.7
Moment of resistance 7222 -4745 12232 -1431 -2006 10021
Diff. of moment 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = -7.92 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 6.190
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 218.8 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.029
fct,eff = = 1.29 Mpa εsm-εcm = -0.00002
>= 0.6σsc/Es= -0.00002
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 75 mm 107
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 32.000 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 440.0 mm Crack width, Wk = = -0.010 mm
Heel side Toe side < 0.3 mm OK
Description Maximum Minimum Maximum
Stress in steel, σs -7.9 11.1 89.5
As 84568.3 84568.3 51616.4
Actual NA 533 533 428
hc,eff 218.8 218.8 218.8
ρp,eff 0.029 0.029 0.018
εsm-εcm -0.00002 0.00003 0.00027
φeq 32.0 25.0 32.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 440.0 399.5 558.0
Crack width, Wk -0.010 0.013 0.150
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
206 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
207 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Counterweght
Dead/Earth load calculation over foundation
Width of footing = 10.500 m Unit wt of concrete = 25 kN/m2
Length of footing = 12.076 m Unit wt of soil = 19 kN/m2
Depth of footing = 2.400 m Depth of footing at edge = 1.250 m
Thickness of wall = 2.000 m
Height of fill at back side = 18.028 m
Height of fill at front side = 5 m
5 (b)
52773 26940 0 -286 0 0.510 -0.005 294 296 536 539
6 (a) 60604 34838 0 54 0 0.575 0.001 321 321 635 635
6 (b) 52846 33208 0 -238 0 0.628 -0.004 266 268 565 567
7 (a) 63287 38576 0 201 0 0.610 0.003 326 324 674 672
7 (b) 49020 31817 0 -534 0 0.649 -0.011 241 245 528 532
7 (c) 68420 35209 0 267 0 0.515 0.004 382 380 699 697
7 (d) 43718 28160 0 -526 0 0.644 -0.012 216 220 470 474
7 (e) 62498 34249 0 107 0 0.548 0.002 339 338 648 647
7 (f) 49639 29120 0 -365 0 0.587 -0.007 259 262 521 524
208 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
A 10.50 X D
T
Y Y
Heel side
12.08
L
2.0
B C
2.40 AB CD 2.40
1.25
4.250 4.250
10.500
Wt.of base slab*1.35 81.0 kN/m2 123.2 kN/m2 Effective depth = 2.4*1000-75-25/2
Wt.of fill*1.5 462.4 kN/m2 128.3 kN/m2 = 2312.5 mm
Total downward load 543.4 kN/m2 251.4 kN/m2
11.2.1.4 Moment & Shear at X-X i.e. long direction
Avg design base Avg design base Avg design base Avg design base Moment along Moment along Shear at dist d Shear at dist d
Load Case pr. along long-AB pr. along long- pr. at face wall-AB pr. at face wall- Long - AB (kN- Long - CD (kN- along Long-AB along Long-CD
(kN/m2) CD (kN/m2) (kN/m2) CD (kN/m2) m/m) m/m) (kN/m) (kN/m)
0.0382 33781 kN
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
a) Support moment
Grade Concrete = M40 Grade of steel = Fe 500
Width of the section = 12076.0 mm Depth of the section = 2400 mm
Clear Cover = 75 mm Main dia of bar used = 25 mm
Dia of shear reinf. = 0 mm Effective depth, d 2312.5 = 2313 mm
R = Mu/bd2 = 0.616 MPa Design Moment = 39766 kN-m
Mu,Lim/bd2 = 0.133xfck = 5.32 MPa Ast = 40259.8 mm2
Lower fractile tensile fctm = 1.94 MPa Where, pt = fck/(2*fy)*(1-sqrt(1-(4.598*R/fck))*100
Min. reinforcement 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 36303.5 mm2
Hence provide 32 dia @ 125 c/c Ast = 77696.8 mm2
0 dia @ 125 c/c > Hence O.K.
209 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
210 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1 1 1.2 1 1
2 (a) 1 1.2 1 1 0.5
2 (b) 1 1 1 1 0.5
Rare Combination
Load Case HL (kN) V (kN) HT (kN) Mx (kN-m) MT (kN-m) ML (kN-m)
1(a) 9813.93 43439.41 71.03 -376.68 -45.41 21388.33
1(b) 9845.41 42929.42 36.70 -188.21 -172.22 14856.99
2 (a) 9570.72 44110.30 274.60 301.21 -21.56 23272.15
2 (b) 9602.21 43600.31 240.28 489.68 -148.38 16740.80
3 (a) 9277.45 45246.32 134.06 246.31 78.24 31031.21
3 (b) 10234.47 44400.15 122.12 -25.37 88.00 11024.57
4 (a) 9363.81 44921.51 171.09 263.38 53.74 29009.09
4 (b) 10089.44 44159.38 153.55 106.74 29.36 12371.27
5 (a) 9489.16 45108.10 71.00 -30.26 62.88 28716.78
5 (b) 10446.18 44261.93 59.06 -301.94 72.64 8710.15
6 (a) 9716.66 44691.14 65.99 -197.57 28.14 25151.71
6 (b) 10442.29 43929.01 48.45 -354.21 3.76 8513.89
Quasi-permanent
1 9812.53 43441.94 71.10 -382.60 -55.51 21397.80
2 (a) 9945.53 43442.13 66.54 -455.97 -62.47 19822.38
2 (b) 9978.41 42929.61 32.14 -261.57 -179.19 19677.37
211 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
T
Y
12.08
L
2.0
B C
X
2.40 AB CD 2.40
1.25
4.250 4.250
10.500
Wt.of base slab 60.0 kN/m2 45.6 kN/m2 Effective depth = 2.4*1000-75-32/2
Wt.of fill 342.5 kN/m2 95.0 kN/m2 = 2309 mm
Total downward load 402.5 kN/m2 140.6 kN/m2
Moment & Shear at X-X i.e. long direction
Avg design Avg design Avg design Avg design Moment
Moment
base pr. along base pr. base pr. at base pr. at along Long -
Load Case along Long -
long-AB along long- face-AB side face-CD side AB (kN-
CD (kN-m/m)
(kN/m2) CD (kN/m2) (kN/m2) (kN/m2) m/m)
Rare Combination
1(a) -156 298 28 28 -10359.4 12860.6
1(b) -131 265 29 29 -8454.2 11759.6
2 (a) -160 312 31 31 -10458.4 13628.7
2 (b) -134 279 33 33 -8553.2 12527.7
3 (a) -186 356 34 34 -12265.8 15392.8
3 (b) -102 259 44 44 -5813.8 12635.9
4 (a) -179 344 33 33 -11819.5 14908.3
4 (b) -110 263 41 41 -6504.2 12565.4
5 (a) -176 345 35 35 -11554.1 15039.1
5 (b) -93 248 45 45 -5102.1 12282.3
6 (a) -163 325 34 34 -10633.3 14318.9
6 (b) -94 244 43 43 -5318.0 11976.0
Maximum -5102.1 15392.8
Minimum -12265.8 11759.6
Quasi-permanent Combination
1 -156 298 28 28 -10360.6 12863.8
2 (a) -149 291 29 29 -9795.1 12704.1
2 (b) -153 287 25 25 -10183.9 12248.6
+ve means upward pressure Maximum -9795.1 12863.8
Minimum -10360.6 12248.6
212 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.00014 2.24
533 7209.74
NA NA
92.79
0.00046
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok =
Total compressive force = 7209.7 kN Total tensile force = 7209.7 kN
Compressive force CG = 177.5 mm Moment of resistance = 15392.8 kNm
Rare Combination Quasi-permanent Combination
Heel side Toe side Heel side Toe side
Description Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum
h or D 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400 2400
b 12076 12076 12076 12076 12076 12076 12076 12076
d 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313 2313
Moment -5102.12 -12265.79 15392.76 0.00 -9795.09 -10360.63 12863.75 0.10
Reinf provided 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia 32 dia 25 dia
125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c
0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia 0 dia
125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 0 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 125 c/c 0 c/c
Ast provided 77696.8 77696.8 47422.3 0.0 77696.8 77696.8 47422.3 0.0
Stress in concrete -0.7 1.8 2.7 1.4 1.5 2.3
Actual NA 533 533 428 533 533 428
Stress in steel -30.8 73.9 149.6 59.0 62.5 125.0
Total ultimate tensile force = -2390 5745 7094 4588 4853 5929
Total ultimate compressive force-2390 5745 7094 4588 4853 5929
Difference of force 0 0 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 177.5 177.5 142.7 177.5 177.5 142.7
Moment of resistance -5102 -12266 15393 -9795 -10361 12864
Diff. of moment 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 59.05 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 6.190
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 218.8 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.029
fct,eff = = 2.12 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.00018
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.00018
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 75 mm 107
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 32.000 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 440.0 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.078 mm
Heel side Toe side < 0.3 mm OK
Description Maximum Minimum Maximum
Stress in steel, σs 59.0 62.5 125.0
As 77696.8 77696.8 47422.3
Actual NA 533 533 428
hc,eff 218.8 218.8 218.8
ρp,eff 0.029 0.029 0.018
εsm-εcm 0.00018 0.00019 0.00038
φeq 32.0 25.0 32.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 440.0 399.5 558.0
Crack width, Wk 0.078 0.075 0.209
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
11.2.3 Details of Reinforcement
Minimum main reinf. 0.26xfctm/fykxbtxd but not less than 0.0013btd = 3006.3 mm2/m
As per clause 16.6.1.1 (3) of IRC-112:2011, minimum tranverse reinforcement is 20% of main reinforcement.
Minimum tranverse reinforcement Longitudinal direction = 6434.0 mm2/m
Tranverse direction = 1286.8 mm2/m
Hence provide Top long 25 dia @ 125 c/c Ast provided = 1608.5 mm2
Top Tranv 16 dia @ 125 c/c Hence OK.
Bottom long 32 dia @ 125 c/c
Bottom Tranv 16 dia @ 125 c/c
Side face 16 dia @ 150 c/c
Open link 12 dia @ 250 c/c Staggered
213 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Staad Inputs
214 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
29911010
298235 73 7
289109 236 180
341
277243 95 314 182
108 349 210 5
276
242 315256 209
34275
227288 35096 317237
290
244 257 35198 214 3
60 278 252 34597 316 318258
238
76
213
343
245291 35299 320
279 308
29.316m
64 259 353101 218 1
292149 360 100319 260 72
217
344
246 329267 346 102321 239 1149
280 148 253 354 323 301
240286151 271
333
364 63 309
359 322261 355
262
104
300234 222
221
302 155 266 347103 324 113 179
78 232 157 368
275 363
328
147 310254
263 356105
285251297 181
11 162337 270 62 325 112
233304 154332 265358 348106 293
66 367 146327 255 281247
1758 336274 362 311 111
177 340161 331269 58
30.794m
357 296 190
230 153 264 250
194 70306 273366 145
361
326 61 284 208
193 6 339
335
160 330268 283
295
249
229 365152 150
198 4 69 313 272
334 282248294 212
197 159
338 156
228 241287
202 2 67 312 158305 216
201 307231303
12 77 220
206 189
205
176
178
186
187
207
192
174
211
196 172
215
171
200
219
170 185
204
188 169
173
183
191
167
195
166
165 199
203
164
184
163
168
13481004
1007
1231
1347 1085
1024
1352
1060
1327 1232
1351 32 33
1252
1315 1201
1346 30 31 1096 1086
1107
10251008
1059
1058 1265
1345 27 28 29 1470 1474
12401108
114467
12511314 1202
1344 25 26 1313 1197 64 65 66
1466 1176
1087
1009
1326 126423 24 1193 1026
1180
1328
1253 1343
1203 22 1462 61 62 63 1473
1239 1148101
1316
1061 1342
1263 20 21 1458 59 60
1309 1469 99
1198 100
1175
1088
1329 1341 19 1454 57 58 13121465 97 98 1010
1027
1254
1317 1017
1340 17 18 1189 1461 1179
1472
1068
1330 1262
1339 15 16 29.316m
1446
1450 55 56
1305 1194 94 95 96
1457 1238 1152
1468 1341351001
1255
1318 1205
1338 13 14 1301 1018 52 53 54 1308 92 93
1453 10981199
1464 131 133
132 1062
1174
1471 1089
1063
1073 1261 12 1442 1190 1311 1237 1350
1178
1324
1248 1337
1210 10 11 1434 1438 49 50 51 13041449 89 90 91 1460 129
1195 130
1143 1467
1200 1247
1349 1090
1156
1173
1353 1336 1206 1456 128 1463 1246
1005
1006 1250
1357 7 8 9 1297
1430 45 46 47 48 1445
1019
1441 85 86 87 88 1307
1452 126127 1310
1459 1335
1260 1177
1095
1227 1215 1191 124 125 1196 1323 1147
1044 1229 5 6 1211
1426 1300
1437 1448 1455 1245
1045
1002
1079 2 3 4 1293
1478 42 43 44 1296 1207
1433 82 83 84 1015 14441303
1211221231451
1306 1331
1256
1 1216 40 41
1358 1429 79 80 81 1440 119120 1192
1447 1319
1204
1091 1230 39 1212
1425 77 78 1299
1436 117 30.794m
118 1302 1334 1151
1080
1103 1023
1014 3738 1292 1208
1432 10161443 1259
1322
1104 3536 1477
1217 75 76 1213 1295 115116 1439 1244 1114
1128 34 1481 1428 114 1298 1333
1224
1361 73 74 1291 1424 111 112113 1435
1209 1258
1321 1155
1160
1081 1022
1013 70 71 72 1218
1476 109 110 1431
1294 1243
1332
1188 1097
1164 69 1480 107 108 1423 1427
1214 1320 1257
1132 68 1225
1483 106 1290 13251242
1159
1082 1021 105 1475
1219 1249 1187
11631012 104 1479 1241 1356
1021031482
1226 1354 1112
1093 1136 1020 1223
1360 1186
11581011
1083 10031074 1142
1127 1162 1185
11401084
1157
1161 1146
1131 1092
1150
1135 1106
1113 1102 1154
1172
1141 1111
1184 1139 1120
1094 1171
1145
1121
1183
1109 1170
1149
1122
1126 1182 1169
1153
1123
1181 1101
1130 1124
1134
1105
1099
1168 1138
1125
1115 1110
1167
1129
1116
1166
1133
1117
1165
1137
1118
1100
1119
Member No
215 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
216 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
217 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1193 96 99; 1194 99 102; 1195 102 105; 1196 105 112; 1197 95 98; 1198 98 101;
1199 101 104; 1200 104 113; 1201 109 95; 1202 108 96; 1203 97 227;
1204 111 281; 1205 149 148; 1206 148 147; 1207 147 146; 1208 146 145;
1209 145 150; 1210 151 155; 1211 155 154; 1212 154 153; 1213 153 152;
1214 152 156; 1215 157 162; 1216 162 161; 1217 161 160; 1218 160 159;
1219 159 158; 1223 231 303; 1224 230 229; 1225 229 228; 1226 228 231;
1227 232 78; 1229 232 233; 1230 233 230; 1231 235 299; 1232 235 236;
1237 239 234; 1238 238 239; 1239 237 238; 1240 236 237; 1241 158 305;
1242 156 282; 1243 150 283; 1244 61 284; 1245 112 285; 1246 113 300;
1247 234 301; 1248 240 286; 1249 241 287; 1250 240 275; 1251 242 288;
1252 243 289; 1253 244 290; 1254 245 291; 1255 246 292; 1256 247 293;
1257 248 294; 1258 249 295; 1259 250 296; 1260 251 297; 1261 246 271;
1262 245 267; 1263 244 252; 1264 242 257; 1265 243 256; 1290 272 241;
1291 273 272; 1292 274 273; 1293 275 274; 1294 268 248; 1295 269 268;
1296 270 269; 1297 271 270; 1298 264 249; 1299 265 264; 1300 266 265;
1301 267 266; 1302 255 250; 1303 254 255; 1304 253 254; 1305 252 253;
1306 263 247; 1307 261 263; 1308 259 261; 1309 257 259; 1310 262 251;
1311 260 262; 1312 258 260; 1313 256 258; 1314 276 242; 1315 277 243;
1316 278 244; 1317 279 245; 1318 280 246; 1319 281 247; 1320 282 248;
1321 283 249; 1322 284 250; 1323 285 251; 1324 286 151; 1325 287 156;
1326 288 227; 1327 289 109; 1328 290 227; 1329 291 60; 1330 292 149;
1331 293 112; 1332 294 150; 1333 295 61; 1334 296 111; 1335 297 113;
1336 286 368; 1337 280 333; 1338 292 364; 1339 279 329; 1340 291 360;
1341 278 308; 1342 290 345; 1343 288 316; 1344 276 350; 1345 277 315;
1346 289 349; 1347 298 235; 1348 299 110; 1349 300 234; 1350 301 114;
1351 298 314; 1352 299 341; 1353 302 240; 1354 303 158; 1356 305 241;
1357 302 337; 1358 304 340; 1360 307 231; 1361 306 313; 1423 365 287;
1424 366 365; 1425 367 366; 1426 368 367; 1427 330 282; 1428 331 330;
1429 332 331; 1430 333 332; 1431 361 294; 1432 362 361; 1433 363 362;
1434 364 363; 1435 326 283; 1436 327 326; 1437 328 327; 1438 329 328;
1439 357 295; 1440 358 357; 1441 359 358; 1442 360 359; 1443 311 284;
1444 310 311; 1445 309 310; 1446 308 309; 1447 348 296; 1448 347 348;
1449 346 347; 1450 345 346; 1451 325 281; 1452 322 325; 1453 319 322;
1454 316 319; 1455 356 293; 1456 354 356; 1457 352 354; 1458 350 352;
1459 324 285; 1460 321 324; 1461 318 321; 1462 315 318; 1463 355 297;
1464 353 355; 1465 351 353; 1466 349 351; 1467 323 300; 1468 320 323;
1469 317 320; 1470 314 317; 1471 344 301; 1472 343 344; 1473 342 343;
1474 341 342; 1475 334 305; 1476 335 334; 1477 336 335; 1478 337 336;
1479 338 303; 1480 339 338; 1481 340 339; 1482 312 307; 1483 313 312;
DEFINE MATERIAL START
ISOTROPIC CONCRETE
E 3.3346e+007
POISSON 0.17
DENSITY 25
ALPHA 1e-005
DAMP 0.05
ISOTROPIC CONCRETE1
E 3.3346e+007
POISSON 0.17
DENSITY 0
ALPHA 1.2e-005
DAMP 0.05
TYPE CONCRETE
STRENGTH FCU 27579
END DEFINE MATERIAL
MEMBER PROPERTY AMERICAN
1001 1002 1007 TO 1014 PRIS YD 2 ZD 2
1103 1107 1157 TO 1160 1173 TO 1176 PRIS YD 0.5 ZD 2
1104 1108 1115 TO 1124 1161 TO 1164 1177 TO 1180 PRIS YD 2 ZD 1
1105 1106 1165 TO 1172 PRIS YD 2 ZD 3.5
1114 1185 TO 1188 PRIS YD 2 ZD 8.244
1113 1181 TO 1184 PRIS YD 2 ZD 8.51
1079 1084 1085 1090 TO 1102 1109 TO 1112 PRIS YD 2 ZD 0.5
1086 TO 1089 1141 TO 1156 PRIS YD 2 ZD 2.769
1080 TO 1083 1125 TO 1140 PRIS YD 2 ZD 3.036
1016 1017 1189 TO 1203 1205 TO 1214 1250 1261 TO 1265 1290 TO 1313 -
1336 TO 1346 1423 TO 1466 PRIS YD 0.225 ZD 0.875
1024 TO 1027 1062 PRIS YD 0.225 ZD 1.75
1215 TO 1219 1232 1237 TO 1240 1351 1352 1357 1358 1467 TO 1480 -
1481 PRIS YD 0.225 ZD 0.875
1224 TO 1226 1229 1230 1361 1482 1483 PRIS YD 0.225 ZD 0.975
1020 TO 1023 1045 PRIS YD 0.225 ZD 1.5
3 TO 30 37 TO 64 71 TO 98 105 TO 132 PRIS AX 1.6 IX 0.0382 IY 0.5581 IZ 0.6916
2 31 32 35 36 65 66 69 70 99 100 103 104 133 -
134 PRIS AX 1.847 IX 0.0648 IY 0.5689 IZ 0.7512
1 33 34 67 68 101 102 135 PRIS AX 2.12 IX 0.1649 IY 0.6034 IZ 0.8213
1003 TO 1006 1044 1058 TO 1061 1063 1068 1073 1074 1204 1223 1227 1231 1241 -
1242 TO 1249 1251 TO 1260 1314 TO 1335 1347 TO 1350 1353 1354 1356 -
1360 PRIS YD 0.225 ZD 0.5
218 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
219 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
220 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
221 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
222 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
223 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
224 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
JOINT LOAD
2 4 6 8 MZ 515
1 3 5 7 MZ -515
LOAD 17 CREEP SHRINKAGE DIFF SHRINKAGE
TEMPERATURE LOAD
1 TO 3 5 9 13 17 21 25 29 31 33 TO 35 37 39 43 47 51 55 59 63 65 67 TO 69 -
71 73 77 81 85 89 93 97 99 101 TO 103 105 107 111 115 119 123 127 131 133 -
135 STRAIN 0.000421
JOINT LOAD
1 3 5 7 MZ -794.1
2 4 6 8 MZ 794.1
LOAD 18 FOOTPATH LIVE LOAD
MEMBER LOAD
102 TO 135 UNI GY -6.1
102 TO 110 127 TO 135 UMOM GX 5.37
111 TO 126 UMOM GX 3.65
LOAD 19 SNOW LOAD FOR 70R LL TRACK
MEMBER LOAD
1 TO 33 UNI GY -8.61
34 TO 101 UNI GY -7.5
102 TO 135 UNI GY -7.17
LOAD 20 SNOW LOAD FOR LL 70R WHEEL
MEMBER LOAD
102 TO 135 UNI GY -4.31
34 TO 101 UNI GY -3.75
1 TO 33 UNI GY -3.59
LOAD 21 BRAKING
MEMBER LOAD
1 TO 135 UNI X 1.67
LOAD 22 PRESTRESS LOSS
MEMBER PRESTRESS LOAD
1 33 FORCE -1065 ES -0.347 EM -0.347 EE -0.347
2 31 32 FORCE -1065 ES -0.396 EM -0.396 EE -0.396
3 TO 5 28 TO 30 FORCE -1065 ES -0.798 EM -0.798 EE -0.798
6 TO 11 22 TO 27 FORCE -1065 ES -1.058 EM -1.058 EE -1.058
12 TO 21 FORCE -1065 ES -1.227 EM -1.227 EE -1.227
34 67 FORCE -1054 ES -0.347 EM -0.347 EE -0.347
35 36 65 66 FORCE -1054 ES -0.396 EM -0.396 EE -0.396
37 TO 39 62 TO 64 FORCE -1054 ES -0.803 EM -0.803 EE -0.803
40 TO 45 56 TO 61 FORCE -1054 ES -1.067 EM -1.067 EE -1.067
46 TO 55 FORCE -1054 ES -1.227 EM -1.227 EE -1.227
68 101 FORCE -1244 ES -0.451 EM -0.451 EE -0.451
69 70 99 100 FORCE -1244 ES -0.49 EM -0.49 EE -0.49
71 TO 73 96 TO 98 FORCE -1244 ES -0.84 EM -0.84 EE -0.84
74 TO 79 90 TO 95 FORCE -1244 ES -1.068 EM -1.068 EE -1.068
80 TO 89 FORCE -1244 ES -1.21 EM -1.21 EE -1.21
102 135 FORCE -1214 ES -0.451 EM -0.451 EE -0.451
103 104 133 134 FORCE -1214 ES -0.49 EM -0.49 EE -0.49
105 TO 107 130 TO 132 FORCE -1214 ES -0.844 EM -0.844 EE -0.844
108 TO 113 124 TO 129 FORCE -1214 ES -1.076 EM -1.076 EE -1.076
114 TO 123 FORCE -1214 ES -1.21 EM -1.21 EE -1.21
LOAD 23 POSTSTRESS LOSS
MEMBER POSTSTRESS LOAD
1 33 FORCE -1065 ES -0.347 EM -0.347 EE -0.347
2 31 32 FORCE -1065 ES -0.396 EM -0.396 EE -0.396
3 TO 5 28 TO 30 FORCE -1065 ES -0.798 EM -0.798 EE -0.798
6 TO 11 22 TO 27 FORCE -1065 ES -1.058 EM -1.058 EE -1.058
12 TO 21 FORCE -1065 ES -1.227 EM -1.227 EE -1.227
34 67 FORCE -1054 ES -0.347 EM -0.347 EE -0.347
35 36 65 66 FORCE -1054 ES -0.396 EM -0.396 EE -0.396
37 TO 39 62 TO 64 FORCE -1054 ES -0.803 EM -0.803 EE -0.803
40 TO 45 56 TO 61 FORCE -1054 ES -1.067 EM -1.067 EE -1.067
46 TO 55 FORCE -1054 ES -1.227 EM -1.227 EE -1.227
68 101 FORCE -1244 ES -0.451 EM -0.451 EE -0.451
69 70 99 100 FORCE -1244 ES -0.49 EM -0.49 EE -0.49
71 TO 73 96 TO 98 FORCE -1244 ES -0.84 EM -0.84 EE -0.84
74 TO 79 90 TO 95 FORCE -1244 ES -1.068 EM -1.068 EE -1.068
80 TO 89 FORCE -1244 ES -1.21 EM -1.21 EE -1.21
102 135 FORCE -1214 ES -0.451 EM -0.451 EE -0.451
103 104 133 134 FORCE -1214 ES -0.49 EM -0.49 EE -0.49
105 TO 107 130 TO 132 FORCE -1214 ES -0.844 EM -0.844 EE -0.844
108 TO 113 124 TO 129 FORCE -1214 ES -1.076 EM -1.076 EE -1.076
114 TO 123 FORCE -1214 ES -1.21 EM -1.21 EE -1.21
225 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
226 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
227 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
228 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
12.0 Design Data for RCC cantilever Retaining wall over foundation Ht = 18.56 m
1.1 Geometric details
Max. Finished road level = 893.96 m
Minimum ground level = 883.00 m
RL at founding level = 873.00 m
Thickness of abutment foundation = 2.400 m
Thickness of retaining wall at base = 2.800 m
Thickness of retaining wall at top = 0.500 m
1.2 Details of wearing coat and backfill matterial
Angle of internal friction (φ) = 30.00 degrees Angle of wall friction (δ) = 20.00 degrees
Slope of backfill soil (β) = 0.00 degrees Angle of earthside wall (α) = 7.06 degrees
Unit weight of soil = 19.0 kN/m3 Surcharge 1.2xγsoil
1.6 Sketch
893.960 m
500
7500 7
1567
o 12500
= 7.06
18560
2279
α
2400 873.0 m
2800
229 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
12.1.2 Active earth Pressure on vertical wall at seismic case 0.00 kN/m2
(As per IS: 1893-2002)
Active earth pressure coefficient at Normal case Ka
= (1+-Av )*Cos2(φ− λ -α)
Cosλ∗Cos2α*Cos(α+δ+λ)*[1+{Sin(φ+δ)*Sin(φ-β−λ)/(Cos(α-β)*Cos(δ+α+λ))}1/2]2
Note :- 50.86 kN/m2
α = Angle subtended by the earth side wall with the
vertical on the earth side = 0.12 radians
φ = Angle of internal friction of the earth fill = 0.52 radians
δ = Angle of friction of the earth side wall with the earth=2φ/3 = 0.35 radians
β = Inclination of the earth fill surface with horizontal = 0.00 radians
γs = Unit weight of Soil at normal case = 19.00 kN/m2
Surcharge = 1.2xγsoil = 22.80 kN/m2
Seismic forces on the structure are calculated as per Cl 222, IRC : 6 - 2014. z S a
Where, Ah = Horizontal Seismic Coefficient 2 g
Ah =
R
z = zone factor = For Zone IV = 0.24 I
I = Importance factor = = 1.20
R = Response Reduction factor = = 2.50
Sa/g = 2.5 for 0.0 < T < 0.55 For Medium Soil
= 1.36/T for 0.55 < T < 4.0
So, Sa/g = = 2.50
Horizontal coefficient - Ah 0.24/2x2.5/(2.5/1.2) = 0.14
230 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Summary of Moment
DL Earth fill EP Live load LL Surcharge Seismic Dy. Incr. of Dynamic inc. of LL
earth pr. surcharge
Wall above base slab 0 0 7988.09 0.0 1229.69 2046.17 3900.21 665.73
12.5m below top of wall 0 0 2440.28 0.0 557.78 781.62 1191.47 301.97
7.5m below top of wall 0 0 527.10 0.0 200.80 209.33 257.36 108.71
Summary of Shear
DL Earth fill EP Live load LL Surcharge Seismic Dy. Incr. of Dynamic inc. of LL
earth pr. surcharge
Wall above base slab 0 0 1024.74 0.0 132.51 220.5 420.3 54.3
12.5m below top of wall 0 0 464.81 0.0 89.24 125.1 190.6 36.6
7.5m below top of wall 0 0 167.33 0.0 53.55 55.8 68.6 22.0
231 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
232 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.01447 7508 kN
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 7508 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 7508 kN
Compressive force CG 216.90 mm Moment of resistance = 18470 kNm
< 15337 kNm Hence O.K.
Basic Combination (UL1) -moment
Description Wall above base slab 12.5m below 7.5m
top of
below
wall top of wall
Moment 15336.65 4976.13 1160.35
D 2800.00 2279.08 1567.45
b 1000.00 1000.00 1000.00
Clear cover 75.00 75.00 75.00
d 2677.00 2156.08 1492.5
R = Mu/bd2 2.14 1.07 0.52
pt 0.00527 0.00254 0.00122
Ast required 14099.3 5480.1 1815.0
32 dia + 32 dia + 0 dia +
32 dia + 32 dia + 0 dia +
Reinf provided 25 dia + 0 dia + 0 dia
25 dia + 25 dia 25 dia
150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c
Ast provided 17268.3 13995.8 3272.5
Actual NA 521 423 99
Strain in steel 0.0145 0.0144 0.0494
Stress in steel 434.8 434.8 434.8
Total ultimate tensile force = 7508 6085 1423
7508
Total ultimate compressive force 6085 1423
Difference of force 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 216.9 175.8 41.1
Moment of resistance 18470 12050 2065
Factor of Safety 1.204 2.422 1.780
Check Safe Safe Safe
233 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
12.3.1.2. Shear
i) Shear Capacity of Cracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
VRD.C = [0.12*K(80*ρ1*fck)^0.33+0.15σcp]*bw*d Subject to VRD.C MIN = {vmin + 0.15σCP)*bw*d
Where, K = 1+sqrt(200/d) <= 2 Where, d is in millimeters
ρ1 = Asl/(bw*d) <= 0.02 fck = 40 Mpa
σcp = NEd/Ac <= 0.2xfcd Where, NEd = axial compression, Ac = Area of section
vmin = 0.031*K^1.5*fck^0.5 fcd = αcc*fck/γm where, αcc =0.67 and γm = 1.5
Description Wall above base slab 12.5m below7.5m
top of
below
wall top of wall
Prestress Force after all losses (kN)
0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective width in mm 1000 1000 1000
Effective Depth (d) in mm 2677 2156 1492
K 1.273 1.305 1.366
Stress due to Prestress ( 0 0 0
Shear Resistance minimum (V754.1 629.9 467.2
Ast provided 17268.3 13995.8 3272.5
Reinforcement ratio, ρ1 0.006 0.006 0.002
Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN)1110.8 918.5 465.3
Design Shear resistance ( V 1110.8 918.5 467.2
1813.14
Max.shear at 1d dist.from face (kN) 868.21 334.80
M tanδ/d 709.96 286.01 66.69
Effective shear 1103.18 582.20 268.10
Factor of Safety 1.01 1.58 1.74
Check Safe Safe Safe
217.54
0.00109
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
=
Total compressive force = 3756.61 kN Total tensile force = 3756.61 kN
Compressive force CG = 288.72 mm Moment of resistance = 8971.85 kNm
234 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
12.4.2. Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 193.69 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 11.996
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 307.5 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.056
fct,eff = = 2.12 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.00081
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000581
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 50 mm
= 75
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 28.9 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 257.6 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.209 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Total for Quasi-permanent (SL3)
Wall 12.5m
Description above below top
base slab of wall
Stress in steel, σs 193.7 90.7
As 17268.3 13995.8
Actual NA 866 699
hc,eff 307.5 307.5
ρp,eff 0.056 0.046
εsm-εcm 0.00081 0.00027
φeq 30.0 32.0
effective cover, c 75.0 75.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 345.9 374.5
Crack width, Wk 0.280 0.102
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
235 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
117.56 7.14
kN/m2 kN/m2
A 16.2 m B
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
6988.01 0.00
kN-m/m kN-m/m
16.16 m
E= = 33346 Mpa
Moment
Cumulativ Moment
Section Distance Depth I M/EI of M/EI
e distance (kN-m)
about B
1 0.000 0.000 0.500 0.01042 0.00 0
2 2.309 2.309 0.829 0.04740 36.68 0.00002 0.00003
3 2.309 4.617 1.157 0.12912 217.34 0.00005 0.00029
4 2.309 6.926 1.486 0.27329 647.92 0.00007 0.00081
5 2.309 9.234 1.814 0.49766 1434.34 0.00009 0.00147
6 2.309 11.543 2.143 0.81997 2682.54 0.00010 0.00221
7 2.309 13.851 2.471 1.25795 4498.45 0.00011 0.00301
8 2.309 16.160 2.800 1.82933 6988.01 0.00011 0.00384
Total 0.01167 m
So, Total deflection = = 11.669 mm = L/ 1385
32 dia
@ 150 c/c
25 dia @ 150 c/c
32 dia
@ 150 c/c
25 dia
@ 150 c/c
5000
236 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
237 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
13.0 Design Data for RCC cantilever Retaining wall - RW-01 Ht = 9.96 m
1.1 Geometric details
Max. Finished road level = 893.96 m
Minimum ground level = 886.00 m
Minimum Depth of Foundation as per cl. 205.2.1 of IRC: 78-2014 = 2.000 m
RL at founding level = 884.00 m
Width of foundation Width of toe = 2.000 m
Width of heel = 4.500 m
Thickness of Stem at base = 1.000 m
Thickness of Toe = 0.900 m
Total width of foundation = 7.500 m
Friction coefficient bet. soil and concrete (as per cl. no. 706.3.4 IRC: 78-2014) = 0.50
Friction coefficient bet. Rock and concrete (as per cl. no. 706.3.4 IRC: 78-2014) = 0.70
238 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1.6 Sketch
12
893.960 m
13
300
4000 7
609
o
= 4.42
7960
8
1 886.000 m
2
11
2000
600 9 4 3 10
5
900 884.0 m
300 6
4500 1000 2000
7500
Section of Retaining Wall
239 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
13.2.2 Active earth Pressure on vertical wall at seismic case 0.00 kN/m2
(As per IS: 1893-2002)
Active earth pressure coefficient at Normal case Ka
= (1+-Av )*Cos2(φ− λ -α)
Cosλ∗Cos2α*Cos(α+δ+λ)*[1+{Sin(φ+δ)*Sin(φ-β−λ)/(Cos(α-β)*Cos(δ+α+λ))}1/2]2
Note :- 26.36 kN/m2
α = Angle subtended by the earth side wall with the
vertical on the earth side = 0.08 radians
φ = Angle of internal friction of the earth fill = 0.52 radians
δ = Angle of friction of the earth side wall with the earth=2φ/3 = 0.35 radians
β = Inclination of the earth fill surface with horizontal = 0.00 radians
γs = Unit weight of Soil at normal case = 19.00 kN/m2
Surcharge = 1.2xγsoil = 22.80 kN/m2
Seismic forces on the structure are calculated as per Cl 222, IRC : 6 - 2014. z S a
Where, Ah = Horizontal Seismic Coefficient 2 g
Ah =
R
z = zone factor = For Zone IV = 0.24 I
I = Importance factor = = 1.20
R = Response Reduction factor = = 2.50
Sa/g = 2.5 for 0.0 < T < 0.55 For Medium Soil
= 1.36/T for 0.55 < T < 4.0
So, Sa/g = = 2.50
Horizontal coefficient - Ah 0.24/2x2.5/(2.5/1.2) = 0.14
Vertical coefficient - Av =2/3Ah = 0.10
λ = Ah/(1+Av) = 0.13
Active earth pressure coefficient at seismic case = Ka = 0.470
Active earth pressure coefficient at normal case = Ka = 0.330
Dynamic increment of static earth pressure coefficient = 0.139
240 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Dynamic increment of Horz. earth pr. at top of base slab = 0.139*(7.96+2-0.9)*19 = 23.98 kN/m2
Dynamic increment of Horz. earth pr. at bottom slab = 0.139*(7.96+2)*19 = 26.36 kN/m2
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. due to LL surcharge = 0.139*22.8 = 3.18 kN/m2
1 1
2 1 1 1
3 1 1 1 1 1
4 1 1 1 0.2 0.2 1 0.33
Load combination at bottom of base slab for verification of equilibrium
Load Case Restoring Forces Overturning Forces
Vertical load Lateral Moment (kN- Vertical load Lateral force Moment
(kN) force (kN) m) (kN) (kN) (kN-m)
1 277.23 0.00 789.82 0.00 0.00 0.00
2 1190.95 0.00 5226.62 0.00 283.46 1185.75
3 1309.51 0.00 5807.56 0.00 351.76 1525.90
4 1223.45 0.00 5342.81 0.00 462.34 2005.60
5 1205.88 0.00 5342.81 0.00 462.34 2005.60
241 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
242 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Wt.of base slab 7.5 kN/m2 22.5 22.5 kN/m2 7.5 kN/m2
Wt.of earth fill 0 kN/m2 0 0 kN/m2 0 kN/m2
Base pressure -10.3 kN/m2 -42.3 -49.4 kN/m2 -63.6 kN/m2
Total pr. -2.8 kN/m2 -19.8 -26.9 kN/m2 -56.1 kN/m2
Moment -85.8 -92.7 kN-m/m
Shear at dist d for toe and face of wall for heel -50.9 -52.9 kN/m
243 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
244 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
245 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.01045 2846 kN
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 2846 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 2846 kN
Compressive force CG 93.95 mm Moment of resistance = 2294 kNm
< 1821 kNm Hence O.K.
Basic Combination (UL1) -moment
Description Wall above base slab 4m below top of wall
At heel slab At toe slab
Moment 1821.13 212.38 1317.36 543.63
D 1000.00 609.05 900.00 900.00
b 1000.00 1000.00 1000.00 1000.00
Clear cover 75.00 75.00 75.00 75.00
d 912.50 534.1 812.5 812.5
R = Mu/bd2 2.19 0.74 2.00 0.82
pt 0.00545 0.00176 0.00494 0.00195
Ast required 4975.9 937.8 4010.3 1582.2
25 dia + 0 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia +
Reinf provided 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia +
150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c
Ast provided 6545.0 3272.5 6545.0 6545.0
Actual NA 226 113 226 226
Strain in steel 0.0106 0.0131 0.0091 0.0091
Stress in steel 434.8 434.8 434.8 434.8
Total ultimate tensile force = 2846 1423 2846 2846
Total ultimate compressive force2846 1423 2846 2846
Difference of force 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 94.0 47.0 94.0 94.0
Moment of resistance 2329 693 2045 2045
Factor of Safety 1.279 3.263 1.552 3.761
Check Safe Safe Safe Safe
13.6.1.2. Shear
i) Shear Capacity of Cracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
VRD.C = [0.12*K(80*ρ1*fck)^0.33+0.15σcp]*bw*d Subject to VRD.C MIN = {vmin + 0.15σCP)*bw*d
Where, K = 1+sqrt(200/d) <= 2 Where, d is in millimeters
ρ1 = Asl/(bw*d) <= 0.02 fck = 35 Mpa
σcp = NEd/Ac <= 0.2xfcd Where, NEd = axial compression, Ac = Area of section
vmin = 0.031*K^1.5*fck^0.5 fcd = αcc*fck/γm where, αcc =0.67 and γm = 1.5
Description Wall above base slab 4m below top of wall
At heel slab At toe slab
Prestress Force after all losses (kN) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective width in mm 1000 1000 1000 1000
Effective Depth (d) in mm 913 534 813 813
K 1.468 1.612 1.496 1.496
Stress due to Prestress (σcp) (Mpa) 0 0 0 0
Shear Resistance minimum (V 297.7 200.5 272.7 272.7
Ast provided 6545.0 3272.5 6545.0 6545.0
Reinforcement ratio, ρ1 0.007 0.006 0.008 0.008
Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 432.6 263.9 407.9 407.9
Design Shear resistance ( VRd,c 432.6 263.9 407.9 407.9
426.37
Max.shear at 1d dist.from face (kN) 114.97 446.20 359.34
M tanδ/d 154.20 30.73 216.18 200.72
Effective shear 272.17 84.25 230.02 158.61
Factor of Safety 1.59 3.13 1.77 2.57
Check Safe Safe Safe Safe
246 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Balanced neutral axis depth = = 307.89 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 309.38 mm
Strain in steel = 0.00107 Stress in steel = 214.3 MPa
Strain in concrete = 0.00056 Comp. stress of concrete = 9.07 Mpa
Stress-strain diagram at Serviceability Limit State condition
0.00056 9.07
1402.54
309.38
NA NA
214.29
0.00107
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
=
Total compressive force = 1402.54 kN Total tensile force = 1402.54 kN
Compressive force CG = 103.13 mm Moment of resistance = 1117.64 kNm
Rare Combination (SL1) Quasi-permanent (SL3)
Wall Wall
Description above 4m below At heel above 4m below At heel
base slab top of wall slab At toe slab base slab top of wall slab At toe slab
h or D 1000 609 900 900 1000 609 900 900
b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
d 913 534 813 813 913 534 813 813
Moment 1117.64 125.05 772.41 362.83 892.48 0.00 614.18 310.17
Reinf provided 25 dia + 0 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 0 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia +
25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia 25 dia
150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c
Ast provided 6545.0 3272.5 6545.0 6545.0 6545.0 3272.5 6545.0 6545.0
Stress in concrete 8.9 3.1 7.4 3.5 7.1 0.0 5.9 3.0
Actual NA 312 171 291 291 312 171 291 291
Stress in steel 211.2 80.1 164.9 77.5 168.7 0.0 131.1 66.2
Total ultimate tensile force = 1382 262 1079 507 1104 0 858 433
Total ultimate compressive force1382 262 1079 507 1104 0 858 433
Difference of force 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 104.0 57.1 96.9 96.9 104.0 57.1 96.9 96.9
Moment of resistance 1118 125 772 363 892 0 614 310
Diff. of moment 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Maximum compressive stress of concrete= 8.9 Mpa < 16.8 Mpa Hence O.K.
Maximum tensile stress of steel= 211.2 Mpa < 400.0 Mpa Hence O.K.
247 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
13.6.2.2. Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 168.66 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 12.381
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 250.0 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.026
fct,eff = = 1.94 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.000598
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000506
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 50 mm
= 75
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 25.0 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 332.3 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.199 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Total for Quasi-permanent (SL3)
Wall
Description above 4m below At heel
base slab top of wall slab At toe slab
Stress in steel, σs 168.7 0.0 131.1 66.2
As 6545.0 3272.5 6545.0 6545.0
Actual NA 312 171 291 291
hc,eff 218.8 187.5 250.0 250.0
ρp,eff 0.030 0.017 0.026 0.026
εsm-εcm 0.00062 0.00000 0.00041 0.00020
φeq 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0
effective cover, c 75.0 0.0 75.0 75.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 397.0 243.5 417.3 417.3
Crack width, Wk 0.247 0.000 0.171 0.083
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
58.63 6.86
kN/m2 kN/m2
A 9.1 m B
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
1173.93 0.00
kN-m/m kN-m/m
9.06 m
E= = 32308 Mpa
Cumulati Moment
Moment
Section Distance ve Depth I M/EI of M/EI
(kN-m)
distance about B
1 0.000 0.000 0.300 0.00225 0.00 0
2 1.294 1.294 0.400 0.00533 8.35 0.00005 0.00002
3 1.294 2.589 0.500 0.01042 43.79 0.00013 0.00022
4 1.294 3.883 0.600 0.01800 121.95 0.00021 0.00071
5 1.294 5.177 0.700 0.02858 258.43 0.00028 0.00144
6 1.294 6.471 0.800 0.04267 468.85 0.00034 0.00234
7 1.294 7.766 0.900 0.06075 768.81 0.00039 0.00337
8 1.294 9.060 1.000 0.08333 1173.93 0.00044 0.00451
Total 0.01261 m
So, Total deflection = = 12.606 mm = L/ 719
248 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
25 dia
@ 150 c/c
16 dia @ 150 c/c
25 dia
@ 150 c/c
249 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
250 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
15.0 Design Data for RCC cantilever Retaining wall - RW-01 Ht = 7.55 m
1.1 Geometric details
Max. Finished road level = 890.55 m
Minimum ground level = 885.00 m
Minimum Depth of Foundation as per cl. 205.2.1 of IRC: 78-2014 = 2.000 m
RL at founding level = 883.00 m
Width of foundation Width of toe = 1.750 m
Width of heel = 3.250 m
Thickness of Stem at base = 0.800 m
Thickness of Toe = 0.800 m
Total width of foundation = 5.800 m
Friction coefficient bet. soil and concrete (as per cl. no. 706.3.4 IRC: 78-2014) = 0.50
Friction coefficient bet. Rock and concrete (as per cl. no. 706.3.4 IRC: 78-2014) = 0.70
251 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
1.6 Sketch
12
890.548 m
13
300
3000 7
522
o
= 4.24
5548
8
1 885.000 m
2
11
2000
500 9 4 3 10
5
800 883.0 m
300 6
3250 800 1750
5800
Section of Retaining Wall
252 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
15.2.2 Active earth Pressure on vertical wall at seismic case 0.00 kN/m2
(As per IS: 1893-2002)
Active earth pressure coefficient at Normal case Ka
= (1+-Av )*Cos2(φ− λ -α)
Cosλ∗Cos2α*Cos(α+δ+λ)*[1+{Sin(φ+δ)*Sin(φ-β−λ)/(Cos(α-β)*Cos(δ+α+λ))}1/2]2
Note :- 19.93 kN/m2
α = Angle subtended by the earth side wall with the
vertical on the earth side = 0.07 radians
φ = Angle of internal friction of the earth fill = 0.52 radians
δ = Angle of friction of the earth side wall with the earth=2φ/3 = 0.35 radians
β = Inclination of the earth fill surface with horizontal = 0.00 radians
γs = Unit weight of Soil at normal case = 19.00 kN/m2
Surcharge = 1.2xγsoil = 22.80 kN/m2
Seismic forces on the structure are calculated as per Cl 222, IRC : 6 - 2014. z S a
Where, Ah = Horizontal Seismic Coefficient 2 g
Ah =
R
z = zone factor = For Zone IV = 0.24 I
I = Importance factor = = 1.20
R = Response Reduction factor = = 2.50
Sa/g = 2.5 for 0.0 < T < 0.55 For Medium Soil
= 1.36/T for 0.55 < T < 4.0
So, Sa/g = = 2.50
Horizontal coefficient - Ah 0.24/2x2.5/(2.5/1.2) = 0.14
Vertical coefficient - Av =2/3Ah = 0.10
λ = Ah/(1+Av) = 0.13
Active earth pressure coefficient at seismic case = Ka = 0.468
Active earth pressure coefficient at normal case = Ka = 0.329
Dynamic increment of static earth pressure coefficient = 0.139
253 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
Dynamic increment of Horz. earth pr. at top of base slab = 0.139*(5.55+2-0.8)*19 = 17.82 kN/m2
Dynamic increment of Horz. earth pr. at bottom slab = 0.139*(5.55+2)*19 = 19.93 kN/m2
Dynamic increment of Earth pr. due to LL surcharge = 0.139*22.8 = 3.17 kN/m2
1 1
2 1 1 1
3 1 1 1 1 1
4 1 1 1 0.2 0.2 1 0.33
254 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
255 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
256 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
257 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
At top of
Type of loads 3m below At heel At toe slab At top of At heel At toe slab
base slab top of wall slab base slab slab
1 0.00 0.00 -50.19 -53.44 0.00 -50.19 -53.44
2 367.71 34.29 236.23 -159.80 367.71 236.23 -159.80
3 492.26 58.91 318.97 -197.25
Maximum 492.26 58.91 318.97 -197.25 367.71 236.23 -159.80
258 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
0.01357 1821 kN
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 1821 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 1821 kN
Compressive force CG 60.13 mm Moment of resistance = 1174 kNm
< 784 kNm Hence O.K.
Basic Combination (UL1) -moment
Description Wall above base slab 3m below top of wall
At heel slab At toe slab
Moment 783.94 98.34 531.22 294.93
D 800.00 522.29 800.00 800.00
b 1000.00 1000.00 1000.00 1000.00
Clear cover 75.00 75.00 75.00 75.00
d 715.00 447.3 715.0 715.0
R = Mu/bd2 1.53 0.49 1.04 0.58
pt 0.00372 0.00115 0.00248 0.00135
Ast required 2662.3 513.9 1770.7 967.0
20 dia + 0 dia + 20 dia + 20 dia +
Reinf provided 20 dia + 20 dia + 16 dia + 16 dia +
150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c
Ast provided 4188.8 2094.4 3434.8 3434.8
Actual NA 145 72 119 119
Strain in steel 0.0138 0.0182 0.0176 0.0176
Stress in steel 434.8 434.8 434.8 434.8
Total ultimate tensile force =1821 911 1493 1493
1821
Total ultimate compressive force 911 1493 1493
Difference of force 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 60.1 30.1 49.3 49.3
Moment of resistance 1193 380 994 994
Factor of Safety 1.521 3.863 1.871 3.371
Check Safe Safe Safe Safe
259 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
15.6.1.2. Shear
i) Shear Capacity of Cracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
VRD.C = [0.12*K(80*ρ1*fck)^0.33+0.15σcp]*bw*d Subject to VRD.C MIN = {vmin + 0.15σCP)*bw*d
Where, K = 1+sqrt(200/d) <= 2 Where, d is in millimeters
ρ1 = Asl/(bw*d) <= 0.02 fck = 35 Mpa
σcp = NEd/Ac <= 0.2xfcd Where, NEd = axial compression, Ac = Area of section
vmin = 0.031*K^1.5*fck^0.5 fcd = αcc*fck/γm where, αcc =0.67 and γm = 1.5
Description Wall above base slab 3m below top of wall
At heel slab At toe slab
Prestress Force after all losses (kN)
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective width in mm 1000 1000 1000 1000
Effective Depth (d) in mm 715 447 715 715
K 1.529 1.669 1.529 1.529
Stress due to Prestress ( 0 0 0 0
Shear Resistance minimum (V247.9 176.8 247.9 247.9
Ast provided 4188.8 2094.4 3434.8 3434.8
Reinforcement ratio, ρ1 0.006 0.005 0.005 0.005
Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 330.2 209.4 309.3 309.3
Design Shear resistance ( V 330.2 209.4 309.3 309.3
249.98
Max.shear at 1d dist.from face (kN) 69.56 263.19 220.56
M tanδ/d 81.24 16.29 114.30 117.85
Effective shear 168.74 53.27 148.89 102.70
Factor of Safety 1.96 3.93 2.08 3.01
Check Safe Safe Safe Safe
Balanced neutral axis depth = = 241.18 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 223.48 mm
Strain in steel = 0.00093 Stress in steel = 186.4 MPa
Strain in concrete = 0.00043 Comp. stress of concrete = 6.99 Mpa
Stress-strain diagram at Serviceability Limit State condition
0.00043 6.99
780.74
223.48
NA NA
186.39
0.00093
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
=
Total compressive force = 780.74 kN Total tensile force = 780.74 kN
Compressive force CG = 74.49 mm Moment of resistance = 492.26 kNm
260 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c
Ast provided 4188.8 2094.4 3434.8 3434.8 4188.8 2094.4 3434.8 3434.8
Stress in concrete 6.8 2.3 4.8 2.9 5.1 2.3 3.5 2.4
Actual NA 225 129 208 208 225 129 208 208
Stress in steel 183.7 69.5 143.8 88.9 137.2 69.5 106.5 72.0
Total ultimate tensile force = 769 146 494 305 575 146 366 247
Total ultimate compressive force769 146 494 305 575 146 366 247
Difference of force 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 75.1 42.9 69.2 69.2 75.1 42.9 69.2 69.2
Moment of resistance 492 59 319 197 368 59 236 160
Diff. of moment 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Maximum compressive stress of concrete= 6.8 Mpa < 16.8 Mpa Hence O.K.
Maximum tensile stress of steel= 183.7 Mpa < 400.0 Mpa Hence O.K.
15.6.2.2. Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 137.19 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 12.381
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 237.5 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.018
fct,eff = = 1.94 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.000412
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000412
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 50 mm
= 75
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 20.0 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 362.8 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.149 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Total for Quasi-permanent (SL3)
Wall
Description above 3m below At heel
base slab top of wall slab At toe slab
Stress in steel, σs 137.2 69.5 106.5 72.0
As 4188.8 2094.4 3434.8 3434.8
Actual NA 225 129 208 208
hc,eff 212.5 187.5 237.5 237.5
ρp,eff 0.020 0.011 0.014 0.014
εsm-εcm 0.00041 0.00021 0.00032 0.00022
φeq 20.0 20.0 18.2 18.2
effective cover, c 75.0 0.0 75.0 75.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 427.5 304.4 469.2 469.2
Crack width, Wk 0.176 0.064 0.150 0.101
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
261 of 275
Ramban Banihal Project HCC MNB-05 - 30m Integral bridge
45.29 6.84
kN/m2 kN/m2
A 6.7 m B
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
523.40 0.00
kN-m/m kN-m/m
6.748 m
E= = 32308 Mpa
Cumulati Moment
Moment
Section Distance ve Depth I M/EI of M/EI
(kN-m)
distance about B
1 0.000 0.000 0.300 0.00225 0.00 0
2 0.964 0.964 0.371 0.00427 4.25 0.00003 0.00001
3 0.964 1.928 0.443 0.00724 21.29 0.00009 0.00008
4 0.964 2.892 0.514 0.01134 57.54 0.00016 0.00029
5 0.964 3.856 0.586 0.01674 119.45 0.00022 0.00061
6 0.964 4.820 0.657 0.02365 213.44 0.00028 0.00105
7 0.964 5.784 0.729 0.03223 345.94 0.00033 0.00156
8 0.964 6.748 0.800 0.04267 523.40 0.00038 0.00215
Total 0.00575 m
So, Total deflection = = 5.754 mm = L/ 1173
20 dia
@ 150 c/c
12 dia @ 150 c/c
20 dia
@ 150 c/c
262 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
263 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
1.0 Design Data for RCC U-Trough (TR-1) for Embankment protection Ht = 10.87 m
1.1 Geometric details
Max. Finished road level = 896.87 m
Minimum ground level = 888.00 m
Minimum Depth of Foundation as per cl. 705.2.1 of IRC: 78-2014 = 2.000 m
RL at founding level = 886.00 m
Width of foundation Width of each toe = 0.250 m
Width of bridge = 12.028 m
Thickness of Stem at base = 1.250 m
Thickness of foundation = 1.000 m
Total width of foundation = 12.528 m
Friction coefficient bet. soil and concrete (as per cl. no. 706.3.4 IRC: 78-2014) = 0.50
Friction coefficient bet. Rock and concrete (as per cl. no. 706.3.4 IRC: 78-2014) = 0.70
264 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
1.6 Sketch
4
896.870 m
8
300
5
4000
685
o 8743
= 5.50
8870
1142
6 α
1 888.000 m
2
7 1000 7
300 2000
3 1000 886.0 m
Sl No Load Calculation Area(m2) Weight (kN) Ver. Lever arm(m) Moment (kN-m)
265 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
2.3.2 Active earth Pressure on vertical wall at seismic case 0.00 kN/m2
(As per IS: 1893-2002)
Active earth pressure coefficient at Normal case Ka
= (1+-Av)*Cos2(φ− λ -α)
Cosλ∗Cos2α*Cos(α+δ+λ)*[1+{Sin(φ+δ)*Sin(φ-β−λ)/(Cos(α-β)*Cos(δ+α+λ))}1/2]2
Note :- 29.02 kN/m2
α = Angle subtended by the earth side wall with the
vertical on the earth side = 0.10 radians
φ = Angle of internal friction of the earth fill = 0.52 radians
δ = Angle of friction of the earth side wall with the earth=2φ/3 = 0.35 radians
β = Inclination of the earth fill surface with horizontal = 0.00 radians
γs = Unit weight of Soil at normal case = 19.00 kN/m2
Surcharge = 1.2xγsoil = 22.80 kN/m2
Seismic forces on the structure are calculated as per Cl 222, IRC : 6 - 2014.
Where, Ah = Horizontal Seismic Coefficient
266 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
1 1
2 1 1 1
3 1 1 1 1 1
4 1 1 1 0.2 0.2 1 0.3
Load combination at bottom of base slab for verification of equilibrium
Load Case Restoring Forces Overturning Forces
Vertical load Lateral force Moment (kN- Lateral force
Vertical load (kN) Moment (kN-m)
(kN) (kN) m) (kN)
1 705.66 0.00 4420.27 0.00 0.00 0.00
2 2680.10 0.00 16788.16 0.00 0.00 0.00
3 2940.66 0.00 18420.30 0.00 75.80 0.00
4a 2809.4 0.00 17598.08 0.00 265.44 1129.28
4b 2655.027 0.00 16631.09 0.00 265.44 1129.28
267 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
268 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
9528 250
12528
269 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
1 1.35
2 1.35 1.5 1.5
3 (a) 1.35 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.2
3 (b) 1 1.5 1 1.5 1.2
3 (c) 1 1.5 1 1.15 1.2
4 (a) 1.35 1 1.5 0.2 0.2 1.50 0.20
4 (b) 1 1 1 0.2 0.2 1.50 0.20
Basic Combination (UL1)
Wall above base slab 8.743m below top of wall4m below top of wall At heel slab At toe slab
Type of
loads Moment (kN- Moment Moment (kN- Moment (kN-
m) Shear (kN) (kN-m) Shear (kN) Moment (kN-m) Shear (kN) m) Shear (kN) m) Shear (kN)
1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 -597.91 -201.48 -1.32 28.55
2 1760.13 333.17 1223.41 333.17 117.16 69.74 133.54 12.39 -7.82 168.88
3 (a) 2167.74 406.33 1543.26 406.33 184.11 103.21 189.09 26.69 -8.79 189.94
3 (b) 1581.03 295.28 1135.45 295.28 145.05 79.97 344.10 78.93 -8.45 182.54
3 (c) 1581.03 295.28 1135.45 295.28 145.05 79.97 331.14 75.59 -8.22 177.62
4 (a) 2950.04 641.00 2017.80 564.79 264.22 182.76 111.64 122.34 -8.04 176.60
4 (b) 2363.34 529.95 1610.00 453.74 225.16 159.51 266.65 174.57 -7.70 169.20
Maximum 2950.04 641.00 2017.80 564.79 264.22 182.76 344.10 174.57 -8.79 28.55
270 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
0.00986 3754 kN
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
Section is under reinforced, Hence ok
Total ultimate compressive force = 3754 kN Total ultimate tensile force = 3754 kN
Compressive force CG 123.94 mm Moment of resistance = 3805 kNm
< 2950 kNm Hence O.K.
271 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
5.1.2. Shear
i) Shear Capacity of Cracked Section as per clause 10.3.2(2) of IRC 112-2010
VRD.C = [0.12*K(80*ρ1*fck)^0.33+0.15σcp]*bw*d Subject to VRD.C MIN = {vmin + 0.15σCP)*bw*d
Where, K = 1+sqrt(200/d) <= 2 Where, d is in millimeters
ρ1 = Asl/(bw*d) <= 0.02 fck = 35 Mpa
σcp = NEd/Ac <= 0.2xfcd Where, NEd = axial compression, Ac = Area of section
vmin = 0.031*K^1.5*fck^0.5 fcd = αcc*fck/γm where, αcc =0.67 and γm = 1.5
Description Wall above base slab 8.743m below top of4m
wall
below top of wall At heel slab At toe slab
Prestress Force after all losses (kN)0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Effective width in mm 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
Effective Depth (d) in mm 1127.0 1054.0 597.5 917.0 917.0
K 1.421 1.436 1.579 1.467 1.467
Stress due to Prestress (σcp 0 0 0 0 0
Shear Resistance minimum (V 350.2 332.5 217.3 298.8 298.8
Ast provided 8634.1 8634.1 3272.5 3434.8 2094.4
Reinforcement ratio, ρ1 0.008 0.008 0.005 0.004 0.002
Shear resistance ( VRd,c) (kN) 528.6 510.6 278.7 350.6 297.8
Design Shear resistance ( V 528.6 510.6 278.7 350.6 298.8
Max.shear at 1d dist.from face 641.00
(kN) 564.79 182.76 174.57 28.55
M tanδ/d 251.95 184.26 42.56 39.38 0.00
Effective shear 389.06 380.53 140.20 135.19 28.55
Factor of Safety 1.36 1.34 1.99 2.59 10.47
Check Safe Safe Safe Safe Safe
Balanced neutral axis depth = = 389.14 mm Actual neutral axis depth = 397.70 mm
Strain in steel = 0.00083 Stress in steel = 166.6 MPa
Strain in concrete = 0.00045 Comp. stress of concrete = 7.23 Mpa
272 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
166.56
0.00083
Strain Diagram Stress Diagram
=
Total compressive force = 1438.06 kN Total tensile force = 1438.06 kN
Compressive force CG = 132.57 mm Moment of resistance = 1445.16 kNm
Rare Combination (SL1) Quasi-permanent (SL3)
Wall 8.743m
Description above below top Wall above
base slab of wall At heel slab At toe slab base slab At toe slab At heel slab At toe slab
h or D 1250 1142 1000 1000 1250 1142 1000 1000
b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
d 1127 1054 917 925 1127 1054 917 925
Moment 1445.16 1028.84 81.77 5.96 1173.42 815.61 44.74 5.31
Reinf provided 25 dia + 25 dia + 20 dia + 20 dia + 25 dia + 25 dia + 20 dia + 20 dia +
32 dia + 32 dia + 16 dia 0 dia 32 dia + 32 dia + 16 dia 0 dia
0 dia 0 dia 0 dia
150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c 150 c/c
Ast provided 8634.1 8634.1 3434.8 2094.4 8634.1 8634.1 3434.8 2094.4
Stress in concrete 7.3 5.8 0.8 0.1 6.0 4.6 0.4 0.1
Actual NA 395 380 240 195 395 380 240 195
Stress in steel 168.2 128.5 28.4 3.3 136.6 101.9 15.6 2.9
Total ultimate tensile force = 1452 1109 98 7 1179 879 53 6
Total ultimate compressive force 1452 1109 98 7 1179 879 53 6
Difference of force 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Compressive force CG 131.8 126.6 80.0 64.9 131.8 126.6 80.0 64.9
Moment of resistance 1445 1029 82 6 1173 816 45 5
Diff. of moment 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Maximum compressive stress of concrete= 7.3 Mpa < 16.8 Mpa Hence O.K.
Maximum tensile stress of steel= 168.2 Mpa < 400.0 Mpa Hence O.K.
273 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
5.2.2. Check for crack width Check crack width As per IRC : 112-2011
Crack width, Wk = Sr,max * (εsm-εcm)
Where, εsm-εcm = (σsc-kt*fct,eff/ρp,eff*(1+αe*ρp,eff))/Es >= 0.6σsc/Es
σsc = 136.56 Mpa αe =Es/Ecm = 12.381
kt = 0.5 hc,eff=min of [2.5(h-d),(h-x/3),h/2]= 281.3 mm
Ac,eff =b*hc,eff ρp,eff = As/Ac,eff = 0.031
fct,eff = = 1.94 Mpa εsm-εcm = 0.000464796
>= 0.6σsc/Es= 0.000409689
Sr,max =3.4c+0.425*k1*k2*φ/ρp,eff Where, c = 75 mm
= 75
k1 = 0.8
φeq=(n1*φ1^2+n2*φ2^2)/((n1*φ1+n2*φ2) = 25.0 mm k2 = 0.5
Sr,max = 393.4 mm Crack width, Wk = = 0.183 mm
< 0.3 mm OK
Total for Quasi-permanent (SL3)
Wall
Description above 4m below
base slab top of wall At heel slab At toe slab
Stress in steel, σs 136.6 101.9 15.6 2.9
As 8634.1 8634.1 3434.8 2094.4
Actual NA 395 380 240 195
hc,eff 307.5 218.8 207.5 187.5
ρp,eff 0.028 0.039 0.017 0.011
εsm-εcm 0.00045 0.00033 0.00005 0.00001
φeq 28.9 28.9 18.2 20.0
effective cover, c 75.0 75.0 75.0 75.0
Crack spacing Sr,max 430.2 379.6 442.1 559.4
Crack width, Wk 0.194 0.124 0.021 0.005
Check <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K. <0.3 O.K.
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
1513.10 0.00
kN-m/m kN-m/m
9.87 m
274 of 275
Ramban-Banihal Projects HCC U-Trough
25 dia
@ 150 c/c
16 dia @ 150 c/c
32 dia 5.9
@ 150 c/c
1250
25 dia @ 150 c/c 20 dia @ 150 c/c
275 of 275