Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
4 v. 14 CR 716 (VM)
11 Before:
13 District Judge
14
APPEARANCES
15
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
16 United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
17 AMANDA HOULE
EMIL BOVE
18 JASON RICHMAN
Assistant United States Attorneys
19
LAW OFFICE OF GEORGE R. GOLTZER
20 Attorneys for Defendant B. Abdalla
GEORGE R. GOLTZER
21 YING STAFFORD
6 specialist from our office, Morgan Hurst, and DEA Special Agent
7 James Stouch.
11 present.
23 examination?
21 the 3500 material for a great deal of time and went through it
21 REDIRECT EXAMINATION
22 BY MS. HOULE:
24 Ms. Cardi regarding New Year's Eve 2016, do you recall that?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. And on New Year's Eve 2016, you went to Ali Punjani's club,
2 is that correct?
3 A. Yes.
6 A. Yes.
8 were injured and you were taken out of the club, is that right?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. Before you left the club, did you see Baktash in the club?
11 A. Yes.
20 the New Year's Eve incident, and she's asking about Baktash at
21 this point.
1 BY MS. HOULE:
2 Q. Before you left the club that evening, did you see Ibrahim
3 there?
4 A. Yes.
15 A. Yes.
22 Afghanistan?
23 A. Yes.
13 right?
14 A. Yes.
22 A. Yes.
1 A. In Baktash's house.
3 A. Baktash.
8 were available?
9 A. Yes.
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. What is a monsoon?
18 heroin?
21 season, they don't allow them to go into the sea because the
22 sea is very rough and it's not advisable for them to go and
23 travel also.
1 recall that?
2 A. Yes.
4 A. 2014.
6 A. Yes.
11 A. Yes.
15 U.S.
17 A. Yes.
2 A. Yes.
4 A. Yes.
8 2014?
15 RECROSS EXAMINATION
16 BY MS. CARDI:
21 for the first time you have added that my client had a handgun
8 that Ibrahim hit -- you said Ibrahim Abdalla hit somebody's car
15 government that Ibrahim pulled out a gun and said: I'll kill
16 you. Correct?
17 A. Always I maintain Ibrahim had the gun and he pulled out the
18 gun.
23 again about the New Year's Eve incident, you say that you saw
24 Ibrahim pull out a gun but you don't say he was beating anyone.
2 Shafin Karar.
3 Q. But you did not tell the government that, did you?
8 Go ahead.
12 BY MS. CARDI:
13 Q. So today for the first time you say that Ibrahim Abdalla at
14 the New Year's Eve party suddenly hit this man called Shabara
17 just said, and I have the transcript cite from yesterday where
21 (Record read)
24 the government's notes did you record that Ibrahim Abdalla hit
4 3 --
10 Q. Did you tell the government on June 27 of 2019 that you saw
13 Punjani's man.
22 RECROSS EXAMINATION
23 BY MR. GOLTZER:
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. Would you agree that in fact the heroin was not available
5 monsoon?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Is that true?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. And for five months Baktash was telling them that there was
17 Q. But he told him that he had heroin available and that the
19 A. Yes.
21 A. Yes.
24 correct?
25 A. Not correct.
1 Q. You agree, do you not, that the heroin was not available in
2 Tanzania for the five months before you took over the drug
6 A. Yes.
10 A. Yes.
12 Gulam Hussein?
13 A. Not mine.
21 Q. And you were present when Rasheed was on the phone with
25 A. That's correct.
5 hearing?
7 would like to address the point made by Ms. Cardi regarding the
8 3500.
9 THE COURT: All right. Thank you, you may step down.
10 You're excused.
24 this witness told the government that at the club that night
3 the notes reflect that that day Ibrahim was identified as being
21 this occasion to do that, you may, and Ms. Cardi, you will have
1 2017, Mr. Goswami told the government about Pinky's murder and
6 asked the question: When was the first time -- isn't it a fact
7 that the first time you raised the Pinky murder was on your
8 eighth session.
25 was present at the mall with Livondo and pulled out his gun
1 that day, that Ibrahim gave Goswami his gun following that
14 government about, and that mostly came in the form of Ms. Cardi
17 there was an actual basis for any of those claims, Ms. Cardi
18 would have presented evidence of it. She did not. For what
19 it's worth, I found exactly one review of that book online, and
12 this Court: I tell the truth. Drug dealers tell the truth.
18 Ibrahim Abdalla. I read from the 3500 material for each and
2 material, any number of other areas that, for example, were not
7 did not rise to the level of somebody who could control the
9 someone who took people to the zoo, maybe chatted them up.
15 as he's doing with our government, he's going to get out, he's
16 going to get away. He's the international drug lord, and he's
17 the one who should be going away to prison for life. But he
18 knows, he's smart enough: I'll give them what they want about
21 But I'm not asking you to take my opinion, I'm asking you to
22 read the transcript. Your Honor, you can decide whether he was
25 our sentencing memos you will not give him the credit the
3 Mr. Goltzer.
8 witness.
11 was Mr. Gulam Hussein, who was the transporter of the hundred
12 kilos of heroin that found its way into Kenya and was
16 the Dubai jail with Mr. Gulam Hussain. He denied it. He said:
2 time but learned later, according to Mr. Hussain, was the word
6 messages.
9 the guy that plays cricket and separately killing the guy in
10 the black coat, and that messages were passed to the sister's
15 you a summary.
5 never seen anything like that. I don't know if the Court has,
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
5 that they never told the judge or the prosecutor that he had
7 they told this court in Dubai that, he'd still be there, where
4 it.
15 The heroin that showed up in connection with this case that the
22 that.
3 So how can you have the monsoon delay drugs that aren't there
5 get you the drugs after the monsoon. But Baktash is telling
6 him I have the drugs, I'll get you the drugs, I have samples.
7 It was nonsense.
10 is complicit in. The real issue for Mr. Baktash at the Fatico
19 allegation.
21 assassin that killed his father? Did the witness ask for
22 details? Did the witness give any details? No. How would
23 Baktash know who killed his father? Since there was never an
25 Honor. How would he know where to find the assassin and how
2 father what street corner they could find the guy on. There is
5 claim, and you know something, Judge, I could tell you that 16
8 the glass. And that's all that's involved with this particular
13 litigators, and the Court understands, that they all say that.
14 It's jury food. It makes them look good to the jury, and,
16 government.
18 tough cases to win. But it's clear that this witness has been
20 potential cases that could cost him the rest of his life in
23 then I'll sell you the bridge that I can see from here, Judge.
25 manipulator.
11 Armstrong and Baktash had been doing the mandrax business for
12 years. He was not only taking over the heroin, which didn't
15 what he was going to do was cut Baktash out, and he was going
20 manipulator, and the notion that he always told the truth, all
21 through his life in every drug deal he's done for 30 years is
22 one of the great fables. And the Grimm Brothers and Hans
8 life sentence for a man who pled guilty, who never brought an
9 ounce of the heroin to Kenya that was supposed to make its way
10 into the United States. They want a life sentence because they
12 happen. It was his gunman who did it, not Baktash's. And
19 they want to give you a life sentence for this man? On a plea?
20 And that guy's going to walk out of this courthouse, and he's
23 was pending in India. There was a time when India had a death
24 penalty for drugs and people were actually hung for it. Then
4 Indian law, because the prior conviction was not in India. But
6 many areas in the Muslim speaking world they cut your head off
8 His crime was in the United Arab Emirates which he went to jail
9 for in Dubai. I don't know what that penalty was, but he's not
13 because they love him, and India loves him -- oh, which reminds
14 me. There are 1.4 billion people in India. They can't find an
15 Indian assassin. They need him. They were going to use him to
5 into one of the biggest drug dealers in the world while he was
15 prison for, what he did when he was in prison, how he got out
16 of prison.
19 the government.
1 drugs. If you lose a ton shipment and you lie about it, you're
11 about the trip to Tanzania and the sample that they viewed
12 there.
16 Sayed. That was Baktash's contact. And that's the heroin that
22 how Pinky was killed, why Pinky was killed, how Baktash was
24 at 421-T. About how the purpose was so that nobody could mess
8 year later on the same street. Mr. Goswami didn't make that
10 recording.
18 what was good for Goswami was good for the Akashas in 2014.
25 Mr. Goswami made. Mr. Goswami testified about how much money
1 he made and the fact that he had spent it. I think it will be
4 money Baktash has made and what's happened to the millions and
6 that supported the lavish home on a beach that your Honor has
11 think now is the appropriate time for us to take that up, but
20 evidence I believe.
24 on. If you look at all these transcripts, you know what drug
4 don't even know who killed him. By the way, if the witness
9 telephone, I killed the man who killed my father, and this guy
10 says he told me he killed the man who killed his father. Makes
12 it's true.
22 high and literary level that Mr. Goltzer and Ms. Cardi has put
4 theme of that poem is the hangman has a day job, and then he
5 goes home, and he has children and dinner with the wife and is
7 The point is that there are some people who have a day
8 job and they also have a nightlife and a night job. And they
14 throughout his life. At the same time, in his night job, this
18 That is the way that I, to some extent, that I view Mr. Goswami
1 the world that occur over a long period, and some of the facts
13 asks about one issue and the witness testifies to that issue.
25 agents who sit there taking notes, and the government's agents
18 these circumstances.
3 necessarily was lying about the issues that are before the
4 Court.
7 also from time to time may tell the truth on some things. It
13 attributed to them.
20 Honor.
22 be here all day on the 7th, if that's convenient for the Court.
18 (Adjourned)
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
1 INDEX OF EXAMINATION
3 VIJAY GOSWAMI
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25