Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/275833965
CITATION READS
1 3,073
4 authors, including:
B. Rajkumar
Babu Banarasi Das College of Dental Sciences,B.B.D. University
45 PUBLICATIONS 28 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Vishesh Gupta on 05 May 2015.
ABSTRACT:
The determination of accurate working length is one of the most critical step in the
endodontic therapy. The cleaning, shaping and obturation cannot be accomplished
accurately unless the working length is determined precisely. Thus the predictable
endodontic success demands an accurate working length determination of the root canal.
This article reviews about working length determination and its clinical implications.
Keywords: Cemento-dentinal junction,Dentistry,Electronic apex locater,Radiographic tooth
length, Stomatognathic system, Working length determination.
*Corresponding Author Address: Dr.Akanksha Bhatt,30,Shiv Sarovar Extension, Bank Colony, Garh Road, Meerut, Uttar
Pradesh(India)-250001 Email:dr.a.bhatt@gmail.com
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
perform, easily reproducible and should be VARIOUS METHODS FOR CALCULATING
confirmative. WORKING LENGTH:
107
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
shaft is needed. The exploring instrument of radiographic distortion, sharply
size must be small enough to negotiate the curving roots and operator
total length of the canal. measuring errors.
108
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
The calculations dealing with the site of Estimate the length of the root (s) either
exiting of the canal (s) length & widths will by measuring the length with a –mm –
help to identify the major and more often ruler on the pre-op radiograph or using
the minor diameter. The calculations the tables in the opposite page.
dealing with the widths & length is valuable
in making the calculation for working Estimate the width of the canals (s) on
length. the radiograph. If the canal estimates is
narrow, consider using a size 10 or 15
The basis for this method’s value is the file, if average select – a size 20 or 25
measurement provided by Kuttler relating file, if wide choose a size 30 or 35, if
to the distance between the major very wide choose size 50 or larger.
diameter (site of exiting of the canal) and
the minor diameter (i.e. the CDJ). In Using the file selected by step (iv) Set
younger patients the distance between the stop for the W.L. according to the
these two positions is approx 0.5 mm and in measurement estimated in step (iii),
older patients due to increased build-up of Place the file in the access cavity and
cementum the distance is approx. 0.67 take an initial radiograph if the file
mm. Using the radiograph the dentist must seems to stop at a length that could be
locate the major diameter and then accurate stop and take a radiograph
interpolate the position of the minor rather than force the file into the
diameter or locate the minor diameter by periapical tissues.
seeing the funneled shape into the tooth If the file appears too long or too short
from the site of the exiting. by more than 1 mm from the minor
Step-by-Step technique for calculation of diameter make the interpolation and
working length by Kuttlers method: use that as the calculated working
length.
Using the information from the straight
and angled radiographs about the If your file reaches the major diameter
expected canal configuration prepare a exactly, subtract .5mm from the length
correct access cavity. Remove whatever if the patient is 35 years old or younger,
pulp tissue and debris needs to be reduce .67 mm from that length if the
removed prior to taking the length. patient is older.
Locate the major diameter and minor If the file reaches the site that you
diameter on the pre-op x ray. In some believe is the minor diameter use that
cases the exact site may not be seen, as the calculated working length. If it is
only that the radiolucent line of the obvious that a great deal of cementum
pulp canal space stops near the tip of has been deposited at the root tip,
the root. subtract a greater amount from the site
of the major diameter to rectify the
increased distance.
109
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
4. Best’s method [6,7] that its internal surface is in flush with the
resin surface contacting the tooth surface.
In 1960 BEST described a technique for
The probe is introduced into the root canal
determining the tooth length. In this
so that the resin touches the incisal edge or
method a steel pin measuring 10 mm is
cusp tip taking care to see that the bend
fixed to the labial surface of the root with
segment of the probe would be parallel to
utility wax keeping the pin parallel to the
the mesio-distal diameters of the crown
long axis of the tooth and a radiograph
thus making it possible to visualize it on the
obtained. The radiograph is then carried to
radiograph. Then the tooth is
a gauge, which would indicate the tooth
radiographed. In this radiograph the
length.
reference points are as follows.
5. Bregman’s method [6,7]
A-Internal angle of intersection of incisal U
It is a method in which 25 mm length flat radicular probe segment.
probes are prepared and each has a steel
B-Apical end of the probe
blade fixed with acrylic resin as a stop,
leaving a free end of 10 mm for placement C-Tooth apex
into the root canal? This probe is place in
Measuring the radiographic image length of
the tooth until the metallic end touches the
the probe. A-B, measuring the radiographic
incisal edge or cusp tip of the tooth. Then a
image length of the tooth from A to C and
radiograph is taken. In the radiographic
then measuring the real length of the
image the following is measured.
probe.
ALT-Apparent length of the tooth (as seen
Now the following equation is applied
in the radiograph)
CRD-Real tooth length
RLI-Real length of the instrument
CRS-Real tooth length
ALI-Apparent length of the instrument
CAD-Tooth length in radiograph
Now RLT (Real length of the tooth) is
calculated from the formula. CAS-Instrument length in radiograph
RLT-ALI x ALT / RLI CRD-CRS x CAD / CAS
6. Bramante’s method [6,7] Measuring the distance between the apical
end of the probe and the tooth apex in the
Bramante described another method to
radiograph. This measure is either added
determine tooth length. He employed
or diminished to obtain the correct length
stainless steel probes of various calibers&
of the tooth. This is somewhat similar to
Lengths. These were bend at one end at
that described by Ingle.
right angel and this bend is inserted
partially in acrylic resin in such a manner
110
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
7. X-ray grid system diagnostic tool in determining root canal
length. It has been stated that although
Everett & Fixott in 1963 designed a
there is no diagnostic difference between
diagnostic X-ray grid system for
Xero-radiography and conventional
determining the length of the tooth. The
radiography in determining the actual
diagnostic X-ray grid designed consists of
length of root canals, Xero-radiographic
lines 1 mm apart running lengthwise and
images of the fire for determining length
cross-wise. A heavier line to make the
are sharper and can be measured faster..
reading easier on the radiograph
These might be useful in detecting carious
accentuates every fifth millimeter.
lesions, especially proximal surface caries of
Enameled copper wires are placed in plexi- adult and primary teeth.
glass and fixed to a regular periapical film.
According to Macro in 1984,
The grid is taped to film to lie between the
Xeroradiography gave closer to accurate
tooth and film during exposure so that the
results in measurement compared to
pattern becomes incorporated in the
conventional radiographs.
finished film. The incorporated grid is used
for accurate measurement of working 9. Direct digital radiography or
length. radio-visiography
111
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
M.M.Negm in 1982 introduced a novel facts that make tactile identification
method of determining the length of root possible.
canal without the use of radiographs. The
i. The unresorbed canal commonly
new instrument apex finder is used to
constricts just before exiting the root .
locate the apex as well as measuring the
root length. The application of this method ii. It frequently changes course in the last 2-
is based on insertion of a fine plastic 3 mm. Both structures apply pressure to
tapered bared shaft through a beveled tube the file. A narrowing presses more tightly
into the root canal. against the instrument, whereas a
curvature deflects the instrument from a
When resistance to withdrawl is felt which
straight path. Both consume energy and
indicates that some barbs have engaged the
sensitive instrument with which the
apical margin, the shaft is marked at the
experienced clinician can accurately
level of the cusp tip. The distance between
determine passage through the foramen.
the mark and the barbs, which caused the
At this point, it also has access to pass
resistance, is measured.
through the apical accessory canal.
2. Audio metric method
4. Paper point evaluation
It is based on the principle of electrical
The paper point may be used to detect
resistance of comparative tissue using a low
bleeding or apical moisture. A bloody or
frequency oscillation sound to indicate
moist tip suggests an over extended
when similarity to electrical resistance has
preparation. Further assessment of the
occurred by a similar sound response. By
apical preparation and working length
placing an instrument in the gingival sulcus
should be made. The point of wetness often
and including an electric current until sound
given an approximate location to the actual
is produced and then repeating this by
canal end point. A wet or bloody point may
placing an instrument through the root
also indicate that the foramen has been
canal until the same sound is heard, one
zipped or the apex perforated during
can determine the length of the tooth.
preparation. These conditions would
3. Tactile method require additional canal shaping in addition
to adjustment of working length.
The experienced clinician develops a keen
tactile sense and can gain considerable 5. Electronics apex locator
information from passing an instrument
Although the term “apex locator” is
through the canal. Following access, when
commonly used and has become accepted
interferences in the coronal third of the
terminology, it is a misnomer. These
canal are removed, the observant clinician
devices attempt to locate the apical
can detect a sudden increase in resistance,
constriction, the cemento-dentinal junction,
as a small file approaches the apex. Careful
or the apical foramen. They are not
study of the apical anatomy discloses two
capable of routinely locating the
112
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
radiographic apex. In 1918, Custer was the Classification and Accuracy of Apex
first to report the use of electric current to Locators:
calculate working length. The scientific
The classification of apex locators
basis for apex locators originated with
presented here is a modification of the
research conducted by Suzuki in 1942. In
classification given by McDonald. This
1960, Gordon was the second to report the
classification is based on the type of current
use of a clinical device for electrical
flow and the opposite to the current flow,
measurement of root canals. Sunada
as well as the number of frequencies
adopted the principle reported by Suzuki
involved.
and was the first to describe the detail of a
simple clinical devise to measure working First-Generation Apex Locators- First –
length in patients. He used a simple direct generation apex locations devices, also
current ohmmeter to measure a constant known as “resistance apex locators”,
resistance of 6.5 kilo-ohms between oral measure opposition to the flow of direct
mucous membrane and the periodontium current or resistance. Eg- sono-explorer.
regardless of the size or shape of the teeth.
The device used by Sunada in his research Second-generation apex locators - Second-
became the basis for most apex locators. generation apex locators, also known as
“impedance apex locators”, measure
All apex locators function by using the opposition to the flow of alternating
human body to complete an electrical current or impedance.
circuit. One side of the apex locator’s
circuitry is connected to an endodontic There is another issue: not all apex locators
instrument. The other side is connected to incorporate the same degree of
the patient’s body either by a contact to the sophistication in electronic circuitry that
patient’s hand. The electrical circuit is adjusts its sensitivity to compensate for the
completed when the endodontic intracanal environment or indicates on its
instrument is advanced apically inside the display that it should be switched from a
root canal until it touches periodontal “wet” to a “dry” mode or vice versa. Eg-
tissue. The display on the apex locator Apex finder, Endo Analyzer.
indicates that the apical area has been
Third –Generation Apex Locators- The
reached. This simple and commonly
principle on which “third-generation” apex
accepted explanation for the electronic
locators are based “comparative
phenomenon has been challenged. It would
impedance”.Since the impedance of a given
be useful clinically to use the apical
circuit may be substantially influenced by
constriction as the ideal apical foramen.
the frequency of the current flow, these
Consideration should also be given to using
devices have been called “frequency
– 0.5 to 0.0 m as the most clinically ideal
dependent”. Eg- Endex.
error tolerance.
Fourth- Generation Apex Locators- The
apex locaters are similar to Impedance-type
113
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
because it measures the impedance of the Reduction of x-ray exposure
tooth at two different frequencies. As the
Artificial perforation can be
file is advanced apically, the difference in
recognized
the impedance value begins to differ greatly
with maximum difference at the apical Can be used in pregnant women –
area. because of no risk of radiation
Fifth-Generation Apex Locators- These Can used in patient with gagging
were developed in 2003. It measures the reflex
capacitance and resistance of the circuit
separately. It is supplied by diagnostic table Can be used when dense zygomatic
that includes the statistics of the values at arch is over lapping the apices of
different positions to diagnose the position upper molars
of the file. Devices employing this method
Can be used unerupted impacted
experience considerable difficulties while
tooth over shadows the apex
operating in dry canals.
Patients who have a phobia of
Sixth-Generation Apex Locators-The sixth
radiographic exposure.
generation Adaptive Apex Locator
overcomes as the disadvantages of the Disadvantages of electronic apex locators
popular apex locators IVth generation low
Requires a special device
accuracy on working in wet canals, as well
the disadvantages of devices Vth generation Accuracy is influenced by the
difficulty on working in dry canals and electrical conditions in the root
necessarily of compulsory, additional canal
wetting. Adaptive Apex Locator
continuously defines humidity of the canal Difficult in tooth with open apex
and immediately adapts to dry or wet canal. Inconsistent results
This way it is possible to use it dry and in
additional wetted canals as well, canals Recent advances:
with blood or exudates, canals with still not
Tomography: Is a radiographic technique
extirpated pulp.
that “slices” teeth in thin sections.
Advantages of electronic apex locators Computers subsequently reassemble the
sections to generate a three-dimensional
Only method that can measure the image. Dental anatomy including bucco-
apical foramen, not to the lingual curvatures shapes of the root canal
radiographic apex. spaces and location of the apical foramen
Accurate (which is important in determining or
calculating the working length) can be
Easy and fast visualized in the third-dimension. Additional
advantage in the elimination of angled
114
Bhatt A. et al, Int J Dent Health Sci 2015; 2(1):105-115
radiographs; all angled views are captured The RVG on screen measurement utility
in just one exposure. allows for rapid additive multiple point
measurement of digital images,
Videography and Intra-Oral Cameras: intra-
automatically tallying the measurement
oral videography is an non-ionizing
points on screen to a tenth of a millimeter.
diagnostic imaging technique. Developers
are using miniature colour CCD (charge Empirically it was expected that multiple
coupled device) chips. With fiber optic measurements along the curve of a canal
probes to assemble video cameras small would be more accurate than a straight-line
enough to transverse periodontal defects measurement from the reference point to
and identify vertical root fractures. These the apex. It was felt that if measurement
devices are useful in endodontics as they points were able to closely follow the curve
can display canal morphology as well aid in a truely estimate of the working length
locating canal orifices. Perforations can be would be obtained.
visualized by inserting the fiber optic probe
CONCLUSION:
down the suspected canal.These devices
are connected to a computer that provides It can be concluded from the current article
enhanced images for teaching and patient that electronic apex locater are not
education. superior to the radiograph in determining
the working length. Thus long term follow
DDR- Fourth generation DDR: one of the
up studies evaluating post-operative
more recent additions to Trophy’s fourth
success comparing radiographic and non-
generation RVG systems is the capability of
radiographic methods are needed to
on screen point-to-point measurements
appreciate the best method of working
using multiple additive points. This
length determination in endodonitics.
capability potentially allows for fast
accurate working length estimation in roots
demonstrating severe apical curvatures.
REFERENCES:
115