Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5

International Journal of Current Medical And Applied Sciences, 2017, March, 14(1),01-05.

ORIGINAL RESEARCH ARTICLE

Utility of Urinary Lipoarabinomannan (LAM) Antigen


Detection Assay for Diagnosis of Pediatric Pulmonary
Tuberculosis.
Swapna Kanade1, Shreshtha Tiwari2, Gita Nataraj3 & Preeti Mehta4
1Associate Professor, 2Resident, 3Professor, 4Professor & Head, Department of Microbiology, Seth GSMC &
KEM Hospital, Parel, Mumbai [MS], India; 400012.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract:
Objective: To determine the utility of lipoarabinomannan detection assay in urine for diagnosing pediatric pulmonary
tuberculosis.
Method: A prospective cross-sectional study was carried out on 100 children less than 14 years of age, with strong
clinical suspicion and radiological evidence suggestive of pulmonary Tuberculosis. One fresh early morning urine
R
sample (approximately 5ml) was collected. The LAM assay was performed using the CLEARVIEW TB ELISA, Alere
Medicals, U.S.A, according to the manufacturer’s package insert. Sputum samples/ gastric lavage were collected. Direct
smears and culture on Lowenstein Jensen media was performed.
Results: Of the 100 children included in the study, culture was positive in 31, microscopy was positive in 13 and LAM
assay in 19 children. When compared with culture, sensitivity and specificity of LAM assay was 45.16% and 92.75%
respectively and the PPV and NPV was 73.68% and 79.1% respectively. Of the 71 children who received ATT, LAM assay
was positive in 17, culture was positive in 31 and microscopy in 13. When intension to treat was used as the standard,
LAM assay had sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of 23.94%, 93.10%, 89.47% and 33.33%. All that were positive by
microscopy were also positive by culture.
Conclusion: The present study reinforces better case detection by combining urinary LAM assay with microscopy and
culture for diagnosis of pediatric pulmonary tuberculosis. Considering high specificity, it can be used as a very usefull
‘add-on’ test to rule out TB in endemic countries.
Keywords: Urine, LAM, Pediatric pulmonary tuberculosis.

Introduction:
Pediatric pulmonary tuberculosis (PPTB) remains a The diagnosis of pulmonary TB [PTB] in children
major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide, remains an unmet challenge in clinical practice
particularly in developing countries [1]. Though the throughout the world today. The reason include but are
actual burden of pediatric tuberculosis is not known due not limited to the non-specific signs / symptoms, low
to diagnostic difficulties, it has been assumed that in bacillary load in PPTB, the method used to recover
India, it accounts for 10 -15% of total TB cases [2]. In samples, and the inherent limitations of the diagnostic
children, it is important to detect TB early and treat tests themselves [4]. Diagnosis is usually based on
effectively since young children are more likely to clinical and radiological manifestations and results of
develop severe disseminated disease as compared to Tuberculin skin test, all of which lacks specificity and
adults. Childhood TB is a sentinel event, indicating on sensitivity.
going transmission of TB within communities [3].

Address for correspondence:


Dr. Swapna Kanade,
Access this Article Online
Associate Professor,
Department of Microbiology, Website:
Seth GSMC & KEM Hospital,
Mumbai [MS], India 400012. www.ijcmaas.com
Email: swapnakanade71@gmail.com
How to cite this article:
Swapna Kanade, Shreshtha Tiwari, Gita Nataraj & Preeti Mehta : Utility Subject:
of Urinary Lipoarabinomannan (LAM) Antigen Detection Assay for Medical Sciences
Diagnosis of Pediatric Pulmonary Tuberculosis.: International Journal
of current Medical and Applied sciences; 2017, 14(1),01-05. Quick Response Code

IJCMAAS,E-ISSN:2321-9335,P-ISSN:2321-9327. Page | 01
Swapna Kanade, Shreshtha Tiwari, Gita Nataraj & Preeti Mehta

As per International standards of TB care, laboratory tests, radiological findings and clinical
microbiological confirmation should be sought in all suspicion, the treatment was initiated by the clinician.
children suspected of having pulmonary TB, through Each child was followed up at the end 15 days. Those
examination of respiratory specimen for smear started on ATT were followed at the end of 2 months
microscopy, Xpert MTB / RIF assay and / or culture and 6 months to note any change in treatment
[5]. Sputum microscopy with a sensitivity of 15% and strategy/ resolution of symptoms such as fever, cough,
culture positivity of 30--40%, bacteriological diagnosis loss of appetite, documented evidence of gain in
of tuberculosis in children is difficult in settings with weight, result of a repeat CXR at end of completion of
limited resources [6]. Nucleic acid amplification test ATT and repeat microscopy results.
(NAAT) offers enormous potential for accurate rapid One fresh early morning urine sample (approximately
diagnosis, but only commercials kits have been 5ml) was collected by clean catch technique from each
validated and are trustworthy for replicable results child. From children > 5 years of age and who could
but are expensive [7]. The specimens required for expectorate, two sputum specimens were collected in
diagnosis of PPTB includes expectorated / induced sterile wide mouthed screw capped containers as per
sputum and gastric lavage which are difficult to obtain Revised National Tuberculosis Control programme
from children. [RNTCP] protocol [13]. In younger children and those
Antigen detection tests provide direct evidence of who could not expectorate, gastric lavage (GL) was
active disease, thus allowing immediate initiation of collected by the paediatrician on 3 consecutive days in
treatment [8]. A number of mycobacterial antigens can sterile, wide mouthed, screw capped containers
be detected in the urine of the patients with having sodium bicarbonate 100 mg for 5–10 ml of GL
pulmonary TB, but most promising of these is the cell to neutralize the acidic pH [14].
wall polysaccharide lipoarabinomannan (LAM) [9]. It Microbiology workup:
is a 17.5k D glycolipid found in the cell wall of LAM ELISA assay on urine
mycobacterium and it accounts for upto 15% of the Urine was refrigerated immediately after collection
total bacterial weight. It serves as an immunogenic and processed within 24 hours of collection. One ml of
virulence factor that is released from metabolically urine was placed in a 1.5 ml micro-centrifuge tube and
active or degrading bacterial cells during TB infection. heated at 95°C for 30 min. After cooling to room
Detection of LAM antigen was originally described temperature, it was centrifuged at 10,000 rpm for 15
using serum but this test was limited due to immune min. Supernatant was collected into a new labelled
complex formation [10,11]. LAM is filtered unchanged tube and stored at −20°C for subsequent ELISA testing.
by the kidneys. Urinary excretion of LAM occurs The LAM assay was performed using the CLEARVIEWR
independent of the anatomical location of the TB ELISA, Alere Medicals, U.S.A, according to the
infection. It is excreted in variable amounts ranging manufacturer’s package insert [15]. Whole procedure
from 0.5 to several hundred ng/ml. Being heat stable, was done in microtitre strips. Optical density [OD] was
it does not get readily degraded in clinical specimens, read immediately at 450 nm using Microelisa plate
increasing its suitability as a diagnostic target [12]. reader (Bio-Rad Laboratories). As recommended by
Detection of LAM in urine has several advantages. the manufacturer, the sample was reported as positive
Urine sample is simple to collect and the infection if OD was at least 0.1 above the signal of the negative
control measures required for processing urine control.
specimen are far fewer than sputum specimen. Any single sample from the subject showing acid fast
Hence, this study was carried out to determine the bacilli on microscopy or growth on LJ medium
utility of lipoarabinomannan detection assay in urine suggestive of MTB was considered as positive sample
for diagnosing pediatric pulmonary tuberculosis. for analysis. Treatment initiated by the clinician was
Material and Method: also noted.
Institutional ethics committee permission was Direct smears were prepared from all respiratory
obtained. A prospective, experimental study was samples, and stained by Ziehl Neelsen method. The
carried out over a period of one year in a tertiary care results were recorded as per RNTCP protocol [13]. All
teaching hospital. 100 children less than 14 years of specimens were decontaminated with NALC-NaOH
age and with strong clinical suspicion of pulmonary method and concentrated by centrifuging at 3000 g for
tuberculosis whose parents/ guardians provided 15 minutes. The supernatant was carefully discarded
written informed consent were included in the study. into a disinfectant container. 1 ml of the supernatant
Symptoms that were likely to suggest a diagnosis of was retained with the sediment which was then
pulmonary TB included, cough >= 2 weeks and / or vortexed to mix properly. Two loopfuls of this mixture
weight loss of at least 10% of healthy body weight or was inoculated on LJ medium and incubated
no weight gain in 3 months and / or symptoms of aerobically at 37oC [16]. All cultures were read daily
fever for >= 2 weeks or one measured temperature for the first week for detecting contamination and
above 38.50C and radiological evidence suggestive of rapidly growing mycobacterium species and then
pulmonary TB. Children who were on anti-TB therapy weekly thereafter, till growth was detected or 8 weeks
(ATT) for pulmonary/ extra-pulmonary TB or those whichever was later. If mycobacterial growth was
who had received ATT within the last 6 months were detected, it was identified as MTB/ NTM using SD
excluded from the study. Based on the results of BIOLINE TB Ag MPT 64 Rapid® .

Logic Publications @ 2017, IJCMAAS, E-ISSN: 2321-9335,P-ISSN:2321-9327. Page | 02


Logic Publications @ 2017, IJCMAAS, E-ISSN: 2321-9335,P-ISSN:2321-9327.

Statistical analysis:
100 clinically suspected PPTB cases were included. Two trained technicians performed the processing of urine and
respiratory sample separately, unaware of the result of other. Data was entered in SPSS version 15.0. Performance
of LAM assay was reported as sensitivity and specificity at 95% confidence interval. Two reference standards were
used for comparison; culture positivity and intention to treat.
Results:
Of 100 consecutive, clinically suspected PPTB cases included in the study, 36 were less than 5 years of age. Gender
ratio was observed to be equal. Gastric lavage was obtained from 41 and expectorated sputum from 59 children.
All respiratory specimens were processed and examined using microscopy and culture and urine specimens were
tested by LAM ELISA assay. Of the 100 children included in the study, culture was positive in 31, microscopy was
positive in 13 and LAM assay in 19 children. All the culture isolates were identified as MTBC by “SD Bioline MPT 64
Rapid” test. In clinically suspected cases of PPTB, the sensitivity of LAM, culture and microscopy was 19%, 31%
and 13% respectively.
Table 1: Comparison of LAM assay and microscopy with culture and Intension to treat (ITT).
Culture ITT
[Intension to treat]
Positive Negative Yes (n=71) No (n=29)
(n=31) (n=69)
Urinary LAM assay
Positive (n=19) 14 (45.16%) 5 (7.25%) 17 (23.94%) 2 (6.90%)
Negative (n=81) 17 (54.84%) 64 (92.75%) 54 (76.06%) 27 (93.10%)
Sputum Microscopy
Positive (n=13) 13 (41.94%) 0 (0%) 13 (18.30%) 0 (0%)
Negative (n=87) 18 (58.06%) 69 (100%) 58 (81.70%) 29 (100%)

Concordant results by LAM assay and culture (Table 1) were observed in 78 children with 14(45.16%) testing
positive both by culture and LAM assay and 64 (92.75%) testing negative by both. Discordance was observed in 22
of which five were LAM positive and culture negative and 17 were LAM negative and culture positive.

Table 2: Sensitivity and specificity of urinary LAM assay and sputum microscopy.
Culture ITT
Test Sensitivity Specificity Sensitivity Specificity
Urinary LAM assay 45.16% 92.75% 23.94% 93.10%
Sputum Microscopy 41.94% 100% 18.30% 100%
When compared with culture (Table 2), sensitivity and studies which have included ITT as standards for
specificity of LAM assay was 45.16% and 92.75% defining performance of the different diagnostic tests
respectively. The PPV was 73.68% and NPV was [17].
79.1%. A number of mycobacterial antigens like LAM,
Of the 100 children enrolled in the study, 29 received mycobacterial sonicates, extracted glycolipids, PPD,
only antibiotics (Amoxicillin or Cloxacillin and / or Antigen 5 (38 KDU), cord factor (trehalose
Amikacin) and responded. Of these, none were acid dimycolate), etc. can be used in antigen detection
fast microscopy positive or culture positive. However, assays for diagnosis of TB. LAM is the cell wall
two of these were LAM assay positive. 71 children polysaccharide released by lysis of metabolically
received ATT. LAM assay was positive in 17 (23.94%) active bacteria in large quantity. Approximately 15 mg
of these cases while culture was positive in 31 of LAM is secreted per gram of bacteria in culture [18].
(43.66%) and microscopy in 13 (18.31%) cases. Development of high tissue concentration of LAM at
When ITT was used as the standard, LAM assay had anatomic sites of disease results in systemic
sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of 23.94%, antigenaemia. LAM has a similar molecular size to
93.10%, 89.47% and 33.33%. All that were positive by myoglobin and is filtered unchanged by the kidneys.
microscopy were also positive by culture. Successful detection of LAM in urine is not associated
with heavy proteinuria, indicating its excretion in
Discussion: kidney having normal glomerular function. It is heat
Definitive diagnosis of pediatric pulmonary TB using stable and so does not readily degrade in clinical
conventional modalities of microscopy and culture has specimens [19].
given unsatisfactory yield. In the present study done The sensitivity of LAM was found to be 45.16% and
on 100 children with clinical presentation strongly specificity was 92.75%. Higher specificity ranging
suggestive of PTB, performance of LAM assay in urine from 87% to 99% has been reported in various studies
specimens has been evaluated against culture on LJ [20,21]. But variable sensitivity has also been reported
medium and intention to treat (ITT) by ranging from 13% -37% [21,22] and 40% -60%
antituberculosis treatment. This is one of the few [20,23,24]. 80.3% sensitivity has been reported by
International Journal of Current Medical And Applied Sciences [IJCMAAS], Volume: 14, Issue: 1.
Swapna Kanade, Shreshtha Tiwari, Gita Nataraj & Preeti Mehta

Boehme et al [25]. The disparity in sensitivity and testing was not performed for the case of treatment
specificity observed in various studies can be due to failure.
poor quality of sample in pediatric age group and Children usually acquire TB from adults. Thus TB in
variable techniques used for culture. In a meta- children reflects the ongoing transmission in the
analysis done, sensitivity of 14% (4-38%) in non HIV community and indirectly reflects on the performance
infected individuals and 47% in HIV infected patients of national programs. This emphasizes the need for
was found with a specificity of more than 96% [26]. diagnosing the disease in children more accurately
Five children had culture negative and LAM positive and rapidly to benefit both the affected child and
results. One child showed improvement with ATT. community. RNTCP emphasizes on acid fast
Two of these responded to antibiotics and two expired microscopy for diagnosis of PTB. In the present study,
during follow up period. False positive LAM results the sensitivity of smear microscopy in children was
could be due to contamination of urine with normal only 13 %. This limits its utility as a diagnostic tool in
commensal flora in the perineum e.g. Candida or due children. Though culture remains the gold standard,
to colonization with NTM [21]. Contamination of its long turnaround time doesn’t have much value in
reagents could be another possible explanation for immediate patient care. As per International
false positivity. standards, microscopy and molecular tests are advised
17 children were culture positive but LAM negative. for diagnosis of PPTB [5]. But considering very high
This could be due to low sensitivity of LAM assay itself. cost of molecular tests, it may not be sustainable in
Immune stimulation by LAM and subsequent long future in resource constrained settings.
formation of large immune complexes which cannot
pass through the glomerular membrane might result Conclusion:
in LAM negative urine sample [27]. Some data suggest Urinary LAM assay alone may not be a useful stand-
that concentration of LAM spiked into urine samples is alone test due to its low sensitivity, but it has a
stable for the first two hours but deteriorate after potential to be used as a very useful ‘add-on’ test.
this [28]. When combined with microscopy and culture, it can
It is clear that LAM ELISA cannot be used as a prove to be a supportive test for diagnosis in
standalone test but has a potentially important role as childhood TB. With proven high specificity of this test,
an add-on tests to microscopy in diagnosis of PPTB. In it can be used to rule out TB in endemic countries.
our study, microscopy as alone detected 13 cases
while LAM alone detected 19 cases. But if LAM is Acknowledgement:
considered as add-on test to microscopy, the The authors would like to acknowledge the
combination of two tests detected 22 cases. Of these operational research grant of RNTCP and funds from
21 were positive by culture. However, further studies Diamond Jubilee Society Trust, Seth GSMC & KEM
using a larger sample size are required to ascertain its hospital, Mumbai.
efficiency. Though Urinary LAM has low sensitivity, it
demonstrated high specificity. Detection of LAM from References:
urine samples promise less cumbersome diagnostic 1. Eamranond P, Jaramillo E. Tuberculosis in children:
technique in children from whom obtaining gastric reassessing the need for improved diagnosis in
lavage samples is difficult. Thus this might support its global control strategies. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2001
role as an adjunct test in diagnosis of pediatric TB. Jul;5 (7):594-603.
Microscopy is a rapid screening test which detects 2. TB India 2014 - TB Control India available
104-105 bacilli/ ml of sample [29]. Culture on solid/ www.tbcindia.nic.in/pdfs/TB%20INDIA%202014.pd
f
liquid media is highly specific and is considered the
3. Mukherjee A, Lodha R, Kabra SK. Changing trends in
gold standard test for diagnosis. It can detect 10-100 childhood tuberculosis. Indian J Pediatr.
viable bacilli/ml. PCR can detect ~10 bacilli/ ml in 2011;78(3):328-33.
respiratory samples which makes it a highly sensitive 4. Dannenberg AM Jr. Perspectives on Clinical and
diagnostic tool. Detection limit of LAM ELISA has not preclinical testing of new tuberculosis vaccines. Clin.
been quantified by manufacturers. Microbiol. Rev. 2010; 23(4):781.
The limitation of this study is that it was a prospective 5. International standards for Tuberculosis care. 3rd
study enrolling 100 clinically and radiologically edition, 2014.
suspected cases of PTB in children. However no 6. Swaminathan S, Rekha B. Paediatric tuberculosis:
global overview and challenges. ClinInfec Dis. 2010;
control group was included to reflect upon the
50(Suppl 3): S184–S194.
predictive values of these tests. The collection of 7. Palomino JC. Molecular detection, identification and
specimen was dependent on the pediatrician. Thus, drug resistance detection in Mycobacterium
there was no control over the quality of specimen and tuberculosis. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol.
transport to laboratory. Smear preparation after 2009;56(2):103-11.
concentration of the specimen and the use of 8. Flores L L, Steingart K R, Dendukuri N, et al.
fluorescent / LED microscopy could have increased Systematic review and meta-analysis of antigen
smear positivity. Use of liquid culture systems might detection tests for the diagnosis of tuberculosis. Clin
have improved the culture yield. Drug susceptibility Vaccine Immunol 2011; 18: 1616–1627.
9. Kashino SS, Pollock N, Napolitano DR, Rodrigues V Jr,
Campos-Neto A: Identification and characterization
Logic Publications @ 2017, IJCMAAS, E-ISSN: 2321-9335,P-ISSN:2321-9327. Page | 04
Logic Publications @ 2017, IJCMAAS, E-ISSN: 2321-9335,P-ISSN:2321-9327.

of Mycobacterium tuberculosis antigens in urine of detection in African tuberculosis suspects and


patients with active pulmonary tuberculosis: an patients. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2009, 13(10):1253–
innovative and alternative approach of antigen 1259.
discovery of useful microbial molecules. 21. Dheda K, Davids V, Lenders L, Roberts T, Meldau
ClinExpImmunol 2008, 153:56–62. R, Ling D et al. Clinical utility of a commercial LAM-
10. Sada E, Brennan PJ, Herrera T, Torres M. Evaluation ELISA assay for TB diagnosis in HIV-infected patients
of lipoarabinomannan for the serological diagnosis using urine and sputum samples. PLoS One. 2010; 5:
of tuberculosis. J ClinMicrobiol 1990;28(12):2587– e9848.
2590. 22. Daley P, Michael JS, Hmar P, Latha A, Chordia P,
11. Tessema TA, Bjune G, Hamasur B, Svenson S, Syre Mathai D et al. Blinded evaluation of commercial
H, Bjorvatn B. Circulating antibodies to urinary lipoarabinomannan for active tuberculosis:
lipoarabinomannan in relation to sputum a pilot study. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2009; 13(8):989–
microscopy, clinical features and urinary anti - 995.
lipoarabinomannan detection in pulmonary 23. Reither K, Saathoff E, Jung J, Minja LT, Kroidl I, Saad
tuberculosis. Scand J Infect Dis 2002;34(2):97–103. E et al. Low sensitivity of a urine LAM-ELISA in the
12. Lawn SD. Point-of-care detection of diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis. BMC Infect Dis.
lipoarabinomannan (LAM) in urine for diagnosis of 2009, 9:141.
HIV-associated tuberculosis: a state of the art 24. Shah M, Variava E, Holmes CB, Coppin A, Golub
review.BMC Infect Dis 2012, 12:103. JE, McCallum J et al. Diagnostic accuracy of a urine
13. Central TB division, Directorate General of Health lipoarabinomannan test for tuberculosis in
Services. Revised National Tuberculosis Control hospitalized patients in a High HIV prevalence
Programme, Module for Laboratory technicians. setting. J Acquir Immune DeficSyndr. 2009;
Smear microscopy for detection of acid-fast bacilli. 52(2):145–151.
Available from: URL: 25. Boehme C, Molokova E, Minja F, Geis S, Loscher
http://www.tbcindia.nic.in/pdfs T, Maboko Let al. Detection of mycobacterial
14. Kent PT, Kubica GP. CDC. Public Health lipoarabinomannan with an antigen-capture ELISA
Mycobacteriology: A Guide for the Level III in unprocessed urine of Tanzanian patients with
Laboratory Atlanta, GA; 1985 suspected tuberculosis. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg.
15. CLEARVIEWR TB ELISA, Alere Medicals, U.S.A, kit 2005; 99(12): 893–900.
insert. 26. Flores L L, Steingart K R, Dendukuri N, et al.
16. Revised National TB Control Programme Manual of Systematic review and meta-analysis of antigen
Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) Culture of detection tests for the diagnosis of tuberculosis. Clin
Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Drug Susceptibility Vaccine Immunol 2011; 18: 1616–1627.
Testing on solid medium. Available from URL: 27. Wood R, Racow K, Bekker L G, et al.
http://www.tbcindia.nic.in/pdfs/standard%20opera Lipoarabinomannan in urine during tuberculosis
ting%20procedures%20for%20C&DST%20labs.pdf. treatment: association with host and pathogen
17. Sandeep K Gupta. Intention-to-treat concept: A factors and mycobacteriuria. BMC Infect Dis
review. PerspectClin Res. 2011, Jul-Sep; 2(3): 109- 2012;12: 47.
112. 28. Mukundan H, Kumar S, Price DN, Ray SM, Lee YJ, Min
18. Hunter SW, Gaylord H, Brennan PJ: Structure and S, Eum S, Kubicek-Sutherland J, Resnick JM, Grace
antigenicity of the phosphorylated WK, et al: Rapid detection of Mycobacterium
lipopolysaccharide antigens from the leprosy and tuberculosis biomarkers in a sandwich immunoassay
tubercle bacilli. J BiolChem 1986, 261:12345–12351. format using a waveguide-based optical biosensor.
19. Sada E, Aguilar D, Torres M, Herrera T: Detection of Tuberculosis (Edinb) 2012, 92:407–416.
lipoarabinomannan as a diagnostic test for 29. Parsons LM, Somoskövi A, Gutierrez C, Lee
tuberculosis. J ClinMicrobiol 1992, 30:2415–2418. E, Paramasivan CN, Abimiku A, et al. Laboratory
20. Mutetwa R, Boehme C, Dimairo M, Bandason diagnosis of tuberculosis in resource-poor countries:
T, Munyati SS, Mangwanya D et al. Diagnostic challenges and opportunities. Clin Microbiol Rev.
accuracy of commercial urinary lipoarabinomannan 2011; 24(2): 314–350.

---------------------------------------------------------------
Conflict of interest: None declared
Source of funding: RNTCP and funds
from Diamond Jubilee Society Trust, Seth
GSMC & KEM hospital, Mumbai.

International Journal of Current Medical And Applied Sciences [IJCMAAS], Volume: 14, Issue: 1.

Вам также может понравиться