Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ
[TJEQYJ@F
]OGYJX[+MJ V7SRJP[M+ J X\H
EKYJ[Q[MJZ-HMJNVIJVQN]IJ
X*Z]H J NVIJVQ)7TF
J QSQ[+]. ),O ]H7 NJ GMJ
]\VX&YVH JTYJ[MJFQ#
ETQMJE
[IJ^HOYW]J
N^IJ9GWHE
EKMJTQE]
#ZVJXZJZVJ
#EYWQYJ[,[Q#
IJYOI2J V/H 9^OIJ
IJYOIJ2V/H = X[+MJ )7MJLX^O, ]O,)H]7 JSP 3([MJEVQMJMJ
#SMJZ.L MJ]O), H]7 J[YHO #J XV7[J
#%OZH
J QR+IZ =J VJ#O2, V/H 9IJ#
IJYIO J2V/H 9TQVPG+MNLJ ]/GWYX
J V7[J B
VWY)J Q7 ^O,
G+MJLN]/GWYJXV7[JB
X^O, (>HOMJ EIQMJEIQMJTOH SHVJ
Foreword
(to The Myanmar Buddhist: His Lil’e
l’rom the Cradle to the Grave)
The first time lmet Saya Hla Pe was in 1964 at SOAS on the
introduction of Dr. Kyin Swee during my attendance at the
Colombo Plan Conference in London. There at his office and
lunch at a nearby Chinese restaurant, we had a lively
discussion where 1 was impressed by Saya's wide knowledge as
well as by his kindly sense ofhumour. My second meeting with
Saya was twenty years later in Paris when he came to give eight
lectures at the College de France d Of four
weeks. I was then working at Unesco in Paris and was unable to
attend any ofhis lectures which were given during the week but
at weekends my wife and I were able meet Saya and
Daw Than Mya socially at the residence of Professors Lucien
andDenise Bennet atAnthonyjust outside Paris over tea ordinner.
false remember taking the friendly couple out for a drive to the
Loire Valley for a leisurely chat in the car and over a liesurely
French lunch. During these conversations my London impression
of Saya's wide and deep knowledge was further strenghtened.
But I must say it reached its climax when 1 was allowed to read
his Paris lectures in original for the purpose ofwriting a foreword
to a bilingual book that U Soe Thein (Maung Wuntha) was
preparing for publication with a Myanmar translation by Dr. Tin
Hlaing.
Saya's book entitled "The Myanmar Buddhist: His Life from
the Cradle to the Grave" (a worthy counterpart to Shway Yoe's
"TheBurman: His Life andNotions) is divided into two sections,
Nurture (geographical, political, cultural, economic, social and
family settings) and Nature (birth, schooling, manhood and the
relationships involved, old age and death). These are often
illustrated by some of his own experiences and observation,
cleverly weaving the general and autobiographical, thereby
sustaining the interest and attention of the most learned and
sophisticated audience that the College de France is. In other
words, Sayahas successfully presented the image ofthe Myanmar
Buddhists, ofwhom he is an exemplary one, to the world.
ReGred Ambassador U Thet Tun
TYQ]ZvMJ
Y6IJE[QJU
QZ7EFYOH]\V3(T+QE[+9^PSRJV7QGO)7TJ
ZIJIJàYWMJ]ESQYOHZF , OH XTRJXE[YJEIGOY H JEKYJ[QYWMJUHY +
U
Q
7H
Q SOH= EGS+QT3JYN^TJ]KSRJU
Q@¡O,GIJàZRJ
EYQMJ#XI(XIQ
7H [¡O[TJ QESQYJUMHO àJ ZRJEYQMJXQ]K[
TYQ
EN]QEU+E)+1Y]KSRJ \OHT3JY]MJ U
Q@ YWJ]W,9Z7ESQ XSH]RQ#
1YMJIQESQ?QSTH[JQ[JYOH1YRJRH/G.L]KSRJU
QLXQO[HX&YHVJ
E[+9SRJVQ7 EIQYJX)7TJ X1YQGO)7TJ[M+ J U
Q]K
(
H7
EG N]MJSTJ]K
P ]KEVQY[OH= TOE
QSOH= [I*E)+EZ][J
YQZX[+MJ
7TJ1YVH J[[ H HE?QEN]Q
IJZQE
QYJT3JYN^TJ]KSRJ\OHT3J
YY6IJE[QJ]K
(
7HPIYJTYOHà¡O,[YJEI
ESQE1YQMJLU
Q@E?QEN]Q
QSO=H VS+QE
QYJ)HMO GJ L]. KSO=EH SQJTEI#[I*E)+XQZ]JGWHI[ J àH=O ]K
(2V/H 9N]MJ
7HN]MJSTJ]KEVQY>I(EVQMJ)7, [OH=@
EIXHVJà YWMJ]ESQ ZYJ^YJ
RJ# RTQ [RJGMJ]+.[OH=à U
Q)7MJL >I(
ESIJNV[OH=XQY6IJE[QJL>I()7MJLX[P S+QE
QYJE[+9UO, K
N]/G.L1Y]K
SRJGMJVMJ[[JESQU
Q>I(EVQMJ)7,XQ SOH= [TJEI=
EGEUQMJ S +Q G. L^ P]KSRJ YQ\.àZRJEYQMJ# N]MJSTJEI=ZJTQ
TQ
MJESQJZRJEYQMJ#THVEJ N]IEN]TYQEN]QUOGH M+ JL
7H2](
IJYOIJ[YÞSHOZJ[YJG.L
Q GO[+MJ NVIJVQTQ
X\PN]/2]( H>ªQ O4J\P[IJ
F+.9YHO ]\VUMJLV7 EXQMJNVMJSRJ
GO[+MJ V?QH>ªQNVIJVQTQ
F+.9
SRJZIJIJ[+MJ UYJZYJ
]RQSMJ1YQ
IJ ]RQE[QJSMJXN^TJ XE
+G,
SRJ
GO[+MJ ZIJIJ[YÞSHOZJ ]RQE
SH]À,EYWQMJV7 ]RQE
(]ZOHVQ F+.9
7HSRJ
EKYJ[QZ7EFSRJ X[+MJ F(F(T( XS,Z8MJL<QI@
S[MJE^IJS#P FQSQN]IJU
Q)7MJL XS,ZM8 LEJ 1YRQSPXN^TJZO]Y J OMH J
G.LSRJ[+MJNVIJVQX*Z]H JXFHQIJN]/TEO
ZYJE\QYJ
XJ([QXN^TJZO]JYOMH GJ
.L QEIQMJXGK[+.^YJXJ([QN^TJZQ@
]KEVQYEFSRJ [+MJV7T[MJ2](Y\HYXN^TJNVIJVQ
TQE])7MJL 3JEYWV-SMJ1YQ]H=GO WSRJGO[+MJ [+F . YJ]KEVQY
)7MJLGO[+MJ]KEVQYXUMJL
7HSRJâ
Q\PVWQ[+MJU
Q&Y(
SRJ F+.9&YH/)7MJL F+.9Z+IJ EYWQMJSQVWQYHO SMJ1YQ]OH=GWG.L2](\OHT3J
X[+MJ TQEV]+.)7MJL 2%H[HIJ
IJ\VJE
+GWJE
TQEV]+.VWQ[+MJ
TQTTJ]O¢H/ZJXN^TJ EUQMJ
+YJG.LSRJ\OH=N]MJ 3E
Q][YÞSHOZJVWQSOH=
S+QE
QYJ2](XGKXQEZWQJT+QE?QEN]Q]HO=GWG.LSRJ
N]RJL[+MJ U
Q&Y(SRJ X2MHVJTQP2](NVIJVQN]RJSOH=N]IJZQ
SRJ>I(ESIJNV)7MJLEVQJZ2VH/MJ[+MJXENGGWEI\HOMJSRJ
]KEVQYEFSRJSMJ1YQE
ZO]JMIJXN]MJ]RQ
]JTQ[VJTQXO]J
E]KMJEYWQJYHOX*ZH]JBNVIJVQFQSQN^MJLE
SQ\O[JE\Q
SRJ
EVQJZ2VH/MJ[+MJ X2MHVJTQFEI\OHMJT3J N]RJ][YÞSHOZJ&Y(VWQY
^H[JV)©YN]/SN^MJL]RQ
]JUOHM
J QE?QEN]Q
SRJU
Q&Y( Yâ
E?QEN]Q]+. N]RJ]G
( XE[+9X1Y,/VWQYHO XE[+XNVMJ V¢>MJ[+MJ
EUQMJ]KVWQE
SQG.L2](V1YQESV(Y[¡O[JN]RJS+QEI=T3JV7[J
TQ[VJYHO E
SQ\O[JEG.LSRJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
NVIJVQFQSQN]IJUOHSP
EKYJ[Q[MJZH-MJ @X[/]À[ÉH
GO^Q+ V,
O Q+ G¡HMO J X
QE[QJ2V/H9IJSG+[]J MJZRJ
Q+ >Q[HN^TJSRJ
+QENVQYJEYWQMJEGU
QE[QJ3(G)©@ ( E
8SVH JE[QJ[Y HO [ J M+ J ]RQT[MJ
SMJ1YQSRJV7\HV)©EZHOMJXHOT>( MJS[ , . X\YJ[IJEYWQMJ
E[QJ[+MJ ]RQSMJSRJV)©EZ[YÞSHOZJ[+MJ UYJZYJ ]RQSMJ2](
¡P]E%FQSQN^MJLSH],À O4\ J P [IJ
F+.9YHO[+MJ
7HSRJ [+MJ
2%H[HS5EYQMJT( YHOZ,FOHT(V,YHIJ
TEYQZQ
7TJ
2](ZIJIJ [YÞSHOZJà
F+.9Z+IJ SMJ1YQSRJ F+.9O4J\P)7MJL EXQMJ2]([+MJ
F+.9
SRJIPYZ(Q¡P]E%X\PN]/SRJ
VEY+#
IJYIO #J EVQJZ2V/H M)J M7 LJ V)©EZ[YÞSZ OH VJ WQ[+MJ U
QXN^TJ
)7TJEYWQJSMJ1YQG.LSRJ[+MJNVIJVQLSH]À,)7MJLIRJ]RQSOE[
SI3(T(<QISOH= E
89EN]QMJ2](R8IJ1YQE
V70[QIJ \VJSRJ
[+MJX4ONV0T+VJXMJ3(T(<QIYHO3(T([RJE\QMJG.L2](]\VU,OR8IJ1YQ
E
V70GW/]J N^TJSRJ
EKYJ[Q[MJZH-MJSRJ [+MJ XN]RJN]RJUOHMJ
Q X4ONV0
T+VJXMJEXWMJT( R(ZQG,àNVIJVQYH O JTQZ7JX^+.9EGKMJEUQMJ
XN^TJ [YJE
QYJG.LSRJ \OHR(ZQG, &YHVJ[+MJ NVIJVQ YHOJTQZ7J
X^+.9MJXN^TJ[YJG.LSRJ[+MJ EGXQ
7]TH^H[JES
)HOMJM,MJ]KESQIPYZ(QIRJ]RQ]PE]KMJEUQMJ
+YJE
X^+.9Y
EKYJ[Q[MJZH-MJYHO 3YÞ`XN^TJ [MJENVQYJG.LSRJ \OHX^+.9@ EYQJV[(
VWQ[+MJ ]KMJG.LSRJ
EKYJ[Q[MJZHM- S J RJ
IJYOIJ IRJ]RQ[YÞSZ HO [J M+ J XGWHI]J OMH J
]KEVQYXN^TJ MK)7TJ SMJ1YQG.LSRJ GO X2MHVJTQ P2](EIQYJ
NVIJVQ)OHMJM,IRJ]RQ]RQ
7MJX^+.9@XZO]JXV-EUQMJXN^TJ[QIJ\VJ
EUQMJU. N^TJSRJIPEQYJSH]À,XYJV(X^+.9MJZRJN^TJSRJ
SOE[SITQ[VJVWQEUQMJ]KE]KMJT,O)7MJL[YÞSHOZJS,OTQXO]J
)7TJXO]JX*ZH]JFQSQ)7MJL
E
SQSRJTQXO]J)7TJXO]JSH]À,]RQE]
EGEXQLT
)7MJL]HOGWRJV5MVJ HO IK]RQ
7MJX[/]À[
ÉH E
SQSRJFHOZH-MJ
YEZQMJXVRJ)7MJLUYJZYJ2](TQE]E
SQEISRJ
>I(ENVNVEU+ X2MHVJTQ¡OYE%Y\HY
)7MJL SQSV(
EQYJ
7HSRJ
CONTENTS
Translator's Foreword 17
1. Introduction 2s
2. Nurture 30
2.1 €ieographical setting 30
2.2 Political setting 31
2.3 Cultural setting 33
2.3.1 Buddhisrri 34
2.3.1.1 The Buddha 3§
2.3.1.2 The Three Major Schools 3b
2.3.1.3 Theravada Buddhism 37
2.3.2 - isrris 39
2.3.2.1 Buddhist celestial gods 40
2.3.2.2 Hindu gods 41
2.3.2.3 Terrestrial gods 42
2.3.2.4 Magic, astrology and others 42
2.4 Economic setting 43
2.5 Social environmemt 45
2.6 The Myanmar family 45
3. Nature: The Myanmar Buddhist 75
3.1 Youth 75
3.1.1 Brith 75
3.1.1.1 Naming ceremony 79
3.1.1.2 Life at home 82
3.1.2 Village School $3
3.1.2.1 Coaxing the psyche 86
3.1.3 English school $$
3. 1 . 3. 1Propitiating rituals 89
(1) U Shin Gyi 90
(2) The guardian spirit ofthe rice fields 91
3.1.3.2 Buddhist initiation ceremony 92
(1) Shin Upagutta 100
3.1.3.3 The ear-boring ceremony 102
3.1.4 University 103
3.1.4.1 Token marriage 107
3.1.4.2 The Guardian spirit ofthe hidden treasure 108
3.1.4.3 Alchemy and magic 109
3.1.4.4 The power of invulnerability 110
3.1.4.5 The magic candle 110
3.1.4.6 Omens iii
(1) The vulture iii
(2) The monitor lizard 112
(3) The owl 112
3.1.4.7 The astrologer 114
3.1.4.5 The Epidemic li 5
3.1.5 England 1 li 5
3.1.6 Myanmar 1957-55 1i9
3.1.6.1 The banyan-tree 1i9
3.1.6.2 The cairn 120
3.1.6.3 The ancestors’ nat 121
3.1.6.4 The auspious days 122
3.1.7 England 11 124
3.2 Manhood 125
3.2.1 Human relations and marriage 125
3.2.1.1 Parents and children 125
3.2.1.2 Teachers and pupils 126
3.2.1.3 Between friends 127
3.2.1.4 Between relatives 125
3.2.1.5 Social contract between man and woman 125
(1)Living together as man and wife 129
(2)Elopement 130
(3)Arranged marriage 134
(a) Investigation 135
(b) Negotiation 136
(c) Consultation 136
(d) Betrothal ceremony 138
(e) Marriage ceremony 139
(4) Married life 142
(5) Divorce 143
3.2.2 The three primary duties 144
3.2.2.1 Dana 145
3.2.2.2 Sila 148
3.2.2.3 Bhavana 149
3.3 Old age 151
3.4 Death 153
3.5 Epilogue 159
Appendix 278
References 285
VQ[HYQ
FQSQN]IJSP@E
73(TYQ
IHKIJ
N]/N]MJ\HIJEYWQMJV-
# ]\(XEIX\Q
# )HOMJM,E
XEIX\Q
# 3JEYWV- XEIX\Q
## %OFQSQ
### %O
### HO4J&Y(S,OHO4J
### E\
QK%OFQSQ
## FQSQXPVWQ
###%OFQSQI[JVWQ
###?H)0I[JVWQ
###âYV«QI[JVWQ
###EV7QJSHH#E%MJ)7MJLXNGQX
QVWQ
# T(]+QE
XEIX\Q
# ZPV-E
][JIJYWMJ
# NVIJVQVHSQTO
SFQ#NVIJVQ%OFQSQ
# ZPMJF
## EV+^+QNGMJ
### XVRJE]YMJV+IJ[]J
### XHVJF
##
+QEYWQMJ
### X])-[JNGMJ
## X*ZH]JEYWQMJ
###]PE>QJ]S]+.VWQ
3(
7MJ&Y(
ZJETQMJLI[J
###%OFQSQ
7MJN]/]+.
7MJ3]O[J
### IQSV*ZQ
## X*ZH]JEYWQMJ
### T[HZYJ\]J\HVJNVQ
### 3TÚQETQMJL
### X¢H]J)7MJL EV7QJX[[J
### 2](EU
### EU^EQMJ[OHMJ
### X[H[JIHVH[J
ZMJ[
^+[J
M7YJUOH
### E%MJU
Q
### Y]JE
QK
## X*ZIJ
## NVIJVQN]RJ
### ERQMJ]MJ&Y(
### G.],O&Y(
### ¡HO
QI[J
### N]×K)7MJL
YJ
Q>Q
## X*ZIJ
# ZPZ[J]HOMJ
## ZPV-UYJU,E
)7MJL XHVJE\QMJE
### VHF)7MJLSQSV(
### U
Q)7MJL[]RJL
### VH[JEU+XGWMJGWMJ
### EU+VWH/XGWMJGWMJ
### EQYWJQVHIJVUYJU,E
>I(EVQMJ)7,F
GHO
QZOHYJ
VHFVWQT(T3JSRJLXHVJE\QMJE
XHVJE\QMJSRJF
Y+Q
7MJN][JT.E
## [JS,OS+J
### KI
### S(Z
### FQIQ
# ZPXHOZP&Y(]HOMJ
# ESNGMJ
# XU,OS[JTYQ
# EIQYJUYJ[+.
#
RJR8IJGWYJ TQXO]JTQ[VJTQ
MJ
TRANSLATOR’S FOREWORD
Prof’ Hla Pc and 1
1 first met Professor Hla Pe in London in September 1972, when l arrived
there for further studies. 1 had brought books for him from Ludu U Hla
and Daw Ahmar and a letter of introduction from Botany
Professor Dr Than Htun. Our meeting lasted only about half-an-hour. 1
vaguely remember his office in a building in Fitzory Square.
Since then 1 have the good fortune to know him intimately and
to listen to his most informative conversations on various subjects.
London University
Around 1973, 1 believe, Prof Hla Pe’s School of Oriental and
African Studies London (SOAS) moved to its present site near the Uni—
versity Senate House in Malet Street. And, 1 was accommodated in Inter—
national Hall nearby. In fact, it was Prof Pe who introduced me to Mr
John Bracken, Deputy Warden of International Hall. Thus, either after
my visits to the University Library in Senate House or when 1 happened
to pass near SOAS, I would go in to see him, mostly without an
appointment. Sometimes, there would be a few of us, Myanmar chaps,
going to visit him. Prof Hla Pe and 1 have, between us, a common
institution, the University of London. He was in SOAS and 1 in Bedford
College in Regent’s Park. But there was also a divide between us; to use
C.P. Snow’s term, we belonged to ‘two cultures’. He was a professor of
Myanmar language, literature and culture, and la student studying physics.
He worked in the ’culture ofculture and I was deep in the 'culture of
scieuce'.
I should remark here that London University is an immense body
with its colleges and schools spread over the city. The structure seems
very loose; the colleges are many and quite independent. Students in one
college have not much chance ofmeeting or knowing professors in other
colleges.
Karma at Work
Again, karmas have seen it that we met again in
Mawlamyaing when ProfPe returned to settle down there after his retire—
ment in 1950. 1 was on the staff of Mawlamyaing College** as Head of
Physics Department. 1 lived on campus and Prof Pe’s home was not far
away. This time my wife and children were introduced to Sayagyi and
(Ma Ma) Daw Than Mya. Their place is in Taungwaing Road, on our
way into town. Occasionally we stopped there, especially when we saw
Sayagyi at work (?) in his garden. Also, I would make a point ofinviting
them to centain ceremonial occassions in the college.
* Tin (Hlaing)
** now Mawlamyaing University
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 19
librarian (at present Professor of Library and Information Science at
Yangon University). He agreed to help and we took turns at the typewriter.
Finally, we finished the manuscript; but, alas, not without mistakes. There
were plenty of mistypes and mistakes and which the author
took care to correct with a pen.
We did not have Xerox copiers then. We made two carbon copies
together with the ribbon-original. ProfHla Pe took the original to Yangon,
where, lbelieve he made a few photo copies. U Thein Lwin reserved one
copy for college library; 1 kept one for myself.
Sayagyi went to Paris and gave the lectures for which the
manuscript formed the basis.
In 1956, I was transferred to Mandalay University, and again in
19951 moved to Yangon. Butldid not leave behind Sayagyi’s manuscript.
It has been with me ever since.
1 retired from government service in 2001. Not having anything
worthwhile doing, I attempted writing articles for magazines, using a
pen-name. When friends asked me, What are you up to these days'?’, 1
would answer ‘Writing, bits and pieces’. In the mean time, 1 have come
to know Saya Maung Wun Tha, author and publisher whose Daung Sar
Pay has been producing Sayagyi Dr Hla Pe’s books in Myanmar. One
day, Saya Wun Tha told me January 5, 2003 was Prof Pe’s ninetieth
birthday and he and a few friends were going to Mawlamyaing for the
occasion. He asked me if 1 could come too. 1 was sorry, I couldn’t join
them.
My Hope
1 have come across Myanmar friends, both at home and aboard,
confronted with the task ofexplaining to foreigners, especially Western—
ers, the subtle and intricate aspects ofMyanmar culture and traditions. 1
witnessed many times, someone muddling through in his attempts, and
often resorting to outright bluff. 1 do not leave myself as an exception.
FHOE[QJ EUU
Q ^PTQE
I[J
G.FHO
FQSQN]IJS@
P E
73(TYQ
]KEVQYZ7EF)7MJLY6IJE[QJ
GO)7TJ TYJ[MJFQZ[+MJ ]KEVQYZ7EF YHO Y6IJE[QJ
]\V X&YHVJ E[+9]KSRJ Y6IJE[QJ F+.9Z+IJ]RQ SMJ
IJ ZIJIJSHO=
E
QYJZQ2]( E[+9NGMJN^TJ@ Y6IJE[QJ)7MJLX[P ZP\O3(Z7EXVQ[HO=
U
QLX[+YJ E]ZHOYEJ SQ TQXO]JVWQ ]KZQ]KSRJ ¡OYE%]KEVQY
EKYJ[ Q SIJ \+I J E
E]ZH OY J ESQ VH [J U YJT QZRJ ]KZQ@
Y6IJE[QJ[HO= IQ
(YJGIJ=SQ E[+9U,O TYQEN]QG.L]KSRJ E[+9U,OSRJL
EI
QV7Q^TJ
+H/MJTY+.QEZE\QMJLY+YJZVJ
7HXEUQYJX3(V7U
Q@
¡,OGIJN^TJE1YQMJY6IJE[QJE
E
V7[JVH]KSRJ
\HOXGWHIJV7T2](Y6IJE[QJSRJY,EYQMJE\QYJVSN^MJLU
QXQ
X&YHVJVWQT+Q E[+9
SRJ U
Q@ %?OSO[N^TJ^+J XE1YQMJX
QVWH/T,O
EN]QTYQIQ1YQ
SRJ
ZIJIJ[YÞSHOZJ
GO GI=J[+MJ ]KEVQYZ7EF@ XE
79[HOMJ)7MJL XQ^
HY
]RQ
]JEYQZH]J ZIJIJ[YÞSZ HO JX[HO
SRJGOZYJ
H7 EI
Q
N^TJESQVJEZZVJ
7H [YÞSHOZJUHIH[JEUQMJXI(EN]QMJE
89G.L]KSRJ
Y6IEJ [QJY\OXH I(
7H XMJ[QIYJ
M7 IJ JE?Q EG)HMO JMT, O, EYWQMJSQ
EUQMJ[+MJ EI\HOMJZWYJ
7H@]KEVQYEFY]MJ Y6IJE[QJLYHO )HOMJM,T,O
EYWQMJSQEUQMJ@ O[HXEUQMJV70 6IJF
YJYMJ)7MJL VH[JU YJ
E]]K@SHO=N^MJLY6IJE[QJUHI[H JEUQMJ
7H[YÞSHOZJTQ1YRJL[HOYJV7XN]IJ
N^TJET XI(N^[JSIJS+QSRJLXGKN^TJETU
QL\,MJE[+9[[J@
]KEVQYSRJ F+.9[TJGON^TJ@EKYJ[QF+.9\YJ NVMJL@\OH=E1YQMJL ]KEVQY]KZ5MJ EKYJ[Q
VZO]H KXZO]S
J EFQ]KESQXGK]KEVQYSO, VRJ
MJ)7( SPYEKYJ[QS,OVRJSH]J
MJ)7( SPY
]\VIQVRJBMJIQVRJEGVRJ
[YÞSHOZJXUMJL[+MJ SRJ X\PN]/ SMJ1YQ
IJ ]RQ
]JIJ S[JV7[J\QESQ
EYQZH]JN^TJ@FQSQT,OSMJ1YQESQEYQZH]JYHOVP EG@
EYWQMJSQEIXEUQMJYHOX*ZH]JY ?OS,O]KSRJ N^TJSRJ
?OVS,O]K
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XGWHIJXGWYJVZO]JF. MJE[+9NGMJN^TJ@[TJGK[TJ
, NVIJVQEYWQMJSQ
XGWH/9XTON^MJL S+Q@]KEVQYZ7EF)7MJL Y6IJE[QJ[HO=1YQ[+MJ )7TJ3(UHOMJ
X^+.9XTRJ&Y(N^TJESQZIJIJ[YÞSHOZJ
7HEI@U
QY [+MJ
Y6IJE[QJY
(WMJL]IJNG,[+MJ
7HFYJ^H=EO YQZH]J[+MJN^TJ@SHOE= SQJU
Q)7MJL
Y6IJE[QJ1YQNGQEIESQTRJ[TJGOY
7HN]IJES@T(](T)HOS,O)-IJESQ
A3JEYWV-)7TJVWH/a
7H
Q Y6IJE[QJ[HO=SRJ [TJ3( 3JEYWV-[TJVWH/T(
N^TJEI1Y@U
QYNVIJVQFQSQTQE])7MLJ 3JEYWV-E
Q]KEVQY#Y6IJ
E[QJY ¡P]E%SMJPEIESQ EYWQMJSQ U
QY A3JEYWV-IJV7
3JEYWV-SVQaN^TJ@Y6IJE[QJYVPASH]À,3JEYWV-IJSQaN^TJEI@
ZIJIJ[YÞSHOZJSRJXZ+IJ&Y(VQESQX^+.9XTRJ&Y(N^TJ@
EYQZH]JE]KMJVWQT+QSRJ 2VH/9E[QJ[TJG+MJ X)7,9 N]IJ=EISRJ ^+.9TRJ],OY
EZWQL
.
. N^TJ@EYQZH]JE]KMJVWQT+Q
7H
QXQZ,OXE[QJ]MJZ+[JZ]JTQ+
T(V,XO]JGW/]JG+MJL
7H1Y@EYQZH]J[TJGOV7EYWQMJSQSRJXNGQEYQZH]J
[TJGOV7]KEVQYVWQYHOE[+9U,OSHY6VJ
IJXG+MJLXZVJSH]JV
7HEGW
]KEVQYEF#]KEVQY¡HOYJT
X(%IJ)7MJLE
8XUMJEYWQYJ[,O&Y(
Y6IJE[QJ ]+.[TJ]+.YHO S[H
]KSRJ 2%H[HIJNVIJVQXSMJSRJ
Y6IJE[QJ[HO=XQXSMJXTRJXEVWQSHO=^H[J1YQEZL
7H@]+.[TJ]+.[+MJ
NVIJVQLF 3JEYWV-)7MJL X)O]RQ[MJUYJ]+. ]KMJEZSRJ \HO]+.SHO=
Y6IEJ [QJ[Y =OH OH ^H[EJ G¡,VO Y_RJS
L RJ]KEGEUQMJZQ)HMO EJ 1YQMJG+MELJ ]@
\HO=E1YQMJL Y6IJE[QJ@]RQ
]J &Y(1Y]JSP EKYJ[Q]([Q¡HOYJT
X(%IJ
GOZIJIJ[YÞSHOZJO4J\PEUQMJ¡]P E%]KEVQY
XQY6IJE[QJ)7MLJ
2%H[HIJNVIJVQ]+.ZHOYJG.L
IJ^H[JEGG.L@U
Q]([Q¡HOYJTJ
X(%IJSRJ[MJN]
ESQNVIJVQ]+.YHOXZ+IJTH[JMJTQEZ
QY6IJE[QJYVJENVQYJVJSQ
N^TJ
@ NVIJVQLF 3JEYWV-)7MJL X)OO]RQYHO VRJSPY [MJUYJSRJ#
FQXE1YQMJX
QN^TJSRJVV7[JVHE[QL]KSHO=ESQJ\HO]+.@EIQYJUYJ[+.
]K[(YHO Y6IJE[QJ S[H
]KSRJ Y6IJE[QJY EKYJ[Q ]([Q¡HOYJTJ
X(%IJYHO ]KEVQYEF)7MLJ VH[JUYJE]]KSRJ [YJE[QL SP[HO=SRJ
[YÞSHOZJ[TJG[ O RJV7U
QVWQN^TJ1Y@EKYJ[Q¡HOYJT
X(%IJYXG+MJL
EYQMJ
SRJ)7MJL NVIJVQ)7MJLUHOMJESQEVG+IJXGWH/9EVEZSRJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
EKYJ[Q¡HOYJT
X(%IJY ]KEVQYEFXQ EN]Q]KSRJ A[MJ
ZH-MJ
.9TQ]+.V7QGWH[J\Q[.L NVIJVQN]YHIJ
7H[JX.(E]YAE
8E
QMJ
EYWQYJ[,O&Y(aZHVVLJ YWF. 2MVH EJ I],Y O
MJ[VV].#X.K&Y([YJ
S H7 ZQ#
X.X ( E1YQMJVWQEN]Q)HOMJ
MJEN]QN]ETGWMJZHOYJ[Qaa]KEVQYEFYSP=YHO
XESTH[J
7MJ N]SRJYOH 1YQ
SN^MJL Y6IJE[QJ1YRJ)P
]KSRJAYW/H Y\ J (
¡H O EYWQYJ [ , O &Y( #
ESL & Y( 3( EGKMJ # FO
Q^P G
( # E[QMJ X [YJ
Z7]SQQESQEY+9EYQYJX[YJG
(aXE1YQMJEN]QN]SRJY6IEJ [QJ
YVP
YJE[+ZE[+GW(2](YWH/YJ\( ¡HOXE1YQMJEN]QVN]N^TJEN]QVN][[J
SRJV7QY6IJE[QJX[+YJ
7^J +? J OG,TQ
]K@Y6IJE[QJYZRJXV7[J
V\QG.VL H Y6IEJ [QJLTQ]+S . =OH E
QYJZQ2]( FO
Q],OE
79V7Q\HMO
J ESQVH[JEU+
VWQYHO
7MJZMJEN]QN]
IJZRJEZLZQV\QVHEGW
Y,Y^IJEZSRJ
[^IJ Y6IJ E [QJ [ H O = Y, Y ^IJ Z QN]IJ S RJ \MJ ] K@
]KEVQYEFSRJX2MHVJTQP2](EVQJZ2VH/M[ J +MJEI\HOMJ
IJN]RJ[ L +MJ
N]IJ Z QSN^MJ L U
Q)7 M J L Y6IJ E [QJ N]IJ Z RJ U , O T RJ
@ \H O T 3J Y
Y6IJE[QJSRJ EVQJZ2VH/ MJ EYQZH]J[+MJ U
QN^TJ@ ¡P]E%<QIV70
[QIJ\VJEISRJ Y6IJE[QJY EYQZH]JMJ[+MJ EI\HOMJ
Q U
Q@
XHVJ)M7 LJ SH]VJ Z7VJ ]KâXGW[
( M+ JY6IEJ [QJL>I(SQSV(VWQYHO U
Q&Y( )7MJL
VV
ESIJ NV[H O = X Q N]S VH [ J U YJ
SRJ U
Q[H O = XH V J Y
E[QMJHOMJZVJ[+MJ N^TJÑ Y6IJE[QJJ[HO= 2VH/9\.S+Q
Q ZVJE][+MJ
7H@
[TJJGK[TJ
, U
QLXHVJ MJ1YSRJ X\P SN^MJL S+Q
MJZQ
MJ U
Q
]IJNG,[M+ J[+MJX]IJEN^EISRJE[+9NVMJYMJE[+9[[J@EYQZH]J[+MJ
XGVJXIQ[GWH/9SHO=ZRJU
Q[HO= >I(EVQMJ)7, YE
QYJ
IJ Y6IJE[QJY
T(T3J ^H[J1YQEZL
7H@
âTQXO]JXE1YQMJ
SHO=V?O[J[+MJU
Q&Y(EKYJ[QZ7EFYX*ZH]J
ZYJ)7H]JTYJEYQMJJEYQMJ¡HOYJ[[JSP
7QE]]K?OY6IJE[QJYHOEN]Q@
U
QY]K
(2VH/9
7HN]MJSTJEYQZH]JEYWQMJV7E?QEN]QSMJ[IJ[TJGOZQ2](
X*ZH]JY
MJ)7(SPYHO]\VXVRJ[TJZ,OSQEG]KSRJ[MJZH-MJ
YHO
MJ)7(SPXE]KMJY
[MJ?OEGSRJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
E?QEN]QE]
IJ^H[J1YQZQE1YQMJEN]QN]]KSRJ\HOX[+YJU
QSRJ
E?QEN]QVRJLXE1YQMJX
QYHOTQVPE
\QSRJZYJ)7H]JTYJ¡HOYJ
IJ
ZHOSRJ\HOEG[JXGKY](T(Y+IJ]W0[QV
7HJES]KEVQJZ2VH/MJ[+MJ ZYJ)7H]J
TYJ ¡HOYJSPE[+
7H]K@ SHO=ESQJ ]RQ
]J TQ[VJ[TJETQMJ[TJ^+.9YHO
X*ZH]JZHOXV7QYMJYMJ¡HOYJ)HOMJSP
7QZ7@
7HSRJYHOY6IJE[QJVSH
Y6IJE[QJ ¡HOYJE]Z5MJ ]HOEYQMJVRJ?O ,O1YRJSRJLX[HOMJ
YHOJ[HOMJ ZYJ)7H]JTYJ ¡HOYJE]]KVRJ?O U
QLYHO EN]QZHOYJ@ Y6IJE[QJ
¡HOYJZ5MJ ]HOEYQMJVRJU
QYXV7[J[V.L V7QG.LZ5MJE[QMJ Y6IJE[QJY
EN]QN] N]/N]MJ E])HO MJVRJ?O \MJEISRJ XGWHIJSH]JV
]K Y6IJE[QJL
¡HOYJ)-IJYE)7EY+Z7SRJXHOZ,](QZYJ)7H]JTYJ)7MJLYHOJT+VJSEZQYJ
T[MJ ¡H OY J] KSRJ V1YQV( ]MJ Y6IJE [QJ S+ Q SRJL )- IJ )7 MJ L XGWHI JV (
V2]()HOMJE1YQMJ E[+9ZQ
E[QL@ \OH=E1YQMJL EYQZH]JTQ1YRJL[HOYJV70
3(SHIJ Z+MJ GO
IJYOIJ [YÞSZ OH [
J +MJ TQ1YRJL[OYH )J 7MLJ SO[]RQ]KEVQY
YHOXYPXR(E[QMJ]KSRJSPYMJE
QYJYPR(ZQSN^MJLY6IJE[QJ[HO=
TYJVIQZPSQIQ2]([TJZ7RJLT(ZO]J1YSRJEIQYJU,OTQVP2](S+Q@
SHEO= SQJXV7QVYMJ]K¡HY O JV7Q\QV7QE[+XVWQ&Y(#YWIJ
TJSRJYZRJ
7@
H TQE
SPU
Q&Y(
YH O [
J MHO ZJ YJ)M7 LJ ¡O[THOYJN^RJ
L N]MJ
EZSRJ
\H O X GWH I J Y VH [ É 0 YP TYJ V
7 H E S]K YQF+ I J E YQJ ] ( )7 T J G O
PZHOYJSRJVP
MJ]\V
EYQJ](YHO]KEVQYZ7EFYP2](
IJYOIJ[+MJ
EIQYJ\]JVH[0É ETQMJE
IRJIRJ]+QSRJ?O \MJ]K@3(SHIJ Z+MJ PESQ
VH[É0YHOTQXO]JGW/]2J ](EVQJZ2VH/MEJ YQZH]JTQ1YRJL[Y HO J[+MJ\QE]]KSRJ
YWIJJVH[É0YHOY6IJE[QJP\QZHOYJ]KSRJ
U
Q&Y(]K
(SQ+ 2](E?QEN]Q]KSRJPSQ+ ESQTQVPYOH XENGG,
\QE?QEN]QNGMJN^TJ@
GO [ + M J Y6IJ E [QJ V)© E Z[YÞ S H O Z J EN]QMJ E
8 9
[QIJ\VJ
]KSRJGO[+MJ
IJYOIJSO=H \]JV,EN]QMJ
N]IJ@SHO=ESQJ
U
Q&Y( @ TQVP Y H O ]TJ V \QG. L ] K EN]QMJ EZ
Q SJ G . L S N^MJ L
Y6IJE[QJ)7MJLX[P XNV.
7HEI]KSRJ
GO[+MJY6IJE[QJX2MHVJTQP]KSRJ[P[P[IJ[IJXZO]J
ZO]JT
QV
7HSN^MJLY6IJE[QJV¢>MJTQETQMJXGWH/9[+MJYEZQMJIQVRJG,2](
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
[HO[HO\+Q\+QE
]KSRJVH[JEU+VWQYAGMJ%WQXGO[EZQFQE[+VWQ
ZO]JEI[OIJa ?O EVZQZ5MJ Y6IJE[QJY ATQE
EI[J# ?HO?Q (?Q
[HO[HO\+Q\+Qa?ON]IJEN^
SRJâXE[QX[+MJY6IJE[QJTQE
U
Q
EVQMJS, )7MLJ SHY6VJ GMJVMJZQSRJSP@EKMJTQE]Y]KEVQYEKYJ[Q
Z7EF@NVIJVQFQSQ)7MJL TQXO]JVWQYHO\O[JEEISRJ[TJEI=[+MJ U
Q
,SYEN]Q]K@GO>IJIK
(
YJEI=SRJU
Q&Y(EKYJJ[Q
Z7EF@)7TJ N]RJL EV+EI= N^TJSRJSP)7MJL VH[JEU+XGWH/9\HO]+.X[+YJ
EVQJZ2VH/MJ S+Q1YVRJ Y6IJE[QJ ZHOYJ)HOMJY ZHOYJG.L]K?O EG]KSRJ
Y6IJE[QJ VZHOYJ)HOMJG.L]KVJIRJ]K@
U
Q&Y(@)7TJN]RJLX[+YJ[TJGOGOZO]JGWMJ
Y6IJ E [QJ Y U
Q&Y( @ )7 T J Y H O UJ N ]RJ L X\H V J XV7 [ J
[TJGOGOZO]J
IJ U)
7H]KSRJ T3JTQZHO YJESQXGK Y6IJE[QJL\,[+MJ
7HEIESQ U
Q@ TQVPYHO S[H
ZQSRJ âTQVPYHO V\O[JE
ES
NVIJVQS,OEQYJSQâTQVPXE1YQMJSHSRJSH\QSP XIRJXMJ
]HO)HOMJSRJTQVP]KXE1YQMJX
QVWQY[IJ^HON^[JV
)HOMJEGWâTQVPYHO
FQSQN]IJ S MJ L S RJ # Y6IJ E [QJ Y H O J [ H O M J N]IJ U H O 2 ]( X* Z H ] J NVIJ V Q
)7TJFQSQ)7MJLTQXO]J\O[JSMJLSRJâXE[+YHOY6IJE[QJU
Q,S)7MJL
[H OM J ]MJ 1 YRJL S RJ SP Y GWYJ G WMJ ZYJ G, SEFQ[P @ TQXO ]J Y H O
)7TJFQSQ)7MJL \O[JE]KVRJ
EV5QJZMJLGWYJ
NVIJVQ3JEYWV-)M7 LJ ¡HO
QXT3JXZQVWQXE1YQMJ)HMO MJ N, GQSQVWQ
X\PSN^MJL XEIQYJ[HOMJSQVWQXQ
7MJN]
IJ YHTÚ1Y,/
ESQ NVIJVQ
VH[JEU+VWQT+QYHO N]RJ[+MJE
Q N]RJ][+MJ]K Y6IJE[QJ E[+9G.L
]KSRJ
âXZO]JYSHVJEV+9¡-]JE\+]KSRJV
7MJVZMJ)7MJLK[Q[QEN]QZHOYJ
ESQSP#[TJGK[TJ
,[+MJEN%QMJ&Y(RQKGWZHOYJSPE[+]MJE[+9
]KSRJ
â\.VQ7 Y6IJE[QJY L
HO J Y6IEJ [QJAMKV]Ka?O"GMJGWYJV\Q]KAYWH/YJ\( ¡HOa
)7MJL ][JSYJ2]( Y6IJE[QJ@ XQIRJGWYJYHO X\YJ[+MJ IJG,2](]K2](
Y6IJE[QJ[OH=SMJPV7[JSQT
QVWQT+QZOHEI]KSRJ
]KEVQYZE7 F@]K
([M+ J GOY[MJN]E?QEN]QGWYS J RJXZ+IJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XUMJLNVMJL]KSRJ \HOE?QEN]QGWYJYHO âTQXO]J[+MJ ¡HOYJ)7H]J\Q]KSRJ
U
Q&Y(@XGWYX J ZYJN]RJLTOG, OMH JVQNGMJ#X*ZH]JFQSQTYQY6VJYWMJ
NGMJSRJ â TQXO]Jà \MJ
7QE]Z+MJ]KSRJ AFHOE[QJa AEUU
Qa
A^PTQE
I[JaTESQNVIJVQXS,O X)-IJYHO X*ZH]EJ K?Q
7Q
IJXV7I]J MJ
GYJG. ]K@EN]QZHOYZ J 5MEJ [QL?O[EJ ]SQ].?O \MJVRJ#YH O F
LJ QSQUHY O
VT3JTQVH]K
U
Q&Y(YE[QL âGYJG.ESQ XZO]JYHO V7IJYIJ[HYW2](
N][JSQ
7MJZMJT+QEN]QE?QE
SQ
G.L]K2](
U
Q&Y(@X*ZH]J)7MJLE
SQGWYJYHONVIJVQN]IJ)7MJLY6IJE[QJY
73J[+.E^QJN]\QSRJV7QSQVIJNVIJVQTQ^[JSPYHO]HOVHOIQZRJSEFQ
E]KYJETZHOÑN^TJ]KSRJNVIJVQ]HOMJYHO1YRJL2]( NVIJVQXS,OX)-IJX[+YJ
X*ZH]EJ K?Q
YHO X*ZH]J]MHO J[+MJ
7Q1YRJL)HOMJSRJSH=VO ?O[JX*ZH]JZHO
T[MJ ^[J¡-2]( VHVH IQZRJ\QSRJVWQ ?O[JV?O[JYHO NVIJVQN]IJ)7MJL
[HOYJUHOMJ 1YRJL)HOMJ]KSRJ
\HE=O 1YQMJL NVIJVQLF)7MLJ 3JEYWV-XE1YQMJYHO NVIJVQ[HY =O X*Z]H J
ZHO]HOVOEH YQMJV+IJT+QEN]QUHO)OMH J
IJâTQXO]JYNVMJL[MJZHVVJL RJ?OY6IJE[QJ
EV5QJZMJL]KSRJ[YJLXEV5QJZMJL&Y(EV5QJZMJLNGMJN^TJ]K@AET[IQI,
FHYEYVQ
QVHa?O%OFO
QE?Q1YQG.L]KSRJY6IJE[QJGO\Q
ESQET[IQSRJY6IJE[QJ@XIQ[JX[+YJEYQMJESQY,N^TJZQ]K
ETS[RJ
EV[ÉQ
]JG,GWYJ
FQSQN]IJUHOGWYJYHO XEYQMJU,O N^TJ
IJ Y6IJE[QJ XT+VJYOIJ
&YH/]VJ]KSRJ FQSQE
# 3JEYWV-)7MJL ZPV- UYJU,E
¡-E\QMJLT,O
]KMJESQ]RQ]HOMJUHOMJ
QâTQE]VWH/YHOFQSQN]IJ
SRJV7QZYJ
+,9T
Q
N^TJ]K@Y6IJE[QJY.LSHO=SH]À,SVQ[TJEQYJX[+YJVP[YJLTHIJEGV-
N^TJEI]KSRJ
SHO=ESQJU
Q&Y(EKYJ[QZ7EF@)7TJN]RJLXGKSV[+MJ
O4JN]/ZHOESQTH[U J )YN]MJN]]K@âU)E>QZ-,9EUQJSN^MJLXQ[YJ
SE
QZO]JGWMJTH[J N^TJZQ]KSRJ
âXE1YQMJX
QVW/H YHO FQSQN]IJ
Q[+MJN]IJUOSH X
P EI)7MLJ XV7Q
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
VWH/T,OZO]JVH)OHMJSRJXH]ÀQJZ+.EGWQJV-[TJT,O[
Q]K
7HEI]KVP]KEVQYEF
E1YQMJL N^TJ
SRJ V?O[J]KFQSQN]IJSP@XN]TJSQN^TJ]K@ATQ^[J
SPVWQ XV7Q[TJT,O[
Q E[+9]KVP YHOJ[HOMJSQ N]MJUMJ^[J¡-]KE[QLa ?O
X)PXR8[J E[QMJ]IJ]KSRJ
\H=NO ]MJ],)O ]7H JSRJL TQVPYOH ]KEVQYEKYJ[QZ7EFYN]IJZRJ^[J¡-
N]MJUMJNGMJVN]/E1YQMJE^QJN]X]J]KSRJFQSQN]IJSPYSQEIQYJU,O
XUMJL N]MJUMJVV- WQYHO ZO]]J KSRJSHN=O ^TJESQE1YQMJL âTQXO]J X*Z]H ]J OMH J
NVIJVQ]HOMJ)7TJ]HOMJZ,O[+MJ]KMJESQXV7Q[TJT,O[
QSRJFQSQN]IJSP@
[QIJSQN^TJ]KSRJ
EYW>P[MJV7[J[VJ
Y6IJE[QJL XEI)7MJL E
7VPZTQVPYOH YPRZ
( YJ)H]7 TJ YJ¡HOYJE]G.EL SQ
]KEVQY 3(SHIJZ+MJXQ EYW>P[MJ]KSRJ >I( ENVNVEU+)7MJL SV(
E
QMJT3JZ-HMJ[HO=Y TH[JMJ[TQ XQE]YPR(SRJLXN]MJ [TJGK[TJ
,
NVIJVQTQXS,O X)-IJXGWH/9N^RJLE]N]MJE]SRJLX[+YJEYW>P[MJ]KSRJ
EIQYJU,OâTQXO]JN^TJENVQYJE
]KMJZO]JEUQMJSPU
QEVQMJ,SXQ
EYW>P[MJ]KSRJ
GOE^E^QJK
(
YJ [MJZH-MJ
THE MYANMAR BUDDHIST:
HIS LIFE FROM THE CRADLE TO THE GRAVE
1. Introduction
This is the third time that 1 have the pleasure and privilege, and
indeed, the honour to address the French scholars and students ofvarious
disciplines on Myanmar studies. It would be too persumptuous ofme to
assume that this repeat performance is called for because my perform—
ances on the two previous occasions had gone down very well. I am
inclined, as a Myanmar Buddhist, to attribute my being here again to the
occasioning of yours as well as mine kurmu, a term that will recur fre—
quently in the course of this lecture. Here it may suffice to say that we
have been ordained to meet for the third time by the causes of our works
ofmerit carried out together in the previous existences. Be that as it may,
1 am here again as large as life.
I have accepted the kind invitation ofl'Assemblee des Professeur
du College du France with pride and humility: pride at the thought ofthe
confidence that the professeurs have reposed in me; and humility at the
awareness of my limitations in trying to prove myself worthy of their
trust. I’ll try not to fail them.
My terms of references are to deliver a series of eight lectures
on The Myanmar Buddhist: his life from the cradle to the grave, for four
weeks, at the rate of two lectures per week. I’ll adhere to the letter and
spirit of the terms. My aim is to inform and to induce reflection. My
purpose is to present to youthe whole spectrum ofthe life ofthe Myanmar
Buddhist — not what it ought to be, but what it really is. lntrying to achieve
it in eight lectures, I may be attempting to put a decalitre ofmilk in a litre
bottle. Nevertheless I’ll try. I’ll take you on a tour in sequential
stages through the exotic regions of(1) Nurture, his own environmental
influences, that is the geographical, political, cultural, economic and social
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 29
settings, together with his upbringing, care and training fostered by his
family that mould his personality; and (2) Nature, his inherited endow-
ment - qualities and characteristics, physical, mental and spiritual, which
to him, and which reflect in his beliefs and practices and diver-
sions during the normal course ofhis life. In this context, I’ll trace his life
form his birth, through the stages of childhood, adolescence, manhood
and old age, ending in his death and its concomitants. Such incidents and
events in his life as engendered by his beliefs and practices will be spot-
lighted give a true perspective to the picture.
In a discourse ofthis nature, it may be unavoidable for me not to
tread on grounds already covered by me in my two lectures at the Institute
of Social Anthropology in Paris in June 1950 ‘Social Contact their
impact on Myanmar culture’, and also in my three lectures on ‘Myanmar
Poetry’ in May 1971 at the National des Langues Orientales
Vinvantes, now known as lnstitut National des Langues ct Civilisations
Orientales. The present series oftalks are in essence a supplementary to
those lectures, in that the highlighting ofthe various aspects ofMyanmar
Buddhist’s life would, 1 trust, add a new dimension to your existing
knowledge of Myanmar and the Myanmar Language, literature and
culture.
A plea may be made here about my competency in giving this
lecture. The subject proper invites many sociological and anthropologi-
cal interpretations on many issues. 1 am giving this discourse in the
capacity as a Professor of Myanmar Language, Literature and Culture.
Sociology and Anthropology, 1 confess to knowing next to nothing, still
less to professing them.
2. Nurture
The Myanmar Buddhist, like the French Christian or the Indian
Hindu, or the Chinese Confucian, is in effect a creature ofcircumstances
which, as already stated, constitute nurture and nature.
Buddhism maintains that the personality ofan individual is what
its karma makes of it. So too is his destiny. The Buddhist concept of
karma is dealt with under 2.3.1 Theruv0du Buddhism. II needs to say here
only that karma encompasses both nurture, environmental influence and
nature, inherited endowment. These determinant agencies will be con-
sidered now to get the background against which the whole spectrum of
the life of the Myanmar Buddhist can be viewed in its true perspective.
2 .1 Geographical setting
Myanmar, the habitat of the Myanmar people, share frontiers
with India on the west and with China on the north and north—east — two
great countries which have contributed no small measure of culture and
civilization to the world. To the east lies Thailand and to the south Malaysia
and to the west the Indian Ocean, which has been the highway for
merchants from the west since the fifth century A.D or earlier.
Myanmar is as large as France, but its population is almost half
that ofFrance. The main physical features are the thickly wooded moun—
tains in the northern region, and high wooded plateaux and hills in the
east and south—east; the plains in the centre intersected by high ridges: the
YakhineYomas (or range of mountains), the Bago Yomas and the Shan
Plateaux; and the valleys ofthe three main rivers — the Ayeyarwaddy, the
Sit-taung and the Thanlwin — which have served as means ofcommunica—
tion from north to south since the dawn of history. And in the south are
the flat areas ofthe Ayeyarwaddy delta .
The climate ofMyanmar is mostly tropical. From May until Octo—
berthere is regular rainfall; for the rest ofyear there is hardly any rain. The
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 31
central part ofMyanmar is known as the Dry Zone, for here the rainfall is
very light. In the hottest months, March and April and part of May, the
temperature in the southern and central parts ofthe country may
100 Farenheit ( 35’ C ), while in December, January and February the
temperature may fall to 60’ F(15 ’C) and become progressively less in the
north.
These physical and climatic conditions are mainly responsible
for the distribution of both agricultural and natural products and also of
the peoples throughout Myanmar. Myanmar has for as we know
been primarily an agricultural country. Rice, cultivated in wet areas as
well as in Dry Zone by means of irrigation, tops the list of agricultural
products. In addition, Myanmar has been endowed with natural resources,
such as mineral wolfram, tin, silver, rubies, jade; and teak forests
which are mostly found in the Bago Yomas and south—eastern part of
Myanmar. Most of these exportable commodities pass through Yangon,
the principal port and capital ofMyanmar.
The indigenous races of Myanmar, which are of Mongoloid
stock, fall into three main groups: the Tibeto—Myanmar, the Mon—Khmer
and the Thai—Chinese. The first group is represented by the Myanmar
proper (concentrated especially in the Ayeyarwaddy valley), Yakhine
(along the western coastal strip), Dawei and Myeik (in the valley ofthe
Tanintharyee), the Nagas, Chins and Kachins and many other tribes in
the mountainous regions of the north. The representatives ofthe second
group are the Mon (in the Ayeyarwaddy delta and Thaton and Kyaik—
kha—mi districts - the regions around the mouths ofthe Sit-taung and the
Thanlwin repectively), the Wa (between the Shan States and Yunan), and
Palaung (in Northern Shan States), while the third group includes the
Shans (on the Shan Plateaux), Karens (in Tanintharyi, Karenni, and the
Ayeyarwaddy delta) and Taung-thu or Pa-o ( chiefly in the Shan States).
There are several thousand domiciled Indians and Chinese scattered all
over Myanmar.
2 . 2 Political setting
The political history ofMyanmar that impinges on the cultural,
economic and social activities of its peoples can be summarised as the
southward advance ofthe Bamas and the unification ofthe country at the
beginning of each dynasty by powerful Bama kings, whose control was
later terminated by misrule or invasions from neighbouring countries.
The making ofMyanmar was periodically interrupted by the struggle for
32 Dr. Hla Pc
supremacy between the Bama and the representatives of the other two
the Mon and the Shan, from which the Bama emerged as the
sovereign power by the middle ofthe eighteenth century. Twice the king-
dom came to an end through external invasion: the first was by the Tartan
under Kublai Khan in the thirteenth century, and the second by the British
in the nineteenth century, and at each time ceased to exist as an independ-
ent or united country for sixty years or so.
Waves of migrations from Certral Asia had been for
thousands of years before the Bamas descended the plains probably in
the mid-ninth century to settle down where the water is clear and the
grass is green. Here they came into contact with the Pyus, now extinct,
and the Mons who had already attained a high level ofcivilization . In the
eleventh century King Anaw-rahta, 1044 -1077, welded into king-
dom a group offormerly independent states and principalities, and ruled
them from his capital city ofBagan. €iradually he extended his sovereignty
down to Tanintharyi in the south and to Thaton, the capital city ofathriving
Mon kingdom; to Yakhine in the west, and over the hills east ofthe Sit-
taung river. The city of Bagan, today one of the famous ruined cities of
South-East Asia, succumbed to the principalities at the end the Bagan
dynasty.
During the next two generations or so, Upper Myanmar formed
part ofthe Shan hegemony with separate capitals at Sagaing, Myin-zaing
and Pin-ya, all only a few miles away from Mandalay, the last capital of
the Myanmar kingdom while the Mons at Bago, north of Yangon, re-
assured their former glory to hold suzerainty over lower Myanmar.
In 1365, the Ava dynasty was founded with its capital at Ava,
south-west ofMandalay. The kings ofthis dynasty devoted much oftheir
time and energy to upholding Buddhism and to encouraging an off-shoot
of that heritage - the Myanmar literature. At the same time while they
were wracking their brains in finding out means and ways ofpreventing
the Shans from their domination, they were also attemping, without much
success, to conquer the Mon kingdom.
Unity of the whole country was re-establishdd only in the six-
teenth century. Two kings of the Taung-ngu dynasty, 1531-1750, called
Tabin Shwe-hti, 1531-50, andBayin Naung, 1500-81, first ruling at Taung-
ngu and then at Bago achieved this long awaited attainment. Bayin Naung
put an end to Ava’s rule in 1555, and taking a leaf out ofAnaw-rahta’s
book, re-gathered the dismembered states into his fold to set up a united
kingdom only to be frittered away by his successors.
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 33
In 1750, the Mons, taking advantage of the internal weakness,
tried to wrest the power and managed to spread their control over the Dry
But they lost their temporary gains as well as their independence
for good when Alaung-hpaya, 1752-1760, chiefofShwebo, north ofMan-
dalay, re-united the whole of Myanmar and founded the Alaung-hpaya
dynasty, known in historical works in English as the Ava dynasty. The
of nineteenth century saw the kingdom of Myanmar reach its
widest extent: it included the whole of modern Myanmar together with
Manipur and part of Assam now integral constituent states of India.
say the Myanmar the kings of this dy-
nasty shifted their seats of government from one capital to another: first
at Shwebo, then Ava, and to Amarapura, and back again Ava and
Amarapura, and finally to Mandalay.
It was unfortunate for the proud and parochial Myanmar kings
to be fated to have as neighbours in the nineteenth century the British,
who had brought under their complete control virtually the whole ofIndia
at the end ofthe eighteenth century. It coincided with the age ofimperialism
- beliefin the value ofcolonies, the policy ofextending a country’s empire
and influence - a precept practised by the Europeans powers ofthe time.
A collision course was now being set between the two nations facing
each other across the borders. Collide, inevitably, they did in the form of
three Anglo-Myanmar Wars of 1524-1526, 1552 and 1555, in the process
ofwhich the Myanmar lost the whole country to the British, piecemeal -
the two coastal strips of Yakhine and Tanintharyi, Lower Myanmar and
Upper Myanmar in succession.
After the Second World War of 1939 to 1945, during which the
country was occupied by the Japanese form 1942 to 1945, Myanmar
regained her independence on 4th January 1948. She did not revert to the
old monarchical type of government, but chose instead to become the
Republic of the Union ofMyanmar.
2.3 Cultural setting
In the lust ofthe two lectures delivered at the Sociological Insti-
tute in 1980, I set out how the social contacts with other races have fash-
ioned the Myanmar culture oftoday. Here it may be necessary to spotlight
only those aspects ofthis culture which have bearing on my theme, such
as Buddhism, particularly Theravada Buddhism, and other -isms, as-
trology, demonology, black and white magic, and kindred sciences, which
the Myanmarpeople have absorbed andMyanmarized, and appropiatedthem
as their own.
34 Dr. Hla Pc
2.3.1 Buddhism
Culturally Myanmar owes an immense debt its neighbours,
especailly to India and Ceylon (Sri Lanka). Both forms ofBuddhism, the
Mahayana, Cireat Vehicle and Theravada, Teaching ofthe Elders, which
came from India together with Tantric Buddhism and Hinduism, had co—
existed side by side with the other two -isms in Myanmar since the fifth
century A.D. Theravada Buddhism, according the Myanmar chroni—
cles, gained predominance over the Mahayana and other —isms , including
animism which the Myanmars were then professing, after the conquest
of Thaton by Anaw-rahta in 1057. The introduction of Theravada Bud—
dhism with its scriptures written in Pali, from the Mons, and later reinforced
from Ceylon, has uplifted the Myanmars to the plane above that of their
cognate people and ofother indigenous ethnic groups. One concrete result
will suffice.
The Bama borrowed the Mon alphabet and reduced their
langauge to writing sometime in the early twelth century A.D. Their evan—
gelical zeal to study and propagate Buddhism in their own tongue, and to
set up stone inscriptions for their works ofmerit - pogodas and monastries
— were the driving force behind this achievement. Ofthe members ofthe
Tibeto—Myanmar sub-family, only the Tibetans and Myanmars can lay
claim to having a script oftheir own.
Myanmar has a vast amount of literature in epigraphs, on palm
leaves and folded paper and in printed books. The epigraphical literature
ofover one thousand inscriptions, dedicatory in motive, dignified in style,
with many allusions to incidents from Buddhist scriptures and stories,
began in the early twelth century. Its contributors were Buddhist monks
or former monks holding official position at the court or in the provinces,
and poetesses; and its notable features were Buddhist piety and courtly
refinement of language. There was a preponderance of adaptation ofthe
Jataka (Buddha's former Birth Stories), epic historical and panegyric
poems in praise ofkings, lyrical poems on love and nature and folk, literary
and musical songs, as well as epistles, letters and dramas in mixed style
ofverse and prose.
Prose literature was relatively small in variety and in number
but large in volume. It comprises translations or adaptations ofBuddhist
scriptures and stories, chronicles, works of Pali grammar, astrology, as—
tronomy and alchemy and kindred sciences; legal precedents, the law
books based cheifly on Hindu legal treatises written in Sanskrit.
The printed literature which appeared comparatively late in the
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 35
nineteenth century such works as Pya-zat, dramatic of
Buddhist and non—Buddhist stories, novels, essays and short poems and
short stories. Some of these modern writings savour of western flavour.
Buddhism has a profound and pervasive influence the
Myanmar. It is deep rooted in the whole fabric ofhis mind. He may hold
an unorthodox belief and even put it into practice for reasons known to
him. Nevertheless, ifyou scratch the veneer ofhis make—up, you are bound
to find Buddhism deeply ingrained underneath the surface. under—
stand the whys and wherefores of his way of life, and his beliefs and
practices we will now turn our attention to this Faith ofhis.
2.3.2 -isms
Buddhism in Myanmar, as in other Theravada countries, is
syncretic. It is, as already mentioned in my lecture in Paris in 1980, tinted
with Hindusim from which it developed, with Tantric and Mahayana Bud—
dhism from which it has superceded, and with animism surviving from
earlier phase of Myanmar history. Behind the facade ofMyanmar Bud—
dhism lie many non—Theravada practices and beliefs, some ofwhich have
merged with those ofthe Theravadin so closely that these alien elements
have been accepted by unsophisticated Myanmars as part and parcel of
their Faith.
The Myanmar Buddhist is really a synthesis of two personalities — a
Buddhist and a Myanmar. He lives not only for the life hereafter, but for
this world as well. The recongnition ofthis dichotomy is essential for the
understanding ofhis dual personality. As a Buddhist he takes refuge (has
faith) in the Three Gems - Buddha, the Law and the Order ofthe monks
40 Dr. Hla Pc
- and practises piety, by among other things, dana making religious offer-
ings, sila (Myanmar thi-lé) observimg precepts, and bhavana
(Myanmar he-wouo) devoting hismself to meditation, all for the next
world, with a view to reaching Nirvana ultimately.
As a Myanmar (1) he has his eyes on this world and sometimes
propitiates both the celestial and terrestrial deities or nat, and spirits and
human adepts in black and white magic, through fear or feelings of inse-
curity; (2) he to magical rites and rituals as to gain material
benefits, or acquire power over animate or inanimate objects; and (3) he
may believe in alchemy, astrology and kindred sciences for various worldly
FN]/N]MJ\HIJEYWQMJV- NVIJVQ[TJEQYJ
.9 FV7Q SP=IJYWMJ
XSHOMJXIJY1S>QSYJE
QYJ],OYHO]\(IJYWMJ#)OOHMJM,E
XENGXEI#
T(]+QE
)7MJL ZPVE-
XEIX\QVWQ)7MJL SP=VHSQTOYSP=YHO ZPZQENVQYJ
SRJX\HFJZHOSMJ1YQN]/TO]WH/E\QMJE][J#FJZHO ],OS+MJ E][J
UHO[Q]KMJ]K[J
SFQIJYWMJ@N]/N]MJV- SFQ][JIJYWMJYNVIJVQ
.9FV7Q
\MJ?]JET[.L¡O]J]HOMJ#TH[J]HOMJ#IQVJ]HOMJ#,O1YRJV-UHOMJ
QXEV+X)7TJXN^TJ
ZYJG,
7H2](SH2](SO[E[+YHOXNVMJSTJ)7MJLN^RJLT+YJE]S+Q)OHMJVJZHO=Y6IJE[QJ
,O1YRJ]K[J
E?QEN]QVRJL XE1YQMJX
QX[+YJ Y6IJE[QJLV7Q ]RQ
RJ
N]RJL]KLVZQUH[ O QI.=][JS[J2](EV[ÉQ
]JG,[MJN]\Q]K
ETY6IJE[QJ
EN]QS+Q VRJL FQSQ
]JXE1YQMJX
Q E[QJE[QJVWQVWQV7Q ZPV-E%
XNVMJ)7MJLV)OO×E%XNVMJVWQYHOXENGG,2](S,OS]JE^IJV-ZHOX]J]K[J
Y6IJE[QJYNVIJVQFQSQTYQTQE])7MJL3JEYWV-FQSQ
]J]KEVQY
[TJEQYJXEI)7MLJ E?QEN]QV7Q]KKE1YQMJL ZPVE- %[H=O V)O×E%[H=O UH[ O L.
]RQIJVWQV7QY6IEJ [QJL %?OS[ O YXZ+IJ XQIRJ]K[JE?QEN]Q)HMO J
EZQYJEXQMJ]RQ
]JVWQV7QY6IJE[QJVY6VJYWMJ[.LXE1YQMJIJG,\Q
ZHO]K[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
FYHON]/N]MJ\HIJEYWQMJNGMJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQZRJN]MJSTJG
TJQIJ#XH)H?H)0FQSQMJ#
[¡O[JY+IJN^0
7]J[Z HO= HO]K].][JIJYWMJN^TJ
]JVWH/T,OYN]/N]MJE]SRJLX[HMO J
&Y( N]MJ
[.L ]O\>O 3JSQN^TJ]K[JSFQEZQY)7MLJ \HVJ EYWQMJN]/N]MJV[ - =HO
E]KMJT]J],OE^QJE][.LF]K].
%OFQSQXPX
]O¢H/ZJ[TJ3(
.9ZP
RJZPES+SHO=V?O[JX[É
],OZ8QYHOY,YV
YT(V,N]/N]MJ]K[JSP=FY,1YVQZRJSRJX[OHMJ
]K].Y,T(V,SRJLX[HOMJN^TJ
]K[J%OXZHOYWY,YV
@SEFQYHO
XGIJ ## V7Q E\
QK%OKEGKMJT3JN^MJL ^+MJLUHO N]\Q]K[J
(V7QE[QL Y,SRJ IJHOMJN]/N]MJ\HIJEYWQMJV-)7MJL 1SYQSEZQY@
1S>QSYJE
QYJV- )7T]J MOH J Z,O )7MLJ SYJUMOH ]J K[JZS =OH QEN]Q)7M]LJ KVJNVIJVQ
%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ
.9FYHO],OV7IJNVMJE[+9)HOMJ
IJâ1S>QSYJE
QYJV-
)7TJVWH/TZ,OYHO S,OS]JS+Q
]KVJ
# ]\(EIQYJG,
NVIJVQ)OHMJM,XEIQYJ^YJV7QXH)HN]RJ#XE
79)7MJLXE
79ENVQYJVQ7
[¡O[NJ ]RJ)HOMMJ &, Y()7T)J MHO MJ ), 7MLJ IJIVH [
H J \HT]JEI]K[JYV«QL 3JEYWV-
XUMJLUMJLN^TJE]V--V7QXZ+IJ1S>QSYJE
QYJ[.L)HOMJM,&Y(E[+]KXE
79
FYJV7Q \HOMJHOQ
)HOMJM, E[QMJFYJV7QE[QL XH)HSVO
Q)7MJL
VEZ
7Q)HOMJM,
7HEI[JXH)HSVO
QYG
TJMK
QTOSHO=V?O[J(\YJ
ETQ[.LXGWHIJV7T2](YOIJS+JE
E1YQMJZVJV&Y(N^TJ]K[J
NVIJVQ)HOMJM,)7MJLN]MJSTJXYWJXIJ_
HQX[P[PEZQYJ]K].
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
SHO=E]VJL ZP3(E
V7QE[QL NVIJVQYN]MJSTJ
.9\YJYJGIJ= SQ
7HVJ
ENVVWYJ)7QS+MJN]MJYE[QL XHYXEI)7MJL E[Q\P\]JESQ ENVQYJ]HOMJ
E[QMJYOIJES#E[QMJ\P\]JSRJLXE
79)7MJLXE
79E[QMJ]HOMJ E[QMJ[IJ
)7MJL YOIJNVMJLES# EIQYJ
GHOMJ¡HOV ].GP¡HOVUHO[.L E[QMJ[IJ&Y(VWQ)7MJL
7VJYOIJENVNVMJL[HO=1YQR]J\QSRJLXZJ]HOMJENVN]IJ=ESVWQ_
Q[(#
TTJE[QMJ#S,ZM+ NJ VTJ&Y( S,O S+@ J NVTJ7VJ ENVN]IJE= SVWQ)7MLJ E[QMJ]OMH JV7Q
_
Q[(NVTJY6IJE]ESEGENVN]IJ=]HOMJVWQ]KMJ]K[JENVN]IJ=ES
VWQYHO N^[JSIJ[.L NVTJ&Y(S,OS+JY E
7E
7XGKV7 T2]( E[QMJENVQYJ
E
ZVJUYJS+JE
ZVJE1YQMJE[+ N^TJ]K[J
NVIJ V QL
QS( 3 [O Y XVWQXQN^MJ L ]P E )+ ]K[J EVZV7
EXQYJ [ H O F QZ X\H ], O V 7 I J VH O
QS( N ^TJ 2 ]( YWIJ Z VWQV7 Q VH O
XZ+IJ
+QG.]K[J)HOMJM,XZJ]HOMJYHOENGQYJES+9
]JIJZHO=EG]K[J
VH O
+ Q S+ I J V- IRJ ZH O = ] K X]P N ]MJ U, O N^TJ [ . L V[J Z _2]( Z )7 M J L EVZ
ETQETQ]HOMJV7Q)HOMJM,XZJ]HOMJ)7MJL E[QMJ]HOMJESVWQYX]PGWHIJ
X\YJE
QYJ)HOMJ]K[J(>MJFQ#>IJIK
(#E^E^K
(V7QE[QL
X]PGWHIJ
X\HUMJ)HMO ]J K[J)HOMMJ ,ENVQYJ]MHO JE
QYJSQ+ Z5MJ
X]PGWHIJY]HO]HO2](YWUMJS+Q]K[J
SRJ
QS(3[O)7MJL E
ENVXEIX\QY THOYJ]WH/S()7,)7MJL SFQ
\+YJYOIJ
7HV-#ZPEIN^IJ=YWYJVV- WQYHON]/N]MJ\HIJY+]J]K[JY6IJE[QJ[HO=
SHVS (7 V5SVHOMJ[TJEZ5QYJZO, NVIJVQ)HOMMJ ,?QTHOYJ]WH/E
XHY)HOMJM,N^TJ]K
[JVHOVWQ
QX
]JVWQV7QUIJT]KTHOYJ]WH/]K[JENGQYJES+9
]JIJV7Q
ZRJ E
S+MJT]K THOYJ]WH/[Q]K]. ZJQ\+YJYOIJV7Q UIJT]KY
\H]JU,O Y]K(N]MJNVIJVQ)HOMJMV, 7QS,>Q[XEI)7MJLE
I,#G.VN^0#X^W/H YS J ,
EGP^
IJ#EM+#][ÉNVQ#EYWQYJTHVJ E[+\+YJ]K[JSTJE[Q\+YJE[+YHO
ZRJ].GP¡HOV)7MJL XE
79E[QMJ]HOMJESVWQV7
]K[J\+YJYOIJVWQYHO
XHYUH]JYVJ2VH/9&Y(N^TJ[.L
IJYOIJV7[TJUMJL N]RJ]YHO [MJ]HO= E
QMJGW
]K[J
NVIJVQ)HMO MJ ,[HMO J
MJSQVWQYV+IJOZ H /+H YJX)+VJ 7Q]KMJ2]([H%YJ
NVIJVQ#V+IJGVQ)7MJL HOQ[¡O[J)+J VWH/TO S,OTOY+.]K[J]\VTOV7Q
ZP3( E
VWQYHO
RJRI8 J SRJGONVIJVQSIJ#N]MJSTJSIJGIJ=
7S
H RJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
%VQTTJTTJVWQ]KMJ2](XZJ]HOMJES_
Q[( NVTJ7VJV7QXHYTOE
EI\HMO J]K[J(]\VXTOV]7 .
GHMO VJ WQYXEIQYJ]MOH J YVJ¡HO [VJESV7Q#
\QJ)7MJL 2VH[JSQVWQY[IS*Q
( YVJ¡HO[IJESVWQV7QIQ#GWMJ #
YGWMJI.= XNGQZPVWH/VWQT+Q[HO=Y E[QMJ\P\]J
Q ENVQYJ]HOMJESE[+V7Q
EI\HMO J1Y]K[JO[ H V+IGJ VQXTOMJVWQV7V+IVJ WQY_
Q[(NVTJES
)7MJLS\,O)7MJLYWH/YV(G¡HOMJ\Y
. TTJE[QMJS,Z+MJNVTJESVWQV7QEI\HOM1J Y
]K[J[HOMJ
MJSQVWQY
7VJN]RJIJ)7MJL PIIJIJV7QEI2](]EZQMJ
VWQ
7VJN]RJENVQYJ]HOMJV7Q EI\HOMJ1Y]K[J [[HXO]JTOV7QE[QL
7VJ
YOIJENVNVMJLV7Q
7VJZPVWH/VWQ# [IS*Q
(# YQN]RJIJ)7MJL _
Q[(
NVTJESV7QY
MJVWQXN]MJE[QMJSPEG]OXOH LVJ WQ#
7VJ N]RJIJVQ7 XHY
EI\HOMJ1Y]K[J XH)H)7MJL [¡O[JVWH/)+JVWQZRJ NVIJVQ)HOMMJ , [TJIJ
Z,OV7QE\QMJE]KMJVWQT+QXENGGWEI\HOMJZ5YJ
7H]K[J
# )HOMJM,E
EIQYJG,
NVIJVQ=3JEYWV-#T(]+QE
)7MZLJ VP E-
E[+YOH ¡HY
O GJ [JZQ[.L )HMO MJ E,
SVHOMJYHOXYW3JGW/]J
Z5MJ%VQVWQ)HOMJM,E[QMJ]HOMJSHO=MJE
QYJZQ[IJGOH
XQ4Q&Y( [.L FO
MJVWQY)HMO MJ T, RJZ,O 2]( VMJUYJVWQE\QMJX.( VMJUYJ
[TJUYJT(V7QEIQYJ]HOMJVMJVWQXO]JGW/]JV-R,L^WMJZQ[.LX[+YJXHVJI(GWMJ
)HOMJM,VWQV7YW0EYWQJMJE
QYJZHO=VMJUYJ]WYJSO3JS+QG.L
[QE[+XT3J
ZHOYJ]KMJ]K[JNVIJVQ)HOMJM,\PE\QMJG.L
QV7QXGKXQEZWQJT+Q%VQ)7MJL
XNGQ X)+JMJ V+IJ# %VQ)7MJL
7VJ XMJXQ2]H/MJUHOMJV-E[+ N^TJG.L]K[J
QTO\.V7QE[QL %VQVWQY [TJ)HOMJZ,OYHO TOTRJ)HOMJG.L]K[J N]RJ]
YW0EYWQJV-E1YQMJLNVIJVQVMJUYJ)7TJUYJN]/[JYWG.L]K[J]\VX&YHVJ
QTOV7QYP%ZHOMJGIJ@[Q[QVWQYW0EYWQZ J Q]K[JO[HX&YVH Y J
QTOV7Q 2%H[HS5 YW0EYWQJMJE
QYJV- N^TJ]K[J )7TJ&YHVJZ,OV7Q
)HOMJM,XGW/]JXGWQXQ4QU,O ¡-,
2](X)7TJGIJT= (1YQNVMJEL XQMJZ+[JZ]J
TRJZ,OESQ)HOMJM,XN^TJV7 YWUMJEIG.L
]K[J
XQ
7XZJ]HOMJESV7 EN]QMJE
89ZQSPVWQ NVIJVQ)HOMJM,X[+MJ
XSO[JZHOYJXSO[JZHOYJMJE
QYJEI\HOMJGL1. Y[Q)7TJE]KMJE\QMJ)7MJLGW(
1YQG.L2](EIQYJUO,
QTOXZJ]OMH JV7Q%VQZPVW/H VWQE
1YRJ
QNVYJ)O
Q
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
ESE[+YHOE
QYJZQ1Y]K[JE
QYJZQSRJL%VQVWQYGOE]WQYJ
Y+JG.L2](N^TJ[.LESG,]W0ZPVWH/VWQ)7MJL\HE[+9
[JXUMJLNVMJL3JEYWV-
7HG.L]K[JNVIJVQ)HOMJM,V7QFO
MJTITJ
N]IJVE\QMJE[QL]KFPSV[)HOMJM,XN^TJ [RJE\QMJZHOYJ]K[J
# 3JEYWV-EIQYJG,
N]RJ)L T7 Y J ZPVE- %SH]V,À Q7 Y6IEJ [QJ)7TGJ WIH J E?QEN]QG.TL 3JVQ7
ZPVWH/NGQ)77MJL \HE[+9 UYJU,V-E1YQMJL EI= NVIJVQ3JEYWV- N^TJE]
EN]QMJZ.ZQG.]L OY , HO EN]Q1YQG.]L K[JGOE?QEN]Q
QV7QE[QLY6IJE[QJ
9.
]MJVXE1YQMJX
QE[+N^TJ[L. %OF QSQ#X\PSN^MJL E\
QK%OF QSQ
)7 MJL XNGQFQSQKVWQXN]MJ NVIJ VQV- N]/2]( YH OJ ]HO MJX N^TJ ZYJ G,
,1O YRJ\Q[.L E%MJIY[J,1O YRJV#- I[JYOH Y+VJ #- XMJXHMO VJ )©QIJEZQY(
]RQVWQ)7MJLSYJUHOMJVRJL3JEYWV-E
QX]HOMJVWQYHOSQXHY\Q
E^QJN]
IJ ZHO]KZHVJLVJ
##%OFQSQ
XHVJI(GWMJXH)H)7MLJS(
HZY*QS(?HO:J
V7NVIJVQY3JEYWV-
ZYJG,
GOV7QXEIQJ
\QVMJS\,ON]RJYHOEXQMJNVMJSHVJ]HOYJ2](SRJLXGKV7
ZPXVWQZYJG,YHOY+JEI[.LV?QI)7MJLE
Q7YJEIESQXNGQXP
X
RJ&Y(VWQ
EV7V7HIJE]WQYJY+J2](E\
KSQSIQE[QJ \+IJYQ
ZQG.L]K[JV+IJ[HO=\,V7 E\
K%OFQSQYHO ]HY[JE[QJVWQ)7MX JL [P
7H2]( EIQMJESQXGK S(
HZY*QV7 \]JV,
7HNGMJE1YQMJL NVIJVQ[HO=Y
XNGQ)+J^+Q[HOMJ
MJSQVWQ\YJ XUMJLNVMJL[YJZQ]K[J
QTOETQETQ]HMO J EZQYJVQ7 %VQYV+IXJ Y
QYHO
7H1Y]K[J
NVIJVQTQE]Y XZ+IJYWJIJ2]( E]TQ# ]O
]HOYJTQ)7MJL ],O)7H]JTQ
XENVQYJXNVQ
7H]K[J
QTO ETQETQ]HOMJV7Q GIJ=RQSRJL XE
XSQ)7MLJ EYWQYJTQE]KMJ[TJE\QMJEYWQY J OH UOE[QMJXH<QIJVWQ#%O MJ
>Q[JE[QJ&Y(VWQV7 V7(PYHOYQ2]( E
SQV- T[MJG.L]K[J YHOJ]HOMJ
TH[JYP N^MJLE
SQESQE]TQ#]O
]HY O TJ QVWQZRJ%OFQSQMJNVIJVQVMJ
VWQYXQE]GW(ENVQYJV-E1YQMJL\+IJYQZQ[J
QTOV7Q&Y(\+Q
7MJSIJZQG.L2](
QTO[+MJ],O)7H]JTYJVWQ[+MJYWJZQSRJX\H[UYJ
[RJ]K].TQE]EYW>P
7MJVWQYE[QL%OFQSQ
?IJVWQ)7MJLIIJ[+MJ )7MJL
IJEE
QYJ
?IJZP\+YJVMJV-\VJVWQ]K].XVWH/SV(Y%WQTQUHOVWQ
ZRJ]KMJ]K[J\PNGQSRJLZY4QYE[QL%OFQSQSYJMJV-)7MJL
\(VPIIJ?IJZ8VJSRJL XGWYJ]K]. XE
XSQE[+V7Q TYQEN]\YJ
ZY*QY Z8VJEI]K[J ZY*QTQE]V7Q ]KMJ[.L XE1YQMJX
QVWQY
FQSQN]IJSHO=V?O[JNVIJVQV-N]/\QSRJL%OMJ>Q[JE[QJ&Y(VWQ#SVHOMJ
EVQJY+IJ)7MJL FOIJE[QJ^+.9# EV[ÉQ^+.9# SFQ^+.9 Y%WQ# ¡HO
Q],ON]MJVWQ#
S(GWMJXN]MJ ZY*QTYQEN])7TJE\+ E
Q7YJSRJL TQ)7MJL >Q[J\O]JVWQ
XVWH/T,OZMJ]K[J
TYQEN]XE
XSQYXVW/H XTQE
QXE
X[+Y]J KIRJ]K]K
[J SHO=ESQJ \O\RJXQN^MJL &Y(VQ]K[J XE1YQMJX
QVWQV7Q
%OTQE])7MLJ IH]K[J]N,O ]MJVWQ#]K:HSKYWVJVWQ#E%MJ#IY[ÉE%#XH
¢ [J)M7 JL
V«(
X[[JVWQ# N^[J\,OVWQ)7MJL SS*Y¡HOYJ FQSQ)7MJL E
SRJL ?H)0
VS[JVWQYHO XENGG,SRJL VS[JYWVJVWQ]KMJ]K[J
],O)7H]JTQYE[QL
QTOXE[QJYEZE)7QMJV7E]ZQ]K[J
N]>Q[JVWQ#[/VWQ#TQ[VJVWQXN]MJY%WQ[HO],O[HOVWQ]KMJ
QV7Q%OMJV7
ZRJV7(#XNGQV7ZRJV7(PE
SQ[QE[+9
]K[J(\.YXGWH/9EG[J
UIJESQXE
XSQVWQV7QXEIQYJ[HOMJUIJ[QZRJE[+9
]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
%OF
QSQYNVIJVQ
.9FYHOFYJE]KMJT,VO 7 &Y( VQESQXE\QYJ
X],LXN^TJ)7MJL N]/N]MJE]]K[J NVIJVQL E[+EGENVQJNVMJ],OV7Q %OFQSQ
Z8VJEI]K[J NVIJVQ[TJEQYJ?Q ¡HO
QV?O[JESQ XPYHO ZYJG,
YWMJLSO, EYQMJYWMJLS,OVJFQZHO= X.(XPZYJG
, [QZRJUHO[QE[QL
SPSQSHZHVJLVJSHO=E]V.LSP=XE],YHOG+Q1YRJL]KSP
.9X>ª[ÉV7QYHIJ
EI[.L%(>]K%OF QSQYHOE[+9V7QXV7IJ]KNVIJVQ[TJEQYJ@FVRJSHO=
VRJ],O N^TJSRJ# FQE1YQMJL SRJZHON^TJ
SRJ UHOSRJL XE1YQMJ
X
MJVWQ)7MJLSP=,O1YRJV-)7MJLXVPXYWMJL[OH=YHOIQZRJSEFQE]KYJ)HOMJ^OH=
SPYHOY+JSRJL %OFQSQXE1YQMJXQ¡,OTHOYJ 1YRJL1Y
EXQMJ
###%O
%OFQSQUHO[Q%OE ?Q1YQ[.L[
Q]K].(FQSQXPYF
EIIRJZVJR8I]J KXEIQYJ[MOH J ]RQ
7MVJ WQIQZRJ\QSZHO ×IE%
^(EZQJEUQJ^(
V?O[J]KFP%OFQSQXT3JXZQV7QXV7IJ[
QSTÚQ
[
Q
YHO ]HOÑ ]HOÑ SHGWMJE>QN^MJL [
Q
7QNGMJ?Q XGWHIJYOIJ¡,OV5]K].
1YYJ3)7MJL1YYJVFJ?QX
MJN^TJTPTVJSZHO]K].(ZHO]. ZPXTFJY#
ZPFJZHON^TJZQXT
7Q[QZRJXGWRJX)7(]K].%OE?Q1YQ[.L]QI
[
QYFZ+[EJ NVQYJE
ZVJN]E]^H=]O K].XNGQFQV5XE
V]K]KFP
%O@FN^TJE[QJT3JYHO1YRJLZ5MJ SRJXGWYJ \MJ
7Q]K[J
%OF
O QVN^TJV( SH[
V MJSQFV7QXH)
H )HMJO MJ , Y]ÀZ( [JN]RJVQ7
)7TJ [HOMJ[HOMJ &Y(T+QESQ TRJTHVJ)7MJL IIJ[+MJ E]WQJEV+9G.L[J
)7TJSQV7QVMJSV(XEGWQXZ7)7MJL TOZWQ
TJ][J\HVJ NVQ[J)7T1J YQ
XHVJE\QMJSRJFSQE[QJEZ^+Q2](V1YQV(V7QSPXHO#SPIQ#SPES#
]KETS[RJZHO=XH<QIJN]/[JV?Q]\(SHVJLSHVJLGK2](SYJESX
Qà
[RJZQE[QLUMJEN]QMJ&Y(ZRJP[O]J¡HOYWH/ZQ#VQ
JI[J)7MJLXE^QJVWQ
ZRJZYJEZWQL \+YJEN]1Y
[J
SRJLEIQYJS%¥R/[·4JE[QJ
^HO=H]×IQ¡-XQ\O[JE[QJVP
[J
7R JZWQ[.L SRJN ^TJE [QJT3JY HO Y6IJE [QJ XYW3J GW,/ ]KVJ
R3L3J ( ,VQ7 YHO JE[QJ[MOH JE
7E
7FVWQT+QN^TJGS L. V5YOH ¡-[ - J]OE%¥IH KS
·4JE[QJ
E[QJV[ P JSIJEGKMJV, Q7 H%T¥ Y/·4JE[QJ
E[QJVP[J
VHOESQYJ,XQ¡,O[YJGWHIJE
QYJ[.LXGKSTÚQEZ]KSHNVMJX
?[ÉVJ
·4JE[QJ
7H2](âFYV«QV7Q]+MJLVRJLFO
QMKUPXIYJEZUPPENVQYJ
FO
QXN^TJ F(T(VQ7 ]+MJLE[QJVP]K[JXVRJIQVEK[VZHO= [++MJ]K
[J FO
QYHOJE[QJNV[JY KZ,O XUYJVN][J [
QESIQ
E?Q1YQE[QJVPG.L2](SYJE[QJ
7TJUJF(T(V7Q]
HIH%¥QIJT,MJE[QJVP
]K[J
( Z ( WMJ EG FQSQXP U H O [ Q EZQYYH O ^IJ U MJ
\HIJ GW/]J E[QJ VP[ .L XI)©[ IJGH OE[QJ
7 MJ [TJ IRJ XQN^MJ L ZP[ HO= \YJ
SQZ+IJNVMJLNV[J2]( X
Q
Q YHO [IJGHOE[QJ)7MJL Z8VJSRJL \Q
FO
Q
EKL
7 H S RJ ? O , O 1 YRJ Y HO Y+ J NGMJ YH O UH O Z H O S RJ ? O UH O ]KY
%OFQSQSRJ
(Z(WMJ?O EGUHO1Y[.LFQSQV?O[J]KFP
%OYSP=YHOJSPZPSQV?O[JZHO=[TJ&YHV[ J TJGKV5VVHIJ=1YQG.L]K
XNGQXI)©[IJGHO
7MJ EKL
[TJ]K]K@XG+MJLXVHIJ=X
[VIJE[QJN^TJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
SRJ?OZRJ [TJGKV5 VVHIJ=1YQ]K YHOJT+VJ·4JT+VJN^MJL ]K
V(N^RJLNGMJ
E1YQMJLSQFO
QXN^TJSHO=ZP=FV7E
QYJSRJ?OSQE?Q]K[J%OYHO
V?QZPSQ?OSQUH\ O YHO ]J K[JZPXVWQZYJG,SRJL XPVQ7 E[QL%OY HO
ZP[O=\ H YJX
Q
QSQZ+IJESQ[IJGOH
7MJXN^TJ,O1YRJV7[JP1Y]K[J
NV[JTQ+ FO
Q[
QE[QJVQ7 VHVYH
OH S
J QYHO Y+
J QUH[
O L. XU,O XVY
XHY]K].YHOJLZVJYHOJ
Q7 EZQL#FO
QXUPUPPYE[QLIH%¥QIJE
QYJ
Q
ZVJV7IJYHO R8IJN],OSQ R8IJN]ZHVJLVRJZHO= %OY VHIJ=E[QJVP[J STÚQ
[
QYHO
7QEI[.L ]RQ
7MJVWQEUQMJ
IJFO
QXU,O XV[TJGOYSRJZ]HO K
AâYQTQE]YWVJIJ)7MJLR(R8[JE]SRJ?OUHOÑZRJXV7IJ[
QXN^TJ
ZYJVG,EZ)7MJL#âYQO[ÉH
7HE]@?OE\QYJUSN^MJLZRJZYJVG,EZ
)7M#LJ VHV[
H =OH EZTQESQU
QYâSH=O UHEO ]SRJ?PÑZRJZYJVG,EZ)7M#LJ
SQYSRJ UIJTTJE^IJV- N]/V7SQ VHVHU
Q E?Q1YQSRJL [
Q@
[IJ^OH XTTJXV7IY J HOSHE]ZHVJLVRJMKFO
QE?Q1YQSV5YHOZRJUIJTTJ
E^IJ2](V7SQ,1O YRJZYJG,1Ya?O[]RJLSQYVWQYHO %OYE?Q1YQ
G.L]K[J
E]OZv
Q?OZQ@ %OE?Q1YQ[
QESIQTQ)7MJLXNGQ
EI
QVWQV7
### ]MJVHO4J&Y(S,OHO4J
%OFQSQV7QFO
Q%OOYHOJ[HOMJE?Q1YQG.LSRJLVP
MJESIQ
VPZV
XN]MJ EIQYJ\]J \]JV,N^RJLT+YJGWYJVWQ ]KMJ]K[J F(T(
EIQYJU,O
QTO[HOMJSRJX\H %OE?Q1YQE[QJVPG.LESQ[
QE[QJVWQYHO
S(
ZH Y*Q[+MJXY
QN^MJLVE
SQ
ES[.X L [+YJVRJSRJLX]HOMJVWQY
VPZVN^TJSRJ#VRJSRJ[Y O=H EIQYJN^RJL N^TJSRJ?O [HN][J]HMO J NGQ
IJ
GYJG.Z]7 K[JXGWH/9ESQ]RQ
7MJVWQXEI)7MLJ EIQYJN^RJX L VWQXN]QYHO
E^QJ\O[J)HOMJ^+J
7H]K[JFQSQ
]J IJ]JYZRJXZ+IJYWJN]IJ=]K
[J
SRJZ)OH M7 LJ %O K?QSYJ[VJ)7TEJ ]KMJEYWQJ [RJ[GL, ]L. K2](
SRJXE[QX[+MJ]QIHO4JS,OHO4JE]E]KYJZQ]K[JE\
QK
UHO[.LE\
J&Y(K&Y(ZVJ
VQIUHO[.L&Y(ESQQ3J
)7MJLEIQYJU,O
>MJ H]×IQ
JZHO= HO4JS,OHO4JN^TJ]K[JE\
QKHO4JYHOE[QL
EKYJ[QZ7EF
?HII ESESQ O[JEZWQLESQQ3J
?O V?QI HO4JMJVWQY
VZHO)7HVJLGWSRJL SEFQ)7MJL EGE[[J]K[J
IJENVXQN^MJL E\
QKY S(
HZY*Q# NVIJVQ# \HOMJ# EZQ)7MJL
YEV«Q(Q )HOMJM,VWQV7Q \+IJYQ]K[J V?QIYE[QL [H%YJ)7MJL
XHVJI(GWMJVWQ V+IJHOZ(Q)7MJL YHO
(QV7Q \+IJYQ2]( EIQYJU,O>MJY
W]IJ)HOMJM,V7Q \+IJYQ]K[J ]\(XEIX\QX
]W,9)7,9],OY \PNGQ
V7[JSQ^+J]K E
7¡HOT+.X[HOMJ VZHOYJ[.L V?QI)7MJL >MJ%OFQSQYHO
SV]HOMJMJ)HOMJM,VWQY ZYJG,2]( X]P]HOMJ )HOMJM,VWQYE[QL E
7¡HOZHOYJ[.L
E\
QKYHO ZYJG,[QE[+9=
]K[J
### E\
QK%O
E\
QKY E
7 VP ZXYWU,O %OO F QSQN^TJ 2]( E[QMJ] HOM J
%OO FQSQZH=Z
O RJEGEEZL
7H]K[JXH)H V7S(
Z H Y*QYHO E\
QK
%OO F
QSQF(TS ( O,
QTOVQ7 E
QYJZQG.2L ](NVIJVQN]RJYEOH [QL
QTOEX(VQ7
E
QYJ[J\HMO J)HMO MJ Y , OH
QTOI=. YEV«Q(QYHO
QTO[VO=H 7QE
QYJ2](
EZQ)HOMJM,YHOE[QL (\YJ EIQYJYWEYQMJEIQYJYW]KZHVJLVJ
E\
QK%OE SIQYHO ]HY[JSO, ],X O N^TJE]KMJTRJ\Q]K[J
]HY[JYNGMJE[QMJZHO=XH]ÀKJ
]K[JKY]HY[JE[QJYHOE][YJ
XY
Q[MJ[.L E
73(XGK[OIJY E]
+YJ
7RJVWQYHO E[QMJ[.\RJL2](
SHVJ URJG.[
L QXE1YQMJN]/EGE[Q]KE[QMJS,O E[QMJ]HY[JSO, ],
O
YE[QLHIRJ#SO[ÉIJ)7MJLXFHVQN^TJ]K[J
HIRJYE[QL
?IJS,'QE[QJVWQYWM1LJ YZ , Y
OH IJ Q
IJTRJYVJ]K].
S,'QX[+YJFOO
Q
7MJ]R[JE[QJVP[.LSHYQ]OJE[+]KMJ]K[JHIRJJ
]R[J[TJGOT(X[+YJXFJE1YQMJLâSHO=]R[J
SRJYHO
7MJZMJSRJL
XE1YQMJ
MJYHZ O RJE^QJN]]K[J3]VQ[TJGS O QE^QJN]E]]KVJVHO [+MJ
S,O ZV7Q
?IJE[QJVWQG
(VS+Q
ZH=O ]R[J]K[JX.(S,O Z?QK[+MJ
YQZ]K].(IH RJ]R[J
[.LXE1YQMJX
MJYVHO [+MJ V7QTHY O ]J WH/\QSRJL
T]KGMJVWQYHO G
(S+Q
?IJVWQIMJEGWVZ H =OH ]WYTJ ( NGMJV7YQY+[ J QU(
IJ
N^TJ]K[J
SO[ÉIJYE[QL]HY[JS,O],OV7QXYWJIJU,O)7MJLXE
X]KU,O
N^TJ]K[J SO[ÉIJYHO FO
QE?Q IHYJMK
]J XN^TJ G+.NGQ\Q]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
IHYJVWQV7QEIQYJU,ON^TJ[.L GOYIHYJYHO E\
QK([HO=X)7TJSYJU,O
N^TJ]K[JSRJ\.V7QZPXVWQSH[.LV])7MJL>Q[YEG>Q[JE[QJVWQ
]KMJ]K[JV]V7QFEYQMJ
QR8IJSRJL K\QVWQ]KMJ2](>Q[YV7Q
Y$EYWQJ ]KMJ]K[J)7TVJ W/H Z,OX[+YJIH]K[J]ON, ]MJVWQ)7MJL
7MJZMJ
EU+E)+GWYJ]KMJEI[J>Q[JIH]K[J],ON]MJVWQYNVIJVQ%OFQSQVWQ
.9
FYHO EN]QMJZ. N]/N]MJE]]K[J
XFHVQYE[QLTH[)J 7MLJ ¡O]J]OMH J E
Q%O ×I]K].XZ+IJ IYJI.
GYJG.[.LX[+YJ X\PN]/ EZLZQSPVWQ)7MJLSQ X]JT]J]K[J E
73(
]HY[J)7TJ],O\YJZRJE)7QMJV7 XY
Q[MJ[QESGWQ]K[J
]HY[JE[QJS,O ],Z O O, YHO ]K:HFQSQ)7MLJ T(
MJ\Q]K[JX<Y\Q
(YQUHO[.L X^+MJLYWVJVWQXN]MJ\]JUMJLX^+MY JL WVJVWQZRJ]K:HFQSQ)7MJL
T(
MJJ\Q2]( E\
QK)HOMJM,S,O TQE]VWQN^MJLZRJ E
SQN]/TO1Y[Q
YWVJE[+
QGW(
7H]K[J SRJ\.V7 XVWQXN]QYHO X\PSN^MJL ]K:HV7
X*ZH]JFQSQN]IJUHO\Q]K[J%OTQE]
.9]VQ4XZ+IJYWJEN]Q2](
TH[J MJTQ^+J IJ]JZRJ T,OZMJZ7]K[J SHO=ESQJZRJ E
79V7Q
EN]QG.LSRJLX[HOMJNVIJVQ%OFQSQ[HO=TH[J)7Z,OV7Q2MH2](T+.MJ[QYE[QL
O [ H ENVQYJ ]H Y [J N ^TJ [ . L SO [ É I J ] K]. ]\VN^TJ [ . L H I RJ Y
S,'Q3]EN^TJ2](XFHVQYE[QLIQZRJ
IJVZ+JIYJI.Z+IJ]K[J
XSYJ)7TU J JEYWQEJ YWQX J
+VJ Q7 SQVIJ%O F QSQMJVWQ?QVHVH
YHO Y+UJ RJY]JSRJL FQSQ@SHX]J^+J
QXENGG,VWQYHOSHIQZRJ2](
N^TJEI]K2]( (ZHO SHEXQMJZRJFOIJE[QJ&Y(VWQYVHVHFQSQN^MJL E
SQ
T(
MJ[.L [
QTQVWQYHO EZLZQSMJP[QZRJ
7H]K[JYHOJYWMLJS(Z
S+IJSMJR8IJN][.L FOIJE[QJ&Y()7MJL U
QVHFVWQ\,V7ZRJ IQPV7[JSQ
1Y
[.LXN]MJTQE])7MJL>Q[JSFMJV7ZRJSH
7HV7[JSQ1Y
[JXSYJ
X
+J
ZQSRJ)7MJLXV5 VHVH
.9FX[H[J#]TÚ/]ÀIJ)7MJL XIQK[JE[+YHO
7YJ)+JUYJS+JE]EI[.LXE1YQMJ[
QS,O]KYHOZRJ]HOVHO2](SHIQ
ZRJZQ1Y]K[J [
QS,O]KYE[QL E
7F EIQYJF
7H[JUHO[.L
MJTQNGMJ#Y,YV
)7MJL IH%¥QIJ[]O=H K].]O/¢H ZJ[TJEQYJYSRJ[
QS,O]K
YHOVRJV5)7Z,OS+MJ[JUHO[QYE[QLSPVRJV5E]KYJE
QYJSZ.UHO[.L
SP=
.9[
QXUMJLE]VP[RJVJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
ZPSHO=V?O[JXNGQS[ÉKXN^TJMJTQNGMJUHO[.LE
79FE?QMJV7
EIQYJFSTJYHO YPEN]QMJ
[.LN^TJT3JYOH S,S
QZHO= EG[+MJ[JS,S
Q
YHOVZ8.VES+YWMZ J RJEI1Y
VRJL][JNGQZRJN^TJT3J&Y(
JZ=HO %OFQSQ
E\
QK([HO=Y ZYJG,,O1YRJ\Q]K[J S[ÉK[HO= YWMJZRJT
Q
F,O
7H]K[JZP=F,OYE[QLZPX[+YJ%?HO<QIE]KLZP=F,OEXQYJV7QX]KJ
EZF,OUHO[.L [H
TÈQIJ# XSP
YJ# 2]H[ÉQI.= M
. F,OEZGO
7H[J ZP=F,O
X\YJV7QI[JN]RJENGQYJ\]JJENGQYJFO
, )7MLJ N%?QF,O
E]KMJX\YJ
F,OF,O
7H[J
Y,YV
.9XH]QÀ JYXZO]J]K].SMJTOY H J]WH/SRJLS()7,SQSMJ
H[JSHVJ
ZHVLJVRJ UHOSRJLSEFQYHON][.L XYWH/N^TJ
IJXE1YQMJ
7HSRJ
UH[O L. Y,[
QYHO EFOWXQN^MJL NVIJVQ%OF QSQYIQZRJ2]( ]KE
7E
7
FYN]/GS L. V5YOSZ
OH J XYOSZHO U
J [
OH L. EYQMJUHO ZO]GJ S
L. V5YEIQYJEIQYJ
FVWQ\HZHOYJ]KXYWH/E][J[TJT,O[TJEQYJESQ]O¢H/ZJ@FV7Q
EYQMJ@UHO@#VEYQMJVUHO
7H@UH[ O L. FXYW/H E]YN]/N]/SV5Y,E[+
E1YQMJL]K].GOVWYJEV7QYJN]/SV5I.=X[H[JY,[HO=YE]KMJT]J2](XIQK[J
EYQMJYWH/ UHOYWH/YHO T(V,]KZHVJLVJ SRJY,)7MJL Y,@ XYWH/UYJY
E
7QMJV
[.L IHQVN^TJT3J]K].SPY]. FSTJV7QFJZHO YOSHOZJT,
2](
FJ XUMJL
VJUHO[QU,ON^[J]K[J]O¢H/ZJ )7TJ3(SHOH= V?O[J XVWQ
X[P[Y+ YOSHOZJN]/1Y
MJ EIQMJFV7QZRJN]IJZRJ U,OURJ1YVJZHO=
%OFQSQMJYIQZRJZYJG,2](N^TJ[JEIQYJ\]JFJ)7TJFFJ
)7TJ N]IJ1Y,/1YU,O1YVZ.UHO[QYE[QL SP[HO= X[PN]/[.= YOSHOZJ
.9X[HOMJ
X[QX
RJXES+E]VP[RJVJY6[[ J VJVMJVGWMJ SP?QFVWQT+Q
YWMJZRJ
MJY]JYV«QVWQT+QN^[JSIJ
E]3(VRJUHO[QZRJ,OV7QNGMJ
V
7H]KFPVJ·4J^HOZJ·4J
2](IH%¥QIJVMJESSV5E[QLS,S
QV7VZ+[J
ESFPZHO= IQZRJ ZYJG,\Q
]KZHVJLVJ
IH%¥QIJ
.9 XH]ÀKJY AV(G+YJ2MHVJNGMJa ZHO= UHO[J XH]ÀKJYHO
XSHTH[J @ U,OGVJ Y6[J[VJMJNGMJ
ZOH= ^+MJLUHO
VJ AFQSQN]IJ
IJ
VN^TJ)HOMJEN]QVN])HOMJ[.LaSRJIH%¥QIJYHOXVWH/VWH/
7MJZMJ^+MJLUHO\Q]K[J
SQVIJ %OFQSQ XVWQTO ZYJG,[Q[QYE[QL AUMJ
.OYXE]KMJV7
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
Z+[JENVQYJNGMJa[
Q]K].E\
QK([TJEQYJX[+YJK?QS,S
Q
[RJ?PESQGWQ
?[JV7 Y6[JZ[ + NJ GMJN^TJ2](KX)©VH
RJV7IJGWYJ]K].
SQVIJNVIJVQ%OFQSQVWQX[+YJE[QLIH%¥QIJUHO[.LEK?Q
Y
E
79FEIQYJFI.= Y, Y,@XYWH/[HO=\YJXE[QJNVMJL]K[JSHO=ESQJ
IH%¥QIJE
QYJ
Q ZVJYHOE[QL %OY R8IJN]\Q]K[J IH%¥QIJE
QYJ
Q
]\VU,O )7MLJ XHYXYWUO, ZVJYE[QLV¢M
J T7 J]KUHO[L. ZVJ]K].(ZVJYHO
(E?QEN]QGWYJ[TJEI
Q)7TJEI
QV7QX\PE^QJN]V7Q]KV¢MJ
7T]J KYE[QL
XPXNVMJV7IJYIJNGMJSVQH`H
X1Y,EYQMJVWQYHO 1Y,TRJNGMJSVQSY*]À
V7IJYIJ EYQMJV+IJESQTYQYHOSQEN]QUHONGMJSVQKTQ
V7IJYIJÑXN]TJYMJESQXZO]JYHOSQN]/ZO]JNGMJSVQYV)©
V7IJYIJESQXSYJEV+NGMJSVQXQ>(
V7IJYIJT+Q&YH/TQXQ\O[JNGMJSVQKV
V7IJYIJESQEXQYJEVLV- S[HXNV.
7HNGMJSVQS[H
V7IJYIJT+Q[RJ1YRJESQSVQH
7HEINGMJSVQSVQH
]\VV¢MJ)7TJ]KYHO]RQV¢MJEG[J#]RQI.=UHOMJ[JO[H
V¢MJS,O]KYE[QL S(ZV¢MJN^TJ[J#XYWMJL)7MJL UHOMJ[J EIQYJU,O
V¢MJS,O]KYE[QL SVQHV¢MJ#SVQHI.= UHOMJ[J
##XPKVWQ
NVIJVQ)HOMJM,%OFQSQYXNGQE\
QK)HOMJM,VWQV7QZHO].XNGQ
XPVWQ)7MJL?]J[IJSV5?]JVEH XQMJR)H -HMJYWMLS J ,O[.LZY4Q
7]H K[J
N]RJY L (]K
(V7Q].Y6IJE[QJE?QEN]QG.L[X
.L [HMO JNVIJVQ%OF QSQV7Q
?H)H0XPXGWH/9 E
QE)7Q]KMJEI]K[J (\.V7Q E\
QKY T+IJ=G+QG.L[.L
V?QII.=[D)©XPZRJXI,=XSYJVYMJFP2](E[QLE
7E
7X\YJ
Y
7HGL[
. L. I[JYOH Y+VJ Y - Z
HO RJE
QE)7QSEZQYJE
QE)7QYWMS LJ O, EI[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ XVRJG,2]( EIQYJY+JV7Q E\
QK VTTJV7IJ[.L XP
XYWMJLVWQ
7HEI[J E\
QKI.= E
QE)7QEISRJL XPV7QVWQYHO
·4JXNVMJ XQIRJ[.L NVIJVQVWQYSP YHOY+JURJY]J[.L %OFQSQ
[
QTTJ [
QV7IJZHO=]. ZYJG,EI1Y]K[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
NVIJVQ%OFQSQUHO[Q[YJE[QL[TJYHOJ[RJZP)7TVJ WH/]K].
[TJ3(Y%OFQSQ#[TJ3(YNVIJVQSPXSYJ
7MJEI\HOMJ[QY[VZ+IJ
FX[+YJSQ V?O[JFP# VWYJEV7QYJFZRJ ]K[J ( +IJ[+.V-YHO
NVMJV7SQ SP=
.9 [TJSYJ )7TJFXN^TJYHO IQZRJ)HOMJ]KVJ %OFQSQ
[TJEQYJXN^TJ SPYFO
Q#[
Q#S,'QUHO[.L
[IQS,O]KYHO URJ
Y]J YHOY+JVJKIUHO[.L Z70KIJE]YVJNGMJ#S(ZUHO[.L XYWMJLS(Z
ETQMJL\HVJNGMJI.= FQIQUHO[.L [
Q¡-V7[JNGMJ N]/VJ KE[+XQZ,O?Q
[VZ+ I J F X[+ Y J I . = EIQYJ U , O IH % ¥ Q IJ E
QYJ
Q E
QYJ E 1YQMJ
XE\QYJX],L N^TJET
IJ
RJSIJ[.LXZO]JE[+N^TJ]K[J
NVIJVQ[TJEQYJXN^TJSPY
VWYJEV7QYJYHO 1YRJL2](¡OYTHO#
FOVTHO#XQYQSTOH[.LI[JVWH/T,OYHOI[JEYQMJI[JNV[JVWQ]KE
Q2](]PE>QJ
]SVJ EV7QJH>ªQ X[[JE[+YHOZRJ ,O1YRJXQ\QVJ V]PE>QJ
MJ
OYE]V7QE1YQYJ[QYHO
TRJTHVJGWVJSQI.=[IJGHO1S>QE[+YHO
GWMJ
ZHZ=O RJSPYEZQY(]RQI.= V«
( X[[JE[+EIQYJZHY O 3J ( VJ#E
7\,O E[+
X[HOMJZHOYJZO]JVJ
2](E[QLXH¢
]J#E%MJ1[QYHOZRJ,1O YRJ
[[J[J
NVIJVQ[HO=
.9 I[JVWH/T,OY XZ+IJXVWH/VWQ E\+N]Q]K[J [GWH/9
I[JVWQY%OFQSQE[+].#[GWH/9YE[QL ?H)0#[GWH/9ZRJ[HOMJ
MJN^TJ
E[+]KSRJ[IJGOH
7MJ I[JE[+YOH S,O VW/H S,O TQG+1. YRJ)L MOH J]K[J
I[JF#,O
N%?QF,OV7 S1YQVMJ)7MJL[Y+ I[JEKVWQUHO[.L %OFQSQI[JVWQ
?H)0I[JVWQ)7MJL
âYV«QV7 I[JVWQ I[JTHVJVWQ
# SRJ\.V7Q
%OFQSQZRJ ]K[J# N]RJ[+MJN^TJ [HOMJ
MJSQ I[JVWQZRJ ]KMJ
]K[J
### I[JN%?QVWQ
N%?QF,OY[TJGO)7MJL[TJGOX\YJEXQYJUMJLZWYJ
7H[J
N%?QEXQYJV7QI[JF,O\]JXT(XT3J)7MJL
7H]K[JI[JEKE[+\.Y
NVIJVQXVWQX[+YJXE
]K[.L XGWH/9YHOXVRJ)M7 LJ SP=ZO]JMIJXVW/H XTQYHO
SH
7H
IJ EN]QN]]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
VQ
JI[J UHO[ .L I[J UHO X\YJV7Q EN]QN]G.L]K2]( EIQYJZRJ
SP=XE1YQMJ \]JGK\]JGK EN]Q
3(V7Q]K SPYE[QL I[JN]RJ \]JV7Q
XNVMJLUO, F,Y
O OH XTHO
[.LI[JVMJ]K].NVIJVQ%OF QSQ
.9TH[JVQ7 SRJI[JVMJ
YHOUHOYWH/E][.LI[JUHOXN^TJNVMJEI]K[J
S1YQVMJSYÞ
YE[QLO[HI[JF,OYHOXTHO
[.LI[JVMJ&Y( ]K].
SEFQEYQMJ[.LI[JVMJ]KSP=V7Q
\Q\HVJVQ[ZH)7MJL%HSOYQXEYWQJ
HS1Y,/I[JSQUHO[.L []RJLVWQ
7H]K[J
GMJ ]K
(E?QEN]Q]+. )7TJ&YHVJV7Q S1YQVMJXE1YQMJ XE[QJ
N]RJTL OE, XQMJEN]QG.2L ](]K2](\]JV2, ]( XIRJMJN^RJTL Y
+ EJ N]QGWM]J KES[J
S1YQVMJYHO?H)0¡HO
QXPV7QXHD)QZHO=EG]K[J%OTQE]\.VQ7 ZRJ
XHD)QUHO[QS1YQVMJ
.9XVRJY+.[TJGO]K].%OTQE]XE[QJVWQVWQV7Q
E^QJN]\Q[QYE[QL%OSQSIQ?QF(T(%O]
HIH%¥QIJN]/2](EIQYJ
)7TJ [RJ[,LVJSQSIQ
.9O[H]HOMJ)7TJ YHOE[QL XHD)Q
S1YQETQMJVL JSRJXGKV7QS1YQVMJYVEYQMJSP]JEYQMJSPYJ
ZHVJLVJGO SQSIQSYÞ
Q>J GO]KEIQYJ[TJGO NVIJVQXVWQ
,O1YRJ[QYS1YQVMJYS&Y*IJGWHIJV7QZP=N]RJUMJ2](S,O
YJEZ
YJ
EI[J S&Y*IJY SS*Y¡HOYJTYQ SY*
)©HV7ZQ[J# VHIJ
QS(V7
VH×
QS(YHO YPEN]QMJGWHIJYHO EG[Q]KS&Y*IJYQZY)7TJT3J _2](
YJV7QT[MJ2](NVIJVQ[HO= E
SFMJUMJ)8.[.L ]+.YQZ]K]+.YQZ_2](
SHO=V?O[J
YJV7Q 2](U,O2]( EIQYJ[TJEI=Y )7TJUIJ [TJ
YJEI=
N^TJ]K[J
Q3JV70VQ[ZHYSP=U
QS1YQVMJETZ8[J[.LXGKZP=N]RJ
ZQ2]( VMJEYQMJ VMJNV[JVWQYHO S1YQT,
Q [Q[ÔSQ I[JN]RJYHO
]MJLEUQMJ]K[J ZP=N]RJZQ[Q )7TJ&YHVJ
7H]K2]( H×1Y,/I[JSQYE[QL
EUQYJZ]O EJ
FYJY]KNVIJVQEK?Q
%HSY O QYSPX = VRJYZQ[Q]K
T[OV?Q
Q>J YE[QL YV«QL E\QMJLEZEI
QV7QETQMJLEI1Y[.L
YV«QETQMJLI[JVMJ&Y(EZ]KN^TJ]K[JXSH[
QN]RJLT,O[.LNVIJVQ%O
FQSQVWQZT3JZ[HOMJZN]RJLEI=V7QS(ZEUQYJ[RJOT¡HOYJE
7QMJ1Y]K
[J FQE1YQMJLZ.UHOE[QL ZN]RJLEI=[HOMJ I[JVMJ&Y(VWQY ZP=N]RJ
E?QEN]QT3JYG
Q>JGO)T7 J!EYQ>QGO!SQSIQGO)7TJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
UMJ1YRJ[ L JEYQMJV-N]/SIP =. VEYQMJV-N]/SVP WQYHO V7[S
J Q2]( [Q[ÔSQ
I[JVWQ\,S[MJ]HO=1Y
[J[Q[ÔSQI[JVWQYZP[HO=YOSHOZJ]+QVWQ
SRJUZ HO 5MJ VJSQ1Y2](YOSZ HO JEYQMJV-VN]/1YZ5MEJ [QLTH[JVJV1YRJ
SQ1YFPZHO= UHO]K[J
¡-]K
### ?H)0I[JVWQ
[TJE1YQMJV?O[J[TJE1YQMJE1YQMJE1YQMJL NVIJVQ%OF QSQVWQ
.9)7Z,OSQV7Q?H)0I[JEKXENVQYJXNVQYHIJ]JEI]K[J]O,FO
Q
ET[(VWQV7Q]H×)HO #SP
H #]
QVH×SY*Y¡HY O ]J K
QVH×K
#V?Q]H).Í
)7MLJ N%?Q¡O]J\OVWQE[+9)HOMJ]K[JSRJI[JVWQXE1YQMJYHOGMJ)T7 J&YHVJ
Y6IJE[QJE?QEN]QT3JYSP
×[(I[JSV()7MX LJ [PXSMJX L [MJL E^QJN]G.L2](
N^TJ ]K[J EIQYJU , O E^QJ N ]G. L[ . L SP
×[( I[JS V( XE1YQMJ YH O
Y6IJE[QJ
.9 GO E?QEN]QGWYJV7Q \RJLS+MJ EN]Q1YQ
IJN^TJZHO= GMJ
SP=XE1YQMJEN]QG.L2](XGWH/9N]IJ\]J
IJ
7H]K[J
?H)0¡HO
Q,1O YRJGWYJX
SP
×[(YSQSV(\+IJYQEXQMJ
T(]+QN^TJEXQMJETQMJLE
7QYJ[.LI[J]KN%?QF,OV7N^TJ2](]RQ)7MJLXE?Q
XEN]QX[[JYHOZRJETQMJL[.LI[JSV(N^TJ]K[JSS*Y¡HOYJFQSQ
TYQI.=EIQ
(XY
QYHO[(\M+ J[QZRJSP].N^TJ2](H>ªQSH]À,X[[J
VWH/T,OYHOZRJGW(ENVQYJSPN^TJ]K[JSHEO= SQJZRJNVIJVQVWQX[+YJE[QL
SRJI[JSV(Y GWTJSP[HO=
.9 EXQMJS+JETQMJLE
7QYJSPZRJ N^TJ]K[J
XGWTIJ QYWSP SOV=H ?O[J VHVH GWTEJ ISPYEV[ÉQV[ON=, ]IJSP XE[QJVWQVWQ?Q
I[JYE[QJI[J\HIJ
YHO GW3JY]J2](VHVY H HOE^VETQMJLE
7QYJ]KETE1YQMJ
SP
×[(YHO ]PE>QJ]S1Y[J
### âENVV7I[JVWQ
âYV«QENVV7QEI1Y[.LI[JVWQYTQ
MJN]/XVWH/G+.NGQ
IJVZ+J
]KFP(\.YXGWH/9X\PSN^MJLXETQMJLI[JVWQXE1YQMJ%OTQE]VWQV7Q
]K
7H]K[JSHO=ESQJZRJN]RJ[+MJN^TJ I[JVWQZRJ
7H]K[JSP[HO=Y
HOQ)HOMJM,V7 A^(a)7MJLUMJUMJ[P]K[JSRJI[JE[+YE[QL
YV« Q EZQYV7 Q
7H
7 H S V5 SYJ
7 H S YJV .L V WQ ZP E [+#
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
EIXHVJE[+#STJ]MJ#E[QE[QMJ#]MJZJYHOTHO[.LETQMJL[.LSVQEI[J
EYQMJVWQ STJ]MJETQMJL[.L ¡OYTHO I[JYE[QL NVIJVQ[HO=)7MJL ]HOVHO
MJ)7(],O
[J
VMJI[JVWQSRJ\V. Q7 SYÞ
S1YQVMJ
YZ+Z . 5MJ
XQZ,O?Q [HOMJ
MJSQ I[JE[+]K]. SP[HO=YHO VE\V.LNVMJL ZO]JZ5MJ
OYE][[J]K[JSRJI[JVWQI[JN^TJZQ
[.L >Q[JZVJE[+YZRJ
TH[JZ-]J
7Q^+J >Q[JZVJE[+]K XQZ,OI(]K?Q XESUHOI.= ES
SP
GWRJ]K].XQZ,OV7QZRJYHOJ]HOMJI[JXVRJ
7H]K[JKE]V.L SP[HO=YHO
I[JXN^TJT[MJXSHXV7[JN]/YHOY+J[QFJSPFJKZ.#FJXGWHIJ
XGKYZ.#FJZHO FJZHO N^TJ[QZ.UHO[QE[QLVSH
H
7 ]KFPXESTH[J
EZLZQ)HOMJ
IJ YHO¡-]K
]J E TQMJ L I [J
+ Q ETQML J I [J V WQ XE1YQMJ ZRJ
¡HO
Q],ON]MJVWQXN^TJNVIJVQTQE]V7QXVWQXN]Q
7H]K[JSP[X O=H E1YQMJ
EN]QT
Q],ON]MJ)7MJLYN][.L>Q[JE[+XVWQ&Y(]K].XGWH/9YHO>Q[JZVJ^+.92](
[/ZO]J \Q]K[J SRJI[J VWQYHOZRJ SMJL
Q SMJL
Q XGKV7Q
XSHXV7[JN]/ ]PE>QJE]
IJ ZHO]K[J
XTH V J SP [ H O = Y E[QL XESUH O )7 M J L XTH V J ES
ESSPVWQY N^TJZQ[.L I[JE[+]K SP[HO= I[JFY G4 YEZ]K].
XVWQU,O GO)T7
J YJSRJXE[QX[+MJV7QVHVH FE?QMJYVHSQTOX[+YJ
XRQXS,O \IJSVQ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
VHO ZMJVRJaa(G,GP WYVJ W/H [¡O[TJ YQ],VO WQV7QZRJE[+9
]K[JAAZ-MH J &Y(
EZ7EXQYJ#E[QMJ&Y(^KEXQYJaaXH]ÀQJYVHIJ VSRJEQYJWQ\YJ
XNV.IHVJL
VRJZHO= UHOZHO[JEI=T3JZO]JMIJXENVQYJXNVQXVWH/SV(VWQ
ZYJ\.V7Q
7HEI]K[J EYWZYJV7Q VHSQTO T(]+QE
V7Q XVWH/SV(
XE
]KE1YQMJN]ZWYJ]K
# ZPV-XSHOMJXIJ
XEIQYJ[HOMJSQ TQE
SP E[QJE[QJVWQVWQY NVIJVQVWQYHO
E]KLE]KL EI E]KLE]KLTQ XE]WQJX]K &YH/YJSPVWQXN^TJ E
\Q]K[J
SHO=E]V.L SP[HO= Y NVIJVQVWQV7Q TH[JXZHOVYW EIQ G,TQ
[Q V
7HJFP#
SP[=HO ZPVW/H \.YZPE[+VQ7 E[QLTH[J2MHVJEUE[+[TJ][ ,O TJ]MJ&Y(ESQYJ2](
ESQY 2MHVJEXQMJ ZO]JEI1Y
[JUHO[Q \RJLVE
1Y]KFP X.(
]OH/¢ ZVJ WQYNVIJVQVWQZJ\. Q\.VQ7 #NVTJ\V. 7QGYJGYJG.G. ]MJ]MJ]VJ]VJ
ZO]J1YYHOM1J Y],OYHOEVLEI]K[JSRJZHOXZO]JZO]JEIGWHIVJ 7QXZO]JXN]MJ
XNGQFQYHOV7XQ¡,OTHOYJ
EXQMJXGWHIJVE])HOMJ1Y
7QFPKE1YQMJLZRJ
SP[HO=E[+ TH[JZYJ X]VJEN^^HO= XG+MJLXGKEZ
ZHOYJ[QI.= XT+VJYOIJ
E]WQJZHOYJ1Y[Q]K
QTO[+MJX\HE^WQJEN^E
ZO]J],OY¡HO¡OHEZ]K].
ZP&YH/YJ XVWQU,OYE[QL ]+. >Q[JTMJ
# XY)7MJL ([ [(V-[JS(UHO[.L
XGKZRJ
7H#EZQMJYTQZRJZO]J[[J1Y[JNVMJ#)+QXEN]2]H/MJ]+.I.=
ZYJ E7= ]+. YHO ZRJ VWQESQXQN^MJL ZN]RJ L
YJV 7Q YWMJ]EZL
7H [. L
]+.SFMJVWQ)7MJL [+.2]( ZO]JLEZL
7H[J GO EN]QSRJL E]WQJT
Q
8MJT
Q
]+.SFMJY ENGQYJES+9 ]+MJLZMJ
QS(V7Q]. ZO]J)HOMJ]K[J SRJZHO
ZPV-IJYWMJ XEIX\QY EG[JSTJE
QYJE[QL EN]QMJZ.ZQ
[Q
X\PEN]QT
QVZHO]KFP2VH/9N]V7Q¡O]J
7MJ¡,O#E[Q
+QV7QXGV.LN]SRJL¡O]J
7MJ#
SRJLXN]MJ EFQZ,O# F[JTY[J EFQ# EFQZ(EFQT[.L XGWHIJS,OT
Q
IRJX^,O^,ONVIJVQN]RJ [TJZ8QV7QN]IJ=]+QEI]K2](
# NVIJVQVHSQTO
X\YJV7QE^QJN]G.L[.LYWJN]IJ=ESQZP=XSHOMJXIJ\.V7QNVIJVQ
%OFQSQ[TJEQYJE]KYJ^Q+ &Y( N]MJ
QN^TJ2](SP)M7 LJ %?H[
O P[L. EIQYJ\]J
XIJXHOMJMJ [RJ
7HEIN]IJ]K[JSP=
.9VHSQTO]K].
EKYJ[QZ7EF
%OXU,OXVYHO ZHOYJIQ[Q [TJE1YQMJ IRJ]RQ V^+,92^H/[Q
[TJE1YQMJXN]MJ][JIJYWMJXEIX\QE1YQMJLNVIJVQLZP=F?QEN^QMJL
EN^QMJ[ L IJ[IJV
7]H KFPXNGQ%OFQSQ)HMO MJ ,VWQZRJSRJX[HMO J ]K].
ZPE[+ ZYJG,[.L T,GWHIJT,R8IJE[+ [IJ^HOE[+YZRJ XEIQYJ[HOMJ)7MJL
Y+.N]Q]K[J ¡O]J[/YHO T+.ZVJ[]JVYJNGMJ\YJ XYWMS JL (Z N]RJL V-Y
- HO
E
79[IJ [MJ]K[J E
QMJL
.[MJ[HVJV-YHO TH[ J[HOMJVYW ZHOFVN]RJL
N^TJEI[Q\YJ [IJ^HO\Q ]K[J XYWMJLS(Z)7MJL EZQYO[É
Q [
Q
N]RJLV-YHO ·4J]RQT+VJXQ \YJ )7TJSYJ ZHOZQ]K[J N]RJSPVWQ
FYXEIQYJV7QEZQYJXUMJLVVWQVE\+N]Q]KFPXEIQYJ[HOMJY
SP[Z O=H [HO IJ[PZPE[+)7MJL 73JZOY
H
J MJSP[O=H ZHOX]JGWYJE[+YIRJ]K[J
2](E[QL SP[HO= ZHO[QE[+
X[+YJSQ]KMJVJSRJ\V. 7Q].\HOMJ1Y#TQ1Y#XH]J1YVWQESQXQN^MJL
1YVJN]MJE]V7Q]K].[GWH/9E[QLZRJVHFVWQ)7MJLX
+JE
QYJSV(]WH/VWQ
X[+YJXGIJ[TJGIJ)7TJGIJYIJ=2](XH]JGIJ^+.9VJ[[J)HOMJSVP WQYXH]J
T
QYO[MJ\RJ\ L QVJXHVVJ )7MLJ [+\ . Q[.L V(^HGO IJZRJ]KVJEI=GMJV7Q
XHVJ[,GKE[+N]0[MJE]KYJE[+^+MJL\QVJVHO [+MJE[QL^+MJLV\QFPE]KL
XQZ,O NG,/1YRJLE[QL KY X[PEI X[PTQ F,OF].# YHOJ]HOMJ S(NGQ
Z+[JZ]JT+QEI\HOMJG+MJL
JZHO=IRJIRJV7V
7H]KFP
IJYOIJ# V)©EZ)7MJL EVQJZ2VH/MJZHO 2VH/9&Y(VWQV7QE[QL 3E
Q]],O
ZPEIXHVJE[+[TJ\]J[HOYJXHVJE[+XVWQ&Y(
7H]K[J
+Q\.YSTJSQ
XHV]J N. ^TJN^TJKXHVJ].N^TJN^TJSHVO= ?O[J2VH/9&Y( Y[TJ\]JX[ O [J HOYJ].N^TJN^TJ
VWQESQXQN^MJL VHSQTO [TJTOZ,O?QS?>Q[N^TJ2](X[PEI\HOMJZWYJ
7H[Q]. XE[+9VWQ]K[J
NVIJVQE[+X[+YJ VZO]J
ZHO= [QNVTJ[QE[+ VWQ[J#EI
[.L
][JIJYWMJXIJXHOMJYZRJ[MJ1Y]J[J(E[QLVHSQTO\.V7QTH[J
E^QYJ N]IJSPE[+ E]KZHVJLVJZHO= XEIQYJ[HOMJSQ XE[QJVWQVWQY
\MJNVMJ^+J
7H]K[JKE[QLN^TJGWMJZRJN^TJ]KZHVJLVJSHO=ESQJSRJZHO
E^QYJN]IJ SRJL ZY4QVWH/E[+ E]E]KYJG.]K[J
NVIJVQE[+YEXEXEUEUEI1Y[QVWQ]K[JK
SP[=OH XYWM]JL . V7I]J K[J[GW/H 9E[QLYH O S
LJ EFQ)7MLJ YH O \
J MJSZHO THMOH J GWMTJ [
H J
7HSVP WQZRJ
7]H K[JSP[Y O=H E[QLSRJZOH EI\HMO
J [QTH[J[OMH J VYWFP #
SRJVG,)HOMJFPUHO2](YHOJ]HMO JXHOXHVJG+.EYQMJG+.]KZHVJLVJSHO=ESQJZRJ
XQZ,O NG,/Z5MJE[QL X\YJV7Q EN]QSRJLX[HOMJ [TJZ,O [TRJ[RJ
XETY]JEISRJL VHSQTO],OS4QIJY[TJ)MOH JMZ , O, ]W9, EI]K[JXE\QYJ
X\Q)7TJGO N]T
Q
7H]K[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
Y6IJE[QJL VHSQTOYO[HYV«QTTJ 2](SRJX\H XHVJENG
GIJ=
7H[L.
+QEZ[TJ
+QV7QEI]K[JSP]IO EJ 1YQMJEL
QT(]+QE
XGYJXG.
E1YQMJ]L KY6IEJ [QJL VHSQTO
+QV7VHMO J GIJ= E[.L EVQJZ2V/JH M2J V/H 9YHO EN]QMJE
89
G.L
]K[JVHSQTOMJYXNV.[VJUJL)7TJEQYJEXQYJEZWQLSRJV
7H#
SRJVHSQTO X&Y(XY.XN^TJ Y6IJE[QJLXF+QY Y+]JY.]K[J XHVJ
E\QMJTO&Y(YZ,OXSTJN^TJ[.L2VH/9][JIJYWMJYHOEN]QMJZQG.L
SRJL[HOMJ
E
7YX[HOMJ]. UYJZYJ EI\HOMJ1Y[JXEN]QMJXZ. [TJGOYE[QL
XF+Q Y+JZ+IJS+Q[L.XGK SP=SV( Y6IJE[QJLXEY XF+QEI
QYHO
PZHOYJ[JSRJVHSQTOV7QZYJ
7H3(E
YGO)7TJEQYJ#UJL)7TJEQYJ
V?O[JE[QLFPXQZ,OGWTJGMJR(R+[J1Y[J
IJYOIJVQ7 Y6IJE[QJLVH[JEU+[TJEQYJ
7H]K[J)7TJVWQV1YQV(
X\HSP
J>I(
JSQ
JSV(S,O EQYJ?Q[TJVOH EXQYJVQ7 SPX = EV#
SP=)7VXTJV
X.SRJ)7VXTJV
.9GMJ]+IJXN]MJSP[HO=VHSQTO#SRJLN]MJ
X]WH/&Y(EIQYJ)7VXTJV
[TJEQYJ#EIQYJXHVJE^QJ)7TEJ QYJXQZ,O
UJL)7TJEQYJEZQYJ X[PEI1Y[J SP[HO= EIXHVJYE[QL XE[QJ
&Y(VQ]K[JY6IJE[QJL VH[EJ U+1YRJL
[QE]WQJE]WQJ
8MJ
8MJ].#FQV5VEYW
VI]J EN]Q[QV
7HFPSP=XEVYZRJ[TJGK[TJ
, Y6IJE[QJL\, TQE
2](
ZP&Y( FV7QVHSQTOI=. EI\HMO
J [QSPGWVJ ENV]L O, EN]Q]K[JSPXF+Q&Y(
YXSYJE[QMJV
7HESFPSPYVHSQTOV7QX\PSN^MJLENVVWQ
)7MJL E]WQJEV+9[J X.(XGWHIJY Y6IJE[QJY X*ZIJV7Q]K UIJ=YWMJ^YJ
73JN]
Z5MJY6IJE[QJI.=Y]JZWYJXHVJI(GWMJXSYJ
+JVOUHOV&Y(
[TJYHOJ[RJEI[JSP=V7QXHVJE\QMJSRJ SQ[TJEQYJ
7H[J
SQVHSQTOYVHMO J GIJ= ESRJL EI
QV7QYH O ]J MOH X
J VH
J [
H7 J[TJEI=E[QL
Y6IJE[QJT]JT]JTOTOSHGWMJZHO=XF+Q&Y(YHOEV[J#GMJ%WQFQZHO=SQI.=
SPV= SH QTOYOH XHVVJ Q7 X[PEGV\QSZ.E]KLSPEN^],Y O [H[ O )OH M7 LJ 3J]K[J
AAMKLF\.SP[HO=MJ¡-]JV7QV&YH/YJFPaa[.L
NVIJVQVHSQTOMJ[TJ3( GWMJ YHO TOTTO RJTRJN^TJEXQMJT(VX , QE][.L
XE1YQMJ[
QE[+
7]H K[JXENGG,XE1YQMJS,O
]JY¡HO
QXT3JXZQ#
XSHOMJXIJ)7MJL%OFQSQN^TJ]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQVWQYE
7¡HJOUIJ]K[JVWH/UYJ XT3JXUYJ
3.1 Youth
3.1.1 Birth
1 was born in a small village situated on a tributary ofthe river
Thanlwin. Ours was for a time a well-to-do Buddhist family. We were
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 79
farmers. Soon after 1 came into the world, 1 am told, the village mid-wife
cut offmy navel or umblical cord, and had it buried in a place safe enough
to be despoilt by animals such as cats and dogs. This traditional practice,
known as chet hmyok, meaning literally ‘navel—buried’ must have been
being universally observed by the Myanmar people. For, this phrase has
acquired the meaning of one’s native place a village, a town
country of one’s birth.
(Khin Zaw)
2. In front ofthis girl’s house
There are one or two clumps of hsut-thuhpu flowers.
The parrots are swarming around them.
Oh, my precious parrots, please spare them.
They are intended to adorn his ears,
When my beloved leaves novicehood.
(Htin Aung)
The most popular time for shin-byu—bwé is after the harvest.
The weather is dry. The people are in a mood to enjoy it after their long
toil in the ricefields and, above all, there is ready money for it.
Now, about the initiation ceremony in which 1 myself was a
candidate.
You may recall my being usually back at the village during the
school holidays. It was during one long summer vacation of April and
May that the four aunts of mine, who brought me up, decided to hold a
shin-byu-bwé for me and my two younger brothers. They had saved
enough money from the sale ofrice, and my grandmother was advanced
in years — she was not even seventy and she lived another fifteen or more
years as you will see later.
1 was then fourteen, but lhasten to add that, unlike those boys in
the songs, 1 did not have a girl friend. The respective ages ofmy brothers
were twelve and eight years. In the meanwhile, an uncle ofmine and his
wife had also decided to have their eldest son, an eleven year old boy,
initiated together with us. Their decision was influenced partly by eco—
nomic reasons, but chiefly by their desire to make my grandmother happy.
This however caused a rather perplexing situation. There is a prevalent
belief, at least in our part of the world, that no shin—byu-bwé should be
held with an even number of candidates. But my aunts got over it by a
stroke of ingenuity. They adopted for the occasion a village boy of thir—
96 Dr. Hla Pc
teen with the consent ofhis parents, who, need 1 say, were only too pleased
to have their son made a novice.
The date ofthe ceremony was fixed by consulting an astrologer,
who gave the time and day for it. Invitation cards were sent
out to relatives and friends living outside our village. All the household-
ers in the village were invited by word of mouth. My grandmother, be-
and respected by the villagers, talked to all those who were going
to play vital tradition, put their old heads together to make arrangements
for the lieutenants for the assignments of duties such as fetching water
from the river and the wells, gathering fuel, cooking huge pots ofrice and
the like. The women's leader consulted with members ofher inner circle
things that needed a woman's touch, for example, the culinary and
aesthetic sides of the ceremony. The middle age people, who were well
experienced in ceremonies of all kinds, took on themselves the job each
was qualified do, such as inviting the monks and attending to their
needs at and looking after and entertaining guests through
out the ceremonial period. Even people between sixty-five and seventy-
five volunteered to help in the preparation of betel boxes and trays of
cigars, cheroots and cigarettes, which are the necessary appurtenances of
every religious ceremony. This is one of those occasions on which one
can see the altruistic instincts ofthe Myanmar Buddhists at their best.
A highly decorated marquee was put up a few days before the
ceremony. Meanwhile, we, the candidates were not allowed to do any-
thing that might damage our limbs orjeorpadise our lives, such as climb-
ing trees and swimming in the river. The elders explained vaguely that
evil spirits might try to put us out of action to spoil the ceremony. They
were, 1 believe, subconsciously thinking of the incident between Mara
and the future Buddha.
The day came without any mishap. The ceremony began with
making offerings to the noble Saint, Shin Upagutta, the vanquisher of
Mara, ofwhom a brief account is appended to the description ofthe shin-
byti-bwé in hand; and also the invocation of well known local deities so
that we could be presented to them. We, clad in princely attire, in the
manner of the princes of the Myanmar court, took part in these rites.
After these preliminaries, we started our tour round the locality on horse-
back, (known in Myanmar as shin-laung hlé - deg. This again was done to
commemorate Prince Siddhattha’s leaving the city. Many other forms of
transport have also been used: motor cars, elephants and even a man
carrying the candidate on his neck. In some cases the candidates have no
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 97
other form of transport except shank’s pony (Ie poney de jumbe), their
own legs.
We went in We had a golden umbrella held
each of us, and a few men dressed like deities as our retinue, apparently
representing those who had helped Prince Siddhatthd QOt tlWtly
the palace. The was made lively by the presence of a
seemingly endless number of dancers and an orchestra led by two aboe
players and three drummers. The horses, well caprisoned and highly
trained, also joined in the festivity. They pranced, and shook and nodded
their heads to the beat of the drums. We first made for the monastery,
which was situated outside our village, and paid our respects to the abbot
and monks, and returned to the village. Here we stopped at almost every
house, and did obeisance to the Buddha’s images on the shelf in the front
In return, the householder contributed according to his means
from say, ten centimes to ten francs. We covered about one hundred out
ofthree hundred houses in the village on the first day.
The next day the procession started earlier. Some ofthe villagers
also decided to share the transport duty with the horses, chiefly to acquire
merit and partly to enjoy themselves. One of my carriers held my two
hands as 1 sat on his neck with my legs dangling on each side of it, and
waltzed around in between, leaping up and down to the beat ofthe drums.
1 suffered some discomfort, but on the whole 1 enjoyed it as much as he
did.
On the third day of the procession, we went by boats to two
neighbouring villages. At the second village, called Kyon-do, about seven
miles away from ours, we were taken round in three cars - a Ford, a
Chevrolet and an Overland, while the orchestra and dancers followed us
in an open bus. We got back about half-past three in the afternoon. To my
surprise, my cousin and 1 were kept under guard at a house while the
villagers took back my two brothers and the village boy to our house.
This gesture is known in Myanmar as shin-laung-hpwet-te, hide the novice
candidates. There they asked for ransom for our release from my aunts
and my cousin's parents, and they got 20 rupess or kyats - roughly about
20 francs today. There was an amusing sequel to this.
About twenty ofthese villagers spent a few rupees on liquor and
had it with their dinner in our house. Five of them had no stomach for
alcohol; and soon after this convivial party, they became merry and sang
and danced in the marquee until the headman arrived. He told them to go
and sleep it off and come and see him the next day. When they came
back, he ticked them off for making fools of theselves in front of other
95 Dr. Hla Pc
people, ordered them to clear all the weeds from the monastery precincts
on the day after the ceremony was over.
At 5 o’clock that evening the head shaving ritual began. My
grandmother, my father (my mother died when 1 was seven years old),
my four aunts and the parents of my and the village boy held in
pairs a square piece ofwhite cloth underneath each ofour heads to receive
the hair as it fell before each stroke ofthe razor blade. The hair of every
novice or monk candidate is regarded as sacred by the Myanmar Buddhists.
You may recall the incident in which Prince Siddhattha cut off his hair
and threw it up, and Sakka caught it and took it his celestial abode.
Then our heads were thoroughly washed in a decoction ofthe soap accacia
fruits and other ingredients. Finally we donned white robes and took our
positions in front ofthe monks, about ten in number, who were already
seated the dais in the marquee for the ceremony of ‘Requesting the
robes’. First the congregation made obeisance to the Three Ciems, and
undertook to observe the Five Precepts. Then came our turn. We recited
a formula in Pali, which we had learnt by heart before the shin—byu—bwé,
requesting the robes from the Abbot - one under, one upper and one outer
robe. He offered us the robes, all of which were in front ofhim in a row.
The village elders helped us to put on the robes, an intricate business for
the uninitiated, and we followed the monks to the monastery.
Early the next morning we, the five novices, came back to the
marquee in a procession behind the monks, for the concluding ceremony
of‘listening to the Sermon and pouring water’. All the religious offerings
have this established pattern of finality.
First, the large congregation, as on the previous evening, paid
obeisance to the Three Gems, undertook to observe the Five Precepts,
and then listened to the discourse by a celebrated monk from Mawlamyine,
specially invited to our village for the big event. His theme was on ‘ini—
tiation ceremony, with reference to that ofRahula, and the merit gained
from holding it. He illustrated with stories from some appropiate portions
ofthe Sutta. The discourse ended with the customary water pouring ritual,
the purpose of which was to invoke the Guardian Spirit of the Earth to
hear witness to the work ofmerit. It was an echo ofwhat the Buddha did
when Mara came to claim the throne. All the monks recited in unison a
set piece in Pali, the substance ofwhich is: ‘Firm in my faith in the Three
Gems, 1 make this offering that I may be free from all the present and
future miseries ofthis round of existence, and that 1 may attain Nirvana,
the cessation ofthe Wheel ofLife. May all the creatures suffering torment
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 99
in the Four States ofMisery reach the happy abodes ofthe celestial beings.
May all my relatives, friends, and all inhabiting the earth and other worlds
share the benefit ofthis work ofmerit. O Earth, and ye deities, guardians
ofthis place, bear witness to the piety ofthis offering.’ The format ofthis
formula has been changed considerabley since then.
Simultaneously with the recitation, my grandmother, as the head
ofthe family, was pouring water from ajug on to the ground. (The water
is usually poured into a basin if the ceremony is held inside a house) As
as the recitation ended she shouted three times: ‘Share this merit
with me’, to which three times the whole congregation replied: ‘Well
done’.
The initiation ceremony was Feeding on a large scale for
the last time began. The monks, the novices and the monastery boys had
their meals, at the end of which we returned the monastery, followed
by a cartload of gifts for the monks. All those who came to attend the
ceremony as well as those who came to make a success of it were fed. It
is said, perhaps in a rather exaggerated way, that no smoke could be seen
issuing from a single house in our village for four days, that is, no cooking
was done in any home.
1 must inform you at this point that my four aunts and their elder
brother, the sponsors of this shin—byte-bwé did not share the miresable
fate of the man, whose story 1 have narrated as an introduction to our
initiation ceremony !
As a climax to this deed, my grandmother provided for the en—
tertainment of the people an open air dramatic performance. A festivity
as a sign ofrejoicing at the work ofmerit was, and still is, common in all
southern Buddhist countries, Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand and
Cambodia. We, the novices, were not allowed to participate in this festivity:
it violates one of the Ten Precepts we had to observe. It was most
tantalizing to have to be contented with looking on from a distance at the
huge crowed milling round the stalls and the stage, while the music from
the orchestra seemed to be signalling us to come.
We, like the monks, had to practise austerities. We went round the
village every morning. We ate our meals only before noon. We told our
beads at least four times a day, directing our mind to the monastery, our
meal, our robes and the medicine we had in case ofillness: we conceived
the monastery as a mere shelter for refuge from the weather: the meal as
a mere sustenance to keep us alive; the robes as pieces ofcloth to cover our
body; and the medicine as a mere substance for curing our illness - and
nothing else. We observed the Ten Precepts, that is five more over and
100 Dr. Hla Pc
above the five 1 mentioned earlier, and said prayers at night,
carrying out oddjobs such as sweeping the grounds ofthe monastery and
its floors. We stayed seven days, the conventional period for novicehood.
On the eighth day of our we paid our respects to the abbot and
and left the monastery to enter what in theory is said be man—
hood. A novice can, however, leave the monastery whenever he wishes,
as can an ordained monk, who does not want to spend the rest ofhis life
in the monastery: he however seldom leaves, as a rule, until he has kept at
least one Buddhist lent, which lasts, as already stated, the three months of
the rainy
Here is an addendum the above. Some years there was
an initiation ceremony in London for the of a Myanmar Embassy
official. The ceremony was a simple affair held at the monastery in the
presence ofhis few friends. And the Buddhist abbot there dispensed with
the practice of the their rounds through the
streets of London.
3.1.4.6 Omens
(1) The vulture
On my trips form our village to Yangon or vice versa, 1 always
had to use Mawlamyine as staging post. On one such occasion I allowed
myselfthe luxury of spending two nights, instead ofthe usual one night,
in Mawlamyine before I retuned home.
As 1 scrolled along a main road , my eyes fell on a dilapidated and
deserted building. It stood singularly alone among the other well main—
tained buildings around it. I remembered seeing it some years ago as a
thriving business centre. On enquiry, my host told me a briefhistory ofit.
It was once a Chinese businessman’s house, which he rented from an
Indian saw—mills owner. About a year or so ago, he said , a vulture alighted
on its roof. The householder and the house owner, who were not truly
conversant with the Myanmar auguries and omens, did not attach any
importance to it, and treated the vulture as they treated any other bird.
The business declined. It went from bad to worse. Then two
members ofthe family died one after the other. The Chinese businessman,
in the meanwhile, heard from his Burmese friends and clients stories of
the repercussions of such an event. In the end he and his family moved
somewhere abandoning the building to its fate. Since then, he said, no
112 Dr. Hla Pc
one had dared to move into it.
This was the only instance I had ever seen with my own eyes.
There are many other similar cases which have been reported
for which 1 cannot vouch their authenticity. Since then, I have been read—
ing books Several of these works say that a vulture, 1 think
because of its ugly look and dirty habits, is an bird. But
some ofthem maintain that a house on which a vulture has alighted is not
necessarily doomed for ever. It depends the cardinal point form
which it to perch the house, and which direction it departs
and the time it perches. The deserted house 1 have spoken ofis now alive
with people who are leading d life.
(2) The monitor lizard
There is an animal which most Myanmar
together with the vulture under the heading of creatures of
ill-luck. It is regarded as aprecursor ofpoverty by many Myanmar people.
Perhaps this concept arises, repeat what has been already said,
the fact that its ashen grey colour, mwt in Myanmar, also denotes poverty
or destitution. In the Myanmar classical poetry ofthe nineteenth century,
especially in dramas and sermons, there are references to the poverty
stricken persons as hput, monitor lizards.
It is a deep rooted belief among the Myanmar people that the
entry of a monitor lizard into a house foretells poverty for its owner.
Reports and stories of such instances are many. In all my life, 1 have seen
only one such instance. It, however, proved neither one thing nor the
other.
During one Christmas vacation, 1 had an occasion to go and see
a farmer in a neighbouring village, to buy a few cows from him. 1 went
with a farm labourer on foot. Just as we were entering the village we saw
a monitor lizard running into a ramshackle hut. Its owner was a lazy
drunkard who could hardly make both ends meet. He beat the unwelcomed
visitor to death and, 1 was told later, had it for his dinner. The man was
already a destitute, and either the perching ofa vulture on his hut, or the
entering of a monitor lizard into it could not in any way make his plight
worse than what it was.
(3) The owl
While still on omens, I would like to tell you about an alleged
connection between the hooting or screeching of an owl and the subse—
quent death of a person. Many Myanmars would strongly defend their
belief that the hooting of an owl in the vicinity or within the hearing
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 113
distance of a critically ill presages his imminent death. Be it a
coincidence or otherwise, 1 had once witnessed an event which seemed
to validate their belief.
In my fourth year at the University of Yangon, 1 returned home
a few days before the Christmas holidays started. 1 received a telegram
from of my aunts saying that a relative of ours was critically ill. 1
went to see him after my arrival at the village. 1 called him ‘little
grandpa’ for the fact that he was a younger cousin of my grandmother.
1 saw his family and the village physician. My little grandpa
was about 65. He hadbeen ill for months, and he was in a critical condition.
The physician was telling his wife that yesterday was his day of concep—
tion and today was his day ofbirth - the day of the week the patient was
born. He added ominously that ifher husband could survive the midnight,
he would pull through and would the mend again.It was about 9
o’clock in the evening.We all decided sit out the crucial midnight.
About 10 o’clock or thereabout, we heard the hooting, rather the screech—
ing of an owl from a nearby tree, followed by a sustained rhythm of
screeches. Our faces fell. Sure enough, my little grandpa died before mid—
night, inspite of all the efforts the physician made to save his life.
Two brief comments may be needed to make: one is the
physician’s notion ofthe day of conception and the day ofbirth; and the
relationship between the owl’s hooting and the death ofa sick person. We
can deduce from the physician’s remark that his notion of the day of
conception and the day ofbirth is not the same as the universal idea ofthe
date of conception of a child, as diagnosed by a gynaecologist and the
date of birth as recognised by the Registrar-General of Births, Deaths
and Marriages. In treating serious cases of illness, Myanmar physicians
attach a great importance to those two days of their patients, which are
crucial factors in time ofcrisis as demonstrated in the physician’s remarks.
Many sceptical people would certainly insist that the connection
between the two phenomena - an owl’s hooting and death - as tenuous.
They will assert that this sort of things are more common in villages
where there are more owls than in towns, and that there must be cases
where an owl’s hooting in the vicinity of a patient’s house does not
invariably bring about his death. Those are sensible arguments. But this
is the traditional belief and tradition dies hard.
3.1.4.7 The astrologer
Youmayremember mytelling you about the government awarding
me a state scholarship to go to Britain for further studies in education.
114 Dr. Hla Pc
That was, as you will recall, after I had been through the process ofsitting
the competitive examination, and being interviewed by a board. It was in
the interim period between these two ordeals that I experienced a mild
surprise.
There was a fourteen—day gap between the date of the
examination and that ofthe interview. I waited in great suspense for this
final act. Days seemed to drag on too slowly for me. The day prior to the
momentous interview, 1 went to see a friend in Yangon town with a view
to whiling the time away with him. It was a Sunday. As he tried to make
conversation with me, perhaps to prevent my mind from dwelling on the
coming interview 1 was having the next day, we heard some one shouting
'Astrologer, astrologer.' My friend asked him in. He was a Moslem. He
was hawking his trade. He was asked by my friend to read my
future. 1 was sure it was for fun. The astrologer first looked at my right
palm, and asked the date of my birth and he scribbled a number of
numerical figures a piece of paper. Finally he said ‘Sahib (Master in
Hindi), you are, 1 see, going to the West’, at which point I interrupted him
with a remark, ‘Bombay, 1 suppose’. He shook his head and told me: 'No,
no, a place much futher than Macca. And, there you will meet three gen—
tlemen, much older than you, and they will be kind to you. One of them
will treat you like his son. Believe me, Sahib, you will prosper there, sir.'
He went on with his prediction.
My friend and I regarded it as a huge joke. He gave the fee the
man asked for, which was not much. But soon afterwards, when some of
the things he had said had sunk in, 1 felt mildly surprised. He couldn’t
have known that 1 had already sat an examination and was awaiting an
interview for a state scholorship to go abroad. Yet, he talked ofmy going
to a place further than Mecca. Curiously enough, all those words of his
quoted above, did come true as you will see later. Equally, many other
things he predicted were widely off the mark.
It is not in mynature to approach either an astrologer or a palmist
and ask him to read myfuture. Yet, twice in mylife, so far, it has been other
people who have delegated themselves to do these for me. The first was
the incident mentioned above. The second was in 1969, when 1 was living
in England. I received athick registered envelope from myyounger brother
in Myanmar, containing three sheets of foolscap paper of predictions on
my future. He had my horoscope and apparently feeling worried about
his long absent brother, sought the aid of a most famous astrologer in
Yangon. One prediction says that 1 would get married in 1970. 1 did.
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 115
3.1.4.5 Epidemic
The summer before 1 left for England there ws a mild form of
cholera epidemic in village. The headman sent for the Health
Inspectors from Mawlamyine. He the villagers take the greatest
care with their food and water. The frightened villagers did as they were
told, but at the same time they requested the to and recite
purittu (protective sacred texts) at the cross—roads evening. There
are seven principal paritta. The Buddha, it is said, sanctioned the recital
ofthe paritta in times ofdanger or sickness, both individual and national.
This customary practice has been observed since the days ofthe Myanmar
kings.
At the end of the ceremony, the villagers held their own
form of ritual. They beat pails and buckets and drums as a means of
any evil spirits who might have a hand in this epidemic.
Incidentally, the beating of pails and other metal containers can also be
heard at the time ofthe eclipse ofthe moon. There is a belief among the
Myanmars that this mysterious phenomenon is caused by Ruhu (the Black
Planet) trying to swallow up the moon and that such an uproarious din
would make the seizer to release its victim, or to vomit it if Rahu has
already swallowed up the moon.
3.1.5 England 1
Having paid my respects to my grandmother and uncles and
aunts, 1 made for Yangon to start myjourney to England. I said good-bye
to Myanmar, totally unaware ofthe fact that 1 would not see her again for
the next nineteen years. 1 finally left Myanmar in August 1938 to join the
Institute ofEducation, University ofLondon. But, since its term began at
the begining of September, 1 was forced by expediency to abandon the
normal way of going to England by ship. In those days the mode of
travelling to and fro from Asia to Europe was by boat; flying by aeroplane
did not come into vouge until in the 1960’s. I went by ship to Calcutta.
From there I crossed the sub-continent of India by train to Bombay,
where I caught a large passenger liner for Marseilles. Here I boarded a
night express for Calais, and thence by ferry boat to Dover to catch a
train to London where 1 arrived on the 3rd of September.
This journey, which took eighteen days by boat and by train
across the vast seas and strange countries, was a traumatic and
enlightening experience for me. lsaw Paris from my carriage window on
the morning of3rd September. I had agood look at it without fully conscious
116 Dr. Hla Pc
that in time to 1 would be having very pleasant and fruitful
association with of its scholars and students. I have been to this
beautiful place five times since 1965.
My trip to England, especially between Bombay and Marseilles
on board the large liner, was abit ofan ordeal. Apart from the sea sickness,
there was the problem ofeating meals at the table in the dining saloon.
1 was then a vegetarian and a teetotaller. The transformation from a
meat eater to a vegetarian was a gradual process. It started when I was at
school in Mawlamyine. On the last evening ofmy returning to school in
Mawlamyine, my young cousins, as a gesture of farewell, would invari—
ably treat me to a meal ofcoconut rice and chicken curry — a dish for the
Myanmar gourmet. At first I enjoyed it. But gradually 1 began to have
scruples about eating chicken. It was perhaps out of compassion for the
animals we had farm cattle, buffaloes, pigs, fowls, ducks and
what have you. Each time I had chicken, I started to wonder whether it
was the white hen 1 fed yesterday, or the brown cockerel I was chasing
the other day. The thought spoilt my appetite. Soon, such emotional
feelings spread to the other animals, and they pricked my conscience so
much so that I gave up eating meat altogether — a life fled throughout my
university days. It was done on humanitarian grounds rather than on reli—
gious considerations. Buddhism is silent on the question of eating meat.
Hinduism is explicit on it. The Buddha ate whatever he was offered, and
so do the monks oftoday. As for the lay—Myanmar, though several veg—
etarians there are among them, they eat meat without giving a thought to
it.
On board the ship, at meal times 1 sat next to an elderly
Englishman. At dinner a menu was given to us. It had thirty to forty
courses, many ofwhich were in French, ofwhich 1 knew next to nothing
then. Acting on the advice of my table—mate 1 chose vegetarian dishes,
and then started eating semi—vegetarian food later — cheese dishes, a few
prawns or small amount of fish with plenty of vegetables. Some of the
waiters looked at me as an odd specimen, the more so when 1 declined
their offer of drinks.
1 shall not portray the life of a Myanmar Buddhist in an alien
clime, where the ambience was different form that ofMyanmar. To do so
would not do fulljustice to my lecture on the life ofthe Myanmar Buddhist
from the cradle to the grave. Instead 1 propose to tell you a brief story of
my days as a student and then as a teacher in England, spotlighting those
incidents, events and dramas, all ofwhich contributed to the changing of
the course ofmy life.
1 would have liked to forget, if I could, the first few months at
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 117
the Institute of Education. It was a kind of nightmare to me. 1 had to
study, among other things, Principles ofEducation, Elementary, Advanced
and Industrial Psychology and the English Education System in England
and Wales, all of which were €ireek to me. And on top of that 1 had to
practise teaching at an English school in London. However, at the end of
the session, 1 got through the examinations. 1 got a diploma in teaching,
which opened the door for me to proceed to the MA degree. It was a
miracle, or was it the working of my karma in the previous existences'?
Anyway, more miracles were to happen in the next ten years.
While I was at a end during the vacation after the
examination, another Myanmar state scholar came see me to tell me
that Dr I.A.Stewart was very keen to meet me. Dr Stewart, an Indian
Civil Servant had served in Myanmar many years. He retired in 1933 and
brought back to England the material for the compilation of a Myanmar
English dictionary. He was appointed lecturer in Myanmar at the School
of Oriental Studies, later to be known as The School of Oriental and
African Studies, London. He became Reader in Myanmar in 1935, and
Professor ofMyanmar in 1944. We went to see him at Bishop’s Stortford,
a town about thirty miles away form London. After a few preliminaries,
Dr Stewart talked me into switching form writing the MA thesis in
Education to preparing a thesis for the PhD degree in Myanmar. I joined
the school as a postgraduate in 1939.
World War 11 came in September ofthat year. All the Myanmar
state scholars in Britain were given an option of either returning to
Myanmar or remaining in Britain to continue their studies. 1 opted for the
latter. 1 prepared my thesis under Dr Stewart’s supervision. One evening
in 1942, 1 believe, while I was walking along a London street, musing
over the twists and tums in my karma during the last few months, several
German bombers started raining down bomb after bomb around me.
1 made for the nearest underground station to take shelter below. There
1 met a London East-Ender, a Cockney, most ofwhom are noted for their
sense ofhumour. He said with a broad grin: ‘Mate, you don’t need to run
so fast. Unless there is your name written on the bomb, you won’t be
killed by it’. When 1 asked him why then he was taking shelter under-
ground, he said: ‘1 ain’t afraid ofthe bomb, I was afraid ofits blast!’ His
remark on the bomb and the name written on it indicates that he was a
fatalist, one step removed from a believer in karma.
1 obtained the PhD degree in 1944, in the same year the title of
Professor of Myanmar was conferred on J.A. Stewart. At the end of the
war in Europe, Stewart asked me to assist him in his Myanmar-English
lls Dr. Hla Pc
Dictionary, then being compiled in the Dictionary office in his garden at
Bishop’s Stortford. I joined him in 1946. He had a colleague, a Mr C.W.
Dunn, another Indian Civil Servant, who had worked together with J.A.
Stewart in Myanmar. Stewart died ofheart attack in May 1945 at the age
of66. Dunn and I carried on the task in hand. In October 1945 I accepted
the offer of lectureship by the School of Oriental and African Studies,
with d that 1 would relinquish the post at the end of my three
years tenureship. It was not to be. 1 had one student after another reading
for the Myanmar Honours degree, besides several others from the Foreign
Office, from the BBC and other quarters. A Mr H.F. Searle,
in Myanmar ofProfessor Stewart and MrDunn, was appointed atemporary
lecturer in Myanmar, and also as an Editor ofthe Dictionary. The title of
Reader in Myanmar was conferred upon me by the University ofLondon
in 1955. My pleasant and profitable association with them was severed
by the death ofMr Searle in 1965 and ofMr Dunn in 1966.
At this juncture, may 1 refresh your memory with what the
Moslem astrologer had told me in 1935, a few months before 1 left for
England! He said: ‘Sahib, you are goig to the West .. . a place much farther
than Mecca. And there you will meet three gentlemen, much older than
you, and they will be very kind to you. One ofthem will treat you like his
son. Believe me... you will prosper there, Sir.’ 1 did meet Stewart, Dunn
and Searle, the three gentlemen who were very kind to me, particularly
Professor Stewart. He did treat me like his son; his eldest son, who was of
the same age as 1, was killed in Italy at the beginning of the war. After
one year of collaboration with Stewart on the Dictionary he began to
conceive in his head that I was the only reliable, trustworthy Myanmar
scholar he had ever met. He told it to his Myanmar wife and said to her in
my presence that Hla Pe should stay in England to work at the School. 1
still remember an incident that took place the day before Stewart’s death.
The Rector ofthe University ofYangon, who was in England at that time,
came to see us at Bishop’s Stortford. He offered me the post ofReader in
Myanmar in Yangon. Stewart, very ill though, angrily told him that that
was not good enough for me, and that 1 could become a professor one
day, if 1 would work at the School.
Auspicious days
1 .Tanhkfi: sa—lha Tanhkii: Friday - Wednesday
thwan: pa—Kuchun Kuchun Saturday - Thursday
Nayun nnwan. ca Nayun Tuesday - Tuesday
on-lha Wachui Wachui Sunday Wednesday
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 123
2.sa-lui Wakhon Wakhofi Friday Wednesday
mrat-toff Tosalan: Tosalan: Thursday Saturday
Sitaii: kywat chi Sitan:kywat Tuesday (Tuesday)
o-li Tanchoiimun: Tanchoiimun: Sunday Wednesday
3. sa-lurii: Natto Natto Friday Wednesday
ma-no Prasui Prasui Thursday Saturday
ci:-fifiui Tabui.twai Tabui.twai Tuesday - Tuesday
ai-wan Sunday Wednesday
We know from the table you have that the propitious days from
each of the months are those given in the last above. A careful
examination ofthis table shows that
(1) only six days out ofthe eight days ofthe week are included:
the two excluded days are Monday and Rahu; and
(2) there is in this a certain pattern.
(a) Five out ofsix days are arranged in pairs: Friday and Wednes-
day; Saturday and Thursday; and Sunday and Wednesday. They repre-
sent the auspicious days in the first, second and fourth months, while
Tuesday alone represents the auspicious day in the third month.
(b) This format ofthe first group offour months repeats itself in
the following second and third groups.
There is also a cryptogramin mnemonics, composed also in verse
form, for the inauspicious days. They too have a pattern, similar in format
to that oftheir opposite numbers, except that there are eight instead ofsix
days. The crytogram is: ta-ma,’ sak-rah., ah-krah., chu. -rac - the names
of four species of trees, representing the inauspicious days of the four
months in each ofthe first, second and third groups. In this case too, as in
that of their opposite numbers, there are four pairs which repeat them-
selves twice to go round the twelve months.
Inauspicious days
ta-ma Saturday-Thursday
sak-ran: Friday-Wednesday
an-karii: Sunday-Monday
chit rac Tuesday-Rahu
The only comment to make here is about ‘ran’ in sak-ran:, line 2
above. The letter ‘r’ is shown under Rahu in the table. But here for rea-
sons unknown it represents Wednesday. (See the table showing the days
ofthe week and their corresponding alphabets in appendix)
3.1.7 England II
OnFriday the 13th ofJune l958lleft onboard the ship Derbyshire
124 Dr. Hla Pc
for England. It was during the monsoon. The Indian ocean was very rough,
but rougher was the Arabian Sea. The ship tossed and rolled amidst moun—
tainous waves. But worse was to come. As she made her way through the
waves towards Aden, lying the north-west of her, there came a gale
force south-west wind. She had to change her due west almost
heading towards the on coming gale. We reached Djibuti instead ofAden.
The ship then made her way to her port—of-call by hugging the coast line
ofAfrica. Eventually we arrived at Aden. The Myanmar passengers natu—
rally put the blame on the date ofthe departure for what they had suffered
far.
Misfortune seldom comes alone. In the Red Sea one ofthe ship’s
engines broke down. When we finally made way Suez, we
began to hear rumours that our ship would not be allowed to go through
the Suez Canal into the Mediterranean sea. Some of you may remember
the Suez Crisis of 1956 and its aftermaths. Many ofus started entertaining
visions of having to go round the Cape of Creed thereby prolong—
ing ourjourney another two months. And some feared that our ship might
be detained by the Egyptian authorities and would not be released until
such time as the British and Egyptian governments could come to an
agreement. Again the date, the 13th and the day, Friday were blamed for
such inconveniences and sufferings. lam not sure what was happening in
those few hours. Even the Captain of the ship wouldn't tell us anything.
Anyway in another few hours we found ourselves, to our great joy, in the
Mediterranean sea.
In the period between 1958 and 1980, with a break ofmy revisit
to Myanmar in 1979, 1 led the life of a Myanmar Buddhist in England.
An account of my life there would still fall within the purview of my
lecture, but it would not arouse much interest in you. All 1 shall mention
here are three facts: my fulfilling the three primary duties of a Buddhist,
the description of which I reserve for the next stage; my fulfilling the
prophecy of the late Professor I.A.Stewart, which he made a few hours
before his death, by becoming a professor in the University ofLondon in
1966; and my fulfilling the wishes ofmy wife by returning to Myanmar
in 1980 for good.
3.2 Manhood
I shall now continue the story ofthe life ofthe Myanmar Buddhist
by transferring the scence to his habitat, Myanmar. You may remember
that we had paused for a while when we reached the stage ofhis transition
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 125
from youth to manhood. It was give myself a chance to continue my
brief autobiography and to highlight a few specimens of his beliefs and
practices. Here 1 shall pick up the thread and try to piece together the
aspects of his life present to you a recognizable portrait of
Myanmar manhood. The material for this and for each of the following
stages his journey in this world, 1 shall draw partly from my own
experience and partly from my own observations.
Having left behind the phase ofadolescence, the Myanmar Bud—
dhist enters into matrimony and a life of domesticity.
(2) Elopement
Contracting marriage by elopement offends the sense ofpropriety
and decorum of the But its gets the hearty of the
young romantics. Elopement is a natural sequel to the two
mentioned above - wooing and falling in
Wooing in old Myanmar was done under the hawk-eyed parents
and elders. In those days when everything moved at a leisurely pace, and
when patience was a virtue, three seasons’ wooing was the rule rather
than the exception. Secret trysts were not as uncommon as they are today.
However, the young beau went to see his sweet heart at her home at the
hour ‘when brothers hardly recognize each other’ (between 5 and 6 pm),
and had a téte-I:i-téte with her. He stayed on ignoring ‘the time when
elderly people rest their heads on pillows’ (10 pm), until ‘the time when
bachelors return’ (11 pm) arrived. He bade adieu to his girl friend and
returned home. Marriage or elopement followed in its wake in due course.
1 have used, you will notice, the then current terms of expressing time to
give a proper atmosphere to the scene.
For many young people oftoday, three years waiting is too long.
Many old restrictions have been dispensed with, there is a change in their
attitude, and temptations have increased manifold. Some ofthem cannot
wait even three months. This is, as you all know, the age of ‘instant cof-
fee’, ‘instant noodles’ and ‘instant this and instant that’. Besides the way
courting is conducted has to adapt itself to the world of changing stand-
ards and values. Young men are more forward and the young girls are
less demure. The man often deploys one ofthe three means to achieve his
desired object. The first is a rather mild tactic. He writes love letters and
either gives them to the girl himselfor send them to her by post or through
an intermediary. The second is by employing a go-between - a tactic that
betrays his timidity. The third is a direct approach: he goes to see the girl
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 131
and, to use the modern parlance, chats her up. If one of these means
brings success to him, he is accepted, and in due course they fall in love
with each other. They want to marry. The parents intervene and object to
their entering into nuptials the grounds of their age unfinished
education and such like. The loved have alternative but
ment, and in a few extreme cases suicide. I’ll tell you about an elopement
1 witnessed myself in our village with a happy ending.
One of my friends who was about nineteen or twenty then ran
away with his sweet-heart, who in vain had tried many times
upon her well-to—do— parents to give their consent. His would—be parents—
in-law looked down upon him as a worthless creature, who would not be
able to keep their daughter in circumstances she was accustomed to. They
threatened to cut her off with a centime. The went into hiding
until the whole affair had been blown over and the parents fury had sub—
sided.
The young man was an orphan. He and his girl—friend approached
a handful of elders including two ladies, the paragon of the art of
reconcilliation. The emissaries came. They met the girl’s parents, and the
two ladies used their maximum power ofpersuasion. They asked the par—
ents to let begones be bygones, and stressed the fact that their daughter
was having the worst of both worlds. To drive their point home, they
quoted the proverb: ‘If the thorn falls, the leaf is pierced; ifthe leaf falls,
the leaf is pierced’. They capped their arguments by putting forward the
irrefutable reason that it was karma that had destined this union. The
parents in the end relented and agreed to have the two erring young ones
in the evening ofa certain auspicious day. Evening is the usual time chosen
for such an occasion: the people have done their day’s work, and life has
quietened down somewhat, and any formal activity will have less public—
ity — a statement that proved to the contrary, as you will see by and by.
At dusk onthat evening, the young couple, accompained by some
of the emissaries, came. They brought with them the traditonal tray of
gifts with which to pay their respects to the girl’s parents. After a brief
preliminary formality they did obeisance to the father and mother, who
gave their blessings: ‘May you both live as husband and wife happily
together to a ripe old age’. The father was now in a convivial mood.
Perhaps, he was feeling nostalgic about the day he eloped with his wife.
He added to those blessings his own. ‘May you also be blessed with a
matful ofchildren’- a number which depends upon the size ofthe mat. It
132 Dr. Hla Pc
may range from five to ten children. For such flippancy he got a digging
in his ribs his wife’s elbow. Just at that very moment stones and
broken pieces ofbricks ofall shapes and sizes began to rain down on the
thatched roof of the house. It was a frightening experience for those in-
side the house.
A band of village lads and two or three middle aged men had
taken up their strategic positions a few minutes before the arrival of the
party at the reception ceremony. They learnt of it time before the
event. They had indulged in this horseplay for what is generally known
as ‘stone fee’, gfi-ho in Myanmar. They kept hurling their missiles
until the father came out and groped his way in the darkness their
leader. He haggled over the sum ofmoney for the stone-fee. He then paid
them offto leave the party in the house in peace. The young couple were
henceforth married in the eye ofthe public.
1 must admit 1 have not the faintest idea of how this custom
originated. A few Myanmar scholars have attempted to explain away its
origin. 1 shall pass to you two versions oftheir accounts for what they are
worth. It is not unlike the story ofthe Fall ofMan.
It began with the beginning ofthe world. Soon after the evolution
ofthis world cycle, many Brahma passed away from their celestial abode
and appeared on earth self-illuminated. They first ate the tasty earth, as a
result of which they lost their self-illumination, and they took to eating
the layers underneath it. The diet tainted their minds with greed, which
brought about the disappearance oftheir sustenance. So they turned to a
fragrant and tasteful creeper called in Pali bodalaté or padalaté. It
disappered in due course, so they partook ofrice. This enterprise oftheirs
turned them into the prototype of modem man.
1 quote:
‘And there appears masculinity to man, feminity to woman.
So that man and woman gaze long at each other. Because they gaze
long at each other, the burning oflust arises. Then they follow their
sensual instincts. Because of their evil practices they are blamed,
censured by the wise; and to hide their sin, they make houses wherein
they dwell’. (The Path of Purity, 1, translated by Pe Maung
Tin,Oxford University Press, 1923, pp. 482 and following.)
It is more than possible that the Myanmar scholars use the story of the
evolution of the world cycle as a peg to hang their explanation on the
origin of the stone-fee. For, to this version they have added their own,
which says, 'The decent minded people make for the dwelling place of
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 133
the shameless individuals, and threw stones on their houses to drive them
away.' Such custom, the scholars maintain, still lingers
The other version ofthis folk—lore has a similar théme with some
variations.
(a) Investigation
Protective Myanmar parents are most particular about a prospec—
tive son or daughter—in—law. Before any commitment they make, they will
use every means at their disposal to find out all about their probable new
acquisition.
In awould-be-son—in-law, they examine chiefly his pedigree, moral
attainments and his intellectual achievements. The girl’s parents are in—
terested to know about his family history: has there ever been or is there
any leper, lunatic, or drug and alcoholic addict among his parents’ relatives;
136 Dr. Hla Pc
and is the young man partial to drinking, gambling or women'? Status and
wealth do count but they are subordinate to his moral virtues.
In a prospective daughter—in—law, the man’s parents scrutinize
her moral character, her looks, her domesticity, and her education. Wealth
can be one ofher assets!
(b) Negotiation
Having satisfied that their enquiries turned out to be all that to
be desired, the parents of one party approach their opposite numbers.
Over a cup oftea or coffee, or round a lunch or dinner table they discuss
the matter ofmatrimony. Ifthe discussions end satisfactorily an astrologer
is consulted about the matters relating to the marriage ofthe two people.
In several instances a go—between (in Myanmar uung-thwe liter—
ally meaning ‘successful connector’) is entrusted with the task for both
investigation and negotiation. A go—between in Myanmar is usually a
mature woman. She depends for her success onthe art ofpersuasive speech
which is much cultivated in Myanmar. It is not mere fluency or plausibility
so much as adroitness in getting on confidential terms with people and
involving them in a conversation they enjoy. Craft, sycophancy, perhaps
impudence may be employed, but never so as to alarm the other party or
to put him on his guard. Nothing will be accomplished unless the person
approached can be made to feel that he has been having a heart-to-heart
talk. The art employed may be described as practical psychology, the
ability to get on the right side of the person, to exploit his vanities or
frailities, and sometimes, of course, to appeal to his better feelings.
(c) Consultation
A reputable astrologer is consulted for two purposes. One is to
accertain whether the would-be-husband and wife are astrologically com-
patible; and the other is to fix the auspicious times and dates for the
betrothal and marriage ceremonies.
To have a happy enduring marriage, it is imperative, say the
astrologers, that many astrological aspects must be examined. There are,
indeed, many ofthem. One may suffice. It concerns the relationship be-
tween the planets under which the prospective husband and wife were
born. Since the eight planets, the Sun, the Moon, Mars, Mercury, Rahu,
Jupiter, Venus and Saturn are represented by the days of the week, the
astrologer attempts to find out whether the days on which they were born
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 137
are friendly to each other not. Mutual sympathy indicates a happy
lasting marriage, and mutual repulsion infuses unhappiness into the mar—
riage or may even cause seperation.
For such ascertainment, there are formulae which are composed
in mnemonic verses, in which the two words in question are juxtaposed.
The friendly and unfriendly days are as follows:
Those who are by the grave side throw lumps ofearth or stones
into the grave before it is filled in. In large cities such as Yangon and
Mandalay, ceremation is superseding this burial practice as well as that
of entombment.
On returning home of the relatives may pick up a lump of
earth or a stone from the top ofthe new grave, take it back to the deceased
house and keep it in the front room. This is a token offering to the spirit of
the dead a temporary refuge for seven days. There is a general belief
among the Myanmar people that the spirit of the departed lingers about
on earth during of seven days after his or her death. Needless
to say it is a non-Buddhist practice and belief.
On the seventh day the ceremony for religious offerings is held.
It is calledyei-/e-zfiu wfii ‘seventh-day to feed the monks’. DrA. Judson
in his dictionary defines yet-le-ztln as ‘a feast given to guests attending a
funeral ceremony seven days after the burial ofthe deceased’. Shwe Yoe,
in his book, subscribed to it (p.959). The seventh day is, however, counted
from the day ofthe death; and it is not a feast given to guests attending a
funeral ceremony, but an offering of food to the monks. The word zfiu or
hsun here means the monk's food. Ofcourse the guests are also fed after
the monks as in every religious offering ceremony.
The ceremony follows the patterns of those of the others men-
tioned earlier: feeding the monks and the people attending it; undertaking
the Five Precepts; the religious discourse appropriate to the occasion; the
water-pouring ritual; and finally the sharing ofmerit with all the denizens
ofthe thirty-one planes of existence including the dead. No other single
event in the life of a Myanmar Buddhist presents the opportunity that a
death does, ofperforming all the religious duties I have been speaking of:
dana, sila and bhavana. lnotice this fact at the funeral ceremony ofone of
my four aunts in 1957 when 1 came back to Myanmar on study leave.
The scale of this kind of ceremony varies from one funeral to
another. There is, at the top, somewhat ostentatious display of offerings,
including gifts for the guests; and at the bottom, a modest form of giving
away food. It is called thabeit-thut 'putting food into the monks alms-
bowl’. It is held at the deceased's house or at a monastery with a handful
of people. At the end of the ceremony the food is placed into the alms-
bowls ofthe monks. According to the Buddha’s teaching be it a grand or
a modest ceremony, merit is gained only by those who make the offerings
with all the sincerity of their hearts.
This then is the story ofthe Myanmar Buddhist, as it were, from
155 Dr. Hla Pc
the cradle to the grave. It needs, however, rounding off by tying up the
loose ends, represented by some ofthe funeral rites. These are non-Bud—
dhist practices, which have been observed so long that they have become
customs nowadays. They lie outside my professional domain, but I will
try explain them as much as I can with the help of the knowledge 1
have gained from Myanmar sources. These sources, you must be warned,
are not well documented.
(1) Washing the body
There is ritualistic significance in it. The body is cleaned
beause it has not been washed since the dead person had been taken ill.
(2) Tying thumbs and big toes
This too is not a ritual either. The function of the string is to
keep in position the limbs ofthe body which is subject to various chemical
reactions.
(3) Placing coils of’ cotton strings on the corpse
1 have no explanation for it. There is a similar custom which is
placing a piece of the cotton—tree wood, or a short stem of the banana
plant in the coffin of an old maid. The explanation for that is to provide
the old spinster with a husband in her next life as a woman. 1 do not know
why two particular items are chosen.
(4) The térry litre
The practice ofinserting a coin between teeth is not uncommon
among many ethnic tribes. Burmese scholars maintain that it is a relic of
an ancient Indian custom. When a person died in those days the relatives
thrust the stem ofa red Hibiscus into its ear-hole, tied silver pieces to the
hem ofhis dress, caused him to be possessed by a spirit and sent it offto
the cemetry. There the grave diggers stopped the walking corpse, took
the money and buried it. The red Hibiscus with its dangling stamen, an—
ther and pollen is known to the Burmese people as the ghost flower,
unlucky to grow in the garden, or to bring it into the house or to adorn it
on one's head. However, 1 prefer the Charon's toll to that given in the
story.
(5) Pouring water in the trail of the coffin
The origin of this custom as given in a Burmese book sounds
most implausible. I shall however repeat it for what it is worth, and suggest
my own plausible conclusion to it.
Once a king would not bury the dead body ofhis most beloved
The Myanmar Buddhist : His Lili From the Cradle to the Grave 159
queen. He kept it in the palace. His preceptor, a hermit, heard of it, and
came to see him. By virtue ofhis supernatural power, the hemit summoned
the late queen, who was by now reborn as a female beetle. When asked in
the presence of the king, she replied that she was happily married, and
that she would not change her husband for any one on earth. On hearing
it, the incensed king kicked the body out ofthe palace, smashed the bier
and had the floor on which it had stood washed down with water.
This is an act of spite which loving relative would commit
against the dead nowadays. 1 suggested that its origin could be traced to
who did a relative he hated, and did have the
which his body had lain, washed down with water. And the people, who
witnessed such an act, followed it blindly without knowing the reason for
it!
(6) Throwing lumps of’ earth or stones into the grave
There is a story purported to explain the of this
practice, but it is so implausible that it is not worth your while to repeat it.
1 shall however repeat what a few Myanmar elders have told me about
the reason for performing this ritual. It is a kind of ‘forgive and forget’
gesture. As one throws lumps of earth into the grave, they assert, one
should say: ‘If there ever exists a state of hostility between you and me,
may it end here and now.' The lumps ofearth represent, 1 believe, a token
of peace offering.
3.5 Epilogue
And now, as a token ofmy appreciation ofyour attending some
or all ofmy eight lectures I shall bring my long discourse to a close. You
have seen the tableau ofthe life ofthe Myanmar Buddhist from birth to
death through the spectrum presented by a man who stands astride two
generations. You might deduce from it that the tableau ofone generation
is a replica of the previous generation. This is far from the truth. Every
thing is subject to changes. Nevertheless, the Myanmar Buddhist’s
fundamental beliefs and practices remain almost unchanged.
The family is still well knit as the community is well welded;
Buddhism still flourishes, so too the people’s practice in piety by fulfilling
the three primary duties ofDana, Sila and Bhavana; their strong faith in
re-incarnation, karma and Nirvana still continues unabated as with their
beliefs and practices in astrology, in deities, in magic and in omens; and
ceremonies ofevery persuasion are still being held. So, you can still meet
the Myanmar Buddhist as portrayed in my lecture all over the Myanmar
oftoday.
160 Dr. Hla Pc
lam deeply grateful to L’ Assemblée des Professeurs du College
de France for inviting me to deliver this series of eight lectures in Paris.
Their kind invitation has enabled me to meet my old friends again and to
make new ones. 1 trust that the time you have spent attending my lectures
are worth your while.
Au
(Hla Pe)
(15th March 1954)
7HE[QLZRJ
V*ZQ
7HESQEI=
YJXGWHIJXGKXN^TJGO>IJIK
(
YJEI=I,IYJ
IQ
(VHITJYHOE%MJ]RQ
7HVWQ[+YJGWYJE]SRJLX[HOMJZ+[JZ]JE
# ZPMJF
##EV+^+QNGMJ
Y6IJE[QJLYHOS,Z+MJNVTJ
.9NVTJZYJ[YJ[TJGOE]Y
+QYEZV7Q
EV+^+Q]K[JY6IEJ [QJL VHSQTOY[TJGWIH [J TJGKYE[QLXSMJXL [MJL GWVJ SQ
YJESQVHSQTO]KZJSVQVHSQTO]K].Y6IJE[QJLYHOEN]QN]1YZHO=
SH
[QYY6IJE[QJLYHOEV+2](E[QL
+QV7ZYJSRJYGWYJ&YH/YHON^[J2](
EG+ E1YQMJ [H
TÈQIJX)©
QJYMJ[.L [TJEI
QV7Q ENVNV/]J]K[J ¡HO
Q
XT3JXZQ[TJ
]J]KAGWYJNV/]Ja[JZHO=EG]K[J)HOMJM,[TJIJNVIJVQ
V7IJSV5ZHOYJIQSRJL¡HO
Q]K(GWYJNV/]JUHO[.LXS,OX)-IJYEV+
Q>Q[H
]J
+Q#2VH/9SHO=V?O[J)HOMJM,YHOR8IJ[.LXH]ÀQJEUQMJZQ]K[J
### YMJ]+IJ[]JV*ZQ
Y6IJE[QJZSQX
+JV7QV+IJZPVWH/N^TJ[.LXF+QYY6IJE[QJLYHO
XVRJE]YMJ]I+ J []J].+ ZO]EJ ]^H=O T(T3J]K[JYMJ]I+ J []JUH[
O QYYMJ]I+ J
RJEZQMJEU[QI.= G
TJQIJYYEZ3(EGKMJE]E
^WIJ[Q[P[J#
2](E[QL IQVRJE][Q [P[J GOEG[JV7QE[QL %OFQSQ V?O[J[.L
\,O [VJXT3JXZQE[+YOH %OF QSQV-N]/2](ZYJGG, WM[ J L. XZQXZQE[+
YJS[É[TJ][JV7Q[TJEI=T(X[+YJS[JV7[JE]\Q[.L NVIJVQXY
QE[+
7H]K[JY6IJE[QJLIQVRJYAZPEGWQZPZ7YEZaZHO=XH]ÀQJ
]K[J
(XGWYY J OH XENGG,EYQYJGWYU J V.+ JU
OH MJ UH[O L. VW/H ¡HO XVRJ
JZ=OH
\RJEL ZLV
7HE1YQMJE[+9]KVJSH=EO SQJZRJXEIQYJ[MOH JUIJSP XE[QJ
VWQVWQY ^GMJ SHO=V?O[J VHGMJFYJV7 IQVRJ [TJZ,OYHO P2]( XVRJ
E
79YN^TJETEIQYJYN^TJET\RJEL ZL
7HZQ[JY6IJE[QJL
.9^GMJY3(EM+
[.L#[IZ*QSQ]KY6IJE[QJ
.9R()7TJEQYJZ,OY1YQS
]E[SQE[+#SP[I=OH QVRJYEVQMJFS+MJ X^@],[ O SP
P )7MLJ EVQMJNVMJS
L IH J
[TJSHIJ ESQSP[\ O=H YJSQZ+IEJ SQSP
]K[.L]H2O ]( ¡-]EJ \+T
QN^TJ[QY
Y6IJE[QJL VHGMJYIQVRJ VGMJ XEVLYHO FJE[QLV7 3(EM+
YE[QJ ZH=O VEG1Y]KFP XESTH[J EZLZQGWYJ SHZ]HO KY
OT[]JE?QYJ[VIJE
NVIJVQ]O¢H/ZJIQVRJVWQ
IJYOIJ SQSIQ
E
<QIV7\O[JESRJ
YHO^[J¡-]K
EG[ÉV5XQZ,ON]IJEYQYJ]KVJNVIJVQ%OFQSQ>I(VQY
SP= X]WH/F IQVRJI.= UYJEI[.L YHTÚ?Q 3JEYWV-# T(]+QE
TITJ#
ZPV-E
\,O[VJ)7MJLSYJEV+ZO]JMIJSFQXTTY+.N]QSRJL)HOMJMV, WQV7Q
[TJZ+.\MJ2](N]×IQE])HOMJ]K[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
Y6IJE[QJL>I(ESIJNVNV
[IQSIJ YJSPXVWH/SV(
Z+IJG.L
ESQ)7TJXE[QJ1YQY2%H[HIJ)HOMJM, E
QYJZQE[QL Y6IJE[QJ[HO= F4JV7Q
]P[+.EM+TQ
MJ^+MJL]K[JF4JVIJEIWQYY6IJE[QJE
Q>I(YHO]KSH]K
[JSHO=ESQJF4JIJ\VJVWQY[TJZ+.V\MJET
IJX[+YJ>I(XVRJV7Q
Y6IJE[QJL IQVRJEIQYJY[+.SMJLE1YQMJX1Y,E]]K[JY6IJE[QJL>I(
YE[QLSP=YHOVTÚTJSIJNVEFSHO=V?O[JVTÚTJEFZHO=SPX*ZIJV7QEISV5
XEGG,
EZE[QL XSQ2MHVJG,EI
7Q[J
]HO2](¡-]J[Q[TJGOYE[QLNVIJVQZPVWH/YOZSV¢X
Q
7H&Y([TJ3(
YHTÚ SP=>I()7MJLX[P )HOMJM,NGQ [TJ)HOMJM, E
QYJS+Q[J E?QJ[J&Y(
[TJGOV7Q[TJRMJ[RJ[JSP=>I(
.9][JTJ]HO=V7QIQVRJY[TJVWH/N^TJEI
E[QLE?QJ[JVIJEIWQYSP[HO=YHO[TJGIJ[RJEI
QVGWGWMJFPYOZ
SV¢ X
Q
7H&Y(YE[QL
7MJN]
7Q]K[JSP=XSYJX
+JI.= SP
.9YOZ
SV¢Y SP
.9
Q\PXUMJLYHO E
QYJEIV7 XENVQMJVQ)7MJL )HOMJM,[YQ
EZ5QYJSQ+ EIZ5MJSPXZ+IJVHOYJV.
QYWV7QE]KLZHO= EN]Q2](NVIJVQ3JEYWV-
\,OT,YHOZRJ
7MJN]]KS[.LX.SP[HO=[TJGIJ[RJ
S+Q]K[J
(ZHO YSHYEXQYJXN^TJYNVIJVQE[+SQ1Y,/
[QV?O[J]KFP
2%[H SH 5E[+E[QMJ
TJ][JG,1Y
[Q].[TJGKY[YÞSZ OH U
J
QV[TJ3( SP
9.
TQXO]TJ Q[VJE[+)7MLJ )HOMMJ ,[YQEU+E)+]+V. WQV7Q[YJE
QYJEU+E)+V--E[+
E1YQMJL ]RQ
7MJ EZQYV7Q \MJE]EYWQJ1YQ ZPSHVWQEI[J SPY
T(]+QE
ZO]MJ IJ
7M[ J TJ3( )7MJL ZYJ\]JZOY
H EJ
Q(U
QVYSP
9. ZPSVH WQ
EI[.LX]WH/FIQVRJYHOFJZYJZ8[JGWMJVZ.SP=X]WH/IQVRJ
I.=].UYJ2](TGIJS+QEI[QE]KLV1YQGMJV7QSP=[YÞSHOZJYXO]JGW/]JE
X^+.9YHO V(^+QG+MJLE[QMJG,TQ[MJE
QX^+.9¡,OF$QE[QJ\HIJYE
7¡HO&Y(
YHOJYWMJLSHYQXEZ\QSPN^TJEI[JX.E[QL
.9V(^+QG+MJL
EZ5QYJZ8Q1YRJL VEYWVGWVJN^TJE
QKI.= G+MJLE]
IJ NMMJUHOZHOYJ]K[J
EIQYJV7 >Q[J
RJZRJEXQMJ
7MJN]ZHO= YHTÚ2](EN]S+Q]KS[.L
Y,[
QSRJVHSQTOTRJZ,O
QV7QXE1YQMJ[TJ
]JN^TJE1YQMJ
Y6IJE[QJ EN]QG.L[Q GMJ%WQ[OH= S[H
EYQMJ
]KZHVJLVJ SRJ\.V7Q
X,VMJ?IJVYWN^TJEI[QYE[QLNVIJVQVHSQTOMJE[+
.9IQVRJE[+]K].
KYZRJ%OFQSQVWQE%MJ,O1YRJ[.LX[+YJ N^TJ
[Q]K
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
###XHVJSQF
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ
.9FV7Q%OFQSQYEI
Q[YQ]KEI[J
SP
.9 XE[+# XEN]Q# XZOO]JE[+V7Q %OE?QEN]Q S+IJSMJGWYJE[+Y
\MJ?]JEI]K[J
Y6IJE[QJ )7TJ)7TJSQ X
+JE
QYJE[QL XE^LFYJY X]WH/&Y(
XEEZEQYJY Y6IJE[QJLYHO EV+TQ]K[J Y,[
Q)7MJL XR(
Y6IJE[QJ VHSQTO XSHOMJXIJ\.V7Q &Y(N]MJG.L
[J XSHOMJXIJY
Y6IJ E[QJ@ XE[+ XNVMJ YH O N]/N]MJ[ J Y6IJ E[QJ ZO]J ],O YH OMJ ],O )7M J L
XYWMJLKSIQE^QJ\O[JE][JY6IJE[QJ@YHOJ]HOMJT¡HOYJZY4QYHO
],OSM+ J E]G.L[JZHO= Y6IJE[QJ,O1YRJ]K[JNVIJVQYEZ[TJEQYJYHO
EV+EY6O[.L ][JIJYWMJY XEIQYJ)HOMJM,VWQ)7MJL XE[QJX[IJ
Y+. N ]Q]K[J Y6IJE [QJ S[HN ]/VHZ Q[Q SH O= V?O [J S[HN ]/EXQMJ
SMJE]G,
[Q[TJGOYEI=T3JFV7QXSYJKYHO3(TQE]
VJ#XHVJV7Q
XSYJX&Y(U,OSPYXHYV$H/MJ N^TJ[JY6IJE[QJ[HO= XHVJV7QE[QL
XF+QE]KLSYJ&Y(K&Y( YHOYHOMJ ¡-HMJ
EZTQ
[QYZP[MHO JYWMLJ [J].
ZO]JGWMJV7 ZO]J[.LG6MJGWYJV?O[J]KFP
Y6IEJ [QJ
+QEYWQMJVS+QESV(XGWIH J XE[QJMJ[L. X
+Y J T2](
ZP&Y(SPVVWQ)7MJL UYJU,
QV7Q ZHOYJIQ
VRJL 3JEYWV- YWMJL[JVWQYHO
SMJE]1Y]K[J [GWH/9YHTÚVWQE[QLZRJ Y6IJE[QJYHOJ[HOMJ XZHOZHO
SHIQZRJZQ[Q
7]H K[JSMJE][.L X\.Y[GWH/9YHO EN]Q
Z5MJ MK#IMJ
VS,O
Y6IEJ [QJZ=OH S,O
VJ3(EZ#3(&Y( #EEZ#E&Y( XTJY#OH XTJV
FJSP FJKTSRJN^MJL XSYJX
+X J ZHOY#J YWQVXZHY O J EG
VJ
(LN]MJY6IEJ [QJY L OH SMJ1YQ[QYXS,YWY J W)J M7 JL AFQRQaEXQJVEN]Q^HO=
NVIJVQTYQ3J3JEYWEYW)7MLJ ?O[Y J GL. MJ%W#EYQMJ]K2]( EETSRJN^MJL
ZP&Y( VWQYHO N]IJEN]Q
QV7QZHY O IJ QT
QSMJ]K[JEGKMJRH[J#EGKMJGK[.L
YH O JXVPX
Q)7MJL ¡HMO J[.L XVPX
QVN]
#EYQMJ]K2]( GMJ%WQ#?O[Y J L. GMJ%W
3J3JEYWEYWEN]Q
VJ(TYQE[+X[+YJ NVIJVQXS,O X)-IJ XVWQ&Y(
7H]K[J¡HOESNGMJK
#)7HVJLGWNGMJIHK[
)7MJLYHOJGWMJTQ[
QVWQYHO
EKYJ[QZ7EF
E[+9
VRJL3]VQE[+]KZP&Y(VWQE
79V7QEI
MJYHOJEIYHO\ J Q?IJ]IJY
]JEI
MJ EGKMJ M,O=\Q
VJ# S+Q
MJ GKYOIJS+Q]K# ESS]JT+Q\HOMJ]K
ZP&Y(YHO[TJGOGOE][.LXGKZYJ)7TJ^YJT,O)7MJLYVJ
VRJGOOEG[JV7QE[QL
ZPE[QJE[QJVWQVWQY ZP&Y(YHO E]T
Q
7H
MJ RQZYJ[TJEI
Q
QYHO
FJZYJY\H\QYHOMJ\Q2](E]EI[QS[HN]/VH]K[JK[(\+MJV-
XSTJ[TJVWH/]K].ZYJ[TJFYJYVXQZ]J
MJE[QLE]T
QYHORQZYJ
)7MJLSQE]
VJ#FJSIJYEZUHO
MJE[QL VZ+JFP
VHEYQMJ^GMJSQSV(X[+YJTQESQYJ]O, TQ]+\ . HOMJXN]/XVP
YZRJ XZ+IJ XE
&Y(]K[J TQESQYJGWHIJE
QYJ
MJ Y6IJE[QJ[HO=
XQZ,O1YVJN]MJE]TQ]+. XIHVY JL EZE
79V7QHMO J \HOM1J Y
VJTQ]+E. ]V7Q
YHOJT(X[+YJ \VMJ]IJYIJ
7HVJ TQ]+.ZJV7Q ?MJEZ]+. SHO=V?O[J
ENGQYJ]+. SHO=V?O[J (L\YJVWQ[.L XVJE[+ ?MJ[TJVWH/ )7TJ]IJYIJT(
GW\QVJ]IJYIJ[TJZ,OZ,OV7 ?MJYHO XF+QG]JPV2](VGWMJFJSPV7
VZ--]J
FPYHOJT2](VTQGMJV7QXF+QV)--HYJ
ES[.L?MJ[TJVJ\.Y
[TJ>+IJG]J2](XF+Q]IJYIJN]Q\.\RJL3(GW
VJ
[TJGK[OIJYXN^TJX]WYJYEZYHOY6IJE[QJE
E
S[H
EI
[J[TJREIV7QY6IEJ [QJLR(XTJYOH VJY+I. =. SPX = EVY6IEJ [QJ[=HO XHVVJ Q7
RTQZQTQ]K[JEY6[QYIRJIRJEIQYJYWEIE[QLEYQMJEZ
Y UQ2](E]KL TQGWMJE>Q)7MJL SPYT2]( )-HYJTQ]KEZE
Q ZP&Y(E[+
V&YH/YJ[L. X
H]JXY.YHOZRJSP¡OVTHY O JFPSPY¡O[J[
YJAEXQMJVJ
EZ%Wa ZHO= EXQJS, 1YQ1Y
[J SP=XEVY &YH[J2]( E]KMJ[+MJE1YQ
ZHVJ[QYHO X.K\H
MJ XZ+IJIQ[.L XSQ)O]HOMJ (EYQMJ ¡HOMJTHOMJ[.L
XN]/XVPYHO XEVY U,OV ZHOYJ[Q]K KVWH/)7MJL )--HMJ73JT
Q XEIQYJ
V7QZRJ
7H]K
.9\VMJTQ]+.VQ7 >I(BGMJ]I+ J YXV7QV7QZO]JYHOMJEN]QUHGO L
. MJ
TQ]+.EXQYJV7QENGI.= E1YQYJ[J V?O[JZQ
XHVJVQ7 Y6IJE[QJ[=OH EI=T3JZO]EJ IYW[TJGOYE[QL],NO ]MJIQE\QMJ
[Q]K¡HO
Q],ON]MJ#IH]K[JE[QJ],ON]MJYHOTQE]XE[QJXSMJL)7,=T]J[.LZP&Y(
VWQYEEN^QN^QEN]QN]]K[J()HOMJM,V7QXH]J
QMJGWHIJ YEZE[+YHO
],ON]MJ ^[JN][QI.= UMJ[P]K]. 2]([.LXGKV7Q (V7QYEZVWQY +[J)HOYJ
X*ZH]JY N]MJSTJY
UHOSZHO Y6IJE[QJ[HO=Y
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
XF+QYHO YIJE[QL2](XH]J
QMJ]K[J
##
+QEYWQMJ
Y6IJE[QJMK)7TJSQX
+JV7Q
+QEYWQMJV7QT[MJ]RQSMJ1YQ
]K[JXHVVJ Q7 XE[+XNVMJE[+¡HY O S
J M+ J [.L EZLYWMGLJ IJE[+EYWQMJYZRJ
UYJZO]J]K[JTRJYVJEYQMJ2](TITJ[YWT(V,XO]JGW/]J[.LEYWQMJ]K
XE
#X^[JX[+YJ XS,OZ,OSMJ
]K[JX.( XGWHIJXGKYT[O[
X
VE]ES]KFPT[O[X
YGOEG[JXEIQYJ)HOMJM,E[+V7QXE[QJ
EG[JTQEI[JXQG,[QXO]JT^O +.9
VJYQ[QX.(T[O[X
]RQVW/H
YE[QL%OO XU,OXV)7MJL ^(ZQ&Y( N^TJZVH VJL J(EYWQMJSQVWH/E]ZQ
MJ
ZRJU
QE[+YE[QJ
HEZWQJ
HE]WQLTHTHV?O[JFP#E
E
ZRJZRJ&YHVIJ .=
XEUQJG,
V7Q].
EYWQMJ]RQ
.9XHYEV5QJV7IJGWYJYTQ[[J^HO=#X[+YJXGWYJ
[[J^HO=I.=YHOJYWMJLSHYQN]/N]MJE]^HO=N^TJ]K[J(VPKN^TJENVQYJEXQMJ
NVMJET^H=O EYWQMJU
Q&Y( Y(EG[JV7QXS,O VWQZQ[.LUOE]4JE]&YVH J
)7MJL1YS
, YQ
TITJYHOZYJYHOMJ\Q]K[JU
QEYWQMJSQUYJU,E
Y$E
QYJZ5MJ (XE1YQMJYHO GW.9\+MJEN]Q3(V7Q]KEN]QG.L[.L &YHVY J 4JE]
[QYHO[MJTQ]K[JUOE]4JE]TITJ]KTQEYQMJEYQMJVZO]JSP#
XHVTJ Q]WYY J Y+ SJ #P EI\HMO NJ ]/V]P OY
, U,O VV7N^TJVRJSL #P (ZOH EYWQMJSQE[+YOH
EI=GMJ\VMJTQEYWQMJUMJGWIH JXHVJN]IJGM+ LJ VE]F.\Q[[J[J&YVH JY
[YJL&YHVJZRJN^TJ]KES[JSH]JXN]TJ&Y([.LSPYHOE[QL&YHVJ[O[J
)7MJLU,OV]K[J
XHVJV7QE
QEYWQMJV7Q]KZYJ)7MJLN^TJET[O[J)7MJLN^TJET¡HOYJ)7YJ
U,OV[QYE[QLVHFU
QVWQZYJS,O]K].[O[JV]KYEZ]WYJT([JZHO=
,O1YRJ\QE[QLXESXGWQU,OV1Y]K[JIQV7V7[[ J JZZHO= .XT+.
7H1Y
[J Y6IJE[QJ V7[JVHSEZQYJ EYWQMJSQFV7Q [TJ&YHVJ[TJGKV5
X¡HOYJVG,
]KFP XHVJV7QE[QL [TJGK )7TJGK X¡HOYJG,
]K[J XF+QY
Y6IJE[QJLYHO ¡HOYJ)7YJ[.L [TJGKYHOE[QL Y6IJE[QJ EVLV
)HOMJEXQMJ]K].
XF+Q¡HOYJ[QX.([TJJGK]K].XF+QYXZ+IJ1YMJIQ[[JSPIQZRJV-
7HSP]KKE]V.LMJSPY&Y(SPYHOV\(V.LNVMJZO]J
MJYH O JXVPX
QYEZ
E[QMJ SRJVG,FP
EKYJ[QZ7EF
Y6IEJ [QJX L TJYHO VJY+[ . TJEQYJYXYWRJTQSIJ[J[TJEI=
E[QL SPY Y6IJE[QJ TH[JUHOEXQMJ T]K[J Y6IJE[QJY N]IJU.E
Q
X.K XI(V7Q
7H[.L XF+Q1YQS+QE[QL GWYJGWMJ]. Y6IJE[QJLYHO XHJVJ
EIQYJE^EGZQ2]([O[JI.=ENGQYJGWYJ¡OY H J]K[JXF+QYFQV5EKS
X
H]JXE
QMJVN]]KFP¡HOYJ
MJI.=AEN]QTVJ#EIQMJU.3(VZQ?.LaEVZHOYJ
¡HOYJZHOYJ Y6IJE[QJYAEIQMJVU.E[QL]KFPXF+Q#EIQMJVU.E[QL]KFPa
)7MJL¡-HYJ
MJ¡H-YJ
MJN]IJEN]Q
]K[J
[GWH/9 XE[QJE
7¡HOUIJ[.L VHFVWQY X
+JE
QYJ[.L SQ&Y(#
SV(&Y( YHO ¡HOY)J Y
7 U J O, V[QZ.
7[ H JZ+IGJ [
L. L. X)7T)J T7 JUJEYWQY J ZPMJ
NVIJVQ>I(EVQMJ)7, ]RQE[QJSMJXN^TJ Y6IJE[QJ[HO= ZIJIJ[YÞSHOZJ
XE
79[HMO J )7MLJ XQ^
HYEZLZQE
EYWQMJYHO E
QYJZQ]K[JF+9. Z+IJ (
(
SMJP^=OH ZQ[Q]KXVWH/SV(YEZYNVIJVQXTHO
X^+9. MJIJ&Y( [TJ3(
.9
SV(]KSP=VHGMJZRJSP[HO=ZHOYJ]HO=
MJZIJIJE
QYJZQ[J[TJEI=V7Q
XEVYEYWQMJZHOYJZQ2](Y6IJE[QJLYHOE[+9]K[JAU
Q&Y((YEZ
E[+ VZHVJVHOVZHVQ
7H
MJ ¡HOYJSQ¡HOYJ]K#VYWH/
MJ V].L
MJ 2]([Q].aUHO2](
Y6IEJ [QJY L OH X]J]K[JSPEN]Q[QYVHFVWQSQSV(YHO EYWQMJX]JSRJL
XGK[HOMJ EN]QEIYW TYQ]K SPEN]Q[.L A(YEZE[+a Y XIRJU,O
XSYJ )7TJUJLS,OEZ)7TJ
7HEI1Y]K2](
Y6IEJ [QJEN]QG.S L RJL A1YS , YQaUOE]SRJL XE1YQMJUYJ]KVJ
EI=\VMJTQGWIH VJ 7QSH=VO ?O[J REIEYWQMJUMJ2]( V7QEYWQMJXO]U J
Q&Y(Y
Y6IJE[QJ[HO=YHOTH[J[+YJSGW*QN^TJN^TJ%?OSO[EVG+IJN^TJN^TJEV[[J]K
[JSP=EVG+IJVWH/YAZP[TJEQYJ [TJVHOMJZVJEZ5QYJ^HO= IQ
(YJ1YQ
[J#SPEZVHOMJEZ5QYJ
MJFJEZQYJ1YQVZ.aSHO=V?O[JANVIJVQ)HOMJM,
2VH/9E[QJYFQZ.aTSRJE]KLEVG+IJYHO X
MJU,OEN^)HOMJSPYHO XHVJX
MJ
N]IJG+MJLE]]K[JVEN^)HOMJ[.LM[,OE[+E[QLEIQYJ]H[JV7XHVJN]IJE]E[QL
U
Q&Y( Y\PG6I[ J L. EYWQMJSQYHO E
+\O[2J ]( [TJEYWQMJZ,O E
79V7QGW(V+VJ
[QZ. ZO]J[[JES[J
Y6IEJ [QJ[O=H EYWQMJEIT3JV7QU,OVS+IS J MJTYQE[+ZRJEN]Q]K
[J#VWQESQXQN^MJL %OF QSQ[
QE[QJYEYQYJ)[ - EJ N]Q[[J]K[J
A
[IQS,O]KURJY]JYHOY+J1Y#XIE)©QXI)©MK]K
7HGOHYIJE[QL1Y#
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
XIE)©QXI)©MK]KY
[IQS,O]K)7MJL VHF#U
QE]KMJMKGO]KXSYJ
&Y(SP#
Q\PO4JSHIJ&Y(SP#]RQ&Y(SPYHO ¡HOESEZTQ1Y%OMJ],ON]MJ
VWQ)7MLZ J RJSMJGIJTQE]]K[JEYQMJV-N]/ZHO= YOSOZ H J
[Q#VEYQMJV-
E1YQMJL VEYQMJYW/H E][Q#Y,Y, @XYW/H YHO R8IJ 2]( U,O VS+IS J MJ]K[J
EYWQMJS,O^[JTQXO]JVWQV7QZRJ(XGWYJE[+NG,/M,O[.L],ON]MJE[+
]KMJ]K[JNVIJVQTQE]YZRJ%OFQSQXVWQ&Y(TPMJEI[QUHOE[QL
U,OV1SKE[+XZ+IJE]K YJ]K[JEZQF#EKS#EVQ?&Y(SPV7Q
N^TJ[[JSRJL XYOSHZ O J#G)©#( EV[ÉQ#Y¡O4Q#STÚQ
7HSP
SRJL YOSOHZJ
E[+YHO XVWQ&Y( E
]K[J],ON]MJE[+YHO EI=EYWQMJGWIH VJ 7Q^[J1Y
]K[J
RGMJEXEXEUEUXHVJVQ7 EI[.L XGWIH JVQ7 ZRJZP&Y( VWQY],NO ]MJE[+
^+9. )+9. EN]Q[Q1YQ
]K[J2](E[QL]+Z . VJ
7[
H X
L. GKR>Q[JSFMJ].V+ 7QZRJ
YN][Q[TJGK[TJ
, E[+9
N]IJ]K[JYEZE[+ V&Y(N]MJV(Y[RJY
3(EGKMJ\.YHO SRJXSH[
QE[+ ¡HOYJS+MJ\QE[QL NVIJVQYEZ [TJ
EQYJV7QKE[+YT+.\MJEI]K[J
(N]MJY6IJE[QJ[OH=[JMKS+JE[+YHOZRJXZ+[JYWYJ\Q1Y
X[+YJ T(T3J[QN^TJVJVHF[É
QMK]K#SQSV([JMK]K#U
QL[J
MK]K#[]RJL[JMK]K#ZMJL[JMK]K#VQ[JMK]KUHO[.L[É
QMK]K
XS(S(
7H[J(TQ
H[É XENGG,E[+YYEZVWQYHO N]/N]MJZ=OH
[.X L GWIH VJ Q7
S+[JS+MJ\Q[Q]KEYWQMJSQ
.9TH[J)7Z,OV7Q[GWH/9T+.YWIJEIV7Q]K].
EYWQMJ^+M
LJ YJVWQV7QREIEZIQ
(V\HO V(ZO]1J Y
[.L [QIJE[+Y
(X
]JN]MJSTJ
V7QVIYJEYWQMJ[YJFO
Q
7GH OH [Q)7MLJ UMJ[]P K].Y6IEJ [QJ
[HO=YFO
Q
7HGHO
++[J1Y
]K[JVWQESQXQN^MJL EYWQMJSQSHO=V?O[J
EYWQMJSP X&Y([TJEQYJ GWE][Q ZHOYJUHO1Y
[J (XT(XT3JV7Q
[IQS,O]KYIJE[QL2](MK]KS(ZG,P
]K[JS(ZMK]KY
VS[J
N^[J)7MJL
VGOH7YJ)7MJL
ZHVJVEN]Q)7MJL
YQVO4J VE^QYJN]IJ)7MJL
X
YJESTQVESQYJ)7MJLEYWQMJSQX
+JX[+YJ X\PEN]QT
Q
VZHO]KFPEIQYJUO, S(Z)7T]J KYHEO [QL\HIJ )HMO [ J JSHEO= SQJ[TJGKV?O[J
[TJGKE[QL YWIJS(ZS,O]KYHO [TJGOGOESQJ ZRJEYQMJ XQZ,OESQJ
ZRJEYQMJGWH/VH]KZHVLJVJSHO=ESQJZRJSP &Y(N]MJZQ[.LXGKS(Z
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XENGG,E[+YSPT= H[JVQ7 T+.YWIJEI]KZHVLVJ JKE1YQMJLSPN]/SV5X
Q
QV7Q
X\HIJXY+]JE[+N^TJEI]K[J
S(Z\HIJY+]JSRJLXE1YQMJEN]Q
MJY6IJE[QJYHOJE[+9N^TJ
]J
[TJGOYHO S[H
ZQ]K[JY6IJE[QJ XE[QJYEZMJ[OIJYXHVJV7Q
X[PEIEYQMJEZ[TJEQYJ
7]H K[JSP)M7 Y LJ 6IEJ [QJ[+V. [
H JSHE=O SQJ
[TJEI=E[QL
IJN^TJ1YE
QX.E( I=REIV7QY6IJE[QJ[=HO NVTJU]H U J MJE
GW/H
1Y[JY6IEJ [QJYX
MJE
\.Y[YJZQ2](SP=XE]VEYQMJ1Y,TH[J
)7MJLSPZ.[JVJLX[JXTQE[+YHO7YJ\QZHOYJ[JNVIJVQN]RJVQ7 Y
### ZH]JN]QEGNGMJ
EYWQMJTEI[.L )7TVJ Q7 XEV7QMJ\Y .
+QZVJX[HMO J EZ5QYJSQ+ [OIJ
Y6IJE[QJ ZIJ=S+Q^P]K[J ZI=J2](^WQE
Q
+QY EUU
Q &YH/TQ
YOSESQJZRJ Y6IJE[QJL X^WQY VSYJSQ]K Y6IJE[QJL X^WQY
SQVIJX^WQV?O[F J PX]V7[ ( Q[TJGGO O]P[QZH=O [GW/H 9YEN]QZQ]K[J
Y6IJE[QJLZH]JN]Q ZIJ=S+Q[J [GWH/9YZRJ Y6IJE[QJLZH]JN]Q TMJSQ+
[J KE1YQMJL ^WQ[JZHO= EN]Q1Y[J XF+Q)7MJL XEVWQYE[QL
ZH]JN]QTMJS+Q[J G)QV7 N]MJ]Z+MJLS+Q[J
ZOH= ,O1YRJ1Y]K[J
(E[QL ¡HO
QX[HOMJZH]JN]QEG^HO=ZO]J1Y]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
Y6IJE[QJL XF+QY ]\V ]TÚRJE[+ T,OEXQMJ TO2]( SPE
79V7Q
T([IJGW \Q]K[J
]IJYIJN]Q [TJGW]JV7Q \VMJUO]J UO]J
UO]JGIJ= \RJ2 ]( \IJZWYJG. [TJG.T( XE]Y XO]JE]]K[J
E
[TJYJEZQYJ\RJL\QSRJLXMJ[,O#EXQYJENGV7QYY+VJS(NGVJ
)7TJZWYJ
>Z,O[TJZ,OYHOZRJE
[TJYJ].\RJL\Q[J>Z,EO ]V7Q
XN^0XI( GWRJ[TJGMJ U+.\QZHO= EZ[HOYJ[HOMJ Z8.EI[J
ZMJ]IJ
YEZ[TJGW]VJ 7QE
8ZYJT+]J\RJL\Q2](ZYJT+]JYHOXI(XN^0GWRJV5M)J 7MJL
GWRJ2](U+.S(],OZO]J\Q[J
]\VY6IJE[QJLXF+QY\VMJUO])J 7MJL ]IJYIJYOH ZYJ)7T^J YJ)M7 JL
V P2](IYJ[TJ]K]KYHO]SSRJL],OVWH/[TJT,O[
Q[HOMJ[RJEN]QUHO]K
[J#2](E[QL]IJYIJN]IJGW[J2]( E[QLXMJ[E,O XQYJENGYY+VJ S([TJ
NGVJYHOPZYJT,O\.V7QYHOMJZWYJ]PE>QJUYJSN]IJ]K[J]S
MJ[TJGOGO
XQVG, Y[HE]]K[J 2](V7 XMJ[O,E
\. Y+VJS(NGVJ N]IJ)7TJZHOYJ
]K[JKYHOX&YHVJ&YVH JZO]J]K[JEIQYJU,O Y+VJ S(NGVJZ,OVWYJ)Q7
N]MJYHOXE]FYJZ7IJ2](T([JZYJT+]JYHOZMJ]IJV7>Z,O\.V7Q[+.EZQMJ
U+2. ]( GEZQYJE]]K[JGWRGJ MJYOH ZYJT]+ ^J YJN]0ZQEXQMJNV0 E][Q]K
XGWH IJ E[QL IRJIRJ 1YQ]K[J KE]V. L EIQYJ U, OV7Q GWRJ GMJ Y
ZYJT+]J
7H
Q ZQ]P]K[J (XGKV7Q XF+QY GWRJGMJYHO ZYJT+]J)7MJL
[+ . G WRJ Z H OY J2 ]( ZYJT + ] J [ + . E ZQMJ )7 MJ L U+ . & YH / YH O Y6IJ E [QJ L Z RJ ]MJ
T+]JE]]K[JY6IJE[QJL ZH]JN]QY6IJE[QJLYHOJ\. N]IJMJZQ]K2]( KY
%OFQSQ)7MJL VUHOMJSRJL ZO]JIRJ ZO]J?IJ[TJGO]K (ZHOZO]J2]( V1YQV(
Y6IJE[QJYWIJVQZQ]K[JY6IJE[QJSHSEZQYJGOZO]J[.L¡HO
QY
NVIJVQN]RJ[TJZ8QZPVWH/TOE]KMJT,OZO]J[[JSRJLXT3JXZQN^TJ]K[J
%OFQSQXEI)7MJLHRQ3JJ
7HSRJ?OZYJVG,]K¡O]J)7MJLIQVJYHOSQ
ZYJG,]K[J¡O]J)7MJLIQVJXE]KMJSRJXSYJ>(HIJN^TJ[J[TJGWHIJGWHIJ
V7QNVIJVQE[+XSYJ>(HIJ)7MJLZH]JN]QYHOE
QE\+S+QG.L[JFJ[OIJY
(ZHO¡-]JE\+G.L[J#FQE1YQMJLUHO[QYHOY6IJE[QJVEN]Q)HOMJ]KFPX
Q
Q
[OHMJV7QYHOJ]HOMJXETQMJLI[J
7H[JZHO=P[.LXPX YMJXYWIJN^TJ^+J
E
8¡HOXVRJG,SPV7QX*ZH]JX
Q
7H&Y( N^TJSRJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
VGWMJ ZO]JVJ (XVWH/SV(Y SP=EQYJWQ
.9 G)QI.= ZH]JN]Q Y+.S+QV7Q
XZ+IJ THO[JSHO=ESQJZRJXNGQ>I(E[+ GMJ]+IJE[+ XVWQ&Y(ZRJ
]K[J
\HOEG[JY NVIJVQN]RJ ]RQE
TITJX
X\YJ[IJEYWQMJV7Q
XIHVU LJ O, X[IJY[[H[IJ]KXNVMJU L O, X[IJY
[IJ]KN]MJSTJ
Y FYÞEZQ
HHOYJ EYWQMJ\+YJZYJV7[J
XUMLJ)7MJL
[IJ[PN^TJ]K[J
&Y/H TQV-#·4J)M7 LJ Y,[Y=OH Y6IEJ [QJY L OH XYW/H E]]K[JU
QVWQ
TH[J[HOMJYW Y6IJE[QJ [TJUMJL2]([TJUMJL [YJZQ]K[JY6IJE[QJ@
YHOLY
J HOJYO H J,1O YRJV-YUMJNGMJ[,O[
QZYJZ+[JSRJX\HZ+IJ[YJ
S+QES[J[TJGKYX][JT3JSGW*QXTVJTQEV]+.V7QEN^T
Q]OJ
E]\Q2]( G+MLNJ ]/GWIH Y J IQ
(Y6IEJ [QJY[TJIQ
(SQSQEZ)7MLJ XQZ,O
[+YJ2](S+Q[J Y6IJE[QJXGIJ\..V7 XGWHIJVETLV( EUQMJL YQ YQ
\+YJS+Q]K[JXV7[JTQ
MJE[+ \+YJE[QL Y6IJE[QJ SOR
]K[J
Y6IJE[QJ VEVL)HOMJSRJL SMJGIJTQ]K].
7TJ[IJ YHO[IJ UJ[IJVWQV7QE[QL NVIJVQTQY Z+.Z5MJ
FQSQ
]J XQZ,O X*ZH]JTQ)7MJL SMJ
]K[J TQEV]+.[HOMJV7Q ]\V#
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
O[H# [[H EI
QE[+YHO XH)HSQ YOZQEZ[TJEQYJ# [NGQ
NVIJ V QEZ [TJ E QYJ ) 7 M J L Y6IJ E [QJ [ O H = ] . X]H O M J T ( \Q]K[J
Y6IJ E [QJ [ O H = \ . Y [TJ EQYJ E QYJ ]\VEI
Q
S+ Q [. L X GK
YWIJ)7TEJ QYJVEYWVGWVJN^TJEIV.LVWY)J 7QE]YHO T3JTQSQ1YRJL]KE[QL
EIQYJ U ,O EYWQMJ 2]( [IJ U, O TQEV]+ . & Y( EN^1Y]K[J
Y6IJE[QJ[OH= S,OEQYJZ,OEXQMJ]K[JY6IJE[QJYFQSQXIYJ
FQSQ O4 J\ P
2]( TEYQZQ
7 T J ]RQSMJ U O ZRJ
]K[J
( T EYQZQ
7 T J V
G. L Z 5MJ Y6IJ E [QJ GO G WH I J \ H
+ Q XI( [TJ H O Y J V 7 Q
ZJ\+IJEI
ZHVLJVJ Y6IJE[QJL 2]H/MJ^YJVWQZRJ TQEV]+.XV7[JE[+
XZ+ I J E YQMJ 1Y]K[J KE]V. L NVIJ V QEZY TEYQZQ
7 T J Y H O
Y6IEJ [QJIL RJ[P
ESQJZRJUMJ
.Z+IJ ZH=O [YÞSZ OH J UYJV[YJ)MOH
J Q7 FP
YO Z Q)7 M J L Y6IJ E [QJ Y Y, E YQMJ ]K[J ( Z P M J
S,OEQYJXE1YQMJI.=X[P FJ],OFJIRJ Y6IJE[QJ T+.T+.NV.NV. Y,,OSP
N^TJZQ
],OYHO EIQYJ]HOMJV7Q EN]Q]KVJ Y6IJE[QJL EYWQMJSQFYHO
XU,OVS[JV( EYWQMJN]MJ]V7 XN^TJX]WYJ S,OGO XE1YQMJ Y6IJE[QJ
EN]Q3(V7 N^TJVJ N]MJSTJHOMJE[+ XZ5,]J[HOYJ2]( VEN]Q]K)7MLJE[QLZHO=
)-[J]H[JE[QMJV7 EN]QYHOEN]Q
VRLJ XN^TJSITJE[+]K
YJ
R 7 J EYWQMJ]H[
J YJX[+MJ Y6IEJ [QJ
Q+ V7Q].EI]K[JUPR,
¡-]EJ \+Z7[.L EVQJZ2V/H MVJ 7 E
Q]K
+QV7QE[QLY6IEJ [QJY[TJ
]J[TJEYW
E
QYJSPTHVJ [TJ
,U,V?O[JFP
+QV7QY6IJE[QJ%OO FQSQV?O[J[L. ¡HO
Q
[GWH/9 1Y,/
]K[J ¡HO¡HONVMJ ¡HO¡HOE[+[[J[.L EYQMJYEZX[+YJ
[X,L[1SN^TJT
QE[+]K
### I[JYHO]+.
EN]QG.L2]([.LX[HOMJ]K].NVIJVQVWQVSHVSQ,O1YRJXQ\Q[.L
XETQMJLI[JE[+XVWQ&Y(
7H[JETQMJLE
7QYJ[JE^V[JZHO=,O1Y
[J (,O1YRJV-YHO XT3JXUYJ XEV+
G.L[QUOHE[QL )7TJT3J I[JYHO
]PE>QJ]S1Y E[QMJ]IJ1Y
]K[J EVLEZWQL]WYJY+YJG.L
MJ SP[HO=E
Q
VHSQTOVWQ]KN]×IQ[YJ)HOMJ[QV?O[JZQSRJ]+.VWH/)7TJ]+.XE1YQMJYHO
V^+.9V)+.9F.)7MJL Y6IJE[QJEN]QN]]KVJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
3(
7MJ&Y(
]\V]+Y . V+IIJ [JYOH ]+. ]PE>QJ]S2]( E[QMJ]IJE[QMJG,[L]. +. V+I[ J =OH
XT3JXUYJ EI\HOMJ
Q EXQYJNVIJVQN]RJV7Q ZPXVWQEZTQ[.LI[J
N^TJ]K[J
NVTJY6IJE]ESYV+IJZPMJEZ[TJEQYJSP=
Q+ SQXGWH/9
)7MJLX[P STJSQ[HOMJZO]JT
Q STJGO[J^HO= EZ7)7MJL ]JZJN^[J2](Y6IJ
[TJY6IJYHOYPS+Q[JVHIJVZ7Y6IJZHO=EG[.LY6IJE]E
QYJS+QE[QL
SRJEYQMJEZYE]WQLGWHGWHZP%Z,EZUHOE[QLSP=YHOEZ7ETQMJLI.=XGWYJ
XN]/[J\QG.L1Y[JSPYXE^QJE[+YHOETQMJL
MJEZ7E]V7Q]KZQG.L[.L
ETQMJYHO[([J Y,UHOSP N^TJEZE[QL SPY ETQMJZYJT+VJ\YJZ72](
XZ7X]I[JSV(E[+YZRJY6IJE]V7QXZ+IEJ ]KETQMJZYJS, 1YQ
E[QLI[JSV()7TEJ QYJYSP=YOH [IJ[IJT+. N^TJ1Y]KE
Q(Z)HO M7 JL (EYQMJ
Y )7TJEQYJZ,O)7MJL EV[ÉQV5[J EZ7SQE[+Y STJGO[J2]( [OHMJE[+
EZ7[TJTMJTQ
E[QLXHVJN]IJ1Y[JY6IJYEIIRJIRJZ7VJSRJL EI
Q
E
QYJE[QLEZ7Y¡O[J[
YJ
]J[IJ=S+Q[JEZ7SQE[+FJZHOZO]J
ZOH=V7 V
EZ7Y VE
+9E[QLFP EZ7SP&Y(Y ¡HO
Q,O1YRJSPN^TJE[QL
EZ7E]V7QY,UOH SP]KZQ2]E( ?LZO=H UHO[JVE?QMJYWVJ TQ\.YW/H IQ)7MLJ
EZMKXGIJ YHO S[H
T
Q]K].
EZ7S&P Y( YY,UOH SPFJSZ P .
7Q^H=O EZ7SQE[+YOH V.)HY
- GJ MOH J[JS,O &YVH J
N]IJ)H-YJ1Y
[JS,O&YHVJZ,OV7QETQMJSVQEZ].\]J2](Y,UHO V. YW
7Q
[JSP=YHO E
\. ]TJGW2](TE[ZHOYJ
[JI[JE[+ U+.\Q[JUHO[.L
EZ7YHO
+QFYJN]IJEZ7QJG.L1Y[J
(V+IJZPMJYHO 3(
7MJ&Y(XVRJI.= I[JX
Q[MJENVQYJZHOYJ[J
E
M,]MOH JI[JE]KL
7M&J Y(UHO[L. XVRJYX
7MJ]HMO J
M7 Y J OH UH[ O J3([]J[QY
E[QLE?QEN]QSRJL )7TJGWHIVJ Q7 Y6IJE[QJ[MJN]G.[ L X.L [HMO J¡HOESSV--
)7MJL[]J[.LTYQ]K
)7 TJ T 3J )7 TJ [H O MJ KVMJ V( N^TJ E T KY6[J 2 ]( N^TJE T >+ IJ Z [+M J
ZN]RJL
YJV7TYJ[MJFQZ[+MJZN]RJL
YJVWQX1YQV7Q3(
7MJ&Y(]S]+.
ZO]J1Y
[JVIYJIQ
()7MJLIQ
(1YQX¡O4J[YJN^TJN^TJREI
IQ
(V7IQ
(X[+MJREIGMJN^TJN^TJXHVJ
7MJVWQY3(
7MJ&Y(]S
[J
Y6IJE[QJ]KMJG.L[.L¡HO¡HO
7MJ
7MJ]S]+.YEZXE1YQMJEN]Q]KVJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
[TJREIGMJV7QI[J]S]+. ZO]JMIJY6VJ[.L
+QZP&Y(I[J\HIJ
[TJEQYJ Y6IJE[QJ[HO= XHVJE
79E
QYJZQ2]( Y+MJN]MJV7Q TQ]+.[TJZ,O
GW]K[JREIIQ
(EZQYJV7QSPYTQ]+.E]^EQMJ[HOMJV(\+IJ2](
XOIJR+IJ=E[+ZRJTQ]+.E]GW[J2](E[QLI,=SQN^0
RJ[TJYJEZQYJ
N^RJL\Q[.L ^IJG+YJ\. SEN]GYJ THOYJ\Q[QZRJ TQ]+.E][MJ[J
EIQYJ ^IJ G + Y J [TJ G + Y JY E[QL XO I J E
]K[J ( E IQYJ >Z, O \ . Y
EYQYJRMJE]KMJ S,O>+IJT(EZQYJYHO ]IJYIJN]Q GW]JV7Q \RJL[J#
2](E[QL UQV\RJLF. EYQYJRMJE]NGTJ\Q[.L XOIJUIJ N^0]K[J
EIQYJU,OM7YJE]WQS(XG+,)8Q2]([TJZ,OT( ]IJYIJ[HOMJZHOYJ\RJL[J
]TÚ R J E[+ XQZ, O YH O ZMJ ] IJ &Y( [TJ G W]J V 7 Q \RJ L ] K[J
EYQYJ R M J E]KMJ E] XO I J S( NGTJ N ^02]( TQS, O SRJ L X GK
X
SQEYQMJEXQMJ UQN^0[Q ]
HS[J SHE YQMJ SH]KZHVJLVJ
(]+.V7QE[QLUQV\RJL
3(
7MJ&Y(YE
M,]HOMJN^TJZHO=
I[J\HIJZP&Y(YTQ]+.U(S+Q
7HGHO3(GW#UHOEIYWI[JYIJE[QLYHO
ZJETQMJLI[J
EIQYJ[TJ&YHVJY6IJE[QJ]KMJG.L[QYZJETQMJLI[J]S]+.]K].
)7TJT3JZO]J
[.L (]+.YHOE[QL I[JY+IJV7QYWMJ]]K[JI[JY+IJY
+QN]MJ
XI(V7Q
7H[J]+.
YJYEVZXZJEZQYJTHOYJ]WH/
QS(T[MJGKI(EI=
[TJEI=]+Z . ]O
J [.L XE1YQMJYS()7X , \+YEJ YQMJET
IJ#ZJQZO]S J Q
VWQYHO EF4J
IJVQIJG]JSVH J V7YQY+EJ TQMJEL
7QYJE]
IJZJETQMJLI[J
YHO]PE>QJE[QMJ]IJ^HO=]K].
+QZP&Y([TJ3(#Y6IJE[QJ)7MJLZJZO]JSQ)7TJ
EQYJE]KMJEZEQYJI[JY+IJYHOS+Q]K[JY6IJE[QJ[OH=)7MJLX[P
SJZQ[QE[+Y\VMJ[TJ>Z,O#1YYJSQ?MJ]+.&Y([TJ]+.#E[QX
YJ
[TJ]OZMJ#M7YEJ ]WQS([TJ^( #XOIJS([TJZO, )7MLJ ^EQMJ[HMO JE[+]K]K[J
KYI[J[MJ
QV7QV]KVN^TJSRJL]TÚRJE[+]KI[JY+IJE
79YTMJE]V7Q
]TÚRJE[+YHO ZP&Y(Y[MJ]K[J^EQMJ[HOMJ V(\+IJ]K[J2](E[QL
Q>MJE[QJ&Y(
X\YJ]KTQ]HOJV7QV7IJIIJ
Q>MJE[QJ&Y(V7 VP
MJX[OHMJN^TJSRJ
###
7MJN]/V*ZQ]+.
GOEN]QEISRJL XT(XT3JVQ7 UYJEN]QVRJL [[H]+Y . %OF
QSQ
]+.]K#E
79YI[J]+.VWQ)7MJL [TJNGQT(]K(]+.V7QNVIJVQ%OOFQSQEQYJWQ
YEZYHOYHO
MJ[JE]]K[JNVIJVQZHO
7MJN]/]+.ZHO=EG]K[J
(]V.+ Q7 Y$)7T
J ]J]KMJ]K[J]\V]HOMJ Y
7MEJ ZQMJZ7RL#J EVQMJ
MJEZQMJYHO ]
HS[J)7MLJ T([IJZ7RZ LJ RJ].+ O[
H ]HMO J YEVQMJ
MJEZQMJYHO
SY*IJ[J
7MJN]/[J
7MJEZQMJZ7RJL]+.YFO
QXEZQMJSH[E[Q
\+YGJ IJYHO N]IJZRJ[MJUYJSRJL SEFQ]K].VMJSQNVMJT(2]( IIJ[+MJ V7
\+YJE[QJVP#SVQEI[JEYQMJI[JNV[JVWQZHOYJ]KETQMJLE
7QYJ#VQ
J
I[JYE)7QMJL7YJ#EIQYJU,OS%¥R/[E
8·4JE[QJ
FO
QN^TJ[.L N^TJ
E[QJT3JYHO N]IJE^QJ]K[J
7MJN]/ YHO
MJ[J
E][Q
.9
RJ
+JGWYJY
%OMJV7XGIJ[TJGIJYHO >Q[JZVJN]IJE^QJ
IJN^TJ]K[JNV[JT+QFO
Q
>Q[H Y]ÀHZ[JN]RJ N]IJZRJ YGW(E[QJVPSRJLXGKXSYJ GOITJ)7TJSQ
7MJN]/
IJX[+YJ%OFQSQVHFVWQYXZ+IJU)N]MJN]1Y]K[JYHO
MLJ
VHFN^TJZQ
[QO4J[YJ[JZ=Z HO RJ\MJ1Y[J1YRJ)PV--ZRJ
1Y
[J[GWH/9VHFVWQYSP[TJ]KSQSV(YHOYHOJLSQSV(]VQ
7MJN]/E]
[QZRJ
7HES[J XZ709YQ XZ709XTJV T(]+QE
E] VP[RJ2](
ZP]
HS[JIRJIRJ)7MJL YW3JYW3J ZO]JSRLJ ]+.VWH/ZRJ
7H# [GVJ[IQ
TRJYQSHOYJ2VH/YJT+Q ZO]J[.L]+.&Y(ZRJ
7H]K[J VHF XVWQTOYE[QL
ZP=SFQX[HOMJ(]+.YHO XT+VJYOIJ Z70ZHOYJGWMJ1Y[J#[GWH/9E[QLZRJ
TRJVS[J)HOMJZHO=XZ70Z+IJS+QSPE[+ VIRJFPNG,/1YRJLZHOYJE[QLKY
[TJSYJV7[TJGKZ70SRJL]+.#FXUYJUYJX[+YJYOSHOZJN]/SRJL]+.]K
VHFVWQYHOFOIJE[QJ&Y( VWQYS+IJSMJ]K[JYH O JLXHO)7MJL YHO U JL IJ[IJ¡,O
ZO]J1Y#)HMO SJ EZQYJZ70ZHO= U,O V]K[J(V7QEG[JXNVMJ
HE7 SQU
QE[QJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
[TJ]KE?Q1YQSRJL [
Q[TJ]OJYHO U(EZWQJEXQMJ N]IJEN]Q]KVJ
[TJGK[OIJYZP[TJEQYJV7QSQS,OEQYJ
7H[J#
7MJN]/
VRJL
X
+JE
QYJEI2](SHO=ESQJSP=V7QZ70[IJ
IJEM+V
7HVH[JEU+[TJEQYJ
YZRJ[HY O [J I+ JEZE[QLSPYVT3JTQVUMJNGMJ)OMH EJ [QLF.XZ70E]]K
[JOYE
QYJ]KYE
QE Y[MJE[QL[QE]KL
VH[JEU+ VMJV7QSQS,OEQYJEV+\Q2](YEZE[+Y&Y(ZQ2](#
7MJN]/E]
VRJL X
+JE
QYJEI2](
XZ70
7MJMKLV7Q]HOYU
J ,V
7HFP)7TJ)7TJEZQYJETQMJL2]( V7SY*IJ[JE]
VZQZHO=
VH[JEU+ [TJZ+. EZ5QYJVE[+)7MLJ FUHO[Q VNV.FP VMJLSQE[+
7MJVN]/
ESV(VMJESS+Q
MJYH O JYW/H VIRJ]KZQFQV7
E[+EVEI)7MJLXZ70ZO]JSQZO]J
XZ70
7MJEXKE]V.LMKE Y[MJV7QTHOSY+Q
VH[JEU+E YV[MJ]KFPY+QVMJ
7H[.L)+QEZEYQMJ\.YS,OEYQMJ
E
QMJZHOYJTVJ#XZ70EYQMJEYQMJE]ZHO=
SE]KLVMJV7Q
VH[JEU+YZRJE]KE[QLXYPE[+ZRJZQ3(V7QXYP
[QYVMJ)+Q^HOVYE]FP
XZ70
7MJEYQMJ2](EZ#MKZ70]KVJ
XZ70V$]J \HO[J#^H[JTQE[+ E[J#]+.YHO FJSPV7
VZQ#[TJEYQMJ[RJYWIJ[.L )+QY[+IJPP
XZ70
7MJ )+QYHOEN]Q
IMJY[+IJZHOYJTVJ#EXXEU+YEZ)7MJL [+IJ
SYHO Y+#IMLJV7QZRJXE^QJE[+V
7HE[QLFP (EIQYJSPY
EKVQIJ)7MLJ EN]QN]IJSRJ
MKLVQ7 )+Q[TJEYQMJYWIJES[J
E?L([TJGKZ70^HO=MKLZQEN]Q3(EZ#EG+VSQ
EWEXT[(]JE
ANVIJVQ%IJTYQVH[JUYJa
IJYOIJ##
TQ]KASHVJS+MJNGMJaY$V7U(EZWQJEXQMJE^QJN]]KSRJ
[YJL¡HO¡HOSQSQYOSHOZJZHOGWMJTH[JXN]MJXZ70]+.ZO]J
SRJL
XNGQXE1YQMJVWQZRJ
7H]K[JXHVJE\QMJ3(T(X&Y(XY.#XSYJ
X
+J
MJ2L ]N( ^TJ[L. XF+QSHV=O ?O[J XFHO [O=H U)N^RJU
L RJE]GWMZ
J =OH N^TJVJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
SHO=JV?O[J Z70[IJZHOYJE[QL X]KJ[,GK ]H[J[JZHO= ,O1YRJ[QZRJ
N^TJVJ#SHO=V?O[J
7MJVN^TJG.L[.LYEZ?QEIQMJV7QZP
QVMJN^TJS+QV7Q
THO[QZRJN^TJ)HOMJ[J
EVQMJ
MJEZQMJVWQ
.9XSYJYMK)7TJYUJLYHO)7TJX\H
7H)HOMJ]K
[JSHO=ESQJZRJEM+E1YXGYJXG.E1YQMJLN^TJET#VHSQTOX&Y(XV70
VWQTH[[ J MOH J YWET^HN=O^TJETXNGQXYIJX = S[JV
7GH Z
L . 5MJ ],VO I7 X
J QN^MJL UJS
L O, )7TJ
V7UJEL NGQYJ)T7 J 1YQV7Q
7MNJ ]/EZL
7]H K[JE
7E
7[OIJ YZRJ(X[OMH J ].
N^TJGL]. ,O
]K[JXE\QYJX\QYHO E
7EG[JE?QMJS(GWMJ E[+V7QE[+9)HMO J
[J
7MJEZQMJXE[QJVWQVWQYGWTJSP
RJTQE[QMJ
7HEI1Y2]((V7Q
E[QLS(GWMJ)7T]J OJE^QJN]]KVJ)7TJ]OJZO, YGWTS J PVHIJYEZUHO[.L S(GWMJ
E[+]\V[TJ]OJYSP=GWTS J P
7MJEZQMJXZ70
YJV[HOMJV( ],O]IJYHO ^+.9UHO]K
[J O[HX]OJYE[QL GWTJSP
7MJEZQMJ
7MJZHMJN]IJ ZP\+YJ
GWHIJYHO
EV5QJ[.LS(GWMJ]K]\VS(GWMJY
XE
79YHOEZ5QYJ]KZHO= XEIQYJYHO[.LEV5QJZHOYJ
MJ
[,G+IJ[HOMJE
8YOYÞQI.=FO
QEZEZFO
QEZEZ
FO
QEZEZFO
QYHONVMJ
TQ]OEZ+EVQMJV7Q]HOYJ]KZHO=[.LTQ]OEZ+TQ]OEZ+
YHOJV7Q]HOYJ]KZHO=TQ]OEZ+EVQMJV7Q]HOYJ]KZHO=
EYWQMJE[QJYHO[.LZHOYJVJN]MJEYWQMJE[QJYHO[.LZHOYJVJN]MJ
FJTQEVQMJSMJV[O,
JZHO= FJTQ FJ)7TJK EVQMJ SMJ
V[O,
JZH=O
FJTQEVQMJSMJV[,O
JZOH=EVEZYHOS,GWH/E)7QZOH=
J
EN]QEZEZEN]QEZEZ EN]QG. L ] K3(
NVIJVQVP
MJ
NVIJVQV7 GMJE>QJ X*ZH]JN]IJ\QSRJ
EIQYJS(GWMJ[TJ]OJY
]WH/EZ[HO=XHVJ3(
U]JS+Q^P[.L[TJ¡,O)7TJ¡,O
EYWE[+YX,O
VX,O]KI.= YHOE
8EYW
J
NVIJVQLT+JT,OYWVJTHIJE%KEGKMJTRJEXQYJV7P]KSRJ
FQSQN]IJSP@VHSQTOV7[JVHSRJLX[OHMJN]IJ]KSRJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
]WH/[HO=EVQMJ
7MJZHMJN]IJE[QL
IQ]IJ^HO=EZ NVIJVQVP
MJ
NVIJVQV7 \MJEXQMJ X*ZH]JN]IJ\QSRJ
7MJN]/]+.YWMJ][QXVWQU,OZYEYQYJSHVJ2](GWHIJN^TJ[J
3[O
QS( ENGQYJES+9[J ZPE[+YZRJ ZJ\.V7Q ¡OIJYIJG.L
QY
XIQ
ZO=H E]WQJGWMJ
8MJGWMJEI1Y[J EIQYJ2]( S,OT
Q EM+
8MJGWHIJZRJ
N^TJN]IJ[J
GOUYJ2](Y6IJE[QJL
7MNJ ]/]+. XE1YQMJUYJ]KVJ
ZP&Y(VMJVWQ XV7[J
]KZHVJLVJ EYWQMJ]H[J
YJ
7RJYQZV7Q
Y6IJE[QJ
+QN]IJEI[QY6IEJ [QLJEV+TQXEVN^TJ[L. XEEZEQYJY
Y6IJE[QJ)7MJLR(XTJYHO)7TEJ QYJYOH
7MJN]/E]^HO= U,O N^[J]K[JEYWQMJ]H[J
\Q[.L E)+[TJE)+_2](EVV7QE]KLT]KE
QMJ\QZO=H EM+ZRJXE[QJYEZ
TOVHEUQMJVH\Q2](#Y6IJE[QJLXF+QYZRJXSYJE[QJE[QJYEZ
MJL
ZQ2]#( XF+QYE[QLGOITJUJE[QMJVN]RJEL S]KFP#EIQYJZRJUJML K
)7TJVYUYJ2](XSYJ
7RJES[QGMJ%WQ[HO=E[+9
]KVJ
XZ70E]E[QLY6IJE[QJYUJLEZ)7TS J Q
7]H K2]( KE]V.LXE
[&Y(EN]Q]K
ETS(GWMJ\.YEYQMJE[+ZHOY6IJE[QJLV7QGWTJSPV
7HES
]KFP Y6IJE[QJL R(VWQYE[QL XSYJ UJL)7TJ)7TJI.=
7TJ)7TJX
+JE[+
(\.V7QY6IJE[QJL 3(EZ[TJEQYJI.= SP=>I(YZRJSP[HO= SQ3(UJL
[TJ)7TJSQYHOY6IJE[QJ[HO=)7MJLE
Q2](
7MJN]/VJZHO=U,ON^[J1Y[J
SP[=XOH T(XT3JY[TJT[ H J[ESXQN^MJLT(]+QE
2GH/NGV, ]- K[J
KE]V.LXHYYE[QLSP=XEVY6IJE[QJLXF+QTH[JGWVJSQEXQMJENVYHO
\RJL[Q]KSHO=ESQJZRJ(ZHOZO]JE[QLN]×IQ[YJN]IJ[JEI
Q[OHMJ
V?O[JE[QMJY6IEJ [QJ[9OH
]J
Q+ V7QXVWQXP
[ 7H QY
7MJN]/].Y
+ HO
7MEJ ZQMJ
3(E
T,O4IJ)7MJL VZO]JEYQMJFP[.LXEVWQY(YHTÚ Z+JZ+J
7MJ
]K[J#]RQ]K[J
+Q\.YUJLSO, )7TJSQEZ[TJEQYJYOH SP=VF H VWQ
\,YE[QMJ EV+TQ
2](
7MJN]/
QV7Q \RJLE][J X\PEN]Q^OHE= [QMJ
VZHO]KFPSP=VF H VWQYZRJSP[S O=H QYHO
7MEJ ZQMJ\RJLZOY H
J [QXZ+IJ
EYWI]JE]KL
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XZ70X[+YJEI=EYQMJ
YJSQYHOE%MJU
QYE
+2](
YJS[J
]K[J
+QN]MJ]EU+VWH/VH[EJ U+VWQYHO^H[TJ Q
+YJYVJ2]( ^H[1J YQ]K[J
+QSP
+QSQVWQYHEO [QLXHV
J H7 ZPYOIJ [TJ
Q+ Z,O]KT]JTYQN^MJL ^H[J1YQ
]K[JY6IJE[QJL XF+QY
+QSP
+QSQVWQGWTJGMJEZTQSP]KXF+QY
XZ70V7Q]KMJYR P 1( YVRJS L P XQZ,O YHO [HMO ]J MJRH) MH- J ]K[J
+QZP&Y( VWQY
¡HO
QXT3JXZQYHO Y6VJ2](SQ]KSP[HO=E[+ XGWMJGWMJ[HOMJ]MJ2](XGVJ
XIQYHTÚYHO[QIJP]K[JYQZSQEGKMJYZRJSP=X^+.9SQVWQ)7MLJ
RH2](XZO]JE[+ G+.EP]K[JSP[HO=YNVTJE
#[+MJE
G]J[.L XZO]J#
\MJEG+#XHO &Y(\VMJGWYJ TSRJZO]1J YVJVHIJ VEGKMJYZRJSPX = [+MJ
ZPE[+)7MJL[HOMJ]MJ#XVWH/SV(VWQFYJYZO]JT
Q[QIJE[+G+.E1Y#SP[HO=
YE[QLXGWYJXN]/[J)7MJLXZ7N]MJYHTÚT[QE[+E]KLZPZ[J]HOMJYZRJ
]+.VWH/T,OXE[+9X1Y,/EYQMJEYQMJ
7H2](SPE[+UHOE[QL[TJ3(GWMJY)HOMJ
Q
)HOMJ
QXZO]JYHOG+.EP1Y[JS,'Q]MJL[.LYHTÚ#Y]ÀHXZO]J#XZ70
X[+MJ _RJLG, TSRJY ZPZ[J]HOMJX[+YJ ENGQYJUJLMK GOITJUJL
MK)7TJ[IJ ZP&Y(VWQZRJ ]KMJYPR(1Y]K[J Y+VJXTJ# EUZH]J%IJ
XZ7N]MJUMJEUZH]J T(Y
YJYZRJ]+.V7QV]KV2]( SRJLX
QE[+N^TJ]K
[J NVIJVQ%OFQSQVWQ
.9 YHOJYWH/V^YJ XVWQXYWH/SJ]HOSRJL
TH[JQ[JYHOX\MJ
7QU,OE[+9
[QSRJ]+.VWH/]K].
XZ70V[HMO VJ (
YJXIRJMJXZHOVQ7 V$]J&Y( [TJEUQMJEUQYJ#
V$]JUMJE[+UMJ]K[JXZ70V[HMO VJ (
YJVWQV7QY6I[ J QJ[=OH
7MEJ ZQMJVWQ
Y \HGHOYJX)©
QJ N^TJ)HOMJ[Q FQV5 VZO]J
YWH/].LV7Q XE)7QMJLX7YJ
N^TJV7QTHOZHO=]KSTJ]MJV[YJ
#NVTJ\.UMJE
VYP
XZ70ZO]JVRJLXGKV7Q
7MJEZQMJYHOI[JUHOE[+YYHOMJ[[J2](XZ70V7QV]K
EXQMJ]+.]WYJEXQMJ
ZO]J[[J[JZOH=ZRJZP&Y(VWQYV
7MJVZMJEN]Q]KES[JFO
Q
XEZQMJYHO VQ
JI[J^WYS J RJL >Q[JZVJYHOSP[=HO VSHZY OH J VSH]KN]IJE[+VH
EI1Y[QN^TJVJZHO= Y6IJE[QJ \MJ]K[J
XZ70
YJYHOEGWQEGWQEVQEVQE
QYJ]K2](XZ70]+.YHO
7MJ3]O[J
]PE>QJ]+.)7MJL T[MJ]K[J
7MJ3]O[JYVQ
JI[JYHO EXQMJSRJL
?)©Q]K
GO
7MJN]/]+.XE1YQMJ EN]Q
MJ)7MJL
7MJ3]O[J XE1YQMJZRJ IRJIRJ
XRQV7QE[QL
+Q?TJ[JZ=OH S,O ]K[JXZ70]+.SH=O YE[QJVP1Y]K%W/H 9?TJ]K[JFQSQN]IJS
P
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
\RJLEN]QV7Q]K 2](E[QL ESG, I[JVWQYHO ]MJL2](
7MJEZQMJN]
]K[J
Y6IJE[QJ[HO=YHOE
7NVIJVQIIJ[+MJVMJR(VMJSQ],OX[HOMJ[JUMJ\Q2](
(XT(XT3JV7QY6IJE[QJ[HO=]KMJ1Y
[J]4QVXT(XT3JVWQ2](E[QL
7MJEZQMJZ7RJL]K[JY6IJE[QJ[HO=YNVMJT(#]
HS[JYT([IJZHOYJ]K2](
+QYHO][J[Q]KSH[E[Q\+YJGIJIIJYG+QSRJLXV7[J[
N]IJZO]J[.L
XZO]J]K].]HO=EUQMJE
XVWH/T,OS,O]K[JYQ#UMJTSRJ]KVJ#[TJGK
[TJ
,
7MJEZQMJYHO ZP[TJEQYJY ]G,O\VJ Z7RJL[QZRJ
7H]K[J
[GWH/9E[QLZRJ ]HO=EUQMJE
FQV5V
7HZOH=
7MJEZQMJE[+ YHOJ]HOMJENG)7MJL
ZVJEZ5QYJZ7RJL
[Q
7H]K[J
Y6IEJ [QJ[=HO T([IJZ7RLZ J RJ].+ \+YGJ L]. K2]( Y6IEJ [QJ[O=H
7MEJ ZQMJ
E[+YHOE
8\([TJZYJT(EUQMJE]\Q]K[JI[JSQ],O[JUMJ\Q[.L
EIQYJ]KE[+
7HES[J KYZRJ SH[VMJSQ IIJY G+Q
QV7Q
I[JEKVWQZHOY]J KETQMJEL
7QYJGLS . RJLX[HOMJT(T3J\Q[Q]K
7MJEZQMJ
Z7RJLYHOTRJYQTHOEN]EXQMJ)7.U
Q)7TJEQYJ)7MJLHO][JXHOTRJSVQS,O
EQYJ]K[.L [(H OMJY VE
V[+Y J)HO MJSRJL YEGWSRJVWQ XY)7M JL
[+^. YJE^WQEJ N^E]]K[JNVMJE[+YZRJNVMJ3JE[+#EYQMJEYQMJEZ
YWMJLE]\Q[Q#ENG?IJYHO TRJYWYWEZ5QYJ#EGKMJGKEGKMJRH[J UHOMJ S,
)7MJLXGWYYJ WYWZO]J2]( ]+.\. NVMJE[+]K]K[J]\V
+Q3(FOIJ &Y( EYWQMJ
U( 3([RJ\+YJ]K[J FOIJE[QJ&Y()7MJL S,'QVWQYHO
7HGHOYIJE[QL2](
+QN]IJ]K[J(XN]IJV7QXHVJETLI(]KXHVJE
79V7Q
]JXHVJE
79GIJFO
QTMJY
FO
Q UMJ[OE[QJYHO
7HGHO
]K[J XHVJ
7MJYZRJ SP [[JXQSV5
[TJVP[TJV[JYXTMKUJ[TJ
QX\HYOSHOZJ\RJLMJ]KVJ]\VEI=
V7Q
+QXHVJENGXIYJXHVJE]KMJGIJ=YHOMJG.L]K[J
EIQYJ[TJEI=E[QL
7MEJ ZQMJ[IJETQETQ\+YJ]K[J
+QSQ
[GWH/9YNVMJVWQ)7MJLX[PZPYHOJ[OHMJ
7MJEZQMJVWQ]HO=EUQMJE
YPR(1Y]K
[JYOSHOZJZGHO WMJ[QXHY]KE]WQJGWMJ[QZRJ]KV7Q]KY6IJE[QJLYHO
[TJEQYJY \VJ]K[J Y6IJE[QJY SP= O[JG+\HOMJ# ENG)7TJ^YJY
[+.EZQMJGW#SPYY6IEJ [QJLZYJ)T7 ^J YJYHMO \ J Q#X\VJSVQYUHMO J GWYJ
XRQEYWZYJ[+MJAEKaEG\VJTMJ)7MJL
7MJEZQMJYHO\VJEZL
7H]K[JFQSQN]IJSP
EKYJ[QZ7EF
R(R(GOIJU+GOIJU+)7MJLZ7RJL][J]K[JY6IJE[QJE[QLEI
[QVSYJSQ
Z7]KSHO=E]V.L Y6IJE[QJE
QSPE
QE]WQJ1Y]K[J
[[HEI=Z7RZ LJ RJ]V+. Q7 Y6IEJ [QJ[=OH EZ7)M7 LJ XI(XIQ
+Q)7TJ
Q+
Z7RJL]K[JO[H
+QIQVRJYYW,/HO#(
+QYY6IJE[QJ[HO=
+QYEIGOITJ
VHOMJGIJ= E]K[J X.(
+QV7QE[QL Y6IJE[QJ[HO=YHO YQ)7MJL Z7RJL]K[J
^HO=YQ#GWYJ]ZYJ)7MJL XH%O QZMJYQS,OT(XY)7MJL[(HOMJSQVWQYE[QL
EIQYJY XVHO^+MJL YQ&Y()7MJL ZHOYJZQ[J EI=GMJ IQ
(G+.EZQYJV7
+QN]IJE
QYJ1Y[JY6IEJ [QJLX[+YJ XZIJ[ = 1YQN^TJT
QE]ZQ[J
Y6IJE[QJLVJY+.R()7MJLY6IJE[QJ[HO=)7TJEQYJYHOXHVJ[TJXHVJV7QXETQMJL
GW2](\HIJ SHVJ\Q[JR()T7 EJ QYJ)7MLJ
+QYEYQMJYEZYHEO [QLXZ70
XHVJYHON]IJ]HO=]K[J(ZHOZO]J[QYHO
7MJEZQMJ^+YJ[JZHO=EG]K[J
E
+P
VJU2OH ]( N]IJE]U+.[QEM+E[QMJ1Y[QE]KLY6IJE[QJLXEVWQY
EM+YW]J)7TJUJE]2](E
+
[JGOEG[JS,ON]MJSTJEM+^
MJLEZQYJ
7HVJ(YEI
J
8MJT
QEIQYJUYJ[+. N^TJZQES[J
7MJEZQMJ^+YJSRJLX^+.9SQ\.V7ZPGIJ=YSP[HO=
[.LEM+\.Y
IRJIRJS,OZHOYJ[JX
YJJ[Q2](E[QLX
YJESQYJ
MJ\VMJ
TQ1YE]KLY6IJE[QJ[HO= XHVJV7Q].SP[HO=\.V7 MKEQYJYX
YJ XEZL
XYWMJ L V
7 H F P V1YQ]KFP SP [ H O = NV0[P ZQ2]( V$]J \ . V 7 Q \
Y1Y]KEZE
Q(XE[QX[+MJ
+QSP&Y(E
QYJZQ[JSP&Y( YVMJ[HO=
XHVJN]IJXH]J1YE[QL#IYJN^IJMKLZQE[+9
VJXVHIJ=GWZHOYJ[JEIQYJEI=
SP[OH= SP&Y(\,S+QE[QL SP&Y(Y SP[HO=YHO ]
HS[JE
79V7Q VP1Y ¡P1Y
VZQUHO2](&YHVJEVQMJ#2](E[QLXZ702]( EIQYJEI=V7QFOIJ&Y(EYWQMJMJ
E]KMJ
7MJ
VRJ ZOH= 4JGWZHOYJ]K[J
X.( [[HEI=REIIQ
(GIJ=V7QEGKMJ
H[JV*ZQT[MJ]K[J
Y6IJE[QJLXF+Q)7MJLXE^XEVYY6IJE[QJGOITJ)7TJSQV7QU,O]K[J
XEEZEQYJ
J VJY+.R(@ VHFVWQ
+QSQ
7MJEZQMJYEZ@
VHFVWQY)7TEJ QYJ[TJ[.+ ]H[JN^0TYHMO 2J ](
H[GJ WZY OH [J L. U,YOH G,1Y]K[J
7MJEZQMJ SHO=V?O[J
?IJS,'Q@ U,YHO X\+[JXNV[JXN^TJ NVIJVQ
%OFQSQ[HO=YV7[JP]K[JSH[VMJSQU,]J[OIJYENVQYJZHOYJ
SRJLU,E[QJYOH SH1YQVMJY^VJP2](I[JN]RJVQ7 ]PE>QJ\Q[QS[H
1Y
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
]KZHVVJL JEGKMJ
H[J2]( E[QLY6IEJ [QJ[O=H YMJ]I+ J S([E
QJEGKMJEZ5Q
J RJ
)7MJLEGKMJEZ5QJ1Y
]K[J2](E[QL[JN^0[J#S,'QE[QJVWQE
79V7Q\HOMJ#
S,'QYUJ]KGIJ=
7HZVH JLVJV$]J[+MJYS,'QTMJE]V7Q\HMO EJ I[J
SY*IJE[QMJX[+YJFOIJ&Y(VWQYXSMJLETQMJLEI[Q]K]\V]
HS[J
Y
[IQS,O]KYIJE[QL#MK]KS(ZG,P1Y[J2](E[QLY6IJE[QJ[O=H
XZ7RJL Y6IEJ [QJ[Y =HO ]K:HZOH SY*IJ E[QMJ
+[U J
HO [JXZ70V[HMO VJ (Y
SY*IJ E[QMJYHO XQ,Y O WY\
J Q1Y
[QU
QLE[QJ\,V7SY*IJ E[QMJ[Q
]KSY*IJY)7TJ\RJXE][J_YS()7MJLEXQYJ]HOMJX[+YJSMJ]HOMJ
XN]MJNG,/\RJ[TJ\RJU
QE[QJ&Y(YE
79V7QXSMJL\Q[.LSY*IJGW( NVM LJ
]K[J
+QZP&Y(VWQY YPR(2]( Y6IJE[QJ[HO=YHO SY*IJ[JE]]K[J
[JEIYWV?O[J
MJSH]JVZ+J]KFPXE[QJYEZXUMJLVWQ]K[J
2]( [Q)7MLJ Y6IEJ [QJ[=OH S,'QE[QJVWQ)7MLJ X[PEYWQMJYHO ZHY O S
J +Q
]K[J
EIQYJ[TJEI=I,IYJGMJV7QY6IJE[QJ[=OH YH
O MJMK]KS,'QE[QJVWQ
EIQYJV7T([IJZHOYJZQ2](XZ70V$]JYHON]IJS+Q
]K[JA]
H[J[
QIQ
XZ70E
TYJGWa2](]+.SHVJ
IJN^TJJ]K[JFQSQE
XZ70X[IJ[HOMJV7Q
SRJ],OT,X[HOMJ].]
H[JIQE
TYJGW2](]+.2](EZL
7H]K[J
VIJEI=REI[OIJYX[HOMJ].#]
HS[J&Y(Y
[IQS,O]K
7HGOH#
MK]KS(ZG,P# EIQYJ EVQJZ2VH/MJV7 X\MJY
U
QE[QJ&Y( GW(NVMJL
E?Q1YQE[QJVPESQ[
QIQP1Y[J(U
QE[QJ&Y( YHO XZ70X[+YJ
[YP[Y ]MJL^H[J\Q[Q]K U
QE[QJ&Y(E?QSRJL [
QXGW/]JY
7MJN]/]+. XE1YQMJ
Q?OZQ
7MJN]/SRJL \,O)7MJL 73JN]
7MJN]/
SRJL
YOSZ OH JXYW/H [
QVWQXE1YQMJU
QE[QJYSO[ÉIEJ SIQV7U(EZWQ
J Q
\O[J)-[J E?Q1YQ]K[J[
Q]+.YHO E
TYJGWXV5E)7MJL ]H[J]K[J
E
TYJGWXV5EYEZQY]KZI[JVMJ&Y(VWQYHOYOSHOZJEYQMJV-N]/
QV7Q
SYJ E S [RJ [ Q]K KYZRJ NV[J T + Q FO
Q ]Zv M J E [QJ Y H O
VQ
JI[JZQZO[IO JYFO
QYE
7YN]/GLS . RJL EYQMJV-]- K
V(YHO ENVSOIYJ
SYJ E SX
Q [RJ ] K EZQL Z H O= XH <QIJ G .L S RJ L %O MJ G IJ YZQ[. L
XT3JXZQ]K].2](E[QL S,'QXQZ,OY]K:HFQSQ)7MJLS,2]H/MJ]
H[J
+[JE[QJVP]K[JXH]QÀ JYE[QLAAFO
Q#[
Q#S,'Q
[IQS,O]KYHO
,1O YRJURJY]J]PE>QJ1Y]K@#[]RJLE[QJFXUYJUYJOYX E]KMJV7
EKYJ[QZ7EF
Z+[J2MHVJ2]( S,S
QV7 Z+[JENVQYJÑ IH%¥QIJYHO VWYJEV7QYJN]/
]KETNGMJ
XYWH / M7Q âEYQMJ V- XTO TO YHO N]/TO Z7 0 KIJ ]K@ X]KJE ZF,O à
YWMZ J RJYIO EJ SQ S[ÉKXE]KMJ[HO= Y6[J1Y]KETS[RJ VHF EU+VWH/
·[YQXE]KMJ )7 MJ L âYV« Q âT1Y :QJ EI\H O M J 1 YYO I J E SQ
S[É KXE]KMJ [O H = âEYQMJ V- @ X^H O = Y H O XV5
1Y]KETS[RJ
XHVJETQMJLI[J#
]JETQMJLI[J#
+QETQMJLI[J#SVQEI[JNV[JI[JEYQMJ
I[JXE]KMJ)7MJL[Y+âENVSOIJSRJEI=N]/SV5
YOSHOZJKIX[+YJ SYJESX
Qà [RJ]KETS[RJa GOEN]QSRJL
E
TYJGWXV5E],OT,YE[QL GO XE[QJYEZEN]QMJZ.G.L]K2](
E
TYJGW UHOEIT3JV7Q VHSQTO X&Y(XY. Y6IJE[QJL XF+QY
Y
Q )7 M J L E
YH O ENVE]EZQMJ GWEI]K[J VWQESQXQN^MJ L
XHVJ[+MJV7QZO]JSRJL]+.N^TJZ5MJE
YHO>Z,O[TJGO\.SHO9EZQMJ\RJL]K[J
E
TYJ GW 2]( U, O [Q)7 M JL [TJ 2 ]H / MJ I YJ XF+Q Y AXV5# XV5# XV5
PE[QJVP1Y]KYOIJEZQLaa ZHO= S,O&YHVJ S,OGK ?TJ2]( XV5E]K[J (ZHO
[TJ G K?TJ [ H O M J V7 Q ]
H S [J Y ASQO # SQO # SQO a EYQMJ EZT+ #
EYQMJEZT+#EYQMJEZT+
UHO2](SQOEG1Y]K[J
7MNJ ]/XZ70]+Z . RJ2]( ]K2]( EIQYJUO , X&YVH J XEY6XEV+_RJGL ], .+ T]K
[J S,'QE[QJVWQ)7MJL YHO
MJVWQY U+VJTQ FOIJ&Y(EYWQMJSQVWQ
YHZO RJEY6EV+]K[J2]( E[QLFOIJ &Y( YH
O MJEYWQMJSQE[+YEYWQMJYHNO ]IJ#
Z70KIJSRJL ]TÚRJ [/VWQYHO Z7RJ )7M[ LJ Y
OH J2]( [TJ]K[RJEYWQMJ]H]=O K[J
YE
QYJZQSRJL _RJ]L
HS[JXQZ,O #EWQTÚZO]EJ UQMJYPRS ( P XQZ,O
YHO EY6EV+]K[J IRJIRJ GW.9YQEN]Q[Q N^TJGWMJ N^TJ]KZHVJLVJ
EZ
YJ Z,OZ,O [TJ
+QZ,OV(GHO[H[J FJXHVJV7QV7 GWYJN]/[J
IJ VZHOZHO=
UHO]K[J
Y6IJE[QJLXEVWQ)7MJLSP[HO=XTJYHO&Y(#GO
7MJN]/]+.XZ709YQ
YQVVWQYE[QLE
79]HOMJV7QE?QEN]QG.L[.L)+QE
QMJSPXZ709
7MJZHOOY
VE
QYJ1YE1YQMJGO ]
HS[JYHO EN]Q]K
ET
XZ70EXQMJ].G+ ,
IJX[+YJY6IJE[QJLXF+QY
+QSP
+QSQVWQYOHO
>Q[JM7Q2](]+.)7MJLE^WQJEN^E]]K[JE[QMJ]HOMJ%OFQSQ)HOMJM,E[+N^TJ[.L
S(
Z H Y*Q#NVIJVQ#HO Q)7MLJ YEV«Q(Q[HV=O Q7 XZ70KI2]( [HMO J TQESQYJ
E]WQJ
8MJ]+. \RJL[QY YOSHOZJ EYQMJV- X\ENVQYJSRJL SEY*[]K].
EI=\HZRJSRJX[HOMJ]K].Y6IJE[QJ[=OH YHO
MJE[+YE[QL]+.V1YRJ
L ]K
2](V7SQZP\+YJ]K[J
(V7QN^RJLT
QEZ[TJGO
7H]K[J)7TJVWQV1YQV(YZIJIJV7Q
NVIJVQS,¡,OX
Q
7H [TJ3(
.9SQ
7MJN]/]+. ZO]J]K[J ]+.Y ¡HO¡HOEZ]K].
^H[J\Q[.LSP=VH[JEU+XGWH/9I.=FOIJ&Y(EYWQMJV7QZO]J]K[JU
QE[QJY
YHO
MJVWQXT3JXZQX[HOMJZIJIJ2VH/9X[+MJU+VJG,\+YJ
VRJL \,OT,YHO
YMJZ+[JG+MJL N]/E[QJVP]K[J
7MJ3]O[J
E
79V7QIHKIJ]WH/G.LSRLJX[HOMJ
7MJ3]O[EÉ G
7MJ3]O[J XE1YQMJ
EN]Q]KVJSPYVQ
JI[JYHO G6[JSP]K
7MJUHO[.L EK?Q
Y%OFQSQ
?IJSHO=V?O[J
?)©QYHOEG[Q]K
7MJ3]O[JY NVMJLVHO
JE[QMJ@ E[QMJFYJX
]J# E[QMJSVO
Q
EXQYJVQ7 E1YK%HVQ IJ&Y( )7MLJ S([MJS,O [JZ=HO UH]O K[JNVMJLV
OH JE[QMJY
EKYJ[QZ7EF
Y6IJEZY6IJ [HOYJ&Y(EZ[HOYJ
.9 %?HOV7Q [RJ
7H[J XE
79Y6IJ #
XEIQYJY6IJ# ENVQYJY6IJ# E[QMJY6IJ E[QMJY6IJYHOE[QL >V¥0(]ZHO=
EG]K[J Y6IJXQZ,O\.V7Q XNV[JU,ON^TJ2]( E\
QK(VWQY SP[HO=
)HOMJM,VWQ (Y6IJV7Q [RJ
7H[JZHO= XGHOMJXVQ UHO1Y]K[J
7MJ3]O[J
E]\+IJ[QYXESQYVMJ&Y( F(T(V7
EG[JV7Q]KXESQY
YXH)H)HOMJM,GOEG[JXGF(?QIJY][IQ2VH/9N^TJ[.LE
7]KZH]O[J
EIN]RJE[QJV7QIIJTHOYJSRJL VQ[HOMJX
7MJ _Y
Q>JFO
MJ&Y(]K
VMJ&Y(Y NVTJYVJV7Q ET[(&Y([TJUP[RJ2]( %OQ[JE[QJ
EV+ E [QJ VWQYH O <Q]IQ]K[J XZQ[P ET[( E [QJ E [+ Y H O Z RJ
>V¥ 0 ( ] KY6IJ EI
Q X)7 , = [RJ \ QET[J # XQZ, O ET[( E ]KMJ
7TJESQMJEZE\QMJZ70]K[JVMJ&Y(YET[(E[QJYHOGOITJ)7TJ#GOITJZ#
GOITJ
YJ[HOMJ[HOMJ ]PE>QJ
IJ U) N]MJN]T+QN^TJ[JZHO= UHO]K[JSHO=ESQJ
VMJ&Y(YVQ
JI[JE)7QYJY 7 JVQ7 YHOE[+]PVH]KS[.L(E[QLSRJ].S + FMJYHO
]MJ^L [H \J Q[.L S,'QE[QJVWQYHO EZ5QYJ\Q[JVQ
JI[JYOH )7VH IJ MJ)HMO VJ RJL
YHOJE[QJ FJSP]KZ. FO
Q S,'QE[QJ[TJ]KY N]IJVHIJ=1YQ[J
VQ
JI[JYHO)HOMJSRLJS,'QXNGQ[TJ]KV5V
7H#
7MJ3]O[ÉXVRJ[+MJESQ
?)©Q[TJ]KE[QL
7S H RJX.(
?)©QSRJVQ
JI[JYOH EXQMJ)OMH Z J HVVJL RJZO=H
VMJ&Y( YHOEN]Q#VMJ&Y(Y
?IJ)7TJ]KZ8[J2](
?)©QYHO ]MJ^L [H JGHOMJ]K[J
7MJ3]O[ÉYVQ
JI[JZO]JSV5YHO )HOMJ]K[J2](E[QL VQ
JI[JYHO G6[J2](
I[JSQFEN]QMJE][JXESQYVMJ[
Q&Y(
.9ET[(E[QJ1YRJR/H
YIJ E [QL S RJ L FO
Q]+ . E [QJ YQZ[TJ E Z5QYJ Z , O VQ
J I [J
IJ V 7
[QNVTJE[QJVP[J
]K:H]HY[JE[QJV7QE[QL
7MJ3]O[ÉYHOE^QJN]\QNGMJV
7H]KFP
SHO=ESQJ
7MJ3]O[É)7MJL VQ
JI[JXE1YQMJYHO XE[QJ N]RJLN]RJLT,OT,O NVIJVQ
V?Q
Q>MJE[QJ&Y(X[+.
#V)©EZGO\O[J TQV7Q
E^QJN]]K
7H]K[J T(XH]JGW
P¡H+/YJU. E
[.L XE
79^WQ ]RQ
]JUHOMJ
Q
N]MJSTJSH]À,EYWQMJ@GO\O[JTQETQMJEYQYJ)-[JGWYJV7A3]O[É)7MJL
VQ
JI[JaTQ[VJ
V7Q ZRJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
]KMJ]K[J \HO=N]MJ ^QSQPWMJMJITJY TQE])7MJL ZPV-E
SH]À,]K
P
EKYJ[QF+.9
X[+YJ[MJS+MJ[.LEZQY]¾[ÉHYWVJ )7MJL E
7%OFQSQ@
T1Y:QXE1YQMJ E[+ NVMJ ] , O
TQ[VJYHO
GOV7Q[MJSM+ J G.]L K[JSP
= 9. F+9. PTQ[VJXYW3JGW/]Y
J OH Y6IEJ [QJ\
L ,]H=EO ]G.L
[J X.(Y EYQYJ)-[J E^QJN]
VJUHOZ5MJ AE
EXQYJ[+MJ E1YK
IIJEUQMJ)7MJL S([MJS,OE[QJVEP SQ
7MJ3]O[É@ SVHOMJVQ
JI[JYHO
G6[J2](EXQMJNVMJT+QFYPEN]QMJG6[J
E])HOMJSPN^TJSRJ
?O]K
7H[Jâ]O¢H/ZJY
Y6IJE[QJLYHO TQ)7MJL UYJS+JG.L^P2]( ZPYHOJ[HOMJ [TJ&YHVJ ZQE[+9^P]K
[JSHO=ESQJF+.9PYWVJYHO[TJGKV5VNVMJE[+9^P]K
VQ
JI[JYHO EXQMJSRJL
7M3J ]O[J FOIJ [IJGOH YHONVIJVQ[HY
=O T+T. N.+ VN. V.
,O1YRJ\QE[QLZO]JZQ1Y[.LXT3JXZQ¡HO
QE[+XVWH/VWH/E]E]KYJ
ZQ[J]H]O 2OH ]( E[QLZRJZO]JZQ1Y]K[JEFU(
IJYQSEFQZO][ J .L
¡HO
Q)7TJVWH/)7MLJURJY]J]PE>QJV-SYJSYJZO]J[.L¡HO
Q[TJGOYHOEN]QN]Z5MJ
Z,OEZQYJ]K[J
FQSQE
]+.[TJ].+ ZO]EJ [QLVJU
OH MJNVIJVQE[+YVQ
JI[JV^WYJ
EXQMJ X[QXU(XEI)7MJL
7MJ3]O[J ]PE>QJ]K[JY6IJE[QJ[HO=
7MJN]/
XZ70V7QZRJKZO]JG.L[QS[HN]/VHV7Q]KY+MJN]MJV7Q>Q[J]+.Y[.LXGKV7Q
ZRJVHOEZE1YQMJL]+.V]WYJ
EXQMJVHO[Q^HO=I.=VQ
JI[J
IJYQY+J^HO=U
Q
]MJL2](
7MJ3]O[J ]PE>QJ]K[J VQ
JI[JY U`VI[JF,OY I[JVMJ&Y(
SH1YQVMJE
QVOHOI[JVMJ]KI[JXQZ,OYSP=YHO E1YQYJ
+,91Y
[J%O
S%¥R/[·4JE[QJ
X,LU.U.VQ
JI[JYXE]KMJX]KE[+)7MJL]ZvMJE[QJ
ZQZO[IO J YZRJSP[X =OH QZ,O FQV5V[[J)MOH #J \+YEJ N]G.1L Y[J>Q[J].+
E[+YOH ENGQYJES+9
QS(VQ7 YWMJ ]EZL
7]H K[JSH=EO SQJZRJNVIJVQN]RJVQ7
XGKV?O[J VHOY
+Q[[J]K[J
7MJ3]O[JY E[QMJ]HOMJ ]MJZJ\.V7 E1Y%HVQIJ&Y()7MJL S([MJ
S,O[JUHO[.LXPYZRJNVIJVQVWQZO]JT
Q¡HO
Q[TJGON^TJET]K[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
)7TJT3J KY6[JSRJL XGK[HOMJNVTJ[+MJV7QAV(E^QMJaEV5Q1Y]K[JKY
XZ+IJ\P[.LV(E[+\HIJKEISRJL]+.GMJ]K].R3JLEV7QMJ[Q)7MJL[2]H/MJIYJ
+QSQE[+SHO=V?O[J2VH/9SQE[+YNVTJZJYHOEZ7EZ7QJS+QVJSP[HO=Y
KSH=VO ?O[J M7YJE]WQ]MJTRJ)7MLJ EUQYJ\Q[.LE^QMJMJYEZE[+VQ7 U(V(
G+YJ ^EQMJ[HOMTJ SRJ\+IJ R\ H Q2]( EZ7)M7 S
JL JZQ#E
ZJE
QYJE[QL
E^QMJE[+ EV5Q[J (E^QMJE[+ N]MJ],OUMJ],O# \RJLSRJL ]TÚRJE[+E
Q
E
EV5QSRJLXGWHIJ]K[TJES)7MJL[TJESV[P1Y]KFPEVQJZ2VH/MJFYJ
V7QE[QLE^QMJE[+YIRJIRJ]HO&Y( [JU(V(^EQMJ[HOMJXN]MJEYWQMJ
EUQMJMJEZN^TJETS]H[JN^TJET]KES[JS]H[J\.VQ7 VOI#J= HOVWH/T,#O
XG+,)8Q2](Z7(2]( STJS(Z,T[QE[+]KVJKE]V.LFQXSQV7V]K
FP
[GWH/9ZRJV(E^QMJEV5Q[QYHO I,IYJGMJX¡O4J[YJGWHIJV7QZO]J1Y[J
EVQJZ2VH/MX J I(IJ[TJIJVQ7 E[QLGHMO GJ MOH Z
J Z
O, O, SH
S
H7 P EN]QN][QYE^QMJYOH
S,'QE[QJVWQU+VJG, YGWHIJVE
QYJVGWMJVEV5QESFPX1YVJXQN^MJL
I,IYJIQ
(V7IQ
(1YQV7EV5Q1Y]KS[.L(]+.YE[QL
7MJ3]O[J ]PE>QJ
[Q]K]. Z70KIJSPE[+ ,O1YRJ[QY VN^TJ)HOMJTEYQMJYHO ,O1YRJ[Q#
EV5QZHOYS J RJL V(E^QMJVWQE
ZJE1YQEVWQ]K2](
7MJ3]O[J S([MJS,O
Q
]MJZJEXQYJ<QIE
QYJS+QVJ[.L
GOEG[JV7Q
7MJ3]O[J ]PE>QJSRJL XEZLX\Y ]RQ[[J
XSHOMJ XIJYHO]K ]W,9)7,9ZQEIE1YQMJ SH
Z5MJ ]
HS[J&Y(X[+YJ
TH[JMJTQ^+J N^TJV7Q]K
### IQ\+MJV*ZQ
XG+MLXJ GKSMJLZ5MJYWMJ ]EZL
H[ 7 .L EIQYJ]+.[TJGY
O IQ\+MJ V*ZQ
]+. N^TJ]K[J KY
7MJN]/]+.YHO N^RJLT+YJSRJL ]+.]K IQE]KYJE^QYJ[J#
IQ\+MJ [JUO[ H QE
7NVIJVQVMJVWQZYJ\YJYIIJ[+MJ ]+.XT3JXZQ]K
\HOEG[JXGKYSQVIJJX
]JSPYEZVWQZRJIQE]KYJE^QYJ1Y[J
SHEO= SQJSP[X
O=H [HOMJZHYO JZO]JSP XVW/H SQYIRJ]K[JVMJSV(YEZ
VWQYE[QL IQE]KYJE^QYJIQ\+MJ[QYHO XGVJXIQ)7MJL VZO]JVN^TJ
ZO]J1Y
]K[J(ZHOIQ\+MJV*ZQ]+.)7MJLIQV\+MJ
ES[.LVMJSV(?Q
\HVJNVQZYJ\]JG+MJL V
7HESFPZHO= XVWQ ZYJG,\Q]K[J
7MJFO
MJ
X[+YJZRJ(]Y +. VZO]JVN^TJ]K].EKYJ[Q\MJEXQMJXUHOX
IQ\+MJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
V*ZQY
Q>FHSHYJVG,V( VZO]JVEI
SRJL ]+.]K 2VH/9&Y(V7Q X
Q
7H&Y(
SH=VO ?O[J GWVJ SQ YJSPVWQ
.9SV(YEZVWQIQ\+MJ V*ZQYHOIIJ[+MJ
XT3JXZQ],OT,X[HOMJZO]J1Y]K[JSV(MJ
7HSRJLVHFVWQYIQ\+MJ
V*ZQYHO
7MJN]/]+.)7MJL [+.2](ZO]JEZL
7H[Q\,OT,]K].X\PSN^MJL 2VH/9VWQV7Q
ZO]J1Y]K[J (ZHO[+.2]( ZO]J
[Q XE1YQMJ)7TJ
]J
7H]K[J ]\VY
T(]+QE
]K [TJ]+.T( S(NGQZO]J
[Q\YJ [TJ]+.[RJV7Q [+.ZO]JE[QL
XYOIX J YWSYJSQ[JEIQYJ[TJE1YQMJZPT= [ H J Q[JE
QSQE[QL
7MJN]/]+.&Y(ZO]JE]2](SV(E[QLFQV5VZO]JE]F.GWIJ\Q
QE
QYJVJ#
SV(TH[JVEYQMJN^TJV7QTHO[J(]+.YFQSQE
)7MJL FQV5 V][JSYJ
]KFP
E%MJU
QS[JV7[J[.L SMJLE[QJ
QEI=)7MJLXGWHIJV7QVHIJYEZYHO
IIJ[JIIJTQUMJE]\Q2]( XVW/H SV(&Y()7TEJ QYJYIJ
,ZWYJ ^,&O Y(
E]V7Q\HOMJGHOMJ\Q[JFHSHYJU
QYV*ZQXGWHIJYWE
QYJE1YQMJ
E1YNMQ[.LXGK IQE^QYJ]RQSRJY VHIJYEZXI(Y]J# E
8X]JYHO
IQ[TJ^YJT(V7QE^QYJS+MJ#ZYJ)7TJEGWQMJ)7MJL\HIJ\Q#E]KYJ2](UHOZ5MJ
E
8X]JYOH Y+MJ Y+MJ2]( XIQE]KYJV7QSRJX[HMO J GWIJ\Q[JVHIJYEZ
Y IQE[QL [+IJ=VJ# EXQJVJ (EG[JV7Q U
QIJY \,OEUE]2](V7
IQ\+MJ]K[JXIQE]WQYJ^O=H
YJIRJIRJ1YQVJX.(E[QLV7IQS,S(
N^TJN^TJIQY]JN^TJN^TJ]IJE]ZOH=
]K[J
##[YÞSHOZJ
ZPZQENVQYJGWHIJYHOSEY*[N]/[.L
7MJN]/]+.XE1YQMJ2](2](UHOE[QL
O[HÉE%X
Y6IJE[QJ EN]QZHVJLVJZHO= EV5QJZMJLT
QE[+YY. ZP=T¡HOYJ
],OS+MJEI[.LXSYJX
+JZ+IJG.L2](#ZP]WH/E]KYJX
+JZRJN^[JSIJG.L2](
UHEO [QLY6IJE[QJXHVEJ \QMJ
YJSQYW[J#VHSQTOF\.YHO E
QYJZQ
]K2]E( ]KLSHE=O SQJZRJ(ZOH EN]QZHO= V
]KFPPFQE1YQMJZ
L U. EOH [QLX.X
( GWIH J
V7QY6IJE[QJUJLEZ)7TJSQSQSQ].
7H]KES[JEIQYJ\]JEYWQMJ
)7TJ)7TJ\]JEI2]( FEIQYJ[TJUMJLYE[QL
IJYOIJ[YÞSHOZJV7Q F+.9&YH/
EYWQMJSQF]K]. [TJGOESQ YQZ[OIJY Y6IJE[QJ FJE[QLV7
E
QYJVRJ V\MJG.L[.L[YÞSHOZJ]K
Y6IJE[QJ[O=H S,OEQYJMJEN^G.L2]( EXQMJZQG.S L RJLEYWQMJ\+YJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
TQEV]+Y . OH ]
HS[J&Y( S[H
GWMJ
]KZHVVJL JTQEV]+. EXQMJTQ
MJV\+YVJ (
V7QY6IJE[QJYZJUMJXZO]JZO]JEI]K2]( [TJEI=E[QLY6IEJ [QLJXE
VWQY Y6IJE[QJLYHO [TJEI
QEG2]( X[+MJTYQ EN]Q]K[J SP[HO=
T(]+QE
YWEI[J#Y6IEJ [QJ[YÞSZ OH J EYWQMJ[YJ)MOH ^J =OH XZQXZQY
SH]JVEYQMJZ7FPE]KL KE]V.L XEVWQY \]JEN]Q]K[J EIQYJ)7TJ
EZQYJUHO
MJE[QLXENGXEIEYQMJZQ)HOMJ[JX.(XGWHIJYZRJ[TJ
YV«QZ,O T(]+QE
YWUMJ[.LXGK VHSQTO[HOMJ
.9 MJEM+YHO \HGHOYJEI2](
(XENGXEIYY6IJE[QJLX[+YJXH]JVYJUHO&Y(VYJ
SZHO]K].#Y6IJE[QJ
VYJ[.L XH]JVYJZ7Z7EZE[+Y2](2](E]KL
SHE=O SQJZRJY,YY6IJE[QJLFYJY
7EH I[JEN]QG.[ L L. X[HMO J ].
EXQMJTQ
MJ\+YJE[QL Y6IJE[QJY ENGQYJFQSQXIYJ MKFQSQ
O 4 J\ P )7MJ L EXQMJ[ J #
IJY OIJ [YÞS HO ZJ V7Q ]RQUYJS MJ )HO MJ
IJ
TEYQZQ
7TJZRJ
[J TEYQZQ
7TJY [TJZ )7TJUJYW]J#
GOEG[JEM+Z.Z7J)-IJI.=S,OEZQEYWQJEYWQJEZ#N]MJSTJEM+I.=E[QL
)7 T J U J L M K^
IJ = E ZQYJ
7 H ] K[J ( E M+ ) 7 M J L U H O Z 5MJ [YÞ S H O Z J Y
EYWQMJEUQMJV7Q EFQJKG YQVH]K [J (EM+]VQ4Y X.(EG[JY
Y6IJE[QJ[O=H [TJVHSQTOZ,O EYQMJEYQMJ V+IJV+IJ EI)HOMJEZQYJ[.L
[TJZXS,OT
H[J]K Y6IJE[QJL XEVWQY E\QYJ],LT
Q ZHO[QY
EYWQMJZG)7MJL Y6IJJE[QJLVOIJ=^HO [TJZ ^
IJ=)7TJUJGIJ= UJLGOITJYW]J
UJL
7TJYW]JGIJ=
N^TJ]K[J GOZHO XG+MJLXZVJ E^QJE][.L X[+YJ
YHOJLY,YHO]. Y6IJE[QJ XE[QJEYW>P[MJ
]K[J
Y6IJE[QJ
.9]RQE
FYHOE[QL],EO ^QJNMVJY+YX J N^TJSQ[MJN]]K
ETEIQYJV7NVIJVQ%OFQSQ
.9,O1YRJV-)7MJL¡HO
QZO]J\,OE[+YHOXSQ
XN^TJNMVJXUMJV7QN^RJL]KVJ
Y6IJE[QJ F+.9&YH/EYWQMJSQXN^TJ ]\V)7TJYE[QL TH[J]WYJ
T
Q]K]. KEZ5QLEZ5QLE]KLE]KL EN]Q[Q]K Y6IJE[QJ EYWQMJ[OIJYI.=
EXQMJTQ
MJ\+YJ2](
YJ]HOMJV7QE\QMJE\QMJ)7MJLENVQYJEI[.LY6IJE[QJL
VQIJE[+ EZZ8Q ]K]K\. Z+MJLEVWQ E]WQYJY+JYOIJ]K2]( EYWQMJ)7MJL
[YÞSHOZJ1YQYXUMJL Y+QNGQV-YXZ+IJYWJSYHOK\YJ
IJYOIJ
[YÞSHOZJY X.( XGWHIJV7Q NVIJVQN]RJ
7H [TJGO[RJESQ [YÞSHOZJ#
]RQE
\H]J\H]J1Y.[HO=SQ
7H
VRJL EI
Q# NVIJVQL ]RQ[[J VZHOMJZ8Q[HO=
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
X[+YJ \QSRJLEI
Q N^TJEI[J Y6IJE[QJ X&YHVJ&YHVJ EXQMJNVMJ
E]KYJENVQYJG.L2](([TJGKE[QLY+.]K2](
SHOE= SQJZRJV1YQV(V7QY6IJE[QJ ZHY O J)HOMJZQ]K[JENGZ7VJ
V7IJV7IJ)7MJLUYJ)HOMJZQ]K[J)7TJ)7TJSMJ
VRJLSMJ¡HOX[+YJ Y6IJE[QJLYHO
[TJ)T7 J)7MLJ X2]( ZO]JGM+ LJ E]]K[JSHE=O SQJZRJ(XG+MLX J E
YHO Y6IJE[QJ
ZYJZ[ 8 ZJ Y OH
J [JXE1YQMJX
MJEIQYJV7 EN]Q]KVJ[YÞSZ OH ]J RQ
E1YQMJL Y6IEJ [QJXNVMJYWZ J Q]K[JKYY6IEJ [QJ)M7 LJ 2%[ H S H 5]KEVQY
VWQ\HE[+9UYJU,
[Q
J#XNGQEYWQMJSQVWQ)7MJL \HE[+9
[QZRJ
]K]K[J#XUMJLNVMJLX*ZH]JTQXO]JVWQ^[J
SRJLXYWH/ZRJ]KMJ]K
[J[N^RJN^RJ)7MLJ Y6IEJ [QJYE^IJE
]HOZO][ J [JZQ[JYH O [
J MOH J
Z+[JZ+[JZ]JZ]J U,ON^[J[QZRJZO]JZQ]K[JSHO=ESQJ Y6IJE[QJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQXN^TJ]. UYJ
7HEI]KVJJ
O[ H )7TJXYOIJVQ7 Y6IJE[QJXE
&Y([.L TQEV].+EXQMJ]K[J
(TQEV]+V. Q7 S,O UJV7 EZUJ
QGHOM)J I- J EZQYJSQEXQMJ]K[JUIJ)7MLJ
^+. G+.\O[JSRJL TQEV]+.]K EYWQMJ[OIJY Y6IJE[QJL 2]H/MJFYJ YOZQ
EYWQMJSQYW]K[JKZRJSPRLZ , =HO V?O[#J TQV&Y/H TQZOZ =H RJV?O[#J
SPY = ], KSPX = E]XZ+I1J S>QE]SRJL SP^= GMJYSQYHO Q[OE%#¡P]E%
)7MLJ >(E%PGOMH J [JSP=SQSIJ[QYX*ZH]TJ Q)7MJL SVHOMJ SPX = E^Y
SQYHOU
QIJN^TJETGWM[ J QSP
.9UHOZ7SRJL YOSOZ H JYE, 1YQMJLY6IEJ [QJL
V7Q XE[+E[+ [S(&Y( T[MJZQ]KE[QL[J ZPMJS,OEQYJ ]RQ
X
RJXGWMJ XUMJ[ L 1P Y[J#[TJEYWQMJ[RJX[P[YJ2]( XG+MX LJ ZVJ
X[P[P
1Y[JSHO=E]V.L (\.Y[TJEQYJN^TJ[.L NVIJVQEYQMJEZY
[YÞSOZ H [ J YJ
IJEM+E1YGW/H 9[.Z L O=H EYWQMJUYJV[YJ)MOH F J . YWI
J TJ
7Q[J
GO YOZQEYWQMJSQYE[QL SP V)7TJSYJ[.L FQSQE[+ X[MJ
PGHOMJ[QG,
2](EYWQMJ\+YJ
N]IJ2](FQE1YQMJL]KZHVJL#(EVG+IJYHOEN^
IJ
Y6IJE[QJT3JTQ]K[J#
ZQ[.L XEN^YE[QL%OXU,O XV]K].E?Q1YQ
S+IS J MJ]OY
, (ZOH FEXQMJNVMJE
X[+YJ]OH/¢ Z[ J TJ3( V7QS,O GOZXHO ]J[J
Y,#·4J#H
H(EI
QV7QY,YV
YHOX[H[JFE[+YE
QVWYJEV7QYJ
FV7Q]KVHVHZO]JG.LSV5XZO]JXQZ,OXYW,/MJ[.LXH]ÀQJ)7MJLS,O\Q]K
[J(XU,OXVE1YQMJLY6IEJ [QJXEN^
[QYSP[=)HO 7TJEQYJVEXQMJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
VNVMJN^TJ1Y
[Q?QY,E1YQMJL].N^TJ[J(YT[MJ2](Y6IJE[QJY,[
Q
YHO ,O1YRJZQ[Q Y6IJE[QJ [YÞSHOZJX\H# [[H)7TJXTV7Q \]J2](
(,O1YRJGWYJ GHOMJVQ^O=H N^TJZQN]IJ[J XEVWQY E[QMJ]IJZQZHO=
Y6IJE[QJLV7QXE
[&Y(U,ON^[JT
QYHTÚE]ZQ[JZP&Y(VMJVWQN]IJ
S[H
]KVJ# Y6IJE[QJY TEYQZQ
7TJ EYWQMJSQ]K TEYQZQ
7TJ
EYWQMJSQ[HOMJ[[H)7TJTYT[MJ2](O4J\P[IJF+.9SMJ[IJ[YJ
VRJLTRJVW3J
7H[J¡HO¡OHF+.9P
MJEIQYJ\]J)7TJ)7TJ)7MLJ 2](VJO4J\P
[IJ[YJZ5MJ 2](^HO= S,O)7TJ1YQVJXEVWQYSP[HO= EM+E
E1YE
GWMJLGWHIJ
[J Y6IJE[QJ O4J\P[IJ[YJEIZ5MJ SP[HO= EYWQMJT
H[J
E\QYJ],L
[Q[TJ)7TJ]H1O YQE[QLVJKE1YQMJLXEVWQYY6IJE[QJLYHO
X1Y,E]]K[JTEYQZQ
7TJXTQT[HOMJ]MJ E\QYJ],LE1Y
EZ5QYJ
ZHOYJ]KZQE]KL XEVWQ U) Y6IJE[QJ ZYJG,]K[J UMJ
.[.L
EYWQMJSQVWQX[+YJE\QYJ],L
IJ
RJ
+JS[JV7[J[.LT[HOMJ]MJYHOY6IJ
E[QJEZ5QYJZHOYJ]K[JT[HOMJ]MJYTEYQZQ
7TJ\YJEM+UJLMKYW]J
]HO]K[JSHO=ESQJZPYU)N]/[J#FO
QSGMJYSMJLSZHOT(V,[J
EZ5QYJZ8Q[MJ2](V1YQV(T[HOMJ]MJFO[JX^+.9YY6IJE[QJLYHOEG
P2]( ZPE[+9 TTJEV]K[J X^+.9 3YÞ`Y ]KEVQY W(XH]JGW
ZOT
#
Y6IJE[QJSP)7MJLVWYJ)7QGWMJUHOMJE[+9
]KEZE
QSPYY6IJE[QJLEZ5QYJ
Z8QYHO1YRJLZ,OEGWZOY H J2](TYÞ0E?QMJ],O \.\RJLZOY H J[J(EIQYJSPY
Y6IEJ [QJY L OH ETLETL&Y( 1YRJ2L ]( FQV5VEN]QF.EYWQYJ¡]O &J Y( ZHO \HMO EJ I[J
)7TJVHITJEZQYJ1YQZHVJLVJ \MJ[J Y6IJE[QJL TH[J\.V7QE[QL )7TJIQ
(
EZQYJ1YQ[J¡O[[ J
YJFO[JX^+.9MJ[TJ3( YY6IEJ [QJOYSYJSQ
EXQMJS+Q)HOMJ2](ZHO=MJEN]Q]K[J(U
Q&Y(YY6IJE[QJEI[.LEYWQMJ
EUQMJYO[ H XEUQMJV07 N^TJEI[JY6IEJ [QJZRJ[,GKE]KYJ
H7 QYHO
XNVIJU,OZ7VJ\+YJE[QL[Q]. X.(EI= RGMJV7Q]. O[H XEUQMJV70
Y6IJE[QJLYHOZQE[+9[J¡HO¡HOF+9. ].P]KE[QLVJUHOZ=HO Y6IJE[QJLYHOU
Q
ZOT
XZ+IJTH[U J OH EI[J#SPYY6IJE[QJY L HO SVHOMJSHVO= ?O[J NVIJVQTQI.=
O4\ J P[IJF+9. ].PETGWM[ J QZHO= OXEUQMJV07 YEN]Q]K[JX.X ( GWIH VJ Q7
Y6IJE[QJYU
QZOT
SMJ[.LXE
79^WQESSVHOMJ)7MJLNVIJVQEYWQYJTQ
X[IJE[+ [YJEI[J U
Q&Y(Y Y6IJE[QJLXE] XEV5QJZMJL&Y(
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
EV5QJZMJL\Q[Q Y6IJE[QJ SH]K[J SPY Y6IJE[QJLYHO [¡O[JFQSQ
E[QMJ X]HO SMJE]VJZHO= UHO\Q]K[J KI.=]. Y6IJE[QJ NVIJVQTQ
O4J\P[IJF+.9P
IJU,ON^[JZHOYJ
]K[JX.(XGWHIJV7Q]KEVQYZOT
YEG[ÉEYQZH]EJ YWQMJXO]&J Y( ZRJN^TJEIE[QLY6IEJ [QJY L OH EN]Q]K[J
Y6IJE[QJ [TJ)7TJ ]HO1YQV7Q N^TJ[.LX[+YJ X.(
YJY T2]( Y6IJE[QJ
EYWQMJZGE]
IJVZHF O P [.LY6IEJ [QJLXEVWQ\,TQE
2](YWH/E1YQMJ
7MJN]
IJ &YH/TQ]KES[JNMMJG,O1Y
[JN]×IQYXE[+XNVMJ
V[P1Y[Q]K].]RQXUMJL Y+QNGQ[Q
J XSYJX
+J V[P[Q
J
Y+QNGQV-
7EH IE[QLZYJG[ , L. T,GWIH TJ ,RI8 JE[+[IJ^OH E[+YV[PN^TJEI[Q]K
SP[HO=YHO XT3J¡HOESEZTQ[JSP[HO= EYW>P[
QYZRJY6IJE[QJL
XE]&Y(VQZ7[J UHOE[QL Y6IJE[QJYXEVWQXE]¡HOMJN]SRJL
EKYJ[QZ7EF
ZY4Q VN]]KFP# Y6IJE[QJY SP[HO=YHO A[O,Z+IJSPa SHO=V?O[J X,VMJ
SPE[+ZHO=VUHO
.]KFPGO
MJUHOMJ
[.LN]×IQYXU,OV7Q)7TJ3()7TJFYJ
EN]EN]ZRJZRJ N^TJS+Q[QEIQYJ]HOMJV7QE]ZQ]KZHVJLVJ
Y6IEJ [QJNVIJVQTQO4\ J P [IJZHYO VJ [
H QYHOEYWI]JE]WQJ
M8 JEI]K
[J(SMJ[IJE1YQMJLY6IJE[QJV1Y,/FPES[.LTH[JMJTQ^+J1YRJ)P
^+J NVIJVQFQSQTQE])7MJL 3JEYWV-IJ\. E
QYJZQ
[J]KEVQY
ZOT
Y ]W0 # E
7NVIJVQ)7MJL E
7E?QMJ)7MJL EG[JZJ V+IJEYWQYJTQVWQ
FQSQ
]JSMJ1YQ]K[JFQSQTYQ^+.9TRJ],O)7MJL[HO[YJEN]QMJZ.V-
EZLZQ[.L I.= XS,\+YJ EZLZQ[.L SE% YHO
U
Q&Y( E^EVQMJ[MJY ]HO=GW]K[J NVIJVQE
7E?QMJ TQE]YHOE[QL
NVIJVQY\HYVWQ SMJ]K[J EIQYJU,O [IJU,O)7TJ E
QYJZQ]K[J
TQEV]+.&Y(YGOV[JZV7QYWMJ]
IJN^TJ]K[JKE]V.LE^E^K
(
YJEI=V7Q[YÞSHOZJ EYWQMJSQEGKMJEUQMJVWQYS]H[JEV7QYJ
IJ
TRJ¡,O]K[JEYWQMJSQEYWQJ[TJEYWQMJZ,O
.9\YJYJEYWQY J
SP[HO=TRJ¡,O
Q]K1Y[JX.(\.Y6IJE[QJZRJ]KS+Q]K[J
Y6IEJ [QJ[Y =OH OH E
8[H Y
O, IO J E[QJE]EGS+Q]K[JEYWQMJEUQMJ
IJEZ5QYJZ8QEG\Q[JEZ5QYJZ8Q]H[J
YJYIYJN^IJVJH[JEU+YHO
XVWQ&Y( EYW>P[MJE1YQMJEN]QZHY O ]J K[JEIQYJ[TJEI=VQ7 SYJUMOH
J Q
<QIYHO Y6IEJ [QJSQ+ UHMO
J QX
Q
7\ H V, Q7 TEYQZQ
7TJ EZ5QYJZQ8 [MJ[J
VWQV1YQV(VQ7 X.( ]RQSMJUX O [+YJ Y6IEJ [QJTQEV]+. EN^
[J2]( E[QL
UIJYQTTJE
+\Q[.LZYJE
+TMJXNGQ)7TJEQYJ)7MJLY6IJE[QJZPE[+9
EVG,
[JXU,OV7QY6IJE[QJ XE
+GWJG,
]K[J
IJYOIJ2VH/9V7QZYJ^YJ
RJUHOMJ
QE]KMJVWQT+Q
7HV7Q]KSHO=E]VJL
S[MJEYQMJ EUQMJZQ[.L Y6IJE[QJL VH[JEU+Y [TJNGQUHOMJ VS+QG.L#
Y6IEJ [QJ\HMO EJ ISRJL UHOMJ\.V7MJZQG.[ L JSPY6IEJ [QLJYHO NVMJE[+9[J#
EIQYJ\]JN^TJZQ[QE[+]
HS[J&Y( SH2]( ]K2]( KV\PUIJFPZQGMJ%WQ
Y6IJE[QJX*ZIJS+Q
IJ
++QV7\+YJG.L[L. I,IYJGMJXHVJNVMJY+MJ Y
VJSQVJIRJT
Q&Y(N^TJEI[JY6IJE[QJ\+YJGQ+ VRJLU.UV. Q7 [IJT(
\HMO EJ I[.L ZP&Y( UJEQYJE
79Y6IEJ [QJP[O]\ J MOH 2J ](
7GH OH YIJE[QL]K[J
UJEQYJYXF+QYXZJV7Q#SP=[TJ^YJV7QSQEZEQYJ
Y6IJE[QJL^GMJX]KXMJ#[NGQ[TJ^YJV7QSP=SV(MKEQYJSRJ\Y .
EZEQYJYY6IJE[QJL EV+TQVHGMJE[+SP[X OH= QZ,OYUOV+IJEYQMJE[+
E]1Y[J#Y6IJE[QJ[HOMJ [TJ]KV7QE]WQJ
M8 JEXQMJNVMJ]KETE1YQMJI.= XNGQ
UOVWH/T,OE]KL3(&Y([TJEQYJYY6IJE[QJG+.G+Q]+. ZYJEUQMJXN^TJV7Q1YQ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
U,OV]K[J Y6IJE[QJ
]JEENVNGQV7Q %OFQSQ NVIJVQZY4QE[+
VE]WQYJEXQMJ\HVJ^HO=# MK]KS(ZNV.^HO= V7Q1YQU,OV]K[J Y6IJE[QJ
AS+QE[QLVJaZHO=SP[HO=YHO)-[JUYJT3JYSP[HO=\.V7XVWQTOYHO Y6IJE[QJ
N]IJE[+9E[QL V7Q V?O[JFPUHO[Q IRJIRJYEZV7 VE[+VH]K
GOV7QNVIJVQN]RJYHOEZLZQE
G+MJL)7MJLY6IJE[QJN]IJZQ[.LXGKN]IJE[+9
[.L
XES,OEQYJY Z+.2]( XNGQSPXQZ,O O[HYV«QTTJX[+MJY
Y+JZ+IJ1Y]K[J
GOX\H Y6IJ E[QJL
.9 ]RQE
FG
( YHO ¡HO SQV7IJY IJT+ Q
EN]QG.]L K2](#EN]Q
MJE]ZQ[.L G,TQGWYJVWQYHO ?IJZO]J ^,OY+J VEN]Q]KFP
(TH[J\Q )7MJL]. Y6IJE[QJL ]RQE
F N^TJ
]JVWQ\.V7 V7[JSQ^+J
N^TJ
]JVWQYHO EN]Q]K3(VJ
### T[H\HVJNVQNGMJ
Y6IJE[QJ
IJYIO J[YÞSZ HO VJ 7QTQSMJ[IJE[+T[YJ2]( V1YQV(VQ7
XQ4Q]HOMJVWQY ]\V)7TJEYWQMJSQVWQ [YJSRJL SMJ[IJVWQ [YJ
E
QYJNGMJV7YMJZ+[JG+MJL Y6IEJ [QJLYOH E]]K[JY6IJE[QJY(YMJZ+[J
G+MLY
J HO NVIJNVIJZYJGZ , OY
H J[J#FQE1YQMJLZ.UEHO [QLY6IJE[QJEYWQMJ[YJ
YQZ[TJ)7TJEZWQS L Q+ V7QYHOSHO=E]V.L(X[HOMJN^TJVZQFPA[TJ)7TJ[IJa
ZHO= XVWQEG[.L X[IJZHOYJ[YJZHO= XE[QJYEZ1YQE[QL Y6IJE[QJ
^WQ]K[JY6IJE[QJXHVJN]IJS+Q
[JEVQJZ2VH/MJYU
QIJ)7MJL 1Y[J
V[JYOSE]]K[J
YJXIRJMJ1YQE[QL]P]MJEI[.LY6IJE[QJLXE
VWQY
+QEUSVQ)7MJL [HMO J]MJ1Y[JU
QYY6IJE[QJL E
QKTHTTJ[J#
SP=XUHOYYHOJE
QKV?O[J#TH[JE
QKZRJV?O[JE
QKZY4QY
]EQMJ[QZH=O SPYUH[ O JYOS
IJZRJ[TJIRJ].
7[ H JY6IEJ [QJL
YHO \HVJNVQ ZYJ\]JE]
VJ KE]V.L X.( YO\,OY Y6IJE[QJLX[+YJ
VN^TJ)HOMJE1YQMJZRJ SVQY SH]K[J XGYJXG.VWQ EYWQJZ8QVJL
IRJZVJSPY].E]]K[JY6IEJ [QJ1YYJN^0V)7MLJ T[HZYJ\]JZY OH [J .L
Y6IEJ [QJEL
QKYEIQYJ\]JUJ
YJ[IJG,EI[J(1YQ\.VQ7
U
QIJYY6IJE[QJ ES+XQIRJE
QKN^TJEI[J UHO2](X.(X[HOMJ
UYJYOSEI]K[J
+QYEUSVQR8IJ1YQGWYJYOH EN]QN]E[QLU
QIJ
YN]/, [JX.([[JEQMJYQ
VJYO
Y6IEJ [QJY L HO FQEUV7V[HY
O Z J 5MJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
2]([Q].#YWIJ[QSP&YH/YJSZHO ZO]J]KETZHO= U
QIJYEN]Q[JZJ
ZO]JSQ[TJEQYJY 1YYJN^0V[TJEYQMJ
7QE][J EUSVQY
1YYJVENGV7Q&Y/H N^0[TJTGWR2J ]( YWI&J Y/H TYHO Y6IEJ [QJL RQZYJVQ7 GWR[
J J
2](E[QL SPYY6IJE[QJ[HO= ZMJVQN^TJ2](ZHO= EN]Q]K[J2](E[QL SPY
&YH/EN^#1YYJVYHO Z8[JZHOYJ[J#\HVJNVQ]+.¡HO
Q2](S+Q]K2](Y6IJE[QJL
VJY+. R(MJVWQYZRJZP&Y(VWQ)7MJLX[P ZYJ\]J]+.V7Q
7HEI1Y[J
SP[Y HO= A1YYJVZMJaZHO= Y6IJE[QJLYOH XVRJEN]QMJ[]J1Y[JZYJ\]J2](
SH]JV1YQFP#Y6IJE[QJEI\HOMJEYQMJZQZHO=[YÞSHOZJYHON]IJZQ]K[J
Y6IJE[QJLE
QKE]WQYJYMJ[QU
QIJ
.9EUE[+T+VJZOH=ZQ#KV7V?OO[J
EUU
QE][.L 1[QEYQMJZHO=ZQY6IJE[QJ VEG+.)HOMJ]K
### 3TÚQETQMJL
N]IJ2]( S[H
VJUO
H MJY6IEJ [QJL[YÞSZ OH Y
J EYWQMJXH]J EYWQMJ
TQ[YÞSHOZ]J KEYWQMJSQXVWQTOYXEUQMJV7QEI1Y[JXEUQMJ
E[+YHONVIJVQ2VH/9E[QJE?QMJVWQXVRJE]\Q[J[EYQMJ#N]RJ#]O,#
S\,O# ].GP# TTJYHOMJ# ]MJ# XMJ XEUQMJE[+ Y6IJE[QJEI[QY
]O,EUQMJV7Q#[TJEQYJ[TJGIJEI
]K[J
[TJRIQ
(GIJ=V7QY6IJE[QJTQZO]JEI[OIJ
,[QYUPUPRR , ,
XS,E1YQMJL XQ¡O,]WYJS+Q]K[J EVNVIJ 1YRJLZHOYJE[QL X[IJ&Y(
EYWQMJSQ[TJEQYJ# VYWIJVVQ¡O]JI.= E]WQLGWHGWHZP# YEQMJY[VJ
N^TJEI[QE[+9=
[JEYWQMJSQ[GWH/9YSP=YHO \HIJSHVJ\Q1Y[J
SP=VH[JEU+
MJ[TJEQYJYSP=E
QKXN^TJSITJYHOY6IJE[QJLXIQY]J
FJSPV7E[QL VEN]Q)7MJLUHO2]( EN]QN]]K[J (ZPY
RJTQ
7H[J[.L
RJTQY3TÚQETQMJLVN^TJEIZOH=XGOX.(3TÚQETQMJL]PEI[Q[.LVH[JEU+
UYJEN]Q[QY3TÚQETQMJL)7MJ^Y =OH [TJIRJSQ
7[
H JSHY
O U
J
Q
7Q
VJ
Y6IJE[QJ[HO=SHOYJU
Q
7QVE[+9]KSHOYJU
QXTQX*ZH]JXH)HYN]Q
[YÞSHOZJU
QIJ E
QYJZQ[J O[HXEUQMJV70Y ZPZ8[J2](
U
QIJ]MJLZHOYJ[QE1YQMJL E
QYJZQ[QO[HXEUQMJV70YV+[TJ ZMJ
FQSQMJU
QIJYSPY = OH ESESGWQGWQTVJS]J1YRJ#L G4T3JTQ2](E[QL
1YYJUPU( [HOYJZHOYJZHO= GHOMJ]K[J ZPIQEZ
.9 SPMJGWMJVWQYE[QL
EKYJ[QZ7EF
[TJVWH/E[+[JU
QIJ)7MJL O[HXEUQMJV70\+YJS+Q1YE[QL SP[HO=
FQSQ SP[HO= ZPIQZRJ]MJI.= ZYJEYQYJV7Q TH]J]O[(E[+ T+]JE][J
[TJEQYJ)7TJEQYJYFO
QO4EJ [QJYOH ]K[H]EH SQFK
+[1J Y
[JKYNVIJVQVWQ]
EZQYSQVWQ)7MLJ 1Y/, UEO, Z[HMO J ZO]EJ I1YX[HMO J
ZO]J[Q]K].
ZPIQ XH]JE]WQJS+Q]K2]( EIQYJVIYJV7Q ],OV7IJ]. SP=TQ]+.E]Y
1YYJUPU(]OZMJY[HO=E[QMJV[HO=
ESFP2](E[QLRYXN^TJSITJYHO
SPFQV7VV7[JVH[.L],OVWH/
### X¢H
[J)7MJLEV7QJX[[J
EZQYUHO[Q XVWH/T,O[Q]K]. ( AXVWH/T,Oa E[+\.V7 [GWH/9YHO
GOEN]QVRJL >Q[JZVJV7QE[+9
]KVJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJXEI)7MJLY6IJE[QJY^GMJYHO[TJ)7TJ
S,O &YVH J YIJE[QL[L. XEZLX\
7]H K[J^GMJYY6IEJ [QJGOITJ)T7 S J QV7Q
XEVU,OS+QZH=O VOUHO ^HO N^TJEI
7Q[JSPYY6IJE[QJ[
O=H Q+ V7VHMO )J T7 U J JGIJ=
E[.L 2VH/9YEZV7QEI]K[JSPY1YMJIQ[[J[.L IQZRJV-
7H[.L ^GMJ]K
SP=XQIRJGWYJ Y6IJE[QJE[+9[Q[TJG]O K].X.KYXH¢
[JYHO SPXT+.&Y(
T+.EI[.LKSIQ]KX¢H
[JE]KYJGWMJEI[Q#Y6IJE[QJYXE^LYHOVN^TJ)HOMJ
[QE[+ ZO]JEI[JZO=H EYQMJEYQMJV+IJV+IJEN]QE[QL ZYJVG,]KFP
XE^YX¢
H [JZHOYJTQ[J#EV7QX J [[JZRJT]JT]JZ]O [ J J
SP=XZO]JY N]KN]QGW2]( XQO(' XSYJ
7RJEU E^QJ^HO= SPTH[JXQ
\YJSIJ[QYXSYJ
R 7 JEU].S[/E[+E
8N^TJVL. IRJ\YJTH[JMJTQ
[JE
QKG]JSHVJE]WQYJ2MHVJVJLEUE[QL EN]QVEI)7MJLE[QLSPY
XSYJ
R 7 2J ]( EIQYJ]M+ VLJ RJL X
HEVE[ÉWF
O QYHO ETQMJ^L P GWM[
J Q#(YV«QV7Q
]+MJLVRJL FO
QMKUPV7Q EIQYJU,OXUPYHO ETQMJLV7Q E
7Y ]O,V7Q
?IJ
7MJX>ªEK4Y Q[JZ,O
2]( ]O[ , TJN]RJZ,O E
8E[+ EM+E[+ XZ5,]J
E]K YJEXQMJZO])J HOMJSRJX\HX¢H
[JE]KYJG[ .L JVWYJZ,O [TJ^YJ
Y)+QVWYJZ,O#[NGQ[TJ^YJYUH[JVWYJZ,OX>ª!UH[JI.= EK4!)+Q
VH=O X>ªEK4[+M[ J QZHO= UO[H J\MJEXQMJX*Z]H JFQSQ)7MELJ
ANVIJVQ
%OFQSQV7 ¡HO
QXPVWQaTQXO]J TQ)7MJL XNGQ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
¡- ] K
Y6IJ E [QJ L
XE^YZRJ XNGQNVIJVQ X¢H
[JXOHVWQZHO]K].#
?IJ&Y(X>ªEK4YHO
XQYW[J#SHO=ESQJ X.K&Y(Y$Q
(]. UOH[QE[QL SP S[HVVPVHFP
SPY >+.)7MJL &YH/]VJESQJZRJ N]KY N]QVN^TJ S+Q]KFP XU,OVE[QL
XE^SQZ5MJ ZPV+. N^TJS+Q
]K[J
Y6IEJ [QJX
L E^XHVY J ZPZVH JZP YQE[+TO
]JN^TJEI[JX¢
H [J
SVQ#FHOE[QJ#EV7QJU
QI.=X.(ZHOG]JE1YQMJE1YQMJZPE[+SP=XHVJZQTO
[JY6IJE[QJSP[HO=\.YXVWQ&Y(E[+9G.L^P]K[JSP=YHOJSPX¢H
[J
SVQUHO[.LSPY X¢H
[JYWVJV7Q]K[.L XH]ÀKJ7YJ\Q[.L X¢H
[JXUQ
E[+YOH XVRJVE^QJ[[J]KFPX.KE[+YTYQ7Y)J M7 LJ E
\Q[QUHEO [QL
SPVE^QJ[[JFPY6IJE[QJYYPR(E]VJZ=HO EN]Q]K[JTYQ7YJE[+#
SYÞ
Q>JXV7[JXSQE[+# X[HOV7[JEUQMJ]OJE[+ NVIJVQZHO
7HEI[QYHO
Y6IJE[QJYXE[QJ&Y(\HE[+9\QSP]K
Y6IJE[QJYPR(E]V7QSPZYJVG,]KSPX = \MJYX*Z]H [ J YÞSZ OH J
EYWQMJSQUHO[Q(ZOH IYJI.[.L H>ªQZVJI.=VX]JT]JSPE]KLSPYY6IJE[QJL
XE^)7MJLSQ [HOMJ]MJE[QL XE^Y SP=YHO Y6IJE[QJL\, R8IJN]E
Q N^TJV7
N^TJ
EZ
EV7QJU
Q[TJEQYJY SP9X[[J]RQI.= UHOMJ[.L I[J[GWH/9
.9
XVRJ]R[JYHOEYQMJEYQMJVSH
7QFPSP=]RQYHOY6IJE[QJV,O1YRJ
E[QLTH[JUHOES[J[TJEI=E[QLSPYY6IJE[QJLXE^YHOEN]Q]K[J#
SRJX*ZH]J]RQ[[JV,OSY*QI.=+TQ
YHONVIJVQEV7QJX[[J
.9XT+VJ
N]2]( [TJGK[RJ G6[JZHOYJVJE]KL AZO]J]K# Y6IJE[QJ SP=XTVJG,]KVJa
ZHO=EN]QZHOYJ[JSPYY6IJE[QJLRQZYJKN^IJ=GHOMJ[J#ZYJKN^IJ=
ZHOYJE[QLSPYZYJ^+.9&Y/H YEZZYJ\.\RJ[ L J#K\QV)©QIJ
+[[ J J#
EV7QS J +MJ[J#Y6IEJ [QJLZYJKUO]JV
ETFPZOH= &YVH J K[J#Y6IEJ [QJY
UO]NJ ]ZHY O [J QE]KLSPYE[QL[X,[ L 1SN^TJ
Q7 [JKE[QMJVEZ5QEL S
SPYZYJ^.9+ YHO UYJU]O \ J QUH2O ]( EIQYJK\Q
+[Z J YOH EJ S[J2]( E[QL
Y6IEJ [QLZ J YJKVN^IJ)= MOH EJ T
FPZH=O 1Y/, KN]IJ[JY6IEJ [QJYZYJKN^IJ=
ZHYO JE
QEIQYJU,O SPZYJENVQYJ]K[JY6IEJ [QJL TH[J[IJGOH \YJZ+IJ
ZHO=ZO]JV
[QZHO=UHO]K[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
###2](EU
NVIJVQTQO4\ J P [IJEYWQMJSQ[TJEQYJN^TJEZE[QLEYWQMJ]H[J
YJ
R 7 VJ Q7 Y6IEJ [QJV)©EZI.= XI(XIQ3JEYWV-<QIVWQV7QN^TJET#]O,V7Q
N^TJETEIEZL
7H]K[J(EI
QE[+V7QNVIJVQLX)O]RQ)7MJL%HSOYQZYJ
Q
E[+YHOZ)7MJLGW(2](EZLZQV7[JSQT
Q
7]H K[J[TJ&YHVJEYWQMJX]H[JVQ7
E[QL FQE1YQMJL
JVSHY6IJE[QJ
+QN]IJEIZHOYJ[JNVIJVQS&Y*IJ
E
SFMJE
QYJZQ[JS&Y*IJXE1YQMJEN]QG.L2](]K2]((]+.YVPZ?H)0
¡HO
QYHONVIJVQYP2](%OFQSQE
]+.ZO]J\Q[Q]KS&Y*IJ
YJS,OEZ
YJYHOZRJ
YJ\P
YJNV[JZHO= XV7[J\Q1Y[JNVIJVQZP&Y(XVWQTO
YE[QL S&Y*IJ[+MJ3]OSJS(ZETQMJL1Y[J
S&Y*IJX[YJEI=V7Q
+Q\. ZPTHVJ[TJEQYJ E
QYJZQ[J
SPY
+QSP&Y(N^TJ[.LY6IJE[QJLVJY+.XTJYHOYHOE[+9GWMJ[JZH=O UHO[J
SPY Y6IJ E[QJ [H O = ]O ¢ H / ZJ & Y( YH O ]TÚ R J [TJG O N]]K[J SP = X UH O Y
E[QYJT+JZ,O ]H[J[.L (]TÚRJY 2](EU]K[JZHO=ZRJ XGOHMJXVQ
UHOES[JNVIJVQXVWQTOYE[QL SPEN]Q[.L 2](EUUHO[QYHO ,O[J
SP&Y(YE[QLSPEN]Q[Q[TJZ,OV5V,O]KFP(E[QLZPTHVJYEM+MKYW]J
XEZQMJXTQZO]JVJ YJT+J EUQMJ\QSP?Q 2](YHO 2](
VJZHO=
UH[ O JSPYO H [J OMH J XT+J EUQMJ2](ESI[JI=. X]TJG,VJZO=H THIEJ G[J
Y6IJE[QJL XTJYHOYE[QL X.K ZPS[JV- N^TJV7Q]. SP&Y(XEII.= KE[QL
VZO]J)HOMJFPZOH=EN]QZOHYJ[JKE]V.LSPYEZQMJVJ[Y.Y.ZO]JEIZHO=
YJ T + J Y H O ]O Z MJ [TJ Z , O V7 Q Y]J &YH / )7 M J L G WRJ [ J SP & Y( Y
)7TJZ,ON]0ESI[JI.= UJYHOYJXY+QYEI ]TJ\RJL ZHOYJ[J ]OZMJ\H#
XTH[JTH[JY+.[Q YJT+JY XTXIE[QMJ
7QV
E[QLFP Y6IJE[QJL
XTJ Y H O SP & Y( Y SP ) H O M J [ . L EZQMJ E1YEM+ Y H O SP M J G WMJ E[+ E ]#
SP=G+MNJL ]/GWYX J
GWYJX
YJ]OZMJE\QMJ2](SP[=Z HO TP O EXQMJ]+.G,1Y]K[J
ESQYJ[QIRJIRJ Z+IJS+Q[J VP2](
IJN^TJE[QL ZP&Y( SPVE[+#
Y6IJE [QJL XF+Q X]KXMJ Y EI=\ P
YJN V[J V7 Q X
YJE SQYJ Z HO =
(ZHON^TJ[QUHO2](E^IJN]TJ[MJ[QG,1Y
[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
###EU^EQMJ[HOMJ
Y6IEJ [QJSMJ1YQ
[.L[YÞSOZ H JSMJ¡OH FQSQVWQV7QE
7E?QMJ
)7MJLXZJEG[JV+IJTQE]]KMJ[QV7[JVH]KZHVJLVJ(FQSQ
]JX[+YJ
EG[JE]V+IJTQE]%?OSO[N^RJLGWMJ[.LX[+YJY6IJE[QJLYHOV+IJTQE][[J
FOIJ &Y( [TJ]K)7MLJ UYJS + JE]
IJ3(EZ[TJEQYJYHO EN]Q]K[JSPY
T(T3JE]]K[J3(EZYY6IJE[QJ[=OH
+QV7 VHOMJGIJ=E[.L X
]JV7Q
EI[J Y6IJE[QJ SP=XHVJV7Q S+QEI2]( FOIJ&Y(\,V7 EG[JSTJ V+IJTQ
SMJP]K[J
3( EZXH VJ V 7 Q EISP ZP MJ [ TJ E QYJ Y VH IJ V EGWQEGWQ
Z7Z 7 EZ [TJ EQYJY H O X¡P XVP &YH / YJE I[J EYQMJV EZY
ZYJVG,FP SPYVHIJYEZYHO XG+ML
J [HMO J GWTEJ
UH[ O J
RJTQTQE[+
E
[J# XE1YQMJY V\PZQ]KFP SPZRJ X¡PXVPN^TJEIE[QL
SPMJGWMJE[+YX1Y· , 4JE]2](
+QSQQ[J¡Y HO J Q[JUMJU
QI.= SPY= HO
E[+9E][J [TJREIE[QL SPY Y6IJE[QJI.=X[P SPMJGWMJ[GWH/9YHO
Q[JU
QXHVJ EGS+Q[J X.(V7Q Q[JU
QY EU^EQMJ[HOMJ
T(
MJEI[QE[+9[J^EQMJ[HOMJYXGWMJTMJ[(V([QEZQYJ#XNVMJL
TMJ[(V([QEZQYJ
7HVJ^EQMJ[HOMJE]V7QZRJXMJY+YJE[+GW#
¡O]J],OE[+U+.2]( ^EQMJ[HOMJ XZJEZQYJV7Q X[JT GWRJ\Q[J
X[JTY XVWH/ SV([J[ .L XYW´ XTN][J SP=XH VJY N^TJ [.LIRJI.=
GHO \O[ZJ Q[Q[.L X.KY6IEJ [QJEIQYJV7 SH
[QQ[JU
QYSP
×[(
VJE[QJ&Y(YHO
7HGOHO4JE[QJ^+MJL#SPYXGWTJ VJE[QJ&Y(EZU
QY
MJ SP=YHOJE
QMJ AV+.a [QY T(]+Q3TÚQ
V
7HUMJ
.[.L AV+.aI.= X[P[P N^TJEI[QE1YQMJL (XP N^TJZQ[QEIV7Q]K
QTOYE
7NVIJVQY%WQVWQX\PSN^MJLN]>Q[JI.=[
QTQVWQV7QT(]+Q
3TÚQUMJ
.SPYHO^+[J)7MJL)-HMJ[QE[+]K[J
XHVJYHO ^+[J[YJZ5MJV+.VRJLIHVH[JUO[ H QNVIJVQVWQT+E. I[.LXP]K
(XN^TJVW/H E[+EN]QEI1Y[QXVWQ&Y(]K].SH=EO SQJY6IEJ [QJ[TJSYJZO,
E[QL[TJGKSQ1Y,/^P]K
.9X.(N^TJ
]JV7QZRJIHVH[JX[HOMJN^TJSRJVN^TJ
FPFQV5XESXGWQSYJESVN]]KFP
[TJ)7TJG
TÚV[JEYWQMJ]H[J[OIJ Y6IJE[QJXI(
+QYZJSVQ
[TJEQYJ)M7 LJ 1Y,/
]K[JS+Q[QYSP\ = V, 7 )+QVE[+J^=]OH KY6IEJ [QJ
)7MLX
J [PZJZO]S J Q[TJEQYJZVJEZ5QYJSQ+ [JY6IEJ [QJ[=OH
+Q\.
ZRJMJE
Q^+[[ J TJEYQMJY[.XOEH Z[TJZ,O \.MJS+Q[QE[+9ZHY O
J
[J[.
7MJYX
YJSVQ#ZP]WMJ#ZYJZO]JZYJTQ#FQV5 X]HOXZ5,
V
7S H P SPYVZHOGWMS J RJL_RJLSRJYOH ¡HY O SJ [JGWYTJ QZHOY[ J JZ=OH EIQYJV7
1YQ
[J(ZPYYOIJEYQYJT
QV
7H[.LZPSP=XHVJZMJ[IQIQ#^+[J
[YJ[YJ EIQYJ\]JV+.T
QFQ
7H]KLVZ.
M7YJUHO
X[H[JIHVH[JXE1YQMJEN]Q
MJ)7MJL M7YJUOH EXQJS,)7MLJ [TJ]K[RJ
ZP[TJEQYJES[.LYHTÚEN]Q]K3(VJXSRJXSIJVVQEISRJLZPIQ
XHVX J I(XIQM7Y]J ]O S J , M7YUJ OH \HO S,
1YQ
Z5MJ ZPIQESE[QLVRJL IHV[ H J
UH[O QNVIJVQE[+X,&O Y( ,[ O JSP[=HO ,1O Y[QYHO?O[S J ZHOZHO \MJT
Q
XN^TJ[TJGO Y6IJE[QJ 1Y,/^P]K[J [HOYJUHOMJ[QZRJ N^TJ)HOMJ[J#
[YJZRJN^TJ)HOMJ[J
IJYOIJ[YÞSHOZJV7QT[O[)7TJXE
QYJG
TÚV[JEYWQMJV]H[JV(
IRJIRJETQ2](Y6IJE[QJ
+QN]IJG.L[JXVWH/\.Y[TJEQYJXSRJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XSIJVVQEI[JZOH=XE[TJEQYJYE1YIIJ¡HOYJZHOYJZHO=ETQETQ
N]IJZQ[Q]KXF+QEVQMJN^TJZHO=Y6IJE[QJYAXFHOEZaZHO=EG]K[J
+QE
QYJE
QYJGWMJAXFHOEZa\, S+QZPVVQEV]K[J
X^HOEZYHOXHVJSQVWQ)7MJLX[P
+QEUSVQ]KE[+9]K[JSP=
XSYJY)7TEJ ZQYJ]KEIVEYQMJ[QYZXE[QJ1YQ2](GOE[QL
EI=ZQRZQN^TJEI2](EUU
QYSP=>I(YHOEN]QEI[JVEI=YSP=
]HSE)EI=#(EI=YEV+EI=[L. SPYIHV[
H ^J [J[J[YJZS=OH QXFHO EZ
(RSIJEGKMJEYWQJ[.LX\HEIG.L
MJE[QLFQV5VN^TJE[QLFP#N]IJEYQMJ
VJE]KLXGWHIJYRIQ
(EZQYJ
7HEI2](Y6IJE[QJ[HO=XQZ,OR3JLZ,O
E]KYJ ZPIQETQMJL1YVJUHO2]( \HOMJETQMLJEI1Y[Q R IQ
(EZQYJ
E
QYJE[QLXHVJXI(STJ]MJE]YM7YJUHO \HOS,1YQ
]KEZE
QXS,TP
TP)7MJLUYJGKUYJGK[+IJEI[QY6IJE[QJ[HO=XQZ,OVWYJTHVWYJ)7Q]WYJ1Y
E
Q?O[J]KL%WQXFHOEZZRJSIJEGKMJ VEYWQJ
7Q]KFPEUSVQ
YE[QL XT+VJYOIJ XSYJYJ]KES
.9
XIRJMJ EU+E)+T
Q)7TJGWYJ
7H]K[J[TJGOYEUU
Q
.9
]HSE)EI=)7MJL EV+EI=)7MJLUHOMJ[.L XP EIQYJ M7YJUHOS,)7MJL ZPES[Q
UYJT]JSRJLYHTÚEUU
QEN]Q[.L]HSE)EI=)7MJLEV+EI=UHO[QY[TJ
YV«QZ,OZYJG,[.L SQ^+QU
QIJS[JV7[JSRJL]HSE)
YJ[HO=^+QES
TQ
MJ\.Y
YJ[)=OH M7 LJ V[P]KFPXSRJXSIJZPVVQYHO YOS[.L EUU
Q
Y(EI=)7TJEI=YHOXZ+IJXE
THOYJ]KVJ
7HV7QE]KLZPIQLXHVJXI(V7QM7YJUOH\HOS,1YQESQJZRJZPIQVES[Q
ZRJ
7HVQ7 ]KZHO= SP[Y
HO= UHOE]ZHVJLVJO[#ÉH O[ÉQ
7[ H .LTYQ]K].SH=EO SQJ
ZRJ(XPYXT3JXZQT+.EI[.L¡HO
Q¡HO
QUHO[QY+JG.]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
###E%MJU
Q
Y6IEJ [QJ 2%[ H IH )J MOH MJ V, Q7 U
QX[[JSMJ^=OH ]RQE[QJSMJU
O [Q
V7[VJ ]H KZHVVJL J KY X2]/H MEJ N^
[.L TQEV]+. TTJ2]( FO[Y J ZPE[+9TTJEU
2]( V7E
+[Q]KTQEV]+). M7 LJ ZPE[+9]+. 1YQV7QX,1L S^+J XN^TJ[TJGY O OH Y6IEJ [QJ
1Y/,
]KES[J
TQEV]+E. N^X2]( ZPE[+9VRJEL I= V[HMO VJ V( Q7
YJEZQYJ NGQEI
[JY6IEJ [QJZRJ[\H[\ J [ H )J M7 LJ SRJX2]( S[J]Y .+ OH ETQMJEL V5QEJ I[Q
IJYIO 2J V/H 9\.YSPMJGWMJ XHVY J OH XZRJSQ+ ]K[JXGWIH NJ ^/IJ ^H=O ]K].X.E( I=Y
[I*E)+EI=E]KL SPMJGWMJ Y Y6IEJ [QJ XMJ[Q%W0X[+YJ ]P]IJVEIEXQMJ
\MJ]K
.9E\+
QEZ]KE[+TYQ
7Q[JX.X ( GHYO J EXQJS1, YQ[JAE%MJ#
E%MJa I.= EXQJ[J SPMJGWMJ Y E%MJU
QYHO XHV[ J M+ J EGZHY O [
J J
E%MJU
QY V+[TJ ZMJ# ZVJEZ5QYJ XHV[ J YQ Z7RLJ E%MJE?QEI[Q
SP M J G WMJ Y Y6IJ E [QJ L X [+ Y J E?QE]]KZH O = GH O M J [J SP Y
XE]WQJE?QGHOMJ[QZH=]O . Y6IJE[QJ XESXGWQ\MJ[J E%MJ U
QY
Y6IEJ [QJL ZY4QYHO X
MJ1YRJ[ L J 2]( E[QL EV+EI= EV+
YJ EV[J
SPY[+YGJ WYJ 4IJE[+ XY+YGJ W2]( E?Q]K[JAUQ?TJU
Q
U
Q
XEIQYJ[MHO J S+Q
VJZ=H O NVMJ[JaY6IEJ [QJYMJE\QYJZY HO [J JAF,EO F
N^TJVJ \MJ[Ja SPY EGKMJGK2]( AV?O[F J P # V?O[F J P # VYÞQ?HF O YJ
XE&Y( EI
QX.V( Q7 GMJ%WQYHO ETQMJEL
7QYJVJL ZP&Y( S,O EQYJE[+9VJ
[TJEQYJYGMJ%WQYHO SQZH\ O QZHVVLJ JY6IEJ [QJE?Q[Q,]O KU
Q
GMJ%WQ?HVO Q7 &Y( ]+QVJaSP[NGQE[+UYJE?Q]KES[J
SPMJGWMJ I.= Y6IEJ [QJ[Y =OH E[QL SPE?Q[Q XE]WQX J ]WY]J . V7[J
ZHY O ]J K[JE%MJU
QYHZ O RJSPE[QMJ[.L E?QGSPMJGWMJ YE]ZHY O J
]K[J# SH]J VVWQ]KFP SHE=O SQJ V1YQ]KFP# SPE?QEN]QG.[ L QE[+ EVLEVL
E]WQYJE]WQYJ N^TJ2]( GKV7 Y6IEJ [QJ XE[QJYEZ X,1L S
[J (U
QY
Y6IEJ [QJ ]RQE[QJSMJ TQEV]+E. N^[Q# XMJ[Q%W0ETQMJEL I[Q VSH]KFP
KE]V.L SPY Y6IEJ [QJ VYÞQ\YJE
Q S+Q
VRJ E?Q[Q \PE[QL
\PUIJ[J X\YJVQ7 EN]QG.L[.LX[HMO J SPE?QSV5E[+Y V7IZ J Q[J
GOV+VJFHOMJ?OXVRJEN]QMJ\QSRJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
EIQYJ]HOMJE[+9]KZHVJLVJSP [NGQE?Q[QE[+Y[YJ[YJTMJZ+.[Q
ZRJ
7H]KES[J
Y6IJE[QJYE[QLE%MJU
QZY4QU
Q\,S+QEVEZLEV\
V
7H]KFPKE]V.L([TJSYJV7QGO\H)7TJ&YVH J
7]H K2](#[NGQZPYY6IEJ [QJL
X[+YJ EVE][Q ]\V[TJ&YHVJY X\YJV7Q EN]QG.L[.L YHTÚ O[H
X&YHVJY GO Y6IJE[QJ X*ZIJV7Q EI\HOMJ[OIJ NVIJVQN]RJY
Y6IJE[QJLR(MJ ]HO=ZHOYJ[.L TQXH[JX\P&Y( [TJXH[J
]K[J (\.V7Q
Y6IJE[QJLX[+YJE?QTQ[VJ^PTYYJTYÞ0S,O
+YJI.=E
\Q[Q]K[J
SP=\,V7QY6IJE[QJL >Q[QY
7HEI[JN]IJVZQ[QXE[QJ1YQEIE[QL
THO
HV[
J J\MJ]K
.9
IJYIO JYIQVRJX&Y( U,OE%MJU
QYHO S+QEV[J
E?QZHOYJ[LX . \.Y[TJGWYJYY6IEJ [QJN]RJL)7TJX[+MJ XHVEJ \QMJ
YWZHVJLVJ[.LX.%WQX.()7TJ\. Y6IJE[QJ XHVJE\QMJYW]K[J
###Y]JE
QK
Y6IJE[QJX*ZIJVS+QV(E)+V7QY6IJE[QJ[=HO
+QV7QXE[QJXSMJL
YPTYJ[.LVJE
QKUHOYJ]K[J
+QSP&Y(YEVQJZ2VH/MJV7YWIJVQE
V70
E[+]MJ]L K[J
+QSQE[+YZ OH RJXTQ)7MELJ
¡OTY OH 1J Y
IJS[HE][J
ZI=J^W]JEI[.L
+QSP
+QSQE[+YZRJSP&Y(EN]QSV5IQE\QMJ]K[J#
GHMO J[QZO]]J K[J#KE]V.L [TJ2]/H M[ J RJV7Q].SP[Y =HO FOIJ &Y( ]MJL
+QZVJU,O
V7QREIGMJ]
H[JIQ1Y[J]
H[JYXE
&Y([.LSO[J GOITJSO[J
7H]K
[J [TJ3(GWMJX[+YJE
Q# [TJ)HOMJM,Z,OX[+YJ]K ^WQIQZ5MJ N^TJET
X)©
QJ
7HZ5MJN^TJET#]
H[J
+[J
IJFO
Q
7MJG+MJLN]/E[QJVP]K[JNVIJVQ
FO
MJVWQ ZYJ\YJY (XT3JXZQX[HOMJ [TJ3(GWMJX[+YJN^TJET
)HOMJM,X[+YJN^TJETXE
7H
MJ
+QV7QZPTOFOIJ&Y(]MJL]
H[J
+[J]K[J
]
H [ J ] + . & Y( 2]( [. L X GKV7 Q
+ Q SQE[+ Y SP [ H O = ¡H O
QE[+
UYJZO]J[J S,],O[(2]( G+YJE[+ ZMJ%IJE[+EGKYJ VEYQMJUHOKI.=
E
QKY]JEFE[+
+QY )7MJ[J [HOYJUHOMJV-[TJGOY ZMK]O]J^VJ[.L
XGWHIJV7QZRJ S,],O[(1Y [J (V7QZRJ NVIJVQE[+Y XP
7H[J
\P\PNGQNGQN^TJ[.L ZMK]O]J ^VJ[QY ZYHO
Q?O 2H/ZJUHO
Y VW/H ^H=O
&YH/TQEI[.LXGKV7QN^TJE][QUPUPR,R,XS,E]2](?TJ\O[JZHOYJ
MJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
ZYHO ^VJVRJL
Q?O Z8[JE]ZHVLJ VJ VWH/ZWYJ[IJZIJ UHOZ5MJZRJ
E\+\O[JZHVJLVJZHO= ,O1YRJ1Y[QE1YQMJLS,],O[([Q]K
##X*ZIJ
XF+Q#3(&Y( #3(EZ#XEVWQYHO YIJE[QL2]( EIQYJX*ZIJG
(
X[+YJ
IJYOIJYHO S+Q]K[J Y6IJE[QJ NVIJVQN]RJYHO )-[JUYJE[QL
EIQYJUJLYHO)7TZ J ,O Z,OYHOJL)MHO MJ ,YHON]IJE[+9V7QV?O[JE1YQMJIRJIRJV7
VE[+VH]KFPGO 1SO[JZV7QY6IJE[QJNVIJVQN]RJYG+Q]K[J
ZIJIJ [YÞSHOZJY ]RQE
EYQZH]JV7Q ]RQURJ]P
IJ N^TJ]K[J
KE]V.L EYQZH]JY TYJ[MJFQZUIJV7Q ^+MJLV7Q# XGWHIJV( E
QYJ)HOM
J IJ
S+Q ¡H OS+QT3J SEF*QG
()7MJL VN^TJE[QL]KFP X.(E G[JY XQ
7I.=
3E
Q]1YQG
(YSEF*Q)7MJLSQS+Q1Y
[Q]KEZQ3JG
(Y
Z+IJX\H EG[JVTQ ES]KFP Y6IJE[QJL G
(Y YQZY[ÉQ YHO
SEF*Q)7MJLS+Q#X.(YV7V(
\Q)7MJLXH)H[HOYJMJN^[JF,OEFV+VJFHOMJ
S+Q G
(SRJ[MJ SEF*Q &Y(YHO EN]QMJ2]( VQEUYHO G
(UYJ[J
X.(V7QRXNVIJV(
\Q)7MJL YJEZS+Q#\]J2](YP[O=H SEF*Q)7MLJ HO%QYP#
HO%QYV(
\Q)7MJL ZIJIJYHO UYJZIJIJYHO Y6IJE[QJ TYJ[MJFQ
YJEI= E
QYJS+Q]K[J
(G
(YTOTEO ]KMJ
YJ1YQ[JSEF*QV(
\QX[IJ[IJI=.
VE
QYJ^P [.L)HOMMJ E, [+E
QYJ#]MJZJN]MJE[+N^[JEYWQJSQ+ G.L
[QXE[QJ
OY1Y,/
[.LG
(]K].XE[+9X1Y,/E[+ZRJ
]K
.9TYJ[MJFQ
YJEI=
I,IYJGMJV7Q]K
(2VH/9YHOV(
\QN]0[MJV7NVMJG.L
]K[J2VH/9YHOESESGWQGWQ
1YRJ]L K[J[TJGWHIVJ 7Q(2VH/9E[QJY]RQ
7MJ&Y( E[+EYWQMJE[QJSQE[+
)7MJLXYWH/
7H
7H YPZPUYJU,
ZHVJLVJUHO[QE[QLIRJIRJV7VSHG.L]KFP
Z7][.L(2VH/9E[QJYHOY6IJE[QJE
QYJ[QV7T2](MK&YHVJ
7H]K2](
Y6IJE[QJ
.9X*ZIJG
(YX\PSN^MJL F,OEFVQEUX]HOMJV7Q
XE[QJG
, ]K[JZ-MH J VP[QXN]MJ\VMJTQGIJV7QTQESQYJ
[QXGYJ
XG.
7H]K[JX.(XGWHIJYY6IJE[QJSYJS[JZ+[JTQ]K[J#X
YJ
VESQYJ]KXSQTQ
QV7SYJS[JZ[ + JN^TJZQ[QY[N^RJN^RJ]K
T[MJ[QEVQJZ2V/H MVJ Q7 EYWQMJEI[OIJ
+QV7EVQJZ2V/H MEJ YWQMJVN]IJV( [TJR
EIV7QY6IEJ [QJR L V( WQY)-[U J YJ]U .+ 2OH ]( XOIJ \VMJ#1YYJSQ?MJI.= NVIJVQ
GOYHOZJ
Y+[ÉQ?OXVRJEN]QMJ2](
EKYJ[QZ7EF
TQEYQMJESQYJ^ +
J EY6]K[J]\VE[QLTQEYQMJ]K[JKE]V.L
[N^RJN^RJI.= 1YYJSQTQ
[QTH[VJ SI=JN^TJZQ[JXHVJYEV+\Q[.L
[H
TÈQIJE[+)+Q#Y6.#YJ#1YYJ#F. TSRJE]KLXEYQMJE[+YHO SIQ
TH[EJ 1YQMJLN^TJ]KZHVLVJ J1YYJSQTQEZ[HOMJ Y6IEJ [QJLVQ7 XE[+MJZQ
]K[J MK VEI=Y XTQEY6[.L 1YYJN^0VEZ EZZQ# [TJEI=Y MK
ZHOYJ^VJ[.L 1YYJ^XRH/EYQMJYEZVWQZQE[+[QE]KLE[+VHE[QL
TQVMJE[QLFP V1YQV(V7Q [NGQ S[ÉKVWQX[+YJ]K TH[JG,TQV- N^TJ
ZQ[JYHOJLTH[JYHOXE[QJ&Y(\HGHOYJZQE[QLY6IJE[QJXSQZ,O
E
7QMJZHOYJ]KE[QL[JY6IJE[QJ[YÞSHOZJEYWQMJSQF[EZ5QYJZO,
]K]. %OFQSQY XSQTQ[Q)7MJL ][JSYJZHO= VRJSHO=V5 VUHO]K ?H)0
YE[QL]+MJL]+MJLZMJZMJUHO]K[JNV[JT+QFO
QYEZQMJZ70SV5XYOIJ
FO3JE]E[QJV]P K[JKE1YQMJLS,'QVWQZRJGOEG[JVQ7 XYOIJFO3JE]
]K[JNVIJVQZP[JE1YQMJE[+\.V7QE[QLSYJS[JZ+[JSVQXVWQ&Y(
##NVIJVQN]RJ#
Y6IJE[QJ E[QMJG,[.LX[+YJ EYQZH]JY Y6IJE[QJLYHO ]RQ
EZLZQE
G+MJLUJZ)7MJL NVIJVQN]RJ N]IJG+MJLE]]K[J XHVJN]IJG
(Y
EKYJ[QZ7EF
Z+IJG.L[.L )7TJ XZQG
(\YJ 2MHVJSYJEXGWVJ]K[J Y6IJE[QJ
Z(%Q]PV7SEF*QT(#[TJZX1YQV7Q
IJYOIJE
QYJ]K[JY6IJE[QJLU,O ¡-, V-
E[+EXQMJNVMJVE- [+YOH N]IJSO, S]J
IJSEF*QE]V7QXGWIH
J [JY6IEJ [QJ
E[+9
VRJL NVIJVQN]RJ&Y( FJZEOH IVZ.E[+1YRJ[ L JY6IEJ [QJYHO NLJ ]RJ
YHOJN]IJE
QYJE[QL XSQTQSP N^TJEI2](# X
YJZRJ ESQYJ2](#
K[MJVYT(Y
YJYZRJESQYJZHOYJES[J
Y6IJ E [QJ L Y H O NVIJ V QN]RJ N]IJ G + M J L E ]ZH O Y J [ QY
NVIJ V QFQSQTQE])7 M J L 3J E YWV- - EZL Z Q
IJ ] K ( ]RQ]H O M J
ZO]JMIJYHOMJMIJE[+I.= ]
HS[JYHO OY VE]E[QL]KFP (XTQ ]HO2](
TH[JMJTQ^+JN^TJVRJL NVIJVQ%OFQSQMJ
.9ZPVF - XE1YQMJEN]Q]KVJ
Y6IJE[QJN]IJE[+9
[.LNVIJVQVWQV7Q%OFQSQ)7MJLXNGQXPVWQ
)7MJL][JSYJ2](XNVMJEN]QMJZ.[QSH]JV
7H]KFPX
MJX[HOMJ%OFQSQ
)7TJ)7TJYQYQSYJMJ,O1YRJSPE[+YHOVNVMJVN^TJNVMJE[+9
]K[J
GOV7Q YWMJ]G.L[.L U`S*KIQ]+.YZRJ SP[HO=
.9 FQSQYHOMJ¡-HMJTH[JYHO
XQN^RJL\Q]K[J NVIJVQVWQY GMJ\YJ ]HO2]( H]×IQXZO]JYHO
XGWIH ]J EHO ]ZQ]K[J#]HZ O ]O ZJ Q1Y[JSH=EO ]VJL]MJV[QIJ)T7 J
]JN^TJ[.L
KIXV-I.=S(ZEUQYJ[RJV-YHO ZTJZW0¡-V\Q].ZO]JEI]K[J[TJ2]H/MJ
[RJ V7 Q EV7 Q J U
QSH H U
QE[+ FO H E[QJ E [+ Y [TJ 3 ( GWMJ E
Q
HO4J4)7MJL]K [HO]+QZQEI[J SP[HO= G,P[.L F+.9XVRJ E[+YZRJ
XNVMJLSQ SHH FJEZQYJ T+VJ[JE[QL VSHFP YHOJE[+9N^TJZHO=
[GWH/9VWQSP[HO=XQ\Q[.LI[JE[+YHOIQVRJE[QMJV7IJV7IJYIJYIJVSH
I[JXGWMJGWMJ UYJ)+J],OYHO ZRJ VSH1YE1YQMJYHOE[QL Y6IJE[QJ
XESXGWQEN]Q)HOMJ]K[J(XEIX\QV7Q\]J2](E[+9
[QYE[QL
Y6IJ E [QJ
IJ Y O I J E
QYJ 2 ]( S, O
YJ E NVQYJ V7 Q RTQTQ S+ Q G. L [ . L
]KEVQY[TJEQYJXHVJY U(&YH/[.L NVMJY+MJ]K]. S(SIJ= T(V,\Q[.L
FO
QGIJV7Q %OUMJ[OE[QJVWQ )7MJLX[P I[J¡O]J\O VWQT+Q 73JZWYJ
E[+9]K[JI[J[GW/H 9
.9¡O]\ J XO VWQ]K[JI[JE[+YT(]+QYOIS J
+ S J Y P OH
&Y(]+QEXQMJ AVa [.LXE1YQMJ Y6IJE[QJLYHO EN]QN]]K[J ]KEVQY
YE[QJYT(]+QE
ZO]JMIJ
7MJN^TJ EISPYHO
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
UYJ2](NVIJVQN]RJV7QY6IJE[QJ1Y,/E[+9G.L[.L,O1YRJV-VWQI.=¡HO
Q
ZO]JEZLZO]J\YHO ZYJZ(E^QYJSRJ GW]KVJ ]\VXE1YQMJX
QY
_
QVERQMJ]MJ&Y(YHO]PE>QJ[.LXE1YQMJ]K].
###ERQMJ]MJ&Y(
Y6IJE[QJL VH[JEU+VWQY%OFQSQP[TJPYHO EGS+Q]K[J
E[QE[QMJE[+N^[JF[JTJYQ)7MLJ S+Q1Y[Q]KYQE]V7QZRJXZ8QT,O
ZP[IJTQXVWH/T,O]KMJ]K[JERQMJ]MJX&Y(&Y([TJ]MJYHOE
QYJE[QL
YQU
QYYQ
]J#XQZ,OYQE]YUMJ2](ERQMJ]MJYHOYIJE[QL1Y
[J(ERQMJ]MJVWH/YNVIJVQN]RJX)7,=XN]QV7QXZ+IJE]K]K[JNVIJVQ
E[+ Y ZRJ ( X ]MJ E [+ Y H O ¡H O E SEZTQ1Y[J VH [ J E U+ V WQE
Q
¡HMO JFQY ]KY6IEJ [QJY L OH XESXGWQEN]Q]K[J(ZVJYHO ZQSPXVWQTOY
(ERQMJ]MJ &Y(YH O YQE]YUMJ ZH O = N^TJ E T YQ\. Y ]. N^TJ N ^TJ
YIJE[QL1Y]KS[.L(\. V]K[QYE[QL G
TJQIJVWQI.= XNGQ,O1YRJV-
ZYJG\ , QSPVWQ].N^TJ[JX.(YUYJ2]( P
H
7 QG
(UYJ]K[JP\Y .
UMJ[OE[QJ E[+ ^PENVQJ^HO=I.= X)O]RQ]IJ]OZYJ
QVWQYHO EZLZQ1Y
IJ
N^TJ]K[J
ERQMJ]MJYVW/H TH[VJ WH/)+JXVWH/VWH/
7[H QSHE[QJV1P YSRJL X[HMO J
]K].SHO=ESQJZRJSQVIJNVIJVQVWQYE[QLERQMJ]MJUOHZ5MJ%O]M+ JLE[QJ
VP[.L E%QH]MJI.= )+J]TJZHOYJVJ SHO=V?O[J
MJ I[JEI]MJ ZO]JZHOYJVJ
ERQMJ]MJYHO¡HOES
[JV\(V.LNVMJVZO]J
FPTH[JMJTQ^+JERQMJ]MJ
],NO ]MJE[+XVWQ&Y(
7]H K[J(VQ7 E[QLY6IEJ [QJFHE
7QTL E[QL^V=OH Q7 EIT3JY
U
QSVQ]KEVQYT[(]J)7MJL NVIJVQ>I([HO= EN]QN]G.L[.L ERQMJ]MJ],ON]MJ].
N]IJEN]Q]KVJ
]\VYV«QTTJYQZV7QT[(]JYX\YJNVIJVQN]RJG¡HOMJ[TJGOV7Q
XE
]HOMJ XO]JGW/]JE
X&Y(XY.
ZO]J
[JSPYTTJ[]J\.V7QZRJ
%HOZJ&Y(XUMJL)7MJLSP=ZYJEXQYJV7QNVIJVQ)7MJLXH)HE[+]K[.LU]J]KVHOMJIQ
[]J
7H[J([]JYFO
MJLXMJWMJI(Q[]J
.9E
73([]J^+.9]K
T[(]J¡O, THY
O
J Q2V/H 9Y2V/H 9ZJVQ7 _
QVERQMJ]MJ&Y(
7[
H J#ERQMJ
]MJEXQYJV7QZRJI[JY+IJ
7H[JERQMJ]MJI.=I[JY+IJYZVJZJV7Q
UHOE[QL Q3JS+Q Q3JZQ ZVJUHO=EI[J FJSPV7ZRJ V\H,LFP
EKYJ[QZ7EF
EIQYJU,OE[QL 2VH/9VWYJ)7Q^,OE[+YT[(]JYHO ZQGW3JY]J1Y[JSPY
TTJSQE[+UMJLEG#ERQMJ]MJYHOVJTHVJHOMJIVHOYJE[+Y]J2](TYÞIJ=]HOMJ
X[+MJ2^H/]TJZHOYJ[J
YJS[ÉS,O][JZRJ1YQE
QT[(]JI.=SP=[]J
SQE[+ VYJUHO]HOE[V(Q GO X(
[J)HOMJM,
TTJENVN]MJS+Q
IJ XVHIJ=
\+YJ]KE
Q
2V/H 9SP2V/H 9SQVWQI.= VTÚTJT[(]JX]KXMJNVIJVQTTJSQYE[QJE[+
YE[QLSP[HO=EQYJWQE[+XHVJ]TJQ]TJTTJ\+YJ1Y
[QI[JY+IJ)7MJL
ERQMJ]MJ&Y( YHO ^WYU J (]TJ[X L. [+YJ I[JYMHO [
J QZOH= XE1YQMJN]1Y]K[J
Z7 E FE
XE
7 9 E[QMJ X Q
7 V 7 SFQX\H V J XV7 [ J V WQ
XJ([QW(F(V(ZJ
IQ#ZIJIJTQ
###G.],O&Y(
X\YJ]KPYN]IJ\Y + JSQ+ [.X L GKV7QYQSVQYXE[QJYEZ
&Y([.L G.],O&Y([TJGO
7H
QYQEVQMJEG]K[JE
QYJE[QL G
(SRJE[+
XQZ,O UMJ2]( G.Z,O EZE[+STJYMHO J E[+X],EO ]]TJ1Y]K[JY6IEJ [QJ
ZRJMJ]K[QE]LKX*ZIJV7Q)7TJ EIG.EL ]VJL MJ2]( UMJ).G8 WMTJ
Q&Y( VH=O
VEI)HOMJFPMJ)8.ZHOYJ[J
(XZO]JYZRJE
7VMJSQ[TJ]K
.9[]RLJEIQYJ]KE[+ZO]JG.L[.L
X[OHMJ¡HO
QV]WYJUYJZO]JG.L[.LYHTÚ]K].VMJSQY]O,VMJUYJ
V7Q EIQYJU,OTHOT,[.L VMJ# SP=YHO XVRJEN]QMJI.= AVMJEG+EGWa ZO=H
EG1Y[J
Q>MJZQTQVP
MJV7 EYQYJ)-[JEN]Q]KVJ
AAVMJEG+EGWVMJN^TJE[QJVPZHOESQJ SPMJE[QJVWQ)7MJL G,ORMJ
YTQ
Q [ZMJ [+ M J EG+ EGWTTJ \ RJ L S RJ Y H O NVMJ E ZESQJ
SPMJE[QJVWQPÑ]TJ2]( Z5MJENVUO]S J TJGYJ[TJEQYJ[TJZYJT(
^,O Ñ^HÑ]OUTJ[O]JYQ]PE>QJYIO @ J #\HS O =OH ]PE>QJESQX],&O Y( VWQT+QYHO
NVMJEZESQJ AâVMJSQSRJV1YQV[MJVMJN^TJZ[É9, a?PÑ]RQ
7[ H = OH
UH1O YYOI@ J aa
E^EVQMJ[MJ)7MJLW(XH]JGW
ZOT
X*ZH]JFQSQN]IJESQV7IJIIJ
Q>MJE[QJ&Y(V7
X\YJTQ]HOJV7QV7IJIIJV7 VP
MJX[HOMJN^TJSRJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
### ¡OH
QI[J
GOE)+
QS(V7Q3[OYZRJXZ+IJ]PN]MJ#TMJ[(
H[J\H
[YJZQ[JVH[JEU+[TJEQYJYY6IEJ [QJY L OH YEZQEGS+Q]K[J
YEZQY
7VJN]RJIJE[QMJ]HOMJYE[QMJTGIJ2VH/9#
QS(3[OYSQQ
EXNVZHO= X*ZH]JX
Q
7HVWQ E)+
QS( XIQPX]IJEN^TGIJE[+\.Y
2VH/9[TJ2V/H 9N^TJ]K[JY6IEJ [QJ[=HO [RJGHOXVH JY\MJ¡- E[Q\.VQ7 #XHV
J M7 JY
Y6IEJ [QJL VH[EJ U+
9. 3(EZSPYXO]GJ W/]EJ
X
Q
7[ H TJEQYJ]K2]( E[QL
SP=YOH FHOE[QJXN^TJZPSHVWQ\MJ
7Q[JSPYE[QLSP=XT+VJYHO YOSOZ H J
N^TJSQS,O]K[J
[TJREIGMJY6IJE[QJ[OH=ZRJ][J
QYN]IJE
QYJ2](V1YQV(V7Q
XHV
J M7
J 9. YQEVQMJSVQE
GKXEN]XZ8QE
QYJZQ[JSPYZRJ
XI(XIQV7QEISP]KXHV
J 7M\ LJ , XEVQ[EYQEN]ZQ[JSPEN]Q[QY
SP XHVJN]IJXE
QYJV7QSP=VHIJVY\HIJV)HOMJ SHVJV
EXQJZHOYJ
JZHOYJ#
ZPE[+ ¡HOYJZHOYJ ]O[JZHOYJ ZO]JEI]K[J V)HOMJFP ZHOYJ1YRJLE]]K
FHOE[QJYHO]MJL[JY6IJE[QJ[HO=XHVJ
7MJFHOE[QJY
7VJZ+JXH[J[TJZ,O
EYQYJZ+J\RJL2]( TQ]+.E]Y &YHVJ[O[JEZ[TJEGWQMJ EYQYJYHOMJ#
SP=YQSVQI.=\+YJS+Q[JY6IJE[QJ[HO=ZRJZHOYJS+Q[JVHIJVY
]HIJS+JS+JEZ#XH]J
Q\.V7QZ7.EI[J#[OIJ[OIJZ-]JZ-]JI.=Z7.EI[Q]K
FHOE[QJY VHIJVYHO 1YRJL¡- TTJEU2]( EGW\Q[.L Y+VJ
+YJE]# SP=YHO
KGHOMJ[J2](E[QLFJZHOX
SQZ.ZHO=EV[JVHIJVYGK[JZHO=
EN^2]( XH]J
QY\^H=O &Y/H TQ[JXE[QJE[QMJ[ L L. SPE= QYJWQI.=SIJVQ[.L
SPE= VQMJ)T7 EJ QYJSQVIRJ\HIJV7SPXH]
J QE]V7QEI[JFHO E[QJY
SP9&YHVJT1YQYHO N]E[QL VHIJVY IRJIRJ 2MHVJYWS+Q[J (VHIJVYHO
¡HO
QI[J]P[QZHO=FHOE[QJYSP= EQYJWQYHOEN]QN]]K[J
FHOE[QJY &YH/I.=S(\Q[.L ZYJ^+.9[TJGO\O[J VHIJVZRJ]MJV7Q
T+]JE]ZHOYJ[J]\VE[QLVHIJVY¡OIJYIJES[JFHOE[QJY]P[.L
I[JYHOVHIJVY[UMJL
EN]QZHOYJ[J#EIQYJ\]JZQ2](VE)7QYJ7YJ]KI.=
E]KLVHIJVY3(EGKMJU[JU[JGK[J(E[QLFHOE[QJYK\QV)©QIJ
[TJ]OJ
+[J2](SP=XVHIJ=N]IJ[J#VHIJVYHO&YHVJI.=EGWQYJZ7IJ=[J(E[QLV7
VHIJVYEGKMJRH[J2](N],/ZQ[JEIQYJ TYÞIJ=XIRJMJ1YQE[QL SP
EKYJ[QZ7EF
],OV7IJ N]IJ N^TJZQ]KE
Q]P[.LI[JY\+YJS+Q]K2](SPYXGIJ\. ?HO?HO
SRJSRJ 1YRJL[J Y6IJE[QJ[HO=XQZ,O V[J[]J
]JEI[QNVMJE[QL
\[.2L ](SP= EQYJWQYHO &YHVJ]KEZE
QY6IJE[QJ[=Y
HO HO ZYJ^YJ
RJVOI=)J 7MJL
_RJLVG,
EYQMJZQSP=EQYJWQYHO UP[Q]K
### N]×K)7MJL
YJ
Q>Q
Y6IJE[QJYEZQV7
IJYOIJN]IJZQ2]([TJZX1YQV7QY6IJE[QJL
R(Y ZQEN]Q]K[J X*ZIJN]IJ
IJX[+YJ Y6IJE[QJ ZHOYJGWMJESQ
KF(¡HM- JQSEF*Q
IJYIO JU]H JYVJUHOYEJ I2]([.LSEF*QYT(T3J\Q[Q
\YJ
YJETQ2](UHOYJZQ[Q>+IJZ
YJESQ1YQEI=V7QSEF*Q
N]IJ\+YJVJZHO=ZRJSH
]K[J
Y6IJ E [QJ SEF* Q \+ Y J
YJ ETQMJ L U H O M J EIU. V 7 Q
EU+VWH/VH[SJ *?VWQZQ2]()-[
- U
J YJ1Y]K[JY6IEJ [QJG
(\+YVJ RJLEI=
SHE[QL[GWH/9E[+YEN]Q]K[JAAU
Q#U
QTQ[[JE][[J]O¢H/Z&J Y(].#
ESQ1YQEI= E
ZVJ G
( VS+QEYQMJFP# OY1Y,/[[J[J UHO[Q
1YQ^PV7Q]KaaZHO=EN]Q]K[JEIQYJ[TJEQYJYE[QL\+YGJ +QVRJ
L YJY
YJN^TJEI[JZ=HO S[HE][JNVIJVQVWQYYHO ZQFJVEYQMJ[.L
4IJZHO= ,O1YRJ1Y[J (4IJY Y6IJE[QJLX\MJ K
VH[É/ Y
ZQ],O
[J# SS*Y¡HOYJTYQ]K XH]ÀQJY ?IJVYW[.LEI= [TJIRJ
N]×KYW[J N]×KY FJ E I= YWSZ. UH O [ Q
[+YJIRJE]\Q[J
YJS[É][JX[+YJ EI=[TJEI=T(V7Q 4IJE[+
E]\Q[J X.(EI=X[+YJ 4IJYHO [TJZ
.9 ZUIJ
YJ SHO=V?O[J
ZUO[J
YJ)M7 LJ E]KMJ
VJ#E]KMJZHY
O Z
J =HO YWG
L. MJX.
( YJ?QN]×K].
NVIJVQ[TJZ[HOMJYHO ZUIJZUO[J )7TJ]HOMJG+.\Q[J[TJ]HOMJT(V7Q
YJ
7H[JJ# G6MJGWYJY V4IJ # # # # # ENVQYJZVWQV7
O[HZYJY
YJEI=].
7HVJ
YJVT,OZEG[J
K
VH[É/Y
[I*E)+EI=4IJ
)7MJL\]J[.LZUIJSHO=V?O[JZUO[J
YJVWQV7Q
YW[J[IZ*QEI= 4IJ
X[+YJYE[QL
YJ UIJBUO[JV7Q
YWVJY6IJE[QJLVH[JEU+EYQMJVWQYY6IJE[QJX.(EI=VS+Q]K)7MJLZHO=
[Q]K[J EIQYJ SEF*QY >PZHOMJZYOIJX\H V
7HESFPUHOE[QL
Y6IJE[QJYXEZ5QL VE])HOMJFP
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
NVIJVQXE[QJXVWQVWQY(XPXUE[+YOH ¡OVTHY O J[QVZHY O JIQ
[QZRJ
7]H K[JXZQ[P].NVIJVQXE[QJVWQVWQ[GWH/9]RQ[[JVWQ
X]KXMJYE[QLZO]MJ IJYHMO JMIJZO]^J =]OH N. ^TJN^TJG
(\+Y^J =]OH N. ^TJN^TJN]×K
YW[.LEI=UHO
MJ VZO]JGWMJ1YFPN]YHIJV7QN]×KI.=
YJ
Q>QE[+ E^QJN]
\Q]K[J#XE
&Y( YHTÚ ZO]TJ
Q
7
H MJN]YIH Z J 7IJ
YJE
+[Q].SHV=O ?O[J
MJZRJN]×K
YJ
Q>Q[+YJ[.L ZY*QYHO
+[J2](
YJ[+YJ1YRJLVJ
(X[+YJXY
QE[+V7QNV/]JYHIJ
7HE[QLXY
QE[+S(ZY*Q^+.9\Q[QYHO
N]IJE^QJ
MJ4IJE[+
VJKE%MJYWVJ E[+VQ7 ]K[JE?Q(V7Q[TJ]O J
NVIJVQZ[TJUJ)L T7 JZ@XVRJVWQV7E
79U,O XY
QYHO X*Z]H TJ QZ,O &Y(
)7MJL E
\Q2]( NVIJVQTQSQYHOE[QL XS,^Z7J\Q]K[J
X*ZH]JFQSQ)7MJLE
SQGWYJX[+YJ UHOZHOSRJ
YJ
Q>Q
[IJGP ZSQZ7 [IJGP Z ESQ1YQEI=%O? P EI=
\+IJ]YUOIJ YUOIZ J TEIEI=1YQS]E[EI=
IOIJR+IJ=T IOIJZ X*KEI=X*KEI=
EXQMJZ7KUHO KUHOZ [I*E)+EI=%O?PEI=
SQZHOKEGKMJ KEGKMJZ ESQ1YQEI=%O?PEI=
NVE[QMJE[QJSZMJ E[QJSZMJZ 1YQS]E[EI=TEIEI=
S([MJY6[JU( S([MJY6[JZ X*KEI=X*KEI=
EXQ
([IJEUQMJVOIJ [IJEUQMJVOIJZ [I*E)+EI=%O?PEI=
GWVJ Z,O I[JE[QJ I[JE[QJZ ESQ1YQEI=%O? P EI=
VHEIQJN]QSHO N]QSHOZ 1YQS]E[EI=TEIEI=
VHRH/[]HO=[+. []HO=[Z +. X*KEI=X*KEI=
\.MJ[E]KMJ [E]KMJZ [I*E)+EI=%O?PEI=
>Q]KEIQYJU,OEYQJZ,V7EI=VWQY[TJZT(X[+YJUHOMJ
Q
YJ
Q>QN^TJ]K[J X\YJ]K >QYHO ESESGWQGWQ EZLZQ
MJ (ZHO
E[+9
VJ
[TJ][JV7Q
7TJ EI=
7HSRJLXIYJ ENGQYJEI=SQ >QV7Q
]KMJ]K[JV]K[.L)7TJEI=Y[IZ*QEI=)7MJL
Q?O
%O?PEI=YOH )7T]J OHMJ G+S
. RJ#I,IYJ]MOH J %O?
P #V+IJ Z+]. HOMJ
Q?O S[JV7[JESQE1YQMJL GOITJ
YJ
S[É][J[+MJ
7TJEI=N^TJ@
EKYJ[QZ7EF
>QV7Q],OT,[TJGO
7HEI[J
Y
]K[.LEI=ENGQYJEI=XIYJEI=MKEI=YX[+.)M7 JL]KMJ]K[J
ESQ1YQI.= %O?P#TEII.= 1YQS]E[#[I*E)+I.= %O?P (EI=E[+Y]\V#
O[H)7MJL T[O[ZVWQV7Q
YJ
Q>Q N^TJEI[J X*KY X[+.V
7H[.L
EI=N^TJ2]([[HZX[+YJ
YJ
Q>QN^TJ[J
G
]\VEZZ[TJTOX[+YJ
YJ
Q>QVWQYO[HEZZ
XTOI.= [[HEZZXTOE[+V7Q(X[HOMJN]IJE][J
XZQ[P]. N]×K
YJE
+^HO= 4IJNV/]J XY
QV7 [JZY*Q
7H]K[J(V7QZRJ],OT,E]]K[J#
YJ
Q>Q[OIJYI.=UMJUMJ].#SHO=ESQJ
ENGQYJEI=V?O[J
7TJEI=N^TJ[J4IJNV/]JZY*QYA[VQ#SYJ
MJ#
XMJ1YMJ# UP
TJa XQZ,O X]MJEZ]MJ IQVRJE[+]K ]\VXO]JTOMJ
EZZX[+YJN]×KEI=E[+YOH YHOTJ QN]/]K[JO[HXO]JTOI.=[[H
XO]JTOZE[+ X[+YJZRJ(X[HOMJN]IJ\]J]K[J(V7QZRJEI=)7TJEI=
X[+.EZ[+.EIQYJ\]J)7TJ&YHVJ E1YQL2](UJL)7TJZX[+YJZQ]K[J
N]×KEI=VWQ
[VQ TEIEI=1YQS]E[EI= [IJGPZX[+YJ
SYJ
MJ ESQ1YQ%O?P YUOIZ J X[+Y
J
XMJ1YMJ [I*E)+[IZ*Q IOIZJ X[+Y
J
UP
TJ X*K
Q?O KUOHZX[+Y
J
O[HEZZ)7MJL [[HEZZX[+YJ (X[HOMJN]IJZQVJ
EN]QT
Q[TJGO
7H[QYO[HXE1YQMJV7Q]K[.LSYJ
MJ\.YA
MJa
YHTÚ XY
Q A
a YHO >QV7Q
Q?O EXQYJV7Q N]\Q[J (V7QE[QL
FJZHON^TJ[JVSHFP#%O?PN^TJEI[J
EIQYJUYJ[+. ¡-]K
##X*ZIJ
GO>+IJZ
YJESQ1YQEI=VQ7 Y6IEJ [QJKF(¡M-H J QSEF*Q
)7MJL X*ZIJ N]IJG.L]K[J XH)HSVO
QY Z-HMJEZ XZ+IJ\IJ[J#
XQE
%W]MJZJY]HU O HO [JE[QMJEZQYJ&Y( [.L Z-MH J E[+1YQV7QSEF*Q
YZHVJLZHOYJ ENVQYJZHOYJ YWZHOYJ EN%QMJUIJEI[JK\YJUHO[QY
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
ZQ3(VJ EXMJ2VH/9U( 3([RJ2]( ZH-MJEZXIJ[O GO[JEVQMJZQT3JV7Q
EZVOIJ[HOMJ&Y(ZQEI]K[JEXMJ2VH/9YSEF*Q
.9XEIQYJENVQYJVQ7
VOIJ[HOMJYXEIQYJE[QMJY ZQ[J SEF*QZVJE1YQMJYHO EN]QMJ
[JXEIQYJTPTPFYJZ7RJL
E[QLZQEI[.LVOIJ[HOMJU([RJL[RJLI(]K
S+QEI
2]( EXMJVE
QYJF. W(FP[(E
QYJS+Q]K[J SPUHOYJ
VJL
UH]Y J VJE
QYJ^=OH SEF*QYXQ^
HYYVJ¡HO [VJYHO Y]J2]( GO[JEVQMJS+Q
[JEIQYJU,OE[QLEXMJYHOE
QYJ]K[JNVIJVQG
(SRJVWQYE[QL
G,
[.L OYSY O X E]KMJI.= G
(ZVJVEGWQ[.L XN^TJYOH \+YZ J Q[.L N]×KEI=].
XN]TJ^HO=1Y]K[J
XYOSHOZJSRJ[TJGO[RJZQG.[J]MJZJI(
YJU(
\.E
QYJ
E[QLSEF*QXMJWMJ[TJZ,O]WYJ[J]HO=UPXYJYHOE
QYJE[QLEYQZ
?QZE[+ 1YQ
[JY6IJE[QJ[HO= SEF*QYHO UPXYJ[PENVQMJN^[J2](
ENV\.]MJZJ VYJ([Q E
I(,]MJZJ
YHO MJG+MJLVE]FP S[MJN^TJ
EI[J]
HS[J\V. 7 [GW/H 9S[H
]KZHVLVJ JGOUPXYJXE
XGMJ
I.=EIQYJUYJ[+.YHTÚE[+G
(SRJ[GWH/9ZRJEYLEXQL+[J?O]JXQ^
H
E[QMJT+IJXMP
YZ7RJL][JS+Q1Y
E[QLV7Q].ZHO=E[+VHZQ2](X.(YSQ
S+Q
MJG
(YEIQYJ\]J)7TJZ1YQE[QLVJ[GWH/9YZRJY6IJE[QJ[=HO
SEF*QYHO X(WTJY \HIJSHVJ\QV7Q 2%H[HS5I.= X(WTJXTHO
[HO= SEFQ
[PR(GWYJV
VGWMJSEF*QYHOZ8[JE]V7QV?O[JFPZHO=THO
HVJZQ1Y[J
(V7QZRJYSHYEXQYJN^TJSV5X[+YJN]×KESQ1YQEI=I.=
YJ
YHO]. XN]TJ[MJ1YN]IJ[JXE
E]EI[.L (IQ
(XIRJMJX[+MJ FQE[+
N^TJEI[JE[QLY6IJE[QJVSH]KFPSEF*QY]À[HIJYE[QMJY6IJE[QJ
[HO=YHOFQV5EN]QVN]]KFPFQE[+N^TJG.LN^TJG.L#EIQYJIQ
(XIRJMJX1YQ
V7QE[QLY6IJE[QJ[HO=ENV\.]MJZJ\.MJZQG.L]K2](#XQZ,OE]WQJE]WQJ]K]K
E]KL
V7N]RJL)7TJ1YQYQZV7QY6IJE[QJX*ZIJV7Q].NVIJVQ
%OFQSQZHOEI]K[J(1YQGOV7Q
IJYIO J[TJEGKYJN]IJE
QYJG.L
[J Y6IJE[QJLF>Q[JE1YQMJ UYJEN]Q
# ZPZ[J]HOMJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ
.9F>Q[JZVJEIQYJG,YHOSPEI\HMO J
Q
NVIJVQN]RJN]IJE
892](Y6IJE[QJUYJEN]Q]KE[QLVJZPMJFV7ZPZQ
ENVQYJGWHIJZPZ[J]HOMJMJGWHIJV7Q
7MJN]/X2](
V7Q>Q[JZVJEG[ÉUOMH J\QG.L
[Q]
HS[JS[H
]KZHVVJL JKYY6IJE[QJLYH O J]HOMJX[/][ À Y ÉH HOXYW3J
EN]Q2](SPO1, YRJ2](ZOY
H Z
J O][
J L. ¡HO
Q\,O [VJE[+YOH V(EVQMJ\HO N]GWMZJ ]=HO K
(V7QE[QL FY$XT,OV7 S.Z+IJT&YH/YHO U+.P2](XQZ,OTOE]KMJ],OE^QJ
]KVJNVIJVQ[TJEQYJYOH ZPZ[J]MOH J ],O ](]N( ]MJN]MJXV7[Z J Y4QE]Z+MJ
ET[.L ],O
H]JYHO E^QJ]KVJ SP=
.9 FG
( GO ZPZ[JX]HOMJX[+YJE
Q
EIQYJZQVRJLX]HOMJVWQX[+YJ]KXGWYJXZYJVWQYHOY6IJE[QJLYHOJ]OMH J
XE[+9X1Y,/V7[GWH/9V7P]KVJ#[GWH/9E[QLY6IJE[QJNVMJE[+91YQSHSV5
Y]K]KZHVJLVJ
ZP ] WH / E]KYJ F Z+ I J E NVQYJ Z Q[. L NVIJ V Q%O F QSQY
\HVJNVQZYJ\]J]KVJ#XHVJE\QMJSRJFI.=EI]KVJ
##ZPV-UYJU,E
)7MJLXHVJE\QMJE
\HVJNVQZYJ\]JNGMJSH=VO ?O[J XHVJE\QMJSRJFXTYHONVIJVQXS,O
X)-IJS,OVWH/I.=E^QJN]]K[JAV*ZQEUQMJSRJa#AZYJ\]JSRJa#ATOZWQ
###VHF)7MJLSQSV(
VH F VWQX[+ Y J [É
QMK]K)7 M J L X[P XT3J X UYJ
ETQMJL\HIJZQSRJL XT3JXZQ# XE[+XNVMJ# ,O1YRJV- \,O[VJ)7MJL
NVIJVQ%OF QSQ[H=O ZYJGG, S
L. V5?QVHFYSQSV(XE]\Q[.LEV[ÉQYHO
NG,/M,ON]EI]K[J VHF[É
QVWQY
VEYQMJ[QVZO]JEXQMJ[QNVTJNGMJ
EYQMJV-EYQMJ
QYHO R8IJN]NGMJ
X[[J]RQSMJ1YQE]NGMJ
ZO]JYHOMJTQ
IJX
MJX)7(E]NGMJ
ZYJ\]J\HVJNVQE]NGMJ
ZY*Q VEYQMJNVTJ \Q# EYQMJ
QR8IJZ [J# X[[JS MJ ET#
E]E)7(
MJ#\HVJNVQNGMJ
VHF EV[ÉQ YHO ASQ[HO= ¡O] J
RJ# S([ QVRJS Q# E
1YRJGWVJNV#
[TJE]KYJYWY#VHF[HO=VJ#2MHVJT[VJaUHO[.LUHO¡HOTYQYEYQMJEYQMJ
E^QJN]EI]K[JSQSV(XE]S,EQ>3J&Y( ]K[JAE[QMJUOH ]Z,O UHO
SQ]TJ
[J#SQUHOSV(UHO V]TJ
aUHO[L. TYQ],Y O ZRJ(SE, Q>3JY
E]ZQ[Q]KVHFVWQYSQSV(YHOSP[HO=)7MJLX[P1YQ)HOMJSV51YQ1YQ
VG.+VG+Q EIETZHO[J
7H[.L ]TÚRJE[+YHOZRJ G+.E S,OT+.ETGWMJ[J
EKYJ[QZ7EF
EIQYJU,O [É
QY R8IJ[.LX[HOMJ SQSV( EYQMJEYQMJV+IJV+IJ XHVJ
E\QMJ
YJSQYW[QZRJ1YRJLZHONVMJZHO[J
SQSV(N]/TO1Y[QYZRJ)HOMJM,SQEYQMJN^TJZQET^HO=#[QIJSH
SQSV( N^TJZQETZHO[.L U)V7 ZQ]K[J AZYJ3(U
Q VRJ\HOYJT+Q
]O]ÀQT
HVH)7MJL^aZHO=E
7E?QMJEUQMJ]OJYUHO[JVHFVWQY(XUHO
.9
ZHO
MJSQVYTQSQXH]ÀQJI.=]KYHOYJEXQMJYWMJL1Y,1Y[J#KV7ZRJ
XSHMO J XIJ][JIJYWMY J AVHEYQMJ^GMJSQSV(aZO=H NVMJ[JASQSV(
VEYQMJ#VHFEGKMJaUO[ H L. TYQYHZO RJZP[MOH J SH\QE[QLVE]KLU1YFP
YV«Q[TJIJV7 VHFXQZ,O IRJ[P SQSV(VWQYHO AUMJT(2]( NVMJ
,[Qa
NVMJGWMJ1Y[JAUMJIMJNVMJYIJG,
[QaVZHOZQ1Y]KFPVHF)7MJLSQ
SV(1YQS,EQ>3J E)7QMJ^+.9V-YNVIJVQN]RJV7QXEIQYJ[HOMJ\YJ GHOMJNV.
]K[J
SQSV(YVHFYHOGWTJGMJ¡HOES[QYZRJG6MJGWYJV
7HZP[HOMJ]K].
VHFEYW>PXE1YQMJ1YQ
#SMJ
#TQXO]JTQE]V7Q^[J1Y
]K[JAVHF
EYW>P NVMJLVHO
JE[QMJ3( VYYW0a ZHO=ZRJ UHO¡HOTYQ [TJGO
HE7 S[J
NVMJLVHO
JE[QMJXE1YQMJEN]QG.L]K2](#T1Y:QV7QXNVMJLU,OE[QMJ#EZY6IJ
%?HOVQ7 ENVQYJY6IJ #E[QMJY6IJ#XE
79Y6IJ#XEIQYJY6IJUHO[.L Y6IJ &Y(
EZY6IJIJ
,EI[JZPZQENVQYJ[.LSQSV(E[+YVHFYHOZO]JEY6
SV-N]/[J#XHOVMJVT+VJVHFVWQYHOETQMJLE
7QYJYPR[ ( JVHFYYH O JLYHO
ZPZQENVQYJSRJX\HEY6EV+N]/TOG.L[.LEYW>PU]J1Y[Q]KVHFVWQYHO
ZRJXIE)©QXI)©MK]KTQ
MJS+MJ\Q[JSQSV(XVWQTOYSP[HO=
[JMK]KYHO SH]K[J
SQSV([J MK]KY
VHFYHOZO]JEY6NGMJ#
VHF[HO=@XV-YHTÚYHOEUQMJ
+YJE]NGMJ#
VHFVWH/)+JYHOETQMJL\HIJNGMJ#
XEV+\HOYJG,EXQMJ N]/YWMJLNGMJ#
VHFX[+YJYOSHOZJEYQMJV-N]/ÑXV5ENGMJ
ZY*Q EY6EV+V]WYJ#EUQMJ
+YJT(V,#EV+G,\HOYJET#ZPV5EÑ#
ETQMJLEZVWH/)+J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
###U
Q)7MJL[]RJL
VHF)7ML J SQSV(UYJUE,
YHO U
Q[]RJL UYJUE,
YX2]/H M J 37 Z
J WYJ
7]H K[J[]RJ[ L X
=OH [+YJ U
QYO[ H VHF]KU
QY[]RJL YH O YJ WIJ VQ
TH[JGWVJSQ2]( ·4J]RQV7Q ^+,9ET^HO=I.= FQSQE
YHOMJ¡H-MJET
IJ XNV.
)7ZO, S+MJ \Q]K[JU
QY[]RJL
.9SMJ1YQN]SPN^TJ[X .L N]MJX1Y,E]
IVPIQN] ]O¢H/ZJZRJ N^TJ]K[J []RJLY U
QYHO ,O1YRJXQ\Q2](
STÚQZRJG,
]K[JX.KE[+YZ HO RJU
QYXZ+V. S,O VHEXQMJ\HIJ
]K
[JVHY O VJ Q7 VHSRJL []RJY L OH U
QYU,O V
IJIJVEZFPA[]RJVL EYQMJ
U
QEGKMJaZHO= TYQ],OY UHO\QV?O[JZQZHO= U
QY EN]QT
Q
7H[J
U
QL [QIJ Y []RJL X QZ, O ZP E YQMJ SP E YQMJ N^TJ ZQET
IJ
],OS+MJE]^HO=]K].
U
QL[JMK]KYE[QL
[[JSHT
QX[[J]RQVWQSMJ1YQE]NGMJ#
VHVH[[JSV5VG6MJVGWIJSMJE]NGMJ#
]HOVHO[YJSHET
IJ
SMJLE[QJ
QXNGQU
QVWQ\, X]J)7,E]NGMJ#
ZHVQEXQMJU,OVN]/N]MJE]NGMJ#
EFX)©
QJV7 YQY+JE]NGMJ
ZY*QX[[JZRJSMJ#].LN]MJU,OV#SH]ÀVGWIJ#EF
IJU(YQ#
SMJL
QX]J^HO=
E
7EG[J[]RJLVWQYU
Q)7MJL]HOVHO
MJ)7(V-
7H],O
]K[J]K:HEK?Q
IJU
QYHO XQYHO[J#XE[QJVWQVWQYU
QLTYQ
ENVJVYW V7[J[J U
QYHO ¡HOESV-)7MJLX[P ZHOYJEZWQR(E\+ZO]J[.L
XYWMY JL U
QLXE],1O YRJV-N^TJZQ[J(1,O YRJVI- .= X[P]K[.LU
Q
EN]QSV5YHO FO
QE?QESIQS^+J XV7IJZHO= V7[JP[.L XYWMJLV7QE]WQL
Y+Y[ J TJGO
7HEI]K[J[]RJLYOH YH O ]J OMH JXT+VJ XTIRJET[J#XE
&Y(
EKYJ[QZ7EF
[.LN]×IQE[+YHO E^IJT[H NJ ^Q1YRJL[L. XEZLXYWMJLVZO]JEXQMJ?IJ[
= Q
[JXT3JXZQGWV7[JZQ[.L
[]RJL[JMK]KYE[QL
\\ Y Y&YH/TQXQ\O[JNGMJ#
U
QU,OVS+IJSMJ X1Y,E]SRJYHO IQG,NGMJ#
SMJ1YQE]SV5YHO SMJPYWYJV7[JNGMJ#
U
QZQESQXGKEYQMJT+QG
(3(&YH/)-[JUYJNGMJ#
U
QL\,]KJ N]/^+JXZO]JYHTÚVWQZO]JE]NGMJ
ZY*Q R(RQ\ Y# U,OVIQP# ZQVP&YH/U(# \,I(ZO]JEY6#
SMJE[+X,
+[J
###VH[JEU+XGWMJGWMJ
XE]KMJXSMJYHO EGUHO[.L EK?Q
)7TJGOY A
.EFQJ SOH=V?O[J
V?QVH[JaXH]QÀ JEUQMJ[L. VH[JEU+I=. SPMJGWMJAMJT3JVQ7 X[PN^TJGLS
. aP
SPMJGWMJ)7TJEQYJ1YQTRJE)7QMJ[.LS,EQ>3JYZRJXZ+IJSIJVQ
]K[JVH[EJ U+VWQA[TJEZ7[RJT(2]([TJG
(\.SQ+ a1Y
[JE]WQJ
M8 J
T
QE
Q]PEU+VJIRJT
QYHO]KSPMJGWMJGWMJV5EG,TQ
[JEXX[P
]PXV5 EI1Y
[J VH[JEU+
MJGWQ N^TJ^HO= T+I=J
[J# STÚQ
7H
[J
(ZHOX]JGWYJX[HOMJVYHOYJR(SPE[+YSQQE]KMJVH[JV5SQN^TJ]K[J
VH[EJ U+E
+GWIJ RJI.= VH[JEU+VWQXE]UYJUN, ]/VP]Y ,O OH R8I[
J L. NVIJVQ
U,OVTQZY*QE[+VIRJZ7]KFP2]( E[QLNVIJVQVHFVWQYZRJSQSV(
VWQZPE]KMJVV7QVHET
IJ[^+^+U,OVZWYJ]KZPE]KMJV7QG.L
MJSP=XSHOMJ
XIJV7QSHYQ YWVJSP]K[.LZPX = ^+.9XTRJ]KO4JSHYQ\HVJXYWMLJ
UHOUHO[Q YPTYJNVIJ[J E
7E
7TYQ],OY AEG+E[QYJ S
YJNVTJGWMJ
7YVJ P XS(GW/H VQ7 XGK]KZWYJ
SQ]WYaJ ZH=O UH]O K[JVH[EJ U+[TJEQYJ
[TJ&YHVJ[TJGKVTTJV7IJ?IJVYW¡,OV5)7MJLUYJU,E
YHOASTJGWH/KGWH/VGWH/
a
ZHO= NVIJVQXU,OXVZRJ
7H]K[J ?IJVYWG.L
MJ N^RJN^RJ)7MJL RMJRMJ
SQSQN^[J
]KVJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
###EU+VWH/XGWMJGWMJ
SQQE]KMJVH[JEU+VWQ
7HSZHOASQQE]KMJEU+VWH/VWQaZRJ
7H]K
[J KY Y6IJE[QJ
.9 EK?Q
\+MJZ,O]K NVIJVQVWQYE[QL AE
8
7HV7
XVWH/E[QJ[JaUHO[.LYHOJLX[+YJSQ
7Q[.LEU+VWH/VWQYHOEGT
QTYQ
7H2](SQ]KAEU+VWH/aYHO AE
8VWH/aXN^TJ TYQZ,ON]MJ2](I3TÚQ
7HV7 XVWH/
E[QJGWMS J PX[+YJS,O)-IJ]K[JXVWH/EYQMJYE[QLXE
UHOZ5MJYPR(
E\QYJ],L
IJXSMJL
7HEIVJNVIJVQ%OFQSQMJVWQTH[JV7QS[H
EIVRJL
FO
QE?QN^QV*ZQ\.YV*ZQ[TJ]K
7H]K[JARQ[YQI3Ú
S*E?QaEU+VWH/RQ[H[X HO= QE\QYJ]LE, ]YVJNGMJSRJV*ZQN^TJ]K[J
[.LXZ+IJV+IJNV[J[.L(V*ZQ[
QYHOTQUHOX[HOMJ[SEV[HVJYWM1LJ Y,
ZHO=Z+IJZ+IJY.Y.E[+
7H[Q,OV7Q^+JV
7H]KFPNVIJVQFO
MJVWQEG[JXGK
\.Y XVWH/YHO E\QYJ],LE]YVJZ+IJZHO= ASQ[PR(VWQ EYQMJTQE
a
N^TJG[ L. QE[+XVWQ&Y( ]K].V7[[ J VJ
7[
H L. SVOMH J [EZ5QYJZO, 3TÚQ YJ1S>Q
[. L XGKZRJ
7 H # V
[. L XGK ZRJ
7 H ] K[J EQYJ W QI. = VH I J V
XE1YQMJ]K1Y[JUHO[QY I^PTQ SHO=V?O[J Y, Y T(V,SRJL YHTÚ].
âXV7 I J [
QY EXQYJ V 7 Q E^QJ N ]VJ L XH V J E \QMJ E
X^+ M J L V 7 Q
E]Z+MJZQ[J
XHVJE\QMJE
?QZPV-E
YHTÚSYJSYJ].FJ[IO J YV7FQSQE
YHTÚX\+[X J NV[J
ZH=O VS[JV7[J]KFP%OFQSQ¡HO
QX
E[QLZP=F
GHO
QZHOYJ
GOH
QZHOYJ2](RQ
[.LXN^TJYE[QLZP&Y(VWQYZYJVG,)HOMJ[.LYHTÚ#
VHEYQMJ^GMJSQSV(V](SZHO=V7[JP[J#SHEO= SQJZRJZPMJ]MHO J¡P¡P
VHOYJVHOYJEZE[+YE[QL XQE]XQENVQYJ ZO]J[J GHOEN][QZRJ
X\YJYEN]QG.L[.L ]HO]IJ#EV[ÉQV5
.9EIQYJUYJ[+.]K].
E
7NVIJVQVWQ]HO]IJ1Y[QYE[QLZP&Y(VHFVWQVWYEJ TLEKYJE\QYJ
1YRJLEI[.L1YQYZO]J1Y
[Q]KE
7EG[JYX
Q
QEXEXEUEU
EKYJ[QZ7EF
THVJEN]IEN]ZO]J1Y
[J#TH[J
7RJ[QYZRJO4J]OJ[TJGON^TJEZE[QL
S,O)7TJS,OVHO]HO]IJ[JUHO[Q\,OT,].G6MJGWYJSH]JV
7HZ7FP[H[J[UH[J
GWIH J E[+9[QE[+(EI=EG[JX[HMO J ].#V
7VH ?O[]J KFPSH=EO SQJYH O YLJ
OH Y
J OH J
ASa\Q[.LEYQMJYEZGWTJSPXHVJAR(XTJYHOVSH[SHXGWHIJaREI
IQ
(V7IQ
(GIJ=
V7QS+QVJ#[HO[HO[HO[HO)7TJYO H 1J YQUHVO JASYJ&Y(
EGKMJGWGWIH JaRIQ
(GIJ=
X\HZRJEQMJZRJZRJI=. VN]IJESF.EI
AZP]WH/N]IJGWHIJaRIQ
(GIJ=
E
QYJV7SP=YEZVYHO)-[JUYJ2](N]IJ[J
XGWHIJ[IJE[QL ZYJ\]J1YVJ#SHO=V?O[J GHOEN]1YVJ(V7QY6IJE[QJ
E
7EG[JS,O XGWHIJN] EK?Q
E[+ S,OG.L[QS[HN]/VHV7Q]K ][JIJYWMJ
XEIX\QYHO NVMJETGWMJZHO=]K
(EG[JV7QE[QL S,O)7TJETQMJL
[Q 1YQZ+IJ[JZHO= ZPMJVWQY
\MJ[JE
7\,OXGW/]JXGWJE[+ V
7HE[QL]KFPXNVMJE[+ EN]QMJ2](
ZHF O E[+YZRJXUVWQT+Q[HO]+QZQ]K2]([GW/H 9VWQS,OZE[QMJVETQMJL
)HMO EJ [QLFP (EG[JYZRJSH[L. X[HMO J ].EZ#AXMJT[MJEL YQJ^a( #AXMJT[MJL
EGKYJU+.a I.= AXMJT[MJL ?HO?Q(?Qa EG[JYHO KLN]MJZRJ YV«Q&Y(Y
EN]QMJZ.ZQ# T,GWIH TJ R , I8 J E[+ [IJ^HO E[+Y EN]QMJZ.ZQE[QL ]HO IRJ
]IJIRJYZRJ ZHOYJEZWQR(E\+ N^TJEXQMJ ZHOYJEN]QMJ
E[QL[QE]KL
EQYJ W QEZVWQY ]H O 2 ]( [RJ L [ H O &Y( N^TJ 2 ]( ]H O
. Z Q[J #
VHIJYEZVWQZRJ
7YJYHO
7YJYIJ2MHVJ2MHVJYO]JYO]J SH]JV?O[JE[QLFP
EQYJWQEZYSP=XZHOYHO N]RJL^HO= IRJS,OIRJ
7H[J [TJIRJIRJYHO
S,OZHVJLVJ]\VIRJYSHOSHOSH]JSH]JIRJ
RJTQTQE
VJ#TQYHO
EYQMJVEZYHO YHOJ[HOMJE]GWMJE]VJ# TQ[HOYJV7 \RJLGWMJ\RJLVJ
SHV=O ?O[J 1YQZPY[UMJL E]GHMO J VJO[ H IRJYEXQMJS + J\QIRJ#
KYSPS[ÉHV
7HZHO=YHOJ[HOMJVZO]J
.[.LXGKS,O[.LIRJ].[[HIRJY
[HOYJ¡HOYJIRJ# VHIJYEZYHO YHOJ[HOMJE[+9 EN]QUHO SHVJS+MJPIRJ
(IRJ\.Y[TJGOGO)7MJL?IJYWG.LZ5MJSP[HO=GWTJSPN^TJ2](ZYJ\]JGWMJ2](ZQ
VHFE[+Y ]KZQE[QL VJ X
+JVE
QYJESZHO= MJ]KES[J#
]RQ[TJ]HOMJ[TJT)7MJL EYWQMJ2]( EXQMJ EI]K3(# TSRJ TSRJE]KL
GWTJSPT,O[+.V7Q[NGQIRJZVJV
7HE[QLFPPUHOZ5MJE[QLGOHVJ#YEZVY
GHO
QZHYO VJ JXZ+IX J Y6, Y.SQ+ [.L [GW/H 9YHTVÚ W/H V7QE[QLESE1YQMJ1Y[ , Q
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
N^TJ[[J[JY6IJE[QJ[HO=
+QYYHOJ[HOMJE[+91Y,/GL
. [.LGHOEN]V-XE1YQMJ
EN]Q]KVJ#E]WQJ
8MJ^+J >Q[JE]KMJYEZ)7MJL]K
Y6IJE[QJLSPMJGWMJ[TJEQYJXSYJEZQYJ
7HVJ#SPY
7MJN]E[QLVNMMJ)HOMJ[.LXE1YQMJN]E]KLVHFE[+YEIQYJU,OZYJEZ5QL
SEFQ[P1Y
XVHOYJXV.YEZE[+YHOXHVJV7QN]IJZYJG,VJ#EI=EYQMJ
7QV
]KFPNVIJVQE
Q]RQ
7MJ[GWH/9ZRJHYHTÚYHO
7MJN]^HO=XQ\O[J^P
]K[J(V7QE[QL
7MJN]],O)7TJVWH/YHOSP[O=HX
7HX[HOMJEN]QN]]KVJ
],ON]MJ)7MJLV[P[QVWH/V?O[J]KFP
(YHTÚYYV«Q3(YTG.[ L QE]KLYV«Q&Y( N^TJE]ZQE[QLI[JN]RJY
N%?Q&Y(E[+ TOE[2](YHOJ]HOMJXE
QMJXKI.= YV«QE]V7QE]ZQ[J
]\VENVU(X
SQYHO X
SQ
7Z H O=H TQ1Y[J#KI.=SP[O=H YHOEJ
QMJY HO J K
E]WQYJY + [J JEIQYJZ7][.LXS+M#J X¡O]JUHO [.L],EO [+N^TJZQE[QL[J
ENVU(X
SQYHO TQZHO=YOIJE[QL EXQYJYENV XZ8QYHO TQ1Y N]IJE
Q#
XTQVSMJLE[QLSP[HO=TH[JV7QEZQFMJZQ[J#EZQFMJE[QLSP[HO=
V7(.T
QYOIJN]IJE
Q(EIQYJ TQT
QA]KZ[QaEG)+JGWH/Y.LSO=EH SQ
X
QYHOTQ1Y
[JXGWHIJ1YQ[.LXGK]KZ[QZRJTQZH=Y O OIJN]IJE
Q
(ZHOI.= XZHOZHOE]KYJ[.L SEZUIJTQ1YN]IJ# EIQYJU,OUIJYHO THOYJ]WH/
TQ
SRJL EG[JZPSQN^TJZQ[JZHO= UHO]K[J
UYJ2](Y6IJE[QJ TQV7Q]K[.LX[HOMJEN]Q]KVJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
AAEQYJWQV7Q EQYJWQN^TJE1YQMJ ¡O]JX*KN^TJE]YOIJ@
VHIJVV7QVHIJVN^TJE1YQMJ¡O]JX*KN^TJE]YOIJ@
\HOSO=H N^TJE]ZQESQXGKEQYJWQSRJVHIJVYHOVHIJVSRJ
ZRJ EQYJWQYHO 1YRJL¡HO 1YRJLT3J\YJ 1YQNVMJLT+Q [THVJLTHVJL
TP TH O Y J Ñ 1YRJ L ¡ - @ \H O S H O = [TH V J L T H V J L 1 YQNVMJ L T + Q TP TH O Y J Ñ
1YRJL¡-N GMJ E1YQMJL \HOVHIJV EQYJW Q[HO=V7Q YQV
Q ]P]IJV-
N^TJ E ]ZQ@ \H O S H O = N^TJ E ]ZQESQE1YQMJ L EV\O IJ X V- Y H O
N]/YWMJLYOIJ@ XSV
SPNV[J[
Q V?O[JSRJL EV\OIJXV-YHO
V7( N. GMJ?PESQXE1YQMJE1YQMJL \HS O [P Y =OH OH ]RQ
7[ H Y =OH Y.
L 9. YOI@ J
ENVV-IJ= N]Q)+QEGW[HO=N^MJL ]YJYOIJE]KYJYOIJZWYJ
RMJU.YIO J@
\H O = E 1YQMJ L \H O X S V Y H O ^O O , Y+ J
IJ X [+ Y J XH V J [ H O = Y H O
EUQYJZO]JYOIJ@aa
G.^HO@VPZXTYHO EN^
7MJN]T
QXN^TJ NVIJVQSOGVHIJVWQYYV«Q3(
N^TJE]],OYOH U+.P XS,O GW\QSRJVQ7 N^TJ)MOH JEGW
7¡H VO, 5VY]KXFJE1YQMJL
UHOESQJ âVPYHO SP[OH= XZHOYW N^RJLT+YJ\Q]KES[JN^RJLT+YJGWYJY
AAX
7YJ
7HYOIJESQ SPE[QJEYQMJ[HO=Y X
7YJV.LSP[HO=X[+YJ XHVJQ
EUQYJE]2]( XHVJYHO G.)7MJL\O2]( )7MJ\O[J1YYOIJ@aa âXT3JXZQSRJ
UYJZYJ[RJ
7HEIU.?O ]RQ
7H[HO=YUHO]K[J
EIQYJ[TJ]TO, ,¡HO
Q],ON]MJYZRJG]JUMJUMJ]K].#Y+Z . V+. - IRJIRJE[QL
]K[J
N%?Q&Y(YHO]KYV«QENVE]E
QYJZQ[J]\V>Q[JZVJV7QZHO
N%?QXVWQ&Y( V?O[F J P SP[Y
=OH UIJYOH PTQ2]( E[QLEQYJWQMKEQYJ
VHIJVEZEQYJXN^TJ XS+MJEN]QMJS+Q[J EQYJWQEZEQYJY
VHIJVEZEQYJYHO YPE^QJXN^TJ PZHOYJ[J EQYJWQFYJ].L [TJ
EQYJYVEYWI]JE[QLE]WQEJ ]WQ
J M8
J M8 J X[+E. [+
9. EIXHVY J OH G.)M7 LJ \O[J
EQYJWQXVWQTO?Q(\.YX[HOMJSQ1Y/,
VHFVWQT(T3JSRJL XHVJE\QMJE
ZP&Y(VWQY T(T3JE][.L XHVJE\QMJE
Y XE
79[HOMJV7Q E
7XGK
Y[RJY
7HG.L[.L XT3JXZQ[TJGO]K %OFO
Q ZYJ\YJY[RJY
(XT3JXZQ
7HG.L2](UHO[QV7[J[VJV7[J
Q)7MJL
7H]K[JFO
QXEZQMJ
SH[Y)7VVJY+.ESQJQYHO\HVJNVQG.L[QVHFVWQ
.9SEFQ[PR(V-
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
I.=]K%OYHOXH)HV7Q^+QNVMJG.L[J#X.(V7QYGOEN]Q[.LVHFVWQT(T3J[.L
XHVEJ \QMJV-TITJ?QFO
QZYJ\YJE[QJJ V[HOMVJ (\YJVWQT+QETQ[.LXGWHIJ
\.Y
7HEI)HOMJ[J(XT3JXZQYHO EI= \HIJSHVJ\Q1YU. N^TJ[J
[¡O[JN]RJV7QZRJ(TITJY)7TJE]KMJE\QMJGW(2](
7HG.L[Q]KNVIJVQN]RJV7Q
E[QL (XT3JXZQYHO XH)HY
P\Q],O].P2](V7 YHOJ]HOMJXT3JXZQ
N^TJEXQMJZ]O J[Q
QTOEX(X[+MJV7QN^TJ)OMH J^+J
7H]K[J
QTOY
T2](XEIQYJ[HOMJ3JEYWV-¡HOYJG[JZQSRJL1YQY(TITJ?QEI=\H
ZRJXQSIJEIU.N^TJ]K[J(TITJYUYJUYJ2](ZRJX[HOMJXU
EN]QMJZ.2](
7HEIV7QE]KLVHFVWQYSQSV(XHVJE\QMJE
E[+V]PVJL
YQZE
QYJ 2 ]( SQSV( Y VH F YH O V¡H O E SVEZTQ[. L X GKV7 S Q
E]WQYJ Y + J ^+ J
7 H ] K[J ( Z H O N ^TJ Z Q^H O = Y E[QL N^TJ ) H O M J E GW
XE[QJE]KZHVJLVJ
XEIQYJ)MOH MJ V, WQV7QZRJ)7T)J MOH MJ V, 7 )HMO MJ X
, &Y( XY.VWQYHO T(T3J\VH J NVQ
E][Q# E[QJMJ VHSQTOMJVWQGWMJ XHVJE\QMJ EI
QGW\QE][QE[+
XHY XQN^MJL )HOMJM,E
XE1YQMJE1YQMJL
QTO)7TJVWQT+Q YWMLJS,OG.L[Q
SVHOMJV7Q E[+9
]K[J SHO=ESQJ N]RJSPZP\OY XO]JTHOSPZP[IJTQYHO
FJ X GKYV7 X[O V P G. L 1 Y]KFP XEIQYJ )H O MJ M , S QVWQY VH F Y
SQSV( YH O XH V J E \QMJ GWE][QYH O TH [ J Y P )7 MJ L ]MJ ZYJ V G, ] KFP
T(T3JEI
QGW\QV-V7Q XYW]JYHOMJ [.LSEFQ ]KEI[JZHO= \MJ[J
Y6IEJ [QJ2%[ H IH VJ Q7
7TH 3J[IO J Y2%[
H S
H 5VH[EJ U+VWQYNVIJVQN]RJVQ7 VHFVWQ
T(T3J[.LXHVJE\QMJE
TITJ
7HEIU.UH[ O Q1YQE[QLXE[QJ&Y([X,[ L 1S
N^TJ1Y[J (\.V7Q Y6IJE[QJ E[+9
[.L SPTHVJZPVWQ]MJ ]KMJ]K[J
(XT3JXZQ&Y(Y EG[J)7MJL VU(EZWQJFP# ^WYJSHVJSMJL2](ZHO= [GWH/9Y
PU[J[GWH/9YZRJKY VJIRJ^+J N^TJT
QZVJT]KEI[JZHO=
UHO[JSP[HO=
.9EFPWS,OS]JGWYJVWQYHOE\QYJG,],O
[.LS[MJ)7TJ]OJ
2%H [ H S 5 S[MJ TQVWQV7 Q ]KZQ[J # [TJ G O Y XEU+ >Q[J Z VJ #
EIQYJ[TJGOYX[MJX1Y]J N]/V- N^TJ]K[J
]\VVJIRJ^+JXN^TJVQ7 YXZ+I[ J MJ[.L E
7¡HO ?H)0 ^GMJYSV(YHO
S[J[.LN^TJ
]J]KSV(Y2%H[HIJV7QEI2](]RQSMJEI[J#^GMJYSP=
X[+YJ
RJTP \Q[.L ZPMJYOH SV(YZ,O ZYJVG,ZO=H N^TJ
[Q]KEIQYJ
[TJGOYZRJXH)HSQX^)7TJ3(XE1YQMJ]K].KYE[QLSV(YSP=
EQYJWQEZVH[JEU+I.=ZHOYJS+QZHO=SV(YVHFU)YHOVIQPFP#SP=YHO
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XH)HSQEYQMJYEZ[TJEQYJI.= IQE^QYJ2](SVYJEZQMJE
+2](
N^TJEI2](XE^YSV(YHOXGIJ]H[JESQLG[J\Q[JKE[+YXZ+IJ
X1Y0N^TJZQ[.LYHTÚE[+]KSH=EO SQJZRJ[TJ^YJV7QY2%H[HIJV7Q].XH)H
)+J SQSV(VWQVHF[HO= T(V,SRJL F1YMJE^QJYHO ZYJG,2](E]WQJ
8MJ^+J
XHVJE\QMJSRJFV7QEI\HOMJZWYJ
7HSPE[+ZRJXVWQ&Y(]K].
XEIQYJ[HOMJSQE[+
.9 3JEYWV- EIQYJG,Y [TJVWH/N^TJEI[J
SP[OHJ=YXE
79[HOMJV7QE
7RJ[RJ[,LEI[.L(\,O[VJT3JZQE[+
.9SEFQ
SFQYHOENGENGNVTJNVTJ\HOE^QYJVNVMJESSV5IQZRJV-
7H
IJVN^TJ)HOMJ
]KFP XE
79V7QY EQYJWQ[TJEQYJ?Q SP=VHFVWQY SP=X[+YJ
E
+\Q[.L VH I J VYH O ]\V ZYJ \ ]J P [ J # EIQYJ V 7 ]H O ]IJ [J
XEIQYJ[HOMJSQE[+YE[QLSP&YH/YJ[.LVHIJVYHOX
MJ]HO[JEIQYJV7
SPE
+ZHOYJ[.LSPYHO ZYJ\]J[J XEIQYJ[MOH J SQVWQYE[QL XE
79Y
TITJYHO YEN]QMJYN]IJ XHV JE \QMJE
ZHO = EGE]ZHVJ LVJ (T ITJ VWH /
X[RJN^TJETZQ[.L XE1YQMJ[
QE[+
7H]K[JNVIJVQ)HOMJM,V7QE[QL
(XE1YQMJE[+YNVIJVQ%OFQSQMJ &Y(N]MJ
[.L FI.= TH[JSEFQ
\Q]K[J VH F VWQYH O ¡H O E SV- I . = EZTQ SV- ] K[J SP = V 7 Q
UIJ=YWMJFYJZHMJI.= UYJU,E]KMJSMJV- IRJ]K[Q]K [J 2](E[QL
AXHVJE\QMJ3(FO
Q[RJEUVMJ
RJTO[J\HOaUHOSZHOZO]J2](
MJN]MJV
[.L
YHTÚXN^TJ XHVJE\QMJE
YHO XEZXIYJ ¡-NVMJ[Q ]K]K[J KE1YQMJL
XHVEJ \QMJSRJ UJ[V.+ Q7
7T[ J Y .+ ZP&Y( VHFVWQ T(T3J[L. XHVEJ \QMJE
YHO
ZYJ G,[ J YQY,
7MJ )7 TJ 3( ^P TQ SHO= V?O[ J Y, [
Q)7MJ L XR(
E
TYJUEO, T[.L IRJZVJ[TJ
]JXN^TJ)7T3J ( )7T^J YJZO, YVHFVWQT(T3J[QYHO
ZYJG,1Y[QX,L1ST
QV
7H]KFP
Y6IJE[QJ [MJN][.L XGWYJE[+YHO 3]VQ)7TJGOE]2]( E]Z+MJEXQMJ
EN]Q]K
ET(N^TJ
]J)7TJGOV7QXTYI3(V7QE[QLZYJVG,NMMJUIJV
- 7H[J#
ZPMJ)7TJ3(YVZHOYJ^YJE]FPZHOZ = RJ\MJT
Q
7H[J#EIQYJU,OV7QE[QL
EXQMJEXQMJNVMJNVMJETLT]JR)H -HMJ 2]( \HVJ NVQE])HMO GJ L[
. JK)7TVJ WQV1YQV(
Y]K
]\V>Q[JZVJV7QZP
+[ J TJEQYJ#¡O]J
RJSIJ=N]IJ=[J#]RQE[QJ
[J#XTHO
Q\P<QI)©
ZRJZYJ
HN7 ^TJ[JSP=VHGMJYEM+U[ HO QZHO[Q
XYOIJ
#EM+
Z5MJXYOIJ2]( ZHO=G,PSPN^TJ[JXEVYSP=SQYHO EM+E1Y
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
GWVJSQ YJ2](XUMJLX[IJ
7H[.L]O¢H/ZJ[TJ3(
.9[PVI.=ZYJ\]J
IJT(V,
[J KYH O SQ VSH E SF. ZO ] J Z H O Y J [ Q YEZVEZY
EQYJWQEZV7Q
7H[.LO4J]OJE[+FQV5V
7
H 7QFPEQYJWQEZYSP=V7Q
RJTQZRJ
7H\Q[J#SP=XEVT(T3JZHO=SPZYJ\]J
VRJLYEZVYHO
E[+9
E[QL TYQEVV
E[QMJ N^TJS+Q
7Q[JSHO=ESQJZRJSP=VHGMJYHO
EZTQV-E1YQMJLVHGMJT(VS , RJXL [HMO JYEZVYHO ZYJ\]JZYHO [
J JSP[O=H
>I(EVQMJ)7,XGOSQ&Y(#SV(&Y(E[+)7MJLN^TJEI2](
O[H>Q[JZVJY VHIJYEZ [TJEQYJXE1YQMJ]K SPY
EGWQEVQZ7]SP# SP=¡O]J
RJE1YQMJL VQIYEZ
7H[J ]RQ[[JZRJ
N^TJN]IJ[J SP=VHFVWQY YJSPE[+]K VHFVWQY SV( EIQMJE
TH[JEX
^HO= ZPMJ[TJEQYJ
.9 VHFVWQYHO UYJS+J2]( \HVJNVQ
IJ
YVJZ7VJ]K[J (ZPYZRJ ]RQ[[JN^TJ2]( XTHO
Q\P&Y(&Y(
ZYJYHOMJ
7H\Q[J XYWMJLS(Z)7MJLZRJ N]RJLT,OSP N^TJ[J SHEO= SQJ
¡O]J
RJY SH]J],OVZQFP SP[HO= \HVJNVQZYJ\]J1Y[J XHVJE\QMJ3(
ZXIRJMJV7Q]+.ZVJSFMJ
7H
MJSP=GMJ]+IJ)7MJLX[P>I(VZHOYZ J QFPZHO=
UHO[JEIQYJU,O E[QLZRJXVWH/SV(YE
QYJ
QFYHO G,PZOY H J[J
SP?QGMJ]+IJSRJ VY+JZ+IJV(X\H>I(EYQMJ[TJEQYJ N^TJ]K[J
ZP&Y(VWQT(T3J[.L XHVJE\QMJE
V7QX\PSN^MJLXE[QJXSMJLN]RJLT,O
Y,OZ,OSPVWQ N^TJG.L
MJ V*ZQVEUQMJV( &YH/[MJ N]MJUMJ[.L XUMJLS,OUMJL
Y
T,OTVJEVNVIJNGMJ
SQSV(YHO
MJXO]JVY+Q\Q[.L VHFVWQY SVYJEZQMJ# EG6V
EZQMJYHOXE[QJYEZE
++[JTYQVZ+IJGMJV7QSP[HO=F\.MJZQ
VJLZPSTJXE1YQMJYHOXT,OSH
EXQMJIRJVWH/T,OI.=T,OTVJVJ
SVYJEZQMJUHO
MJ SP[HO= THTTJ[QY VWH/¡HO# XYWMJLTQ
H[ÉI.= ]RQ
X
RJXGWMJ ]KVJSV(
7MVJ WQYSP=VWH/¡HO>QTJNVTJSHGWMJ[J#XVW/H \.VQ7
YHOJE
N]Q E
QKSRJ )PIQ
]KSZQ# ¡PS+]JSP ]KSZQ# VPTJ
ESQYJTQSPEYQXVW/H \.V7Q
7SH ZQT,TO VJVJSPY OH [
J MOH Y
J EYQ[TJGK
EKYJ[QZ7EF
[TJ
, ESQYJTQ[[JSZQ#EZQMJYTQSZQ#VHIJV¡-]J[[JSZQ
SHGWMJ1Y[J
Q\PXUMJLX[IJI.= I3TÚQYHO\RJEL [QL[Y + [
J J#SHE=O SQJ
TQ
H[ÉO4J]OJE[+EZQYJ XE
V&Y(FP
EG6VEZQMJ1YRJL[.LXGKEQYJWQEZVHFVWQYXYWMLJTQ
H[É
THTTJVJ#¡O]
J RJYHO 1YRJVL J#XHVEJ \QMJ\IH JSHVJ V-)HMO IJ MJSZQ1YRJVL J#
EIQYJSP
.9]RQX
RJXGWMJ]TÚRJ 3TÚQYZRJVHIJYEZ
.9O4J]OJ
[TJ
]J N^TJ)HOMJ]K[J
G
RHH)-HMJNGMJ
T,OTVJEVNVIJZHO= EYWI]J1Y2](UZ
HO 5MEJ [QL[TJFYJYVHFVWQYXNGQ
[TJFYJYHOGW3JY]JUYJS+J[JZYJ^YJ
RJEYQJ^(X[PESQYJ
MJ
N^TJET#EI=TQN^TJN^TJ RTQN^TJN^TJ X[PTQ
MJN^TJETSQ[HO= SV([HO=YHTÚ
EN]Q1YVJ XTT XUMJ E N]Z5MJ E [QL E%MJ U
Q\, S + Q #
YQY,
7MJ)7TJ3(
.9>Q[Q[HOYJUHOMJTTJEU#EI=I,SMJLVSMJLEVE[QLVJ
>Q[JZ VJXE[QJVWQVWQV7Q EXQMJS+ JZHO]K[J EXQMJS +J
EXQMJ NVMJEXQMJ UYJS+JE]SP
YHO T,OTVJE
V7QE
Q RH)-HMJE
V7Q]K
[QIJ E][[J[JNVIJVQEXQMJS+JYVWQESQXQN^MJL
MJLYWYJ[.L
VHI J V [TJ E QYJ N^TJ VJ SP = X ZO ]J E XQMJN VMJ ^H O = TYQ[[J [ J #
U+J[[J[JNVIJVQN]RJV7QY(TYQX
QV7QXE[QJ\+IJYQ]K[J
XQ>ª I J EYQMJ ¡, O # XU+ J E YQMJ ¡, O ) 7 M J L V2]( FP # ZWMJ
[J #
XYMJ]K
[J)7T^J YJTE+. XQMJEN]Q[[JU[ HO [J[L. X[+MJ TYQEN]QT
Q
ZPX ,O N^TJTH[GJ W
SPN^TJVJENVQYJZY HO J]MJLZOY
H J EN]QVJ#ZH
O MJZOS H ZHO
G]J¡HOJMJ¡HOMJ YZH[H[H EN]Q[IJZRJ EN]Q
VJ SHO=ESQJ FJE[QLV7
[TJ^YJSQ ZIJ=S+QEXQMJ VEN]Q
. VUHO
. N^TJEXQMJE[QL VEN]QFP
SPGW3JY]JG,
SPY )7TJ^YJ
MJ^+MJLTYQ UHOEI[Q].ZHO= V\MJG.L
MJ FQV5
N^TJZQV7Q V?O[JFP SPS,O[.L X[[J]RQYHO ZYJE[+9TH[J]RQZHO=
UHO)HOMJE]VJL ZPYHO VHEXQMJ ^VJ^OH=# SP= O4JN]JE
Q E]WQLY+YJE[+YHO]K
ZHOSZHOS,O
VJZHOX]J
MJSP=FMJEG+9VRJLTYQZRJEN]Q
ZHVLJVJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
[HOMJ[HOMJ]MJ]MJ
IQVRJ&Y(E%MJU
QEV^H=Z O [ HO J#XE1YQMJ)7TGJ OX[+Y]J K#[TJGY O
SV(GMJ]+IJN^TJZQVRJL SP)7TEJ QYJEI=IS , MJL
.9ZQTHTTJ^=HO EIQYJ[TJGY O
ETLT]JE1YQMJZVJ^HO=I.= ZYJ\]J]+.X[+YJ EI=EYQMJ
YJSQE
+ XGWHIJ]K
S[J^HO= N^TJ]K[J
XHVJE\QMJE
GHOMJNV.ET^HO=E%MJIY[J[HOYJUHOMJTTJEU
IJZHO[JZHO=
E%MJ]RQ
7HVWQYUHO]K[JTTJEUT
QE[+YXVWQ&Y(
7H[J[TJGO
)7MJLZRJ Z,OEZQYJ]K[J X.KYE[QL GMJ]+IJEZQMJI.= >I(EZQMJ[HO=
EV+I, 2H/?J
[HOYJUHOMJ1YRJL^HO=]K]. 2H/?J&Y(
7TJZ,O
7H[J [I*E)+ EI
#
[IZ*QZ
#X*K#%O?P#
Q?O#1YQS]E[#ESQ1YQ#TEI(2H/Z
J 7TJGO
X[+YJ
YJS[ÉGIO TJ
YJ[TJ][JYOH
7TEJ I=G+.S[JVJ [ 7 J[JE%MJU
QY
SP[O=H EV+EI=VWQ EI=I, SMJLVSMJL
MJ)7(GWTJGMJV-
7HV
7H
TTJEU]K[J
XGWMJGWMJ S]ÀQN^TJ[.L EI=I,UHZ O 5MJ XHVJE\QMJE
NV.[J XGWMJGWMJ
S]ÀQVN^TJ1YZ5MEJ [QLXHVEJ \QMJE
VSQQFP#Y+.E[QMJY+). MHO J[J
KYHOESESGWQGWQTHTTJ^HO=],OES[+YJIRJ
7H]K[JEI=I,NV/]JZY*Q
S(\Q[JZY*QV7QTYQ)7TZ J O, Y]JZWYJ]K[JSMJ[ L L. EI=II, .= VSMJL[.L
EI=I,E[+Y(ZHO
7H[J
EI=I,SMJLEV+EI=X[.+VWQ
3SQ [I*E)+ESQ1YQ
THIJ]IJ X*K1YQS]E[
IJZ7 TEI%O?P
7QYOVJ
Q?O [IZ*Q
EI=I,VSMJL EV+EI=X[+.VWQ
VQ TEI1YQS]E[
ESQY ESQ1YQ[IZ*Q
XMJ [I*E)+%O?P
Q>Q
Q?OX*K
X\YJ>QYHO 1YRJLZ5MJ XEYQMJU,O [+.^YJVH[.L EV+EI=E[+Y
EKYJ[QZ7EF
[I*E)++)7MJL ESQ1YQ# X*K)7MJL 1YQS]E[# %O?P)7MJL TEII.=
Q?O)7MJL
[IZ*QX[+.E[+].VSMJ[ L L. X[+.E[+YTEI)7MLJ 1YQS]E[#ESQ1YQ)7MJL
[IZ*Q#[I*E)+)7MJL%O?PI.=
Q?O)7MJLX*KEIQYJUYJ[+.¡-]K
XGOEN]Q[.LSMJL[.LEI=I,I.=VSMJL[.LEI=I,E[+YHOEXQYJ]K>QX[HOMJ
N]IJ2](T(ZHOYJVJ
EV+EI= SMJL[.LEI=I, EI=I,VSMJL
[I*E)+ ESQ1YQ %O?P
[IZ*Q
Q?O ESQ1YQ
X*K 1YQS]E[
Q?O
%O?P TEI [I*E)+
1YQS]E[ X*K TEI
ESQ1YQ [I*E)+ [IZ*Q
TEI %O?P 1YQS]E[
Q?O [IZ*Q X*K
(>QX
THTTJV-XN]MJXNGQE%MJYHIJGIJ2H/?JEI2H/?J\QE[+]K
E%MJU
QY[+YJGWYJ1YRJL
MJXHVJE\QMJE
X[+YJXRL,E[+9GWMJE[+9
VJSHE=O SQJVHFVWQYZRJU,O N^[J2](EI2]U ( ZOH 5MJ E%MJU
QYHO ZO]JSMJL
ZO ] J \ H O Y J [ QE[+ S Q ZO ] J E ]]KE[QL Z H O = EN]QVJ U
QY
ETLT]JE1YQMJZVJ^HO= EI=EYQMJ
YJSQE
+# XGWHIJIQ
(]K S[JE]VJ
V*ZQ]+. X[+YJZRJ
YJE
+XGWHIS J [JE]VJ2/H ?JIY[EJ [+YHO FQV5
V-VEIF.ZYJ\]J1Y[.LXHVJE\QMJE[+ZRJXVWQ&Y(
7EH 1YQMJY6IEJ [QJ
(V7QXESXGWQEN]QT
QZRJ
7H]K[J
'
ETLT]JE1YQMJZVJ]+.
NVIJVQN]RJYETLT]JE1YQMJZVJ]+.YXEIQYJ)OMH MJ E, [+V7Q\YJ\,O IRJ
)7MJL TITJ[YWZO]J[JVWQESQXQN^MJL VHIJYEZXHVJV7QZO]J[J
]
HS[JVWQZ5MJV$]J\HOVJ#SHO=V?O[JTQESQYJUHOMJ#?HO[JTSRJVQ7
ZO]JVJ Z+IJG.L[.L [TJ)7TJGIJ=Y EVQJZ2VH/MJV7Q ZO]J[.L ]+.[TJ]+.XE1YQMJ
Y6IJE[QJ EN]Q]KVJX.(]+.V7QY6IJE[QJY3(EUQMJ]KMJG.L
]K[J
VH[EJ U+VOUOH ^H[
O TJEQYJY[TJ3( [RJESQSV(ETLT]JE1YQMJZVJ]+.
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
ZO]JV7QVHO=SP=XHVJYHO YE
QYJGW(NVMJLE]]KUHO2](Y6IJE[QJ)7MJL>I(YHO^H[J]K
[JY6IEJ [QJ[=OH S+Q1YE
Q_RJLSRJE[+XE[QJVWQVWQE
QYJEI]K2](
XE^N^TJSPY Y6IJE[QJLYHO XGVJXIQV7Q TYQIRJIRJ EN]QE]]KZHO=
K[Q[QEN]Q]K[JY6IJE[QJYZRJSPEN]Q[QXV7[J[V.L].EIVH
[J¡O[J[
YJ]. Y6IJE[QJ[O=H TQ]+.V7Q\HOMJEI[.LEVQJZ2VH/MJU
QX[[J
SMJEYQZH]JEYWQMJXO]J&Y(YV[J[[J
]JZHOYJ2](SPXSMJLE
PZQ[.L
X[HOMJ^[J
EN]Q]K[JSPYV*ZQ
7HESQ(EI=V7QSP (YHOZQ
[Q
SQZHVQ
.9VHFVWQYEV[ÉQ
]JGG, WYX J
]KZH=O UH[
O JUYJEN]Q]K[J
SQVHFVWQ
.9YHOJTQ SV( ^GMJYHO \,O[VJT3JZQ)7MJL XR( \HVJNVQ
ZYJ\]JG+MNJL ]/
IJETLT]JE1YQMJZVJ]KE1YQMJ#SEFQ[PZYJG,
IJEV[ÉQ
]JG,]KE1YQMJSPYUYJ2](EQYJWQEZVHFVWQFX[/]À[ÉHUYJ2](
EN]QN][JEQYWJQEZ
.9XYWMJLTQ
H[É)7MJL]RQX
RJXGWMJYHOZRJ
EN]QN]]K[JGOZOH SPYVHFVWQYHOJTQETLT]JZQ[QYHO [TJFYJV7
ZYJG,SEFQ[PVJZHO= ,O1YRJ]KE1YQMJEN]Q2](XU,OS[JS+Q]K[J
VHIJ YEZXE^YY6IJE[QJF L YJZ7RL1J YRJLVWYJ
H]NJ ][JSPYHOJ
TQEN]QE]]KE]KLY6IJE[QJV[J[[J
]J#X\YJYEN]QS+Q[QI.=ZHOYJ
^YJVJLTYQ N]IJEN]Q]K[J GOZHO O4JSE
7HGHOYIJE[QL
IJ N^TJ]K[J XGVJXIQ 2](]K2]( VHIJYEZ XE^Y
_RJLSRJVWQYHO EY6EV+_RJLG,]K[J
M
ZYJ\]JV*ZQ].+
ZYJ\]JV*ZQ]+.E[+YESZHOYJ2](],TO ,Y]+. K[JZO]JT
Q\,O[VJ
E[+YHOE[QLX
]J[HOMJZHOYJIQ1Y]K[J
]J
+Q\,OT,X
IRJIRJ]K]K
Y+QNGQV-
7H)HOMJ[JSYJUHOMJ
QVHFVWQ
.9EM+E1YXMJXQE1YQMJLZRJ
Y+.N]QV- N^TJ)HOMJ]K[JETLT]J]+.V7QZHO]. X[HOMJX[QZHOYJ2](XGVJXIQ
YWMJ][.L EI
QY+.N]Q]K[J XHVMJ JEZV7Q]. YWMJ])HOMJ[J# ?HO[J
&Y(&Y(ZRJ N^TJ)HOMJ[JJ XYW3J¡,O2](ZO]J[.L ]+.YEZ N^TJGWMJN^TJVJ#
[TJ)7TJV7Q [TJGKSQ 1Y,/[[J[.L ]+.VWH/ZRJ N^TJ)HOMJ]K[J ZYJ\]J
\HVJNVQV-YHOEUQMJ
+YJE]SPY
]J
+QZP&Y([TJEQYJN^TJ)HOMJ[J#)HOMJM,
V7Q X&Y(U,OX
Q
7H&Y(ZRJ N^TJ)HOMJ[J FJSPZO]JZO]J
]K[J
E
7¡HOZHOYJ[.LNVIJVQVWQYE[QLV*ZQ]+.V7QN%Q?4]O4ºQFHSY H JU
QYHO
V*ZQ XT(XT3JV70 FHSHYJU
Q
XN^TJEUQMJ
+YJETZHO[J ]O4ºQ
FHSHYJU
Q V
)HOMJ
MJZRJ V*ZQXGVJXIQV70)7MJL]. YWMJ]]K[J
XQZ,OIQZRJZYJG\ , Q[.L]R[JGWYJ[TJG
O ]7H K[JK[+MJ V7QV*ZQ
VEUQMJ
]KFPY6IJE[QJLX\MJ(YTH ÚY
?IJE[QJVWQK[+MJG
(VS+Q
[.L FO
QHIRJE[QJ SHYQ]OJYHO ZPE[+ XEYQYJPZ+.[Q EIV7Q]K
NV[JT+QFO
QYK[+MJV7Q
?IJE[QJVWQXTOZHOYJX^+.9ZHY O JG
( YGW(Z5MJ
ZJQE[+ ]WYJT(V7QTHO
HVJZHO= ]R[JE[QJVPG.L[Q]K
NVIJVQN]RJV7QY6IJE[QJS+QG.L
[.L V*ZQ]+.XVWQ&Y( ]K(\.Y]+.)T7 ]J +.
XE1YQMJN]IJEN]Q]KVJ]\V]+Y . V)©EZV7Q#O[H]+.YEVQJZ2V/H MVJ Q7 ]K
V)©EZV*ZQ]+.YS[HO=SV(XHVJV7QYWMJ]]K[JE%MJU
QS[J
\Q[.L V*ZQXGWHIJXGK VYWV( VHITJXIRJMJ XZHOV7Q S[HO=SQY
V*ZQ[JT,O[J2](S[HO=SQ
,NG,
,2](XHVJ&Y(E
79GIJYHOE
QYJZQ]K[J
XGIJYEYQE>QXN]RJLGMJ\Q2](Y[É]( K^,O&Y()7TJGO73JGMJ\Q[J
S[O=S H QYY[(É]K^,OE]MJ\HOMJZHOY[ J JS[HO=SQX
,YSP=EIQYJVQ7
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
EI
QP[JG4EIE[QL
[IQE[+T(NGJ\Q[.LS[HO=SV(XGIJ[+MJ
MJZQ[J S[HO=SV(X
,ZRJ ]KZQ[J S[HO=SV(Y S[HO=SQ
ZYJ.FYJYY[É(]K^,OE]EI
QP]K[JS[HO=SV(X
,YEIQYJV7Q
\HOMJ[J ^H[J1YQ\Q[.L ]
HS[JXE]KMJY VHITJXE[QJ1YQ SP[HO9
T,O[+.YHO]. XQ¡,OTHOYJ1YRJLEI[J
V*ZQXGWHIJE
QYJ[.LXGKN%Q?4]O4ºQFHSHYU J
Q
YG¡OSMJ
YHOSP=ZYJ^. YJV7QTZ+S J MHO J ZWYJMJZQ]K[JSPYEXQMJE1YQMJN^Q
SRJLX\HVJXV7[JG¡OSMJV-[J2]( XGVJXIQT[MJ]K[JFHSY H JU
Q
Y S[HO=SQ ZYJQZYJYHOYHOMJ ZYJKYHO XE]FYJN^IJ=\Q[J
2](E[QLS[HO=SV(ZYJQZYJYHOS[HO=SQZYJE]\]JZYJ\]J
2](
ZYJXT,OYOH X[JN^0TOZWQ)7MLJ
TJ][JTOZWQ
TJ][J
E]]K[J2]( E[QL
ZYJXT,OYHO \]JZWYJ EM+^ZQ\. )7TJ]K[J EM+^ZQY S[HO=SQ#
S[HS =O V(E
79V7QGW\Q[Q#E
[TJYJEZQYJ\RJ\ L Q[JFHSY H U
J
Q
YK\QV)©QIJE[+
+[J[J#SS*Y¡HOYF J QSQ)7MLJ
+[[
J Q2](E[QLZYJ
)7TJ^YJYHOE
\.YN]IJUJ#G¡OSMJV-[J2](V*ZQSFMJFHSHYJY$YHO
XU,O S[J]K[J (]Y .+ OH 1YRJNL GMJN^MJL \HVJ NVQV*ZQYHO FQE1YQMJL ZYJ\]J].+
EG[JUH[ O QNVMJE[+9]K2](
EIQYJXT(XT3JVQ7 E[QLIQVRJ&Y( XUHEO [QJ[TJEQYJY
[OU]OH K
[J
[OYS[OS H= QS[HO=SV(I.=VHFVWQ
.9O4J]OJE[+E
^+.9\Q[Q]K
XT(XT3J XU,OVS[JV( EN]Q[[J E?Q[[J[.L TQ[[JE][[J NVIJVQ
[TJEQYJYTYQEN]Q]KES[J>I(EVQMJ)7,X[+YJ U,OV1SKI.=
SHT
Q V7[JT
QE[+ EN]Q]K[J SPY V*ZQXGVJXIQ YWMJ]
[.L
RJ
+JGWYJI.= XH]ÀQJ
7MJN]]K[J# 2](E[QL >I(EVQMJ)7, [TJ3(XE]
[TJ3( STÚQ
7H^HO= EIQYJ ZMJL[É
QMK]K# VQ[É
QMK]K UYJEN]Q
]K[J
ZMJL[É
QMK]K
VQYHO[IJ^HO\Q
VRJ#V\(EZTQVN]/
#
7QE^+
SV5 ]TÚRJYHOVQ\,X]J)7,
VRJ#
XHVJE\QMJE
E^QYJN]QYW0Z+IJV7Q+MJNGMJVN]/
#
EKYJ[QZ7EF
>I(YHO X[JXTQZYJ[J
[IQJP
UMJNVIJE]
VRJ#
VQYHO NV[J)HO1YMJIQ
VRJ
ZY*Q V\(VY .L MJ#X]J)M7 J3TÚQ#VHTQÈ VV7Q#[JTQUMJMJ#NV[J)OH 1YMJ
VQ[JMK]KY
XHVJ[+MJV- T(V,ZO]JEUQMJ
VRJ#
EU+VWH/SQGWMJVWQYHO SMJLEZWQJEXQMJ EV5E]YVJ
VRJ#
XHVJE\QMJE
E^QYJN]IJV7Q+MJYW0Z+IJNGMJVN]/
#
]TÚRJ3TÚQYHO \HIJSHVJETQMJLE
7QYJ
VRJ#
V]WMJV
H
#ZO]JT
Q
7H[QZO]J
VRJ
ZY*Q XHVJ[+MJV-ZO]J#SHVJ\O]JESGWQ#VHTÈQ1Y3JE
7QMJ#EZWQJEXQMJ
N^I=JGWH#]WMJ
HVVP
]O¢H/ZJ&Y(U,OV1SK2]([Q)7MJL [2]H/MJIYJ VHIJYEZVWQYXSMJL
]HOY\J Q[.L EM+^ZQ&Y(VWQV7)-Y H J2P ]( E
88VOH EM+VHO
+Q]K[JN^IJ1= Y[
. \
L. V. Q7
E]KYJE]KYJ]IJI.= EM+XE YE[+]+ KVJ2]( Z5MJ _RJS L RJE[QJVWQYHO EY6EV+
_RJLG,]K[J XQZ,O2]([.LXGK EM+
[O# E
8+
[O# ][ÉNVQ
[O YWMJ]2](
N^TJ[.L XHVJE\QMJSYJ
7RJ O4JSE
7H[J^PTQE
XYWH/E[QJEUQMJE]KLEZSPYE1YTQV?O[J#EV[ÉQ
RJI.=YPR(SP]KV*ZQ]+.YG]JYW3JYW3J]K].#)7TJ^YJVHFVWQYSH]JV[[J
)HOMJ1Y
7QFP
]KEVQY&Y(Y[TJ]+.Z,OSP[TJEQYJ)M7 JL2](EXQMJZO]JS+Q]K[J
[TJGIJ[TJEI
QV7Q]. Y6IJE[QJI.= >I(YHO EV[ÉQ
]J2](ZYJ\]JE]GOHMJ]K
[JY6IJE[QJ)7MJL>I(YHO ZYJ\]JE]^HO=EV[ÉQ
]JG,[QYO4J
7HEXQMJ
YWYS J E
[OH EXQMJZO][ J Q\MJ]K[JY6IEJ [QJYS[HS =O QZYJYY HO MOH #J
ZYJ^KXE]N^IJ=\QY6IJE[QJL>I(YS[O=HSV(ZYJYHOYHOMJZYJ^K
EXQYJFYJ N^IJ=2]( S[HO=SQZYJE]V7Q \]JE]]K[J ]KEVQYY
X[JN^0)7MLJ ZYJ)T7 J^YJYOH
TJ][JE]2](EIQYJJ Y6IJE[QJ[=Y OH ZYJX[+Y . HO
E
79V7QGW\Q[.LEM+^ZQ\.V7QE
)7TJE]ZHY O J]K[JU
Q&Y(YSPZ = YJ.
FYJEFV7QG¡OSMJE[QLZ+\ J Q[J#[YJVV-[]J KFPV-[? J IJE[QL
N]/]K[JSPYSS*Y¡HOYJV)©QIJV
+[JFP (XTQ%OYWVJIJZQK\Q
]K:HIRJIRJ
+[J]K[JS[HO=SQI.=S[OH=SV(XE1YQMJ\O]À[JYHOZRJ
EN]Q]K[J
[O^[J[QE[QL V]KFP(LN]MJ ]KEVQYYV*ZQ]+.V7Q%O
FQSQZY4Q]K[.L XT(XT3J[TJGO\]J\RJ]L K[JXGVJXIQV2]( V(VQ7
]
HS[J\.YVHIJYEZ[TJEQYJ TMJNVMJL
7H
Q\+YJZQ2](ZYJ\]J2](
>I(EVQMJ)7,YHO]IJTRJ[TJTRJE]]K[J]IJTRJY)7MJU(#STÚQ]IJI.=
SEN]GYJ]K[J (X[HOMJ MK&YHVJZO]J]K[J# MK&YHVJ[HOMJ[HOMJ >I(
EKYJ[QZ7EF
EVQMJ)7,XT,OY]\V
[IQS,O]KYHO
7HGHOYIJE[QL]K[JO[H
]JETQMJL
2V/H 9ETQMJIL [JXE]KMJYHOYIJE[QL[J[[HVHFVWQI.= T[O[U
QSVQ
VWQ#EIQYJU,O]
HS[JYHO
7HGHOYIJE[QL]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQVWQYV*ZQXGVJXIQV7Q%OFQSQXT(XT3JVWQ
S+[JS+MJZQ[.LZY4Q
7H]K[J[GWH/9E[+YZRJZP[YQZO]J¡HO\,OT,
E[+YHO ZHOYJVZO]J1YE[QL[QZRJ E[+9
]K[J Y6IJE[QJ S+QG.L^P[.L
V*ZQ]+.[GWH/9V7QFOIJE[QJ&Y(VWQXHVJYHO]MJL2](U+VJY]J[J#KV*ZQ
YOSHOZJP[Q]K [TJXHVJV7QE[QL S[HO=SV( VHFVWQY 2VH/9
+Q \O,T,E[+
Z,O VZO]EJ [QLFP U
QE[QJ&Y( [TJ]KX]KS,'QMK]KYHOV*ZQXHVJYHO
]MJ^L [H [ J J]
HS[JYMK]KS(ZG,2P ]( U
QE[QJY[
QGW( NVM ]LJ K[J
U
QE[QJ[ L
QYYWVJ IJVQ7 ]K[.L S(
HZY*QY6IJV7FO
Q[
Q1YRJR/H 2](
SK[
Q\YJJSIJ[.L >I(EVQMJ),X 7 E1YQMJ]KU
QE[QJY(>I(EVQMJ),
7 9.
T,\Q^+JFXE1YQMJ)7MJLSP[O=H Y+Z J +IEJ [QLZRJI[JN]RJV7QN]IJZRJ
E]KMJ^YJ
SRJLXE1YQMJE?Q]K[J(I]H K[J]NO, ]MJYHO S[HS =O QS[OSH= V(
IVPIQ\QYWMJL1Y,S+Q1Y^HO=1SK[
QGW(NVMJL]K[JS,'QE[QJVWQYHO
X
MJU+VJY]J2]( ZP]
HS[JYHO EIQYJV7 EY6EV+]K[J ZPMJ)7TJ3(
>I(EVQMJ)7,N^TJ2](ZHO= XVWQXSHXV7[J N]/2](]K2](
XHVJE\QMJSRJF
Y6IJE[QJLYHONVIJVQES+&Y([.LZPZOH=XEN]QG,
GWMJG,
]KETNVIJVQ
N]RJVQ7 YXEIQYJVQ7 \YJXHVEJ \QMJE
GOMH NJ V]. K[JZ=HO EN]Q]K
ETSPTVH J
[
, )7TJEQYJ X[P E]KMJ^YJ EI\HOMJ[QYHO GOHMJNV.EXQMJ VNVMJSQ[.L
TRJE)7QMJ&YH/E[+
7H]K[J]\VEV[ÉQ[
Q)7MJL¡HOESEZTQV-#NVIJVQ
VWQY(V$H/MJ)7TJ
]JYHO XENGN]/ &Y(N]MJ1Y
[Q].FYHO ]WYJT(ETVJL
U+E. UQMJ[]JVYJVE- [+YZRJXEIQYJ)M7 LJ TQZ5MJ IRJ]K]K[J[[H
XEI)7MJLXE
X&Y(U,ON^TJ[.LE]E]Z+MJZ+MJVNVMJ
ESQJZRJ[YJ
T]MJI ( JEG+
J#VHIJV
J#EKI]J]MJ
J¡HOYJE]EZEYQMJEZ].
UOH[.LX*ZH]JTYQ],O)7MJLUMJUMJ[P[JSPY>I(YHOSP=)7VY.LSHO=SEFQ
\Q[JA)7VaZHO=].EGVJSPY>I(YHO[TJZ\YJ]HO2](1YQ1YQ]TJ\Q
G.LZ=HO VN^TJFPZHZ =O . SPS]H K[JA\YJZT7 Q+ ESQETQMJSVQSRJETQMJ)7MJL
S,OZYMJVP ZYJ]WYJYOIJ@# E[QJV7IJZ7T+QESQ VQN^TJZ5MJVPZRJ
ZMJ)7MJL[TJZYMJVP]WYJYOIJ@#a ZHO=UHO
7H]K[JSPY>I(G6.[[J],OEZYHO
ZRJX2VX . V7[
J EIVJ#VHIJ VY\]J\]JGKEN]Q
MJSPYZHY O EJ ZWQ
[Q].
2](E[QL SPYVHIJV X&YH/YJ XNV.[VJ VZHOYJ
IJZRJ S)ÍH`QIJZHOY
J MJ
VHOYJ
QYWE]ZHVJLVJ#VHIJVXE]SEFQ\Q&Y(
QE[QLVE
QYJE]FP
>I(FYJY1YRJLZ5MJ XTYI3(V7QE[QLXQYW^ + JV
7HSZH]O K].
NVIJVQN]RJV7QYAXHVJE\QMJ3(FO
Q[RJEUVMJ
RJTO]J\HOaUHO[.LZO]JVH
Z5MJ N]MJV
[.LYHTÚ S,O
]J
7H[JXHVJE\QMJN]/[QN]MJV
#FO
Q[RJ2](
N]MJV
# VMJE1YQMJEU¡O]J\HO2]( N]MJV
>I(Y N^TJZQ
MJ )7TJGKIQVRJL
FYJY Y+Q
7MJ[Q]. N^TJN^TJ# SPYZMJYHO]TJ]TJ# ZMJYSP=YHO]TJ]TJ
SPX = [+YX J ¡-, ].SHE=P SQJZRJAEG+ZHEO QYWQJ a)7MU
LJ YJE]KMJ2]( [SYJZO,
UMJ
.OYG,EIVRJLXTQZMJVQY+.VJUHO[.L>I(YZRJXVWQ&Y(
7H]K
[JVHIJV
.9XHVEJ \QMJE
XEIX\QYTYQ],EO [+YUHO\QSEZQYJ
EZQYI([HV7 XUONH ^TJSRJ EZQYI([H[+MJ AMK
YJV5 ETQMJ)7MJLYMJVPa ?O UOH]KSRJ
UJLMKETQMJ[+.V3Ú0SYTQE]GO#V)©EZFQSQN]IJSP@V7[JGWYJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
VUHOZ7]KFP XUHOE[+YZRJ [TJGO)7MJL[TJGO YIJ=ZIJ= N^TJEI[QE[+
XVWQ&Y(
7H]K[J
NVIJVQZMJSQY SEFQXQN^MJLE[QL XHVJE\QMJ3(T(]K].ZHO=
UHOG.L]K2](ZYJE[+9V7QE[QL AXSHOYJXNV,/aYHOZ8VJ[QYVHIJV]K#VHIJVY
XG
Q]KSHO=ESQJSP=XG+MJLXE
SP=Z+[JZ]JG+MLJ UHO2](E
79[IJV[MJ]KFP
SPYZMJYHO GWTJE1YQYJ¡HOES[J[TJGK[TJ
, VHGMJ]VQ#[TJGK[EZ
ZRJ)7VXZQ#YWIJXGWHIJVWQV7QE[QL Y6IJY.LSHO=ESQVQN^TJ]K[J
VQYZMJYHOGWTJGWTJGMJGMJEGE
QV7QNVIJVQZHOAXTJYHOaZHO=S,O[J
XTJYHO&Y(ZHO= XH]ÀQJ
[J X
Q
QYHO SP=X[+YJ N^RJLURJE]^HO=
ZMJLFOIJY,YHO XQ\Q[JFE
YIJ\.YE
)7MJL1YQZHO].ZMJYE
#
SPY1YQ E
NVMJLV7 1YQ[MJLVJUHO[Q SPS[H\Q[J X]JS+Q
Q
GWRJ]KUHO[.LX[HOMJ F G
(V7Q ZMJS+Q
Q VQ]K
V7Q].ZHO= G,P2](
UHOSRJN^TJETEYQMJSRJN^TJETZMJ3(EUQMJ
QVQYZHOYJ]KVJ
XGIJ=VSMJLZHO=XHVJE\QMJG+.1Y[.LXGKV7QE[QMJNVIJVQ>I(VQY
XEIQYJ[HOMJ>I((VQVWQ\YJXEIX\Q]HOEYQMJ]K[J]TÚRJG+E.
VRJUHOZ5MJ XHVJE\QMJ3(]TÚRJ ]K
MJYHOE[QL )7TJ3(UHOMJ
QP1Y[J
ZMJ
7QSRJ]L TÚRJSHV=O ?O[J VQ
7QSRJL]TÚRJ SHV=O ?O[J )7T3J (X[P
Q7 SRJL
ZYJ\YJ]+Q]TÚRJGIJV7QE[QL )7TJ3(SEFQ[P G+.E1Y
VJSHO=V?O[J
[
Q¡,OXU,OXN^[J)7MJL G+.E
VJ
Y+Q
7MJN][JT.E
GO)7TJVQ7 \O[JE[.LTQXO]JV7QE
8¡HOYY+Q
7MJ [.LYHTÚ)7MJL ][J
SYJ2]( (ZUOH ]OH K[JAZMJVQY+Q
7MJ V-E[+Y]O/¢ HZX
J VWQE
SZHO
V?O[J]KFP#XZ+IJIRJ]K]K[JVHSQTOEV[ÉQXE)+Q[JY(ZPVWH/
.9
XGHOMJVQU,O %(>ZY4Q[TJGO]K]. 2](E[QL NVIJVQY SP=>I(YHO XZ+IJ
1YMJIQ[J#VHIJYEZXQZ,OYHOZRJMJMJEZ[RJYEQYWJQ
UHO
MJEZEZTQTQ UYJU,
VJZHO= SMJ1YQ\Q[J X
Q
QV7Q
EQYWJQXU,OXN^[JYHO 3(TQE]VJ#SHO=ESQJ NVIJVQVYXH)H>I(
VQ\YJ VWQT+Q Z+[JZ]JV-
7H[J XHVJE\QMJE
\,O[VJE[+Y
Z+JYP Z7[JZHO= NVIJVQZPVWH/YHO XN]TJUHO[QZ+J]K[J SHO=E]VJL
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
SP[HO=TITJY TH[J]WYJT
QEYQMJ[.L VZHOYJV^YJ T,O[+.FYHO NVIJNVIJ
XU,OS[JE][JXE^VE][.Y L EZZRJXZ+IJ=XZ+IJ
7Q]K]K[J
EIQYJU,O EN]Q
Z5MJXHVJE\QMJY
+. IJGHOMGJ MOH Z J OZ
, ,O SHSQ[.X L E1YQMJV
7HG
.L MJ
VQY+Q ZMJI.= ZMJY+QVQ )7TJEQYJZ,O XE]V7Q][JIJYWMJY
[J2](SEFQ VYW GWMJFP VQYHO]TJGWMJZHO= FOIJ&Y(EYWQMJS+Q
SY*IJ[JSPYHO E[Q\+YJ ZHO=EG[J# SH]JV)7TJZHO[.L SEFQ]K[.L
XS,OX)-,]KXH]ÀQJYF[TJSYJ[QE[Q\.\+YJS+QSP[.LZMJI.=
Y+Q
7MJ[.L VHIJVYHOE[QL [TJGOZ]J EG[J [TJGOZ]JYHO X2V.[VJ
N]YJZ,O\O[JT
QXN^TJ NVMJ1Y]K[J
AX]WH/ZRJV?O[J#XHVJE\QMJV
7H#VOUHOVZRJV?O[J#XHO)7MJL
X^,O]VQEQYWJQ[YQ)7MLJ X,YWVRJL YEZVE]].#XHO[TJGOZ]JVYHO
ZP]WH/1YQ1YQ Z7RJLT
Q VZHO]KFPEZa [.L ZP
8MJE[QJY N]YJZ,O
ZO]J[J
E
8¡HO @NVIJVQ#SP9F)7MJLEZQYXNVMJTQ
X*ZH]JTQXO]J
YHOR8IJ]KSRJ
E
8¡HO@ EFOWS,OS]JGWYJVWQ V7IJYIJZ7]K[JSPEN]QSV5
XGWYJE[QJE[QJVWQYGOYQZVQY+QEQYWJQ)7MJLZMJYQ+ VHIJV[HO=
1Y,/
[.LXN^TJSITJE[+]K].[TJGOZ]JUHO[.LEK?Q
YSHOSHOSH]JSH]JVEI
[[JS#P YH O S
LJ Y
H Q YHOJ V\HIJ [[JSZ P H=O XH]QÀ JE
QYJET[.L XS,O X)-IJ
N^TJSQ+ )HMO ]J K[J[GW/H 9Y[TJGZ O ]JYOH V\(VNL. VMJZ]O GJ WMJ [[J[J#)7QEGKMJ
¡-,9GWMJ1Y[J VOUHOVI.= VOUHO^HOYHOE[QL XSHOMJXHOMJY GMJGMJVMJVMJ
1YMJ1YMJIQIQUYJU,[[J]K[JVQY+Q\Q[.LEQYWJQYEIQYJ
\]JXHVJE\QMJN]/VJUHO
MJXHVJE\QMJETWY+YJV7QZP]W/H I=. VOUHO ^HO
.9EIQYJY
[IJT(
ZHVJLVJ#T+,^HO=XG+MJLXZVJXIRJU,ON^TJ2](XVWQ[YQY
A[TJGOZ]J[TJZMJY+QYRQ[TJYWH]J)7MJL VZ.)HOMJ]Ka
ZHO= UHO1YESQJZRJ ZMJY+QVHIJV EIQYJ\]JXHVJE\QMJN]/VJUHO
MJE[QL
XG+MJLXZVJYXE[QJIRJS+Q]K2](SP?QXN]TJV
7HSPN^TJEYQMJN^TJ]K
ZHVLVJ JSHEO= ]VJL[TJGOZ]JU[ HO QI.= AX1Y), M7 LJ VHIJ VaAG]J]W], WX
, TQa\.YZHO=
NVMJ[[J1Y]K[JSH=EO SQJZRJ[TJGZ O ]JVQ7 FQI^PTQ]KEZVZ.#SPYY ,
V7[JGWYJE
8¡HOXVRJG,TQE
SPSRJX*ZH]JZPVWH/ N^TJSRJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
FJZHOUHO[Q FJZP X[[J EN]Q)HOMJ]KVZ. SP=Y,YHO X[[JEN]QV
FPEZ
##[JS,OS+J
NVIJVQ[TJEQYJ?Q%OFQSQZRJN^TJVJ#Z+[JZ+[JZ]JZ]J
E[+EG[[J# YWH/E1YQMJE^IJ THTTJ[[JSPZRJN^TJVJUHOZ5MJ SP=F
V7QTH[J)7TJG+N^TJT
QE[+ E[+91Y,/
]KZHVJLVJEYWQMJSQFV7QSP=U
Q
SMJ1YQSV5YHO ENVJVYWV7[JSQIQP
VJL [QIJY[TJ^YJ#XV7IJ
[
QYHO NVMJEXQMJ1YRJ[ L [J
Q7 [[JEXQMJEZLYWMS JL MJ
P V7QY[TJ^YJ
N^TJEIVJXHVEJ \QMJ
M7 FJ V7QE[QLSPZ]O YJ MHO
J VRJL ]
HESIVJTQE
XZO]JY[TJ^YJ# X2V.[VJ
7HEI[.L XENGG,]R[J[JS,O
]JI.= 2V.
VRJL
]3ÚS(ZY[TJ^YJ N^TJEIN]IJ[JK\Q]KE[QLSPYXHVJE\QMJSRJ
[EQYJXEI)7MJL ]`QI [JS,O]KN^TJ[.L FQSQE
XZO]J KI# S(Z#
FQIQYHO SPZO]J
VJZHO= XEZXIYJG,P]K[J KIY FQSQE
X[+YJE]YVJZ70KIJNGMJ#S(ZYYH O JYWML]J R[JVWQYHOZYJG,YWMS JL ,O
NGMJ# FQIQYE[QL YV`QIJXZO]J)7MJL [
Q¡-V7[JXQ\O[JNGMJN^TJ]K
[J
###KI
FQSQE
YHOMJ
-HMJSPV7IJZ5MJ[JS,OS+J
7H[.LXIYJKIYHOE[QL
NVIJVQ%OFQSQMJY X)7TJSYJU,ON^TJ^+J
7H]K[J KYSVHOMJT[MJ
Y[RJY]K]. E
79V7QY6IJE[QJEN]QG.L[.L
7MJN]/V*ZQ]+.?Q FQSQE
YOSZ HO JX[+YJ Z70KIJ[.L].]+ K].]TÚRJ 3TÚQSQY,Z O
O, MJKIYN]/
IJXZ+J
U,O[JN^TJ]K[JZ70[IJZHOYJ[.L FO
QEYWQMJYIJZHO EYQMJV-E[+Y
NVMJ)HOMJE[+9)HOMJ[.LXN]MJ XZ709YQ XZ709XV XN^TJZRJYOSHOZJ
7MJV7Q
O4JN]J[YJ[JZHO=Y6IJE[QJ\MJ]K[JVMJTHO
Q>QE
Q
]JSP
+QSQ]K
NVIJN]RJ[Z8Q [RJEUQYJZ70KIJG.L1Y[.L FQSQE
XEUQYJX3(E[+
SIJ)7MJGW(2](
7HEI]K[JE[QMJ\H]J#YVP\H]J#YOIJ\H]JE]KMJVWQT+QV7QE
Q
ENVN]IJ)= 7MLJ NVTJYVJ]KE[+VQ7 ]KE
8E
QMJ[MJMJ#\,O E^+E^+FO
QET[(E[+
1YRJR/H ^ + J ^PE[+9)HMO ]J K[J]O2, V/H 9E?QMJV7QFO
QET[(EZSIJMKSHIJ
GIJ=
7H[JZHO=Z7RJMJ¡HOS,[R,R,UHO¡HO)7MJL
XT3JXZQV7[JG.L1Y[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
(XE
X[+YJYX1YVJXQN^MJL [TJUJ[ L TJT[O
IJV([QV7QFO
Q[TJUP
N^TJ]K[J (EYQMJV-E[+V7Q YOSHOZJ
7MJVWQY Z70KIJV- XTOTOX[+YJ
UOE[QMJ V7[J[VJE[+# SP=EYQMJV-YHO ^WYJZHO^WYJU(ZO]JVRJLSPVWQYHO
YWHIJ[.LYWHIJTQE[+YHOEYWQYJTQYVÀRJ\HO2](V7[J[HOMJTHOYJG.L[QE[+ZRJ
E[+9
]K[J(EYWQYJTQE[+YHO^[JZHOYJ
MJXZ709
7MJ
.9Z70KIJ[.L
RJ
+JGWYJSH)HOMJ]K[J
UOE[QMJE[+XVWQ&Y(
7H]K[J(\.YUOE[QMJ)7TJGOI.=EIQYJ
YWHIJTQE[+XE1YQMJEN]QN]GWMJ]K[J]\VUOE[QMJYVH^O
Q[TJ]K
E
\HO[.L EYWQYJTQ]K ]KEVQY ZP=T
YE[QL E?QZHOJ],OT, E[+9NVMJ
QXH]ÀQJVWQXE1YQMJE^IJ S,OS]JT
Q
7H]K[J
XVW/H SV()7T3J ( Z,OYUOE[QMJXU,O V7QIH%¥QIJE
QYJ
]KZH@ O UOE[QMJ
\Q]K[JA2MHVJEXESQIH%¥QIJGWVJSQaI.=AZ+[JENVQYJ
]KZHO@a]KMJ]K
[J(EI=X\HNVIJVQ%OF QSQVWQFO
Q
7HGHOXU,OV7QUOE[QMJEI[.L]T,O ,
(X[HOMJN^TJ]K[J
O[HUOE[QMJV7Q]KMJ[.LUMJ
.[
QMK]KYHONVIJVQ%OFQSQ[HOMJ
ZHOZHOSH
7H2](SQ]KFO
Q
7HGHO[HOMJUMJ
.XE]KMJV7YMJZ+[J2MHVJ
]KZHO@
UOE[QMJEIYW]K].KYIH%¥QIJUOE[QMJ[QI.= X[P[P]K].
XV5X[VJE[.L YHTÚ KO[ H UOE[QMJV7Q].]K[JKZRJ].(EG[J
V7QYOSHOZJ
7MJYZ70KIJV-YHTÚ2](U,O[HOMJZO]J[.LXZO]J]K].
RJ
+JGWYJSH]JVV+IJNV[JZ7[.LXZ70
7MJE[+ZRJ
7H]K[JAFO
QYQa
AEYWQMJYQaASHVJYQaAVQ¡,OXZ709
7MJaTSRJN^MJLYQVWH/T,ON^TJGWMJZHO=
Z70SPE[+
7H]K[JXVRJI.=[+.2](YQYHOF+.9[TJGOZHO O4J]OJ[]JZHOYJ
MJ
SP
= 9. ZP=XUMJNL ]SEY*[S^+J S,O T+). MHO [ J X
L. [+Y]J K].GONVIJVQN]RJN]IJ
G.LT3JY FO
QYQ# FO
QXV# EYWQMJYQEYWQMJXVN^TJ1Y[.L E
7¡HO
NVIJVQ%OFQSQSYJ&Y(]HOMJXVWH/SV(&Y(XE[QJVWQVWQE[+9G.L]K[J
SP[HO=)7MJLEN]QUHO
QV7Q Y6IJE[QJY XVWQN]RJSPX[+YJ TQ1YRJL[HOYJ
EUQYJZO]JZ70KIJ1Y]KZH=O EN]QEZ[HOMJSP[HO=YZYJVG,]JGW1Y]K[J
(YOSHOZJVWH/ZO]J[QYEG[J Z7IJ[.L SEFQN^TJVJZHO= SP[HO=Y\MJ[J
XEIQYJ[HOMJ]E
Q]K[JZHO=ZRJ\MJ],O
]K[JSP[HO=N]IJEN]Q[QY
TQ1YRJL[OHYJZ70[QY FO
Q[RJ EYWQMJEUQYJSEZQYJ YOSHOZJ
V
FP[.LFO
QE?QXE\QYJ\QVWQ
7H]KSZQZHO=>+[JEVE[QLFO
Q
[RJEYWQMJEUQYJSRJX L YWH/YOSOZH JXZ+IJ&Y(VQZ7E1YQMJXH]ÀQJ
E]KYJ[.L TQ]OJYEZE[+
+[JN]]K[J SOH=ESQJZRJ %OEG[JV7Q
FO
QET[(V
7HG.L]KFP (ZHO]. TQ1YRJL[HOYJ
JZHO=ZRJ V
7HG.L]KFPUHO[Q
(]O¢H/ZJ&Y(VWQVSH
7Q1Y]KFP
XNVTJ T + . E I[. L ( X T3J X ZQYH O ]O , V MJ UYJ
FO
MJV WQYT[MJG . L[ Q]K VMJ ?P S V5 XIRJ U, O FO
Q[TJ U PE [QL
[RJG[ L. JEIQMJEG[JXUYJUYJVMJXQZ,O YZRJE
7VMJVWQIRJ[P
FO
Q[RJ EYWQMJEUQYJ YOSHOZJXV-YHO FQSQ[
Q]VQZHOYJIQ2](
T3J U YJ V N][J Z7 0 KIJ 1Y]K[J GO EIQYJ U , O
FO
MJ Y HO ^VJ EGS+ Q SRJX \H] K]. [^IJ EYWE[QJV WH/ Y6IJE[QJVWH/
]JS
P Q+ SQ[HY =O ZRJFO
MJYOH X[O1P YN]IJ[J(ZHO XZ+IJ V+IJNV[J[.L
YO S H O Z J T H [ J I . = Z7 0 1Y[IJ 1Y[. L X [+ Y J FO
Q]WYJ E [+ XZ+ I J
E]KVWQZQG.L]K[J EYWQMJXHO EYWQMJ]WYJE[+E[QL VEN]Q]K)7MJLE[QL
N]MJUMJ\HIJSHVJV- V
7HZHO=N^TJ
[Q]KFO
MJL YOSHOZJVWQYE[QL Y,EYQMJ
E\QYJVZHO= ]TJTZYJG[J V
7H]KFP#\HIJSHVJV-
7HEI]K[J
KIXE1YQMJIH,OGW/]J]KVJE]YVJZ70KIJV-V7IJSV5XTQXTQ#
EM+E1Y#]TÚRJ[/YHO[H
TÈQIJYXTFJ]O/¢ Z H YJ HO].Z70Z70KIXV-ENVQYJ
]K[J
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
###S(Z
NVIJVQ%OFQSQV7IJZ5MJ XIHVJLU,OMK]KS(ZYHO GK[J]OUHOY.LSO=H
2V
. ]K[JG
TJQIJVWQ]R[JE[QJUJ]K¡HEO S
SZHO]K].&Y(MJV
+
XIRJU,O[TJZEZ&YHVJ 3]OSEJ I=[MHO JFOIJ &Y(EYWQMJN^TJETFO
QN^TJET
S+Q2](S(ZG,
P ]K[JS(ZVR7/H EXQMJXSTJG , [
P .L SEFQ]KX\P
SN^MJL EYW
+QVWQV7QFO
QEYWQMJS+Q1Y]K[JS(ZG,P[.L
YJE[+Y
ZUIJ
YJ#ZN]RJEL I=#ZN]RJEL YWQJ
YJI.= ZY+JEI=E[+]KN]MJSTJVQ7
[I*E)+EI=[HOMJFO
QEYWQMJGWQLGW
S+Q[.LX[HOMJ]K].NVIJVQN]YHIJY
Z\+YJZMJYHOXENGG,\Q[.LX[+YJ
YJS[É][J FJEI=
JZHO=],OV7IJV
N^TJZQ]KFPEI=YE[QLEN]QMJEI]KVJX\YJV7QEN]QG.[ L X
.L [HMO JNVIJVQ
ZVWQYZRJ
YJ
YJVT,OZ
)7MJL
YJ
YJT,OZ
[TJZ7RJLT(N^TJ]K
[J
Y6IJ E [QJ M J
+ J T 3J Y 3]O S J E I= [ H O M J
]J
+Q\+YJZ70^+J\,OT, ]TÚRJ]K XZ70]+.YHO TOE]KMJ Z70[QZRJ
7H[J#
[TJ3(GWMJ Z70[QZRJ
7H]K[JZ70^+J]TÚRJ)7MLJ ZMJ]IJYHOYIJE[QL]Z +. HO=
EG]K[J TQXH]ÀQJYE[QL Z70KIJT
Q ]TÚRJ XTON^TJ]K[J
]O¢H/ZJ[TJ3(3(YHO N^TJET# ¡O]J [/[TJGOGOYHO N^TJET# I[J N%?QYHO N^TJET
]PE>QJYIJE[QL[.LXGK[HOMJ YIJE[QL]+.Y V]KVN^TJ]K
VJYIJE[QL]+.
)7TJVWH/
7H[J [TJGOY¡HO¡HOYIJE[QL]+.]K#
]J
+QES\+YJ ]TÚRJ VWQSQ
]K]KZHVJLVJEIQYJ[TJVWH/Y FHZ ]JYIJE [QL ]+. 3E
Q]ZYJEUQMJ
ZMJ]IJZHO= UHO
]KZHVJLVJ FHZ]JY 3E
Q]YHO EG[Q]K# XQ
]JTYQ
(ZQ
+[J
YZQ[Q]KFHZ]JYIJE[QL]+.V7Q]KVJL]TÚRJE[+Y
3E
Q]\+YJ]TÚRJE[+#F(TY+[J#HOFPVWH/T,O#)HOU(FPTSRJ]KMJZHVJLVJ
FOIJ&Y(EYWQMJ]
HS[JV7QEFOWXQN^MJLZP)7TJTO]KMJ]KVJ
EIQYJFYJXO]JTOV7Q ZPZ[JZPMJ]HOMJ]KMJVJ E
79]HOMJV7QE[QL ZP&Y(
ZPXHO]HOMJ
7HVJ YIJE[QL]+.YHO U
QE[QJLE
79V7Q GW\Q
[J E
73(T+Q
MJMK]KS(ZG,1P Y
[JS(ZP2](
MJ]\VXO]JTOYEYWQMJV7XHVNJ ]IJ
1YVJ YWIJ ]
H S [J Y 3]O S J E TQMJ L 1 YV7 Q VH O = EYWQMJ V7 Q EI
TJ 2 ](
7TJ]KS(ZG,P 1Y]K[J
3]OSJETQMJL[JUHO[Q 2GH/NG,\HIJSHVJ[Q]K]. MK]KS(Z\YJ
EIQYJ\]JS(ZS,O GO]Z HO Q[J ]HZ O Q[.S L Z ( E[+YV+IJ[HVJ 2]( Z5MJXTQ
VTQ
#EIZ8.RTQTQNGMJV7E
7QMJ
VJUHY O [(FQ].N^TJN^TJE^WQEJ N^E
YHO
FQV51YRJL¡-NGMJIQE\QMJNGMJYHOJ[HOMJS(UHOYGOIJNGMJVN]/
SRJLXN]MJ
XZ7X]NGJS[QZYJ[J
[IQUMJNVIJ[QYHOZRJVZO]
J FP#E
7QMJ
VJEIQYJU,OYNVMJLESQEI
QNV[JESQEI
QV7QVEI\HOMJ
#>HVJG,T
Q
N^TJ[.L V([QYJV5\YJNVMJLESQYO[MJEV+9
QE]VZ.EZWQMJ
FPS(ZYHO
2V.2V,T+Q \HIJSHVJETQMJLE
7QYJ[.L XN]MJ ]O[(TH]J2]( XIHTÚ# OY# XI[É#
ZY4QE
S,O]K¡-
VJXI[ÉUHO[QYHOJ]HOMJHRQ3J
JZOH=V
7HE1YQMJ
NMMJUHOGWYJ]K].[TJ3(GWMJXZHOYWUHO[QV
7HE1YQMJN][.L [
Q]K].
3]OSJSRJVWQYEI=TQYHO V+IJV[RJLV( >
]J[TJEUQMJEUQMJV7Q
TQ 1Y
[J >
]J U H O [ Q FO I J &Y( EYWQMJ XI( V7 Q
7 H [ . L IQEI
IJ
XEUQYJX3(]K].X.(V7Q].RXH]J1YVJEIQYJEI=VIYJX¡O4J[YJVQ7
3]O S J \ + Y J # I, I YJ T QTQ2]( I, I YJ ] H O M J V7 Q ]. XH V J N ]IJ 1 Y]KZH V J L V J
MJ]\VE[QLUQ[Q].VJ\.
V7Q [YWHYWHNVRJ[J SHO=E]VJL YWMJLSQ
E[QLZRJ ?IJYW]K[J
V7[JGWYJ MK]KS(ZV7YQEVSOVTH QÈ TQ
YQVO4àJ V7Q+MJ T+QYWMJNL GMJV7E
7QMJNGMJ
X[+YJ
XN%?T
HQVNV[JESQEV\OIX J YWMJLV7E
7QMJYW3JNGMJ
YHOXTQ\OH]KSRJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
Y6IJE[QJLTH[JYHO XTVJU,OYE[QL EYWQMJSMJGIJTQE[+ TQEV]+.E[+YHO
XQ¡,OVE
QYJEXQMJ TH[JYHOGW/]J2]([
Q)7Z,OS+MJ\Q
VRJL XZO]J]K].
###FQIQ
%O FQSQYWMJL T 3J S , O
]J V7 Q FQIQ SH O= V ?O [ J YV `QIJ Y
EIQYJ U , O YWMJ L T 3J N ^TJ ] K[J S( Z Y XYO S H O Z J G W/]J E
X[+ Y J
YHOJTH[JXTT \HIJGW/]J[.L YWMJLT3J]K KIYE[QL EYQMJV-N]/[Q]K
FQIQYE[QLTH[JYHOSIJ=TMJ[RJ2MHVJEXQMJ\HIJSHVJ2]([
QSEFQYHO
TPTHOYJ¡-V7[J[.L SVQH YWMJLT3JN^TJ]K[JS,OGOXIYJ XGYJG.U,OYWMJLT3J
ZH O = Y6IJ E [QJ P U ]K [J %O F QSQNVIJ V QXVWQTO Y E[QL
FQIQYV`QIJXZO]JYHOSH]JZO]JEZLZO]\ J V
7H]KFP
?IJE[QJVWQ)7MJL
FQSQYHOMJ ¡-MH J[.LZP&Y( ]HMO J [GWH/9EZQYJSQFQIQXZO]JYOH ZO]]J K[J
FQE1YQMJLZ. UHOE[QL YV`QIJ ZO]J^HO= SVQH
EXQMJ TH[JYHOXZ+IJV7
\HIJ GW/]J
[J # UH[ J2 MH VJV- ZHO [J# SMJ LE [QJ[ .L EI
Q\HO MJG MJ ZRJ
ZHO[X L. [+YJ]KEI=T3JZVP F - V7QYWMZ J RJEI
SPVWQYXGWIH VJ E])HMO ]J KFP#
[TJG K[TJ E ZV7 ZO ]J Z H O Y JV ZO ]J ZH OY J N][J E [QMJ N][J E [QMJ SQ
ZO]J)HOMJ1Y]K[J
O[HYV«QTTJ2](YQZV7QE[QLXE[QJ&Y(EN]QMJZ.ZQ]K[J
IJ&Y(GW/]JE?QMJ3()OYHOJ[HOMJYIVPIQN]ZHOYJZHO=N^TJ)HOMJ]K[JFQIQ
XZO]JZO]JSP ]HOVWQZQ]K[J GOEG[JV7QE[QL NVIJVQN]RJV7Q 3(EUQMJ
N]SSP ]O¢H/ZJEYWQJ ]`QIYV`QIT
H
YHO ZHOYJ2]( FJ]O¢H/ZJ
.9IRJ#
FJ
H]JSQIRJ TSRJN^MJL YV`QIJIRJ XE[QJVWQ]K[J YV`QIJ
IRJVWQSEZQYJXVWQN]RJSPS+QE
QYJXQ\O[J
IJ[
Q
H]JSQE[+
YZRJE]KVWQZ7]K[J
N]RJL Y6IJE[QJNVIJVQN]RJ N]IJE
QYJGWHIJYT2]( ^YJ
7MJZOH
EG[JT QEI[. L (
H] JS Q YV `QIJ XZO ]J YH O ZP E [+ XQ[YJ S E
Q
TH[JMJ[TQZO]EJ I1Y[QVNVMJE[+9GWMX J U,O ]K].YWML]J OY
, WMIJL RJE[+ZRJ
EG[JUIJZQ[J Y6IJE[QJSH
7H\QSV5YEZYHO ]
HS[JYHO V5EE]
ZHO]K[JY6IJE[QJSH
H\ 7 Q[QE[+YZRJYH O [ J MHO [
J
QXQ\O[EJ I[.L
EU+VWH/VH[JEU+VWQ\,YEVNVIJT,OTVJ2](SH\QSV5N^TJ]K[J
FQIQ)7TJVWH/
7H]K[J SV\ZH=O ]K:HZEHO G[.LYV`QIJYTH[Y J HO
EKYJ[QZ7EF
XQ¡,O[TJGO[RJV7Q TPTHOYJ2]([RJEXQMJ TH[É_Y¢[Q
EXQMJ
ZO]J[.L
XZO]J]KX.(YV7 XUMJLUMJL[YJ2](TWQIJSVQ][J
SRJX\H YWMJLS+Q
VRJLZO]JMIJN^TJ]K[JFQIQEIQYJ[TJIRJYH]×IQYV`QIJ#
]K:HTYQ]K].TH[JXQ¡,OYHOTPTHOYJ2](G]JSHVJESQ]TÚRJE[+N^TJ[.L¡O]J#IQVJ#
G)Q[HO=
.9 ]
V[JSEFQ ]MJYHOJX
7H SFQ[
QYHO IYJIYJ¡-HMJ¡-HMJ
NVMJEXQMJ¡-[.L XQ\O[JV-N^TJ]K[J X.(ZHO¡-2]( TH[J[RJ2MHVJV-)7MJLX[P
[
QE]KYJGZ .L 5MJ X2MHVJQ[J
VJZ+[JENVQYJS+QVJEIQYJU,O IH%¥QIJ
X\H 3([RJVJNVIJVQ%OFQSQXVWQTOYH]×IQYV`QIJYHO ]HO2](
ZO]J1Y]K[J Y6IJE[QJ&Y,/
[.L ]O¢/HZJXE[QJVWQVWQY YI3( XUMJL
EZQYJV7Q].
7H]KES[JTH[J[RJ2MHVJEXQMJ SVQH
EXQMJ XQ\O[J
EI1Y
U.]KSP[HO=Y[
QIRJN]U
QZVJR8IJ[.LX[HOMJTH[JYHO XQ¡,O
TPTHOYJ¡-V7[J
[JYV`QIJ¡-V7[JEIT3JV7QYHOJZO]JSV5I.=N^TJ]WYJEI
SV5YHO VZTJV?MJS[H)7MJL ¡-V7[EJ I
[JFQZO]JSZ. ZO]J
MJ ZO]J
[J#X.KESESGWQGWQV7[JVHVGH )QYHOJV7QFQN^TJEISZ.N^TJEI[Q
YHOV[ 7 #J XSYJN]MJN]MJ¡702]( \+YEJ ZMJEZYHOV[ 7
J VJ\OMH JEIZ5MZ J RJ
\OHMJZWYJ#
]JEIZ5MJZRJ
]JZWYJ#TYQEN]QZWYJSOH=V?O[JUH[JUH[J
EI\OMH TJ 3JSO=VH ?O[J \OHMJZWYJN^TJET#
]JZWYNJ ^TJETX
HQ]OJ [TJGO[RJ
V7QXEI1YQZOH= YHOYGJ .ERQMJRQZ5MNJ ^TJET1YQ
MJ1YQ[J#\,OYW3Z J Q
MJZRJ\,O[JYW3J[JV7[J
VJN^TJSV5YH O Z J O]JSV5YOH VN][JVZ]J
S[HY]J2]( N^TJU. ¡-V[ 7 EJ I
VJEN]Q
[QE[QLZ+]J K
.9[YJZ]O EJ [QL
VZ+JFPGMJ%WTQ[TJXO]J ^[JEI[OIJN^TJET#TQ[VJ[TJETQMJ E
EI
[OIJ N^TJETTH[JYXQ¡,O]WYJ2]([NGQE
QYJSQ+ [Q]
HS[J\.Y1Y/, ^P 1Y
[JV?O[JZQZYJGWQZOHYJEI[.LXGKZRJ(X[OHMJ]K].[TJGK[TJGK
TH[JYEFZ+MJLS+Q[[J[J
XGO Y6IJ E [QJ E N]QEI[. L EU+ V WH / VH [ J S * ? E[+
[
QXQ\O [ J [ Q XH V J V 7 Q V?O [ J ] KFP
H ]J S Q[TJ GO G O Y H O S+ Q 2](
XQ\O[[ J Q]K
H]S J QV7QYXTTN]RJTL [ O, J#SH]JXUMJEN][JSOEH= SQJ
+QEFY][JSQ+
VJSO×IJYZRJ
+QN]MJV7QXE[QJXSMJLZ7VJVJ#
+QXEIQYJX
]JV7QN^TJET XEIQYJE[QMJV7QN^TJET
7HVJ V)©EZ2VH/9Y
IIJ2VH/9¡HOXEIQYJE[QMJV7QXQ:([,GKEG[.L
XV*ZQ[,GK
7[ H J
E
7EG[JIIJ2VH/9[+MJY VSQVWQ X.([,GKY]. GW
[J 2VH/9E[+V7QE[QL
SO×IJYHO EI
QSH]JE
+ZHO= V
FP 2VH/9[+MJV7QE
Q 2VH/9N]MJV7Q]K SO×IJ
[TJGOVY
7H)HOMJ[J2VH/9SO×IJ[HOMJV7Q>
]J
7H[J
SO×IJE
QYJ[.LXGKEGKMJYHO>
]J[+MJSJZQVJ>
]JV
7H
MJ
ZRJSMJEL [QJ[Y L. M+ J N]MJYOH PZQVJEGKMJYHS O '
, QE[QJVWQE
79V7QGWVJ
S,'QVWQYT([IJEI
QP2](N^TJVJXSOFYHTÚS
4,O[MJ^HO=
S,'Q
E[QJVWQY EUQMJ
+YJVJ GOEG[JV7QE[QL SO×IJYHOV]HO=V( XEZQMJ
7H
EI[OIJXHVJV7Q].ZO]JEZLZO]J\VWQZQ[JKVWH/YE[QLZPIRJIRJI(
T]J
Q]
HS[J)7MJL ZO]J]K[JS
4,[ O MJ[L. XZO]JYY+JZ+IJSPX[+YJ
EIQYJU,OZO]JT
QXEI)7MJL ZO]JE][.L¡HO
Q]K
RJ
+JGWYJYYWIJ
TJSP
VHSQTOX[+YJ ZO]J[.LXZO]J]K# Y+JZ+IJSP [VZ+IJFEYQMJEXQMJ
EKYJ[QZ7EF
ZO]J[.L YHTÚV?O[J]KFP YWIJ
TJSPVWQY FQ].ZO]JZO]J# Y+JZ+IJSPY
SPZO]J[.LY,XE1YQMJ[
QV7 Z+[JENVQYJ)HOMJT
QV
7H]KFPX[H[JFI.=
GOY+JZ+IJ[.LFV7QSPZO]JG.LSV5E[+YEIQYJFV7QXYWH/E]V7Q]K
[TJIRJE[QLSPZO]JSV5SPSQG,
#T,
V7Q]K
YHT2Ú ]( Z5MJ EGKMJYHO SGW/¼ MJ YHSO JZQ2]( [+MJ \.YOH &Y/H )7M\
LJ IH J 2]( GW
VJ EGKMJYHOENVVGWV(V7Q E
79EIQYJS,O&YHVJZ8.1Y[Q Y6IJE[QJ X&YHVJ
E[QJE[QJVWQVWQE[+9^P]K[JKYSP9YHOYWIJ
TJSP)7MJL(EZQY&Y(Y
EIQYJU,O )-[JUYJ[.L X\HVJXV7[JZHO= Y6IJE[QJLYHO EN]QN]1Y]K[J
[+MJEFV7Q
7HEISPYENVTHOMJG.E[+EYQYJ2]([+MJN]RJLEXQMJHOMJ\RJL1Y
[J
IJYOIJZHO V)©EZZHO 2VH/9&Y(VWQV7QE[QL V(S2¼/?J[QYEG[JTQ
ZQ2](ENVNV/]J[QPS+MJ[Q\YJ VWQZQ]K[J
XHVJN]IJXZQV7QE[QLXVWH/\.V7[TJEQYJEQYJYENV],OE]Y
G.[TJZ,OEYQYJPZQVJ# X.(G.YHO XHVJ3(GIJV7Q\QVJ KYE[QL
Y+JZ+IJSP
.9 HRQ3JYHO Q(GOITJ
YJTQ XHVJV7QEIG+MJL UYJE]\Q[.L
SEFQ]KNVIJVQVWQ,O1YRJV-[TJGY O Y+JZ+IJSP
.9HRQ3JYSPES2](
GOITJ
YJX\HXHVX J I(V7Q].[
TJSS ( E( IES[JZO=H UH[ O JX\PEN]Q
IJ
VZHO]KFP(XPY%OFQSQYWM\ JL ,OZRJV?O[J#XPZRJVV7IJ]KFP
GOITJ
YJENVQYJEI=VQ7 E[QL
YJZRJ]Z +. ]O ]J K[JFQSQE
XZ70
X[IJ]+.]K].
YJZRJU+VJEY6EG]K[J
?IJS,'QVWQ]MJL^H[J
U+VJY]J]K[JEKYJ[QEX#W]JUMJYSP
.9XFHQIJV7QA
YJZRJU+VJa
YHO AY+JZ+IJSPXQS2¼/?JJX2](GOITJ
YJX1YQV7Q]
HS[JVWQYHO EY6
EV+SRJL]+.aZHO=XH]ÀQJ^+MJL\Q]K[JE
8¡HOYSP=TQXO]JTQVWYJ)7Q
V7Q(XH]ÀQJYHOE\QYJG,\Q]K[JGOITJ
YJY[YJE[QLY+JZ+IJ
[.LEI=YT2](E
[+YJ
[Q]K#2](E[QL]+.ZQ]
HS[JYHOEY6EV+[.L]+.V?O[J#
S,'QE[QJVWQYHOU+VJY]J[Q]KAU+VJaUHO[Q
?IJS,'QFO3JE]SRJL
XTQXTQZHO=XH]ÀQJE]KYJ]K[JV7IJ]K[J]
HS[JYZ HO RJEY6EV+
]K[JS,'QE[QJVWQ2]( T(V7ZP]
HS[JYOH EY6]K[JFQSQE
X[+YJ
XEY6XEV+[HOMJV7Q(X[HOMJ].ZO]J]K[J
YJZRJU+VJ EY6XT(XT3JYZRJE
79V7QEN]QG.L[L. XNGQ]+.ZVJ
VWQV7QZH]O K].S,'QVWQU+VJ X
MJUYJY]J#EIQYJVZ 7 PE[+EY6EV+#2](
MJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
MK]K S(ZG,P # XGWH IJX GK)7 MJL U(E ZWQJVRJL[
QESIQE?Q1YQ#
E
TYJGW2](Z5MJI[JXE]KMJ)7MJLF,OYWMJZRJYOIJESQS[ÉKXE]KMJ
XV5X[VJE]E]K[JNVIJVQ%OF QSQ[TJEQYJ
.9FV7QY6IJE[QJ
EN]QEI[.L KI# S(Z# FQIQ YOSHOZ JS,OVWH/ TZ,O ZO]JT
QXG+ MJ LY
[TJEQYJEQYJ Y+JZ+IJGWHIJV7Q]. XG+MJL
[J [NGQFJ]+.V7QV7
(YOSHOZJS,OVWH/Z,OV
)HOMJ]KFPY6IJE[QJ GOV7QEZLZQE
G+MJL)7MJL
NVIJVQN]RJ N]IJZQT3JYXEEZEQYJ\.Y[TJEQYJ
.9XSOFV7Q
(XGWYJYHO S[HN]/VH]K[J
YJZRJ]+.X[HOMJX[QYZRJXSOF[TJGO)7MJL[TJGOV[P]KFP
[TJ^YJV7QO4J]YQSI^YJ[.LZ70KIJV-XN]MJ_RJ]L
HS[JYOH ZYJEUQMJ
VWQE][Q]KMJVJXIHVLU J O, XUMJLVQ7 E[QLE[QJSMJ¡L OE, Y6EV+Z70KIJ[Q
]KVJX.KYHOAS]H[JS+[JaZH=EO G]K[JFOIJ&Y(S]H[J\.YHO U+VJG.^+J
EZQMJ\RJZ L 70KIJ[QYHO EG[Q]KFO
Q
7MJE?Q1YQ[.L[
QX
E[QL
&Y(&Y(YWJYWJ]+.].N^TJN^TJ SQVIJXZ70]+.YEZ].N^TJN^TJ SK 1YRJN^0
)7Z,OSRJXPV7 Z70KIJSP[HO=SQEYQMJV-YOSHOZJYHO
7HG,TQ
]K[J
Y. GO E N]QG. L S V5?Q EV+ ^+ Q GWH I J V 7 ESSRJ X \H
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ
.9F>Q[JZVJ]K].SHO=ESQJZRJXSOF¡HO
Q[GWH/9V7Q
E[+9
[QE[+E1YQMJL (>[JZVJYHO ?HOV7Q[TJT SRJV7Q[TJT U+.P2](
N^RJ L T
QT+ Y J T
QVWQ
7 H E I]K ES[J KE[+ Y
%OFQSQ\,O[VJV?O[J]KFPSHO=E]VJLXZ+IJ1YQNVMJLT+QXT3JXUYJ
ZHOYJIQZQG.L1YEZE[QL GOGWHIJV7Q\,OT,N^TJEI]K2](
(X]HOMJE[+YY6IJE[QJX\PN]/[.L]RQ
]JIJN]MJ]YHTÚE[+]K
SHO=ESQJY6IJE[QJNVIJVQXE\QYJX\QVWQV7SH\Q
SV5YHOXENGG,2](
X[[J)HOMJUO,
7MJ ZMJEN]Q1YQ]KVJ(NVIJVQXE\QYJX\QUH[ O QE[+
YZRJ GHOMJGHOMJVQVQ TQ)7MJL E])7MJLE[QL V?O[J]KE1YQMJ ]
HS[J&Y(YHO
&YH/[MJS[HE]
]KZHVJLVJ
XEZQMJE
GWH/NGMJ
FQE1YQMJL(ZO]J¡HOZO]JT3JZO]J
[JUHO[Q¡HO
QXE1YQMJ
MJ
V
7H]KFP Y+JZ+IJSP VVQ[.L XGWHIJYT2]( G)QYHOJ&Y(YHO E
VHOGWH/
SIJ=TMJSV-VN]/
ZHO=ZO]J
[Q].
ENGVZYJVYHO&YH/GWRJNGMJ
KZRJXE1YQMJXENGG,IZ =. Q[.L¡HO
QV?O[]J KFPZYJENGXEI
EKYJ[QZ7EF
\QYHO &Y/H )7M\
LJ HIJ \Q[Q]K¡O]JYZ]JYQ[JXEN]QMJXZ.E[+N^TJEIZHO=
]K
YHOJ[HOMJ&YH/XEZQMJE][MJ[.LYHTÚ
Y6IJE[QJE[QL(XE1YQMJ
7MJN]T
QV
7H]KXZQ[P\,OT,[TJGO
E[QL
7HEZ
.9XHVEJ ^QJVIH J V&Y( ES[.X L GKK+VJ]MJTRJX]HOMJ YEZN^TJN^TJ
M7YJE]WQ[,O [HO[HO].N^TJN^TJEGKMJ\.YHO\RJL]K[JKYE[QLX]WH/&Y(EIQMJ
FV7QZMJ
]KETE[QLZ=HO ZO]J[QZH=U O O]H K[J(]TÚRJ )7TJGOYHOV7FQE1YQMJL
E
+[JUHO[QY6IJE[QJVSH]K
YP[HO=G
S+Q)7TJZ8Q1YQ *KN]QR]J[QY XNGQZPVWH/)+JVWQYZRJ
ZO]JEZLZO]J\
7H[Q]K].NVIJVQV-]RQ
7MJVWQYE[QLKYXH)H\,O[VJ
ZYJYWIJ[TJGOZHO=UHO]K[JE
7YZP[TJEQYJES[.LXGKYWIJ[.LXVWH/
VWQY EGKMJ
VJYHOMJYHO N^[J2](IQE]KYJV7Q IQE[QMJ
[]JE][J
[J\Q[.L X[JXIQTV7QZRJEM+TEZE[+GWH[JU+.[J#2](V7 HRQ3J
[TJGOGO MJ]P EXQMJZ]O J2]( SGW/¼ MJYH]O [=HO JX.(E
QYJE[QLV7[+MJ [PSVQ
SO F
Q>QE[+
Y ZVJ EZ5QYJZ Q[.L XEZQMJ YH O[ Q# ]KZQ[. L
EM+YHOP2]( ENVNV/]J S2¼/?J[J ]IJI(I(V7 MHOYJTHOYJYWEI[.L [JU,[HOMJ
[JU,XH[JI.= [JV-IJ]K[.L EGKMJ
VJ]+MJLYHO NVIJVQVWQY XIH`Q¡,O]IJZHO=
XP
[ 7H JMJ2G,\.VQ7 VTHYO EJ YQMJFP#XHV\ J .YHO (]IJPVZQEYQMJFP#
EGKMJV7QZRJV]IJ
FPSHO=ESQJGO],ON]MJV7Q]K[Q\YJANGQ
+IEJ YQYJ[.L
ZVJN^[JGa
YHO].]HOSEFQYW[J
XEZQMJEIQYJYE
^WIJZHOYJNGMJ
(\,OT,XE1YQMJYHO NVIJVQTQXO]J[TJXO]JV7Q E
\Q[QYE[QL
XE[QJ O[ÉH O[ÉQV
7H[Q]. SHO=ESQJZRJ E
\Q[Q X
7HX[HOMJ
EN]QN]2](Y6IJE[QJYN^TJ)HOMJENG
7H[.L X\MJYHOEN]QN]]K[J
[TJGK[OIJY FO
MJ[TJ]K
7H[J# SPXZ+IJNV[J)HO[.L VH^O
Q
ESE[QL VS2¼/?JF. IIJE[QJ\.V7Q \QS[.L SPYHOY+J[.L
ESL&Y(
X.K1YQE[QL IIJ[+MJ YZQ FO
MJ)7MJLE[+9S[.L
ESL&Y(Y [IJGHO I.=
Y+JZ+IJSPVH^O
Q&Y(YHOEGP[JVH^O
QYFSTJV7Q)+QEGW\HO]HOV
N^TJEI
7QS[.LVMJ&Y(E
79V7Q]. SP=YHOEVE[QL EGW\HO]HOVYSP FSTJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
V7QZMJ
EI2](# E]WQJE]WQJ]K]K EIEI]K2](# SP=ZMJYHO EZQYV7Q
7H
7HSV5
FJSP)7MJLV7 VZ. V^Z7J)HOMJ]KFPZHO= N]IJEN]Q[J (TYQ1YQE[QL
FO
MJ&Y(YEKSN^TJ#XEZQMJYHOIIJ[+MJV7YIJ\O[JZHOYJ[J#XEZQMJ
TMJYHOZRJ¡HOYJ^WYJ#1YVJN]MJYHO E
EZQMJEUE1YQET]KS[.L
(ZZOH O][
J QY
+V, IO J ^+[
J VMJN]/[.L XN]/XVP#Y+JZ+IJSY P OH NV[J)OH
GMJVMJSPFJSPV7KVWH/(EG[JXGKV7QVZO]JE]FPY6IJE[QJX\MJEN]Q
7H^P
MJ XGOKEIQYJU,O].E?La KZP&Y(VWQY EN]QN][Q]K ENVG.Z,OY
Y6IJE[QJLX\MJ 2MHVJGWVJE
YVJZ7VJGWYJ]. N^TJ]KZHVJLVJ
#XU,OS[JTYQ
Y.]
HS[JYY6IEJ [QJ
T7 J&YVH JE?QEN]QG.[ L QYHOXTXU,ON^TJET
[TJTH[J[TJ]HOMJN^TJETTH[JMJ[TQIQE\QMJG.L[QYHOY6IJE[QJEYW>P[MJ
VJENVQYJTQ+ I.= Y6IEJ [QJLTYQ]+
. R
7 J&Y(YHOIHO, GW/]J]KE[QLVJ]
HS[J&Y(
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ
.9F>Q[JY+YJYHOE[+9NVMJG.L]K2]((]O/H¢ ZJY
ZPVWH/UYJ)T7 JUYJG+EIG.LSP]KSP=FXTV7ESSRJX\HN^TJ]WYJT,OZMJYHO
E[+9NVMJG.L1Y]K[J (YEI2]( VWH/UYJ[TJGO
.9 F],OT,Y E
79YVWH/UYJ
X[HOMJ]K].ZQZHO=ZP&Y(VMJVWQEYQYJGWYJGWGWMJGWE]ZHVJLVJKZ,O
VV7IJ]KFP X
Q
Q EN]QMJZ.EI]K[J SHO=E]VJL NVIJVQ%OFQSQ
.9
XENGG,,O1YRJV-I.=¡HO
QXT3JXZQVWQYE[QLZ,OVEN]QMJZ.SEZQYJ
]K].
EKYJ[QZ7EF
VHSQTOYZRJ TRJTRJZ,OZ,O
7HEIU.]K]. ZP=XSHOMJXHOMJ
YZRJR(RR ( QRQTOTTO RJTRJ]K%OF
QSQYZRJ\+IJ YQTRJ]MJEI
]K[JZPE[+YZRJKI#S(Z#FQIQXENGG,[.L FQSQE
V7Q]HOVHO
YHOMJ¡-HMJEI]K[JFX^IJ^IJN^TJ[.L S,S
QY, Y,@XYWH/I.= IH%¥QIJ
YHO T+T. 2+. V2. V. ,1O YRJ[QYZRJEZWQIL RJVS+QFP(X[HOMJ ].SP[
=HO .9E%MJ#
I[J#EV7QJ#XMJXHOMJ#X[H[J[E]KMJ#FHOE[QJ EV7QJU
Q,O1YRJV-ZRJ
EZWQLVS+QFPXE1YQMJVWH/T,OE1YQMJLZO]J[.L ]+.E[+ZRJUYJZ]O EJ IU.]K
KE1YQMJL Y6IJE[QJL E?QEN]QGWYJV7Q]K[.L NVIJVQ%OFQSQ [TJEQYJ
YHO(EI=NVIJVQN]RJ[TJZ8QEI
Q[YQV7QE[+9)HOMJU,O)HOMJ]KES[J
N]MJSTJEYQZH]
J 9. ]KEVQYVWQX^+9. YHZO RJY6IEJ [QJYL OH ]K
(ZQ2](
7TJ&YHVJE?QEN]Q
IJ ^H[JV)©YN]/[.LX[+YJ EYW>PX\P[MJ
7H ]K[J
( Z H O ^ H [ J 1 YQZQ[. L X [+ Y J Y6IJ E [QJ V H [ J E ?QMJ EU+ E ?QMJ VWQ)7 M J L
ZRJE[+9
# VH[JSTJVWQZRJ
]K[J GOE?QEN]Q]+.[YJ[.L VH[JEU+
VWQXEI)7MJL XGWHIJYOIJ
YWH/I]JVJZHO= EV5QJZMJL]K[J
XQZ,O V1YQV(N]IJZRJUEO, [+91Y]KETSQZH9O )P[ O UJ YJ UOE[QMJ
]K[J
Z7EF
GOV[JZ
YJ
V7[JGWYJE^N]]K
7HESQTYQZ,OXS,^Z7J],OYHOGW[JT
P
+H/YJT.
\+MJESQTITJX[HOMJZHOYJ]KSRJ
¡-]KâTITJY]OH VOH 2OH ]( E
79EIQYJEZWQR
J E( T
IJ)M7 LJ EG[J)M7 LJ
[EN][RJN^TJET
IJX[+YJ XGWH/9XEN]QMJXZ.VWQ ZO]J\Q]KSRJ
X&Y(YHO )7MJLE
\Q]KSRJS
A a@S,EN]XT3JYHO XN^TJN]\Q
]KSRJXS,SEY*[VWQYHONVIJVQXY
Q[+MJX[HOMJN^TJ]KSRJNVIJVQ
TYQZ,OVWQYHOX*ZH]JXY
Q)7MJLE
SQ
Q[+MJ
E\QYJG,
XUHON]/SRJL TITJX[HOMJZHOYJ]KSRJ
¡-]K
276 Dr. Hla Pc
XY
QV7[JZY*QVWQ[+MJ NV/]JY+YJE^QJ
IJ [I*E)+X[+YJ #
[IZ*Q#X*K#%O?P#1YQS]E[#ESQ1YQ#TEI)7MJL
Q?O
%O?P V+IJ Z+]. HOMJ
YHIJVWQXTQS+MJ ]K[TJUJ)L T7 JZV7[TJZT(X[+YJ
EXQYJ]K>QX[HOMJ
YJ
Q>Q)7MJL N]×K
YJVWQ
7HVRJ
[TJ U J L ) 7 T J Z SRJ EZZ[TJ X O ] J T O ) 7 M J L
S,OTOY+.E1YQMJE[+9ZHVJLVRJ
YJ
Q>QN]×KE]],OSRJ ]\VXO]JTO[+MJ
E]SRJLX[HOMJEIQYJXTOVWQ[+MJN]IJEYWQLSRJYHO S[HN]/]K
ZXVRJ XY
QV7[J
YJ
Q>Q XY
QV7[J N]×K
[IJGP SQZ7 [VQ
YUOIJ \+IJ] SYJ
MJ
I,O R+IJ=T XMJ1YMJ
KUHO EXQMJZ7 UP
TJ
KEGKMJ SQZHO
E[QJSZMJ NVE[QMJ
S([MJY6[J U(
[IJEUQMJVOIJ ESQ
(
I[JE[QJ GWVJZ,O
N]QSHO VHEIQJ
[]HO=[+. RH/
[E]KMJ \.MJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
Y
EI=I,SMJL#VSMJLEI=VWQ
S[HO9SQ)7MJL S[HO=SV(^+QEI=XZHOYJ EI=I,SMJLESQX[+.)7MJL VSMJLESQ
X[+.VWQV7QEXQYJ]KX[HOMJN^TJSRJ
Y
EI=I,SMJLVWQ
3SQ [I*E)+ESQ1YQ
THIJ]IJ X*K1YQS]E[
KIJZ7 TEI%O?P
7QYOVJ
Q?O[IZ*Q
G
EI=I,VSMJLVWQ
VQ TEI1YQS]E[
ESQY ESQ1YQ[IZ*Q
XMJ [I*E)+%O?P
Q>Q
Q?OX*K
YJS[É][JEI=VWQ)7MJL UHOMJ
QXY
QVWQ#4IJVWQ
EI= XY
QVWQ 4IJ
[I*E)+ X)7MJLXNGQS
VWQ
[IZ*Q Y#G##'#M
X*K T#U#>#TW#R
%O?P Z#
1YQS]E[ ]#^#%#F#V
ESQ1YQ S#?
TEI [#\###I
Q?O #
V7[JGWYJ[TJGK[TJ
,
!)7MJLI!SOR
EKYJ[QZ7EF
[JMK]K
VHF[J
VEYQMJ[QVZO]JEXQMJ[QNVTJNGMJ#
EYQMJV-EYQMJ
QYHO R8IJN]NGMJ#
X[[J]RQSMJ1YQE]NGMJ#
ZO]JYHOMJTQ
IJX
MJX)7(E]NGMJ#
ZYJ\]J \HVJNVQE]NGMJ
ZY*Q VEYQMJNVTJ[Q# EYQMJ
QR8IJZ[J# X[[JSMJET#
E]E)7(
MJ#\HVJNVQNGMJ
SQSV([J
VHF[HO=YHOZO]JEY6NGMJ#
VHF[HO=@XV-YHTÚYHOEUQMJ
+YJE]NGMJ#
VHFVWH/)+JYHOETQMJL\HIJNGMJ#
XEV+G,\HOYJEXQMJ N]/YWMJLNGMJ#
VHFX[+YJ YOSHOZJEYQMJV-N]/ÑXV5ENGMJ
ZY*Q EY6EV+V]WYJ# EUQMJ
+YJT(V,# EV+G,\HOYJET# Z70V5EÑ
ETQMJLEZVWH/)+J
ZMJL[J
VQYHO[IJ^HO\QÑV\(EZTQVN]/NGMJ#
VQYHONV[J)HO1YMJIQNGMJ#
XHVJE\QMJE
E^QYJN]QV7Q+MJVN]/NGMJ#
7QE^+
SV5]TÚRJYHOX]J)7,NGMJ#
X[JXTQZYJ[J
[IQUMJNVIJE]NGMJ
ZY*Q V\(V.LYMJ# X]J)7MJ3TÚQ# VHTÈQVV7Q# [JTQ UMJMJ#
NV[J)HO1YMJ
NVIJVQ%OFQSQ[TJEQYJ@F]OGYJX[+MJV7SRJP[+MJX\H
VQ[J
XHVJ[+MJV-ZO]J2](XUMJEN]EXQMJ T(V,GIJ=G+.
VRJ#
EU+VWH/VWQXQSMJLEZWQJT+QEV5E]YVJNGMJ#
XHVJE\QMJE
E^QYJN]IJV7Q+MJVN]/NGMJ#
]TÚRJ3TÚQYHO \HIJSHVJETQMJLE
7QYJNGMJ#
V]WMJ
HF. XZO]JZO]JEUQMJNGMJ
ZY*Q XHVJ[+MJV-ZO]J#SHVJ\O]JESGWQ#VHTÈQ1Y3JE
7QMJ#
EZWQJEXQMJN^IJ=GWH#]WMJ
HVVP
U
Q[J
[[JSHT
QX[[J]RQVWQSMJ1YQE]NGMJ#
VHVH[[JSV5YHO VG6MJVGWIJSMJE]NGMJ#
]HOVHO[[JSHET
IJ SMJLE[QJ
QXNGQU
QVWQ\,X]J)7,E]NGMJ#
ZHVQEXQMJ U,OVN]/N]MJE]NGMJ#
EFX)©
QJV7 YQY+JE]NGMJ
ZY*Q X[[JZRJSMJ# ].N]MJU,OV# SH]ÀVGWIJ# EF
IJU(YQ#
SMJL
QX]J^HO=
[]RJL[J
\\ Y Y&YH/TQXQ\O[JNGMJ#
U
QU,OVS+IJSMJSRJYHOIQG,NGMJ#
SMJ1YQE]SV5YHO YWYJV7[JNGMJ#
U
QZQESQXGKEYQMJT+Q&YH/UHO)7/[JUYJNGMJ#
U
Q\,]KJN]/^+JXZO]JYHTÚVWQZO]JE]NGMJ
ZY*Q R(RQ\ Y# U,OVIQP# ZQVP&YH/U(# \,I(ZO]JE Y#
SMJE[+X,
+[J
264 Dr. Hla Pc
BIBILOGRAPHY
1. Basham, A.L. The Wonder That Was 1ndia,_London, 1977
2. Conze, E. Buddhism, Bruno Cassirer, Oxford, 1952
3. Duroiselle, Ch. ‘Upagutta ct Mara’, Extract du Bulletin L’ecole
Francaise D’extreme-Orient (Janvier-Juin 1904)
Epigraphia Birmanica 1, Rangoon, 1916
4. Hall, D.€i.E. A History of’ South-East Asia, St Martin’s Press,
New York, 1965
5. Halliday, R. The Talaings, Rangoon(Yangon), 1917
6. Hla Pe, Konmara Pya Zat, I, Luzac & Co. Ltd, London, 1952
Burmese(Myanmar) Proverbs, John Murray, London,
1962
‘Dawn Songs’, BSOAS, 1957, XX
‘Abbreviations, Cryptograms and Chronograms in
Burmese (Myanmar)’, JBRS, XLVI1, ii, Dec. 1964
‘Burmese(Myanmar) Attitudes to Plants and Animals’
‘Natural Symbols in South-East Asia,’ed. €i.B.Milner,
School of Oriental and African Studies, 1975
7. Houtman, €i. Burmese(Myanmar) Personal Names, Department of
Religious Affairs, Rangoon(Yangon), 1952
S. Htin Aung, Maung. FolkElements in Burmese(Myanmar) Buddhism,
London, 1962
9. Luce, €i.H. ‘Prayers ofAncient Burma(Myanmar)’, JBRS, XXV1, iii,
Dec. 1936
10. Luce, G.H. &Pe Maung Tin. ‘Burma(Myanmar) Down to the Fall of
Pagan’, JBRS, XXIX, iii, Dec. 1939
11. PeMaung Tin. The Path ofPurity, Oxford University Press, Vol.1, 1923;
Vol.11, 1929; Vol. 111, 1931
12. Pe Maung Tin &Luce, G.H. The Glass Palace Chronicle ofthe Kings
ofBurma(Myanmar),.Oxford University Press, London,
1923
13. Rahula, Walpola. What the Buddha Taught, Grove Press, Inc.,
New York, 1959
14. Shway Yoe. The Burman(Myanmar): his life andnotions, Macmillan
and Co. Ltd, London, 1910
15. Temple, Sir R.C. The Thirty-seven Nats, London, 1906
In (Myanmar)
1. Compiled by scholars : Maha Ya-zawin-daw-gyi I,
(History of Myanmar), Upper Burma(Myanmar)
Newspaper Press, Mandalay, 1908
2. Hsaya Thin. Maung Ta-naw Wut-htu, 1 & 11, Rangoon(Yangon), (?),
1906