Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: A new concept named mass connectivity index (MCI) to encode bond contributions and to allow quanti-
Received 26 May 2010 fying the extent of branching in a molecule, especially of ionic liquids, is proposed. The concept is based
Received in revised form 24 June 2010 on the molecular connectivity concept first introduced by Randic in 1975 and modified in different forms
Accepted 25 June 2010
by several authors. The proposed concept is much easier to calculate than any of the connectivity indexes
Available online 3 July 2010
available in the literature. Thus the only data required for determining the MCI are the groups forming the
molecule and the mass of the groups. The groups forming the molecule are defined as commonly done
Keywords:
in group contribution methods. The index is used as a variable in generalized correlations to accurately
Ionic liquids
Connectivity index
estimate the density and the heat capacity of ionic liquids.
Molecular structure © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Molecular parameters
General correlations
0378-3812/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.fluid.2010.06.015
108 J.O. Valderrama, R.E. Rojas / Fluid Phase Equilibria 297 (2010) 107–112
What is common in all these proposals is the use of some sort 3. Connectivity index
of parameters related to the structure of the molecule. This is a
reasonable approach for ILs since the values of the properties are The molecular connectivity concept was first introduced by
highly dependent not only on the type of anion and cation forming Randic [24] and later developed and expanded by Kier and Hall
the ILs but also on the structure and the branching of the molecule [25,26]. Randic proposed an algorithm to encode bond contri-
[19–21]. In this work a molecular parameter that better involves butions to a molecular branching index that is known today as
some characteristics of the molecular structure of the ionic liquid molecular connectivity. This concept has allows in some way to
is proposed as a discriminating parameter for generalized correla- at least partially quantify the extent of branching in a molecule, an
tions or neural network models. For hydrocarbons, for instance the aspect of especial importance in group contribution methods, espe-
acentric factor is a good parameter for correlating several proper- cially when the method is applied to ILs. The essence of molecular
ties and has been widely employed in many applications [1]. This connectivity is the encoding of the structure in a non-empirical
is not the case for ILs and acentric factors can be roughly estimated way. It is not a measured property nor does it derive from or
with the properties available at present, so a new easy-to-calculate directly translate into a particular physical property. According to
parameter seems to be needed. Hall and Kier [27], this has not been understood by some investi-
gators employing structure–activity models. The authors examined
2. Property correlations the Randic algorithm, proposed an alternate structure concept, and
offer an interpretation of the information encoded by molecular
In the ranges for which density and heat capacity data for ILs connectivity.
are available, the behavior of these properties with temperature The molecular connectivity index is calculated by drawing out
is relatively simple and well known: the dependency of density a chemical compound in a hydrogen-suppressed molecular struc-
() on temperature is approximately lineal and the heat capacity ture and designating a value for each atom. The value of an atom
(CP ) follows a quadratic dependency (second order polynomial). equals the number of adjacent non-hydrogen atoms. The values of
Fig. 1 shows data from the literature of these properties for some each atom forming a bond pair designate a bond value, and the bond
selected ILs. Some authors have proposed to generalize the slopes values are then summed over all the bonds in the chemical struc-
of these linear or quadratic expressions in terms of some specific ture to calculate . In a similar way a valence connectivity index
J.O. Valderrama, R.E. Rojas / Fluid Phase Equilibria 297 (2010) 107–112 109
Table 1 Table 2
Groups considered in this study for defining the mass connectivity index. Groups connections for [S111] [BF4 ] for the calculation of the MCI.
v has been defined and used in some applications [24,28]. The Replacing the values of m1 , m2 , m3 and m4 for the groups forming
expressions for the molecular connectivity index and the valence the molecule, the value of for trimethylsulfonium tetrafluorobo-
connectivity index v are: rate is 0.9389. Values of for some selected ionic liquids are shown
in Table 3. The supplementary material provides values of for
1 476 ILs and an excel file to easily evaluate the connectivity index
= (5) for other ionic liquids.
ıi ıj The advantage of the defined mass connectivity index, besides
⎛ ⎞ the simplicity of its calculation, is that not only it encodes the
1 degree of skeletal branching but also the mass of the groups being
v = ⎝ ⎠ (6) connected. In addition to that, the new mass connectivity index is
ıiv ıvj simple to calculate and it is directly related to the indexes defined
by Randic and other indexes such as that modified by Kier and
Here ıi is the number of non-hydrogen atoms to which the non- Hall v . Fig. 2 shows the relation between the mass connectivity
hydrogen atom i is bonded while ıvi incorporates multiple bonding, index and other molecular indexes for several organic compounds.
heteroatoms and valence states. The values of and v were taken from Li and Li28 , while was
These indexes are neither simple nor straightforward to be determined from Eq. (2).
determined although the concept behind them is of especial impor- Despite these advantages, the simplicity of the defined MCI
tance to account for the structure and branching of a molecule in a implies certain limitations. Since the calculation of the MCI is simi-
quantitative way. What it seem to be a deficiency of these indexes is lar to a group contribution method based on the mass of each group
that they do not consider de size of the groups forming the molecule and the way they connect with their neighboring groups, the def-
but only their connections with other groups. inition does not reflect other possible factors. Among these, the
A simple mass connectivity index, designated by , which con- electrostatic interaction or hydrogen-bonding effects that may be
siders both the type of connections between groups and the mass of of importance to correlate other physical properties which are more
such groups is defined in this work. The index is based on the mass dependent on these complex interactions, that are unique to ionic
of defined functional groups forming the molecules and is much liquids. Further analysis on these aspects is needed.
simpler to calculate than similar indexes proposed in the literature. In this work the mass connectivity index is used as an effective
Table 1 shows the groups considered in this method, which are the parameter to discriminate between different ILs so the substance
same used by the authors in a method to estimate critical prop- dependent parameters in the models for determining the temper-
erties and in predicting densities using artificial neural networks ature dependency of density and heat capacity on temperature are
[7,8]. defined in terms of . Since an experimental reference value of the
110 J.O. Valderrama, R.E. Rojas / Fluid Phase Equilibria 297 (2010) 107–112
Table 3
Values of mass connectivity index for some selected ionic liquids. A complete table including for 476 ionic liquids is given as a l.
properties at a reference temperature To are used (o and CPo ), the 4. Results and discussion
influence of molecular structure, represented by the connectivity
index on density and heat capacity is included in the temperature The parameters in Eqs. (9) and (10) were determined by regres-
functionality for each of the properties. For simplicity the depen- sion analysis of available experimental data obtained from the
dency on is considered to be linear for the properties studied: literature. All data were taken from the NIST Database [22]. For
density and heat capacity. Therefore, the final equations for and both the density and the heat capacity part of the data were used
CP are: for determining the model parameters and part of the data (around
10%), were used to check the predictive capabilities of the proposed
= o + a(T − To ) (9) models. For the density, 479 data points for 106 ILs were used for
determining the parameter “a” in Eq. (9) while 50 values of were
CP = C Po + [c(T − To ) + d(T 2 − To2 )] (10) predicted. For the heat capacity, 461 data points for 31 ILs were
used for determining the parameters “c” and “d” in Eq. (10) while
The constant “a” for the density and “c” and “d” for the heat capacity 65 values of CP were predicted. The final general models for the
are determined from experimental data taken from the literature. density and the heat capacity are:
Once the equation parameters are calculated the constants become
= o − 3.119 × 10−3 (T − To ) (11)
universal parameters to be used for any ionic liquid and the mass
−4 2
connectivity index is the parameter that discriminates between CP = C Po + [0.4579(T − To ) − 3.533 × 10 (T − To2 )] (12)
different ionic liquids, providing the temperature dependency of
density and heat capacity. In these equations o and CPo are the density and the heat capacity
at T0 = 298 K and is the mass connectivity index (listed in Table 3).
Table 4 summarizes the results, showing the values of the
parameters for each property and some parameters that describe
the accuracy of the proposed models, for both correlation and
prediction. It should be emphasized that the cases considered
for prediction were not used for determining the parameters
of the models. Therefore this type of calculation represents a
good test to check the predictive capabilities of the models. Not
only that but also for some ionic liquids not a single value of
the properties were used for determining the model parameters,
so the calculated temperature dependency is totally predictive
using the mass connectivity index as the parameter that identi-
fies the ionic liquid. Table 5 shows that deviations in predicting
the density for four ILs not included in determining the model
parameters ([tibmp][pTSO3], [bmim][TPES], [bmim][TMEM] and
[C10mim][bti]), are within the limits of the correlation itself.
Similar results are found for heat capacity predictions for other
four ionic liquids ([hdmapy][bti], [bmim][PF6], [emim][SO4] and
[bpy][BF4]).
Tables 6 and 7 present some statistical parameters for the val-
ues calculated by the proposed method and other approaches
reported in the literature. For density there are some general meth-
ods but less information has been published for the heat capacity.
Table 5 shows overall deviations in calculated densities using
the proposed correlation compared with predictions by COSMO-
RS, a model based on quantum chemistry calculations reported
by Palomar et al. [29], with a group contribution method pro-
Fig. 2. Randic connectivity indexes and the mass connectivity index proposed in this
work for selected substances. In the figure: Randic connectivity and 䊉 Randic posed by Jacquemin et al. [12], and with a generalized correlation
valence connectivity v . previously proposed by the authors [14]. Table 6 shows overall
J.O. Valderrama, R.E. Rojas / Fluid Phase Equilibria 297 (2010) 107–112 111
Table 4
Results for the density (Eq. (7)) and the heat capacity (Eq. (8)) using the general model including the mass connectivity index.
Table 5
Density and heat capacity deviations for ionic liquids and temperatures not considered in the calculation of the model parameters.
Density prediction
[tibmp] [pTSO3] 3.003 298–355 0.8
[bmim] [TPES] 3.381 283–348 1.2
[bmim] [TMEM] 3.229 298–333 0.7
[C10mim] [bti] 3.520 293–298 0.3
Table 6
Overall deviations in calculated densities using the proposed correlation and other methods from the literature.
This work Palomar et al. [29] Jacquemin et al. [12] Valderrama and Zarricueta [14]
Table 7
Overall deviations in calculated heat capacity using the proposed correlation and other methods from the literature.
This work Waliszewski et al. [16] Ge et al. [30] Gardas and Coutinho [9]
deviations in calculated heat capacities using the proposed corre- 1528 values correspond to just one ionic liquid [bmim][PF6]. Addi-
lation compared with predictions by group contribution methods tionally, Cadena and Maginn [31] presented calculated values of
of Waliszewski et al. [16], of Ge et al. [30], and of Gardas and heat capacity for 12 ionic liquids. The value calculated by these
Coutinho [9]. authors for [bmim][NO3] is 248 (J/mol K) while an experimental
However, care must be taken when comparing one method to values are of the order of 350 (J/mol K), as reported by Strechan et
another. For instance the values of Palomar et al. [29] for the den- al. [32].
sity were given for only five 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium type As seen in the Table 4, average absolute deviations for the den-
ionic liquids. Also, the values reported by Jacquemin et al. [12] sity are 0.3% in correlation and 0.7% in prediction. For the heat
are correlating values only and no predictions were reported. Sim- capacity, average absolute deviations are 0.8% in correlation and
ilarly for heat capacity, Waliszewski et al. [16] estimated values 0.9% in prediction. Maximum deviations are lower than 4% for the
for four ionic liquids using a group contribution method developed density and lower than 6% for the heat capacity for both correla-
for organic liquids. Ge et al. [30] determined the contributions of tion and prediction. Considering the predictive capabilities of the
17 groups using literature heat capacity data and correlated values correlations this deviations are acceptable for engineering calcula-
for 53 ionic liquids. Gardas and Coutinho [9] presented correlated tions and are below the deviations given by other methods available
values only and no predictions were reported. Furthermore, only in the literature [9–14]. All these results guarantee the robustness
imidazolium-, pyridinium-, and pyrrolidinium-based ionic liquids of the proposed models and the appropriateness of the new mass
were considered in the correlations and of the 2396 data points, connectivity index defined in this work.
112 J.O. Valderrama, R.E. Rojas / Fluid Phase Equilibria 297 (2010) 107–112