THE 2nd MOTION
This House Would ban Countries from Using Naturalized Athletes in International Tounaments.
PROS
All must be carefully considered, seeing the quality of
naturalized athletes become a liability the team coach
must perform.
Playing in foreign clubs or long-time abroad education is
not guarantee that they have a quality over the talents of
local athletes.
“that national athlete was not determined whether he
was naturalized or not, it was all defined by quality. I’m
afraid, it’s dangerous that all naturalized athletes will
easily enter the Indonesian team” Fachry Husaini said
when interviewed by INDOSPORT.
Moreover, when naturalized athletes are givena chance
to play in the international tournaments, they are unable
to present any merit.
For example, in the 2014, Alfred was insert the named
Victor Igbonefo, Sergio Van Dijk, and Raphael Maitimo in
National Team of Indonesia. The result? Completely
failed.
Source by www.kaskus.co.id and www.bola.net
Reflecting on the experience of several years ago, the
presence of naturalized atheletes has nothad a significant
impact on the performance of Indonesian sports in
international tournaments.
Besides, Budiman (ex Persija Jakarta player) argued, the
local youth potential should be more maximized.
Because, the naturalization of foreign athletes also
reflects fallen spirit of early age.
www.bolasport.com
If a naturalized athletes is played in an international
tournament, it will give a negative impact on the local
athletes. Such a disappointment that the Its country
supports naturalized athletes more than local athletes.
And the impact made other countries think that the local
athletes from that country were less qualified and
CONS
Have the quality more than local athletes.
Naturalized athletes is also foreign players who was
coming to Indonesia. They certainly have some innate
ability of their country. They came to Indonesia and
became Indonesian citizens (WNI) certainly with a ability
over than local athletes. It’s an added value for the
Indonesian Team, especially to raise the team’s level of
play.
In addition, naturalized athletes can also help
communicate between foreign coaches and players. For
example, Luis Milla has claimed to be benefited by the
presence of Ilja Spasojevic for being a translator for him in
the field.
Source by www.indosport.com
Indonesia has had a recent crisis in football’s striker sector.
The absence of good striker finally, made senior team even
U-23 use the naturalized athletes. Nevertheless, the
presence of a naturalized athletes is a complement of the
existing national team.
In addition, many naturalized athletes actually excel in
domestic competition. It became the proof of naturalized
athletes that they are Indonesian, just like any other local
athletes who has a right to defend his country.
For example, Indonesian national team started using
naturalized athletes during the AFF 2010 Cup. Back then,
Christian Gonzales went crazy with his 2 gols in the
semifinal while trying to shut down the Filipino
naturalization team. Although weakened in the final,
however Gonzales played the role of bringing the senior
team to the final AFF 2010.
Source by www.indosport.com
However, there is still a loophole in the club bringing in as
many foreign athletes as possible. The demands of high
achievers make them more inclined to build competitive
team strength. Foreign athletes in abundance are instant
solution.
weaker than naturalized athletes, because they prefer to
use naturalized athletes more. It will make the country’s
image bad in the eyes of other countries.
Source by
For example, on the 1st 2017 league stage, the clubs can
only contract the maximum of four foreign players. Where,
one of them had to come from Asia. The club can have
more slots if they can bring in foreign athletes with a
Marquee Player status. This has kept the impetus of the
work for the import-player getting narrower. Not to
mention the last 2 seasons the PSSI have left their chance
of flying the league 2 stage. The applications appear in this
2018 Presidential Cup. Therefore, the naturalized athletes
is needed to play in international tournaments because it
would have a good impact on the country in the future.
Source by www.liputan6.com