Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1 a Mesh that failed as result of corrosion; b fall of ground attributed to corroded rock support
metals. Conductivity, the ability of a solution to transport account the atmospheric pressure and water salinity and
current, is recorded in siemens per metre (S m21) in SI are reported in parts per million . Water sample tempe-
units. As the conductivity of a solution increases, in most rature was recorded in degree celsius. Typically, corrosion
cases, so does the corrosion of immersed metals. rates increase as temperatures increase.
Solubility is the quantity of an ion or gas in a solution. An appropriate interpretation of the results presented
A high oxygen concentration in water results in a high in Table 1 requires attention to the specificity of each
rate of corrosion of iron. The corrosion rate of iron mine. For example, mine 4 operates at greater depth and
increases in the presence of higher dissolved oxygen. as a result of the geothermal gradient, the ground water at
Salinity is reported as total dissolved solids (TDS) and two sampling sites is almost 20uC higher. High tempera-
quantified as parts per thousand or parts per million. In tures increase the susceptibility of a support system to
general, saline waters have a higher conductivity. The corrosion. Only mines 4 and 5 were characterised as
dissolved oxygen readings were calibrated to take into acidic environments; the rest of the mines were described
Parameter Units Site #1 Site #2 Site #3 Site #4 Site #5 Site #1 Site #2 Site #3 Site #1 Site #2
Parameter Units Site #1 Site #2 Site #3 Site #4 Site #1 Site #2 Site #3 Site #4 Site #1 Site #2
21
HCO3 mg L 44 150 NA NA 120 – NA NA NA NA
Ca mg L21 278 295 404 449 585 336 424 381 290 182
Cu mg L21 – – 154 0 – – 14 – – –
Fe mg L21 90 57 589 33 106 675 334 2170 1 0
K mg L21 6 5 17 117 8 4 7 14 12 5
Mg mg L21 56 55 591 187 154 106 380 446 46 29
Na mg L21 57 43 821 859 113 9 132 63 416 136
Zn mg L21 33 8 14 000 13 000 3 2 10 4 7 2
Cl mg L21 78 80 368 789 10 19 50 140 1450 49
NO3 mg L21 NA NA – 1696 6 519 93 – – –
SO4 mg L21 NA NA 45 757 19 029 88 NA 5128 18 053 67 84
pH 5?7 6?4 3?4 4?4 5?9 3?3 2?9 4?0 7?2 7?1
Conductivity mS 1614 1400 30 800 9650 2894 3106 5240 11 250 2743 1301
Salinity ppt 1?2 1?0 17?9 5?0 2?0 2?1 3?5 8?2 2?2 1?0
Dissolved oxygen ppm 12?8 12?3 6?5 7?4 11?8 12?9 8?0 8?8 11?2 9?3
Temperature uC 10?5 9?8 27 28?4 13?4 13?6 15?7 14?6 8?0 7?9
Table 2 Average atmospheric data at selected sites between July 2008 and January 2009
Parameter Site #3 Site #4 Site #5 Site #1 Site #2 Site #3 Site #1 Site #2 Site #3
Temperature (uC) 15?4 14?5 16?7 12?3 12?2 12?5 15?1 11?5 11?7
Relative humidity (%) 68 58 73 .85 85 .80 68 69 76
Condensation Weak Weak Dry Wet Weak Wet Splashing Dry Dry
Dust Weak No Strong No No No Yes No Yes
Gas No No Yes No No Weak Yes No Yes
Air flow (cfm) 45 000 132 500 47 000 0 42 000 0 88 000 52 000 262 000
Air quality Fresh Fresh Operation Stagnant Fresh Stagnant 70% recycled Fresh Exhaust
Mine 4 Mine 5
4 a Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) photography of a plate corrosion crust containing many different minerals par-
ticles; b SEM photography of a corrosion coupon exposed to atmospheric corrosion
Table 3 Linking onsite observations to resulting loss of capacity and required intervention
C3: surface Corrosion over 75% of the 0?04–0?15 20–35 4?00–4?50 None to
corrosion surface. Corrosionis only follow up
on surface. If a corrosion crust
is present, it is very thin. Can
identify blisters
C4: advanced 100% of the surface is corroded. 0?15–0?30 35–50 3?50–4?50 Follow up. If
corrosion Can identify blisters. Thin installed over
corrosion crust (,1 mm) is 12 months, it
easily removed will display
signs of severe
corrosion
C5: very ad- 100% of the surface is corroded. 0?30–0?60 50–75 2?50–3?50 Consider
vanced Thick corrosion crust (.1 mm) replacement
corrosion and flaky of installed units
C6: extreme Corrosion goes through the .0?50 .75 ,2?50 Reconditioning.
corrosion steel. Integrity of steel has May require
been damaged. Pieces are immediate
easily breakable by hand intervention
context, 0?1 m3 of broken rock should be retained by a constant corrosion environment, the mesh diameter will
wire mesh used with a rock bolting patent of be reduced to 4?78 mm.
1?261?2 m. The mesh is pinned using short bolts (18–
:
24 inches long, 45?72–60?96 cm). Based on the design Residual capacityð%Þ~2:8|D2 2
chart in Fig. 7, the loss in mesh capacity after 2 years of : (3)
exposure (2 years60?05 mm/year) and assuming a ~2:8|(4:78)2 2 ~87%
Reinforcement Friction bolts (split set) High Hollow bolts with low thickness steel. Decrease
Swelling bolts (Swellex) in thickness of bolt can result in large loss of
capacity. Borehole conditions susceptible to
exposure to water. Contact with rock or sulphides
Surface support Mesh High Strands of thin mesh are exposed over large areas.
Push plate Push plate thickness is thin
Reinforcement Rock bolts Medium Bolt rods are solid and have a relatively thick
Bolt nuts diameter
Eye-bolt, J-bolt
Surface support Plates Medium Plate thickness is greater
Straps
Reinforcement Reinforcement elements Medium to low Corrosion attack delayed by protection and use of
that have been treated inhibitors. In some corrosive environments,
(galvanised, Mn, etc.) galvanisation can offer long-term protection.
Thickness of bolts is important
Surface support Support elements that have Medium to low Attack delayed by protection and inhibitors. In some
been treated (galvanised, corrosive environments, galvanised support protects
Mn, etc.) for the long term. Plate thickness is an important
factor
Reinforcement Resin rebar or grout rebar Low Protection from environment (air, water). Corrosion
Grout cable localised and/or stress cracking corrosion if the resin
or cement is cracked
Surface support Support installed under Low Protection from environment (air, water). Corrosion
shotcrete localised and/or stress cracking
7 Relationship between residual capacity of strands and their diameter when screen is loaded with a 0?1 m3 of rock of
given specific density (2?5, 3?0, 3?5, 4?0)
If the mesh is exposed for 20 years conduct surveillance (monitoring) of support in place.
2:2 2:2 These charts should be used with classification charts of
2:8|D ~2:8|(4:88{(0:05 20)) ~55% (4) aqueous and atmospheric corrosion and with respect to
support susceptibility guide for assessing corrosion.
There are several tools that can be used to characterise
the corrosivity of a mining environment exposed to
Selection and design of support systems aqueous and atmospheric conditions. As the field studies
accounting for corrosion demonstrated, a number of variables can result in
There are several guidelines for the selection and design aggressive corrosive environments for rock support
of support systems. Quite often mine operators rely on systems. The use of the analytical tests in conjunction
experience, or the use of empirical and analytical tools. with the corrosivity classification can provide a design
A common limitation of most approaches is that they tool and can allow the reporting of corrosion in a
do not seem to account for the potential impact of consistent matter by those responsible for quality
corrosion on the longevity of a reinforcement or support control of rock support systems. It furthermore provides
element. Table 4, based on the in situ and laboratory a tool to monitor the evolution of support system
investigations, aims to provide a tool to alert mine corrosion support over time and allow time for prompt
operators to the susceptibility of reinforcement and intervention as required.
support elements to corrosion. It is recognised that This process does not replace the geomechanical
failure of any element can result in failure of the support design guidelines for the selection of support systems.
system. Rather it complements the selection and design process
The flowcharts in Figs. 9 and 10 provide a pathway to as it identifies the implications of using a particular
characterise the susceptibility to corrosion of diffe- reinforcement or surface support element in a corrosive
rent mining environments, and guide the planning and environment. As such it can be useful in any trade-off
9 Design methodology for corrosivity classification and selecting of reinforcement and support
study that has to account for geomechanical, corrosion, Coupons installed at different sites provided a consistent
economic and production considerations in the choice of narrative on the evolution of corrosion of support in a
a support system. range of environments. The implementation of a tensile
test programme demonstrated the direct relationship
between the tensile strength of corroded samples and the
Conclusions recorded corrosion rate, or thickness, of the component.
The corrosion of support systems has significant This has allowed the construction of a design chart to
economic and safety consequences for operating mines. quantify the impact of corrosion on the loss of capacity
A better understanding of the conditions that control of rock support. A review of onsite observations over a
the corrosion rate of support systems can be used to 5-year period and from the experimental programme has
predict how long it will take for the support capacity to allowed the preparation of a series of guidelines on the
be reduced based on the mineralogy of an orebody. This susceptibility of different support elements. This can
in turn can be used by mine operators in mine planning, provide an additional design tool to identify the
to improve strategies for choosing support. For instance, optimum support strategy for a given mining operation.
different support materials may be used depending upon
whether an area is for short- or long-term access. In
addition, it can be used to identify areas that may need
Author Note
reconditioning of support. This paper has been reproduced with the kind permission
It has been demonstrated that corrosion coupons of the Australian Centre for Geomechanics, the University
provide an excellent method to quantify the corrosion of Western Australia. The 7th International Sympo-
rate of support in an underground mining environment. sium on Ground Support in Mining and Underground
Construction Proc. Volume, 13–15 May 2013, Perth, ASTM International, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700,
West Conshohocken, PA 19428–2959, United States.
Australia. ISBN 978-0-9806154-7-0, www.acg.
ASTM G4-01 Standard Designation. 2003. Standard guide for
uwa.edu.au. conducting corrosion tests in field applications, ASTM
International, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West
Acknowledgement Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959, United States.
Charette, F. 2012. Stochastic approach to the corrosion assessment of
The authors acknowledge the continued support of the rock bolts, ROCKENG12, Proc. 21st Canadian Rock Mechanics
management and onsite personnel of the following mine Symp., May 5–9, 2012, Edmonton, CARMA, 303–310.
Charette, F., Germain, P. and Hadjigeorgiou, J. 2004. Corrosion
sites: LaRonde, Mouska, Doyon-Weswood, Niobec, behaviour of Swellex bolts in underground mining environments,
Persévérance and Géant-Dormant. The authors further Edmonton, AB, Canadian Institute of Mining, Annual General
acknowledge the technical support provided by Vicky Meeting.
Dodier, Daniel Marcotte, Geneviève Bruneau, Maude Dorion, J. F. and Hadjigeorgiou, J. 2008. Caractérisation des
Larouche, Jean Frenette and Marie-Josée Bouchard. environnements miniers menant à la corrosion des systèmes de
soutènement, Proc. Maintenance Engineering Underground Mine
Operators Conf., CIM, Val D’Or, CD-ROM only.
References Dorion, J. F., Hadjigeorgiou, J. and Ghali, E. 2009. Quantifying the
rate of corrosion in selected underground mines, Proc. Rock
ASTM E8-99 Standard Designation. 1999. Standard test methods to Eng09, May 9–14, 2009, Toronto, ON, CARMA.
tension testing of metallic materials, ASTM International, 100 Dorion, J. F., Hadjigeorgiou, J. and Ghali, E. 2010. Influence of
Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West Conshohocken, PA corrosion rate on the capacity of rock support, ARMA 10–259,
19428–2959, United States. American Rock Mechanics Association, Proc. 44th US Rock
ASTM G1-03 Standard Designation. 2001. Standard practice for Mechanics Symp. and 5th U.S.-Canada Rock Mechanics Symp.,
preparing, cleaning, and evaluating corrosion test specimens, June 27–30, 2010, Salt Lake City, UT.
Hadjigeorgiou, J., Dorion, J. F. and Ghali, E. 2008. Support system in mining, (eds. E. Villaescusa, C. R. Windsor and A. G.
performance under different corrosion conditions, J. South. Afr. Thompson), 69–75, Rotterdam, A.A. Balkema.
Inst. Min. Metall., 108, 359–365. Robinson, J. and Tyler, D. B. 1999. A study of corrosion in
Hadjigeorgiou, J., Ghali, E., Charette, F. and Krishnadev, M. R. 2002. underground reinforcement at Mount Isa Mines, corrosion
Fracture analysis of friction rock bolts, Proc. 5th North American classification of the underground environment, Rock Support
Rock Mechanics Symp. and the 17th Tunnelling Association of and Reinforcement Practice in Mining, (eds. E. Villaescusa, C. R.
Canada, Conf.: NARMS-TAC, 7–10 July 2002, University of Windsor and A. G. Thompson), Rotterdam, A.A. Balkema, 77–
Toronto Press, 881–887. 82.
Hassell, R., Villaescusa, E., Thompson, A. G. and Kinsella, B. 2004. Villaescusa, E., Hassell, R. and Thompson, A. G. 2008. Development
Corrosion assessment of ground support systems, Proc. 5th Int. of a corrosivity classification for cement grouted cable strand in
Symp. on ‘Ground support, ground support in mining and underground hard-rock mining excavations, J. South. Afr. Inst.
underground construction’, (eds. E. Villaescusa and Y. Potvin), Min. Metall., 108, 301–308.
September 28–30, 2004, Perth, WA, Australia, Rotterdam, A.A. Villaescusa, E. 2004. Weld mesh for static rock support in Australia, in
Balkema, 529–542. Surface support in mining, (eds. Y. Potvin, T. R. Stacey and J.
Li, C. and Lindblad, K. 1999. Corrosion classification of the under- Hadjigeorgiou), 385–389, Perth, WA, Australian Centre for
ground environment, in Rock support and reinforcement practice Geomechanics.