AHLUSSUNNAH WAL JAMA:’AH

TAQDI:R AND MIRZA

JHELUMI
REFUTING ALI MIRZA
ABTALAT ZAHRAH NAQVI
10-Sep-19

Refuting the heretic concepts of Mirza Jhelumi about Taqdi:r

 Page 1 of 3

Mirza Jhelumi: and Taqdi:r.

Mirza: Jhelumi: does follow the Mu’tazilite View of Taqdi:r.

He has delivered some lectures on the topic, mixing truth with falsehood. So it is required to discuss the
topic in some detail.

Preliminary 1

Every thing from the beginning of the World to the Qiamah is written in the Conserved Tablet.

Page 1 of 3
 Page 2 of 3

So what ever a Rational Suppositum does is written on a tablet written by the Divine Will just after
the beginning of the Creation.

It is impossible for a Person to do any thing against the heavenly Written Tablet.

Preliminary 2

What G-d wrote on the Tablet is a portion of Divine Omniscience.

So it is Impossible for any one to violate practically from the Divine Omniscience.

Preliminary 3

Human Will, and all human Voluntary acts are Created by G-d.

Some believed that G-d Created immediately the first Creatures , and these First Creatures Created the
Secondary Creatures, these Secondary Creatures were not Created by G-d.

Based on this Mu’tazilites claimed that G-d Createth the Human Beings, and Human Beings Creates
there respective voluntary acts, and these acts are not Created by G-d.( This is what Mirza: Jhelumi
believes in).)

Some went further by proposing that G-d Created the First Human Beings and Secondary Human Beings
were neither Created by G-d nor by First Human Beings but were produced by the Process of
Reproduction and Generation, How ever all the human beings Create their own acts and G-d is nether
in contact nor in connection with their voluntary acts.

Preliminary 4

They do believe that Human and Jinn Voluntary acts are neither by immediate Divine Will nor by Direct
Divine Will. Similarly they are neither by Direct Omnipotence not by immediate Omnipotence.

They have nothing to do with the Divine TACVI:N.

The only thing is that G-d granted Human , Jinn and Angel Beings some Power , but after granting power,
they are not in Divine Power any more. What a Human or a Jinn Being does, is independent from the
Divine Will and Divine Omnipotence.

Conclusion

This clearly proves that Mirza: Jhelumi: has a very heretic belief in regard to Qad:a: Va Qadr, and Qadr
Va Jabr.

In such a case he is a heretic and a Qadri: , even if he denies to be. This is very important and one shall
not be misguided by this person . The Person from Jhelum.

Man From Jhelum is a Heretic and a Qadri , even if he denies to be a Qadri, more than a Billion times.

Page 2 of 3
 Page 3 of 3

Pure Sunni Belief

All the Acts of all beings are created by G-d. How ever Voluntary acts of Rational Supposita say humans,
Jinns , and in some cases of Angels, their agents [‘Al Fa:’:il] are their respective beings, but Creator is G-
d without any change of meaning howsoever small. Similarly a person cannot do an act and cannot will
an act without the divine Will. That is for each and every Voluntary Act of a Human or a Jinn or An Angel
Being there is Divine Will, which choses that particular act for the person, and then the Human or Jinn or
Angel will is connected to it.

Although there are some rational objections to this belief , and it is likely that the person from Jhelum
may use them, but they are all incorrect, and true beliefs cannot be rejected due to some rational
objections raised on it.

Disclaimer

The author is not responsible for any distortion of meaning due to errors in typing.

The Tradition of la Jabr Va La Qadr Ascribed to Saiyiduna: ‘:Ali: RD: Shall be discussed separately.

Page 3 of 3