Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
DOI 10.1007/s11249-017-0940-7
ORIGINAL PAPER
Abstract Engineering components can be subjected to fretting with intermittent opening of contact is similar to
normal and/or rotational fretting wear with contacts that are that of fretting with diamond-like abrasives at the contact.
intermittently exposed to the atmosphere. Exposure to the
environment may lead to the alteration at the contact due Keywords Accelerated fretting tests · Diamond-like
to the changing role of third body particles such as hard abrasives · Fretting wear simulations/modeling
oxides which can result in abrasion. The abrasion due to
hard oxide particles differs for the closed contact and inter-
mittently opened contact. In the former scenario, the oxides 1 Introduction
are compacted into tribo-film, while in the latter case they
remain loose, leading to bigger role of abrasion. Standard Fretting wear is one of the major failure modes of the com-
fretting test setup employed to estimate the fretting wear ponents used in turbo machinery. Components of gas tur-
characteristic operates with a constant load such that the bine combustor like liner stop, swirler collar, fuel burner,
contact remains closed between the counter surfaces and aft support, aft bracket, forward bracket and hula seal are
does not simulate the opening and closing of the contacts as subjected to fretting phenomenon induced by structural
observed in certain applications. The forceful interruptions vibration during the turbine operation. Some of these parts
to the experiments to simulate open and close condition of experience intermittent opening of the contact exposing the
the contact require considerable amount of time and effort. worn surfaces to open air atmosphere that support formation
In this paper, an accelerated test procedure is proposed and of hard oxide debris. To determine wear behavior of these
investigated to capture the effect of intermittent opening of engineering components, many a time coupon-level fretting
the contact without stopping the experiments. A test rig is wear tests are performed in the research laboratories. These
designed to simulate the opening and closing conditions, and fretting tests are performed without opening the contact and
tests were performed with abrasive diamond-like particles. would result in incorrect estimate of wear rates as the worn
Friction and wear results are compared with those of inter- surface is never exposed to open air especially when the slip
mittently contact opening conditions along with operating amplitude is less than length of the contact along fretting
wear mechanisms. Scanning electron microscope analysis direction. Building a test setup that can open the contact
showed that the wear mechanism observed in the case of after few fretting cycles is expensive and also increases the
testing time for the fretting experiments. An accelerated test
procedure is investigated in this paper, to capture the effect
* Vamshidhar Done
of intermittent opening of the contact without stopping the
vamshidhar.done@insa‑lyon.fr
experiments. A test rig was designed to simulate the open-
1
GE Global Research, John F Welch Technology Centre, ing and closing conditions, and tests were performed with
Whitefield Road, Bangalore, India abrasive (diamond-like) particles. The wear volume and
2
GE Power Gas Power Systems, Greenville, SC, USA wear depth results are compared with those of intermittently
3
LaMCoS, CNRS UMR5259, INSA‑Lyon, Univ Lyon, contact opening.
Lyon 69621, France
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
153 Page 2 of 9 Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153
Iwabuchi [1] studied the role of oxide debris during fret- stress relaxation and intermetallic compound formation
ting by artificially supplying oxide particles between two occurring under accelerated test conditions. Using these
contacting surfaces before fretting. It was found that the algorithms and fretting model, test exposures of tin-plated
action of the oxide to facilitate or to prevent wear depends copper base alloy contacts were compared to typical field
on the experimental conditions. Wear is less, if a compact conditions. Increased z-height as to create constant force
layer of oxide particles is formed at the contact interface contact was proposed by Kiely et al. [11] for accelerated
due to high load. Removal of debris particles increases with wear testing procedure for head–disc interfaces. Wear rate
increase in slip amplitude, and the abrasive action of the for various combinations of head–media combination was
particles increases the wear rate. The effect of large debris established using the accelerated wear test procedure. An
particles on friction coefficient was studied by Suh and Sin accelerated nano-fretting test technique was developed by
[2] and was observed that the larger debris particles lead to Beake et al. [12] to study small-scale wear of Si(1 0 0).
higher friction coefficient. Similar observations of increased Application of abrupt load showed similar crack morphology
friction in the presence of hard debris particles were reported to that observed in repetitive nano-impact tests. Okamoto
by Sherrington and Hayhurst [3]. Saber et al. [4] studied the et al. [13] have showed that cross-grooved surface textur-
cyclic oxidation behavior of Ni-based superalloy (Inconel ing is very effective to achieve accelerated initial running-
617) in air at various temperatures. They performed many in during fretting wear. High contact pressure with small
oxidation tests and microstructural analyses to conclude contact areas of cross-grooved textured surfaces promotes
that the thickness of oxide scales increased with time and contact deformation leading to acceleration of the initial
temperature. The oxide scales are compact, dense, adher- running-in process. Trezona et al. [14] conducted abrasive
ent and distributed uniformly across the surface. Xin et al. wear tests using particles of SiC, A
l2O3 and diamond; the
[5] have characterized the subsurface layers underneath the authors observed that the wear rate changes with change
worn surface of Inconel 690 alloy which is subjected to dry in concentration of abrasive particles in the slurry. It was
fretting at 220 °C. Their results indicate five layers: oxide documented by the authors that the wear mechanisms seen
layer, mixed layer, tribological transformed structure (TTS) with the concentrated diamond slurries are two-body paral-
layer, plastic deformation layer and base materials. They lel grooving, whereas the mechanism seen with SiC slurries
observed that oxygen easily penetrated TTS and preferen- is three-body wear by rolling particles. Kassman et al. [15]
tially oxidized Cr and Ni to produce Cr2O3 and NiO. Due and Staia [16] have used diamond particles to perform wear
to sufficient oxidation on worn surface, stable oxide layer of tests and develop abrasive wear resistance coatings. The
NiCr2O4 and Fe2O3 was formed. Soria et al. [6] performed proposed test procedure in this article uses diamond-like
fretting experiments on Incoloy 800 against AISI 304 for particle to perform accelerated wear tests under cylinder-
displacement amplitudes of 70, 116 and 160 µm at room on-flat conditions.
temperature. They observed adhesive and abrasive wear due
to the formation of hard oxides between the surfaces during
fretting process. The composition of debris was found to 2 Accelerated Fretting Wear Test Procedure
contain (Ni, Fe)(Fe,Cr)2O4. Jin et al. [7] studied the role
of wear scar geometry and oxide-based debris beds on the To perform fretting wear tests that capture the phenomenon
temperature of a fretting contact. Debris layer was found to observed in gas turbine components, the contact at the two
increase temperature of the contact locally if the thermal rubbing surfaces needs to be separated after few fretting
conductivity of the layer is significantly lower than that of cycles and the contact needs to be exposed to atmosphere.
the base material. Jin et al. [8] also studied the role of envi- The required test setup becomes complex if it includes both
ronmental temperature and fretting frequency on wear rate. sliding motion and opening the contact at regular intervals.
At low temperatures, continual oxide formation and egress Also, the time taken to execute opening the contact while
from the contact take place, whereas at high temperatures, performing fretting experiments is very large. A new test
wear rate is less due to protective bed formed by oxide. procedure is proposed in which the contact is not separated,
Technique of ultrasonic fretting was used by Soderberg and as a substitute of opening the contact, diamond parti-
et al. [9] to accelerate fretting wear testing. It was observed cle-like abrasive is introduced at the contact. The abrasive
that ultrasonic fretting displays many characteristics of low- particles (3–5 µm) perform the role of hard metallic oxide
frequency fretting. But the ultrasonic fretting has increased that is formed at the contact when the surface is exposed to
severity of the initial adhesive stage at ultrasonic frequencies atmosphere after the fretting. The direction of fretting in the
and has higher wear rate compared to low-frequency fretting. test facility is aligned to vertical direction so that the debris
Use of elevated dry temperature testing was proposed by gets dropped down due to gravitational force. Also, smaller
Malucci et al. [10] to accelerate fretting degradation. Algo- radius is used for the specimen while performing the fretting
rithms were developed to simulate the levels of oxidation, experiments so that the debris is not entrapped at the contact.
13
Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153 Page 3 of 9 153
13
153 Page 4 of 9 Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153
100,000 cycles, a semi-analytical wear simulation of fret- • Wear law = Fouvry’s Law (Fouvry et al. [22])
ting wear is proposed. These numerical simulations use the • Time steps for each cycle = 81
wear and friction coefficients to predict the wear profiles • Maximum number of wear cycles for simulation: 200,000
of the two contacting surfaces. The wear methodology was • Operating temperature = room temperature
successfully implemented and validated in the earlier paper
by the authors Kesavan et al. [17]. The methodology was
derived from previous research presented by Gallego et al. 3 Results and Discussion
[18–20], contact solver published by Antaluca and Nélias
[21] and wear law proposed by Fouvry et al. [22]. The model 3.1 Results from Fretting Wear Experiments
was later extended to include debris entrapped at the contact
interface and published by authors Done et al. [23]. The Fretting experiments were performed on cylinder and flat
approach involves discretization of contact area to obtain a specimens under three types of test conditions listed in the
rectangular node set; contact pressure is obtained by apply- previous section. The results obtained from these tests were
ing conjugate gradient method. To improve the speed of compared with each other to check the effectiveness of accel-
calculations, fast Fourier transformations are applied. Wear erated wear test procedure. Optical non-contact profilometer
law is used to relate the frictional dissipated energy, fretting was used to capture images of wear scars on flat specimens
displacement and wear coefficient with the wear volume. after 100,000 fretting cycles. The wear scars obtained from
The wear volume is then used to compute wear depth at each three test conditions are presented in Fig. 2. The material
grid point on both the contact surfaces. loss observed in these experiments is shown in Fig. 3.
For numerical simulations, the geometry of test speci- Wear observed was low in the case of normal fretting
mens is replicated. A cylinder of 20 mm and 3 mm of length when the contact is not opened till the end of 100,000 cycles.
is considered fretting on a flat surface. Elastic modulus of Higher wear was observed in the case of opening the contact
219 GPa is used for Nimonic-80A material at room tempera- and in the case when diamond particle paste is introduced at
ture for both cylinder and flat surface.
Values of the parameters considered in the simulation are
presented below:
Fig. 2 Wear scar images for a fretting without opening contact b fretting with opening contact and c fretting with diamond particle paste
13
Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153 Page 5 of 9 153
the contact. This observation is in line with wear phenom- Diamond particle paste is added at the start of experiment,
enon noticed by Iwabuchi [1] that the hard particles at the and the experiment is run without opening the contact.
contact interface increase the abrasive wear rate. In normal Application of diamond particle paste is not repeated. The
fretting, when the contact is not opened, surface is less oxi- low friction coefficient in the initial few cycles observed
dized due to lesser contact exposure to air leading to lesser for case of diamond particle test in Fig. 4 may be attributed
formation of hard particles and results in low wear. Friction to the solvent, and later the diamond particles start playing
value is stabilized well before 10,000 cycles and continuous role of abrasive. The diamond paste is added to accelerate
same till 100,000 cycles. fretting test and to avoid costly opening and cleaning of the
Identical and high wear was observed in other two cases, surface.
one with regular opening of the contact and one in which
diamond particle paste is introduced at the contact without 3.2 Study of Wear Mechanisms Using Scanning
opening the contact. Due to temperature raise (frictional Electron Microscope
heat) at the contact surface and exposure to atmosphere,
metallic oxide is formed when contact is intermittently To determine the wear mechanisms under different contact
opened. The metallic oxide has high hardness which is conditions, samples from each test case are analyzed using
comparable with hardness of diamond particles and shows scanning electron microscope (SEM). Scan images are pre-
similar wear behavior. At room temperature, the hardness of sented in Figs. 5, 6 and 7. Low-resolution images presented
metallic oxide debris formed from Nimonic-80A is close to in these figures and Fig. 2 show that the surface generated
4 GPa as per the study performed by Inman and Datta [24]. after normal fretting (contact closed condition throughout
For the abrasive particles introduced in our experimental the experiment) is more uniform compared to that of inter-
study, the hardness is close to 10 GPa (Prelas et al. [25]. mittent contact opening case and contact with diamond par-
The test setup used to perform the fretting experiments ticle at the interface.
has a load cell that can measure the frictional force at the As seen in Fig. 5, the size of wear debris in normal con-
contact when load in the direction normal to contact is tact is small and looks granular. The worn surface generated
applied. The frictional force was recorded for every 10,000 after fretting is uniform leading to low friction and low wear
fretting cycles, and the coefficient of friction is calculated. as presented in Figs. 3 and 4. Because size of debris is small,
Figure 4 shows the variation of friction for three test cases a constant wear rate can be expected in this continuously
from 100th cycle to 100,000th cycle. Coefficient of friction closed contact fretting. For the case of fretting with inter-
(COF) for normal fretting settles down to a lower value of mittent opening of contact, Fig. 6 shows long debris formed
0.36. For both the cases of fretting, i.e., with contact opening due to subsurface crack propagation parallel to contact sur-
and with diamond particle paste, the COF reaches a higher face. Formation of flake-like debris can be explained using
value close to 0.7. This observation is in line with the simi- delamination theory proposed by Suh [26]. Because of large
larity observed in the loss of material between the last two chunks of material coming out of contact surface, the result-
cases. Increase in friction coefficient due to presence of hard ant surface is rough and wear rate is non-uniform. Suh and
debris particles was also reported by Suh and Sin [2] and
Sherrington and Hayhurst [3].
The diamond particle used in the experiments is MetaDi
paste manufactured by Buehler. The composition of paste
is diproplylene glycol (70–80%) and diamond (20–30%).
Fig. 4 Change in friction coefficient with progression of fretting Fig. 5 High-resolution SEM image of worn sample with normal fret-
cycles ting
13
153 Page 6 of 9 Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153
13
Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153 Page 7 of 9 153
Fig. 8 a Location at which chemical characterization is performed. b Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy results of base material
Fig. 9 a Location at which chemical characterization is performed. b Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy results of debris material
13
153 Page 8 of 9 Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153
4 Conclusion
References
13
Tribol Lett (2017) 65:153 Page 9 of 9 153
11. Kiely, J., Peng, W., Hsia, Y.-T.: Accelerated wear testing of head- 20. Gallego, L., Fulleringer, B., Deyber, S., Nelias, D.: Multiscale
disc interfaces. Tribol. Int. 38, 652–656 (2005) computation of fretting wear at the blade/disk interface. Tribol.
12. Beake, B.D., Liskiewicz, T.W., Pickford, N.J., Smith, J.F.: Accel- Int. 43, 708–718 (2010)
erated nano-fretting testing of Si(1 0 0). Tribol. Int. 46, 114–118 21. Antaluca, E., Nélias, D.: Contact fatigue analysis of a dented sur-
(2012) face in a dry elastic–plastic circular point contact. Tribol. Lett. 29,
13. Okamoto, M., Jibiki, T., Ito, S., Motoda, T.: Role of cross-grooved 139–153 (2008)
type texturing in acceleration of initial running-in under lubricated 22. Fouvry, S., Kapsa, P., Vincent, L.: Quantification of fretting dam-
fretting. Tribol. Int. 100, 126–131 (2016) age. Wear 200, 186–205 (1996)
14. Trezona, R.I., Allsopp, D.N., Hutchings, I.M.: Transitions 23. Done, V., Kesavan, D., Krishna, R.M., Chaise, T., Nelias, D.: Semi
between two-body and three-body abrasive wear: influence of test analytical fretting wear simulation including wear debris. Tribol.
conditions in the microscale abrasive wear test. Wear 229–229, Int. 109, 1–9 (2017)
205–214 (1999) 24. Inman, I.A., Datta, P.S.: Studies of high temperature sliding wear
15. Kassman, A., Jacobson, S., Erickson, L., Hedenqvist, P., Olsson, of metallic dissimilar interfaces IV: nimonic 80A versus Incoloy
M.: A new test method for the intrinsic abrasion resistance of thin 800HT. Tribol. Int. 44, 1902–1919 (2011)
coatings. Surf. Coat. Technol. 50, 75–84 (1991) 25. Prelas, M.A., Popovici, G., Bigelow, L.K.: Handbook of Industrial
16. Staia, M.H., Enriquez, C., Puchi, E.S.: Influence of the heat treat- Diamonds and Diamond Films, pp. 59–78. Marcel Dekker INC,
ment on the abrasive wear resistance of electroless Ni–P. Surf. New York (1998)
Coat. Technol. 94–95, 543–548 (1997) 26. Suh, N.P.: The delamination theory of wear. Wear 25, 111–124
17. Kesavan, D., Done, V., Sridhar, M.R., Billig, R., Nélias, D.: High (1973)
temperature fretting wear prediction of exhaust valve material. 27. Fouvry, S., Arnaud, P., Mignot, A., Neubauer, P.: Contact size,
Tribol. Int. 100, 280–286 (2016) frequency and cyclic normal force effects on Ti–6Al–4 V fretting
18. Gallego, L., Nélias, D., Jacq, C.: A comprehensive method to pre- wear processes: an approach combining friction power and contact
dict wear and to define the optimum geometry of fretting surfaces. oxygenation. Tribol. Int. 113, 460–473 (2017)
J. Tribol. 128(3), 476–485 (2006) 28. Kato, H., Komai, K.: Tribofilm formation and mild wear by tribo-
19. Gallego, L., Nélias, D.: A modeling of fretting wear under gross sintering of nanometer-sized oxide particles on rubbing steel sur-
slip and partial slip conditions. J. Tribol. 129(3), 528–535 (2007) faces. Wear 262, 1–2 (2007)
13