Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
FIGURE 1. A and B, The preoperative posture of an adolescent with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy who had not undergone any
earlier surgery is shown. The extreme degree of crouch is evident. He can barely walk 15 m.
the help of a goniometer. The power of the quadriceps Lateral radiographs of the knee were taken with
was assessed by manual muscle testing and also with the the hip and knee flexed to 30 degrees and the position of
help of a hand-held dynamometer (Chatillon DMG 250, the patella was measured by the Insall-Salvati Index.6 The
Jamar) by the make and break tests. The “make” test was Physiological Cost Index (PCI) was estimated after the
carried out with the child sitting with the legs hanging child walked 50 m at a self-determined speed as described
over the edge of a couch. The dynamometer was held with by Raja et al.7 The ambulatory capacity of the child was
the force pad in contact with the shin 2 cm above the rated on the Functional Mobility Scale for 5, 50, and
ankle joint, and the child was asked to actively extend the 500 m (FMS-5, FMS-50, FMS-500)8 and with the Hoffer
knee with as much force as possible. The force of knee et al’ grading.9 All these variables were measured again at
extension was read off from the dynamometer. The strength the end of 2 years after the last surgery.
of the quadriceps was then estimated by the “break” test. Ten children were treated between April 2002 and
The child was asked to actively hold the knee in as much May 2005, and 7 children were treated after May 2005.
extension as possible and the force pad of the dynamometer Children treated before 2005 did not have preoperative
was held against the shin, 2 cm above the ankle. The dynamometric measurements of the power of the quad-
examiner exerted force on the tibia and the reading from the riceps and PCI estimation. The objective preoperative
dynamometer was recorded as soon as the knee began to assessments of children treated after 2005 and follow-up
flex. The degree of spasticity of the hamstrings was assessed assessments of all the children were done by the same
by the modified Ashworth Scale.5 The gait pattern was investigator.
documented by direct visual observation, still photographs, The assessment of postoperative improvement of
and video recording. gait was based on subjective clinical impression of the
Patellar
tendon Patella Central slip
split into pulled pulled up &
three & the distally sutured to
lateral slips patella
detached
from tibial
attachment
(central slip Lateral slips
left intact) Flaps of pulled down
periosteum & buried under
raised periosteal flaps
FIGURE 3. Line figure showing the technique of patellar tendon advancement in skeletally mature adolescents with patella alta
and crouch gait.
fusion on that limb after the knee had been operated on improved dramatically with substantial reduction of the
(Figs. 4A, B). The patients underwent supervised physio- crouch posture (Figs. 5A, B). Flexion deformity of the
therapy and gait training for 2 weeks after cast removal. knee, the popliteal angle, and the modified popliteal angle
Thereafter they were instructed to continue quadriceps decreased significantly. The range of knee movement and
strengthening and hamstring stretching exercises at home. the Insall-Salvati Index increased significantly from the
preoperative status to final follow-up (Table 1). The
power of the quadriceps improved in every instance and
RESULTS the extensor lag reduced (Fig. 6). There was no significant
The reproducibility of measurement of all the reduction in the spasticity of the hamstrings measured on
variables assessed in these patients was good with no the Ashworth Scale. The FMS-5, FMS-50, and FMS-500
variable showing significant difference between 2 repeated scores improved from 3, 1, and 1, respectively to 5, 3, and
measurements. In all the 17 children, the gait pattern 3, respectively. Three household ambulators remained as
FIGURE 4. A and B, The preoperative appearances of the lower limbs of an adolescent with cerebral palsy are shown (A). Apart
from severe crouch there is an equinovarus deformity of the left foot. The foot deformity was treated with a triple arthrodesis. This
patient used an ankle-foot orthosis on the left foot postoperatively (B). The excellent alignment of the knees is also evident.
FIGURE 5. A and B, The posture of the adolescent, shown in Figure 1, 4 months after surgery is markedly improved. He stands
and walks without crouch; excessive lumbar lordosis is not present and he has become a community ambulator. Four years later
he continues to be a community ambulator.
TABLE 1. Preoperative and Final Follow-up Values of Variables Measured in 17 Children With Crouch Gait
Preoperative At Final Follow-up
Variable Median IQR (Range) Median IQR (Range) P
Flexion deformity of the knee (degrees) 22 20, 34 (12-40) 2 0, 7.5 (0-12) <0.05
Popliteal angle (degrees) 61 53, 75 (50-78) 31 20, 40 (28-46) <0.05
Modified popliteal angle (degrees) 52 40, 61.5 (30-70) 20 16.5, 23.5 (12-28) <0.05
Quadriceps power (manual muscle testing-MRC grade) 3 3, 3 (2-4) 4 4, 4 (3-4) <0.05
Quadriceps power (kg) dynamometric “make” test* 6.2 4.5, 6.8 (4.5-7.9) 10.77 9.1, 11.3 (4.5-13.6) <0.05
Quadriceps power (kg) dynamometric “break” test* 2.3 2.3, 3.4 (2.3-4.5) 4.5 4.5, 5.3 (2.3-6.8) <0.05
Range of motion of the knee (degrees) 118 110, 121 (106-136) 136 130, 140 (128-142) <0.05
Insall-Salvati Index (ratio) 0.7 0.7, 0.8 (0.7-0.8) 1.45 1.02, 1.7 (1-1.9) <0.05
IQR indicates interquartile ranges.
*These measurements were made only on 7 children treated after 2005.
FIGURE 7. A and B, Before surgery, patella alta, fracture-separation of the patella, and fragmentation of the tibial tuberosity are
seen (A). After surgery, the patella alta has been corrected and the fracture of the patella and the fragmentation of the tibial
tuberosity have healed spontaneously (B).
Correction of Flexion Deformity of the Knee is removed as the tendon is transferred to the back of the
In these children with severe long-standing crouch, femur. A similar approach has been reported by
it is unlikely that complete correction of the flexion Uyttendaele et al.16 We opted to anchor the transferred
deformity would have been achieved by mere release of tendon to the medial side of the distal femur rather than
the hamstrings. In the past, we have combined release of the lateral side as advocated by Sutherland et al17 who
the hamstrings with a supracondylar extension osteotomy were attempting to deal with internal rotation gait. The
recommended by some researchers.10,11 We refrained fact that very mild recurvatum was noted in just 2
from attempting correction of the deformity in this patients suggests that the hamstrings have not been
manner in these children because on an earlier occasion, weakened so much as to create imbalance in the opposite
permanent injury to the common peroneal nerve has direction as with the classical Egger transfer.18
occurred. This worrisome complication has been well
documented in the literature,12 and may well be more Augmenting the Power of the Knee and Hip
frequent than recognized.13 Rodda et al4 noted 2 Extension
instances of paresthesia in the distribution of the common
Unless the quadriceps muscle is strong enough to
peroneal nerve in patients with flexion deformities of 22
act against the gravity, the child will continue to crouch
and 28 degrees, respectively among the 10 patients that
even if the deformity is fully corrected and the hamstrings
they reported. It is pertinent to note that several of our
have been weakened. Plication of the patellar tendon
patients had deformities in this range (Table 1). We opted
effectively corrected the patella alta and this clearly
to shorten the femur to avoid stretching of the sciatic
resulted in evident improvement in the strength of the
nerve. In all our patients, complete correction of the
quadriceps muscle very early in the rehabilitation period.
flexion deformity was achieved during surgery. The same
The technique of patellar tendon plication that we
surgical approach was adopted for all degrees of fixed
describe is easy to perform and does not require any
flexion deformity, although the amount of shortening
anchorage of the patella with sutures or wires14 or internal
required was greater with increasing severity of deformity fixation of the tibial tubercle after advancement.19,20 The
and some tilt of the distal fragment into extension was
method of burying the strips of the patellar tendon under
required in the 2 most severe cases.
the periosteum of the tibia is almost identical to that
Another interesting outcome of femoral shortening
described recently by Novacheck et al.14 The risk of loss of
noted in the study was an actual increase in the range of
continuity of the quadriceps, if the anchorage fails, is
motion of the knee from a median value of 118 to 136
avoided by leaving the central third of the tendon attached
degrees (Table 1). A supracondylar extension osteotomy
to the tibial tuberosity and the patella.
would have altered the arc of motion with an increase in
In most of the children, the patella seemed to have
knee extension equal to the angle of the wedge removed
been brought down excessively as the postoperative values
but there would have been a concomitant reduction in
of the Insall-Salvati Index were above normal. This was
knee flexion. A loss of knee flexion can be disabling in partly because often the patella itself became more
communities such as ours in which squatting and sitting
elongated as the fracture-separation healed (Figs. 4A, B),
on the floor is a way of life.
thereby influencing the patella to patellar tendon length
It has been suggested that in long-standing crouch,
ratio. None of the patients complained of anterior knee
contracture of the posterior capsule of the knee may also
pain at final follow-up.
occur.14,15 However, as shortening of the femur in the
The transferred semitendinous may help in pulling
supracondylar region corrected the flexion deformity
the femur backwards, and thus provide additional hip
without having to tilt the distal fragment into extension
extensor power during the stance phase, although we have
in all but 2 patients, it suggests that in the majority of
no proof that this does occur, as we did not measure hip
instances capsular contracture is not present. Even if mild
extensor power before and after surgery. Even if the
residual deformity because of capsular contracture
transferred tendon does not actively facilitate the hip and
persisted after surgery as described here, it could probably
knee extension we hope that it may at least act as a
be corrected safely by serial casting without risk of stretch
tenodesis.
on the nerve that has been rendered lax by the femoral
shortening.
Effectiveness of the Treatment Approach
Weakening the Hamstrings Our approach to dealing with severe crouch in
As one of the primary causes of crouch is spastic cerebral palsy differs from that reported by other
overactivity of the hamstring muscles it is imperative that surgeons. Beals15 advocated a combination of hamstring
they are sufficiently weakened to correct the muscle lengthening, posterior capsulotomy of the knee, and
imbalance and also to reduce the risk of recurrence. We patellar tendon advancement, whereas Stout et al,10 and
believe that a combination of femoral shortening and Novacheck et al14 recommended distal femoral extension
aponeurotic lengthening of the semimembranous and the osteotomy combined with patellar tendon advancement.
biceps femoris will sufficiently weaken these muscles by Rodda et al4 reported a combination of distal femoral
reducing the resting length of the muscle fibers. In extension osteotomy, hamstring release, and postopera-
addition, the knee flexor function of the semitendinous tive bracing with a rear-entry floor reaction orthosis.
We opted to shorten the femur to correct the In the absence of gait analysis it is difficult to
disparity in length between the contracted hamstrings and determine conclusively if any of our patients have
the skeleton, and thereby correcting the flexion deformity. developed anterior pelvic tilt, an undesirable outcome of
It may be argued that an extension osteotomy is a more excessive weakening of the hamstrings, and consequently
appropriate approach but our results, which have the hip extensors.
remained good even in the children whom we have
followed to 6 years, show that shortening the femur is an REFERENCES
acceptable option. We believe that femoral shortening is 1. Arnold AS, Liu MQ, Schwartz MH, et al. The role of estimating
the preferred option in children with major flexion muscle-tendon lengths and velocities of the hamstrings in the
evaluation and treatment of crouch gait. Gait Posture. 2006;23-3:
deformity as it effectively reduces that risk of nerve 273–281.
damage. 2. Arnold AS, Anderson FC, Pandy MG, et al. Muscular contributions
We are unaware of any published report of the to hip and knee extension during the single limb stance phase of
combination of femoral shortening, patellar tendon normal gait: a framework for investigating the causes of crouch gait.
J Biomech. 2005;38-11:2181–2189.
advancement, hamstring release and transfer for the 3. Lotman DB. Knee flexion deformity and patella alta in spastic
treatment of severe crouch gait in cerebral palsy. cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1976;18-3:315–319.
However, a similar approach has been alluded to in the 4. Rodda JM, Graham HK, Nattrass GR, et al. Correction of severe
review of Aiona and Sussman13 and in the presentation of crouch gait in patients with spastic diplegia with use of multilevel
Selber et al.21 orthopaedic surgery. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2006;88-12:2653–2664.
5. Bohannon RW, Smith MB. Interrater reliability of a modified
Some of the published studies report improvement Ashworth scale of muscle spasticity. Phys Ther. 1987;67:206–207.
in the status of the patients on the basis of instrumented 6. Insall J, Salvati E. Patella position in the normal knee joint.
gait analysis, which we did not have access to. As the Radiology. 1971;10:101–104.
outcome variables in these studies differ from those used 7. Raja K, Joseph B, Benjamin S, et al. Physiological cost index in
cerebral palsy: its role in evaluating the efficiency of ambulation.
in this study, it is difficult to compare our results with J Pediatr Orthop. 2007;27:130–136.
these earlier reports. However, our clinical evaluation 8. Graham HK, Harvey A, Rodda J, et al. The Functional Mobility
data suggest that the results in our patients have been Scale (FMS). J Pediatr Orthop. 2004;24:514–520.
quite satisfactory; the deformity was corrected, knee 9. Hoffer MM, Feiwell E, Perry R, et al. Functional ambulation in
extensor power improved, the range of motion increased, patients with myelomeningocele. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1973;55:
137–148.
and the patients walked more. In addition, none of our 10. Stout J, Gage JR, Novacheck TF, et al. Distal femoral extension
patients required postoperative bracing to maintain knee osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement for treatment of
extension, which we believe is a distinct advantage. persistent crouch gait in individuals with cerebral palsy. Dev Med
Finally, we immobilized the limbs in plaster for 3 Child Neurol. 2004;46(suppl 99):14.
11. Zimmerman MH, Smith CF, Oppenheim WL. Supracondylar
months because we did not use any additional method of femoral extension osteotomies in the treatment of fixed flexion
fixation of the patellar tendon after advancement and the deformity of the knee. Clin Orthop. 1982;171:87–93.
semitendinous tendon after transfer, apart from sutures, 12. Aspden RM, Porter RW. Nerve traction during correction of knee
to the periosteum. Despite this, the patients were flexion deformity. A case report and calculation. J Bone Joint Surg
Br. 1994;76:471–473.
ambulating well within 3 weeks and we could not show
13. Aiona MD, Sussman MD. Treatment of spastic diplegia in patients
any adverse effects of immobilization. with cerebral palsy: Part II. J Pediatr Orthop B. 2004;13:S13–S38.
14. Novacheck TF, Stout JL, Gage JR, et al. Distal femoral extension
Limitations of This Study osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement to treat persistent
We did not use the Gross Motor Function crouch gait in cerebral palsy. Surgical technique. J Bone Joint Surg
Classification Scale to document the preoperative status Am. 2009;91:271–286.
of the children. This was because none of our patients 15. Beals RK. Treatment of knee contracture in cerebral palsy by
hamstring lengthening, posterior capsulotomy, and quadriceps
possessed a walking aid or a wheelchair before surgery; to mechanism shortening. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2001;43:802–805.
allocate them to a Gross Motor Function Classification 16. Uyttendaele D, Kimpe E, Dellaert F, et al. Lengthening and
Scale level based on the projected use of a walking aid or transposition of the hamstrings in cerebral palsy. A long-term
wheelchair would have been conjectural and inappropri- follow-up. Acta Orthop Belg. 1984;50:198–205.
17. Sutherland DH, Schottstaedt ER, Larsen LJ, et al. Clinical and
ate. We opted to use the FMS and the Hoffer et al’s electromyographic study of seven spastic children with internal
grading to assess the improvement of the ambulatory rotation gait. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1969;51:1070–1082.
status after surgery. 18. Eggers GWN. Transplantation of hamstrings to femoral condyles in
As we did not have instrumented gait analysis we order to improve hip extension and to decrease knee flexion in
could not quantify improvement of the pattern of gait cerebral spastic paralysis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1952;34A:827–830.
19. Chandler FA. Re-establishment of normal leverage of the patella in
and, consequently, could not compare our results with knee flexion deformity in spastic paralysis. Surg Gynecol Obstet.
other studies. The impression of the improvement of gait 1933;57:523–527.
was partly based on the subjective criteria of surgeons and 20. Bosworth DM, Thompson FR. Fixation of the transplanted tibial
therapists involved in the treatment and this introduces tubercle. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1946;28:285–287.
21. Selber P, Ferraretto I, Machado P, et al. Preliminary results of
bias. However, we considered the gait to have improved patellar tendon shortening as a salvage procedure in crouch gait in
only if our impressions concurred with those of the cerebral palsy. Vancouver: Paediatric Orthopaedic Society of North
parents and the children. America Annual Meeting Book; 2000:71.