Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
00
Pnnted m Circa Bntan. All nghts mcrved CopyrIght I’ IWI Pcrgamon Pxss plc
Summary-Leguminous plant materials used as mulches. green manures and cover crops are generally
assumed to provide a readily-available source of N to crops. However. little is known about the chemical
composition and N release patterns of the variety of legumes being used in tropical agroecosystems. N
release patterns from the leaflets of IO tropical legumes and rice straw were determined in a laboratory
expenment. Ground leaf material was allowed to dtxompose in an acid soil (pH 4.5) for 8 weeks and the
soil was analyzed periodically for extractable NH;-N and NO;-N. N release in the soil plus plant
material were compared IO that of the soil without plant material added and related IO the N. lignin and
polyphenolic concentrations of the leaflets. Three patterns of net N mineralization emerged during the
S-weeks. One pattern exhibited by the control ~011. rice straw and leaves of two of the leguminous plants
was a low. positive net mineralization. Another pattern showed much higher rates of mincrulization than
the control soil and the third pattern showed initial net immobilization followed by low but positive net
mincrahrutton rates. The amount of N mineralized during the 8 weeks as compared to the control soil
ranged from +46 IO -20% of the N added in plant matcnal. Net mincralizltion was not correlated to
% N or % lignin in the leaf material but was found to he negatively correlated to the polyphcnolic
conccntrntcon. r = -0.63. or the polyplicnolic-to-N ratio. r = -0.75. Mineralization in excess of the
control soil was found only for materials with a polyphenolic-to-N ratio ~0.5. Mechanisms to explain
the low mincralir;ttion by materials high in polyphcnolics include the formation of slahlc polymers
bctwccn polyphcnolics and amino groups. and nitrosotion. a chemical reaction of nitrite (NOI ) with
p<>lyphcnollcs. Our results show that Icguminous plant material with ;I high polyphcnollc content or
polyphcnollc-to-N ratio may not be a rc;ltlily-av;lil;thlc source of N.
83
83 C. A. PALM and P. A. SANCHEZ
Lidxvator~ e.\-periment
Leaflets from ten leguminous trees and shrubs and
mature rice straw (Ory:n satha) were used as treat-
ments in the laboratory incubation (Table I). The
plant materials were collected from agroforestry trials
at the Yurimaguas Experiment Station in the Peru-
vian Amazon. All plants, except Leuceana leuco-
cephtrln (Lamb) de Witt. were growing on acid,
upland soils (Typic Palcudults, pH 4.5): L. kuco-
cqd~aiu was growing on a more fcrtilc alluvial soil
(Tropofluvcnt. pH 6.0). The acid, upland soils arc
rcprcscntativc of cn 30”/0 of the soils found in the
lowland humid tropics (Sanchez. 1989). All of the
spccics arc used in agroforcstry systems in the humid
tropics, four spccics are native to South or Central
America and the othsrs arc exotics (Table I). A
mixture of young and mature Icavcs wcrc hand
picked from scvcral trees of each spccics. only Icallcts
wcrc used in the cxpcrimcnt to avoid confounding N
dynamics by including lignilicd rachiscs. The fresh
Icallcts wcrc air dried and thsn ground (< I mm).
Soil used for the cxpcrimcnt was taken from the
top IOcm of the Typic Palcudult. The soil had a
loamy sand tcxturc. I% organic matter content. pH
value of 4.5, and etti.ctive cation cxchangc capacity of
3.3 cmol dm -‘. Fresh soil was sieved (<2 mm) to
remove roots and organic debris. Extractable
NH,’ ‘N and NO;. N at the beginning of the incu-
bation were 4.6 and 15.9 ilg N g-’ soil, respectively.
For each treatment, 88 mg of ground leaves were
mixed with fresh soil equivalent to 500 g oven dry
weight. to approximate a mulch rate of 3.3 I dried
plant material ha-‘. Deionized water was added
to attain a moisture content of IlOmg g-‘. field
capacity for the soil being CN I50 mg g _I. Soil without
added plant material served as a control and soil
with mature rice straw as a non-leguminous com-
parison. The soil and plant mixtures were scaled in
plastic bags and kept in the dark at room tcmpcraturc
of cu 26 C. Each trcatmcnt was replicated three
times.
Subsamples (IO g) were taken from each bag and
analyzed for cxchangcablc NH,+-N and NO;-N
immcdiatcly after addition of plant material and then
again at I. 2. 3, 4 and 8 weeks. Soil was extracted by
shaking for 30 min in 30ml of 0.5 M K$O,, cen-
trifugcd. and aliquots analyzed for NH,’ and NO<.
Ammonium was analyzed by the indophcnol blue
method (Dorich and Nelson. 1982) and nitrate by the
method of Cataldo et al. (1975). Net mineralization
was considered the diffcrcnce in exchangcablc NH,’
and NO; between two samplings.
N release from tropical legumes 85
% L1gnm % Phcnohc
Cumulative % %
NH; + NO, % N Lignin Phcnolics % N % N
Table 3. Cumulatwc concm:rauons’ of extractable NH;-N term. A combination of the two types of legumes may
and Ir;O, -N m the sod for the dlffcrmt treatmmts at provide the best agroecosystem management.
8 veeks
NH;-N NO;-?4 Acknonledgemenfs-We thank 4. Salazar for providing the
TEatmmt cpg N g-1 soli) diverse plant material and W. H. Schlesinger and W.
COfll~Ol 6.89 (0.48) 37.64 ( I .98) Johnson for providing facilities for polyphenolic and lignin
G. *qYprum 30 lO(1 08) 44.54 (0.97) analyses. respectively. Comments on earlier drafts by S.
&rt.rhrmo sp 16.50(1.31) 4.4 50 (2.26) Buol. C. B. Davey. G. Hoyt. R. H. Miller. M. Reynolds.
A. sal?lan 18.51 (0.48) 43.26 (0.68)
W. H. Schlesinger. D. Worsham. and two anonymous
I. rrlulu 3.97 (0.92) 38.63 (3.17)
reviewers were helpful and much appreciated. This work
0. SUIII’U 4.8J(O.40) 39.10 (0.06)
Inru sp 3. I6 (0.79) 39.22 (0.55) was part of the North Carolina State University TROP-
L. luururephalu 5 58 (0.54) 41.21 (1 ‘l9) SOILS Program. supported by US Agency for International
c. rrriluluru 3.70 (0.50) 41 OO(l 97) Development (USAID).
ca. w/on I 89(0.:4) 37.17(1.74)
Drsmdum ~~~~rclrr 088(0.31) 37.11(1.1?)
D. o~hf~drum ORO(O.lll 36 2: (0.46)
REFERESCES
‘Mean (SD) of three rC,?h‘XleS.
Azhar El Sayed. Van Cleemput 0. and Verstruete W.
(1986a) Nitrification mediated nitrogen immobilization in
soils. Plonr and Soil 94, 4Ol-tOV.
Pattern I in which little net mineralization or Azhar El Sayed. Verhe R.. Proot M.. Sandra P. and
immobilization occurred. as for both Itrgu species, Verstraete W. (1986b) Bindlng of nitrite-N on polyphe-
could reflect their higher lignin content. and therefore nols during nitrification. Plant rrntl Soil 94, 369-382.
supposedly lower soluble-C. of these materials. The Berg B. and Staff H. (1981) Leaching. accumulation and
two In,qcl species had 50% higher lignin contents than release of nitrogen in decomposing forest htter. In Tu~I~,~-
the other spccics. Lignin content may influcncc the rricrl Nitroxc*n C~ck0.r (F. E. Clark and T. Rosswall. Eds).
pp. 163-178. Ecological Bulletin 33 (Stockholm).
long-term N rclcasc as is indicated by a weak corre-
Broughton W. J. (1977) Erect of various covers on soil
lation found for the S-week cumulative mincraliz-
fertility under flerxvr hrcuiliens~s and on growth of the
ation and the lignin-to-N ratio. tree. /(pro-Eco.ql.vlrn~s 3. I47 170.
The patterns of N mineralization obtained in this Cafaldo D. A.. Ilaroon M.. Schr;lder L. E. and Young V. L.
study arc complex and involve ;I variety of factors. (1975) Rapid colorlmctric dctcmunations of nitrate I”
The lignin-10-N ratio. which has hccn shown to plant tissue by titration of salicyclic ;~cld. <.~~,,r,frrtrri~tr/rr,,rs
control dccornposition and mincrali~ation in non- LI .%lil .scrcncX, urtd I’llrnl .-lncrl,~.vr.~
6, 7 I no.
Icguminous kxvcs (Mclillo (‘I trl.. 1982). was not ;I Dorlch R. A. and Nelson D. W. (IOX?) I)lrect coIorImctric
controlling factor in lhcsc leguminous Icallcts. at least measurement of ammonium m potassium chloride CX-
tracts in soil. SOI/ .%ic*trcv*Sf~.rc,ry I)/’ ~ln~c~r~~rJf~~rrtcrl 47.
in the short term. The lignin-to-N ratios of the
x33 X36.
Icguminous IC;IVUS used in this study, howcvcr. were
Ilarmscn G. W. and v;m Schrcvcn 0. A. (1955)Mmcr;lll/-
below that of the plant nxttorials used in the study by ation of organic nilrogcn in soil. A&mc~c*s Cr ,Igrr~n0nr~’
Mclillo C’Itrl. (I%?). Our study suggests that polyphe- 7, 299 -39x.
nolics content could control the short-term N rele;lsc Iritani W. M. and Arnold C. Y. (1960) Nitrogen release 01
and availability from legumes. Leguminous plant vegetable crop residues during incubation as rel;lred IO
materials have previously been considered as readily their chemical composition. Soil Science 89. 74 82.
available sources of N. This assumption may be Kang B. T.. Wilson G. F. and Sipkrns L. (19X1) Allcycrop-
incorrsct if ths plant material has a high poiyphenolic ping maize (Zrcr ntcr):r L.) and leucaens (Lrucorno Ieucrr-
cephulu Lam.) in southern Nigeria. Pl~rrtr und Soi/ 63.
content, or ;I polyphcnolic-to-N ratio >O.S. This type
165-179.
ofshort-term incubation could be useful for screening
King J. G. C. and tlrath G. W. (1967) The chemical analyhis
Irgumcs. Another cxperimcntal study using plant of small samples of leaf material and the rclationshlp
materials, including non-legumes, with a broader between the disappearance and composition of leaves.
range in N, lignin and polyphenolic content would Pedohiolcq+ 7. 191-197.
provide addltionul information on 1hc overall import- Ladd J. N.. Oades J. M. and Amato M. (1981) Dlstrihution
ance of polyphenolics and their interaction with and recovery of nitrogen from legume residues decompos-
lignins in controlling N release from plant materials. ing in soils sown to wheat in the tield. Soil Biohqy &
Also. it must bc pointed out that only leaflets were Biochenri.srry 13. 251-256.
Martin J. P. and Haider K. (1980) Microbial degradation
used in this study, N release patterns from the entire
and stabilization of “C-labeled lignins. phenols. and
lcavcs may be different and should be investigated.
phenolic polymers in relation to soil humus formation. In
The diverse N release patterns observed from the L&yin Biode~rudution: Microbiology. Chenkfry ud P o -
Ic;lRets of IO tropical legumes and the possible role of rmriul Applicurions. Vol. 2 (T. K. Kirk, T. Higuchi and
polyphcnolics on N availability have several manage- H. M. Chang. Eds). pp. 78-100. CRC Press. Wesr Palm
mcnt implications. Lcgumcs with low polyphcnolic Beach.
content used as green manure or mulch may release Martin J. S. and Martin M. M. (19X2) Tannin assays in
N rapidly and provide sutficient N for plant growth, ecological studies: lack of correlation between phenolics.
but the N may be readily lost by lcaching if not proanthocyanidins and protein- precipitating constituents
in mature foliage of six oak species. Oecofogio 51,
relenscd in synchrony with plant demands. Legumes
2052 I I.
with high polyphenolic content may rcac1 with or-
Melillo J. M. and Aber J. D. (1983) Nutrient immobilization
ganic N compounds do not provide enough N for in decaying litter: an example of carbon-nutrtent inter-
plant growth in the short term, but they may contrib- actions. In Trendy in Ecoloxicul Research fkr rhe 1980’s
utc to the build-up of organic N in the soil and (J. H. Cooley and F. 8. Golley. Eds). pp. 193-215.
provide a low but continual supply of N in the long Plenum. New York.
88 C. A. PALM and P. A. SANCHEZ
Melillo J. M.. Aber J. D. and Muratore J. F. (1982) Swtft M. J. (1985) Tropical Soil Btology and Fertility
Nitrogen and hgnm control of hardwood leaf litter dc- (TSBF). Planning and Research. Biolog! Inrernur~ond
composition dynamics. Ecology 63. 621626. Sprcd Issue 9. International Union of Biological Sci-
Millar H. C., Smith F. B. and Brown P. E. (1936) ences, Paris.
The influence of organic matter on mtrate accumulation Swift M. J.. Heal 0. W. and Anderson J. M. (1979)
and the base exchange capacity of Dickinson fine sandy Decompowion in Terrestriul Ecos~srems. Studies in Ecol-
loam. Journal of Ihe rlmericun Socier_v of .4gronom_v 28. ogy, Vol. 5. University of California Press. Berkeley.
856866. Tenney F. G. and Waksman S. A. (1929) Composition of
Mole S. and Waterman P. G. (1987b) A critical analysis of natural organic materials and their decomposition: IV.
techniques for measuring tannins in ecological studies. II. The nature and rapidity of decomposition of the various
Techniques for biochemically defining tannins. Oecologiu organic complexes in different plant materials. under
72, 1388156. aerobic conditions. Soil Scrrnce 28. 55-83.
Nelson D. W. and Bremner D. W. (1969) Factors affecting Valhs 1. and Jones R. J. (1973) Net mineralization of
chemical transformations of nitrite in soils. Soil Bioiogr mtrogen in leaves and leaf litter of De.mrudium inrvrrum
& Bwchemisrr~ 1, 229-239. and Phuseolur utropurpureus mixed with soil. Suil Bwlogj
Sanchez P. A. (1989) Souls. In Trr~prcal Rorr$ore.rr Eco- & Biochemisrrj, 5. 391-399.
syrfems (H. Lieth and M. J. A. Werger. Eds), pp. 73HH. Van Soest P. J. and Wine R. H. (1968) Determination of
Elsevier. Amsterdam. lignin and cellulose in acid-detergent fiber with permanga-
Silvapalan K.. Fernando R. and Thenabadu M. W. (1985) nate. Journal of the .4ssc~ciurion of O_ficid .4nol~~r1cul
N-mineralization in polyphenol-rich plant residues and Chcmisrs 51. 75C-785.
their affect on nitrification of applied ammonium sul- Vitousek P. M. and Matson P. A. (1985) Disturbance.
phate. Soil Biology & Biochcmisrr~ 17, 547-551. mtrogen, availability, and nitrogen losses in an intens-
Stevenson F. J. (1982) Hwws Chenrisrr!: Genesis. Compo - ively managed loblolly pine plantation. Ecology 66.
scion. Rcucrions. Wiley, New York. 1360-1376.
Stevenson F. J. (1986) C~clcs q/ Soil Curhwi. Nitrogen. Wade M. K. and Sanchez P. A. (1983) Mulching and green
Pho.cphorus. &fur. .~licrurturric,nr.c.Wiley. New York. manure applications for contmuous crop production in
Swain T. (1979) Tannins and lignins. In Hc*rhwore.r Therr the Amazon Basin. Jm~nul of Agrmtomy 75. 39-45.
Irrrercrcrions dir Sewndury Plunr klvrcrholi/es (G. A. Weeraratna C. S. (1979) Pattern of nitrogen release during
Rosenthal and D. H Janzcn. Eds). pp. 657-822. Aca- decomposition of some green manures in a tropical
demic Press, New York. alluvial soil. Phmr und Sod 53. 2X7-294.