Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/324226924
CITATIONS READS
0 8,271
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Arijit Roy on 30 July 2018.
417 Am. J. Phys. 86 (6), June 2018 http://aapt.org/ajp C 2018 American Association of Physics Teachers
V 417
is equal to the voltage difference between the supply voltage
and the capacitor voltage
Vd ¼ VS VC : (2)
where a Is =ðCVT Þ.
418 Am. J. Phys., Vol. 86, No. 6, June 2018 Roy et al. 418
IS
VC ¼ Vi t: (9)
C
As we found earlier, Eq. (9) is linear with time. (Vi is the ini-
tial voltage of the capacitor.) When Eqs. (8) and (4) are plot-
ted together, the graphs are not distinguishable and overlap
one another. Thus, the assumption taken to simplify Eq. (4)
into Eq. (8) is valid and a good approximation for the above
cases under consideration. A similar observation is noticed
when Eqs. (9) and (6) are plotted together.
Experimental charging and discharging results for a diode
are shown in Fig. 3. The electrical circuits for these experi-
ments are the same as those shown in Fig. 1. Figure 3 is
experimental verification for a linear time dependence of the
charging and discharging voltage on a capacitor through a
reverse-biased diode. In addition, the slopes (charging or dis-
charging) obtained theoretically (from Fig. 2) and experi-
mentally (from Fig. 3) are found to be 30 V/s and 32 V/s,
respectively. The small deviation between the theoretical
419 Am. J. Phys., Vol. 86, No. 6, June 2018 Roy et al. 419
and experimental findings is within the acceptable limit of of order 1 nA and that for a Schottky diode (in our example,
the experimental error. 1N5822) is 1 lA. As a result, for a given capacitance, a sili-
The use of an oscillator as a voltage source for charging con diode needs a longer time to charge or discharge in com-
the capacitor is not suitable for cases of longer charging and parison to a Schottky diode. In other words, the rate of
discharging time. The first half cycle of the oscillator’s out- charge and discharge will be slower in the case of a silicon
put is used to charge the capacitor while the time for the sec- diode. Hence, instead of an oscillator, a DC source with a
ond half cycle is used for discharging of the capacitor. Thus, push button switch technique is to be used for silicon diodes.
if tc is the charging (or discharging time), then the time For curiosity, the reverse saturation current for a silicon
period requirement is 2tc (or longer), or in other words the diode is estimated from the experimental plot. The magni-
frequency f must be 1/2 tc (or lower). Thus, for tc ¼ 1 s, the tude of the slope (i.e., Is/C) of the plot shown at the top of
frequency requirement is f ¼ 0.5 Hz or lower. Such an oscil- Fig. 4 is estimated to be 0.3 V/s. Thus, in this case (with
lator of low frequency range is not commonly used in the C ¼ 0.01 lF), the reverse saturation current Is ¼ 3 nA, and it
laboratory. is indeed found to be in good agreement with the range
If required, the oscillator can be replaced by a DC quoted in the datasheet.8
source with a push button switch. With this cost-effective A deeper inspection of Figs. 3 and 4 reveals slight depar-
alternative, the capacitor gets charged by pressing the but- ture from a straight line response for both the charging and
ton and is allowed to discharge by releasing the button. discharging cases. The slight departure from the linearity
Experimental results obtained by using this technique are arises mainly from three factors. The first factor is the inter-
shown in Fig. 4. As a further improvement of this tech- nal resistance of the supply voltage (which is the internal
nique, we suggest using a digital switch instead of an ana- resistance of the oscillator used in our experiments), and
log switch. this resistance appears in series with the voltage source.
In the reverse voltage range of 0–5 V, the reverse satura- The second factor is the input impedance of the voltage-
tion current for a silicon diode (in our example, 1N4007) is measuring instrument across the capacitor (which is the
Arduino in our experiments). In our circuit, this impedance
provides an additional voltage discharge path for the
charged capacitor. The third factor is the finite leakage cur-
rent of any capacitor.
The first factor can be minimized by using an oscillator
(or DC source) of very low output impedance (10 X or so).
Although this effect cannot be removed completely for the
charging case (due to the existence of a small but finite
impedance of the charging voltage source), the same can be
removed completely for the discharging case using a DC
source with a digital switch. The second factor can be mini-
mized by using a voltage measuring instrument having a
very high input impedance. The higher the input impedance,
the better the result. The third factor can be minimized by
using a capacitor of low internal leakage current. Instead of a
polyester capacitor (used in this work), a film capacitor
would give better results as the leakage current is minimal in
a film capacitor.
V. CONCLUSION
It is evident from this work that both the charging and
discharging voltages of a capacitor are a linear function of
time when a reverse-biased diode is used for charging or
discharging. Good agreement is shown between analytical
and experimental estimations. The magnitude of the slope
of the time-dependent charging and discharging voltage is
shown to be the ratio of the reverse saturation current of
the diode to the value of the capacitor. In laboratory prac-
tice, a little nonlinearity is observed in the voltage versus
time plot and relevant factors causing the nonlinearity are
discussed. It is instructive to compare responses from a
resistor-capacitor circuit with the diode-capacitor circuit. A
low-cost experiment is presented here, and the proposed
experiment is suitable for an undergraduate physics and
electronics laboratory.
Fig. 4. Instead of an oscillator, a DC source with push button switch is used
to charge and discharge a capacitor. The discharge is allowed through a ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
reverse-biased diode and the responses are shown in this figure. Top: Silicon
diode (1N4007), C ¼ 0.01 lF. Bottom: Schottky diode (1N5822), Abhishek Mallick, Aparna Adhikari, and Priyanka Guin
C ¼ 0.22 lF. would like to thank the Department of Science and
420 Am. J. Phys., Vol. 86, No. 6, June 2018 Roy et al. 420
4
Technology, Government of India for providing research J. E. Gordon and P. R. Grant, “Series RC circuits revisited,” Am. J. Phys.
fellowship under “DST Inspire Fellow” scheme. 72, 655–661 (2004).
5
Robert Ross and Prasad Venugopal, “On the problem of (dis)charging a
a) capacitor through a lamp,” Am. J. Phys. 74, 523–525 (2006).
Electronic mail: arijitroy@live.com 6
1
S. M. Sze and Kwok K. Ng, Physics of Semiconductor Devices, 3rd ed. Edward H. Hellen, “Verifying the diode-capacitor circuit voltage decay,”
(John Wiley Sons, New Jersey, 2007), pp. 90–102. Am. J. Phys. 71(8), 797–800 (2003).
7
2
J. Millman and C. C. Halkias, Electronics Devices and Circuits (McGraw Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC, Rev. 10, Publication Order
Hill, New York, 1997), pp. 124–129. Number: 1N5820/D, Dec. (2007).
3 8
Edward H. Hellen and Matthew J. Lanctot, “Nonlinear damping of the LC Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC, Rev. 13, Publication Order
circuit using antiparallel diodes,” Am. J. Phys. 75, 326–330 (2007). Number: 1N4001/D, Oct. (2012).
421 Am. J. Phys., Vol. 86, No. 6, June 2018 Roy et al. 421