Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Strategy
Business digitalization is changing the competitive landscape in many industries. Digi-
tally savvy customers are demanding more while threats of digital disruptions from
new entrants are rising. This article describes how DBS, a large Asian bank, responded
to digital threats and opportunities by adopting a digital business strategy. It identi-
Peter Weill
Business digitalization is changing the competitive landscape for many industries, and the
banking industry is no exception. With the rapid adoption of the Internet, ecommerce and
smartphones, consumers are increasingly turning to computers, tablets, mobile phones and
smartphones to interact and transact with banks. As a consequence, because bank customers
are visiting branches less frequently, the number of physical bank branches has declined
steadily over the years. This trend will likely continue—for example, McKinsey sees a sharp rise
in digital banking consumers, estimating that the number in Asia will rise from 670 million in
2016 to 1.7 billion by 2020. At the same time, a new breed of digital players is entering the
2
revolution, JP Morgan Chase
Korea launched its N mobile platform, which allows customers to use their smartphones to
withdraw cash from ATMs, send money and pay at stores.5 Money management functionalities,
location-based offers and credit facilities are also integrated into the platform.
1 Dorothy Leidner is the accepting senior editor for this article.
challenging to respond to the digital threats and Bank of Australia engaged with its customers
opportunities and are struggling to compete in throughout the entire home-buying process
an increasingly digital marketplace. They are by integrating a property listing database and
often weighed down by their legacy IT systems the full range of mortgage services on a simple
and cumbersome legacy processes. Burdened mobile app.8 Other banks are also experimenting
by heavy compliance requirements, these banks with innovative digital offerings, but often within
also have little capacity to experiment with digital a particular business function or division.
innovation. Yet digitalization hits at the core of a Moving forward, however, there is a growing
bank—i.e., the digitalization of money and all the sense that such functionally oriented experiments
related functions around money. fail to maximize the potential of digital business
IT is not just critical in the running of strategy. A digital business strategy is inherently
banking business but is also an important cross-functional and thus requires simultaneous
source of banking innovations and has strategic
implications for future banking models. Hence, business resources across multiple organizational
processes. A more holistic and integrated
strategy with business strategy. IT needs to be approach is needed if companies are to respond
pervasively embedded in every aspect of a bank effectively to the threats and opportunities arising
and be an integral part of the business strategy. from digitalization. To do so, companies need to
The IT strategy of a bank is thus inextricably develop several related capabilities in the areas
fused with the business strategy. Bharadwaj et of leadership, operations, customer needs and
al. termed this fusion of IT strategy and business innovation.
strategy digital business strategy.6 How can a Leadership. CEOs need to be transparent,
bank pursue such a digital business strategy? adaptive and resilient, and senior executives
must acquire new competencies.9 The senior
achieve the fusion between business and IT so 10
it can respond to the new digital threats and able to understand the potential and challenges
opportunities? These are the questions that this of digitalization and have a shared vision of
study aims to address. digitalization being central to the growth of the
business. Top management leadership is crucial
Pursuing a Digital Business for articulating the digital business strategy
Strategy and for aligning the necessary investment in
resources.
Best practice for pursuing a digital business Operations. The pursuit of a digital business
strategy is still in its infancy. Most organizations
simply respond to new digital threats and platform on which digital products and services
opportunities in an ad hoc manner within some can be readily delivered. These digitized business
organizational functions. For example, some processes, based on standards and integration
MIS Quarterly
MIS Quarterly
106 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
three years.
successful digital business strategy (see the
“Whether we know it or not, the digital
revolution has put banks under siege.
With Internet 2.0 and mobility, the game
DBS Bank Background
a burning platform of competition from
mobile and Internet companies. If we don’t
bank to become the largest bank by assets in embrace digital—and quickly—there is a
real danger that our lunch will be eaten. It is
services for institutional banking, consumer only a matter of time before the disruption
that the retail and telecom industries have
MIS Quarterly
MIS Quarterly
cataclysmic disruption
put digital
Rewiring DBS Bank For the at the heart of banking
Digital Era continually asked his senior executives was how
well the business was exploiting the digitalization
strategy involved strategic initiatives and of banking products and services. Technology
“The point about moving to information banking through digital channels, the need
and mobile [digital] is that we need to for a large geographic footprint in order
rethink what our business strategy is and to scale up in large geographies such as
how our business model is going to change. China, India or Indonesia becomes less of
It is not just about developing mobile apps an imperative. A successful digital banking
but about rethinking the organization. How strategy will enable us to accelerate our
do you rewire an organization for [digital access to emerging markets without the
transformation]?”20 David Gledhill, Head of need for a large and expensive bricks and
mortar network.”
108 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
executives were kept up to date with the latest traditional senior bankers with a bunch of
developments in the digital landscape through 20-year-old coders and see what happens.
various forums to help them see the potential It’s fascinating to watch. On day 1 or 2, there
disruptions and threats of disintermediation are two camps, the bankers and coders,
from new market entrants. For example, Ms. neither really sure of what to think of each
other. By the end of the week, there’s such
Division, became more acutely aware of the passion and intensity about what they are
rapid commoditization of wealth management creating that we really think we’ve [ignited]
by online retail investment players (e.g., a very magical spark [that] changes
people’s thinking in the organization.” Neal
bypassed traditional wealth management
advisors and put their money directly into funds,
the lucrative management fees that banks collect The cultivation of leadership for digital
for wealth management services were at the risk transformation was not just restricted to senior
becoming history executives but also systematically cascaded
Committed to transforming herself from a down the hierarchy to mobilize the change
technology idiot digital warrior 21 agenda. Investments in collaborative technology
response to the digital threat was to deploy IBM
Watson, a cognitive cloud-based data analytics telepresence videoconferencing systems and
solution in the Wealth Management Division. IBM
Watson helped relationship managers (who may coordination and the gathering of feedback from
different stakeholders. Mr. Gledhill explained
and customer data so they could deliver greater how he pushed his employees to participate in
We encourage people to
This initiative was just one of the many speak up, to put their views on the table. We want
technology investment decisions jointly planned people with the change agenda. This is a big shift in
by senior business and technology executives culture
through their annual technology road-mapping
workshops. The close collaboration between set up in the internal enterprise portal in 2011.
business and technology executives was This forum encouraged staff across the region to
evident in the strong business ownership of the provide regular feedback or make improvement
technology roadmap; the business heads, not suggestions directly to the CEO. The portal was
their IT managers, would present their strategic
IT plans to senior executives themselves.
Increasingly, senior banking executives were The forum proved to be an effective channel for
also encouraged to innovate and think digitally, getting wider inputs from employees, cutting
Figure 2: Reporting Structure for DBS’ Group Technology and Operations Division
110 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
also enabled rapid rollout of new products, such The wealth management system was quickly
as investment or insurance plans denominated followed in 2012 by IDEALTM
and mobile banking platform for businesses.
IDEALTM offered corporate customers a
hired a new head of process transformation, We have been very focused on executing
Paul Cobban, who was tasked with applying against our IT strategy to enable us to be
process improvement methods and lean more nimble and innovative in the ways we
engage our customers, including changing
requirement for all new T&O projects to undergo the way people bank.”28 David Gledhill,
process transformation with stretch targets and
measurement of outcomes. Cross-functional
teams, comprising 10 to 20 people from around
the bank (including senior executives and new experiences was guided by a set of principles
112 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
A second focus was the better use of data technology at its call center, which handled over
to map the customer experiences and seek to “What we’ve built into these pods is enough
understand issues encountered by customers technology so 95% of the interaction can
across multiple touchpoints. be done without the [staff member] leaving
their seat. That’s where the technology
“… we look at the journeys our customers comes in, but we actually hide it away.
are taking and then we try and get inside It’s kind of hidden behind the teller, and
the mind of the customer, feel like we are it’s something the customer doesn’t see.”33
the customer. We actually create a pretend David Gledhill, Head of Group T&O,
customer that represents our base. We give
them a name and age and occupation, and
then we take them through the journey as
“Digital is all about making what can be
they apply for a mortgage or a credit card,
seen unseen—making services so smooth
and we try to understand what they are
and seamless that it becomes invisible to the
going through. We consider what they are
customer.”34 Neal Cross, Chief Innovation
thinking, what are their emotions, what is
their experience, what are they concerned
about, and then try and improve that
process so their journey is more joyful.”32
where customers could obtain a queue number
For example, after observing that its customers
spent a total of 15,000 hours a month at ATMs
they became more amenable to speaking with
staff, resulting in double-digit sales growth for
bancassurance35 and investment products at the
customers could carry out basic transactions,
branches.36
including checking balances, paying card bills
and transferring funds to their own accounts. 4. Incubate and Accelerate Emerging
Digital Innovations
added alternative banking touchpoints as more
transactions occurred outside traditional bank Council chaired by the CEO to provide a
branches—e.g., through self-service kiosks
and digital partnerships (e.g., with Guardian
The
Financial Brand
The
114 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
and subsequently rolled out to other business to such disruptions if necessary. An example of
lines. The Watson Engagement Advisor solution
market research and transactional behaviors in banking services to outsiders to encourage others
guiding relationship managers to offer advice
aim is to become a banking industry platform
investment portfolio. Another collaboration was player (i.e., to provide the architectural platform
39
capabilities so it could deepen its understanding opened up to developers of new banking apps. It
was building a new digital front end that would
personalized interactions. connect to about 20 different ecosystem partners
so those partners could build products on top of
innovation ideas by actively engaging the
tech start-up community through accelerator
Benefits Gained from DBS Bank’s
Digital Business Strategy
“The DBS hackathon is now a regular The substantial investment in technology as
part of the DBS training curriculum; we a foundation for growth appeared to have paid
were looking to break the stereotypes that
consecutive quarter of year-on-year growth, and
the way we trained our people so that
they would embrace a digital mindset.
We sought to foster a cultural exchange
between our employees and startups. We
created a “sandbox” for our people to
experiment like startups, to identify and act In addition, the stable growth
40
on opportunities quickly.” Neal Cross, Chief enabled by the robust technology infrastructure
41
and best-capitalized banks,
We need to fundamentally
received a range of accolades, including being
educate the bank in another way. We experiment—
try things quickly—so we start to act a bit more
like a startup, like an e-commerce company. It is 42
In
about taking small, calculated risks that have no
impact if they fail. This year we are running 1,000
small experiments across the bank, and they will be 43
exactly that, small things we can test in safety that
only Asian bank among the top 10 private banks
give us a huge amount of insight into action 38
The Asian
Banker -
116 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
enterprise for digital innovation. The case shows digital business strategy is not a project, nor
gradually built up the necessary capabilities department or IT division, but is a core belief
to pursue a successful digital business that needs to pervade the entire enterprise.
strategy: cultivating the leadership for digital
transformation, developing agile and scalable the management structure put in place played a
digital operations, designing new digitally key role in creating the digital mindset that is a
enabled customer experiences, and incubating prerequisite for fusing business and technology
and accelerating emerging digital innovations. strategies. This was evident in the deep
These capabilities dynamically complemented commitment of the visionary CEO, the inclusion
each other, with the new digital leadership of the Head of Group T&O as a key member of
providing both the impetus to transform and the central executive committee, and a team of
the resolve to develop the enterprise digital transformed senior business executives who
platforms on which new digitally enabled
customer experiences were designed. At the innovation in their respective business domains.
same time, new innovation capabilities were The convergence of various reporting lines was
gradually developed through strategic incubation, also crucial in that it allowed the underlying
technology partnering and mindset change. tensions between exploring and exploiting to
The building of each capability was not a one- surface and be dealt with at the strategic level—
time initiative but required a full organizational an ambidextrous skill that leaders driving digital
transformation must develop.
process, technology and people elements (see
2. An Agile and Scalable “Core” Is
were radical because they needed new senior Critical
executives to be appointed, departments to be
merged, strategic external talents to be hired highlights the importance of building an agile
and changes to formal reporting relationships.
In fact, the convergence of various reporting infrastructure enables organizations to capture
lines says a lot about the strategic emphasis
and continuously to build a modular and
The line of business T&O, country T&O, process agile technology infrastructure that enables
transformation, customer experience and subsequent scalability of new initiatives (e.g., a
innovation were brought together under the
Head of Group T&O, and ultimately under the CEO banking platforms, straight-through processing,
•
• • •
•
sions and geographical
Structure • •
• • • •
•
nance and coordi • Enterprise architecting •
nation •
Process •
design
•
•
shops •
• • • •
• •
• Enterprise portal
•
• •
•
Technology
•
• Enterprise application
nologies
• • • •
People
ing
ence
118 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
wrong
a digital wealth management platform for its developments might bring. These explorations
customers. essentially created strategic options for the future
At the same time, by assessing such potential Which parts should we seek to
space for ourselves in the new world order.” themselves these questions:
1. To what extent does the organization have
Hence, organizations aspiring to pursue a the required digital capabilities to counter
digital business strategy need to be prepared to the threats or exploit the opportunities
continuously navigate the dynamic and emerging from digital disruptions?
digital landscape. They need to assess how • To what extent have the leadership
quickly and on what scale disruptive innovations skills required for digital
are likely to occur, and devise strategic responses transformation been cultivated among
to cope with dynamic shifts. This requires the the senior executives?
willingness to experiment and explore new digital • To what extent has the organization
frontiers to create strategic options for the future. developed agile and scalable
It also requires subjecting the organization to digital operations to respond to the
dynamism of the digital era?
clarify its core competencies and unique assets.
However, a digital business strategy cannot • To what extent has the organization
be conceived independently of the business leveraged its abundance of data to
ecosystem the organization is in. In the banking design new digitally enabled customer
sector, organizations need to develop clarity experiences?
about the new sources of value creation in the • To what extent has the organization
accelerated the pace of innovation
value. Thus, banks need to ask themselves: and incubated emerging digital
Which parts of the business should we innovations?
keep in-house and at the forefront of 2. What can the organization do to
develop its digital capabilities further
by overhauling the related elements in
Which parts should we collaborate structure, process, technology and people?
120 MIS Quarterly Executive | June 2016 (15:2) misqe.org | © 2016 University of Minnesota
How DBS Bank Pursued a Digital Business Strategy
Christina Soh