Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
• Compare the differences and similarities among the objects in our solar system
• Figure out what physical processes could have led to them
• Then construct a model of how our solar system formed based on this
-------
• This model must explain our own solar system…
• …but might or might not explain other planetary systems
• If not, modify the model to accommodate discrepancies
• That is the scientific process
• Let’s look at the solar system characteristics comparative planetology has to work with…
Solar System Formation -- Characteristics of Our Solar System
1. Large bodies have orderly motions and are isolated from each other
– All planets and most moons have nearly circular orbits going in the same
direction in nearly the same plane
Solar System Formation -- Characteristics of Our Solar System
1. Large bodies have orderly motions and are isolated from each other
– All planets and most moons have nearly circular orbits going in the same
direction in nearly the same plane
– The Sun and most of the planets rotate in this same direction as well
Solar System Formation -- Characteristics of Our Solar System
1. Large bodies have orderly motions and are isolated from each other
– All planets and most moons have nearly circular orbits going in the same
direction in nearly the same plane
– The Sun and most of the planets rotate in this same direction as well
– Most moons orbit their planet in the direction it rotates
Solar System Formation -- Characteristics of Our Solar System
• The nebular theory is the best current explanation of our solar system
• It is not a new idea…
• …some well-known 18th-century philosophers suggested it:
– Emanuel Swedenborg
– Immanuel Kant
• Like all scientific theories, it is still being refined and improved
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Stars make heavier elements from lighter ones through nuclear fusion
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Stars make heavier elements from lighter ones through nuclear fusion
• The heavy elements (the “metals”) mix into the interstellar medium when the stars die
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Stars make heavier elements from lighter ones through nuclear fusion
• The heavy elements (the “metals”) mix into the interstellar medium when the stars die
• New stars form from the enriched gas and dust, and the cycle continues
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Stars make heavier elements from lighter ones through nuclear fusion
• The heavy elements (the “metals”) mix into the interstellar medium when the stars die
• New stars form from the enriched gas and dust, and the cycle continues
• And at the same time stars are forming …planetary systems can form
• Here’s how it works…
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• After all, the solar nebula collapsed 4.6 billion years ago
• The Sun’s been making new atoms with nuclear fusion ever since
• Wouldn’t this change the composition of the Sun’s atmosphere?
• The answer has to do with where the new atoms are being made…
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• The fusion reactions making new atoms generate the energy that gives us sunlight
• The critical question is, Where are these fusion reactions taking place?
– The answer: In its core
– And that’s in the Sun’s center, far from the surface
• So the surface layers should be essentially unchanged
• And their composition should be very similar to the solar nebula
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• So it seems reasonable to say that the composition of Sun’s atmosphere is the same as the
composition of the solar nebula
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• The key to the nebular theory is the condensation temperature of these materials, at which
they will condense into solid form
• The nebula was initially very cold, so everything except H and He was in solid form
• But it heated up as it collapsed…
• …and the temperature was different at different distances from the center
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• The frost line was located between the present-day orbits of Mars and Jupiter
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Once materials condense into solid form they can stick together
• This is called “accretion”
• And it launches the next step in planet formation…
• “Core accretion”
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Small clumps grow like
snowballs until they
become planetesimals
the size of moons
• The planetesimals collide
and coalesce until
planets are born
• This suffices to explain
terrestrial planet
formation, but jovian
planets require adding an
extra layer to the
process...literally
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• Jovian planets also begin
by core accretion
• But this happens in the
outer solar system,
beyond the frost line,
where there is 3x more
solid material available
• So the cores get much
bigger (10-15 times the
mass of Earth)
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• It is not known for certain whether jovian planets form by core accretion or disk instability
• Perhaps they form one way in some circumstances and the other way in others
• The main difference is in the way the process begins
• Once it starts, the nebular gas swirls in an accretion disk around the growing jovian
planet
• In that accretion disk, moons would form around the jovian planet like planets formed in
the solar nebula around the Sun
Solar System Formation – The Nebular Theory
• The icy planetesimals that formed beyond the frost line near Jupiter and Saturn
were thrown in random orbits, forming the Oort Cloud
How Does the Nebular Theory Do?
• Large bodies in the solar system have orderly motions and are isolated from each other
• Planets fall into two main categories
• Those that formed beyond Neptune were relatively unaffected, and make up the
Kuiper Belt
How Does the Nebular Theory Do?
• Large bodies in the solar system have orderly motions and are isolated from each other
• Planets fall into two main categories
• Those that formed near Uranus and Neptune were flung into the inner solar
system, and some provided water for Earth and other terrestrial planets
How Does the Nebular Theory Do?
• Large bodies in the solar system have orderly motions and are isolated from each other
• Planets fall into two main categories
• Swarms of asteroids and comets populate the solar system:
http://archserve.id.ucsb.edu/courses/anth/fagan/anth3/courseware/Chronology/movies/Melting.html
When did all this happen?
• These protoplanetary disks are exactly what the nebular theory predicts
• But until the 1990s, there was no convincing evidence for planets around other stars, now called
extrasolar planets or exoplanets
• As of today, nearly 3500 exoplanets have been confirmed
Detecting Extrasolar Planets by Radial Velocity
• The first extrasolar planets were found by the radial velocity technique
• This technique depends on the gravitational effect of a planet on its star
• In the transit method (used by the Kepler SpaceTelescope), astronomers look for a periodic
decrease in the light from a star
• The decrease indicates that a planet is transiting the star, blocking some of the starlight
• How often and how much the light decreases gives information about the planet’s orbit and size
• Combining this info with radial velocity info can give the density of the planet
Detecting Extrasolar Planets by Imaging
• Planets do not emit their own light, and so are hard to see in telescopes, but a small number of
extrasolar planets have been found this way
• The red object in the image above is the first of them
• It is orbiting a brown dwarf (the brighter object)
Detecting Extrasolar Planets
• In this method, the light from a distant star is bent by the gravity of an intervening star
• If the intervening star has a planet, the planet’s gravity adds to the effect in a recognizable way
• A statistical analysis of planets detected by this technique led to the prediction that each star in
the Milky Way has ~1.6 planets
• You can see a list of all the known extrasolar planets and more at
The Extrasolar Planets Encyclopedia
NASA Exoplanet Archive
Detecting Extrasolar Planets
• At one time, most confirmed exoplanets were very large and very close to their star
• This was not because extrasolar systems more like ours do not exist (they do)
• It was simply a reflection of the methods that are used
• They tend to be more sensitive to large planets close to their star
Detecting Extrasolar Planets
• But the existence of “hot Jupiters” – jovian planets very close to their star – is not
consistent with the nebular theory we have discussed
• Following the scientific method, we need to see if there is some way the nebular theory
can be modified to account for this
• And there is…
Detecting Extrasolar Planets