CERTIFICATION ELECTION

1. Dong Seung Inc. vs BLR, L-162356, 3rd Div., Austria-Martinez, 551 SCRA 211 (2008)
2. Sumifru vs Carino, GR 202091
3. Belyca Corp vs Pura Ferrer-Calleja. 168 SCRA 184 (1988)
4. Holy Child Catholic School vs Sto. Tomas, EN BANC, Peralta, 701 SCRA 589 (2013)
5. NAFTU vs Mainit Lumber ULGWP, 192 SCRA 598, (1992)
6. SMC vs Laguesma , 236 SCRA 595 (1994)
7. Mechanical Dept Labor Union vs CIR, 24 SCRA 925 (1968), JBL Reyes
8. San Miguel Foods, Inc. vs SMC Supervisors, 655 SCRA 1, Aug 1, 2011, 3rd Div, Peralta
9. SMC Supervisors and Exempt Employees Union vs Laguesma 277 SCRA 370 (1997)
10. International School Alliance of Educator (ISAE) vs Quisumbing, L-128845, June 1, 2000, 333 SCRA 13
11. Sta. Lucia East Commercial Corp vs Secretary, 596 SCRA 92 (Aug 14, 2009), 1st Div. Carpio
12. LVN vs Phil. Musicians, 1 SCRA 132 (1961)
13. Maricalum Corp vs Brion, 482 SCRA 87 (2006)
14. NAFTU vs BLR, 164 SCRA 12 (1988)
15. Central Negros Electric Coop vs Secretary, 201 SCRA 584, (1991)
16. Eagle Ridge Golf & Country Club vs CA, 616 SCRA 116 (2010)
17. Digital Telecommunications vs Digitel Employees Union (DEU), 683 SCRA 466 (2012)
18. Legend International Resorts Limited vs Kilusang Manggagawa ng Legenda (KML-Independent), 644 SCRA 94,
106 (2011)
19. Association of CA Employees vs Ferrer Calleja, 203 SCRA 596 (1991)
20. Samahan ng Manggagawa sa Pacific Plastic vs Hon. Laguesma, 267 SCRA 303 (1997)
21. ALU vs Quisumbing, 305 SCRA 762, at 769 (1999)
22. PICOP Resources Inc. (PRI) vs Dequilla, 661 SCRA 732 (2011)
23. Phil Fruits vs Torres, 211 SCRA 95 (1992)
24. Litex Employees vs Eduvala, 79 SCRA 88 (1977)
25. Federation of Unions of Rizal vs PF Calleja, L-85794, May 24, 1989, 3rd Div., Minute Resolution
26. Benguet vs BCI Employees, 23 SCRA 465 (1968)
27. Pambansang Kapatiran vs Secretary, 253 SCRA 96 (1996)

COLLECTIVE BARGAINING

1. Mantrade/FMMC Division Employees & Workers Union vs Bacungan 144 S 510 (1986)
2. Balais vs Velasco 252 S 707 (1996)
3. Luzon Development Bank vs Association, 249 S 162 (1995)
4. Baronda vs CA, GR 161006, 771 S 276, Oct. 14, 2015, 1st Division, Bersamin
5. La Perla, Inc. vs VA Rene Ofreneo, et al., GR No. 117811, Oct 16, 1995
6. Standard Electric Employees Union-NAFLU vs Juan Bautista et al., GR No. 106202, Oct 16,1995
7. Samahan ng mga Manggagawa sa Hyatt-NUWHRAIN-APL vs VA Bancungan, L-149050, March 25, 2009, 2nd
Div., Tinga
8. Pili vs NLRC, 217 S 338
9. Standard Electric Manufacturing Corp. vs Standard Electric Employees Union-NAFLU-KMU, L-166111, Aug. 25,
2005, 468 S 316, at 328.
10. General Milling Corp. vs Casio et al, 615 S 13 (2010), 1st Div., Leonardo de Castro
11. Sanyo Phil. Worker vs Canizares, 211 S 361 (1992)
12. Malayang Samahan vs Ramos, 326 S 428 (2000)
13. TUPAS-FSM vs Laguesma, 236 S 586 (1994)
14. St. Luke’s Medical Center vs Torres, 233 S 779 (1993)
15. Phil. Metal Foundries vs CIR, 90 S 135, at 141 (1979)
16. Republic Savings Bank vs CIR, 21 S 226 (1967)
17. Union of Filipro Employees vs Nestle, 499 S 521 (2006), 1st Div., Chico-Nazario
18. Union of Filipino Employees-Drug, Food & Allied Industries Unions-KMU (UFE-DFA-KMU) vs Nestle Phils., 547 S
323, March 3, 2008, Special 3rd Div., Chico-Nazario
19. Standard Chartered Bank Employees Union (NUBE) vs Confesor, GR 114974, June 6, 2004, 432 S 308
20. National Union of Restaurant Workers (PTUC) vs CIR, 10 S 843 (1964)
21. Caltex (Phil.) vs Philippine Labor Organizations, Caltex Chapter, 93 Phil. 295 (1953)
22. San Carlos Milling Co. vs CIR, 1 S 740 (1961), J.B.L. Reyes
23. St. John Colleges, Inc. vs St. John Academy Faculty and Employees Union, 505 S 764 (Oct. 27, 2006), 1 st Div.,
Ynares-Santiago
24. Divine Word University of Tacloban vs Secretary, GR 91915, Sept. 11, 1992, 213 S 759