Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 11

Proceedings of ASME Turbo Expo 2004

Power for Land, Sea, and Air


                 !  "   # $  % & & '

June 14-17, 2004, Vienna, Austria


  (      ) *   +   * + *     

, !   - ' . - / + % & & ' + 0     * +  !  1   *

GT2004-53867

2 3 4 5 6 7 7 8 9 3 L 4 T 7 9 @ 2 R ? 9 V >
U

7 > 5 5 ? > @ > 9 A B 3 2 > 5 C > A D R R 6 A X L A B > D 6 A X L A B > ? > @ > 9 A B 3 Y 9 V L A 9 C L A Z


: ; < ; = W < ; ;

D 2 7 > I > 7 9 5 J D K 3 6 L M M X ] D K 3 6 L M M O
E < F G H H H N F [ \ ; F N N G P F N

O M D B 3 4 5 6 7 7 R 3 9 3 S T A B R 5 9 @ 9 R T L I ^ O D J L 4 T 7 9 @ R A 9 V > S a b 9 c V R 9 c R d 6 7
H P G N N G P N Q Q N Q G F F G P _ ` H

@ b 6 ? R 9 J 6 9
; [

6 A B A 9 c C 5 T 6 5 > @
= e ; e

K 5 > > 4 d 9 5 5 9 Z D 2 6 5 B 6 5 5 9 C 6 D K 3 6 L M O
: [ F H F G P N ` H

O M M D 9 @ b 6 R a 9 J 6 9 S 9 > R T > R B L d
F H N G N G N F `

 f  g  h
 n o o n  j n m r  m   n j o o n t t  m k j    m w |  o u j t t x m  u m  n

 m p  o k  r j s s j k o r  q  m n j   k t j n  n m k j s t  u w   u j p j  z k  q  t j ~
 j k l   j m  n  j   j    o  m  m p j o   n   m o n  q j r n
i

p  o k  l o s t  u o  l k l  j o r j p j t    m o  r j  j k n o  m   l m r n  
n r p n m k  m   j l m r j  o n m r  m   s  j s t  u s  j t r m j n   j k n o  m   s

t n  j  n   j  n  m  k  m r    m o m j n  o n t t w
n s   u n  r v o u j   n m o  m  k k  q   j o o       w  j   t j  s  
i

k t j n  n m k j s t  u n m r  o  m j  n k   m u    j  n o o n  j o   k x  m

€  g ‚ ƒ „ h € ‚ 

o n t t  m k j    m n  j n m n t  y j r  m r j n  t w  j n r  n m r l m o j n r    j j v

|  o u j t t x m  u m  n n t n   j      m  s n j   r  m n q  k t  o o  m

r  q j m o   m n t p  o k  l o s t  u k n t k l t n   m o n  j n   t  j r   n  m s t  u

q  r j  m  n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   o  k k l  o m j n   j       o j k   m w

s  j t r o n p n    l o   j  n  m  k  m r    m o w  j m l q j   k n t  j o l t o n  j
i

  q  t j ~ s t  u o  l k l  j o m j n   j k n o  m  n   o j s   q  m j  n k   m o

s   o k  q  n  j r u   n p n  t n t j q j n o l  j r r n n w  j m z  j
i

j u j j m  j   k t j n  n m k j s t  u z  n o o n  j o   k x z n m r t n r j

m l q j   k n t t   n  m j r s t  u s  j t r o n  j  m j     n j r   r j m  s   j

 l m r n   t n  j  o n m r  s j m t  q   j   j  n  m   n m  j w … l q j   l o

  t j o  s s t  u  m j  n k   m o j u j j m  j   k t j n  n m k j s t  u z  j

j ~  j   q j m n t n m r n m n t   k n t o l r  j o  s j m r u n t t s t  u o  l k l  j o  m

 n o o n  j o   k x z n m r  j t n r j { j m r u n t t  l m r n   t n  j  o w | m

 n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   o  n p j j j m  j    j r † s   j ~ n q  t j z

n r r    m   j s t  u s  j t r u   m  q  m n t   k t j n  n m k j z u  q   j

r n q k y  x j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ ‰ Š z    j m  n p j  j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ ‹ Š z  n  n m r

s t  u s  j t r o n  j n m n t  y j r  m   r j    r j m  s   j q j k  n m  o q o  s

 j t t n k  ‡ ˆ ˆ ˆ Š z    q n ‡ ˆ ˆ  Š z  l r j  n m r  j t j o  m n ‡ ˆ ˆ Ž Š z
Œ

t  k x n  j  j m j  n   m }  m j u   y j     k t j n  n m k j z n m r  m j u  

n m  n m j j n t w ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ’ Š z “ n j n m r  n  ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‘ Š ” w t   l   q n m 


m  q  m n t   k t j n  n m k j  m  j s   u n  r      m  s  j t n r j n m r

r j n  t o  s  j j m r u n t t s t  u o  l k l  j  m  n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   o

y j   k t j n  n m k j  m  j n s      m w

 n p j j q j   j r s   q  j o j o l r  j o z  j   j k  o j s t  u q j k  n m  o q o

 j k l   j m o l r  o   u o  n  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r  j o
i

 n t j n r  o n t t  m k j    m z j o  j k  n t t   j   t j  s  j  

m   j n x r  u m z j p j m u  j m  j       j  n j o  m n o n t t j r

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ z n  j m  k t j n  t  l m r j  o   r w

k  m r    m w | m j  n k   m j u j j m  j o   k x n m r  j o l k   m o l  s n k j

“ j k j m t  z p n    l o o l r  j o † s   j ~ n q  t j z  k  t j k    j q n m r

 l m r n   t n  j  k n l o j o  j o   k x z n m r  j  j s   j  j   k t j n  n m k j

 j y j   k  ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š z   s s q n m m n m r – n t t q n m m ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‰ Š z — n q n r n j
Œ

p   j ~ z   o k  t t n j w   u j p j  z s    j k l   j m t   m p j o   n j r

n t w ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‰ Š ”  n p j      o j r   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  j n x r  u m n o n

 n m o  m  k k  q   j o o       z o  v k n t t j r  j n x r  u m  s  j  

  o o  t j k n l o j  s o n t t  m   n   m  m n k  m p j m   m n t t  r j o   m j r

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r  j o m   k k l  r l   m  o n t t  m k j    m w

    w   j ~  j n x r  u m  o  j s j   j r  n o n   j m  q j m  m  m


 j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~      m n j o m j n   j t j n r  m  j r  j
i

u   k  n m n  l  k  n m  j  m  j p   j ~ k   j o  l k l  j  k k l  o w | m

  z l q  p j o r  u m u n  r  m  j o  n m u  o j r   j k   m  m o  r j  j

 n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   o z   o n   l j r  n o   k x {   v p   j ~

t n r j  n o o n  j w t  u q  q j m l q  j    m r j p j t   o n  p j  j  

 m j  n k   m k n m k n l o j p   j ~  j n x r  u m w   q j  j n t w ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‘ Š
i

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ s   q s t  u      m n  m  s   q  j k n o  m 

o l r  j r  j  m j  n k   m j u j j m t  m   l r  m n t p    k j o n m r m   q n t

 l m r n   t n  j  w  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n l  t r o l   q q j r  n j t 
i

n m r  t  ˜ l j o   k x o w  j       o j r k   j   n s    j  k k l   j m k j
i

r  u m o  j n q  s  j  n o o n  j o   k x n m r n  p j  j k   j p   j ~ w

 s p   j ~  j n x r  u m s   q  j   o l r  w | m n    k n t  n m o  m  k

  o n  j n q    n j o  u n  r  j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j t n r j  n o o n  j
i

k  q   j o o   m j n   j o n t t k  m r    m z  j   k   j p   j ~  o

n o  j s t  u  n j  o r j k  j n o j r w  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n   j p j m o
i

 t  ˜ l j   j  n o o n  j o   k x n m r  j o u   t  m j m o    s  j k   j

 m k  q  m  s t  u s   q  n o o  m     l    j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j

       
   

1 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


p   j ~ o j j q o   u j n x s   p   j ~  j n x r  u m n o j r  m  j  j x j  r j o   m  n  n q j j  o  s  j     n  j   p j m  m n t j w
i i

k   j   n      o j r    q j  j n t w ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‘ Š w | m  j   j o j m o l r  z  j     u n o o u j  s   u n  r l o  m    k    r n   j t  m  n m r
i i

 j j  n p     s  j   k t j n  n m k j k   j p   j ~  m  j k l   j m     n m  j m  n t t j n m  m  j r   j k   m  s   n   m w  j r j o   m
i

u n o o l r  j r s   o   r j m  s  n m   j n x v l  r l   m  o n t t w – j k n l o j    k j r l  j u n o  r j m  k n t   n l o j r  r j o   m l m o u j      o

m   j n x l   s  j   k t j n  n m k j k   j p   j ~  k k l   j r z  j      m n m r  o   j o j m j r  œ n r  n n m r n u ‡ ˆ ˆ ‰ Š w  j     u n o
Πi

 s t  k x n  j m j n   j k n o  m  r l   m  o n t t u n o s l   j  j ~ n q  m j r w j o j r n  j   q   j o o   j   r  m n q  k “ j o j n  k  n   n   
Œ

–    j n m r | o q n j t ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š n m r  n  n m r “ n j ‡ ‘ ’ ’ Š †  “ ” n œ      n j  o  m   ›   k j – n o j † œ  › – ” w ž j n  t o
Œ

o l r  j r o n t t  m k j    m  m  n m o  m  k k  q   j o o       o  s  j o j l  z  m o  l q j m n   m z n m r j ~  j   q j m n t l m k j  n  m  j o n  j

m l q j   k n t t  w  j n m r | o q n j t ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š k n t k l t n j r   l  s ‰ ‹ t n r j r j o k   j r  n u n m r œ n r  n ‡ ˆ ˆ ‰ Š w  ~  j   q j m n t
Œ

 n o o n  j o  s …  ™ o “    ‰ •  o  q l t n j   n  m  o n t t  m o  l q j m n   m  m k t l r j r s t  u q j n o l  j q j m o n  j o n  j  m t j

 m k j    m w  n  n m r “ n j ‡ ‘ ’ ’ Š  j  s   q j r s l t t v n m m l t l o n m r j ~  z  m o  l q j m n   m s    n t   j o o l  j n m r  n t j q  j  n l  j

k n t k l t n   m o   m p j o   n j o n t t  m k j    m  m n q  r j  m     v   v n  j r  u m o  j n q o n   t j n r  m  j r  j z n m r o j n r  n m r r  m n q  k

o  j j r  n m o  m  k k  q   j o o       w –    s  j o j o  q l t n   m o   j o o l  j q j n o l  j q j m o n t  m   j     k n o  m  w “     l m m  m 

l o j r  j t n  p j t  k  n  o j k  q  l n   m n t    r o  n k k  q q  r n j  j  q j   n m r q j n o l  j r   k t j n  n m k j  s ’ w ’ ‘  m k  j o n  j l o j r s  

q l t  v  n o o n  j l m o j n r  p  o k  l o s t  u o  q l t n   m o š  j  j s   j z  j m l q j   k n t n m n t  o  o w  j  j s   j z r j s t j k   m o  s  j    
i

r j n  t j r s t  u o  l k l  j o  m o  r j  j k n o  m   l m r n   t n  j  u j  j  j  q j   n  l m m  m  o  j j r u j  j     j  t  n k k  l m j r s    m  j

m  s l t t   j o  t p j r w   u j p j  z   o l r  j o  j p j n t j r  n  j o n t t m l q j   k n t o  q l t n   m o w

   k j o o  m n m  o  t n j r  n m o  m  k k  q   j o o        o r  s s j  j m

 „   g € h  )  g ‚ h  ƒ „ g    ƒ h ‚   „  € ‚   )

s   q  n  m n o l o  m  k k  q   j o o       w | m n m  o  t n j r

¢
g € ƒ

 n m o  m  k k  q   j o o       z  j  n o o n  j o   k x o l    j o o j o

 j n r  n m r l m o j n r  z   j j v r  q j m o   m n t z “ j  m  t r o v

l  o  j n q     n  n   m  s s t  u r  o l  n m k j o m j n   j    l o  r j

n p j  n  j r … n p  j  v   x j o j ˜ l n   m o u j  j o  t p j r   n  m o j n r 

 j u n t t  l m r n   t n  j  o w o n  j o l t z p n   n   m o  m s t  u

n m r l m o j n r  s t  u s  j t r o n p n    l o   j  n  m  k  m r    m o w

o  l k l  j j u j j m t n r j  n o o n  j o n  j t j o o    m  l m k j r  m o n t t j r

m o j n r  o  t l   m o u j  j l o j r   r j m  s  q  p j q j m  s  j  
£

 n m o  m  k     o  n m  m o n t t j r o l o  m  k     o w ›    j   j o j m

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ n o n t j   j  n  m  k  m r    m o n m r   n  m

o l r  z n o  m  t j v  n o o n  j s t  u o  q l t n   m  o l o j r  o l r   j

 m o n m n m j  l o s t  u o  l k l  j o r l   m  o n t t  m k j    m w

 m j  n k   m j u j j m  j   k t j n  n m k j k   j p   j ~ n m r  j

| m  j k l   j m o l r  z  j   p j  m  m  j ˜ l n   m o n  j o  t p j r

 n o o n  j o   k x w œ   t j n o  m  t j v  n o o n  j s t  u n m n t  o  o k n m m 

u   n   j o o l  j v n o j r  q  t  k  q j   r l o  m  n s l t t  k  m o j  p n  p j

o  q l t n j n o  q q j   k s j n l  j o  s  j s t  u  m  j o n t t j r

k  m   t p  t l q j n     n k  w q  r  s  j r u  v j ˜ l n   m l  l t j m k j

k  m r    m z  k n m j l o j r  j ~ n q  m j r j n  t j r j  n p     s  j  

q  r j t  o n   t  j r s   l  l t j m k j k t  o l  j w    r v   r j  n k k l  n j

k t j n  n m k j k   j p   j ~ n m r  o  m j  n k   m u    j  n o o n  j o   k x

 m j    t n   m o k  j q j  o l o j r s    j o  n  n t r  o k  j  y n   m  s

r l   m  o n t t n  n m o  m  k   j  n  m  k  m r    m o w

k  m p j k   m j  q o n m r k j m  n t r  s s j  j m k  m   o l o j r s   r  s s l o   m

 j k  m k j   s n o u j   n m o  m  k      n o j j m  m   r l k j r
i

j  q o w  j q j   r  o  s o j k  m r v   r j  o  n  n t n k k l  n k   m
i

 m  j r j o   m  s     t  t  n r j r z     v    l   v s t  u z  n m o  m  k

o q    t  p n    m     r o w ›    q j v r j  j m r j m j  q o z n m  q  t  k 

k  q   j o o   o   j n  m n j   r  m n q  k j s s  k  j m k  n m r   j  n  m 

o j k  m r v   r j  o k  j q j  o l o j r n m r n m l q j   s o l v  j  n   m o n  j

 n m  j u    j  m k  j n o  m        o  j j r † s   j ~ n q  t j z

 j  s   q j r n j n k   q j o j  w   j p   l o o l r  j o l o  m   j k l   j m

œ j m m j  o   q n m r  l j  n l   ‡ ˆ  Ž Š ” w –   q j n o l  j q j m o n m r

m l q j   k n t k  r j  m r  k n j  n n j   r  m n q  k t  o o j o  m n    k n t

m l q j   k n t o l r  j o  n p j o   u m  n n s   u n  r v o u j       n o n

 n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   n  j   j r  k j r u j t t j m  l   s   j m   m j j   m 

t n   j  o n t t q n    m n m r     j  j s s  k  j m k   n m n o  q  t n   n r  n t t 

 l  r n m k j  m r j o   m n   t  k n   m o w t o  z  j ˜ l n t  n  p j o n t t  n m  j

o n k x j r     † œ n r  n j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š z  n  j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ  Š ” w ž j n  t j r

 o k n t k l t n j r  j n o  m n t  u j t t u    j m l q j   k n t k  r j w ž j n  t o

o l r  j o  s j m r u n t t s t  u o  l k l  j o  m o u j  k  q   j o o       o

 s  j k l   j m q j   r n m r n   t  k n   m o   n m o  m  k s t  u o n  j

  j  n  m  m j n  o n t t  n p j m   j j j m  j    j r w

  p j m   n  n m r œ j m m j  o   q ‡ ˆ ˆ Š w

 j    q n    Ÿ j k  p j o  s  j k l   j m u   x n  j n o s  t t  u o }
i

 j k  q  l n   m n t    r  o o   u m  m ›   w w o  m  t j t n r j
i

w   m p j o   n j r j n  t j r s t  u o  l k l  j o  m  j j m r u n t t
i

 n o o n  j k  m o  o o  s ˆ  m  r j o  m  j t n r j v  v t n r j r   j k   m z

 j    m z  m k t l r  m   m j  n k   m o j u j j m  j   k t j n  n m k j

• • m  r j o  m  j o  n m u  o j r   j k   m z n m r ‘  ’ m  r j o  m  j

s t  u z  n o o n  j o   k x z n m r t n r j  l m r n   t n  j  o w

o  j n q u  o j r   j k   m w  j       k t j n  n m k j  j  q j    o
i

‘ w  j ~ n q  m j  j j  n p     s  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r l   m 
i

n k k l  n j t   j   j o j m j r  ‘  m  r j o  m t n r j v  v t n r j r   j k   m z

o n t t  m k j    m w

‰ ’ m  r j o  m  j o  n m u  o j r   j k   m z  ¤ m  r j o  m  j o  j n q u  o j

‰ w   j k  q q j m r s l l  j  j o j n  k  j s s   o  m k  m   t t  m 
i

r   j k   m w  j | v    r    t     o l o j r   j r l k j    r o x j u m j o o z
i

j m r u n t t s t  u j  n p     m  n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   o w

n m r n o  m  t j v t  k x    r  o l o j r s    j q n  m  n o o n  j n m r  j  

  ‚ g ¡  g ƒ .  ¡   g ‚ ‚ g

k t j n  n m k j w

›   l  j o   u o n   j j v r  q j m o   m n t p  j u  s  j s   u n  r v
 n m r n  r  l m r n   k  m r    m o s    o  t n j r     s t  u u j  j

o u j       m p j o   n j r  m  j k l   j m o l r  w  j     u n o
i n   t  j r n  j  l m r n   j o  s  j k  q  l n   m n t r  q n  m w …  m v

r j o   m j r   q    p j  j  j  s   q n m k j  s n m n t  j n r  u j t t v
 j s t j k  m   l m r n   k  m r    m o u j  j n   t  j r n  j  m t j n m r  j

r j o   m j r  n r  n t t  o n k x j r        l   n j   r  m n q  k o u j j  w
j ~  w  j    r  k   k  m r    m o u j  j n   t  j r n  j  j    r  k

‘        
   

2 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


o l  s n k j o z n m r m  v o t   k  m r    m o u j  j l o j r  m o  t  r u n t t o w

§ ¨ © ª « ¬ ­ ® ¯ ¬ ® ­ ° ª ± ¬ ² ³ ° ­ © ´ ± µ ¶ ¨ ° · ­ · ¸ ¯ °

  o  t n j j s s j k o  s   k t j n  n m k j s t  u  m o n t t  m k j    m z n
  j p   l o o l r      j m  n p j  j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š o   u j r  n n  q j i

s t  u s  j t r u   y j     k t j n  n m k j u n o  m p j o   n j r s   o w
o j   s ’ w ’ ’ ’ ‘ ¤ o j k w u n o m j k j o o n    k n  l  j o   k x q    m  m n

t   l    j   k t j n  n m k j u n o j s s j k  p j t  o j  y j   z  j k n o  m 
o  q  t n   n m o  m  k     w ›    j   j o j m o l r  z  j l m o j n r 

 j q n  m j r o n   m n   u    j t n  p j q    m j u j j m  j     n m r
m n l  j  s  j s t  u      m n j o    q n   t  s   q  j  m j  n k   m  s

 j k n o  m  w ›   l  j o ¤ n m r ‹ o   u  n k  m l q j  k  m  l  o n m r
 j o   k x u    j t n r j  l m r n   t n  j  n m r  j  j o l t  m  p   j ~

p j t  k   p j k   o m j n   j t j n r  m  j r  j n  j m j n  v o n t t   j  n  m 
o  j r r  m  w  j  j s   j z n  q j o j   s ’ w ’ ’ ’ ’ ‘ ¤ o j k w u n o l o j r s  
i

k  m r    m w  j  j o l t o o   u  n  j  l m r n   t n  j   m  j t n r j
n t t l m o j n r  s t  u o  q l t n   m o w i

o l k   m o l  s n k j o j  n  n j o r  u m o  j n q  s  j  n o o n  j o   k x w

h ‚    g €  ‚  ¡ € ¥     „ g  ƒ ƒ  

   m  k   o o s t  u s   q  j o l k   m o l  s n k j   j   j o o l  j

 j n o l  j r n m r k n t k l t n j r      j  s   q n m k j q n  o n  j

o l  s n k j  q q j r  n j t  r  u m o  j n q  s  j o   k x  j o l t o  m

  j o j m j r  m ›   w ‘ w  n t k l t n   m o u j  j  j  s   q j r u    j

o j  n  n   m  s  j j m r u n t t  l m r n   t n  j  w   m o j ˜ l j m t  z  j

m  q  m n t   k t j n  n m k j n m r u   y j     k t j n  n m k j w r r    m n t

s t  u  m k  r j m k j m j n   j t j n r  m  j r  j  m k  j n o j o r  n o  k n t t  w

k n t k l t n   m o u j  j  j  s   q j r m j n   j o n t t k  m r    m s   n  n   n t

  j p   l o o l r  j o  m k  q   j o o   o n t t   j m  q j m n † s   j ~ n q  t j z

k t j n  n m k j k n o j u   m  q  m n t k t j n  n m k j  m  j s   u n  r Ž ’ ¦

“ n j n m r  n  ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‘ Š ”  m r  k n j  n o n t t  m   n j o u  j m  

k    r n m r y j   k t j n  n m k j  m  j n s ‹ ’ ¦ k    r w   q  n  j r 

k t j n  n m k j s t  u o   t t o  m   j n r Ÿ n k j m t n r j  n o o n  j s   q  j

 j q j n o l  j q j m o z  j   j o j m m l q j   k n t    k j r l  j k n t k l t n j o n

  j o o l  j o  r j n  j t j n r  m  j r  j w  j  j o l t o  m ›   w ‹ n o   u
i

o t    t      j    j o o l  j   o j n m r n o t    t  t  u j  n r  n n  k

 n     s t  u  m k  r j m k j  j o l t o s   q o   m  k   o o s t  u

j s s  k  j m k  s    j k l   j m k  q   j o o   w  j q j n o l  j r    
i

r  u m o  j n q  s  j  n o o n  j o   k x u  j  j  j j m r u n t t  l m r n  

k  n  n k j   o  k o n  j r j   p j r s   q q j n o l  j q j m o r  u m o  j n q  s

t n  j  o j  n  n j o n m r n t n   j t  k x n  j  o s   q j r w “ j o l t o  m ›   w ‹

 j o n   w …  n j q  o u j  j q n r j   n  m j j  n   j j q j m

n t o   m r  k n j  n  j  m k  j n o j  m s t  u  m k  r j m k j  o t n   j o m j n 

u    j q j n o l  j q j m o w   j p   l o o l r  j o  m n o  q  t n     

 j j m r u n t t n m r  n o n t t  m   n j o p j   k t  o j   j k n o  m  z m 

†    j m  n p j  j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ ‹ Š ” o   u j r  n  j k l   j m m l q j   k n t

n u n  s   q  j k n o  m  w

   k j r l  j  j   j o j m o q j n o l  j r s t  u k  n  n k j   o  k o u j t t j m  l  

s     o   j  s  m p j o   n   m w œ   y j   k t j n  n m k j z  j j s s  k  j m k  § ¨ © ª « ¬ ­ ® ¯ ¬ ® ­ ° ª ± ¬ ² ¹ © º ± ¸ · ¨ ´ ± µ ¶ ¨ ° · ­ · ¸ ¯ °

›   l  j • o   u o j m     k  m  l  o  m o j p j  n t n ~  n t  t n m j o n

 m k  j n o j o  n  l w ‘ ¦ w   o r  s s j  j m k j  o k t  o j   j s  m r  m  o
i

  j j   j  n  m  k  m r    m o w   j j v r  q j m o   m n t  n k j o  s  j  
i
 s w  w  q   ‡ ˆ • ’ Š n m r n   j j o u   n   j p   l o o l r   m  j
Œ

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ n  j n t o  o   u m w  j   p   j ~  n k j o n  j
i

j s s j k o  s   k t j n  n m k j  m  j  j  s   q n m k j  s n  n m o  m  k

s   q j r   j t j n o  m   n   k t j o s   q  j  j    m ¦ k    r

k  q   j o o       †    j m  n p j  j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ ‹ Š ” w t o  u   y j  

r  u m o  j n q  s  j t j n r  m  j r  j n m r ¤ ¦ m   q n t  y j r  

k t j n  n m k j z  j o n t t q n    m  m k  j n o j o  n  l ‘ ’ ¦ w ž  s s j  j m k j o

k t j n  n m k j n  p j  j t n r j   w  j   k t j n  n m k j p    k j o n  j
i
 m j s s  k  j m k  n m r o n t t q n    m j u j j m  j y j   k t j n  n m k j n m r

q n  m n  m j r n m r o  v k n t t j r p   j ~  j n x r  u m  o m   o j  p j r z

 j m  q  m n t k t j n  n m k j k n o j o  j   j o j m  j m j j s s j k o  s  

j p j m n  j  m v o n t t   j  n  m  k  m r    m w n    l o   j p   l o o l r  j o


k t j n  n m k j w  j  n   n t   k t j n  n m k j k n o j j ~    o n m  m k  j n o j  m
i

† s   j ~ n q  t j z  k  t j k    j q n m r  j y j   k  ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š z   s s q n m m
Œ

o n t t q n    m  s n  l ¤ ¦ u   m   m k  j n o j  m j s s  k  j m k  w

n m r – n t t q n m m ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‰ Š z — n q n r n j n t w ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‰ Š ”  n p j  m r  k n j r  n

›    j m  q  m n t k t j n  n m k j k n o j z  j m j n  v o n t t   j  n  m 

  k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  j n x r  u m  k k l  o u  j m  j   k t j n  n m k j

   m k    j o   m r o   j     j o n k x   j o o l  j n u   k  n o n t j z

p   j ~  m j  n k o u    j  n o o n  j o   k x n m j n  v o n t t k  m r    m o w

o j n r  z m l q j   k n t o  t l   m k n m j  n  m j r u   n s  ~ j r j ~ 

| u n o  m r   j k t   q  t  j r  n p   j ~  j n x r  u m k n l o j o o n t t

o n  k   j o o l  j w   r j m  s   j m j n  v o n t t   j  n  m  k  m r    m z
i

 m k j    m  m  j    m p j o   n   m o  m  n m o  m  k s t  u  m n  n r  n t t 

 j n k x   j o o l  j u n o  m k  j n o j r   m k  j q j m o  s ’ w ’  o  m j n 

o n k x j r     † …  ™ o “    ‰ • ” w  j  j o l t o  m ›   w • r  m 
i

 j o n t t t  q  l m  t n o  t l   m k  l t r m  t  m  j  j  n  m j r w 
i

o   u o  q  t n  j  n p     s  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r l   m  o n t t

l m r j  o n m r k  n m  j o  m s t  u o  l k l  j r l   m   j o n t t    k j o o z n m

 m k j    m w  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~      m n j o m j n   j t j n r  m 
i

l m o j n r  k n t k l t n   m u n o  j  s   q j r u   n  n  o j r n k x   j o o l  j w

j r  j s   q  m j  n k   m j u j j m  j  m k  q  m  s t  u n m r s t  u

m  m o n m n m j  l o o  t l   m s   q   o k n t k l t n   m  o  r j m  s  j r  m

k  q  m   p j   j t n r j   w o  j t n r j t  n r  m   m k  j n o j o z  j

›   w ‘ n o n m  m v o n t t k  m r    m w › l   j  l m o j n r  k n t k l t n   m o

  j o o l  j   n r  j m  p j   j    m k  j n o j o n m r  j   p   j ~ q  p j o

u j  j n t o   j  s   q j r n  j m j n  v o n t t k  m r    m   m p j o   n j  j

s l   j  n u n  s   q  j t n r j n s j  s   q n   m n  j t j n r  m  j r  j w

l m o j n r  m n l  j  s  m j  n k   m o j u j j m  j   k t j n  n m k j s t  u z

 j   k t j n  n m k j k   j p   j ~ n t o  q  p j o  n r  n t t   m u n  r n o 
i

 j  n o o n  j o   k x z n m r  j t n r j  l m r n   t n  j  o w

q  p j o r  u m o  j n q w    Ÿ j k   m  s  j   k t j n  n m k j p    k j o

 j n o l  j r n m r k n t k l t n j r  q j v n p j  n  j r   j o o l  j k  m  l  o

 m  n m n ~  n t k   o o  t n m j  o o   u m  m ›   w  s   n t t   j j

 m  j k n o  m  s    j m  q  m n t k t j n  n m k j k n o j n  j k  q  n  j r  m

  j  n  m  k  m r    m o w  j t n k x k   k l t n  n  k n  p j  j  n k j o
i

›   o w ‰ n m r Ž w  j  j o l t o  m r  k n j  n  j m l q j   k n t    k j r l  j
i

 j   j o j m o  j q n k   m j k n o  m  w  j p    k j o      m n j n  j
i
k n t k l t n j o  j  p j  n t t s t  u o  l k l  j k    j k t  n r  s s j  j m s t  u

t n r j t j n r  m  j r  j  m  j t j s n m r     n  n j  m  j

k  m r    m o w  j  j s   j z m l q j   k n t o  t l   m o n r  s s j  j m   j  n  m 
i

k   k l q s j  j m  n t r   j k   m   j     w o n t t z  j   p   j ~

k  m r    m o k n m j n m n t  y j r  m r j n  t  o l r   j   t j o  s  j  

q  p j o  n r  n t t   m u n  r q   j  n m n  j n x j s s  k  j m k  w

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ n m r  j  n o o n  j o   k x  m o n t t  m k j    m s    j

  j o j m s   u n  r v o u j      w

‰        
   

3 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


›   l  j ˆ o   u o j m     k  m  l  o n  j t n r j   n m r n t j n r  m  j r  j   j o   k x t j  q  p j o  n r  n t t  r  u m u n  r n m r

ˆ ‹ ¦ o  n m z n t  m  u     k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  n k j o w    u o o n  o u    m  j t n r j  n o o n  j w   q j  s  j s t l  r n q  r v  n 

 r j m  s  t  u q  q j m l q  j    m o m j n   j k n o  m  z n o o  k  n j r u   s   q  j o   k x t j    j  n  t  m  j r  j  n o o j o    l    j  

    j m     w o o   u m  m ›   o w • n m r ˆ z  j n  j n o u   t  u k t j n  n m k j  s  j n r Ÿ n k j m t n r j z  j o l t  m   m o  v k n t t j r r  l t j

q  q j m l q s t l  r n  j m  r   j k t   j t n j r   j  n Ÿ j k     s  j t j n x n  j w ›    j k l   j m s   u n  r v o u j      z s   q n   m  s  j

  k t j n  n m k j p    k j o w t  u q  q j m l q n  j n m j n   j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j t n r j m j n   j

›   l  j ’ o   u o p j t  k   p j k   o k  t   j r   n k  m l q j  k n o  m  n m r  j  j o l t  m  t n   j t  k x n  j n  j m  k n l o j r   j

n  j t n r j   n t  m  u     k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  n k j o s   n t t  j n x r  u m  s  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ w

  j j   j  n  m  k  m r    m o w ž  s s j  j m k j o  m  j   k t j n  n m k j

§ ¨ © ª « ¬ ­ ® ¯ ¬ ® ­ ° ª ± ¬ ² » · ­ ¬ ± · ¨ ´ ± µ ¶ ¨ ° · ­ · ¸ ¯ °

p   j ~  n k j o n m r p j t  k   s  j t r o m j n   j t j n r  m  j r  j n

 j ~ n q  m j  j      m n m r  j  m s t l j m k j  s  j o   m  k   o o
i

r  s s j  j m   j  n  m  k  m r    m o n  j k t j n  t   t t l o  n j r  m ›   w ’ w

s t  u n   o  m  s   q  j  m j  n k   m  s  j  n o o n  j o   k x n m r  j

o n t t z t  x j  j y j   k t j n  n m k j s t  u s  j t r n o n t t z n o   m  k   o o

t n r j o l k   m o l  s n k j z n s t  u s  j t r u   y j     k t j n  n m k j  m  j

s t  u r j p j t   o u  j  j  j  n o o n  j o   k x  m j  n k o u    j t n r j

n s ‹ ’ ¦  s  j k    r u n o m l q j   k n t t  o  q l t n j r w | m ›   w ‰ z

 l m r n   t n  j  w   o k   o o s t  u o j j q o  k n    t  u q  q j m l q
i

 n k  m l q j  k  m  l  o z  n   k t j  n k j o s    j   k t j n  n m k j

s t l  r s   q  j l  o  j n q j m r u n t t  l m r n   t n  j  w   o
i

p   j ~ z n m r  n k j o s    j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n n  j o   u m s    j

n k k l q l t n   m  s t  u q  q j m l q s t l  r  m k  j n o j o s t  u t  k x n  j

m j n  v o n t t k  m r    m w   q  l j r p j t  k   p j k   o n  j t n r j  

m j n   j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j t j n r  m  j r  j n m r   j p j m o

o j k   m n  j o   u m  m ›   w Ž w – j k n l o j  j    n   o y j   u  j  j

 m k  q  m  s t  u s   q j m j   m   j  n o o n  j  m  n  j    m z n o

 j  n o o n  j o   k x  m j  n k o u    j o l k   m o l  s n k j z m   n   k t j o

o   u m  m ›   w ’ k w j t  k   p j k   o m j n   j t j n r  m  j r  j  m


k n m s t  u  p j   j t n r j    u n  r  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n w

›   w ’ k o   u  n   k t j n  n m k j s t  u o   t t o  m   j n r Ÿ n k j m

  u j p j  z o   m  k   o o s t  u o  t t r j p j t   o n o  m  j y j  

t n r j  n o o n  j s   q  j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j t j n r  m  j r  j r l j 

k t j n  n m k j k n o j n m r s t  u  n   k t j o s   q  j l  o  j n q j m r u n t t

 j t  k x n  j  s   o t  u q  q j m l q n  j n w

 l m r n   t n  j  n k k l q l t n j  k  j n j  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n w

j q  o u j  j q n r j   n k j l  o  j n q  s  m r  j      m o  s

o o   u m  m  j      j  s   q n m k j q n  o  s ›   w ‘ z  j  n   n t

 j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n o w ›   l  j o   u o k n t k l t n j r  n k 

t  k x n  j  s  j    n  j ~ j m r o  j   j  n  m   n m  j  s  j    

m l q j  k  m  l  o n ˆ ‹ ¦ o  n m n m r n  j t n r j   o j k   m n  j

o  q j u  n u    l n m   m k  j n o j  m j s s  k  j m k  z u   k   m r  k n j o

o n t t k  m r    m w   j j v r  q j m o   m n t  n   k t j  n k j o †  m t l j ” u j  j
i

 n q  o  s  j  m s t l j m k j  s  j    n  s t  u  o r l j   j

 j t j n o j r s   q  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n o n   o j o  n m u  o j

     m  m  j s   u n  r  n   s  j t n r j w

t  k n   m o n m r  n k j r   l  o  j n q n m r r  u m o  j n q w o o   u m

 m ›   w z  j n k k l q l t n   m  s  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n  o m 

¼ ½ ½ ½
¯ ± ¨ ¨ · ¬ ± © ¸ © ¾ » · · ¿ ° « ² © ¯ À · ¸ Á ´ ± µ ¶ ¨ ° · ­ · ¸ ¯ ° Â © ­ ¬ ° Ã

 j  j o l t  s n m   j n x r  u m  s  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ w | m o  q j

  j p   l o o l r  j o † s   j ~ n q  t j z    j m  n p j  j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ • Š ”

n m  j m  n t t  k n   m o z  j j m r u n t t  l m r n   t n  j  j ~ j m r o m j n  t 

 n p j o   u m  n  j  n o o n  j o   k x  o k  t t n j o  p j  n o q l k  n o

¤ ¦  s  j t n r j o  n m  m   j s t  u s  j t r z n o o   u m  m ›   w • w  j
i

‘ ¦  s  j t n r j k    r  m n o  q  t n   n m o  m  k k  q   j o o   w   j  x j

t  u q  q j m l q n  j n n ˆ ‹ ¦ o  n m  o s   q j r  s t l  r k  q  m 

j n t w ‡ ˆ ˆ Ž Š n t o  q j n o l  j r l m o j n r  q  p j q j m  s n  

s   q  j l  o  j n q k n o  m   l m r n   t n  j  w   o s t l  r q  p j o
i

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  m  j   j ~  j   q j m n t o l r   s n t  u o  j j r

 n r  n t t   m u n  r n m r u  n  o n   l m r  j k   j p   j ~ m j n   j o   k x

n ~  n t  l q  w | m  j k l   j m o l r  z l m o j n r  k n t k l t n   m o u   n

o l  s n k j w o o   u m  m ›   w n z   o s t l  r k  n m  j o s t  u r   j k   m

 q j o j   s ’ w ’ ’ ’ ’ ‘ ¤ o j k w u j  j  j  s   q j r s    j m  q  m n t  

o  n   t  n   l m r  j k   j p   j ~ w … j  n  p j n ~  n t p j t  k  

k t j n  n m k j n  j m j n  v o n t t k  m r    m w ›   l  j ¤ o   u o  n k 

k  q   m j m o n  j k  q q  m t   o j  p j r n   o o  n m w  n k j o s   q
i

m l q j  k  m  l  o n m r  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ n   j j r  s s j  j m

 j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n n  j t n r j   o j k   m o   u  n  j

 m o n m o  m  q j w  j  n o o n  j o   k x k n m j o j j m   o k  t t n j r l j
i

t  u q  q j m l q n  j n  o s   q j r  s t l  r  n k   o o j o  j t n r j  

  j  m j  n k   m j u j j m  j  n o o n  j o   k x n m r  j t n r j

n  l Ž ’ v ¤ ’ ¦ k    r s   q  j t j n r  m  j r  j w   o s t l  r  n o o j o
i

 l m r n   t n  j  z n m r n m   j o l t  m  p   j ~ o  j r r  m  w o  j o   k x

 p j   j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ n m r  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n  o

 o k  t t n j o z  j k   o o s t  u      m n  m  n  j o   k x t j  n t o 

s   q j r m j n   j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j t n r j j   m r  j  

 o k  t t n j o n m r  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ k  n m  j o  o  n Ÿ j k    w

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ w   o s t l  r n t o  s  t t  u o  j k   o o s t  u
i

  u j p j  z  j k   j p   j ~ r  j o m   j n x r  u m w  j s t  u
i

r   j k   m  o j  p j r n  j t n r j    m ›   w ’ k w  j  j    m o u  
i

l m o j n r  m j o o  o j  p j r m j n   j o n t t k  m r    m  m   o  n m o  m  k

t  u q  q j m l q s t l  r  m o  r j  j k n o  m   l m r n   t n  j  n  j

     o m  r l j   j  j n x r  u m  s  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ w

s   q j r    q n   t  u   s t l  r s   q  j l  o  j n q k n o  m   l m r n  

 j l m o j n r  m j o o  m  j k l   j m k  q   j o o        o q n  m t  r l j
i

t n  j  n m r  n   k t j o k   o o  m   p j   j    n  r  u m o  j n q  s  j

 o   k x {  l m r n   v t n  j   m j  n k   m n m r n m   j o l t  m  p   j ~

t j n r  m  j r  j w ›   l  j ‘ o   u o  j  p j  n t t o  l k l  j  s  j  

o  j r r  m  w Ä  n l o j ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‘ Š n m r   q j  j n t w ‡ ‘ ’ ’ ‘ Š k  m k t l r j r
i

k t j n  n m k j s t  u n  j o n t t k  m r    m u    n   k t j  n k j o  j t j n o j r

 n  j s   q n   m  s n o n  m n   m    m  o  j ˜ l   j r s    j  m o j

s   q   j j  n r  n t t  k n   m o  m  j    n  w  j   k   j p   j ~  o
i

 s o t j m r j  p   j ~  j n x r  u m w ›   q  j   o l r  z  o j j q o  n  j

s   q j r  s t l  r      m n  m  m j n   j t j n r  m  j r  j  s  j t n r j

  k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ o   l t r  m j  n k u   n m   q n t o   k x s  

  o j k   m w › t l  r      m n  m  m j n   j  n o o n  j o   k x t j   m  j

p   j ~  j n x r  u m   k k l  w o o   u m  m   o o l r  z  j  

t n r j o l k   m o  r j m j n   j    n p j t o n  p j  j k   j p   j ~ n m r

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  m j  n k o u   n m  t  ˜ l j o   k x  m    j

s   q o  j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n w   o  s  j s t l  r s   q  j

Ž        
   

4 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


t n r j v  v t n r j n m r o  n m u  o j r   j k   m o w   o q    k  m   l j    j m  n p j  z œ w œ w z  n   j u z  w “ w z  n  z  w z n m r œ n r  n z w “ w z
i

  j s n k  n  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r  j o m   j n x r  u m s   ˆ ˆ ‹ z É  j  s s j k o  s    t j n  n m k j  m n  u j   n m o  m  k
i i i

 j k l   j m     z j p j m r l   m   j j n  t  o n t t  m   n   m    k j o o w   q   j o o   “    z Ê     l  m n t  s l   q n k   m j   z  t w
Æ i 

 z   w ‘ ‰ ’ v ‘ ‰ ˆ w

¢
h ‚  h ) „ ƒ €  g    g Å 

ž j n  t j r s t  u s j n l  j o m j n   j k n o  m   m n s   u n  r v o u j 

   j m  n p j  z œ w œ w z  l j  n l   z  w w z  n  z  w z ˆ ˆ • z
Œ

 n m o  m  k k  q   j o o       u j  j o l r  j r u   o j n r  n m r

É m o j n r  › t  u n m r    k x     m  m n  n m o  m  k   q   j o o  
£ i

l m o j n r    j j v r  q j m o   m n t p  o k  l o s t  u n m n t  o j o w  j q n  m
i

“    z Ê |  l  m n t  s     l t o   m n m r   u j  z  t w ‰ z   w
Æ 

 Ÿ j k  p j o  s  j o l r  u j  j  l m r j  o n m r  j   t j o  t n  j r  m

• v ‘ ‰ w

o n t t  m k j    m  s t  u  m j  n k   m o j u j j m  j   k t j n  n m k j

s t  u z  j  n o o n  j o   k x z n m r  j t n r j n m r j m r u n t t  l m r n  

 n  z  w z    j m  n p j  z œ w œ w z  l j  n l   z  w w z n m r œ n r  n z w
Œ

t n  j  o w  j s  t t  u  m  k  m k t l o   m o u j  j r  n u m w
i

“ w z ˆ ˆ  z É   m   t  s    k x   l k l  j n m r  j k  m r n   › t  u

›  j t r | m o  r j  n m o  m  k   q   j o o   “    o    l  
i i

w  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ z u   k   o s   q j r  s t l  r k   o o  m 
i

j   r  m n q  k  u j j  z Ê     n  j  ˆ  v È v ¤ ‹ w
i

 j    n  p j   k t  o j  j t j n r  m  j r  j z q  p j o n u n  s   q

 j o l k   m o  r j n m r  n r  n t t   m u n  r n o  j       j  n j o

 n  z  n m r  j t t n k  z w z ˆ ˆ ˆ z É ž j p j t   q j m  s  l    m j 
Œ Æ

k t  o j    j o n t t k  m r    m

 n t t n m r  o | m s t l j m k j  m  j  j  s   q n m k j  s ~  n t   q   j o o  

‘ w  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r  j o m   j n x r  u m z j p j m s  
i

– t n r j “  u o z Ê     l  m n t  s l   q n k   m j   z  t w ‘ z …  w
Æ i 

      j  n   m  m  j o n t t j r k  m r    m w

z   w ‹ • v • • w

‰ w t  u q  q j m l q n  j n  k k l  o  q q j r  n j t  r  u m o  j n q  s

 j  n o o n  j o   k x n m r p j   k t  o j   j k n o  m  w  j  
i

 n  z  w n m r “ n j z ž w  w z ‘ ’ ’ z É “  t j  s    t j n  n m k j › t  u o
i

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  n o o j o l m r j    o t  u q  q j m l q n  j n w

 m › t  u | m o n  t    m ~  n t › t  u   q   j o o   o z Ê |  –   n  j 

 j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n  o s   q j r u   s t l  r s   q  j
i

‘ ’ ’ v ‘ ‘ ‰ w

l  o  j n q j m r u n t t  l m r n   t n  j  n m r  o t  k n j r q l k 

k t  o j    j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j t n r j  n m  o  j  

 n  z  w n m r œ j m m j  o   q z w w z ˆ ˆ z É   j j v ž  q j m o   m n t
Æ i

k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ w  j s   q n   m  s   o t  u q  q j m l q
i

› t  u ›  j t r o | m o  r j n  n m o  m  k   q   j o o   u    u j 
i

 j    m  o m  r   j k t   j t n j r   j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~  

– t n r j o z Ê     l  m n t  s l   q n k   m j   z  t w ‰ z …  w z
Æ i 

n m    o o  t j  j n x r  u m  s  j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ w   o
i

  w ‘ Ž v ‘ ¤ w

t  k x n  j n  j n q  p j o s l   j   u n  r  j   j o o l  j o  r j  s  j

t n r j s   m j n  v o n t t   j  n   m w  p j m l n t t  z   o t  k x n  j

 j z w n m r | o q n j t z w Ç w z ˆ ˆ • z É   q  l n   m o  s – t n r j “  u
Œ Æ

s   k j o   k t j n  n m k j s t  u  o   t t  m   j n r Ÿ n k j m t n r j

 n t t | m k j    m  m  n m o  m  k › t  u o z Ê |  –     k j j r  m  o z   w
i

 n o o n  j s   q  j   j o o l  j o  r j z u   k   m   n j o o n t t

‹ ˆ • v • ’ • w

 m k j    m w

Ž w  p j m   l    j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ r  j o m   j n x r  u m z

  s s q n m z œ w  w n m r – n t t q n m z w z ‘ ’ ’ ‰ z É   q j o  j k o  s  
Æ i

 j s t  u s  j t r j k  q j o l m o j n r  r l j  o   k x  o k  t t n   m w

  j ~ – j  n p     m n  n m o  m  k l   k  q   j o o   z Ê |  – 
 i i

 j   k t j n  n m k j p   j ~ o l o j ˜ l j m t   o k  t t n j o z l
i

 n  j  ‘ ’ ’ ‰ v ‘ ‘ ‰ w

u    l n m   j n x r  u m w

¤ w › l   j  o l r  j o n  j m j k j o o n    s  m r u n  o  k  m   t  j

Ä  n l o j z  w z ‘ ’ ’ ‘ z É ~  n t › t  u  m  t j m r j     k j o z Ê    k j j r  m 


s t  u o  l k l  j m j n   j k n o  m  z j o  j k  n t t   j s   q n   m  s

 s ›  s  œ   t r   m   j o o  m   q  l n   m n t  j k  n m  k o w

 j t  u q  q j m l q n  j n z s   j s s  k  j m   j  n   m u   n u  r j

o n t t q n    m w

n u z  w  w n m r œ n r  n z w “ w z ˆ ˆ ‰ z É  u o  j k “ n  
Œ Œ

 n m o  m  k “    o z  n  } – n o j t  m j ž j o   m n m r  j  s   q n m k j z Ê
i

¢
 h Å  ‚ ¡ )  ƒ    

    l  m n t  s l   q n k   m j   z  t w ¤ z   w ‘  v ‘ ‘ ¤ w
Æ i 

 j n l    o u  l t r t  x j  n k x m  u t j r  j  j k  m   l   m  s
i

w  j t t n k   s |  Ç    m   j  n   m   j  t t l o  n   m o w
Æ Œ

“ n j z ž w  w z n m r  n  z  w z ‘ ’ ’ ‘ z É   t  k n   m  s  n o  m 

   k l q s j  j m  n t È    p j o s   | q    p j r  n t t  n    m  m n

g     g   h  

 n m o  m  k ~  n t   q   j o o   z Ê     n  j  È v ‘ ’ ’ ‘ v ‰ ’ ‹ Ž w
i i

r n q k y  x z w w z  j t j o  m n z  w w z n m r È  j  y j  z  w  w z ˆ ˆ ‰ z
Æ Æ Œ

É  j “  t j  s    t j n  n m k j  m     v   j j r › n m  n t t z Ê   
i i

 k  t j k    j q z  w n m r  j y j   k  z  w z ˆ ˆ • z É –  j n x r  u m  s  
Πi

 l  m n t  s l   q n k   m j   z  t w ¤ z   w ‘  v ‰  w
Æ i 

j n x n  j    k j o  m   q   j o o   o n › t  u   m r    m o  t  o j 
Œ 

 n t t z Ê     n  j  ˆ • v È v Ž w
i

   q n z “ w w z ˆ ˆ  z É  n t k l t n   m  s    t j n  n m k j  s s j k o  m n
 i

 n m o  m  k   q   j o o   “    z Ê     l  m n t  s
i Æ

 l r j  z Ä w w z n m r  j t j o  m n z  w w z ˆ ˆ Ž z É  ~  j   q j m n t n m r
Œ Œ

l   q n k   m j   z  t w ‘ ’ z   w ‰ v ‰ ˆ w
i 

  q  l n   m n t | m p j o   n   m  s  j    t j n  n m k j › t  u  m n
i

 n m o  m  k ~  n t   q   j o o   “    z Ê …   v ’ ‹ • w
i i

¤        
   

5 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


  q j  z Ç w z Ä t n o o z  w z  k    j r j  z œ w z n m r Ä  n l o j z  w z ‘ ’ ’ ‘ z œ n r  n z w “ w z  y l k  z  w … w z n m r   n t t z ž w z ˆ ˆ • z É | m m j 
i

É | m j  n k   m j u j j m  m   l r  m n t    k j o n m r …   q n t n m r œ   x  m  o  s j   r  m n q  k  u j j  z Ê     n  j  ˆ • v È v Ž ’ w
Œ  i

Ç t  ˜ l j    k x o z Ê    k j j r  m  o  s ›  s  œ   t r   m   j o o  m

  q  l n   m n t  j k  n m  k o w œ j m m j  o   q z w w n m r  l j  n l    w w z ˆ  Ž z É   j j v
Æ Œ i

ž  q j m o   m n t   r j t s    j   j r  k   m  s    k x  o o j o  m
Œ

n m  n m j z ž w  w z   n y  o n  z w w z œ   r z w “ w z  n  n u n  z  w   q   j o o   – t n r j “  u o z Ê     l  m n t  s  m   m j j   m  s  
 Æ Æ Æ

ž w z Ç x   o   z w  w z ‘ ’ ’ ’ z É “ j k  q q j m r n   m o s   k   j p  m  È n o l   m j o n m r   u j  z  t w ’ ‹ z   w ‘ ˆ ¤ v ‘ ˆ ˆ w
i i 

k k l  n j … l q j   k n t   q l t n   m  s  j    t j n  n m k j › t  u o  m n
i

 n m o  m  k   q   j o o   “    z Ê     l  m n t  s — n q n r n z Ä z › l  l x n u n z  w z | m  l j z  w z n m r › l m n y n x  z Ä w z ‘ ’ ’ ‰ z
i Æ

l   q n k   m j   z  t w ‘ ‘ z   w • ‰ ‰ v • Ž ‘ w É … l q j   k n t m n t  o  o  s   j n x n  j › t  u ›  j t r  m n  n m o  m  k
i  i Œ i

~  n t   q   j o o   “    z Ê | È   n  j  ‘ ’ ’ ‰ v ’ ˆ ¤ w
i

œ n r  n z w “ w n m r n u z  w  w z ˆ ˆ ‰ z É  u o  j k “ n  
Œ Œ

 n m o  m  k “    o z  n  ‘ } | m s t l j m k j  s  k n   m  s  n ~  q l q   j  x j z œ w  w z   n x n z œ w w z n m r n  t   z  w ž w z ˆ ˆ ‰ z É  j
i Πi i

  k x m j o o  m  n m o  m  k   q   j o o    j  s   q n m k j z Ê        “ j  m  t r o … l q j  › t  u    l   n m ~  n t v › t  u  l q  Ê
i i i

 l  m n t  s l   q n k   m j   z  t w ¤ z   w ‘ ‘ ‹ v ‘ ‰ ˆ w  j  j m m o  t p n m  n  n j m  p j  o   { “ j k  m  k n t “ j    …  w
Æ i  i £ Œ i

“ ˆ ‰ v ‘ w
i

O R
N

½ ½
´ · Ë ¨ ° Ì Í Î © ¬ © ­ Ï ° Ð Ñ ° ± ¿ ¸ » · ­ · º ° ¬ ° ­ Í

 n  n q j j  n t l j


O R O

  j k  s  k › t  u Ž ‰ w ‹ t q { o j k v s Ò

    j k j r     j j r ¤ ’ ’ s { o j k
i

× ß

â ã ä å å

 n  j   j o o l  j “ n   w ˆ ‘

O R
H

æ ç ä è â ã ä å å

| m t j     j k j r › t  u ‹ w  t { o j k

é ç ä ê ç ë ë ì í ì ç æ í î
Ý

 j n o l  j r  n  j  s s  k  j m k  ’ w  • ‹ Ž

| m t j “ n r  l o “ n   ’ w ‰ ‘

2 9 7 B R 5 L d 6 5 9 7 B 7 > 9 A 9 5 B >

  ž  n q j j  •  m
i

> 9 @ 4 A > d > 5 C


E

Ù Ø

R ^
H

… l q j   s – t n r j o ‘ ’

2 9 7 B R á > A L B 7 > 9 A 9 5 B >

× Ø

2 9 7 B R b 9 A C 6 9 7 B 7 > 9 A 9 5 B >

 j n m o  j k “ n   w ‰ ‘

p j  n  j   t  r   ‘ w ‰

R
H _

F ` F F P ` P F

h       1    *     Ó  ( Ô Ó " Õ    Ö

ï ½ ½
· ð ­ © ¬ © ­ µ ­ ° ® ­ ° ­ · ¬ ± ©

R ^ M
`

R ^ O
`

â ã ä å å

÷
ô

R ^
`

à ô

é ç ä ê ç ë ë ì í ì ç æ í î

R
` _ _

à ô

æ ç ä è â ã ä å å

ó R
` _ P

2 9 7 B R 5 L d 6 5 9 7

ò
B 7 > 9 A 9 5 B >

> 9 @ 4 A > d > 5 C


E

R M
` _

2 7 7

R O
` _

O M O M
F F F P F _ P ` P P

h       1    *     Ó  ( Ô Ó " Õ    Ö

ï
Ë ð ­ © ¬ © ­ ° ¾ ¾ ± ¯ ± ° ¸ ¯ Ð

½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° ù Í ú ° · ® ­ ° Á · ¸ Á ¯ · ¨ ¯ ® ¨ · ¬ ° Á ­ © ¬ © ­ µ ° ­ ¾ © ­ º · ¸ ¯ °

§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì Í ¶ © º µ ® ¬ · ¬ ± © ¸ · ¨ ¿ ­ ± Á Í

½
º · µ Í

‹        
   

6 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


ï ½ ï ï ½ ï
· ð º ° · ® ­ ° Á Ë ð ¯ · ¨ ¯ ® ¨ · ¬ ° Á · ð º ° · ® ­ ° Á Ë ð ¯ · ¨ ¯ ® ¨ · ¬ ° Á

½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° û Í ¶ © º µ · ­ ± © ¸ © ¾ º ° · ® ­ ° Á · ¸ Á ¯ · ¨ ¯ ® ¨ · ¬ ° Á ² ­ © ® Á § ± ¿ ® ­ ° ü Í ¶ © º µ · ­ ± © ¸ © ¾ º ° · ® ­ ° Á · ¸ Á ¯ · ¨ ¯ ® ¨ · ¬ ° Á ² ­ © ® Á

½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½
¬ · ¬ ± ¯ µ ­ ° ® ­ ° · ¬ µ ° · À ° ¾ ¾ ± ¯ ± ° ¸ ¯ Ð Í ¬ · ¬ ± ¯ µ ­ ° ® ­ ° · ¬ ¸ ° · ­ ý ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ Í

ï ½ ï ½
· ð þ þ Í ÿ µ · ¸ Ë ð þ ÿ µ · ¸

½

½ ½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° ÿ Í ú · ¯ ² ¸ ® º Ë ° ­ ¯ © ¸ ¬ © ® ­ ¾ © ­ ° ­ © ¯ ¨ ° · ­ · ¸ ¯ ° ¯ · ° · ¬ ¸ ° · ­ ý ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ Í

h      Ó  (

ï ½ ï ½
· ð þ þ Í ÿ µ · ¸ Ë ð þ ÿ µ · ¸

 
½

½ ½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Í Â ° ¨ © ¯ ± ¬ Ð ° ¯ ¬ © ­ ¾ © ­ ° ­ © ¯ ¨ ° · ­ · ¸ ¯ ° ¯ · ° · ¬ ¸ ° · ­ ý ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ Í

•        
   

7 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


h    !       1  * Ó ƒ     1   

)  *    

   

  *          

  *   1 * Ó Ó

 1 * Ó Ó

ï
 
½
· ð µ ° · À ° ¾ ¾ ± ¯ ± ° ¸ ¯ Ð ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ § ± ¿ ® ­ ° Í Î · Á ± · ¨ º ± ¿ ­ · ¬ ± © ¸ © ¾ ¬ ± µ © ­ ¬ ± ¯ ° · ¬ µ ° · À ° ¾ ¾ ± ¯ ± ° ¸ ¯ Ð 

½

½ ½
¸ ° · ­ ý ¬ · ¨ ¨ · ¸ Á ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ Í

)  (

     1 ! 

   *

ï ½
Ë ð ¸ ° · ­ ý ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸

ï

½
· ð ° ¸ ¬ ­ © µ Ð · ¬ þ µ · ¸

)  (

     1 ! 

   *

ï ½
¯ ð ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸

ï
Ë ð ° ¸ ¬ ­ © µ Ð · ¬ Ë ¨ · Á ° ¬ ± µ

§ ± ¿ ® ­ °  Í ´ ± µ  © ­ ¬ ° Ã ¬ ­ · ¯ °
½
· ¸ Á ° ¸ ¬ ­ © µ Ð © ¸ ¯ ­ ©
½ ½
µ ¨ · ¸ °
½
Í


½ ½ ½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° þ Í ´ ± µ © ­ ¬ ° Ã ¬ ­ · ¯ ° · ¸ Á ° ¸ ¬ ­ © µ Ð ¯ © ¸ ¬ © ® ­ · ¬ ¬ · ¨ ¨

¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ Í

        
   

8 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


ï ï ½ ½
· ð µ ° · À ° ¾ ¾ ± ¯ ± ° ¸ ¯ Ð ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ · ð ú · ¯ ² ¸ ® º Ë ° ­ ¯ © ¸ ¬ © ® ­ · ¸ Á ¨ © ª ý º © º ° ¸ ¬ ® º ¬ ­ · ¯ ° · ¬


½
þ µ · ¸

ï ½
Ë ð ¸ ° · ­ ý ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸

ï ½ ½
Ë ð ú · ¯ ² ¸ ® º Ë ° ­ ¯ © ¸ ¬ © ® ­ · ¸ Á ¨ © ª ý º © º ° ¸ ¬ ® º ¬ ­ · ¯ ° · ¬

Ë ¨ · Á ° ¬ ± µ

§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì Ì Í ´ ± µ  © ­ ¬ ° Ã ¬ ­ · ¯ °
½
 ¬ ­ · ¯ °
½
¬ ² ­ © ® ¿ ² ¨ © ª ý º © º ° ¸ ¬ ® º


½ ½
· ­ ° · · ¸ Á ú · ¯ ² ¸ ® º Ë ° ­ ¯ © ¸ ¬ © ® ­ · ¬ ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ Í

ï ½
¯ ð ¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸

§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì
Í ´ ± µ  © ­ ¬ ° Ã ¬ ­ · ¯ °
½
· ¸ Á ¬ ± µ ý
½
° ¯ ¬ ± © ¸  ° ¨ © ¯ ± ¬ Ð  ° ¯ ¬ © ­
½

¯ © ¨ © ­ ° Á Ë Ð ú · ¯ ² ¸ ® º Ë ° ­ Í

ˆ        
   

9 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


 $ h   

0   1  #  

f Ó ! 

)  (

     1 ! 

   *

ï ½
· ð ¬ ­ · ¯ ° · ¬ ÿ ¿ · µ ² ° ± ¿ ² ¬


½

½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì û Í ´ ± µ © ­ ¬ ° Ã ¬ ­ · ¯ ° ¬ ­ · ¯ ° ¬ ² ­ © ® ¿ ² ¨ © ª ý º © º ° ¸ ¬ ® º

· ­ ° ·  · ¸ Á ú · ¯ ² ¸ ® º Ë ° ­ · ¬ Ë ¨ · Á ° ¬ ± µ  µ · ­ ¬ ± · ¨ ¬ ± µ ¿ · µ Í

ï ½
Ë ð ¬ ­ · ¯ ° · ¬ ÿ
¿ · µ ² ° ± ¿ ² ¬


½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì ü Í Â ° ¨ © ¯ ± ¬ Ð ° ¯ ¬ © ­ · ¬ Ë ¨ · Á ° ¬ ± µ  µ · ­ ¬ ± · ¨ ¬ ± µ ¿ · µ Í

ï ½
¯ ð ¬ ­ · ¯ ° · ¬ þ ÿ ¿ · µ ² ° ± ¿ ² ¬

½ ½
§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì ù Í ´ ² ­ ° ° ý Á ± º ° ¸ ± © ¸ · ¨ ¬ ­ ® ¯ ¬ ® ­ ° © ¾ ¬ ± µ ¨ ° · À · ¿ °

¾ ¨ © ª Í

’        
   

10 Copyright © 2004 by ASME


ï ½
· ð ¬ ± º ° ¬ ° µ Ì Í

ï ½
Ë ð ¬ ± º ° ¬ ° µ ù

ï ½
¯ ð ¬ ± º ° ¬ ° µ û

§ ± ¿ ® ­ ° Ì ÿ Í ¸
½
¬ · ¸ ¬ · ¸ ° © ®
½
¬ ± µ  © ­ ¬ ° Ã ¬ ­ · ¯ °
½
· ¸ Á ú · ¯ ²

½ ½
¸ ® º Ë ° ­ ¯ © ¸ ¬ © ® ­ · ¬ ¬ ² ° ¬ ± µ ° ¯ ¬ ± © ¸  ¸ ° · ­
½
¬ · ¨ ¨ ¯ © ¸ Á ± ¬ ± © ¸ 

½
¬ ± º ° ¬ ° µ û Í

       
   

11 Copyright © 2004 by ASME

Вам также может понравиться