Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
Association of American Geographers, Taylor & Francis, Ltd. are collaborating with
JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Annals of the Association of American
Geographers
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism
Michael Dear and Steven Flusty
Theories of urban structure are a scarce commodity. Most twentieth-century analyses have been
predicated on the Chicago School model of concentric zones, despite the obvious claims of
competing models. This paper examines the contemporary forms of Southern California urbanism
as an initial step toward deriving a concept of "postmodern urbanism." The Los Angeles model
consists of several fundamental characteristics, including a global-local connection, a ubiquitous
social polarization, and a reterritorialization of the urban process in which hinterland organizes the
center (in direct contradiction to the Chicago model). The resultant urbanism is distinguished by
a centerless urban form termed "keno capitalism," which we advance as the basis for a research
agenda in comparative urban analysis. Key Words: postmodem, urbanism, urban structure, Chicago,
Los Angeles.
Sometimes, falling asleep in Santa Monica, he won- Modern Age is being succeded by a post-modern
dered vaguely if there might have been a larger period (1959:165-66).
system, a field of greater perspective. Perhaps the
whole of DatAmerica possessed its own nodal Mills believed that it was vital to conceptualize
points, infofaults that might be followed down to the categories of change in order to "grasp the
some other kind of truth, another mode of knowing, outline of the new epoch we suppose ourselves to
deep within the gray shoals of information. But onlybe entering" (1959:166).
if there were someone there to pose the right ques- Have we arrived at a radical break in the way
tion (William Gibson, 1996:39). cities are developing? Is there something called
O ne of the most enervating aspects of a postmodern urbanism, which presumes that we
recent debates on the postmodern con- can identify some form of template that defines
dition is the notion that there has been its critical dimensions?2 This inquiry is based on
a radical break from past trends in political, a simple premise: that just as the central tenets
economic, and sociocultural life. There is no of modernist thought have been undermined,
clear consensus about the nature of this osten- its core evacuated and replaced by a rush of
sible break. Some analysts have declared the competing epistemologies, so too have the tra-
current condition to be nothing more than ditional logics of earlier urbanisms evaporated,
business as usual, only faster a "hypermod- and in the absence of a single new imperative,
ern" or "supermodern" phase of advanced capi- multiple urban (ir)rationalities are competing
talism.1 Others have noted that the pace of to fill the void. It is the concretization and
change in all aspects of our global society is localization of these effects, global in scope but
sufficient for us to begin to speak of "revolu- generated and manifested locally, that are cre-
tion." In this essay, we are cognizant of an ating the geographies of postmodern society a
invocation of Jacques Derrida, who invited new time-space fabric.3 We begin this search by
those interested in assessing the extent and outlining the fundamental precepts of the Chi-
volume of contemporary change to "rehearse cago School, a classical modernist vision of the
the break," intimating that only by assuming a industrial metropolis, and contrasting these
radical break had occurred would our capacity with evidence of a nascent postmodern Los
to recognize it be released. Similar advice was Angeles School.4 Next we examine a broad
offered by C. Wright Mills in The Sociological range of contemporary Southern California ur-
Imagination (1959): banisms, before going on to suggest a critical
reinterpretation of this evidence that encom-
We are at the ending of what is called The Modern passes and defines the problematic of a post-
Age. Just as Antiquity was followed by several cen-
modern urbanism. In conclusion, we offer
turies of Oriental ascendancy, which Westerners
comments intended to assist in formulating an
provincially called The Dark Ages, so now The
agenda for comparative urban research.
Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 88(1), 1998, pp. 50-72
(? 1998 by Association of American Geographers
Published by Blackwell Publishers, 350 Main Street, Maiden, MA 02148, and 108 Cowley Road, Oxford, OX4 1JF, UK.
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 51
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
52 Dear and Flusty
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 53
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
54 Dear and Flusty
Raban makes no claims to a postmodern con- (8) stylishness (appealing to the fashionable,
sciousness, yet his invocation of the relationship chic, and affluent),
between the cognitive and the real leads to in- (9) reconnection with the local (involving delib-
sights that are unmistakably postmodern in their erate historical/geographical reconstruc-
sensitivities. tion), and
Ted Relph (1987) was one of the first geogra- (10) pedestrian-automobile split (to redress the
phers to catalogue the built forms that comprise modernist bias toward the car).
the places of postmodernity. He describes post- Raban's emphasis on the cognitive and Relph's
modern urbanism as a self-conscious and selec- on the concrete underscore the importance of
tive revival of elements of older styles, though he both dimensions in understanding sociospatial
cautions that postmodernism is not simply a style urban process. The pallette of urbanisms that
but also a frame of mind (p. 213). He observes arises from merging the two is thick and multidi-
how the confluence of many trends gentrifica- mensional. We turn now to the task of construct-
tion, heritage conservation, architectural fash- ing that palette (what we earlier described as a
ion, urban design, and participatory template) by examining empirical evidence of
planning caused the collapse of the modernist recent urban developments in Southern Califor-
vision of a future city filled with skyscrapers and nia (Table 1). In this review, we take our lead from
other austere icons of scientific rationalism. The what exists, rather than what we consider to be a
new urbanism is principally distinguishable from comprehensive urban research agenda.9 From
the old by its eclecticism. Relph's periodization of this, we move quickly to a synthesis that is pre-
twentieth-century urbanism involves a premod- figurative of a protopostmodern urbanism, which
ern transitional period (up to 1940); an era of we hope will serve as an invitation to a more
modernist cityscapes (after 1945); and a period of broadly based comparative analysis.
postmodern townscapes (since 1970). The dis-
tinction between cityscape and townscape is cru-
Edge Cities
cial to his diagnosis. Modernist cityscapes, he
claims, are characterized by five elements (Relph
Joel Garreau noted the central significance of
1987:242-50):
Los Angeles in understanding contemporary
(1) megastructural bigness (few street entrances
metropolitan growth in the U.S. He asserts
to buildings, little architectural detailing,
(1991:3) that: "Every single American city that is
etc.),
growing, is growing in the fashion of Los Angeles,"
(2) straight-space / prairie space (city-center
and refers to L.A. as the "great-granddaddy" of
canyons, endless suburban vistas),
edge cities (he claims there are twenty- six of them
(3) rational order and flexibility (the landscapes
within a five -county area in Southern California).
of total order, verging on boredom),
For Garreau, edge cities represent the crucible of
(4) hardness and opacity (including freeways
America's urban future. The classic location for
and the displacement of nature),
contemporary edge cities is at the intersection of
(5) discontinuous serial vision (deriving from
an urban beltway and a hub-and-spoke lateral
the dominance of the automobile).
road. The central conditions that have propelled
Conversely, postmodern townscapes are more de-
such development are the dominance of the auto-
tailed, handcrafted, and intricate. They celebrate
mobile and the associated need for parking, the
difference, polyculturalism, variety, and stylish-
communications revolution, and the entry of
ness (pp. 252-58). Their elements are:
women in large numbers into the labor market.
(6) quaintspace (a deliberate cuteness),
Although Garreau agrees with Robert Fishman
(7) textured facades (for pedestrians, rich in de-
that "[a] 11 new city forms appear in their early
tail, often with an "aged" appearance),
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 55
stages to be chaotic" (1991:9), he is able to iden- (McKenzie 1994:19). It has provoked a culture of
tify three basic types of edge city. These are: nonparticipation.
uptowns (peripheral pre-automobile settlements McKenzie warns that far from being a benign
that have subsequently been absorbed by urban or inconsequential trend, CIDs already define a
sprawl); boomers (the classic edge cities, located new norm for the mass production of housing in
at freeway intersections); and greenfields (the cur- the U.S. Equally important, their organizations
rent state-of-the-art, "occurring at the intersec- are now allied through something called the
tion of several thousand acres of farmland and Community Associations Institute, "whose pur-
one developer's monumental ego" [p. 1161). poses include the standardizing and professional-
One essential feature of the edge city is that izing of CID governance" (1994:184). McKenzie
politics is not yet established there. Into the po- notes how this "secession of the successful" (the
litical vacuum moves a "shadow government" a phrase is Robert Reich's) has altered concepts of
privatized protogovernment that is essentially a citizenship, in which "one's duties consist of sat-
plutocratic alternative to normal politics. isfying one's obligations to private property"
Shadow governments can tax, legislate for, and (1994:196). In her futuristic novel of L.A. wars
police their communities, but they are rarely ac- between walled-community dwellers and those
countable, are responsive primarily to wealth (as beyond the walls (Parable of the Sower, 1993),
opposed to numbers of voters), and subject to few Octavia Butler has envisioned a dystopian priva-
constitutional constraints (Garreau 1991:187). topian future. It includes a balkanized nation of
Jennifer Wolch (1990) has described the rise of defended neighborhoods at odds with one an-
the shadow state as part of a society-wide trend other, where entire communities are wiped out for
toward privatization. In edge cities, "community" a handful of fresh lemons or a few cups of potable
is scarce, occurring not through propinquity but water; where torture and murder of one's enemies
via telephone, fax, and private mail service. The is common; and where company-town slavery is
walls that typically surround such neighborhoods attractive to those who are fortunate enough to
are social boundaries, but they act as community sell their services to the hyperdefended enclaves
"recognizers," not community "organizers" (pp. of the very rich.
275-8 1). In the edge-city era, Garreau notes, the
term "master-planned" community is little more
than a marketing device (p. 301). Other studies Cultures of Heteropolis
of suburbanization in L.A., most notably by Hise
(1997) and Waldie (1996), provide a basis for One of the most prominent sociocultural ten-
comparing past practices of planned community dencies in contemporary Southern California is
marketing in Southern California. the rise of minority populations (Ong et al. 1994;
Roseman et al. 1996; Waldinger and Bozorgmehr
1996). Provoked to comprehend the causes and
Privatopia implications of the 1992 civil disturbances in Los
Angeles, Charles Jencks (1993:32) zeroes in on
Privatopia, perhaps the quintessential edge- the city's diversity as the key to L.A.'s emergent
city residential form, is a private housing devel- urbanism: "Los Angeles is a combination of en-
opment based in common-interest developments claves with high identity, and multienclaves with
(CIDs) and administered by homeowners' asso- mixed identity, and, taken as a whole, it is perhaps
ciations. There were fewer than 500 such associa- the most heterogeneous city in the world." Such
tions in 1964; by 1992, there were 150,000 ethnic pluralism has given rise to what Jencks
associations privately governing approximately calls a hetero-architecture, which has demon-
32 million Americans. In 1990, the 11.6 million strated that: "there is a great virtue, and pleasure,
CID units constituted more than 11 percent of to be had in mixing categories, transgressing
the nation's housing stock (McKenzie 1994:11). boundaries, inverting customs and adopting the
Sustained by an expanding catalogue of cove- marginal usage" (1993:123). The vigor and
nants, conditions, and restrictions (or CC&Rs, imagination underlying these intense cultural dy-
the proscriptive constitutions formalizing CID namics is everywhere evident in the region, from
behavioral and aesthetic norms), privatopia has the diversity of ethnic adaptations (Park 1996)
been fueled by a large dose of privatization, and through the concentration of cultural producers
promoted by an ideology of "hostile privatism" in the region (Molotch 1996), to the hybrid com-
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
56 Dear and Flusty
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 57
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
58 Dear and Flusty
Globalization
Fordist versus Post-Fordist Regimes of
Accumulation and Regulation Needless to say, any consideration of the
changing nature of industrial production sooner
Many observers agree that one of the most im- or later must encompass the globalization ques-
portant underlying shifts in the contemporary po- tion (cf. Knox and Taylor 1995). In his reference
litical economy is from a Fordist to a post-Fordist to the global context of L.A.'s localisms, Mike
industrial organization. In a series of important Davis (1992b) claims that if L.A. is in any sense
books, Allen Scott and Michael Storper have por- paradigmatic, it is because the city condenses the
trayed the burgeoning urbanism of Southern Cali- intended and unintended spatial consequences of
fornia as a consequence of this deep-seated post-Fordism. He insists that there is no simple
structural change in the capitalist political economy
master-logic of restructuring, focusing instead on
(Scott 1988a, 1988b, 1993; Storper and Walker two key localized macro-processes: the overaccu-
1989). For instance, Scott's basic argument is that mulation in Southern California of bank and
there have been two major phases of urbanization real-estate capital, principally from the East
in the U.S. The first related to an era of Fordist mass
Asian trade surplus, and the reflux of low-wage
production, during which the paradigmatic cities of manufacturing and labor-intensive service indus-
industrial capitalism (Detroit, Chicago, Pittsburgh, tries, following upon immigration from Mexico
etc.) coalesced around industries that were them- and Central America. For instance, Davis notes
selves based upon ideas of mass production. The how the City of Los Angeles used tax dollars
second phase is associated with the decline of the gleaned from international capital investments to
Fordist era and the rise of a post-Fordist "flexible subsidize its downtown (Bunker Hill) urban re-
production." This is a form of industrial activity newal, a process he refers to as "municipalized
based on small-size, small-batch units of (typically land speculation" (1992b:26). Through such
subcontracted) production that are nevertheless connections, what happens today in Asia and
integrated into clusters of economic activity. Such Central America will tomorrow have an effect in
clusters have been observed in two manifestations: Los Angeles. This global/local dialectic has al-
labor-intensive craft forms (in Los Angeles, typically ready become an important (if somewhat impre-
garments and jewelry), and high technology (espe- cise) leitmotif of contemporary urban theory.
cially the defense and aerospace industries). Ac-
cording to Scott, these so-called "technopoles"
until recently constituted the principal geographical Politics of Nature
loci of contemporary (sub) urbanization in Southern
California (a development prefigured in Fishman s The natural environment of Southern Califor-
description of the "technoburb"; see Fishman 1987; nia has been under constant assault since the first
Castells and Hall 1994). colonial settlements. Human habitation on a
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 59
Globalization /Restructuring
Cultures of Political-Economic
Heteropolis Polarization
Interdictory Spaces
Politics of Nature
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
60 Dear and Flusty
GLOBAL LATIFUNDIA
HOLSTEINIZATION
PRAEDATORIANISM
FLEXISM
KENO CAPITALISM
CITISTAT
Commudities
Cyburbia
Citidel
In-Beyond
Cyberia
POLLYANNARCHY
DISINFORMATION SUPERHIGHWAY
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 61
|CYBERGEOISIE ||PROTOSURPS|
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
62 Dear and Flusty
From these exchange asymmetries emerges a lapping in both membership and space, resulting
new world bi-polar disorder. This is a globally bi- in a class of marginalized indigenous populations
furcated social order, many times more compli- and peripheral immigrants who are relatively less
cated than conventional class structures, in holsteinized.
which those overseeing the global latifundia en- The sociocultural collisions and intermeshings
joy concentrated power. Those who are depend- of protosurp affinity groups, generated by flexist-
ent upon their command-and-control decisions induced immigration and severe social differen-
find themselves in progressively weaker positions, tiation, serves to produce wild memetic
pitted against each other globally, and forced to contagion. 13This is a process by which cultural
accept shrinking compensation for their efforts elements of one individual or group exert cross-
(assuming that compensation is offered in the first over influences upon the culture of another, pre-
place). Of the two groups, the cybergeoisie reside viously unexposed individual/group. Memetic
in the "big house" of the global latifundia, provid- contagion is evidenced in Los Angeles by such
ing indispensable, presently unautomatable com- hybridized agents and intercultural conflicts as
mand-and-control functions. They are Mexican and Central American practitioners of
predominantly stockholders, the core employees Afro-Caribbean religion (McGuire and
of thinned-down corporations, and write-your- Scrymgeour forthcoming), blue-bandanna'd
own-ticket freelancers (e.g., CEOs, subcontract Thai Crips, or the adjustments prompted by poor
entrepreneurs, and celebrities). They may also African-Americans' offense at Korean mer-
shelter members of marginal creative professions, chants' disinclination to smile casually. Memetic
who comprise a kind of paracybergeoisie. The contagion should not be taken for a mere epiphe-
cybergoisie enjoy perceived socioeconomic secu- nomenon of an underlying political economic
rity and comparatively long-term horizons in de- order, generating colorfully chaotic ornamenta-
cision making; consequently their anxieties tend tions for a flexist regime. Rather, it entails the
toward unforeseen social disruptions such as mar- assemblage of novel ways of seeing and being,
ket fluctuations and crime. Commanding, con- from whence new identities, cultures, and politi-
trolling, and prodigiously enjoying the fruits of a cal alignments emerge. These new social configu-
shared global exchange of goods and information, rations, in turn, may act to force change in
the cybergoisie exercise global coordination func- existing institutions and structures, and to spawn
tions that predispose them to a similar ideology cognitive conceptions that are incommensurable
and, thus, they are relatively heavily holsteinized. with, though not necessarily any less valid than,
Protosurps, on the other hand, are the share- existing models. The inevitable tensions between
croppers of the global latifundia. They are in- the anarchic diversification born of memetic con-
creasingly marginalized "surplus" labor providing tagion and the manipulations of the holsteiniza-
just-in-time services when called upon by flexist tion process may yet prove to be the central
production processes, but otherwise alienated cultural contradiction of flexism.
from global systems of production (though not of With the flexist imposition of global impera-
consumption). Protosurps include temporary or tives on local economies and cultures, the spatial
day laborers, fire-at-will service workers, a bur- logic of Fordism has given way to a new, more
geoning class of intra- and international itinerant dissonant international geographical order. In the
laborers specializing in pursuing the migrations of absence of conventional communication and
fluid investment. True surpdom is a state of super- transportation imperatives mandating propin-
fluity beyond peonage-a vagrancy that is in- quity, the once-standard Chicago School logic
creasingly criminalized through antihomeless has given way to a seemingly haphazard juxtapo-
ordinances, welfare-state erosion, and wide- sition of land uses scattered over the landscape.
spread community intolerance (of, for instance, Worldwide, agricultural lands sprout monocul-
all forms of panhandling). Protosurps are called tures of exportable strawberry or broccoli in lieu
upon to provide as yet unautomated service func- of diverse staple crops grown for local consump-
tions designed to be performed by anyone. Sub- tion. Sitting amid these fields, identical assembly
jected to high degrees of uncertainty by the lines produce the same brand of automobile, sup-
omnipresent threat of instant unemployment, plied with parts and managed from distant conti-
protosurps are prone to clustering into affinity nents. Expensive condominiums appear among
groups for support in the face of adversity. These squatter slums, indistinguishable in form and oc-
affinity groups, however, are not exclusive, over- cupancy from (and often in direct communica-
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 63
tion with) luxury housing built atop homeless habitat preferences of the well-recompensed cy-
encampments elsewhere in the world. Yet what in bergeoisie. They commonly consist of carefully
close-up appears to be a fragmentary, collaged manicured residential and commercial ecologies
polyculture is, from a longer perspective, a geo- managed through privatopian self-administra-
graphically disjointed but hyperspatially inte- tion, and maintained against internal and exter-
grated monoculture, that is, shuffled sames set nal outlaws by a repertoire of interdictory
amid adaptive and persistent local variations. prohibitions. Increasingly, these prepackaged en-
The result is a landscape not unlike that formed vironments jockey with one another for clientele
by a keno gamecard. The card itself appears as a on the basis of recreational, cultural, security, and
numbered grid, with some squares being marked educational amenities. Commonly located on dif-
during the course of the game and others not, ficult-to-access sites like hilltops or urban edges,
according to some random draw. The process far from restless populations undergoing conver-
governing this marking ultimately determines sion to protosurpdom, individual commudities
which player will achieve a jackpot-winning pat- are increasingly teleintegrated to form cyburbia
tern; it is, however, determined by a rationalized (Dewey 1994), the interactive tollways compris-
set of procedures beyond the territory of the card ing the high-rent district of Citistat's hyperspatial
itself. Similarly, the apparently random develop- electronic shadow. (This process may soon find a
ment and redevelopment of urban land may be geographical analog in the conversion of automo-
regarded as the outcome of exogenous invest-
tive freeways linking commudities via exclusive
ment processes inherent to flexism, thus creating
tollways.) Teleintegration is already complete
the landscapes of keno capitalism.
(and de rigeur) for the citidels, which are commer-
Keno capitalism's contingent mosaic of vari-
cial commodities consisting of highrise corporate
egated monocultures renders discussion of "the
towers from which the control and coordination
city" increasingly reductionist. More holistically,
of production and distribution in the global lati-
the dispersed net of megalopoles may be viewed
fundia is exercised.
as a single integrated urban system, or Citistat
Citista-t's internal periphery and repository of
(Figure 3). Citistat, the collective world city, has
cheap on-call labor lies at the in-beyond, com-
emerged from competing urban webs of colonial
prised of a shifting matrix of protosurp affinity
and postcolonial eras to become a geographically
clusters. The in-beyond may be envisioned as a
diffuse hub of an omnipresent periphery, drawing
patchwork quilt of variously defined interest
labor and materials from readily substitutable lo-
groups (with differing levels of economic, cul-
cations throughout that periphery. Citistat is both
tural, and street influence), none of which pos-
geographically corporeal, in the sense that urban
sesses the wherewithal to achieve hegemonic
places exist, and yet ageographically ethereal in
status or to secede. Secession may occur locally
the sense that communication systems create a
to some degree, as in the cases of the publicly
virtual space, permitting coordination across
subsidized reconfiguration of L.A.'s Little Tokyo,
physical space. Both realms reinforce each an-
and the consolidation of Koreatown through the
other while (re) producing the new world bipolar
disorder. import, adjacent extraction, and community re-
Materially, Citistat consists of commudities circulation of capital. The piecemeal diversity of
(centers of command and control), and the in-be- the in-beyond makes it a hotbed of wild memetic
yond (internal peripheries simultaneously under- contagion. The global connectivity of the in-be-
going but resisting instrumentalization in myriad yond is considerably less glamorous than that of
ways). Virtually, Citistat consists of cyburbia, the the cybergeoisie's commodities, but it is no less
collection of state-of-the-art data-transmission, extensive. Intermittent phone contact and wire-
premium pay-per-use, and interactive services service remittances occur throughout cyberia
generally reliant upon costly and technologically (Rushkoff 1995; also see Knox and Taylor 1995).
complex interfaces; and cyberia, an electronic The pot-holed public streets of Citista-t's virtual
outland of rudimentary communications includ- twin are augmented by extensive networks of
ing basic phone service and telegraphy, inter- snail mail, personal migration, and the hand-to-
woven with and preceptorally conditioned by the hand passage of mediated communications (e.g.,
disinformation superhighway (DSH). cassette tapes). Such contacts occasionally dif-
Commudities are commodified communities fuse into commodities, as with the conversion of
created expressly to satisfy (and profit from) the cybergeosie youth to wannabe gangstas.
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
64 Dear and Flusty
DISINFORMATION SUPERHIGHWAY
POLLYANNRCY
Figure 3. Elements of a postmodern urbanism - 2.
Political relations in Citistat tend toward poly- bolic value of commodities. At the same time, it
anarchy, a politics of grudging tolerance of differ- serves as the highly filtered sensory organ through
ence that emerges from interactions and which commodities and the in-beyond perceive
accommodations within the in-beyond and be- the world outside their unmediated daily experi-
tween commodities, and less frequently, between ences. The DSH is Citistat's "consent factory"
in-beyond and commudity. Its more pervasive (Chomsky and Herman 1988), engineering me-
form is pollyannarchy, an exaggerated, manufac- metic contagion to encourage participation in a
tured optimism that promotes a self-congratula- global latifundia that is represented as both inevi-
tory awareness and respect for difference and the table and desirable. But since the DSH is a broad-
asymmetries of power. Pollyannarchy is thus a band distributor of information designed
pathological form of polyanarchy, disempowering primarily to attract and deliver consumers to
those who would challenge the controlling bene- advertisers, the ultimate reception of messages
ficiaries of the new world bipolar disorder. Polly- carried by the DSH is difficult to target and
annarchy is evident in the continuing spectacle predetermine. Thus the DSH also serves inadver-
of electoral politics, or in the citywide unity cam- tently as a vector for memetic contagion, e.g., the
paign run by corporate sponsors following the conversion of cybergeoisie youth to wannabe
1992 uprising in Los Angeles. gangstas via the dissemination of hip-hop culture
Wired throughout the body of the Citistat is over commudity boundaries. The DSH serves as
the disinformation superhighway (or DSH), a mass a network of preceptoral control, and is thus
info-tain-mercial media owned by roughly two distinct from the coercive mechanisms of the
dozen cybergeoisie institutions. The DSH dis- praedatorian guard. Overlap between the two is
seminates holsteinizing ideologies and incentives, increasingly common, however, as in the case of
creates wants and dreams, and inflates the sym- televised disinfotainment programs like Amer-
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 65
ica's Most Wanted, in which crimes are dramati- guide to contemporary urbanism. In this first
cally reenacted and viewers invited to call in and sense, our investigation has uncovered an episte-
betray alleged perpetrators. mological radical break with past practices,
As the cybergeoisie increasingly withdraw from which in itself is sufficient justification for
the Fordist redistributive triad of big government, something called a Los Angeles School. The
big business, and big labor to establish their own concentric ring structure of the Chicago School
micronations, the social support functions of the was essentially a concept of the city as an or-
state disintegrate, along with the survivability of ganic accretion around a central, organizing
less affluent citizens. The global migrations of core. Instead, we have identified a postmodern
work to the lowest-wage locations of the in-be- urban process in which the urban periphery
yond, and of consumer capital to the citidels, organizes the center within the context of a
result in power asymmetries that become so pro- globalizing capitalism.
nounced that even the DSH is at times incapable The postmodern urban process remains reso-
of obscuring them, leaving protosurps increas- lutely capitalist, but the nature of that enter-
ingly disinclined to adhere to the remnants of a prise is changing in very significant ways,
tattered social contract. This instability in turn especially through (for instance) the telecom-
creates the potential for violence, pitting Citistat munications revolution, the changing nature of
and cybergeoisie against the protosurp in-beyond, work, and globalization. Thus, in this second
and leading inevitably to a demand for the sup- sense also, we understand that a radical break is
pression of protosurp intractibility. The praeda- occurring, this time in the conditions of our
torian guard thus emerges as the principal material world. Contemporary urbanism is a
remaining vestige of the police powers of the consequence of how local and interlocal flows
state. This increasingly privatized public/private of material and information (including sym-
partnership of mercenary sentries, police expedi- bols) intersect in a rapidly converging globally
tionary forces, and their technological extensions integrated economy driven by the imperatives
(e.g., video cameras, helicopters, criminological of flexism. Landscapes and peoples are homoge-
data uplinks, etc.) watches over the commudities nized to facilitate large-scale production and
and minimizes disruptiveness by acting as a force consumption. Highly mobile capital and com-
of occupation within the in-beyond. The praeda- modity flows outmaneuver geographically fixed
torian guard achieves control through coercion, labor markets, communities, and nation-states,
even at the international level where asymmetri- and cause a globally bifurcated polarization.
cal trade relations are reinforced by the militaryThe beneficiaries of this system are the cyber-
and its clientele. It may only be a matter of timegoisie, even as the numbers of permanently
before the local and national praedatorians are marginalized protosurps grow. In the new
administratively and functionally merged, as ex- global order, socioeconomic polarization and
massive, sudden population migrations spawn
emplified by proposals to deploy military units for
policing inner-city streets or the U.S.-Mexico cultural hybrids through the process of me-
border. metic contagion. Cities no longer develop as
concentrated loci of population and economic
activity, but as fragmented parcels within Citi-
An Alternative Model of Urban Structure stat, the collective world city. Materially, the
Citistat consists of commodities (commodified
We have begun the process of interrogating communities) and the in-beyond (the perma-
prior models of urban structure with an alter- nently marginalized). Virtually, the Citistat is
native model based upon the recent experi- composed of cyburbia (those hooked into the
ences of Los Angeles. We do not pretend to electronic world) and cyberia (those who are
have completed this project, nor claim that the not). Social order is maintained by the ideologi-
Southern Californian experience is necessarily cal apparatus of the DSH, the Citistat's consent
typical of other metropolitan regions in the U.S. factory, and by the praedatorian guard, the
or the world. Still less would we advocate re- privatized vestiges of the nation-state's police
placing the old models with a new hegemony. powers.
But discourse has to start somewhere, and by Keno capitalism is the synoptic term that we
now it is clear that the most influential of have adopted to describe the spatial manifesta-
existing urban models is no longer tenable as a tions of the postmodern urban condition (Figure
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
66 Dear and Flusty
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 67
tions about a research agenda. Our knowledge of Each of these themes (globalization, polariza-
the literature suggests at least four broad themes tion, fragmentation and cultural hybrids, and cy-
that overlap with the substance of this essay. bercities) holds a place in our postmodern
(1) World City: In its contemporary manifesta- urbanism. But (as we hope is by now clear) none
tion, the emphasis on a system of world cities can of them individually provide a sufficient explana-
be traced back to Peter Hall's The World Cities tion for the urban outcomes we are currently
(1966). The concept was updated by Friedmann observing. A proper accounting of contemporary
and Wolff (1982) to emphasize the emergence of pattern and process will require a much more
a relatively few centers of command and control strenuous effort directed toward comparative ur-
in a globalizing economy. Extensions and apprais- ban analysis. Unfortunately, the empirical, meth-
als of the concept have been offered in, for exam- odological, and theoretical bases for such analysis
ple, Knox and Taylor (1995) and special issues of are weak. We lack, for instance, adequate infor-
Urban Geography (1996) and the Annals of the mation on a full sample of national and interna-
American Academy of Political and Social Science tional cities, although valuable current syntheses
("Globalization and the Changing U.S. City" are available in Urban Geography (1996) and the
1997). A significant emphasis in the more recent Annals of the American Academy of Political and
work has been on the global-local connection, Social Sciences ("Globalization and the U.S. City"
and on the implications of the sheer size of the 1997). There are a number of explicit compara-
emergent megacities (Dogan and Kasarda 1988;
tive studies, but these tend to focus on already
Sudjic 1992).
well, documented centers such as London, Tokyo,
(2) Dual City: One of the most persistent
and New York City (e.g., Fainstein 1994; Sassen
themes in contemporary urban analysis is social
1991). In contrast, the vibrancy and potential of
polarization, i.e., the increasing gap between rich
important centers such as Miami still remain
and poor; between the powerful and powerless;
closeted (Nijman 1996, 1997; Portes and Stepick
between different ethnic, racial, and religious
1993). Our methodological and theoretical appa-
groupings; and between genders (O'Loughlin and
ratuses for cross-cultural urban analyses are also
Friedrichs 1996; Mollenkopf and Castells 1991).
underdeveloped. Castells (1996, 1997) offers an
Too few analyses have traced how this broad class
insightful engagement with global urban condi-
of polarizations is translated into the spatial struc-
tions, and the theoretical insights of Ellin (1996),
ture of cities (e.g., Ley 1996; Sassen 1991, 1994).
King (1996), and Soja (1996b) on a putative
(3) Altered spaces: Another prevalent condi-
postmodern urbanism are much needed excur-
tion of contemporary urban existence is fragmen-
sions into a neglected field.14 In addition,
tation, both in material and cognitive life. It has
Chauncy Harris's (1997) recent reworking of his
been noted by observers who place themselves
multiple nuclei model into what he terms a pe-
both within and beyond the postmodern ethos
ripheral model of urban areas reveals an acute
(see, for instance, Watson and Gibson 1995, and
the essays in the City journal ["It All Comes sensitivity to the contemporary urban condition,
Together in Los Angeles" 1996]). Their concerns but engages theoretical precepts quite different
often focus on the collapse of conventional com- from ours. Finally, work on cities of the develop-
munities and the rise of new cultural categories ing, postcolonial, and non-Western worlds re-
and spaces, including especially cultural hybrids mains sparse and unsustained, as well as being
(Canclini 1996; Olalquiaga 1992; Morley and stubbornly immune from the broader lessons of
Robins 1995; Zukin 1994). Western-based theory-even though the empiri-
(4) Cybercity: No one can ignore the chal- cal parallels between, for example, Seabrook's
lenges of the information age, which promises to (1996) subtitle, "Scenes from a Developing
unseat many of our cherished notions about so- World" and our construction of postmodern ur-
ciospatial structuring. Castells (1996, 1997) has banism are striking.
undertaken an ambitious three-volume account We intend this essay as an invitation to exam-
of this social revolution, but as yet relatively few ine the concept of a postmodern urbanism. We
people (beyond science-fiction authors such as recognize that we have only begun to sketch its
William Gibson and Neal Stephenson) have ex- potential, that its validity will only be properly
plored what this revolution portends for cities. assessed if researchers elsewhere in the world are
One pioneering exception is William J. Mitchell's willing to examine its precepts. We urge others to
City of Bits (1995). share in this enterprise because, even though our
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
68 Dear and Flusty
6. For example,
vision is tentative, weLongstreth
are(1997) examines the role
convinced
glimpsed a new way of Los of
Angeles in the invention of the regional
understandin
shopping mall. See also Hayden (1994).
7. The claims of a "Los Angeles School" may have
already been overtaken by a burgeoning "Orange
Acknowledgments
County School." According to Mark Gottdiener
and George Kephart in Postsuburban California, it
Earlier versions of this paper have been presented at
is Orange County that is the paradigmatic window
a "Theory, Culture & Society" conference in Berlin,
on late-twentieth-century urbanism:
the University of Turku on behalf of the Finnish Acad-
We have focussed on what we consider to be a
emy of Science, the Howell Lecture in the School of
new form of settlement space-the fully urban-
Architecture, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, the
ized, multinucleated, and independent county.
School of Architecture, Building and Planning, Uni-
. . formally separated from but adjacent to large
versity of Melbourne, the annual meetings of the As-
well-known metropolitan regions.... As a new
sociation of Collegiate Schools of Architecture and the
form of settlement space, they are the first such
Association of American Geographers, and the Center
occurrence in five thousand years of urban his-
for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences, Stan-
tory (1991:51).
ford University. We are grateful to Scott Lash and Mike
Postsuburban districts, they further state, "possess
Featherstone, Harri Anderson and Jouni Hikli, Ross
relatively large populations; they are polynu-
King and Ruth Fincher, Sharon Lord Gaber, and Robert
cleated, with no single center that dominates
Harris for invitations to present papers on these occa-
development as it does in the traditional urban
sions. Thanks also to the many conference participants
model; and they possess relatively robust employ-
who provided constructive criticism. Kim Dovey, Ruth
ment bases and also serve as residential areas,
Fincher, Robert Harris, John Kaliski, Carol Levy, John
especially for the white middle class" (p. 51). Such
Levy, Claudio Minca, Jan Nijman, Kevin Robins, Mi-
districts appear to be identifiable by four charac-
chael Webber, and Jennifer Wolch were supportive of
teristics: "postsuburban spatial organization, in-
the enterprise and offered helpful comments, as did a
formation capitalism, consumerism, and
number of anonymous referees. Deanna Knicker-
cosmopolitanism" (1991:4).
bocker and Dallas Dishman prepared the figures. None
8. Rabanfs view finds echoes in the seminal work of
of these people should be blamed for anything in this
de Certeau (1984).
essay. This paper was first written while Dear was a
9. It is worth emphasizing that in the overview, we
fellow at the Center for Advanced Study in the Behav-
focus solely on the concatenation of urban
ioral Sciences at Stanford. The support of the Center
events that are occurring in contemporary
and the National Science Foundation SES-9022192 is
Southern California. This is not to suggest that
gratefully acknowledged.
such trends are absent in other cities, nor that
a larger literature on these topics and cities is
missing. A complete review of these other
Notes places and literatures is simply beyond the
scope of this paper.
1. See, for example, Pred (1995) and Auge (1995). 10. Such sentiments find echoes in Neil Smith's
2. Some elements of this discussion may be found in assessment of the new urban frontier, where
Watson and Gibson (1995), Ellin (1996), and expansion is powered by two industries: real-
Knox and Taylor (1995). estate developers (who package and define
3. The theoretical bases for this argument are exam- value), and the manufacturers of culture (who
ined more fully in Dear (1988, 1991). For specific define taste and consumption preferences)
considerations of the rhetoric of city planning in (Smith 1992:75).
the new urbanism, see Dear (1989). 11. The list of L.A. novels and movies is endless.
4. This should not be confused with the L.A. School Typical of the dystopian cinematic vision are
of architecture, discussed by Charles Jencks "Blade Runner" (Ridley Scott 1986) and "China-
(1993). town" (Roman Polanski 1974); and of silly opti-
5. The term "school" is problematic, but we mism, "L.A. Story" (Mick Jackson 1991).
here follow Jennifer Pratt and use the term to 12. One critic accused us (quite cleverly) of "neolo-
refer to "a collection of individuals working gorrhea."
in the same environment who at the time and 13. This term is a combination of Rene Girard's "mi-
through their own retrospective construc- metic contagion" and animal ethologist Richard
tions of their identity and the impartations of Dawkin's hypothesis that cultural informations
intellectual historians are defined as repre- are gene-type units, or "memes," transmitted vi-
senting a distinct approach to a scholarly rus-like from head to head. We here employ the
endeavor" (1995:2). term "hybridized" in recognition of the recency
and novelty of the combination, not to assert
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 69
some prior purity to the component elements Castells, M. 1997. The Information Age: Economy, Soci-
forming the hybrid. ety, and Culture, vol. 1: The Rise of the Network
14. The collection of essays assembled in Benko and Society, and vol. 2: The Power of Identity. Cam-
Strohmayer (1997) is an excellent overview of the bridge: Blackwell.
relationship between space and postmodernism, and Hall, P 1994. Technopoles of the World: The
including the urban question. Kevin Robins's Making of the 21st Century Industrial Complexes.
valuable work on media, visual cultures, and rep- New York: Routledge.
resentational issues also deserves a wide audience Cenzatti, M. 1993. Los Angeles and the L.A. School:
(e.g., Robins 1996; Morley and Robins 1995). Postmodernism and Urban Studies. Los Angeles:
15. A much fuller treatment of this assertion is to be Los Angeles Forum for Architecture and Urban
found in Dear (forthcoming). Design.
Chomsky, N. and Herman, E. 1988. Manufacturing
Consent. New York: Pantheon Books.
References Darlington, D. 1996. The Mojave: Portrait of the Defini-
tive American Desert. New York: Henry Holt.
Abelmann, N., and Lie, J. 1995. Blue Dreams: Korean Davis, M. 1996. How Eden Lost Its Garden: A Political
Americans and the Los Angeles Riots. Cambridge: History of the Los Angeles Landscape. In The
Harvard University Press. City: Los Angeles & Urban Theory at the End of the
Anderson, S. 1996. A City Called Heaven: Black En- Twentieth Century, ed. A. J. Scott and E. Soja, pp.
chantment and Despair in Los Angeles. In The 160-85. Los Angeles: University of California
City: Los Angeles & Urban Theory at the End of the Press.
Twentieth Century, ed. A. J. Scott and E. Soja, pp. Davis, M. L. 1990. City of Quartz: Excavating the Future
336-64. Los Angeles: University of California in Los Angeles. New York: Verso.
Press. . 1992a. Fortress Los Angeles: The Militarization
Auge, M. 1995. Non-places: Introduction to an Anthro- of Urban Space. In Variations on a Theme Park, ed.
pology of Super-Modernity. New York: Verso. M. Sorkin, pp. 154-80. New York: Noonday Press.
Baldassare, M., ed. 1994. The Los Angeles Riots. Boul- . 1992b. Chinatown Revisited? The Internation-
der, CO: Westview Press. alization of Downtown Los Angeles. In Sex, Death
Banham, R. 1973. Los Angeles: The Architecture of Four and God in L.A., ed. D. Reid, pp. 54-71. New York:
Ecologies. London: Penguin Books. Pantheon Books.
Benko, C., and Strohmayer, U., eds. 1997. Space and . 1992c. Think Green. In Remaking L.A., by
Social Theory: Interpreting Modernity and Postmod- Aaron Betsky. Los Angeles Times Magazine, De-
ernity. Oxford: Blackwell. cember 13.
Bottles, S. 1987. Los Angeles and the Automobile: The . 1993. Rivers in the Desert: William Mulholland
Making of the Modern City. Los Angeles: Univer- and the Inventing of Los Angeles. New York: Harper
sity of California Press. Collins.
Boyd, T 1997. Am I Black Enough for You? Indianapolis: Dawkins, R. 1976. The Selfish Gene. New York: Oxford
University of Indiana Press. University Press.
. 1996. A Small Introduction to the 'G' Funk Era: De Certeau, M. 1984. The Practice of Everyday Life.
Gangsta Rap and Black Masculinity in Contem- Berkeley: University of California Press.
porary Los Angeles. In Rethinking Los Angeles, ed. Dear, M. 1988. The Postmodern Challenge: Recon-
M. Dear, H. E. Schockman, and G. Hise, pp. structing Human Geography. Transactions of the
127-46. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Institute of British Geographers 13:262-74.
Bullard, R.D.; Grigsby, J. E.; and Lee, C. 1994. Residen- . 1989. Privatization and the Rhetoric of Plan-
tial Apartheid. Los Angeles: UCLA Center for ning Practice. Society & Space 7:449-62.
Afro-American Studies. . 1991. The Premature Demise of Postmodern
Burgess, E. W 1925. The Growth of the City. In The Urbanism. Cultural Anthropology 6:538-52.
City: Suggestions of Investigation of Human Behavior . Forthcoming. The Postmodern Urban Condition.
in the Urban Environment, ed. R.E. Park, E.W Oxford: Blackwell.
Burgess, and R. D. McKenzie, pp. 47-62. Chicago: ; Schockmnan, H. E.; and Hise, G., eds. 1996.
University of Chicago Press. Rethinking Los Angeles. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Butler, 0. E. 1993. Parable of the Sower. New York: Four Publications.
Walls Eight Windows. Del Castillo, R. 1979. The Los Angeles Barrio,
Canclini, N. G. 1996. Cultural Hybrids. Minneapolis: 1850-1890: A Social History. Los Angeles: Uni-
University of Minnesota Press. versity of California Press.
Candida Smith, R. 1995. Utopia and Dissent: Art, Po- Deverell, W 1994. Railroad Crossing: Californians and
etry, and Politics in California. Los Angeles: Univer- the Railroad 1850-1910. Los Angeles: University
sity of California Press. of California Press.
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
70 Dear and Flusty
Dewey, F. 1994. Cyburbia: Los Angeles as the New Harris, C. D. 1997. The Nature of Cities. Urban Geog-
Frontier, or Grave? Los Angeles Forum for Archi- raphy 18:15-35.
tecture and Urban Design Newletter, May, pp. and Ullman, E. L. 1945. The Nature of Cities.
6-7. Annals of the American Academy of Political and
Dogan, M., and Kasarda, J., eds. 1988. The Metropolis Social Science 242:7-17.
Era, vol. 1: A World of Giant Cities, and vol. 2.: Hayden, Delores. 1994. The Power of Place. Cambridge:
Mega-Cities. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications. The MIT Press.
Ellin, N. 1996. Postmodern Urbanism. Oxford: Black- Hise, G. 1997. Magnetic Los Angeles: Planning the Twen-
well. tieth-Century Metropolis. Baltimore: Johns Hop-
Erie, S. P Forthcoming. Global Los Angeles: Growth and kins University Press.
Crisis of a Developmental City-State. Stanford, CA: Hoeg, P 1993. Smilla's Sense of Snow. New York: Farrar
Stanford University Press. Straus & Giroux.
Fainstein, S. 1994. The City Builders: Property, Politics, Hoyt, H. 1939. The Structure and Growth of Residential
& Planning in London and New York. Oxford: Neighbourhoods in American Cities. Washington:
Blackwell. U.S. Federal Housing Administration.
Fishman, R. 1987. Bourgeois Utopias: The Rise and Fall . 1933. One Hundred Years of Land Values in
of Suburbia. New York: Basic Books, Inc. Chicago. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
FitzSimmons, M., and Gottlieb, Robert. 1996. Bound- It All Comes Together in Los Angeles? 1996. City 1/2,
ing and Binding Metropolitan Space: The Am- January.
biguous Politics of Nature in Los Angeles. In The Jameson, F. 1991. Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic
City: Los Angeles & Urban Theory at the End of the of Late Capitalism. Durham, NC: Duke University
Twentieth Century, ed. A. J. Scott and E. Soja, pp. Press.
186-224. Los Angeles: University of California Janowitz, M. 1967. Introduction. In The City: Sugges-
Press. tions for Investigation of Human Behavior in the
Flusty, S. 1994. Building Paranoia: The Proliferation of Urban Environment, ed. Robert E. Park, Ernest W
Interdictory Space and the Erosion of Spatial Justice. Burgess and Roderick D. McKenzie, pp. vii-x.
West Hollywood, CA: Los Angeles Forum for Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Architecture and Urban Design. Jencks, C. 1993. Heteropolis: Los Angeles, the Riots and
Folgelson, R.M. 1967. The Fragmented Metropolis: Los the Strange Beauty of Hetero-Architecture. London:
Angeles 1850-1970. Berkeley: University of Cali- Academy Editions; Berlin: Ernst & Sohn; New
fornia Press. York: St. Martin's Press.
Friedmann, John, and Wolf, Goetz. 1982. World City King, R. 1996. Emancipating Space: Geography, Archi-
Formation. An Agenda for Research and Action. tecture, and Urban Design. New York: Guilford
International Journal of Urban and Regional Re- Press.
search 6:309-44. Klein, M. 1995. The American Street Gang: Its Nature,
Fulton, W 1997. The Reluctant Metropolis: The Politics Prevalence, and Control. New York: Oxford Uni-
of Urban Growth in Los Angeles. Point Arena, CA: versity Press.
Solano Press Books. Knox, P, and Taylor, P. J., eds. 1995. World Cities in a
Garreau, J. 1991. Edge City: Life on the New Frontier. World System. Cambridge: Cambridge University
New York: Doubleday. Press.
Gibson, W 1996. Idoru. New York: Putnam. Ley, D. 1996. The New Middle Class and the Remaking
Globalization and the Changing U.S. City. 1997. An- of the Central City. New York: Oxford University
nals of the American Academy of Political and Social Press.
Science, May. Longstreth, R. 1997. City Central to Regional Mall:
Gooding-Williams, R., ed. 1993. Reading Rodney King, Architecture, the Automobile, and Retailing in Los
Reading Urban Uprising. New York: Routledge. Angeles, 1920-1950. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Gottdiener, M., and Kephart, G. 1991. The Multinu- McGuire, B., and Scrymgeour, D. Forthcoming. Sante-
cleated Metropolitan Region: A Comparative ria and Curanderismo in Los Angeles. In New
Analysis. In Postsuburban California: The Transfor- Trends and Developments in African Religion, ed.
mation of Orange County since World War II, ed. R. Peter Clarke. Westport, CT Greenwood Publish-
Kling and Olin M. Poster, pp. 31-54. Berkeley: ing.
University of California Press. McKenzie, E. 1994. Privatopia: Homeowner Associations
Gottlieb, R., and FitzSimmons, M. 1991. Thirst for and the Rise of Residential Private Government. New
Growth: Water Agencies and Hidden Government in Haven: Yale University Press.
California. Tucson: University of Arizona Press. McPhee, J. 1989. The Control of Nature. New York:
Hall, P 1966. World Cities. New York: McGraw-Hill. Noonday Press.
Hall, S. 1992. Cultural Studies and Its Theoretical McWilliams, C. 1946. Southern California: An Island on
Legacies. In Cultural Studies, ed. L. Grossberg, C. the Land. Salt Lake City: Peregrine Smith Books.
Nelson, and P Treichler, pp. 277-94. New York:
Routledge.
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Postmodern Urbanism 71
Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Century, ed. A. J. Scott and E. Soja, pp. 426-62.
Pred, A. 1995. Recognizing European Modernities. New Los Angeles: University of California Press.
York: Routledge. . 1996b. Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and
Pulido, L. 1996. Multiracial Organizing among Envi- Other Real-And-Imagined Places. Cambridge:
ronmental Justice Activists in Los Angeles. In Blackwell.
Rethinking Los Angeles, ed. M. Dear, H. E. Schock- and Scott, A. J. 1986. Los Angeles: Capital of
man, and G. Hise, pp. 171-89. Thousand Oaks, the Late Twentieth Century. Society & Space
CA: Sage Publications. 4:249-54.
Raban, J. 1974. Soft City. New York: E. P Dutton. Sonenshein, R. 1993. Politics in Black and White: Race
Reid, D., ed. 1992. Sex, Death and God in L.A. New and Power in Los Angeles. Princeton, NJ: Princeton
York: Pantheon Books. University Press.
Reisner, M. 1993. Cadillac Desert: The American West Sorkin, M., ed. 1992. Variations on a Theme Park: The
and Its Disappearing Water. New York: Penguin New American City and the End of Public Space.
Books. New York: Hill and Wang.
Relph, E. C. 1987. The Modern Urban Landscape. Bal- Steinberg, J. B.; Lyon, D.W; and Vaiana, M. E., eds.
timore: Johns Hopkins University Press. 1992. Urban America: Policy Choices for Los Ange-
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
72 Dear and Flusty
les and the Nation. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Watson, S., and Gibson, K., eds. 1995. Postmodern Cities
Corp. and Spaces. Cambridge: Blackwell.
Storper, M., and Walker, R. 1989. The Capitalist Impera- Weiss, M. 1987. The Rise of the Community Builders: The
tive. Cambridge: Blackwell. American Real Estate Industry and Urban Land
Sudjic, D. 1992. The 1 00-Mile City. San Diego: Harvest Planning. New York: Columbia University Press.
Original. Wolch, J. 1990. The Shadow State: Government and
Suisman, D. R. 1989. Los Angeles Boulevard. Los Ange- Voluntary Sector in Transition. New York: The
les: Los Angeles Forum for Architectural and Foundation Center.
Urban Design. . 1996. From Global to Local: The Rise of Home-
Fygiel, J. 1994. The Great Los Angeles Swindle: Oil, lessness in Los Angeles during the 1980s. In The
Stocks, and Scandal during the Roaring Twenties. City: Los Angeles & Urban Theory at the End of the
New York: Oxford University Press. Twentieth Century, ed. A. J. Scott & E. Soja,
Urban Geography 17(1). Columbia: Bellwether Pub- pp. 390-425. Los Angeles: University of Califor-
lishing, Ltd. nia Press.
Vigil, J. 1988. Barrio Gangs: Streetlife and Identity in and Dear, M. 1993. Malign Neglect: Homelessness
Southern California. Austin: University of Texas in an American City. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Press. and Sommer, J. 1997. Los Angeles in an Era of
Wachs, M. 1996. The Evolution of Transportation Pol- Welfare Reform: Implications for Poor People and
icy in Los Angeles: Images of Past Policies and Community Well-being. Los Angeles: Liberty Hill
Future Prospects. In The City: Los Angeles & Foundation.
Urban Theory at the End of the Twentieth Century, Yoon, I. 1997. On My Own: Korean Businesses and Race
ed. A. J. Scott and E. Soja, pp. 106-59. Los Relations in America. Chicago: University of Chi-
Angeles: University of California Press. cago Press.
Waldie, D. J. 1996. Holy Land: A Suburban Memoir. Zukin, S. 1994. The Culture of Cities. Oxford: Black-
New York: WW Norton. well.
Waldinger, R., and Bozorgmehr, M. 1996. Ethnic Los
Angeles. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Correspondence: Southern California Studies Center, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA
90089-1696.
This content downloaded from 5.196.89.225 on Sun, 17 Sep 2017 22:05:39 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms