Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Please cite this article in press as: Yates K, Le Couteur A, Diagnosing autism/autism spectrum disorders, Paediatrics and Child Health (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paed.2016.08.004
SYMPOSIUM: PSYCHIATRY
since the 1990s. There are no high quality robust studies con- Clinical research has demonstrated differences in trajectories
firming a rise in the true prevalence. The condition is three to of head growth in children with ASD. Macrocephaly is a recog-
four times more common in boys, with a male preponderance nized feature of ASD in 20e30% of cases though must be
rising in the high functioning group. NICE guidelines recognise interpreted in the context of parental head circumferences.
that in clinical practice girls may be under-diagnosed. It has been Studies have shown that as a group, head circumference accel-
suggested that high functioning females may be better at masking erates during the first 2 years of life, with deceleration possibly
their difficulties through imitation and observation of social ac- occurring in later childhood since average head circumference
tions and better verbal skills. has been reported in adolescence and adulthood. Although there
have been conflicting views around the relevance and cause of
What causes autism spectrum disorders? these changes, they are reported to happen prior to the onset of
clinical symptoms and may be a useful clinical indicator. Gene
ASD is accepted to be a neurodevelopmental condition with a
mutations in PTEN (Phosphatase and Tensin Homolog) have
biological basis. The heterogeneity of affected individuals and
been found in children with ASD and macrocephaly with case
genetic complexity has undoubtedly contributed to the daunting
series reporting a yield of 5% in those with head circumferences
task of identifying the cause(s) of ASD. Continuing research has
greater than 98th percentile.
not identified a clear aetiology, but evidence suggests that it has a
Research continues to study neurobiological differences in
complex genetic basis with strong heritability (60% concordance
ASD considering variation in neurotransmitters, volumetric and
reported in twin studies). Recurrence rates for siblings have been
functioning differences of various regions within the brain, but
reported between 3 and 10% with up to 18.7% when the broader
the relevance to clinical practice of most identified abnormalities
autism spectrum is considered.
has not been established.
Advances in molecular genetics have identified genetic vari-
Various environmental factors have been reported in the
ations e.g. ‘rare causal’ copy number variants and single gene
literature. Risk factors are shown in Box 1 and include prema-
polymorphisms which are significant or ‘causal’ in approxi-
turity less than 35 weeks gestation, prenatal maternal valproate
mately 10% of people diagnosed with ASD. De novo events may
use and congenital rubella. The controversy of links between the
be implicated in simplex families, whereas multiplex families
MMR vaccine and ASD are unfounded.
(when more than one family member is affected by ASD) may
pass a specific genetic variation through the generations which
Making a diagnosis
increases the risk of ASD. It is possible that several genes of small
effect may act through an epigenetic mechanism and environ- ASD is a heterogeneous condition with no single pathognomonic
mental factors influence phenotypic expression. In 10e15% of feature or specific diagnostic test. Diagnosis can be challenging
cases ASD is associated with a known medical condition. as affected individuals display variation in the degree of behav-
Consistently recognized genetic conditions include tuberous ioural severity, language and intellectual abilities. Moreover,
sclerosis (TS) and fragile X. Studies have shown that between 1% their behavioural profiles are likely to change with age and co-
and 3% of children with autism have TS and similar percentages occurring problems and co-morbidities are common. DSM-5
have fragile X. Other associations and a list of additional medical recognises that symptoms in the early developmental period
risk factors are shown in Box 1. may not manifest until capabilities are exceeded by social de-
mands. Similarly, there is recognition that for some adolescents,
repetitive behavioural manifestations are reduced through
Risk factors for autism spectrum disorder
developmental progress or intervention so criterion can be met
C Sibling with ASD
based on history. For a diagnosis of ASD under ICD-10, abnormal
C Parental schizophrenia-like-psychosis or affective disorder
or impaired development should be present by the age of 3 years.
C Maternal sodium valproate use during pregnancy
Many parents express concerns as early as 15e18 months of
C Gestational age less than 35 weeks
age, but despite increased awareness and guidance, average age
C Intellectual disability
at diagnosis remains at 4e5 years. This is possibly due to a
C Birth defects associated with central nervous system including
combination of factors that include variability of assessment
cerebral palsy
pathways, demand on services, lack of recognition of subtle
C Down syndrome
difficulties at a young age, presence of additional diagnoses and
C Fragile X
inclusion of school age individuals who may only present at an
C Tuberous sclerosis
older age when their difficulties may become more overt as they
Other medical conditions associated with ASD
are unable to manage increasingly challenging academic and/or
C Neurofibromatosis
social expectations. Studies have shown that diagnosis of ASD at
C Phenylketonuria (untreated)
2 years of age is possible and stable over time, although it is less
C Fetal alcohol syndrome
reliable for the broader autism spectrum.
C SmitheLemlieOpitz syndrome
C CHARGE syndrome
Symptoms and signs of autism spectrum disorders
C Duchenne muscular dystrophy
C Congenital rubella Social communication
C Iron-deficiency anaemia Difficulties and delay in social interaction are often the earliest
features in ASDs, but they can be subtle and easily missed.
Box 1 Risk factors and medical conditions associated with autism spec-
trum disorder Absence of joint attention (i.e. failure to show interest, share a
Please cite this article in press as: Yates K, Le Couteur A, Diagnosing autism/autism spectrum disorders, Paediatrics and Child Health (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paed.2016.08.004
SYMPOSIUM: PSYCHIATRY
focus of attention and follow gaze) is highly suggestive of ASD. distress and/or temper tantrums. Hypo- or hyper-sensitivity to
Carers may describe that the child fails to respond to their environmental stimuli or unusual interest in sensory aspects of
name when called repeatedly, raising the possibility of a the environment can be seen e.g. response to specific sounds or
hearing impairment. Inadequate facial expressions, including textures, insensitivity to pain, or fascination with smells, tex-
lack of social smiling and limited use of gestures, e.g. shaking tures or colours of food or fabrics.
head, nodding, waving, clapping, are also features. Individuals Repetitive behaviours are common in young children and are
with ASD lack awareness of others feelings and the impact of part of normal development. However for individuals with ASD
their behaviour on others. Sometimes this manifests as inap- excessive rates of repetitive behaviours can cause significant
propriate behaviour in a specific social context or inappropriate social impairment, interfere with learning new skills and
response to others’ emotions. There can be misinterpretation of contribute to levels of parental stress. For individuals with an
tone of voice and facial expressions of others, leading to dif- absence of restricted, repetitive patterns of behaviour, but who
ficulties with peers, often combined with the failure to develop have persistent difficulties in the social use of verbal and
mutual sharing of interests, activities and emotions. Younger nonverbal communication which limits effective communica-
children may not seek to share enjoyment, e.g. showing a toy tion, social relationships and learning (not explained by low
to a parent or pointing out objects of interest to others. cognitive ability), a new DSM-5 diagnosis of Social (pragmatic)
Conversely, higher functioning individuals often seek interac- Communication Disorder may be considered.
tion with others and make attempts to socialize, but come
across as socially odd. Often, social play is limited and in Regression
isolation to their peers. Regression or a period of stasis occurs in 20e30% of cases.
Concerns may be raised when a child has failed to acquire Regression most commonly affects language, usually at the less
language as expected. Some children with ASD may develop no than 10 word stage, therefore it is most often reported from 18
useful communicative speech or sounds. In contrast to those to 24 months of age. Motor development is preserved, but
with specific language disorders, children with ASD often fail to other skills can be affected and parents may concurrently
use gestures or mime to compensate. Instead, parents may report a change in sleeping or eating habits, loss of eye contact
describe the child either obtaining a required object themselves and development of a specific interest. Signs and symptoms of
or taking another person’s hand to the object as if to use them as ASD with regression in social communication skills in a child
a ‘tool’. Language is often atypical with idiosyncratic use of under 3 years is strongly associated with a diagnosis of ASD
words or phrases, e.g. nonsense or jargon words, or referral to although the aetiology is not understood. Regression can occur
self as ‘you’ (pronominal reversal). Other features include in children with ASD above 24 months, but pre-existing
abnormal delivery of speech (prosody), i.e. unusual pitch, speed, development is usually atypical. Autistic regression in chil-
volume or tone. Whatever the language skills present, two-way dren over 3 years or regression in motor domains warrant
reciprocal conversational interchanges tend to be difficult, careful assessment by a paediatrician or paediatric neurologist
particularly if the topic of conversation is restricted to the nar- to consider neurodegenerative conditions, such as Rett syn-
rowed/circumscribed and repetitive interest of the affected in- drome and Landau Kleffner.
dividual. An individual with ASD often struggles to engage in
social chat and build on conversation about someone else’s Learning disabilities
hobby or interest. Historically autism was mainly recognized in individuals with
severe impairment and learning disabilities (IQ less than 70.)
Restricted, repetitive behaviours, interests and With widening of the spectrum, comorbid learning disability is
activities reported to affect approximately 50% of people with ASD’s. In-
Interests and activities in individuals with ASD are often dividuals may show an unusual cognitive profile with significant
restrictive and repetitive. Stereotyped or repetitive motor discrepancies between verbal and non-verbal scores (in either
mannerisms such as hand flapping, finger flicking, head direction.) However, it is important to note that for individuals
banging and twirling may be seen. Repetitive use of objects i.e. with “higher” scores in either verbal or non-verbal abilities this
lining up toys, and repetitive use of speech e.g. delayed may not reflect their social skills nor their everyday adaptive
echolalia or stereotyped phrases (with constant form or living skills which are likely to be significantly impaired.
pattern) are well recognised. Delayed echolalia is the term
applied to copied or directly imitated speech, e.g. from an adult Epilepsy
(such as a relative or teacher, television or radio) that is The risk of epilepsy in ASD is increased compared with the
repeated some time after it is originally heard. For many in- general population and linked to lower IQ and regression, with
dividuals, play may lack creativity and imagination, but iso- peaks of incidence occurring at pre-school age and adolescence.
lated examples of pretend play and imitative behaviour do not Between 18% and 29% of children with ASD are affected and
exclude a diagnosis of ASD. A child may have a preoccupation any seizure type can occur. Epileptiform EEGs are common in
with an interest that is abnormal in intensity, content or both. ASD, and studies have shown that 10% of children with ASD
Some individuals with ASD have superior or special splinter have an epileptiform EEG without any clinical evidence of sei-
skills/abilities in one or more areas of functioning e.g. calcu- zures. There is no evidence that these discharges have a causal
lations, memory, music, artistic endeavours. There can be relationship to ASD or that routine EEGs should be performed.
insistence on sameness such that changes in routines or envi- Any investigation and treatment should be guided by the clinical
ronment are often resisted and not uncommonly result in presentation of the individual.
Please cite this article in press as: Yates K, Le Couteur A, Diagnosing autism/autism spectrum disorders, Paediatrics and Child Health (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paed.2016.08.004
SYMPOSIUM: PSYCHIATRY
Psychiatric, behavioural and neurodevelopmental co- Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder Dif-
morbidities associated with autism spectrum disorder ferential diagnoses may also be coexisting conditions
Box 2 Box 3
Please cite this article in press as: Yates K, Le Couteur A, Diagnosing autism/autism spectrum disorders, Paediatrics and Child Health (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paed.2016.08.004
SYMPOSIUM: PSYCHIATRY
Please cite this article in press as: Yates K, Le Couteur A, Diagnosing autism/autism spectrum disorders, Paediatrics and Child Health (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paed.2016.08.004
SYMPOSIUM: PSYCHIATRY
include severity of behaviours, cognitive abilities and verbal ca- USEFUL RESOURCES
pacity. Studies have reported encouraging findings for individuals 7 www.nas.org.uk National Autistic Society.
receiving early intervention focussing on skills development, but 8 www.researchautism.net Research autism.
further research is needed to determine how early interventions 9 www.autismgenome.org Autism genome project.
will impact on individuals with ASD in the longer term. A 10 www.effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov Therapies for children with
ASD 2014.
11 www.cafamily.org.uk Contact a family.
FURTHER READING 12 www.rarechromo.org Unique: understanding chromosome
disorders.
1 National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence. Autism in under
19s: recognition, referral and diagnosis of children and young
people on the autism spectrum. Clinical Guideline CG128. Practice points
September 2011. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence,
www.nice.org.uk.
C ASD is a heterogeneous lifelong neurodevelopmental condition
2 National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence. Autism in under with behavioural difficulties affecting social communication and
19s: support and management. Clinical Guideline CG170. August restricted repetitive patterns of behaviour, activities and interests.
2013. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, www.nice.
C Assessment of children and young people with suspected ASD
org.uk. should be a timely multidisciplinary process with local pathways
3 American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical providing access to a specialist ASD team.
manual of mental disorders. 5th edn. 2013. Washington, DC:
C Aetiology of ASD is unknown though it is highly heritable. Epi-
American Psychiatric Association, www.dsm5.org. genetics is likely to play a role in phenotypical presentation.
4 World Health Organisation. The ICD-10 classification of mental and
C Diagnosis is clinical and can be made accurately in the pre-school
behavioural disorders, 10th revision. Geneva: World Health Orga- period.
nisation, 1993.
C Girls on the autism spectrum may be underdiagnosed.
5 NICE Guideline 43. Transition from children’s to adult’s services for
C Medical investigations should be guided by clinical presentation
young people using health or social care services. February 2016. and features of the individual patient.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, www.nice.org.uk.
C Early recognition of the condition is likely to have a positive
6 National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence. Challenging impact on outcome.
behaviour and learning disabilities: prevention and interventions for
C Co-morbid conditions are common and should be recognized and
people with learning disabilities whose behaviour challenges. NICE managed appropriately.
Guideline 11. May 2015. National Institute for Health and Care
Excellence, www.nice.org.uk.
Please cite this article in press as: Yates K, Le Couteur A, Diagnosing autism/autism spectrum disorders, Paediatrics and Child Health (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paed.2016.08.004