Nike v. Skechers U.S.A. - Complaint (C.D. Cal. 2019)

Case 2:19-cv-08418 Document 1 Filed 09/30/19 Page 1 of 37 Page ID #:1
1
Jeffrey T. Thomas, SBN 106409
2 jtthomas@gibsondunn.com
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
3
3161 Michelson Drive
4 Irvine, CA 92612-4412
Telephone: (949) 451-3800
5
Facsimile: (949) 451-4220
6
Sean S. Twomey, SBN 279527 Christopher J. Renk (pro hac vice to
7
stwomey@gibsondunn.com be filed)
8 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP crenk@bannerwitcoff.com
9
333 South Grand Avenue BANNER & WITCOFF, LTD.
Los Angeles, CA 90071-3197 71 South Wacker Drive, Suite 3600
10 Telephone: (213) 229-7284 Chicago, IL 60606
11
Facsimile: (213) 229-6284 Telephone: (312) 463-5000
Facsimile: (312) 463-5001
12 [Additional Counsel Listed on Signature
13 Page] Attorneys for Plaintiff NIKE, Inc.
14 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

15 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
16
17 ) Case No. 2:19-cv-08418
NIKE, INC., )
18 ) COMPLAINT FOR PATENT
Plaintiff,
19 ) INFRINGEMENT
vs. )
20 )
SKECHERS U.S.A., INC., JURY TRIAL REQUESTED
21 )
Defendant
)
22
)
23
24
25
26
27
28
1 Plaintiff NIKE, Inc. (“NIKE”) for its Complaint against Defendant Skechers
2 U.S.A., Inc. (“Skechers”) alleges as follows:
3 INTRODUCTION
4 1. NIKE is the world’s leading designer, marketer, and distributor of athletic
5 footwear. NIKE became the industry leader, and maintains that position, by investing
6 heavily in research, design, and development; creating game-changing designs and
7 technologies.
8 2. Skechers also markets and distributes athletic footwear. But instead of
9 innovating its own designs and technologies, Skechers often copies the successful
10 products of others. As one commentator explained, “it’s hard to mask that [Skechers]
11 is a copy-cat” that “has blatantly knocked off” the popular designs of others like
12 NIKE. (https://sneakernews.com/2016/07/11/skechers-knockoff-shoes/.)
13 3. Skechers’ copying strategy is driven by its CEO, Robert Greenberg. In a
14 prior lawsuit, a Skechers corporate witness testified that Mr. Greenberg gave orders
15 to knock-off competitor products. adidas Am., Inc. v. Skechers USA, Inc., No. 3:15-
16 CV-01741-HZ, 2017 WL 3319190, at *12 (D. Or. Aug. 3, 2017). Even Skechers’
17 attorneys admitted that Skechers sets-out to make “Skecherized version[s]” of
18 competitor products, and that the directions to do so come from Mr. Greenberg. Id.
19 4. Skechers contends it merely takes inspiration from competitor products,
20 which it calls “Skecherizing.” But that argument is belied by Skechers’ own
21 documents. In a prior lawsuit, a court found Skechers uses code words in its internal
22 documents to attempt to shield the documents from discovery. Id. The documents
23 Skechers hoped to hide from discovery in that case showed Skechers employees
24 holding prototype shoes next to competitor shoes with detailed instructions on how
25 to transform the prototypes into “exact copies” of the competitor shoes. Id.
26 5. Skechers’ business strategy includes copying its competitors’ designs to
27 gain market share.
28
1
1 6. NIKE’s strategy is to compete fairly. As such, NIKE’s intellectual

2 property rights are important to its brand, its success, and its competitive position.
3 NIKE pursues available protections of these rights and vigorously protects them
4 against third-party theft and infringement.
5 7. This lawsuit is another one in a series of lawsuits NIKE has filed against
6 Skechers to protect its valuable innovations, particularly its designs.
7 8. NIKE and its subsidiary, Converse Inc., have previously filed two
8 lawsuits against Skechers for its infringements. Both of those lawsuits are still
9 pending.
10 9. In the first lawsuit, Converse initiated an ITC investigation against
11 Skechers for infringing Converse’s trademark rights in the midsole configuration
12 Converse has used on its Chuck Taylor All Star shoes since 1932. In the Matter of
13 Certain Footwear Products, USITC Inv. No. 337-TA-936. The illustrations below
14 show an authentic Converse All Star shoe next to an example Skechers’ infringing
15 shoe that bears an identical midsole configuration.
16
Converse All Star Shoe Skechers Infringing Shoe
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
10. The second lawsuit is currently pending in this Court. NIKE, Inc. v.
24
Skechers U.S.A., Inc., Case No. 2:17-cv-08509-JAK (Ex). NIKE filed that lawsuit to
25
stop Skechers’ infringements of NIKE’s patented NIKE Free and Flyknit designs.
26
The illustrations below show examples of NIKE’s patented designs next to examples
27
of Skechers’ infringing shoes at issue in that lawsuit.
28
2
1
Examples of Skechers’ Infringements in Pending Lawsuit
2 NIKE Designs Skechers Infringing Shoes
3
10
11. Skechers continues to copy NIKE’s designs. In particular, Skechers is
11
now copying NIKE’s VaporMax designs and NIKE’s Air Max 270 designs.
12
12. The illustrations below show examples of NIKE’s VaporMax and Air
13
Max 270 shoes next to examples of Skechers’ infringing shoes.
14
15 Examples of Skechers’ Infringements in this Lawsuit

16 NIKE Shoes Skechers Infringing Shoes
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
13. One commentator posted a YouTube video review of the Skech-Air Atlas
26
shoe—the Skechers shoe shown in the top row above—in which he describes the shoe
27
as a “blatant knockoff” that has a midsole design that looks “exactly the same” as
28
3
1 NIKE’s VaporMax design. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p99LtKMjjL0). An

2 excerpt from his post is reproduced below.
3
10 14. NIKE filed this lawsuit to continue to defend its design innovation and
11 stop Skechers from free-riding on NIKE’s significant investment of talent and
12 resources that are deployed to innovate.
13 THE PARTIES
14 15. NIKE is a corporation organized under the laws of the State of Oregon
15 with a principal place of business at One Bowerman Drive, Beaverton, Oregon 97005.
16 16. Skechers is a corporation organized under the laws of the State of
17 Delaware with a principal place of business at 228 Manhattan Beach Boulevard,
18 Manhattan Beach, California 90266.
19 JURISDICTION AND VENUE
20 17. This is an action for patent infringement arising under the patent laws of
21 the United States, 35 U.S.C. § 100 et seq. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction
22 pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a).
23 18. This Court has personal jurisdiction over Skechers because Skechers
24 maintains its headquarters and principal place of business in this District. This Court
25 also has personal jurisdiction over Skechers because Skechers regularly solicits and
26 conducts business in this District and engages in other persistent courses of conduct
27 in this District. This Court also has personal jurisdiction over Skechers because
28 Skechers derives substantial revenue from goods and services sold to persons or
4
1 entities in this District and commits acts of infringement in this District, including but
2 not limited to making, using, offering to sell, selling, and/or importing products that
3 infringe one or more claims of NIKE’s patents at issue in this lawsuit.
4 19. Venue is proper in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391 and 1400
5 because Skechers maintains a regular and established place of business in this District
6 and has committed, and continues to commit, acts of infringement in this District,
7 including but not limited to making, using, offering to sell, selling, and/or importing
8 products that infringe one or more claims of NIKE’s patents at issue in this lawsuit.
9 FACTUAL BACKGROUND
10 20. NIKE’s principal business activity is the design, development and
11 worldwide marketing and selling of athletic footwear, apparel, equipment,
12 accessories, and services.
13 21. NIKE invests heavily in research, design, and development; and those
14 efforts are key to NIKE’s success.
15 22. NIKE’s investments in research, design, and development have led to
16 many innovative footwear designs and technologies, including the designs at issue in
17 this case.
18 NIKE’S VAPORMAX AND AIR MAX 270 DESIGNS
19 23. NIKE’s VaporMax and Air Max 270 designs are associated with footwear
20 with Air sole units. The Air sole units are located in the midsole area beneath the
21 heel, forefoot, or in both areas.
22 24. NIKE first introduced shoes with Air sole units in 1979. But for the first
23 eight years, the Air sole units were embedded in sole structures and not visible. They
24 were felt rather than seen.
25 25. That changed in 1987, when NIKE introduced its Air Max shoe, which
26 was NIKE’s first shoe to showcase a design with a visible Air sole unit. The original
27 Air Max shoe is shown below.
28
5
1
Original Air Max
2
8 26. The revolution of NIKE shoe designs with visible Air sole units had
9 begun. NIKE shoe designs with visible Air sole units quickly spread, from running
10 to basketball to training and tennis, at the same time becoming a coveted lifestyle
11 product across the globe.
12 27. NIKE continued to innovate, creating shoe designs with visible Air sole
13 units over the following three decades. For example, in 1997, NIKE introduced the
14 Air Max 97 shoe, which had a visible Air sole unit along the entire sole of the shoe.
15 The illustration below shows the evolution of NIKE shoe designs with visible Air sole
16 units from 1987 through 2015.
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
6
1
Evolution of NIKE Shoe Designs With Visible Air Sole Units
2
10
11
12
13
28. NIKE continued the design evolution in 2017 when it introduced its
14
VaporMax footwear. The VaporMax built upon the nearly 30-year legacy of NIKE
15
shoe designs with visible Air sole units. An example NIKE VaporMax shoe is shown
16
below with its unique design.
17
NIKE’s VaporMax
18

19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26 29. In 2018, NIKE introduced its Air Max 270. While there had been other
27 NIKE shoe designs with Air sole units designed especially for lifestyle, they all
28 featured Air sole units originally created for running performance. The Air Max 270
7
1 was NIKE’s first 100-percent lifestyle Air shoe. An example NIKE Air Max 270
2 shoe is shown below with its unique design.
3
NIKE’s Air Max 270
4
10
11
12
30. NIKE’s VaporMax and Air Max 270 designs are important components
13
of NIKE’s strategy and they are integral to NIKE’s success.
14
31. NIKE has taken steps to protect its VaporMax and Air Max 270 designs,
15
including by filing and obtaining design patents around the world.
16
32. Relevant to this dispute, NIKE owns all right, title, and interest in, and
17
has the right to sue and recover for past, present, and future infringement of, design
18
patents related to its VaporMax designs, including the design patents identified in
19
Table 1 below (the “VaporMax Patents”).
20
21 Table 1: VaporMax Patents

U.S. Pat. No. Title Issue Date Complaint Exhibit
22
D850,068 Shoe June 4, 2019 A
23 D850,072 Shoe June 4, 2019 B
24
D850,074 Shoe June 4, 2019 C
D850,075 Shoe June 4, 2019 D
25 D850,076 Shoe June 4, 2019 E
26 D850,077 Shoe June 4, 2019 F
27
28
8
1 33. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (“USPTO”) duly and legally
2 issued the VaporMax Patents on June 4, 2019. A copy of each VaporMax Patent is
3 attached to this Complaint as indicated in Table 1.
4 34. NIKE gives the public, including Skechers, notice that the VaporMax
5 designs are patented by marking its VaporMax footwear pursuant to 35 U.S.C §
6 287(a), including by virtually marking the footwear at
7 www.nike.com/patentsvirtualmarking as of or shortly after the date of issuance of
8 each patent.
9 35. NIKE also owns all right, title, and interest in, and has the right to sue and
10 recover for past, present, and future infringement of, design patents related to its Air
11 Max 270 designs, including the design patents identified in Table 2 below (the “Air
12 Max 270 Patents”).
13
Table 2: Air Max 270 Patents
14 U.S. Pat. No. Title Issue Date Complaint Exhibit
15 D858,962 Shoe September 10, 2019 G
D860,606 Shoe September 24, 2019 H
16
D860,607 Shoe September 24, 2019 I
17 D860,608 Shoe September 24, 2019 J
D860,610 Shoe September 24, 2019 K
18
D860,611 Shoe September 24, 2019 L
19
36. The USPTO duly and legally issued the Air Max 270 Patents on
20
September 10 and 24, 2019. A copy of each Air Max 270 Patent is attached to this
21
Complaint as indicated in Table 2.
22
37. NIKE gives the public, including Skechers, notice that the Air Max 270
23
designs are patented by marking its Air Max 270 footwear pursuant to 35 U.S.C §
24
287(a), including by virtually marking the footwear at
25
www.nike.com/patentsvirtualmarking as of or shortly after the date of issuance of
26
each patent.
27
38. The VaporMax Patents and the Air Max 270 Patents are all presumed to
28
be valid.
9
1 SKECHERS USES THE VAPORMAX DESIGNS WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION

2 39. Without NIKE’s authorization, Skechers has made, used, offered for sale,
3 sold, and/or imported into the United States shoes having designs that violate the
4 VaporMax Patents. Skechers’ infringing shoes include at least the Skech-Air Atlas
5 with model numbers 52970 and 52973, as well as all other shoes bearing the same or
6 similar designs to the Skech-Air Atlas regardless of model name and number
7 (collectively, the “Skech-Air Atlas Shoes”).
8 40. The overall appearance of the claimed designs of the VaporMax Patents
9 and the corresponding designs of the Skech-Air Atlas Shoes are substantially the
10 same.
11 41. An ordinary observer will perceive the overall appearance of the claimed
12 designs of the VaporMax Patents and the corresponding designs of the Skech-Air
13 Atlas Shoes to be substantially the same.
14 42. Tables 3 through 8 below illustrate Skechers’ infringements by
15 comparing figures from the VaporMax Patents with images of the Skech-Air Atlas
16 Shoes. In NIKE’s patent figures, the claimed designs are shown in solid lines. The
17 broken lines depicting the remainder of the shoe show features that form no part of
18 the claimed designs.
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
10
1
Table 3: Comparison of ’068 Patent with Skech-Air Atlas Shoe
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
11
1
2
10 Table 5: Comparison of ’074 Patent with Skech-Air Atlas Shoe

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
12
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
13
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
14
1
2
10

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
15
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
26 sold, and/or imported into the United States additional shoes having designs that
27 violate at least the ’072 Patent and the ’074 Patent. These additional infringing shoes
28 include at least the Skech-Air 92 with model numbers 13221 and 52569, as well as
16
1 all shoes bearing the same or similar designs to the Skech-Air 92 regardless of model
2 name and number (collectively, the “Skech-Air 92 Shoes”).
3 44. The overall appearance of the claimed designs of the ’072 Patent and the
4 ’074 Patent and the corresponding designs of the Skech-Air 92 Shoes are substantially
5 the same.
7 designs of the ’072 Patent and the ’074 Patent and the corresponding designs of the
8 Skech-Air 92 Shoes to be substantially the same.
9 46. Tables 9 and 10 below illustrate Skechers’ infringements by comparing
10 figures from the ’072 Patent and ’074 Patent with images of the Skech-Air 92 Shoes.
11 In NIKE’s patent figures, the claimed designs are shown in solid lines. The broken
12 lines depicting the remainder of the shoe show features that form no part of the
13 claimed designs.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
17
1
Table 9: Comparison of ’072 Patent with Skech-Air 92 Shoe
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
18
1
2
9 47. On information and belief, Skechers intended to copy the claimed designs
10 of the VaporMax Patents by creating the same or similar overall impression as
11 NIKE’s designs.
12 SKECHERS USES THE AIR MAX 270 DESIGNS WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION
14 sold, and/or imported into the United States shoes having designs that violate the Air
15 Max 270 Patents. Skechers’ infringing shoes include at least the Skech-Air Stratus
16 with model numbers 13275, 13276, and 13278, as well as all shoes bearing the same
17 or similar designs to the Skech-Air Stratus regardless of model name and number
18 (collectively, the “Skech-Air Stratus Shoes”), and the Skech-Air Blast with model
19 numbers 97742, 97743, and 97744, as well as all shoes bearing the same or similar
20 designs to the Skech-Air Blast regardless of model name and number (collectively,
21 the “Skech-Air Blast Shoes”).
22 49. The overall appearance of the claimed designs of the Air Max 270
23 Patents, on the one hand, and the corresponding designs of the Skech-Air Stratus
24 Shoes and the Skech-Air Blast Shoes, on the other hand, are substantially the same.
26 designs of the Air Max 270 Patents, on the one hand, and the corresponding designs
27 of the Skech-Air Stratus Shoes and the Skech-Air Blast Shoes, on the other hand, to
28 be substantially the same.
19
1 51. Tables 11 through 22 below illustrate Skechers’ infringements by

2 comparing figures from the Air Max 270 Patents with images of the Skech-Air Stratus
3 Shoes and the Skech-Air Blast Shoes. In NIKE’s patent figures, the claimed designs
4 are shown in solid lines. The broken lines depicting the remainder of the shoe show
5 features that form no part of the claimed designs.
6
Table 11: Comparison of ’962 Patent with Skech-Air Stratus Shoe
7
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
20
2 Table 12: Comparison of ’606 Patent with Skech-Air Stratus Shoe
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
21
1
2
10

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
22
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
23
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
24
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
25
1
2
10
11 Table 17: Comparison of ’962 Patent with Skech-Air Blast Shoe
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
26
1
Table 17: Comparison of ’962 Patent with Skech-Air Blast Shoe
2

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
27
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18

20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
28
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
30
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
31
1
2
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18 52. On information and belief, Skechers intended to copy the claimed designs
19 of the Air Max 270 Patents by creating the same or similar overall impression as
20 NIKE’s designs.
21 FIRST CLAIM FOR RELIEF

(INFRINGEMENT UNDER 35 U.S.C. § 271 OF THE VAPORMAX PATENTS)
22
23 53. NIKE re-alleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
24 paragraphs 1–52 of this Complaint.
25 54. Skechers, without authorization from NIKE, has made, used, offered for
26 sale, sold, and/or imported in or into the United States, and continues to make, use,
27 offer for sale, sell, and/or import in or into the United States, shoes having designs
28 that infringe the VaporMax Patents, including at least the Skech-Air Atlas Shoes.
32
1 55. On information and belief, Skechers’ infringement has been willful,

2 intentional, and deliberate, at least as of the filing date of this complaint. Skechers
3 knew or should have known that continuing to make, use, offer to sell, sell, and/or
4 import the Skech-Air Atlas Shoes into the United States would directly infringe the
5 VaporMax Patents, yet Skechers infringed and continues to infringe the VaporMax
6 Patents.
7 56. NIKE has been and will continue to be irreparably harmed by Skechers’
8 infringements of the VaporMax Patents.
9 57. NIKE has no adequate remedy at law for Skechers’ infringements of the
10 VaporMax Patents.
11 58. On information and belief, Skechers’ infringements of the VaporMax
12 Patents will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
13
SECOND CLAIM FOR RELIEF
14 (INFRINGEMENT UNDER 35 U.S.C. § 271 OF THE ’072 PATENT AND ’074 PATENT)
20 that infringe the ’072 Patent and the ’074 Patent, including at least the Skech-Air 92
21 Shoes.
25 import the Skech-Air 92 into the United States would directly infringe the ’072 Patent
26 and ’074 Patent, yet Skechers infringed and continues to infringe the ’072 Patent and
27 ’074 Patent.
28
33
2 infringements of the ’072 Patent and ’074 Patent.
4 ’072 Patent and ’074 Patent.
5 64. On information and belief, Skechers’ infringements of the ’072 Patent and
6 ’074 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
7 THIRD CLAIM FOR RELIEF
8 (INFRINGEMENT UNDER 35 U.S.C. § 271 OF THE AIR MAX 270 PATENTS)
14 that infringe the Air Max 270 Patents, including at least the Skech-Air Stratus Shoes
15 and the Skech-Air Blast Shoes.
19 import the Skech-Air Stratus Shoes and Skech-Air Blast Shoes into the United States
20 would directly infringe the Air Max 270 Patents, yet Skechers infringed and continues
21 to infringe the Air Max 270 Patents.
23 infringements of the Air Max 270 Patents.
25 Air Max 270 Patents.
26 70. On information and belief, Skechers’ infringements of the Air Max 270
27 Patents will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
28
34
1 JURY DEMAND
2 71. Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38(b), NIKE hereby demands
3 a trial by jury of all issues so triable.
4
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
5
WHEREFORE, NIKE respectfully prays for:
6
A. A judgment and order that Skechers has infringed the VaporMax Patents
7
and the Air Max 270 Patents by making, using, offering to sell, selling, and/or
8
importing its infringing shoes into the United States;
9
B. A judgment and order permanently enjoining Skechers and its affiliates,
10
officers, agents, employees, attorneys, and all other persons acting in concert with
11
Skechers, from infringing the VaporMax Patents and the Air Max 270 Patents;
12
C. A judgment and order requiring Skechers to pay NIKE damages adequate
13
to compensate NIKE for Skechers’ infringements of the VaporMax Patents and the
14
Air Max 270 Patents pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 284, or the total profit made by Skechers
15
from its infringements of the VaporMax Patents and the Air Max 270 Patents pursuant
16
to 35 U.S.C. § 289;
17
E. A judgment and order requiring Skechers to pay NIKE supplemental
18
damages or profits for any continuing post-verdict infringement up until entry of the
19
final judgment, with an accounting, as needed;
20
F. A judgment and order requiring Skechers to pay NIKE increased damages
21
up to three times the amount found or assessed pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 284;
22
G. A judgment and order requiring Skechers to pay NIKE pre-judgment and
23
post-judgment interest on any damages or profits awarded;
24
H. A determination that this action is an exceptional case pursuant to 35
25
U.S.C. § 285;
26
I. An award of NIKE’s attorneys’ fees for bringing and prosecuting this
27
action;
28
35
1 J. An award of NIKE’s costs and expenses incurred in bringing and

2 prosecuting this action; and
3 K. Such further and additional relief as this Court deems just and proper.
4
5 Dated: September 30, 2019

6
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
7
8 By: /s/ Jeffrey T. Thomas .
9 Jeffrey T. Thomas, SBN 106409

10 jtthomas@gibsondunn.com
Sean S. Twomey, SBN 279527
11 stwomey@gibsondunn.com
12 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
3161 Michelson Drive
13 Irvine, CA 92612
14 Telephone: (949) 451-3800
Facsimile: (949) 451-4220
15
16 Christopher J. Renk (pro hac vice to be filed)

crenk@bannerwitcoff.com
17 Michael J. Harris (pro hac vice to be filed)
18 mharris@bannerwitcoff.com
Audra C. Eidem Heinze (pro hac vice to be filed)
19 aheinze@bannerwitcoff.com
20
BANNER & WITCOFF, LTD
21 71 South Wacker Drive, Suite 3600
22 Chicago, IL 60606
Telephone: (312) 463-5000
23 Facsimile: (312) 463-5001
24
Attorneys for Plaintiff NIKE, Inc.
25
26
27
28
36
Case 2:19-cv-08418 Document 1-1 Filed 09/30/19 Page 1 of 8 Page ID #:38
EXHIBIT A
Exhibit A - Page 37
USOOD850068S
(12 ) Campos
Unitedet States
al.
Design Patent (10) Patent No.: US D850,068 S
(45) Date of Patent: * * * Jun . 4 , 2019
(54 ) SHOE (56 ) References Cited
(71) Applicant: NIKE , Inc., Beaverton , OR (US) U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS
(72 ) Inventors : Fidencio Campos, Dallas, OR (US); D29,749 S 11/1898 Bunker
Troy C . Lindner , Portland , OR (US) ; 632 ,423 A 9 / 1899 Peacock
2 , 468, 886 A 5 / 1949 Lutey
Tetsuya T . Minami, Portland , OR (US) D169 ,556 S * 5 / 1953 Maling D2 /947
2 ,826 ,832 A 3 /1958 Rollman
(73 ) Assignee : NIKE , Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) 2 ,853 , 809 A
2 ,954 ,618 A
9 / 1958 Bianchi
10 / 1960 Rados
( * ) Notice : This patent is subject to a terminal dis D196 ,491 S 10 /1963 Papoutsy
3 ,793 ,750 A 2 / 1974 Bowerman
claimer . D241,688 S 10 / 1976 Johnson
4 ,096 ,649 A 6 / 1978 Saurwein
(* *) Term : 15 Years D253 ,257 S
D254 ,818 S
10 / 1979
4 /1980
Pasquier
Jones
(21) Appl. No.: 29/669 ,716 4 , 271,606 A 6 /1981 Rudy
(Continued )
(22) Filed : Nov. 9, 2018
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Related U .S . Application Data
Women 's Skech -Air by Skechers USA , Inc . USA [online ]. [retrieved
(63 ) Continuation of application No. 29/ 557, 831, filed on Apr. 10 , 2014 ]. Retrieved from the Internet < URL : http ://www .
Mar. 11, 2016 , which is a continuation -in - part of skechers.com /style /11848/ skech-air# Color =GYHP > .
application No. 29/ 542,737 , filed on Oct. 16 , 2015 ,
now abandoned , which is a continuation of (Continued )
application No . 29 /519 , 930 , filed on Mar. 9 , 2015 , Primary Examiner — T Chase Nelson
now abandoned .
(51) LOC ( 11) CI. ............... 02 - 04 (74 ) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Banner & Witcoff, Ltd.
(52) U . S . CI.
USPC . . . . . . . . . . .. .... ..... ................ D2/947
(58 ) Field of Classification Search (57 ) CLAIM
USPC .... ........... D2 /902, 906 , 908, 916 , 918 , 925 ,
D2 / 946 – 962, 977 ; 36 /3 B , 22 R , 24 . 5 , The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described .
36 /25 R , 28 , 32 R , 34 R , 59 C , 67 A , 103
??? . A43B 13 /00 ; A43B 13 /02 ; A43B 13 /023 ;
A43B 13 /026 ; A43B 13 /04 ; A43B 13 /08 ; DESCRIPTION
A43B 13 / 10 ; A43B 13 / 12 ; A43B 13 / 14 ;
A43B 13 / 141; A43B 13 / 143 ; A43B FIG . 1 is a side view of a shoe showing our new design ;
13/ 16 ; A43B 13/ 18; A43B 13 / 181; A43B FIG . 2 is an opposite side view thereof; and ,
13 / 187 ; A43B 13 / 189 ; A43B 13 / 20 ; A43B FIG . 3 is a rear view thereof.
13 /22 ; A43B 13 / 223 ; A43B 13 / 24 ; A43B The broken lines depicting the remainder of the shoe show
13 /28 ; A43B 13 /30 ; A43B 13 /32 ; A43B features that form no part of the claimed design .
13 /34 ; A43B 13 / 36
See application file for complete search history. 1 Claim , 3 Drawing Sheets
- - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - -
D
Exhibit A - Page 38
US D850 , 068 S
Page 2
(56 ) References Cited 6 ,694 ,642 B2 * 2 /2004 Turner ................· A43B 13 / 143
36 /28
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D494 ,748 S 8 / 2004 McClaskie
D495, 857 S 9 /2004 Herbst
4 ,309,831 A 1/ 1982 Pritt D497 ,706 S 11/ 2004 Belley et al .
4 , 377 ,041 A 3 / 1983 Alchermes D497 ,707 S 11/2004 Lee
4 ,378 ,643 A 4 / 1983 Johnson D512 ,817 S 12/2005 Ammon
4 ,439, 936 A 4 / 1984 Clarke et al. D519 ,267 S 4 /2006 Hlavacs
4 , 577,417 A 3/ 1986 Cole D520 ,220 S 5 /2006 Morgan et al.
D288 ,621 S 3/ 1987 Surpuriya et al. D523 ,627 S 6 /2006 Avar
D294,768 S 3 / 1988 Famolare, Jr. D524 ,035 S 7 /2006 Greene et al.
D297 ,383 S 8 / 1988 Mourad et al. D529 , 266 S 10 /2006 Le
D299 ,681 S 2 / 1989 Miller et al. D529, 267 S 10 /2006 Portzline
D300 ,085 S 3 / 1989 Ito et al. D529 ,706 S 10 /2006 Paz
D301, 184 S 5 / 1989 Hase D533 ,708 S 12 /2006 Earle
D301,659 S 6 / 1989 Le D536 , 163 S 2 /2007 McClaskie
D301,800 S 6 / 1989 Mitsui D538,519 S 3 / 2007 McClaskie
D321,973 S 12 / 1991 Hatfield D541,015 S 4 /2007 Diaz
D322 , 154 S 12 / 1991 Trueman D541,020 S 4 /2007 McClaskie
5 , 197 ,207 A 3 / 1993 Shorten D543 ,677 S * 6 / 2007 Andrews D2 /946
D335 ,572 S 5 / 1993 Peterson D545, 534 S 7 / 2007 McClaskie
D341, 708 S 11/ 1993 Blissett D547,033 S 7 /2007 Canavan
D344 ,847 S 3/ 1994 Mancebo D547 ,037 S 7 /2007 Nakano
D353 ,935 S 1/ 1995 Pollack D556 , 988S 12 /2007 Horne et al.
D356 ,672 S 3 / 1995 Ueda D557 ,484 S 12 / 2007 McClaskie
D362,747 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck .... D2 /977 D561,438 S 2 /2008 Belley
D362,954 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck ................ .......... D2 /977 D561,439 S 2 /2008 Schoenborn et al.
D380 ,889 S 7 / 1997 Earle D561,440 S. 2 / 2008 Andersen et al.
5 ,664,341 A 9 / 1997 Schmidt et al. 7 ,383 ,647
B2 6 / 2008 Chan et al.
D388,314 S 12 / 1997 Tresser D572 ,440 S * 7 /2008 Polegato Moretti ........... D2/907
D390 ,348 S 2 / 1998 Meyer et al. D573,779 S 7 / 2008 Stauffer
D390 ,349 S 2 / 1998 Murai et al . D578,745 S 10 /2008 Kaufman
D393, 538 S 4 / 1998 Marshall D579 ,185 S * 10 /2008 Mariman .. .. .. .. D2/947
D394 ,541 S 5 / 1998 Burgess 7 ,430 ,817 B2 10 /2008 Abadjian et al.
D395 ,340 S 6 / 1998 Tresser D580 ,636 S * 11/2008 Brandt ....... D2 /946
D395, 740 S 7 / 1998 Cass D583 , 132 S 12 /2008 Polegato Moretti
D395 , 744 S * 7 / 1998 Edington D2 /961 D583, 135 S * 12 / 2008 Mariman ... D2 /947
D397 ,546 S 9 / 1998 Merceron 7 ,464 ,489 B2 12/2008 Ho
D400, 000 S 10 / 1998 Hatfield et al. D592, 383 S 5 /2009 Wawrousek
D400, 345 S 11/ 1998 Teaque D599 ,986 S 9 / 2009 Reiss
5 ,836 ,094 A 11/ 1998 Figel D607, 192 S 1/ 2010 McClaskie
D401,745 S 12 / 1998 Greenberg D611,689 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D403 , 846 S 1 / 1999 Bove et al. D611,690 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D404 ,897 S 2 / 1999 Marshall 7 , 704 ,430 B2 4 / 2010 Johnson et al.
D407 , 193 S 3 / 1999 Doxey D621, 144 S 8 /2010 McClaskie
D409, 360 S * 5 / 1999 Movitz D2/947 D632, 879 S * 2 /2011 Merkazy D2 /953
D411 ,912 S 7 / 1999 Van Noy et al. D634 ,922 S 3/ 2011 Pauk et al .
D412 ,612 S 8 / 1999 Boyer 7, 918 , 041 B2 4 / 2011 Cho
D412 ,777 S * 8 / 1999 Norton D2/ 947 D639 ,540 S 6 /2011 Raysse
5 ,955 , 159 A 9 / 1999 Allen et al. D643 ,599 S * 8 /2011 Fontanarosa D2 /916
D414 ,597 S * 10 / 1999 Marvin D2/972 D650 ,978 S 12/2011 Lee
5 ,985, 383 A 11/ 1999 Allen et al. D652, 201 S 1/ 2012 Vestuti et al .
D418 ,665 S 1 /2000 Hatfield 8 ,099 ,880 B2 1/ 2012 Brewer et al.
6 ,018 ,889 A 2 / 2000 Friton D655 ,901 S * 3 /2012 Raysse ..... D2/951
D423 ,201 S 4 / 2000 Wilson D657, 941 S 4 / 2012 Bramani et al .
D430 , 966 S 9 / 2000 Brady et al . D659 ,959 S 5 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D434 ,208 S 11 / 2000 Kimball et al. 8 , 191,284 B2 6/ 2012 Cho
D436 ,431 S 1/ 2001 Agnew et al. 8 , 205 ,355 B2 * 6 /2012 Kawai ................ A43B 13 /026
D437 ,474 S 2 / 2001 Agnew et al. 36 / 107
D438 ,368 S 3 / 2001 Akhidime D666 ,404 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D441, 948 S 5 / 2001 Link D666 ,406 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D442,768 S 5 / 2001 Matis D667,211 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,230, 501 B15 / 2001 Bailey , Sr. et al. D667,625 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D447, 856 S 9 / 2001 Rake D667,626 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 , 295, 472 B1 9 / 2001 Rubinstein et al. D667,627 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,295 , 742 B1 10 /2001 Bathum D668,031 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,354 ,020 B1 * 3/ 2002 Kimball .............. A43B 13 /203 D668 ,032 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
36 / 135 D668,033 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D458,441 S 6 / 2002 Gillespie D668,034 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D468,518 S 1 / 2003 Sedlbauer D668,035 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D473,047 S 4 / 2003 Wilson D669, 254 S 10 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D474 ,586 S 5 /2003 Recchi D669,673 S 10 / 2012 Alush
D474 ,876 S 5 /2003 Ortuno Santa D671,730 S 12/2012 Shaffer
D475 ,509 S 6 / 2003 Avar D672 ,543 S 12 /2012 Williams, Jr.
D475 ,514 S 6 / 2003 Burg et al. D672 ,949 S 12 /2012 Bramani et al.
D476 ,474 S 7/ 2003 McDowell D674 , 172 S 1/ 2013 Bramani et al.
D479 ,035 S 9 /2003 Adams et al. D674 , 173 S 1/ 2013 Bramani et al.
6 ,665,958 B2 12/ 2003 Goodwin D675 ,002 S 1/ 2013 Marvin et al.
D485, 053 S 1/2004 McDowell 8 , 375 ,604 B2 2 /2013 Eder et al.
Exhibit A - Page 39
US D850 , 068 S
Page 3
(56 ) References Cited D736 , 507

D738,079
S
S
8 / 2015 Hlavacs et al.
* 9 / 2015 Bates D2/951
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D745 ,256
D747,596
S
S
* 12 /2015 Montross .....
* 1/2016 Vestuti
D2/951
D2 /951
D677,043 S 3 / 2013 Loverin D756 ,093 S * 5 / 2016 Mahoney D2/ 951
D677, 866 S * 3/ 2013 Vestuti D2/ 947 D756 ,096 S * 5 /2016 Bizzo D2/951
D681,319 S 5 / 2013 Schwartz D756 ,617 S * 5 / 2016 Weddle ....... D2 /951
D682 ,519 S 5 / 2013 Litchfield et al. D759 , 359 S 6 / 2016 Dombrow
D682, 522 S 5 / 2013 Raysse D761,541 S 7 / 2016 Hermes
D683, 117 S * 5 / 2013 Truelsen ... ........... D2/951 D762 , 365 S * 8 /2016 Vestuti .. D2/947
D683, 118 S 5 /2013 Pauk D767, 263 S * 9 /2016 Reiser ............ D2 /947
8 ,453, 349 B2 6 / 2013 Auger et al. D770 , 153 S 11 / 2016 Marvin et al.
8 , 460, 593 B2 6 / 2013 Fogg et al . D770, 159 S * 11/ 2016 Williams, Jr. ............ D2 /972
D686 ,402 S 7 / 2013 Portzline D776 ,411 S * 1/ 2017 Christensen ............. D2 /951
D687 ,623 S 8 / 2013 Norris D777 ,413 S 1/2017 Hermes
D692,218 S * 10 /2013 Anceresi D2 /947 D778 ,552 S * 2 /2017 Chang ............... A43B 13/ 186
D692,219 S * 10VI/ZVIJ
2013 A Anceresi
lceresi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D2/947 D2/947
D693, 550 S * 11/ 2013 Montross . . . .. . . .. .. D2 /951 D781,040 S * 3 / 2017 Scofield D2 /947
D693, 551 S * 11/ 2013 Montross
entross ................ D2/ 951 D783 ,245 S * 4 / 2017 Hatfield ... ...... .... D2/ 947
D694 ,512 S 12 / 2013 James D783 ,959 S * 4 /2017 Chang .................. A43B 7 / 1425
D695 , 502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D2/947
D696 , 501 S 12 / 2013 Miner D2 /947 D786 ,544 S 5 / 2017 Marvin et al.
D696 ,502 S 12 /2013 Miner D789 ,044 S * 6 /2017 Taestensen . . . . .. .......... D2/ 908
D696 ,503 S 12/ 2013 Miner D789 ,048 S * 6 /2017 Lee . . . . . . . . . D2/912
D696 , 505 S 12 / 2013 Miner D792 ,068 S * 7 /2017 Lee .. .. . . D2 /947
D696 , 846 S 1/ 2014 Klug D796 , 167 S 9 / 2017 Bates et al.
D696 ,853 S 1 / 2014 Martin D798, 550 S * 10 / 2017 Fudalik ... . .. D2/ 947
D697 ,293 S * 1/2014 Vestuti D2 /947 D801,015 S * 10 / 2017 Gibson ... D2/953
D697 ,294 S 1/ 2014 Miner D802,898 S * 11/ 2017 Montross ............. A43B 13 / 189
8 ,631,590 B2 1/ 2014 Droege et al . D2/954
D699,420 S 2 / 2014 Teteriatnikov D804 , 159 S 12 /2017 Allemann et al.
D700 ,423 S 3 / 2014 Martin D807,623 S * 1/ 2018 Vestuti ......... D2 /954
D700, 426 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D810 ,406 S * 2 /2018 Teteriatnikov .... ......... D2/947
D700 ,428 S 3 / 2014 Kuerbis D816 ,309 S * 5 /2018 Cooper ...................... D2/947
D701,036 S 3/ 2014 Martin D816 , 963 S * 5 /2018 Dieudonne D2/ 954
D701, 037 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D818 ,683 S 5 /2018 Marvin et al.
D702, 031 S 4 /2014 Nakano D823 ,581 S * 7 /2018 Umehara . D2 /951
D702, 428 S 4 /2014 Hlavacs D824 ,645 S 8 / 2018 Gibson et al.
D702 ,929 S 4 / 2014 Rustam D825 . 159 S * 8 /2018 Gibson D2 /947
D703 ,425 S 4 / 2014 Lee D825, 904 S * 8 / 2018 Petrenka ................. D2 /953
D703, 929 S 5 /2014 Avar et al. D828,684 S * 9 / 2018 Varesco D2 /947
D703 ,931 S 5 /2014 Bikowski D833, 129 S * 11/ 2018 Fudalik D2/954
D707 ,023 S 6 / 2014 Della Valle et al. D834 , 800 S * 12 / 2018 Raysse D2/ 947
D707, 027 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer D838 ,450 S * 1 /2019 Anceresi . ... . .. .. D2/ 947
D707 ,028 S 6 / 2014 Parker et al. D839 ,563 S * 2 /2019 Karnazes . ...................... D2/ 947
D707 ,032 S 6 / 2014 Martin 2002/0078598 A1 6 / 2002 Bell
D707,033 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer 2006 /0101671 A1 5 /2006 Berend et al.
D707,433 S * 6 / 2014 Grott D2 /951 2006 /0201028 A1 9 /2006 Chan et al.
D707, 933 S 7 / 2014 McCourt 2008 /0022562 A1 1/2008 Manis
D708 ,430 S 7 /2014 Weeks 2008/ 0060225 A1 3 /2008 Kilgore
D709, 274 S 7 / 2014 Roulo 2008 / 0078101 A1 4 /2008 Smith et al.
8 ,776 ,403 B2 7 / 2014 Eder et al. 2009/0013558 A1 * 1/2009 Hazenberg ........... A43B 1/0009
8 ,789 ,253 B2 7 / 2014 Kilgore et al. 36 /88
D710 , 078 S 8 / 2014 Joseph 2009 /0133290 A1 5 /2009 Kawai
D711,636 S * 8 /2014 Christensen .. ............. D2/951 2009 /0139112 A1 6 /2009 Gameau
D712 ,643 S 9 / 2014 Seo 2009 /0183392 AL 7 /2009 Shane
D714 , 036 S *
D716 ,535 S
9 / 2014 Etcheverry
11/ 2014 Seo
leverry ................ D2/951 2009 /0300945 Al 12 / 2009 Droege et al.
2010 / 0005684 A1 * 1/ 2010 Nishiwaki . ........... A43B 7 / 1425
D718 ,033 S 11/ 2014 Cin 36 / 28
D719 , 327 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al . 2010 /0170106 AL 7/ 2010 Brewer et al.
D719 ,329 S * 12/2014 Smith D2/951 2010 / 0251565 Al 10 /2010 Litchfield et al.
D719 , 330 S 12/ 2014 Lindner et al. 2010 / 0281711 A1 11/2010 Vestuti et al.
D719 ,332 S 12 /2014 Lindner et al . 2010 /0293811 Al 11 /2010 Truelsen
D719 , 333 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/ 0099845 Al 5 /2011 Miller
D719 ,334 S 12/ 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/ 0099855 Al 5 / 2011 Cho
D719 ,335 S 12/ 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/0185590 A1 * 8/ 2011 Nishiwaki .......... A43B 5 / 06
D721, 879 S * 2 / 2015 Lindner ... . .. . D2/951 36 /28
D722, 224 S 2 / 2015 Williams, Jr.
D722 ,428 S 2/ 2015 Lindner et al. 2011/0197469 A1 * 8/2011 Nishiwaki .... ........... A43B 7 /24
D723, 776 S * 3/ 2015 Lidner . ........ .. . . . . .. . D2/951 36 /28
D725 ,881 S * 4 /2015 Weeks .......... .......... . D2/951 2012/0073160 A1 * 3/2012 Marvin ............... A43B 13 / 186
D727 ,609 S 4 /2015 Hlavacs et al. 36 /28
D728, 205 S 5 / 2015 Weddle et al. 2013/0167401 Al * 7/2013 Christensen ....... A43B 1336/184
/ 29
D730,638 S * 6 / 2015 Christensen D2/ 951
D731 , 164 S 6 / 2015 Williams, Jr. 2013/0212909 A1* 8/2013 Bates .................. A43B 13 / 189
D732 ,776 S 6 / 2015 Chung et al. 36 / 102
D734 ,008 S 7/ 2015 Marvin et al. 2013 /0283641 Al 10 /2013 Rapf et al.
D734,600 S * 7 / 2015 Gargiulo ....... D2 /947 2014 /0013617 Al * 1/2014 Montross A43B 7/32
D734,601 S * 7 /2015 Montross .. D2/951 36 / 28
Exhibit A - Page 40
US D850 , 068 S
Page 4
( 56 ) References Cited
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS
2014 /0150297 A1 6 / 2014 Holmes et al.
2014 /0259786 AL 9 /2014 Heard et al .
2014 /0283413 A1* 9/ 2014 Christensen . ....... A43B 3/0057
36 / 102
2015 / 0272271 A1 * 10 / 2015 Campos , II .......... B29D 35 / 122
36 /29
2016/ 0353834 A1 * 12 / 2016 Luedecke .............. A43B 13 /16
2017 /0042286 A1 * 2/ 2017 Meschter .... ... A43B 13 / 141
2017/0135439 A1 * 5 / 2017 Davis A43B 13/ 14
2017 /0265565 A1 * 9 / 2017 Connell ................. A43B 13 /04
2018 /0125160 A1 * 5 /2018 Dojan .................. A43B 13 /122
2018/0199666 A1 * 7 / 2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16
2018 / 0279720 A1 * 10 / 2018 Iuchi ....... ... A43B 1/04
2018 /0339445 A1 * 11/ 2018 Loveder ................ B29C 64 / 245
2019 /0059512 A1 * 2 /2019 Goldston ............. A43B 13/ 181
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2003 Late Spring : Men 's, Women 's, and
Kids' Footwear, p . M3, published Sep . 2002 , NIKE., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2010 Holiday : Men 's Footwear : Perfor
mance, p . 7 , published Feb . 2010 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2011 Fall: Young Athletes Footwear, p . 24 ,
published Nov . 2010 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2012 Holiday : Women ' s Performance
Footwear, p . 10 , published Feb . 2012 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2013 Holiday: Womens Performance Foot
wear, p . 9 , published Feb . 2013 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
* cited by examiner
Exhibit A - Page 41
U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 3 US D850 , 068 S
FIG
.
1
-
PA
*
vet
Exhibit A - Page 42
V-W
-W W
ww.
2
.
FIG
wcwe.
.
*mmmm
Exhibit A - Page 43
Axiom 3
.
FIG
Exhibit A - Page 44
EXHIBIT B
Exhibit B - Page 45
USOOD8500725
(12 ) Campos
Unitedet States
al.
2 , 468, 886 A 5 / 1949 Lutey
2 ,826 ,832 A 3 /1958 Rollman
(73 ) Assignee : NIKE , Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) 2 ,853 , 809
2 ,954 ,618
A
A
9 / 1958 Bianchi
10 / 1960 Rados
3 ,793 ,750 A 2 / 1974 Bowerman
4 ,096 ,649 A 6 / 1978 Saurwein
(* *) Term : 15 Years D253 , 257 S 10 / 1979 Pasquier
D254,818 S 4 / 1980 Jones
(21) Appl. No.: 29/669 ,726 (Continued )
(22) Filed : Nov. 9, 2018 OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Related U .S . Application Data Women 's Skech -Air by SkechersUSA , INC . USA [online ]. [retrieved
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/557,831, filed on Apr. 10 , 2014 ]. Retrieved from the Internet < URL :http ://www .
Mar. 11, 2016 , which is a continuation -in - part of skechers. com /style / 11848/skech -air # Color =GYHP > .
application No. 29/ 542,737 , filed on Oct. 16 , 2015 , (Continued )
now abandoned , which is a continuation of
application No. 29 /519, 930 , filed on Mar. 9 , 2015 , Primary Examiner — T Chase Nelson
now abandoned . (74 ) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Banner & Witcoff, Ltd .
(51) LOC ( 11) CI. . ... 02 -04
(52) U . S . CI.
USPC . . . . . . . . . . .. ...................... D2/947 (57) CLAIM
(58 ) Field of Classification Search
USPC ..... ........... D2 /902, 906 , 908, 916 , 918 , 925 , The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described .
D2/946 - 962 , 977; 36 /3 B , 22 R , 24 .5 ,
36 /25 R , 28 , 32 R , 34 R , 59 C , 67 A , 103
??? . A43B 13 /00 ; A43B 13 /02 ; A43B 13 /023 ; DESCRIPTION
A43B 13 /026 ; A43B 13 /04 ; A43B 13 /08 ;
A43B 13 / 10 ; A43B 13 / 12 ; A43B 13 / 14 ; FIG . 1 a side view thereof of a shoe showing our new design ;
A43B 13 / 141; A43B 13 / 143 ; A43B and,
13 / 16 ; A43B 13 /18 ; A43B 13 / 181; A43B FIG . 2 is an enlarged front perspective view of the design
13 / 187 ; A43B 13 / 189 ; A43B 13 / 20 ; A43B identified by region 2 in FIG . 1 .
13 /28 ; A43B 13 / 30 ; A43B 13 /32 ; A43B features that form no part of the claimed design .
13 /34 ; A43B 13 / 36
. . - - - . . - . . - - - -
- -- - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - -
Exhibit B - Page 46
US D850 , 072 S
Page 2
(56 ) References Cited D485 ,053 S 1/2004 McDowell

6 ,694 ,642 B2 * 2 /2004 Turner ..... .. .. .. .. . . A43B 13 / 143
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS 36 / 28
D494,748 S 8/ 2004 McClaskie
4 ,271 ,606 A 6 / 1981 Rudy D495 ,857 S 9 /2004 Herbst
4 ,309,831 A 1/ 1982 Pritt D497 ,706 S 11/ 2004 Belley et al.
4 , 377 ,041 A 3 / 1983 Alchermes D497,707 S 11/2004 Lee
4 ,577 ,417 A 3 / 1986 Cole D520 ,220 S 5 /2006 Morgan et al.
D288,621 S 3 / 1987 Surpuriya et al. D523,627 S 6 /2006 Avar
D294, 768 S 3 / 1988 Famolare , Jr. D524 ,035 S 7 /2006 Greene et al.
D299 ,681 S 2 / 1989 Miller et al. D529 ,267 S 10 /2006 Portzline
D300 ,085 S 3 / 1989 Ito et al. D529, 706 S 10 /2006 Paz
D301, 184 S 5 / 1989 Hase D533, 708 S 12 /2006 Earle
D301,800 S 6 / 1989 Mitsui D538 ,519 S 3 / 2007 McClaskie
D321,973 S 12/ 1991 Hatfield D541,015 S 4 /2007 Diaz
D322 , 154 S 12 / 1991 Trueman D541,020 S 4 / 2007 McClaskie
5 ,197 ,207 A 3 / 1993 Shorten D543,677 S * 6 /2007 Andrews D2/946
D335 ,572 S 5 / 1993 Peterson D545 ,534 S 7 / 2007 McClaskie
D341,708 S 11/ 1993 Blissett D547, 033 S 7 /2007 Canavan
D344 ,847 S 3/ 1994 Mancebo D547,037 S 7 /2007 Nakano
D353 ,935 S 1/ 1995 Pollack D556 ,988 S 12 / 2007 Horne et al.
D356 ,672 S 3/ 1995 Veda D557 ,484 S 12 /2007 McClaskie
D362,747 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck ..... D2/977 D561,438 S 2 /2008 Belley
D362, 954 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2 /977 D561,439 S 2 / 2008 Schoenborn et al .
D380, 889 S 7 / 1997 Earle D561, 440 S 2 /2008 Andersen et al.
5 ,664,341 A 9 / 1997 Schmidt et al. 7 , 383 ,647
B2 6 / 2008 Chan et al.
D388 ,314 S 12/ 1997 Tresser D572 ,440 S * 7 / 2008 Polegato Moretti ........... 12/ 907
D390, 349 S 2 / 1998 Murai et al. D578 ,745 S 10 /2008 Kaufman
D393, 538 S 4 / 1998 Marshall D579 ,185 S * 10 /2008 Mariman .................... D2/ 947
D395 ,340 S 6 / 1998 Tresser D580 ,636 S * 11/ 2008 Brandt D2/946
D395, 740 S 7 / 1998 Cass D583 , 132 S 12 /2008 Polegato Moretti
D395 ,744 S * 7 / 1998 Edington .. .. . . . D2961 D583 , 135 S * 12/2008 Mariman . . . . . . D2/947
D397 ,546 S 9 / 1998 Merceron 7 ,464, 489 B2 12 /2008 Ho
D400 ,000 S 10 / 1998 Hatfield et al. D592 ,383 S 5 / 2009 Wawrousek
D400 ,345 S 11/ 1998 Teague D599, 986 S 9 /2009 Reiss
D403 ,846 S 1/ 1999 Bove et al. D611,690 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D404 ,897 S 2 / 1999 Marshall 7 ,704 ,430 B2 4 /2010 Johnson et al.
D407 , 193 S 3 / 1999 Doxey D621, 144 S 8 / 2010 McClaskie
D409, 360 S * 5 / 1999 Movitz D2/947 D632,879 S * 2 /2011 Merkazy .. .. .. ... . D2/953
D411 ,912 S 7 / 1999 Van Noy et al. D634, 922 S 3 /2011 Pauk et al.
D412 ,612 S 8 / 1999 Boyer 7 ,918, 041 B2 4 / 2011 Cho
5 ,955 , 159 A 9 / 1999 Allen et al. D643 ,599 S * 8 /2011 Fontanarosa ......... D2/916
D414 ,597 S * 10 / 1999 Marvin D2/972 D650, 978 S 12 / 2011 Lee
5 ,985, 383 A 11/ 1999 Allen et al . D652, 201 S 1/ 2012 Vestuti et al.
D418,665 S 1/ 2000 Hatfield 8 ,099 ,880 B2 1/2012 Brewer et al.
6 ,018 ,889 A 2 / 2000 Friton D655 ,901 S * 3 /2012 Raysse ....... D2/951
D423 , 201 S 4 /2000 Wilson D657, 941 S 4 / 2012 Bramani et al.
D430 ,966 S 9 / 2000 Brady et al. D659,959 S 5 /2012 Vestuti et al.
D434 ,208 S 11/ 2000 Kimball et al. 8 , 191, 284 B2 6 / 2012 Cho
D436 ,431 S 1/ 2001 Agnew et al. 8 , 205 ,355 B2 * 6 /2012 Kawai ............... A43B 13 /026
D437 ,474 S 2 /2001 Agnew et al. 36 /107
D438 , 368 S 3 / 2001 Akhidime D666 ,404 s 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D441,948 S 5 /2001 Link D666 ,406 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D442 , 768 S 5 / 2001 Matis D667,211 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 , 230 , 501 B1 5 /2001 Bailey, Sr. et al. D667,625 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D447 , 856 S 9 / 2001 Rake D667,626 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,295 ,472 B19 / 2001 Rubinstein et al. D667,627 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 , 295,742 B1 10 / 2001 Bathum D668, 031 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
6 , 354 ,020 B1 * 3 /2002 Kimball . . .. A43B 13 / 203 D668,032 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
36 / 135 D668,033 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D458 ,441 S 6 / 2002 Gillespie D668,034 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D468 ,518 S 1/ 2003 Sedlbauer D668 ,035 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D473 ,047 S 4 /2003 Wilson D669,254 S 10 /2012 Vestuti et al.
D474 ,586 S 5 / 2003 Recchi D669,673 S 10 / 2012 Alush
D474, 876 S 5 / 2003 Ortuno Santa D671,730 S 12 / 2012 Shaffer
D475 ,509 S 6 /2003 Avar D672 ,543 S 12 /2012 Williams, Jr.
D475 ,514 S 6 /2003 Burg et al. D672 ,949 S 12 / 2012 Bramani et al.
D476 ,474 S 7 /2003 McDowell D674 ,172 S 1/2013 Bramani et al.
D479 ,035 S 9 / 2003 Adams et al. D674 , 173 S 1/ 2013 Bramani et al.
6 ,665, 958 B2 12 /2003 Goodwin D675 ,002 S 1/2013 Marvin et al.
Exhibit B - Page 47
US D850 ,072 S
Page 3
(56 ) References Cited D734,601

D736 , 507
S
S
* 7 / 2015
8 / 2015
Montross
Montross ....................... D2/951
Hlavacs et al.
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D738, 079 S * 9 /2015 Bates D2 /951
D745 ,256 S * 12 / 2015 Montross .... D2/ 951
8 ,375 ,604 B2 2/ 2013 Eder et al. D747,596 S * 1/ 2016 Vestuti D2 /951
D677,043 S 3 / 2013 Loverin D756 ,093 S * 5 / 2016 Mahoney . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. D2 /951
D677 , 866 S * 3/ 2013 Vestuti D2/ 947 D756 ,096 S * 5 / 2016 Bizzo D2/951
D681,319 S 5 /2013 Schwartz D756 ,617 S * 5 / 2016 Weddle ....... D2/ 951
D682 ,519 S 5 /2013 Litchfield et al. D759 ,359 S 6 / 2016 Dombrow
D682 ,522 S 5 /2013 Raysse D761,541 S 7 /2016 Hermes
D683, 117 S * 5 / 2013 Truelsen ..... ......... D2/951 D762 , 365 S * 8 /2016 Vestuti D2/947
D683,118 S 5 / 2013 Pauk D767 , 263 S * 9 /2016 Reiser D2 /947
8 ,453, 349 B2 6 / 2013 Auger et al. D770, 153 S 11/ 2016 Marvin et al.
8 , 460, 593 B2 6 /2013 Fogg et al. D770 , 159 S * 11 /2016 Williams, Jr. D2/ 972
D686 ,402 S 7 /2013 Portzline D776 ,411 S * 1/2017 Christensen ................... D2/951
D687,623 S 8 /2013 Norris D777,413 S 1/ 2017 Hermes
D692,218 S * 10 / 2013 Anceresi ......... D2/947 D778,552 S * 2 /2017 Chang .................. A43B 13 /186
D692,219 S * 10 / 2013 Anceresi .. .. ... .. . ... . D2 /947 D2/947
D693, 550 S * 11/ 2013 Montross ................. D2/951 D781,040 S * 3 /2017 Scofield ........... D2 /947
D693, 551 S * 11/ 2013 Montross ...................... D2/ 951 D783 ,245 S * 4 /2017 Hatfield ............ D2/947
D694 ,512 S 12 / 2013 James D783 ,959 S * 4 /2017 Chang .................. A43B 7 /1425
D695, 502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D2 /947
D696 ,501 S * 12 /2013 Miner D2/ 947 D786 ,544 S 5 /2017 Marvin et al.
D696 , 502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D789, 044 S * 6 / 2017 Taestensen .. .. .. ... .. . D2 /908
D696 , 503 S 12 / 2013 Miner D789 ,048 S * 6 /2017 Lee
Lee ................ ............... D2/912
14
12 / 2013 Miner D792, 068 S * 7 /2017 Lee D2/947
D696 , 846 S 1/ 2014 Klug D796 , 167 S 9 /2017 Bates et al .
D696 , 853 S 1/ 2014 Martin D798 ,550 S * 10 /2017 Fudalik .......................... D2/947
D697,293 S * 1/2014 Vestuti D2/947 D801,015 S * 10 /2017 Gibson .......................... 12/953
D697, 294 S 1 / 2014 Miner D802, 898 S * 11/ 2017 Montross ............. A43B 13 / 189
8 ,631, 590 B2 1/ 2014 Droege et al. D2/ 954
D699 ,420 S 2 /2014 Teteriatnikov D804 ,159 S 12/ 2017 Allemann et al.
D700 ,423 S 3/ 2014 Martin D807,623 S * 1/2018 Vestuti D2/954
D700, 426 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D810 ,406 S * 2 /2018 Teteriatnikov .............. D2 /947
D700 ,428 S 3 / 2014 Kuerbis D816 , 309 S * 5 /2018 Cooper ... D2/947
D701,036 S 3 / 2014 Martin D816 , 963 S * 5 / 2018 Dieudonne ........ D2/ 954
D701,037 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D818 ,683 S 5 / 2018 Marvin et al.
D702,031 S 4 / 2014 Nakano D823 ,581 S * 7 /2018 Umehara D2 /951
D702 ,428 S 4 / 2014 Hlavacs D824 ,645 S 8 / 2018 Gibson et al.
D702,929 S 4 / 2014 Rustam D825, 159 S * 8/ 2018 Gibson ......... D2/947
D703, 425 S 4 / 2014 Lee D825 ,904 S * 8 /2018 Petrenka ..................... D2 /953
D703 ,929 S 5 / 2014 Avar et al. D828,684 S * 9 / 2018 Varesco D2/947
D703 ,931 S 5 / 2014 Bikowski D833, 129 S * 11/ 2018 Fudalik D2/ 954
. .. . .. . . ..
D707 ,023 S 6 / 2014 Della Valle et al. D834 ,800 S * 12/2018 Raysse .. ........... D2/ 947
D707 ,027 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer D838,450 S * 1/ 2019 Anceresi .................... D2 /947
D707,028 S 6 /2014 Parker et al. D839 , 563 S * 2 / 2019 Karnazes D2/947
D707, 032 S 6 / 2014 Martin 2002 / 0078598 A1 6 /2002 Bell
D707,033 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer 2006 /0101671 Al 5 /2006 Berend et al.
D707,433 S * 6 /2014 Grott D2/ 951 2006 /0201028 Al 9 / 2006 Chan et al.
D707 ,933 S 7 / 2014 McCourt 2008/ 0022562 A1 1 /2008 Manis
D708,430 S 7 / 2014 Weeks 2008 /0060225 Al 3 / 2008 Kilgore
D709,274 S 7 / 2014 Roulo 2008/ 0078101 A1 4 /2008 Smith et al.
8 ,776 ,403 B2 7 / 2014 Eder et al.
8 ,789,253 B2 7/ 2014 Kilgore et al. 2009 /0013558 A1 * 1 /2009 Hazenberg ........... A43B 1 /0009
D710 ,078 S 8 / 2014 Joseph 36 / 88
D711,636 S * 8 /2014 Christensen D2/ 951 2009 /0133290 A1 5 /2009 Kawai
D712 ,643 S 9 /2014 Seo 2009/0139112 A1 6 /2009 Garneau
D714 ,036 S * 9 /2014 Etcheverry .................... D2 /951 2009/0183392 Al 7 /2009 Shane
D716 , 535 S 11/ 2014 Seo 2009 /0300945 A1 12 /2009 Droege et al.
D718 , 033 S 11/ 2014 Cin 2010 /0005684 A1 * 1/2010 Nishiwaki ...... ..... A43B 7 /1425
D719 , 327 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 36 / 28
D719 ,329 S * 12 /2014 Smith ......... D2/ 951 2010 /0170106 A17 /2010 Brewer et al.
D719 ,330 S 12 /2014 Lindner et al. 2010 /0251565 A 10 / 2010 Litchfield et al.
D719 ,332 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al . 2010 /0281711 A111/2010 Vestuti et al.
D719 ,333 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2010 / 0293811 A111/ 2010 Truelsen
D719 , 334 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/0099845 Al 5 / 2011 Miller
D719 , 335 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011 /0099855 AL 5 / 2011 Cho
D721, 879 S * 2 / 2015 Lindnerr ... . .. .. D2/951 2011/0185590 A1 * 8/ 2011 Nishiwaki A43B 5 / 06
D722 ,224 S 2 / 2015 Williams, Jr. 36 / 28
D722 ,428 S 2 / 2015 Lindner et al.
D723, 776 S * 3 / 2015 Lidner .......... D2 / 951 2011/0197469 A1* 8/ 2011 Nishiwaki ...... A43B 7/ 24
D725 ,881 S * 4 /2015 Weeks ......... D2/951 36 /28
D727,609 S 4 / 2015 Hlavacs et al. 2012/0073160 A1* 3/2012 Marvin .............. A43B 13 /186
D728 ,205 S 5 /2015 Weddle et al. 36 / 28
D730 ,638 S * 6 /2015 Christensen ... D2 / 951 2013/0167401 Al * 7/2013 Christensen ......... A43B 13/ 184
D731, 164 S 6 / 2015 Williams, Jr. 36 /29
D732 ,776 S 6 / 2015 Chung et al. 2013/0212909 A1* 8/2013 Bates .................. A43B 13/ 189 36 / 102
D734 ,008 S 7 / 2015 Marvin et al.
D734 ,600 S * 7 /2015 Gargiulo ... . 12/ 947 2013/0283641 A1 10/2013 Rapf et al.
Exhibit B - Page 48
US D850 , 072 S
Page 4
(56 ) References Cited

2014 /0013617 Al * 1/2014 Montross ................. A43B 7 /32
36 /28
2014 /0150297 A1 6 / 2014 Holmes et al.
2014 /0259786 AL 9 /2014 Heard et al .
2014 /0283413 A1* 9/ 2014 Christensen ......... A43B 3/0057
36 / 102
2015 /0272271 A1 * 10 / 2015 Campos, II .......... B29D 35 / 122
36 /29
2016/ 0353834 A1 * 12 / 2016 Luedecke .............. A43B 13/ 16
2017 /0042286 A1 * 2 /2017 Meschter ............. A43B 13 /141
2017 /0135439 A1 * 5 / 2017 Davis ... .. . .. A43B 13 / 14
2017 /0265565 A1 * 9 /2017 Connell ................. A43B 13/04
2018 /0125160 A1 * 5 / 2018 Dojan .................. A43B 13 / 122
2018 /0199666 A1 * 7 /2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16
2018 /0279720 A1 * 10 / 2018 Iuchi A43B 1 /04
2018 / 0339445 A1 * 11/ 2018 Loveder ................ B29C 64 /245
2019 /0059512 Al * 2 / 2019 Goldston ............. A43B 3 /0031
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2003 Late Spring: Men 's , Women 's, and
Kids' Footwear, p . M3, published Sep . 2002 , NIKE., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2010 Holiday: Men ' s Footwear: Perfor
mance, p . 7 , published Feb . 2010 , NIKE , Inc., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog, 2011 Fall: Young Athletes Footwear, p . 24 ,
Footwear, p . 10 , published Feb . 2012, NIKE, Inc ., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2013 Holiday : Womens Performance Foot
wear, p . 9, published Feb . 2013 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
* cited by examiner
Exhibit B - Page 49
U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 2 US D850 ,072 S
be
Gre -
.
FIG
1
YA
inte
-
.
we
w
W
BeeGeta.
Motor
Exhibit B - Page 50
smo
n
in
2
.
FIG
-
---
Exhibit B - Page 51
EXHIBIT C
Exhibit C - Page 52
USOOD8500745
(12 ) Campos
Unitedet States
al.
2 , 468, 886 A 5 / 1949 Lutey
2 ,826 ,832 A 3 /1958 Rollman
(73 ) Assignee : NIKE , Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) 2 ,853 , 809 A
2 ,954 ,618 A
9 / 1958 Bianchi
10 / 1960 Rados
3 ,793 ,750 A 2 / 1974 Bowerman
4 ,096 ,649 A 6 / 1978 Saurwein
(* *) Term : 15 Years D253 ,257 S
D254 ,818 S
10 / 1979
4 /1980
Pasquier
Jones
(21) Appl. No.: 29 /669,728 4 , 271,606 A 6 /1981 Rudy
(Continued )
(22) Filed : Nov. 9, 2018
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(63 ) Continuation of application No. 29/ 557, 831, filed on Apr. 10 , 2014 ]. Retrieved from the Internet < URL : http ://www .
Mar. 11, 2016 , which is a continuation -in - part of skechers.com /style /11848/ skech-air# Color =GYHP > .
now abandoned , which is a continuation of (Continued )
application No . 29 /519 , 930 , filed on Mar. 9 , 2015 , Primary Examiner — T Chase Nelson
now abandoned .
(51) LOC ( 11) CI. ............... 02 - 04 (74 ) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Banner & Witcoff, Ltd.
(52) U . S . CI.
USPC . . . . . . . . . . .. .... ..... ................ D2/947
(58 ) Field of Classification Search (57 ) CLAIM
USPC .... ........... D2 /902, 906 , 908, 916 , 918 , 925 ,
D2 / 946 – 962. 977 ; 36 /3 B , 22 R , 24 . 5 , The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described .
36 /25 R , 28 , 32 R , 34 R , 59 C , 67 A , 103
??? . A43B 13 /00 ; A43B 13 /02 ; A43B 13 /023 ;
A43B 13 /026 ; A43B 13 /04 ; A43B 13 /08 ; DESCRIPTION
A43B 13 / 10 ; A43B 13 / 12 ; A43B 13 / 14 ;
A43B 13 / 141; A43B 13 / 143 ; A43B FIG . 1 is a frontperspective view of a shoe showing our new
13/ 16 ; A43B 13/ 18; A43B 13 / 181; A43B design ; and ,
13 / 187 ; A43B 13 / 189 ; A43B 13 / 20 ; A43B FIG . 2 is a side view thereof.
13 / 28 ; A43B 13 / 30 ; A43B 13 / 32 ; A43B features that form no part of the claimed design .
13 /34 ; A43B 13 / 36
-- - - - - - - - .
- --- - - - - - - - -- --- - -
-
RENESAMO Od
-
Exhibit C - Page 53
US D850 , 074 S
Page 2
(56 ) References Cited 6 ,694 ,642 B2 * 2 /2004 Turner ................· A43B 13 / 143
36 /28
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D494 ,748 S 8 / 2004 McClaskie
D495, 857 S 9 /2004 Herbst
4 ,309,831 A 1/ 1982 Pritt D497 ,706 S 11/ 2004 Belley et al .
4 , 377 ,041 A 3 / 1983 Alchermes D497 ,707 S 11/2004 Lee
4 , 577,417 A 3/ 1986 Cole D520 ,220 S 5 /2006 Morgan et al.
D288 ,621 S 3/ 1987 Surpuriya et al. D523 ,627 S 6 /2006 Avar
D294,768 S 3 / 1988 Famolare, Jr. D524 ,035 S 7 /2006 Greene et al.
D300 ,085 S 3 / 1989 Ito et al. D529 ,706 S 10 /2006 Paz
D301, 184 S 5 / 1989 Hase D533 ,708 S 12 /2006 Earle
D301,800 S 6 / 1989 Mitsui D538,519 S 3 / 2007 McClaskie
D321,973 S 12 / 1991 Hatfield D541,015 S 4 /2007 Diaz
D322 , 154 S 12 / 1991 Trueman D541,020 S 4 /2007 McClaskie
5 , 197 ,207 A 3 / 1993 Shorten D543 ,677 S * 6 / 2007 Andrews D2 /946
D335 ,572 S 5 / 1993 Peterson D545, 534 S 7 / 2007 McClaskie
D341, 708 S 11/ 1993 Blissett D547,033 S 7 /2007 Canavan
D344 ,847 S 3/ 1994 Mancebo D547 ,037 S 7 /2007 Nakano
D353 ,935 S 1/ 1995 Pollack D556 , 988S 12 /2007 Horne et al.
D356 ,672 S 3 / 1995 Ueda D557 ,484 S 12 / 2007 McClaskie
D362,747 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck .... D2 /977 D561,438 S 2 /2008 Belley
D362,954 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck ................ .......... D2 /977 D561,439 S 2 /2008 Schoenborn et al.
D380 ,889 S 7 / 1997 Earle D561,440 S. 2 / 2008 Andersen et al.
5 ,664,341 A 9 / 1997 Schmidt et al. 7 ,383 ,647
B2 6 / 2008 Chan et al.
D388,314 S 12 / 1997 Tresser D572 ,440 S * 7 /2008 Polegato Moretti ........... D2/907
D390 ,349 S 2 / 1998 Murai et al . D578,745 S 10 /2008 Kaufman
D393, 538 S 4 / 1998 Marshall D579 ,185 S * 10 /2008 Mariman .. .. .. .. D2/947
D395 ,340 S 6 / 1998 Tresser D580 ,636 S * 11/2008 Brandt ....... D2 /946
D395 ,740 S 7 / 1998 Cass D583 , 132 S 12 /2008 Polegato Moretti
D395 , 744 S * 7 / 1998 Edington D2 /961 D583, 135 S * 12 / 2008 Mariman ... D2 /947
D397 ,546 S 9 / 1998 Merceron 7 ,464 ,489 B2 12/2008 Ho
D400, 000 S 10 / 1998 Hatfield et al. D592, 383 S 5 /2009 Wawrousek
D400, 345 S 11/ 1998 Teaque D599 ,986 S 9 / 2009 Reiss
D403 , 846 S 1 / 1999 Bove et al. D611,690 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D404 ,897 S 2 / 1999 Marshall 7 , 704 ,430 B2 4 / 2010 Johnson et al.
D407 , 193 S 3 / 1999 Doxey D621, 144 S 8 /2010 McClaskie
D409, 360 S * 5 / 1999 Movitz D2/947 D632, 879 S * 2 /2011 Merkazy D2 /953
D411 ,912 S 7 / 1999 Van Noy et al. D634 ,922 S 3/ 2011 Pauk et al .
D412 ,612 S 8 / 1999 Boyer 7, 918 , 041 B2 4 / 2011 Cho
5 ,955 , 159 A 9 / 1999 Allen et al. D643 ,599 S * 8 /2011 Fontanarosa D2 /916
D414 ,597 S * 10 / 1999 Marvin D2/972 D650 ,978 S 12/2011 Lee
5 ,985, 383 A 11/ 1999 Allen et al. D652, 201 S 1/ 2012 Vestuti et al .
D418 ,665 S 1 /2000 Hatfield 8 ,099 ,880 B2 1/ 2012 Brewer et al.
6 ,018 ,889 A 2 / 2000 Friton D655 ,901 S * 3 /2012 Raysse ..... D2/951
D423 ,201 S 4 / 2000 Wilson D657, 941 S 4 / 2012 Bramani et al .
D430 , 966 S 9 / 2000 Brady et al . D659 ,959 S 5 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D434 ,208 S 11 / 2000 Kimball et al. 8 , 191,284 B2 6/ 2012 Cho
D436 ,431 S 1/ 2001 Agnew et al. 8 , 205 ,355 B2 * 6 /2012 Kawai ................ A43B 13 /026
D437 ,474 S 2 / 2001 Agnew et al. 36 / 107
D438 ,368 S 3 / 2001 Akhidime D666 ,404 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D441, 948 S 5 / 2001 Link D666 ,406 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D442,768 S 5 / 2001 Matis D667,211 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,230, 501 B15 / 2001 Bailey , Sr. et al. D667,625 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D447, 856 S 9 / 2001 Rake D667,626 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 , 295, 472 B1 9 / 2001 Rubinstein et al. D667,627 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,295 , 742 B1 10 /2001 Bathum D668,031 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,354 ,020 B1 * 3/ 2002 Kimball .............. A43B 13 /203 D668 ,032 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
36 / 135 D668,033 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D458,441 S 6 / 2002 Gillespie D668,034 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D473,047 S 4 / 2003 Wilson D669, 254 S 10 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D474 ,586 S 5 /2003 Recchi D669,673 S 10 / 2012 Alush
D474 ,876 S 5 /2003 Ortuno Santa D671,730 S 12/2012 Shaffer
D475 ,514 S 6 / 2003 Burg et al. D672 ,949 S 12 /2012 Bramani et al.
D476 ,474 S 7/ 2003 McDowell D674 , 172 S 1/ 2013 Bramani et al.
D479 ,035 S 9 /2003 Adams et al. D674 , 173 S 1/ 2013 Bramani et al.
6 ,665,958 B2 12/ 2003 Goodwin D675 ,002 S 1/ 2013 Marvin et al.
D485, 053 S 1/2004 McDowell 8 , 375 ,604 B2 2 /2013 Eder et al.
Exhibit C - Page 54
US D850 ,074 S
Page 3
(56 ) References Cited D736 , 507

D738,079
S
S
8 / 2015 Hlavacs et al.
* 9 / 2015 Bates D2/951
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D745 ,256
D747,596
S
S
* 12 /2015 Montross .....
* 1/2016 Vestuti
D2/951
D2 /951
D677,043 S 3 / 2013 Loverin D756 ,093 S * 5 / 2016 Mahoney D2/ 951
D677, 866 S * 3/ 2013 Vestuti D2/ 947 D756 ,096 S * 5 /2016 Bizzo D2/951
D681,319 S 5 / 2013 Schwartz D756 ,617 S * 5 / 2016 wedale
Weddle .. .. . . .. .. . D2 /951
D682 ,519 S 5 / 2013 Litchfield et al. D759 , 359 S 6 / 2016 Dombrow
D683, 117 S * 5 /2013 Truelsen ........... D2/951 D762 , 365 S * 8 /2016 Vestuti .. D2/947
D683, 118 S 5 /2013 Pauk D767, 263 S * 9 /2016 Reiser ............ D2 /947
8 ,453, 349 B2 6 / 2013 Auger et al. D770 , 153 S 11 / 2016 Marvin et al.
8 , 460, 593 B2 6 / 2013 Fogg et al . D770, 159 S * 11/ 2016 Williams, Jr. ............ D2 /972
D686 ,402 S 7 / 2013 Portzline D776 ,411 S * 1/ 2017 Christensen ............. D2 /951
D687 ,623 S 8 / 2013 Norris D777 ,413 S 1/2017 Hermes
D692,218 S * 10 /2013 Anceresi D2 /947 D778 ,552 S * 2 /2017 Chang ............... A43B 13/ 186
D692,219 S * 10VI/ZVIJ
2013 A Anceresi
lceresi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D2/947 D2/947
D693, 550 S * 11/ 2013 Montross . . . .. . . .. .. D2 /951 D781,040 S * 3 / 2017 Scofield D2 /947
D693, 551 S * 11/ 2013 Montross
entross ................ D2/ 951 D783 ,245 S * 4 / 2017 Hatfield ... ...... .... D2/ 947
D694 ,512 S 12 / 2013 James D783 ,959 S * 4 /2017 Chang .................. A43B 7 / 1425
D695 , 502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D2/947
D696 , 501 S 12 / 2013 Miner D2 /947 D786 , 544 S 5 / 2017 Marvin et al.
D696 ,502 S 12 /2013 Miner D789 ,044 S * 6 /2017 Taestensen . . . . .. .......... D2/ 908
D696 ,503 S 12/ 2013 Miner D789 ,048 S * 6 /2017 Lee . . . . . . . . . D2/912
D696 , 505 S 12 / 2013 Miner D792 ,068 S * 7 /2017 Lee D2 /947
.. .. . .
D696 .846 S 1/ 2014 Klug D796 , 167 S 9 /2017 Bates et al.
D696 ,853 S 1 / 2014 Martin D798 ,550 S * 10 / 2017 Fudalik ........................ 12/947
D697 ,293 S * 1/2014 Vestuti D2 /947 D801,015 S * 10 / 2017 Gibson ... D2/953
D697 ,294 S 1/ 2014 Miner D802,898 S * 11/ 2017 Montross ............. A43B 13 / 189
8 ,631,590 B2 1/ 2014 Droege et al . D2/954
D699,420 S 2 / 2014 Teteriatnikov D804 , 159 S 12 /2017 Allemann et al.
D700 ,423 S 3 / 2014 Martin D807,623 S * 1/ 2018 Vestuti ......... D2 /954
D700, 426 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D810 ,406 S * 2 /2018 Teteriatnikov .... ......... D2/947
D700 ,428 S 3 / 2014 Kuerbis D816 ,309 S * 5 /2018 Cooper ...................... D2/947
D701,036 S 3/ 2014 Martin D816 , 963 S * 5 /2018 Dieudonne D2/ 954
D701, 037 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D818 ,683 S 5 /2018 Marvin et al.
D702, 031 S 4 /2014 Nakano D823 ,581 S * 7 /2018 Umehara . D2 /951
D702, 428 S 4 /2014 Hlavacs D824 ,645 S 8 / 2018 Gibson et al.
D702 ,929 S 4 / 2014 Rustam D825 . 159 S * 8 /2018 Gibson D2 /947
D703 ,425 S 4 / 2014 Lee D825, 904 S * 8 / 2018 Petrenka ................. D2 /953
D703, 929 S 5 /2014 Avar et al. D828,684 S * 9 / 2018 Varesco D2 /947
D703 ,931 S 5 /2014 Bikowski D833, 129 S * 11/ 2018 Fudalik D2/954
D707 ,023 S 6 / 2014 Della Valle et al. D834 , 800 S * 12 / 2018 Raysse D2/ 947
D707, 027 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer D838 ,450 S * 1 /2019 Anceresi . ... . .. .. D2/ 947
D707 ,028 S 6 / 2014 Parker et al. D839 ,563 S * 2 /2019 Karnazes . ...................... D2/ 947
D707 ,032 S 6 / 2014 Martin 2002/0078598 A1 6 / 2002 Bell
D707,433 S * 6 / 2014 Grott D2 /951 2006 /0201028 A1 9 /2006 Chan et al.
D707, 933 S 7 / 2014 McCourt 2008 /0022562 A1 1/2008 Manis
D708 ,430 S 7 /2014 Weeks 2008/ 0060225 A1 3 /2008 Kilgore
D709, 274 S 7 / 2014 Roulo 2008 / 0078101 A1 4 /2008 Smith et al.
8 ,776 ,403 B2 7 / 2014 Eder et al. 2009/0013558 A1 * 1/2009 Hazenberg ........... A43B 1/0009
8 ,789 ,253 B2 7 / 2014 Kilgore et al. 36 /88
D710 , 078 S 8 / 2014 Joseph 2009 /0133290 A1 5 /2009 Kawai
D711,636 S * 8 /2014 Christensen .. ............. D2/951 2009 /0139112 A1 6 /2009 Gameau
D712 ,643 S 9 / 2014 Seo 2009 /0183392 AL 7 /2009 Shane
D714 , 036 S *
D716 ,535 S
9 / 2014 Etcheverry
11/ 2014 Seo
leverry ................ D2/951 2009 /0300945 Al 12 / 2009 Droege et al.
2010 / 0005684 A1 * 1/ 2010 Nishiwaki . ........... A43B 7 / 1425
D718 ,033 S 11/ 2014 Cin 36 / 28
D719 ,329 S * 12/2014 Smith D2/951 2010 / 0251565 Al 10 /2010 Litchfield et al.
D719 , 330 S 12/ 2014 Lindner et al. 2010 / 0281711 A1 11/2010 Vestuti et al.
D719 ,332 S 12 /2014 Lindner et al . 2010 /0293811 Al 11 /2010 Truelsen
D719 , 333 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/ 0099845 Al 5 /2011 Miller
D719 ,334 S 12/ 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/ 0099855 Al 5 / 2011 Cho
D719 ,335 S 12/ 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/0185590 A1 * 8/ 2011 Nishiwaki .......... A43B 5 / 06
D721, 879 S * 2 / 2015 Lindner ... . .. . D2/951 36 /28
D722, 224 S 2 / 2015 Williams, Jr.
D722 ,428 S 2/ 2015 Lindner et al. 2011/0197469 A1 * 8/2011 Nishiwaki .... ........... A43B 7 /24
D723, 776 S * 3/ 2015 Lidner . ........ .. . . . . .. . D2/951 36 /28
D725 ,881 S * 4 /2015 Weeks .......... .......... . D2/951 2012/0073160 A1 * 3/2012 Marvin ............... A43B 13 / 186
D727 ,609 S 4 /2015 Hlavacs et al. 36 /28
D728, 205 S 5 / 2015 Weddle et al. 2013/0167401 Al * 7/2013 Christensen ....... A43B 1336/184
/ 29
D730,638 S * 6 / 2015 Christensen D2/ 951
D731 , 164 S 6 / 2015 Williams, Jr. 2013/0212909 A1* 8/2013 Bates .................. A43B 13 / 189
D732 ,776 S 6 / 2015 Chung et al. 36 / 102
D734 ,008 S 7/ 2015 Marvin et al. 2013 /0283641 Al 10 /2013 Rapf et al.
D734,600 S * 7 / 2015 Gargiulo ....... D2 /947 2014 /0013617 Al * 1/2014 Montross A43B 7/32
D734,601 S * 7 /2015 Montross .. D2/951 36 / 28
Exhibit C - Page 55
US D850 ,074 S
Page 4
2014 /0150297 A1 6 / 2014 Holmes et al.
2014 /0259786 AL 9 /2014 Heard et al .
2014 /0283413 A1* 9/ 2014 Christensen . ....... A43B 3/0057
36 / 102
2015 / 0272271 A1 * 10 / 2015 Campos , II .......... B29D 35 / 122
36 /29
2016/ 0353834 A1 * 12 / 2016 Luedecke .............. A43B 13 /16
*
2017 /0042286 A1 * 2/ 2017 Meschter .... ...

*
A43B 13 / 141
2017/0135439 A1 * 5 / 2017 Davis
*
A43B 13/ 14
2017 /0265565 A1 * 9 / 2017 Connell ................. A43B 13 /04
*
2018 /0125160 A1 * *
5 /2018 Dojan .................. A43B 13 /122

2018/0199666 A1 * *
7 / 2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16

2018 / 0279720 A1 * 10 / 2018 Iuchi ....... .. A43B 1/04
2018 /0339445 A1 * 11/ 2018 Loveder ................ B29C 64 / 245
2019 /0059512 A1 * 2 /2019 Goldston ............. A43B 13/ 181
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Nike Footwear Catalog, 2003 Late Spring: Men 's, Women 's , and
Kids' Footwear, p . M3, published Sep . 2002 , Nike., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2010 Holiday : Men 's Footwear : Perfor
mance, p . 7 , published Feb . 2010 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
Footwear, p . 10 , published Feb . 2012 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
wear, p . 9 , published Feb . 2013 , NIKE, Inc ., USA .
* cited by examiner
Exhibit C - Page 56
-
---
-
-
--
-
**
**
-
-
-
.
FIG
1
Exhibit C - Page 57
U . S . Patent Jun. 4 , 2019 Sheet 2 of 2 US D850 ,074 S
??
2
.
FIG
??
?
?
–
=
???
:
Exhibit C - Page 58
EXHIBIT D
Exhibit D - Page 59
USOOD850075S
(12 ) Campos
Unitedet States
al.
2 , 468, 886 A 5 / 1949 Lutey
2 ,826 ,832 A 3 /1958 Rollman
2 ,954 ,618
A
A
9 / 1958 Bianchi
10 / 1960 Rados
( * ) Notice : This patent is subject to a terminal dis D196 ,491 S 10/ 1963 Papoutsy
3 ,793 ,750 A 2 / 1974 Bowerman
4 ,096 ,649 A 6 / 1978 Saurwein
(* *) Term : 15 Years D253 ,257 S 10 / 1979 Pasquier
(Continued )
(21) Appl. No.: 29 /669,729
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(22) Filed : Nov. 9, 2018
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2003 Late Spring : Men 's, Women 's, and
Related U .S. Application Data Kids' Footwear, p . M3, published Sep . 2002 , Nike., USA .
(63 ) Continuation of application No. 29 /557 ,831, filed on (Continued )
Mar. 11, 2016 , which is a continuation -in - part of
MaricationNo.29154richtinea on
application No. 29 /519, 930 , filed on Mar. 9 , 2015 ,
now abandoned .
Primary Examiner — T Chase Nelson
(74 ) Attorney , Agent, or Firm — Banner & Witcoff , Ltd .
(51) LOC ( 11) CI. ............... 02 -04 (57) CLAIM

(52) U . S . CI.
USPC . . . . . . . . . . .. ........... D2 /947 The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described .
USPC .... ........... D2 /902, 906 , 908, 916 , 918 , 925 ,
D2/946 - 962 , 977; 36 /3 B , 22 R , 24 .5 , DESCRIPTION
36 /25 R , 28 , 32 R , 34 R , 59 C , 67 A , 103
??? . A43B 13 / 00 ; A43B 13 /02 ; A43B 13 /023 ; FIG . 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing our new
A43B 13 /026 ; A43B 13 /04 ; A43B 13 /08 ; design ;
A43B 13 / 10 ; A43B 13 / 12 ; A43B 13/ 14 ; FIG . 2 is a side view thereof;
A43B 13 / 141; A43B 13 / 143 ; A43B FIG . 3 is an opposite side view thereof;
13/ 16 ; A43B 13/ 18; A43B 13 / 181; A43B FIG . 4 is a front view thereof; and ,
13 /34 ; A43B 13 / 36
.
.
.
-- -- .- . - . - - . - - . - . - . - . - . - . - . - .
X
RAY - AT - 6710 DH
Exhibit D - Page 60
US D850 , 075 S
Page 2
(56 ) References Cited 6 ,665, 958 B2

D485 ,053 S
12 / 2003 Goodwin
1/2004 McDowell
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS 6 ,694 ,642 B2 * 2 /2004 Turner . . .. . . .. . . . A43B 13 / 143
36 / 28
D254 ,818 S 4 / 1980 Jones D494 ,748 S 8 /2004 McClaskie
4 ,271 ,606 A 6 / 1981 Rudy D495 ,857 S 9 /2004 Herbst
4 , 309 ,831 A 1/ 1982 Pritt D497,706 S 11/2004 Belley et al.
4 , 377 ,041 A 3 / 1983 Alchermes D497 ,707 S 11/ 2004 Lee
4 ,378 ,643 A 4 / 1983 Johnson D512 ,817 S 12 /2005 Ammon
4 ,439 ,936 A 4 / 1984 Clarke et al. D519 , 267 S 4 /2006 Hlavacs
4 ,577,417 A 3 / 1986 Cole D520 ,220 S 5 /2006 Morgan et al .
D288 ,621 S 3 / 1987 Surpuriya et al. D523 ,627 S 6 /2006 Avar
D294 , 768 S 3/ 1988 Famolare , Jr. D524 ,035 S 7 / 2006 Greene et al.
D297 ,383 S 8 / 1988 Mourad et al. D529 ,266 S 10 /2006 Le
D300, 085 S 3 / 1989 Ito et al. D529 ,706 S 10 /2006 Paz
D301, 184 S 5 / 1989 Hase D533 ,708 S 12 /2006 Earle
D301,659 S 6 / 1989 Le D536 , 163 S 2 / 2007 McClaskie
D301, 800 S 6 / 1989 Mitsui D538 ,519 S 3 /2007 McClaskie
D321,973 S 12 / 1991 Hatfield D541,015 S 4 / 2007 Diaz
D322 , 154 S 12/ 1991 Trueman D541,020 S 4 / 2007 McClaskie
5 , 197 ,207 A 3 / 1993 Shorten D543,677 S * 6 /2007 Andrews . . . . . . D2 /946
D341,708 S 11/ 1993 Blissett D547,033 S 7 /2007 Canavan
D344,847 S 3 / 1994 Mancebo D547 ,037 S 7 / 2007 Nakano
D353,935 S 1/ 1995 Pollack D556 ,988 S . 12/ 2007 Horne et al.
D356 .672 S 3 / 1995 Ueda D557 ,484 s 12 /2007 McClaskie
D362, 747 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2/977 D561,438 S . 2 / 2008 Belley
D362,954 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2 /977 D561,439 S 2 / 2008 Schoenborn et al .
D380 ,889 S 7 / 1997 Earle D561,440 S 2 / 2008 Andersen et al.
5 ,664 ,341 A 9/ 1997 Schmidt et al. 7 ,383,647 B26 / 2008 Chan et al.
D388 ,314 S 12 / 1997 Tresser D572 ,440 S * 7 /2008 Polegato Moretti ........... D2/ 907
D390, 348 S 2/ 1998 Meyer et al. D573 ,779 S 7 /2008 Stauffer
D390 ,349 S 2 / 1998 Murai et al. D578,745 S 10 / 2008 Kaufman
D393,538 S 4 / 1998 Marshall D579 , 185 S * 10 /2008 Mariman ...... D2/ 947
D394 , 541 S 5 / 1998 Burgess 7 ,430 ,817 B2 10 /2008 Abadjian et al.
D395 ,340 S 6 / 1998 Tresser D580 ,636 S * 11/2008 Brandt ........ D2/946
D395 ,740 S 7 / 1998 Cass D583 , 132 S 12 / 2008 Polegato Moretti
D395 ,744 S * 7 / 1998 Edington D2/961 D583 , 135 S * 12/2008 Mariman . . . . . . D2/ 947
D397, 546 S 9 / 1998 Merceron 7 ,464 ,489 B2 12 / 2008 Ho
D400 ,000 S 10 / 1998 Hatfield et al. D592, 383 S 5 / 2009 Wawrousek
D400 ,345 S 11/ 1998 Teaque D599, 986 S 9 /2009 Reiss
5 , 836 ,094 A 11/ 1998 Figel D607 , 192 S 1/2010 McClaskie
D401,745 S 12 /1998 Greenberg D611 ,689 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D403, 846 S 1/ 1999 Bove et al. D611,690 S 3 /2010 Stubblefield
D404, 897 S 2 / 1999 Marshall 7 ,704 ,430 B2 4 / 2010 Johnson et al.
D407, 193 S 3 / 1999 Doxey D621, 144 S 8 / 2010 McClaskie
D409 , 360 S * 5 / 1999 Movitz .......... D2/947 D632 ,879 S * 2 /2011 Merkazy D2/953
D411 ,912 S 7 / 1999 Van Noy et al. D634 ,922 S 3 / 2011 Pauk et al.
D412 ,612 S 8/ 1999 Boyer 7 ,918, 041 B2 4/ 2011 Cho
D412 ,777 S * 8 / 1999 Norton D2/947 D639 ,540 S 6 /2011 Raysse
5 ,955 , 159 A 9 / 1999 Allen et al. D643,599 S * 8 / 2011 Fontanarosa ...... D2 /916
D414 ,597 S * 10 / 1999 Marvin .... . D2/972 D650 ,978 S 12/ 2011 Lee
5 ,985 ,383 A 11 / 1999 Allen et al. D652, 201 S 1 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D418 ,665 S 1 / 2000 Hatfield 8 ,099, 880 B2 1/ 2012 Brewer et al.
6 ,018,889 A 2 / 2000 Friton D655, 901 S * 3/ 2012 Raysse ...... D2/951
D423 ,201 S 4 / 2000 Wilson D657,941 S 4 /2012 Bramani et al.
D430 , 966 S 9 /2000 Brady et al . D659 ,959 S 5 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D434 , 208 S 11 / 2000 Kimball et al. 8,191, 284 B2 6/ 2012 Cho
D436 ,431 S 1/ 2001 Agnew et al. 8 , 205, 355 B2 * 6 / 2012 Kawai . .. .. .. .. .. . A43B 13 /026
D437,474 S 2 / 2001 Agnew et al. 36 / 107
D438 , 368 S 3 / 2001 Akhidime D666 ,404 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D441,948 S 5 /2001 Link D666 ,406 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D442, 768 S 5 / 2001 Matis D667,211 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 ,230, 501 B1 5 /2001 Bailey , Sr. et al. D667,625 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D447 ,856 S 9 / 2001 Rake D667,626 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 , 295 ,472 B1 9 / 2001 Rubinstein et al. D667,627 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,295,742 B1 10 / 2001 Bathum D668,031 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,354 ,020 B1 * 3 / 2002 Kimball ............... A43B 13 / 203 D668,032 S 10/ 2012 Shaffer
36 / 135 D668,033 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D458 ,441 S 6 / 2002 Gillespie D668, 034 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D473, 047 S 4 /2003 Wilson D669 ,254 S 10 /2012 Vestuti et al.
D474 ,876 S 5 /2003 Ortuno Santa D671,730 S 12 /2012 Shaffer
D475, 509 S 6 /2003 Avar D672 ,543 S 12 / 2012 Williams, Jr.
D475 ,514 S 6 /2003 Burg et al. D672 ,949 S 12/2012 Bramani et al.
D476 , 474 S 7 / 2003 McDowell D674 , 172 S . 1 /2013 Bramani et al .
Exhibit D - Page 61
US D850 , 075 S
Page 3
(56 ) References Cited D734 ,600 S * 7 / 2015 Gargiulo ........... D2 /947

D734 ,601 S * 7 / 2015 Montross . D2 /951
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D736 , 507 S 8 /2015 Hlavacs et al .
D738, 079 S * 9 /2015 Bates D2 /951
D675 ,002 S 1/ 2013 Marvin et al. D745,256 S * 12 / 2015 Montross D2/951
8 , 375 ,604 B2 2 / 2013 Eder et al. D747 ,596 S * 1 /2016 Vestuti D2/951
D677 ,043 S 3/ 2013 Loverin D756 ,093 S * 5 /2016 Mahoney ............. D2 /951
D677 ,866 S * 3 /2013 Vestuti D2 /947 D756 ,096 S * 5 /2016 Bizzo D2 /951
D681,319 S 5 / 2013 Schwartz D756 ,617 S * 5 /2016 Weddle ...... D2/ 951
D683, 117 S * 5 / 2013 Truelsen ... . . .. . .. D2/ 951 D762, 365 S * 8 / 2016 Vestuti D2/947
D683 ,118 S 5 /2013 Pauk D767, 263 S * 9 / 2016 Reiser D2/ 947
8 ,453, 349 B2 6 /2013 Auger et al. D770 ,153 S 11/ 2016 Marvin et al.
8 ,460 ,593 B2 6 / 2013 Fogg et al . D770 , 159 S * 11/ 2016 Williams, Jr. .. . . .. . .. .. . D2/ 972
D686 ,402 S 7 / 2013 Portzline D776 ,411 S * 1/ 2017 Christensen ... ........... D2 /951
D687 ,623 S 8 / 2013 Norris D777,413 S 1 / 2017 Hermes
D692 ,218 S * 10 /2013 Anceresi .... ........... D2/947 D778, 552 S * 2 / 2017 C D2/947
D692 ,219 S * 10 /2013 Anceresi D2 /947 D781,040 S * 3 / 2017 Scofield ... D2 /947
D693, 550 S * 11/ 2013 Montross . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D2/951 D783 ,245 S * 4 /2017 Hatfield . . . . . . . . . . D2/947
D693 ,551 S * 11/ 2013 Montross ....................... D2 /951 D783,959 S * 4 /2017 Chang ........... D2/947
D694 ,512 S 12 /2013 James D786 ,544 S 5 /2017 Marvin et al .
D695 ,502 S 12 /2013 Miner D789 ,044 S * 6 / 2017 Taestensen .... .. . . . D2 /908
D696 ,501 S * 12 / 2013 Miner D2/947 D789 ,048 S * 6 /2017 Lee ............... D2/912
D696 , 502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D792,068 S * 7 / 2017 Lee . ... . ............ D2/ 947
D696 , 503 S 12 / 2013 Miner D796 , 167 S 9 /2017 Bates et al.
D696 ,505 S 12 / 2013 Miner D798,550 S * 10 /2017 Fudalik D2/ 947
D696 ,846 S 1/2014 Klug D801, 015 S * 10 /2017 Gibson D2 /953
D696 ,853 S 1/ 2014 Martin D802 ,898 S * 11/2017 Montross ......... ... .... D2/954
D697, 293 S * 1/ 2014 Vestuti D2/ 947 D804, 159 S 12 / 2017 Allemann et al.
D697 ,294 S 1/2014 Miner D807,623 S * 1/2018 Vestuti ... D2 /954
8 ,631,590 B2 1 /2014 Droege et al. D810 ,406 S * 2 /2018 Teteriatnikov ................. D2/947
D699 ,420 S 2 / 2014 Teteriatnikov D816 ,309 S * 5 /2018 Cooper . . . . . . . . D2/947
D700 ,423 S 3 /2014 Martin D816 , 963 S * 5 / 2018 Dieudonne .......... D2/954
D700 ,426 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D818 ,683 S. 5 / 2018 Marvin et al .
D700 ,428 S 3 / 2014 Kuerbis D823 ,581 S * 7 /2018 Umehara ... D2/951
D701,036 S 3 / 2014 Martin D824 ,645 S 8 /2018 Gibson et al.
D701,037 S 3 /2014 Ho et al. D825 , 159 S * 8 / 2018 Gibson ... D2/ 947
D702,031 S 4 / 2014 Nakano D825 ,904 S * 8 /2018 Petrenka ........ D2/ 953
D702,428 S 4 / 2014 Hlavacs D828,684 S * 9 / 2018 Varesco D2/947
D702 ,929 S 4 / 2014 Rustam D833, 129 S * 11/2018 Fudalik D2 /954
D703,425 S 4 / 2014 Lee D834, 800 S * 12 / 2018 Raysse * * * . . . . . ... D2 /947
D703 ,929 S 5 / 2014 Avar et al. D838,450 S * 1/2019 Anceresi D2/947
D703, 931 S 5 / 2014 Bikowski D839, 563 S * 2 / 2019 Karnazes ......................... D2/947
D707,023 S 6 / 2014 Della Valle et al. 2002/0078598 A1 6 /2002 Bell
D707, 027 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer 2006 /0101671 Al 5 / 2006 Berend et al.
D707, 028 S 6 / 2014 Parker et al. 2006 /0201028 Al 9 / 2006 Chan et al.
D707,032 S 6 / 2014 Martin 2008 /0022562 Al 1/2008 Manis
D707,033 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer 2008/ 0060225 Al 3 /2008 Kilgore
D707, 433 S * 6 /2014 Grott D2 /951 2008/ 0078101 A1 4 / 2008 Smith et al.
D707,933 S 7 / 2014 McCourt 2009 /0013558 A1 * 1/ 2009 Hazenberg ........... A43B 1/0009
D708 ,430 S 7 / 2014 Weeks 36 /88
D709 ,274 S . 7 / 2014 Roulo 2009 /0133290 A1 5 /2009 Kawai
8 ,776 , 403 B2 7 / 2014 Eder et al. 2009 /0139112 A1 6 /2009 Garneau
8 ,789, 253 B2 7 / 2014 Kilgore et al. 2009 /0183392 AL 7 /2009 Shane
D710 ,078 S 8 / 2014 Joseph 2009/ 0300945 Al 12/ 2009 Droege et al.
D711,636 S * 8/ 2014 Christensen ............. D2/951 2010 /0005684 A1 * 1/2010 Nishiwaki ............ A43B 7 /1425
D712 ,643 S 9 /2014 Seo 36 / 28
D714 , 036 S * 9 / 2014 Etcheverry ... D2/951 2010 /0170106 AL 7/ 2010 Brewer et al.
D716 ,535 S 11/2014 Seo 2010 /0251565 A1 10 /2010 Litchfield et al.
D718 ,033 S 11/2014 Cin 2010 /0281711 A111/2010 Vestuti et al.
D719 , 327 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al . 2010 / 0293811 A1 11 /2010 Truelsen
D719 . 329 S * 12 /2014 Smith .... D2/ 951 2011/ 0099845 Al 5 /2011 Miller
D719 , 330 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al . 2011 /0099855 AL 5 / 2011 Cho
D719 ,332 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/0185590 Al * 8/2011 Nishiwaki . ....... ...... A43B 5/06
D719 , 333 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 36 /28
D719 , 334 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/0197469 A1 * 8/ 2011 Nishiwaki A43B 7 / 24
D719 ,335 S 12 /2014 Lindner et al. 36 / 28
D721,879 S * 2 / 2015 Lindner ........ D2/951 2012 /0073160 A1 * 3 /2012 Marvin ............... A43B 13 /186
D722 ,224 S 2 /2015 Williams, Jr.
D722 ,428 S 2 /2015 Lindner et al . 36 / 28
D723,776 S * 3 /2015 Lidner .......... D2 /951 2013 /0167401 A1* 7/2013 Christensen ........ A43B 13 / 184
D725, 881 S * 4 / 2015 Weeks ........... ...... D2 /951 36 /29
D727,609 S 4 /2015 Hlavacs et al. 2013 /0212909 A1* 8 /2013 Bates A43B 13 / 189
D728, 205 S 5 / 2015 Weddle et al. 36 / 102
D730 ,638 S * 6 / 2015 Christensen . D2/951 2013 /0283641 Al 10 /2013 Rapf et al.
D731 , 164 S 6 /2015 Williams, Jr. 2014 /0013617 A1 * 1/ 2014 Montross ... A43B 7 / 32
D732 ,776 S 6 / 2015 Chung et al. 36 / 28
D734,008 S 7 /2015 Marvin et al. 2014 /0150297 A1 6 /2014 Holmes et al.
Exhibit D - Page 62
US D850 , 075 S
Page 4
2014 /0259786 AL 9 /2014 Heard et al.
2014 /0283413 A1 * 9 /2014 Christensen ......... A43B 3 /0057
36 / 102
2015/0272271 A1* 10 / 2015 Campos, II .......... B29D 35 / 122
36 /29
2016 /0353834 A1 * 12 / 2016 Luedecke .............. A43B 13 / 16
2017 /0042286 A1 * 2/ 2017 Meschter ............. A43B 13 / 141
2017 /0135439 A1 * 5 / 2017 Davis A43B 13/ 14
2017 /0265565 A1 * 9/ 2017 Connell A43B 13 /04
2018 /0125160 A1 * 5 / 2018 Dojan .................. A43B 13 / 122
2018 /0199666 A1 * 7 / 2018 Moriyasu ... ............ A43B 13 / 16
2018 / 0279720 A1 * 10 / 2018 Iuchi .. . ... .. A43B 1 /04
2018 /0339445 A1 * 11/ 2018 Loveder ................ B29C 64 / 245
2019/ 0059512 A1* 2/ 2019 Goldston . ........... A43B 13 /181
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Nike Footwear Catalog, 2010 Holiday: Men ' s Footwear: Perfor
mance , p . 7 , published Feb . 2010 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
published Nov . 2010 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2012 Holiday : Women 's Performance
Footwear, p . 10 , published Feb . 2012 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
wear, p . 9, published Feb . 2013, NIKE, Inc ., USA .
Apr. 10 , 2014 ]. Retrieved from the Internet <URL : http ://www .
skechers .com / style / 11848/skech - air# Color =GYHP > .
* cited by examiner
Exhibit D - Page 63
- L
men
"
mis
1
.
FIG
Exhibit D - Page 64
2
.
FIG
Exhibit D - Page 65
3
.
FIG
-
-
Exhibit D - Page 66
ter
EXIT w
FIG
.
4
Exhibit D - Page 67
U . S . Patent Jun. 4 , 2019 Sheet 5 of 5 US D850,075 S
? 5
.
FIG
?
???
?
Exhibit D - Page 68
EXHIBIT E
Exhibit E - Page 69
USOOD850076S
(12 ) Campos
Unitedet States
al.
2 , 468, 886 A 5 / 1949 Lutey
2 ,826 ,832 A 3 /1958 Rollman
(73 ) Assignee : NIKE , Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) 2 ,853, 809 A
2 ,954 ,618 A
9 / 1958 Bianchi
10 / 1960 Rados
3 ,793,750 A 2 /1974 Bowerman
claimer .
(Continued )
(* *) Term : 15 Years
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(21) Appl. No.: 29 /669,730 Nike Footwear Catalog , 2003 Late Spring : Men 's, Women 's, and
(22 ) Filed : Nov. 9, 2018 Kids' Footwear, p . M3, published Sep . 2002, Nike., USA .
(Continued )
(63 ) Continuation of application No. 29 /557 ,831, filed on Primary Examiner — T Chase Nelson
Mar. 11, 2016 , which is a continuation -in - part of (74 ) Attorney, Agent , or Firm — Banner & Witcoff, Ltd .
application doned, which istilah on Mar.
application No . 29 /519, 930 , filed on Mar. 9 , 2015 , (57 ) CLAIM
now abandoned .
(51) LOC ( 11) CI. . ......... 02-04 The ornamental design for a shoe , as shown and described .
(52) U . S . CI.
USPC . . . . . . . . . . .. .... ..... ................ 12/947
(58 ) Field of Classification Search DESCRIPTION
USPC .... ........... D2 /902, 906 , 908, 916 , 918 , 925 ,
D2/ 946 – 962, 977 ; 36 /3 B , 22 R , 24 . 5 , FIG . 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing our new
36 /25 R , 28 , 32 R , 34 R , 59 C , 67 A , 103 design ;
??? . A43B 13/00 ; A43B 13/02; A43B 13 / 023; FIG . 2 is a side view thereof;
A43B 13 /026 ; A43B 13 /04 ; A43B 13 /08 ; FIG . 3 is an opposite side view thereof;
A43B 13 / 10 ; A43B 13 / 12 ; A43B 13 / 14; FIG . 4 is a front view thereof; and ,
A43B 13 / 141; A43B 13 / 143 ; A43B FIG . 5 is a rear view thereof.
13 / 16 ; A43B 13 /18 ; A43B 13 / 181; A43B The broken lines immediately adjacent to the shaded area
13 / 187 ; A43B 13 / 189 ; A43B 13 / 20 ; A43B define the bounds of the claimed design and form no part
13 /22 ; A43B 13 / 223 ; A43B 13 / 24 ; A43B thereof. The broken lines depicting the remainder of the shoe
13 / 28 ; A43B 13 / 30 ; A43B 13 / 32 ; A43B show features that form no part of the claimed design .
13 /34 ; A43B 13 / 36
- -- - - - = . .
INHomeE2hbe
T
-- - - - -- -
Exhibit E - Page 70
US D850 , 076 S
Page 2
(56 ) References Cited D475 ,514 S 6 /2003 Burg et al.

D476 ,474 S 7 /2003 McDowell
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D479 ,035 S 9 /2003 Adams et al.
6 ,665,958 B2 12 /2003 Goodwin
D241 ,688 S 10 / 1976 Johnson D485 ,053 S 1/2004 McDowell
4 ,096 ,649 A 6 / 1978 Saurwein 6 ,694 ,642 B2 * 2 /2004 Turner A43B 13 / 143
D253 , 257 S 10 / 1979 Pasquier 36 / 28
D254 ,818 S 4 / 1980 Jones D494 ,748 S 8 / 2004 McClaskie
4 ,271 ,606 A 6 / 1981 Rudy D495 ,857 S 9 /2004 Herbst
4 ,309,831 A 1/ 1982 Pritt D497 ,706 S 11/ 2004 Belley et al.
4 ,377 ,041 A 3 / 1983 Alchermes D497 ,707 S 11/2004 Lee
4 ,378,643 A 4 / 1983 Johnson D512 ,817 S 12/2005 Ammon
4 ,577 ,417 A 3 / 1986 Cole D520 ,220 S 5 / 2006 Morgan et al.
D288 ,621 S 3/ 1987 Surpuriya et al. D523 ,627 S 6 / 2006 Avar
D294, 768 S 3 / 1988 Famolare, Jr. D524 ,035 S 7 / 2006 Greene et al.
D297,383 S 8 / 1988 Mourad et al. D529 ,266 S 10 /2006 Le
D299 ,681 S 2 2 / 1989 Miller et al. D529, 267 S 10 / 2006 Portzline
D300 ,085 S 3 / 1989 Ito et al. D529 ,706 S 10 /2006 Paz
D301, 184 S 5 / 1989 Hase D533 ,708 S 12/2006 Earle
D321,973 S 12/ 1991 Hatfield D541,015 S 4 / 2007 Diaz
D322, 154 S 12 / 1991 Trueman D541,020 S 4 /2007 McClaskie
5 , 197,207 A 3 / 1993 Shorten D543 ,677 S * 6 /2007 Andrews D2/946
D335 ,572 S 5 / 1993 Peterson D545 ,534 S 7 /2007 McClaskie
D341 ,708 S 11/ 1993 Blissett D547 ,033 S 7 / 2007 Canavan
D344, 847 S 3/ 1994 Mancebo D547 ,037 S 7 /2007 Nakano
D353, 935 S 1 / 1995 Pollack D556 ,988 S . 12 /2007 Horne et al .
D356 ,672 S. 3/ 1995 Veda D557, 484 S 12 /2007 McClaskie
D362, 747 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2/977 D561, 438 S 2 /2008 Belley
D362, 954 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2/977 D561,439 S 2 / 2008 Schoenborn et al.
5 ,664, 341 A 9 / 1997 Schmidt et al. 7 , 383 ,647 B2 6 / 2008 Chan et al.
D388 ,314 S 12 / 1997 Tresser D572 ,440 S * 7/2008 Polegato Moretti ........... D2/907
D390 ,348 S 2/ 1998 Meyer et al. D573 ,779 S 7 / 2008 Stauffer
D393, 538 S 4 / 1998 Marshall D579 ,185 S * 10 /2008 Mariman D2/947
D395,340 S 6 / 1998 Tresser D580 ,636 S * 11 /2008 Brandt D2/946
D395,740 S 7 / 1998 Cass D583 , 132 S 12 /2008 Polegato Moretti
D395,744 S * 7 / 1998 Edington . . . . . D2 / 961 D583, 135 S * 12 / 2008 Mariman ... . . D2 947
D397,546 S 9 / 1998 Merceron 7 ,464 ,489 B2 12/2008 Ho
D400 , 000 S 10 / 1998 Hatfield et al. D592 ,383 S 5 /2009 Wawrousek
D400 ,345 S 11/ 1998 Teaque D599 ,986 S 9 / 2009 Reiss
5 ,836 ,094 A 11/ 1998 Figel D607,192 S 1 /2010 McClaskie
D401, 745 S 12/ 1998 Greenberg D611 ,689 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D403, 846 S 1 / 1999 Bove et al . D611,690 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D404 ,897 S 2 / 1999 Marshall 7 ,704,430 B2 4 /2010 Johnson et al.
D407 , 193 S 3 / 1999 Doxey D621,144 S 8 /2010 McClaskie
D409 , 360 S * 5 / 1999 Movitz D2 /947 D632 ,879 S * 2 /2011 Merkazy D2 /953
D411 ,912 S 7 / 1999 Van Noy et al. D634 ,922 S 3 /2011 Pauk et al.
D412 ,612 S 8 / 1999 Boyer 7 , 918, 041 B2 4 /2011 Cho
D412 , 777 S * 8 / 1999 Norton .. . D2/947 D639 ,540 S 6 / 2011 Raysse
5 ,955, 159 A 9 / 1999 Allen et al . D643, 599 S * 8 /2011 Fontanarosa ............ D2/916
D414 ,597 S * 10 / 1999 Marvin ... ......... D2/972 D650, 978 S 12 / 2011 Lee
5 ,985, 383 A 11/ 1999 Allen et al. D652,201 S 1 /2012 Vestuti et al .
6 ,018, 889 A 2 / 2000 Friton D655, 901 S * 3 / 2012 Raysse ........ .. .. . . D2/ 951
D423 , 201 S 4 / 2000 Wilson D657 ,941 S 4 /2012 Bramani et al.
D430 , 966 S 9 / 2000 Brady et al. D659 , 959 S 5 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D434, 208 S 11/ 2000 Kimball et al. 8 , 191,284 B2 6/ 2012 Cho
D436 ,431 S 1/ 2001 Agnew et al. 8 ,205 ,355 B2 * 6 /2012 Kawai ................. A43B 13 /026
D437 ,474 S 2 /2001 Agnew et al. 36 / 107
D438 , 368 S 3 /2001 Akhidime D666 ,404 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D441, 948 S 5 /2001 Link D666 ,406 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
D442 , 768 S 5 /2001 Matis D667,211 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 ,230 ,501 B1 5 / 2001 Bailey, Sr. et al. D667,625 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 ,295,472 B1 9 /2001 Rubinstein et al. D667,627 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,295 ,742 B1 10 /2001 Bathum D668, 031 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,354 ,020 B1 * 3/2002 Kimball ......... A43B 13 /203 D668,032 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
36 /135 D668 ,033 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D458 ,441 S 6 / 2002 Gillespie D668,034 S 10 / 2012 Shaffer
D468,518 S 1/ 2003 Sedlbauer D668 ,035 S 10 / 2012 Shaffer
D473, 047 S 4 / 2003 Wilson D669,254 S 10 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D474 ,586 S 5 / 2003 Recchi D669 ,673 S 10 / 2012 Alush
D474 ,876 S 5 / 2003 Ortuno Santa D671,730 S 12 / 2012 Shaffer
Exhibit E - Page 71
US D850 ,076 S
Page 3
(56 ) References Cited D731, 164 S

D732, 776 S
6 /2015 Williams, Jr.
6 /2015 Chung et al.
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D734 ,008 S 7 /2015 Marvin et al.
D734 ,600 S * 7 /2015 Gargiulo .... . D2/ 947
D672 ,949 S 12/ 2012 Bramani et al. D734 ,601 S * 7 /2015 Montross . D2 /951
D674 , 172 S 1/2013 Bramani et al . D736 ,507 S 8 /2015 Hlavacs et al.
D674 , 173 S 1/ 2013 Bramani et al. D738,079 S * 9 / 2015 Bates D2 /951
D675 ,002 S 1/ 2013 Marvin et al. D745 ,256 S * 12/ 2015 Montross .... D2 /951
8 , 375,604 B2 2 /2013 Eder et al. D747, 596 S * 1/ 2016 Vestuti D2/ 951
D677 ,043 S 3 / 2013 Loverin D756 ,093 S * 5 /2016 Mahoney .... D2/951
D677 , 866 S * 3 /2013 Vestuti ........ D2 /947 D756 ,096 S * 5 / 2016 Bizzo .. .. ... D2/951
D681,319 S 5 / 2013 Schwartz D756 ,617 S * 5 /2016 Weddle D2/951
D682 ,519 S 5 / 2013 Litchfield et al. D759 ,359 S 6 /2016 Dombrow
D683, 117 S * 5 / 2013 Truelsen ..... D2/951 D762 , 365 S * 8 /2016 Vestuti ............ D2/947
D683, 118 S 5 / 2013 Pauk D767, 263 S * 9 /2016 Reiser ... D2/947
8 ,453, 349 B2 6 /2013 Auger et al. D770, 153 S 11/ 2016 Marvin et al.
8 ,460 ,593 B2 6 /2013 Fogg et al . D770 , 159 S * 11/2016 Williams, Jr. .... ............ D2/972
D686 ,402 S 7/ 2013 Portzline 1776 .411 S * 1/2017 Christensen ........... D2 /951
D687 ,623 S 8/ 2013 Norris D777,413 S 1/ 2017 Hermes
D692 ,218 S * 10 / 2013 Anceresi ........ D2/947 D778 ,552 S * 2/2017 Chang .................. A43B 13 /143
D692 ,219 S * 10 / 2013 Anceresi D2/947 D2 /947
D693, 550 S * 11/ 2013 Montross D2/951 D781,040 S * 3 / 2017 Scofield D2/ 947
D693, 551 S * 11/ 2013 Montross . .. . . .. . . . .. . . .. . . .. . . . D2 /951 D783, 245 S * 4 / 2017 Hatfield ......................... D2 /947
D694,512 S 12 / 2013 James D783 ,959 S * 4 /2017 Chang D2/947
D695 ,502 S 12/2013 Miner D786 ,544 S 5/ 2017 Marvin et al.
D696 ,501 S * 12/2013 Miner .. .. ......... D2 /947 D789,044 S * 6 /2017 Taestensen ... D2/ 908
D696 ,502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D789 ,048 S * 6 /2017 Lee ........ . ... .. .. D2/912
D696 ,503 S 12 / 2013 Miner D792, 068 S * 7 /2017
2017 Lee ...... .............. A43B 3 /0031
D696 ,505 S 12/ 2013 Miner D2/ 947
D696 ,846 S 1 /2014 Klug D796 , 167 S 9 / 2017 Bates et al.
D696 ,853 S 1 /2014 Martin D798 ,550 S * 10 /2017 Fudalik ................. B29C 64 / 245
D697,293 S * 1/2014 Vestuti D2/947 D2 /947
D697 ,294 S 1/ 2014 Miner D801,015 S * 10 / 2017 Gibson ........... . 12/953
8 ,631 ,590 B2 1/ 2014 Droege et al. D802 , 898 S * 11/2017 Montross ................. A43B 1/04
D699 ,420 S 2 / 2014 Teteriatnikov D2 /954
D700 ,423 S 3 /2014 Martin D804 , 159 S 12 /2017 Allemann et al.
D700 ,426 S 3 /2014 Ho et al. D807,623 S * 1/2018 Vestuti . .... D2/954
D700 ,428 S 3 / 2014 Kuerbis D810 ,406 S * 2 /2018 Teteriatnikov .............. D2 /947
D701,036 S 3 / 2014 Martin D816 ,309 S * 5 /2018 Cooper .................. A43B 13 / 16
D701,037 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D2/ 947
D702 ,031 S 4 / 2014 Nakano D816 ,963 S * 5 / 2018 Dieudonne .... ........... .. D2/ 954
D702 ,428 S 4 / 2014 Hlavacs D818 ,683 S 5 / 2018 Marvin et al.
D702,929 S 4 / 2014 Rustam D823, 581 S * 7 / 2018 Umehara .. D2/ 951
D703 ,425 S 4 / 2014 Lee D824 ,645 S 8 /2018 Gibson et al.
D703 ,929 S 5 / 2014 Avar et al. D825 , 159 S * 8 / 2018 Gibson D2/947
D703, 931 S 5 / 2014 Bikowski D825 , 904 S * 8 /2018 Petrenka D2/953
D707,023 S 6 / 2014 Della Valle et al. D828,684 S * 9 / 2018 Varesco D2/ 947
D707,027 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer D833, 129 S * 11/2018 Fudalik ............. D2 /954
D707 ,028 S 6 /2014 Parker et al. D834 ,800 S * 12 /2018 Raysse ............ D2/947
D707 ,032 S 6 / 2014 Martin D838,450 S * 1/2019 Anceresi ........ ................ D2/947
D707 ,033 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer D839 , 563 S * 2 /2019 Karnaze
Karnazes ....... .... ............ D2/947
D707,433 S * 6 / 2014 Grott D2/951 2002/0078598 A1 6 /2002 Bell
D707,933 S 7 /2014 McCourt 2006 /0101671 A1 5 / 2006 Berend et al.
D708,430 S 7 / 2014 Weeks 2006 /0201028 A1 9 / 2006 Chan et al.
D709 ,274 S 7 /2014 Roulo 2008/ 0022562 A1 1/ 2008 Manis
8 ,776 ,403 B2 7 / 2014 Eder et al. 2008/ 0060225 A1 3 / 2008 Kilgore
8 ,789 ,253 B2 7 / 2014 Kilgore et al. 2008/ 0078101 A1 4 /2008 Smith et al.
D710 ,078 S 8 /2014 Joseph 2009 /0013558 A1 * 1/2009 Hazenberg . .......... A43B 1/0009
D711 ,636 S * 8 /2014 Christensen ............ D2/ 951 36 / 88
D712 ,643 S 9 / 2014 Seo 2009/0133290 AL 5 /2009 Kawai
D714 ,036 S * 9 /2014 Etcheverry ............... D2/ 951 2009 /0139112 A16 / 2009 Gameau
D716 , 535 S 11/ 2014 Seo 2009/0183392 A1 7 / 2009 Shane
D718 ,033 S 11/2014 Cin 2009 /0300945 A1 12 /2009 Droege et al.
D719 , 327 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2010 / 0005684 Al * 1/ 2010 Nishiwaki ............ A43B 7 / 1425
D719 ,329 S * 12/2014 Smith .. .. . . . .. .. D2 /951 36 /28
D719 ,330 S 12/2014 Lindner et al .
D719 ,333 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2010 /0251565 Al 10 /2010 Litchfield et al.
D719 ,334 S 12 /2014 Lindner et al. 2010 /0281711 AL 11/2010 Vestuti et al.
D719 ,335 S 12/2014 Lindner et al . 2010 /0293811 A111/2010 Truelsen
D721,879 S * 2 /2015 Lindner ........ D2/951 2011 /0099845 A15 /2011 Miller
D722 ,224 S 2 / 2015 Williams, Jr. 2011/ 0099855 Al 5 / 2011 Cho
D722 ,428 S 2 / 2015 Lindner et al. 2011/0185590 A1 * 8 / 2011 Nishiwaki A43B 5 /06
D723 ,776 S * 3 /2015 Lidner D2/951 36 / 28
D725, 881 S * 4 / 2015 Weeks ... ...... ........... D2/ 951 2011/0197469 A1* 8/2011 Nishiwaki ... A43B 7 /24
D727,609 S 4 / 2015 Hlavacs et al. 36 / 28
D728 ,205 S 5 /2015 Weddle et al. 2012/0073160 A1* 3/2012 Marvin ............... A43B 13 /186
D730 ,638 S * 6 / 2015 Christensen ........... D2/951 36 / 28
Exhibit E - Page 72
US D850 ,076 S
Page 4
(56) References Cited 2018 /0199666 A1 * 7/ 2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16

2018 /0279720 A1 * 10 /2018 Iuchi ....... A43B 1 /04
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS 2018 /0339445 A1* 11/2018 Loveder ............... B29C 64 /245
2019 /0059512 A1 * 2 /2019 Goldston ............ A43B 3 /0031
2013 /0167401 A1 * 7 /2013 Christensen ......... A43B 13 / 184
36 / 29
2013/0212909 A1 * 8/ 2013 Bates ................... A43B 13 / 189 OTHER PUBLICATIONS
36 / 102 Nike Footwear Catalog, 2010 Holiday : Men 's Footwear: Perfor
2013 / 0283641 Al 10 / 2013 Rapf et al.
intross ................. A43B 7 /32
2014 /0013617 A1 * 1/ 2014 Montross mance, p . 7 , published Feb . 2010 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
36 /28 Nike Footwear Catalog, 2011 Fall : Young Athletes Footwear, p . 24 ,
2014 /0150297 A1 6 / 2014 Holmes et al. published Nov . 2010 , NIKE, Inc., USA .
2014 /0259786 AL 9 / 2014 Heard et al. Nike Footwear Catalog, 2012 Holiday: Women ' s Performance
2014/0283413 A1 * 9 / 2014 Christensen ......... A43B 3/ 0057 Footwear, p . 10 , published Feb . 2012 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
36 / 102 Nike Footwear Catalog, 2013 Holiday : Womens Performance Foot
2015 /0272271 A1 * 10 / 2015 Campos, II .......... B290 35 / 122 wear, p . 9, published Feb . 2013 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
36 /29 Women 's Skech -Air by Skechers USA , Inc . USA [online ]. [retrieved
2016/ 0353834 A1 * 12/2016 Luedecke .............. A43B 13/ 16 Apr. 10 , 2014 ]. Retrieved from the Internet < URL : http ://www .
2017 /0042286 A1 * 2 / 2017 Meschter ............. A43B 13 / 141
2017 /0135439 A1 * 5 / 2017 Davis ....... ......... A43B 13 / 14 skechers.com /style /11848/ skech-air# Color =GYHP > .
2017 /0265565 A1 * 9 /2017 Connell ................. A43B 13 /04
2018 /0125160 A1 * 5 /2018 Dojan A43B 13 /122 * cited by examiner
Exhibit E - Page 73
=
==
==
==
==*
*-
:=
:=
-
1
.
FIG
Exhibit E - Page 74
Eco
-
2
.
FIG
VARME
Exhibit E - Page 75
the
am
-
*
FIG
.
3
TI
Exhibit E - Page 76
ad lnawgn
-Djeling
-meinem po 4
.
FIG
in
Exhibit E - Page 77
ASK7 5
.
FIG
Exhibit E - Page 78
EXHIBIT F
Exhibit F - Page 79
USOOD8500775
(12 ) Campos
Unitedet States
al.
2 , 468, 886 A 5 / 1949 Lutey
2 ,826 ,832 A 3 /1958 Rollman
2 ,954 ,618
A
A
9 / 1958 Bianchi
10 / 1960 Rados
( * ) Notice : This patent is subject to a terminal dis D196 ,491 S 10/ 1963 Papoutsy
3 ,793 ,750 A 2 / 1974 Bowerman
4 ,096 ,649 A 6 / 1978 Saurwein
(* *) Term : 15 Years D253 ,257 S 10 / 1979 Pasquier
(Continued )
(21) Appl. No.: 29 /669,731
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(22 ) Filed : Nov. 9, 2018
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2003 Late Spring : Men 's , Women 's , and
Related U .S. Application Data Kids' Footwear, p . M3, published Sep . 2002 , NIKE., USA .
(63 ) Continuation of application No. 29 /557 ,831, filed on (Continued )
Mar. 11, 2016 , which is a continuation -in - part of
MaricationNo.29154richtinea on
application No. 29 /519, 930 , filed on Mar. 9 , 2015 ,
now abandoned .
Primary Examiner — T Chase Nelson
(74 ) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Banner & Witcoff , Ltd .
(51) LOC ( 11) CI. ............... 02- 04 (57) CLAIM

(52) U . S . CI.
USPC . . . . . . . . . . .. ........... D2 /947 The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described .
USPC .... ........... D2 /902, 906 , 908, 916 , 918 , 925 ,
D2/946 - 962 , 977; 36 /3 B , 22 R , 24 .5 , DESCRIPTION
36 /25 R , 28 , 32 R , 34 R , 59 C , 67 A , 103
??? . A43B 13 / 00 ; A43B 13 /02 ; A43B 13 /023 ; FIG . 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing our new
A43B 13 /026 ; A43B 13 /04 ; A43B 13 /08 ; design ;
A43B 13 / 10 ; A43B 13 / 12 ; A43B 13/ 14 ; FIG . 2 is a side view thereof;
A43B 13 / 141; A43B 13 / 143 ; A43B FIG . 3 is an opposite side view thereof;
13 / 16 ; A43B 13 /18 ; A43B 13 / 181; A43B FIG . 4 is a front view thereof; and ,
13 /34 ; A43B 13 / 36
--
--
Kui ::
STACIONES LS
- - -- - 7
Exhibit F - Page 80
US D850 ,077 s
Page 2
(56 ) References Cited 6 ,665, 958 B2

D485 ,053 S
12 / 2003 Goodwin
1/2004 McDowell
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS 6 ,694 ,642 B2 * 2 /2004 Turner . . .. . . .. . . . A43B 13 / 143
36 / 28
D254 ,818 S 4 / 1980 Jones D494 ,748 S 8 /2004 McClaskie
4 ,271 ,606 A 6 / 1981 Rudy D495 ,857 S 9 /2004 Herbst
4 , 309 ,831 A 1/ 1982 Pritt D497,706 S 11/2004 Belley et al.
4 , 377 ,041 A 3 / 1983 Alchermes D497 ,707 S 11/ 2004 Lee
4 ,378 ,643 A 4 / 1983 Johnson D512 ,817 S 12 /2005 Ammon
4 ,577,417 A 3 / 1986 Cole D520 ,220 S 5 /2006 Morgan et al .
D288 ,621 S 3 / 1987 Surpuriya et al. D523 ,627 S 6 /2006 Avar
D294 , 768 S 3/ 1988 Famolare , Jr. D524 ,035 S 7 / 2006 Greene et al.
D297 ,383 S 8 / 1988 Mourad et al. D529 ,266 S 10 /2006 Le
D300, 085 S 3 / 1989 Ito et al. D529 ,706 S 10 /2006 Paz
D301, 184 S 5 / 1989 Hase D533 ,708 S 12 /2006 Earle
D301,659 S 6 / 1989 Le D536 , 163 S 2 / 2007 McClaskie
D321,973 S 12 / 1991 Hatfield D541,015 S 4 / 2007 Diaz
D322 , 154 S 12/ 1991 Trueman D541,020 S 4 / 2007 McClaskie
5 , 197 ,207 A 3 / 1993 Shorten D543,677 S * 6 /2007 Andrews . . . . . . D2 /946
D341,708 S 11/ 1993 Blissett D547,033 S 7 /2007 Canavan
D344,847 S 3 / 1994 Mancebo D547 ,037 S 7 / 2007 Nakano
D353 ,935 S 1/ 1995 Pollack D556 ,988 S . 12/ 2007 Horne et al.
D356 ,672 S 3 / 1995 Ueda D557 ,484 s 12 /2007 McClaskie
D362, 747 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2/977 D561,438 S . 2 / 2008 Belley
D362,954 S * 10 / 1995 Orzeck D2 /977 D561,439 S 2 / 2008 Schoenborn et al .
5 ,664 ,341 A 9/ 1997 Schmidt et al. 7 ,383,647 B26 / 2008 Chan et al.
D388 ,314 S 12 / 1997 Tresser D572 ,440 S * 7 /2008 Polegato Moretti ........... D2/ 907
D390, 348 S 2/ 1998 Meyer et al. D573 ,779 S 7 /2008 Stauffer
D393,538 S 4 / 1998 Marshall D579 , 185 S * 10 /2008 Mariman ...... D2/ 947
D394 , 541 S 5 / 1998 Burgess 7 ,430 ,817 B2 10 /2008 Abadjian et al.
D395 ,340 S 6 / 1998 Tresser D580 ,636 S * 11/2008 Brandt ........ D2/946
D395 ,740 S 7 / 1998 Cass D583 , 132 S 12 / 2008 Polegato Moretti
D395 ,744 S * 7 / 1998 Edington D2/961 D583 , 135 S * 12/2008 Mariman . . . . . . D2/ 947
D397, 546 S 9 / 1998 Merceron 7 ,464 ,489 B2 12 / 2008 Ho
D400 ,000 S 10 / 1998 Hatfield et al. D592, 383 S 5 / 2009 Wawrousek
D400 ,345 S 11/ 1998 Teaque D599, 986 S 9 /2009 Reiss
5 , 836 ,094 A 11/ 1998 Figel D607 , 192 S 1/2010 McClaskie
D401,745 S 12 /1998 Greenberg D611 ,689 S 3 / 2010 Stubblefield
D403, 846 S 1/ 1999 Bove et al. D611,690 S 3 /2010 Stubblefield
D404, 897 S 2 / 1999 Marshall 7 ,704 ,430 B2 4 / 2010 Johnson et al.
D407, 193 S 3 / 1999 Doxey D621, 144 S 8 / 2010 McClaskie
D409 , 360 S * 5 / 1999 Movitz .......... D2/947 D632 ,879 S * 2 /2011 Merkazy D2/953
D411 ,912 S 7 / 1999 Van Noy et al. D634 ,922 S 3 / 2011 Pauk et al.
D412 ,612 S 8/ 1999 Boyer 7 ,918, 041 B2 4/ 2011 Cho
D412 ,777 S * 8 / 1999 Norton D2/947 D639 ,540 S 6 /2011 Raysse
5 ,955 , 159 A 9 / 1999 Allen et al. D643,599 S * 8 / 2011 Fontanarosa ...... D2 /916
D414 ,597 S * 10 / 1999 Marvin .... . D2/972 D650 ,978 S 12/ 2011 Lee
5 ,985 ,383 A 11 / 1999 Allen et al. D652, 201 S 1 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
6 ,018,889 A 2 / 2000 Friton D655, 901 S * 3/ 2012 Raysse ...... D2/951
D423 ,201 S 4 / 2000 Wilson D657,941 S 4 /2012 Bramani et al.
D430 , 966 S 9 /2000 Brady et al . D659 ,959 S 5 / 2012 Vestuti et al.
D434 , 208 S 11 / 2000 Kimball et al. 8,191, 284 B2 6/ 2012 Cho
D436 ,431 S 1/ 2001 Agnew et al. 8 , 205, 355 B2 * 6 / 2012 Kawai . .. .. .. .. .. . A43B 13 /026
D437,474 S 2 / 2001 Agnew et al. 36 / 107
D438 , 368 S 3 / 2001 Akhidime D666 ,404 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D441,948 S 5 /2001 Link D666 ,406 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
D442, 768 S 5 / 2001 Matis D667,211 S 9 / 2012 Shaffer
6 ,230, 501 B1 5 /2001 Bailey , Sr. et al. D667,625 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 , 295 ,472 B1 9 / 2001 Rubinstein et al. D667,627 S 9 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,295,742 B1 10 / 2001 Bathum D668,031 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
6 ,354 ,020 B1 * 3 / 2002 Kimball ............... A43B 13 / 203 D668,032 S 10/ 2012 Shaffer
36 / 135 D668,033 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D458 ,441 S 6 / 2002 Gillespie D668, 034 S 10 /2012 Shaffer
D473, 047 S 4 /2003 Wilson D669 ,254 S 10 /2012 Vestuti et al.
D474 ,876 S 5 /2003 Ortuno Santa D671,730 S 12 /2012 Shaffer
D475, 509 S 6 /2003 Avar D672 ,543 S 12 / 2012 Williams, Jr.
D475 ,514 S 6 /2003 Burg et al. D672 ,949 S 12/2012 Bramani et al.
D476 , 474 S 7 / 2003 McDowell D674 , 172 S . 1 /2013 Bramani et al .
Exhibit F - Page 81
US D850 ,077 s
Page 3
(56 ) References Cited D734 ,600 S * *
7 / 2015 Gargiulo ........... D2 /947

D734 ,601 S * 7 / 2015 Montross . D2 /951
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D736 , 507 S 8 /2015 Hlavacs et al .
D738, 079 S *
* 9 /2015 Bates D2 /951

D675 ,002 S 1/ 2013 Marvin et al. D745,256 S *
* 12 / 2015 Montross D2/951

8 , 375 ,604 B2 2 / 2013 Eder et al. D747 ,596 S *
* 1 /2016 Vestuti D2/951

D677 ,043 S 3/ 2013 Loverin D756 ,093 S * *
5 /2016 Mahoney ............. D2 /951

D677 ,866 S * 3 /2013 Vestuti D2 /947 D756 ,096 S * *
5 /2016 Bizzo D2 /951

D681,319 S 5 / 2013 Schwartz D756 ,617 S * *
5 /2016 Weddle ...... D2/ 951

D683, 117 S * 5 / 2013 Truelsen ... . . .. . .. D2/ 951 D762, 365 S * 8 / 2016 Vestuti D2/947
D683 ,118 S 5 /2013 Pauk D767, 263 S * 9 / 2016 Reiser. ..... .. . ..... D2/ 947
8 ,453, 349 B2 6 /2013 Auger et al. D770 ,153 S 11/ 2016 Marvin et al.
8 ,460 ,593 B2 6 / 2013 Fogg et al . D770 ,159 S * 11/ 2016 Williams, Jr. ................. D2/972
D686 ,402 S 7 / 2013 Portzline D776 ,411 S * 1/ 2017 Christensen ....... ........... D2 /951
D687 ,623 S 8 / 2013 Norris D777,413 S 1/2017 Hermes
D692 ,218 S * 10 /2013 Anceresi .... ........... D2 /947 D778,552 S * 2 /2017 Chang .................. A43B 13 / 186
D692 ,219 S * 10 /2013 Anceresi .. . .. . . D2 /947 D2/947
D693, 550 S * 11/ 2013 Montross . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D2/951 D781, 040 S * 3/ 2017 Scofield ....... .. ............ D2 /947
D693 ,551 S * 11/ 2013 Montross ....................... D2 /951 D783 ,245 S * 4 /2017 Hatfield ..... .. ... D2/ 947
D694 ,512 S 12 /2013 James D783,959 S * 4 /2017 Chang .................. A43B 7 / 1425
D695 ,502 S 12 /2013 Miner D2 /947
D696 ,501 S * 12 / 2013 Miner D2/947 D786 ,544 S 5 /2017 Marvin et al.
D696 , 502 S 12 / 2013 Miner D789,044 S * 6 / 2017 Taestensen .. .. .. ... .. . D2/ 908
D696 , 503 S 12 / 2013 Miner D789 ,048 S * 6 /2017 Lee ............ .. . .. .. . . . . D2 /912
D696 ,505 S 12 / 2013 Miner D792, 068 S * 7 / 2017 Lee ...... D2/947
D696 ,846 S 1/2014 Klug D796 , 167 S 9 / 2017 Bates et al.
D696 ,853 S 1/ 2014 Martin D798, 550 S * 10 / 2017 Fudalik ... .. . . . . D2/ 947
D697, 293 S * 1/ 2014 Vestuti D2/ 947 D801,015 S * 10 / 2017 Gibson . . . . . . D2/953
D697 ,294 S 1/2014 Miner D802 ,898 S * 11/2017 Montross ............. A43B 13 / 189
8 ,631,590 B2 1 /2014 Droege et al. D2/ 954
D699 ,420 S 2 / 2014 Teteriatnikov D804 , 159 S 12 /2017 Allemann et al.
D700 ,423 S 3 /2014 Martin D807,623 S * 1/2018 Vestuti .... D2 /954
D700 ,426 S 3 / 2014 Ho et al. D810 ,406 S * 2 /2018 Teteriatnikov . . .............. D2/947
D700 ,428 S 3 / 2014 Kuerbis D816 , 309 S * 5 / 2018 Cooper D2/947
D701,036 S 3 / 2014 Martin D816 , 963 S * 5 / 2018 Dieudonne D2/954
D701,037 S 3 /2014 Ho et al. D818 ,683 S 5 / 2018 Marvin et al.
D702,031 S 4 / 2014 Nakano D823 .581 S * 7 / 2018 Umehara .... . D2 /951
D702,428 S 4 / 2014 Hlavacs D824 ,645 S 8 /2018 Gibson et al.
D702 ,929 S 4 / 2014 Rustam D825, 159 S * 8 /2018 Gibson ......... . .. . .. . D2/947
D703,425 S 4 / 2014 Lee D825 ,904 S * 8 / 2018 Petrenka ..... D2/953
D703 ,929 S 5 / 2014 Avar et al. D828,684 S * 9 /2018 Varesco D2/947
D703, 931 S 5 / 2014 Bikowski D833 , 129 S * 11/2018 Fudalik D2/954
D707,023 S 6 / 2014 Della Valle et al. D834 ,800 S * 12 / 2018 Raysse .. .. . .. D2/ 947
D707, 027 S 6 / 2014 Shaffer D838 ,450 S * 1/ 2019 Anceresi .. ... .. ..... ... ... D2 /947
D707, 028 S 6 / 2014 Parker et al. D839, 563 S * 2 / 2019 Karnazes D2 /947
D707,032 S 6 / 2014 Martin 2002/0078598 A1 6 /2002 Bell
D707, 433 S * 6 /2014 Grott D2 /951 2006 /0201028 A 9 /2006 Chan et al.
D707,933 S 7 / 2014 McCourt 2008/ 0022562 AL 1/ 2008 Manis
D708 ,430 S 7 / 2014 Weeks 2008 /0060225 A1 3 /2008 Kilgore
D709 ,274 S . 7 / 2014 Roulo 2008/0078101 A1 4 / 2008 Smith et al.
8 ,776 , 403 B2 7 / 2014 Eder et al. 2009/ 0013558 A1 * 1/2009 Hazenberg . ......... A43B 1/0009
8 ,789, 253 B2 7 / 2014 Kilgore et al. 36 / 88
D710 ,078 S 8 / 2014 Joseph 2009 /0133290 A1 5 / 2009 Kawai
D711,636 S * 8/ 2014 Christensen ............. D2/951 2009/0139112 A1 6 /2009 Garneau
D712 ,643 S 9 /2014 Seo 2009/0183392 A1 7 /2009 Shane
D714 , 036 S * 9 / 2014 Etcheverry D2 /951 2009/ 0300945 A1 12 / 2009 Droege et al.
D716 ,535 S 11/2014 Seo 2010 /0005684 A1 * 1/2010 Nishiwaki ............ A43B 7 /1425
D718 ,033 S 11/2014 Cin 36 / 28
D719 , 327 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al . 2010 /0170106 AL 7 /2010 Brewer et al.
D719 . 329 S * 12 /2014 Smith .... D2 /951 2010 /0251565 A1 10 /2010 Litchfield et al.
D719 , 330 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al . 2010 / 0281711 A1 11/2010 Vestuti et al.
D719 ,332 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2010 / 0293811 AL 11/2010 Truelsen
D719 , 333 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011 /0099845 Al 5 / 2011 Miller
D719 , 334 S 12 / 2014 Lindner et al. 2011/ 0099855 Al 5/ 2011 Cho
D719 ,335 S 12 /2014 Lindner et al.
D721,879 S * 2 / 2015 Lindner ........ D2/951 2011/0185590 A1 * 8 / 2011 Nishiwaki A43B 5 /06
D722 ,224 S 2 /2015 Williams, Jr. 36 / 28
D722 ,428 S 2 /2015 Lindner et al . 2011/0197469 Al * 8/ 2011 Nishiwaki A43B 7 / 24
D723,776 S * 3 /2015 Lidner .......... D2/951 36 / 28
D725, 881 S * 4 / 2015 Weeks ........... ...... D2/951 2012/0073160 A1 * 3/2012 Marvin ............... A43B 1336/186
D727,609 S 4 /2015 Hlavacs et al. / 28
D728, 205
D730 ,638 S *
S 5 / 2015 Weddle et al.
6 / 2015 Christensen . D2/951
2013/0167401 Al * 7/2013 Christensen ......... A43B 1336/ /184
29
D731 , 164 S
D732 ,776 S
6 /2015 Williams, Jr.
6 / 2015 Chung et al.
2013/0212909 AL* 8/ 2013 Bates .............. A43B 3613//102
189
D734,008 S 7 /2015 Marvin et al. 2013 /0283641 Al 10/2013 Rapf et al.
Exhibit F - Page 82
US D850 ,077 s
Page 4
(56 ) References Cited

2014 /0013617 Al * 1/2014 Montross ................. A43B 7 /32
36 /28
2014 /0150297 A1 6 / 2014 Holmes et al.
2014 /0259786 AL 9 /2014 Heard et al .
2014 / 0283413 A1 * 9/ 201414 Christensen ......... A43B 3 /0057
36 / 102
2015 /0272271 A1 * 10 / 2015 Campos, II .......... B29D 35 / 122
36 /29
2016/ 0353834 A1 * 12 / 2016 Luedecke .............. A43B 13/ 16
2017 / 0042286 A1 * 2 / 2017
2017 Meschter ............. A43B 13 / 141
2017 /0135439 A1 * 5 / 2017 Davis ... .. . .. A43B 13 / 14
2017 /0265565 A1 * 9 /2017 Connell ................. A43B 13/04
2018 /0125160 A1 * 5 / 2018 Dojan .................. A43B 13 / 122
2018 /0199666 A1 * 7 /2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16
2018 /0279720 A1 * 10 / 2018 Iuchi A43B 1 /04
2018 / 0339445 A1 * 11/ 2018 Loveder ................ B29C 64 /245
2019 /0059512 Al * 2 / 2019 Goldston ............. A43B 3 /0031
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Nike Footwear Catalog, 2010 Holiday : Men 's Footwear: Perfor
mance, p . 7 , published Feb . 2010 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
published Nov. 2010 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
Footwear, p . 10 , published Feb . 2012 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
Nike Footwear Catalog , 2013 Holiday : Womens Performance Foot
wear, p . 9, published Feb . 2013 , NIKE , Inc ., USA .
Women 's Skech -Air by Skechers USA , Inc . USA [online ]. [ retrieved
Apr. 10 , 2014 ). Retrieved from the Internet < URL : http ://www .
skechers.com / style / 11848/skech -air# Color =GYHP> .
* cited by examiner
Exhibit F - Page 83
Fw
-
thewaterinport
the
-
-
-
n
i
1
.
FIG
Exhibit F - Page 84
LO
-
.
FIG
2
what
w
Exhibit F - Page 85
.
FIG
3
Litu
L CV
Exhibit F - Page 86
-
-
mamp
IT ON 4
.
FIG
wan
Exhibit F - Page 87
ROS
-
5
.
FIG
-
LA
ww
AN
A
L
V
WY
Exhibit F - Page 88
EXHIBIT G
Exhibit G - Page 89
IIIIII IIIIIIII Ill lllll llllll llll lllll lllll lllll lllll lllll 111111111111111111
USOOD858962S
c12) United States Design Patent c10) Patent No.: US D858,962 S

Small et al. (45) Date of Patent: ** *Sep. 10, 2019
(54) SHOE (56) References Cited
(71) Applicant: NIKE, Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
2,208,330 A 7/1940 Oakley

(72) Inventors: Jessica Small, Portland, OR (US); Can 3,851,411 A 12/1974 Crosbie et al.
Eidem, Portland, OR (US) D261,446 S 10/1981 Schmohl
D262,159 S 12/1981 Bartneck
D280,776 S 10/1985 Gamm
(73) Assignee: NIKE, Inc., Beaverton, OR (US)
(Continued)
( *) Notice: This patent is subject to a terminal dis-
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
claimer.
CA 2014256 Al 10/1991
(**) Term: 15 Years CA 2802538 Al 12/2011
(Continued)
(21) Appl. No.: 29/692,932
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(22) Filed: May 29, 2019
Nike Air Max 93 "Blue Graphite" Available now [online], [retrieved
Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <URL: <http://sneakerbardetroit.
com/nike-air-max-93-blue-graphite-available-now/>>; 4 color sheets,
Related U.S. Application Data Dated Feb. 5, 2015.
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/604,274, filed on (Continued)
May 16, 2017.
Primary Examiner - T Chase Nelson
(51) LOC (12) Cl. ............................................... 02-04 (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm - Banner & Witcoff, Ltd.
(52) U.S. Cl.
(57) CLAIM
USPC . ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... . D2/947
The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described.
( 58) Field of Classification Search
DESCRIPTION
USPC ................. D21902, 906, 908, 916, 918, 925,
D2/946-962, 977; 36/3 B, 22 R, 24.5, FIG. 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing my new
36/25 R, 28, 32 R, 34 R, 59 C, 67 A, 103 design;
CPC ....... A43B 13/00; A43B 13/02; A43B 13/023; FIG. 2 is a side view thereof;
A43B 13/026; A43B 13/04; A43B 13/08; FIG. 3 is an opposite side view thereof; and,
A43B 13/10; A43B 13/12; A43B 13/14; FIG. 4 is a front view thereof.
A43B 13/141; A43B 13/143; A43B The broken line immediately adjacent to the top of the
13/16; A43B 13/18; A43B 13/181; A43B shaded area defines the upper bounds of the claimed design
and forms no part thereof. The curved oblique shade lines
13/187; A43B 13/189; A43B 13/20; A43B
represent a translucent or transparent appearance. The bro-
13/22; A43B 13/223; A43B 13/24; A43B ken lines depicting the remainder of the shoe show features
13/28; A43B 13/30; A43B 13/32; A43B that form no part of the claimed design.
13/34; A43B 13/36
See application file for complete search history. 1 Claim, 4 Drawing Sheets
Exhibit G - Page 90
US D858,962 S
Page 2
(56) References Cited D503,523 S 4/2005 Matis et al.

D506,597 S 6/2005 Matis et al.
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS D511,617 S 11/2005 Matis
D511,886 S 11/2005 Galway
D280,778 S 10/1985 Gamm D515,305 S 2/2006 Andrews-Kramer
4,878,301 A 11/1989 Kiyosawa D520,726 S 5/2006 Duclos
D310,442 S 9/1990 Hatfield D522,722 S 6/2006 Wilkenfeld et al.
D315,054 S 3/1991 Hatfield 7,162,815 B2 1/2007 Miyauchi et al.
5,060,401 A 10/1991 Whatley D559,509 S 1/2008 Hayes
D321,584 S 11/1991 Mitsui D563,653 S 3/2008 Schoenborn et al.
D324,131 S 2/1992 Lucas D566,942 S 4/2008 Juan
D324,294 S 3/1992 Hatfield D566,960 S 4/2008 Rivas et al.
D324,762 S 3/1992 Hatfield D572,455 S 7/2008 Lubrano
D325,289 S 4/1992 Aveni D572,462 S 7/2008 Hatfield et al.
D325,464 S 4/1992 Smith D576,394 S 9/2008 Heller
D325,667 S 4/1992 Smith, III D577,478 S 9/2008 Peveto et al.
D326,952 S 6/1992 Smith, III 7,421,806 B2 9/2008 Braynock et al.
D329,938 S 10/1992 Lucas D577,892 S 10/2008 St-Louis et al.
D330,110 S 10/1992 Worthington D577,893 S 10/2008 St-Louis et al.
D330,lll S 10/1992 Hatfield et al. D580,134 S 11/2008 Beiley et al.
D330,797 S 11/1992 Lucas D594,202 S 6/2009 Sorofman
D330,970 S 11/1992 Hatfield et al. 7,549,236 B2 6/2009 Dillon et al.
D331,143 S 11/1992 McDonald D599,102 S 9/2009 Purdom et al.
D332,861 S 2/1993 Worthington 7,644,518 B2 1/2010 Chandler et al.
D333,034 S 2/1993 McDonald 7,730,640 B2 6/2010 Clark et al.
D333,378 S 2/1993 Close 7,797,856 B2 9/2010 Andrews et al.
D333,551 S 3/1993 Bailey D625,097 S 10/2010 Portzline
D333,720 S 3/1993 Hatfield D626,316 S * 11/2010 Akhidime ...................... D21946
D334,280 S 3/1993 Teague D629,598 S 12/2010 Portzline et al.
D334,650 S 4/1993 Teague D634,918 S 3/2011 Katz et al.
D335,952 S 6/1993 F orland et al. D635,748 S 4/2011 Katz et al.
D336,771 S 6/1993 Hatfield et al. D636,567 S 4/2011 Raysse
D338,995 S 9/1993 Snell D636,568 S 4/2011 McMillan
D341,478 S 11/1993 F orland et al. D636,570 S 4/2011 Merritt et al.
D343,044 S 1/1994 Kilgore et al. D638,615 S 5/2011 McMillan
D343,045 S 1/1994 Bailey 7,980,006 B2 7/2011 Aveni et al.
D343,046 S 1/1994 Feller et al. D650,980 S 12/2011 Raysse
D343,722 S 2/1994 Lucas D655,483 S 3/2012 Portzline
D344,848 S 3/1994 Smith D661,878 S 6/2012 Grenet
D346,486 S 5/1994 Morris et al. D661,879 S 6/2012 Raysse
D347,106 S 5/1994 Sell, Jr. et al. 8,241,450 B2 8/2012 Hensley et al.
D347,318 S 5/1994 Avar 8,327,560 B2 12/2012 Berend
D349,808 S 8/1994 Passke et al. D674,996 S 1/2013 Sallee
D350,016 S 8/1994 Passke et al. D679,485 S 4/2013 Raysse
D350,023 S 8/1994 Hatfield et al. D680,712 S * 4/2013 Della Valle .................... D2/908
D350,433 S 9/1994 Kilgore D680,713 S 4/2013 Della Valle et al.
5,353,526 A 10/1994 Foley et al. D681,314 S 5/2013 Durnain
D356,884 S 4/1995 Ho D686,805 S 7/2013 Day, Jr.
D357,575 S 4/1995 Dahlsten 8,584,377 B2 11/2013 Blevens et al.
D358,702 S 5/1995 Edwards 8,640,361 B2 2/2014 Testa et al.
5,425,184 A 6/1995 Lyden et al. D702,025 S 4/2014 Della Valle et al.
D363,372 S 10/1995 Hatfield et al. D708,828 S 7/2014 Avar et al.
D366,756 S 2/1996 F orland et al. D713,133 S 9/2014 Della Valle et al.
D377,411 S * 1/1997 Murray .......................... D2/953 D716,535 S 11/2014 Seo
D378,550 S 3/1997 Morris D722,749 S 2/2015 Svensson et al.
D379,865 S 6/1997 Hewett 8,997,380 B2 4/2015 Dombrow et al.
D381,796 S 8/1997 Kittle et al. D765,360 S 9/2016 Petrie
D383,300 S 9/1997 Teague D765,363 S 9/2016 Petrie
D386,291 S 11/1997 Napurano, Jr. D772,547 S 11/2016 Raysse
D401,043 S 11/1998 Truelsen D777,410 S 1/2017 Takahashi et al.
D404,896 S 2/1999 Cooper D778,551 S 2/2017 Pauk
D407,540 S 4/1999 Dolinsky D778,553 S 2/2017 DeAlmeida
D408,618 S 4/1999 Wilborn et al. D783,246 S * 4/2017 Chang ............................ D2/947
D410,691 S 6/1999 Boyer D783,960 S 4/2017 Hatfield
D413,013 S 8/1999 Koh D783,991 S 4/2017 Chang
D418,282 S 1/2000 von Conta et al. 9,629,414 B2 4/2017 Elder et al.
D439,399 S 3/2001 Matis et al. D789,044 S 6/2017 Taestensen
D441,l 75 S 5/2001 Ritter et al. D789,047 S 6/2017 Bruder et al.
D458,013 S 6/2002 Matis D789,051 S 6/2017 Kuerbis
D458,014 S 6/2002 Matis D789,052 S 6/2017 Hardman
D458,442 S 6/2002 Matis D789,054 S 6/2017 Shyllon
D458,443 S 6/2002 Matis D789,504 S 6/2017 Won
D459,575 S 7/2002 Garcia D790,173 S * 6/2017 Raasch .......................... D2/947
D466,276 S 12/2002 Tomczak 9,687,042 B2 6/2017 Berend et al.
D474,879 S 5/2003 Nason D794,287 S 8/2017 Raasch
6,662,474 B2 12/2003 Tomat D795,539 S 8/2017 Mason et al.
D489,525 S 5/2004 Snow et al. D796,800 S * 9/2017 Chang ............................ D2/947
D503,267 S 3/2005 Matis et al. D796,802 S 9/2017 Kinley
Exhibit G - Page 91
US D858,962 S
Page 3
(56) References Cited FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS

U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS EP 0096542 Al 12/1983
EP 1880626 Bl 10/2011
D798,555 S 10/2017 Enayah
D799,179 S 10/2017 Comeaux
D799,180 S 10/2017 Sokol OTHER PUBLICATIONS
D799,182 S * 10/2017 Matthews D21947
D799,798 S 10/2017 Knoll The Legend of Future Past the Air Max 95 OG [online], [retrieved
D799,799 S 10/2017 Knoll Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <URL: http://news.nike.
D802,266 S 11/2017 Hardman
D803,531 S 11/2017 Petrie corn/news/the-legend-of-future-past-the-air-max-95-og>; 8 color sheets,
D805,753 S 12/2017 Enayah Dated Jul. 23, 2015.
D807,631 S 1/2018 Sullivan Closer Look at the Nike Air Max 97 in Navy and Royal [online],
D807,632 S 1/2018 Sullivan [retrieved Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Sneakernews.com [Inter-
D808,629 S 1/2018 Parrett et al.
net] <URL: https://sneakernews.corn/2017/07 /07/nike-air-max-97-
D809,769 S 2/2018 Hong
D810,407 S 2/2018 DeAlmeida navy-royal-retro-colorways-coming-soon/>; Dated Jul. 7, 2017.
D810,408 S 2/2018 Hernandez Nike Air Max 360 // Throwback Thursday [online], [retrieved Jun.
D813,506 S 3/2018 O'Connor 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <https://www.nicekicks.com/
D817,611 S 5/2018 Small nike-air-max-360-throwback-thursday/>; Dated Feb. 28, 2019.
D817,612 S 5/2018 Small
D817,628 S 5/2018 Hatfield Nike Air Max 2014 I First Look [online], [[retrieved Jun. 13, 2019],
D819,311 S * 6/2018 Jury D21947 Retrieved from Internet <URL:http://www.nikeblog.com/2013/05/
D819,323 S 6/2018 Hobson 09/nike-air-max-2014-first-look/>>; 4 color sheets, Dated May 9,
D822,349 S 7/2018 Petrenka 2013.
D822,965 S * 7/2018 DeAlmeida. D21947
Nike Air Vapormax Reveals the Pinnacle of Air [online], [retrieved
D823,581 S * 7/2018 Umehara A43B 13/16
D2/951 Jun. 13, 2019], retrieved from internet <URL: <http://news.nike.
D825,902 S * 8/2018 Tokumoto . A43B 13/20 com/news/air-max-vapor/>; 3 color sheets, Dated Feb. 20, 2017.
D2/951 The Nike Air Max 270 Is More Than Just Hot Air, GQ.com, by Tyler
D826,526 S * 8/2018 Small A43B 13/223 Watamanuk, Oct. 31, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D21957 <URL: https://www.gq.com/story/nike-air-max-270-announced> (Year:
D827,279 S 9/2018 Taylor et al.
2017).
D829,423 S 10/2018 Robusti
D835,389 S 12/2018 Durflinger Nike Air Max 270, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D838,463 S * 1/2019 Durflinger A43B 13/20 <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-mens-shoe-DNTBjl4e/
D21972 AH8050-002> (Year: 2018).
D840,135 S * 2/2019 Dombrow. D21947 Nike Air Max 270 Review, YouTube.com, Seth Fowler, Published
D841,297 S * 2/2019 Small A43B 13/12 on Feb. 5, 2018, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL:
D21947
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v~8-AkYj7cpl4> (Year: 2018).
D841,298 S * 2/2019 Small B29D 35/122
D21947 Nike Air Force 270 Utility, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D841,306 S * 2/2019 Small D21972 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-force-270-utility-mens-
D841,954 S * 3/2019 Petrenka D21953 shoe-JNM5hJ> (Year: 2018).
D843,098 S 3/2019 Natowich McPhee et al. Nike Air Max 270, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D846,840 S 4/2019 Howe
<URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-mens-shoe-6mG33D>
D846,841 S 4/2019 Howe
D846,858 S 4/2019 Bacon et al. ( Year: 2018).
D851,877 S * 6/2019 Small D21947 Nike Air Max 270 Futura, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D851,878 S * 6/2019 Pauk D21947 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-futura-mens-
D853,701 S * 7/2019 Hong D21947 shoe-KxqGHg> (Year: 2018).
D853,702 S * 7/2019 Mokos D21953 Air Jordan 3 Retro OG, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
2002/0129516 Al 9/2002 Lucas et al. 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-jordan-3- retro-og-mens-
2004/0148803 Al* 8/2004 Grove A43B 13/223
shoe-VbxR2D> (Year 2018).
36/103
PG 2 "Palmdale", Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
2005/0138846 Al 6/2005 O'Connor
2010/0122471 Al 5/2010 Edington et al. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/pg-2- palmdale-mens-basketball-
2010/0251565 Al* 10/2010 Litchfield A43B 13/12 shoe-wXw2n/A01750-300> (Year: 2018).
36/28 LeBron Soldier XI, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
2012/0131819 Al 5/2012 Loverin <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/lebron-soldier-xi-basketball-shoe-
2012/0167413 Al* 7/2012 Marvin A43B 13/20 gXTOxmg8/897644-010> (Year: 2018).
36/83 Jordan Spizike, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
2013/0118035 Al 5/2013 Segato et al. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/jordan-spizike-mens-shoe-ERTBikNW/
2013/0152428 Al* 6/2013 Bishop. A43B 13/16 315371-034> (Year: 2018).
36/103 Nike Free Hypervenom Mid with Speckled Midsole, SneakerFiles.
2014/0150298 Al 6/2014 Crowley et al. com, By Brian Betschart-Jan. 13, 2015, [online], [site visited Jun.
2014/0230276 Al* 8/2014 Campos, II B29D 35/122 13, 2019]. <URL: https://www.sneakerfiles.com/nike-free-hypervenom-
36/84 mid-speckled-midsole/> (Year: 2015).
2014/0259784 Al 9/2014 Jenkins et al.
Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 33 Review, SoleReview.com, Oct. 10,
2016/0192737 Al* 7/2016 Campos, II A43B 13/20
2016, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL: https://www.
36/28
2016/0366976 Al 12/2016 Cross solereview.corn/nike-air-zoom-pegasus-33-review/> (Year: 2016).
2016/0374428 Al 12/2016 Kormann et al. Introducing the Nike Zoom Vaporfly Elite Featuring Nike ZoomX
2017/0150778 Al 6/2017 Youngs et al. Midsole, News.Nike.com, Mar. 7, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun.
2017/0273404 Al 9/2017 Doenges et al. 13, 2019]. <URL: https://news.nike.corn/news/nike-zoom-vaporfly-
2017/0347747 Al 12/2017 Groeneweg et al. elite (Year: 2017).
Exhibit G - Page 92
US D858,962 S
Page 4
(56) References Cited
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Sneaker Talk: Let's Talk-Air Jordan 5 Retro "Sport Royal",

SneakerBarDetroit.com, Sep. 29, 2013, [online], [site visited Jun.
13, 2019] <URL: https://sneakerbardetroit.com/air-jordan-5-retro-
sport-royal/> (Year: 2013).
* cited by examiner
Exhibit G - Page 93
U.S. Patent Sep.10,2019 Sheet 1 of 4 US D858,962 S
,,,-----
/\ - "\
I \ ,
' ' \
I ---....1 \
; \ \
i \ \
; \ \
; i \
/ i \
/
/ i I
\ I
, I \
I I '
/ \ )
~-r-"- '
<..' /•
l I
'-I S
</ ,,
.c...-/ \
l I I
I I •
, I I
( ?'
ef
,/~j
'-/
, I
I
I
I I
'
-u.
C)
/' /~/ ! l
/ - 1· I I
/- '· I I
/
, ,~ I I <I
/ I""''
, 7 I I
I
"
' ~· ; 1'
I ,~· • ,
. I . I /
\' ',; I, .--?{
\ /
I
'
I
'
I '
/•
J
l
-------......
''\.., ,,
'
,I I ' f._,'I
// I
I , fI
_._:::. •
:
/
,/ ,,'\.. f/ /~~ c:~·-, ! i
1
/
,1 /
\ 1 /
/ ,
/I ; /
I Lt)
),
I·------- I / /-._-._f 11 1' I
\ ,/ / / /~ ":;--:_·:·=1 I ;'
, ~ _ _,,, /'
1
/ / • l
"~-"---
'-<~j ---- \.. -, __ 1,.-::-..,
·)~
I )I
! I ,
'-" '--1.,
.:"-'- -· ;' !-,'
"~--==- ,I
/j,.-?'
Exhibit G - Page 94
Sheet 2 of 4 US D858,962 S
U.S. Patent Sep.10,2019
/~:::::..··.:-,,
I \ '-
/ '
\
\'
< I \
I
I
. \
\
. ,
\
,
I I \
I \ ,
< I \
I \ ,
, ' (
I
/ l ' I \
/ I I
I , \
i \ \
, \ I
f, I I
/ -.... I I
I
.
\
// I
// - , I
, I
,
', 7 ' (
,/ I,,/ , ,I ',, N
,/ -.....; I I •
/ 1, I I '"
,
/ I;"
,-.... I I """
,/ -........,
I I,
I
I '
I
U..
-
/ ·,, I I
/ !, / i ._,,)
I I ' I "\
u
/ / / ( I
I ,/.k..... i /i / I
'-- ----- ,\\ iJ --_ec::--- (J!

;•//if ___ ::;Ii
\ ~, ·~ ! ii
1\ / / ( 11'
/h
/1·1' I
// i I ('1 I.:_:,> _f !!
,/ ,,/ , / ,i ,i~ s-=c:-= 11 t_J
./,,,· / I
/./ /- ( I I 1
i _,, . , \
{)-,
I I 1 I I
r;< , • .. / / / /
·\~(·i----- \,
,/.:C:..."?-._
·'"" I ._,
• ,
\~, ------\_ I / . '::--...--- I ,/j
-~ ~ 0~---- 1 ,I;'
~ 1
/j/
Exhibit G - Page 95
U.S. Patent Sep. 10,2019 Sheet 3 of 4 US D858,962 S
,,........._
,/# '
'";).
/ ,---_... \ \ '
\ \\
~
;~/
, ,,,.
{ {((
·---
------ __.-
---;·'- \ __..,,<.
I
)~ "?;.-=-\\ \\ \
;' ,\:::\
\ .\
\
\\
.\
'-rI
1
. "- I \ \ \ ).
" " I '\ \ti
-, '" ( \ \/ '\ I ,
-,, \ \ \ __:3:' . • I
\\ \ \\ j_:_:··~-1 ),
·~\ \ \\ !•I
/ \\ \ \ !\ !i
/ \ \} \
I
/ h''\\1:::.::....J,I
Y\ ! ·,;
,.-.:::...- ...... , \ ' \ ~ - · · - ·1 l'
I ·":'--/ , \ \\ .. -r'
'\ '-<'\ \\ '1\
\1\
I
,-,
\
\ /
\ ,
\
I
I J!._
1;
•
'
"\ .,.\ ·, l
'
"
,.,.. '
'" \ / \
,
,, ,/\
/\
'
I
.
\
I'
I
i
I -
(!)
LL
'~,_,,,,\ \ i
'.,/\
\ ,/ "'\
\
.l
.I
I
'- , , I
'~ I I
\ '
i
'
I
I
\ I /I
\ \
i
I
''i I
\
'
I
I I
I
\ I I
I
' '
\, ,I II
\ I ,
• I /
\, ,I I,
\ I
I
I /
\ I ,
\ ,.._...._____i. / /,
Exhibit G - Page 96
"I "
'~
I' \,
. I
I •
. I •
I .
. I
I ,
. I
I .
-
(!)
LL
. I
\, I'
I ,
'I
;f
Exhibit G - Page 97
EXHIBIT H
Exhibit H - Page 98
USOOD860606S

2,208,330 A 7/1940 Oakley

D262,159 S 12/1981 Bartneck
D280,776 S 10/1985 Gamm
(73) Assignee: NIKE, Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) D280,778 S 10/1985 Gamm
4,878,301 A 11/1989 Kiyosawa
( *) Notice: This patent is subject to a terminal dis- D310,442 S 9/1990 Hatfield
claimer. (Continued)
(**) Term: 15 Years FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
(21) Appl. No.: 29/692,926 CA 2014256 Al 10/1991

CA 2802538 Al 12/2011
(Continued)
(22) Filed: May 29, 2019
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Related U.S. Application Data Nike Air Max 93 "Blue Graphite" Available now [online], [retrieved
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/604,274, filed on corn/nike-air-max-93-blue-graphite-available-now/>>; 4 color sheets,
May 16, 2017. Dated Feb. 5, 2015.
(51) LOC (12) Cl. ............................................... 02-04 (Continued)
(52) U.S. Cl. Primary Examiner - T Chase Nelson
USPC . ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... . D2/947 (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm - Banner & Witcoff, Ltd.
(57) CLAIM
USPC ................. D21902, 906, 908, 916, 918, 925,
D2/946-962, 977; 36/3 B, 22 R, 24.5,
36/25 R, 28, 32 R, 34 R, 59 C, 67 A, 103 DESCRIPTION
CPC ....... A43B 13/00; A43B 13/02; A43B 13/023; FIG. 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing my new
A43B 13/026; A43B 13/04; A43B 13/08; design;
A43B 13/10; A43B 13/12; A43B 13/14; FIG. 2 is a side view thereof;
A43B 13/141; A43B 13/143; A43B FIG. 3 is an opposite side view thereof; and,
13/16; A43B 13/18; A43B 13/181; A43B FIG. 4 is a rear view thereof.
13/187; A43B 13/189; A43B 13/20; A43B The curved oblique shade lines represent a translucent or
transparent appearance. The broken lines depicting the
13/22; A43B 13/223; A43B 13/24; A43B
remainder of the shoe show features that form no part of the
13/28; A43B 13/30; A43B 13/32; A43B claimed design.
13/34; A43B 13/36
,c-~-/~:A~~\;,
I
\
------ _/,/ / '··-. \
/ / i
t:~: :~=~·•············~;Y
Exhibit H - Page 99
US D860,606 S
Page 2
(56) References Cited D511,886 S 11/2005 Galway

D515,305 S 2/2006 Andrews-Kramer
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS D520,726 S 5/2006 Duclos
D522,722 S 6/2006 Wilkenfeld et al.
D324,131 S 2/1992 Lucas D566,942 S 4/2008 Juan
D333,720 S 3/1993 Hatfield D626,316 S * 11/2010 Akhidime . D21946
D347,318 S 5/1994 Avar 8,327,560 B2 12/2012 Berend
D356,884 S 4/1995 Ho D686,805 S 7/2013 Day, Jr.
D377,411 S * 1/1997 Murray . D21953 D716,535 S 11/2014 Seo
D404,896 S 2/1999 Cooper D778,551 S 2/2017 Pauk
D413,013 S 8/1999 Koh D783,991 S 4/2017 Chang
D458,443 S 6/2002 Matis D789,504 S 6/2017 Won
D503,523 S 4/2005 Matis et al. D798,555 S 10/2017 Enayah
D506,597 S 6/2005 Matis et al. D799,179 S 10/2017 Comeaux
D511,617 S 11/2005 Matis D799,180 S 10/2017 Sokol
Exhibit H - Page 100
US D860,606 S
Page 3

EP 1880626 Bl 10/2011
D799,182 S * 10/2017 Matthews D21947
D799,798 S 10/2017 Knoll
D799,799 S 10/2017 Knoll OTHER PUBLICATIONS
D802,266 S 11/2017 Hardman
D803,531 S 11/2017 Petrie The Legend of Future Past the Air Max 95 OG [online], [retrieved
D805,753 S 12/2017 Enayah Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <URL: http://news.nike.
D807,631 S 1/2018 Sullivan corn/news/the-legend-of-future-past-the-air-max-95-og>; 8 color sheets,
D807,632 S 1/2018 Sullivan Dated Jul. 23, 2015.
D809,769 S 2/2018 Hong Closer Look at the Nike Air Max 97 in Navy and Royal [online],
D810,407 S 2/2018 DeAlmeida [retrieved Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Sneakernews.com [Inter-
D810,408 S 2/2018 Hernandez net] <URL: https://sneakernews.corn/2017/07 /07/nike-air-max-97-
D813,506 S 3/2018 O'Connor navy-royal-retro-colorways-coming-soon/>; Dated Jul. 7, 2017.
D817,611 S 5/2018 Small Nike Air Max 360 II Throwback Thursday [online], [retrieved Jun.
D817,612 S 5/2018 Small 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <https://www.nicekicks.com/
D817,628 S 5/2018 Hatfield
nike-air-max-360-throwback-thursday/>; Dated Feb. 28, 2019.
D819,311 S * 6/2018 Jury D21947
D819,323 S 6/2018 Hobson Nike Air Max 2014 I First Look [online], [[retrieved Jun. 13, 2019],
D822,349 S 7/2018 Petrenka Retrieved from Internet <URL:http://www.nikeblog.com/2013/05/
D822,965 S * 7/2018 DeAlmeida. D21947 09/nike-air-max-2014-first-look/>>; 4 color sheets, Dated May 9,
D823,581 S * 7/2018 Umehara A43B 13/16 2013.
D2/951 Nike Air Vapormax Reveals the Pinnacle of Air [online], [retrieved
D825,902 S * 8/2018 Tokumoto . A43B 13/20 Jun. 13, 2019], retrieved from internet <URL: <http://news.nike.
D2/951 com/news/air-max-vapor/>; 3 color sheets, Dated Feb. 20, 2017.
D826,526 S * 8/2018 Small A43B 13/223
The Nike Air Max 270 Is More Than Just Hot Air, GQ.com, by Tyler
D21957
D827,279 S 9/2018 Taylor et al. Watamanuk, Oct. 31, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D829,423 S 10/2018 Robusti <URL: https://www.gq.com/story/nike-air-max-270-announced> (Year:
D835,389 S 12/2018 Durflinger 2017).
D838,463 S * 1/2019 Durflinger A43B 13/20 Nike Air Max 270, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D21972 <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-mens-shoe-DNTBjl4e/
D840,135 S * 2/2019 Dombrow. D21947 AH8050-002> (Year: 2018).
D841,297 S * 2/2019 Small A43B 13/12
Nike Air Max 270 Review, YouTube.com, Seth Fowler, Published
D21947
D841,298 S * 2/2019 Small B29D 35/122 on Feb. 5, 2018, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL:
D21947 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v~8-AkYj7cpl4> (Year: 2018).
D841,306 S * 2/2019 Small D21972 Nike Air Force 270 Utility, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D841,954 S * 3/2019 Petrenka D21953 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-force-270-utility-mens-
D843,098 S 3/2019 Natowich McPhee et al. shoe-JNM5hJ> (Year: 2018).
D846,840 S 4/2019 Howe Nike Air Max 270, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D846,841 S 4/2019 Howe <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-mens-shoe-6mG33D>
D846,858 S 4/2019 Bacon et al.
D851,877 S * 6/2019 Small D21947
( Year: 2018).
D851,878 S * 6/2019 Pauk D21947 Nike Air Max 270 Futura, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D853,701 S * 7/2019 Hong D21947 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-futura-mens-
D853,702 S * 7/2019 Mokos D21953 shoe-KxqGHg> (Year: 2018).
2002/0129516 Al 9/2002 Lucas et al. Air Jordan 3 Retro OG, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
2004/0148803 Al * 8/2004 Grove A43B 13/223 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-jordan-3-retro-og-mens-
36/103 shoe-VbxR2D> (Year 2018).
2005/0138846 Al 6/2005 O'Connor PG 2 "Palmdale", Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
2010/0251565 Al* 10/2010 Litchfield A43B 13/12 shoe-wXw2n/ AOl 750-300> (Year: 2018).
36/28
LeBron Soldier XI, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
2012/0131819 Al 5/2012 Loverin
<URL: https://www.nike.com/t/ lebron-soldier-xi-basketball-shoe-
2012/0167413 Al* 7/2012 Marvin A43B 13/20
gXTOxmg8/897644-010> (Year: 2018).
36/83
Jordan Spizike, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
2013/0118035 Al 5/2013 Segato et al.
2013/0152428 Al* 6/2013 Bishop. A43B 13/16 <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/jordan-spizike-mens-shoe-ERTBikNW/
36/103 315371-034> (Year: 2018).
2014/0150298 Al 6/2014 Crowley et al. Nike Free Hypervenom Mid with Speckled Midsole, SneakerFiles.
2014/0230276 Al* 8/2014 Campos, II B29D 35/122 com, by Brian Betschart-Jan. 13, 2015, [online], [sit: visited Jun.
36/84 13, 2019]. <URL: https://www.sneakerfiles.com/nike-free-hypervenom-
2014/0259784 Al 9/2014 Jenkins et al. mid-speckled-midsole/> (Year: 2015).
2016/0192737 Al* 7/2016 Campos, II A43B 13/20 Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 33 Review, SoleReview.com, Oct. 10,
36/28 2016, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL: https://www.
2016/0374428 Al 12/2016 Kormann et al. Introducing the Nike Zoom Vaporfly Elite Featuing Nike ZoomX
US D860,606 S
Page 4
OTHER PUBLICATIONS

sport-royal/> (Year 2013).
* cited by examiner

-------......_
I
/\ \ \,
I
, '
---1 \ \
; \ \
i \ \
'
I \I
\ I
I \ \
; i \
I
i \' \I
I, I, \,
/ \ )
,""-,/-.'\
</ '
I, ,1.
,c.,/ \ I I
•
-u.
(/' \ I l
/ , I I C)
?' /~j I <
(
,:/
· ' /
, I
I
I I
J' ' I I
,/ /~/
·, I '
,· j
I
/ ,~
I..._,,_'
/ / <I
'/ I ...
I ·, ! I /
I I I I
{ /~/ I ,
\, ·-..../
, I '
-~ /
\ • I I, _,- :--:;,
. :, )
------, " ···l
'" i ,/ >:f
/'" I/ ~: ·-t !
,{
// '";\ /
,./ ·.-.
>Jl
}
I'..._ _____ I / :/ /
\, __ .,,,--/ r'.// 'c:_-:_':=.===:c Ji
~-"--·-
,,._ \ - - - .. _
\. "
::":J/
::{ I
-~j '-----'\ '-,':_':_-==.:·

~, /g/ .·., /

c..-::::..:-.....,
I \ \.
I
I
, \
\ '
I \ \
J ' '\
I \ ,
I O \
I \ ,
I
'
\
. \
,
'
I' \ (
,
' . \
/ I ·,
I , .
I \ \
, \ I
f, I '
/ ) , I
, ''/ I \
/,'/ !_ ' II I
, '/ 7 ' (
/ ,,j I '), N
,/
, I ,
-.....; I
,
I .
'
/
/
/
/'"
',,j
I
1'
i
I
'
I
'
I
i
'
-
(!)
LL
,/ /'/ I I
/ -'!, I /)
/ ; ! 11
/
I
/
,,,,,....... I I
, /
1
ti
1 ·..·.1
l
-- _,,,,,- -,
\ i/ c.~'=_:c'j '} l
\, I // I: ··.i., i,
/\>- / \·]
I ,, / I !1
I // / 1
.i i
,
/:>/
//,.
/
/
\
' I
""·· · II icf,;- l .··:~,,
I
l;f:~ \ / :J ,i
\•{(
;:,.·,,,._ ------ \ I
I· :·7':::i1
-~-~
--:~ '\., ----'\..--, ~'-·=- !I .'!··>J'
'\~ ·-. ,~---lJ I
/ .:?,/'

'\,::)\',
, # /'"i)..
I / /./::...---
1::.)\\ ,· \
/#_' , / __ ,___ , :;.-;;---:=- \·:.·.\ '·
'o.,,,,,... --.,-- I
{ 1(( ----- , , . .\ I
f:_'"- / \ ::. '1
\ ,,, / \.<)I
',, '"
'<\ · \
\
\ ' \
~-c...._ .
/.-·:::::·
\ ,',i
·1·
I
.-.'_t
::_·J
I
\, ' '·?,
'\\, \\ !I.::.. ·1· I'
I · ·.-., I
I \ .. ·\r
/ t\ >- i) !
·""'--
I -, -,_ / / \
I
\
'
/::c:3 ·.-_l
.• L
I
' ----- _-:;, \ \ . :.:f
\ \ \ \ :/ l
\
' /\ ,
\
, ,
2:
·.-:I .
•
\, \/\
\
'\
'" \ / \
,
/\
'
\
I
\
I
1
I
'
I
-
(!)
u..
'" ,/\ \\ i
'\/\ ' i
'-,/\ \ I
\ ~ I I
,/. \ I I
"- '
-~\ '1
j
I
'
I
·1
' ' I
\\ !
I I
I < I
\
I
I I
I
I
\
I
I
I /
I
\
I
I I /
I
\ I ,
\ I /
\ I ,
I I /
\ I I
I I /
\ I ,
\ ,.-.... __
..........._ __,,,
~
; / /

'.'\\
. :j \
·) I
.. I
.:! l •
.-:! i
. ·I
.·'
.· I
I
I
I
-
(!)
LL
·, I
• ·\ I
>I I
.>.\.. I I
(.);j'

EXHIBIT I
Exhibit I - Page 107

USOOD860607S

2,208,330 A 7/1940 Oakley

D262,159 S 12/1981 Bartneck
D280,776 S 10/1985 Gamm
4,878,301 A 11/1989 Kiyosawa
(21) Appl. No.: 29/692,927 CA 2014256 Al 10/1991

CA 2802538 Al 12/2011
(Continued)
(22) Filed: May 29, 2019
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/604,274, filed on com/nike-air-max-93-blue-graphite-available-now/>>; 4 color sheets,
May 16, 2017. Dated Feb. 5, 2015.
(51) LOC (12) Cl. ............................................... 02-04 (Continued)
(57) CLAIM
USPC ................. D21902, 906, 908, 916, 918, 925,
D2/946-962, 977; 36/3 B, 22 R, 24.5,
A43B 13/026; A43B 13/04; A43B 13/08; design; and,
A43B 13/10; A43B 13/12; A43B 13/14; FIG. 2 is a side view thereof.
A43B 13/141; A43B 13/143; A43B The broken lines immediately adjacent to the shaded area
13/16; A43B 13/18; A43B 13/181; A43B define the bounds of the claimed design and form no part
13/187; A43B 13/189; A43B 13/20; A43B thereof. The curved oblique shade lines represent a translu-
cent or transparent appearance. The broken lines depicting
13/22; A43B 13/223; A43B 13/24; A43B
the remainder of the shoe show features that form no part of
13/28; A43B 13/30; A43B 13/32; A43B the claimed design.
13/34; A43B 13/36
'-
1\
ii
---/
/
_, .....,, ___________ ..,,,-... ~---

US D860,607 S
Page 2

D324,131 S 2/1992 Lucas D566,942 S 4/2008 Juan
D347,318 S 5/1994 Avar 8,327,560 B2 12/2012 Berend
D356,884 S 4/1995 Ho D686,805 S 7/2013 Day, Jr.
D377,411 S * 1/1997 Murray . D21953 D716,535 S 11/2014 Seo
D404,896 S 2/1999 Cooper D778,551 S 2/2017 Pauk
D413,013 S 8/1999 Koh D783,991 S 4/2017 Chang
D458,443 S 6/2002 Matis D789,504 S 6/2017 Won
D511,617 S 11/2005 Matis D799,180 S 10/2017 Sokol
US D860,607 S
Page 3

EP 1880626 Bl 10/2011
D799,182 S * 10/2017 Matthews D21947
D799,798 S 10/2017 Knoll
D802,266 S 11/2017 Hardman
D817,628 S 5/2018 Hatfield
D819,311 S * 6/2018 Jury D21947
D822,965 S * 7/2018 DeAlmeida. D21947 09/nike-air-max-2014-first-look/>>; 4 color sheets, Dated May 9,
D823,581 S * 7/2018 Umehara A43B 13/16 2013.
D826,526 S * 8/2018 Small A43B 13/223
The Nike Air Max 270 Is More Than Just Hot Air, GQ.com, by Tyler
D21957
D827,279 S 9/2018 Taylor et al. Watamanuk, Oct. 31, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D829,423 S 10/2018 Robusti <URL: https://www.gq.com/story/nike-air-max-270-announced> (Year:
D835,389 S 12/2018 Durflinger 2017).
D841,297 S * 2/2019 Small A43B 13/12
D21947
D841,298 S * 2/2019 Small B29D 35/122 on Feb. 5, 2018, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL:
D21947 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v~8-AkYj7cpl4> (Year: 2018).
D846,858 S 4/2019 Bacon et al.
D851,877 S * 6/2019 Small D21947
( Year: 2018).
2004/0148803 Al * 8/2004 Grove A43B 13/223 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-jordan-3-retro-og-mens-
36/103 shoe-VbxR2D> (Year 2018).
2010/0122471 Al 5/2010 Edington et al. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/pg-2-pahndale-mens-basketball-shoe-
2010/0251565 Al* 10/2010 Litchfield A43B 13/12 w X w2n/AOl750-300> (Year: 2018).
36/28
2012/0131819 Al 5/2012 Loverin
2012/0167413 Al* 7/2012 Marvin A43B 13/20
gXTOxmg8/897644-010> (Year: 2018).
36/83
2013/0118035 Al 5/2013 Segato et al.
2013/0152428 Al* 6/2013 Bishop. A43B 13/16 <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/jordan-spizike-mens-shoe-ERTBlkNW/
36/103 315371-034> (Year: 2018).
2014/0230276 Al* 8/2014 Campos, II B29D 35/122 com, by Brian Betschart-Jan. 13, 2015, [online], [site visited Jun.
US D860,607 S
Page 4
OTHER PUBLICATIONS

* cited by examiner

US D860,607 S
Sheet 1 of 2
Sep.24,2019
U.S. Patent
,,,.-----
/(
, '"' '
\
I' \ \
,
l ' \,
I I
.....\ \
\ \
I
t
\ I
\ \
I \ I
\ \
I
I
\ I
\ I
I \ \
I , ,
I I \
, \
.
I' \, \,
I I
, \ \
,
/ \ )
~
,<::.., / " " ' , \ ,\
t..' /.. ' . •
-
> '\. \ \
{ .<:..-./
, \\ ,\ ,\ (!)
t.?'
,,.
/'-/....!
I
i i u.
ef I I
/
/ /.,._ /
, ;"
!
I
\I
/, ,.. I I
, .~ I I (I
I ""' , "I
f/ , 7 I I
, -/ / ,·
I '~../ I
·, I·-1 I I
\ , I ' I
1' / /
! :·:;· 1'
I
,'J'
______ ,___ , ,·, / I ·:_·l,.,,
' '
I I 'lI I' :··.:/.-~'
, I I
,/ / ',-, f I I , ~=· 1 ·· 1" I

,/ i ,, o- I-:.·'L. ,·
I I I
,{ ~\ / // // 1-:..J1
t\ \·------~~ /' I
1 /, // 1' ;'C::--::: ~:3-· i'
.., I
·., I
' .,/ I/ I I ·> ' :11

tr-.:_,___ \ / I I.:·_:)I
'\::.~~ '\ ____ . . _ I ;':::--::; 1 .-:1' I
' '-...)'
,, ------~- ' II.··, /
- '!,I <~=
'i·''
-·
I :.:!-1·
_,,i_,.,..., ;:~

---
G--,........ ,
I \ "
I , \
I \ \
I \ \
I I \
I \ ,
I I \
I \ ,
I I \
I
I \ I /
I
I
\ I
, \
I \ ,
I \
\ I
/
I \
/
I I
/-- i \
/,) i \
/'/ I , \
/l' ,....,, I
'
I
V I I (
' / I ,,/
' I
/ I
N
,/ -....; I I •
,
/
/
,/
/
,,
----.,
I
;''
;'
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
-u.
C)
I
/ /'-1'
' i, i I'
/' 'I I
i :-:n <
f /!
., 1' I.,fl. .::l.· ·r1
l___ /- '\ 1' ' / I _:::_. :<
\ ,/ji~-·.r1
\ [I I I .·., i
, 1 1!_
/\~ ,/ Ir . .·1
1 ··· .
/ ,. / // /·:()·
I' II ii ·.:! I
i i ~ -~
I I /
/ // / 1 · . \..)
,/;.,./ / ( I ,:o-.;: 1 · .::I

/--- ,/- ' / / ·.·/,'1
I ,/ \ / / / ·.' I
l.:;:::: \ I ' I / •
\~{/--- / / ._., '

\~~
\
- - - - - __:, / /~ ' /1 _:-..;J·,

'""~'
~
\ , ,,
-~
'-
•,__
~-1::C- .. I
,
.·~
··1·
I
I
,.?,'

EXHIBIT J
Exhibit J - Page 114

USOOD860608S

2,208,330 A 7/1940 Oakley

Eidem, Portland, OR (US) D261,446 S 10/1981 Schrnohl
D262,159 S 12/1981 Bartneck
D280,776 S 10/1985 Ganun
(73) Assignee: NIKE, Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) D280,778 S 10/1985 Ganun
(Continued)
claimer. FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
(**) Term: 15 Years CA 2014256 Al 10/1991

CA 2802538 Al 12/2011
(21) Appl. No.: 29/692,928 (Continued)
(22) Filed: May 29, 2019 OTHER PUBLICATIONS

Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved frorn Internet <URL: <http://sneakerbardetroit.
Related U.S. Application Data corn/nike-air-rnax-93-blue-graphite-available-now/»; 4 color sheets,
Dated Feb. 5, 2015.
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/604,274, filed on
(Continued)
May 16, 2017.
(51) LOC (12) Cl. ............................................... 02-04 Primary Examiner - T Chase Nelson
(52) U.S. Cl. (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm - Banner & Witcoff, Ltd.
USPC . ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... . D2/947 (57) CLAIM
( 58) Field of Classification Search The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described.
USPC ................. D21902, 906, 908, 916, 918, 925, DESCRIPTION
D2/946-962, 977; 36/3 B, 22 R, 24.5,
36/25 R, 28, 32 R, 34 R, 59 C, 67 A, 103 FIG. 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing my new
design;
CPC ....... A43B 13/00; A43B 13/02; A43B 13/023;
FIG. 2 is a side view thereof;
13/22; A43B 13/223; A43B 13/24; A43B cent or transparent appearance. The broken lines depicting
13/28; A43B 13/30; A43B 13/32; A43B
the claimed design.
13/34; A43B 13/36

US D860,608 S
Page 2

D511,617 S 11/2005 Matis
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS D511,886 S 11/2005 Galway
5,060,401 A 10/1991 Whatley D559,509 S 1/2008 Hayes et al.
D324,131 S 2/1992 Lucas D566,942 S 4/2008 Juan
D347,318 S 5/1994 Avar 8,327,560 B2 12/2012 Berend
D356,884 S 4/1995 Ho D686,805 S 7/2013 Day, Jr.
D377,411 S * 1/1997 Murray .......................... D2/953 D716,535 S 11/2014 Seo
D404,896 S 2/1999 Cooper D778,551 S 2/2017 Pauk
D413,013 S 8/1999 Koh D783,991 S 4/2017 Chang
D458,443 S 6/2002 Matis D789,504 S 6/2017 Won
US D860,608 S
Page 3

EP 1880626 Bl 10/2011
D799,179 S 10/2017 Comeaux
D799,180 S 10/2017 Sokol
D799,182 S * 10/2017 Matthews D21947 OTHER PUBLICATIONS
D799,798 S 10/2017 Knoll
D802,266 S 11/2017 Hardman Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <URL: http://news.nike.
D803,531 S 11/2017 Petrie
D805,753 S 12/2017 Enayah corn/news/the-legend-of-future-past-the-air-max-95-og>; 8 color sheets,
D807,632 S 1/2018 Sullivan Closer Look At the Nike Air Max 97 in Navy and Royal [online],
D808,629 S 1/2018 Parrett et al. [retrieved Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Sneakernews.com [Inter-
D809,769 S 2/2018 Hong
D810,407 S 2/2018 DeAlmeida
D810,408 S 2/2018 Hernandez navy-royal-retro-colorways-coming-soon/>; Dated Jul. 7, 2017.
D813,506 S 3/2018 O'Connor Nike Air Max 360 // Throwback Thursday [online], [retrieved Jun.
D817,628 S 5/2018 Hatfield
D819,311 S * 6/2018 Jury D21947 Nike Air Max 2014 I First Look [online], [[retrieved Jun. 13, 2019],
D819,323 S 6/2018 Hobson Retrieved from Internet <URL:http://www.nikeblog.com/2013/05/
D822,349 S 7/2018 Petrenka 09/nike-air-max-2014-first-look/»; 4 color sheets, Dated May 9,
D822,965 S * 7/2018 DeAlmeida. D21947 2013.
D823,581 S * 7/2018 Umehara A43B 13/16 Nike Air Vapormax Reveals the Pinnacle of Air [online], [retrieved
D2/951
Jun. 13, 2019], retrieved from internet <URL: <http://news.nike.
D825,902 S * 8/2018 Tokumoto . A43B 13/20
D826,526 S * 8/2018 Small A43B 13/223 The Nike Air Max 270 Is More Than Just Hot Air, GQ.com, By
D21957 Tyler Watamanuk, Oct. 31, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D827,279 S 9/2018 Taylor et al. 2019]. <URL: https://www.gq.com/ story/nike-air-max-270-
D829,423 S 10/2018 Robusti announced> (Year: 2017).
D838,463 S * 1/2019 Durflinger A43B 13/20
<URL: https://www.nike.com/air-max-270-mens-shoe-DNTBjI4e/
D21972
D840,135 S * 2/2019 Dombrow. D21947
AH8050-002> (Year: 2018).
D841,297 S * 2/2019 Small A43B 13/12 Nike Air Max 270 Review, YouTube.com, Seth Fowler, Published
D21947 on Feb. 5, 2018, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL:
D841,298 S * 2/2019 Small B29D 35/122 http://www.youtube.com/watch7F8-AkYj7cpl4> (Year: 2018).
D841,954 S * 3/2019 Petrenka D21953
shoe-JNM5hJ> (Year: 2018).
D843,098 S 3/2019 Natowich McPhee et al.
Nike Air Max 270, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D846,840 S 4/2019 Howe
D846,858 S 4/2019 Bacon et al. (Year: 2018).
2002/0129516 Al 9/2002 Lucas et al. 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-jordan-3-retro-og-mens-
2004/0148803 Al* 8/2004 Grove A43B 13/223
shoe-VbxR2D> (Year: 2018).
36/103
2005/0138846 Al 6/2005 O'Connor
2010/0122471 Al 5/2010 Edington et al. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/pg-2-pahndale-mens-basketball-shoe-
2010/0251565 Al* 10/2010 Litchfield A43B 13/12 wXw2n/A01750-300> (Year: 2018).
2012/0131819 Al 5/2012 Loverin <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/ lebron-soldier-xi-basketball-shoe-
2013/0152428 Al* 6/2013 Bishop. A43B 13/16 315371-034> (Year: 2018).
2014/0150298 Al 6/2014 Crowley et al. com, by Brian Betschart-Jan. 13, 2015, [online], [site visited Jun.
2014/0259784 Al 9/2014 Jenkins et al.
2016/0192737 Al* 7/2016 Campos, II A43B 13/20
36/28
US D860,608 S
Page 4
OTHER PUBLICATIONS

* cited by examiner

-----"
/\ \
.
I
I \
'
----..,
,
\
\
i \ \
i \ \
i \ \
i \ \
I \ \
I
/ i, \,
I I, \,
/ \ )
A,/'" I ' \
</ ' y
' ' ' - ••
•
(. ,"
,c.-/ \
\ .I
.
I •
r./
(,?'
/
,/~j
'/
,
,
.
I
l.
I
I'
'
-
(!)
LJ..
, /' "~ ;'
I-...... I• I'
/;
/ , ,...
/ /
J
I
'
/
, ,~ I I (I
I-......., , "
, , 7 I 1
I '-... I I
· I I '
I
I I
'~../ I I I!
\ -----1
, , I "'1J'
\
______ ,_/___
'
~ ;'
I' ,7/I
/.
' 'I I -:.)•
..~:t /
/ ·O"r'
1'
/ , /''-
', ;' /
/ I/,/"' ::..~:::/'
·- : ,I
.·-:f·,
' .' J
/ \ /> iI '
/ ::~:)
,!
/ ./ 1
/ ; ' 1' I:)·
l ·---------_/ I _/, /
/ i"'' ~::--~ I >.f ;I
~ -__::- r' I / I :tJ
,:~j ---"-, ___ L
,,\ " ---
' "
, ,
f-"'';
:._,, ___
I ·. 1
1 / ·
I·., 1
-..,.,. ., ,'-':..-:::=].?!'

c:.-:=..:--.....,
I \ '\
I , \
. \' '
\
.I I \
'
\
•
\
,
• t \
I \ ,
I
' .\ \
,
' . (
I \ ·,
/ I •
I . \
/
' \I i.
)-. i \
/--.....} i \
/ ( ! ' \
// 'i
/ ,-...../
. I , .
I
; ·,
/
. N
.
·/ ---..; I I
/
,/
•/
/
I ''-/~
·" I
1
,I
.I
'
I,
I
I,
-
(!)
LL
·-..... · I I
;' ( ,I / /
I ~ I ,,
/
l ,/
.L . /1' /
fl
·
,{I ) l
: Jl
,_,/ \ / / I I
\ \
,··ti
/ I I
.() I 1
\ • // .J I
;\ // i ( '\
J
I ,,
( JI
I )..
•
/ iI I
·/1
I. / .·I I
I ' •
I '' ,
I
.//// / ii ?:_-c?C:C:· .-t)
_.,.,/- / I ' . ~-::: 1
l-,i:r1------- '\ ;/;/ <~·:

I
I
/__.-'
,\(~
,/'
/
----
,
\
\
I I
<
;' ;·~'\
1
.·_.;,·1
I
ii
·::1
\:~ ......., _'-_,_ /}
•x ~
"~ :_: I '
·;·
,?,'

'\"'\',
, /'";}., - ,~--?\
·. \
/ ,, ,
,,(?/
#/
----
_,--·-
I \ \;/,
/~-----
;;;-_;---_--:::- . :'
\ ·:\ ,
\
!JK------
(',, I
/ \\ \ \
\·:\~,}
>1
•
' " I • , \ .f \
' , '"
-,, , \
,
(
\
\ r:
\ \
' > ·;.>;:__
·. . I
\ .'•i
! . ·\1
I
\
'\ \ \ \ /---~::- I . )
\\ \ \\ \-:-: · 1
\, \ \ I ! ::_-i I
I , .\ \ ·..• I
\ \ '"- )1·
I . .\ 'A
I \, \ \ ! ·.-y I
<\ '\ < ---· i : :'
,.-.::::..-,,. I \ ,\ , \ ~-~-- . .-! '1
- I • \'
~ "<::::;:, \ ·:L
\I\ :. . j
\ \ \ '\\ _:) l
\ \, \,,\,,\ \'\ .J!l M
•
" \.
" '
,,,
,"
'
,,,
· , \,......\
I
\
I
I
>
I' -
\J
'"
LL
~ .A \\ i
',\,,.\ ' i
"-./\ \ >
I
\
,/\ I
\ '
"- '
·~
'1 I >
\ '
i
I
I I
\ I //
\ I
j
O
·~ I
\ I
I l
I
I
\ I I
I I / '
\ I I
I I /
\ I I
' I I
\ t
I I /
I
\ I ,
• I I
\ I ,
\ , ____ ,,; / /
............. ~ '

-u.

EXHIBIT K
Exhibit K - Page 123

USOOD86061 OS

2,208,330 A 7/1940 Oakley

D262,159 S 12/1981 Bartneck
D280,776 S 10/1985 Gamm
4,878,301 A 11/1989 Kiyosawa
(21) Appl. No.: 29/692,935 CA 2014256 Al 10/1991

CA 2802538 Al 12/2011
(Continued)
(22) Filed: May 29, 2019
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/604,274, filed on corn/nike-air-max-93-blue-graphite-available-now/<<; 4 color sheets,
May 16, 2017. Dated Feb. 5, 2015.
(51) LOC (12) Cl. ............................................... 02-04 (Continued)
(57) CLAIM
USPC ................. D21902, 906, 908, 916, 918, 925,
D2/946-962, 977; 36/3 B, 22 R, 24.5,
A43B 13/026; A43B 13/04; A43B 13/08; design; and,
A43B 13/10; A43B 13/12; A43B 13/14; FIG. 2 is a side view thereof.
cent or transparent appearance. The broken lines depicting
13/22; A43B 13/223; A43B 13/24; A43B
13/28; A43B 13/30; A43B 13/32; A43B the claimed design.
13/34; A43B 13/36
' i"\
ii
_/-;
/

US D860,610 S
Page 2

D324,131 S 2/1992 Lucas D566,942 S 4/2008 Juan
D347,318 S 5/1994 Avar 8,327,560 B2 12/2012 Berend
D356,884 S 4/1995 Ho D686,805 S 7/2013 Day, Jr.
D377,411 S * 1/1997 Murray . D21953 D716,535 S 11/2014 Seo
D404,896 S 2/1999 Cooper D778,551 S 2/2017 Pauk
D413,013 S 8/1999 Koh D783,991 S 4/2017 Chang
D458,443 S 6/2002 Matis D789,504 S 6/2017 Won
D511,617 S 11/2005 Matis D799,180 S 10/2017 Sokol
US D860,610 S
Page 3

EP 1880626 Bl 10/2011
D799,182 S * 10/2017 Matthews D21947
D799,798 S 10/2017 Knoll
D802,266 S 11/2017 Hardman
D817,628 S 5/2018 Hatfield
D819,311 S * 6/2018 Jury D21947
D822,965 S * 7/2018 DeAlmeida. D21947 09/nike-air-max-2014-first-look/<<; 4 color sheets, Dated May 9,
D823,581 S * 7/2018 Umehara A43B 13/16 2013.
D826,526 S * 8/2018 Small A43B 13/223
The Nike Air Max 270 Is More Than Just Hot Air, GQ.com, By
D21957
D827,279 S 9/2018 Taylor et al. Tyler Watamanuk, Oct. 31, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D829,423 S 10/2018 Robusti 2019]. <URL: https://www.gq.com/story/nike-air-max-270-
D835,389 S 12/2018 Durflinger announced> (Year: 2017).
D841,297 S * 2/2019 Small A43B 13/12
D21947
D841,298 S * 2/2019 Small B29D 35/122 on Feb. 5, 2018, [online], [sitevisitedJun.13, 2019]. <URL: https://
D21947 www.youtube.com/watch?v~8-Akyj7cpl 4> (Year: 2018).
D846,858 S 4/2019 Bacon et al.
D851,877 S * 6/2019 Small D21947
(Year: 2018).
2004/0148803 Al * 8/2004 Grove A43B 13/223 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-jordan-3- retro-og-mens-
36/103 shoe-VbxR2D> (Year: 2018).
2010/0251565 Al* 10/2010 Litchfield A43B 13/12 shoe-wXw2n/ AOl 750-300> (Year: 2018).
36/28
2012/0131819 Al 5/2012 Loverin
2012/0167413 Al* 7/2012 Marvin A43B 13/20
gXTOxmg8/897644-010> (Year: 2018).
36/83
2013/0118035 Al 5/2013 Segato et al.
2013/0152428 Al* 6/2013 Bishop. A43B 13/16 <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/jordan-spizike-mens-shoe-ERTBikNW/
36/103 315371-034> (Year: 2018).
2014/0230276 Al* 8/2014 Campos, II B29D 35/122 com, By Brian Betschart-Jan. 13, 2015, [online], [site visited Jun.
2016/0374428 Al 12/2016 Kormann et al. Introducing the Nike Zoom Vaportly Elite Featuring Nike ZoomX
US D860,610 S
Page 4
OTHER PUBLICATIONS

sport-royal/> (Year: 2013).
* cited by examiner

.,,......---
/\
, "\
.
I
I \
'
-- ....... ,
,
\
\
i \ \
; \ \
i \ \
i \ \
/J
I \
C
\
t
, I \
/ I I
/
I I
I f
/ \ )
r-,
,<::.,
(/.. '
I
'
~.J
.I ~
,e..-/ \ I
('/ ' ) i i (!)
(J' /~/ j i -LL
r.;/ '--./ ' '
,I' /~ / / !
/, / -'--v/ I
/ I J
/
, ,~ I I (I
I """- ,
/
, , l I, "
I
....... ' '
'I 1 I I
' I .~~ y/ / I
\ '-...../ I
\, I I
/ -·-?
1·1 • 1'
I ,' L"
.I I , I..,_. I -~·'/
-I! , J'I
------....... I //
',
/ ,,,
,/ '·, {/' lt~ : --- !· ! i 1
/ ', / 1 / // L.,)
I.,1 ______ ,,,,/>- , / /:.,, I I'I 'J.I
\' ,/' _,,,,/ / -~ ~::-:~-,,J L! ,·
,-~ I - --- '"
/ /' , I
~-===-..:-.
. '"
1
1 }j
- / ·-/~':
/_":. / ,•
\. '
,f' I, / 1
' ,_..,,
-,, -- '-....c.--- 1/ !-1,
?::--':::.--==- I·
,, 1'
I
£,.,.

c-::..:,,
I \ \
' I \
I \ I
I . \
I
\ I
' \
I \ ,
I > \
I \ ,
' ' \
I
I \ I /
I
I \ ,
I I \
/ I .
i ' \
/
' \I i,
j, i \
/......_) ,· \
~,, / /. . ,f I' \,
,/ i I (1
/' I '/ ''-/ /

I
1'
A.I
, ....
, -.....; I I •
/ ;' I I ,n
/ ,, I I '-'
, I;" , , -
,/ ·--....
I I
I I I
U.
/ I
',,
., I {
;' ( ,t 1' '

/ _.,.,, .....,,,,
I i . I! I'\
.
l
I
--......
_.,.,. -- ,\
1· 1i1
' '1
,·,uI
-- '\ , i // //// ~-~-ii
•
---- ,· i (1 I
\, ,/ I·~
i.
,'II
1I , ,
1\
1 ), /
/ i ,'
1 / l·,· 1 l
I ,. , t I ,· rJ
' // / ' J 1! i '
,,-//
/;.,/,/ {
/ !~
//
,,,, i: t./
Ii (:,,
I ,/ \ I I I,'
;J
I
~f."-- \ ;! ! }
\{(
\:,~
------
--- ·,
/ '
/
/~
,,.I //
; I
'\~'~
~~
_,_ I
,,__--:=:,} / /
~--- , 1
i~-t/

EXHIBIT L
Exhibit L - Page 130

USOOD860611S

2,208,330 A 7/1940 Oakley

Eidem, Portland, OR (US) D261,446 S 10/1981 Schrnohl
D262,159 S 12/1981 Bartneck
D280,776 S 10/1985 Ganun
(73) Assignee: NIKE, Inc., Beaverton, OR (US) D280,778 S 10/1985 Ganun
(Continued)
claimer. FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
(**) Term: 15 Years CA 2014256 Al 10/1991

CA 2802538 Al 12/2011
(21) Appl. No.: 29/692,939 (Continued)
(22) Filed: May 29, 2019 OTHER PUBLICATIONS

Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved frorn Internet <URL: <http://sneakerbardetroit.
Related U.S. Application Data corn/nike-air-rnax-93-blue-graphite-available-now/>>; 4 color sheets,
Dated Feb. 5, 2015.
(63) Continuation of application No. 29/604,274, filed on
(Continued)
May 16, 2017.
(51) LOC (12) Cl. ............................................... 02-04 Primary Examiner - T Chase Nelson
(52) U.S. Cl. (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm - Banner & Witcoff, Ltd.
USPC . ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... . D2/947 (57) CLAIM
( 58) Field of Classification Search The ornamental design for a shoe, as shown and described.
USPC ................. D21902, 906, 908, 916, 918, 925, DESCRIPTION
D2/946-962, 977; 36/3 B, 22 R, 24.5,
36/25 R, 28, 32 R, 34 R, 59 C, 67 A, 103 FIG. 1 is a front perspective view of a shoe showing my new
design;
CPC ....... A43B 13/00; A43B 13/02; A43B 13/023;
FIG. 2 is a side view thereof;
13/22; A43B 13/223; A43B 13/24; A43B cent or transparent appearance. The broken lines depicting
13/28; A43B 13/30; A43B 13/32; A43B
the claimed design.
13/34; A43B 13/36

US D860,611 S
Page 2

D511,617 S 11/2005 Matis
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS D511,886 S 11/2005 Galway
D324,131 S 2/1992 Lucas D566,942 S 4/2008 Juan
D347,318 S 5/1994 Avar 8,327,560 B2 12/2012 Berend
D356,884 S 4/1995 Ho D686,805 S 7/2013 Day, Jr.
D377,411 S * 1/1997 Murray .......................... D2/953 D716,535 S 11/2014 Seo
D404,896 S 2/1999 Cooper D778,551 S 2/2017 Pauk
D413,013 S 8/1999 Koh D783,991 S 4/2017 Chang
D458,443 S 6/2002 Matis D789,504 S 6/2017 Won
US D860,611 S
Page 3

EP 1880626 Bl 10/2011
D799,179 S 10/2017 Comeaux
D799,180 S 10/2017 Sokol
D799,182 S * 10/2017 Matthews D21947 OTHER PUBLICATIONS
D799,798 S 10/2017 Knoll
D802,266 S 11/2017 Hardman Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Internet <URL: http://news.nike.
D803,531 S 11/2017 Petrie
D805,753 S 12/2017 Enayah corn/news/the-legend-of-future-past-the-air-max-95-og>; 8 color sheets,
D807,632 S 1/2018 Sullivan Closer Look at the Nike Air Max 97 in Navy and Royal [online],
D808,629 S 1/2018 Parrett et al. [retrieved Jun. 13, 2019], Retrieved from Sneakernews.com [Inter-
D809,769 S 2/2018 Hong
D810,407 S 2/2018 DeAlmeida
D810,408 S 2/2018 Hernandez navy-royal-retro-colorways-coming-soon/>; Dated Jul. 7, 2017.
D813,506 S 3/2018 O'Connor Nike Air Max 360 // Throwback Thursday [online], [retrieved Jun.
D817,628 S 5/2018 Hatfield
D819,311 S * 6/2018 Jury D21947 Nike Air Max 2014 I First Look [online], [[retrieved Jun. 13, 2019],
D819,323 S 6/2018 Hobson Retrieved from Internet <URL:http://www.nikeblog.com/2013/05/
D822,349 S 7/2018 Petrenka 09/nike-air-max-2014-first-look/>>; 4 color sheets, Dated May 9,
D822,965 S * 7/2018 DeAlmeida. D21947 2013.
D823,581 S * 7/2018 Umehara A43B 13/16 Nike Air Vapormax Reveals the Pinnacle of Air [online], [retrieved
D2/951
Jun. 13, 2019], retrieved from internet <URL: <http://news.nike.
D825,902 S * 8/2018 Tokumoto . A43B 13/20
D826,526 S * 8/2018 Small A43B 13/223 The Nike Air Max 270 Is More Than Just Hot Air, GQ.com, By
D21957 Tyler Watamanuk, Oct. 31, 2017, [online], [site visited Jun. 13,
D827,279 S 9/2018 Taylor et al. 2019]. <URL: https://www.gq.com/ story/nike-air-max-270-
D829,423 S 10/2018 Robusti announced> (Year: 2017).
D838,463 S * 1/2019 Durflinger A43B 13/20
<URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-max-270-mens-shoe-DNTBjl4e/
D21972
D840,135 S * 2/2019 Dombrow. D21947
AH8050-002> (Year: 2018).
D841,297 S * 2/2019 Small A43B 13/12 Nike Air Max 270 Review, YouTube.com, Seth Fowler, Published
D21947 on Feb. 5, 2018, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019]. <URL:
D841,298 S * 2/2019 Small B29D 35/122 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v~8-AkYj7cpl4> (Year: 2018).
D841,954 S * 3/2019 Petrenka D21953
shoe-JNM5hJ> (Year: 2018).
D843,098 S 3/2019 Natowich McPhee et al.
Nike Air Max 270, Nike.com, [online], [site visited Jun. 13, 2019].
D846,840 S 4/2019 Howe
D846,858 S 4/2019 Bacon et al. (Year: 2018).
2002/0129516 Al 9/2002 Lucas et al. 2019]. <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/air-jordan-3- retro-pg-mens-
2004/0148803 Al* 8/2004 Grove A43B 13/223
shoe-VbxR2D> (Year: 2018).
36/103
2005/0138846 Al 6/2005 O'Connor
2010/0251565 Al* 10/2010 Litchfield A43B 13/12 shoe-wXw2n/ A01750-300>(Year: 2018).
2012/0131819 Al 5/2012 Loverin <URL: https://www.nike.com/t/ lebron-soldier-xi-basketball-shoe-
2013/0152428 Al* 6/2013 Bishop. A43B 13/16 315371-034> (Year: 2018).
2014/0150298 Al 6/2014 Crowley et al. com, By Brian Betschart-Jan. 13, 2015, [online], [site visited Jun.
2014/0259784 Al 9/2014 Jenkins et al.
2016/0192737 Al* 7/2016 Campos, II A43B 13/20
36/28
US D860,611 S
Page 4
OTHER PUBLICATIONS

* cited by examiner

.,.----
/\
, "\
I \ ,
I ' \
I ----.1 \
i \ \
I \ \
i \ \
I
I \ I
\ I
I
I \ \
/ I I
I I \
. \
,
\ \
I ' I
/ \ )
~./"'', I ,1
<' /.,, . l ..
,C..•/· \' I I
•
(/ ) i i
f'
(
qi'
?' I
/-::,,,.j
'/
'
, I'
I
'
I'
'
I
-
(!)
LL
/
, /~I
, ;"
1' ,
I
/, '~ I I
/
, ,~ I
I ~, I
I (I'f
I
I ,
....... I
7 ,
I I
I ! I '
! /~/ ; !
\ -,; I
\, I ;'
/ --·--j
1·1 , ;'
------....._ I // I ,' L
·, / /j/ _I{ /1·
/ , / -,,, / / /(: ':.-=-~_:_---)I! ( j
/ \ / / I /. L,,l
'I ) / ' I'I ),
f ·------~;
\ / /
,/ /c-{ v---CC~-/ • 1' I
I /0
' _ _ _. , . - ,/ I I
':;_-:::----
!·1L II I
~"~-----
,:~J - ~ -, __ I {-:_J
;~
1! )I
,JI/
'-...)) ~"',===- /j !-,' J,~
_::.,,-..

c-:=.:-.........
I \ '\
i
I
' \ \ '
I , \
I
\ '
'
\
I \ ,
< I \
I \ ,
'
I '
\ \
I
, I (
I \ ,
I ' \
I \ ,
I \
/
I I
/ I \
, I \
f· i 'I
,,,, I
/ ) I
I
/ t t . I
// 'i I /
,//'·/ i ', N
/ -~ I i •
/
,
/
/
I I
,,..,
·--...,
I
I
,
I
I '
I,
I
-u.
t!)
,/ ,. . . ._ / I i
I I I
~·I <I\
I '
,
I -~ ' I
I 1
!l _{
,,,,,. - 1· "1i I 'i Lir
1. 1
___ ./ \ / / f / c-:::_--::-j !
u-
1
\ I/ 'I (1
\' ;'
~ ,··:.\,-, !·11 I• I I
1 I 1 ...._.
I\, , I , ·1 I
I \ I II I I
'I Ii" I
, I I
I
,' r l
,, .•
·i ! I
I
I ,, / /.:_)
_,,,.:'/;/ / rt?,-:_-:,=?,!, 1.1
/ __,.- / { / / ·I /'1
i _..,./ \ I I 11,1' 1'
~17-- \ /:s{ j, I ,
\'(( ------ ' , ;'C:::: •/ "1,

~-
',_,~ ·- · - - \
'~'\., -,_
I I
I ::-_---._
I;' / /
I I ,
1 1
'\;: ""'., :::C.:::-=:'===
~
I
•!• I
i~?-'

. ,...,
-~
, /#/' I /_,<-----'\\ \
'\,~ \
I
1
/#;,
, ,,,r
(;.l.-\\.
{((
>-
----- __.....
---/-
;'
I
\ ____..)-c:/
,. . ,_,
·,-:::-\
\ I
.,;;;--::=:-- ,'\
\
I
.'\ '~\
\ I
\
\
'
(',,, / \ \\ i\ ).,
', ' I \ 1 'I '1 I
"' "I I ,\ 1•;::, I I t I
,,\, \, ;~ :;:;:::----- '1l l)

·\ \ \ \ ,----::::,j I
\, \ \\ I. ("
\\ \ '\ i! i !
/ \' \\ \\_. I.'I ·'-,•I
I \ ·-::!: 'I I
I \'\ \-1 I. ,..,
.\ 'I I
!
I
,-=:..·,-, I \ \ \ \ :::::-::0-! I I
I ,,' - - / I \ \ \ I!'11I
l,J
\ \
I ,_..,.,. \ ''\
\ \\ \ , • ,")
\ , , 11 I)
\ ,,,-\ \ ,,j_L
I •
", \,~1,,,-\ I\
.lI
"'" \/\
,
, '
.
\
,
.I -
(!)
LL
·, ,/\ \\ i
'\/\ I i
"-./\ \ .
\,/\ i !
" '
I~
'1 I
I
• I I
\ ! '
\ I /I
I I"i
\
\
I I I I
\ I I
' I I
\
I
II /
I
\, ,I I,
\ I
\ I I I
\ I ,
\ j I
I • /
\ I
;
I
\ 't...._ _ _ .. /
/
......_ ... ___.,,,

--..:::::..--i- - - '\"s.
I· ~
I '
----.:::i>----(
',I
f
----;;,-- I
,1 f';;~: j, I \
/,/
-
-~-
4~ '"
'\
I I
I--~
,/
lj
i '
I \
I
' //
J..<-- •
\ ,i-·::-·· 1'1· !
I
1'
•
i
'
I,
\
!
~~
\\ -,:,,
,,
/
)
! i
I
/
I
I
I
?~:.jj
.. II
!!\I i
I
I
i
-
C)
LL
,"--, '"-~
'""
I '\, \ ,\::::.-::...
\·1 I\ jI
-
I
~--~-.., \,/' \\ \\-s

~--,,
-:.... -- \ i ~"=:\'1 I
I· ''l/,
---,-:---
----
I
.J~
----

Nike v. Skechers U.S.A. - Complaint (C.D. Cal. 2019)

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Nike v. Skechers U.S.A. - Complaint (C.D. Cal. 2019)

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Case 2:19-cv-08418 Document 1 Filed 09/30/19 Page 1 of 37 Page ID #:1

14 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

1 6. NIKE’s strategy is to compete fairly. As such, NIKE’s intellectual

15 Examples of Skechers’ Infringements in this Lawsuit

1 NIKE’s VaporMax design. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p99LtKMjjL0). An

21 Table 1: VaporMax Patents

1 SKECHERS USES THE VAPORMAX DESIGNS WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION

10 Table 5: Comparison of ’074 Patent with Skech-Air Atlas Shoe

2 Table 7: Comparison of ’076 Patent with Skech-Air Atlas Shoe

11 Table 8: Comparison of ’077 Patent with Skech-Air Atlas Shoe

1 51. Tables 11 through 22 below illustrate Skechers’ infringements by

2 Table 12: Comparison of ’606 Patent with Skech-Air Stratus Shoe

11 Table 13: Comparison of ’607 Patent with Skech-Air Stratus Shoe

2 Table 14: Comparison of ’608 Patent with Skech-Air Stratus Shoe

11 Table 17: Comparison of ’962 Patent with Skech-Air Blast Shoe

10 Table 18: Comparison of ’606 Patent with Skech-Air Blast Shoe

19 Table 19: Comparison of ’607 Patent with Skech-Air Blast Shoe

21 FIRST CLAIM FOR RELIEF

24 paragraphs 1–52 of this Complaint.

1 55. On information and belief, Skechers’ infringement has been willful,

1 J. An award of NIKE’s costs and expenses incurred in bringing and

5 Dated: September 30, 2019

8 By: /s/ Jeffrey T. Thomas .

9 Jeffrey T. Thomas, SBN 106409

16 Christopher J. Renk (pro hac vice to be filed)

(56 ) References Cited D736 , 507

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 3 US D850 , 068 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 2 of 3 US D850 , 068 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 3 of 3 US D850 , 068 S

(56 ) References Cited D485 ,053 S 1/2004 McDowell

(56 ) References Cited D734,601

(56 ) References Cited

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 2 US D850 ,072 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 2 of 2 US D850 ,072 S

(56 ) References Cited D736 , 507

2017 /0042286 A1 * 2/ 2017 Meschter .... ...

5 /2018 Dojan .................. A43B 13 /122

7 / 2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 2 US D850 ,074 S

U . S . Patent Jun. 4 , 2019 Sheet 2 of 2 US D850 ,074 S

(51) LOC ( 11) CI. ............... 02 -04 (57) CLAIM

(56 ) References Cited 6 ,665, 958 B2

(56 ) References Cited D734 ,600 S * 7 / 2015 Gargiulo ........... D2 /947

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 5 US D850 ,075 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 2 of 5 US D850 ,075 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 3 of 5 US D850 ,075 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 4 of 5 US D850 ,075 S

U . S . Patent Jun. 4 , 2019 Sheet 5 of 5 US D850,075 S

(56 ) References Cited D475 ,514 S 6 /2003 Burg et al.

(56 ) References Cited D731, 164 S

(56) References Cited 2018 /0199666 A1 * 7/ 2018 Moriyasu ............... A43B 13 / 16

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 1 of 5 US D850 ,076 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 2 of 5 US D850 ,076 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 3 of 5 US D850 ,076 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 4 of 5 US D850 ,076 S

U . S . Patent Jun . 4 , 2019 Sheet 5 of 5 US D850 ,076 S

(51) LOC ( 11) CI. ............... 02- 04 (57) CLAIM

(56 ) References Cited 6 ,665, 958 B2

(56 ) References Cited D734 ,600 S * *

7 / 2015 Gargiulo ........... D2 /947

* 9 /2015 Bates D2 /951

* 12 / 2015 Montross D2/951

* 1 /2016 Vestuti D2/951

5 /2016 Mahoney ............. D2 /951