Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8

9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

The Big Read Artificial intelligence

Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job

Advances in machine learning software means some white-collar jobs could be swept away by digital change

Robert Wright in London 18 HOURS AGO

When Matt Radwell, a customer support officer for a small local authority in the UK, first started
answering queries from the area’s residents, it was a frustrating and time-consuming business. If a
resident contacted Aylesbury Vale District Council, 40 miles north of London, about an issue like
housing benefit in which he lacked expertise, Mr Radwell might keep the caller waiting as long as
20 minutes. He had to find someone who could give him the relevant information.

Over the past two years, however, his job has been transformed. When a resident types a question
into the council’s online chat facility, an advanced computer system starts reading it.

For around 40 per cent of inquiries, the system — which has been trained to recognise residents’
questions by using machine learning, a form of artificial intelligence — presents Mr Radwell and
other customer support officers with a series of potential, pre-written responses. Each is labelled
with an estimated probability of its being the correct choice. If one is appropriate, Mr Radwell
clicks on it, satisfying the resident far more quickly and easily than before.

The council’s machine learning system — provided by Digital Genius, a San Francisco-based
specialist in customer service systems — has put it at the forefront of a transformation under way
in millions of white-collar jobs worldwide.

The relentless advance of robotics and AI in the workplace has focused attention largely on the
impact on manual labour. In many of the parts of the developing world that have yet to see a wave

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 1/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

of industrialisation and the employment boost that it can bring, there is a fear that they might have
already missed their chance, given the growing use of automation in factories.

AI being used by Matt Radwell, a customer support officer at Aylesbury Vale District Council. His job has been transformed in the past two years © Tom
Pilston
However, the growing power of software such as Digital Genius has opened up the possibility that
new, intelligent systems will vastly improve the productivity of a range of office jobs from clerical
to professional roles — which will reduce some of the drudgery involved in menial tasks but could
lead to some people losing their positions.

In The Globotics Upheaval published earlier this year, Richard Baldwin, professor of international
economics at the Graduate Institute Geneva, predicts that white-collar jobs will be swept away
faster by digital change than in any previous economic transformation.

“The explosive potential comes from the mismatch between the speed at which disruptive energy is
injected into the system by job displacement and the system’s ability to absorb it with job creation,”
Prof Baldwin writes.

The potential impact goes beyond relatively basic customer service roles such as Mr Radwell’s,
extending into professional services roles such as insurance and law that have seemed wholly
reliant on humans’ judgment and understanding. Research last year by PwC, the consultants,
found that 30 per cent of jobs in finance and insurance in developed economies were at risk of
automation by 2029 and that in the same period 50 per cent of all clerical roles in the same
countries were imperilled by automation.

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 2/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

Michael Lewis, chief executive of Claim Technology, whose machine learning systems
automate insurance processes, says AI technologies will remove the repetitive, dull aspects of
handling insurance claims and enable staff to focus on “value-added activities”.

“Artificial intelligence will enable us to do . . . things that weren’t possible previously, or do things
that are possible now [but] with far less effort and at lower cost and provide a better customer
experience,” Mr Lewis says.

Yet a look around Mr Radwell’s still-busy open-plan office raises questions about how rapidly the
changes under way will sweep through offices.

Digital Genius has allowed the customer service team to leave two roles on the team unfilled — it
otherwise might have had to take on extra staff to handle the growing volume of calls from the
area’s expanding population. But the team still employs eight people.

This experience backs up the arguments of Richard Freeman, an economics professor at Harvard
University who studies the impact of technology on work. Prof Freeman predicts few companies
would be able to make sweeping changes such as dismissing their accounting department
wholesale and leaving only a couple of people to manage the computers.

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 3/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

“I think the disruptions are going to be slower than people are claiming,” he told a seminar held by
the Oxford university Business and Economics Programme in July.

Mr Radwell rejects the idea that the introduction of


Digital Genius threatens his future employment
You are still going to need prospects, saying it has made the team “smaller but
people. The skillsets they more versatile”.
deploy and what they
“We can take more stuff on and there are fewer
actually do will change
people here,” he says. “I wouldn’t say it’s put my job
at risk — it’s made my job better.”

There are undoubtedly fields where machine learning systems, which are trained to analyse and
quickly spot patterns in pools of data too big for humans to detect, have given employers
extraordinary new capabilities.

Engage Talent, a start-up based in Charleston, South Carolina, analyses recruitment and retention
patterns at companies, tracking thousands of public data sources, such as companies’ ratings on
Glassdoor, the employment site, analyst ratings, share price movement and regulatory action. It
uses the information to advise clients on questions such as when might be a good time to approach
staff at a rival.

Matt Pietsch, Engage Talent’s chief revenue officer, says its models flagged up in advance a series
of redundancies at Tesla, the electric carmaker. Signs from its model of unhappy staff had been
“spiking” months before Elon Musk, the company’s chief executive, tweeted about its restructuring
plans in June, according to Mr Pietsch.

“If I’m a recruiter and I have the data from our system and I want to recruit people from Tesla, I’d
want to target individuals on April 1 versus when the announcement is made and 6,000 other
recruiters are targeting them,” Mr Pietsch says.

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 4/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

It is a far bigger challenge, however, to fit machine learning into existing roles where
employers and customers have become used to the strong sense of intuition and flexibility of
human staff.

The issues are clear in the low-rise glass block housing the Swindon offices of Zurich, the Swiss
insurer, which handles everything from the processing of insurance claims to back-office functions
such as human resources. Staff at the office 85 miles west of London have seen some significant
benefits from robotic process automation or RPA, a relatively simple form of automation that takes
over some predictable clerical tasks.

Among the benefits of RPA have been that human resources staff no longer spend three days at the
start of every month reconciling ledgers of the scheduled deductions from staff’s pay packets with
the actual deductions the system is due to make. The RPA software does the reconciliation itself
and flags up only apparent errors for humans to solve.

RPA has reduced the number of staff needed in parts of Zurich’s businesses, although the company
says it seeks to redeploy those affected, often by training them in automation.

“The team know exactly which ledgers they need to investigate,” Dan Humeniuk, an automation
consultant for Zurich, says of the HR staff. “They go and speak to the team members and

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 5/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

investigate, without having three days from hell at the start of every month.”

It is less clear, however, that machine learning is poised to take over more complex analytical and
sorting work, such as the assessment of insurance claims for car crashes or burglaries. Alastair
Robertson, Zurich’s head of continuous improvement and automation for the UK, is one of many in
the field to express doubt about whether current systems are up to the task.

When Zurich ran a pilot scheme three years ago using machine learning to sift claims, humans had
to override the computer’s decision too often for the technology to be worthwhile.

Richard Freeman, an economics professor at Harvard University, predicts few companies would be able to make sweeping changes © Getty
“While it could give a there-or-thereabouts picture, the individual was still having to step in,” Mr
Robertson says. “We’ve piloted it. We’ve found out what the software can do and what it cannot do.
So it’s not something we’ve rolled out.”

The claim that machine learning is unable to match the reliability and accuracy of human staff is a
widespread one. Ben Allgrove, head of global research and development for Baker McKenzie, the
law firm, says that, in insurance, only operators dealing with high volumes of routine, low-level
claims have so far found the technology useful.

A number of insurers — including Japan’s Fukoku Mutual Life — have said they are handling
routine claims processing to machine-learning systems. Walmart, the US retailer, uses the
technology to handle personal injury claims.

“What is common about those two fact patterns is high volume, highly standardised,” Mr Allgrove
says. “Yes, you can automate. How much you can automate probably depends [on what standard
you want to achieve].”

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 6/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

Even for organisations that have enjoyed success with machine learning, there has been
considerable cost and effort. While Aylesbury Vale District Council is confident that Digital Genius
has paid for itself in reduced salaries and improved service to local residents, the council faced a
huge challenge feeding the system with sufficient data about residents’ needs.

Maryvonne Hassall, the council’s assistant director for digital transformation, says it was only after
four months of pilot programmes that the system started to show enough understanding to be a
useful tool. “You need to work with it to help it to learn,” she says.

For more specialist professional services firms, the effort required to train a system is often
unjustifiably high, says Mr Allgrove. He says managers “massively underestimate” the cost of
introducing machine-learning systems.

“People [are] figuring out where is it that the investments make sense when the legal industry is so
fragmented and segmented that those business cases are so hard to come by,” he says. “Finding the
main use case that makes economic sense at the moment is not easy.”

Instead, workers are likely to find evolutionary new technologies being gradually introduced beside
them. Mr Allgrove compares the process to how typing pools have disappeared from offices but
many personal assistants are still employed by senior executives.

“Individual jobs will change with the organisations,” he predicts. “But you are still going to need
people. The skillsets they deploy and what they actually do will change.”

30%
Prof Freeman told the July seminar in Oxford
that people often expected rapid introduction of new
technologies in white-collar environments. They saw
Finance and insurance jobs in developed
them as similar to blue-collar roles, where a robot
economies at risk of automation by 2029,
could often be inserted into a process without
according to PwC
disrupting the wider system.

But that misunderstood how white-collar roles fitted into most organisations. “If you’re bringing in
the latest accounting software, the company has to change the way it’s doing reporting, controls, to
do a lot of stuff,” he said. “It’s actually a much slower process of adjustment.”

Some participants are confident that improvements in machine-learning technology will eventually
bring tasks such as assessing insurance claims within reach of automation. Zurich’s Mr Robertson
acknowledges there is software available that is “starting to go on that track”, although his
company is not yet ready to deploy it.

But, for many involved, the experience of automating knowledge work has reinforced not only the
potential of new technologies but also the many, continuing advantages of dealing with intelligent,
flexible humans.

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 7/8
9/29/2019 Workplace automation: how AI is coming for your job | Financial Times

Mr Allgrove acknowledges that lawyers increasingly rely on machine-learning systems capable of


scanning huge numbers of relevant legal cases to assess their chances of a success in a given case.
But he insists the best lawyers’ judgments and their relationships with clients still trump such
software.

“The litigators who are most trusted in the market say, ‘We probably only have a 50-50 chance of
winning but this is a case we must fight’,” he says. “We feel that the world has changed; social
positions have changed slightly; the nature of the bench has changed’.”

Echoing the views of people in many white-collar sectors, Mr Allgrove insists that the ability to
exercise such nuanced judgments remains a “high-value skill”.

“I think for the foreseeable future — by which I mean five to 10 years — that’s still there,” Mr
Allgrove says.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2019. All rights reserved.

https://www.ft.com/content/c4bf787a-d4a0-11e9-a0bd-ab8ec6435630 8/8

Вам также может понравиться