Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
General Editor
William H. Swatos, Jr.
VOLUME 17
Conversion
in the Age of Pluralism
Edited by
Guiseppe Giordan
LEIDEN • BOSTON
2009
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
BL639.C659 2009
248.2'4–dc22
2009020449
ISSN 1061-5210
ISBN 978 90 04 17803 8
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher.
Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV
provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center,
222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA.
Fees are subject to change.
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 329
PREFACE: THE SOCIOLOGY OF CONVERSION
Roberto Cipriani
book as a whole was published under the sponsorship of the Society for the Scientific
Study of Religion (SSSR), hence carried its implied imprimatur.
2 Mauss was himself a product of the sociology program at Berkeley at the same time
as the earlier studies by Stark and Lofland were being produced. Mauss’s heritage in the
tradition of the LDS Church, whose sociological analysis has been the primary field of his
own expertise, particularly prepared him to appreciate the significance of the approach
advanced in the early work of Stark and Lofland.
preface ix
3 Stark. Richardson, Bromley, and Barker (in that temporal order) have each served
and the differences between it and the Catholic model upon which the
historic religious confessions in France (i.e., Protestant, Jewish, and more
recently Muslim) have been configured in relation to each other and to
the French state. Individualistic bricolage on the part of devotees is dif-
ficult to comprehend within a quasi-political model in which corporate,
rather than personal, devotion has been the primary mode of religious
action and articulation among the historic confessions.
What has been said above is just an introduction to the wide com-
plex of conversion phenomena and aims at preparing the reader for the
variety of observations and issues raised and addressed in this book. Fur-
thermore, a number of individual behaviors, which are often neglected
by current macro-sociological analyses, are here observed with fine accu-
racy and dedication, thus completing the original relevance and success-
ful approach of this work.
References
Anthony, Dick and Thomas Robbins (eds.). . In Gods We Trust: New Patterns
of Religious Pluralism in America. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
Barker, Eileen V. . The Making of a Moonie: Brainwashing or Choice? Oxford:
Blackwell.
——— . New Religious Movements: A Practical Introduction. London: Her
Majesty’s Stationery Office.
Beckford, James A. . “Accounting for Conversion.” British Journal of Sociol-
ogy : –.
Bromley, David G. and James T. Richardson (eds.). . The Brainwashing/
Deprogramming Controversy: Sociological, Psychological, Legal and Historical
Perspectives. Lewiston, NY: Mellen.
Freud, Sigmund. []. “A Religious Experience.” Pp. – in The
Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud ,
edited by John Strachey. London: Hogarth.
Gonzáles de Santalla, Tirso. /. Manuductio ad conversionem mahumeta-
norum. Dillingen.
Greil, Arthur L. and Tom Robbins (eds.). . Between the Sacred and the
Secular: Research and Theory on Quasi-Religion Movements. Greenwich, CT:
JAI.
Hammond, Phillip, E. . The Sacred in a Secular Age: Toward Revision in the
Scientific Study of Religion. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Hervieu-Léger, Danièle. . Le pèlerin et le converti. La religion en mouvement.
Paris: Flammarion.
James, William. . The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human
Nature. New York: Longmans.
Martin, David. . A General Theory of Secularization. Oxford: Blackwell.
preface xiii
——— . “The Secularization Issue: Prospect and Retrospect.” British Journal
of Sociology : –.
Richardson, James T. . Conversion Careers. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Robbins, Thomas. . Cults, Converts, and Charisma: The Sociology of New
Religious Movements. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
——— and Susan Palmer (eds.). . Millennium, Messiahs, and Mayhem. New
York: Routledge.
Sanz, Manuel. . Breve trattato nel quale con ragioni dimostrative si con-
vertono manifestamente i Turchi. Catania: Bisagni.
Wilson, Bryan R. . “An Analysis of Sect Development.” American Sociolog-
ical Review : –.
——— . Sects and Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.
——— . Magic and Millennium. London: Heinemann.
——— . The Noble Savages: The Primitive Origins of Charisma and Its Con-
temporary Survival. Berkeley: University of California Press.
——— . The Social Impact of New Religious Movements. New York: Rose of
Sharon Press.
——— . The Social Dimensions of Sectarianism: Sects and New Religious
Movements in Contemporary Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
——— and Karel Dobbelaere. . A Time to Chant: The Soka Gakkai Buddhists
in Britain. Oxford: Clarendon.
INTRODUCTION:
THE VARIETIES OF CONVERSION EXPERIENCE
Giuseppe Giordan
Although the theme of conversion is not one that has a long history in
sociology, it constitutes a privileged observation point to study society,
especially the complex framework linking together the individual and
the socio-cultural contexts in which he is included. Change in the per-
sonal biographic route and social and cultural change are very closely
interwoven when we speak of conversion: values, speech, norms, behav-
iors, beliefs, lifestyles, relations, interests—everything becomes open to
potential debate when the individual decides to “convert.”
The experience of believing often originates in or is accompanied by
the experience of conversion, which is expressed in terms of radical
change, a transformation that is almost always described in terms of a
“before” and an “after,” to the point of leading to a kind of “re-birth” and
to the construction of a new identity. It’s a process of re-socialization that
can be described, at least in some aspects, in terms of social mobility, and
since each type of social mobility carries in itself a dynamic of uprooting
and a new rooting, conversion can jeopardize an existing equilibrium in
order to work out a totally new one. This fracture, this caesura with one’s
past, cannot make us forget that, beside the issues of break are issues
of continuity, hence one’s identity actually does not dissolve but is re-
defined, is modified, both on the individual and on the social side: the old
and the new then find a form of co-existence capable of giving meaning
to everyday life. It is a new light that illuminates a previously existing
reality in a different way.
The title of the present volume puts in evidence the perspective from
which the theme of conversion is developed—that is to say, connecting
it to the dynamics of pluralism, which seems to be the most peculiar
cultural characteristic of the contemporary epoch: what does it mean to
speak of “conversion” in a time in which it seems that one only “true”
truth does not exist any more, but in which many different truths live
together, all of them with their own plausible judgment criteria, with
their boundaries circumscribing universes of meaning that are quite dif-
ferent from one another? Is it still possible to speak of conversion in
giuseppe giordan
a world such as the Western world in which truth seems to have lost
its character of absoluteness and has become relative—not only because
of intellectual currents but equally because of quite different migrant
flows from past centuries? Who is today capable of assessing, in the
religious ambit, the credibility of a value that has universal relevance?
At the same time, however, just this relativization of truth has carried
within itself the need to confirm the necessity of strong identities, even
religiously speaking, and in this perspective conversion may assume
an important role in defining such identities. If on one side pluralism
may lead to more or less stressed forms of relativism, on the other side
its outcome may be the necessity of detecting new religious identifica-
tions.
Religious conversion is to be located on this ground, the contemporary
religious field, which sometimes presents contradictory elements: on one
side secularization with its effects, and on the other side what has been
defined as the “return of God.” Two simple examples, drawn out of the
Italian context, may help us understand how such contradictory features
are verifiable in everyday life.
The first example comes from research carried out among young
people in their last year of the upper secondary schools in the Valley
of Aosta, the smallest Italian “region,” placed at the foot of Mont Blanc.
Almost , interviewees were asked to say whether they agreed with
the statement “every religion is true and leads to God”: about two out
of three subjects stated that they agreed with this statement, without any
relevant differences between boys and girls, or between people belonging
to different economic categories or attending different types of schools.
This attitude is also shared by one young person out of two among
those who attend Sunday Mass regularly. The radicalness of this datum is
heightened when it is inserted in the Italian context where Catholicism
has a quasi-monopolistic position. In the questionnaire there was also
another question that affects our theme directly: “Do you believe it
is right for a Church to try to convert believers of other religions?”
Four interviewees out of five answered “no,” and the remaining ones
were divided into those who answered “yes” ( ) and those who didn’t
answer at all. Through further interview research on this aspect, the
students confirmed how “each one can choose the religion he wants, and
consequently can even change his religion, but it isn’t very correct to
speak of a religion that is more true than others.” In this perspective the
meaning of conversion appears to be fading away, being more connected
with a question of “taste” than a “dramatic” choice between Good and
introduction
Evil, True and False. If all religions are more or less equivalent, as these
youth seem to believe, what’s the meaning of converting from one to the
other?
A second example leads us to consider the other side of the coin. On
March , Magdi Allam, an Egyptian Muslim journalist who has
lived in Italy for many years, renounced his original religion and con-
verted to Catholicism. The event went around the world because Allam,
deputy editor of the Corriere della Sera, one of the most popular Ital-
ian dailies, was baptized in St. Peter’s basilica in Rome by Pope Bene-
dict XVI during the solemn Easter eve liturgy. On the following day,
Easter Day, the neo-converted journalist wrote a long letter in the news-
paper of which he is the deputy editor, explaining the reasons why he has
decided to leave the Muslim religion to convert to Catholicism. Among
the various considerations, after stating precisely that since that day his
new name was to be Magdi “Christian” Allam, there is a statement that
couldn’t but provoke burning controversies, both within Catholicism and
within the Muslim world:
I have wondered how it was possible that one who has fought bravely and
with great conviction for a “moderate Islam,” as I did, undertaking the
responsibility of exposing himself personally to extremist denunciations
and Islamic terrorism, has then ended being sentenced to death in the
name of Islam and on the basis of Koranic legitimation. I have hence had to
take cognizance of the fact that, beyond the contingent situation recording
the advantage of the world-wide phenomenon of extremism and of Islamic
terrorism, the root of evil resides in an Islam that is physiologically violent
and historically conflictual.1
Owing to the reactions that greeted this last statement, the Vatican itself,
through the Jesuit Federico Lombardi, Director of Vatican Radio and of
the Press Room of the Holy See, had to specify that, if on one side Allam
has the right to express his opinions freely, on the other side they are
his personal opinions and cannot be attributed to the Pope. The lively
and at times harsh discussion following Allam’s letter has offered an
occasion to pass in review all the implications that “conversion” portends
today, from its public relevance to the freedom of religion, from the
right to give evidence on behalf of one’s own beliefs to proselytism, from
the possibility of communicating among the different religions to their
irreducible differences and reciprocal closure.
But the most interesting point is the one that concerns the mean-
ing of conversion in the context of the contemporary world: a fact that,
although personal and private, cannot but have social and public impli-
cations, and this is true for every type of conversion, as that from one reli-
gion to the other, from non-religion to religion and vice-versa (including
that particular form of conversion that consists in re-discovering one’s
own religion in an active and responsible way). The different social con-
texts have much to say on this subject. If in the more and more secular-
ized and pluralist Western world, as we have already seen, the choice of
being religious is the result of a strictly individual choice, in other socio-
cultural contexts such an option appears to be a way of totally identifying
oneself with the environment. Even the concept of conversion, in other
words, must be interpreted in different ways according to the geopolitical
dimension considered.
Between the attitude of the students of the Valley of Aosta and that of
Magdi Christian Allam we find the various potential meanings support-
ing the choice of conversion today. As paradoxical as it may seem, it is a
fact that just as growing cultural and social pluralism has brought to the
limelight the phenomenon of conversion, it is meant by the subjects as
a chance to re-search questions of meaning. This dynamic, inserted into
the process of de-institutionalization of the traditional religions, opens
up a considerable space to religious mobility where the individual takes
in charge “on his own” the faith which he decides to join.
When religious belief gets out of the “taken for granted” and out of
habitualized sociocultural practices to become the outcome of reflection
and creative research, the individual activates a biographic route whose
outcome can be true metanoia, a radical change concerning the way of
seeing, interpreting and judging the world around him. It’s a complex
movement that gathers not only the faculty of reason, but also, and most
of all, the affective, emotional and aesthetic faculties: these are rather
heterogeneous components that all the same are referable to the freedom
of choice of the subject.
But the individual issue, when we speak of conversion, is only one vari-
able: historically the institutional aspect has played an equally impor-
tant (if not even more important) role. The Christian and the Muslim
religions have much to say on this subject. Cutting a long story short,
and considering the tradition of Christianity, the message “convert and
believe in the Gospel” has inspired the missionary work of the Church
since the first centuries. Throughout history such missionary work has
developed in manifold ways and not without gross contradictions with
introduction
of one’s life. The chapters in the present volume are examples of how
variously this experience can be lived.
In the opening chapter, Anthony Blasi clarifies his definition of con-
version, redirection and functional acceptance in broad, straightforward
and generally received interpretations of these terms. He then proceeds to
focus on a theoretical understanding of conversion and trust. He explores
the kinds of religious phenomena that arise within the ten largest social
realities suggested by Gurvitch as well as the push/pull factor that consti-
tutes the conversion experience, and concludes by considering collective
conversion in the Vineyard Christian Fellowship and the individual con-
version of John Henry Newman from the Church of England to Roman
Catholicism.
In Chapter Two, Kieran Flanagan paints a portrait of the convert with
broad strokes. He asserts that it is religion, not ideology, that marks the
great division of culture. He see conversion as multidisciplinary, includ-
ing psychology, philosophy and cultural studies. The most obvious aca-
demic reference point for understanding the convert lies in religion and
theology along with a consideration of both soft forms of conversion and
hard forms of conversion, as well as holistic spirituality. He distinguishes
between holistic and ecclesial spirituality, as well as hard and soft forms
of conversion, and draws from a large array of religious beliefs to explore
the implications of conversion on the individual once the process of con-
version is complete. He ends his chapter with an account of his personal
conversion.
In the following chapter, Patrick Michel sees conversion as an indicator
of the recomposition of identity and loyalty. Although it is often given
strongly religious overtones, Michel argues that it is rather a sign of the
complex interplay of reciprocal interactions and usages that govern the
relation between religion and politics, religion and ideology, religion and
economy. Conversion is a part of the mixture of forces that indicates a
movement of passage. It is a process in which religion is certainly a part,
but only one part, of many factors leading to a change from one identity
to another.
Kees de Groot turns next to empirical research to address the ques-
tion: Are there patterns of religious development in liquid modernity?
He uses a study based on observation and interviews of a New Town,
conducted between September and June , to determine the
beliefs of city dwellers. Although religion is far from self-evident among
city dwellers, it seems present in many and varied forms closely based on
personal relationships. Although considered private, religious beliefs are
introduction
deeply woven into the social fabric. With little social solidarity to anchor
beliefs, however, they take many and varied forms.
In Chapter Five, Bill Swatos, who has been developing a corpus of work
on pilgrimage over the past decade, looks at the relationship between
pilgrimage and conversion. He begins by contrasting the present-day
concept of pilgrimage with that of the past, and notes that pilgrimage
takes the form of both revivals and historic journeys as well as new
innovations of gathering places that lack direct connection to explicit
religious tradition. The rise of tourism has broadened the concept of
pilgrimage, for it is not always an either/or situation but can certainly
be both/and. The term pilgrim has extended contemporary tourism and
pilgrimage to form part of one broad type of travel. Pilgrimage implies
both motion and change that can be both external and internal, and it is
the internal change that has the possibility of bringing conversion with it.
In a way that has fascinating similarities to and differences from the
geographic kinds of pilgrimages of which Swatos writes, Régis Dericque-
bourg discusses a relatively recent modification to the religious field in
the past forty years as “seekers” find answers to questions of the mean-
ing of life outside the established spiritual paths. They experiment with
several spiritual practices as well as non-spiritual practices which they
find helpful. This assortment of expressions is located under the umbrella
of the New Age. Dericquebourg asks the question “Is entering the New
Age a conversion experience?” He presents an overview of the New Age,
refers to Anthony Blasi’s understanding of conversion from a sociological
viewpoint, and through a guided life-story format and semi-structured
interviews concludes that the New Age is a spiritual “place” where one
adheres successively or simultaneously to ideas or practices put forward
in a market that is in constant evolution.
Roberto Motta, by contrast, understands conversion as a move from
the “iron cage” of rationalization and disenchantment to an enchanted
theology which by being participatory provides a sense of identity. He
uses movements in Brazil from Catholicism and mainline Protestantism
to Pentecostalism and Afro-Brazilian cults to demonstrate this point.
Although he specifies that his writing will deal with conversion as it
appears in Brazil in the abandonment of allegiance to the Roman Cath-
olic church in favor of, first, historical Protestantism, but more recently
and powerfully Afro-Brazilian cults and Pentecostalism, he asserts the
cultural hypotheses of the paper that religious conversion implies every-
where, the refusal of the “iron cage” of rationalization, secularism and
disenchantment as they have came to prevail in the Western world.
giuseppe giordan
tinuing value not only within the narrow confines of specific religious
traditions but also, and with more sociological salience, in relation to
national and international issues of culture, politics, and economy.
chapter one
Anthony J. Blasi
The term conversion is often used to refer to a change from one reli-
gious tradition or denomination within a tradition or world religion,
to another tradition or denomination. Surveys usually focus on changes
in religious preference, while ethnographic studies tend to focus on the
process of becoming members. The distinction between preference and
membership is an important one (Hoge, Johnson and Luidens ).
Tamney () identified changes in religious membership for purposes
of research; he acknowledged that such was less than ideal as a defini-
tion of conversion but was the most practical approach (see also Wal-
lace ). Setting aside cases of changes in merely nominal affiliation,
which may turn up in survey data but would not be a genuine conver-
sion (though capable of precipitating such), a conversion in this sense
involves engaging a different context of commitment, meaning, or both.
Conversion is also used to refer to a discovery, personal renewal, or trans-
formation, termed “development” by Tamney (: –); this usually
occurs within one tradition or denomination but can also occur on the
occasion of converting in the first sense given above. Rambo (: xii)
speaks of “genuine” conversion as a total transformation of the person by
the power of God. With Rambo, one would tend to think of conversion
as a religious phenomenon, but there can also be secular conversions. An
anthropologist may “go native,” or someone may leave one political sect
and find meaning in life in another one. For purposes of the present dis-
cussion, I would like to subsume all the meanings of conversion, except
for changes of merely nominal affiliation, under the formula, “redirection
of foundational trust.”
Redirection is to be understood in a straightforward way. Before the
conversion the trust is placed in one entity, and afterwards it is placed
in another one. If foundational trust is taken for granted and neglected
altogether, coming to cultivate and direct a genuine foundational trust
can be seen as a conversion. By foundational I simply mean that the trust
anthony j. blasi
2 In general, studies of populations of converts have been beset by the problem of not
We can begin with the material culture of religion, its most empirical
aspect. Different religions may have a greater or lesser number of mate-
rial artifacts. A Calvinist church building or a Cistercian chapel may
have fewer artifacts in the sense of paintings, statues, decorous furniture,
and the like, and a Daoist temple or Latin American cathedral may have
more. But it goes beyond art and architecture: In Nashville, Tennessee, a
Catholic Hispanic ministry that had purchased and moved into a larger
former Southern Baptist church found that the pews lacked kneelers; part
of the Latino worship involved public bodily gestures that the Baptist had
not. A spot needed to be constructed for the painting of the Guadalupe
Madonna, as well as platforms to accommodate the banks of flowers that
the Latino families brought to set before it. The clergy had to borrow
3 Dialectics, for Gurvitch (), involved not only polarity, as with the Hegelian
ments in the outside social world. Just as there can be a greater or lesser
amount of religious material culture, there can be more or less religious
organization, both in the sense of the degree of structure and in the over-
all size of the entity. A greater degree of organization can make it diffi-
cult for a member to remain within the organization if marginalized by
organizational politics, unpalatable official doctrines, or norms that are
unreasonably confining. Conflicts within a church can lead to schisms or,
alternatively, to departures of members who then convert to some other
religious organization. For example, Ammerman (: ) describes
the options available to those who did not prevail in a conflict within
the Southern Baptist Convention as accommodation, becoming a loyal
opposition, or leaving. A religion that is heavily invested in an organi-
zational apparatus can better undertake such collective ventures as mis-
sions, schools, and social services, but will have difficulty maintaining its
basic functions if the resources required by the organizational apparatus
are lacking. The more organizationally-oriented a religious tradition is,
the more likely it will be that specialized life-style sub-organizations will
develop within it; hence there could be monasteries and orders. Even a
transitory life-style can take an organizational form, as with the adoles-
cent Buddhist monastic apprenticeship and the two Mormon missionary
years.4 The simple size of an organization can also create tensions that
engender conversions. As Simmel pointed out, the thoroughness of con-
trol over members, or “strictness,” becomes less possible as size increases
(: –).
A lower degree of organization may leave the faithful quite dependent
on the entrepreneurial charisma of a clergyperson. The latitude in doc-
trine that may arise absent such charisma may be quite disconcerting.
The maintenance of any meaning may necessitate an even greater doc-
trinal rigidity than occurs with strongly organizational religion. Those
marginalized by the charisma of an entrepreneurial clergyperson, those
seeking structure and tradition where doctrines are too individualized
and diffuse, as well as those seeking intellectual freedom where doctrines
are too collective and rigid for fear of individualism and diffuseness—in
short, those seeking more organization will be ripe for conversion.
Social models cue in kinds of shared activity (Gurvitch : –
). Worship, sacred feasts, orthodoxy, blessings, dietary restrictions,
forgiveness, and donations are all social models. Religious phenomena
5 Blumer () used the expression collective behavior to refer to mindless and
minded behavior both, and in defense of his usage it can be noted that much collective
activity involves elements of both.
6 There are, of course, other types. Troeltsch () added mysticism to church and
sect. Mysticism is not considered here because it is less in a dialectic with collective
ideas and values than are the other two. Becker () and Colin Campbell ()
include mysticism and private religiosity in general in the category cult. There are further
scholarly uses of the term cult, but where they pertain to ideas and values they blend into
the concept of sect.
anthony j. blasi
Denominations would fit comfortably in their host societies; they are not
in tension with their surrounding cultures. Sects would be in tension
with their host societies and environing cultures. Each of these types can
occasion ambivalence in the individual. Someone who has a misgiving
about some aspect of a society would be ambivalent about a church
or about denominations in and of that society. A sect member who
engages the social world in a friendly manner could experience similar
ambivalence.
Greil (: ff.) notes that changes in cognitive style, which would
be an aspect of collective ideas and values, often correlate with changes
in reference others (or reference groups, as they are often termed in
the textbooks). Thus an intellectually oriented individual may seek out
reference others who share the cognitive style that the individual has
begun to use. Alternatively, an individual may select certain persons or
categories of people as reference others in the process of participating in
or planning to participate in an organization, and assume the cognitive
style of those others in the process. A parallel phenomenon occurs
when a previously little-educated population becomes a more highly-
educated one (see Tong , on Chinese Singaporeans abandoning
folk religion for Christianity or no religion). What is often interesting
about collective ideas in conversion is the lack of their relevance; most
conversions involve a switch to a denomination within the same tradition
or world religion, usually to one somewhat similar to that which was left
(Babchuck and Whitt ).
The tendency is to understand various mental states and acts—rep-
resentations, memory, suffering, satisfaction, preferences, effort, and the
like—as individual experiences, but they can be borne by an individual,
a subsocietal group of individuals, or the whole society of individuals. In
the latter two instances we can refer to collective mental states and psychic
acts (Gurvitch : ). Religiously, there can be shared sentiments
during a holy day, commemoration, or ceremony, for example, or shared
ethical dissatisfaction or satisfaction over some public event. This would
encompass the civil religious phenomena described eloquently by Bellah
(). The sentiment may or may not be embodied in the same symbols,
and the fact that it may not be provides the rationale for thinking of
collective mental states and psychic acts apart from their symbolization.
It is natural to think in terms of collective mental states and psychic acts
working against conversion from a majority religious stance and to a
deviant one; consequently seemingly deviant ones may go out of their
way to be civic and patriotic.
the meaning of conversion
It might be useful to speak of push factors and pull factors that constitute
the conversion context. Theoretically, push and pull factors can emerge at
any one layer of social reality and have consequences in that same layer or
in any other layer. Thus organizational politics may marginalize a person,
with the result that the person seeks a less structured or at least differently
structured religious organization within the same religious tradition, but
the person may seek instead a collective attitude—for example, contem-
plative reverence for the sacred—and find it in a religious book club held
under the auspices of a different religious entity. Alternatively, the indi-
vidual may seek an opportunity to engage in social service and participate
in a different religious organization’s program of charities, but as a vol-
unteer with a minimum of organizational involvement. In such cases the
push factor would be at the organizational level, but the pull factors that
give character to the conversion that takes place could be at the organiza-
tional level, at the level of collective attitudes, or at the level of collective
conduct that shares some regularity. Theoretically, one could construct
a ten-by-ten matrix of push and pull factors and have a resultant inven-
tory of a hundred kinds of conversion. We need not pursue that exercise
here.
We can consider a relatively new religious entity, most of whose mem-
bers, simply because the entity is new, must be converts. The Vineyard
Christian Fellowship in the Evangelical tradition is an example. A study
conducted in shows that about a third of the members had been
reared in conservative Protestant churches, one third in liberal Protes-
tant churches, and one third in the Roman Catholic Church. However,
immediately prior to joining Vineyard only fifteen percent had belonged
to liberal Protestant denominations and only six percent to the Catholic
Church; the majority had joined or had been reared in traditional con-
servative Christian churches or independent non-denominational Chris-
tian churches. The Vineyard members rated the members of their pre-
vious churches as less committed and having less missionary zeal than
their Vineyard fellow members, but no less strict or disciplined (Perrin
and Mauss ). Culturally, Vineyard churches attract college-educated
young adults and have a contemporary popular-culture style of wor-
ship; thus they accommodate rather than maintain tension with the envi-
roning culture (Shibley ). A British study notes that once a pas-
tor had introduced the Vineyard style in a Church of England parish,
thereby precipitating the departure of the music minister and choir, the
anthony j. blasi
7 For a parallel case of a growing church dependent on converts, see Tamney’s account
Edward Hawkins, over whether tutors should watch over the religious life
of their pupils. From Hawkins, who held they should not, ceased
assigning him pupils. Newman resigned his tutorship in , when his
last pupil graduated. In he had also been appointed Vicar of St. Mary
the Virgin parish, which served as Oxford’s church, and it was from that
post that he became an influential personage in the Oxford setting.
What is interesting about Newman is that from a satisfying ministry
in a citadel of the Church of England he began to migrate intellectually
out of the Church, ever so gradually, and into Roman Catholicism. In
Newman set about reading the ancient Church Fathers in chrono-
logical order (Newman : ). He was particularly impressed by
the Alexandrian writers, whose arguments for doctrinal orthodoxy influ-
enced his evaluation of the state of affairs of his own ecclesiastical con-
text. He was not left satisfied; he wrote that his “mind had not found its
ultimate rest, and in some sense or other I was on a journey” (: –
). He began writing about the ancient Church councils in .
By the Church of England served a minority of the British pop-
ulace, and its lower clergy were not deeply trained in theology. The gov-
ernment began reorganizing it, consolidating some parishes and elimi-
nating others. The Church was also divided between the High Church
party, which was oriented to the doctrines and sacraments received from
antiquity, and the Evangelical or Protestant party, which was oriented to
scripture alone. “With the Establishment thus divided and threatened”
by the liberalism of the government, Newman wrote, “I compared that
fresh vigorous power of which I was reading in the first centuries” (:
). His convictions were decidedly High Church, but he was more wary
of the rationalism of the liberals than of the emotionalism and biblicism
of the Evangelicals. Thoroughly socialized into the anti-Roman stance of
the times, he conceived of no tenable position apart from the Church of
England; yet at the same time, the (non-Roman) Catholic position forced
him to think of what transcended Anglican boundaries. “ . . . I ever kept
before me that there was something greater than the Established Church,
and that was the Church Catholic and Apostolic, set up from the begin-
ning, of which she was but the local presence and organ. She was nothing,
unless she was this” (: ).
Newman began writing tracts anonymously arguing for the Anglo
Catholic, “Via Media,” position of dogma, sacraments, and opposition
to Rome, and he was joined by others; he served for a time as editor
of a series of position papers, Tracts for the Times. However, he began
to sense that Anglo Catholicism was more a construct than a social
anthony j. blasi
reality. “Protestantism and Papacy are real religions . . . but the Via
Media, viewed as an integral system, has scarcely had an existence except
on paper” (: ). By he began to reconsider his stance; he
began to draw comparisons between the Reformation and Anglican
separations from the Roman Church and the ancient schisms that he was
studying. “Alas! it was my portion for whole years to remain without any
satisfactory basis for my religious profession, in a state of moral sickness,
neither able to acquiesce in Anglicanism, nor able to go to Rome” (:
).
It would be tempting to predict that Newman’s intellectual conclusions
would lead him to convert to Roman Catholicism. Such was simply not
the case. He was well networked in the Anglican context of Oxford,
had thrown his energies into the Tractarian cause within Anglicanism,
and had not yet called into question his received anti-Romanism, in
both its emotional and cognitive aspects. An episode in , however,
would strain his network and transform his social context, leaving him
to work out his problems with Roman Catholicism on his own. He
turned to the Articles of Faith of the Church of England, a symbol of
his religious commitments, and wrote a tract giving them a Catholic
rather than Protestant reading. There was nothing particularly Roman
Catholic about his Tract , but it certainly employed a Church Catholic
and Apostolic hermeneutic (: ). It caused a storm of criticism
from the Evangelical party, and his bishop agreed not to demand that
he withdraw it so long as he ceased from authoring or editing any
further tracts. The public uproar continued, however, and other Church
authorities began to condemn him. The result was that Newman was not
only alienated from his larger social context, but also lost his place in
the Tractarian movement to which he had devoted his energies. “I saw
indeed clearly that my place in the Movement was lost; public confidence
was at an end; my occupation was gone” (: ). He left a curate
in charge of St. Mary’s and retired to a small chapel in Littlemore. But
even in Littlemore the critics and the press would not leave him in peace.
Some undergraduates from Oxford went to Littlemore to stay with him
and work through their own issues with the Church of England, and that
led to rumors that he was founding a Roman Catholic monastery.
Meanwhile, the Church of England not only proved to be hostile to
Newman’s brand of Anglo Catholicism, but it also entertained cooper-
ation with un-Catholic factions. Specifically, in a government-inspired
counter to Russian and French influence in the Middle East, the Church
established a bishopric in Jerusalem that Prussian Lutherans and east-
the meaning of conversion
Conclusion
We began with the simple idea that conversion, especially in the reli-
gious sense, is a redirection of foundational trust. We suggested that a
focus on the redirecting, “process models” as they are usually termed,
allows for theorizing in the middle range but not for a general theoretical
framework. Focusing on the adjective foundational would lead one into
philosophical rather than social theoretical concerns. Trust, however, is a
human personal and social phenomenon in itself—though, when foun-
dational, may be oriented to the transcendent. For purposes of general
theorizing, we suggested that the general nature of social situatedness, as
approached by Georges Gurvitch, could be a useful approach. We then
explored the kinds of religious phenomena that arise within the ten lay-
ers or realms of social reality that Gurvitch suggests, often finding the
potential for engendering conversion within them. However, the align-
ing of events across layers seemed to be the most intriguing approach to
conversion.
We examined two cases of conversion—one of them looking at a
group situation and one of them the conversion of an individual. In the
case of the group study, that of the Vineyard congregations, the use of
social layers in the manner of Gurvitch for purposes of interpretation
enabled us to see the pattern of late adolescent management of peer
material culture and family values being preserved in the kind of church
to which the converts turn. The individuals who converted were no
longer adolescents managing the juxtaposition of peer material culture
and family values but parents creating space for their own children to
do so. In the case of the individual, we saw the trajectory of change of
church membership on the part of John Henry Newman proceeding in
parallel to but not in lock-step with his intellectual itinerary. The change
in church membership was related to the breakdown of his relationship to
the Anglican Church as an organization, of his place in the role patterns
of Oxford, and his suddenly tenuous place in the social movement to
which he had devoted his energies. In this instance, Newman was not
swept up into a social network offering affective bonds, as often reported
in the conversions to new religions of the s, but had to seek out a
new network.
the meaning of conversion
References
Albrecht, Stan L., and Marie Cornwall. . “Life Events and Religious Change.”
Review of Religious Research : –.
Ammerman, Nancy Tatom. . Baptist Battles. Social Change and Religious
Conflict in the Southern Baptist Convention. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers
University Press.
Babchuck, Nicholas and Hugh P. Whitt. . “R-order and Religious Switching.”
Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion : –.
Ballis, Peter H. . Leaving the Adventist Ministry: A Study of the Process of
Exiting. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Bankston, William B., Craig J. Forsyth, and H. Hugh Floyd, Jr. . “Toward
a General Model of the Process of Radical Conversion: An Interactionist
Perspective on the Transformation of Self-Identity.” Qualitative Sociology :
–.
Becker, Howard. . Systematic Sociology. New York: Wiley.
Bellah, Robert N. . “Civil Religion in America.” Daedalus : –.
Blasi, Anthony J. . Segregationist Violence and Civil Rights Movements in
Tuscaloosa. Washington, DC: University Press of America.
———. . “On the Social Affinity between Religion and Values. A Multi-
disciplinary Consideration.” Pp. – in Values and Post-Soviet Youth. The
Problem of Transition, edited by Luigi Tomasi. Milano: FrancoAngeli.
———. . “Età e Fede Cristiana tra Religiosi ed ex Religiosi di Comunità
Maschili e Femminili.” Concilium : –.
Blumer, Herbert. . “Collective Behavior.” Pp. – in Principles of Sociol-
ogy, edited by Alfred McClung Lee. New York: Barnes & Noble.
Campbell, Colin. . “The Cult, the Cultic Milieu and Secularization.” A
Sociological Yearbook of Religion in Britain : –. London: SCM Press.
Campbell, Ernest Q. and Thomas F. Pettigrew. . “Racial and Moral Crisis:
The Role of Little Rock Ministers.” American Journal of Sociology : –.
Carmona, Francisco J. . Cambios en la identitad católica: juventud de Alfonso
Carlos Comím. Madrid: Libertarias/Prodhufi.
Casanova, José. . Public Religions in the Modern World. Chicago: University
of Chicago Press.
Downton, James V., Jr. . “An Evolutionary Theory of Spiritual Conversion
and Commitment: The Case of Divine Light Mission.” Journal for the Scientific
Study of Religion : –.
Ebaugh, Helen Rose and Janet Saltzman Chafetz. . Religion and the New
Immigrants. Continuities and Adaptations in Immigrant Congregations. Wal-
nut Creek, CA: AltaMira.
Flora, Cornelia Butler. . “Social Dislocation and Pentecostalism: A Multi-
variate Analysis” Sociological Analysis : –.
Geoffroy, Martin and Jean-Guy Vaillancourt. . “The New Pilgrimage—
Return to Tradition or Adaptation to Modernity? The Case of Saint Joseph’s
Oratory, Montreal.” Pp. – in On the Road to Being There: Studies in
Pilgrimage and Tourism in Late Modernity, edited by William H. Swatos, Jr.
Leiden: Brill.
anthony j. blasi
Quinley, Harold E. . The Prophetic Clergy. Social Activism among Protestant
Ministers. New York: Wiley.
Rambo, Lewis. . Understanding Religious Conversion. New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press.
Schutz, Alfred. []. “Max Scheler’s Philosophy.” Pp. – in Col-
lected Papers III: Studies in Phenomenological Philosophy, edited by Ilse
Schutz. The Hague: Nijhoff.
Shibley, Mark A. . “The Californication of American Evangelicalism: De-
viance and Cultural Accommodation in a Midwest Vineyard Congregation.”
Pp. – in Sex, Lies, and Sanctity: Religion and Deviance in Contemporary
North America, edited by Mary Jo Neitz and Marion S. Goldman. Greenwich,
CT: JAI Press.
Simmel, Georg. . Soziologie. Untersuchungen über die Formen der Verge-
sellschaftung. Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot.
Singer, Merrill. . “The Social Context of Conversion to a Black Religious
Sect.” Review of Religious Research : –.
Smilde, David. . “A Qualitative Comparative Analysis of Conversion to
Venezuelan Evangelism: How Networks Matter.” American Journal of Soci-
ology : –.
Smith, Christian. . Resisting Reagan: The U.S. Central America Peace Move-
ment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Sorokin, Pitirim A. –. Social and Cultural Dynamics ( vols.). New
York: American Book Company (vols. –) and Bedminster Press (vol. ).
Staples, Clifford L. and Armand L. Mauss. . “Conversion or Commitment?
A Reassessment of the Snow and Machalek Approach to the Study of Con-
version.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion : –.
Tamney, Joseph B. . An Exploratory Study of Religious Conversion. Unpub-
lished Ph.D. dissertation, Cornell University.
———. . The Resilience of Conservative Religion: The Case of Popular, Con-
servative Protestant Congregations. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Tong, Chee Kiong. . “Changing Lives, Switching Faiths: Religious Conver-
sion and Participation in Singapore.” Pp. – in Religions sans Fron-
tières?: Present and Future Trends of Migration, Culture, and Communication,
edited by Roberto Cipriani. Rome: Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.
Troeltsch, Ernst. . The Social Teaching of the Christian Churches. London:
Allen & Unwin.
Tygart, Clarence E. . “Social Movement Participation: Clergy and the Anti-
Vietnam War Movement.” Sociological Analysis : –.
Wallace, Ruth A. . “A Model of Change of Religious Affiliation.” Journal for
the Scientific Study of Religion : –.
———. . They Call Her Pastor: A New Role for Catholic Women. Albany: State
University of New York Press.
———. . They Call Him Pastor: Married Men in Charge of Catholic Parishes.
Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press.
Warner, R. Stephen and Judith G. Wittner (eds.). . Gatherings in Diaspora:
Religious Communities and the New Immigration. Philadelphia: Temple Uni-
versity Press.
chapter two
Kieran Flanagan
A curious facet of Weber’s ideal type has been the expansion of its
use from conceptual categorizations into the construction of person-
ages equally abstract but set as the imaginary friends of sociology, ones
it chooses to designate. These personages of the sociological imagina-
tion give witness to the capacity of the discipline to personify the needs
and cultural practices of the age in ways no rivals can realize. Wrested
from the flux of life and mounted as in tableaux, these personages are
the trophies of sociology, the prizes of its gift to encapsulate the cul-
tural moment. Thus, the flâneur is lodged to signify the idle gazer whose
exercise is so characteristic of modernity; Max Weber’s Calvinist stands
as the manqué capitalist, the unwilling beneficiary of worldly efforts to
resolve his salvation anxiety; the curious figures of Erving Goffman’s
world all stand out enigmatically, an array including the stigmatized,
lunatics, impression managers and gamblers; and then there is Simmel’s
stranger, the image and likeness of the sociologist, the one who passes
with impunity across territories, hearing confessions but giving no abso-
lution. Gazing more closely, one figure is missing: the convert.
Zygmunt Bauman’s diagnosis of the culture of postmodernity might
account for this absence. He has further nominations better fitted to the
times. His exemplary figures for the pantheon are the strollers and the
players, the tourists and the vagabonds, the last two being nominated
as the heroes and victims of postmodernity. These four types sing often
discordantly in a postmodern chorus (: –; : –). They
denote the transience of life in postmodernity, where the indefinite, the
contingent and the ambiguous endlessly expand into limitless uncer-
tainty whose nihilism justifies escape as the motif of the age. Stoicism
reflects the demands of these times of fracture and doubt when it is nec-
essary to accept that the “well constructed identity turns from asset into
liability” and that the “the hub of postmodern life strategy is not identity
building, but the avoidance of being fixed” (: ).
kieran flanagan
cultural sensibilities. Yet, it is in these hard forms that the convert takes
on heroic properties as redemption is sought in a world increasingly con-
stituted by reference to sociological argot. Resistance, transgressions and
crossings characterize these hard forms of conversions where turnings
are not to be taken lightly and where the identities so secured reflect striv-
ings and strategies worthy of sociological interrogation.
Organized religions, such as Catholicism offer means of channeling
forms of spirituality in ways where their authenticity can be given credi-
ble and authoritative designations. Its theology certifies what is worthy of
emulation by reference to tradition and to codifications of belief. Thus,
spiritual manifestations that bear on conversion can be contextualized
and placed in an inheritance of discernment of such visits from the Holy
Spirit. What is worthy of emulation can be stipulated in ways that relate
to sociology, notably in the case of Weber’s notion of office charisma.
These two strands of spirituality operate in competition (Flanagan and
Jupp ) but with implications for how sociology is to understand con-
version.
Unlike the case of holistic spirituality, ecclesial forms of spirituality
make definite demands on the convert. He is required to move across
boundaries, from unbelief to belief, from affiliations treated as insecure
to those designated as secure and from forms of spirituality treated as
untrustworthy to those deemed trustworthy. For that reason, the hard
forms of conversion require a factual property, so that the turning made
by the convert is permanent not temporary, is definite and not indefinite,
and the transformation secured requires reference to the social to state
in public that a change in affiliations has occurred. The convert finds in
the authority of the belief system resources that enable him to believe in
his own conversion and to trust that he will become what is promised by
his turning into the occupation of a new identity where the older form
has been cast off.
These hard and soft forms of conversion present matters of choice to
the sociologist. Is the soft version preferable for its agnostic properties
that seem to reflect the professional obligations of the sociologist not to
occupy a definite religious stance? After all, the soft version reflects the
times sociologists are called to refract, but the mirroring has limitations.
The individualism of the soft version presupposes weak structures and
few entailments to use the social as a means of manifestation of belief and
of certifications of its acceptance by converts. On the other hand, the hard
version seems to carry a price of giving some unwarranted credibility to
forms of theology inimical to sociological speculation. But then it does
kieran flanagan
In the famous essay of Georg Simmel, the stranger was the Jewish
trader, one whose wandering status gave him a capacity for objectifica-
tion because of his travels across boundaries. Being without the need
to root commitment, the stranger receives all manner of confidences.
He does not judge, has no local interests to negotiate, and is not com-
promised by any confidences. His transience enables him to see across
boundaries what those who live within them cannot (Simmel : –
). So, given that the stranger makes no conversion and derives his
enigmatic status from not making commitments, why make a parallel
with the convert?
Both have a property of transience, of moving across boundaries with
a mysterious ability. In that regard they share Simmel’s notion of “the
potential wanderer.” Each begs questions as to whether they will move
on or settle. Each stands enigmatically to those to whom they have come,
each sharing a common position that “is determined, essentially, by the
fact that he has not belonged to it from the beginning, that he imports
into it, which do not and cannot stem from the group itself ” (: ).
It is for this reason the convert unsettles. The basis of his definition of the
situation can generate perplexities difficult to resolve for those he left and
those whom he wishes to join.
The definition of the situation refers to the processes of examination
and deliberation surrounding events and circumstances that need to be
defined. These bear on the personality of the actor for they mark his
whole life-policy. Definitions need to reconciled between those society
invokes and those to which the actor aspires. The discrepancies between
both suggest a disjunction between fact and aspiration (Thomas :
–). The convert has changed his definition of the situation but with
what implications?
the concern with conversion. Those who buckle before this compassion
and convert might confirm the notion that converts act from positions of
weakness and that they have no “good” reasons for their conversion. But
the powers of modernity yield strange ambiguities. Conversion might
well be an instrument of oppression, but it can also be a resource for
emancipation. It can be invoked by converts who change identities to
liberate the oppressed. Thus, far from being an act of weakness, conver-
sion can also be a gesture of strength, an exercise in heroic virtue, one
occasioned by the particular properties of modernity.
In the case of India, the advent of modernity and secularization gen-
erated a peculiar paradox. Instead of leading to religious indifference,
these processes operated to accentuate a sense of difference between all
the major religions in India. In this context, the convert emerged as an
inconvenient category of considerable cultural, religious and legal signifi-
cance. Almost reluctantly, the legal apparatus of the state was drawn into
judgment on the civil rights of converts from Hinduism to Christian-
ity in relation to marriage settlements and inheritance. Complications
emerged for the state in reconciling indigenous legal frameworks and
customs formulated by reference to Hinduism with principles derived
from English law, based on notions of right arbitrated by appeal to rea-
son but also to Christian principles. To secure civil order, the response of
the state to matters presented for its judgment was to conceive conver-
sion less in terms of religious belief and more as a category of identifi-
cation whose disruptive outcomes the colonizing state sought to control
(Viswanathan : xii).
It is against this background that Viswanathan’s main thesis emerges
“that conversion is a subversion of secular power” (: ). She treats
the conversions of Newman and Ambedkar “as critiques of the failure of
secular ideologies to extend full political rights” (: ). The convert
appeals to a higher authority for his right to cross religious and cultural
boundaries in order to reconstitute their basis in the light of the failure
of the state to fulfill its promise to do so. Appeals to the supreme claims
of reason in matters of law are always thwarted by reference to a higher
court, one whose judgments are formed by reference to religion. When
the state fails, then religion becomes the resource of the oppressed. It is
used to galvanize the marginal and to give to them a vision of ultimate
redress beyond that which the civil apparatus can invoke. The American
civil rights movement illustrates this point.
Religion generates a power to mobilize but also to enshrine what is of
sacred value in a culture. When this sense of the sacred is ruptured as in
kieran flanagan
equality he sought for his people. In this way, the category of the convert
facilitated their liberation from economic, occupational and cultural
servitude (Tartakov : –).
Controversies surrounding conversions in India still surface even after
Independence. According a BBC News report () an amendment
to the law relating to conversions was proposed by the Gujarat Gov-
ernment (in the hands of the Hindu party—the BJP) to protect low
caste Hindus. Buddhism and Jainism were re-classified as branches of
the Hindu religion, so that conversions between these were treated as
“inter-denomination conversion,” thus leaving converts to Christianity
and Islam open to fines and imprisonment. The tolerance Christianity
gives to Islam in the West, expressed in laws against religious discrimi-
nation, is not often reciprocated. Converts from Islam to Christianity in
Saudi Arabia and Malaysia and other countries are not legally recognized
by the state. A report from Christian Solidarity Worldwide, entitled No
Place to Call Home claimed that even in the United Kingdom “apostates”
from Islam face “gross and wide-ranging” human rights abuses (Church
Times ).
Modernity seems to have a peculiar power to enhance awareness of
the dangers surrounding conversion. Because it can be subject to politi-
cization, expectations of response and redress increase, not decrease, in
ways particular to modernity. This awareness of the dangers surround-
ing conversion can become all too apparent when attention is directed
to religions that claim a monopoly on Divine revelation as in the cases
of Judaism, Islam and Christianity. As religions of the Book, conver-
sion represents a change in regard to which form of Revelation is to
be recognized. Thus, conversions are not simply matters of changes in
identity, but of switches that go to the heart of theological dispute as to
how God reveals Himself and to whom, with obviously binding conse-
quences. This generates acute worries of over who should be converted
and how those targeted will respond. Thus, much publicity surrounded
a motion tabled for the General Synod of the Church of England in July
that Muslims should be targeted for conversion. The motion was
eventually withdrawn. Similar difficulties have arisen over the Good Fri-
day prayers of intercession in the revived Extraordinary Rite (Tridentine
mass) where Benedict XVI encountered considerable hostility from Jews
who felt threatened by the notion that they should receive the light of
faith to convert.
The controversies surrounding these prayers can traced back to the
dilemmas Paul faced in seeking to bind Jews into a Christian life. The
kieran flanagan
prayers go to the heart of the truth claims of Christianity that it has a New
Covenant expressed in a New Testament. The legacy of the Holocaust
hangs heavily in this area, adding a further complexity to the category of
the convert in ways peculiar to modernity. In turn, it generates paradoxes
that are peculiar to the status of conversion, where those who do not
convert might claim a heroic status. The examples one has in mind
are Henri Bergson and Simone Weil who, although wishing to convert,
refused to do so in solidarity with their fellow Jews who were suffering
and dying in concentration camps in Germany and elsewhere. Another
complexity emerges surrounding the issue of conversion. Even though
they did not convert, by being baptized, they could be deemed in Catholic
theology to succeed by default. In their refusal they could be regarded as
having received a baptism of desire. But accepting this form of baptism
might be to endorse the thorny notion that outside the Church there is
no salvation (D’Costa ). Baptism of desire would seem to resolve the
salvation anxieties of potential converts and the worries of those already
converted. In this context, sociology’s handling of conversion enters a
theological minefield, one that is laid out in response to perceptions of
modernity and the need to adjust ecclesial teaching accordingly. Since
Vatican II, if not before, this belief that outside the Church there is no
salvation has been discounted, if not treated as heretical.
But here one encounters a fault-line running between sociology and
theology. Intolerant of the indefinite, as in the case of the application
of rational choice theory to religion, sociology inclines to a far more
hard-line approach than theologians to the matter of the goods requi-
site for salvation. Because sociology inclines towards monopolistic views
of organized religion, it requires sanctions to underpin the exercise of
power and how these relate to the afterlife. Thus, perhaps, unsurpris-
ingly Weber asserted that “extra ecclesiam nulla salus is the motto of all
churches” (cited in Verter : ). This stipulation of Weber flows into
Bourdieu. It will not be forgotten that Weber’s great work The Protestant
Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism was hinged around the issue of salva-
tion anxiety. It might seem that liberal equivocations over the efficacy of
goods for salvation convert a crucial plank of sociological characteriza-
tions of culture into a beam riddled with theological dry rot and unsafe
to affirm. In response, is sociology to formulate its own theology of the
afterlife, but with no authority to do so? A hard-line-position on salva-
tion would greatly simplify sociological characterizations of conversion.
Having uncovered the significance of the category of the convert and
the definiteness of its basis in Indian responses to modernity, it might
conversion: heroes and their sociological redemption
seem odd to find that in modern Catholicism the process has become
slightly indefinite but also more complicated for sociological interven-
tions.
In his admirable effort to make consistent statistics on Catholicism in
England and Wales, Anthony Spencer draws attention to the complexities
surrounding the term “convert” which includes baptisms for those over
seven and also receptions of adults (: –). Allowing for a number
of qualifications on the data, his exercise in religious demography in
England and Wales shows a fall in the number of converts from about
, in to , in (: ). Spencer well illustrates the
complexities surrounding the category of the convert, notably over who
is to be counted as one.
These complexities further emerge in regard to the form of instruc-
tion now used for potential converts in Catholicism. The Rite of Chris-
tian Initiation of Adults (RCIA) was specifically formulated to meet
the circumstances of conversion in the setting of modernity. Yamane
and MacMillen indicate “its normative candidate for initiation . . . is an
unbaptized, uncatechized adult” (: ). But in their study, only
one third of adults initiated are unbaptized, the remainder being either
reverts or members of other churches. Ecumenical sensitivities might
generate queries as to whether those already baptized are to be treated as
converts. This points to a further complication in recent Catholic under-
standings of conversion.
In Catechism of the Catholic Church, while baptism is treated as “the
first and fundamental conversion,” it is penance that is designated as the
sacrament of conversion (: –). Thus in the subject index of
the Catechism the term conversion is cross-referenced to contrition. This
shifting of the term to ongoing conversion marks a distance from older
understandings of baptism as solely supplying the necessary goods to
achieve salvation. This sense of distancing from baptism as the entry
ticket to heaven finds expression also in the debate in contemporary
Catholicism surrounding the abolition of limbo, the place where unbap-
tized infants went. If limbo is abolished, a well understood right and duty
of lay Catholics to baptize in emergency is undermined with concomi-
tant effects on the wider issue of conversion. Rendering some goods for
salvation unnecessary can mean that some potential converts feel it not
so imperative to be baptized.
The change in emphasis might be a response to the fall in the use
of confession. To counteract this decline in use, it might seem that the
nature of conversion has been changed in a crucial way, one that involves
kieran flanagan
former times, fear of damnation was a sound motive to convert. Sin was
felt deeply and the stewardship of the soul was exercised in a scrupulous
manner that now would border on the theologically eccentric. But if in
the light of modernity, theologians have drawn the sting from death in
terms of its fate in the afterlife and have taken the fear away, unexpectedly
sociologists have stepped into the breach to press the claims for the
stewardship of the soul, obligations that find expression in Verter’s notion
of spiritual capital.
In his use, spiritual capital has three forms: embodied, objectified, and
institutional. It is the first one that is of significance here. Verter argues
that the embodied state refers to “the knowledge, abilities, tastes and
credentials an individual has amassed in the field of religion.” Almost
as a larder, this state stocks the goods for salvation which the convert
feels called on to raid, whatever the entailments. These entailments find
expression in the notion of habitus (disposition), “the socially structured
mode of apprehending and acting in the world.” The convert aspires to
inhabit this embodied form of spiritual capital, to naturalize it in terms
of his habitus and to render it his own. This process bears similarities to
Ricoeur’s notion of appropriation in regard to hermeneutics. If zealous,
the convert seeks to consume the resources of spiritual capital in the
most efficacious and competent manner possible. But embodied forms of
spiritual capital need a relational dimension, and this is to be found in the
objectified version. It refers to objects, artifacts and texts of and for belief
(Verter : ). The convert’s desire is to fuse both forms efficaciously.
To actualize his conversion he has to implicate himself in the use of both.
This strategy bears on Verter’s point that “assessing the labor value of
investment in spiritual capital may help to understand the trajectory of
conversion careers” (: ). This trajectory involves reference to the
strategies set to realize the performative identity of being a convert, but
also the embodiment that needs to be taken into account to secure such
“passing.”
A little used concept of Bourdieu, hexis illuminates these processes.
Bourdieu links hexis to Goffman’s notion of decorum and refers to forms
of regulation of the body, its manner of appearing that signifies the
realization of a belief but also its embodiment in a mode recognizable
to others. The term is linked to habitus, where disposition strives to
regulate the body in a durable form of manifestation cast to display the
knowing that constitutes an identity, sexual in Bourdieu’s use, religious
in this context. Hexis refers to the aspiration “to evoke the whole system
of which it is part” (Bourdieu : –). The term signifies a knowing
kieran flanagan
striving to employ hexis to Divine ends, both the zealous Catholic and the
guilt-ridden Bevindelijken reveal heroic properties in their conversion as
they struggle against presumption and skepticism in a cultural climate
unfavorable to their efforts to render conversion an ongoing project and
where redemption is to be sought but not assumed to be found in one
solitary act of turning.
In his study Belzen reveals an unexpected point. He writes “I have tried
to get as close to bevindelijken conversion as seemed possible without,
however, ever becoming ‘one of them,’ without any inside experience of
their religiosity of my own” (: ). The study of their conversion
generated a risk that he, the sociologist, would go native, that he would
convert. What if the study of religious conversions generated habits of
affiliation in the sociologist in ways Pascal noted above? One outcome
would be the corruption of the sociological gaze and a breach of Bour-
dieu’s injunction to keep a distance in the study of religion.
But what is presented as a professional stance masks a secular inhi-
bition, one that sociology imposes on itself in the study of religion, not
to convert most especially when the focal point of the research is con-
version. Yet, secularization generates a paradox, one that Bruce Kapferer
claims anthropology is the first to encounter: the limits “to the rational-
ity and reasoning of the demythologized and secular realities integral to
its very invention.” In facing this paradox, “anthropology is secularism’s
doubt” (: –). Matters have taken a more pressing turn with
the admission of reflexivity into the domain of sociological deliberations.
Distance no longer suffices, for proximity to those under study is now a
disciplinary entailment, one that is both moral and methodological. The
need to represent the tribe presupposes an empathy with their sensibili-
ties. If this is so, is it to be argued that reflexivity exercised in the religious
domain requires that spiritual sensibilities be lobotomized lest the soci-
ologist loses his analytical marbles and capitulates to the unthinkable: his
own conversion?
that risked going too far to the point of forgetting the Enlightenment,
which he treats “as part of a movement of emancipation from religion”
(Fabian : xi). There is a Weberian cast to his worry that such conver-
sions breached the integrity of the discipline. In other words, any conver-
sion no matter how bizarre is acceptable as long as it is not to Catholicism!
Here one encounters a willful amnesia. The English character of social
anthropology, valued by so many, doubtlessly was greatly influenced by
Durkheim, but much more significantly, it was shaped more by Catholi-
cism than many now would like to admit. Mary Douglas, Victor and
Edith Turner and, perhaps most notably Edward Evans-Pritchard were
Catholics. Except for Douglas, they were all converts. But did these con-
versions render them heroes for the power they exhibited to cross dis-
ciplinary boundaries between theology and anthropology, or did their
crossing generate unsettlements best not signified by those who act as
guardians of the latter’s sacred identity? The account of the Turners’ con-
version to Catholicism is likely to upset these guardians: It was unex-
pected. It was in the “wrong” direction. It should not have happened,
most especially to two important anthropologists.
Earlier in their career, the Turners had converted to Marxism, so
turning was not an unfamiliar exercise. As an outcome of their first
exercises in fieldwork that dealt with the Ndembu rituals, they returned
to Manchester—not in an ecstatic state but in a state of dissatisfaction.
They wanted to know about religious rituals for comparative purposes,
and the fact that they were in Manchester did not hold them back. After
shopping around various churches in Manchester, they found a Catholic
church that seemed to fit their disciplinary needs. There amidst all the
symbols, the gestures and the atmosphere of a Mass said in Latin, where
the ritual occupied a “strange liminal world,” Edith whispered “Vic! It’s
like Africa.” Thus, it was in a Catholic church in Manchester that they
felt a call to convert. They acted on it. As Edith Turner noted “we went
to see the priest to take instruction. This wasn’t research any more, this
was serious” (: –). After instruction for six months, the whole
family was received into the Catholic Church.
Their conversion, which emerged from what they considered purely
an exercise in fieldwork, had a parallel with the experience of Paul
Claudel, the famous French dramatist. He too went to a service, Vespers
on Christmas Day at Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris, solely to gather
material for a book he was writing. He had to return to building on
that day as he had attended a High Mass there earlier “without any great
pleasure.” In the midst of Vespers he experienced a profound experience,
kieran flanagan
ience. Yet, this reticence had one advantage: no other sociologist could
hex what was in my mind, for in there the transformation occurred. The
conversion was radical: it was a capricious switching of the self, rather like
what occurs in an old fashioned wall clock, where one figure comes out a
door, vanishes, and emerges as something different. This particular con-
version experience might well have been about two selves, one old that
vanished and one new that came suddenly, all in instance. Kolakowski
describes the process well when he suggests that “conversion is a radical
intellectual or spiritual turning point leading to comprehensive under-
standing of the world, free of uncertainty, resolving all theoretical and
practical questions, and eliminating all doubts” (: ).
Despite impeccably sociological supervisors and already working in a
department of sociology, I have always had a property of being in exile
in the discipline and in occupation of another. Part of the reticence sur-
rounding the conversion might have been due to doing a D.Phil. thesis,
decidedly historical, but sociological in cast. Its title (passed in ) was:
“The Rise and Fall of the Celtic Ineligible: Competitive Examinations for
the Irish and Indian Civil Services in Relation to the Educational and
Occupation Structure of Ireland: –.” Only two external exam-
iners were possible: one mad and the other dead. One did not wish to
add to the eccentricity surrounding the thesis and present a career lim-
iting disclosure of a religious conversion. This was in pre-reflexive times
in the s when disciplinary proprieties had to be observed that ruled
out such startling testimonies. Anyhow, in no sense could the conversion
experience be a projection that emerged during research.
From Dublin, with a middle class background, I studied at University
College, Dublin then went on to the University of Minnesota for an M.A.
in historical sociology, conferred in . In that time, I was impeccably
lapsed from Catholicism. The pseudo-radicalism of the chaplaincy in
response to the Vietnam War fuelled the exit role. Somehow Catholicism
as practiced there seemed cast in clothing donned by self-proclaimers,
broadcasting their angsts for all with ears to hear. It all seemed egoistic,
shallow, opportunistic and deeply hypocritical. It was all like deplorable
sociology but devoid of disciplinary accountability. One’s calling as a
sociologist was even more deeply affirmed; religion had no place in it.
Coming to Bristol, antipathy to religion softened notably in response
to the Gothic but also to choral evensong, where a choir of men and
boys seemed to transform time in ways that undermined resistance to
the aesthetic side of theology. Certainly, I was not a Catholic at the time—
the category would have been refused. Yet, some sliding was occurring.
kieran flanagan
It had little to do with the gloom of being lost in a D. Phil. thesis or being
insecure in a temporary lectureship at the University of Bristol (later
made permanent). These seemed the stresses of young academic life and
in a lane certainly not pointing in a religious direction for resolution.
Going to Downside in was part of a general sense of unsettlement
and drift. The flat was drab and dreary; the food at Downside was
supposed to be excellent; all in all it was time for quick exit from the
academic coal-face. But there all things changed unexpectedly.
Frankly, insofar as a sociologist might have a conversion experience,
this one was ill-fitted. It is easier to say what it was not. It did not occur in
the field of study or in a ritual where some effervescence blew the mind
into ecstasis (hence my envy of Claudel); there was no visual or exter-
nal stimulant; there was no petition for conversion. It just happened—
completely and inexplicably in the mind. So baffling was the experience
that on immediate return to Bristol I raided a colleague’s office for a copy
of William James’ The Varieties of Religious Experience. Rapidly leafing
through two chapters on conversion, what had happened to me came
into focus. He articulated what I was clueless to express: I had had a con-
version experience. Insofar as conversion involves crossing boundaries,
my transition was one of moving slowly from history into another soci-
ological exile, this time in theology. The conversion experience made the
emergent disjunctions tolerable. One could play with impunity in the
dangerous waters of postmodernity without sociological injury. Some-
how, I could cope with antinomies, ambiguities and signs of contradic-
tion with impunity, for the transformed self was given a shell-like cover
resistant to the acids of postmodernity. The house of the self was secure.
Orthodoxy of belief seemed natural; it was the unorthodox, the liberal
theologians, who seemed “unnatural.” One knew what to believe: it was
in black and white, perhaps reflecting the conversion experience itself.
Walking slowly up to the North transept in Downside Abbey, an
impeccably Gothic building, I went past the little angel lodged on the
pillar in the aisle just before the entrance to the high altar on the left
and on to the Lady Chapel that lay behind the reredos. Even on a sunlit
morning, this area is dark. On the left at the foot of the steps up to the
Lady Chapel was a solitary prie-dieu. In front was a row of lit candles
and above a statue of the Blessed Virgin. I knelt, not bothering to look
up. Shutting my eyes, nothing happened. Then suddenly a cloud of
black filled the mind, angry, vicious and depressive, and it went down
the body like a cold poison. If a monk had come by, so evil was the
feeling that he would have been punched. Before the mind could settle
conversion: heroes and their sociological redemption
References
Patrick Michel
1 This is the conclusion to which Géraldine Mossière came after a study of works on
conversion. Mossière notes in passing that “it is not uncommon to see the authors of
these works being personally involved in their object of study, either being themselves
converted (Jules-Rosette, Rambo), or belonging to a religion of which they study the
newcomers (Köse, Setta)” (: ).
patrick michel
2 Even though this figure takes place in a context that is already strongly connoted. A
pilgrimage sets itself a goal straightaway: Rome, Compostela, Mecca, and so on. Therefore
the pilgrim has a relation to space in which space is immediately organized, mapped,
“finalized.” I would thus prefer to the models of the “pilgrim” and the “convert” the figures
of the “wanderer” and the “member,” which are more neutral (cf. Bertrand ).
patrick michel
Now that these remarks have been made, I will set out to present, without
any claim to an exhaustive list, some elements of a political sociology
of the use of the religious resources and of the meanings of this use.
In this perspective, conversion can be apprehended as an indicator and
modality of the management of a new relation by societies enmeshed in
pluralism, the set up of this relation being experienced as a destabilizing
and multiform crisis of traditional points of reference (or references
presented as such).
Michel de Certeau (: ) has noted that
Religion provides a global symbolization of their uneasiness to scattered
men, who are all the more separated from each other as their common
references are broken and they react to the pressure of a foreign culture
without order, without common courses of action, and without any means
to compensate for the anomie and disintegration. Whether it is egalitarian,
eschatological or revolutionary, a new use of religion concerns the whole
of human experience. Religious language opens on to a disarray (which
has often remained nocturnal)—an exit, like a day enlightening the nature
of the experience problem: it is the whole.
In fact, the concept of “religion” and the concepts associated with it,
such as “secularity,” or even those that can be drawn from theses on “de-
secularization,” become, in a situation of the complete social legitimacy
of the construction of a relation to meaning, more and more obscure
concepts, and therefore largely unusable, at least as long as we persist
in recognizing a relevance that would be specific to them. As a result,
“religion” is only the indicator of larger recompositions, in which it
moreover takes part as an instrument of management. Thus it makes
sense only as an intermediary object, an analyzer, which, once it is
contextualized, can turn out to be quite invaluable.
What is at stake here is the revelation, due to the dissolving work of
the global, of the loss of relevance of the criteria “traditionally” used to
justify the stable nature of identity patterns. But it is not an absolute loss:
the criteria are somewhat recycled, given a new meaning because of the
very circulation to which the loss of relative relevance gives rise. In other
words, this oscillation doubly constitutes a strong indicator of the identity
deregulation and the space where the work of redefinition takes place.
The oscillation thus becomes the major characteristic of a landscape
where identities are felt to be simultaneously waiting for organizing
centralities, in a situation of ceaseless circulation between the different
supplies of articulated centrality and of the inevitable relativization of the
content of these supplies. This, of course, does not imply that joining—
converting—such and such supply cannot take place at a given time
and for a given time. Individuals acquire, in the words of Marc Augé
(: ), “cosmologies portable”—individualized cosmologies that can
be made to fit a person’s situation as circumstances require.
Of what, in this landscape, is “conversion” the sign?
First, conversion shows the unbridled pluralization of the religious
supply. This is obvious, but it has nonetheless to be emphasized. For, so
that one “can turn away in order to turn toward,” there needs to be an
opportunity. But this pluralization of the religious supply must here be
understood as one of the facets of a larger process in the evolution of soci-
eties, where the fiction of homogeneity tends to substitute itself for the
obviousness of pluralism. This can be verified in all the registers, whether
the issue is the acceleration of the passage to so-called multi-racial or
multi-ethnic societies; claims aiming at taking into account and respect-
ing the rights of more and more visible minorities, whatever the displayed
criterion of difference (sexual, skin color, origin, denomination, specific
memory); the outbreak in the number of family “models” that can be
observed; or more simply the capacity felt by an individual to establish
patrick michel
The distinctive feature shared by the two religions that are rising the
fastest at the international level—neo-Pentecostalism and Islam—is that
they both have a specific relationship with the process of globalization,
which is reorganizing the world stage. Both authorize the articulation of
a renewed relation to the world in its transformations.
Renovated Pentecostalism does not try very hard to hide its close links
with a specifically North American conservative conception of society
and the world. In this conception, of which it is one of the major vehicles,
the frontiers between politics, religion, economy and ideology tend to
fade or even disappear. The collapse of communism has most certainly
deprived this movement of the enemy that endowed it with a certain
meaning, but insofar as it is interpreted as a sign of a godsend, this
very collapse draws the horizon of a planet painted with the American
colors—a project that is given form by a “prosperity theology” at the
service of the “mission” that America would have to carry through.
According to this vision, the relation to Islam is essential, since radical
Islam appears just as well to be the other religion and the religion of the
Other, which would back up the existence of a “clash of civilizations” in
which, like the East-West axis before, the United States would embody
Good.
This parallel with radical Islam is also likely to make sense in the reg-
ister of contemporary identities and of the generalized oscillation they
would experience because of the recompositions induced by the global-
ization of the economy and culture. As this radical Islam would be a pure
product of the confrontation with Western modernity that is simultane-
ously desired and rejected, a privileged space where fantasies and frustra-
tions are articulated, the progress of conservative Evangelicalism would
constitute, as such, an interpretative grid to approach the modalities of
management of the reconstruction of identitary mechanisms allowing
it to come to grips with the movement. And, in the final analysis—
patrick michel
But this reading through discontinuity once again does not do justice
to a complexity that is greater than one might think by looking at only one
chronology. For example, the failure in Latin America of “Liberation The-
ology,” hostile to mainstream liberalism, led to a “Prosperity Theology”
in phase with North American neo-Conservatism. The true continuity
lies indeed in the tenacious effort made by societies to create the modal-
ities allowing people to live as comfortably as possible in the world that
is taking shape. The social movement toward which Liberation Theology
tended also constituted a privileged space of invention and experience
for the individual.
Conversion to neo-Pentecostalism, which opens the horizon to Pros-
perity, also aims, still on the basis of Latin American experience, to allow
the emergence of the individual, by extricating him from the constraints
of the community, which have supposedly stifled him. But this means
that he is even more subjected to a real formatting, which implies the
gathering of all the available information on the convert, who is called to
subject himself to the institution and is totally taken charge of, as far as
both his schedule (Bible reading, prayer, singing, sermons, group activ-
ities) and the reorganization of his social relationships are concerned.3
How can someone be excluded when the submission to God required by
Prosperity Theology does not eventually constitute a stage in a process
in which this submission would potentially become an instrument in the
hands of an individual who is likely to invent his autonomy thanks to it?
In fact, when one considers the world-wide rise of neo-Pentecostalism
(, conversions a day throughout the world),4 as when one speaks of
globalized Islam, does one talk first of religion or of the way globalization
can been seen through the particular prism of the religious, that is to say,
and more precisely, through the way it is being mobilized?
Regarding the French example, the conversions of original Christians
play a marginal role in an evolution that leads Islam to be the second reli-
gion of the country as far as the number of believers is concerned. The
only “statistically significant phenomenon” concerns, as Claude Dargent
3 His budget is also checked. This formatting of the individual, which is the result
million out of billion Christians; it is estimated that , conversions happen
everyday. There are already , evangelical denominations consisting of million
Churches, led by million ministers working full time” (Zeghidour ).
patrick michel
Khosrokhavar (: ), who “mentions the case of young women seduced by the
relative freedom that exists in Christianity, in particular in its Protestant version, and of
young men who also converted—for instance former drug-addicts who converted after
undergoing treatment for drug addiction in a Christian facility.”
elements for a semiotics of “conversion”
France (or Germany, Great Britain, the Netherlands) are not Muslim and
are not supposed to become Muslim. Although conversion is a process
of (re)identification, it is also and eventually based, between metaphor
and euphemism, on verifying the capacity of the religious to make this
(re)identification possible. Although conversion constitutes the space
where one can construct a reference exteriority that has to be invoked
in order to be used to take a stand on the movement (and therefore the
emergence of the individual in line with this), no essentialism appears to
be involved here—that is, there is no need to call for contents of belief.
What is centrally at stake is the operationality of this exteriority.
In a situation of oscillation, the identitary claim prevails, de facto,
over any adherence to content or to a definition of identity through
the content. This content—which is always presented as stable, but is
in fact always the result of a process aiming at inventing it, since this
alleged stability is an integral part of the process of invention, of which
it simultaneously is a major condition—is always simply the medium of
the information. As such, it is of course likely to be reinterpreted, in order
to submit it to the constraints that a modification in the context would
put on the initial assertion. In that sense, as Nathalie Clayer (: )
notes in the case of Albania, “ ‘conversions’ are like many sociopolitical
assertions. Thus, for instance, ‘conversions’ to Christianity are often a way
of expressing one’s adhesion to the Western world. The reassertion of
a Muslim identity is often a request to re-assess a sociopolitical status
rather than a religious assertion as such.”
In conclusion, this is another way of saying that thinking “conversion”
is solely a religious assertion partakes of the same logic as the one we can
imagine inspired Robert M. Pirsig when he gave the title Zen and the Art
of Motorcycle Maintenance to a book in which he only allusively treated
the issue of Zen and even more incidentally referred to motorcycle
maintenance. But after all, although it is very hard to find a black cat in a
dark room (especially when there is no cat), the most difficult thing is still
to understand how someone can, in such a situation, suddenly exclaim:
“That’s it, I have found it!”
patrick michel
References
Augé, Marc. . Pour une anthropologie des mondes contemporains. Paris:
Flammarion.
Berger, Peter, Grace Davie and Effie Fokas. . Religious America, Secular
Europe?: A Theme and Variations. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
Bréchon, Pierre. . “L’Évolution du religieux,” Futuribles : –.
Bertrand, Romain. . “Pèlerinages politiques,” Politix : –.
Certeau, Michel de. L’Absent de l’Histoire. Paris: Repères-Mame, Paris, .
———. . “L’Institution du croire.” Recherches de Science Religieuse : –.
Clayer, Nathalie. . “Religion et nation dans les Balkans post-communistes:
Le cas de l’Albanie.” Pp. – in Religion(s) et identité(s) en Europe:
L’Epreuve du pluriel, edited by Antonela Capelle-Pogacean, Patrick Michel
and Enzo Pace. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po.
Dargent, Claude. . “Les Musulmans déclarés en France: Affirmation reli-
gieuse, subordination sociale et progressisme politique.” Les Cahiers du
CEVIPOF .
Decobert, Christian. . “Conversion, Tradition, Institution.” Archives de Sci-
ences Sociales des Religion : –.
Donnard, Giselle. . “Recension de Patrick Haenni.” http://multitudes
.samizdat.net/Recension-de-Patrick-Haenni-L ( September).
Drewermann, Eugen. . “L’Europe Chrétienne et l’illusion de Maastricht.”
Cahiers d’Europe : –.
Fleury, Brigitte. . Étude de la conversion religieuse d’un point de vue commu-
nicationnel: Le cas de Roger Garaudy. Master’s thesis. Department of Com-
munications, University of Quebec at Montreal.
Greil, Arthur.L. and David R. Rudy. . “Conversion to the Worldview of
Alcoholics Anonymous: A Refinement of Conversion Theory.” Qualitative
Sociology : –.
———. . “What Have We Learned from Process Models of Conversion? An
Examination of Ten Case Studies.” Sociological Focus : –.
Haenni, Patrick. . L’Islam de marché: L’Autre révolution conservatrice. Paris:
Seuil.
Hervieu-Léger Danièle. . Le pèlerin et le converti: La religion en mouvement.
Paris: Flammarion.
———. . “Quelques paradoxes de la modernité religieuse.” Futuribles :
–.
———. . “La conversion ou choisir son identité religieuse.” www.cnrs.fr/
presse/thema/.htm.
Huntington, Samuel. . The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World
Order. New York: Simon & Schuster.
———. . Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity. New
York, Simon & Schuster.
Khosrokhavar, Farhad. . L’Islam des jeunes. Paris: Flammarion.
Meintel, Deidre. . “When There is No Conversion.” Anthropologica : –
.
elements for a semiotics of “conversion”
Kees de Groot
1 In , when the data were collected, of the inhabitants were of foreign origin
(www.zoetermeer.nl).
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
happening here.” This is illustrated by the fact that the Dutch Genera-
tion X writers (including, for example, Ronald Giphart) took the city’s
name as the title for their literary magazine. Even now, the city has a
reputation for being staggeringly boring: “An exhibition of postmodern
architecture without a city life.” “A city without roots.” “A city without a
face.” However, as urbanization increases, urban issues such as vandalism
and idling, troublesome youngsters also increase.
Concerned about the social cohesion in their urbanizing suburb, the
municipality of Zoetermeer subsidized a research project of the Uni-
versity of Amsterdam to investigate the supposedly problematic situa-
tion. According to the researchers there were no severe societal prob-
lems. Yet, they advised investment in projects to strengthen ties between
inhabitants (Strengthening ties). In a scholarly article, Amsterdam urban
sociologists focused on the construction of the situation as problem-
atic and referred to this phenomenon as the tragedy of suburban resi-
dents (Van Ginkel, Deben and Lupi : ). After all, crime, street
noise, pollution, vandalism—in short: the experience of insecurity—are
the exact reasons why these people fled the big city. Tensions between
ethnic groups and between adults and youngsters spoil the suburban
dream, they concluded. Incidentally, youngsters have to do little more
than make some noise and gather in groups on the street to be consid-
ered problematic. Suburbanized people, they claimed, are simply more
sensitive to situations that interfere with their idea of peace and quiet.
Not only the absence of a sense of urgency, but also the absence of
interest in the role of religion stood out in this report. It was mentioned
neither as a source of disruption, nor as a potential for cohesion. This was
remarkable—and noticed as such by the Christian Democrats in the city
council—against the background of the growing tension in multicultural
Dutch society. After a period in which multiculturalism had dominated
public discourse, a more critical discourse about (descendants of) immi-
grants, especially from Turkey, Morocco and the African continent as a
whole took hold (Vellenga ). Global Islamist terrorism, such as the
religiously motivated attacks on New York’s Twin Towers (//),
started to influence the interpretation and evaluation of the project of
multiculturalism. It enforced the tendency to perceive immigrants as
Muslims, and to evaluate the presence of Islam in the Netherlands as neg-
ative (cf. Bauman ).
kees de groot
Suburban Theory
2 This is the purport of Baumgartner’s Moral Order of the Suburb. Her account is still
regarded as being characteristic of today’s suburbia (cf. Savage, Warde and Ward :
).
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
The data upon which I will draw were collected during a project (Septem-
ber –January ) that was initiated by the staff of the Zoeter-
meer City Museum. This direct context has influenced the selection of
the respondents. In order to understand the nature of this influence, it
is necessary to explore the wider cultural and political climate in which
this project took place (Van der Ploeg and De Groot ). “What do
our city dwellers believe?” is the intriguing question staff at the Zoeter-
meer City Museum asked themselves—intriguing not only because it is
only recently that modern times have become a topic in museums, but
also because Dutch public institutions used to leave matters of religion to
others (Kennedy ). This has been the case since the collapse of the
system of institutionally organized religious diversity known as “pillar-
ization.”
kees de groot
3 Journalists recurrently announce the end of the “God is dead” age, e.g., “God Lives”
was the title of a news feature about the “return of religion” (Vrij Nederland, April
).
4 Job Cohen elaborated his viewpoint in the Cleveringa Lecture ( November )
Collecting Believers
The aim of the project was to have the religious diversity (including non-
believers) of Zoetermeer represented in the sample. The aim was not,
therefore, to provide a representative image of the population as a whole.
An accurate representation would have required a good-sized, random
selection from the Zoetermeer population register, with all people thus
retrieved being required to cooperate. In this procedure the focus was on
5 Presentation of the museum director Jouetta van der Ploeg at the closing event
( December ); journalist René Lamers in an email to the author ( May ).
6 The continuation of the project is described in De Groot .
kees de groot
one’s individual faith, and qualitative diversity was the leading principle.
Part of the selection procedure, furthermore, was the question whether
people would be prepared to appear with their name and their photo in
the City Museum. A February article in the Haagsche Courant
launching the project was accompanied by three interviews: with a Mus-
lim, a Hindu, and a “spiritual” individual. Seven people, practicing believ-
ers or people with very outspoken views, responded to the appeal printed
in the article. Apparently, an appeal in a general medium was not enough
to recruit other respondents, including somewhat less highly profiled
believers.
Letters went out to religious groups, welfare organizations, and foreign
national organizations inviting them to give publicity to the project
among their followers. Fourteen people responded, mainly from the
Bahá"í community (who had just acquired a piece of land in Zoetermeer
to build their temple for North West Europe) and the Church of Jesus
Christ of Latter-day Saints. Almost all respondents who were approached
via their religious communities played a leading role or were well-known
within their communities. However, the majority of the respondents
were invited personally: they were relatives of friends of the interviewer,
people he met in Zoetermeer, even a lady who served his meal in a Greek
restaurant. He did not manage to get in contact with people from the
Buddhist Asian communities and from the Jehovah’s Witnesses. Three
Jewish respondents decided to call off their cooperation, because they
disliked the idea of exposing their story and their picture to anti-Jewish
sentiments. One non-denominational evangelical later withdrew from
the project. The aim to have representatives from the different religions
as well as bricoloeurs and non-believers was largely successful.
A Selective Sample
Compared with the population in general, this group shared some unique
characteristics. The age of the Zoetermeer residents who were inter-
viewed ranged from eighteen to seventy-seven. Their average age was
forty-eight. The sample is not representative, therefore, of the young
municipality of Zoetermeer. There were equal numbers of male and
female participants, and almost as many Zoetermeer respondents of for-
eign, Indonesian or Surinam, origin (), as Zoetermeer respondents of
Dutch origin (). The share of Zoetermeer residents of foreign origin in
this exhibition is therefore three times as high as the overall Zoetermeer
population ( percent).
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
7 I went through the material several times. In the first round, I used only a few
standard pre-assigned variables. During the second round I developed new ones, focusing
on the individual’s attitude toward the supply of religion and alternative worldviews. In a
third round this was corrected on the basis of a central metaphor: the relation toward
a tradition. Each relational type received its own specific items. These items together
constituted the codebook for the following rounds.
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
A Relational Typology
9 Both the approaches of Gooren () and Blasi (in this volume) are meant to find
or continue to date (polygamy). Finally, there are people who turn down
any form of relationship—out of choice or because they see no alterna-
tive. They are single.
When this diversity is applied to the religious sphere the following
pattern is shown: Many people are religious because that is how they
were brought up, although they may later also make a conscious choice
to follow this belief. While this belief may fade, it will remain part of
one’s identity (the monodox). People may also come into contact with
a belief by choice and then stick to this belief for the rest of their lives
(the neodox). After a while they may discover that their love for this
belief has worn and that another belief suits them better, perhaps inspired
by a meeting, a geographic move, or a different social circle (the serial
monodox). Others refrain from making a more or less definitive choice,
but continue to choose and combine. They continue to select from the
abundant religious supply (the polydox). Finally, there are people that
do not follow any religious traditions, but seek their own more or less
individual path (the singles). All of these religious relationship patterns
emerged during the interviews.
Before I present these, three remarks should be made. First, this soci-
ological approach distinguishes structural differences in the way indi-
viduals position themselves toward religious traditions, alternative tra-
ditions, or secular worldviews (all called doxa). It does not distinguish
between religious contents, as conventional typologies in religious stud-
ies do. Secondly, the typology is exclusively developed to interpret these
data. Usage in other contexts might prompt the addition of other cate-
gories that now remain empty and therefore unmentioned. The following
systematic account of the types will make this clear.
The typology involves three basic categories: a relation with no, one or
several traditions (single, mono, poly). Only the second category (mono)
has been refined, based on the criterion “choice” (no/yes). The latter
option has been refined again, using the question “one change or sev-
eral?” Other data might make it necessary to differentiate between indi-
viduals who are polydox through their upbringing and those who have
chosen to be so themselves, or between disaffiliated singles and singles
due to their upbringing. In this sample, the monodox prevailed, which
made it more urgent to refine this particular category. A third comment:
this categorization of individuals reflects a biographical account of one’s
religious career at a particular moment in time. Over the years, individ-
uals may receive different categorizations.
kees de groot
The Monodox
More than half of all interviewees were religious due to their upbringing.
While there was more to their stories, upbringing did form the basis for
their religious identity. A woman, fifty-four years old, tells how she was
reared by parents who were active in urban ministry. She has received
several signs that God exists. Now, she prays to “the big boss” in her own
private “little church,” upstairs in her house: “The incense, the flowers,
the music serve to comfort me. There’s also a bracelet. It was on the table
when I asked God to give the people a sign” (Stijntje Bregman). She made
a commitment later in life, while others remained fairly inactive, and one
or two had snatched bits from other religions as well. All had been reared
by their parents in a particular religious tradition.
The distinction between the culture from which they came and the
religion that went with it was often difficult to make. A forty-one year
old woman states: “was reared in Greece as an Orthodox Christian. I
went to church with my mother, though not every Sunday. When I am
in Greece, I go to church. That’s something that is a part of me, like my
native tongue” (Anna Vokorokou).
Others came from multi-religious societies, such as Surinam or In-
donesia, or were brought up in more or less oppressed minority reli-
gious communities (including the Coptic Christian minority in Egypt
or a Bahá"í family in Iran). Religion also represented ties to family and
population for these respondents.
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
The Neodox
The “new believers” at the exposition happened to be Zoetermeer resi-
dents of Dutch origin who at one time came into contact with a partic-
ular religion or denomination, wanted to become part of it, and stuck
by it. Six people told about being brought up with little or no religious
input while two others had never been able to do much with what they
had been offered in church. The presence of mosques, temples, and a
Pentecostal community in and around Zoetermeer contributed to their
change.
A wide range of events in their lives preceded their conversion: a
personal crisis, meeting a life partner, a long search for the meaning of
life, or a sudden and extraordinary experience. The transition itself was
equally different. Still, three familiar patterns of conversion stories can be
recognized in these unique and highly personal histories (McGuire :
–; cf. Burke ).
The first pattern is the story of sudden change. Such is the story of
a thirty-eight year old man whose parents got involved in a Pentecostal
congregation:
My mother was about to go there alone and I can remember I was in my
bed and suddenly I received this inspiration: “Go with her.” Which was
kind of bizarre, because I didn’t fancy the idea at all. I wasn’t happy about
my mother going there alone. I went with her. I entered the place and
had an experience with God. I realized: God is here. I felt the presence
of God’s spirit so strongly that it sent shivers down my spine. Electricity
went through me; it was like having a warm blanket put over me (Lodi
Kuijvenhoven).
Life prior to the introduction to a new world perspective changes com-
pletely, while the future takes on an entirely new dimension.
The second pattern stresses continuity. It was like meeting with an old
acquaintance. A forty-five year old woman makes it quite clear how her
experience of conversion should be understood:
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
Some four years ago, the penny dropped: I was a witch. I had been working
with herbs, gemstones and energies, such as in Reiki. I didn’t know that
Wicca existed. Then, I read about this book in a newspaper and I knew it.
I could gather it all under one denominator and that was Wicca! It was a
great sensation; a kind of confirmation (Eveliene de Bakker).
People of this type felt instantly “at home” in the new religious tradition
they encountered.
Another respondent decided to become involved with a new faith
following a period of introduction: “I did not get baptized head over
heels. I started an easy-going investigation. I went to meetings, received
teaching, studied the Scriptures. You have to be touched. Another person
cannot push you into it. I wanted to be part of that” (Patty Brouwer).
Her story followed the pattern of individual choice. She finally made her
choice after weighing up all the pros and cons.
The new faith has an impact on many aspects of a neodox’s life. Besides
spiritual growth, it involves material aspects such as finding a house and a
job. With regard to others, some believers see it as their role to contribute
to their environment’s happiness, while others see it as a witness of God’s
love. Others found the relationship with nature very important.
For some, dedication to this one religion implied distancing them-
selves from other religions and movements, under the heading “Only this
road leads to eternal life” (Lodi Kijvenhove) or the desire that everybody
follow this road: “If we were all Buddhist, there would be no more war”
(Marian Koek). For others their own (Bahá"í) community represents a
synthesis of the good found in the various religions (Peggy Hoek). A third
road is the road of respect for another person’s convictions and whose
relationship with his or her belief is probably the same as theirs (Tycho
Huijts).
Sacre Coeur and they were “dusting.” I mean: they were celebrating Mass as
if they were dusting. I thought: this can’t be. That was one of the last times
I said: I believe in Jesus. I had always been interested in the East. [ . . . ] It
took a while before I became a Buddhist. I am not the kind of person who
thinks: I don’t like this. I’ll go for something else (Ewalda Buiting).
A sixty-one year old man found Zen Buddhism via Bhagwan. He had
been a Catholic since the age of six. Before that he was “blank.” He
switched to orthodox-Calvinist Protestantism in order to marry a Dutch
Reformed girl. The marriage ended in a divorce: “Already during my
marriage, I was looking around. At first, I began to read books by Osho,
by Baghwan. I couldn’t do that when I was in that Protestant marriage”
(Ruud Bruggeman).
A sixty-three year old woman of Jewish origin tells how she ended up
in the Bahá"í Community:
When I was ten years old, my parents were baptized into the Mennon-
ite congregation, but they did not become practicing members. When I
was sixteen, I started searching. I went along with my friends to vari-
ous churches. Some time later, I met my, now, ex-husband and I stopped
“doing” religion. In about , I came into contact with the Bahá"í Com-
munity (Anneke de Lugt).
Compared with the neodox believers, the move of these respondents
was fairly undramatic. In their own perception they often did not so
much transfer to another religion, as come to the conclusion that the old
religion was no longer theirs. They wanted a religion that suited them.
In order to remain loyal to themselves, they felt it right to say goodbye
and make a fresh start. This change was sometimes inspired by school,
migration, marriage, divorce, or a deeply-felt death. Some interviewees
met other people, sometimes in Zoetermeer, who introduced them to the
new belief. In their newly found belief they found happiness, enjoyment
of life, and an insight into their lives.
The Polydox
This type does not conform to a single tradition, excluding all others, but
values one element in one tradition, something else in another tradition,
and even more aspects in a third. This so-called bricoleur was expected to
be found frequently in Zoetermeer, but this appeared not to be so. There
were only three “Sheilaists,” strictly speaking, among the respondents.
They were freely liaising with all sorts of cultures and traditions. One
woman, forty years old, devoured books about spirituality:
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
The Singles
While many were critical of the church as an institution and of the
authority of the Pope or the imam, only a few talked about distancing
themselves entirely from religious traditions and what they have to offer.
One man, thirty-seven years old, regarded religious belief as a weakness:
I am an atheist and very much against faith, because I observe that a lot of
people are being indoctrinated by leaders. Believing is a sign of weakness;
when times are rough, people seek refuge in the church. My parents were
already non-practicing, and I went to church only at Christmas or on
holidays. I reach out for support from friends, acquaintances and relatives.
Communication is important to me—television, music, the Internet—
because it provides answers to your questions. I talk to myself as well.
[ . . . ] If you try to make conscious what’s unconscious, you can feel things
happening that you want to prevent (Reinier Groeneveld).
Both of these men said one had to “enjoy life and not let anyone tell you
different.” These two men went through life without having contact with
one or more religious traditions. They remained or had become single.
11 I would like to express my gratitude to René Lamers for providing the transcribed
interviews that are presented in this article, and to Jaap van der Linden and Jouetta van
kees de groot
References
Bauman, Gerd. . The Multicultural Riddle: Rethinking National, Ethnic and
Religious Identities. New York: Routledge.
Bauman, Zygmunt. . Liquid Modernity. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Baumgartner, Mary Pat. . Moral Order of the Suburb. New York: Oxford
University Press.
Bellah, Robert N., Richard Madsen, William M. Sullivan, Ann Swidler, and
Steven M. Tipton. . Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment
in American Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Burke, Kenneth. . A Rhetoric of Motives. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-
Hall.
Davie, Grace. . Religion in Britain since : Believing without Belonging.
Oxford: Blackwell.
Giddens, Anthony. . Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late
Modern Age. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Ginkel, Rob van, Léon Deben and Ineke Lupi. . “Suburbane dromen: Ide-
alen en praktijken van het leven in Zoetermeer.” Amsterdams Sociologisch
Tijdschrift : –.
Gooren, Henri. . “Reassessing Conventional Approaches to Conversion:
Towards a New Synthesis.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion : –
.
Gorringe, T.J. . A Theology of the Built Environment: Justice, Empowerment,
Redemption. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Groot, Ger and Frans Maas. . Geloven en Geluk: Over het krediet van een
religieuze cultuur. Radboudstichting: Vught.
Groot, Kees de. . “For Love of Faith: Patterns of Religious Engagement in
Zoetermeer.” Pp. – in Zoeter-Meer tussen Hemel en Aarde: Ziel en geweten
van een moderne groeistad, edited by Jouetta van der Ploeg and M. van Dijk.
Zoetermeer: Meinema/Stadsmuseum Zoetermeer.
———. . “The Church in Liquid Modernity: A Sociological and Theological
Exploration of a Liquid Church.” International Journal for the Study of the
Christian Church : –.
———. . “Rethinking Church in Liquid Modernity.” Pp. – in Religion
Inside and Outside Traditional Institutions, edited by Heinz Streib. Leiden:
Brill.
———. . “Three Types of Liquid Religion.” Implicit Religion : –.
Hamers, David. . Tijd voor Suburbia. De Amerikaanse buitenwijk in weten-
schap en literatuur. Amsterdam: Van Gennep.
Hart, Joep de. . “Spirituele nomaden: Individualisering en religie in het
huidige Nederland.” Pp. – in Langs de kramen van het geluk. Heil zoeken
der Ploeg for inviting me to participate in their project. This article is an extended version
of the text that I wrote for the introduction to the catalogue of the exposition ZoeterMeer
between Heaven and Earth: Soul and Conscience of a Modern New Town [ September
– January ] (De Groot ).
patterns of religious engagement in a new town
in deze tijd, edited by André Lascaris, Barbara Leijnse and Leo Oosterveen.
Zoetermeer: DSTS/Meinema.
Hervieu-Léger, Danièle. . La religion en mouvement: Le pélerin et le converti.
Paris: Flammarion.
Hijmans, Ellen. . Je moet er het beste van maken: Een empirisch onderzoek
naar hedendaagse zingevingssystemen. Nijmegen: ITS.
Janssen, Jacques. . “De jeugd, de toekomst en de religie. Een analyse op basis
van recent onderzoek.” Jeugd en samenleving : –.
Kennedy, James. . Bouwen aan nieuw Babylon. Amsterdam: Boom.
Lange, Frits de. . “De flexibele mens.” Lecture presented at: Vinex Ecclesiolo-
gie: De postmoderne gemeente op zoek naar een vinex-ecclesiologie. Septem-
ber . Kampen: ThUK-PAO.
McGuire, Meredith B. . Religion: The Social Context, th ed. Belmont CA:
Wadsworth.
Pels, Dick. . De geest van Pim: Het gedachtegoed van een politieke dandy.
Amsterdam: Anthos.
Ploeg, Jouetta van der and Kees de Groot. . “Towards a City Museum as
a Centre of Civic Dialogue.” Pp. – in City Museums as Centres of Civic
Dialogue? Proceedings of the Fourth Conference of the International Association
of City Museum. Amsterdam: Edita/Amsterdam Historical Museum.
Savage, Mike, Alan Warde and Kevin Ward, eds. . Urban Sociology, Capital-
ism and Modernity. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Sennett, Richard. . The Corrosion of Character: The Personal Consequences
of Work in the New Capitalism. New York: Norton.
Vellenga, Sipco J. . “Huntington in Holland: The Public Debate on Muslim
Immigrants in the Netherlands.” Nordic Journal of Religion and Society :
–.
Zock, Hetty. . “Paradigms in Psychological Conversion Research: Between
Social Science and Literary Research.” Pp. – in Paradigms, Poetics and
Politics of Conversion, edited by Jan N. Bremmer, Wout J. van Bekkum and
Arie L. Molendijk. Leuven: Peeters.
chapter five
Continuing from the last quarter of the twentieth century into the
present, experiences that participants consider as “pilgrimage” have
undergone enormous growth. Pilgrimages take the form both of revivals
of historic religious journeys and new innovations of gathering places
that lack direct connection to explicit religious traditions (see Swatos
). Both forms, in turn, have also acquired a touristic component, as
people choose to go “see” pilgrimage venues, without necessarily them-
selves taking on the expressed identity of “pilgrim.” They remain in their
own eyes “tourists” (sometimes expressed as “just a tourist”) who pri-
marily watch the pilgrims on the one hand and view the site on the
other.
At the same time, the definition of “pilgrim” as a term-in-use seems
to have extended to going on a tour of sites, especially those of religious
significance, in the company of a church group or religious sodality—
without reference to any set of specific requirements or performances
required to fulfill the mandate of an identifiable religious body (like the
Roman Catholic Church) for performing a “true” pilgrimage. While these
differences may cause conflicts at specific sites and/or during specific
times, as John Eade () has pointed out, it is equally true that the
Turners’ dictum “a tourist is half a pilgrim, if a pilgrim is half a tourist”
(: ) more accurately captures the give-and-take of activity at most
sites most of the time. It is difficult to imagine that pilgrimage in this
period could or would have come about without the tourism industry, yet
at the same time, it is hard to fathom how the tourism industry could have
“sold” sites to customers if there were not some interest in the religious
or the spiritual as a category of both being and acting. Contemporary
tourism and pilgrimage form part of one broad type of travel “package,”
built on the broader foundations of both leisure time and quests for
meaning, purpose, and well-being. It is in this context that it can make
some sense to talk about pilgrimage and conversion, and this represents
a new twist to historic pilgrimage phenomena, at least in the West.
william h. swatos, jr.
1 This has not entirely been displaced. Frey (: ) reports that “Since , in
conjunction with the Belgian Ministry of Justice, a nonprofit group called Oikoten . . .
has used the Camino de Santiago as a path of rehabilitation of young social reprobates.
In an attempt to reintegrate these young people into society, Oikoten . . . sends one or
two young people with one or more monitors on a four-month version of the pilgrimage
for reflection and repentance.”
pilgrimage and conversion
cer, on the other hand, reminds us that even in what some medievalists
might think of as the best of times, there were plenty of mixed moti-
vations to go around among pilgrims—and this was certainly true of the
Crusades as well.2 Nevertheless, one might anticipate that in earlier times
there were some commonalities that could be counted on—not least, that
pilgrims to Christian holy sites would be Christians, pilgrims to Muslim
holy sites would be Muslims, and so on. That is, at least at the level of
“conventional religion,” pilgrims to a religious site would be people who
shared the religious profession both of those who operated the site and
of other pilgrims they might meet both on the way and upon arrival.
There was, in a sense, a religious lingua franca to a given site that was
shared among all the participants—mixed motivations notwithstanding.
I remember quite clearly that a great deal of the class time in my high
school English class that included Canterbury Tales involved explaining
details of Catholic faith and practice to a class that was majority non-
Catholic. I think that was my first introduction to Catholicism—and the
teacher was a good Methodist! Conflicts in Islam, by contrast, swirled
over who was holy and who was not, whereas the Protestant disdain for
the power of saints laid that particular locus of conflict to rest—but didn’t
prevent the destruction of significant sites in the process.3
What made holy sites so reprehensible to Protestants, however, was not
who was interred in any one of them nor what specific miracles associated
with them were or were not “genuine,” but rather the generalized belief
that earth and heaven were forever separated. Thus no physical remains
of anyone had any power whatsoever (or, in limited cases, might be
argued to have negative power [viz., Satan’s power]). Going to the tomb
of this or that saint was just as idolatrous as praying before this or
that statue. Indeed, the extent to which Catholic shrine devotion had
become involved with images of saints, simply extended the Protestant
objection all the more, inasmuch as such practice was taken as an explicit
violation of the Second Commandment. The rise of nationalism only
2 While there were females who went on pilgrimages in the early Christian centuries,
as time passed geographic pilgrimage was more and more restricted to men—in turn
giving rise to one of the earliest forms of “virtual pilgrimage”: Stations of the Cross (see
Adler ; Kaelber ).
3 A current acknowledgment and attempt at reparation for the desecration of impor-
tant Marian images connected to English shrines, not least Our Lady of Walsingham, by
Lord Privy Seal Sir Thomas Cromwell in , is the proposal by the Art and Reconcilia-
tion Trust to fund and place a memorial sculpture by Paul Day in Chelsea Embankment
Gardens. The sculpture will center on the Virgin and Child image, but also embody in its
design depictions of the culturally destructive effects of iconoclasm.
william h. swatos, jr.
4 I remember, for example, being at Sacre Coeur in Paris for First Friday (i.e., Sacred
Heart) Benediction one afternoon when a terrific rainstorm broke out, and hundreds of
william h. swatos, jr.
tourists came inside, making it impossible for the Benediction procession, which tends
to be relatively crowded with worshippers anyway, to move through the basilica.
pilgrimage and conversion
5 The Pope’s visit aside, it is significant that Eade’s “conflict” theory of pilgrimage is
based on his fieldwork in Lourdes—in the sense that Lourdes’s explicit significances are
at least two-fold: on the one hand is the significance of the site to the Roman Catholic
dogma of the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary, which especially
draws ultramontanist Catholics, inasmuch as this belief and that of papal infallibility
were both promulgated at the same Council (in the th century); on the other hand
are those who come to the spring which was revealed to Bernadette and is understood
(“documented”) to have healing powers, hence underlies the medical bureau and hospital
that is a continuous part of Lourdes life. While these twain certainly do meet, it is
not necessarily the case that they all do so for the same purposes or with the same
presuppositions. To these must be added, of course, both townspeople trying to carry
on ordinary livelihoods and “pure” tourists who are mainly present to see the Pyrenees
or kayak on the river.
6 The badges we received, for example, were written in neither French nor English, but
Portuguese. When we joined a group saying the prayers required at one of the four sites at
which one or another of the stamps was to be obtained, they were said in either Polish or
Italian. Two things that we found especially interesting were that Italians came to Lourdes
in considerable numbers for the papal visit and that the first requirement on the list of
requirements that all had to be completed to obtain a plenary indulgence in connection
with the pilgrimage was to go to confession. Inasmuch as going to confession is among the
activities that has declined most dramatically among Catholics in the last quarter century,
not only requiring the pilgrim to go to confession to obtain the indulgence, but putting
this requirement first on the list suggests a specifically conservative piety underlying the
promised favor.
william h. swatos, jr.
() than what might only a decade or two ago have been anticipated
by a papal pilgrimage to a holy site, and there was an almost Disneyesque
character to the Pope standing in the Popemobile waving from one side
to the other. Yes, it really was the Pope, not a mannequin, but the “con-
tainerization” of the person within the object was also and in the same
measure a dehumanization of the Pope that had a mechanical, rather than
extraterrestrial, quality. Mais oui, the Pope did wave, and we waved back.
Conversion as Process
which two different kinds of religiosities occur hence why in the United
States, for example, exceptionally large, nondenominational “seeker”
churches make “converts”—viz., their converts are pilgrims! That is, the
megachurch has much more in common stylistically with the pilgrim
model than it does with the historic religiosity of the practitioner type.
Rather than “get lost” among the crowd of the megachurch or the mass
of thousands or millions on pilgrimage, the pilgrim “finds himself or
herself ” in the processes that occur in the dynamics of expressive wor-
ship. The pilgrim-convert constructs a self that resides in the kernel of
the religious dynamic which the individual experiences among other
selves as communitas. This is not, however, community at all in the his-
toric sense of an ongoing interactive set of individuals sharing a common
space—e.g., as in monastics “living in community.” Communitas rather
transcends limits of time and space, albeit imperfectly. Because it is an
experience that transcends the mundane, it is transitory and always at
one and the same time both in the process of becoming and yet fleeting.
Different in form, yet consistent in results, is the labyrinth as both a
devotional tool and a pilgrimage destination, as described by Lori Bea-
man (). The labyrinth involves a walking-out or walking-through
that enables the person to re-think or think-out a situation. The walking
is a known pilgrim style but occurs within a confined, potentially med-
itative space that allows the participant again to engage in the finding-
self process that is characteristic of the elements of the pilgrim style as
Hervieu-Léger enumerates them. The unique characteristic of this form
is that it adds the dimension of motion to meditation. There can, how-
ever, also be a double pilgrimage experience—that is, both an inner,
labyrinthine journey and actual travel—as when someone goes to
Chartres in order to walk the labyrinth of that cathedral. Walking a
labyrinth in a medieval cathedral may bring experiences and emotions
that other settings could not generate.
These practitioner and pilgrim types, though clearly different, need
not, however, be oppositional. Parish groups, for example, can go on
pilgrimages or rallies and still return to a parish religiosity that at least
has affinities with the practitioner style. Just as it is possible to play touch
football with the same group of guys each weekend but also make an
annual trip to see a Bears game, so a person can be both a loyal local
parishioner and go to Lourdes. Pilgrimage experiences can provide rites
of intensification that enhance the local experience, hence should not be
seen in a contest for possession of the self.
william h. swatos, jr.
sounds, and smells—not least the ex votos of generations past that con-
cretize the reality of the miraculous—create an ambience through which
conversion may be heightened. Some of these in turn become devotees,
hence reinforcing the “truth” of the experience for others, and in so doing
enable the potential for a new pilgrimage/devotional cycle to begin.
Conversion as Motion
menstruation sanctions, infant circumcision, etc., in which the participant has little if any
control. This would also pertain to those experiences in which a participant is placed into
a trance state or takes hallucinogens.
william h. swatos, jr.
principally the Chapel of the Miraculous Medal in Paris, and in Lourdes. The project
has been supported by the Association for the Sociology of Religion through its Joseph
H. Fichter Research Grants program. Sophie-Hélène Trigeaud and André Sleiman have
collaborated with me in this work.
william h. swatos, jr.
9 During our research at the Chapel of the Miraculous Medal we similarly encoun-
tered Japanese persons who explicitly denied being Christian yet also were buying Mirac-
ulous Medals to take home to many friends.
pilgrimage and conversion
References
Adler, Judith. . “The Holy Man as Traveler and Travel Attraction: Early
Christian Asceticism and the Moral Problematic of Modernity.” Pp. – in
From Medieval Pilgrimage to Religious Tourism: The Social and Cultural Eco-
nomics of Piety, edited by William H. Swatos, Jr., and Luigi Tomasi. Westport,
CT: Praeger.
Beaman, Lori G. . “Labyrinth as Heterotopia: The Pilgrim’s Creation of
Space.” Pp. – in On the Road to Being There: Studies in Pilgrimage and
Tourism in Late Modernity, edited by William H. Swatos, Jr. Leiden: Brill.
Chemin, Eduardo. . The Pilgrim’s Discourse in the Milky Way: A Study on
the Religiosity of British Pilgrims on the Road to Santiago de Compostela. B.Sc.
(hons) thesis. Thames Valley University, London.
william h. swatos, jr.
Eade, John. . “Pilgrimage and Tourism at Lourdes, France.” Annals of Tour-
ism Research : –.
Frey, Nancy Louise. . Pilgrim Stories. Berkeley: University of California
Press.
Gilmore, Lee. . “Desert Pilgrimage: Liminality, Transformation and the
Other at the Burning Man Festival.” Pp. – in On the Road to Being
There: Studies in Pilgrimage and Tourism in Late Modernity, edited by William
H. Swatos, Jr. Leiden: Brill.
Hervieu-Léger, Danièle. . Le Pèlerin et le Converti: La Religion en Mouve-
ment. Paris: Flammarion.
Kaelber, Lutz. . “Place and Pilgrimage: Real and Imagined.” Pp. –
in On the Road to Being There: Studies in Pilgrimage and Tourism in Late
Modernity, edited by William H. Swatos, Jr. Leiden: Brill.
Kaufman, Judith. . Consuming Visions: Mass Culture and the Lourdes Shrine.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Swatos, William H., Jr., ed. . On the Road to Being There: Studies in Pilgrim-
age and Tourism in Late Modernity. Leiden: Brill.
Tomasi, Luigi. . “Homo Viator: From Pilgrimage to Religious Tourism via
the Journey.” Pp. – in From Medieval Pilgrimage to Religious Tourism: The
Social and Cultural Economics of Piety, edited by William H. Swatos, Jr., and
Luigi Tomasi. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Turner, Victor and Edith B. Turner. . Image and Pilgrimage in Christian
Culture. Oxford: Blackwell.
chapter six
Régis Dericquebourg
Buddhism—but they were more rare, and only a few intellectuals were
concerned. This is no longer the case now, because, from the s to
the s forward, these religions have been attracting people from the
middle classes and drawing correspondingly more disciples. Thus, socio-
religious mobility in a space where alternative propositions of mean-
ing are extensive has renewed the interest of researchers in the phe-
nomenon/a of conversion. Among the public, the word caused uneasi-
ness. We witnessed a shift in meaning because, under the influence of
the anti-cultists and the media, conversion was considered the result of
mental manipulation or brainwashing due to a weakness of the individ-
ual and to the action of unscrupulous “gurus” (Anthony and Introvigne
).
Religious mutation does not concern only the religious denomina-
tions we just evoked. From the decade – on, the whole reli-
gious landscape was altered. Many Westerners do not find or do not seek
the answers to final questions upon the meaning of life in a church or
even in a sect or a denomination. Moreover, they refuse to belong to
organized religious movements. They examine multiple propositions in
the religious field. They learn different doctrines. They experiment with
several spiritual practices. They sometimes devote themselves to non-
spiritual practices and consider them as useful elements for their quest
for salvation here and now or post mortem. All this is simultaneously or
successively accomplished in a system of thought and practice popularly
dubbed the New Age. Some researchers call this spirituality a “free-choice
religion” and the itinerary of its disciples “gleaning.” Even though these
expressions may seem caricatured, it is nonetheless true that it is an atyp-
ical religiosity where one cannot a priori discriminate a religious conver-
sion such as generally described by sociologists and psychologists—i.e.,
as a rupture in life.
How can we define entering the New Age? Is it a new conversion,
when New Agers go from one group to another? Is there such a thing
as a global conversion to the New Age? Is the latter a form of spirituality
without conversion? Is it a path without any culminating experience? In
this chapter, we will examine those questions through the life stories of
three followers.
becoming a new ager
In order to discuss the ways of joining the New Age, we must briefly
consider what it is.
This is not easy because, among the sociologists who constructed
it as a social reality, it is a nebula made of study groups, movements,
training courses, training seminars, bookshops, music concerts, festivals,
relations to masters, with the whole thing in constant evolution.
In his book devoted to the New Age, Massimo Introvigne (: –
) tries to define the trend: “it is rather a climate, an environment,
an atmosphere, a body of realities that have a family likeness among
them, but which also present ‘differences and contradictions’.” For this
reason, the New Age can be more easily be described through differ-
ent angles than propositionally defined. From the philosophical point of
view, it rests on the idea that a radical change in all the domains of exis-
tence (including scientific paradigms) is happening or is going to take
place. From the sociological point of view, it is a network of networks (a
“metanetwork”) in which a group pf people, who are not formally affil-
iated “Members of the New Age,” participate. In that respect, it is not a
structured movement, even though it includes movements or organized
groups that sometimes existed even before its appearance. From a doc-
trinal point of view, it does not comprise any unique thought system.
Everyone can create his or her own image of the world. The rational sys-
tem underlying this one has no importance: New Agers have teachings
validated through personal experiment and experience.
Martin Geoffroy, contrary to Introvigne, argues that the New Age is
a full-fledged social movement, structured as a varied “gathering space”
where disciples can go from one group to another relatively easily. The
individual is only one side of the New Age movement, which cannot be
studied as a union of individualisms “even though the cult of the individ-
ual occupies much space in it.” Geoffroy enumerates three tendencies in
the New Age: the socio-cultural trend, the esoteric-occultist trend, and
the bio-psychological one. As a social movement, the New Age broadens
spaces of autonomy within civil society and can involve social protest.
Its disciples want to change the social system progressively, basing them-
selves on “harmony and inner serenity” (Geoffroy : –)—i.e., on
a conversionist pattern. According to that use, following Bryan Wilson’s
pattern of sect types (), the world improves as people become better.
The rallying of New Age disciples to the “Cultural Creatives” (Ray and
Anderson ), in particular the “Alter Creatives” (Cultural Creatives
with a path in spirituality), illustrates this. Protest sometimes comes to
régis dericquebourg
the Second Coming, but they will do it with a greater thrill if the
announcement made by the leaders of the movement concerns
a precise date. If the anticipated event does not occur, they will
participate in the collective rationalization of the failure.
. With conversion, Witnesses will separate from the State and from
the world of work, to make greater room for Jehovah in their lives,
something they did not do before.
. The elders will advise the neophyte not to be too much engrossed in
worldly affairs, to choose “moral” leisure, not to gamble and to break
off relationships with people that could lead them far from Jehovist
morals. They no longer model their lives on the national calendar
or the Christian calendar. Witnesses do not celebrate Christmas
any longer, because Witnesses think its date is not relevant. They
commemorate Christ’s death on the fixed date of the th of the
month of Nizan, not on the Easter cycle like other Christians. They
do not take part any more in national commemorations in other
countries because they are not Christian. Thus, a breach will take
place in the cultural festival calendar of Jehovah’s Witnesses in
whatever society of which they are a part.
The sociological construction of conversion, in terms of modification
of social behaviors on the basis of “redirection of foundational trust,”
proposed by Blasi, is totally relevant for Jehovah’s Witnesses, which is
typical of the convert organization. This is similarly illustrated by Max
Weber’s famous account of a Baptist convert in North Carolina, whom
Weber mentions in The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism
(: –).1 The man wanted to open a banking business and
his conversion to (and acceptance by) the Baptist church could show
everyone that he could be expected to be reliable in life and in business,
because of the conscious directing and leading that lay behind “the entire
organization of the believer’s life” (Lebensführung [: lxxix, ]) that
the conversion to Baptist standards should produce. According to Weber,
life behavior refers to a structured body of behaviors and practices. In the
1 The original the Protestant Ethic essays appeared in German in /, but were
later supplemented by a revision that included a extension of the original, with
special reference to the United States. It is in the material that the North Carolina
baptism first appears. The classic English-language translations are those of the original
essays by Talcott Parsons in , plus the additional materials, first published in English
by C. Wright Mills and Hans Gerth in . Those translations are here supplemented by
the third Roxbury edition, at the hands of Stephen Kalberg.
régis dericquebourg
Methodology
We looked for people who had for a long time frequently seen groups
that we may classify among the New Age cadre, and who took an active
part in them. Being active means they were regular in attendance and
took responsibility as organizers or teachers of doctrines and techniques
they had been taught and with which they had experimented. Three were
accepted. Two of them think their course has come to an end. Another
one elaborated his own synthesis. He is teaching and sees only the circle
he founded. He has become a spiritual master. He also devotes himself
to the fight for religious freedom, because the groups he belonged to, as
well as his own circle, were under the accusation of being “sects,” with
the result of disastrous social consequences, on the personal, professional
and family levels.
In the interviews, each person was asked to relate his or her path within
the New Age (an expression they accepted). We then asked questions
about the “illumination” experience itself, questions about the changes
frequenting those groups had produced in their self-perception and in
their lives. Moreover, we asked them whether they perceived an under-
lying quest in themselves, what their relationship was to the mainstream
religious denominations, whether each group they belonged to had
brought them anything, and whether these possible contributions added
up—i.e., whether they had reached a philosophy of life at the end of these
experiences. We asked them whether they had the feeling that, at a certain
time, they had been “converted.” Interviews were recorded and translit-
erated. They are provided as a basis for analysis, after removing all verbal
tics, slips, pauses, etc.
I remember that when I was eighteen, I felt confined because I came from
a modest background. I had no life experience. We didn’t have a tele-
phone at home. I was very shy, and I joined a tennis club at that age.
It was my first social experience. I did all the possible jobs: secretary,
tournament organizer, chairman in my club for eight years. I then taught
tennis for ten years. It all began when I was twenty. I am sixty now, and
have been playing tennis for forty years. Then, as I began teaching math-
ematics in high school, I saw people who went to the university parish.
The woman who introduced me was called Martine, she taught history
and geography. I joined the group, we met once a month with a priest,
régis dericquebourg
Father R., who is still alive. We met once a month and debated about a
subject which was chosen beforehand, society facts for instance. There I
met a priest who taught mathematics in a denominational high school
and who was friends with a neighbor of mine who studied mathemat-
ics. We did a lot of talk. At a certain period, he was a surrogate father
because I had grown up fatherless. This priest was full of questioning.
He wondered why he had become a priest. Then we began to build a
group of self-improvement and therapy with a priest who was a psychi-
atrist.
In fact, when I studied math at the university, I was interested in the
subconscious. I wanted to know what deep forces were. I wondered if my
choices were guided by rationality or by the unconscious. I knew there
was a world to discover. It was a passion for me. I wondered why I had
this passion. My mother worked as a cleaning lady, my great-aunt had no
culture at all. I don’t know what brought me to that rage for discovery,
but it was deep-rooted. Therefore, I registered for that therapy group that
taught to discover oneself—a discovery of one’s unconscious through the
body. It thrilled me. I attended it for about two years, with a session about
every two months. In that group, I met a girl who practiced yoga. She
invited me to yoga training during the month of August. Ultimately, I
went to it and I discovered yoga with Jacques H. During that fifteen-
days training, I experienced an extraordinary feeling of relaxation, and it
brought me a lot. Then I took weekly yoga courses for two years. Then,
as I experienced anguish while deeply relaxing, I stopped for one year,
to get back to it afterwards. After that, I didn’t stop it, except when my
children were born, for two or three years. I have been practicing yoga
for about thirty years. Jacques H. was chairman of the CISL. He was
heavily into therapies and groups, and looked for clients in yoga groups.
I was a bachelor then, and this took the weekends, with a passion for self-
discovery and entering deep into meditation. He got me into something
else, another life out of the movement, out of social life. I felt as if I
had done something enormous that brought me maybe near the state
of death. I am very interested in that question: what does happen after
death, and I feel I tame . . . (a silence).
I followed courses in self-development based upon bio-energy with
hyperventilation and catharsis. So when I discovered that, that was such
an extraordinary thing in terms of beatitude. I remember times when I
stopped at red lights in a state of utter happiness so I went to that kind of
group for three more years.
Then I went to Tantra groups, or rather neo-Tantra because we reach
becoming a new ager
towards the spirit, the body is a door towards the spirit. It is also true with
tennis or golf.
R.D.: Do you think you followed a spiritual path?
J.P.: Yes. At a certain point, I felt I was more of a Buddhist than a Christian.
Tantra gives a perfect example. The body brings transcendence. What
interests me in tennis or in golf is the learning process. I am a spiritual
student, always discovering, going ever deeper in self-knowledge, in
order to develop my potential, I wouldn’t say in a pathological but in
a childish way. It’s the “know thyself,” too. This spiritual path is all the
same very near the religious quest because I have a blind and simple faith
that is family heirloom. I went to mass Sunday mornings until twenty-
five, and the belief in a God helped me much. Then with yoga, my quest
became more spiritual. I looked for transcendence, what is divine in me.
Buddhism brings a godless answer. I find a divine part in myself like a
grain of the universe without the presence of an outer God and it’s a bit
hard for me to make all that live together. I made up my own religious
truth. I feel near the Christian God, but at the same time, I wonder. For
me, all religions have good sides. What is immanent? What can survive in
what I am at present? I haven’t found out, except that in deep meditation,
things happen that I can’t explain. It’s an emptiness that isn’t a void. It’s
comforting though, to come back from meditation to living my everyday
life.
R.D.: Does everything each group brings you accumulate and do you
theorize your experience?
J.P.: The experiences accumulated. Maturity is a series of experiences that
accumulate, I am therefore more able to answer to new experiences. The
richer and more varied the experiences are, the more comfortable I feel
in my everyday life.
R.D.: Did it change your lifestyle?
J.P.: No, I didn’t bring myself into question. My vision of the couple didn’t
change. Not even the side of consumption.
R.D.: What about detachment?
J.P.: It is actually advocated by Buddhism, and from this perspective, I
haven’t changed. Eventually, at twenty, I owned a “deux-chevaux” [an
economical car by Citroën]. If I had not owned one, I would have
managed otherwise. If I had had a bigger car, I would have been pleased,
becoming a new ager
fact weren’t. In fact, I managed to distance myself from all that. In fact,
when I see a contradiction, the very fact of unearthing it, of getting to
know it, changes my actions.
R.D.: Is it a distance towards conflicts?
J.P.: Yes.
R.D.: Did your path bring you nearer to religion?
J.P.: No, it drove me away from it.
Commentary
2 Hara is the vital center of the human, the seat of one’s spiritual energy in Japanese
and Chinese energetic representation of the body. Hara is located in the belly. Some
practices centered on the hara could increase well-being.
becoming a new ager
J.V.: I think that, by and by, I concretely realized what I knew in my head,
and I was still in my head. A thought by the mystic Ruysbroek comes to
my mind: if you were in prayer and very deep orison, if somebody told
you your brother was sick, leave your orison and go have a bowl of broth
warmed; thus, you leave God for God. The God of orison may be illusory.
The God of love never is. If you ask how I work with Graf Dürckheim to
build my own perception of the other, I can say that all this demanding
personal work taught me to be awakened to the other, at the best, to pass
on what he is: his human touch, and that it will be communicated by what
you may call friendship or a kind of love.
R.D.: Did you experience an illumination?
J.V.: I will answer by referring to the two years I spent as a Carthusian.
Every night, we sang the Hours. It was a great period of deep inner light,
and after two years, on a st of August, the whole office was devoted
to the Holy Virgin Mary. I spent two hours, not in the air, but in a kind
of state of euphoria; it wasn’t an ecstasy in the out-of-the-ordinary sense
of the word, but total euphoria, at the end of which I sensed my body
didn’t follow. I left the following week. The old body wasn’t able to live
this Carthusian life for a long time and stay in full balance, and I can say
this total inner experience keeps me on my feet. I gained through it a
kind of serenity in the painful events I underwent. It is a light that holds
me but is within human relationships.
R.D.: So, you had this illumination in a Catholic surrounding?
J.V.: Definitely. This light, received in the heart of the Catholic faith and
inside the inner, spiritual path of the monk I was for two years, through
singing and concrete life. So there!
R.D.: You joined the Carthusians when on a quest?
J.V.: That’s it, and in fact, I entered the monastery at twenty-five, thinking
that my calling was to live in the Church’s vision of the spiritual union.
I can say, nevertheless, that at fifty, that is twenty years later, I was
converted a second time, from that encounter with Graf Dürckheim on.
R.D.: Did each group you met successively bring you new material?
J.V.: What I received took place between thirty and fifty, when I met dis-
abled persons. I was lucky enough to meet during these twenty years
men and women who, in the heart of disastrous physical, psychologi-
cal, moral conditions, disclosed to me the inner mystery of things and
becoming a new ager
Commentary
Jacques V. is a Catholic who discovers the New Age at fifty and who in
the end stays attached to Catholicism. Within the church, he is outstand-
ing. He does not just have a regular practice of his religion. He wants to
become priest. He follows training for priesthood. Then, aiming to more
than the charisma of function, he adopts the way of the mystic and joins
the order of the Carthusians, where he meets with a mystical experience
that scares him so much that he flees from monastic life. Of course, he was
a Catholic, so he did not need to join that Church after being converted.
becoming a new ager
3 Reliance is an association in Northern France that was a meeting point for people
4 School of Arcanes was created by Alice Bayley (). The school prepares corre-
spondence-course lessons upon esotericism for home study and organizes meetings and
teaching sessions in its centers.
becoming a new ager
see is a stage of life. I know that all these being will evolve. I approach
a human being in a more global way, rather than seeing him, or her,
in his own self. It has allowed me to stand back a great deal. I also use
the knowledge that makes free by a sense of humor, because things don’t
last.
R.D.: Was your life transformed by the knowledge gained in spirituality
and by the experiences?
T.B.: On the intellectual level, yes, it’s true. On the social level, it’s true
too, because one doesn’t make friends with everyone. I gather that if I
hadn’t lived that spiritual quest, I wouldn’t be the same. I take delight in
life. I have total hope. I am quite confident that everything is constantly
evolving. I don’t live the same way as if I hadn’t have that spiritual quest.
Life wouldn’t be so joyous on the inside, because joy is there. I am certain
that life is endless. People frequently ask me how I can manage to keep
that joy in spite of all the onslaught. My life would be totally different
without that spirituality.
R.D.: Where do you stand as far as mainstream denominations are con-
cerned?
T.B.: The mainstream denominations are unsuccessful religious quests.
One day, someone perceives a part of the Whole and says it’s the truth.
His truth becomes Truth. I observe them as one of the means to lead
further to spiritual life. So, it’s a passage.
R.D.: Are you still a Catholic?
T.B.: I am interested in a religion in a purely cultural way, not in a spiritual
one. I know that I won’t find any answers to my questions in whichever
religion. My aim is not to have any dogma—and to serve other people.
R.D.: What about self-development?
T.B.: My spiritual quest wasn’t only bookish. I started an association
whose goal was to deliver a teaching and to give psychological training.
We did interpersonal psychology. As such, we studied Jung, Maslow. I
came onto different trends in psychotherapy to put them in parallel. I
practice Socrates’ maieutic with this experience in psychology. I use the
tools of awakening, of knowledge and consciousness-raising—with the
idea that knowledge makes you free. I practice therapy by listening.
R.D.: What about body psychotherapy?
becoming a new ager
Commentary
Conclusion
The cases of the three New Agers reported here show that the New
Age did not bring a biographic disruption in spite of the emotions and
intellectual questioning these practices produced in them. It is rather a
becoming a new ager
social space in which they brought into motion resources they thought
useful to upbuild themselves, as well as reach salvation goods in a path
they had chosen. This path was never replaced by a commitment bringing
a change in social behaviors. Mobilizing resources could be furthered
in Gnostic networks, through the encounter with “other signifiers”—the
“Reliance” association, as well as so called “interesting” people, or people
who “became good friends.” Those became structures of plausibility
validating their quest. We could compare this phenomenon with what
takes place in Protestantism, the interdenominational trend, in which
any believer can taste for a while the specificities of every Protestant
movement—Evangelicalism for instance—where the person experiences
the intense emotional and spiritual healing prayer—while remaining
a registered member of his denomination of standard Protestantism.
The New Age perhaps is a place where one adheres successively or
simultaneously to ideas or practices put forward on a market in constant
evolution—in which some trends seem to be a craze, which gives the
impression that people join to keep riding the wave of fashion.
References
Acquaviva, Sabino and Enzo Pace. . Sociologie des religions. Paris: Cerf.
Anthony, Dick and Massimo Introvigne. Le lavage de cerveau: mythe ou réalité?
Paris: L’Harmattan.
Berger Peter and Thomas Luckmann. . The Social Construction of Reality.
Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
Bertaux, Daniel. . Les récits de vie: Perspectives ethnosociologiques, Paris:
Nathan.
Bruns, Roger A. . Preacher, Billy Sunday and Big-Time Evangelism. Urbana:
University of Illinois Press.
Champion, François and Danièle Hervieu-Léger . De l’émotion en religion.
Paris: Le Centurion.
Delestre, Antoine. . Les religions des étudiants, Paris: L’Harmattan.
Dericquebourg, Régis. . Les Témoins de Jéhovah. Unpublished doctoral
thesis. University of Paris , Sorbonne.
———. . “Max Weber et les charismes spécifiques.” Archives de Sciences
Sociales des religions : –.
———. . “Playing With a Tradition or Belonging to Another Tradition?”
Paper presented at the CESNUR/INFORM Conference, Twenty Years
and More: Research into Minority Religions, New Religious Movements, and
“The New Spirituality.” London School of Economics. www.cesnur.org//
london_deriquebourg.htm.
Desplan, Fabrice. Structuration de l’action collective adventiste: Approche
régis dericquebourg
ENCHANTMENT, IDENTITY,
COMMUNITY, AND CONVERSION: CATHOLICS,
AFRO-BRAZILIANS AND PROTESTANTS IN BRAZIL
Roberto Motta
1 Brazilian historiography holds that Brazil’s independence from Portugal was “pro-
claimed” on September , by Pedro, then a resident of Brazil, who was the son and
heir of João VI, King of Portugal. The Prince became Brazil’s first Emperor as Pedro I, but
this did not prevent him from also becoming King of Portugal for a brief period in .
According to many historians, Brazil’s independence was only consummated in ,
when Pedro I was pressured to abdicate Brazil’s crown in favor of his son, Pedro II, who
reigned until the Republic was proclaimed in , having always enjoyed the reputation
of an enlightened, benevolent, and not particularly Catholic, monarch.
2 Or, at that, to “think the world.” A full-fledged, if mainly implicit, Weltanschauung
[. . .] At any rate a good deal of religious activity in this situation comes to be dominated
by the logic of market economics.”
4 For a standard history of Protestantism in Brazil, cf. Léonard . He is also the
other terms, was a frequent one among missionaries and early converts. Celeste Porvir
is also the title of a standard reference book concerning the history of early Protestant
missions in Brazil (Mendonça ).
6 With the adoption of cultural relativism by a part of the intellectual elites, Brazil, the
grams over Protestant wires, read their papers over Protestant spectacles,
and they walk over in Protestant shoes to see the nuns sewing on Protestant
machines.7
Early Protestantism in Brazil—that is, the kind of Protestantism associ-
ated with some of the “historical” churches of the English-speaking world
(Baptists, Methodists, and Presbyterians), which began doing missionary
work and gaining converts around —appealed to the progressivist
elites of the country.8 Using a vocabulary not as fashionable in the mid-
dle of the th century as it is nowadays, we can say that early Brazilian
Protestantism appealed to “those who hunger and thirst” after rational-
ity, wanting to fill the country with it. Rationality implies in this case
a form of thought that would discard the iconophilism associated with
traditional Roman Catholic worship to the benefit of a kind of thought
associated with the logos, the abstract Word entailing free access to the
Bible by an autonomous individual who rejects the mediation of a priest-
hood.9 Early Protestantism appealed thus to the social and cultural elites
of the country.10
7 The dating of Taylor’s memoirs is approximate. The memoirs are located in the
library of the Univesrity of California at Los Angeles. Cf. Mendonça for a more
detailed study of the social thought of other missionaries and early converts in Brazil.
8 The equation between Protestantism and progress is found, in nearly ideal-typical
way, in the political activity and in the writings of the Brazilian “Apostle of Progress,”
Aureliano Tavares Bastos (–). He wanted Brazil to gain “a new soul.” In order to
undergo such a complete change, the country should learn from others the recipe for
progress which he, very much like Max Weber, recognized in the liberal spirit of the
Protestant Reformation, that led a small colony in New England to give rise to the “mighty,
rich, large, enlightened, free, intelligent, generous, courageous republic of the United
States of America.” For the United States had not suffered from “the stupid fanaticism
of the th century priests, having instead been settled by Quakers and members of
other independent sects.” According to Bastos, thanks to the Reformation the United
States had been impregnated with “morality, industriousness, intelligence, perseverance,
consciousness of human dignity and the sense of personal freedom, which are the
message of the Gospel and stand out as the basic features of the races of the North of
the Globe” (Vieira : ).
9 This is especially the case with such Catholicism as was practiced by the average
lay person in the colonial and newly independent countries of Latin America. The mere
possession of a Bible (all the more so if translated into the vernacular) was considered an
offense belonging to the jurisdiction of the Inquisition.
10 Those elites had their followings, their clientele, who often accompanied them in
their new faith. To this day the Presbyterian and Baptist churches (mainly, it is true, in
the more traditional region of the Nordeste) bear the stamp of prominent patriarchal
or quasi-patriarchal families, whose dependents joined them in their new religion (cf.
Perruci ).
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
11 Victor Turner (: ) remarks that “iconophilic religions often develop com-
plex and elaborate systems of ritual; symbols tend to be visual and exegesis is bound up
with the ritual round. Iconoclastic religions are associated with reform and seek to purify
the ‘underlying meaning’ by erasing the signantia, the iconic symbols, which appear to
them to be ‘idols’ interposing themselves between individual believers and the truths
enunciated by religious founders.”
12 One might also say that these were more “logophilic” or even more “logical” forms
of Catholicism, giving the word the meaning it has in Paul’s letter to the Romans (: ),
in which Christians are advised to engage in “logikèn latreían,” translated as “obsequium
rationale” in the Latin Vulgate and as “reasonable service” in the King James version.
13 The first published translations of the missal into Brazilian Portuguese date from
Both the Roman Catholic and historical Protestant churches had made—
to use a phrase that became fashionable only later in church circles—a
“preferential option” for the elite, not so much under the assumption that
elite people’s souls were elite souls, but rather expecting that by gaining
or maintaining their religious hold on the upper classes they would gain
or keep the whole country. Such strategy appeared as all the more advis-
able as priests and missionaries were few in number. The pace of secular-
ization was certainly slower among the lower classes. But the members
of these classes possess neither the culture, the outlook, or the educa-
tional requirements that would qualify them as adequate candidates for
either the Catholic priesthood or the ministry of the historic Protestant
churches—i.e., for full-fledged participation as members of the Church at
all levels. Hence the importation of foreign priests (mainly but not only
members of so-called regular clergy) from the late decades of the th
century down to Vatican II and beyond. The native Brazilian clergy were
recruited in regions of old settlement (like the interior of the Northeast)
from a thin layer of “poor whites,” if educated enough to meet the require-
ments for an intensive study of Latin, which was indispensable until the
s in the education of priests.14
Catholic priests were also recruited—indeed still are to the present
day—from the German, Italian, and Polish communities who settled in
the Southernmost states of Brazil and soon were among the main carriers
of Roman Catholicism in Brazil—increasingly so, indeed, as among old-
stock Brazilians secularization and conversion to other religions grew
and did not stop growing in the second half of the th century. This is the
central problem in the sociological interpretation of Brazilian Catholi-
cism: who are the people who carry it—Max Weber’s Träger? The old aris-
tocracy of planters, Crown and Republic officers, and their descendents
forsook it. They thought they had found better things either in a certain
latitudinarianism or even in outright conversion to Protestantism. But
14 Textbooks in both philosophy and theology were written in Latin, although lectures
by the s were, as a general rule, delivered in the vernacular. Serbin () provides
a comprehensive history of Brazil’s clergy and seminaries.
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
the old subordinated classes, the descendents of African slaves and sub-
jugated Indians, déclassé whites, poor laborers, owners of small tracts of
land and their like, in both rural and urban Brazil, people of many shades
of racial and cultural mixture, did not feel responsible for the Church
either—all the more so as their sons were not admitted into seminaries for
no other reason than they did not meet the basic cultural requirements.
They were considered as strangers until able to meet these requirements,
that is, until becoming able to undergo the kind of cultural conversion
that would render them full participants in Catholicism with the ritual
and cultural characteristics that had become canonical by the turn of the
th century.
The conversionary failure of the Catholic Church in Brazil is primarily
and essentially due to this gap and the wondrous success, from the late
th century to the present, of Pentecostals and, in their own way, of
Afro-Brazilians, in whose institutions no similar gap exists. They belong,
as it has been said, to “religions of participation” (cf. Ribeiro ).
This may be understood in many ways and from several points of view
that tend rather to complement than exclude one another. On the plane
of ritual, it may refer to ordinary trance or trance-like states—that is,
to the immediate cognitive and emotional seizure of the “holy” or of
what is conceived as such. On the same plane it may also mean that
ritual is enacted by devotees and not simply watched or attended by
them.15 They are the actors, and it is the expression of their identity. It
may also mean that ritual, in down-to-earth fashion, meets the daily life
problems of devotees and tries to solve them. The search for healing is,
for instance, a frequent ingredient of rituals of participation. From the
examples that were just given it may also be concluded that, on the plane
of organization, there is no gap between the laity and the clergy—or at
least it means that access of the layperson to clerical office is not barred
by reasons of cultural distance, social status, race, and the like.
A given religion functions as the source of foundational trust to the
extent that it works as both the source and the expression of a basic
15 This entails a first magnitude problem to Catholicism with its fundamental distinc-
tion between priests and laymen. Several solutions have been proposed in the course of
history to the problems caused by this gap. The Council of Trent reiterated the distinc-
tion, with all the consequences it entails, in clear-cut opposition to the principles of the
Reformation. Theological trends of the th century (cf. Congar ) culminating in
Vatican II, have tended to attenuate (or to euphemize) the distinction by appealing to the
notion of the basic priesthood of believers, which would not as such exclude a “ministe-
rial” priesthood.
roberto motta
Everything changed in Brazil during the second half of the th cen-
tury, and this change continues into the present. A basic feature of this
process was the demographic explosion, associated with the intensive
flow of migrants from the countryside to the cities, indeed to the largest
and most important ones, such as São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Salvador de
Bahia, and Recife. These migrations have coincided with an equally accel-
erated process of economic modernization. These trends have resulted
not only in the rise of an urban working class, but also of a lumpen class,
in the sense of an amorphous group of dispossessed and uprooted indi-
viduals, set off by their inferior status from the economic and social class
with which they used to be identified, without having, at the same time,
succeeded in establishing new roots of a stable and formal character.
Between the working class and the lumpen class (which may as well, at
least for our purposes, be called the “informal sector”), there is no clear-
cut border. In Brazil, like in other emergent countries, transit is rapid and
easy between the two categories.
Whatever their precise economic and social status, the migrants have
willy-nilly lost contact with their former supporting structures, their
links with their former communities, the formal or informal associations,
the brotherhoods, shrines and feasts of their original setting.16 They have
been lost in transition, that is, they have fallen into a state of anomie
which, among other things, entails perplexity and loss of identity and
of that foundational trust which, in the last resort, is the foundation of
psychological and sociological being. As Ronald Glen Frase (: –
) writes:
16 Roger Bastide, drawing intentionally from Ribeiro (), dealt extensively with
The real victims of this gigantic social dislocation were the rural migrants
stripped of the social institutions of extended family, patron-client and
face-to-face relationships which had provided them with a degree of secu-
rity and a framework of meaning in their traditional habitat. . . . The rural
migrants striving to survive in an urban milieu they did not understand
found themselves in a state social scientists describe as anomie. . . . This
inchoate urban population, bereft of traditional institutions which were
left behind when they made their journey into the city, were susceptible
to new ideologies which could make meaning of their existence and offer
hope for the future. . . . It appears useful to understand Pentecostalism and
various forms of Spiritism [that is, Afro-Brazilian Candomblé and similar
cults] as compensating mechanisms whereby the lower classes seek effec-
tive participation in society.17
A mighty struggle has taken place in Brazil. There has been a main loser,
the Roman Catholic Church; a secondary gainer (which also has been
a secondary loser), historical Protestantism; and two primary gainers,
Afro-Brazilian Candomblé and Pentecostalism. Historical Protestantism
has discussed earlier in this chapter. These other two religious tendencies
will now be briefly examined from the standpoint of participation, iden-
tity, and enchantment that have been recognized as basic in the process
of redirection of foundational trust.
Candomblé
17 Frase builds on older foundations, laid by both foreign and Brazilian authors,
especially among them Camargo (; ), Durkheim (), Moura (), Willems
(), and Wilson ().
18 The word Candomblé is used here to designate the whole of the Afro-Bazilian
religions (Xangô, Mina, Batuque, Umbanda) and others, which, in spite of regional, ritual
and theological variations, share the basic beliefs of the dyadic contract with the saints
and of access to them through trance of possession. (cf. Motta .)
19 It appears, however, that the original carriers of Candomblé were free Africans
and their desdendents, petty traders, petty craftsmen, and the like, representing a kind
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
of early lumpen in port cities such as Bahia, Recife, and Rio de Janeiro. Candomblé
and similar cults have by no means been rural manifestations but have taken place in
urban contexts. Candomblé starts to loom large on the Brazilian scene by the turn of
the th century. While, unlike Protestantism, it did not claim a rank comparable to
that of the Catholic Church, its emergence nevertheless points to the gap in identity (or
identification) between Catholicism and Brazilianhood that began to be felt by the same
time.
20 Concerning the notion of a bilateral (or “dyadic”) contract between saints and men,
which the Afro-Brazilians largely inherited from popular Catholicism (cf. Foster ,
which remains to this day as a classic study on this topic). Regarding Catholicism in
Brazil, cf. Azevedo , or in the context of the concept of a religious marketplace, cf.
Greenfield .
21 This expression derives form Marx (:): “For a society based upon the pro-
duction of commodities . . . the cultus of abstract man, more especially in its bourgeois
developments, Protestantism, Deism, etc, is the most fitting form of religion.”
roberto motta
22 Pierre Verger (: ) sees the trance of Candomblé as “something more than a
steady process of expansion from the old historical center, where the oldest shrines were
found, to more and more distant peripheries.
24 This was strongly emphasised, no doubt with a certain amount of poetic license,
among others, by George Lapassade and Marco-Aurélio Luz (: xix), who studied
the Candomblé of Rio de Janeiro. According to them, in the rites of that religion “Blacks
symbolically speak about all liberations: from slavery, to be sure, but they also speak about
the liberation of Blacks as Blacks; and they also mean the liberation of Eros, of mad love.
. . . We see there Dionysus, the Greek god of the slaves and of the women, fighting against
Apollo, the god of the Masters.”
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
Pentecostalism
Man shall not live by liberation alone, but by every logically consistent
theological system, such as that which is represented in contemporary
Brazil by the Pentecostal churches, the fastest growing religious move-
ment in Brazil and in the rest of Latin America. To the masses marginal-
ized by anarchic economic and demographic change, Pentecostalism
offers the pride that originates from the experience of the Holy Spirit and
from the certitudo salutis, accompanied by an ethical project that gives
method, order and sense to daily life.
In marked contrast with both Candomblé and with popular Catholi-
cism (Vulgarkatholicismus in Weberian parlance), the specific core of
Pentecostalism consists of a kind of emotional sectarianism that leads to
the adoption of ascetic rules of personal behavior. This applies primar-
ily to the sphere of all spontaneous forms of enjoyment, not only with
regard to sexual activity (allowed only in marriage), but also to include
roberto motta
25 A popular Brazilian song draws a neat contrast between o crente e o cachaceiro, “the
economic entrepreneurship. They certainly have at least some elements of the Protestant
ethic, although they are not necessarily the “carriers,” in Weberian terms, of “the spirit of
Capitalism.”
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
large urban centers can be considered as the areas of the keenest religious
competition” (Jacob et al. : ).27
The growth of Pentecostalism in Brazil (and elsewhere in Latin Amer-
ica) has occasioned the growth of a vast literature, which would deserve
a full study in its own right, implying a kind of Sociology of Sociology. As
an almost absolute rule, scholars have tended to take sides for reasons of
a general philosophy of history, being either strongly in favor or strongly
against the new churches. Among the former, largely influenced by The
Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism thesis can be listed Willems
(), Martin (), Freston (), Mariz (), and many others.
Among the latter, Lalive d’Épinay particularly stands out (; cf. Bas-
tian ; Corten ). Although his empirical references are Chilean
and Argentinean, he has influenced to a significant extent all subsequent
research in Brazil and in the rest of Latin America. Lalive at least implic-
itly follows the Marxist thesis of religion as alienation, and as he uses
it, the expression “haven to the masses” (all the more so in the Spanish
refugio de las masas) is strongly reminiscent of Marx’s “the opium of the
people.” Francisco Cartaxo Rolim (, ), who has played a leading
role in Brazilian research, has been even more explicitly, indeed dogmat-
ically, influenced by Marxism.
27 This belongs to the Durkheimian, rather than Weberian, core of the sociology of
religion and can also be found in Thomas O’Dea (:): “Social change, and especially
social disorganization, result in a loss of cultural consensus and group solidarity, and set
men upon a “quest for community”, that is, looking for new values to which they might
adhere and new groups to which they might belong. This implies that conversion—the
acceptance of a new religion—is itself closely related to needs and aspirations which
are highly affected by the social circumstances of the people involved, although social
conditions are not a simple and unique causal element in such cases.”
roberto motta
28 Vagner Gonçalves da Silva is the editor of the volume and one of its contributors,
besides Ari Pedro Oro, Alejandro Frigerio, Ricardo Mariano, Emerson Giumbelli, and
others.
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
than that which originates from the need of regulation, indeed of repres-
sion, associated with the superego, all the more so if regulation and
repression are associated with a consistent and enchanted theology.29
According to Rolim (: –):
[T]he recent magical and religious manifestations of Pentecostalism are a
sign among others of support for the capitalist system. What is in question
there is not the divine, even if it is called the power of God or the power
of the Spirit. What is in question is the profane power, the bourgeois
ideology. The reenchantment of the world, if we are allowed to call it so,
is nothing else but the absence of a critical consciousness open to the
contradictions of capitalist society. . . . [I]t must be said to those who are
afraid of experiments outside of the magical, religious, ahistorical ground,
that such experiments would encompass a view of society and a religious
consciousness open to the situation of the poor and thus able to give them
the means to recover their religious potential and to translate into the
concrete their thirst after liberation as subjects of their history.
29 Consistent, that is, as theology, and not as social science or as science of any
kind. (Though consistent, the theology of Pentecostalism, like the theological training
of its ministers, is far simpler than those of the historical Protestant churches and of
Catholicism.)
roberto motta
during a limited period, either because it represented a kind of “interim ethics,” meant to
assure a smooth transition from religion into a basically secularized politics or because it
resulted from a tactical alliance with a given aim, say, an electoral victory—and this very
likely done in full awareness by at least some of its proponents. This is made possible pre-
cisely because of its syncretic character, its religious and political components being sim-
ply juxtaposed in a kind of cognitive penumbra. Liberation Theology also represents the
quest for a new source of legitimation—valid at least for the interim, a reasonable interval
before complete secularization, during which the vested interests resulting from previous
commitments can be decently safeguarded—for the very existence of the Church, which
will now devote itself to performing high quality services of a political and “historical”
kind.
31 This need not mean, however, that an exit from religion, or from a given religion,
cannot be caused by the inconsistency of a given religious system or even that religious
systems are per se inconsistent.
catholics, afro-brazilians and protestants in brazil
As simple and as attractive as this is, things take a decided turn to the
more complex, when we read that “the uses were dogmatically changed.
Whoever attributed to religion the task of explaining or giving a meaning
to personal or family situations that have no sense at all (illness, death,
failures, disasters) had now to restrict it exclusively to the decodification
of social relations and politics of oppression” (: ).
A nearly totalitarian order was imposed on the diocese:
The whole network of religious services [ . . . ] was declared to be unnec-
essary and even harmful, since it was oriented toward the consumption
of sacraments rather than to evangelization. Movements such as Cursillo,
roberto motta
In spite of the many papers that have been devoted to Liberation Theol-
ogy in Brazil, there has not yet been a sociological, historical, or even
theological full-fledged evaluation of Liberation Theology in Brazil. It
is not clear what, in terms of costs and benefits, it has represented to
the Catholic Church. One of the indicators of those costs and benefits
could be presumed to consist in the demographic evolution of Brazil-
ian Catholicism. According to Brazilian census data, which has included
religious affiliation in virtually every decennial compilation, there were
,, Catholics in and ,, in . There were, in
absolute numbers, ,, more Catholics in the latter year than in
the former.32 Yet, respective to the total population of the country, the
percentage of Catholics fell from in to in . In Rio de
Janeiro which, in spite of its having lost the rank of capital to Brasília, is
still a trend-setting city for the whole country, Catholics were no more
than in .
Meanwhile, the combined membership of the Pentecostal churches
and sects leaped from ,, in (when, for the first time the
census treated them as a separate category) to ,, in —that
is, from . to . of the whole population.33 Pentecostals have
been growing to the tune of one million new adherents each year. A
single church, Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus, experienced indeed
astonishing growth, passing from mere , members in to over
,, in —and it keeps increasing.
Pentecostals have obviously been filling a religious void. On the other
hand, it can be safely stated that the Liberation Theology has not been
32 Brazil underwent very rapid demographic growth in the second half of the th
century. Thus, from around ,, in , the total population had incrased to
around ,, in .
33 Protestants in general (that is, Pentecostals and affiliates of so-called “historical
filling a void. And it does not seem qualified to do so due to its lack of
a consistent theodicy, oriented not only to the coming of a new Heaven,
indeed of a new Earth, but also to the personal, subjective, ordinary needs
of people, taking into account disease, aging, addictions, love, rivalries,
employment, financial difficulties, and all the many dismal failures of
everyday life. “Catholic radicalism,” to use the vocabulary of Emanuel
de Kadt’s () pioneering study, could hardly fail to reflect structural
changes in Brazilian society. It does indeed reflect, to mention but one
aspect of the change, the demographic explosion that took place both in
urban and rural areas of Brazil, originating the huge masses of migrants,
the “marginal population” (cf. Pereira ) that became a prime object
of the interest of radical theologians and who joined so massively the
shrines of Candomblé and the temples of the Pentecostals. At the same
time the clergy have tried to assure themselves, should the end of religion
be at hand, a decent interim by cooperating with the social and political
forces which, during the second half of the th century, could be seen,
at least in Latin America, as the “possessors of History.” In the time of
Gutierrez’s writing of his classic book, there were reasons for his like to
hope that the Cuban model of revolution would sooner or later dominate
the whole continent. The fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of real
socialism in Eastern Europe among other factors entailed the indefinite
postponement of that dream.
Final Remarks
act of faith, which may be associated, according to the case, with elaborate systems of
mythology and of magical practice. But even without mythological systems and/or the
magic practices, religion remains enchanted by the appeal to the supernatural referent.
roberto motta
References
O’Dea, Thomas F. . The Sociology of Religion. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice
Hall.
Otto, Rudolf. . The Idea of the Holy. London: Oxford University Press.
Paim, Antonio (ed.). Pombal e a Cultura Brasileira. Rio de Janeiro: Tempo
Brasileiro.
Perrruci, Glaucília. . Relações de Parentesco e Filiação Religiosa: Uma Visão
Antropológica. Recife: Imprensa Universitária.
Pessoa, Jadir de Morais. . A Igreja da Denúncia e o Silêncio do Fiel. Camp-
inas: Alínea.
Ribeiro, René. . “As Estruturas de Apoio e as Reações do Negro ao Cristian-
ismo na América Portuguesa.” Boletim do Instituto Joaquim Nabuco : –
.
———. . Antropologia da Religião e Outros Estudos. Recife: Massangana.
Rodrigues, Raimundo Nina. . O Animismo Fetichista dos Negros Bahianos.
Rio de Janeiro: Civilização Brasileira.
Rolim, Francisco Cartaxo. . Pentecostais no Brasil: Uma Interpretação Sócio-
Religiosa. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes.
———. “Pentecôtismes et Visions du Monde.” Social Compass : –.
Serbin, Kenneth P. . Needs of the Heart: A Social and Cultural History of
Brazil’s Clergy and Seminaries. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame
Press.
Taylor, Zachary. . The Rise and Progress of Baptist Mission in Brazil, type-
script.
Turner, Victor. “Symbolic Studies.” Annual Review of Anthropology ; –
.
Verger, Pierre. . Notes sur le Culte des Orisa et Vodun à Bahia, la Baie de
tous les Saints au Brésil et à l’ancienne Cote des Esclaves en Afrique. Dakar:
Mémoires de l’Institut Français d’Afrique Noire.
Vieira, David Gueiros. O Protestantismo, a Maçonaria e a Questão Religiosa
no Brasil. Brasília: Editora Universidade de Brasília.
Weber, Max. . “Zwischenbetrachtung: Theorie der Stufen und Richtungen
religiöser Weltablehnung.” Pp. – in Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Religions-
soziologie . Tübingen: Mohr-Siebeck.
———. . Economy and Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.
———. . The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism London: Routledge.
Willems, Emílio. . Followers of New Faith. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt Uni-
versity Press.
Wilson, Bryan R. . Magic and Millennium. Berkeley: University of Califor-
nia Press.
chapter eight
Enzo Pace
stop here to discuss the issue thoroughly) that many religions have always
treated those who embrace another faith as traitors, renegades, heretics,
apostates, and so on. Apostasy, in particular, has been considered a
punishable crime (and still is by some schools of Muslim law), even
warranting the death penalty, since it is configured and still seen not only
as offending God (a sin), but also as a gross deviation from the established
social and political order (a crime). In other words, it is like a breach of
contract, and the party at fault must face the consequences. A person who
converts contracts a new debt, a new obligation to the system of belief that
he has chosen more or less of his own free will. The degree to which his
action is voluntary depends on the historical and social circumstances
in which the conversion takes place and can be determined from the set
of constraints on the conversion process itself. It is one thing to speak
of compulsory conversions, quite another when an individual has had
freedom of choice: between two opposite poles—no freedom on the one
hand and total arbitrary freedom on the other. (There are also various
intermediate situations to which we shall return later.)
There is therefore a sort of irony for the systems of belief: the more
they claim to be faithful custodians of an absolute truth and entrust the
responsibility for defending it to an established authority, the supreme
head of a religious organization, the more conversions are seen as a snub
of this authority (rather than of the truth, which can continue to circulate
freely, albeit in fragments, in the socio-religious environment), because
conversions point to a weakness in the image the authority wants to
portray of itself as the illuminated and ultimate holder of the truth.
While on this issue, it is worth noting what happens in the now
boundless world of Protestant branches and denominations, where new
churches and new sects have continued to flourish ever since the Ref-
ormation, confirming the structural weakness of the organizing princi-
ple that has progressively taken shape behind Protestantism (Willaime
), unlike other Christian churches, and the Catholic church in par-
ticular. Since this organizing principle is founded on the idea that every
human being illuminated by the faith, as laid down in the Bible, poten-
tially has the church within him, conversion becomes more of a men-
tal attitude than of individuals choosing to become associated with one
church rather than another, abandoning the church of their birth to join
a new sect, and so on.
This is why it is important to make the point that not all conversions are
equal. There is clearly a huge difference between the conversion of Paul
of Tarsus and the compulsory conversions of Hebrews and Muslims after
convert, revert, pervert
. Rational-instrumental: . Rational-value-oriented:
Conversion is the result of a more or less Conversion is the outcome of a convinced
refined calculation. adhesion to a system of belief and its
values.
I become converted because it suits my
purposes, without allowing myself to I become converted because I think the
become very involved on an emotional new faith offers a better set of values than
plane or in terms of my lifestyle. others.
. Traditional-conformist: . Charismatic-subjective:
The conversion is due to the conversion The conversion derives from an affective
policy that a dominant system of belief and emotional interaction between a
adopts in relation to those who originally spiritual leader and a disciple, who allows
did not adhere to it. himself to be guided along the paths of
the spirit.
I become converted to conform to the
rules of social interplay that the religion I become converted because I have found
of the majority helps to reinforce, since it a life that leads to an interior illumination
is seen as a pillar of the established social and the discovery of a truth that the
order. religion of my birth (or lack of religion)
was unable to make me understand.
enzo pace
The first case study that I propose to examine concerns the phenomenon
of conversions in modern-day Indian society. For some years now, there
has been both political and religious controversy over the increasing
number of conversions from Hinduism to other religions—particularly
to Islam, Christianity, and the Bahá"i faith. It is hard to say how many
people change religion in a year because such information is often pro-
vided by the leaders of movements undertaking intensive conversion
campaigns. It is relatively easy, instead, to document the controversies
that have arisen in India since between movements of different
religious and political tendencies, the bone of contention being places
of worship or conversions from one religion to another. The choice of
this date is merely a convention and refers to a march organized by Shri
convert, revert, pervert
Advani (born in Pakistan in ), the leader of the BJP (Bharatiya Janata
Party, the center-right nationalist party that governed India from to
), from the Hindu temple of Somnath in the state of Gujarat to the
Babri Mosque, which dated back to the time of the moguls (built in ),
in the city of Ayodhya, in the state of Uttar Pradesh. This was not the only
place of Muslim prayer in the city of Ayodhya or in the surrounding state
of "Uttar Pradesh, which has approximately million Muslim residents
amidst a total population of more than million people, but its sym-
bolic significance was particularly manipulable by neo-Hinduists.
This march between the two cities took the form of a pilgrimage based
on a very popular Hindu ritual called the rath yatra (yatra meaning pil-
grimage, while rath means cart), a religious festival particularly famous
in the state of Orissa, when millions of people embark on a spiritual walk
in summer, accompanying large allegorical carts on which the principal
Hindu divinities are enthroned. The march became one of the first politi-
cal and religious actions launched by the new nationalist party. As leader
of the BJP, Advani was to say: “If Muslims are entitled to an Islamic atmo-
sphere in Mecca, and if Christians are entitled to a Christian atmosphere
in the Vatican, why is it wrong for the Hindus to expect a Hindu atmo-
sphere in Ayodhya?” (in Brass : ).
The message was clear, and the important point to note is that the
leader of the neo-Hinduist party, with the aid of the movements and
groups for Hindu religious reawakening, invented a repertoire for trig-
gering a collective action along two planes, one religious and the other
political. The traditional rituals were reinvented and become a set of
collective gestures expressing a political tension, a visible statement of
Hindu identity that was seen as being threatened by Muslims, Jainists,
Christians or the followers of Bahá"i, as the case may be. At the time of the
first march in , for instance, there were numerous incidents with the
police along the way, especially when the kar sevaks (militants who took
part in the march or joined in along the way) claimed to each be carrying
a brick that was to serve in the reconstruction of the Rama temple, after
the mosque in Ayodhya had been destroyed. The police succeeded then
in preventing an assault on the mosque, though some people lost their
lives in the fight, and they immediately became the martyrs of Ayodhya.
The organizers of the march had dotted the whole route with a number
of rituals well known to the Hindu population, such as blowing shankhs
(conch shells) in the streets, ghanta gharial (ringing prayer bells and
beating on alloyed metal plates), raising saffron flags in the day-time
and organizing mashals (processions bearing flaming torches) at night
enzo pace
Saraswati, who founded the Noble Society (Arya Samaj) in . This
project was designed as a genuine hermeneutic effort to renew Hinduism
and make it suitable for meeting the challenges of the modern world
imposed by British colonial rule. There are interesting analogies here with
the reawakening movement that developed around the same time in the
American Protestant and the Sunnite Muslim environments—i.e. in very
different parts of the world and in profoundly different settings, in the
sense that Arya Samaj also proposed to redefine the fundamentals of the
real Hindu faith. In order of importance, these are:
Faith in a single, supreme God, the source of all knowledge, an intelligent
and merciful, right and universal presence, the only entity worthy of being
venerated.
The Veda (or scriptures) are the only source of truth and understanding,
the infallible, unchangeable, holy word to which all Arya must conform.
All human actions must comply with the cosmic law of the Dharma, and
must consequently be inspired by principles of love, justice and rectitude;
All this is achieved by promoting the well-being of all and being committed
to promoting understanding and defeating ignorance.
As we can see, Dayananda’s thinking tends to redraw the universe of
Hindu beliefs in monotheistic terms, bringing the foundations of the
faith down to a simplified system of belief that we can picture as follows:
Arya Samaj thus stands at the crossroads between two powerful move-
ments in Indian society at the end of the th century: on the one hand,
there is the need to be free of the British colonial yoke; on the other, the
hope of a cultural and spiritual redemption achieved by returning to the
purified and revisited religious roots of Hinduism, from which to embark
on a path of reawakening (Singh ). One of Dayananda’s closest col-
laborators within the Arya Samaj reinterpreted the ancient shuddhi ritual
to adapt it to what we might define as a reversion policy. In fact, it literally
means purification, but also reversion (or reverting after converting). Its
origins can probably be traced back to the times when India was domi-
nated by the Mogul empire, and many Hindus converted to Islam. With
the decline of Muslim rule, the shuddhi was subsequently perfected to
facilitate the return of these converts to their original religion, taking
on a form that the Arya Samaj leaders and militants revived to restore
these converts to Hinduism. The ceremony is straightforward: it involves
washing your feet and drinking a little water from the holy river Ganges
(Gangajal). Such a re-baptism in water symbolically cleanses the person
who had been contaminated by another religion. In the language of the
Arya Samaj, this means bringing “home” those who were lost, returning
them to the fold. So, reversion presupposes not only a previous conver-
sion, but also the idea that said conversion to another faith has tainted
the individual with an infamous sin, making him a pervert, a traitor to
the faith of his forbears.
The context in which the revisited shuddhi ritual takes place today is
characterized by recurrent socio-religious disputes, more acute in some
areas and less so in others, but generally arising in all the states where
Hindu extremists are particularly active in accusing people who have
converted to Islam or Christianity of being responsible for the Hindu
people’s loss of traditional values and identity, supporting the political
rhetoric of movements like the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), a
national voluntary organization founded in by a physician origi-
nally from Nagpur, or the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP or World Hindu
Council), a branch of the RSS created in . The shuddhi is part of a
repertoire of collective activities that functionally rally political consent
in favor of the BJP, the political party that has succeeded in becoming the
essence of, and an image for the above-mentioned movements.
The repertoire includes actions with variable degrees of violence, both
symbolic and physical: from insistent efforts to persuade people who
have converted to re-convert to their original religion, to assaults on
places of worship (as in a case of the mosque in Ayodhya), to acts of
convert, revert, pervert
The table gives just a very brief idea of the conversion controversy that,
for many years now, has not only made the news, but has also and above
all become a social indicator of the religious and political conflicts taking
place in more or less violent and aggressive forms in various Indian states.
It is not easy to distinguish clearly between the different dimensions of
these conflicts, where religion ends and politics or economics begins, and
vice versa. There was certainly an increase in the number of such conflicts
between and , a decade in which Indian society underwent
profound economic changes that altered the social stratification founded
on the survival of the caste system. The most evident sign of these changes
is the growth of the Dalit movement, which is striving to overcome the
cultural and socio-economic obstacles that currently prevent . of
the Indian population from fully accessing the rights of citizenship. There
is often a very close link between their expectations of social justice and
economic reinstatement on the one hand, and a propensity to abandon
the mainly-Hindu religion of their birth and opt for other religions on
the other (Fernandes , Oddie ).
This case study on conversions in the Indian subcontinent is an inter-
esting test for analyzing the conversion phenomenon as a battle taking
place along the symbolic boundaries between systems of belief in a soci-
ety that has historically been pluralist from the religious standpoint. The
battle follows a precise narrative scheme: conversion is seen by a sys-
tem of belief as a perversion, so action to obtain a reversion becomes
a communication and action strategy (a socio-religious action strategy)
implemented by one system against another. The action is imagined as
the reconquest of a lost soul and celebrated with rites of purification. To
defend its boundaries, each system tends to describe its competitors as
the expression of falsity, impurity, the reign of darkness, as opposed to
its own, the one and only true and pure faith, the resplendent reign of
light (i.e., truth). The conversion-reversion processes thus act like pilot
lights, showing how difficult it is for the systems of belief to preside
over their territories and their sacred boundaries, since it has become
so easy for these boundaries to be overcome, as if they had become
porous and communicative, despite attempts made by each opposing sys-
tem to demonstrate that they, and only they, are bearers of the truth. By
dint of shouting at each other that their converts are perverts or that
they have renounced the light of the true faith, the representatives of
the various Indian religious denominations seem to be admitting that
their respective systems of belief are no longer able to control the pro-
duction of sense, since an individual’s freedom to choose the religion
enzo pace
that suits his spiritual needs and his expectations of social justice have
evidently increased in their socio-religious setting. So the case of India
is telling us that a process is underway that is eroding “the principle of
religious revenue”: a system of belief that represents itself as the hori-
zon of sense, and that was taken for granted as part of the daily life
of an entire population, is being put to the test by these conversions,
which give us a measure (in the case discussed here) of a liquid reli-
giousness, to borrow a category dear to Bauman (), which precisely
translates the idea of a permeability of the system’s symbolic bound-
aries.
The second case study concerns Habad. The name is an acronym derived
from the first letters of the Hebrew words hochmah (wisdom), binah
(understanding), and da"at (knowledge). The movement began in a small
town in Belarus called Lubavitch, around the figure of the first rebbe, or
charismatic leader, Schneur Zalman, from Liadi (–). The move-
ment forms part of a larger network of Hasidic (hasidim, or ‘the pious’, in
Hebrew) communities (or courts), composed of a number of families.
Originally, these families traced their common descent from a charis-
matic leader who transmitted his extraordinary powers “through the
blood.” The leader of a Hasidic court is considered a mediator between
the “celestial court” and the “earthly” one. Thanks to his exceptional pow-
ers of sanctity, the leader is able to put the human community in commu-
nication with the world of the divine. At the same time, he has often been
seen as a spiritual master and healer, the community’s political leader and
the bearer of a special gift, the ability to perform miracles (mofsin) and
to ward off misfortune. Because of this concentration of extraordinary
powers, the Hasidic communities chose to call their leaders rebbe, rather
than use the traditional term of rabbi (Abramovitch and Galvin ,
Mintz , Ravitzky ).
The last Rebbe of the Habad movement was Menachem Mendel
Schneerson. His views form part of the Jewish Messianic school of
thought, which sees redemption as a public event that will occur in his-
tory and arise within the community of the pious who await the Messiah.
The community, therefore, is a sort of living laboratory from which the
face of the Messiah will emerge. The Messiah in question is Ben David, of
convert, revert, pervert
really proclaimed himself as such, but he also did little to counter this
belief. In April , a group of Lubavitch rabbis made an authoritative
statement in which they identified the messianic traits of Rebbe Schneer-
son (Ravitzky : ), provoking criticism from within the movement
itself from other, more cautious rabbis who had misgivings about identi-
fying the figure of the Messiah with the head of the movement. Ten years
after the Rebbe’s death, the messianic belief is still very much alive. Its
missionary zeal provides ample proof of this: the movement has grown
by in ten years and can boast approximately , missionaries in
countries around the world.
Habad Messianism thus represents a sort of symbolic capital that has
accumulated thanks to the charismatic force of a leader who, in his
lifetime, became a cultural resource for the organization that has helped
make the Habad movement active and competitive in the contemporary
Jewish religious market. It is against this backdrop of a reawakening of the
observance of the precepts of the Torah and the refound Jewish identity
that we can understand the conversion policy fine-tuned by the Habad
movement. This is inspired by the conviction that the Messiah will arrive
when the last Jew returns to complying with all the divine precepts. This
means that militants of the movement consider Jews who have chosen to
live their religion of birth in a more secular manner as a hindrance, an
intolerable cause of delay in the Messiah’s return, the signs of which are
now unequivocal, according to Lubavitch’s followers (signs such as the
opportunity to re-establish the holy boundaries of the Promised Land in
Israel after the victorious Six-Day War of ).
Habad’s proselytism consequently focuses primarily on all those Jews
who no longer practice their religion or who have a purely cultural
relationship with the religion of their birth. A passerby might be asked,
“Excuse me, are you Jewish?” If they answer yes, they are invited to
climb into a camper van with a view to restoring them to the right
path. Jews who have become assimilated and secularized are the main
target in the battle conducted by these militants in their tanks. Such
military language is not used by accident and is not ours, but typical
of the missionary rhetoric of the Habad: their camper vans are spiritual
combat vehicles that can be converted into a mini synagogue every time
someone agrees to revert—wearing as a sign of purification the teffilin
(the phylactery, which indicate the refound link with the divinity and
with the community of the pure and the holy sons of Israel).
Jews who have become assimilated with the world are consequently
seen as people who have allowed themselves to be contaminated by the
enzo pace
spirit of modernity. They have become impure. They no longer wear the
clothes of their forebears. They do not pray according to the ritual rules,
and they fail to follow the kashrut (strict diet), to respect the Sabbath, and
so on. The mitzvah tank, according to Schneerson, was a standard van; its
back door was rolled up, showing a cargo of one large wooden table, two
wooden benches, and a dozen young men with beards and black hats. A
poster taped to the sides of the moving van said “Teffilin on board” and
“Mitzvot On The Spot For People On The Go.” They are modern means,
or rather machines, where a cleansing ritual is celebrated for those who
have lost the true faith. From this point of view, they are like traveling
clinics, where zealous soul-doctors seek to convince all those who seem
Jewish to them, or have admitted to being Jewish, to “return home,” to
emerge from the perverse condition that failure to comply with the Holy
Commandments evokes in their eyes.
This time the battle is not conducted along boundaries separating
different systems of belief, but within one and the same system that has
experienced a process of wide diversification in the course of its historical
evolution, and especially in modern times, along an axis with people who
no longer believe, or whose way of life has become entirely secularized,
at one end and those who wish to observe all the precepts to the letter
at the other, with a variety of types of behavior and attitudes in between,
depending on the variable scale of intensity of their belief, their sense of
belonging, and their religious practices.
Conclusion
References
Abramovitch, Ilana, and Seán Galvin (eds.). . Jews in Brooklyn. London:
University Press of England.
Allievi, Stefano. . I nuovi musulmani. Rome: Edizioni Lavoro.
Bacchetta, Paola. . “Sacred Space in Conflict in India: the Babri Masjid
Affair.” Growth and Change : –.
Bauman, Zygmunt. . Vita liquida. Rome-Bari: Laterza.
Bhatt, Chetan. . Hindu Nationalism. Oxford: Berg.
Brass, Paul (ed.). , Riots and Pogroms. New York: New York University Press.
———. , The Production of Hindu-Muslim Violence in Contemporary India.
Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Brodowicz, Schlomoh. . L’âme d’Israël. Paris: Édition du Rocher.
Davie, Grace, Paul Heelas, Linda Woodhead (eds.). . Predicting Religion.
Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
Douglas, Mary. . Purity and Danger. London: Routledge.
Dumont, Louis. . Homo Hierarchicus. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ehrlich, Avrum M. . Leadership in the Habad Movement. Jerusalem: Jason
Aronson.
Elst, Koenraad. . The Saffron and the Swastika. New Delhi: Voice of India.
Feldman, Jan. . Lubavitcher as Citizens. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Fernandes Walter. . Caste and Conversion Movement in India. New Delhi:
Indian Social Institute.
Flanagan, Kieran, and Peter Jupp (eds.), A Sociology of Spirituality. Aldershot,
UK: Ashgate.
Foucault, Michel. . Dits et Ecrits, vol. . Paris: Gallimard.
———. . Naissance de la biopolitique. Paris: Gallimard.
Giordan, Giuseppe. . “Spirituality: From a Religious Concept to a Socio-
logical Theory.” Pp. – in A Sociology of Spirituality, edited by Kieran
Flanagan and Peter Jupp. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
enzo pace
In the Italian context of the last twenty years, Buddhism has been one of
the fastest growing religious traditions. In this religious environment, it
appears that forms of religious identification not foreseeing the abandon-
ment of one’s primary religious identity have been increasingly spread-
ing. Therefore, “Catholics in Buddhism,” referring specifically to Soka
Gakkai, will be considered here as an exemplary case of conversion as a
new lifestyle. We will thus analyze, in actual cases, the practices through
which this type of conversion and consequent identification develop, and
the cognitive strategies utilized to place this identification inside a differ-
ent religious identity.1
This first section examines the notion of a post-secular society—a soci-
ety in which secularization has encouraged new religious and culturally
significant phenomena to manifest themselves because of their connec-
tions with the secularized world and religions. The second section rein-
troduces the classic four-cell typology of conversion: vertical conversion,
processual conversion, interactionist and horizontal conversion, coer-
cive conversion. In the third section, an additional type of conversion
is hypothesized: conversion as a new lifestyle. Finally, we report data col-
lected through field work conducted in the city of Torino (Turin) in
by way of interviews and accounts of people converted to Soka Gakkai.2
1 The text of the chapter as a whole is by Luigi Berzano, except for the detailed research
men. In Italy there are , members. Comparable data for the North American context
can be found in Coleman () and Geekie ().
conversion as a new lifestyle
some cases it means practicing the religion to which one already belongs
more actively; in other cases the final result of the search is a more or less
exclusive following of a new religion.
The second factor that contributes to the phenomenon of new con-
versions is the enfeeblement of the conviction that one’s own religion
is the sole “true religion.” In a pluralistic society it is difficult to main-
tain the conviction that there is just one true religion and that all the
others are wrong. The dogmatic principle of Catholic theology—extra
ecclesiam nulla salus—is substituted by that of thousands of ways of sal-
vation to be followed through individual choices. The globalization of
science and technology has brought down the barriers of time and space
that separated individuals and have produced the condition, which Peter
Berger has defined as “urbanization of conscience” in our modern world:
all individuals are bombarded by multiplicities of communications and
information (see Berger, Berger and Kellner : ). In the future, the
Internet will intensify this horizontal dimension of society and religions,
thus creating a global and immediate culture that will enfeeble all tra-
ditional ties of faith and reciprocity. For religions the fall of their verti-
cal and hierarchical structure will mean a fall—in the area of reflected
thought—of a sole metaphysical thought in favor of processes of abstrac-
tion that will be led by the sciences and technologies.
In Italy, an indicator of the growing enfeeblement of the Catholic
faith as the sole point of reference for its followers is represented by
what has been described as: strong identity and enfeebled identification
by some research (Berzano, Genova and Pace ; Berzano and Zoc-
catelli ). Religious identity is the religious definition individuals give
of themselves so that they can speak of we/us as opposed to I/me. About
of Italians still declare themselves to have a Catholic identity. To
date, therefore, the Catholic identity has held fast as if by the “law of
inertia,” almost as if the imprinting of primary socialization still has a
significant effect. On the other hand, among Italian Catholics strong
identification (upholding beliefs, practices and Catholic morals) occurs
among less than . Identification means the influence of an indi-
vidual’s self-recognition in the developed collective Catholic entity on
choices, actions, and interests. Strong identification for most Catholics
means more and more a waiver of one’s own independence or “a luxury”
to which one cannot aspire. The context of growing religious supply can-
not but stimulate more attempts to experiment with successive and serial
identifications; it is in such contexts that processes of socialization start
up, leading to other religious universes. This datum, moreover, is partly
conversion as a new lifestyle
encouraged by the fact that many groups and religious movements do not
require an effective conversion, but often simply require a lifestyle that
does not exclude multiple religious belonging. Therefore, today, religious
contexts prevail, and the Italian one is no exception, in which religious
identities do not always consequently correspond to religious identifica-
tions. Identity and identification do not reproduce each other ascriptively
in the same way.
The analysis of today’s conversions cannot underestimate these two
aspects of differentiation between identity and identification. The for-
mer differentiation refers to the rise of religious pluralism and the mul-
tiplication of religious groups and associations available on the religious
market; the latter concerns the differentiation of practices, interests, and
styles of religious activity that the individual chooses among various reli-
gious organizations. On the basis of this double differentiation, it can
be said that the opportunities to develop new forms of identity and
identification have never been as many as they are in current societies.
The current religious condition therefore allows the individual to alter-
nate between developing identities and identifications in two directions:
either by broadening affinities and differences based on personal moti-
vations or, instead, by regressing toward elementary and fundamentalist
identities and identifications.
The third factor that triggers new sociological interest in the study
of conversion is the current age, which defines itself as post-secular.
Post-secular not in the sense that secularization processes are no longer
present, but in the sense, instead, that—paraphrasing Weber—due to a
linking of circumstances, they have led in the very field of disenchant-
ment and secularization to the manifestation of significant cultural phe-
nomena due to the connections between the secularized world and reli-
gions. The effects of secularization have not emptied religion of its reli-
gious experience, its history and its knowledge; they have simply trans-
formed links with the diversity of the secular world. In historical religions
the post-secular condition is that which is characterized by all the effects
of secularization, but also by the new spiritual resources and links that
living secularism generates.
This is the current picture of religious interests and of spiritual moods
together with their links with the post-secular age: a reassessment of
experiences of the sacred, the rebirth of multiple forms of religion, a
demand for spirituality and ethical needs addressed to religious expe-
rience but not always automatically derivable from rationality, new spir-
itual bents for religious knowledge, and an ever-increasing differentia-
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
Vertical Conversion
According to Gerardus Van der Leeuw (: –), vertical conver-
sion is a type of conversion in all religions, where there is a second ego that
rises beside the first ego; everything is transformed and a new life com-
mences. The fundamental experience is the same for all converts: new
potential enters life and the convert feels completely different. Life has a
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
new foundation and starts again. At the beginning of this type of con-
version there is a sort of ecstasy or theophany that totally consumes the
convert. Historically these conversions have accompanied great move-
ments or “awakenings.”
Converts recount this type of conversion as a narrative of a transfor-
mation from an initial to a final state, mediated by a turning point that
represents the crucial event around which the whole story is built. The
convert reinterprets past events and characters on the basis of the ideol-
ogy of the new group and of its value system. In recounting the experi-
ence, the convert provides two interpretations: a negative one concerning
the past and a positive one concerning the present. The past before con-
version is described as something that had to be overcome. The convert
finds the positive premises in the actual negative ones of the past, and
this is where the conversion begins. By highlighting this discontinuity
with the past, even the identity of the convert represents a rebirth that
solves all problems.
In converts’ accounts of their turning point there is always a move from
a reference-language function to a constitutive one. In the former, the
convert recalls meanings, values and beliefs (the doctrinal system) shared
by the group to which conversion was made. However, in this phase
there is a repertoire of semi-propositional elements that are not clearly
defined.3 The constitutive function of language occurs when the subject
acknowledges the new doctrinal system and takes possession of it. Insofar
as the convert internalizes the newly shared beliefs and values, the group
is enriched with the production of progressive narratives concerning the
change.
Processual Conversion
Processual conversion is a gradual religious transformation both of the
religious identity of an individual and of one’s everyday identification
with the new religion. The gradualness of such a process is character-
ized in the subsequent phases through which the convert acquires the
knowledge, motivation, attitudes, and practices needed to live with the
new religious and relational world to which she or he aspires to belong.
terized by an undetermined content and are not supported by empirical data. This does
not mean they are irrational: they are assumed rationally if there are rational grounds to
trust the source of the beliefs.
conversion as a new lifestyle
4 Some authors (e.g., Dawson :–) refer to this biographical process as the
tions and interactions with individuals and groups with whom one lives.
Conversions occur from social events and social networks that are built
on the basis of proximity and working and living together. In particu-
lar in post-secular societies where the two pillars of traditional religious
identity (ascribed religion and the only true religion) have become fee-
ble, religions, too, are constituted more and more as horizontal social sys-
tems.
Lofland and Stark () propose a seven-stage model, Wilson and
Dobbelaere () a four-stage one, and Mara Einstein () a “rela-
tionship marketing” one, all of which include features unique to the cases
and interactionist features. Lofland and Stark’s model is based on inter-
views with a group of converted “Moonies,” one of the early communities
of the growing movement of Reverend Moon’s Unification Church in the
United States. This model is constituted by seven factors that slowly lead
the individual to become, first a convert in words and then a total convert.
These converts begin as followers who profess a faith and are accepted
by members of the core group as sincere, but do not have an active role
in the movement. Total converts show their involvement through words
and actions. According to the Lofland/Stark conversion model, a person
must () experience enduring and acutely-felt tensions, () within a reli-
gious problem-solving perspective, () which results in self-designation
as a religious seeker, and the prospective convert must () encounter the
movement or cult at a turning point in life, () wherein an affective bond
is formed with one or more converts, () where extra-cult attachments
are absent or neutralized, and () where the convert is exposed to inten-
sive interaction to become an active and dependable adherent. Each of
the seven steps is required, but only the sum of them leads to a true—
that is, total—conversion.
Wilson and Dobbelaere’s model, which includes four phases already
described by Remy and Hiernaux (), is significant because it inter-
prets the Soka Gakkai-like conversion process in Great Britain not as a
search for religious meaning but as a solution to the problems of one’s
daily life. Only after conversion does the convert with perseverance in the
new religion move on from daily problems to search and conquer bud-
dhity, that is, “inner light,” which is defined as a condition of profound
and total happiness. The most important object of the cult, the gohonzon,
is bestowed to the convert only in this phase. As for the factors that trig-
ger conversion, Wilson and Dobbelaere (: ) report the importance
of social networks and affective bonds: came to know the move-
ment thanks to social interaction. Of these, the majority ( ) were
conversion as a new lifestyle
Forced Conversion
According to the model of mental manipulation (“brainwashing”) con-
version would occur in the case of individuals affected by serious psycho-
logical problems, or where groups would attract followers into confined
communities and exert pressure, threats, or even physical abuse against
them. The literature concerning coercive conversions goes beyond the
purely phenomenological interest of this chapter, to deal with the reasons
and mechanisms of conversion above all, and possible physical abuse
to the subjects involved. An exemplary example of coercive conversion
might be that of suicide terrorists. However Iannaccone and Introvi-
gne () conducted research on the membership of new movements
and religious groups involved in terrorist actions or suicides. On the
basis of the data of this research, they concluded that it is not the well-
known brainwashing factor (nor even poverty or social exclusion) that
explains forced conversions, but instead a set of personal relations. Con-
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
5 Thus Reimer (:) says that “the analysis of lifestyles therefore should show
similarities and differences between groups of individuals rather than similarities and
differences between individuals.”
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
We chose to conduct a field study with the Soka Gakkai in Torino, given
the particularly hybrid nature of this Buddhist movement. It is in fact
secular and completely integrated with advanced modern society. It is
missionary in using one sole text of Buddha’s teachings, the Lotus Sutra. It
proposes a gradual conversion to its followers. It has a strong community
spirit. The aim of the research was to establish: () whether the method of
conversion is interactionist, horizontal, and/or the result of a process—
i.e., how much interpersonal relations count and whether the conversion
is sudden or the result of a process; () to what extent the converts
sought a new spiritual experience to solve their daily problems rather
than exclusive and irreversible adherence to a religion; () to what extent
they wished to try practices, i.e., a new lifestyle, rather than follow an
organized set of beliefs and moral obligations.
Our considerations and the tables reported are based on interviews
and life histories of the followers of the Soka Gakkai in Torino, inter-
viewed in and . There were women and men, aged
conversion as a new lifestyle
Ways of Conversion
“I would like to know how you came to know Soka Gakkai. When and
how did you join? What was your course?” As Table shows, almost
all the interviewees replied that they had learned about Soka Gakkai
mainly through friends, then relatives or acquaintances. Among acquain-
tances, there are, for instance, co-workers, neighbors, and a teacher.
There is a difference as far as the person who does shakubuku, (intro-
duces one to Soka Gakkai Buddhism): women were mostly introduced
by friends, while for men, it was with the same frequency for a friend as
a relative/partner. Neo-converts related during interviews how they got
involved through a person they trusted.
6 The extracts quoted are from both the interviews and life histories, without dis-
crimination between the two data sources. The nine life stories were collected by Nicola
Pannofino ().
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
A friend had joined the organization about two years before. She often
spoke to me about Buddhism. Out of interest I asked if I could attend a
meeting. It was in October , and I have never stopped attending since.
(S)
A good friend told me, someone who is very dear to me and still is. She
spoke to me in a difficult moment of my life; I was going through a hard
time on all counts and she spoke to me about Buddhism because she had
learned about it from her sister, who is also a close friend of mine . . . . I
have known her since I was . . . six years old, and so we grew up together.
We were in elementary and middle school, and so I trusted her. (S)
At times more than one family member is involved, often a sister, brother,
mother, daughter or partner convert because they see the change in their
loved one; or either the neo-convert manages to convince someone to try
the practice with insistence.
My sister started to practice after one year, and she told me it was because
she had seen the change in me and that made me happy. (S)
My daughter introduced me to SG, she would say: “I’m going to the
Buddhist meeting,” and I thought it was those chanting Hare Krishna
whom I had seen once in Florence. I thought “My daughter has gone
crazy!” And then I saw her at home chanting this mantra. Then she said:
“Why don’t you come to the meeting?” and I went because I have always
had great trust in my children and so I thought if she was asking me . . . I
went a little—so to speak—taken by the hand, led, right? (S)
My girlfriend [ . . .] when she saw I was practicing she came along as well.
Now she practices every day. (S)
My girlfriend told me about this practice. We have been engaged for over
six years. She started telling me about the practice when we got engaged. At
the start this thing sort of—I won’t say bothered me—but I said to myself:
“It’s her business, these things have nothing to do with me.” In fact, the
more she tried to talk me into it, the more it bothered me. I’d say: “Forget
it!” (S)
Buddhism was like, how it worked, the fundamental things. And then we
decided to take part in the first meeting, which was at her house, with her
father’s consent of course . . .. Following the first meeting I started to take
an interest in it, too, and then we went some of the way together. We used
to attend the fortnightly meetings, and at home we tried to pray together,
helping each other, that is to say when one, say, didn’t [feel like it] then
the other would encourage her a little [ . . . ] Anyway it was a novelty for us
both. (S)
Only in one case out of thirty-five interviewees did the encounter with
Soka Gakkai not occur through social networks but was triggered by
happenstance:
It was pretty strange because I went to a fortune-teller. I was curious
because it was a very difficult time in my life, I couldn’t find answers to
questions I had put to myself, and I met this person in a shop. I went
to see her. This person read my cards. She told me some very general
things, and then she said: “If you really want to change your life, recite this
sentence” and she wrote it for me on a piece of paper, she actually wrote
the pronunciation. (S)
We must notice the difference here with Wilson and Dobbelaere’s
research conducted in the early s in Great Britain concerning the
go-between of conversion. In that research, of the people learned
about Soka Gakkai through such things as the media, an exhibition, a
concert, or letters, while another by chance encounters (:).
In our case almost everyone started practicing upon the advice of people
well known to them; there is only one case of a chance meeting, and even
it involved an interpersonal interaction. There are also significant differ-
ences concerning the person who does shakubuku (a friend, relative or
acquaintance), if the years of practice are taken into account. In Table
it can be seen that neo-converts (from months to five years of prac-
tice) learned about Soka Gakkai mainly through relatives or co-workers;
for those who have between six and ten years practice, the go-between
is with the same frequency a friend or a relative/partner; for those who
have more than ten years of practice, the go-between was more often a
friend. These data may shed some light on how the social network that
leads to conversion changes in time.
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
problems. She is slowly getting used to it. She’s still not happy when I say:
“It’s Thursday, I’m going to the meeting . . ..” She’s not happy, but there’s no
longer that distressing anger. It was real rage at the start. (S)
Our study hypothesized that joining Soka Gakkai was the result of a pro-
cess rather than immediate conversion, which in fact proved to be the
most frequent course. Usually our interviewees acquired practices that
gradually became part of their daily lives. Theoretical study was under-
taken only later through workshops or courses in Italy and abroad. How-
ever, occasionally there was strong identification concerning Buddhist
philosophy or belief from the very start.
My conversion started because I was finally getting the answers I hadn’t
found previously. . . . [I]t was like . . . putting on some comfortable shoes
that fit perfectly, that’s what Buddhism was like for me . . . I keep on saying
it’s like you had a question in life to answer, you feel like you are in the
wrong place, at a certain stage someone arrives who says. “This is the
answer” and it’s just perfect, there’s no other answer. That’s what I feel. (S)
The Buddhist principles seemed to belong to me, I felt them deep down,
at last ideas and language which suit my way of life. That was the trigger.
(S)
This philosophy is . . . like a made-to-measure dress. In fact when I
approached this Buddhism, I read a book entitled “Buddhist philosophy”,
I thought that if I had had such clear ideas I could have written it myself, I
mean it was exactly my way of interpreting life. (S)
Just over half of the interviewees appear to have had a period of seeking
before they met up with Soka Gakkai Buddhism. For example, either
they had shown interest in white magic and astrology or had undertaken
spiritual or religious readings, or they had practiced yoga, reiki and
martial arts (judo, kungfu), or Japan and the Far East appealed to them.
Others had followed a psychological track.
I have always believed . . . er . . . believed in the universe, the planets, the
influence of the planets on man. So I looked into it a little, therefore white
magic and cards, yes, card reading and stones . . . I didn’t just read my
horoscope in magazines, I actually studied zodiac signs, planet matching,
that sort of thing . . . I love Japan, manga already appealed to me . . . My
boyfriend was studying Japanese, that is we were really getting into this
thing on Japan . . . Initially I went because I was curious, because they took
their shoes off and did these Japanese things. (S)
I have always been a seeker, and I got into white magic; I did solstice and
equinox rites . . . I did some research on Buddhism which I had learned
about through reading Hermann Hesse, who is one of my favorite writers.
(S)
conversion as a new lifestyle
At the root of the three hypotheses on which this survey was grounded,
we were interested in examining a new type of conversion that includes
horizontal and processual transformation, together with greater atten-
tion to practices rather than values, which constitutes a new type of con-
version: conversion as a lifestyle.
As far as the hypothesis regarding horizontality and processual trans-
formation, the data revealed that all the interviewees followed an inter-
actionist and horizontal procedure. Practically all the interviewees were
introduced to Soka Gakkai by friends, relatives, or acquaintances. There
is just one case of a totally chance meeting (a fortune-teller). There-
fore the message is transmitted by social networks; the message deserves
credit because it comes from a well-known person who is trusted. Most
of the conversion procedures can be described as a process. The intervie-
wees were usually encouraged to attend a meeting by a person of their
social circle, or they received simple instructions from them on how to
recite the daimoku. They started practicing immediately or after some
time. The initially erratic practice became daily thereafter. A pattern of
conversion can be traced in clearly distinguishable stages:
. Crisis or search: The reason to join is due to a difficult moment in
life or because curiosity is aroused. In the latter case, the person was
already into religious or spiritual-esoteric seeking.
. Meeting and practicing the daimoku: Following a trusted person’s
instructions one starts practicing or attends a meeting. There may
be discontinuity in this phase; practicing may start and stop. Defec-
tion is highest at this stage.
. Stabilization: Practice becomes a daily routine, and one mixes with
the practicing group. Usually material benefits can be seen in one’s
life.
. Maturity: The practice has become binding; there is total religious
identification. There are psychological and spiritual benefits. Ex-
pressive vocabulary that makes the group legitimate is seen in the
interviews. Often converts join the hierarchy and may criticize the
organization or the people in charge.
The second hypothesis was aimed at understanding to what extent the
neo-converts sought a new spiritual experience to solve their everyday
problems, rather than wanting to belong exclusively and irreversibly to
a religion. The interviews revealed that most people started practicing
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
because they were in a state of crisis, almost as if it were the last resort.
This means trying a practice that seems to offer therapeutic benefits, not
identifying with a religion. Others, who were not affected by a crisis,
seemed to be more or less consciously seeking a spiritual path, certainly
not a religion with its rules and its clergy.
As for the hypothesized conversion as a lifestyle, it can be said that,
particularly in this type of Buddhism, the individual is often involved in
practice and participation in a group well before assimilating the philo-
sophical and value system. Reasons for conversion often rest on the indi-
vidual’s personal sensitivity and the personal meaning that is attributed to
the framework of practices. This can clearly been seen in the reasons the
interviewees give when they say they consider themselves Soka Gakkai
Buddhists. They claim they approached Buddhism because it is a philos-
ophy that does not contemplate a superior being and relies significantly
on individual responsibility. It helps to understand the mechanisms of life
and supplies answers to great issues. It is not constituted by a set of rules.
There is no organized structure with clergy. The community of follow-
ers helps and supports those in need, in the practice and in the harmo-
nizing of objectives. To support this last hypothesis there are numerous
instances in the interviews and life stories:
I needed to find a spiritual dimension that suited me. (S)
I can’t stand dogmas, even less so obligations . . . Buddhism is freedom . . .
That’s what really appealed to me at the beginning. (S)
I was fascinated by this religion above all because it did not impose any
type of rules, there were no obligations of any sort. (S)
There is no church, and the church as a body is quite castrating and
restrictive. (S)
Buddhism tells me that in the very moment I decide to be happy, I am
already happy . . . It means that from that moment on I will make every
effort and I will be . . . I will become happy . . . It tells me every day is
New Year’s Day so I can decide to change my life every day. I can set new
objectives . . . and I don’t have to look back and say: “I missed the boat”
. . . . Understanding how our life works: why we repeat the same actions or
why the same things always happen to us . . . It’s these things that intrigue
me, and it still does because it is a never-ending study of life and of how to
live better. (S)
Among the Buddhists I immediately found a much better climate than
that which was around me at the time. Above all normal people, very
serene, at least when we met. The atmosphere was warm. This was a great
encouragement. (S)
conversion as a new lifestyle
The Soka Gakkai is a great family, I mean if anyone is in need we help each
other, we support each other. (S)
Friendship is one of the fundamental things that ties me to Soka Gakkai:
friendship and mutual support among followers, which is basic to life; it
should be for everyone. (S)
Conclusions
important to him and so I said: let’s go and see where he goes, largely
because there were people who phoned him . . . (S)
As far as our second hypothesis, it was revealed that the majority of the
neo converts were looking for a new spiritual experience to solve the
problems of daily life more than belonging exclusively and irreversibly
to a religion. Joining Soka Gakkai is therefore a voluntary act. The orga-
nization does not pressure new arrivals to feel converted at once, but
encourages them to take one step at a time. But between one reading
of the daimoku of the Lotus Sutra and another, relations consolidate that
involve the new followers in the system of beliefs and friendships with
the members of Soka Gakkai. The organization’s objective is to spur the
desire in the new arrivals to belong, knowing that authentic religious con-
version is based on personal needs, even if external factors may foster it.
Our data confirm Thierry Mathé (), who concludes his research
on Tibetan Buddhism and Soka Gakkai in France by observing that con-
versions in these two movements represent a need for regeneration more
than for re-conversion; they consist in breaking a lifestyle on the existen-
tial level (hence a new lifestyle) rather than on the level of the meaning
of life, since the issue of truth is considered insignificant. These are con-
versions that respond more to the need to adjust to one’s own personal
situation rather than to the system of beliefs of an institutionalized reli-
gion.
I wanted answers concerning my mother’s illness . . . “Why couldn’t I have
a normal life like any other -year-old?”—and so, Buddhism gave me the
answers to all this. Catholicism had not. At the time I read the Mormon law,
the Koran, the Holy Scriptures. I was looking everywhere. I didn’t think of
Buddhism because it probably wasn’t the right time. (S)
I was looking for answers, and I found one for each of my questions: What
is the meaning of life? What is the meaning of death? Is life worth living?
How do you live? What is my life worth? Why do bad things happen? . . .
(S)
It was a really bad period; I did nothing but cry about my situation . . .
family . . . (S)
I wanted to change my life; I was sick and tired of the life I was leading,
because I had made lots of attempts, of all types, but there was no way out
of this situation. (S)
As far as the third hypothesis, it can be said that nearly all the inter-
viewees wanted to try new practices through conversion, that is a new
lifestyle, more than adopting an organic set of beliefs and moral obliga-
tions. Conversion as a new lifestyle, which concerns the majority of our
conversion as a new lifestyle
7 According to some authors, this type of conversion, which has been growing since
, is homogeneous to the consumer culture, in which sharing the same brand knits
social ties among the consumers themselves and links them as in a community. This
is confirmed by brand communities, brandfests, and the power of cult branding in
general, in which the three elements that constitute every community are to be found:
shared awareness, rituals and traditions, and a sense of moral responsibility. Roof says
(:), “The generation of baby boomers, which was greatly influenced by the
consumer culture, has grown up considering religion like a commodity and trading it
practically like any other product.”
luigi berzano and eliana martoglio
References
CONVERSION AS OPPOSITION
Giuseppe Giordan
gions themselves: “Religious syncretism is not a particular kind of religion, but the struc-
tural characteristic peculiar to the systems of religious belief: ‘syncretism’ is the word for
what we conventionally label ‘complexity.’ Systems with a religious basis are complex by
definition, hence to survive they must learn to differentiate from the environment; they
must learn to reduce the complexity they find in the environment, partially transferring
it inside themselves” (Pace : ).
conversion as opposition
2 In order to examine closely the role of the Catholic religion inside Italian society see
Cipriani (), Diotallevi (, ), Garelli (, , ), Garelli, Guizzardi
and Pace (), and Nesti ().
3 This research is based on in-depth interviews of about one hour each, carried on
during the months of June and July in Montaner. Among the interviewees, are
witnesses of the facts as they happened at the moment of the conversion to Orthodoxy;
therefore they are from age upward. The remainder are youth or young adults born in
the s.
giuseppe giordan
All the Montaner events occurred between December and Novem-
ber .4 On December , , Monsignor Giuseppe Faè, the old
parish priest who had guided the Montaner community for forty years
died. The figure of Msgr. Faè was characterized by a strong personal
charisma and an authoritative temper, determined and resolute, that con-
tributed to creating his role not only as a spiritual, but also a social and
cultural guide for this somewhat isolated and poor village in the Venetian
mountains. Msgr. Faè not only did everything in his power to offer spir-
itual and moral assistance to the population, but also to provide for the
material needs of his community from a nursery school, to an orphanage,
to a small hall for public meetings (successively destined to become a the-
atre and a cinema). In addition to this, he also was very important guid-
ing the anti-fascist forces of the area who were getting organized covertly
against the German troops during the civil war that burst in Italy after
September , , when Mussolini’s regime collapsed. In March ,
Msgr. Faè was arrested for his anti-fascist activity and, after the end of the
war in , just for his having been put in jail, he started calling himself
“Father Jail.” When he returned to Montaner, he engaged himself further
in improving the living conditions of the population of this little village:
he worked to obtain the telephone line, electric light, running water into
4 No volume yet exists fully reconstructing the facts of the Montaner event as devel-
oped from the beginning until today. Nevertheless there are some degree theses con-
taining information of an historical and anthropological character (Ciciliot ). Some
sociological thesises have also provided interpretive criteria: in particular Nardi (),
Resenterra (), and Chies (). Berzano and Cassinasco () provide a sociolog-
ical study of Orthodoxy in Italy.
conversion as opposition
their houses, a daily bus service to the nearby center of Vittorio Veneto,
the opening of a post office, and the construction of a new school build-
ing.
During his parish activity he was supported by younger priests, and
in the last three years of his life, being by that time old and ill, he was
assisted one named Father Antonio Botteon. At the time of his death,
the Monsignor was highly esteemed, even revered as a saint, by the
population. The interviewees who have met him tell odd anecdotes about
his often bizarre behavior and about his presumed miraculous powers.
After Msgr. Faè’s death, a trial of strength started between the Bishop,
who had already chosen a successor, and the population of Montaner,
who saw in Fr. Botteon the right parish priest for the purpose of ensuring
continuity with the work of the deceased Monsignor. According to the
code of Canon Law, however, the appointment of a parish priests is not
the congregation’s concern, but rather it is the exclusive competence
of the Bishop. In Montaner a committee was formed who asked the
Bishop for an audience in order to obtain Fr. Botteon’s appointment as
their parish priest.5 The answer was negative, and this not only because
the appointment of a parish priest is the Bishop’s concern and not the
community’s, but also because Fr. Botteon was considered to be too
young for such role.
Just after the visit of the Montaner committee, the Bishop appointed
another priest as the new parish priest, to take office in Montaner on
January , . During the night between the th and st of January
some men from Montaner built a wall in front of the doors of the
church and of the rectory. Before the church a notice was posted in
which “the people of Montaner” proclaimed Fr. Botteon as their parish
priest, and justified this choice as the fruit of democratic consultation.
The afternoon of the st the new parish priest appointed by the Bishop
arrived in Montaner with his own things, but the population in the
square prevented him from carrying out his move—although the police
were also there to guarantee public order. In this way the “war” between
the people of Montaner and the Bishop started, a war in which the
protagonists were the women, since the men either emigrated or worked
all day at considerable distance from the village. In the first days of
February, another delegation went to visit the Bishop bringing a request
5 In those years the bishop of the Vittorio Veneto diocese was Monsignor Albino
Luciani, who became Pope in taking the name of John Paul I. (His pontificate lasted
only days, and he is now remebered by history as “the smiling Pope”.)
giuseppe giordan
signed by families out of a total of asking him to accept the
appointment of Fr. Betteon as their parish priest, but the answer once
again was negative.
During the first protest actions, the village seemed to be more or less
close-knit, but as the conflict escalated, many people drew back from
the protest, and the group of those who believed it was unfair to object
to authority became more and more numerous. So Montaner split into
two factions, between whom a true conflict broke out, based on such
deep hatred that it is still present today. The two factions took the names
of “mice” and “cats”: the former were those who remained faithful to
the bishop’s decision and the Catholic church, and were so-called in
reference to the expression “sacristy mice” in order to describe peo-
ple devoutly linked to the ecclesiastic institution; while the latter were
those who successively became members of the Orthodox Church. All
the people interviewed are keen to remember that this image had the
function of intending to remind everyone that “cats, sooner or later, eat
mice.”
The case, as it is not difficult to imagine, ended up in some national
newspapers, and the quarrel in this way became known outside the local
context. In the first months of representatives of other religious
confessions arrived in Montaner, in particular Protestants and members
of the Orthodox Church, even though the possibility of a conversion
from Catholicism to another religious confession was not taken into
serious consideration in the first months of the fight. Feeble attempts of
reconciliation followed, but strong stands were taken the part of both
the cats and the ecclesiastic institutionalists. The split turned so bitter
that it could not be healed. In the following months the cats, who had
gone to visit the bishop many times and even to visit the Pope in Rome
without obtaining anything, organized some meetings to decide how
to continue their protest, and during such meetings the possibility of
shifting to another religious tradition “as a protest” was considered.
Angela’s response, in connection with this subject, is particularly
enlightening: “I must admit that we didn’t have very clear ideas. On the
contrary, there was much confusion about what we wanted to do. Nev-
ertheless it seemed to us that changing religion might be a good way to
express our disagreement and our anger toward the Catholic hierarchy.”
conversion as opposition
ing from the interviewer that things in the beginning were exactly like
this. Paola’s and Antonio’s answers are enlightening with regard to this
subject.
Paola, who at the time of these events was twenty years old, says:
I remember those months as a period of great enthusiasm as regards the
new experience that was going to start . . . Montaner had never appeared
in the newspapers, but at that time everybody spoke of us. To tell the truth,
however, it was a period of suffering, because in the village, and also among
our own friends, there was an atmosphere of hatred . . . . Well, maybe to
call it hatred is too much . . . Let’s say the interpersonal relations were not
good. We didn’t greet each other any longer. We didn’t go shopping any
longer to the shop where the keeper belonged to the other religion . . . . A
bad atmosphere indeed, with suspicion, calumny, hatred . . . Yes, I told you
that the word hatred was perhaps too much, but I do believe that, at certain
moments, it was a matter of hatred. Just think that I didn’t speak any more
to my uncle, who remained Catholic, not even during his long disease that
led to his death.
against those who did not convert to Orthodoxy, and of “confusion” for
what is involved in the entrance into the new religious confession.6
From the interviews as a whole the impression is that what it meant to
decide to become a member of the Orthodox Church wasn’t very clear.
Perhaps Francesco, who at the time of the consecration of the Orthodox
Church was nine years old, is right when he asserts, somewhat between
irony and regret, that those “who became a member of the Orthodox
Church converted ‘by chance’.”
But the accounts we collected from the interviewees tell us not only
what was actually the initial situation (“hatred” and “confusion”), but they
also report reflections that have been stored forty years in the memory
of this disunited little community, with respect to both their personal
memory as well as the collective memory. It is not difficult to imagine
that, with the passing of time, those people have wondered whether it
was possible to change their religion “only” out of resentment toward the
hierarchy of the religion in which they were born and brought up.
In other words, even if things seem to have happened exactly in this
way, when the subjects were interviewed about this event, the language
they use becomes more complex, more intricate than the simple narra-
tion of a conflict. As noted above, and consistent with the observations of
Pace with which this chapter opened, in the conversion accounts of the
people from Montaner we find a contamination of languages where the
borders between culture, politics, religion and common sense fade away
until they become difficult to reconstruct. However, in the narration of
the single subject who uses all these symbolic universes of meaning in
order to rebuild his own experience, we may notice the predominance of
either element, according to what one intends to justify or to legitimate
by means of such narration.
6 The experience of the Montaner Orthodox Church had a rather troubled beginning
even because of the unclear position of the first Orthodox priest who guided it. He was an
Italian man, who, it seems, had initially been an Evangelical minister and who declared he
successively converted to Orthodoxy. We know that he signed with the title “Italian Exarc
of the Episcopal Catholic Apostolic Orthodox Church,” even if nobody has ever known
to what Church he actually belonged. He was a kind of “wandering priest,” and when he
arrived at Montaner he declared he was a member of the Russian Orthodox Church. For
many years the liturgical functions of the new Church were more similar to the Catholic
functions than to the Orthodox ones, and this too perhaps contributed to making the
converted people feel that the change had been more formal than substantial.
giuseppe giordan
a matter of fact, Fr. Faè had long debated with the Bishop of Vittorio Veneto the request
of elevating the little parish church to the level of a “cathedral.” Still in line with the
autonomist will of the inhabitants of Montaner as regards the municipality of Sarmede,
there is also a will to change the name of the municipality into “Montaner of Italy.”
giuseppe giordan
historical situation in which the Catholic Church has lived in the years
following Vatican Council II (–). The Council had aroused
inside the Catholic communities many expectations of a profound re-
form of the Church, especially on the ecumenical side.
Many Italian Bishops, however, turned out to be unprepared to face
such efforts of “updating” and “renewal,” and they limited themselves
to retouching some aspects of the traditional positions that, after all,
had worked in the past. Thus, inside Italian Catholicism two opposite
interpretative lines of the Council developed: the “traditionalists,” who
were very critical about some aspects of novelty of the Council, and the
“dissenting protagonists,” who considered the Council a starting point for
the radical renewal of the Church (Ciciliot ).
This general frame of great ecclesial change is reconstructed in the
words of some of our interviewees in order to adapt it to the situation
of Montaner, putting together the ideas that in those years animated
the theological debates and the more limited exigencies of the local
community of Montaner. It is an interesting effort to connect the “little
history” of the village to the “great history” of the Church, as if they
wished to legitimate their choice of converting on the basis of the unkept
promises of renovation from the Catholic Church. Mario’s story clearly
expresses such connection between the local situation and the theological
debate of those years:
The Council expressed themselves in favor of the “Church of the poor,” and
the concept of “God’s people” was very important. These are perspectives
that asked that everybody do their best to change the inequities of the
society in which we lived . . .. The official Church didn’t actually seem to
want to change. The Vatican was not inclined to sell their riches to give
them to the poor, and even less inclined were they to lose their power
of control over people or to acknowledge the dignity of “God’s people.”
Through my conversion to Orthodoxy, I wanted to say “Enough!” to the
power of the Catholic hierarchy, and I wanted to take sides with the poor
and the marginalized ones.
they eluded the direct control of the ecclesiastical authorities, and they
were most of all engaged in the need for social and ecclesiastical reforms.
The legitimation for their work of protest and reform was guaranteed
by a direct relation with the Bible: from personal and public reading of
the Holy Scriptures the “basic communities” found the inspiration and
strength to challenge the existing order and to try to change it by recon-
structing a kind of primitive Christianity. The Montaner community took
inspiration from this model, and still does, in some people’s opinion,
even if we cannot understand very clearly, talking with the interviewees,
why they chose the Orthodox tradition and not the Protestant tradition.
When it was pointed out that the personal reading of the Bible is more
consistent with Protestantism than with Orthodoxy, Serena answered to
us that “the Bible has always existed, hence it is valid for the Catholics
as well as for the members of the Orthodox Church and for the Protes-
tants as well . . . . Only there are people who implement it better than
others!”—an answer that clarifies the controversy with the Catholics, but
that doesn’t explain, from the strictly religious point of view, the reason
for conversion to Orthodoxy.
Serena is also very keen to let us know that Montaner had fully
received the ecumenical aspirations of the Council, according to which
all the Christian churches would link together again after the centuries of
division and reciprocal excommunication; however when it was pointed
out to her that “to convert” from Catholicism to Orthodoxy is not exactly
what the Council says about the theme of ecumenism, Serena, a little
out of patience, said that “if all the Christian ‘religions’ are equal, I don’t
understand the reason why people are so scandalized if one decides to
shift from one to the other.” Obviously, an interview situation is not one
to teach the difference between “confessions” and “religions.” Besides, the
simplification of the Council made by Serena doesn’t take into account
the fact that the Council’s ecumenism acknowledges equal dignity to all
confessions, but doesn’t say that they are all equal.
The language used by Serena and Mario, as well as before by Angela,
doesn’t enter upon theological subjects, but seems to derive information
freely from the Council’s vocabulary of ecclesiastical reform, sometimes
even distorting its meaning, in order to justify some choices—including
the “conversion” choice, which otherwise would be more delicate to
justify. Between the lines of this language, as well as, after all, between
the lines of the language of politics, it is not hard to detect reference to
the “hatred” and “confusion” mentioned at the beginning of this chapter.
These are elaborations deriving from rather different cultural universes
giuseppe giordan
There is a last group of interviewees who do not feel at ease with the lan-
guages about which we have just spoken: it is the youngest ones, those
who have not “converted” to Orthodoxy, because they were born into
families that had become Orthodox a few years before their birth. The
seven young and young-adult people who have been interviewed repre-
sent the quasi-totality of the choir who presently accompany Mass with
their chants on Sundays. The choir gathers practically all the young and
young-adult people who consistantly participate in the Sunday Mass.
The language they use to express their being members of the Orthodox
Church is remarkably distant from that of their parents. It isn’t a matter
of completely different languages: both actually understand the linguis-
tic and expressive languages used by the others. However the youngest
tion is not between priest and people, but between bishop and priest-and-people.
giuseppe giordan
ones are well aware of the reasons that have led their community to
become Orthodox, and they are rather critical in regard to those rea-
sons.
First, they do not hide from themselves the fact that in the beginning
there was much “confusion,” or that the true reason for the conversion,
according to what practically all the interviewees of this group have told
us, was the wounded pride of this little community who would not resign
themselves to having to obey a bishop who authoritatively denied what
seemed to them to be a right.
Accounts the effects of the “hatred” for the more adult ones have not
completely disappeared, even if by now they are memories that weaken
more and more with the passing of time. “When I was a child,” says Marco
who was born at the beginning of the s,
I remember that we, the members of the Orthodox Church, were a small
closed group, we stayed on our own, and our parents did not let us go
to play football with the Catholic kids. When we grew up, this division
definitely weakened, even if none of us still today can claim to have real
friends in the other group . . .. This situation, analyzed with today’s eyes,
seems to me to be simply hilarious, a paradoxical situation that enlightens
how religion may be dangerous and create conflicts, rather than make the
world more human.
Having been invited to go deeper into this question about religion, Marco
explains what Orthodoxy is to him: not a religion with dogmas, moral
rules to follow, a hierarchy to obey, but a kind of spirituality inducing
reciprocal love, brotherly help, inviting one to cultivate within oneself a
sense of mystery leading to God. What Marco said tells us not so much
what Orthodoxy is in itself, which is also dogmas, moral rules and hier-
archy, but what he believes the Orthodox religion is. And this personal
route has also led him to expose the possible violent implications that
religions carry within themselves, implications that in Montaner have
actually shown their negative effects in the past.
Elisabetta’s evidence, partially following what stated by Marco, goes
further into “Orthodox spirituality” as she means it:
What I like most in the Orthodox religion is the silence during the Sunday
liturgy: it is a kind of silence that makes me feel well with myself, that
makes me discover God in my heart of hearts, that enlightens me as to the
choices to make during the noisy everyday life . . . When I participate in the
Catholic liturgy, maybe for some funeral or friends’ wedding, I feel uneasy
because on those occasions it’s all running, never stopping, answering
prayers automatically . . .. Catholicism seems to educate people to obey
rules. Orthodoxy has helped me to become freer, to be more myself.
conversion as opposition
The issues highlighted by the last two interviewees are expressed with
a vocabulary that remarkably differentiates their discourse compared
to what we previously described. Not only do the words change; the
grammar and the syntax also change. Although the comparison with
Catholicism persists, it is no longer this that legitimates the choice of
being and remaining members of the Orthodox Church. Now there are
the “personal” reasons referring to a social and cultural context that has
radically changed in comparison with the context at the end of the s’
era.
If we wish to bring back to sociological categories what the youngest
members of the Orthodox Church say about their religious experience,
the connection with the debate about the relation between religion and
spirituality is immediately evident.9 The core of the matter lies on the
foundation of believing, moving from obedience to the ecclesiastic au-
thority, external to the subject, to the liberty of choice of the subjec-
tive self: not only the relation between religious institution and personal
experience is polarized, but the latter is superior to the former. We may
speak of a “democratization of the sacred,” in which the subject is capable
of deciding autonomously, and is legitimated to do so even socially, about
the various aspects of his existence, including the “religious” aspect. More
than the certainties offered by the traditional churches, nowadays the
believer seems to be inclined to run the risks of research and exploration,
where there are no more neat differences and borders and where iden-
tities are constructed more by inclusion than by exclusion (Wuthnow
).
The language spirituality speaks of personal well-being, of self-fulfill-
ment, of attention to the feelings and to the meaning of life: according to
the words used by Elisabetta, “spirituality is something that helps you in
the journey of life, and not a series of prohibitions that don’t allow you
to appreciate it thoroughly.” While in the other three languages we have
identified the hybridization phenomenon that takes place among social,
political, religious factors and personal experience that fuse together to
the point of becoming an identity matrix, this last language is one that
brings attention back to the innerness of the subject. In this perspective
conversion happens not so much from one religion to the other, but
rather from a modality of believing given by tradition to a modality of
believing more knowingly and autonomously chosen and experimented.
9 On “religion” and “spirituality,” cf. Roof (, ), Wuthnow (, ),
Giordan (, ), Heelas and Woodhead (), and Flanagan and Jupp ().
giuseppe giordan
Conclusion
References
———. . Creative Spirituality: The Way of the Artist. Berkeley: University of
California Press.
chapter eleven
Sophie-Hélène Trigeaud
1 The LDS Church annually publishes Statistical Reports for the General Conferences.
The statistics concern the LDS records as of December for the prior year. Cf., “Sta-
tistical Report” (. , , , , , , , , ); “Annual
General Conferences,” Ensign. Salt Lake City: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
sophie-hélène trigeaud
Although the goal of this project is a study at the level of the global
system, it is necessary to begin with a specific case study of conversion
to Mormonism today, one that can offer concrete grounding for our
analysis. France indeed is a country where the LDS Church is neither
a traditional nor an indigenous church. Although it is true that the first
LDS missionary arrived in France in —which is to say only nineteen
years after the establishment of the LDS Church by Joseph Smith at
Fayette, New York—implanting the church in France was difficult. The
Mormon mission had to be transferred or closed four times.3 Very few
converts where baptized. There were less than French Mormons in
the s. As shown in the Table ., it was only after World War II,
and especially in the s, that the LDS Church experienced significant
growth in France.4 As of , there were , members in France
distributed across congregations.
“young adults” population comprised between . and . of the total LDS French
population in December . But this number represented people registered in the LDS
record and was not an actual count of the activity or non-activity of these members.
7 Questionnaire JA-francophone: the complete data and analyses of this questionnaire
8 For instance in the Questionnaire JA-francophone: “Were you born in the Church
or converted?” “If converted, how long have you been converted, and what was your
religious affiliation before?” “What was the reason for your baptism or conversion?”
9 The distinction between “exterior” and “interior” makes reference to outside and
inside the LDS community. It is the fifteen exterior converts who are represented in
Table ..
sophie-hélène trigeaud
two were not members any more. Eighty-three percent were worshiping
weekly in their parish meetings, and thirty-one percent had been mis-
sionaries.
Mormonism would let them be both a priest and married. Such kind of change, in
Catholic as in other Christian contexts, appears moreover in different LDS sources. (cf.
From Clergy to Convert, an LDS book which is a collection of conversion-to-Mormonism
stories related by former clergymen and women of various denominations [Gibson
]).
13 I am currently engaged in research that compares the origins of young converts
today with those who converted as young adults twenty or thirty years ago in order to
explore these differences.
conversions in the lds community today
14 For instance such items as: “What age were you baptized?” “Were you baptized as a
convert (not previously participating in LDS Church activities)?” “Have you ever been
involved in other religion practices previous to your participation in the LDS faith?”
“Why have you chosen the LDS religion? Or what was your conversion experience?” “LDS
membership status of your family?” “Are there members of your extended family who are
also LDS members?” “When was the first member of your family baptized?”
15 Because of its diachronic dimension, tradition is different from “social capital” and
[About testimony] It was not a quick thing, but it came through time and
experiences. I had nevertheless to search. My faith had to be tested. [Male,
, active member]
Far from any Mormon specificity, this emphasis on the personal expe-
rience of religion, if it is here opposed to family heritage, could be
solely interpreted as a common fact of the religious modernity, that
many authors have already highlighted. For example, Roland Campiche
stresses the importance of a “new religious revolution” in the way that
in modernity, children were influenced by their parents’ example on the
condition that they “experienced this themselves” (: ). In her
book on The Pilgrim and the Convert as well, Hervieu-Léger pointed out
this individual experience as the basis of conversion in the individual-
izing context of religious modernity: “In a society where religion has
become a matter of privacy and optional choice, conversion enters, above
conversions in the lds community today
: ).
sophie-hélène trigeaud
17 Among the remaining responses, three persons left the question blank, while two
and that have come into mine as I have lived the gospel. They have helped
to expand my knowledge about the Plan our Heavenly Father has for us.
They haven’t forced me to do anything but have given me agency to choose
for myself. By doing this I know that this is what I want in my life. [Female,
, active member, baptized at age ]
I have members of my family who crossed the Plains. I’m so thankful
that they were willing to give up the comforts of life so that they could
be with the church. I’m most thankful to my parents who have dedicated
their lives to living the gospel and to teach all children to be faithful.
They never coerced us into the church, it was there and we all in our
time developed our own testimonies; I very much feel the influence of my
pioneer ancestors who made the decision to give their all to the gospel.
[Female, , active member, baptized at age ]
These data reflect that the young adult LDS members who declared
that they were “born in the church” generally claim having been both
autonomous searchers and conscious heirs in their conversion from the
interior process. Their perception is that they “had to chose” though this
choice was in a tradition, because they belong to a lineage represented
not only by their closest relatives (“my parents,” “my relatives”), but also
by their ancestry (“my pioneer ancestors”), and even by their whole
community (“the church”).
Should we hence adopt Margaret Mead’s determinist stance toward the
“child’s dependence upon tradition”? According to her, in the mechanism
of the transmission, it is a quasi-physical law that no child can escape
the tradition of the adults who are around him: “The forces of imitation
are so much more potent than any adult technique for exploiting them;
the child’s receptivity to its surroundings is so much more important
than any methods of stimulation, that as long as every adult with whom
he comes in contact is saturated with the tradition, he cannot escape a
similar saturation” (: ). In such a mechanism, Mead primarily
advanced not the psychologists’ idea of “identification,” which they sup-
pose leads to the formation of personality, but a “process by which the
growing individual is inducted into his cultural inheritance” (: ,
cf. ). The Mormon narratives that we just considered could allow us
to agree with Mead. Nevertheless Mead’s stance may not be completely
appropriate to the Mormon field: on the one hand, a significant amount of
people “born into the Church” grow to become inactive or non-Mormon;
on the other hand, some converts declare that they grew up in totally
non-Mormon surroundings.
It is difficult to know for sure how many people being “born” Mormon
eventually quit the LDS Church, but we can obtain a few examples of
sophie-hélène trigeaud
ports—for example, the Missionary Training Centers, such manuals as the Missionary
Handbook () or Preach My Gospel: A Guide to Missionary Service (), and
www.mission.net. The worldwide Mormon mission network has been the object of many
studies (cf. Davies ; Durfee ; Introvigne ; Penley ; Ramstad ;
Rigal-Cellard ; Stark ; Stark and Bainbridge ; Trigeaud ).
20 “Investigator” is the name given to an LDS catechumen.
sophie-hélène trigeaud
Heaton, Bahr and Jacobson ; Stark :; Trigeaud , .
23 On the “ritual function of testimony bearing,” see Mauss : .
sophie-hélène trigeaud
see Shepherd and Shepherd, : –. Again we see an influence from Protes-
tantism (e.g., Weber, : –; cf. Davies : –).
25 On the Protestant background of the Mormons “demanding commitment from
each believer,” see Davies : . On the economic dimension of this commitment in
the LDS context, see Davies : , ; Bousquet ; Trigeaud .
26 On the influence of this thought on Mormon culture, see Trigeaud .
conversions in the lds community today
References
Bellah, Robert N. . The Broken Covenant: American Civil Religion in Time
of Trial. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
———, Richard Madsen, William M. Sullivan, Ann Swidler, and Steven M. Tip-
ton. . Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment in American
Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Bousquet, Georges H. . Les Mormons. Paris: Presses Universitaires de
France.
Bréchon, Pierre, ed. . Les Valeurs des Français. Paris: Colin.
Campiche, Roland J. . “Entre l’Exemple et l’Expérience: de la Transmission
par la Famille d’une Tradition à celle d’un ethos Religieux.” Pp. –
in Figures des dieux: Rites et mouvements religieux, edited by Liliane Voyé.
Bruxelles: De Boeck Université.
27 Cf., A study manual for LDS Institute of Religion students: “How Does ‘Binding’
Oneself by Covenants Help One Become Holy? There is tremendous value in making
commitments to one another and to the Lord. By entering into covenants or making
commitments with others, we bind ourself by our own integrity to act in a certain way.
This arrangement becomes a fortification against the powers of opposition. In other
words, covenants bring a sense of responsibility, which in turn becomes a power of
reinforcement for positive action and a deterrent to slothfulness. Covenant making can
help us break away from routines or habits of the past as we clearly identify a course to
pursue and then establish a means of accountability by making the commitment known
to others.” (Doctrine and Covenants-Student Manual-Religion and :–).
sophie-hélène trigeaud
Christensen, Joe and Barbara Christensen. . Making your Home a Mission-
ary Training Center. Salt Lake City: Deseret Book Company.
Davie, Grace. . “Believing without Belonging: Is This the Future of Religion
in Britain?” Social Compass : –.
Davies, Douglas J. . The Mormon Culture of Salvation: Force, Grace and
Glory. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
———. . An Introduction to Mormonism. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Durfee, Richard E. . “Modernity and Conversion: Mormonism in th
century Japan.” Unpublished M.A. thesis. Tempe: Arizona State University.
Euvrard, Christian. . Louis Auguste Bertrand (–), Journalist and
Pionnier Mormon: “La Vérité et la liberté, deux mots sublimes, telle est notre
devise nationale.” Tournan-en-Brie: Privately printed.
Galland, Olivier and Bernard Roudet, eds. . Les jeunes Européens et leurs
valeurs: Europe occidentale, Europe centrale et orientale. Paris: La Découverte.
Galland, Olivier. . Sociologie de la jeunesse. Paris: Colin.
Gibson, Stephen W. . From Clergy to Convert: Fourteen Conversation Stories
by Former Catholic and Protestant Leaders who Found the Restored Gospel. Salt
Lake City: Bookcraft.
Gisel, Pierre. . L’excès du croire: Expérience du monde et accès à soi. Paris:
Desclée de Brouwer.
Heaton Tim B., Stephen J. Bahr Stephen and Cardell K. Jacobson Cardell. . A
Statistical Profile of Mormons: Health, Wealth and Social Life. Lewiston, N.Y.:
Edwin Mellen Press.
Hervieu-Léger, Danièle. . “Pour une Sociologie de la transmission Reli-
gieuse: Esquisse d’une Perspective théorique et méthodologique.” Pp. –
in Figures des dieux: Rites et mouvements religieux, edited by Liliane Voyé.
Bruxelles: De Boeck Université.
———. . Le pèlerin et le converti: La religion en mouvement. Paris: Champs
Flammarion.
Introvigne, Massimo. Mormons. Maredsous, Belgium: Brépols, .
Lambert, Yves. . “La Religion: un paysage en profonde évolution.” Pp. –
in Les valeurs des Français, edited by H. Riffault. Paris: P.U.F.
———. . “Un regain religieux chez les jeunes d’Europe de l’Ouest et de l’Est.”
Pp. – in Les jeunes Européens et leurs valeurs: Europe occidentale, Europe
centrale et orientale, edited by Olivier Galland and Bernard Roudet. Paris: La
Découverte.
——— and Guy Michelat, eds. . Crépuscule des religions chez les jeunes? Jeunes
et religions en France. Paris: L’Harmattan.
Mauss, Armand L. . The Angel and the Beehive: The Mormon Struggle with
Assimilation. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
———. . “Mormonism.” Pp. – in Encyclopedia of Religion and Society,
edited by William H. Swatos, Jr. Walnut Creek, Calif.: AltaMira Press.
———. . All Abraham’s Children: Changing Mormon Conception of Race and
Lineage. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Mead, Margaret. . Growing up in New Guinea: A Study of Adolescence and
Sex in Primitive Societies. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin Books.
conversions in the lds community today
Missionary Handbook. . Salt Lake City: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day
Saints.
Monson, Thomas S., Jr. . “The Sustaining of Church Officers.” Ensign (May):
.
Penley, Kaija H. . Leadership of Mormon Missionary Efforts in Finland and its
Influence on Conversion Rates in the Finnish Mission, –. Ann Arbor,
Mich.: University Microfilms.
Pitcher, Brian L. . “Callings.” Pp. – in Encyclopedia of Mormonism,
edited by Daniel H. Ludlow. New York: Macmillan.
Preach My Gospel: A Guide to Missionary Service. . Salt Lake City: Church
of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Ramstad, Mette. . Conversion in the Pacific: Eastern Polynesian Latter-
day Saints’ Conversion Accounts and their Development of a LDS Identity.
Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Bergen, Norway.
Ravenshear A.F. . “Testimony and Authority.” Mind (New Series) (): –
.
Rigal-Cellard, Bernadette. . “Etre Français dans une Église d’Origine Améri-
caine: les Mormons de France.” Pp. – Les Mutations Transatlantiques
des Religions, edited by Christian Lerat and Bernadette Rigal-Cellard. Pessac:
Presses Universitaires de Bordeaux.
Roudet, Bernard. . “Les Sociétés Européennes au Miroir des Jeunes.” Pp. –
in Les Jeunes Européens et Leurs Valeurs: Europe Occidentale, Europe
Centrale et Orientale, edited by Olivier Galland and Bernard Roudet. Paris:
La Découverte.
Seguy, Jean. . “Les Non-conformismes religieux d’occident.” Pp. –
in Histoire des Religions, vol. . Paris: Gallimard.
Shepherd, Gary and Gordon Shepherd. . A Kingdom Transformed: Themes
in the Development of Mormonism. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
Smith, Christian with Melinda Lundquist Denton. . Soul Searching: The
Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers. Oxford: Oxford Univer-
sity Press.
Stark, Rodney. . Sociological Perspectives on the Mormon Subculture. An-
nual Review of Sociology : –.
———. . The Rise of Mormonism. New York: Columbia University Press.
———. . “Extracting Social Scientific Models from Mormon History.” Pp.
– in The Mormon Association’s Tanner Lectures: The First Twenty Years,
edited by Dean L. May and Reid L. Neilson. Urbana: University of Illinois
Press.
Stark, Rodney and William Sims Bainbridge. . The Future of Religion: Sec-
ularization, Revival, and Cult Formation. Berkeley: University of California
Press.
Statistical Reports. , , , , , , , , , .
Annual General Conferences. Ensign. Salt Lake City: Church of Jesus Christ
of Latter-day Saints.
Trigeaud, Sophie-Hélène. . “Mission” et “missionnaires” de l’É.S.D.J.: Prosé-
lytisme, passage et éducation. Unpublished M.A. thesis. Bordeaux: Université
Victor Segalen.
sophie-hélène trigeaud
Preliminary Considerations
Our research into the mental structures causing human behavior begins
from the (cognitivist) conviction that the output (the behavior) is richer
than the input (the stimulus)—that is to say, than the circumstances
that originated it. This conviction is based on the “thesis of the poverty
of the stimulus” (Fodor ; Plotkin ): what the mind represents
of the world is not a simple secular representation of reality but its
reconstruction, containing more information than that in the material
offered by the stimuli. This is certainly evident in perceptive, mnemonic
and linguistic outputs. Deaf children in a school where signs and gestures
are forbidden develop a systemic language governed by rules, as Senghas
and Coppola (: ) report:
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
It has long been postulated that language is not purely learned, but arises
from an interaction between environmental exposure and innate abilities.
The innate component becomes more evident in rare situations in which
the environment is markedly impoverished. The present study investigated
the language production of a generation of deaf Nicaraguans who had not
been exposed to a developed language. We examined the changing use of
early linguistic structures (specifically, spatial modulations) in a sign lan-
guage that has emerged since the Nicaraguan group first came together. In
under two decades, sequential cohorts of learners systematized the gram-
mar of this new sign language. We examined whether the systematicity
being added to the language stems from children or adults; our results indi-
cate that such changes originate in children aged and younger. Thus,
sequential cohorts of interacting young children collectively possess the
capacity not only to learn, but also to create, language.
(cf. Harris, ; Schaller, ; Pinker, )
The very phenomenon of enrichment of the stimulus, due to the men-
tal elaboration of the lived experience, is what happens in the process of
religious conversion: some historical facts become, for the believer, “dis-
closure” events, enriching a meaning that is not immediately referable to
the facts themselves (Schillebeeckx, , ). The conversion route
described in the Gospel, leading the believer to professing the Jesus of
history as the Christ of faith, is described as a process characterized by
the awarding of a new and further meaning to the observable facts: “Then
their eyes were opened and they recognized him [ . . . ]. They asked each
other, ‘Were not our hearts burning within us while he talked with us on
the road and opened the Scriptures to us?’ ” (Luke : –).1
The conversion route, meant as a product of the mental elaboration of
information and facts, is therefore outlined as a process that—being read,
for example, through the field theory of Kurt Lewin ()—assigns to
the totality of the coexisting factors a higher value than the sum of the
single elements. This approach of a holistic kind, typical of the Gestalt
school, in which the structure of the psychological field acquires a new
form and defines a new and manifest meaning (insight), in some way
gives reason to a conversion process that is a manifestation and awareness
of a new meaning of reality.
In this respect, reference to a German legend reported by Koffka (:
) in Principles of Gestalt Psychology can be helpful:
1 All scriptural citations are from the Holy Bible: New International Version. London:
In what environment, Koffka asks, did the behavior of the stranger take
place? The question, Koffka insists, will have to say that there is a second
meaning to the word “environment,” according to which “our horseman
did not ride across the lake at all, but across an ordinary snow-swept
plain. His behavior was a riding-over-a-plain, but not a riding-over-a-
lake.” This legend suggests to us, first, that the mental representation of
reality (the iced bare patch) does not always coincide with its physical
characteristics (the Lake of Constance); second, that the awareness of
one or the other world is not simply discovered in consequence of a
direct and immediate experience of the environment, but is the result
of sharing meanings in a social context that transmits them; finally, that
the meaning we attribute to reality has a crucial importance for human
existence: it either vivifies or kills, bears to the world or withdraws us
from it. Therefore, that new and manifest meaning, that insight that
releases the spring of the conversion process, does not emerge out of a
solipsistic re-elaboration of mental processes, but is an additive factor
that, as it is narrated in the German legend, is the result of a meeting, the
product of a social interaction that determines its shared meaning.
We find this additive principle again narrated even in one among the
most famous evangelical pericopes, this time drawn from John’s Gospel
that, in the image of a miraculous multiplication of loaves and fishes,
offers to us the conversion route that the disciples first and the crowd
after must cover in order to disclose to that sense capable of satisfying a
people’s hunger:
When Jesus looked up and saw a great crowd coming toward him, he said
to Philip, “Where shall we buy bread for these people to eat?” He asked
this only to test him, for he already had in mind what he was going to do.
Philip answered him, “Eight months’ wages would not buy enough bread
for each one to have a bite!” Another of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s
brother, spoke up, “Here is a boy with five small barley loaves and two
small fish, but how far will they go among so many?” Jesus said, “Have
the people sit down.” There was plenty of grass in that place, and the men
sat down, about five thousand of them. Jesus then took the loaves, gave
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
thanks, and distributed to those who were seated as much as they wanted.
He did the same with the fish. When they had all had enough to eat, he
said to his disciples, “Gather the pieces that are left over. Let nothing be
wasted.” So they gathered them and filled twelve baskets with the pieces
of the five barley loaves left over by those who had eaten. After the people
saw the miraculous sign that Jesus did, they began to say, “Surely this is the
Prophet who is to come into the world”. (: –)
To Philip there is only one way to answer Jesus’ provocative question
about how to obtain that indispensable good for human subsistence
(bread): using money. But in this world there is no remedy to poverty:
no money, no food. Andrew’s intervention redefines the problem and
allows us to get to a new interpretive modality through which it is pos-
sible to overturn the indigent condition of the crowd into a miraculous
superabundance. Here the evangelical teaching through the sign of the
multiplication of loaves and fishes is clear: a society based on the value
of money will not satisfy hungry people, but a society founded on the
sharing of goods will be able to transform the little owned by each of us,
if shared, into superabundance for everyone. The loaves’ multiplication
expresses in a narrative and symbolic style that principle according to
which the whole is more than the sum of its parts: love, manifest through
the solid sharing of one’s goods, transforms what to our eyes appears to
be insufficient into superabundance for everyone, provided it is shared.
The goal we set ourselves here is not that of demonstrating the exis-
tence of a mental module of God, capable of grasping the sense of the
divine in the prosaic facts around us, but that of analyzing some of the
mental functions underlying conversion—meant exactly according to the
model inferred from the Gospel—if it is considered from a psychologi-
cal perspective—functions that certainly do not exhaust the reasons for
a conversion, but that form the conditions without which such model
of conversion would not be “humanly” imaginable. We wish to search
for some of those cognitive structures that have been at the basis of the
cultural development that has produced that richness of religious sym-
bols and signs through which such an idea of conversion is received and
negotiated.
Following such analysis, we may even make the hypothesis of a com-
munity of universally recognizable elements that form that “universal
grammar” of the “religious man,” without which an experience such as
that of the World Day of Prayer in Assisi in —where for the first
time in history hundreds of representatives of the different religions
of the world assembled in a prayer meeting sharing a deep religious
a cognitive psychology perspective
Just as the fact that it is possible to make use of any language to con-
vey any message makes us believe that all languages are made of the
same material (Chomsky ; Pinker , ), similarly the exis-
tence of religious universals, making a religious experience translatable
and sharable, encourages us accept the existence of universal and innate
mental mechanisms which, even in the variety of the social and cultural
experiences, make certain specific religious behaviors universally intelli-
gible and sharable.
The comparison between the Gospels and the analysis of cognitive
psychology conveys at least two great conversion models that we wish to
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
outline here and that, according to the latest observations, we may believe
have universal validity. The possible universality of these two models
then makes them conceivable as compatible models. However, we cannot
exclude their inconceivability, in an alternative sense, if some reciprocal
traits are radicalized.
Causality
explaining and predisposing one’s behavior in connection with the context in which one
operates. Leaving out of consideration the type of identification process of the casuality
of the events and of the human behaviors, whether they are based on specific causal
schemes (Kelley ), turned to identifying the major causes or reasons for the events
(Buss ) or mainly guided by data and theories (Alloy and Tabachnik ), it is
chiefly a spontaneous process contributing to supplying reality with sense. Thus, finding
causality becomes not only the first agent of the organization of events, but a codification
system of reality that defines it and makes it accessible by virtue of its unique meaning—
omnicomprehensive and participatory at the same time.
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
3 Pyysiainen, Lindeman and Honkela (: , cf. Pyysianinen ) provide
“evidence for the hypothesis that persons consider counterintuitive representations more
likely to be religious than other kinds of beliefs. In three studies the subjects were asked
to rate the probable religiousness of various kinds of imaginary beliefs. The results show
that counterintuitive representations in general, and counterintuitive representations
involving a conscious agent in particular, are considered much more likely to be religious.
Counterintuitiveness thus seems to be an important element in a folk-understanding of
religion.”
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
a model to imitate in order to be saved. Jesus does not ask this man
to follow him and embrace the new faith—as a matter of fact he dis-
misses him saying: “Go! It will be done just as you believed it would.”—
because he has recognized in him that generative religious grammar
typical of every authentic experience of faith, on which every religion
leans and that all faiths share. Jesus and the centurion have spoken
to each other and have understood each other because they have suc-
ceeded in communicating about those human universals that are at the
basis of each authentic conversion, having become like children again.
The acknowledgment of a causal (supernatural) power of Jesus pro-
vokes admiration, independently from the fact that this same power
in the centurion’s faith will be attributed to a pantheon of animate fig-
ures.
4 Our ability to understand the basic aspects of society, of expressing love and
attitudes and of being able to distinguish between different actors and social categories is
apparent from childhood. For example, various studies have demonstrated that, starting
from age five, children show specific attitudes and preferences toward particular ethnic
groups (Barrett and Short ). The conception a child has of the social categories
and the ethnic outgroup, initially based on perceptive aspects, would be subsequently
redefined and mitigated when the awareness of the reciprocity of social relations increases
(Aboud ). From these studies, then, “the evidence of the very high sensitivity of
a cognitive psychology perspective
young children to the more primitive aspects of the value system of their societies”
(Tajfel : ) would emerge. Therefore, this human capability of recognizing and
distinguishing the differences and social belongings, and of being able to understand
and share the complex system of norms and reference values through social interaction,
provides us with the explicative background of the conversion process in the sharing of
meaning outlined so far.
5 Empathy, which is usually considered an element preceding the implementation
of behaviors aimed at helping other people (Hoffman ), is made explicit through
emotional activation associated with a cognitive process in which one assumes the other’s
perspective. To be able to assume the other’s needs implies perceiving similarity between
people expressed in a system of rules and shared social norms. The theoretical reflection
about empathy as preceeding prosocial and altruistic behavior, then, concerns the fact
that the individual assumes a definition of himself as an unselfish person embodying
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
and sharing social values of respect and mutual help. Therefore, the self perception as
an altruistic individual is emphasized through a social sharing process implying the
acknowledgment of one’s altruistic dimension even from the others: “who are told that
they are the kind of people who like to help whenever they can may infer that prosocial
behaviors across a variety of situations are expected of them” (Grusec and Redler :
). The capability of identifying oneself with the other and of assuaging his suffering in
this way become participative modalities in virtue of one’s belonging to a sharing social
system considering the neighbor as oneself (see Batson ; Batson et al. ).
a cognitive psychology perspective
References
beneath such meaning of conversion. A theoretical link to this type of process may actu-
ally be offered by the self-categorization theory of Turner and his collaborators (Turner
et al. ). Self-categorization theory aims at explaining how an individual gets to
defining himself as somebody belonging to a specific category or social group. Starting
from the process of social categorization, through which one’s subjective experience of
social reality is organized and defined, the individual would define himself on the basis
a cognitive psychology perspective
Barkow, Jerome H., Leda Cosmides and John Tooby (eds.). . The Adapted
Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Baron-Cohen, Simon. . Mindblindness: An Essay on Autism and Theory of
Mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Barrett, M. and J. Short. . “Images of European People in a Group of –-
Year-Old English Schoolchildren.” British Journal of Developmental Psychol-
ogy : –.
Batson, C.D. . “Sociobiology and the Role of Religion in Promoting Proso-
cial Behavior: An Alternative View.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychol-
ogy : –.
Batson, C.D., Judy G. Batson, Cari A. Griffitt, Sergio Barrientos, J.R. Brandt,
Peter Sprengelmeyer, and Michael J. Bayly. . “Negative-State Relief and
the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychol-
ogy : –.
Brown, Donald E. . Human Universals. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
———. . “Human Universals.” Pp. – in The MIT Encyclopedia of the
Cognitive Sciences, edited by Robert A. Wilson and Frank C. Keil. Cambridge,
MA: MIT Press.
Buss, Allan R. . “Causes and Reasons in Attribution Theory: A Conceptual
Critique.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology : –.
Carey, Susan. . “Constraints on Semantic Development.” Pp. – in
Neonate Cognition: Beyond the Blooming Buzzing Confusion, edited by Jacques
Mehler and Robin Fox. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Chomsky, Noam. . “Review of B.F. Skinner’s Verbal Behavior.” Language :
–.
Dennett, Daniel C. . “Beliefs About Beliefs.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences
: –.
———. . Brainstorms: Philosophical Essays on Mind and Psychology. Brigh-
ton, UK: Harvester Press.
Dunn, Judy. . The Beginnings of Social Understanding. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
Ekman, Paul and Richard J. Davidson. . The Nature of Emotion. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Fischer, Heribert. . “Mistica.” Pp. – in Sacramentum Mundi , edited
by Karl Rahner. Brescia: Morcelliana.
Fodor, Jerry A. . The Modularity of Mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Gazzaniga, Michael S. . The Mind’s Past. Berkeley, CA: University of Cali-
fornia Press.
of his position into specific social categories. The most salient environment, hence the one
which is most capable of explaining differences and similarities inside the reference social
schemes, would allow for activating the diverse social definitions of oneself. The impor-
tance of a new social categorization and the deriving perception of similarity among its
members would then serve as a shared basis for the definition of oneself and of one’s
behavior as a function of a different organization of reality.
s. federici, p. caddeo, and f.v. tommasi
Grusec, Joan E. and Erica Redler. . “Attribution, Reinforcement, and Altru-
ism: A Developmental Analysis.” Developmental Psychology : –.
Harris, Judith R. . The Nurture Assumption: Why Children Turn Out the Way
They Do. Washington, DC: Free Press.
Harris, Paul L. . Children and Emotion: The Development of Psychological
Understanding. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
Heidegger, Martin. . Sein Und Zeit. Frankfurt am Main: Klostermann.
———. . Identität Und Differenz. Frankfurt am Main: Klostermann.
Hoffman, Martin L. . “Developmental Synthesis of Affect and Cognition
and Its Implications for Altruistic Motivation.” Developmental Psychology :
–.
Howlin, Patricia, Simon Baron-Cohen and Julie Hadwin. . Teaching Chil-
dren With Autism to Mind-Read: A Practical Guide for Teachers and Parents.
Baffin Lane, UK: Wiley.
Husserl, Edmund. . Cartesianische Meditationen Und Pariser Vorträge. Den
Haag: Nijhoff.
———. –. Die Krisis Der Europäischen Wissenschaften Und Die Tran-
szendentale Phänomenologie. Eine Einleitung in Die Phänomenologische Philo-
sophie. Den Haag: Nijhoff.
John Paul II. . “Address of John Paul II to the Representatives of the Chris-
tian Churches and Ecclesial Communities and of the World Religions—
Basilica of Saint Francis – October.” http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/
john_paul_ii/speeches//october/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe__
prayer-peace-assisi-final_en.html (accessed May ).
Kelley, H.H. . “Attribution in Social Interaction.” Pp. – in Attribution:
Perceiving the Causes of Behavior: Perceiving the Causes of Behavior, edited by
Edward E. Jones. Morristown, NJ: General Learning Press.
Koffka, Kurt. . Principles of Gestalt Psychology. New York: Harcourt, Brace.
Lazarus, Richard S. . Emotion and Adaptation. New York: Oxford University
Press.
Leslie, Alan M. . “ToMM, ToBy, and Agency: Core Architecture and Do-
main Specificity.” Pp. – in Mapping the Mind. Domain Specificity in
Cognition, edited by Lawrence A. Hirschfeld and Susan A. Gelman. NewYork:
Cambridge University Press.
Lévinas, Emmanuel. . De Dieu Qui Vient à L’Idée. Paris: Vrin.
Lewin, Kurt. . Field Theory in Social Science. New York: Harper.
Marion, Jean-Luc. . Dieu Sans L’Être. Paris: Fayard.
Moioli, Giovanni. . “Mistica Cristiana.” Pp. – in Nuovo Dizionario
Di Spiritualità, th ed., edited by Stefano De Fiores and Tullio Goffi. Cinisello
Balsamo: Edizioni Paoline.
Newberg, Andrew B., Eugene G. d’Aquili and Vince Rause. . Why God Won’t
Go Away: Brain Science and the Biology of Belief. New York: Ballantine Books.
Olivetti, Marco M. . Analogia Del Soggetto. Rome-Bari: La Terza.
———. . “Filosofia Della Religione.” Pp. – in La Filosofia, vol. , edited
by Paolo Rossi. Turin: UTET.
Pinker, Steven. . The Language Instinct: How the Mind Creates Language.
New York: Perennial.
a cognitive psychology perspective
———. . The Blank Slate: the Modern Denial of Human Nature. New York:
Viking Penguin.
Plotkin, Henry. . Evolution in Mind: An Introduction to Evolutionary Psy-
chology. London: Allen Lane & Penguin.
Premack, David. . “The Infant’s Theory of Self-Propelled Objects.” Cognition
: –.
Pyysiainen, Ilkka. . How Religion Works. Toward a New Cognitive Science of
Religion. Boston, MA: Brill.
Pyysiainen, Ilkka, Marjaana Lindeman and Timo Honkela. . “Counterintu-
itiveness as the Hallmark of Religiosity.” Religion : –.
Schaller, Susan. . A Man Without Words. New York: Summit Books.
Schillebeeckx, Edward. . Jesus. Freiburg: Herder.
———. . Menschen. Die Geschichte Von Gott. Freiburg: Herder.
Schüssler Fiorenza, Elisabeth. . In Memory of Her: A Feminist Theological
Reconstruction of Christian Origins. New York: Crossroad.
Senghas, Ann and Marie Coppola. . “Children Creating Language: How
Nicaraguan Sign Language Acquired a Spatial Grammar.” Psychological Sci-
ence : –.
Spelke, Elisabeth S. . “Initial Knowledge: Six Suggestions.” Cognition :
–.
Spelke, Elisabeth S., A. Phillips and A.L. Woodward. . “Infant’s Knowledge
of Object Emotion and Human Action.” Pp. – in Causal Cognition:
A Multidisciplinary Debate, edited by Dan Sperber, David Premack and Ann
J. Premack. NewYork: Oxford University Press.
Spelke, Elisabeth S. and G. van de Walle. . “Perceiving and Reasoning About
Objects: Insights From Infants.” Pp. – in Spatial Representation, edited
by Naomi Eilan, Rosaleen McCarthy and Bill Brewer. Oxford: Blackwell.
Stein, Edith. . Zum Problem Der Einfühlung. Halle: Buchdruckerei des
Waisenhauses.
Tajfel, Henri. . Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social Psy-
chology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tooby, John and Leda Cosmides. . “The Psychological Foundation of Cul-
ture.” Pp. – in The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Gen-
eration of Culture, edited by Jerome H. Barkow, Leda Cosmides and John
Tooby. New York: Oxford University Press.
Turner, John C. . Rediscovering the Social Group. A Self-Categorization
Theory. Oxford: Blackwell.
Wellman, Henry M. . The Child’s Theory of Mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press.
Wimmer, Heinz and Josef Perner. . “Beliefs About Beliefs: Representation
and Constraining Function of Wrong Beliefs in Young Children’s Under-
standing of Deception.” Cognition : –.
chapter thirteen
Paul-André Turcotte
The history of Christian missions goes back to the very origins of the
faith, whether through the writings of missionaries or in the form of
external relations. The perspectives and descriptions have adopted some
formulations that are accorded to the currents that go through the evo-
lution of the method and historical narrative. The relations are incor-
porated, in that case, in the discovery accounts. The objective pursued
seeks to evince, directly or indirectly, conditions of missionary insertion
and its action in the evangelization of non-Christian or de-Christianized
lands. Since the first centuries of Christianity some people were sent to
proclaim the message of the gospel in those frontiers at the limits of the
Roman Empire. Following this, the missionaries addressed themselves to
the peoples considered barbarians on the great European continent and
from there to other continents (Décobert ).
Missionary action accounts have elicited renewed interest within
Catholic and Protestant missions that have functioned since the six-
teenth century. With the discovery of the American continent, Chris-
tian Europe had to deal with a new world—which became “The New
World”—characterized especially by religious syncretism along with the
merging of races and cultures. The questioning and innovations that
resulted from unprecedented situations had few immediate effects on
the structures, the symbols and the practices of the Churches or groups
from metropolitan Europe. The relevant institutions, strong through
their acquired experience, were able to readjust some strategies of im-
plantation and expansion, of conversion and the organization of new
Christians, without having to modify significantly their ways of doing
things or the vision of things in their home country. As a result of trans-
actions between organized religion, cultural or economic and political
conditions, though not without resistance, Christianity in the Americas
ended up becoming singularized while at the same time admitting the
same base in belief and the same divisions in ministries and functions in
structures that were relatively similar or identical. Tensions traversed the
exchanges between the different places of implantation and regulation.
This was the case within the great state churches and, to some degree,
in the minority groups, including the Catholic religious orders (so Prud-
homme : –; Bosch ).
The expansion of Catholic or Protestant detachments took on greater
importance with the facilitation of movement through the moderniza-
missionary insertion and christianization
with the papacy to establish a complete Church, the obligation for the
missions to tend to self-sufficiency, including economic self-sufficiency.
With respect to evangelization, the missionaries were to avoid transport-
ing their European culture with themselves, consequently they were to
be careful with changing the rites, customs and practices of the peoples
if they were not against religion and morality (Prudhomme : –,
; Union missionnaire du Clergé ).
These instructions produce a great variety of sometimes opposing
positions in different moments and places throughout history. The re-
fusal to recognize the difference of cultural alterity meets compromise
understood as an agreement that integrates contrary, even antagonistic,
elements thanks to mediations that permit reciprocity while respecting
the alterity of the elements. It is a transaction where the reciprocity is
without fusion and the distinction is without rupture. In the best of cases,
each of the parties finds its place, beyond the reciprocal concessions, in
the negotiations in which power relations intervene, as well as the third
party regulations, directive principles, shared values and so on. These
relations can be exacerbated in case of the refusal to compromise, to
accept shared criteria that are at the juncture of socially recognized rules
and particularities that derive from the singularity of a point to be gauged
and articulated (Turcotte ).
Whatever the modality of his insertion may be, the missionary is that
migrant, that foreigner who testifies to a total personal experience and, at
the same time, acts as a delegate of an institution, which results from its
organization, its beliefs, rites and discipline of life. Hailing from another
land he is faced with the challenge of making a collectivity, which con-
stitutes an organic whole that comes from another social environment,
believe with a view to an adhesion that supposes a change of life that is
optatively whole, both on the part of individuals and of the collectivity.
Structural or formal movements are in question, and these contribute to
changing the mentality and the behavior of the individuals who make up
a society. The process of transformation of interpersonal relations (people
and groups) and social structures is dialectical. In addition, the message
and the activity of conversion are modified to the extent that individual
and collective alterations take place. Strategies and mediations compete
in a process of change that is globally tendentious (Russell : –
). Such an aim is ramified in a configuration of objectives with the
complexification of the modes of action and the tentacular and sectorial
reading of reality.
In doing this, it is highly likely that an interpenetration of the reli-
missionary insertion and christianization
the language of the place as well as one’s own is often cited as one of the
principal problems, even if that language is learned well. Proverbs, popu-
lar expressions, piercing formulations and other things continue to elude
even the speaker who is familiar with the language. It is also necessary to
learn another system of social conventions and, worse, the complexity of
the rules of day-to-day life which are based on a cultural sensibility and
which will never be fully appropriated. If the missionary is white, he is
assimilated into the race that claims industrial and technical superiority,
which has a heavy colonial, religious and cultural past, even if Canada
never had any colonies as such. The Catholic institution, as the religion
of the white man, has the ambiguous prestige of western power and tech-
nology. The native demands intellectual knowledge from the missionary
with a view to social and economic development and for a Christian syn-
thesis that is capable of expressing the native cultural context. In order to
attain this, it is fundamental to remain a non-native, different through
one’s previous formation and education (: ). In addition, the mis-
sionary changes with contact with the people who have become “his” to
the point of relativizing his own cultural world. Upon returning to his
country of origin, on vacation or definitively, he also feels himself to be
even more a foreigner than in missionary activity. He will share his con-
dition of being foreign with those who have lived or live the same expe-
rience, as was the case—exceptional, naturally—of profound friendships
with the natives.
The second testimony is of an altogether different order. A Canadian
Viatorian, René Pageau tells of his experience in Haiti where he was supe-
rior of missions from to . He does so in poetic terms, which
occurs rarely in Catholic missions. The tragic reality of Haitian existence,
however crude, is described in literary form, in the search for human-
ization. Generally the idea is that of an inner perception, of one who is
not entirely involved. This position is not comfortable, but it allows for
audacity, denunciations which would be otherwise unreceivable, politi-
cally speaking. With respect to struggles for power in the midst of Haitian
institutions, in both the Church and the State, the missionary poet does
not hesitate to say the unspeakable:
My country is a poem but there is misery and hunger/there is fear and
betrayal/the class struggle/at fraternal war/those close to power/silently
frequent/the presidency/while priests/in the episcopal poultry yard/talk
and probe kidneys and hearts/to get to know who among them/will be the
next bishop/or the next cardinal/of the first black republic/independent
for two centuries/the victory of slaves decided/to take their destiny into
missionary insertion and christianization
with the true religious spirit.” The benefactor Barthélemy Joliette him-
self “did not frequent the sacraments” (Hébert : ). With regard
to religion, one responsibility was remarked by the French Viatorians:
cooperate with the clergy and other religious orders to stop the loss of
Catholics to Protestantism, and work to revitalize an old religiosity, to
give new credibility to the institutional Church in the eyes of the faith-
ful.
Catholicism of New France, where male and female religious orders had
played a role of great importance. The ceding of this France in the New
World to England had, among its consequences, that of the interdiction
of male religious orders, Jesuits and the Récollets, and of recruiting for
them, along with the confiscation of their goods, like the College of the
Jesuits of Ville Marie, which was to become McGill University after a
long legal process; the chapel of the Récollets of Québec, which was
transformed into a Presbyterian church, and that of Trois-Rivières, with
the convent which was given to the Anglicans. The Sulpicians avoided the
confiscation, insisting on their status as a society of priests, along with
the Foreign Missions of the Seminary of Québec, founded by Monsignor
Laval in . The derogation, however fragile it was, and an object of
revision during almost the whole century, had permitted financial aid to
be given to works undertaken by female communities, being untouched
by the measures against male communities, and the creation of works
at the behest of the male orders, such as the creation of the College
of Montréal in , in substitution for the College of the Jesuits, by
the Canadian Sulpician Curatteau de la Blaiserie (Turcotte : –
).
Positivistic historians continue to reckon with the reasons and the fac-
tors for the arrival of the male French religious orders after . Some
functional religious reasons are advanced: their episcopal instrumen-
talization with an end to control by religious orders, the extension of
Catholic works thanks to cheap labor, and the recovery of establishments
taken over by the conquering English. Financial reasoning seems to be
the least grounded for the period which interests us: the average salary
was equivalent to that of non-clergy in the positions they occupied in
society, salaries which were, in fact, higher than those in France at the
time (Dussault : –). Nonetheless the economic difficulties were
important in the process of the implantation of new communities. The
various salaries in the recognized civil projects proved to be insufficient
to cover the cost of the intellectual and spiritual formation of the new
recruits and to compensate those involved in pastoral and philanthropic
activities who were badly paid. A common policy took hold: produce the
maximum and consume the minimum. It was necessary to establish a
price: that of sacrificing one or two generations of men, which was done,
not without variations according to the communities, taking into account
the deaths of young men in their twenties and thirties that took place
among the religious as evinced by the tombstones in cemeteries of the
communities (Dussault : –).
missionary insertion and christianization
the gospel in the living out of daily life. This was evinced in the will
to affirm publicly a revivified Canadian culture that was in continuity
with the Catholic heritage, while at the same time respecting the existing
cultural and religious diversity. To reach such objectives, Msgr. Bourget
invited ten female religious orders, the greater part of whom were at first
associated with educational or charitable work. All of them worked for
the religious and sociocultural objectives, with effects that were political
as well as economic. Multiple transactions were put in place that tran-
scended confessional or linguistic limits and even the limits of the state.
In this totality, in affinity with its aspirations and vision of things, an
industrial and commercial bourgeoisie found the legitimate symbolism
of its advancement along with other people who came from a Catholic
context and were open to change and a portion of the Anglo-Protestant
bourgeoisie.
The Francophone Catholic public space became increasingly socially
identifiable upon the adoption of an architectural style which was almost
uniformly classical and installed itself even in Anglo-Protestant bas-
tions—for example, the construction of the archdiocesan cathedral of
Montréal, in the heart of the financial center, built according to the
plans of the Viatorian Michaud, or afterwards, the University of Mon-
tréal on Mont Royal in the middle of an Anglophone quarter. The dec-
oration of churches generally followed the Roman style of grand fres-
coes and paintings with dramatic scenes or those close to day-to-day life,
done by Canadian or European painters. To render religion accessible
to the whole of the faithful supposed a liturgical theatre that inspired
an openness to the marvelous, to emotions, and to the reaction of the
senses and not only the spirit. The revitalization of popular culture, pre-
viously highly politicized and weakened by the latest English repres-
sion, benefited as well, but not exclusively, from the revitalization of a
Tridentine Catholicism, which was characterized by doctrinal rectitude,
a religiosity which appealed to the heart, the Christ-centered conver-
sion of the person, and the cult of saints in the framework of the insti-
tutional hierarchy. Counter to the great North American confessions
which proposed religious practice within the confines of sacred spaces,
Bourget supported religious processions, even in the heart of commer-
cial neighborhoods or ones which were populated by non-Catholics, as
a public expression of the faith of French Canadians. In greater Mon-
tréal and the newer surrounding towns, the Catholic church created a
French-speaking institutional space, offering services whose competence
escaped the control of the Anglo-Protestant majority in Canada, the
missionary insertion and christianization
men are free through Natural Law, hence colonization should be tem-
porary and should prepare for emancipation. This argument does not
consider the economic aspects of colonization (Martin ). Sepulveda
justifies the conquest and subjection of indigenous peoples due to the
rights of men over positive rights. What does this mean? Evangelization
and colonization constitute necessary conditions for the access to civ-
ilization and to salvation of those savage people, who practice human
sacrifices, cannibalism, and idolatry. Colonization, the “necessary evil”
we would say today, is necessary to put an end to barbarity (Merle
; Union missionaire du clergé ; Prudhomme : –, –
).
These three positions, typical in more than one way, will be reprised
in similar ways, if not given way to opposing arguments on the topic
of slavery and the consequences of European colonization. From this
point of view the humanizing action of the Dehonians inscribes itself
in a long debate and a history of Catholic missions, which were not
globalized in univocal terms, especially with respect to the legitimation
of relations of the missions with colonial policies, traversed as they
are by cooperation and opposition, by transaction and distinction. The
reference to Natural or humanitarian Law, in terms of equality or human
liberty, that is to say the human’s fundamental and universal dignity
on account of absolute Natural Law, and at the same time through the
affirmation of the primacy of the religious message over economic and
political objectives, constitute the symbolic weapons of missionary action
for the advancement in the humanization of social relations, especially
when the conditions of subservience affect Christianized populations or
those who are being converted.
to a change in life that will meet with some reticence and obstacles.
Some selective arrangements with respect to ways of perceiving and
living, among them some with respect to power and the economy can
correspond to this resistance. In the best of cases, the tension releases a
process which produces a transaction that is the fruit of negotiations and
of points of agreement among actors as well as the recognition, explicit
or implicit, of difference. The compromise in question supposes a human
cost, notably of a spiritual nature, for the missionary (Turcotte and Remy
: –). To discharge exclusively upon the witness or the institution
can psychologically solve the problem of identity through the closure
of positions at the risk of ignoring or endorsing contradictions and
hardening conflicting positions to the point of rupture. The possibility is
high that things will be otherwise when the missionary is able to combine
the two aspects of the mission. In any case the figure of the missionary
is a complex one, more so since he is situated at the crossroads between
the witness and the institution, the intensity of belief and its extension, of
compromise and intransigence, of the continuity and the discontinuity in
the recomposition of the things of life with reference to the foundational
message and the tradition of another religion.
References
ISSN 1610–5210
The series Religion and the Social Order was initiated by the Association for the Sociology
of Religion in , under the General Editorship of David G. Bromley. In an
agreement between Brill and the ASR renewed the series.