Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 4

Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology Vol. 27 No.

1, Jan-June 2010

ORIGINAL ARTICLE
INJURIES DUE TO FALL FROM HEIGHT – A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY
Jagannatha SR1, Pradeep Kumar MV1, Naveen Kumar T2, Ananda K3, Venkatesha VT4

ABSTRACT sustained vary depending on the falling height, the


Fall from height cause serious and fatal injuries every composition of the impact surface, rate of deceleration,
year which add significantly to morbidity and mortality intermediate objects encountered during the process of
of the area. The fatality of the injuries depends not only on fall, the position of the body when landing and individual
the height of fall but also on body landing position, impact factors such as age, body weight, pre-existing disease,
surface, clothing and the safety measures used as seen in and type of the person (child, adult, elderly). In India,
cases of laborers working in higher altitude. Fall from fall from height is one of the common causes of severe
high places are frequently encountered in accidents, blunt trauma. Fall from high places are frequently
suicides & rarely in homicides. The severity of the injury encountered in accidents, suicides & sometimes rarely
increases by increasing the rate of deceleration & in homicides.
decreasing the distance through which the body is Falls are examples of vertical deceleration injuries (VDI)
decelerated. This retrospective study has been undertaken and the patterns of injury differ from horizontal deceleration
on 120 cases during a period of seven years and pattern of injuries (HDI) associated with motor vehicle accidents.
injuries was evaluated. An effort is also made to correlate Vertical deceleration injuries characteristically involve major
it with the height of fall. weight bearing structures with forces transmitted through
Keywords: Fall from Height; Vertical Deceleration the foot, leg, pelvis & vertebral column2. Injuries of the
Injuries; Soft tissue injuries; Safety measures. lower extremity are likely to be unilateral & comminuted
because the force of deceleration is applied to a small area.
INTRODUCTION The severity of the injury increases by increasing the rate
of deceleration & decreasing the distance through which
Injury is recognized as a major health problem and a the body is decelerated. More severe injury occurs when
leading cause of death globally1. Fall from height are deceleration forces are applied to the body in the vertical
responsible for many serious and fatal injuries every year. axis compared with the transverse, provided that mass,
In an urban setting, morbidity and mortality of the area is velocity & stopping distance remain the same.
dependent on the accidental injuries out of which, injuries
due to fall from height add significantly. If the height of fall The mode of impact influence the individual injuries
is less; it may leave the victim with disability so as to make sustained independently of deceleration force, hence, it is
him unable to do his routine work. If a person falls from a known that fall on the head is more likely to be fatal than on
height above six feet and more, there is likelihood that he any other position, there is no way in which the pathology
may sustain serious injury, examples include fall from roof of falls can be generalized as the circumstance will differ in
top, from tanks, from the edge of elevated structures, or major aspect in every case.
from the top of vehicles or trailers. The extent of injuries Head (depressed skull fracture, cerebral contusion,
intracranial hemorrhage), thoracic (pulmonary contusion,
1 MBBS, MD, Assistant Professor ruptured bronchus or aorta, sternal fracture resulting from
3 MBBS, MD, Professor & HOD hyper flexion of the chin), spinal (burst vertebral bodies) &
4 Professor
abdominal (shearing of the bowel at the junction of fixed
Department of Forensic Medicine, and mobile portions) injuries are common, most often
Kempegowda Institute of Medical Sciences skeletal injuries predominate3.
Banashankari II stage, Bangalore-560070
Several studies exist which evaluate the pattern of
2 MBBS, MD Assistant Professor injuries from falls. However there are very few studies
Department of Forensic Medicine exclusively discussing the pattern of injuries in vertical
Rajarajeshwari Medical College and Hospital deceleration injuries to major cavities of the body.
Bangalore-560074.
Corresponding Author: This study has been undertaken to evaluate the pattern
Dr Jagannatha SR MBBS, MD of skeletal & soft tissue injuries and to correlate it with the
Assistant Professor, Department of Forensic Medicine height of fall. Also an effort is made to look into the
Kempegowda Institute of Medical Sciences demographic profile, manner of death in cases of fall from
Banashankari II stage, Bangalore-560070 heights.
Karnataka State, INDIA E-mail: pradi003@rediffmail.com
47
Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology Vol. 27 No. 1, Jan-June 2010

MATERIALS AND METHODS victims were construction workers by occupation. The


youngest was a baby of 18 months old & the oldest being
The Department of Forensic Medicine at KIMS, a Post
80 years. Out of 120 cases 112 (93.33 %) cases are accidental
Graduate institute conducts autopsies of all violent,
and 8 (6.66%) cases were suicidal. The descent of fall varied
unexpected and suspicious death in the southern part of
from 8 feet to 75 feet. Most of the victims 37 (30.8%) fell
Bangalore. This retrospective study was conducted by
from a height ranging from 31-40 feet followed by 21 (17.5%)
scrutinizing the Post mortem reports & other relevant
victims who fell from a height of 41-50 feet (Fig 1).
documents that are suggestive of fall from height. The
relevant documents considered are police reports, suicide Toxicological tests were performed only on selected
notes, medical records & scene photographs. The age, sex, cases. Ethanol was detected in 5(4.1%) cases. Blood alcohol
height of descent, injuries, circumstances, place of fall & concentrations ranged from 0.08 to 0.490%.
manner of death where available were reviewed. The other Abrasions, contusions & lacerations were evenly
types of violent deaths & fall from the same level were distributed all over the body. As the height of fall increased
excluded from the study. Toxicological results were reviewed there was an increase in the severity of the injuries, involving
in available cases. The patterns of injuries were discussed soft tissues and skeleton. Skeletal injuries involved Skull
according to type of body region. It is divided into head, 87, followed by Ribs 51 & Femur in 31 cases (Fig 2). Among
chest and abdomen and the injuries are compared with level soft tissue injuries brain involved in 91 cases followed by
of descent. liver in 42 cases & lungs in 33 cases (Fig 3). Majority of

RESULTS
Department of Forensic Medicine, KIMS, a post
graduate institute, Bangalore conducted autopsies
concerned with our study on 120 cases during a period of
seven years. The 120 fatalities due to descent from height
comprised 4.139 % of the 2899 autopsies performed during
the study period.
Among 120 cases studied, 104 were males & 16 were
females (Table 1). 21 to 30 years age group individuals
dominated other age group victims (Table 2). Most of the
Table 1 Fig 1

Year No. of No. of Sex distribution of


Autopsies fall from fall from height cases
conducted height cases Males Females
2003 345 12 11 01
2004 409 15 14 01
2005 421 14 12 02
2006 410 20 17 03
2007 416 17 16 01
2008 433 20 14 06
2009 465 22 20 02
Total 2899 120 104 16 Fig 2
Table 2
Age in years Male Female Total
00-10 3 2 5
11-20 15 3 18
21-30 37 2 39
31-40 19 3 22
41-50 16 2 18
51-60 8 3 11
>60 6 1 7
Total 104 16 120 Fig 3
48
Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology Vol. 27 No. 1, Jan-June 2010

head injuries were due to primary impact of head. Vault liver is a solid organ, covering most of the area in the
fractures 44 (36.66%) were the most common type of skeletal abdominal cavity. Injuries of liver and spleen are seen in
injury of skull followed by basal fractures with vault fracture high falls from heights beyond 24m, irrespective of the
in 30 cases (25%). manner of impact 7. In our study liver lacerations were seen
in falls from a height of 40 ft (12-2m) and above which can
DISCUSSION
be explained by the fact that most of the victims are laborers
Falls are examples of vertical deceleration injuries (VDI) by occupation and probably at the time of fall they might
and the patterns of injury differ from horizontal deceleration have not maintained the safety measures needed. It is not
injuries (HDI) associated with motor vehicle accidents. the scenario in the western world, as most of them follow
Vertical deceleration injuries characteristically involve major the protocol so the injury pattern and height differ.
weight bearing structures where forces transmit through
If the person falls on the head, both vault and base of
the foot, leg, pelvis & vertebral column2. The pattern of
skull can fracture, with extrusion of brain. When the person
injuries can help in the determination of causation of
falls to the side of the body, severe abdominal and thoracic
injuries & manner of death 4. In the abrupt vertical
injuries can occur 8. Cardiac injuries (54%) are found in
deceleration that occurs on impact after a free fall, tissue
falls from height exceeding 6m 9. But in our study we did
damage is caused by the absorption by the body of the
not find a single case of cardiac injury, probably due to the
energy accumulated during the free fall. Patients sustain a
fact the mode of impact, influence the individual injuries
unique injury pattern that is predictably different from that
sustained independently of deceleration force and in most
seen with other forms of blunt multiple trauma5.
of the cases it is the body lands on the head or on the feet
Falls from heights are most commonly due to accidents and very rarely on the side of the body. The cardiac injuries
in children and suicide, accident and crime related incidents may be seen in cases where the fractured ends of the ribs
in adults. Two types of injury result from falls from heights: or sternal pierce the heart. In most of the cases in our study
injury resulting from direct impact and deceleration type of the lungs were edematous covering the surface of heart
injury. The injuries resulting from direct impact are mostly which might have acted as a cushion, preventing cardiac
fractures. The body position at the time of impact is very injuries. Direct impact to the chest can lead to cardiac
crucial. The deceleration forces immediately post-impact injuries. Haemothorax was seen in cases of rib fractures 9,
result primarily in visceral and internal injury, including 10
. Workers in maintenance and construction and many other
Cerebral injury. Height of descent, body landing position, people in a variety of jobs could be at risk of falling from
impact surface and clothing affects the extent & distribution height at work. Bangalore being a developing city with the
of skeletal injuries and soft tissue injuries 6. emerging buildings is the main cause behind the accidental
fall involving laborers. Most of the victims were workers
The frequency and extent of the injured body regions
aged 21 to 30 years, contributing for daytime falls. This is
and organs are related to the fall height. In the present
in contrast to findings of Kohli & Banerjee 11 who were of
study it was found that 37 victims (30.8%) fell from a height
the view that most of the falls occurred late at night as in
ranging from 31-40 feet followed by 21 (17.5%) victims who
our study out of 120 cases 112 (93.33 %) cases are accidental
fell from a height of 41-50 feet. Skeletal injuries involved
and 8 (6.66%) cases were suicidal in nature. In India
Skull 87, followed by Ribs 51, Femur 31 and Vertebrae in 25
poisoning (34.8%) is the common type followed by hanging
cases. Among soft tissue injuries brain involved in 91 cases
(32.2%) to commit suicide. Jumping from building accounted
followed by liver in 42 cases and lungs in 33 cases. Various
only 0.5% of the total number of suicide deaths in 2008 12.
studies describe that head injuries are characteristic of the
falls from heights and brain injuries in high falls from heights
CONCLUSION
beyond 30 m show an absence of contre coup contusions
and macroscopically evident intracranial bleeding. In our The extent of injuries sustained due to fall from height
study, we could not compare the height of fall with that of vary depending on the falling height, composition of the
coup and contre coup injuries as it is an retrospective study impact surface, rate of deceleration, intermediate objects
and in most of the reports these specific findings were encountered during the process of fall, position of the
missing as only the presence of injuries were mentioned in body when landing, individual factors such as age, body
the reports and not mentioning the exact location of the weight, pre-existing disease and also type of the person
injuries. This can be considered as one of the limitation of (child, adult, elderly). Craniocerebral trauma (head injury)
the study. In our study 37 victims (30.8%) fell from a height is the primary cause of mortality amongst skeletal injuries.
ranging from 31-40 feet and head being the target region of Among soft tissue injuries, injury to brain followed by
the body of impact. The Severity of chest and abdominal liver, lung and spleen were frequent. As most of the victims
injuries have statistically significant association with the were construction workers and where work at height cannot
fall height which is in accordance with our study. Liver be avoided, a risk assessment should be carried out before
injuries are the most common abdominal injury seen in most any work at height is undertaken by the employers. Fall
of the studies. This can be explained by the fact that the restraint and arrest equipment such as nets, airbags and

49
Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology Vol. 27 No. 1, Jan-June 2010

harnesses, etc. should be considered as safety measures Dallemagne F, Beruben A et al. Prognostic factors in
at the work place. All work at height should be planned, victims of falls from height. Critical Care Medicine.
organized and carried out by competent persons. But none 2005; 33(6):1239-42.
the less every case has to be weighed on its own merits. 7. Atanasijevic T, Savic S, Kolic S, Djokic V. Frequency
and severity of injuries in correlation with the height
REFERENCES of fall. Journal of Forensic Sciences. 2005; 50(3).
1. Sethi D, Habibula S, McGee K, Peden M, Bennett S, 8. Reddy KSN. The essentials of Forensic Medicine and
Hyder AA, Klevens J, Odero W, Suriyawongpaisal Toxicology. 26th edition. Suguna publisher, India.
P. Guidelines for conducting community surveys on 2007; 238.
injuries and violence. WHO; 2004. 9. Turk, EE, Tsokos M. Blunt cardiac trauma caused by
2. Maull KI, Whitley RE, Cardea JA. Vertical fatal falls from height. The Journal of Trauma. 2004;
deceleration injuries. Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 1981; 57 (2):301-304.
153(2):233-6. 10. Eryilmaz M, Durusum M, Menteso, Ozert, Kicics,
3. Buckman RF and Buckman PD. Vertical deceleration Ersoy G, Actinel O, Calemoglu M, Torer N.
trauma: principles of management. Surg. Clin. North. Comparison of Trauma Scores in adults who fell from
Am. 1991; 71:331–44. height as survival predictivity. Turk J Med Sci. 2009;
39 (2):247-252.
4. Gill JR. Fatal descent from height in New York City;
J. Forensic. Sciences; 2001; 46(5):1132-37. 11. Kohli A, Banerjee KK. Pattern of injuries in fatal falls
from buildings. Med. Sci. Law. 2006; 46(4):335-41.
5. Tan S. Free fall trauma. Trauma. 2006; 8(3):157-167.
12. http://ncrb.nic.in/ADSI2008/suicides-08.pdf
6. Lapostolle F, Gere C, Borron SW, Petovic T,
assessed on 18-03-2010.

50

Вам также может понравиться