Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
an increase in the use of anhydrous ethanol mixed with and Moscow. There is a very tiny production of sugarcane in
gasoline, thanks to the expansion of Brazil's light vehicle the Amazon (less than .2% of the Brazilian total production)
fleet. By then, in 30 years of large scale use of ethanol, Brazil that is processed at four mills that were built more than 20
had developed engine technologies and distribution logistics years ago at a time when the government provided fiscal
that were unprecedented in the world. The network of fuelling incentives to set up industries in this region to supply the local
stations in which pure ethanol could be purchased reached 28 market. Without subsides these mills would not have been
thousand. economically viable since the Amazon region does not offer
favorable conditions for commercial sugarcane production.
In March of 2003, Flex-Fuel vehicles were introduced. For this reason, future expansion is anticipated to continue in
These could run on ethanol, gasoline or any mixture of the South-Central Brazil, primarily in degraded pastures. I
two, thanks to technology that could identify the precise fuel
mixture in the tank at any given time, and adjust engine
performance to match. The novelty led to a new wave of
growth in the sugarcane industry, which was helped along by
concerns surrounding the availability and cost of fossil fuels
and growing fears about the environment and global warming.
All of these combined to make ethanol an increasingly viable
and important renewable fuel alternative, for Brazil and the
world.
C. Sugarcane today
As of late 2007, sugarcane fields occupied about 7.8
million hectares in Brazil, or about 2% of all arable lands
available in the country. This makes Brazil the number one
producer of sugarcane in the world, followed by India, Fig. I. Sugarcane production regions in Brazil
Thailand and Australia . Main production region are South-
Central Brazil, where close to 90% of overall production is B. Myth # 2: Displacement ofOther Agricultural Activities
concentrated, and the Northeast, which accounts for the A second myth is that sugarcane expansion displaces other
remainder. There are two harvests per year, which allows agricultural activities into the rainforest.
Brazil to produce sugar and ethanol year round for both the The fact is that, according to the Brazilian Institute of
internal market and for export. Spatial Research (INPE), about 65% of recent sugarcane
With the end of government involvement in the sector in expansion took place on pastures, mostly degraded, in the
the late 1990s, free market rules became the norm, without Central-South of the country. As such, growing sugarcane in
subsidies. Sugar and ethanol prices have since been set these areas do not increase competition for land or displace
according to supply and demand variations, while sugarcane other crops. Amazon deforestation, which has been going on
prices became hinged on quality and percentage share in the for many decades, has been caused by a complex set of social
finished products. and economic factors completely unrelated to the expansion of
To properly manage and balance both production and the Brazilian sugarcane industry. One of the main issues is the
demands from within the sector, the industry has sought to absence of clear land titles that leaves the region exposed to
create market instruments, such as futures trading, while rampant land speculation and squatters.
developing new opportunities for both sugar and ethanol
through the removal of protectionist barriers. The industry is C. Myth # 3: Detrimentation ofFood Production and Prices
also heavily involved in efforts to develop standards for A third myth is that Brazil is being overrun by sugarcane
ethanol, as a first step to make it a globally tradable in detriment of food production and prices.
environmental commodity. The fact is that sugarcane for ethanol production in Brazil
occupies 3.4 million hectares, or roughly 1% of the country's
III. BRAZILIAN SUGARCANE ETHANOL - FALLACIOUS 355 million hectares of arable farmlands. The cultivated area
MYTHS VS. FACTS is 1I4th of that dedicated to com, 1I8th of the area planted with
soybeans and 1I60th of the land used for cattle farming. With
A. Myth # 1: Deforestation ofthe Amazon Rainforest
only 1% of its arable land dedicated to sugarcane for ethanol
A first myth is that the Brazilian sugarcane ethanol leads to production, Brazil has been able to replace half of its gasoline
the deforestation of the Amazon rainforest. needs with sugarcane ethanol. While cane production has
The fact is that most sugarcane for ethanol production increased steadily in recent years, food production in Brazil
(90%) is harvested in South-Central Brazil, over 2,500 km has grown dramatically without any price increases. The 2007
(1,550 miles) from the Amazon (See Fig. 1). The remainder grain and oilseed harvest set a record at 142 million metric
(10%) is grown in Northeastern Brazil, about the same tons, a doubling of production in the last ten years . Brazil is
distance from the easternmost fringe. This is roughly the
distance between Montreal and Vancouver or between Paris I UNICA - Brazilian Sugarcane Industry Association
3
widely recognized for its diversity and highly efficient longer, but also an octane booster.
agricultural sector - it is the world's leading exporter of beef,
G. Myth # 7: Only Brazil Can Benefit
coffee, orange juice, poultry, soybeans and sugar.
A seventh myth is that sugarcane ethanol is a unique
D. Myth # 4: More Environment's Damage than Fossil Fuels solution that only Brazil can benefit.
A fourth myth is that ethanol production and use can cause The fact is that more than 100 countries grow sugarcane
more damage to the environment that of fossil fuels. and most could produce and use ethanol, repeating Brazil's
The fact is that claims that ethanol production could successful experience. The potential for expansion is
actually increase carbon emissions compared with fossil fuels impressive. According to FAO, only 10% of the world 200
are flawed. The basis for such assumptions lack transparency million hectares (excluding forest and protected areas)
and lead to absurd conclusion that dwindling fossil fuels are available and suitable for sugarcane production are actually
better to the environment. Brazilian ethanol produced from used. Most sugarcane producing countries are tropical,
sugarcane reduces greenhouse gas emissions by up 90% developing countries that would benefit from an opportunity
compared to gasoline, a reduction unmatched by any other for significant economic development. Ethanol production and
biofuel produced by existing technology. This positive balance use creates jobs, fosters development of new technologies,
is not affected by changes in land use. In fact, when compared allows for the introduction of cheap renewable electricity in
to crops such as com or soybeans, sugarcane captures more rural areas, cut down on oil imports and provides new export
carbon because it is a unique semi-perennial crop replanted opportunities. Ethanol production in 100 countries would also
every six years. In addition, the use of degraded pastures - the enhance energy security by reducing the world reliance on
expansion area of choice for sugarcane in Brazil - actually only 20 oil producing countries.
generates a carbon credit, as sugarcane captures significantly
larger amounts of carbon than the quantities originally stocked IV. BRAZILIAN ETHANOL POWER INDUSTRY
in this type of land. In addition, the by-products of sugarcane
A. Brazilian Sugarcane Biomass Fuels: Bagasse and Straw
ethanol production (bagasse and straw) are used to produce
clean, renewable electricity, currently accounting for 3% Bioelectricity may well be the most significant area for
Brazil's power needs and expected to reach 15% by 2015. Brazil's sugarcane industry and one can spark another
revolution on the scale of ethanol. Bioelectricity is produced
E. Myth # 5: Consumes Less Energy than Generates by burning bagasse, the dry, fibrous waste that is left after
A fifth myth is that ethanol production consumes more sugarcane has been processed. This already happens in almost
energy than it generates. all Brazilian sugarcane mills and ethanol distilleries, but much
The fact is that, when the entire process is considered, from more energy could be produced if the bagasse as well as the
the planting of sugarcane to the use of ethanol as a motor sugarcane straw - the tops and leaves of stalks - were to be
vehicle fuel in what is known as a well-to-tank analysis, burned in high-efficiency boilers. Much of the approximately
sugarcane produces 9.3 units of clean, renewable fuel for two thirds of the sugarcane's theoretical total energy potential,
every unit of fossil energy utilized. Ethanol produced from contained in the bagasse and straw, remains unharnessed.
other feedstock such as sugarbeet, cereals and grains (com, Sugarcane energy is concentrated roughly one third in
barley, wheat, etc.) have between 1/1 and 2/1 ratio today (See juice, one third in bagasse and one third in straw. Until
Table I). recently the juice has been used to produce sugar and ethanol
while the most of the bagasse has been burned in low-
TABLE I efficiency boilers to produce steam and generates
ENERGY BALANCE FOR THE ETHANOL PRODUCED BY DIFFERENT FEEDSTOCK
bioelectricity to cover only the plant's own needs. With
FEEDSTOCK RENEWABLE ENERGY!
hydrolysis technologies now under development, it will be
FOSSIL ENERGY USED possible to produce additional ethanol from bagasse and straw,
SUGARCANE ETHANOL (BRAZIL) 9.3 while the lignin that remains will also be used as biomass to
CORN ETHANOL (USA) 1.3 generate additional bioelectricity.
SUGARBEET(GERMANY) 2.0
WHEAT ETHANOL (EUROPE) 2.0 B. The Bioelectricity in Brazil
MANIOC ETHANOL 1.0
Brazil is increasingly turning to alternative power
generation fuels such as biomass in order to increase power
F. Myth # 6: No Price Reductions When Added to Gasoline supply and reduce its dependence on hydropower. Biomass
power represents around 4.1 percent of the total installed
A sixth myth is that gasoline prices in Brazil are not
capacity in Brazil at present and most biomass cogeneration is
reduced by the use of ethanol.
based on sugarcane bagasse. At present, sugarcane bagasse
The fact is that added to gasoline, ethanol is a key factor to
cogeneration accounts for 3.03 percent of the total Brazilian
keep fuel prices competitive and more affordable. Recent
energy matrix.
studies have shown that if ethanol were entirely removed from
the fuel supply, gasoline prices in Brazil would rice by 15- New analysis reveals that the market reached 3.0 GW in
2007 and expects to reach 12.2 GW in 2014.
30% at the pump. Used as an additive, ethanol is not only an
The Brazilian sugar and alcohol sector envisages to market
effective fuel extender which makes gasoline supplies last
4
electricity surplus to the national grid. In order to produce for the production of second-generation ethanol because they
marketable amounts of electricity, the sector is expected to would allow for increased fuel production without expanding
invest in new technologies, including cogeneration equipment. cultivated areas.
There is a clear trend toward the implementation of boilers Conservatives estimates indicate that hydrolysis has the
with higher steam-production capacity. New boilers and steam potential to increase ethanol production by around 40 liters per
turbines with higher capacity and efficiency would ton of sugarcane, raising the current average of 85 liters per
substantially increase the electricity surplus the mills would be ton of sugarcane in South-Central Brazil to around 125 lit. By
able to sell. 2020, the introduction of second-generation ethanol, together
with new varieties of sugarcane, should allow for continued
C. Obstacles to the Ethanol Power Industry Expansion
growth of production without further expansion of planted
Unattractive prices are discouraging companies looking to area.
sell their excess electricity to the national grid. Brazilian sugar For centuries, sugarcane fields around the world have been
and alcohol plants produce around 95% of their electricity burned before cutting to facilitate the manual harvest. New
needs, purchasing the remaining 5% from national-grade technology to mechanize the harvest with considerable
transmission and distribution (GT&D) companies. Plants efficiency gains is now in place. In an effort to gradually
claim that the prices they pay to those companies for this phase out manual cutting, more than 130 sugar and ethanol
additional power are several times higher than the prices paid mills have subscribed a "Green Protocol" with the Sao Paulo
by GT&Ds for the plants' electricity surplus. State Government. This calls for the eradication of pre-harvest
Another significant restraint for the cogeneration market is burning by 2014 in areas where harvesting can be mechanized
the lack of connection to the power grid. In addressing this, and by 2017 where mechanization is currently not feasible -
many sugarcane cogeneration plants are working on building for example, where the cane is planted on steep slopes. With
generation distributive center units that will collectively the harvest fully mechanized, the straw will no longer be
transmit electricity cogenerated in the mills and input it into wasted. Instead, it will be collected and burned along with the
the grid. bagasse in high efficient boilers (more than 60 bars), thus
Structured tax and fmancial policies would serve as a driver allowing a growing number of sugar and ethanol plants to sell
for the expansion of sugarcane bagasse cogeneration their surplus bioelectricity to the national grid. At the start of
technologies. Government and related regulatory agencies the 2008/2009 harvest, about 50% of the sugarcane harvest in
should develop clear planning and regulatory structures in Sao Paulo State was already mechanized.
order to boost cogeneration capacities in sugar mills. This The possibility of generating surplus power has been under
includes the easy and efficient connection to the grid, and the consideration by the Brazilian sugar/ethanol mills for many
establishment of fair prices to pay back the high investments years, but several factors have hindered the realization of the
of the mills. existing potential. Changes in the regulatory framework and
privatization of the power sector have changed the background
V. CONCLUSIONS AND PERSPECTIVES
towards more favorable conditions to generate and sell
As already said, the Brazilian sugarcane ethanol industry is electricity. This has created a new surge of interest among the
a case of success. There are innovations in all areas. mills and several projects are being developed contemplating
In terms of transportation, the Brazilian automotive small- to medium size systems for surplus power generation
industry is now selling the "second-generation" of flex-fuel during the crushing season. Larger systems with more than
cars that do not more need a little separated tank for gasoline 100 kWh/t cane to be injected in the grid, operating the year
that was used to start the vehicle in very cold days. round, will require fuel supplementary to bagasse. Countries
Current technology for production of ethanol from biomass or areas that have installed such larger systems, such as
relies on processes of fermentation and distillation and Mauritius, Reunion, Guadalupe and Hawaii, are using fossil
requires feedstocks that contain sucrose (sugarcane, sugar fuel for the off-season operation. In Brazil, it has been
beet, etc.) or starch (com, wheat, cassava, potato, etc.). Global implemented the use of straw as a supplementary fuel to
demand for alternative, sustained fuel sources has created the increase the power generation capacity of mills.
need to experiment with new feedstocks and develop Bioelectricity is power generation having vegetable
innovative processes for the production of ethanol. Generally biomass as fuel. For the sugar and ethanol sector this normally
speaking, "second-generation" biofuels are those produced means cogeneration - producing two types of energy, thermal
from celluloses and hemicelluloses, which can be found in and mechanical - using just one fuel, the biomass (bagasse
agricultural and forestry residues as well as organic wastes. and/or sugarcane straw) as the primary energy source. With
There are others emerging processes, such as gasification, that current technology, Brazil sugarcane sector has the installed
may be able to produce hydrocarbons from biomass capacity to generate 1,800 average megawatts (MWyear) in
feedstocks such as sugarcane bagasse. 2007/2008. Bearing in mind that industry estimates for
Research into hydrolysis technology is advancing quite 2020/2021 indicate a sugarcane harvest of one billion ton, the
rapidly in many countries and that second-generation ethanol bioelectricity from bagasse should then be 7,600 MWyear,
will become viable within the next five years. In Brazil, reaching 14,400 MWyear when both bagasse and straw
sugarcane and bagasse are particularly attractive as feedstocks become available thanks to mechanical harvesting. Even
5
greater amount of energy could be generated if the sugar and 3. Improve the carbon credit certification process for the
ethanol producers receive a fair tariff that would give biomass power generation thought the utilization of
incentive to implement combined-cycle plants, as the example sugarcane bagasse and straw.
that can be seen in Fig. 2 bellow . 4. Implement combined-cycle plants to increase the
efficiency and output of sugar/ethanol power stations .
Cresciumal 5. Implement the existing technology of condensing/
New eog.,..",tlOIi P,.", Coge neration ii Proc:en • extraction steam turbine (CEST) or the advanced
P roj e ct Plan t • Plant
;
•
Sugarcane Milli ng Rate :
Power Prod ucti on :
380tlh
36 MW
technology of biomass integrated gasification/gas turbine
I Co ns um ed Powe r: 06 MW
i S ur p lus POW@r: JO MW (BIG/GT).
i Produc ed Bagasse : 98 tJh
• Con sumed Baga sse : . 2 tJh 6. Reformulate completely the criteria of the centralized
Surplus Baga sse: 06tJh
Brazilian power system expansion planning studies in
order to consider, by one side, the benefits of the annual
21 kgf/cnr
power generation complementation between the
70 Uh hydroelectric and the sugar/ethanol power plants; and, by
1 .~ kg/e m' other side, the benefit of the location of those distributed
30 Uh
biomass power generation close to the load centers . The
s.. ~
Condenser ___..L-_... Prooe ss Sf ea m 14 0 tlh
COGEN/SP is developing technical and economic studies
Fig. 2. Crisciumal - New Cogeneration Plant Project to explore the positive externalities of the bioelectricity,
which is produced in the dry periods, and so, in
More efficient power generation can be obtained by the use complement to the base hydroelectric energy that is
of the existing technology of condensing/extraction steam produced in the yet period. 2 Studies from the Brazilian
turbine (CEST) or the advanced technology of biomass National System Operator indicate that each 1,000 MWa
integrated gasification/gas turbine (BIG/GT). of bioelectricity in the Southeastern Region correspond to
Generating bioelectricity offers numerous benefits : the add more 4% of water in the reservoirs. Furthermore, the
environment impact is low and producers can obtain carbon COGEN/SP studies should include the benefits of
credits, while project are relatively small. This means reduced investments reduction (or even avoid) on the transmission
risks, in particular of the kind that frequently cause and/or distribution grids, which are overloaded, with the
construction delays in large-scale hydroelectric projects. injection of sugarcane ethanol distributed power plants
Moreover, bagasse and straw cogeneration represents a boost close to the load centers. And also the environmental
for the Brazilian equipment industry and creates numerous benefits in the referred studies are been considered.
jobs, while drawing on know-how developed over many years 7. Reformulate completely the criteria of definition of the
of cogeneration for internal consumption and at sugar and tariffs by the centralized Brazilian power system
ethanol plants. expansion planner that privileges diesel and oil thermal
Bioelectricity from sugarcane is a particularly interesting power plants in detriment to the biomass power plants .
for Brazil because so much of the country's generation comes 8. Create a special "green tariff' that considers all the
from large hydroelectric power plants far away from the load environmental benefits provided by the sugarcane ethanol
centers . The sugarcane harvesting period, when the most power plants in comparison with the greenhouse gas
biomass is available, coincides with the dry season when emissions of the fossil fuel power plants. So, as the
hydroelectric power plants sometimes has to reduce the European legislation example , the "green tariff' would be
production in order to avoid big depletion on the reservoirs. a price composition that considers the benefits of the
This makes the two sources of electricity complementary. In complementarities, of the losses reduction and of the
addition, the majority of sugar/ethanol mills are located fairy environmental gains .
closed to the most populous region of Brazil, where the power
load is the highest. VII. REFERENCES
Periodicals:
VI. RECOMMENDATIONS [I] M. R. L. V. Leal, 1. C. Macedo and S. 1. Hassuani, "A Review of
Biomass Integrated-Gasifier/Gas Turbine Combined Cycle Technology
After the comprehensive analysis done in the previous and its Application in Sugarcane Industries, with an Analysis for Cuba"
items, the authors make the following recommendations in Energy for Sustainable Development - The Journal of the International
order to minimize the bottlenecks of the sugarcane power Energy Initiative, vol. V No.1 , Princeton, New Jersey, Mar. 2001.
[2] M. R. L. V. Leal, 1. C. Macedo and S. 1. Hassuani , "Sugarcane Residues
generation expansion in Brazil : for Power Generation in the SugarlEthanol Mills in Brazil" Energy f or
1. Share with the distribution companies the costs for the Sustainable Development - The Journal of the International Energy
interconnection of the sugar/ethanol power plants into the Initiative, vol. V No.1, Princeton , New Jersey , Mar. 2001.
[3] J. Goldenberg , S. T. Coelho, P. M. Nastari and O. Lucon, "Ethanol
national power grid. Learning Curve - The Brazilian Experience" Biomass and Bioenergy,
2. Accelerate the process of the sugarcane harvesting vol. 26, issue 3, Elsevier Press, 2004, p.30 1-304.
mechanization in order to maximize the availability of
sugarcane bagasse and straw to be used in high efficient
boilers (more than 60 bars). 2 COGEN /SP - Paulista Association of Cogeneration
6
Books : since 1990; and Associate of the International Consultant Corporation - ICC
[4] A. Walter, P. Dolzan , O. Quilodran, 1. Garcia, C. Silva, F. Piacente and (Washington, DC, USA) , since 1994. And, since 2009 , Dr. Marques De
A. Segerdtedt, A Sustainability Analysis of the Brazilian Ethanol, vol. I, Azevedo is acting , also , as Visiting Professor at the Department of Electrical
Campinas: UNICAMP, 2009 , p.167 . and Computer Engineering of McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
[5] J. Goldenberg, F. E. B. Nigro and S. T. Coelho, Bionergia no Estado de
Sao Paulo - Situacao Atual, Perspectivas , Barreiras e Propostas, vol. I,
Silo Paulo: Imprensa Official, 2008 , p.152 .
[6] L. B. Reis , Geracao de Energia Eletrica, vol. I. Silo Paulo : Tec Art Francisco D. Galiana Electrical Engineer
Editora, 1998, p. 203. (Honours), McGill University, 1966; M.Sc. on
(7] L. B. Reis and S. Silveira (org), Energia Eletrica para 0 Electrical Engineering, MIT (Mas sachusetts Institute
Desenvolvimento Sustentavel, vol. I. Silo Paulo: EDUSP , 2000 , p. 284. ~J!l!I:i!-"i.rP~of Technology), 1968; Ph.D. on Electrical
[8] L. B. Reis (org), Energia, Recursos Naturais e a Prdtica do Engineering, MIT, 197 I. Research Engineer on
Desenvolvimento Sustentavel, vol. I. Silo Paulo : Editora Manole, 2005 , Automatic Control at Brown Boveri Co., 1971/1974 .
p.415p. Assistant Professor, University of Michigan's
Electrical and Computer Engineering Department,
Papers Presented at Conferences: 1974/1976 . Associate Professor, McGill
[9] L. A. Barroso, P. Lino, M. Pereira and S. Granville, "Sweet Dreams are University 's Electrical Engineering Department,
made of This: Bioelectricity in Brazil", presented at the IEEE PES 1976/1983. Professor, McGill University's
General Meeting, Tampa, USA, 2007 . Electrical and Computer Engineering Department,
[10] L. A. Barroso, H. Rudnick, R. Moreno and B. Bezerra, "Ensuring since 1983. Prof. Galiana wrote several books and publications. Over the
Resources Adequacy with Auctions of Options and Forward Contracts", past six years Prof. Galiana has supervised more than 87 highly qualified
presented at the IEEE PES General Meeting, Tampa , USA, 2007. research personnel, including nine at the doctoral level and seven at the
[II] L. A. Barroso, P. Lino, F. Ralston , M. Pereira and S. Granville, "Recent post-doctoral level. Prof. Galiana is an IEEE 's Fellow , since 1992, for
Advances of Sugarcane Biomass Cogeneration in Brazil" , presented at sustained innovations in power flow and contingency analysis for power
the IEEE PES General Meeting, Calgary, CA, 2009 . systems planning and operation.
[12] L. A. Barroso, R. Chabar, L. M. Thome, M. Pereira and F. Porrua,
"Incorporating Large-Scale Renewable to the Transmission Grid :
technical and regulatory Issues" , presented at the IEEE PES General
Meeting, Calgary, CA, 2009 .
[13] L. A. Barroso, R. Moreno, S. Mocarquer, H. Rudnick and B. Bezerra,
"Auctioning Adequacy in South America through Long-Term Contracts
and Options: From Classic Pay-as-Bid to Multi-Item Dynamic
Auctions", presented at the IEEE PES General Meeting, Calgary , CA,
2009.
Thesis:
[16] 1. Marques De Azevedo, "Urna Visao Integrada do Planejamento da
Expansao e da Operacao Energetica do Sistema Eletrico Brasileiro".
Ph.D. Thesis on Electrical Engineering, Escola Politecnica da
Universidade de Silo Paulo, SP, 2006 . Available:
<http.l/www.usp.br/portaldosaber.pdf>.
VIII. BIOGRAPHIES