Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
B2B MARKETPLACES
White Paper
2017 - 2018
U P P L E R 1
THE FOUNDER’S PERSPECTIVE
Grégoire CHAUVIN
Managing Director
Over the past years, the industry has THE DEMANDE FOR B2B
witnessed the resurgence of B2B MARKETPLACES IS
marketplaces. Even though new
REACHING MATURITY
actors are arguably gaining traction,
we have to remember lessons from
Through insight and execution, B2B
the past. Many were those too quick
marketplaces can help you digitize
to praise B2B marketplaces in the
efficiently your business ecosystem,
late 90’s… For the result we know.
by selling more and interacting
However caution must not come at
better.
the expense of hope.
I hope this booklet will help you
It is my belief that the demande for
understand the causes and vectors
B2B marketplaces is reaching
of this revolution to come.
maturity.
Enjoy your reading!
From a technical standpoint, I can
say for sure that the products are
Grégoire Chauvin
more efficient and scalable than
ever. On the demand side, we are
seeing growing interest across all
geographies and verticals.
2
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
6
Executive Summary
7 -- 8
A booming yet fragmented market
9 -- 18
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
10
Alibaba, the open door to the Chinese market
13
A variety of early starters
16
Shortcomings of early B2B marketplaces
17
At the turn of 2009, innovative players emerge
18
A market now fragmented by vertical and geographic location
19 --21
Key requirements and features of B2B marketplaces
20
Confidentiality , Pricing
21
Transactional features, product navigation and industry specific
features
4
22 -- 24
Go to market strategies
23
The connected approach
24
The SaaS based approach
25 -- 28
Technical notes
26
The 4 interfaces of the marketplace
28
All in One solution vs. Modular solutions
29
Final thoughts
30
About Uppler
5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
B2B Specificities
B2B actors need flexibility when it Competition is rife, players are
comes to displaying their product, plentiful. In this context, one way of
their price, and negotiating the terms achieving long term growth and
of payments. strategic advantage is by offering
innovative product and services. B2B
They also require a robust system, marketplaces are an incredible field
that keeps product data constantly of experiment, from a technical
up to date and purchases secure. perspective at least.
Flexibility and robustness are all the This white paper will provide a
more crucial that the sums at stake useful tool to those who wish to
are sizeable. The average transaction navigate this complex yet fascinating
value in the B2B world is way higher market.
than in a B2C context.
6
A BOOMING YET
FRAGMENTED MARKET
U P P L E R
7
A booming yet fragmented market
2000
1st Generation
horizontal
2010
2nd Generation
vertical specific
8
A BRIEF HISTORY OF B2B
MARKETPLACE
U P P L E R
9
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
Of course that was possible to large from Chinese merchants, but also
companies, who had sufficient funds the demand for international
and expertise to develop such a long products on the Chinese market.
lasting relationship. Alibaba has now become a key
partner for every B2B seller willing
But traditional oversea to launch on the Middle Empire. It is
manufacturers had to resort to the also taking full advantage of China’s
services of import houses, since they monetary policy of competitive
couldn’t afford starting production devaluation, that mechanically favour
facilities in China. On the other side, Chinese exports. In addition to being
SMBs and small entrepreneurs in a successful international trade
China, who were not large enough to enabler, Alibaba has managed to stay
get noticed by international firms, in a dominant position on a
had limited access to international domestic scale. The main reason
markets. To those businesses, being that Alibaba’s products are not
Alibaba offered a simple, fast and indexed by Baidu’s search engine,
convenient way of finding making the marketplace one of the
international buyers, effectively most visited and searched website in
bypassing all the legislative trouble China. As a result it serves more
previously mentioned. than 18 million buyers and sellers
Like its rival Amazon, Alibaba chose worldwide, and counting!
to monetize its B2B platform by
charging commissions on
transactions. Moreover, they offer In a nutshell, Alibaba’s success in the
annual subscriptions for sellers B2B sphere is linked to two things.
willing to fine tune their personal Favorable demographics; by
shop (SEO, larger product listings). targeting a huge untapped market on
both sides (supply and demand),
However, the two heavyweights of Alibaba was able to quickly
e-commerce differ fundamentally in consolidate its position as a market
their approach to partnership. leader. Correlatively, they were able
Amazon launched the Fulfilled by to scale up so quickly thanks a
Amazon offer, aimed at leveraging peculiar revenue and cost structure
their state of the art logistic chain (with very limited ownership of
for smaller businesses. Alibaba on assets). Alibaba’s success paved the
the contrary holds no warehouses, way for other B2B marketplaces,
and remains a pure platform operating in different markets, and
player, merely providing access to a offering tailor-made features when
pool of buyers/sellers. Alibaba sticked to its “mass market”
positioning.
11
“Following in the footsteps of
Alibaba, several marketplaces
came into existence…"
12
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
Others tried to surf on the potential Their product assortment and their
of newly opened markets, like EC21 customer base is really broad. You
in South Korea, or India Mart and can find pretty much everything you
Trade India for the eponymous want, and since the onboarding
market...Most of them managed to process is not tightly monitored, you
make it to today, some others didn’t. don’t need to be a pro to join the
And the spectacular failure of PEP marketplace.
market and Commerce One are here The lack of confidentiality and
to remind us that B2B marketplaces industry specific features explains
are a very competitive playing field. why price is a key differentiation
element on those platforms.
However diverse they may seem, first
generation B2B marketplaces
followed a rather simple pattern; Proven leaders are:
they focused on a specific geography
and/or on a specific product. • China: Alibaba - 18M buyers
Indeed, the B2B universe has more • USA: ThomasNet - 1.8M buyers
constraints embedded; sales cycles • India: TradeIndia - 1.6M buyers
are longer, quantities are larger,
expectations are higher. This makes • South-Korea: EC21 - 1M buyers
it difficult for a single player to
emerge as dominant, unlike in B2C
marketplaces where the duopoly
Alibaba Amazon crushes down
competition. In the B2B world, there
is room for various actors.
13
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
These marketplaces are more recent. Services B2B marketplaces are most
They have been created later (after of the time global and public. The
2010) because their level of buying process is very different from
complexity is much higher than in physical goods marketplaces. Most
generalist marketplaces. Indeed they of the time you do not choose a
adapt to the specificities of each supplier or an offer, but send a
sector, and enforce a stricter request for quotation through the
onboarding process. Companies system, and receive offers from all
willing to join need registration and the service providers. Hence buyers
approval from the operator before generally can not browse seller
accessing products and prices. Most profiles.
of the time, suppliers can adapt their
price and product categories to each • Freelances / World : Upwork
client browsing their shop. • Micro Services / World : Fiverr
• Emerging leaders are: • Music / World : AudioNetwork
• Fashion / USA: Joor - 100k • Outsourcing / USA; Blur
buyers
• Sourcing / USA: Makers Row -
100k buyers
• Craft / USA: Etsy, wholesale
section - 20k buyers
• Beauty / USA : Salon Centric
• Spirits/ USA: SevenFifty
• Industrial supplies: Systemax
14
“…B2B marketplaces suffered
badly after the burst of the
Tech bubble in 2001 ."
15
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
One could definitely lay the blame Another problem that arose was the
on market conditions; overfunded neutrality problem, several
and burning their cash at insane marketplaces were operated by a
rates, those marketplaces were company… that also featured as a
doomed to fail. But a curious reader buyer or a seller on the marketplace.
might take a closer look at the It is difficult in that situation to
intrinsic reasons of this bloodbath. onboard new suppliers/buyers on
Most marketplaces at the time relied the platform for basic neutrality
on the reverse auction model, i.e. a reasons. In fact, who would want to
buyer sends out a public request for join a marketplace owned by a
proposal, and sellers bid on this competitor that charges you a
contract. The lowest bidder gets to commission every time you use it?
sale its product. This triggered a
war on price between suppliers that To wrap it up, a large number of
turned out to be disastrous for their B2B marketplaces failed in the
margins, and detrimental in terms of aftermaths of the dotcom bubble for
quality of service for buyers. three main reasons.
Competing on price is not the right The first obvious one being macro;
approach in a B2B market, where investments were withdrawn from
purchase decisions are made in a those firms, hence dooming those
holistic way. Buyers factor price, as cash hungry businesses to failure.
well as quality (product and servicing
capabilities…). Since few of the first
generations marketplaces integrated
effective review systems or social
capabilities, it became difficult for
16
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
The second reason lies in the feature Fashion is indeed an interesting use
of the products, that did not offer case for B2B marketplaces. Business
enough warranties to buyer as to the is basically evenly spread throughout
quality of the product they bought. the year with very specific windows
Lack of social integration for product showcase and product
condemned those marketplaces to launch. Winter and Spring Summer
price competition. plus additional “ad hoc” collections
The third problem, correlative to this featuring famous designers).
one, was a problem of trust. Trust Collections are rolled out
between buyers and sellers, but trust progressively throughout various
between marketplace actors and distribution channels, not to
marketplace operators in some cases. overload the supply chain and to
Those shortcomings will be fixed, to sustain the interest of buyers. The
a certain extent, by the second end of the season is usually followed
generation of B2B marketplaces. by sales, where brands have the
opportunity to empty their stocks at
Emergence of innovative a fairly competitive price. Note
players however that the more upscale the
brand is, the less likely it is to empty
After the burst of the dotcom its stock during sales. Luxury and
bubble, the B2B marketplace some premium brands would rather
landscape suffered a period of burn their stock than lowering the
sluggish growth, further exacerbated prices, hereby harming brand equity.
by the 2008 crisis. As global trade In addition to this seasonality and
levels plunged, so did B2B very packed schedule, the emergence
exchanges, hence negatively of fast fashion puts additional
impacting other stakeholders in the pressure on the brands. Retailers
ecosystem. Alibaba, however, demand shorter product replacement
managed to stay afloat thanks to a cycles to match the desires of
very diversified customer base and consumers. This trend, pioneered by
solid market shares on the Chinese large fashion players (H&M,
market. Inditex), using proprietary
Yet, at the turn of year 2009, 3 new, procurement softwares, puts
innovative players emerged, in the pressure on brands’ supply chain by
fashion industry mostly. In 2009 was requiring ever shorter time to
created le New Black, followed by market.
Joor the year after and NuOrder in
2011. A new gold rush had started,
and fashion was the name of the
game.
17
A brief history of B2B marketplaces
18
KEY REQUIREMENTS
& FEATURES
U P P L E R
19
Key requirements and features
Confidentiality Pricing
Confidentiality is one of the main Pricing is another key topic for B2B
rifting points between B2B actors. It is indeed a sensitive
marketplaces and their B2C information in the B2B world. Or
counterparts. Sellers must be able to better yet, a critical set of
protect sensitive information about information. When we talk about
their products. Their appearance price in a B2B context, we might
(fashion industry), their tech specs refer to a wholesale price of
(electronics) to avoid copycat, and course… but also of the
of course their price. It is also useful manufacturer’s suggested retail price
from a brand equity perspective. (MSRP), an information that is most
Sellers should be able to select useful to buyers.
buyers depending on their
positioning. A premium fashion In a B2B context, price is also
brand might try to avoid being dynamic. Bulk pricing is a standard
distributed by a discount retailer. requirement for this kind of
From that perspective, filling transaction. Seller should therefore
exhaustive profiles, and having them be able to select the threshold above
duly checked by an operator, is the which certain discounts apply, and
key to building trust between both the amount of discounts (percentage
sides of the marketplace. of order value, or absolute amount).
Of course, price should also
depends on the various options you
add for your product (material…).
If we were to push even further in
terms of personalization on the
pricing aspect, we could offer tiered
pricing by customer segments. Those
segments could be created based on
their transaction history (volume or
number of transactions).
20
Key requirements and features
21
GO-TO-MARKET
STRATEGIES
U P P L E R
22
Go-to-market strategies
23
Go-to-market strategies
The following graph sums up the pros and cons of both approaches
24
TECHNICAL
REQUIREMENTS
U P P L E R
25
Technical requirements
Let’s touch up a little bit on the • A back office allows the operator
technical issues of the marketplace to monitor the transactional and
creation. non transactional activity on the
marketplace, from early
First we need to understand how onboarding validation to auto
marketplaces operate as programs. send of customer newsletters
A marketplace functions thanks to
interactions between four basic • A fourth layer includes several
layers: bricks of software that, even
though non mandatory, are
• A front office, for buyers to embraced as standard in a B2B
browse and shop the products environment. It could be product
available information management (PIM)
• A middle office for sellers to software, or customer relationship
upload and refresh their product management (CRM) softwares, as
range. In addition to catalogue well as payment enablers…
adjustments, the middle office Opposite is a simplified visualization
includes several transaction linked of a marketplace.
features (editing purchase
agreements, sales dashboards)
26
Technical requirements
Logistics
Payment
Services
MIDDLE-OFFICE for Sellers
27
Technical requirements
28
FINAL THOUGHTS
29
ABOUT UPPLER
CONTACT
Grégoire CHAUVIN
Managing Director
gregoire.chauvin@uppler.com
30
U P P L E R
25