Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1982
Prepared Under Grant No. 78051
FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY
UNITED STATES FIRE ADMINISTRATION
Washington, DC 20472
1---------- ------------------------------+-:-=---=----=---------1
9. Perform'nc O....nizetlon Name and Address 10. ProjectlTnlclWoril Unit No.
(G) 78051
12. Sponsorine O,.anlzation Name and Address 13. Type of Repott & Period Covered
Three national model building codes, i.e., Basic Buildin~ Code, Uniform Building Code,
and Standard, Building Code, were examined for current code provisions relative to
automatic fire extinguishing systems. The study sought to find the rationale for
those provisions, and especially to determine the adequacy of code provisions for
sprinkler and design options, and to bring other pertinent research to the attention
of design professionals and building and code enforcement officials in evaluating
alternative fire protection methods, including economic impact.' Among other things
it was found that (a) the model codes are generally in agreement about sprinkler re-
quirements and design options, (b) a majority of state and local building regulations
are based on one of the model codes, (c) little documentation exists with respect to
why most design options are permitted, and (d) initial costs of the sprinklered and
nonsprinklered versions of three building types did not differ substantially in the
two cost analyses prepared in this study. The recommendation was made that the United
States Fire Administration undertake the development of a comprehensive research
program to obtain reliable information to serve as the-technical basis for code
provisions on sp~inklers and design options.
BOCA
ICBO
SBCCI
c. COSATI FJeld/Group ;
Ill. security Cia•• (ThIs RePOrt) 21. No. of pqn
UNCLASSIFIED 1lf-1
--------------l----~------
Release Unlimited 2IL Security Cln. (ThIs Pap) 22. Price
UNCLASSIFIED
See ANSI-Z39.J8) See Instructions on R....,.. OPnONAL FORM 272 (4-77)
(Formerly NTI>3S)
Department of Commerce
GENERAL DISCLAIMER
This document may be affected by ODe or more of the following statements
• This document has been reproduced from the best copy furnished by
the sponsoring agency. It is being released in the interest of making
available as much information as possible.
• Portions of this document are not fully legible due to the historical
na tu re of some of the material. However, it is the best reproduction
available from the original submission.
•
Trlis was a study of the provIsions of model codes that are under continuous
review. ThE' provisions are revised as new information becomes available.
Although cnre has been ta~en to assure a high degree of accuracy in
reporting the content of these provisions, neither the
study participants nor the members of the review panel accept any liability
for reliance upon information contained herein as justification for compliance
or non-compliance 'I'.'ith uny model code or any code system adopted by
8 locd or sUite government.
PARTICIPANTS iii
I. INTRODUCTION :r -'(,"
,"
. '
A. Basic Principles
: \
1. Use Group Classifications , \ II 2
2. Construction Classifications " 'I II - 3
D. System Requirements
1. Applicable Standards II - 24
2. Alarms II - 24
3. Water Supplies II - 24
4. Standpipes II - 24
5. Fire Department Connections II - 25
6. Appendix II - 30
A. Basic Principles
1.
• •
Automatic Sprinkler Trade-Offs and Options
D. Systems Requirements
A. Basic Principles
1. Occupancy Classifications IV - 2
2. Construction Classifications IV - 4
D. System Requirements
1. Applicable Standards IV - 24
2. Alarms IV - 24
3. Water Supplies IV - 24
4. Standpipes IV - 24
5. Appendix IV - 25
• PREFACE
-ii-
• PARTICIPANTS
Project 1\lanager
Project Advisor
Project Officers
-i ii-
\
\
I. INTRODUCTION
• ,
1M,cy"~
The~g Codes
nuilding codes contain mInimum ncceptablc criteria for health, safety and public
welfare in the adopting jurisdiction. Fire safety criteria nrc established in these
codes.
Buildings are classified on the basis of occupancy. use and construction type.
Specific criteria are applied to buildings within each classification. Fire sl1fety
criteria includes requirements for such elements as: exits, flame spread ratings
for finish rna terials, fire resistant rat ings for construction materials and
materials assemblies, and fire suppression systems.
Project Program
The study was undertaken to identify the research basis or rationale for current
code provisions relative to automatic fire extinguishing systems and other
building fire protection, to bring other pertinent research to the forefront for
use by design professionals and building Rnd fire code enforcement officials in
evaluating alternative fire protection methods, including economic impact. To
accomplish these objectives. the study was conducted in several parts: they are:
For the purposes of this study, several information sources were investigated but
the comparison was limited to the following model codes:
There has been no effort to investigate requirements of local and state codes,
federal agencies, or such standards as NFPA 13, Standard for the Installation of
Sprinkler Syste ms.
Findings
~- 2 .c.
6.
• •
The rfltionale for revIsing sprinkler and design options provIsions is
documented for only about the last decade; most of the historical
background does not exist in useable form.
Recommendation
This investigation attempted to review the research that has been conducted
specifically to determine the adequacy of code provisions for sprinklers and
design options. While there have been research projects and tests that con-
tribute information on the subject there has been no definitive research program
. designed to provide substantiation of all such code provisions.
11,;,1 '
Ie BASIC BUILDING C:ODE1978
A. Basic Principles
1. Use Group Classifications'
All buildings and structures are classified with respect to the use groups listed
in Section 202,. and the sub-groups found in the nine sections following:
Group B - Business
Group F - Factory and Industrial.
Group H - High Hazard
Group I - Institutional
1-1 Jails, reformatories, and similar
1-2 Hospitals, orphanages, police stations, and similar·
Group M - Mercantile
Group R - Residential
R·l Hotels, motels, and similar (accommodations for more than 20
{'\
individuals)
::::::;'..1"/
R-2 Multiple.family dwellings (accommodations for more than 5 but
less than 20 individuals) .
R-3 One- and two-family dwellings
R-4 One- and two-family dwellings not more than 3 stories in height
Group S - Storage
S·l Moderate hazard (refer to Table 210.2)
5-2 Low hazard (refer to Table 210.3)
Table 210.3
USE GROUP S-2 STORAGE USES. LOW HAZARD
Asbestos Ivory
Chalk and crayons Metals
Food products Porce lain and poltery
Glass Talc and soapstones
iI- 2
2. Construction Classifications
Construction types are defined in Table 214 according to the fireresistance
ratings of their structural elements.
Table 214
FIRERESISTANCE RATINGS OF STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS (IN HOURS)
Type of construction section 214.0
Type J Type 4
Type 1
Section :215,0
Type 2'
Section 216.0 Section 217.0
! Section 218.0
Slrucluf<ll element Noncombustible Note c Extenor masonry walls Frame
Note a
! Heavy
F'ireproof timbers Ordinary
Protected Unprotected F'rotected Unprotected
(mill) Protected Unprotected
"
lA ' 18 2A 28 2C , JA J8 JC I
4A I ,a
Exterior walls (Section 906.0 and ! i I
i
Nate b)
Beanng II 4 J 2 1 0 2 2
I 2 1
I
0
Fire separation of 30' or more I I I
Non ·beari n II 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i 0 0 0
0 I I 0 I 0
Note ~
II- 3
' . ' . .
432.2 Covered Malls (Group M) Ali . Throughout the covered mall and all
·buildings connected· thereto. Note: The
mall area must be. protected by a~
independent system.
1202.3 Group A2 - Assembly All When area exceeds 5,000 sq. ft.
(nightclubs, dancehalls)
or
1'202.4 Group A3 - Assembly All When area exceeds 12,000 sq. ft.
(museums, lecture halls;
libraries, recreation centers)
1-' (Institutional-Restrained)
Occupancies having on occupant
load of less than 6.
il1 1-'
(Institutional-Restrained)
OCcupol"'cies the fire suppression sys·
tem shall be a sprinkler system which
may be manual or automatic.
11- ~
Section Construction Complete Suppression
Number . Use Groups Types Affected System Required . . . .
1202.8 Group M - Mercantile All When crea exceeds 12,000 sq. ft. for
Group S-1 - Moderate to one story.
Hazardous Storage
Group F - Factory and or
Industrial When area exceeds 24,000 sq. ft. on
all floors.
or
1202.9 Public Garages All When area exceeds 10,000 sq. ft.
or
or
or
or
or
II-5
I
Number Construction Complete Suppression·
Section Use .Groups Types Affected System Required . . .
or
II-6
2. Partial Automatic Fire Suppression Protection Required
1202.5" Stages in Assembly Use All, For stages of any size in, assembly occu-
(Group A-l-A) panCies, in the following locations:
and
Stage gridirons (sidewall sprinklers ;"'ith:
135 0 F ,rated heads with heat-baffle
,plates installed around the entire peri-
meter of the stage at points not more
than 30 inches below the gridiron, nor
more than 6 inches below the baffle
plate);
Il- 7
Section , Construction Partial (Limited Area)
Number Use 'Groups Types Affected, Suppression System Required ...
o'nd,
Under all. fly galleries;
and
Over, the proscenium opening on the
. stage side; ,
". and
,and
'In all basements, cellars, work rooms,
dressing rooms, store rooms," and prop-
erty . rooms;
and
In toilet, lounge/and smoking rooms.
1202.12 Group A - Assembly All In .all areas occupied for storage, work-
Group' B -- Business . shop, or. similar purposes.
Group I - Institutional
Group R1 ~ Residential Exception: . Individual storage or work·
Hotels shop areas located entirely within a
Group R2 - Residential dwelling unit.
Multi-family
or
When, regardless of access, cellar area
exceeds 2,500 sq. ft.
II-8
Section Use Groups Construction Partial (Limited Area)
Number Types Affected Suppression System Required
'-.
II- 9.
.
.-
.,
- - '
.. . .
Table _ 305 Height and Area Limitations establishes floor area and - height
limitations between exterior walls,-- or between -exterior' walls and fire walls, for
buildings of each use group end construction type.
Table 305 -
HEIGHT AND AREA LIMITATIONS -OF BUILDINGS -
Height limitations of buildings (shown in upper figure as stories and feet above -gradel, and area
limitations of one· or two·story buildings facing on one street or public space not less than 30
feet wide (shown in lower figure as area in square feet per floorl. See Note a. -
N.F'.-Nol permitted
, Unlimited
! ) ~ln.ryJoi5Iedl' I
F'1I'eprool
Note b
I Protected Unpro.
tlcled
il (H',T.)
Mill
Pro-
leered
lunpro- I
Ilectecl II_Cled
Prt; I U'P'>-
Iet:ted --\
- _ J
Note I IA I ,. I 2A I 2. 2C i]A I 3. I JC i... I •• '--_/
165U5'! <51. SO' 1 251. JO' 1 , 51.20' 251.JO' i 25'JO'I, 51.20'1' 5t. 201
1
I 1<1400: 11400: 7,~ 4.800 i 7,'lOO E600 [ 4,BOO
L 51001 NP
oil-I-A ASMI'I'Il:lly, theat~s
A·J-B
Without stail!! (motion
plclurl!! theatres)
I
1
Ii 551.65' i 3 St 0'! 2 Sl3C'
19,950! 13,11' 1,'00 I
! 3 St. 40'
1 12,600
Ii J SUO'
11,5>0
2 St)l)' lIst. 2D'II 1St. 2V'
1,'00: 1,925 ',200
'-3
L@Clure I'Ialis. r~rI!2!lon centers, 1
I 5 SUS' i J St 40" 251.):)' 3 St.'ll" I.' J St.O' 12 ~t. 3D' 11 51 ~I, 1 St. 20'
termrn.als. rl!Stauranh other than
nlQ:I'It club~ : i 19,950: 13,125 5,'00 lZ,6O:l! 11,550: 8400 i 8.925
1
4.200
65 I J 5t 40' i 2 St. 30' ~ J St..w i J St. 40': 2 St, 3lY 11 7\ 1{)'i 1 SI. 20'
I s Stloi.200! 22.500 I ).... 400 i :i'1.600: 19,800 ~ 14,COO I .5.3OO j 7,200
Note c i i ' I i Nolt' 0 ! i ' : Note d I' NOle d
BUSlnll!S5
6 St. 75' ! • St. SlY I 2 SI l:l" 1.51 50' I J SI .-0' I 2 Sf. ]0' : 2 Sl 3a' i I 51 2G
i
I'
! 5S( 75'1 "S~ SC': 251.30': 1512'O'! 251.3O'! 251. 3O'1'! SL:ro'! I 5t 2(1'1
1-' '18,00J: l(2~', ',j)':', 6,00J, 9.COJ! E.2SOf 6.00J: 6.37:'! Nr>
I~SlllutIO"iJl, InCapaCI(.Iltl!C:
i B5l SO'!.45l5IYr2S1.3lYi ISl2"'J'!2SIl'Yi2St »1 i5t 2O'j lSI 20'1
" ! 21.6aJ! 17.100: 11,.2!lO 7.2'00! 10,8OO! 9,90:)' 7,~ i 7,650
1
, NP
.-, i 9 S( 100'; .. St 50' i 3 St £QI i .. St,~'! .. St, 5D': ) 5: tC'! J 51 4a~2': St 15'
RI!!IOII!"\I.I, multl.famlly.
I 22,800 l 15,COJ i 9,6iXl I lUOC I lJ,2?J: 9,6cr.:! 10.200: UOO
I ! Nol~ f 1 I I Not!! f: : i
.-3 , .. st,5D':" St.~! J St.40'! .. 5t SO': .. 5t 50'! 351 4D'1 35! 40'121,J:5:)5
22,BOO lS,ro.:: 9,60: i 1~,.i)2 i D.200: 'Hf.(1 i Ie 200i .,!iX.
I
! :. St. 6:' .. SUD"; .2 SUD" i 451 5C' ! J S: .dO'! .2 5t. JQ ; .2 51_ 30': : S~. 2C"
5·1 Net!!!. Ii: Ind !'l
19,~, lJ.125; B.w:!
l2.&OO j :15SO i 8,4CO: i 8,9:'~1 •. 2OC'
5-1
! ;
~~,=-~~I
II- 10
Reproduced from
best available copy.
Notes applicable to Table 30S
Note a, See the following sections for general exceptions to Table 305,
Section 305.4 A:lowable area reduction for multi-story buildings,
Section 3Q6.2 Allowable area increase due to street frontage.
Section 306,3 A!lowable area increase due to automatic fire suppression system ir.stallation.
Section 307.0 Unllmlled area one-Slory buildings.
Section 308.1 Allowable height increase due to automatic fire suppression system Installa·
t1or" '\
Note b. Type 1 buildings permtlted unlimited tabular heights and areas are not subject to
special reqUirements that allow Increased heights and areas for other types of construction.
Note c. The tabular area of one-story school buildings of use group A-4 may be Increased
two hundred (200) per cent provided every cla~sroom has at least one (1) door opening
directly to the exterior of the building. Not less than one-half (1,',) of the required eXltways
from any assembly room included In such buildings shall ,also open directly to the exterior
of the bUilding. ,
Note d. Church auditoriums of Type 3A construction may be erected to sixty-five (65) feet
In height, and of Type 4 coristructlon to forty-five (45) feet in height.
Note e. For exceptions to height and area limitations of high hazard use buildings. see
Article 4 governing the specific use. For other special fireresistlve requirements governing
specific uses. see Section 905,0,
Note f. For exceptions to height of multi-family dwellings of Types 28 and 38 construction,
see Section 905.6.
Note g. For height and area exceptions covering open parking structures. see Section 429,0.
Note h. For height and area exceptions covering petroleum bUlk-storage, buildings, see
Section 905.3,
The area per floor of buildings over two stories in height is controlled by Table
305.4 - Percent Reduction Of Area Limits:
Table 305.4
Type of construction
No. of stories lA & IB 2A 2B,2C, 3A, 3B, 3C,4A, 4B
1 None None None
2 None None None
3 None 5% 20%
4 None 10% 20%
5 None. 15% 30%
6. None 20% 40%
7 None 25% 50%
8 None 30% 60%
9 ' None 35% 70%
10 None 40% 80%
--,---
Example:
A Group M -,Mercantile occupa~cy of Type 2A '...:.. Protected Noncombustible con-
struction is limited by Table 305 to an area .of 22,800 square feet. This ;s the allow-
able area per floor for a one- or two-story' building.
If ci three-story building was being designed, Table 305.4 calls for a 5% reduction
in area ,per flo.or. For the type 2-A Mercan'tile, this. would mean an allowable area
per floor of . .
22;800
.05 (22;800)
21,660 sq. f.t. per floor
II-ll
" . e'·'
Example:
, If 50% o'f abuilding's perimeter fronts on a street not less than 30 feet in width, the"
'tobular cuea ,in TabJe 305 may' be incrr?osed by'
·,2{50%.25%)=50%
"(Figure, B:2)
75% frontage
tabular area plus 100%
(2.) Sprinkler Increase Option, Use Groups: All except H • High Hazard
Section 306,3 - Construction Types: All
When a building is equipped with on approved automatic fire suppression
system, the tabular areas may be increased by 2001.. (tripled) for one-
story buildings and by 100% (doubled) for multi-story buildings.
Il-12
,c
Example:
square feet.
Note: Sections 306.2 and 306.3 may be used in combination. Area in-.
creases are additive.
Example:
A one-story Type 28 Mercantile (Group 'M) is limited by Table 305 to an area of
15,000 square feet. '
If the building will border on accessible open' space, along 80% of its perimeter,
the street frontage increase of Section 306.2 may be applied:
2(80%- 25%) = 110% x 15,000 sq. ft. =16,500 sq. ft.
If the building is equipped with' on automatic sprinkler system, the area increase of
Section 306,3 may be applied: 200% x 15,000 sq. ft. = 30,000 sq. ft.
The area'increases are additive. 15,000 tabular
16,500 access increase.
+ 30,000 sprinkler increase
61,500 sq. ft. total
Note: The area increase ,for sprinklers' may be appliedsiniultaneously with' the
height,increase for sprinklers of Section 308.1 .
'II_13,
",
Oriestory school buildings of Type 2; 3-A, ,ond 3-B construction 'may, be
unlimited, in area if a directexitway to .the' outside is provided from each
classroom, fire separation' on all, sides is provided in accordance with' 307.2
and if the building i~ equipped thro~ghoCt with an cipproveda'utomatic fire
suppression system:
"Table 429
HEIGHT ANOAREA LIMITATION FOR OPEN PARKING STRUCTURES
Note 1. Type 28 and 2C construction may be six (6) stones In height and unlimited in area when at
least fifly (~o) per cent open on all Sides and when the honzontal distance from any pOint on any level to
an extenor wall opening on a' street, alley, courtyard or any other permanent open space does not ex·
ceed two hU~dred (200) feet
Example:
Table 305. allows unlimited area furniture warehouses (Use Group S- J) ~nly if of
Type J "fireproof" construction; Such warehouses can be built of all, except Frame
construction (Type 4) if the side separation and egress requirements are met and if
provided with on automatic sprinkler system, '
Note: The height increase for sprinklers may' be applied simultaneously with the
area increase for sprinklers of Section 306,3,
II_14
Example:
A Tyoe 4A - Protected Fi·':lme nursing home :'Use Group 1-2) is limited to a height
of one story or twenty fee, by Table 305, If equipped with automatic sprinklers, an
additional one story or twenty feet may be added.
c. FIRERESISTANCE OPTIONS
(1.) Fireresistance Reduction From Area and Height Increase Options
Use Groups: All
Construction Types: All
The area and height increase options allowed in the Basic Building Code'
have the net effect of reducing the fireresistance ratin'g requirements for
a ,given occupancy design.' In· other words,- a-given building size would
ordinarily require a cer1ain construction type in accordance with Table
305. However, because area and height' increases are allowed, lesser
construction types can be utilized' when the .building is sprinklered.
Example:
,Through use of the area increase 'option, automatic 'sprinkler installation permits' a
one.storybusiness occupancy of Type 4A construction to be built to an area of over
45,000 square feet. For the designer to obtain the same allowable, area without auto-
matic sprinklers, he would have to use Type J B construction or better . . ,
By installing automatic sprinklers, the designer is, in effect, reducing the fireresistance
rating requirements of the building's structural components, Those rating requirements
can' be compared in Table 2 J 4 (page 3 of this Guide);
Unsprinklered Sprinklered'
, Component' Type 18,' Type 4A'
Exterior Bearing Walls 3 hrs. ,J hr.
Interior Bearing Walls & Partitions 2 hrs. J hr.
Columns. Girders, Trusses and Framing' 2 hrsc, J hr.
Floor· , 2 hrs. 7 hr.
Roof J~,'2 hrs. 7 hr:
Whot, does this mean interms of economics? BOCA, !~ternalional periodicplly pub",
lishes a "Building V~/uatio't1 Data Report" which .oresents ave'rage ·cubicfoot con-
struction costs.' The April 1980 report lists the following average costs ,for Group
B' occupancies. (see Appendix):
·Type·7B type 4A
. 53]2/c,,) , ft. $2.59/cu ft .
.11- 15
Example: (continued)
,Assuming a ten foot b~ild~ng height, the construction cost per square foot for the
nightclub would be:
Type 7B ' Type 4A
$37,20 $25.90
The "Building Valuation Dota' Report", provides 0,' figure of $0.084/ cu. ft. as the
average cost of sprinkler add-~n.
, "
This brings the totol cost of the :msprink'lered 'and sprinklered buildings to~ , '
Unsprinklered - Type 7B '
$37.20/sq. ft. x 45,000 sq. 'ft. =
$7,674,000
Sprinklered - Type 4k, ' '
$(2.59, -t- .084/ cu. H) x 70ft. x 45,000 sq, ft. $7 ~203,300
The sprinklered' building co~ld be built for approximately 30/0 les~' than the un-
sprinklered building_
Table 407.5
, EXPOSURE DISTANCE FOR PYROXYLIN STORAGE BUILDINGS
II- 16
(5.; Floor-Ceiling Assemblies Below Grade Option
Section 905.7.1- ,Use Groups: All except R-3 - Dwellings
Construction Types: All except Type I
In buildings with habitable or occupiable stories or basements below grade,
floor-ceiling assemblies and supports must either have a fire resistance
rating of 1 hour, be of heavy mill (Type 3A) construction, or be protected
,with an automatic fire suppression system.
Doorways Corridors
Passageways Interior, stairways
Exterior Stairways Moving stairways
Smoke-proof enclosures Ramps
Horizontal exits Bridges
Balconies Fire escapes
Exitway - "That portion of a means of egress separated from all other spaces
of a building . . . to provide a protected way of \ravel to the
exitway discharge."
Exitway Discharge --' "That portion of a means' of, egress between the termi-
nation of anexitway and. a public space.". ,
11- 17
Table 507
LENGTH, OF EXITWAY ACCESS TRAVEL 1FT.)
r.::::=:::::===.......,----------,
Example: I'" i
One advantage gained through increased exi,'woy . r
access travel IS the' increase In building' area rho' 200' maxlmu~1
can be served bya single exit system. For example, exit length .1.
on assembly (Group A) building designed as a
square can be built to a certain maximum area
using one exit on each side. I
For on unsprinklered building, this maximum area is
90,000 square feet, For a sprinklered building, on
1
'area of 160,000 square feet' could be served,
In this manner, eve'n buildings "unlimited" In area
by virtue of Type 1 construction can benefit from
sprinkler instal/ation, since such buildings must 160,000 sq ft
nevertheless satisfy the egress requirements of
Article 6.
Table 50B
CAPACITY PER UNIT EGRESS WIDTH
11-18
Example:
In a lecture hall {Use Group A-3-Assembly;, the capacity per unit egress width of
corridors and doorways is limited to J00 persons in an unsprinklered building or 150
persons in a sprinklered building.
Assuming a single exit corridor of a lecture hali needs to be designed for 300 persons,
the corridors and doorways in the unsprinkler-.:d building would have to be at least
66 inches wide (300/100 =
3 x 22 =
66). The corridors and doorways in the building
would only need to be 44 inches wide (300/) 50 = 2 x 22 = 44) if the lecture
hall were sprinklered.
For an exit that ;s J50 feet long, the decrease in required exit width gained through
the installation of automatic sprinklers represents a gain in "net usable" floor area
of J 50 ft. x (66-44) inches = 150 ft. x 1.883 ft. = 275 square feet.
BOCA's Building Valuation Data Report for April of 1980 shows that Group A·3
buildings average about 53.19 per cubic foot ill construction costs (refer to Appendix).
At a height of fifteen feet, that would translate to a cost of $48 per square foot.
Two hundred seventy-five square feet at $48 per square foot is worth about $13,200
to the building owner per exit corridor.
Used with permission from NFPA 13, hstella'!io~n o,f Automelic Sprinkler Syslems,'·
Copyright, 1976" I"lc~lonoi Fi~e 'Protection c.,s'iociaflon, Boston, Moss. .
II- 19
'.,-
Table 920
INTERIOR FINISH REDUIREMENTS
Required Corridors
vertical providing Rooms or
exitwavs and exitway enclosed
Use groups passage'ways Id) access spaces, (a)
A·j Assembly, theatres I I II (bl
A-2 Assembly, night clubs I I II (b)
A-3 Assembly, halls, terminals, I I II (b)
restaurants
A·4 Assembly, churches. schools I I III
B Business I II III
F Factory and industrial I II III
H High hazard I II III
1-] Institutional. restrained I I I (c)
1·2 InstitutIOnal, incapaCitated I II I Ic)
M Mercantile walls,' I II III
ceilings I II II (e)
R-] ReSidential, hotels I II III
R-2 ReSidential. multi·famlly I II III
dwellings
R-3 Residential, I and 2 family I III III III
dwellings
S-I Storage, moderate hazard I II III
S-2 Storage. low hazard I II I 111
1I- 20
Note a. h.equlrem,:nts for rooms 0: encl'Jsec spaces are based L:pon SDClC8S enclosed In partitions af the
~":liair'5or str'~cture. ana where fHereslstance r[Jtlng IS requlfed ~or the sH:..:ctuaJ elerT,ents the enclos~niS par·
tlt:ons sha!1 e)'t,=n,:, from the floor to the c,;lilns_ P2.rtltlons 'l/hiCh co j,ot com;J):; ',',11th thiS shall be consicerea
as ~rclosjng s;Jaces and the ,oem:=: or spaces on b8th ~:des thereof shall be CD~nte:i as one. In determining
the applicable requirements fer roo:ns or enclosed spaces, tile sceclflc us~ or occupancy tr.ereof shall be the
2:0vernlnb factor, regardless of the occupancy group. clasSlflcatlcn of the bUllclng or structur~. V/hen an ap-
provea automatic fire suporesslon system is provided. the intenor finish of Class II or III materials may be
used ,n,place of Class I or II materials respectively, where reouired In the tabie,
Note b. Cless III ,nleCior finish materrals may be used In place of assembly '/11th a capacity of three
hundred (300) per::ons or less.
Note c. Class III Interior finish materials may be ',jsed In administrative areas, Class II intericr finish mate-
rials may be used in indlvlcual rooms of not over, four (":) persons capacity. PfOlJiSIOnS in Note a allOWing a
change In interior f,n,sn classes when fire scpprAsslon protection is prOVided shall not apply.
Note d. Cless III interIOr finish materrals may be used for wainscoting or paneling for not more than one
thousano 11.000) square feet of applied surface area In the grade lobby when apolied directly to a non-cem-
bustlble base or over lurC!ng strrps applied to a noncombustible base and fire-stopped as required by Section
921 0,
Note e_ Class 111 Interror finish materials may be used in mercantile occupancies of three thousand (3,000)
square feet or less gross area. Us~u for sales purposes on the street floor only. (8alcony permitted).
Table 904
INTERIOR FINISH CLASSifiCATION'
Class Surface burning characteristics
of material test Itunneltestl
I o to 25
II 26 to 75
III 76 to 200
'.
The numerical values obtained from the Tunnel Test are dimensionless.
They represent a comparison to reference classifications of 100 for a
section of red-oak flooring and 0 for asbestos-cement board.
b. PLASTIC OPTIONS·
(J.) Foam Plastic Insulation Option
II- 21
, ,6'.
. ~.
Table ,1903
AREA LIMITATION AND SEPARATION REQUIREMENTS FOR PLASTIC WALL PANELS' :~'
.: J
Max. % area Minimum separation
of ext. wall of panels
Fire separation Class of in plastic . Max. SQ. tt. (ft.)
(ft.) plastic I .' panels single area Vertical Horizontal
6 ft. or less - NP.J NP - -
6 ft. or more Cl 10 50 8 4
but less than 11 ft. C2 NP NP - -
11 ft. or more Cl 25 90 6 4
but less than 30 ft. I
t
C2 15 70 8 4
Over 30 CI 50 Not limited 32 0
I C2 I 50 100 6' 3
Note 1. See Section 1903.3 fat combination of glazing and wall panel areas permitted.
Nole 2. See Section 1903.1.5.
Note 3. Not permitted.
1I- 22
IS.) Skylight Assemblies Option
Section 1905.1.6 - Use Groups: All except H and I
Construction Types: All
Except in Use Group H, skylight assemblies may be glazed with ap-
proved plastic materials. The aggregate area of skylights must not ex-
ceed 2570 of the corresponding floor area sheltered by thp. roof in
which they are installed.
4. High.Rise Options
High-rise provisions are found in Chapter 4 - Special Use and Occupancy
Requirements. Section 431.0 - High-Rise Buildings addresses itse,lf to build-
ings, more than 6 stories'or 75 feet in heignt of the following use groups:
B- Business
R-l - Residential, Hotel
R·2 - Residential, Multi~family .
. . :., '." '.. .. ..
'
1I- 23
. :.,',t' ....... '
Automatic
Compartmentation . Fire Suppression
Smoke Detectors Smoke detectors in all mechanical equip- No requirements for rooms protected with
ment rooms and return air ducts and automatic suppression system.
plenums.
Fire Alarm Approved automatic fire alarm system to No requirements voice alarm activaTed
activate voice alarm system. by sprinkler operation.
Central Control Containing panels controlling a[1d main- Same. requirements - contains sprinkler
Station taining detection, alarm, communication, valve and woter flow detector indicators ..
and elevator systems:
II- 24
Automatic
Compartmentation Fire Suppression
Smoke Control Venting faci lities I equ ired - panels or Mechanical air handling equipment may
windows in exterior wall that can be be designed to accomplish smoke removal.
opened from an approved lacation other
or
~hcn the fire floor.
Windows or panels may be manually
openable from within the fire floor or fixed
tempered glass windows may be used in
lieu of remotely operated panels.
Elevators At least one elevator for fire department At least one elevator· for fire department
access. Elevator must be in smoke proof access. No smokeproof enclosure require-
enclosure or open into lobby separated ments.
from remainder of building by one hour
resista nee.
Emergency Permanent standby power generation sys- Same requirements. Electric fire pumps In-
Power and tem conforming to requirements of Article cluded on emergency power.
Light 15.
Exitway Travel 200 feet maximum exitway access travel 300 feet maximum exitway access travel.
Length for Business, 100 ft. for Residential.
/
Type of construction Modified type of construction
set forth in Table 214 permitted hereunder .
1A 1B
18 2A
2A 28
":'i.:
Automatic .
. Compartmentation . Fire Suppression
'. Smokeproof AI least '. one exitway required to be 'a' SmoKeproof enclos·ures. ma'y be omitted if
Enclosures· smoke proof enclosure in accordance .with required stairways' are' pressurized to .15
Section 618 ..' inches of water column. .
Standpipes must be placed at 200 foot intervals along the covered moll.
II-26
b. AUTOMATIC ALARM OPTION
Section 1216.4 Use Groups: All
Construction Types: All
Buildings or portions of buildings equipped wirh automatic fire suppres-
sion protection are not required to be equipped with an automatic fire
alarm system.
However, the manual fire alarm stations are not required in buildings
equipped with an automatic· fire suppression system .and less than 7
stories in height.
.11- 27
.... ~:.
e"
D~ 'System Requiremerits
1. ApplicableStandareis
The 1978 editi~n of the Bas,ic Building Code adopts by reference the fo:low',
ing standards;·
NFPA13 - Automatic Sprinklers":" 1976 edition
2. Alarms
Section 1204.5
Approved audible or visual alarm devices must, bec6nnected to every water
sprinkler system and such ,alarm device must be located in an approved location.
Exception: Alarms not required for limited ar,ea sprinkler systems (refer to
Section 1205.0 of code).
One additi~nal oudible or visual alarm device must be installed yvithin the
building.
3. Water Supplies
Section 1214.0 -
All fire suppression systems must be provided with at least one 'automatic supply
of exti~guishing' material' of adequate pressure, capacity, and' reliability to
,
,,""1
~.~'. j
perform the function intended. --""-
Where sprinkler systems are' combined with standpipes, the water supply must
be adequate for the greater of demands of the sprinklers or standpipes.
Where a' sprinkler system is connected to the domestic water supply system as
allowed by the code, a check valve must be installed in the sprinkler supply
line to prevent contamination of the domestic water. '
4. Standpipes
Section 1211.0
Standpipes are required In the following buildings:
II- 28
5. Fire Department Connections
Section 1213.0 -
All sprinkler and standpipe systems must be provided with at least one Two-
way fire department connection.
Fire department connection must be not less than l' 6" nor more than 3'
6" in elevation measured from \=lround level to center line of ttre inlets.
II-29
/
~~~. STANDARD BU~LDaNG C ~!\'C
~~ -
"'~7"\~."
tsl7'" '7
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A. BASIC PRINCIPLES
1. Occupancy Classifications 2
2. Construction Clossifications 3
B. WHERE AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER SYSTEMS ARE REQUIRED
1. Complete Automatic Sprinkler Systems Required 4
2. Partial Automatic Sprinkler Protection Required 6
C. AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER TRADE-OFFS AND OPTIONS
1. Area, Height, and Fire-Resistance Options 7
a. Area Increase Options
(1.) Area Increases for Sprinklers
(2.). Unlimited Area Options
b. Height Increase Options
(1.) Height Increase for Sprinklers
c. Fire-Resistance' Options
(1.) Fire-Resistance Reductions from Area and Height Increase Options
(2.) Fire-Resistance Reduction Option In Type I Construction
(3.) Fire-Resistance Reduction Option Within Fire, District
,(4.) Fire-Resistance Reduction Option for Floors Above Usable Cellar
Space In Schools
(5.) Roof Framing Reduction' Option for, Type III ConstruCtion
..,'
(6.) Grain Elevator Fire-Resistance Reduction Option -
(7~) Exit, Enclosures Option, '
(8.) Vertical Openings a~d Shaft En~losure Options
(9.) Hoistway Vent 'Op.tion ~c -'-",
c- ::." ' ".,'.: _ ,_'
. ,': ~
'III-1
.f· ....'.
A. Basic. Principles
- '1. Occupancy CI~ssifications
.~ , . .
'The Code categorizes every new and existing' building, structure or, port there-
of according to use. The following. occupancy groups are established.
Group A - Assembly
A-1 Large Assembly
Theatres with working stage and capacity of 700 or,' more, or places
of .as·sembly without working stage having a capacity of 1,000 'or
more persons. ,
Group B - Business
Offices, banks, service stations, non-school libraries, bowling alleys,
restaurants accommodating less than 100, etc.
Group E - Educational
Schools
Group H - Hazardous
Involving highly combustible, f:~mmcible, or explosive. materials.
Group F - Factory-Industrial
. Assembling, disassembling, repairing, fabricating, .' finishing, manufac-
turing, packaging, or' processing operations 'not classified ,as"' ha7ardous.·
Group I - Institutional
Medical treatment or care of aged, "infirmed, disabled.·
Institutional - Restrained
Jails, reformatories, etc.
Institutional - Unrestrained
Hospitals, orphanages, homes for aged, etc.
Group M - Mercantile
Display and sale of merchandise.
Group S - Storage
Aircraft hangers, garages, warehouses, etc.
III- 2
2. Construction Classifications
Buildings are classified into construction types according to the amount of fire
resistance as per Table 600:
TABLE 600 - FIRE PROTECTIVE REQUIRE;\IENTS
REQUIRED FIRE RESISTANCE IN HOURS
Ty~e IV Ty~e V Type VI
STRUCTURAL ELEMENT
I I I
\ TYllI I TYlll II TYllI II! I
1· Hour 1- Hour
I II Protected Unprotocted I Protect.d Un~rotOtlod
i
l·Hour
Protect,d I Unprotoctod
tMCSC TYPE OF
CONSTRUCTION
Type I
443
I Type I
332
Type IV Type 11 TYDe II I Type lit Type III Tyne V Type V
I 3HH 211 100 311 300 111 100
PARTY Al'ID FIRE
WALLS' (a) 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
INTERIOR BEARING (i) , (i)
WALLS ! I
Supporting more than i I
I
one floor. column. or
other bearing wall.
Supporting one floor' only
I 4 3
2'
2 I 1 NC 1 0 1
1
0
3 1 1 NC 1 0 1 0
Supporting a roof, only 3 2 1 I 1 NC 1 I 0 1
I 0
INTERIOR NONBEAR- I
ING PARTITIONS
I See Sections 403" 701 I and i'QZ I II
COLUMNS (e)
Supporting mar<! than one
I See Sec. 604 I
floor or other columns 4 ,3 H(d) 1 I NC 1 0 1 0
Supporting one floor only 3 2 H(d) 1 NC 1 0 1 0
Supporting 8 roof only' 3 2 H(d) 'I NC 1 0 1 0
BEAMS, GIRDERS.
TRUSSES &: See See. 604
ARCHES (e)
SupportIng more thaD
one floor OJ" column. 4 3 H(d) 1 NO 1 0 1 0
Supporti ng one floor only 8 2 ,H(d) 1 NC 1 0 1 0
Supporting .. roof only
I 1 J,I, (f) 1 (f. g) H(d)' ,I NC 1 0 1
I
0
! , I,
ISee,sa
FLOOR c 604
CONSTRUCTION 3'
I 2 . 1' 1 . NC I ,1 0 I 1 0
ROOF
CONSTRUCTION, (h).
EXTERIOR BEARING
1% (f)
;.,-
·1 1 (f:~)
See See. 6041
. H(d),· 1 NC
"
I 1 0 I' I' 0
WALLS (hI (j) ',(% indica.tes pereent ' of wall opening p"rn,itted)
Horizontal separation-' ..
(diltance from' common -
property line or a88umed 'I
property line).
,Oft. to 3. ft. (c) 4 (0%) 3(0%) 3(0%)(b) 2(0%). 1(0%) . 3(0%) (hI 3(0%I(b) 110%) 1(0%) ,
. over 3 ft. to, 10 ft. (c)
over 10 ft. to 20 ft. (c)
over 20 ft; to 30' ft.
4
4
4
(10%)
(20'1'0)
(40%)
3(10%)
3(20%)
3(40%),
2(10%)(b)'
2(20%)(h')
. 1(40%)
I 1(40%)
1(10% )
20% I
, I(
l(lO%)
INC(20%)
NC(40%)
2(100/0I(bl 2 (100/0)(b) 1(20%)
2(20% lib) 2(20%) (b) 1(40%)
1(40%) 1(40%) I 1 (60%)
0(20%) ,
0(40%)
0(60%)
over 30 ft. 4 (NL) I, 3(NL) , I(NL) l(NL) NC(NL) I(NLl I(NL)
I I(NL) O(NL)
I
indic~te.
EXtERIOR NONBEAR.
ING WALLS (h)'(w) '(% I: percent of wall opening I permitted) I
Horizontal separation-·
(distance from common
I
property line or auumed,
property line).
I I,
'1~(0%) : I 3-(0%)
"
o ft. to 3ft. (c) 3·(0%) 3·(0% ) 3·(0%)' 2.(0%) 3.(0%) 1.(0%) 1"(0%)
over 3 ft. to 10 ft. (c) 2·(10% \' 2·(10%) "2·(10%) 11'110%) 1·(10%) 2·(10%) 2-(10%)' 1-(20%) 0.(200/,-1
over 10 ft... to 20, ft. (c) .' 2·(20%)' '2·(200/01 2·(20%) 1-(20%)· NC-(20%) 2·(20%) 2·(20%) 1.(40%) 0.(40%)
over 20 ft. to 30 ft. , 1.(40;§]) . 1·(40%\ '1-(400/. I., NC.(40%) NC.(400/0) I 1·(40%) 1'(40%) 0.{6011o) 0.(60%)
over' 30 ft. NC· (. L) NC· (NLI NC· (NL) INC. (NL). NC· (NL) NC· (NL) NC· (NL) O-(NL) 'O.(NL)
I I .1
,
.-:see Section 608.3, H-HeaVl" Timber Sizes
NC-Non Combuetible See Section 604
INL)-No Limita t For informational purpose. only
,TARLE 600 - REFERE..'I1CEj NOTES-
a. Pai-ty and Fire Walla '.hall enend not les~' than three (3) " f;"'t, f. 'In two (2) story,buildings approved Fire Retanln;'t Treated Wood
above the roof, except' that fire walls. need not extend above the' may be ust'd.
roof where the roof is of noncombuatible construction for the
In buildings of Group· A' - Assembly'and GroupE. Educational oc-
ares. within forty (40) feet of each side of the ";·all. -: .
cupancies, fireproofing may be omitted where structural members
b: Exterior walls shall extend not less than eighteen '(18) inches ,support a roof only and are twent}· (20). feet or more clear above
above the roof, except that parapet walls need. not be constructed any floor or balcony. •
on buildings where the roof alopea'more than four (4) inchea·ver·
g. In one, (» .tory building" ,tructural'members of heavy li!'!'.ber
tical to twelve (12), inch~. horizontal irom the'back of the e"terior
sizes may be' used as a.n alternate to unprotected structural roof
wall of sucb buildings or where the exterior waH', of, such build·: - ,members. - -, .
ing is located, fifteen' (IS) feet or more distant trom the common
. property line or the center line of 8 public way. ' Ii.. See Section 716' for Penthouses and Roor' Structures.,
c. See Section' 703 for protection of wall ope;'ings. i.. The use of, combustible 'construction 'for interior bearing partitions
'd.. Where ,horizontal separ~tion of t";'enty (20) feet o~ more is'pro. 'shall be limited to'the support of not more than Iwo (2) floor. and,
a roof.
vided, wood columns, arches, beams, and roof deck conIor1ning to
heavy, timber si~es may be used externally. ' . . j .. E"lerior walls shall be fire tested in accordance with Section 601.2
from Ihe' interior side, of. Ihe wall for Iherequired time period.
e. Coluinn., beams, trusses and girders supporting masonry or ·con·
crete walls eight· (8) feet.or more in, height shall have, the fire
res is_lance required for 'th~ wall they support, but in 110 ca.se Jess
than one (1) hour.
1II-3
B~ ,Where Automatic Sprinkler, Systems Are ~. equired
1. Complete Automatic Sprinkler Systems Req~ired
Section Construction'
Number Occupancies Types Affected" Complete Syst~m Required
412.4(f) ,Aircraft Hanger All " ,In buildings used, for painting or
Accessory Buildi ngs "daping" involving use of a volatile'
(Group,S) , ,flammable solvent.
412.4(g) Aircraft Hangers All When area exceeds '10,000 square feet. "
(Group 5)
" .
507.3(g) Covered Malls All Throughout the mall and all tenant
(Group M), spaces co'nnected thereto.,
703.2(a) All - Windowless and' All ' Whe~openings: are not prOVided on at
901.6(a)2 Underground Buildings least one side' every .50 ,linear ft. up •
~
0-
. -;. ~. (Blank Wall Construction) , to ,75 . ft. in height. Openings must ,be ,",J
:aminimum 'of 32 inches wide and 48
inches higl;, with bottom of opening no
more "than 32, inches above floor.
Note: Sprinklered buildings must have
access panels every 200 feet.
or
901.7 Group F Commercial Garages All When 'enclosed and over 65 ft. in height
and exceeding 10,000 sq. ft. per floor.
or
X 32" min
111-4
Section Construction
Number Occupancies Types Affected Complete System Required .
or
or
or
When used for storage of commercial
trucks and exceeding 5,000 sq. ft. in
area, .
or
When bus' garage is 3 or more:, stories
in height.
:' _ ..
901.8(0) Group M' - Me'r~~ntile When story floor' area exceeds 15,000
s9: ft..
901.8(b) Group I Institutional All In every hospital sanitarium, convalescenl
· home or hospital, nursing home and home
for the aged. In every. institutional occu-
pancy where restraint' is practiced (jails,.,
reformatories, prisons, mental institutions.)
Exception: In' hospitals only, sprinklers
'may be omitted from operating, delivery,
x-ray, cardiac, 'and intensive care rooms
and patient sleeping rooms not exceed-
ing600 square feet. when each room is..
provided with an approved listed smoke
·detector connected. to the. alarm system.
Note: The required' 'approved sprinkler
system in institutional occupancies w'here
restraint is. practiced may be automatic.
or manual. ' .
III...s ..'
·.e
2. Partial Automatic Sprinkler Protection Required
404.7 Group A 1 - Large Assembly All Over stage; in toilet' rooms, lounges,
with working stage smoking' rooms, and. all other parts in·
c1uding basements, cellars, property
rooms, dressing rooms, storerooms,
workshops,.' and all portions. 'of stage
and rooms under' the· stage floor level.
." I --
Exceptions: :
Auditoriums, foyers;' and lobbies,. over
generators ond other electrical equip-
ment and switch boa rds.
901.6(a)1 All - basements and cellars In basements and cellars with ceiling less
than 4' 6" above grade having floor
areas exceeding 2,500 'square feet when';
used 'as workshops or for the manu-
facture, repair, sale, ·or storage of com-
bustible materials, .. or' when used as
lounges or. nightclubs regardless of the
size.
901.8(c) Group A1 - Lorge Assembly Over areas which could be used for the
display, sale or storage of combustible
materials when such area exceeds 15,000
sq. ft.
III-6
c. Automatic Sprinkler Trade-Offs and Options
1. Area, Height, and Fire-Resistance Options
Area (building) . . . the maximum horizontally projected area of the building
at or above grade, exclusive of court and vent shafts.
Height (building) . . . the .vertical distance from grade to the highest finished
roof surface for flat roofs, or to a point at the average height of roofs having
a pitch of more than 1 foot in 4~/i feet.
TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION
(A·l)
ASSEMBLY·LARGE
d
-
I·
(Wor~ing
Stag.) -
a,b,c UH UA UA
80' UA UA UA UA
MUI".S~Of'; 1 UA UA UA UA NP NP NP NP 1';> NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP
(A-II
ASSEMBLY-LARGE
d 0 0 0 •
(Wilhoul .worl<ing
Sl.ge)
a,b,c UH UA UA,
O' UA UA UA UA
Multi·Story 1 UA UA . Uk UA NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP
On. Story Only· Uk. UA: UA UA 120 36.0 12.0 36.0 8.0 24.0" 12.0 36.0 . 8.0 24,0 NP NP NP NP
(A·2)
ASSEMBLY·SMALL
d e
• 0 ~
(Wor.,ng. Stage)
'.
.. a,b UH . UA UA
0' 'JA UA' UA ,.UA·
Mu/r,'-Staty 1 UA UA ' UA VA NP, NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP
Ono S,ory Only UA UA UA UA 100 300 ., 90 27.0' 60' 78.0 9.0 270 6.0. 18.0 .5 13,5 3.0 9.0
(A·21
AS"SEMBL Y-SMA lL
d
, • • • 0
(Wlthour' wor~lng
SI.gel
. a.b ~H UA UA
O' UA UA UA UA
2 IJA UA !JA I UA 12 Q 2'.0 12.0 2.0 eo, 150
I
120 ,2.,0. 8.0 160
Mull/-Story 1 VA UA UA IJA 12.0· 2•. 0 8.0 . 12.0 160 NP NP NP NP
2'.0 12.0 18.0
'1 2•. 0 8.0
One Siory Onfy UA UA IJA UA I 12 a 36.0 12.0 360 B.O 2•. 0 12.0 36.0 B.O ., 2' 0 7.5 225 5.0 150
..
(B) f I,d f I h h h h h h
BUSINESS H UA UA
a,c.9 2 UA UA
0 IJA UA • UA IJA ..
5 IJA ,UA UA UA 25.5 ,51.0 25.5 51.0 " 3.'0 21.0 .2.0 28.0
• UA UA UA UA 25.5 51.0 25,5· 51.0 3'.0 27,0 . '2.0 2B.0
3
2
UA
UA
UA
UA' ,
UA
IJA
UA
UA
25.5
25.5,
51.0,
5/.0
25.5 .
2~.~
5/.0
51.0 :Il·O
J4.0
3•.0
I 21.0
21.0
.2.0
.2.0 14.0
28.0
28.0 13.5 . 27.0 9.0 B.O
Mult,-Story 1 . UA IJA . UA UA 25.5 51.0 25.5 5/.0 '17.0 H.O. '21.0 '2.0 28.0 '13.5 27.0 9,0 8.0
.. ' •.0
On. S,ory Only UA UA UA IJA 25.5 76.5 25.~ 76.5 .17.0 5 1.0 21:0 63.0 1•. 0' '2.0 1J.5 .O.~ 9.0 ~7.0
1II-7
, ~ \'
e~··.
'.
.. "
(E) d I I I I
EDlJCATlOHAL
;
' •• b· ilJH UA. UA
SO' UA lJA lJA III','
2 lJA III', UA III', 18.0 38.0 18.0 :Ill.O 18.0 38.0 12.0 24.0
ltIulfi.srOfY 7 III', IJA IJA UA IB.O 311.0 18.0 311.0 NP NP 18.0 3e.0 NP NP 12.0 2 •. 0 NP NP
0". Slory Only III', III', III', IIA 18.0 5•. 0 18.0 54.0 12.0 38.0 18.0 54.0 12.0 38.0 12.0 311.0 8,0 2'.0
(H)
HAZARDOUS
b.1
•
3
NP
NP
11.5
11.5 NP 8.'
2 NP fI.S NP 8.3 NP 7~
lIIulli-Slory 1 NP II~ NP 8.3 NP 7.5 NP NP NP NP NP 'NP 'NP NP NP NP NP NP
0". SlOry O"/r NP lU NP '8.3 NP 7.5 HP 5.0 NP 5.0 ··NP 5.0 NP 5.0 NP NP NP NP
IF) d
FACTORY· .
INDUSTRIAL UH III', IJA "
. (/)
INSTITUTIONAL UH NP VA
RESTRAINED BO' NP UA NP VA
MulU-Story I NP UA NP VA NP NP NP NP .. NO N~ NP NP NP NP NP NP NP NP
(I)
INSTITUT/ONAl
UNRESTRAINED
b.< UH
BO'
I NP
NP
UA
UA lJA
2 NP VA VA 2•. 0 21.0 27.0
MtJ'fj·Sro,¥ / NP VA NP VA NP NP 21.0 NP NP NP 21.0 NP NP NP NP NP 1'0
2'.0
One Story Only NP VA NP UA NP 35.0 NP 315 NP 30.0 NP 3/.5 NP NP NP 225 NP NP
Multi·SIOf."
2
, 150
15,0
VA
VA
150
150
VA
UA
13.5
13,5
27.0
27.0
13.5
73.5
27.0
~7.0
9.0
9.0
18.0
18.0
13.5
13.5
27.0
27.0
9.0
9.0
16.0
16.0
9.0
9.0
16.0
16.0
5.0
5.0
120
12.0
One SIO,)' Onfy 150 UA 150 UA 13,5 40.5 135 40,5 90 2T,0 1J5 .0,5 9.0 270 90 27.0 SO 160
111-8
. TABLE 400 - ALLOWABLE HEIGHTS AND AREAS - Continued
TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION
I TYPE I TYPE II TYPE I" TYPE IV TYPE V i TYPE v/
H
E . AlCSC Type I
'-Hour Unprotected 7-'010;;1 Unprotected 1·!-/our Unororec/"d
OCCUPANCY
I G
H
I AlCSC Type I
4'3
AlCSC Typ! I
332 3HH Alcse Type II
211
IAcse TyP!
700 . "I MCSC Type II
]11
AlCSC T~pe "
300
Alcse Type V
711
Alesc Type V
700
T
p P p p p I pi p p p
Un.p/( 51'/( Un.pl< 51'1< Unsp/( 51" Uf'lS~"c 51'/( Un. 1'1< 51'1< Unsp,1( Spl< U"5,,/Je Spl< Unspl< Spl< Un.pl< Spl<
One Slo,y Only VA UA VA VA 78.0 5.0 18.0 S'.O . 72.0 36.0 18.0 5'.0 12.0 36.0 10.5 37.5 7.0 21.0
(5)
STORAGE
a,b,g,l<,o,m VH UA UA
.6
5
3
2
'
UA
UA
UA
UA
UA
UA
UA
UA
UA
UA
30.0
30.0
30.0
30,0
. 30,0
60.0
50.0
60.0
50.0
60,0 24.0
'8.0
'8.0
'8,0·
'8,0
'8.0 2•. 0
48.0
.8,0
'8.0 16'.0
32.0
32.0
32.0 2'.0
'8.0
'8.0
'8.0 16.0
32.0
32.0
32.0
Mult/-Slory 1 UA UA 30.0 60,0 2' 0 '8.0 2•. 0 48.0 76.0 32.0 2'.0 .8.0 160 32.0 Np NP NP NP
One Slo,y Only UA UA 30,0 90.0 2.0 72.0 24.0 72.0 16.0 .8.0 2',0 72.0 160 '8.0 9.0 27.0 6.0 18,0
TABLE,400 NOTES
e. Fo, height modUlc.llon. artd limir.rlon•. by Occupancy,,'••:
1. Slory /nc,...e lor 'Prink/e,. .•02.2 (I)
Z.. Mell.n/ne. . '02.2 (c)
3. BaSSmerH! .02.2 (d)
•. As•• mbly-B..,menl. .02.2 (e)
5. Bu.ine.. .02.2 (g) ..
8, Educ.tlona/-S..emenl. '02,2 (e)
7. Merc.nWe '02.2 (g)
B. R.ir/denrl., .02.2 (b) & (I)
.• These r.'.renca. ar. to. I". Mod.1 Codes StandardilaUon Council. ·r.commendad typo'. Of consrructlon and ar. Ipr in/ormatjonal "urpoee. only.
III- 9.
.:.
"e
>
Example:
This is an increase
floor" area allowed for sprinkler
Occupancy grau'p' 5; type V • Unpr-;'i'~'cted
'installation. " Sprinklered area limit = 48,000 sq. ft.
111-10
Example:
If the warehouse in the previous example is surrounded on 0/1 sides by 60 feet of
open space and is provided with automatic sprinklers, the area restrictions of Table
400 do not apply, and the building may be built to an unlimited area.
---------- --==--.J:::>---""il
Example:
A small theater without a working' stage (GroupA-2) of Type III construction (heavy'
timber) is limited by Table 400 to two stories of 12,000 square feet each if un-
sprinklered, or two stories of 24,000 square feet each if sprinklered. By not specifying
areas for a third story, Table 400 does not, allow such theaters to. be constructed to
more than two stories.
However~ under the, provisions of footnote p, a third story can be added to. the
unsprinklered building whim sprinklers are providec/o This would add a third story
of 12,000 square feet. ......', ' , ,
.. Therefor:e, the designer has' the option.· of choosing' the "horizontal" movement .to
, build a two-story theater of 4.8,000 square feet maximum total area, or the "vertical" ,
movement which will allow; a three-story theater of 36,000 square feet maximum
total area. . . .
: , r. .'
III- 11
'··a ' ~'
. c. FIRE-RESISTANCE OPTIONS
.n.} Fire: Resistance'Reductions from Area and' Height Increase Options
Table 400"::" Occupanci~s: All ,
Construction Type~: All
The area and height increas~,optibns allowed in the Code have the net
effect of, reducing the 'fire-resistance requirements for a given occupancy
design. In other words, lesser construction types can be utilized when
the building issprinklered. .
Example:'
Table, 400 permits a one-story Group B office occupancy of Type VI-One Hour
construction to be, built to an area of over 40,000 square feet, by includi~g automatic
sprinklers. If sprinklers are not installed, the office building would hove to be built
using Type I or II construdi,on, to be allowed, an area of 40,000 ,square feet. By
aI/owing Type, VI-One Hour construction in' lieu of', Type .. 11 'construction, the Code
is accepting sprinkler protection' as a, substitute for part of the fire resistance ,re-
qu~eme~L '
The Southern Building Code Congress periodically publishes Building Valuation Data
representing average building costs (See Appendix), The data for July of 1979 in-
cludes the following costs for Group B Offices:
II.I- 12
(2.) Fire-Resistance Reduction Option in Type I Construction
Table 400 - footnote d Occupancies: A, B, E, F, R
Construction Types: I
In Group A, B, E, F, and R occupancies of Type I construction, the par-
titions, columns, trusses, girders, beams, and floors may be reduced by one
hour if the building is equipped with an automatic sprinkler system
throughout. No component may be of less than one hour fire-resistcince.
Example:
If. sprinklers are installed in a two-story'
school (Group E) building of Type I con·
struction, the fire-resistance rating of par-
titions, columns, trusses, girders, beams,
and floors may be reduced by one hour,
but to no lower than one hour fire- re-
sistance. Consider the construction of a'
first-floor interior classroom:'
Beams Supporting ./
Interior Non- .
,Bearing Partitions :: 1 hr.. lhr:
• III- 13 '
',,-
"'.,' ,: ,".
111-14
.e
. TABLE 1103 MAXIl\WM DISTANCE OF THAI.VEL TO
AN EXIT, IN FEET
Occupancy Unsprinklered . Sprinklered
Group A-Assembly 150 . 200
Group B-Business 150 200
Group E-Educational 150 200
Group H-Hazardous NP 75
Group F-Factory-Industrial 150 200
Group I -Institutional NP 200
Group M-Mercantile 150 200
Group R-Residential 150 200
Group S-Storage 150 200
Open Parking Structures 200 200
Example:
A three-story open-plan office building is designed in a "W" shape to allow maximum
olJtdoor views through a' glasS" curtain wall ,on one side. The Code requires at least
two exits for all areas, "located as remote from each other as practicable and . . .
arranged to provide direct access in separate directions from any point in the area
served".
If the oHice building ;s unsprinklered.. the maximum allowable distance of travel to
an exit stair.way is 150 feet. At least five- exit stairways would be required .
. :-'
. ' .
If the. building were sprinklered, three exit stairways would suffice, since they could
be reached from 0/1 areas within the 200 feet' of exit travel distance' allowed.
The elimination of tho~e two 'exit stairways could easily create an economy, of 400
square' feet per floor, or 1,200 square feet overall for the three stories. . .
At $38 per square foot, that' is a savings of over $45,000. Alternatively~ the elimina-.
tion' of stairwells can' be . viewecJ as an in crease in the rentable floor space .
. III-15
Section 1103.1 (d)-'-
In one-story' storage and factory-industrial (Gr~~ps ·s and F) occupancies ..
equipped with. complete . automatic . sprinkler. protection;. the Building
Official.may·,. by special ruling~ permit exit travel distances up to 400 feel. .
b. ESCALATOR PROTECTioN
Sections. 70 1.4 and 1122 Occupancies: All
Construction Types: All
. Escalators in . unspr.inklered buildings. are required to be enclosed' by
reference to ANSI A17.1 -1971. "American Safety Code for Elevators,
Dumbwaiters,Escalators, and Moving Walks."" .
The 1971 edition of ANSIA17.1 adopts ·the NFPA'101 Section 6 -123 ....
. Spray. Nozzle Method as' a'n, .alternate to enclosure of escalators in
sprinklered buildings. This· method consists of an arrangement of automatic
heat 'or smoke detectors and .a system of high velocity" open spray nozzles;
The water supply may betaken from the sprinkler, system. Draft curtains'
are required. .
An important exception in ANSI A17.1. - 1971 states that "The floor
opening protection specified is not required for escalotors that ore' not
accredited os a required means of egress, ond which connect ·floors
permitted by local laws and ordinances' to be connected by unenclosed
stairways." Therefore, the spray nozzles. would. not be required in
sprinklered buildings for which the escalators do not serve as a required
means ·of egress.
..-.......
~.
,
;, • .-Y-
.'
111-16
3. Use of Materials Options
a. INTERIOR FINISH OPTIONS
(1.) Flamespread 0Pfion
Carpet materia Is used on floors of exit access' corridors and enclosed exits
must withstand the following minimum critical levels of radiant flux:
Occupancy Unsprinklered . Sprinkle red
Group I .-,- 0.45 watt/ cm 2 0.22watt/ cm 2
. Institutional
All Others .0.22watt/ cm 2 . N.A. .
111- 17
.'.t,.
" : ... '
',,'
'~
a'. /
Section 717.2(c)
Foa~ clastic insulation with flame scread of 25 or less may'be used ,in
thickne'sses up to 4 inches in or on ~alls when' 'the foam plasti~ is covered
by a metal facing of not, less than 0.032' inch aluminum or 0.019 inch,
galvanized steel sheet and the, insu,lated ar,ea is protected with automatic
sprinklers.,. .
(2.) Glazing of Unproteded Openings Option
Section 2602 - Use, Groups: All except Rand E
Construction Types: All
In other than Residential and Educational buildings, openings not required
to be fire, protected may be glozed' or equipped with approved plastic
materials in up to 25% of. the wall face of the story in which they are
installed. '
, When a complete approved automatic sprinkler system is provided, the
"permissible area of glazing may be increased to, a maximum of 50%
of :the wall face of the' ,story. '
(3.) Exterior Wall -Panels Option
"Section ,2603 :-UseGro~ps: All except I, A.l; and H
Construction Types: All '
Except in Use Groups I, A·1 and H, approved plastic materials may be
used as wall panels in exterior wails not required to have a fire·resistive,
rating. Table 2603.1 states area limitation and separation requirements.
TABLE 2603.1- AREA, LIMITATIONS AND SEPARATION
REQUIREMENTS FOR PLASTIC WALL PANELS·
Minimum Separation
Ma:=<. % area of Panel.
of Ext. Walla (ft.)
"Fire Separation Claa. of in Plastic Max. SQ. ft.
(ft.) Plastic Panel. Single Area Vertical Horizontal
11 ft. or more CC 1 25 90 6 4
But less than CC 2 15 70 8 4
30 ft.
·See Section 2602.2 (0) for combination ot' glazing and wall panel aTe.... permitted.
··See Section 2602.1 (a) 2.
'IlI-18
(4.) Roof Panels Option
Section 2604 - Use Groups: All except I, A-1, and H
Construction Types: All
Except in Use Groups I, A-I, and H, approved plastic roof panels may be
installed where, the roof is not required to have a fire-resistance rating,
where the roof panels meet the requ'irements for roof coverings of
the particular occupancy group, or where the building is protected by a
complete approved automatic sprinkler system.
III-19
'.- "
Manual ,Manual (pull~box)',fire' alarm' system're- No, 'reguirements ~voice alarm system
'Fire. Alarm 'quired 'to' activate voice alarm system. aClivated by sprinklers. '~".
,,,,~~
Voice Alarm Pre-recorded message, activated by man- Similar .reguirements - Sprinkler' opera-
System' ual 'alarm. tian~will activate.
Central Control Containing panels for voice communica- Same requirements contains sprinkler
Station tion, fire detection, and alarm systems; supervisory equipment and valve control
elevator and oil' handling controls, mechanism.
Smoke Control Venting facilities required - panels or Mechanical oil' handling equipment may
windows in exterior wall that can be be designed to assist or accomplish smoke
opened from an approved location other removal.
than the fire floor.
or
Exit Travel 150 feet maximum exit access travel. 200 feet maxim um exit access travel.
Length
IIl- 20
Compartmentation Automatic Sprinklers
Hose Cabinets 1 l /:: hose lines required on each floor for No requirements.
use by occupants.
Standpipes Standpipes required at each floor for fire Standpipes may be combined with sprink-
department use. ler risers.
Smokeproof At least one of the required exits must No requirements ~ required exit stairways
Enclosures be a smokeproof enclosure with vestibule, to , ,be pressurized to 0.15 inch water
meeting, the natural or mechanic'al ventic column.
lotion requirements of Section 1104.6.
III- 21
5.. Other Options
. .
a. FIRE ALARMS - ", -
. ..
Section 1126 ~ oc:~upa~Cies: R, B, E, I, A, F, H
.'-
Constructio~ Types: All . .
Group' E: Schools.
IIl-22
D. System Requirements
1. Applicable Standards
Section 901.2 -
The Code requires that sprinkler systems conform with the 1976 edition
of NFPA 13 - Installation of Sprinkler Systems.
Section 902.1 -
Unless otherwise provided within the Code, standpipes, standpipe systems,
hose, water su'pply, pumps, connections, etc. must be constructed and in-
stalled to meet the requirements of the 1976 edition of NFPA 14 - Stand-
pipe and Hose Systems.
2. Supervision
Section 901.9 -
Where an automatic sprinkler system is provided whether as a require-
ment or as an alternate to another requirement of the Code, the system
must be supervised. Closing of control valves or interruption of power
must sound a local trouble· alarm. System actuation must' initiate an alarm
either directly to the Fire Dept. or through a central station facility or
other approved equ91.
3. Water Supplies
Sections 901.2 - . : . . . . . . ..
A single water supply of adequate pressure, c~pacity, and reliability, equal
:to the primary supply required by NFPA 13, may be permitted. by the
______________~_l!.j1~i_ng. Official, . .. .
- ..
~
4. Sta~dpipes
Section 902 -
Standpipes - are to - be installed in accordance with NFPA 14' with .the
following exceptions:-
b.· Wet (NFPAClass II) standpipes shall be located so that all portions
of the building' ~re within. 20 feet of a nozzle attached to 75 feet of
hose, and each outlet shal.1 be supplied. with a hose not less than
'P/2 inches: in· diameter. and equipped· with an approved variable
fog' n o z z l e . , ' .
111-23,
.. _
..
IIl- 24
Appendix
The following Building Valuation Data ment architectural, engineering, and! costs listed here, It should be noted that
represents the average costs for most contractor profits. Special site conditions, these values are based on national
buidings and IS presented as a service and architectural or structural extras averages and may change from day to
to our members. These unit costs include may require adjustments to the average day.
plumbing, electrical, mechanical equip-
~-I
struction Type
I
Type
II
Type
III
Ty~elV
l·Hour Unprotected l·Hour
Ty e V
Unprotected
Tye e VI
'·Hour Unprotected
Occupancy
Apartment (R) 35.20 33.10 31.00 30.90 29.10 29.70 27.10 25.80 24.00
Automobile
Parking Structure (S)
24.20 22.00 20.00 1980
.
18.00 19.20 17.50 19.10 17.40
Church (A) 40,20 38.00 32.20 32.70 30.20 32.20 29.70 28.20 26.40
Covalescent (I) . 47.90 45.70, 39.00 38.90 37.10 36.80 NP 3300 I~P
Dwelling (R) 39.30 37,10. 35.00 34,90 33.10 32.90 31.10 3040. '28.60
Educational (E) '39.40 37.20 33.60. 33.50 31.70 33.60 31.60 31.40 29.50 I
..
--
Factory-Industrial (F) - 24.20 22.00 17.70 18,10 16.30. 17.70 15.80 . 15.80 14.00
Hazardous (H) 20.60 18.80 ·16.50 16.60 14.20 16,50 1410 NP I~P
--
Hospital (I) 68,30 66,10 64.00 63.90 62.10 59.20 NP 49.70 NP
--
Hotel (R)' 38,30 36.10 31.50 31.00 29.20 '30.50 28:70 30AO 28.60
Office (B) 41.40 ,39.20 3320 30040 28.60 2990 28.10 29.80 28.00
-
Private Garage
18,90 , 16:70 15.00 14.50 . 12.70 14.00 12.20 13.90 12.10
And/Or Shed (5)
- - 1------
Public Garage (5) 24.40 22,20 . ,17.00' 16.80 .15 00 '1690 . 14.50 16.80 14.50
--
Restaurant (Aor B) 41.90 39.70 36.40 35:30 33.50 3530 .3350 35.30 32,80 I
--
Retail Store (M) 32.70 30,50 25.70 23.90 22.10 23.40 . 21,60 2330 21,50
--
Service Station (B) ~38.50 36.30 33.00 . 32.50 30.80 31.90 30.10 2760 . 25.80
-- 1 - - - - - -
Theater '(A) 45.20 43,00 35.30 33.70 31.90 .3320 31.40 •3310 3.1 30
Warehouse (5) 19,60, 1780 15.50 15,60 13.20 15.50 13.10 14.80 13.00
I
. Notes:
1.. Np·Not permited by code
" ..,
',' :',
,-.
.. ::;.-
--e-
o'
.' ,~." ,
Appendix -
, The Building Valuation Date should be used i~ conjunction with "theJollov.'-tng· modifiers. Choose the type'of con·
struction for -the building and mu Itiply the Q\;erage cost per square foot by the modifier listed for the state Example: To .
'0
adjust cost ofa woodframe dwelling for the Florida area, select Regional Modifier 1.02 and average unit cost per
square foot from Building Valuation Data $28.60, Multiplying! you obtain 1.02 x 28:60' $29.17. '
CENTRAL U.S. ' Modifiers' EASTERN U:S. Modifiers WESTERN U.S. ~odifiers
III-26
~v. UNUFORBV\ BU~lro~NG coro~ -1979
TABLE OF' CONTENTS
A. BASIC PRINCIPLES
1. Occupancy Classifications 2
2. Construction Classifications 4
D. SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS
1. Applicable Standards 24
2. Alarms 24
3. Water Supplies 24
4. Standpipes 24
APPENDIX:
Building Valuation Data ,25
Tables appearing on pages 2, ,3,4,.7, 8, 17, lB,and 24, a;Ei copyright, 1979, by the
Int,e'rnational Conference of Building Officials,and.are reproduced· herein with '
their permission .. The tableapp~dring O~ page 25 is
copyright, 1980, by the inter-
national Conference of Building Officials .
.. IV- ,
, .... , '
A.· Basic PrinCiples
. 1. Occupancy Classifications
Occupancy groups are· c1a~sifjed .in Table 5-A:
TABLE NO. 5-A-WALL AND OPENING PROTECTION OF OCCUPANCIES BASED ON LOCATION ON PROPERTY
TYPES II ONE-HOUR, II-N AND V CONSTRUCTION: For exlariorwall and opening proteclion of Types II One-hour, II·N and·
V buildings, see table below. Exceptions to limitation for Types II One·hour, II·N and Type V Construction, as provided in
'. Sections 709,1903 and 2203 apply. For Types I, II·F R., III and IV Construction , see Sections 1803 , 1903, 2003 and 2103
EX~~~~~~~~~' "
FIRE RESISTANCE OF
GROUP DESCRIPTION OF OCCUPANCY EXTERIOR WALLS
I-Any assembly building with a stage and an occupant load of 1000 or
more in the building Not applicable [See Section 602 (all
4-Sladiums, reviewing stands and amusement park structures not in- , 1 hour less than 10 feet Protected less than
c1uded within other Group A Occupancies 10 feet
4-lce plants, power plants, pumping plants, cold stOrage and cream-
eries, factories and workshops using noncombustible and nonexplosive 1 hour less than 5 feet Not permilled less
materials. Storage and sales rooms of noncombustible and nonex- than 5 feet
plosive materials
I-Any building used for educational purposes through the 12th grade by
E 50 or more persons for more than 12 hours per week or four hours in
anyone day
See also No! permitted less
Section 2-Any building used for educational purposes through the 12th grade by 2 hours less than 5 than 5 feet
802 less than 50 persons for more than 12 hours per week or four hours In feet, 1 hour less than Protected less than
anyone day 10 feel' 10 feel'
3-Any building used for day-care purposes for more than six children
I-Storage and handling of hazardous and highly flammable or ex- See Chapter 9 and the Fire Code
plosive materials other than flammable liquids
5-Aircraft repair hangars 1 hour less than 60 feet Protected less than
60 feet
I-Nurseries for full-time care of children under the age of six (each ac-
commodating more than five persons), 2 hours less than 5 Not permitted less
Hospitals, sanitariums. nursing homes with nonambulatory patients feet, 1 hour elsewhere than 5 feet
and similar buildings (each accommodating more than five persons) PrOlected less than
10 feet
[ , 2-Nursing homes for ambulatory patients, homes for children SIX
years of age or over (each accommodating more than five persons) I hour
See also
Section 3-Mental hospitals, mental sanitariums. jails, prisons, reformatories Permitted in Types I and [I-F,R, buildings only
1002 and buildings where personal liberties of inmates are similarly [See Section 902 (b)]
restrained
l-Private garages, carports, sheds and agricultural buildings I hour less than 3 feet Not permitted less
(or may be than 3 feet
protected on the ex·
terior with materials
approved forI-hour
fire-resistive
construction)
M"
2-Fences over 6 feet high. tanks and towers Not regulated for fire resistance
R
See also I-Hotels and apartment houses 1 hour'less than 5 feet Not permitted less
Section Convents and monasteries (each accommodating more than 10 persons) than 5 feet
1202
3-Dwellings and lodging houses I hour less than 3 feet Not permitted less
than 3 feet
NOTES: (I) See Section ~04 for types of walls affected and requirements covering percentage of openings permllled'in eXlerior walls,
(2) For addillonal restriclions, see chaplers under Occupancy and Types of Construction,
(3) For waUs facing streelS, yards and public ways, seo: Part IV. '
(4) Openings shall be protecled by a fire assembly having a 'lhree-fourths-hou'fire-protection rating.
1'1- 3
.e •••••
2 .. ConstructionC lassifications
. Construction types 'ore defined according to the fire·resistance requirem~nts
in Table 17.-A:.
TYPEI TYPE II f
TYPE III TYPE I\' TYPE \'
NONCOMBUSTIBLE I COMBUSTIBLE
FI..... , ,. Fir.· I,
BUILDING ELEMENT R••I.U•• R••I.II•• '·Hr. N i·Hr. N H.T. '·Hr. : N
. 4
4 ! 4 4 4
'Exter;'or Bearin" Wall, Sec.
1903 (a) 1 N 2003 (a) 2003 (a) 2103 (a) 1 1\
1803 (a)
Interior Bearing Walls 3 2 I N 1 N 1 1 N
Exterior !':onhearing 4 4 4 4
Sec, 4 I N 1 N
Wall.' 1903 (a) 2003 (a) 2003 (a) 210.3 (a)
1803 ( a )
lor ' '1
N N
Structural Frame! .3 2 1
" II I
I H.T.
I or
PartitlOn:-.. - Permanent 12 P ]2 i'\ 1 1\ ] N
I, I B.T.
1 I
Shaft Enclosures 2 2 I 1 1 1 1. ] 1706 1706
Floors 2 2 1 N I 1 N H.T. 1 N
2 I 1
Roofs
Sec. 11106 1906 1906
N 1 N H.T. 1 N
IV - 4
B. Where Automatic Sprinkler Syste:ms Are Required
1. Complete Automatic Sprinkler Systems Required
3802(b)2.B Group A - Assembly All When occupancy· area usable for ex-'
hibition or display exceeds 12,000 sq. ft.
'3802(b)4 Group I ,~ Institutional All Excepf: In hospitals of Types I, II·FR, and
11-1 hr. construction the automatic sprinkler
system may be omitted from operating'
rooms, X-ray rooms, ·delivery rooms, cardiac
and intensive care. rooms, and patient
sleeping rooms not exceeding 450 sq. ft.
in area when each such room is provided
with smoke detectors connected to a con-
tinuously attended station. Increases for
area and height do not apply when this
exception is used. In jails, prisons and
. reformatories, the sprinkler system may be
manual.
.3802(b)5 Groups H 1 and H2 -,- All. When area exceeds ',500 sq. ft.
High Hazard
Storage and handling
of hazardous materials
GroupH3 - High Hazard . All When area exceeds 3,000 sq. ft.
Woodworking shops, storage'
of combustible materials
Group H4 - High .Hazard All When over one story in height.
'Repair garages,
3802(b)6 Group B2 - Business All When single story 'sales roam exceeds'
Retail Sales Room 12~OOO sq. ft.
or.
Wheil multiple-story total sales' area ex-
ceeds 24,000 sq. ft;
UFC High Piled Storage All When. used for the storage of high-piled
combustibies (in accordance .with Uniform
'Fire Code when, orea exceeds two-thirds
'of:floor area.): ' .
IV- 5'
2. Partial Automatic Sprinkler Protection R~quired
3802(b)2.C Groups A2, A2.1, A3, In any enclosed usable space below or over a
and A4-Assembly stairway. See Section 3308(f).
Group E - Educational
Group I - Institutional
3802(b)2.D Group Al -..-:. Assembly Under the roof and gridiron, in the tie and fly
Theatres with stage galleries and in all places behind the proscenium
wall of stages, over enclosed platforms in excess
of 500 square feet in area, and in dressing rooms,
workshops, and accessory· storerooms.
Exceptions:
Stages or enclosed platforms open to audi-
torium on 3 or more sides.
1'/-6
c. Automatic Sprinkler Trade-GUs and Options
1. Area, Height, and Fire Resistance Options
Floor Area - ~he area included within the surrounding exterior walls of a
building or portion thereof, exclusive of vent shafts and courts.
TABLE NO. S·C-BASIC ALLOWABLE FLOOR AREA FOR BUILDINGS ONE STORY IN HEIGHT
(In Square Feel)
TYPES OF CONSTRUCTION
II II IV II
OCCUPANCY
I
F.R. F.R.
II
ONE·HOUR , N II ONE·HOUR
III
I N. Ii H.T. II ONE·HOUR "I N
'For open parking garages. ,ee Section 709. !II-No requirement for fire re5l.5tance
'See Sect ion 903 .. F.R.-Fire Resisrive
'See Section 1002 (b). H.T.-Heavy Timber.
'For agricultural buildings, see also AppendlX Chapter II'.
'For limitations and excepuons, see Section 1202 (b).
The total area of all floors ~f multi-story buildings cannot exceed twice the
area allowed for .one-story buildings. (Section SOS(b) )
. .
I
:x~~~~e:R_1 hote/occupancy of Typell/-') Hour construction is assigned a basic
aUowable . floo~ area of 13,500 . sq. fi.-. in Table S~c. This is for a building one story
in height.
, .
A two-story building would be allowed twice that area, Or 27,000 sq: ft.
A . three'-story building could' not exceed, 27,000 sq. ft. in total, area for' all floors.
If the three' stories are to be of. equal areas', th~ basic allowable floor area per
floor .is./imited to:.." '
27,000 sq. ft./3 = 9,000 sq. ft.'
Similar/y".a four-story hate! .'of such construction ';"'ould be limited to· an area per
'floor of. ".. : ... '
27,000sqft/4 =6,7S0sq: ft.
IV- 7
TABLE NO. S·D-MAXIMUM HEIGHT OF BUILDINGS
TYPES OF CONSTRUCTION
, 11 II n III' IV V
OCCUPANCY F.R II F.R. I ONE·HOUR I N 1I0NE·HOUR I N II H.T II ONE-HOUR ! N
MAXIMUM HEIGHT IN FEET
'.
Unlimited II 160 65 . 55 65 55 65 50 40
MAXIMUM HEIGHT IN STORIES -
A-I ·Unlimited 4 NOI Permitted
A) 2-2.1 unlimited 4 2 NOl 2 No! 2 ·2 0'01
Permitted Permitled Permitted
,
A) 3-4 Unlimited 12 I I .1 2 2 r
B) 1-2-3' Unlimiled 12
"
4 2 4. 2 4 3 2
8-4 Unlimlted 12 4 2 4 2 . 3 2
E' Unlimited 4 2' I 2' I 2' 2' I
H-I Unlimited 2 I I I I I I 1
H) 2·3-4-5 Unlimited 5 2 I 2 I 2 2 I
1-1 Unlimited 3 I Not I NOI I I Not
Permitted Permltled Permitted
1-2 Unlimited 3 2 t"Ot 2 Not 2 2 Not
Permitted Permitled Permitted
1-3 Unlimited 2 Not Permitted'
M' Sp, rh~nlPr II
R-I Unlimited II 12 4 2' .4 '. II 4 3 2~
R-3 Unlimited- 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
'For open parking garages. see Section 709. N-No requiremem for rire reSISlance
. 'See Section 802 (c) - F.R.-Flre ReSISlive
'See Section 1002 (b). H_T.-Heayy Timber
'Fer agricultural buildings. see also Appendix Chapler II.
'For limilp- -, and exceplions. se "liOn 1202 (b)_
Example:
A building con be built, in effect, by
"stocking" smoller buildings side by side
until the desired total area is obtained.
The area separation requirements are
severe,. however, and such construction
necessitates their added expense and
design inconvenience.
1'/ - 8
(2.) Separation on Sides Increase
Section 506(a) - Occupancies: All
Construction Types: All
Where public space,· streets, ar yards more than 20 feet in width ex-
tend along and adjoin more than one side of a building, rhe basic floor
area may be increased at a given rate for each foot by which the
minimum width exceeds 20 feet.
RATE OF AREA INCREASE FOR SEPARATION
Area Increase Rate Maximum Increase
Separation on two sides 11::' /0 per foot over 50;:1r
20 feet of width
Separation on' three sides 2 1 i S>;o per foot over 100S;c
20 feet of width
Separation on all sides 5% per foot over 100%
20 feet of width
Example:
'An occupancy with two sides fronting on open space 40 feet in width is entitled to
an area increase of:
=
1~/4%(40 ft. - 20 ft.) 25%
If the scace were' 60 feet in width, the allowable increase would be
Yt
! %(60 ft. - 20 ft.) = 50%
1'1- 9
• '.l
e",
Note:/ncrease not applicable when automatic sprInkler system is in-
, stalled'in accordance ,with:
Sec1ion 507"':'" height increase for sprinklers
Section 3802(b) 5 :- tor Groups,Hl and H2,high" haiard,
, ,occupancies
Example:
A Group E School of Type III-N can:
struetion is assigned a bas'ic allowable floor
area of 13,500 sq. ft. in Table 5-C If
, sprinklered, th~ area of a one-story school
sq, It.
could be increased by 2007~' to an area
of 40,500 sq. ft.
The basic allowable area of a two-story
school of Type III·N construction would be
twice the one-story area, or 27,000 sq. feet.
If automatic sprinklers were provided, the
area could be increased by 100/'0, or
doubled, to a .total of 54,000 sq, feet.
Example:
Factories are classified as Group B occupancies. If surrounded by at least 60 feet 'of
open space on all sides and provided with an automatic sprinkler system, factories
can be built of any type construction to unlimited areas.
~m.\
.~~)
~
, IV -10
IS.) Combinations and Limitations
Section 506(c) states that the area increase option allowed for automatic
sprinkler systems may be compounded with the area increases allowed
for separation on building sides.
Example:
Suppose that the one-story school of Type III-N construction from a previous example
is being designed for a site outside the city fire limits which has at leasl 40 ft ~ of open
space on all sides, The area increases for separation on sides and automatic sprinklers
mar be compounded:
13,SOO sq. ft basic area
IV- 11
·e.', .,e
Example:
A' group' A3 assembly of T.ype, II·N .constr uctibn' IS limited. la' a 'height of, one' story
by i able S·D. If sprinklered; the assembly may be bui'''' to a heighlof tw,o stories .
Example:
In a previous example, it was demonstrated that a one-story school of Type III-N
construction could be built to on area of over 80,000 square feet by using the com·
pounding feature with the area increase options for side separation and automatic
sprinklers.
If automatic sorinkiers were not installed: the - 80,000 square feet could be obtained
uSing construct"ion of either Type I or Type II - ' fire resistiv€'. For a Group E occu-
pancy, Type II - fire resistive is assigned- a basic allowable floor area of 45,200
square feet, but this may be increased for the side separations:
45,200 Basic area
x 20010 J 00'1'0 separation increase (maximum)
90,400 sq, ft ..
Thus. by installing" aulomatic sprinklers in the school and taking advantage of the
resultant area increase allowance. the designer is able to use Type III-N conslrue/ion
instead of Type II - fire resistive. The Code ;s ac/ually allowing a reduction in the
fire resistance requirements for the 80,000 square foot building.
IV- 12
Example: (continued)
It is p05Sible to compare the Fire resistance requirements of various components for
the two comtruction types' in Tobie 17 -A.
Unsprinklered Sprinkiered
Component Type II - F.R. Type III-N
Exterior Bearing Walls 1 hr. N
Interior Bearing Walls 2 hrs. N
Structural Frome 2 hrs. N
Permanent Partilions 1 hr. N
Floor 2 hrs. N
Roof 7 hr. N
N - No protection requirements; noncombustible construction
What does the fire resislance reduction amount to in terms of construction cost?
ICBO periodically. publishes "B uilding Valuation Data" .(see Appendix), a com-
pilatIon of average costs of construclion for the various occupancies of each type
construction. The April 19BO data states the rollowing average costs for schools:
Type II - F.R. Type III-N
$64.00jsq. ft. ' $43.00/sq. ft.
The report provides a figure of $1.30/sq. ft,' as Ihe average cost of sprinkler systems.
, This brings Ihe total cost of the unsprinklered and sprinklered schools to:
Unsprinklered - Type II - F.R ..
$64.00/ sq. ft. x BO,OOO sq. ft. = $5,120,000
Sprinklered -.: Type II/ N
($43.00/sq. ft.-'- $7.30/sq. fl.) x BO,OOO sq. ft.
$44.30/sq. ft. x 80,000 s~, ft. =' $3,544,000
The ~prinklered s~hool' could be built for approximately 70% the cost of the un-
sprinklered school; 0 savings of 30%.
1:1/- 13
, ,
Example:
A single exit has 'the capability of serving
a specific maximum, area. For compart-
mented buildings, such area is dependent
upon partitioning. For open floor areas:
the "service area" of an exit is theoretical-
ly semi-circular, but roughly triangular for
practical purposes. This is due to the fact
that most egress must travel through grid-
ded aisles as established by sales displays,
machinery or furniture arrangements, or
~' I
seating configurations, 200 ---'---oj EXIT
In an unsprinklered building, the maximum •
exit travel distance of 150 feet allows a
service area' of approximately 22,500
square feet.
I
1
The increased travel distance of 200 feet
allowed in a sprinklered building results
in a service area increase of 780/0, to a
total of 40,000 square feet.
Occupancies: Group B4
Construction Types: All
In a one-story Group B4 occupancy cl05sified as a factory or warehouse
and in one~story airplane hangers, the exit travel distance may be in·
creased to 400 feet if the building is equipped throughout with an auto-
matic sprinkler system and provided with smoke and heat ventilation.
1'1-·14
Section 3317(c) - Occupancies: Group E
Construction Types: All
No point in a room in a Group E - Educational building may be more
than 75 feet from 0 minimum protection as provided by an exit corridor,
enclosed stairway, or building exterior. In buildings protected by a
complete automatic rire-extinguishing system, the distance may be in-
creased ro 110 feet.
No· point in an unsprinklered school building may be more than 150
feet from an exterior exit door, horizontal exit, exit passageway, or
enclosed stoirwoy. In a building prctecte:J by an automatic fire ex-
tinguishing system, the .distance may be increased to 225 reet.
Used witt, permission from NFPA 13, Installation 'ot Automotic Sprinkler Systems,
Copyright, 1976, Notional Fire Pro~ection A:ssoci'otlon, Boslon, Me:!.!..
IV- 15
Section' 1706(a)6 - Occupancie:s: 'All
'Construction Types: All
'Gas vents' and, ~on~ombu;tible pipiriginstalled in walls of buildings must
comply with Table, 17-A, if passing 'thr,ough, more than' .three floors: I!
equipped with, a sprinkler system, compliance with Table 17-A is' re-
quired when passing through more than four floors.
IV-16
3. Use of Materials Options
Automatic sprinkier systems can be specified to widen the designers choice aT
materials for interior finish," ta compensate for higher flame spread character-
istics of certain finishes, or to allow the use of ce~tain plastics and foam plastics
with dangeraus burning characteristics.
UL 723
ASTM E-84
I I 0- :25
II 26- 75
III 76-200
. ,',
,Section 4203.2
Where walls' an'd ceilings are' required' to' be of, .fire-resistive, or non-
combustible construction and walls are set out or ceilings are dropped
distances greater than 1 ~ inches, Closs I, finish mate~ials must be used
except where the finish, materials are protected on both sides 'by auto-
matic .'fire sprinkler systems or are attached to a, noncombustible backing
arto fu~ring strips as 'specified in Section 4203.1,·
Section 4204 -.
iV-.l7
" ->
•••
< •• '
, "~.
OCCUPANCY ENCLOSED
VERilCAL OTHER ROOMSOR
'GROUP EXITWAYS' AREAS
EXITWAYS
A I- lL III
E I II III
I I II II'
H I II III'
B I II III
R-I I II III
R-3 III III III'
M' NO RESTRICTIONS
'In rooms in which personal libenie< of ,nmates are forcibl~ restrained. Class I
material only shall be used.
'Over two stories shall be of Class II.
'Flame-spread provisions are nOt applicable to kitchens and bathrooms of Group
R, .Division) Occupancies.
'Foam plastics shall comply with the requirements specified in Section 1717.
'Finish classIfication is not applicable [0 interior walls and·ceillngs of exterior exit
balconies.·
b. PLASTIC OPTIONS
(l.J Foam Plastic Insulation Option
Section 1717(b)2 - Occupancies: All
Constructio'n Types: All except as noted
Foam plastic insulation with a flame spreae of 75 or less (tested in
thickness of 4.inches) may be used up to 10 inches thick in cold storage
rooms, food processing rooms, ice plant and similar rooms .when pro-
tected w'ith automatic sprinklers and when protected from building
interior with portland cement or other approved material with a finish
rating af not less than 15 minutes.
Section 1717(b)3 -
1'1- 18
(3.) Skylights Option
Section 5207 - Occupancies: All except A 1, A2, I and H
Construction Types: All
Approved plastics may be used in skylights installed on roofs in ac-
cordance with listed provisions, among which are:
4. Each skylight unit may have a maximum area of 100 sguare feet
within the curb for CC2 material and 200 sq. ft. far eCl material.,
111- 19
.', . ~:. ' :
Barriers No Requirements
or if
Spondrel, Sprinklered
1V- 20
Com pa rtmentation Automatic Sprinkler Systems
Smoke proof A vestibule and continuous stairway en- Smokeproof enclosures may be eliminated
Enclosures closed by 2-hour construction must be made if required stairways are pressurized to
smokeproof by natural ventilation or mech- .15 inch water column.
anical ventilation with a positive pressure
of .05 inch - of water column in the stair
shaft and an additional _1a inch of water
in the vestibule. (Section 3309)
Voice Alarm Detection and alarm systems must activate Same requirements - system operated by
System a" voice alarm system operated from central sprinkler activation.
control station.
Central Control < Containing panels for voice communica- Some requirements. Contains sprinkler
Station tions systems, detection and alarm systems, . supervisory equipmenr and valve controls.
elevator and air handling 'controls, stand·
, by power control, etc.
Smoke "Co"ntrol Venting facilitie"s required - panels or' Sprinklers' allow, design of air handling,
windows in exterior woll that can be equ'ipment to effect smoke removal. Win-
opened from other than fire floor"" dows or panels manually openable from
within the' fire -floor or approved fixed,
tempered glass may be used in lieu of
the remotely operated ponels and windows .
. IV - 21
... - ~:, . ','-~:
,
'-.
,,'"
Exit Travel" 150 feet maximum to harizontal exit ar 300 ·feet maximum to horizontal' exit or
Length enclosed stairway. encl.osed stairway from most remote point.
1V-22
5. Other Options
a. STANDPIPE OPTION
Table 38·A - Occupancies: A1, A2, A2.1, H, B, R1
Construction Types: All
Standpipes for occupant use (i.e. NFPA Class II standpipes) must be
provided in ail Group A occupancies with an occupant load exceeding
1,000, in all occupancies (except R3) exceeding 150 feet or 4 stories in
height, and in Group I, H, B1, 82, and 83 occupancies with a floor area
exceeding 20,000 sq. ft. per floor. Such standpipes must extend from
the cellar or basement into the topmost story. Class il. standpipes are not,
however, in basements or cellars equipped with a complete automatic
sprinkler system .. UBC Standard 38-3 permits ~he omission of the 1 L~-inch
hose and hose outlets in buildings equipped with an automatic sprinkler
system throughout (See page 5-26).
11/-23
I'
.,- .
Stcindpipe syste~s must comply y.-ith UBC Standard' No. 38-3. This standard
is. based on NFPA 14 - Standpipes and Hose Streams ~ 1976.
2. Alarms
Section 3802(c) - ,
3. Water Supplies
Section 3801 (d)
4. Standpipes
Standpipe requirements are ,summarized in Table. 38·A:
TABLE NO.,38·A-STANDPIPE REQUIREMENTS
NONSPRINKLERED SPRINKLERED
BUILDING3 BUILDING3 4
Slandplpe Hose Standpipe Hose
Occupancyl Class ReqUirement Class ReQulremenl
J. OccupanCies ~
1 SO It In height and III Yes III No
more than one story
2. Occupancies 4 stones or
more but less than 150 I and No land No
ft. In height, except II S( or III) Yes II (or Jll) No
Group R Oi ..... 3
3. Group A Occupancies No
with occupant load II Yes No
exceeding 1000 ReQuirement
5. Groups I, H, B, DIV. I
2 or 3 Occupancies less
than 4 stories on height []5
I Yes,
No
UBC Standard 38-3 permits the omission of 1',i-inch' hose and hose out-
lets (Closs II service) in buildings equipped with an automatic sprinkler
system throughout, provided each standpipe outlet is equipped with a
2 Jh-inch hose valve, a 2Y2-inch b/ 1%·inch reducer, and a cop with
attachment chain. Sprinkler risers may be combined with standpipes.
IV- 24
Appendix
3. CHURCHES: EQUIPMENT
!vpe I or II F.R ... 5050
AIR CO,'iDITIONING:
Tvpe III-I-Hour. 4000
Tvpe 111-i\J 38.00
Commercial 80
Residential. .40
Type V-l-Hour 35.50
Type V-,\J
SPRINKLER SYSTEMS: . .30
340C
.. ,Ado 0.8 percenr to torai cost (Dr eJch s:ory over tnree
4. CONVALESCHH HOSPITALS:
'Type I or II F, R. 6900
Type 111-1-Hour. 5650
Type V-1-Hour . 4890
S. DWElliNGS:
Type V-;Masonry 4440 34 50
Type V-Wood Frame 41 AD 3110
Basements-
Finished. 10.80 790
Regional Modifiers
Unrlnished, 8.40 6.30 The [allowing modifiers are recommended [or use In
conlunctlon with the Budding Valuation Data in addi-
6, HOSPITALS: tion, certain local conditions may require further mod!~
"Type I or II F,R". 85.00 ficalions To use these modifiers merely multiply the
Type 111-1-Hour . 75.80 listed cost per square root bv the approoriate regional
Type V- 1-Hour, . 69.40 modliler. For example:
d\.\'ellln~
Valuation Type
Type
V-1-Hour .
V-N.
B. INDUSTRIAL PLANTS:
Type I or II F.R ..
39,50
37.80
31.00
ladjusted cos I per square foot)
that this is the most appropriate fire protection. The hazard demandin~
Reproduced from
besl available copy.
~).
v -'.1
T:.:ole 1 - Primary Considerations for Sprirlkler RequiTD'::lents in the Model Codes
Institutional x
--------------_---.:_------------
Assembly
Exhibition x x
Nightclub x
EdL;cational x
Theater StagE: x
Mercc.ntile x x
Fac.tory/Storage/
High Hazard x
High Rise x x
Undergro-,md and
Hindmvless x x
·Vi - 2
In recognition of the improved safety achi-eved thrGugh the jn-
--,
(
"
'. -,,'
~ .../
V -: 3
Table 2 - Design Options for Automatic Sprinkler Systems
unlimited areas Certain occupancies under Certain occupancies under Certain occupancies under
specific conditions specific conditions specific conditions
Fireproofing
e
Spacing of fires tops Triple area between attic
stops 3,000-9,000
, roof framing reduction Within fire district and for For all components in all
school floors above cellars. For types, except shaft enclos-
partitions, columns, beams, etc. ures, corridors, etc.
in Type I, but 1 hr. minimum.
,
Basic ", Standard Uniform
1978 1979 1979
Use of Materials
VI Alarms
Smoke detection
Other
These area and height limits depend upon the nature of the occupancy and the
construction type. mIen a sprinkler system is provided, the codes generally permit
permit the height of a sprink1ered bui Idj ng to be one story above that \"bich \\Iould
in the United States as early as 1885, predating the publication of the first model
building code in 1905. The 1905 edition of the Natjonal Building Code pJ2ced
The si;;~c limitations have their origins in a concern for property prot2c tion.
It 'das recognized that the ultimate extent of a fire can generally be 1im_~ted by
could re.asonab1y control. The specific maximLcw bllj_lding areas and heights are
judgmental, based on the available fire experience and r~cords. The depth and
outside fire-·fighting.
To some extent, the area increases for sprinklers Here brought aboll t by industry's
need for larger areas for eccno'niC2.1 manuf accuriilg and assembly processes. Sprinkler
performance statistics demonstrated that the large majority of fires were controlled
v- 6
2. Fire Resistance
structure resists the effect of fire. While numerous fires have indicated that it is
often the contents rather than the building vlhich burn, fire containment has been
of building codes, and has essential life safety implications as well. Fire resistance
can prevent or delay the collapse of primary and secondary structural members, can
protect agcdnst the passage of fire and smoke when related to ban.. iers such as
fire divisions and partitions, and can help maintain a safe path for egress.
Although the first model building (1905 National Building Code) included provisions
for "fireproof" buildings, it Has the first edition of the Uniform Building Code jn
1927 whic~ introduced the concept of fire resistance ratings. From the start, tile
,---"\
\J idea has been to ba~ance the degree of fire resistance of the buildi~g against the
weight of combustible contents and construction. Testing begun in 1922 by the Nationgl
and the fire j_ntensity of the ASTM E1l9 standard time-ter.1perature curve. (Figure I )
The El19 curve had been adopted in 1918 as a "measuring stick" agai.nst which the fire-
5 1/2
7~ 3/4
10 I
Table 5 15 1-1/2
20 2
30 3
40 4-1/2
v "'".7
I ).<~,\\D· ",° --l
1 I
-
Figure 1 / J
! TI__ r=
lif
1-' - I
I Iii 13
11
,0
I i ,I!:~
I lil~~
! Ii 2
I
2 3 4
TIME III HRS
For each type of construction, the model building codes specify a minimelr,1
hourly rating of fire resistance for each building cOr.1ponent such as columns, beams,
partitions, and floors. These hourly ratings refer to the per£orirance of the component
All four of the model building codes effectively pel:mit fire resistance r,"ouctioES
for sprinklers by virtue of permitting area and height increases. Such increases can
have the net effect of allowing a given occupancy of a given size to be built using
reductions that are allowed. In general, the codes permit automatic sprinkler
protection to substitute for one hour of fire resistance. In many cases sprinklers
may be provided in lieu of one-hour fire resistive construction. Some codes, however,
"'ill permit a reduction by one hour but to a minimum of one hour, 1. e. they do nOl:
There has been considerable testing and other subsLantiation demonstrating the
which took place in the late 19 ZfO's and early 1950's at Factory [':utual Research shO\Jed U1at
the sprinklers ,Jere able to eliminate active flaming comeustion of wood ceilings by
preventIng adjacent air from rising substantially above lOOOoF. Extensive testing
c' Rack Storage of Materials and 231 - General Storage showed' that sprinkler systems alone
prevented overhead bare steel roof DlCmbers from reaelling critical temperatures, thereby
v..:. 8
eliIilinating the need for fire resistance ratings of SIJch nJE'mbers.
both Underwriters Laboratories and Factory Mutual Research as paft of their product
approval criteria. A 300-pound wood crib is centered under four sprinklers and
shows that s~rinklers are activated after approximately one minute, by whicl1 time ceiljng
temperatures can reach over l400 0 F. Within five minutes and throughout the duration of
0
the test the sprinklers must bring temperatures back to below 600 F. Crib wei.ght loss
must be less than 20%. The ASTM EJ19 curve is superimposed for purposes of cQrnp~rison.
substitute for fire resistance. These curves were prOd\lCed by Factory ~Jtual in 1965.
Curve A represents the temperatures reached by a bare steel. H-column during a fire
exposure in accordance with the Ell9 standard tir::.e--te.r.lperature curve. The resC'3rchLYS
found th2t a 2.8 gpm gasoline spray fire directed upward 1 inch away from th? cclumn
could have an effect close to that of the El19 exposure. Curve B, however, shOl;::;
the reduction in temperature which occurs when sprinklers located 25 feet above are
activated by the fire. Without sprinkJ ers, the bare steel caul,:} be expectr:.d to fail
in 11 to 15 minutes. With sprinklers, the steel will maintain its strength indefinitely.
In this manner, the sprinkler system effectively substitutes [or fire resistant
Laboratories in 1969 proved that t~npered double-pane glass windows with sprinkler
protection maintained fire integrity at least equivalent to wire glass with a 45-minute
rating. Later small-scale testing established that even single-pane glass could
fail a standard fire test within 5 minutes could be protected from a room fire
,'J 1-', /.,.f .. / . ; : I . ' ; , / : I,I'J,:.,I.l : ;;,1 :.,.!;!il·I~I:: I ! .:'\ !.I.~.\+t-:'\"'I: \' \
--~I(/'O~-.[L_-- ·....:.t-r--"--'-~l-~I'. ~,-- i' I J .. --h-~I-:-'--" "'-i 'n'--,---: -t-~~t--, --i, I ' i--
-~. ;- .,( : JI ~I: '~i-~' - ;. ,: i--:- ,;-. ji·~ I_-~ +-~ - ~ 'r: ~-i: 1< i- '. !- -J-: -H"": -,'~: -~- .~~.+ -:. -~-':' \:~ --~\ :,~-.:J.";-~.~, ",: ........,.
. ", '1'" a •
. ,- ,. . l ' ' , ' I I : I I l I . ' I " --...1....... 11"',.,.. _';.-_-+--_.
. . ji'±J l .~ i :·1-: ,-: ,-: -r--l-~~r ;. -: .j.:
:r~~;;~- 11
~~\"II~'::~:- -~-j.: t·~- -:r~t~'! -.-~' -1-:
. -r-:-1,-;"!-I-··I·'r'·t_':
~'~~"I~~.,:. -J·'-:~·:~t-·:·~T·:-r''''~'-~ t-::'il:~' -:.-!' --:--:-:-- -~-~':-I'-';. -r--~=++~
.!, 'I" " 'I' 'i . '" -"j"1' i·,1 I "
,- "'!""l'! "'['i' ' i -- ... --
---i,---I·,: !
' - .J_ -- l..-·-~-i-- ..:...-. -.. -I: i=::1[.. "
.. ·1--·, -.. _1-- . .,: ......... " ' . j " ._-j, "'i-- ",------!---- --':--- --"-
--'-~ -_.. ~-- ----;--I~--I-·- ..
I' ; I :, I, ':' ; 1 ;..·... 1 .... • : I :: '.i· , : .'. .::' -, : ,. :
.. :,.,; , j :Ii m',-,: -:".,
. ~ ~ I': -- 1 • ~ -
l : ,-"
-~FOO-'
,! ~: ' I-',-:. - I ' " ; I' I,: . J ,i- i - -. - - - - -
i' - .. '".~-I----'-:------·-
~."". I I" i ' i· 'I' I: --'-1-'--
j " ' ; ' 1__---,
::_; . I "I.. · .: - ':" ']
" ;
--" I'
... " .,-,-'
, : ,-
1
---'-LJ;0 11 +\-~ -'T-T'jI'-~-: t,~,~>rL -T- 'i ·1' ~~I '-i' -;- I :.--!1:-r~11~ ~-l ~:l':' i-=~:-i-:-,: I, .r-
m
~~ 1'- ':-'~t --1'-: \ .. :, I Spri?klcr,( 'm'us y red~ce' c1ilin~ tem~cr,qtt1!es t~ bej~;:.;-53bOF ~'~'ov'~' -J'l~bi-e~t~'iJ;;i~_-'
. :N"":
:~I-'I'J,OO' j- I • I}]::::::--.......... ~YULll~(.J'_I\"I;-;:')LlL ([',LitI'l:,n at c c e , i ' : j , -; i I ~-I-~
~'I " ! ' p' , "I~" ( .. : ." , , !' ,
' llil-'-UUC~~------..........--"',' I"~
,1-1' I" :--: -'L··.. .i f:--;'--' ':';''''1-- .:. I :
I .. I . i . ' : i., ! ",--~"-"';~I':' [ . -;-:-:-1'.. ·.. !~! .. ,~ ! . '~.~-~o .... -'"
1_- --5-00 1 -- -----I ' '--:- ,-".--~-~- ---. ·_·__ !_-----l_ _ ..j,_·_~----I-- -- - ' -t-~.-~~,;:--..--:~A:,,._-
,'! I ; I : t,: I I,',": I I : ;" " . ! 'I i' I I
'I-f -~' If, ",i'~ ~,
:.. i": i ' 1-;' i~';'1 ,.;' i ": I -; K~,l:Ll'r:d{".1,Ce~11:ngltcj;]pl;rab;~cs.. (9yPlca:r te::it) . ! --:-- i''': ---j-: I : - !--:--j':-------j-------j---:--
0
:-"- .;; 0., ~JI" '-!~ :-rtJj:-;-+-~-1 :-:.-'tl'-~-Ll:~- LI---,I,-----~I----_:_i --1--,.'--,-' -----;~-;--~I-, j:" i . ii, I'
! - :
"'-~---~I';~-I! -4 i--+~-+-h-=-fl-~~~I---~-=r_~·:'~-~I~_+L--l! -~ ~_:~[!~~--i II' ',- i-
'-I-:r-HT ,Tn- l '
:.:-- --; -1 ;' 1-;' ': '1;-
;-~-~--,' ~ ii /--'I~· :'·-'I":'-T'~-~tJ=_J-· :.;:!'; '1-: "L': I' !-- 1-----1--:--:---1--:--1"':--:-1,,---· "i".. _
. . --!.-~ . . - -
'
~,;---:2\OC."-ll~'~~~-·-r-I'· -: r, I=J'~"':-I~-J.---: -"--'-~----'--l -:-·-f-·-· 'I----T-·-,i----' --r-.;. I,. I . i I' .--1.-.;__
-, !: - ---',---- :--- \ -':--' -, -,--, I '" : . : . :.. l ., ".;' ". " 'I ' . . i' - I .- .. II' Ii' !.. , .... -- . I, - - --, ! ,- --, . - --: " ---
", I! r.==;.;1--=---:-.----.'-: :,,_'_l~ i' f-'. I' i i ::: ," "', i'" ::. ~
:-:-~I--\OO (r- ~:froadv~~iadb'efrocmo 'f'--I"--:-'I--~--I ,-:-·-T--r-~'-~--- r---,-1'-----1----' ----1-'-T-~' i -:--;-~--;---i ---.
--- -- ! ' , ,;' lI][ py." I - ,- -- I .. " I' ,- " ". I', ,I ,. 1
,-!". . • , , ' I,' . t ' - .. -. ' ,. - I '- _ 0 __ , ,-, --
conduC'Led in 1971f for the American Health Care Assoc.iation conc.luded that corric(Jl"
FIGURE 3
Reproduced from
best available copy.
v - 11.
3. Vertical and Horizontal Openi~gs
and is often aided by the absence of fire cut-offs at openings between building
limiting potential fire grovlth by means of maintaining fire v:alls and compart-
mentation.
is for escalators. All of the Codes permit the use of the escalator protection
lieu of enclosure for non-required meal",S of egress. The first testing of sprj_:1kler
protection for escalators was a joint effort by the Otis Elevator Company,
Heslinghouse Electric Cc'opany and the Grinnell Comp,:my in 1947. Other private
tests led to the present protection criteria. Hany of the Codes utilize sprinklEr
walls, and all of the Codes effectively call upon sprinklers to provine horizontal
that while ordinary sprinklers designed to provide a vJater curtain over a doon;r2y
were not effective in countering the flow of hot gases through the opening, care-
ful positioning of nozzles and spray was capable of protecting conveyor system
examine sprinkler and spray nozzle methods· for the protection of stain.,ays and
other openings.
v - 12
(
FIGURE 4
".----~
i .
\ .. /
v - 13
4. HCcrris of E~ess
,,,hich pre-dated the Build.ing EXi~~od~, automatic sprinklers have been permitted
to modify the requirements for egress fad.lities. Initially this ,,-,as in the fonT!
of allowing more occupants per floor in sprinklered buildings. In the 1930's the
concept of exit capacity was introduced, and sprinklered buildings were permitted
more occupants per ur..it of exit ~"idth. Today, while some Codes (Basic BuDding
Code, NFPA Life Safety Code) permit exit capacity increases for sprinklers and
one (National Building Cocia) contains spc':'.ial floor use options fur sprinkle:.:-s.
the Codes are nearly uniform in their allowance of lon8cr exit travel distances in
Thp populari,ty of exit travel distance increase options may be due in paJ:t
/"'-""-,
\j to their compatibi.li ty ~"i th area increase a llm,:ances for spd.nkleTf:d build in~~.s.
The apparent rationale for all means of egress options is the observed Clb:U.ity of
Follo~,Ting the Our L2.dy of the Angel s School f ire in Chicago in 1958: Hhi ch
killc:d 95 pu;}ils and teachers, the Los Anzeles Fire Departrr,ent l;~ld2rtGok Cl 5e1'ie2,
The teGtf~ c.oncluded th::lt a complete system of automatic. sprinkleY.':; ,-,ill lIli.d.rJti:lln
low t~nper~turcs throughout the building and will reduce build-up of smoke and
irritating gases, allowing more time for evacuating occupants. Partial automatic
sprinklers (installed in corridors and stairways hut n8t over the test fire) did
In 1966, tests conducted by the City of Denver at the Park Lane Hotel in-
,·.- .",, clicated that sprinklers located in corridors ouly were able to permit egress past
l ..-
,
an open fire room. Research sponsored by the Departments of Dousing and Urban
Development (HUD) and Health, Education and Welfare (HEW) at the National Bureau
v - 14
• TABLE 6
OCCUPANCY CODES
-
Basic Standard Uniform
1978 1979 1979
--
NP ~ Not Permitted
* ~ Where floor area is divided into small areas an additional 50 feet is permitted
from cO;("Tidor entrance to remote point on such areas. -. - . . -;. .- -,,--
-- .-" - . - --- -
V-IS
Page 2
In general, exit travel distance increases are based on the idea that sprinklers
"dll permit more time for evacuating occupants, due to early fire control.
,j"'" .......
v- 16
5.
,r'
Int2rior Finish
While factors such as ventilation and geometry of fuel can also greatly
Tl-,e. Ill'Jdel codes uniforJ1.',ly restrict fla,nmabj lity of lining materials lly
assigned a z:ero rating and -red oak fleoring is assigned a value of 100.
Basic
----
Standard Uniform
- ----
0-25 I A I
26-75 11 B II
76-200 III "
C III
normally required.
r-", that combustible interior finishes (Class C) did not play any role ip. fire
~
~,~
the room.
v - 17
In 1975, the National Bureau of Standards intro~uced the Flooring
( Radiant Pnnel Test for evaluating flooring systems used in corridors and
floor coverings, the Bureau observed that the need for such regulation
Use of Plastics
(-'" 'vl'C:l spri111~ler S 2re provided. Hc:wy of these options are baseo un 1ar ge-
"... ~.....
scale corner tests conducted by the Factory Mutual Research Corporation for
v- 18
• r
6. Alarms
!
\
NFPA 13, to sour..d a local ,·,'aterflo,v alarm u:Jon actuation, for any system
for heat detection ~ysteTi1s, the basis is eCll1ivCilency. In other c&ses, such as
desire on the part of the Codes to help offset the costs of the sprinkler
system, with the underlying assumption that sprinklers will. provide better
the National Bureau of Standards, that automatic sprinklers ctre much slo\o"er
Reproduced from
best available copy.
!
v - 19
Case Studies olprinldered vs. Unsprink:lered BUil~
The purpose of thes,:- studies is to examine the economic impnct that instAlling
an automatic sprink:ler system has on the cost of constructing vnrious types of
buildillt:;::> under the provisions of the three most widely used model building
codes. Allhough it was not possible to conduct a thorough study of all building
types and occupancies because of time and cost constraints, an analysis has been
made of the cost differences bet ween sprink:lered and unsprinklered buildings of
three different types: a high-rise office building, a two-story combination
mercantile and office building and a four-story apartment building. Each of the
buildings is typical of its selected from of construction and all make' use of
conventional materials and structural systems.
The building used for the study was designed as a speculative office building.
Construction documents were completed and bids were received in 1975, but the
project was not built.
The method used to establish the cost differential between the sprinl\lered and
unsprinklered designs was to redesign the original sprinklered building as an
unsprinklered building in conformance with the requirements of the three model
building codes and then mal\ing a detailed cost estimate of the differences
between the sprinklered and compartmented designs.
Draw ings 1 and 2 show typical tenant floors of the building in the sprinklered
and compartmented configurations. The differences are considerable. The most
obvious, and the most difficult to cope with for a designer are the two-hour fire
rated compartmenting wall and the one-hour rated exit access corridors and
elevator lobby enclosure. Not as difficult to deal with from a design point of
view but very important as regards cost is the code requirement to provide
smok:e vents that are operable from a point other than on the fire floor in the
compartmented design. In a sprinklered building tempered glass window panels
can be used in place of remotely operable smoke vents. Drawing 3 shows a
smoke vent of the type required in a compartmented high-rise building. The
vents would be operable from the fire control station on the ground floor of the
building.
An option exists in the codes to use the building exhaust system for smol\e
removal in a sprinklered building in place of the tempered glass smol\e vents. In
this instance, this option was not selected because the cost of the controls and
additional emergency power necessary to achieve the required number of exhaust
VI - 1
.
Other differences between the code requirements for sprinkle red and unsprink-
lered buildings nrc the need to provide a smokeproof tower. fire alarm pull boxes
und first aid fire hose cabinets in a compartmented building. In addition, the
fire protection requirements are increased in unsprinklered buildin~ from
2 hours to 3 hours for columns; from 1 1/2 to 2 hours for floor/ceiling assemblies
and from 1 hour to 2 hours for vert ical shafts.
Drawing 4 shows the interior partition assemblies used for the purposes of this
study. Drawing 5 shows the exterior wall asseJTlbly proposed for the building.
Although all of the model codes offer a trade-off involving the fire rating of
spandrel panels, no effective way of taking economic advantage of this option
was found.
The model codes differ slightly in that the Basic Building Code only requires that
when exit access corridors are provided in a sprinklered building that they be of
noncombustible construction whereas the Standard Building Code and Uniform
Building Code stipulate that corridors must have a one-hour fire rating. This
difference is not reflected in following differential cost analysis as there is
essentially r.o difference in the cost of the two types of wall assemblies.
There are only minor differences in the design of the heating, ventilating and air
conditioning systems for the sprinklered and unsprinklered buildings. As none of
the model codes permits a duct to penetrate the 2-hour fire separation wall in
an unsprinldered building, the air supply, return and exhaust systems must be
entirely separate for each compartment. In this case it was necessary to provide
an additional toilet exhaust system in the unsprinklered design to conform with
this requirement. Of greater economic importance in an unsprinklered building
is the requirement to provide automatic fire dampers on all ducts penetrating a
shaft or corridor wall and automatic self-closing fire rated doors activated by
smoke detectors \\'hen such doors are located in a fire rated wall and are
normally held in an open position.
In both versions of the building, the mechanical equipment rooms are fUlly
sprinklered. This decision was made because the code provision prohibiting the
penetration of a fire separation wall would make it necessary to provide two
entirely sepurate air handling systems, one for each compartment. This would
not make economic sense in view of the relative cost of providing sprinkler
protection. The mod::l codes differ slightly with respect to mechanical
equipment spaces. The Basic Building Code requires that all such spaces be
equipped with automatic sprinklers but does not require the installation of a
smoke detection system. The Standard Building Code and Uniform Building Code
require smoke detection systems but n,ake the installation of sprinklers optional.
VI - 2
.j
{
,'l
Reproduced from
FIG. 1 best available copy.
HIGH RISE OFFICE BUILDING
VI - 3
~.-O------==UF-=~--~- ------=-1
1
, I
~,
C
t
/2
,
:~
!~
'--------'
:~
~
I~
,1
~ IJ
0.
:.
-. i.
==CJ
~
b=--cc-~ -------
- --=---
-- -----
,
!
•
I
b ~
D-l
TYPICAL TENANT FLOOR
SPRINKLERED BUILDING
VT - /.
..
~ e
"
-0-' =0 =q
e
l
.' i
I"
,i
CJ C
.,
----- -
.,
I ' .,
./ "./" -
o
ow
I"
---, I
l?'I..... _-~
1
¢I
,
,' J'
,o •• ,.
6.=--~~_. -~.:- - ~
D-2
TYPICAL TENANT FLOOR
COMPA R TMEN TED BUILD ING
VI - 5
' ......
D-3
SMOKE VENT
D-4
IN'TERIOR FA R TI TIONS
.~
,
~
~
~
I I
j
lL .J . = .. ...,
-
fD:J .
, --"-
- .... -
.
nRL ""'"
:§g--
----
I
--
~ ._---
""""""'" .."..,ne
llU ClEtlJIIIlQ
D-5
EXTERIOR WALL
VI - 6
SPRINY-.LER SYMBOL LIST
- 1'\ ' . i;:>CRIP1 !ON
-<1- "'-"TER FLOW 5"'110< ~DOlE
<&- los Il.Y GATE V.AtV£!'YT~~ SI'!.!TC!!
..0- TYPE A, Uf.'l'I'GHT o!l P£HDANT HeADS
1.-&-" r~~£!-USH--.!.'r~~ADs
~- 'TYJ>£ c..£~t~tJ ~~,
....-<l TYP1: D SI~WALL HEADS
I
~ F!G, 1 PRES5URE GiUGE
I-~ 1OlIAI;>j & TEST YALVE
-0- s.c, I SiGI'T GLASS
TYPICAL ~TAIL Of
SPRlNI'(LER CONNECTION
TO FS,P' RISER
-=-,
=-it
J
I l_LI
,..,
" --u--.,
~-
=E:~
~*
~~-
~~~
-".~ .... -
="_--1'----
..
,E:::5IWiiOz . .
D-6
SPRINKLER SYSTEM
MEZ ZANINE FLOOR-D RA \IrING
SYMBOLS-TYPICAL DETAIL
VI - 7
9 '1Jf- -----LJI.. .- --....-.. . O!f-I--_----~:-~]
I
I
: I
I
I 1 I
I
I
I I
I
~D:
I
l'.
g I II]
I
I
I
- I
I
I
1
I
1
I
I
,I
I:J I !Ql
r
------f'
I
I
I
1 I
I
l. __________
----' , - -
-'
I
g -G
r i r - - ~-
i
1
,
~tC~V
~ 9~o ,
. ~G
"
t ,'tIgti1
U -_
' 'I
,
':
1
i,
I , •
,
»c,
~
~OS~C&T"OrolLOl)3'r
c,'
;,..,,(.. ~-J
., ,-------.
;--->
~
-~ ~.AZJaJII:C '~I.O q
IDQ s.o.n A' Cl1 r",Rl.~ M
"I]' 1"I:iA..:l IilAl
ClE"",1"""T
e-- I : • I
!~r
~
~
-, -', I
~J
~
=: :::; 0;:::: ,
" 1 ! l l
~.
0--
T
..,=-=:I 1 1
I ~
b 9
I
I
I
,i
J
' II I:J~ 0
I I
!
I
iI
, ..
P"""""% ?
.
I
Jf--------'~1_1 --1,';=ill- L
L~ :~:IDj
Reproduced from
best available copy.
D-7
SPRINKLER SYSTEM
LOBBY FLOOR
VI - 8
. ~-~-- -- ty.r---
r
i
I
l
=
•
.I
I
...J-...
L.- _....J
_~L---.J
'-----1""',- ~
ICI
='" :=.;
·I~~· . ... ,-:.
~;~
,, ,
-L-.
-_._--- --
Ir
i
--'- - - - --,.
o ,
I
t .
I "
-----=;;
D-8
SPRINKLER SYSTEM
TYPICAL TENANT FLOOR 2-10
VI - 9
y~i
e r
t.=iJ
I 1
b
I .tP1I 01 ......,. UllQlot
LC(»('!" to\o!llaltO WI ,~; co n PL~ lo4;[AC
0 t:W:O 00" ... , OlC Co/"'fII CIOH OltGIl"'l'
[1 I I
~
I
[j]
, I I
I,
,I
i
iI
I
,
!
Q 0
, I
0 •
'Oi'
I
i!I
1
1 i
T I
I
r-----a ~ 0-0 --_oo-----eo--c---_. 0
r=
I
I
1
,\ . I
;
, ......
~
L~---~r j I
t ,
i
,I
I
L-.1----./,---
r-'
1
.---" g
j g
~
I
11"1
T I
I
II
ti
i~:
I
,, I
1
I
D-9
SPRINK LER SYS TEM
TYPICAL TENANT FLOOR 11-16
VI - 10
r, --, ~ ~,: . -';}
i " [l cdi
'1· cJJ ,:.-
I
I
I
-~(--
- -=-~I
; _ .. - - '--
-----~
---'--
, >. .
, a.
I ' EO
o U
I ..= cu
-I
:
I -f~
~~
j'
lOra ,
"'-'
' a. III ,
f Q)Q)I
ll~-D l
=
..
---.--.:r-----
D-10
SPRINKLER SYSTEM
MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT PENTHOUSE
VI - 11
lI"T1oo----- TYPIClles;: V~LVE
~ VALVE I'll TM'lP8l SWiTCH
DO
CHECII VALVE-
FLOW SWlTCH-
"
Y
- - HOSE VALVE
FSP SIAMESE CONN
'- Pl'\ESS RELIEF VAl.VE
S"FIRE SERVICE--
FS-P SIAIo'ESE - - J '
~
D-ll
SPRINKLER SYSTEM
RISER DIAGRAM
VI - 12
l1ruwings 6 throughtt show the sprinlder installation de,11Cd for this b:J;;ding.
The system is hydraulically designed in aCCOrdflnCe with the requirements of the
National Fire Protection Association flnd all of the modcl codes with one
exception. The Standard Building Code requires that a secondary on-site source
of water be provided in all cases whereas the Basic Building Code and L'nifcrm
Building Code only impose this requirement in seism ic zones 2 and 3. In the
following differential cost analysis the added expense of providing a secondary
source of water has been identified.
Drawing 11 shows the fire standpipe and sprinkler riser diagram for the building.
[n both configurations this installation would be nearly identical. In the
sprinklered design the sprinkler supply run""Juts are equipped with automatic
supervision. In the unsprinklered design these connections would be required to
feed the firehose cabinets but would not be equipped with supervision devices.
The following cost analysis was prepared for the purpose of comparing the cost
of constructing the high-rise office building used for the study in sprinklered nnd
unsprinklered configurations. The costs represent national average costs in mid
1978 and therefore would differ somewhat in areas that have higher or lower
than average construction cost indexes. The analysis was prepared by Lothrop
.-\ssociates, Architects, assisted by Jaros, Baum and Bolles, Consulting Engineers
and the Turner Construction Company.
The following additional costs are associated with the unsprinklered version of
the building:
1. Fire Doors
Sub-total $ 54,582
Sub-total $ 62,978
VI -13.
3. Remote Control Smoke Vents (Other options
availnble that may be less costly)
Sub-total $345,382
Sub-total S 13,068
Sub-total S 3,993
7. Additional Fire Dampers
Dampers $ 12,000
General contractor's overhead
and profit @ 10% + 10% 2.520
Sub-total $ 14,520
VI - 14
9. Fire Alarm Pull -,:_cs
Sub-total $ 6.534
The following items are not required III the unsprinklered configuration:
Sub-total S348,480
Summary
Sub-total $573,657
vi-=-- 15
· e
Delete cost Items:
Tank $ 16,000
Additional piping, valves, etc. 5,000
Additional supporting structure 6,000
General contractor's overhead
and profit © 10% + 1096 5,670
-- -
S 32,670
Although the above cost comparison is based upon national average costs, the
conclusions that can be drawn from it would remain the same throughout the
nation. First, there is very little difference in the construction cost of a
sprinkle red and unsprinklered high-rise office building of this construction type
with perhaps a slightly lower cost for a sprinklered building particularly if a
secondary water supply is not required. Second, space planning within a
sprinklered building is more flexible than in a compartmented building becallse
of the elimination of fire separation walls.
During the course of the study the differences in certain operating costs were
investigated. While most operating costs were the sa me for sprinklered and
unsprinklered buildings some of the differences would be of interest to a building
owner.
Improved Risk 1\1 utuals, an insurance company, was asked to analyze and rate
both building designs and establish a fiie insurance rate for each. They
concluded that the insurance rate for the sprinkle red building would be about 25
percent lower than the rate for the unsprinklered building. \\'hile this may seem
significant, the fact is that well designed high-rise office buildings of either type
are very safe buildings as reflected in the actual cost difference of insuring the
two buildings of approximately $7,000 per year. This amounts to about two
cents per rental square foot per year in reduced insurance premiums. It should
also be noted that only one company of a highly specialized type was asked to
rate the buildings. Competition for actual business among several insurance
companies might change the picture somewhat.
The differenct~ in the maintenance cost for a smoke detect ion and manual fire
alarm system and a sprinkler system was found to be insignificant with the
former perhaps slightly higher because of the need to inspect and maintain the
smoke venting system.
,'-,-
VI ::. 16
A cost that is associld with 8. sprinklered building th. was impossible to
quanti fy but nevertheless must be considered by an owner is the Ii fe cycle cost
of moving sprinkler heads when II renovation teh:es place. While this mny not
be a significl:int cost in an owner-occupied building, it can become an appreciable
expense in a rental building with multiple tenants.
\\'hen the building was originally designed, it was to be constructed to meet the
requirements of the Type 2A, noncombustible, protected construction classifica-
tion because it was felt that at some time in the future all or parts of the
structure might be used for institutional purposes. The permitted construction
types for the multifamily residence occupancy classification do not meet the
requirements for an institutional occupancy. Therefore, in order to present a
more accurate picture of the economic impact of installing a sprinkler system
in this occupancy the construction classificetion has been changed to 28 for the
unsprinklered version and 2C, noncombustible, unprotected for the sprinklered
design.
The trade-offs offered in return for providing automatic fire protection in mid-
rise multifamily residential buildings while limited offer the designer of such a
building an interesting set of options. Basically there are three economically
significant trade-offs available for consideration. A one-story height increase
within a given construction classification, a floor area increase that varies with
the height of the proposed building within a given construction classification and
an increase in the permitted travel distance to a required exit. It is interesting
to note that while all of the model codes provide similar relief under normal
circumstances it would probably not be possible to take advantage of all of the
available trade-offs b.~"'use of zoning restrictions whicll2d toke precedence.
For example, there.... d be nothing gained from a perl1.ed height increase
from three stories to four stories in 8 residence zone that limited buildings to
two and one-half stories in height. On all but the very largest sites, tile
increased travel distance permitted in sprinklered buildings would probably not
provide much relief. Also, as a general rule, area and bulk restrictions combined
with the need to provide automobile parking and required open space inevitably
combine to reduce the a mount of construction that can be put on a given site
to far below what would be possible if only height and set-back requirements had
to be met.
The economic impact of three different sprinkler system designs were examined.
The first, a system in which only the corridors are sprinklered is of the type
required by the Federal Housing Administration ]l,linimum Property Standards for
all government financed multifamily housing. While systems of this type may
provide a certain level of protection, none of the model codes offer any trade-
orfs when such a system is provided. Thus, the additional cost of the system
is, by definition, a straight additional cost. Also, the fact that very few
apartment house fires start in corridors causes one to seriously question the
logic behind this F.H.A. requirement. Drawings D-l and D-2 show the system
design used for the study. While it is an economical system utilizing only 148
sprinkler heads and pipe sizes ranging from one inch to one and one-half inch,
its cost, $38,720 cannot be off-set as mentioned above.
The second system studied is a modified version of the first. In this system an
additional sprinkler head is installed just inside each corridor door. While the
logic behind the design of this type of system would seem to be an improvement
over a system in which only the corridors are sprinklered as virtually all
apartment house fires start within rooms, none of the model codes regard this
type of system as being adequate. Thus, no trade-offs are available to off -set
the cost of such a system. Because of the similarity between this system and
a corridor-only system, no additional drawings were prepared beyond sketches
for estimating purposes. The system utilizes 256 sprinkler heads and its cost has
been estimated at $58,080.
Drawings D-3 and D-4 show the fully sprinklered design use for this study. The
system meets all of the requirements of the National Fire Protection Association
and thus is in conformance with all of the model building codes. The system
utilizes 880 sprinkler heads and pipe sizes range from two inches to one inch.
The total estimated cost of the system is $137,940. However, as was mentioned
above, one very important trade-off could be utilized to off -set the cost of the
system. By changing from noncombustible, protected to noncombustible,
VI - 18
."
r.r--:-i~
~
~ L~~n~ ~
i J ..
-
-,
n,:
J
I
II
C ;
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
..
:>
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
__ J
, ,,
,,
-"
".. ,\
VI - 19
·.....
~
VI - 20
.....
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
.....
I
I
m I
I
I
/ • ...J
/
/
1
...............-L __ ../
VI - 21
."
~
51
.."
c
~
......
N
• :z;
0 W ~
[-l 0
'- '<t
tf)
>-'
'J)
0
L:.
L:.
I ~
0 f-<
~
~
-
....:l U
0.. :l.
~ >-'
0 !-<
U
.6.
:>
i
..0"
.,...
VI - 22
•
r---- i ~~C\!i\)M.&t;j';!'~\DlTr~~'1>"ij@;::"r!i~'
I '1 I"SiGHT GLASS
CHECK VALVE
TO SPRINKLER
L
--0.- - - - /}f=" WATER FLOW DETECTOR
SYSTEM
I
"
.
A
t3f~ I r O.S.BlV. SHUT OFF VALVE
TO FIRE HOSE CABINET
(NO HOSE CABINET IF
o SLEEVE
D-5
RISER DIAGRAM
VI - 23
unprotected constructio.a cost saving of $1.52 per sq ft e be reAlized. As
the gross building area is approximately 98,000 sq ft. this trElnslntes to a
construction cost saving of $148,960. The model codes also permit the
elimination of fire hose cabinets in fUlly sprinklcrcd buildings which would
produce an additional saving of $4,356. Thus, the totHl sBving, $153,316 more
than off -sets the cost of the sprinkler system in this particular set of
circumstances.
Sub-total $ 38,720
Code permitted trade-offs -0-
Sub-total S 58,080
Code permitted trade-offs -0-
---
Total additional cost $ 58,080
Sub-total $137,940
Code permitted trade-offs -0-
Reduction in construction requirements
98,000 sq ft @ $1.52 ($148.960)
ElirT'iilate fire hose cabinets
12 @ $363 (4,356)
Sub-total (S153,316)
VI - 24
- e
Once again, the reader is reminded that the above findings reflect El particular
set of circumstances and cannot be used to reAch a gener,:tl conclusion.
However, experience with this and other similar projects leads to the opinion
that the trade-offs available in the model codes would permit an owner or
developer to install an automatic fire suppression system in a multifamily
residential building under many circumstances without increasing the construc-
tion cost.
The building used a:; the prototype for this case study was completed in mid 1979
and contained a branch bank on the ground floor and bank offices on the second
floor. The building was, however, quite small so for the purpose of this study
it was increased in size from 4,400 gross sq ft to 10,000 gross sq ft in order to
present a more realistic idea of the cost of providing .. an automatic fire
protection system in this typical building type.
For buildings of the size, occupancy and construction type used in this case
study, none of the model building codes offer any meaningful trade-orrs to
reduce the additional cost of a sprinkler system. However, although not
considered in this case study, a building of this size and occupancy could be built
of unprotected wood frame construction outside of a fire district if it was
equipped with sprinklers. If it was not so equipped, it would not be permit ted
by the model codes. If this trade-off option had been used, the building
construction cost could have been reduced by considerably more than the cost
of the fire protection system. However, as buildings of this type are normally
located within a fire district, the use of noncombustible construction is more
rea list ic.
The sprinkler system designed for this case study is a hydraulically calculated
system that meets the requirements of National Fire Protection Association
Code 13 and is acceptable under all of the model codes. Drawings 1 and 2 show
the sprinkler system design used for this case study. The design area of
application is 1,500 sq ft and the area covered per sprinkler is 130 sq ft for the
mercantile space and 225 sq ft for the office space. The incoming water service
is four inch pipe. Distribution piping ranges in size from three inches to one
inch. Drawing 3 shows the riser diagra m for the syste m.
VI~- 25
• •
As mentioned above, the model codes did not provide an:,!st reducing trade-
ofCs for buildings of this type that could be taken advantage of using this
building design. There is one possible saving offered that could be taken
advantage of if the building were sprinklered and the top floor were occupied by
more than one tenant. If the space were divided for two or more tenants, a
corridor connecting the two exits would have to be provided. In an unsprinklered
building the corridor walls would be required to have a one-hour fire rating
whereas in a sprinklered building this requirement is waived. Although this
would appear to provide some cost savings, the fact is that the least expensive
corridor wall construction, steel studs and gypsum board, can provide the
necessary fire rating at little or no increase in cost over an unrated wall.
The significant cost saving is obtained through a reduction in both owner's and
tenant's insurance rates. An estimate obtained indicated a premium reduction
to the owner in the area of $2,000 per year which would mean that the cost of
a sprinkler system would be covered in about four years. If the owner were also
the tenant the payback period would be even shorter. If the owner were not the
tenant, the reduced insurance rates available to the tenant might induce him to
rent space or possibly to pay a slightly higher rent.
....
VI726
•
,.'
; '.-,
VI - 27
• •
. :i iI
:~I ::
-3" SPK, ON
AlARMBEl~
~- WATER SUPPLY
F.D, CONN, REFER TO RISER DIA
o 5 10 15 20
15""'"'''\",,,,•.-., 1'" !*~;::;;I
• -;, I
VI - 28
D-l
GROUND FLOOR SPRINKLER SYSTEM
•
I,!I
I
"
<>--4l---+-- CALCULATED AREA 1500 FT. 2
SPACING AT 225 FT 2
I
!
L__ I·
i
I
I
I,
I
!
Ii
II
I
i!
,i
II
:;J"\;, '~
II
-2 SPK DN
o 5 10 15 20
'''I.J!?$HiI
VI - 29
D-2
SECOND FLOOR SPRINKLER SYSTEM
':
f
~ !:
t
\
.
D -3
RISER DIAGRAM
VI - 30