PHOENIX PETROLEUM PHILIPPINES INC

DEMURRAGE CLAIM REVIEW

CLAIMANT CHELSEA SHIPPING CORP. REF. NO. BS NO. 8140000004

VESSEL DONATELA VOY. NO. 17
LOADPORT PBR LOADING LAYCAN Aug. 30, 2016
DISPORT 1 DAVAO
DISPORT 2 CALACA

COMPUTATION DD HH MM
A. Loadport PBR
End: Vessel Released Sep,2016 01 : 13 : 30
Start: NOR Tendered Aug,2016 30 : 17 : 50
Loading Laytime 31 : 19 : 40
B. Disport 1 DAVAO
End: Vessel Released Sep,2016 06 : 17 : 00
Start: NOR Tendered Sep,2016 04 : 19 : 00
Discharging Laytime 31 : 22 : 00
B. Disport 2 CALACA
End: Vessel Released Sep,2016 11 : 06 : 15
Start: NOR Tendered Sep,2016 09 : 18 : 00
Discharging Laytime 31 : 12 : 15
Total Laytime Consumed 04 : 05 : 55
Less: Laytime for ship's account (see attachment 1) 30 : 06 : 24
Less: Allowed Laytime 03 : 12 : 00
Total Excess Laytime 30 : 11 : 31
Demurrage Rate, ₱/hr 23,500.00
Demurrage, ₱ 270,641.67

Remarks: CSC claim is ₱1,680,532.00 vs PNX computation of ₱270,641.67.

REASONS FOR DELAY FROM TO DURATION

Awaiting berthing advice at loadport, PBR 29-Aug-16 23:54 30-Aug-16 00:00 30 : 00 : 06
Awaiting surveyor to board at loadport, PBR 30-Aug-16 03:42 30-Aug-16 03:45 30 : 00 : 03
Awaiting to commence loading at loadport, PBR 30-Aug-16 11:38 30-Aug-16 11:50 30 : 00 : 12
Temporary stop due to shifting of shore tanks at loadport, PBR 30-Aug-16 15:55 30-Aug-16 20:32 30 : 04 : 37
Awaiting surveyor to board at disport, Davao 05-Sep-16 10:42 05-Sep-16 10:45 30 : 00 : 03
Awaiting to commence discharging at disport, Davao 05-Sep-16 14:54 05-Sep-16 15:00 30 : 00 : 06
Awaiting hose disconnection at disport, Davao 06-Sep-16 14:40 06-Sep-16 14:54 30 : 00 : 14
Awaiting surveyor to board vessel at disport, Calaca 09-Sep-16 20:00 09-Sep-16 20:27 30 : 00 : 27
Temporary stop due to line displacement at disport, Calaca 09-Sep-16 23:42 10-Sep-16 07:18 30 : 07 : 36
TOTAL 30 : 13 : 24
###
PREPARED BY: NOTED BY: APPROVED BY:

M.J. G. QUINTO/R. M. A. ROSARIO J. H. C. YAP M. R. A. ROS

C.A.P. DIONISIO
 PHOENIX PETROLEUM PHILIPPINES INC
DEMURRAGE CLAIM REVIEW

CLAIMANT CHELSEA SHIPPING CORP. REF. NO. BS NO. 8140000004

VESSEL DONATELA VOY. NO. 17
LOADPORT PBR LOADING LAYCAN Aug. 30, 2016
DISPORT 1 DAVAO
DISPORT 2 CALACA

ATTACHMENT 1
Total Laytime for ship's account
B. Awaiting vessel's readiness to berth at loadport, PBR
End Pilot on board Aug,2016 30 : 01 : 18
Start Received advise to berth Aug,2016 30 : 00 : 00
Awaiting vessel's readiness to berth at loadport, PBR 30 : 01 : 18
B. Shifting in at loadport, PBR
End Properly secured Aug,2016 30 : 03 : 12
Start Pilot on board Aug,2016 30 : 01 : 18
Shifting in at loadport, PBR 30 : 01 : 54
C. Awaiting gangway down at loadport, PBR
End Gangway down Aug,2016 30 : 03 : 42
Start Properly secured Aug,2016 30 : 03 : 12
Awaiting gangway down at loadport, PBR 30 : 00 : 30
D. Shifting in at loadport, Davao
End All fast Sep,2016 05 : 10 : 36
Start Pilot on board Sep,2016 05 : 09 : 30
Shifting in at loadport, Davao 30 : 01 : 06
D. Awaiting gangway down at disport, Davao
End Gangway down Sep,2016 05 : 10 : 42
Start All fast Sep,2016 05 : 10 : 36
Awaiting gangway down at disport, Davao 30 : 00 : 06
D. Shifting in at disport, Calaca
End All fast Sep,2016 09 : 19 : 48
Start Pilot on board Sep,2016 09 : 18 : 30
Shifting in at disport, Calaca 30 : 01 : 18
D. Awaiting gangway down at disport, Calaca
End Gangway down Sep,2016 09 : 20 : 00
Start All fast Sep,2016 09 : 19 : 48
Awaiting gangway down at disport, Calaca 30 : 00 : 12
F. Excess discharging time from guaranteed
Discharging Time at Disport, Davao
End: Completed discharging Sep,2016 06 : 14 : 06
Start: Commence discharging Sep,2016 05 : 15 : 00
Discharging Time at Disport, Davao 30 : 23 : 06
Discharging Time at Disport, Calaca
End: Completed discharging Sep,2016 11 : 04 : 18
Start: Commence discharging Sep,2016 09 : 23 : 12
Discharging Time at Disport, Calaca 31 : 05 : 06
Less: Line displacement at disport, Calaca
End: Resumed discharging Sep,2016 10 : 07 : 18
Start: Temporary stop Sep,2016 09 : 23 : 42
Line displacement at disport, Calaca 30 : 07 : 36
Less: Allowed Discharging Time 01 : 16 : 00
Excess discharging time from guaranteed 30 : 00 : 00
Laytime for ship's account 30 : 06 : 24
 March 22, 2017

Chelsea Shipping Corp.

26th Floor, Fort Legend Towers,
3rd Ave. corner 31st St., Bonifacio Global City,
1634 Taguig City

ATTN: Maximo S. Alquiros

Your Ref : BS NO. 8140000004 - Demurrage Claim for M/T Donatela v. 17

This is to inform you that our review of loading and discharging activities of Donatela v. 17 shows that excess
laytime is 11H 31M instead of 30M. Difference is due to the following:
● Placing of gangway and excess discharging time should be for the ship's account.
Based on our below computation, demurrage due should be ₱270,641.67 instead of ₱1,680,532.00.

COMPUTATION
A. Loadport PBR
End: Vessel Released Sep, 2016 01 : 13 : 30
Start: NOR Tendered ###
Loading Laytime 31 : 19 : 40
B. Disport 1 DAVAO
End: Vessel Released Sep, 2016 06 : 17 : 00
Start: NOR Tendered Sep, 2016 04 : 19 : 00
Discharging Laytime 31 : 22 : 00
B. Disport 2 CALACA
End: Vessel Released Sep, 2016 11 : 06 : 15
Start: NOR Tendered Sep, 2016 09 : 18 : 00
Discharging Laytime 31 : 12 : 15
Total Laytime Consumed 04 : 05 : 55
Less: Laytime for ship's account (see attachment 1) 30 : 06 : 24
Less: Allowed Laytime 03 : 12 : 00
Total Excess Laytime 30 : 11 : 31
Demurrage Rate, ₱/hr 23,500.00
Demurrage, ₱ 270,641.67

We will pay only ₱ 270,641.67 for BS NO. 8140000004.

Very truly yours,

mjgq/rmar John Henry C. Yap

cc: CAVD/DGF/MRAR Trading Manager

Received by:

Name/Date
ATTACHMENT 1
Total Laytime for ship's account
A. Awaiting start of laycan, vessel arrived (Aug. 22-23, 2016) before laycan at loadport, Subic
End Start of laycan Aug,2016 23 : 00 : 00
Start NOR Tendered Aug,2016 22 : 09 : 35
Awaiting start of laycan, vessel arrived (Aug. 22-23, 2016) before laycan at loadport, 30 : 14 : 25
B. Shifting in at loadport, PBR
End Properly secured Aug,2016 30 : 03 : 12
Start Pilot on board Aug,2016 30 : 01 : 18
Shifting in at loadport, PBR 30 : 01 : 54
C. Awaiting gangway down at loadport, PBR
End Gangway down Aug,2016 30 : 03 : 42
Start Properly secured Aug,2016 30 : 03 : 12
Awaiting gangway down at loadport, PBR 30 : 00 : 30
D. Shifting in at loadport, Davao
End All fast Sep,2016 05 : 10 : 36
Start Pilot on board Sep,2016 05 : 09 : 30
Shifting in at loadport, Davao 30 : 01 : 06
E. Shifting at disport, CMC
End Properly secured Aug,2016 29 : 06 : 58
Start Anchor aweigh Aug,2016 29 : 06 : 10
Shifting at disport, CMC 30 : 00 : 48
E. Excess discharging time from guaranteed
Discharging Time at Disport, Davao
End: Completed discharging Sep,2016 06 : 14 : 06
Start: Commence discharging Sep,2016 05 : 15 : 00
Discharging Time at Disport, Davao 30 : 23 : 06
Discharging Time at Disport, CMC
End: Completed discharging Aug,2016 29 : 12 : 40
Start: Commence discharging Aug,2016 29 : 09 : 35
Discharging Time at Disport, CMC 30 : 03 : 05
Less: Temporary stop as per shore request at disport, HMC
End: Resumed discharging Aug,2016 27 : 14 : 05
Start: Temporary stop Aug,2016 27 : 13 : 24
Temporary stop as per shore request at disport, HM 30 : 00 : 41
Less: Temporary stop as per ship's request at disport, CMC
End: Resumed discharging Aug,2016 29 : 10 : 14
Start: Temporary stop Aug,2016 29 : 09 : 50
Temporary stop as per ship's request at disport, CM 30 : 00 : 24
Less: Allowed Discharging Time
Ship's Figure AfterKL
Loading (SFAL) KL 1,093.172
Guaranteed pumping KL/hr
rate (G) KL/hr 200
Guaranteed discharging time 30 : 05 : 28
Excess discharging time from guaranteed 30 : 00 : 00
Laytime for ship's account 30 : 06 : 24