Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
) de Wit)
As an Alternative Source of Floor Wax
A Research Paper
Presented to the Science Faculty
Leyte Normal University
Presented by:
Carreon, Jhanver A.; Lazaro, John Patrick G.; Libutan, Joelour D.
March 2011
APPROVAL SHEET
PANEL OF EXAMINERS
Examined and approved by the Panel of Examiners on March 31, 2011 with a
grade of .
The main objective of this study was to determine the possibility of producing an
acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax that can be an alternative to the present commercial floor
wax in terms of its use in a concrete smooth cemented pavement. Three floor waxes were
compared; two were Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and mature leaves and the third one
is the commercial floor wax. The floor waxes from young and mature leaves of Ipil-Ipil
were statistically compared in their acceptability as basis for determining the more
acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax in terms of five quality attributes – color, odor, texture,
luster, general acceptability.
The samples of this study consisted of two (2) Ipil-Ipil trees randomly and
purposively selected from the town of Marabut, Samar, Philippines. The respondents
involve in this study consisted of 15 janitors of the Leyte Normal University who
responded to Ipil-Ipil floor wax Acceptability Measure. The pertinent findings of this
study are (1) both the two Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and mature leaves were
acceptable floor wax in terms of color, odor, texture, luster, general acceptability when
applied in a concrete cemented smooth pavement and (2) there is no significant
difference between the acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and mature leaves and
the commercial floor wax in terms of effectiveness/acceptability in a concrete cemented
smooth pavement.
The results further verifies that the Ipil-Ipil floor wax is at par with the
commercial floor wax and can be a potential alternative in terms of acceptability and
effectiveness of its use in a concrete smooth cemented pavement.
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The researchers are extremely grateful to the many individuals mentioned below
The researchers’ adviser, Mr. Mel Brian D. Berida for his moral support and
To Mrs. Ma. Victoria D. Naboya for her unselfish and critical evaluation and
The Chairman and members of the Panel of Examiners, Prof. Leslie D. Radaza,
Prof. Milagros A. Lumpas, and Mr. Facundo Rey M. Ladiao for their constructive
University for allowing the researchers to conduct data collection inside the University.
To Mrs. Josephine Go, Janitorial Services Supervisor and the 15 janitors of Leyte
Normal University, for their unfailing support and cooperation in the collection of data
Special thanks to, Mr. Christian G. Abalos for his suggestions, assistance and for
analyzing the data needed for the completion of the research study.
Above all to the Almighty GOD for giving the researchers the knowledge and
determination and for the guidance and blessings HE bestowed upon the researchers.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Title Page
APPROVAL SHEET
ABSTRACT-------------------------------------------------------------------------- iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT --------------------------------------------------------- iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS---------------------------------------------------------- v
Chapter
1 The Problem
Definition of Terms 7
3 Methodology
v
Research Locale ---------------------------------------------------- 18
Procedure ----------------------------------------------------------- 20
Hypothesis One----------------------------------------------------- 26
Summary ----------------------------------------------------------- 35
Conclusion --------------------------------------------------------- 37
Implication --------------------------------------------------------- 37
Recommendation -------------------------------------------------- 38
Bibliography
Appendices
vi
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE
1 Distributions of Samples
vii
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE
3 Double Boiler
4 Sample Ipil-Ipil leaves - (A) 200g young leaves, (B) 200g mature Leaves
11 A and B
12 B and C
13 A, B and C
viii
LIST OF APPENDIX TABLES
APPENDIX TABLE
ix
Chapter 1
The Problem
Floor waxes’ and polishes’ evident use and benefits to man are undeniable.
Processed products from petroleum, particularly floor waxes and polishers are popularly
Paulsen (1999) as cited by Larsson, et.al (2009) stated that, “Two of the more
common floor care methods currently in use are wax treatment and polishing. Both
methods entail the floor being given a basic treatment on installation, during which a
protective layer of wax or polish is applied. This is followed by frequent care up until the
floor needs to be restored to its original condition through what is referred to as periodic
maintenance.”
In connection to floor care methods, the researchers have known one unusual but
common practice inside classrooms of one town in Eastern Samar, Philippines. This
practice involves the use of Ipil-Ipil (Leucaena leucocephala) leaves in waxing and
polishing a concrete cemented smooth pavement. The continued application and rubbing
of Ipil-Ipil leaves against the concrete smooth pavement results into a shiny colored-
green floor. Being a natural, safe and eco-friendly method, this practice has been
The use of commercial floor wax on the other hand shows some disadvantages.
Due to some of the wax’s synthetic constituents, it is difficult to ignore certain illness
related to chemical sensitivity that might be brought to people using this product.
Similarly, the commercial floor wax’s market value might be the reason for some people
As evidence of this, Paulsen (2008) as cited by Larsson, et.al (2009) agrees that,
It is further stated that, “When the floor undergoes wear, the chemicals that have
been bound to the floor through the periodic maintenance can be released into the air.
cleaners contain a number of chemicals. These chemicals can be hazardous to your health
and are not necessary to have a clean home. Making your own household cleaners saves
money and ensures the ingredients are natural. Homemade floor wax smells good, is
great for wood floor finishes and is good for the environment.”
For these reasons, the researchers would like to produce floor wax from leaves of
L. leucocephala tree.
This study sought to produce floor wax from leaves of Leucaena leucocephala
tree.
2
1. Which type of Ipil-Ipil leaves (young or mature) can produce a more acceptable floor
wax in terms of the quality attributes – color, odor, texture, luster, general
acceptability?
2. Is there a significant difference between the more acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax from
Hypotheses
The following null hypotheses have been set for this study:
Hο1: None of the two Ipil-Ipil leaves (i.e. young and mature) can yield a more
Hο2: There is no significant difference between the more acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax
pavement.
3
Conceptual Framework
Ipil-Ipil leaves show a potential source for floor wax production. It has been
assumed in this study that Ipil-Ipil leaves be the independent variable and the quality of
the floor wax produced be the dependent variable. Furthermore, this undertaking
considered the possibility that the quality of floor wax produced from leaves of Ipil-Ipil
be affected or altered by some intervening variables such as the kind of Ipil–Ipil leaves
used (either mature or young) and the ingredients (e.g. carnauba wax) that will constitute
4
Significance of the Study
Petroleum is one of the valuable assets of human beings. Petroleum or crude oil
showed its potential in producing various products which is very much useful in the
kerosene, diesel, lubricating oil-stocks and tar. Far be it, waxes are also produced from
processed petroleum.
As evidence of this, The New Encyclopedia Britannica (1993) adds that, “About
90 percent of the wax used for commercial purposes is recovered from petroleum by
dewaxing lubricating oil stocks.” These waxes include the commercial floor waxes in
most markets.
all by-products of petroleum including floor waxes may come into unavailability due to
The main burden of this investigation was to find out an alternative source of
The researchers believe that this study is deemed significant to the following
persons:
Teachers and Students. Particularly those practicing the use of Ipil-Ipil leaves as floor
wax. Findings of the study could be use as basis for either continuing or ending the
aforementioned practice.
Parents and community. This study will also increase the awareness of parents and the
community towards the possible use of Ipil-Ipil leaves as a source of floor wax.
5
Commercial industries. It has been with optimism that this investigation was undertaken
Agricultural sectors. It is hoped that from the findings of this study, farmers and those
concerned with agriculture will value the worth of Ipil-Ipil tree and continue
Other researchers. If it is realized, this study may also be used as springboard by other
The main focus of this study was to determine the possibility of producing floor
wax out of leaves of Ipil-Ipil (Leucaena leucocephala) tree. This inquiry is limited to
purely producing floor wax from Ipil-Ipil (L. leucocephala) leaves and its use on a
Geographically, this study was confined to the Ipil-Ipil trees situated in Marabut,
Samar, Philippines and the sample leaves of Ipil-Ipil were taken from and were limited to
two (2) Ipil-Ipil trees, purposively selected in order to make the study more manageable.
Area and Leyte Normal University (LNU) Science Laboratory accessibility were also
The researchers conducted and concluded the investigation during the 2nd
6
Definition of Terms
To provide a common frame of reference to those who may read this research, the
Floor wax. A preparation containing wax and used to polish and preserve the finish of
floors.
Philippines.
Mature leaves. As used in this study refers to the green, tender leaves found at the
Young leaves. As used in this study refers to the yellow-green, soft leaves found at the
7
Chapter 2
The researchers are not aware of any study concerned or conducted on producing
floor wax from leaves of Ipil-Ipil (Leucaena leucocephala) tree, nor on the possibility of
producing such product from Ipil-Ipil leaves. Hence, readings presented in this Chapter
This part of the chapter presents a review of what Ipil-Ipil (L. leucocephala) is, its
The species of Leucaena leucocephala has been world widely known for its many
In the Philippines, this species of trees is locally known as Ipil-Ipil. The tree
grows gregariously and in abundance mostly found in the settled areas at low and
medium altitudes. It is now pan tropic in distribution since its introduction from tropical
America many years ago (Bureau of Plant Industry (BPI) of the Department of
Agriculture).
Today, Ipil-Ipil tree in the Philippines is generally and popularly valued for
firewood and in reforestation work. The plant is also much used as a cover crop and is a
good exterminator of “kogon”. The bark is valued for its significant potential in
producing brown dye while the seeds of Ipil–Ipil in some provinces are used as coffee
substitute.
A. Botanic Description.
shrubby and highly branched (ssp. Leucocephala) to medium-sized tree with a short, clear
bole to 5 m, upright angular branching and a narrow open crown (ssp. Glabrata), 3-
15(max. 20) m tall, bole diameter 10-50 cm. Bark on young branches smooth, grey-
brown, slash salmon pink, darker grey-brown and rougher with shallow, rusty orange-
brown vertical fissures and deep red inner bark on older branches and bole. This
evergreen plant is deep rooted. It often has a combination of flowers, immature and
small tree, 2 to 6 meters high. The leaves are compound, 15 to 25 centimeters long, with
hairy rachises. The pinnae are 8 to 16, and 5 to 8 centimeters long. The leaflets are 20 to
30, linear-oblong, and 7 to 12 millimeters in length. The heads are solitary, at the axils of
the leaves, long-peduncled, globose, and 2 to 5 centimeters in diameter, with many white
flowers. The pods are thin, flat, strap-shaped, 12 to 18 centimeters long, and 1.4 to 2
seeds.
B. Morphological Constituents/Composition
To define and identify the different constituents of Ipil-Ipil tree, specifically the
major composition of its leaves (either young or mature), which was the main focus of
the study; certain studies conducted all over the world were taken into account.
9
Numerous researches had already been conducted to determine the composition of
the leaves of L. leucocephala. Findings of such researches do confirm the potential use of
the tree’s leaves as edible forage for animals and as safe food for human consumption
based on the leaves nutritive portions and components. Results also show a wide variety
of chemical compounds in the leaves which might be the reason for its many uses and
application.
Duke (1983) of Purdue University of West Lafayette, Indiana, U.S. noted that,
most leaves of L. leucocephala contain traces of glucoside quercetrin about 0.08 percent
and in every g of N, there are 294 mg of arginine, 88 cystine, 125 histidine, 563
isoleucine, 469 leucine, 313 lycine, 100 methionine, 188 methionine + cystine, 294
It is further reported that, raw young leaves show a potential source as forage for
ruminant animals, containing per 100 g edible portion: 68 calories, 79.5 percent moisture,
2.9 g protein, 0.8 g fat, 15.3 g total carbohydrate, 1.8 g fiber, 1.5 g ash, 553 mg Ca, and
51 mg P. Raw, tender tops and pods contain per 100 g edible portion: 59 calories, 80.7
percent moisture, 8.4 g protein, 0.9 g fat, 8.8 g total carbohydrate, 3.8 g fiber, 1.2 g ash,
137 mg Ca, 11 mg P. 9.2 mg Fe, 4,730 mg b-carotene equivalent, 0.09 mg riboflavin, 5.4
mg niacin, and 8 mg ascorbic acid. The genus Leucaena is also reported to contain
Accordingly, the crude protein (CP) of edible material (leaves and small stems) of
L. leucocephala ranged from 14-30%. The high crude protein in leucaena relative to
grass highlights the importance of maintaining adequate quantities of high protein legume
10
in the pasture and in the diet (Khamseekhiew et al. (2001) as cited by Aganga and
Tshwenyane, 2003).
various localities in Western Nigeria shows that young leaves, pods and seeds contain
more crude protein but lower crude fibre and ether extract than mature ones. The crude
fat component was higher in the seeds (4.6% and 5.5% for green and ripe seeds,
respectively) than in any other edible part of the plant, while the green and brown seed
coats contain the least amount of ether extract and total ash. The mineral composition of
the dry matter of mature leaves is 2.8% calcium, 0.26% phosphorus, 0.37% magnesium,
2010).
The primary wax that coats leaves of most plants found in family Fabaeae in
Leucaena leucocephala has a wide variety of uses and it was this multiplicity of
roles that led to the worldwide reputation of the species as a ‘miracle tree’ Brewbaker and
Shelton (1994).
It is further stated that, “the leaves of leucaena are highly nutritious for ruminants
and many excellent animal production data have been published confirming the fodder
heating value, and makes excellent charcoal, producing little ash and smoke. It also can
be used for parquet flooring and small furniture as well as for paper pulp.”
The plant is also valued in the production of necklaces from seeds and the use of
young leaves and seeds as vegetables for human consumption. Young green pods can be
split open and the fresh immature seeds eaten raw or cooked. Only small amounts can be
eaten in this way because of the presence in seed and young growth of the toxic amino
acid mimosine. L. leucocephala will occasionally produce a gum similar to gum Arabic
Furthermore, red, brown and black dyes are extracted from the pods, leaves and
The New Encyclopedia Britannica (1993) states that, “wax is any class of pliable
substance of animals, plants, minerals, or synthetic origin that differs from fats in being
less greasy, harder and more brittle and in containing principally compounds of high
molecular weight. Waxes melt at moderate temperature and form hard films that can be
polished to a high gloss, making them ideal for use in a wide array of polishes.”
production of waxes. Paraffin is one type of Petroleum wax that is commercially used in
manufacturing candles, crayons and industrial polishes. It assists and supplies a water
applications to resilient flooring such as vinyl tile or wood to maintain a clean and
sanitary appearance in high traffic public areas. The polish is cleaned and buffed, often
daily, to restore the shine, and then periodically stripped and re-applied. Longer
maintenance intervals are often preferred, to minimize labor costs, but only if the polish
Waxes and polishes satisfy man of his demands for a clean and shiny floor. These
home cleaning materials are often used not only in improving the floor’s attribute
qualities but also in restoring the floor’s durability especially for wood floorings.
As evidence of this, Radaza and Amante et.al (2008) noted that, floor wax is
important for housekeeping. It is used in coating to protect floors. Because waxes are
insoluble in the water, they are particularly useful for water proofing. Some plastics have
characteristics, and maybe blended with waxes, add glass, durability and increase
toughness. To make floor wax is very easy. In order to save money from buying
commercial and costly floor wax, we should learn how to make a cheap and easy to use
floor wax.
SpecialChem S.A. (2010) adds that, “wax surface modifiers satisfy many of the
performance demands of a floor polish. Proper selection and usage will control how the
polish responds to buffing; minimize black heel marks; and provide slip control, i.e. the
proper coefficient of friction to provide traction for foot traffic in wet or dry conditions.
13
By enhancing mar, scratch, and abrasion resistance, the surface modifier may also extend
Most commercial products especially synthetic ones (which might also be true for
waxes and polishes) are composed of some harmful compounds that might cause illness
among consumers.
In fact, the use of floor waxes and polishes is quite dangerous as claimed by the
such as floor waxes and polishes often contain mineral spirits and petroleum solvents,
both of which are neurotoxin and can cause severe eye and skin irritation as well as
Stoddard solvent which is also neurotoxin. Petroleum solvents may contain traces of
carcinogenic benzene. Some wax removers with ammonia contain tripropylene glycol
monomethyl ether which can cause narcosis and kidney injury with repeated and
C. Future Expectations
The call for a more natural, safer and acceptable way of maintaining the
cleanliness and durability of most floors must be world widely addressed to the
manufacturing industries.
Moreover, the use and addition of some harmful chemicals to floor wax and
polish making shall be banned and stopped, if not, at least strictly monitored by the
authorities responsible in securing the health and safety of consumers of the product.
14
Addressing the need of limiting the use and incorporation of harmful and toxic
compounds to floor waxes and polishes, SpecialChem S.A. (2010) testifies the notion
1. The nature of the sanitary maintenance market, of which floor wax and polish is a
Increasingly, the industry is adopting safer methods and materials to mitigate the
risks.
2. Today's floor polishes which include floor waxes are expected to be free of
The Ipil-Ipil (Leucaena leucocephala) tree has been considered as the ‘miracle
tree’ because of its variety of uses. Its value either locally or in global perspective cannot
Fat, crude fiber, nitrogen free material other than fiber, nitrogen, sucrose, water
histidine, isoleucene, phenylalanine, etc. It also contains high protein and nutritive value
Waxes on the other hand are pliable and insoluble in water. They are less greasy,
harder and more brittle than fats. Nonetheless, waxes and fats share common
characteristics.
15
Since Ipil-Ipil leaves contain epicuticular waxes such as paraffin and fats, which
might be in large quantity. Then it might be the reason why the concrete cemented
To this extent, the researchers assumed that the epicuticular wax and other wax-
like components and constituents of Ipil-Ipil leaves can be a source of and utilized to
16
Chapter 3
Methodology
Research Design
apart from the routine of ordinary living and by manipulating one or more independent
different treatments and then studies their effects. Results of this type are likely to lead to
Specifically, the research design that the researchers applied in this undertaking is
groups to be considered and include in the experiment. The researcher or researchers are
allowed to measure not only the main effect of each independent variable (e.g. the effects
of kind, quantity of leaves used, production process, ingredients used in the quality of
Ipil-Ipil floor wax) but also the interaction effects of these independent variables.
The term factorial denotes that two or more independent variables are being
investigated, each variable or whether or not the effects are specific levels of the control
variable.
In this research undertaking, more than two variables are considered and
manipulated, interactions between them might also be present and their effects to one
sampling. Samples of this inquiry were randomly and purposively selected in order to
make the study more manageable. Due to some factors that cause variations among the
different samples of the study, the researchers randomly selected Ipil-Ipil trees by
categorizing and classifying them based on their age and condition-young or mature.
From this randomly classified Ipil-Ipil trees, two (2) were purposively selected as
subjects of the study based on the quality of leaves produced specifically, one (1) young
Research Locale
This study was confined to the Ipil-Ipil trees situated in Marabut, Samar,
18
More so, the Ipil-Ipil trees in the town grow in abundance and was easily categorized and
The freshness and the virginity of the environment to which the Ipil-Ipil trees
grow were also considered in the selection of the locale of the study.
The samples that were used, manipulated and studied in this undertaking
comprised Ipil-Ipil leaves. Thus, data needed for the pursuit of this study was gathered
and collected from the two (2) Ipil-Ipil trees randomly and purposively selected from the
town of Marabut, Samar, Philippines. Two (2) Ipil-Ipil trees were young and mature. Of
the two Ipil-Ipil trees, leaves were gathered in a quantity of about 200 g each.
Particularly, 200 g of young leaves, and 200 g of mature leaves of Ipil-Ipil tree. This data
Young 200 g
Mature 200 g
19
Instruments, Apparatus, and Equipment
The materials used in this study are presented and enumerated in the following
illustration. These materials were arranged in such a way to give the prospective readers
an idea of what were utilized and manipulated in producing floor wax from leaves of Ipil-
Ipil tree. These materials include fresh leaves of Ipil-Ipil (i.e. young and mature), water,
Illustration: Water
Ipil - Ipil leaves - 200 g (for each type i.e. young, and mature)
The instruments, apparatus, and equipment used in this inquiry are hereby
mentioned. Things used in producing floor wax from leaves of Ipil-Ipil includes a pot,
bowl, freezer bag, towel, rolling pin, wooden spoon, glass jar, funnel, stove, and gloves.
Procedure
The entire experimentation which includes the set-up and reactions was
performed at room temperature and at atmospheric pressure. It has been designed by the
researchers to divide the entire experimental procedure into two parts. Particularly,
starting from Part I which is the preparation of the Ipil-Ipil leaves (i.e. young and mature
leaves) followed by Part II which is the production of floor wax using the Ipil-Ipil leaves
in Part I.
20
Furthermore, no alterations or further purifications were employed to the
materials used in this study except the Ipil-Ipil leaves which undergone the process of
cleansing with water as prescribed and designed by the researchers. The general
1. Each of the two (2) – 200 g Ipil-Ipil leaves (i.e. young, mature leaves) was
2. Leaves of each young and mature Ipil-Ipil were removed and separated from the
3. Washed Ipil-Ipil leaves were placed accordingly in two bowls, each of which is
1. A double boiler using a cooking pot and an oven-safe bowl was used. Tap water
was poured into the pot, the bowl on the other hand was placed on top of the pot.
2. The double boiler was then placed on the top of the stove over low flame.
3. Two (170) g of Carnauba wax were broken up and placed into the bowl. There
should be small pieces of Carnauba wax. Hence, it was first placed into a freezer
bag, zipped-in-closed, covered with a kitchen towel and pounded with a rolling
pin.
4. The 200 g of young leaves of Ipil-Ipil was added into the bowl of the double
boiler.
21
5. The ingredients were mixed and stirred together slowly using a wooden spoon
6. The bowl was then removed from the pot of water using gloves and the stove
switched off.
7. Mixture was allowed to cool but not solidify. The floor wax was fluid enough to
8. Mixture was poured into a clean, dry, glass jar using a plastic funnel.
9. The finished Ipil-Ipil floor wax was placed in a cool and dry place.
The same sequence and procedure was employed for the mature Ipil-Ipil leaves.
Data for this study was derived from the responses of fifteen (15) panelists based
on their assessment of the quality attributes of the floor wax produced from leaves of Ipil-
Ipil tree such as color, odor, texture, luster, and general acceptability when applied in a
The fifteen panelists consisted of fifteen janitors. The 15 janitors were chosen
based on their experience and employment as part of the janitorial services of the Leyte
Normal University. It has been the researchers’ interest to select janitors as the panelists
of this undertaking due to their cleaning expertise. Far be it, their perception and view
upon the use of Ipil-Ipil floor wax can be justified by their experiences as cleaners.
22
Application and use of Ipil-Ipil floor wax was done in one area of SR AV Hall,
inside the Leyte Normal University. The area was free from people for 2 consecutive
weeks and was visited by the 15 trained janitors every other day, that is, one day interval
for the next visit (e.g. Mon., Wed., Fri., Sun). Each day was coded Day 1, 3, 5, 7 for the
1st week and Day 9, 11, 13, and 15 for the 2nd week.
The Ipil-Ipil floor wax Acceptability Measure in the form of a rating scale,
specifically designed by the researchers were used by the 15 panelists in assessing the
attribute qualities of the two Ipil-Ipil floor waxes and commercial floor wax (i.e. color,
pavement. Each criterion is rated by scales ranging from 1 to 5, were 1 (dislike very
much), 2 (dislike slightly), 3 (neither like nor dislike), 4 (like moderately), and 5 (like
very much).
Three floor waxes were compared, one is produced commercially (A) the other
one from young leaves of Ipil-Ipil (B) and the last one is from mature leaves (C). Codes
(e.g. A, B, C) were assigned to each of these products; hence the panelists could hardly
Biostatistical Treatment
Arithmetic mean and Analysis of variance (ANOVA) were the Biostatistical tools
The researchers used the mean in determining the acceptability of the Ipil-Ipil
23
x = ∑x / N
Where x represents for the arithmetic mean; ∑x denotes the sum of the
difference on the color, odor, texture, effectiveness and general acceptability of the more
acceptable and the commercial floor wax. The test was made with the aid of SPSS
version 17.0.
24
Chapter 4
This chapter treats statistically the hypotheses stated in Chapter 1 of the study.
Data collected are analyzed and findings are based on these analyses.
The main purpose of giving the Ipil-Ipil floor wax acceptability measure was to
determine the effectiveness of Ipil-Ipil floor wax when applied in a concrete cemented
smooth pavement. It sought to find out also the mean difference between the Ipil-Ipil
floor wax from young and mature leaves and the commercially available floor wax.
There were two hypotheses drawn from the Ipil-Ipil floor wax acceptability
measure data.
Hypothesis one stated that none of the two Ipil-Ipil leaves (i.e. young and mature)
Hypothesis two stated that there is no significant difference between the more
acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax and commercial floor wax when applied in a concrete
A mean rating of 3.0 was set as the level of acceptability of the Ipil-Ipil floor wax
effectiveness for the measure used as tool in the study. The ratings ranges from as high as
pavement.
4 – like moderately
2 – dislike slightly
As shown in table 3, the mean ratings of the fifteen (15) respondents to the
following criteria for effectiveness of Ipil-Ipil floor wax from young leaves; for color
3.392, for odor 3.298, for texture 3.560, for luster 3.427 and for general acceptability
3.443.
Color 3.392
Odor 3.298
Texture 3.560
Luster 3.427
26
As shown in table 4, the mean ratings of the fifteen (15) respondents to the
following criteria for effectiveness of Ipil-Ipil floor wax from mature leaves; for color
3.098, for odor 3.135, for texture 3.335, for luster 3.388, and for general acceptability
3.440.
Color 3.098
Odor 3.135
Texture 3.335
Luster 3.388
27
These results show that a weighted mean obtained by the Ipil-Ipil floor wax from
both young and mature leaves for each of the five criteria for effectiveness or
acceptability reaches the standard mean of 3.00 set as level of Ipil-Ipil floor wax
the standard level. The Ipil-Ipil floor wax from young leaves obtained an over all mean of
3.424 and the Ipil-Ipil floor wax from mature leaves obtained an over all mean score of
3.279.
Evidence by this outcome, one is justified to conclude that both Ipil-Ipil floor wax
from young and mature leaves produce an acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax. Since a
negligible mean difference is derived between the two Ipil-Ipil floor waxes, both are then
considered to be acceptable.
Therefore, hypothesis one is rejected; that is, none of the two Ipil-Ipil leaves (i.e.
young and mature) can yield a more acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax.
This finding leads one to believe that both young and mature leaves of Ipil-Ipil
smooth pavement.
Hypothesis two compared the mean scores obtained by the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes’
cemented pavement.
acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax, in this case both the acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes (i.e.
28
young and mature leaves) and commercial floor wax when applied in a concrete smooth
cemented pavement.
As in hypothesis one, the samples of this study were the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes
from both young and mature leaves and the commercial floor wax.
difference on the color, odor, texture, luster and general acceptability of the more
acceptable, in this case both the acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes (young and mature
Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and mature leaves in general, it is not yet known
whether Ipil-Ipil floor wax is comparable with the commercially available floor wax.
As to whether the mean difference between the acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes
from young and mature leaves and the commercial floor wax is significant, table 5
presents the mean scores obtained by the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes and commercial floor wax
As shown in the table, the Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves) and Ipil-Ipil floor
wax (mature leaves) obtained weighted mean scores to the following criteria of
acceptability/effectiveness: 3.392, 3.098 for color; 3.298, 3.135 for odor; 3.560, 3.335 for
texture; 3.427, 3.388 for luster; and 3.443, 3.440 for general acceptability respectively.
29
Table 4. The Weighted Mean Scores on the Effectiveness/Acceptability of the three
floor waxes in two (2) weeks
Color
3.223
Commercial floor wax
3.392
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves)
3.098
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (mature leaves)
Odor
Commercial floor wax 3.057
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves) 3.298
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (mature leaves) 3.135
Texture
Commercial floor wax 3.418
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves) 3.560
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (mature leaves) 3.335
Luster
Commercial floor wax 3.165
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves) 3.427
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (mature leaves) 3.388
General Acceptability
Commercial floor wax 3.783
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves) 3.443
Ipil-Ipil floor wax (mature leaves) 3.440
pavement.
Further analysis of the data also shows that, Ipil-Ipil floor wax from young leaves
having an overall mean score of 3.424 is at par with the Ipil-Ipil floor wax from mature
The commercial floor wax, on the other hand, obtained the following mean scores
to the following criteria of acceptability/effectiveness: 3.223 for color, 3.057 for odor,
3.418 for texture, 3.165 for luster, and 3.783 for general acceptability.
Based from the standard level of floor wax acceptability/effectiveness (3.0), the
result shows that the commercial floor wax is also generally acceptable to be used in a
concrete cemented smooth pavement after attaining an overall mean score of 3.329.
acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes, that is the Ipil-Ipil floor wax from young leaves and
mature leaves and the commercially available floor wax, it is shown that there is no
significant difference between the mean scores obtained by the three floor waxes.
Hence, it can be concluded that the Ipil-Ipil floor wax either from young or
mature leaves is at par with the commercially prepared floor wax in terms of acceptability
31
Comparing the mean scores of acceptability/effectiveness obtained by the Ipil-Ipil
floor waxes from young and mature leaves and the commercial floor wax, Table 6 shows
the following F-values obtained for the different criteria of effectiveness or acceptability;
color 0.593, odor 0.682, texture 0.008, luster 0.702, and general acceptability 0.902.
Table 5. The Difference between the Mean scores obtained by the three floor waxes
in terms of the five criteria of effectiveness/acceptability in a concrete
smooth cemented pavement
Criteria F Sig.
These data indicate the test statistic to be the F value of 0.593 for color, 0.682 for
odor, 0.008 for texture, 0.702 for luster, and 0.902 for general acceptability. Using an α
of .05, we have p > 0.05. Since the significance (p) for each criterion is greater than the
significant value (α), the difference between the mean scores obtained by the Ipil-Ipil
floor waxes (young and mature leaves) and commercial floor wax for the criteria of
32
color, odor, texture, luster and general acceptability is statistically insignificant.
difference exists between the mean scores of the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and
mature leaves and the commercial floor wax on the effectiveness/acceptability criteria of
This result supports one to accept the second hypothesis; that is, there is no
significant difference between the more acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax, in this case the two
acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and mature leaves and the commercial floor
This result further verifies that the Ipil-Ipil floor wax is at par comparable with the
commercial floor wax and can be a potential alternative in terms of acceptability and
33
Chapter 5
A brief review of the study treating the problems and hypothesis is presented in
this chapter. The bases for the conclusions of this study were data presented in Chapter 4.
Implications for household cleaners especially those involve in household keeping are
findings of the study together with the problems for further investigations close Chapter
5.
Summary
of Ipil-Ipil floor wax on a concrete cemented smooth pavement. Specifically, it was the
purpose of the study to investigate (1) whether it is the young or the mature Ipil-Ipil
leaves that can produce a more acceptable floor wax in terms of the quality attributes –
color, odor, texture, luster, general acceptability; (2) if there a significant difference
between the most acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor wax from commercial floor wax when applied
Hο1: None of the two Ipil-Ipil leaves (i.e. young and mature) can yield a more
pavement.
The panelists of this investigation were the 15 janitors of the Leyte Normal
University.
One data gathering tool, Ipil-Ipil floor wax Acceptability Measure in the form of
a rating scale was administered to collect the data needed to test the hypotheses of this
study. The rating scale consists of five criteria of effectiveness/acceptability (i.e. color,
odor, texture, luster, general acceptability), each criterion is rated by scales ranging from
1 to 5, were 1 (dislike very much), 2 (dislike slightly), 3 (neither like nor dislike), 4 (like
moderately), and 5 (like very much). From the rating scale were taken the data needed to
The statistical technique used to analyze the data were the Arithmetic mean and
concrete cemented smooth pavement. The Arithmetic mean was used to test hypothesis
one and F-test was treated to test hypothesis two of the study.
35
Conclusion
Based from the findings of this study, the following conclusions are drawn:
1. Since hypothesis one is rejected, it can be said that both the two Ipil-Ipil floor waxes
from young and mature leaves can produce an acceptable floor wax when applied in a
2. Based from the acceptance of hypothesis two, it can be concluded that there is no
significant difference between the acceptable Ipil-Ipil floor waxes from young and
The results further verifies that the Ipil-Ipil floor wax is at par comparable with
the commercial floor wax and can be a potential alternative in terms of acceptability and
Implications
drawn:
2. Ipil-Ipil floor wax from young and mature leaves and commercial floor wax are
almost the same in characteristics in terms of the different criteria of effectiveness (color,
odor, texture, luster, general acceptability). Hence, household cleaners can use it as an
36
Recommendation
help improve the Ipil-Ipil floor wax attribute qualities for improved effectiveness and
Particularly those practicing the use of Ipil-Ipil leaves for polishing their
cemented floors inside the classroom should continue and observe such practice.
Parents and Household cleaners can use Ipil-Ipil floor wax as alternative to
commercial floor wax for waxing and polishing cemented smooth floors.
Commercial Industries
waxes with the commercial floor wax, it is hereby recommended for the product-
processing sectors involve in floor wax production to try to venture on using Ipil-Ipil as
Agricultural Sectors
It is hoped that farmers and those people involve in agriculture will continue
37
Future Researchers
(e.g. wood)
cemented pavement.
38
Bibliography
A. Book
B. Encyclopedias / Journals
Adeneye J.A. (1979). A note on the nutrient and mineral composition of Leucaena
leucocephala in western Nigeria. Anim. Feed Sci. Tech. 4 (3):221-225.
Aganga, A.A. and Tshwenyane, S.O., 2003. Lucerne, Lablab and Leucaena leucocephala
forages: Production and utilization for livestock production, Pakistan Journal of
Nutrition 2, 46–53
Wax. (1993). In The new encyclopaedia Britannica (Vol. 12). Chicago: Encyclopaedia
Britannica.
C. Online Sources
Duke, J. A., 1983. Handbook of Energy crops. Retrieved 2 Dec. 2010 from
<http:www.hort.purdue.edu/newcrop/duke-energy/ Medicago-sativa.
Html#cultivation>
Floor Polish Coatings. SpecialChem S.A., 2010. Retrieved 3 Dec. 2010 from
<http://www.specialchem4coatings.com/tc/wax/index.aspx?id=floor>
Guide to less Toxic Products. Environmental Health Association of Nova Scotia, 2004.
Retrieved 4 Dec. 2010 from<http://lesstoxicguide.ca/index.asp?fetch=household>
Popovitch, Trish, 2008. How to make Homemade floor wax. Retrieved 3 Dec. 2010 from
<http://www.ehow.com/how_5200154_make-homemade-floor-wax.html>
Radaza, M.A. and A. Arante. Homemade Floor wax out of Waste Plastic Rappers. 16 Jul.
2008.Retrieved 3 Dec. 2010 from
<http://region10.dost.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=263
&Itemid=77>
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A
Letter for Permission
Sir:
Greetings!
We are one group of BSEd 3rd year students who is presently taking the course
Sci 158 (Research in Physical Science). One of the major requirements of the said course
is a research paper.
Presently, we are writing a research paper about “Ipil-Ipil (Leucaena
leucocephala (Lam.) de wit) As an Alternative Source of Floor wax”.
In connection to this, we would like to ask the permission from your good office
to allow us to do the following:
- conduct our data gathering inside the Leyte Normal University, preferably
securing one area of the SR AV Hall for two (2) weeks.
- ask the assistance of fifteen (15) janitors under your supervision as panellists
for two (2) weeks, specifically those assigned in or near SR building.
The data that will be gathered from the responses of the fifteen (15) trained
janitors on the effectiveness of Ipil-Ipil floor wax in a concrete cemented smooth
pavement will be a great help for this research undertaking.
We are looking forward to your favourable consideration.
Truly yours,
___∕__Approved
_____Disapproved
Quality 1 3 5 7 Total
attributes A B C A B C A B C A B C
Color
Odor
Texture
Luster
General
Acceptability
Total
Scale:
4 – like moderately
2 – dislike slightly
Quality 9 11 13 15 Total
attributes A B C A B C A B C A B C
Color
Odor
Texture
Luster
General
Acceptability
Total
Scale:
4 – like moderately
2 – dislike slightly
First Week
Janitor
Color Odor Texture Luster General Acceptability
A B C A B C A B C A B C A B C
1 2.5 3.8 4 1.8 3.8 3.5 3 4 5 1.3 3.3 3.5 2 3.3 4.3
2 1.8 1.5 1.8 1.5 1.8 1.8 2 2 2 2.3 2.3 2.3 2 2.3 2.3
3 3.3 2 1.8 3.5 3.3 3.3 3.8 3.8 3.8 2.8 4 4 4.3 3.3 3.3
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
5 4.8 4.5 4.5 5 4.3 4 4.8 5 4.8 5 4.5 4.5 5 4.5 4.3
6 2.8 3.3 2.5 2 3.8 2.5 4 5 3.5 3 2.3 3.5 3 4.3 2.8
7 1 4.5 3.3 1 4.3 3.8 1.8 3.8 4 1.3 3.5 4.5 2.5 4.3 3.8
8 2.3 2 2 1.8 2.3 2.3 1.5 2.3 1.8 2.8 2.3 2 2.5 2.8 2.5
9 2.8 2.2 2.2 2.8 2.2 2.2 2.8 2.2 2.2 2.8 2.2 2.2 2.8 2.2 2.2
10 3.8 3.3 4.5 3.3 3.5 3.5 3.8 3.5 3.3 3.3 2.8 3 4 2.5 3.3
11 3 3.3 2 2.3 2 2 3.3 3.3 2.8 2.8 2.5 2.5 2 3 3.3
12 4.3 4 4.3 4.8 4 4 4 3.8 4 4.3 4.3 3.3 4.3 4 4.5
13 3.5 4.8 3.5 2.8 3.8 3.8 5 3.5 4 3.3 3.8 4.3 3.3 4.5 3.3
14 3.8 2.5 2.5 3.8 3.3 3.3 3 3.3 2.8 3.3 3 2.5 2.3 2.5 3.3
15 4 3.3 2.3 3.3 1.3 1.3 3.5 4.3 2.8 3.3 2.5 2.3 5 2.3 2.5
Total 47.7 49 45.2 43.7 47.7 45.3 50.3 53.8 50.8 45.6 47.3 48.4 49 49.8 49.7
Mean 3.18 3.26667 3.01333 2.91333 3.18 3.02 3.35333 3.58667 3.38667 3.04 3.15333 3.22667 3.26667 3.32 3.31333
A – Commercial floor wax C – Ipil –Ipil floor wax (mature leaves)
B – Ipil-Ipil floor wax (young leaves)
Table 3. Overall Mean Score obtained from 15 Janitors’ responses on Ipil-Ipil floor wax and commercial floor wax
effectiveness/acceptability for two (2) weeks
Criteria of Acceptability/Effectiveness
Color Odor Texture Luster General Acceptability
A B C A B C A B C A B C A B C
Mean (1st week) 3.18 3.266667 3.013333 2.913333 3.18 3.02 3.353333 3.586667 3.386667 3.04 3.153333 3.226667 3.266667 3.32 3.313333
Mean (2nd week) 3.2666667 3.5166667 3.1833333 3.2 3.4166667 3.25 3.4833333 3.5333333 3.28333333 3.29 3.7 3.55 4.3 3.56666667 3.56666667
Over all mean 3.2233333 3.3916668 3.0983332 3.0566665 3.2983333 3.135 3.4183332 3.5600002 3.33500017 3.165 3.4266665 3.3883335 3.7833335 3.44333333 3.43999983
Sum of
Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups .648 2 .324 .593 .557
Within Groups 22.946 42 .546
Total 23.593 44
Table 5. Multiple Comparisons of the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes and Commercial floor
wax based on Odor Rating.
Sum of
Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups .781 2 .390 .682 .511
Within Groups 24.031 42 .572
Total 24.812 44
Table 6. Multiple Comparisons of the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes and Commercial floor
wax based on Texture Rating.
Sum of
Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups .010 2 .005 .008 .992
Within Groups 24.088 42 .574
Total 24.098 44
Table 7. Multiple Comparisons of the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes and Commercial floor
wax based on Luster Rating.
Sum of
Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups .680 2 .340 .702 .501
Within Groups 20.334 42 .484
Total 21.014 44
Table 8. Multiple Comparisons of the Ipil-Ipil floor waxes and Commercial floor
wax based on General Acceptability Rating.
Sum of
Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups .899 2 .450 .902 .414
Within Groups 20.950 42 .499
Total 21.849 44
APPENDIX D
Figure 4. Sample Ipil-Ipil leaves - (A) 200g young leaves, (B) 200g mature Leaves
APPENDIX E
Results after Applying the Commercial Floor wax (A), Ipil-Ipil Floor wax from
young leaves (B) and Ipil-Ipil floor wax from mature leaves (C) in a concrete
cemented smooth pavement
Figure 8. Commercial Floor wax (A) Figure 9. Ipil-Ipil Floor wax from
young leaves (B)