Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/235282474
CITATIONS READS
29 615
2 authors, including:
Vincent-Wayne Mitchell
The University of Sydney
146 PUBLICATIONS 6,829 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Vincent-Wayne Mitchell on 04 January 2017.
(2009),"Indulgent snack experience attributes and healthy choice alternatives", British Food Journal, Vol. 111 Iss 5 pp.
486-497 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/00070700910957311
Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by emerald-srm:476352 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service
information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please visit
www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of
more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online
products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication
Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
C
ereal bars are increasingly becoming a Table I. Size of the UK Cereal Bar Market, 1981-1987
popular snack amongst the younger age
groups. How healthy are they?
Value Percentage
Year (£ million) Change
1987 launched Jordan's chewy cereal bar which was H1 = Younger, female, and consumers of a higher
claimed to be the healthiest bar on the market. The bar social class will purchase significantly more
contains no added sugar and uses honey to sweeten the cereal bars.
product. Others in the market have concentrated on
developing a snack product which benefits from being H2 = Younger, female, and consumers of a higher
perceived as healthy. The brand leader is believed to be social class will be significantly more health
Tracker which is produced by Mars. Tracker is sold conscious.
predominantly beside confectionery products as compared (3) determine whether consumer perceptions of cereal
with the majority of cereal bars which are sold alongside bar as a healthy snack alternative were borne out
biscuits. Jump, launched in 1985 as a "natural, healthy by the nutritional content of these bars.
snack that is tasty as well as fun", is believed to be the
most popular cereal bar among children. It seems clear The NACNE (1983) report had provided guidelines as to
that these cereal bars are being positioned in the minds what might be viewed as healthy. As a point of comparison
of the consumer as the "healthy snack alternative". In the favourite less-healthy alternatives for cereal bars would
1983 an influential report published nutritional guidelines also be examined.
Downloaded by City, University of London At 09:15 04 January 2017 (PT)
for health education in Britain (NACNE, 1983). Four (4) examine consumer taste preferences for bars which
recommendations of that report are particularly important have been analysed under objective 3. Ideally H3
in relation to cereal bars, these are that consumers should would be accepted.
be encouraged to eat foods which have a:
H3 = Cereal bars with the healthiest nutritional
• low sugar content content will be significantly preferred by
• low fat content consumers.
• low salt content To achieve the stated objectives a three-stage methodology
• high fibre content. was employed. It consisted of a questionnaire survey
(n=200), a chemical analysis of seven cereal bars and
This pilot study set out to investigate some of the sensory tests on a pilot group of consumers.
marketing issues involved in the cereal bar market. More
specifically we wished to:
(1) examine the motives for cereal bar purchase and Stage 1: The Survey
see to what extent cereal bars were bought for A questionnaire was elaborated which contained three
health reasons. Do consumers associate cereal bars sections. Section one included questions on cereal bar
with health food? Do consumers purchase cereal purchase — when, where, which, etc. The answers to
bars as a slimming aid? Are purchasers more health this section enabled the survey results to be compared
conscious than non-purchasers? What would most with existing market intelligence. Section two concentrated
consumers eat if cereal bars were not available? on the perceptions of cereal bars, purchase motives, health
consciousness and which alternative snack would be
These are some of the questions we wished to chosen, i.e. data which were not available from secondary
answer. sources. Section three contained demographic type
(2) determine the effect of age, sex and social class questions which were used in the analysis of sections one
on purchasing patterns, reasons for purchase and and two and in gaining the quota sample. The instrument
health awareness. was piloted on a convenience sample of pedestrians in the
Eldon Square Shopping Centre, Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
Younger respondents, who have been exposed to The North East was chosen as it represented the area
more health education, should be generally more with the lowest sale of cereal bars in the UK. It was
health conscious than older respondents. Females believed that in an area of the lowest sales health
are usually more conscious about their food intake consciousness would be lower. If this awareness was lower
than males. One might also expect that the higher there would be less difference between perceived
the social class of the respondent the greater will healthiness of cereal bars and actual healthiness. If a
be their propensity to purchase and read nutritional difference in perception was found in the North East this
information. This may be a function of education, would surely be replicated in areas where sales were
i.e. that nutritional information has more meaning greater and health consciousness more apparent.
to them or that their education has taught them
nutritional values which they perceive cereal bars Although the majority of the questionnaire was highly
to have. It may also be a result of their increased structured several open-ended questions were included
willingness to try new products and/or increased which were aimed at testing the mental associations of
ability to pay for those trials. These ideas may be the words cereal bar, e.g. "What comes to mind when
combined to form two hypotheses: I mention the words 'cereal bar'?" Several questions were
CEREAL BARS: A PERCEPTUAL, CHEMICAL AND SENSORY ANALYSIS 19
rephrased and repeated throughout the questionnaire in 1.59, respectively). Thus H1 can only be partially
order to test the consistency of the respondent's accepted, in that younger people are significantly more
answers. The final questionnaire was administered to a likely to consume cereal bars, therefore there is an age
quota sample of 200 pedestrians in the Eldon Square difference, but sex and social class make no difference
shopping centre. The age, sex and socioeconomic profile to the propensity to consume.
of the sample reflected that of the census profile of the
surrounding area. Every fifth person who passed two When analysing the effects of age, sex and social class on
identified points was approached and interview schedules whether consumers associate cereal bars with health food,
were spread across times of day and day of week to some chi-squared analyses could not be undertaken because
minimise these biases. The results obtained on section expected cell frequencies were lessthanfive. This was the
one of the question suggested that the repondents gave case for age and social class. In the case of age the data
answers which were similar to those given by suggest that younger consumers do have a stronger
respondents to market intelligence survey data available association between health and cereal bars while for social
from secondary sources. This gives additional confidence class no relationship was discernible. Table V presents the
when interpreting the results of section two. contingency table for the effect of sex on the association.
The result was significant and indicates that females exhibit
Downloaded by City, University of London At 09:15 04 January 2017 (PT)
Table II. Reasons Why Cereal Bars Are Bought Table IV. A Comparison of Age against Whether or
Not Cereal Bars Are Eaten
Number of Number of
Responses Subjects Subjects (%) Response >15 15-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65+ Total
Table V. A Comparison of Sex against Whether or Not by the questionnaire. Although the contents of many of
Cereal Bars Are Associated with Health Food the cereal bars are given on the packet, tests for the above
substances were still carried out because not all packages
were able to provide the necessary information and there
Response Male Female Total was a desire to cross-check manufacturers' claims. Tests
were also conducted on the two most popular alternatives
Yes 30 61 91
to cereal bars which the survey determined to be Mars
No 8 5 13 bars and chocolate digestives, receiving respectively 18
Total 38 66 104 per cent and 15 per cent of the survey vote. A Clandon
2
Chi-square (x ) = 3.850 industrial analyser was used to measure both glucose and
Degree of freedom = 1 sucrose levels. Two samples from each product and two
readings from each sample were used to calculate an
average sugar content. In determining the extractable fat
content using soxhlet apparatus, the sodium chloride
calories, fat and fibre as influencing their choice. Of these content and the fibre contents, which were measured using
Downloaded by City, University of London At 09:15 04 January 2017 (PT)
respondents 73 per cent tried to limit these in their diet, the acid detergent method, three samples of each product
62 per cent limit calories and 38 per cent fat. On balance were taken and the mean calculated from the two closest
there is only partial support for H2; that younger, female, results.
and consumers of a higher social class will be more health
conscious than others.
Chemical Analysis Results
On the whole the results of the survey confirm the idea Generally the experimental results compare favourably
that people perceive cereal bars to be healthy. However, with those provided by the manufacturer. Discrepancies
is this perception justified in terms of the nutritional can be accounted for by the different methods used to
content of these bars, or is it the influence of skilful assess these substances, experimental error and sampling
marketing communications? error. The nutritional content provided by the manu-
facturer will be an average of many samples taken from
the production process. Some bars will have more than
Stage 2 : Chemical Analysis average, some less. It may be that, in the case of Jordan's
The analysis of sugar, fat, salt and fibre contents were raisin bar, for example, the particular experimental sample
carried out on the seven most popular bars as determined had more fibre than average.
Jordans
(raisin) 10.8 1 0.13 2 15.5 5 14.0 4 1.62 4 14.0 1 2.8
Tracker
(chocolate) 17.7 5 0.37 5 13.3 3 10.0 1 2.29 2 3.0 6 3.7
Jordans
(honey) 24.7 8 0.02 1 20.5 6 34.2 8 3.16 1 14.0 1 4.2
Harvest
Chewy 14.5 2 0.40 7 12.8 2 16.0 5 0.68 7 3.3 5 4.2
Cluster 16.4 4 0.66 9 10.5 1 13.3 3 13.3 6 4.0 3 4.3
Tracker
(nut) 15.8 3 0.38 6 21.5 7 10.9 2 1.45 5 N/A 4.6
Harvest
Crunch 19.1 6 0.26 3 23.5 8 23.4 7 1.83 3 3.6 4 5.2
Mars 41.6 9 0.29 4 14.6 4 21.3 6 0.43 9 N/A — 6.4
Chocolate
digestive 24.1 7 0.65 8 25.6 9 35.5 9 0.57 8 N/A — 8.4
(The "healthier" the result the higher the rank)
CEREAL BARS: A PERCEPTUAL, CHEMICAL AND SENSORY ANALYSIS 21
Overall, Jordans chewy raisin bar was deemed to be the Table VII. New Coding for Statistical Analysis
healthiest bar showing the lowest sugar and salt content
and highest fibre content of all the bars. This supports
publicity and advertising claims made for the bar. The least Cereal Bars New Code
healthy bar appears to be Harvest Crunch. Interestingly,
there was some overlap between "healthy" snacks, such Tracker roasted nut A
as cereal bars, and traditional "less healthy" snacks, such Tracker chocolate chip B
as Mars bars and chocolate digestives. Mars bars, in Jordans raisin and hazelnut C
particular, had lower salt and fat content, gram for gram, Jordans honey and almond D
than several cereal bars. It appears that cereal bars in Harvest Chewy chocolate chip E
general are only marginally healthier than traditional
snacks. Harvest Crunch peanut F
Cluster apple and hazelnut G
It is also worth noting the three gaps in the table which
are as a result of manufacturers' labelling practices. The
Downloaded by City, University of London At 09:15 04 January 2017 (PT)
pressure has grown over the last few years for more
nutritional information to be displayed on packaging. This and served on white plates at room temperature through
pressure must continue as results are beginning to show. a hatch. Seven bars were tested which resulted in 21 paired
comparisons. To avoid fatiguing panellists, four sessions
were conducted, all of which took place mid-afternoon.
Stage 3: Organolaptic Tests Panellists should be feeling slightly hungry in order to gain
Hedonic scaling, commonly used in sensory evaluation, maximum sensory sensitivity (Hamilton, 1978).
would have been inappropriate in this case since panellists
would have been asked to assess too many variables and Organolaptic Test Results
respondent fatigue may have invalidated the results. For ease of presentation of statistical results each bar has
Untrained panellists were sought because of the need to been assigned a letter (see Table VII).
measure their naïve preferences. In order to ease the
judgement process and to allow the researcher to check
the consistency of each assessor, a paired comparison test
was employed.
Consumers need to
be sure that health food is
Tests were carried out more healthy
under laboratory
conditions Table VIII shows the number of comparisons in which each
cereal bar was preferred. Chocolate chip cereal bars were
found to be most preferred with Tracker chocolate chip
Ten panellists were selected to meet all of the following being slightly preferred to Harvest Chewy chocolate chip.
criteria; be willing to participate, be available for all tasting Before any statistical analysis was conducted a check was
sessions, be in good physical and mental health, and not made on the consistency of the panellists' assessments.
to dislike the food under assessment. At this pilot stage Using the standard deviation of the preferences panellists
considerations of sample structure and size were thought 5 and 7 were found to exhibit 6 and 5 triads respectively:
to be less important than to test protocols and data A circular triad occurs when a subject indicates they prefer
collection mechanisms. Tests were carried out under A to B, B to C and C to A. This finding means that these
laboratory conditions where distractions and any external two panellists' judgements were not consistent and as a
factors such as lighting, ventilation, temperature, etc. result their assessments were removed from the statistical
which might influence the sensitivity of panellists were calculations. Although inconsistency of judgement would
controlled. Panellists were enclosed in separate booths be the norm if no difference existed between the samples,
and asked to refrain from communicating with each other it was considered that this was not the explanation in this
both before and after assessment sessions in order to case.
ensure the independence of assessments. Glasses of
ambient temperature water and apple wedges were made Tests were carried out to determine whether the
available to assessors for them to cleanse their palates differences in preferences were statistically significant.
between sample tastings. To eliminate bias, samples were Figure 1 shows which bars were deemed to be not
cut into similar shapes and sizes, given a three-digit code significantly different from each other at the 5 per cent
22 BRITISH FOOD JOURNAL 92,5
Table VIII. The Number of Comparisons in which and hazelnut bar should have been the most preferred and
Each Cereal Bar Was Preferred
Harvest Crunch the least preferred. This was clearly not
the case and H3 is not supported by the data, i.e. cereal
bars with the healthiest nutritional content were not most
Cereal Bar
A B C D E F G Mean SD
preferred by the consumer panel. Perhaps some solace
Panellists can be taken from the outstanding performances of the
two chocolate chip cereal bars which did not fare badly
1 2 3 4 5 6 0 1 3.00 2.160 in chemical analysis. Manufacturers may be able to develop
2 4 5 1 3 6 2 0 3.00 2.160 an extremely healthy base mixture to which they can then
3 3 6 2 1 5 4 0 3.00 2.160 add chocolate chip to increase its palatability to consumers.
4 1 6 2 2 5 4 1 3.00 2.000
5 3 4 0 4 3 2 5 3.00 1.633
6 4 6 0 1 5 3 2 3.00 2.160 Conclusions
7 5 5 3 2 3 0 3 3.00 1.732 Cereal bars are gaining in popularity amongst consumers
8 3 6 2 1 5 4 0 3.00 2.160 as a tasty, healthy, convenient snack. It was found that
Downloaded by City, University of London At 09:15 04 January 2017 (PT)
Pari Boustani is a Researcher and Vincent-Wayne Mitchell is a Lecturer in Marketing, both based at the Manchester
School of Management, UMIST, UK.
This article has been cited by:
1. J. Martínez-Gómez, D. Ibarra, S. Villacis, P. Cuji, P.R. Cruz. 2016. Analysis of LPG, electric and induction cookers during
cooking typical Ecuadorian dishes into the national efficient cooking program. Food Policy 59, 88-102. [CrossRef]
2. Mina K. Kim, Patrick Greve, Youngseung Lee. 2016. Identification of Drivers of Liking for Bar-Type Snacks Based on
Individual Consumer Preference. Journal of Food Science 81:1, S174-S181. [CrossRef]
3. Neelam Rawat, Indrani Darappa. 2015. Effect of ingredients on rheological, nutritional and quality characteristics of fibre
and protein enriched baked energy bars. Journal of Food Science and Technology 52:5, 3006-3013. [CrossRef]
4. Emily C. Crofton, Anne Markey, Amalia G.M. Scannell. 2014. Perceptions of healthy snacking among Irish adolescents: a
qualitative investigation. International Journal of Health Promotion and Education 52:4, 188-199. [CrossRef]
5. Luciana Pereira Lobato, Alissana Ester Iakmiu Camargo Pereira, Marcela Marta Lazaretti, Décio Sabattini Barbosa, Clisia
Mara Carreira, José Marcos Gontijo Mandarino, Maria Victoria Eiras Grossmann. 2012. Snack bars with high soy protein
and isoflavone content for use in diets to control dyslipidaemia. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition 63:1,
49-58. [CrossRef]
6. PATRICK GREVE, YOUNG SEUNG LEE, JEAN-FRANCOIS MEULLENET, BENNO KUNZ. 2010. IMPROVING
THE PREDICTION FOR SENSORY TEXTURE ATTRIBUTES FOR MULTICOMPONENT SNACK BARS BY
OPTIMIZING INSTRUMENTAL TEST CONDITIONS. Journal of Texture Studies 41:3, 358-380. [CrossRef]
7. K. MAHANNA, S.Y. LEE. 2010. CONSUMER ACCEPTANCE OF FOOD BARS. Journal of Sensory Studies . [CrossRef]
8. K. MAHANNA, H.R. MOSKOWITZ, S.-Y. LEE. 2009. ASSESSING CONSUMER EXPECTATIONS FOR FOOD
Downloaded by City, University of London At 09:15 04 January 2017 (PT)