Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Legal Medicine
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/legalmed
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: It appears still questionable whether fractures to the superior thyroid horns can be used for forensic
Received 26 May 2012 reconstruction purposes regarding the functional mechanism causing compression of the neck soft tis-
Received in revised form 26 October 2012 sues. Localisations and types of such fractures were documented in 118 cases of superior thyroid horn
Accepted 27 October 2012
fractures caused by suicidal hanging. The placement of the ligature was above the larynx in 109 cases
Available online 20 December 2012
and in the remaining nine cases across the thyroid cartilage. As a secondary parameter the degree of ossi-
fication of thyroid cartilages and superior horns was used.
Keywords:
Bone densities of typical cases (equidensities) were measured radiologically. Additionally, dummy tests
Superior thyroid horns
Fractures
were performed focused on two extreme shapes of superior thyroid horns to assess stress peaks using
Suicidal hanging resin dummies and polarised light. Such peaks were located in the lower thirds of the horns close to their
Ossification bases. With the larynx still cartilaginous, the base appears a typical location for fractures caused by sui-
Photo-elastic experiments cidal hanging.
Gender differences An ossification pattern defined as ‘‘type 1’’ showed broad and osseous superior thyroid horns. If ossi-
Reconstruction fication was homogenous, fractures were located at the sites of maximum mechanical stress. In case of
inhomogenous ossification, being the more common mode, the horn bases were more resistant to pres-
sure and bending so that no fractures occurred. They were instead located at the sites of the greatest dif-
ferences in density and distributed in an apparent random pattern.
Narrow and deep insertions of the superior thyroid horns at the back surface of the upper thirds of the
thyroid cartilages (posterior aspects) were classified as ‘‘type 2’’ ossification. Upon flexion, the long horns
came into contact with the upper edges of the dorsal aspect creating a torque. Further flexion from an
increasing impact by the ligature extended the long lever arm causing the base of the upper thyroid horn
being broadly torn out of the dorsal aspect. The results suggest that localisations of fractures to the supe-
rior thyroid horns in connection with ossification patterns may be helpful for the reconstruction in sui-
cidal hanging regarding the mechanics of the ligature in relation to its position around the neck.
Ó 2012 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
1344-6223/$ - see front matter Ó 2012 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.legalmed.2012.10.008
K.-S. Saternus et al. / Legal Medicine 15 (2013) 134–139 135
3. Results
transfers force to the superior thyroid horn, similar the way the lar-
3.1. Degree/type of ossification and fracture location (Table 1) ynx can forcibly be pressed towards the cervical spine by suicidal
hanging. Nevertheless, AralditeÒ resin was not intended to replace
Five percent of the horn fractures showed the larynx completely bone in the photo-elastic experiments. It was used to demonstrate
cartilaginous with the fracture levels located in the lower thirds of the loading peaks in an object shaped similar to a superior thyroid
the superior horns (Fig. 1). This level corresponded to the load horn. Together with X-ray of bone density, this technique is a
peaks shown in isotropic material (AralditeÒ) by photo-elastic widely recognised method in biomechanics [15,24–26].
experiments. In 11% of the cases, the superior horns were not yet
or only partially ossified with the fractures located at the level of 3.4. Photo-elastic experiments
the ossification front. In 43% the thyroid cartilage was already ossi-
fied up to its upper edge, and completely ossified in 41% of the In addition to the distribution of loads, causation of fractures
cases. Macroscopically, fracture levels initially appeared to follow was primarily assessed by the degree of ossification. Fig. 2a and
a random pattern (Table 1). b shows that the maximum number of isochromatic bands (pat-
tern) are not located directly at the base of the horn but in its lower
3.2. Configuration types of the superior thyroid horns third close to its base. This observation appeared independent from
the configuration of the horns. If the peak load during force transfer
Especially angles and configurations of the superior thyroid by suspension occurs close to the base within the lower third of the
horns showed wide variations within the sagittal plane ranging horn for both extreme types of shape, this conclusion applies also
from straight angles off to the dorsal plane to others bending to to horn shapes between the two extremes. An extensive study
the anterior one. Authors who had previously examined the sam- found superior thyroid horns to point dorsally in over 60%, verti-
ple from Cologne [22,23] defined a dorsally tilted, straight horn cally in 48.5% and anteriorly in only 1.5% [8].
as ‘‘male type’’ and anteriorly bent horns as ‘‘female type’’. Apparently, the number of isochromatic bands depends on the
amount of the applied force. The peak loads observed in the
3.3. Distribution of mechanical loads photo-elastic experiments appear applicable to bone, with the
shape of the superior horn determining the length of the lever
In Fig. 2a and b the isochromatic bands, corresponding to the arm although there might be differences between resin dummies
locations of equal loads, were shown by polarised light. The stamp and real bone.
Table 1
3.5. Ossification patterns and types of upper thyroid horns (Table 2)
Correlation between degree/type of ossification and fracture location.
n % State of larynx/superior horns Location of fracture(s) Examinations of ossification patterns of superior thyroid horns
6 5.1 Completely cartilaginous Lower thirds of superior horns were performed to understand the mechanisms of superior horn
13 11.0 Horns not yet/partially ossified Level of ossification front fractures, but not to present a comprehensive illustration of the
51 43.2 Ossification up to upper edge Random pattern
ossification types of the thyroid cartilage. Ossification of upper
48 40.7 Complete ossification Random pattern
horns shows inhomogeneous patterns, typically starting from their
136 K.-S. Saternus et al. / Legal Medicine 15 (2013) 134–139
Fig. 2. Load distribution (photo-elastic analysis) in resin dummies showing two extreme shapes (a vs. b) of superior thyroid horns in simulated strangulation with load peaks
located in the inferior third/base of the horn.
Table 2
Different types of upper thyroid horns.
the ossification front. Bone density has also been shown in a grey
scale (equidensity pattern) with the bright structures representing
higher densities and dark ones those of lower density. A fracture
(dislocation) is located in the transitional zone between higher
and lower bone densities with the fragment showing dorsal
ossification.
Fig. 5 shows ‘‘type 1’’ ossification with superior horn fractures.
The ossification line is located more cranially compared to Fig. 4
and the dislocated horn can be seen exactly at this level.
A ‘‘type 2’’ ossification shows an insertion of the superior horn
in the upper to middle third of its dorsal aspect. The bone matrix
forms part of the lower oval and extends along the orientation of
the inferior thyroid tubercle. The matrix may be intersected by
bony extensions originating from the lower horn (Fig. 6). Such
superior horns should be regarded as much longer lever arms than
‘‘type 1’’ horns. In suicidal hanging, flexion of the horn within the
sagittal plane is caused by being moved towards the cervical spine
leading to anterior excursion to a contact point. Mostly the upper
part of the thyroid cartilage’s ovoid ossification where a torque
Fig. 5. Pressure- and flexion-resistant horn (equidensities). Horn fracture within develops shows broad dislocation of the horn out of the dorsal as-
the transitional region to the largest density differences (221/79). pect (via the long upper lever arm).
In a ‘‘type 3’’ ossification, the abutting bed for the anteriorly
flexed horn is not osseous but cartilaginous. Fig. 7 demonstrates
a torque occurring upon contact with a regressively altered carti-
lage. The superior part of the dorsal part is torn out via the long le-
ver arm created by this process.
4. Discussion
5. Final conclusions
References
Fig. 9. Medio-anterior and inward bending of the superior thyroid horn. Lateral (a)
[1] Khokhlov VD. Injuries to the hyoid bone and laryngeal cartilages. Effectiveness
dislocation of a lamella from the border of the thyroid cartilage, medial (b)
of different methods of medico-legal investigation. Forensic Sci Int
impression resulting in a release fracture (156/85).
1997;88:173–83.
[2] Brinkmann B, Koops E, Wischhusen F, Kleiber M. Compression of the neck and
arterial obstruction. Z Rechtsmed 1981;87:58–73.
the frontal plane. In 85 specimens selected by age and gender, [3] Haumeder R. Über den Entstehungsmechanismus der Verletzungen des
horns were tilted laterally in none of the cases [32]. The deviation Kehlkopfes und des Zungenbeins beim Erhängen. Wien Med Presse
from the sagittal plane to the medial one had a minimum of 5°, a 1882;24:737.
[4] Hofmann v ER. Zur Kenntnis der Entstehungsarten von Kehlkopffrakturen.
maximum of 46.5°, and a mean of 27°, with no correlations to Wien Med Wochenschr 1886;44:1466–70.
age or gender. [5] Strassmann F. Lehrbuch der gerichtlichen Medicin. Stuttgart: Enke; 1895.
Therefore, it appears that fractures of the superior thyroid horns [6] Kratter J. Lehrbuch der gerichtlichen Medizin. Stuttgart: Enke; 1912.
[7] Hofmann v ER. Einige weitere Beobachtungen über indirekte Brüche des
with fragments shifting anteriorly and inwardly are rather com- Kehlkopfes durch Sturz auf den Kopf. Wien Klin Wochenschr 1891;36:663–5.
mon with an example pictured in Fig. 9a and b. The dislocation [8] Maxeiner H. Verletzungen des Kehlkopfs. In: Brinkmann B, Madea B, editors.
of an osseous lamella can be identified on the outer aspect Handbuch der gerichtlichen Medizin Bd I. Berlin: Springer; 2004. p. 734–48.
[9] Saternus K-S. On the injuries of the cervical vertebral spine and neck soft
(Fig. 9a) and some impingement is seen on the inner side of the tissues. Stuttgart: Hippokrates Publishing Company; 1979.
thyroid cartilage edge forming a slightly compressed fragment [10] Missliwetz J. Morphologie von Kehlkopf und Zungenbein beim Erhängen. Beitr
(Fig. 9b). Gerichtl Med 1981;39:257–63.
[11] Luke JL, Reay DT, Eisele JW, Bonnell HJ. Correlation of circumstances with
Other research revealed that superior thyroid horns in males
pathological findings in asphyxial death by hanging: a prospective study of 61
were age-dependently aligned slightly laterally [33]. In suicidal cases from Seattle. J Forensic Sci 1985;30:1140–7.
hanging lateral bending of superior horns occurred less frequently [12] Sharma BR, Harish D, Sharma A, Sharma S, Singh H. Injuries to the structures in
deaths due to constriction of neck, with a special reference to hanging. J
than shifting into the sagittal plane. This may be linked to the horn
Forensic Med 2008;15:298–305.
configuration showing a wide range of variants in a right–left com- [13] Wastrak P. Forensic radiology of the larynx with special reference to the
parison [17,22,32,34]. Thus, the throat skeleton can also be subject determination of age and gender. Doctoral Thesis, Cologne; 1970.
to an off-centre impact even if the ligature is positioned [14] Saternus K-S, Koebke J. Das Verletzungsmuster des Zungenbeins (The injury
pattern of the hyoid bone). Z Rechtsmed 1979;84:19–35.
symmetrically. [15] Koebke J, Saternus K-S. On the morphology of the adult human hyoid bone. Z
Possible slight sagittal alignments of the superior thyroid horns Rechtsmed 1979;84:7–18.
and bending loads within the sagittal plane have also to be taken [16] Tillmann B, Wustrow F. Kehlkopf. Onto- und Phylogenese, Fehlbildungen,
Zysten und Fisteln, funktionelle Anatomie, Histologie, Untersuchungsme-
into account. Some deviations of the directions of the vectors can thoden. In: Berendes J, Link R, Zöllner F, editors. Hals-Nasen-Ohren-Heilkunde
be identified due to this effect. Our results show that the high fre- Bd 4/I. Stuttgart: Thieme; 1982.
K.-S. Saternus et al. / Legal Medicine 15 (2013) 134–139 139
[17] Scheik A. Injuries of hyoid bone and larynx in cases of killing by strangling or [26] Kummer B. Kausale Histogenese der Gewebe des Bewegungsapparats. In:
throttling, suicidal hanging and emergency intubation. Doctoral Thesis, Ferner F, Staubesand J, editors. Benninghoff – Lehrbuch der Anatomie Bd I,
Cologne; 1987. Urban & Schwarzenberg. Vienna: Berlin, Munich; 1975.
[18] Maxeiner H. ‘‘Hidden’’ laryngeal injuries in homicidal strangulation: how to [27] Langreuter K. Über die mechanischen Bedingungen des Todes durch
detect and interpret these findings. J Forensic Sci 1998;43:784–91. Strangulation. Vjschr Gerichtl Med III 1886;F 45:295–309.
[19] Maxeiner H. Weichteilblutungen im Kehlkopfinneren nach Strangulation. Z [28] Berg SP. Grundriß der Rechtsmedizin. 11th ed. Munich: Mueller & Steinicke;
Rechtsmed 1985;94:127–35. 1976.
[20] Maxeiner H, Dietz W. Anleitung für eine vollständige Kehlkopfpräparation. Z [29] Hofmann ER, Haberda A. Lehrbuch der gerichtlichen Medizin. 11th ed. Berlin,
Rechtsmed 1986;96:11–6. Vienna: Urban & Schwarzenberg; 1927. p. 675.
[21] Oehmichen M, Karres-Balting U, Saternus K-S. Reactive alterations due to [30] Knight B. Forensic pathology. 2nd ed. London, Sydney, Auckland: Arnold; 1996.
injuries of soft tissue in the inner part of the larynx. Beitr Gerichtl Med [31] Saternus K-S. Zungenbein. In: Saternus K-S, Madea B, editors. Forensic autopsy.
1987;45:73–8. Handling of the human corpse. Research in legal medicine, vol.
[22] Tamaska L. Über die forensische Bedeutung der Varietäten des Schildknorpels. 36. Lübeck: Schmidt-Römhild; 2007. p. 166–7.
Zacchia 1963;26:479–89. [32] Thiel S. The dorsal configuration of the laryngeal cartilages. Doctoral Thesis,
[23] Tamaska L, Hinz P. Injuries of the larynx due to whiplash injury of the cervical Göttingen University; 2005.
vertebral spine. Zbl Verkehrs Med 1969;15:98–104. [33] Watanabe H, Kurihara K, Murai T. A morphometrical study of laryngeal
[24] Pauwels F. Collected papers about the functional anatomy of the locomotor cartilages. Med Sci Law 1982;22:255–60.
system. 3rd ed. Heidelberg, New York: Springer Berlin; 1965. [34] Ajmani ML, Jain SP, Saxena SK. A metrical study of laryngeal cartilages and
[25] Schlüter K. Shape and structure of the normal vs. the pathologically altered their ossification. Anat Anz 1980;148:42–8.
vertebrae. Stuttgart: Hippokrates Publishing Company; 1965.