Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
COMPLAINT
COMES the Plaintiffs, AMANDA ROLLINS and JILL FRANKLIN, by and through their
attorney, W. Tyler Weiss, and sues the Defendants ROBERT (“ROBBIE”) COLE, NATHAN
HENDERSON, DR. JAMES JONES, KELLY KIMSEY, TREVA HYATT and POLK COUNTY
BOARD OF EDUCATION, and for cause of action would show unto the Court as follows:
I. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
1. The Defendants, Robert (“Robbie”) Cole, a duly elected member of the Polk
County Board of Education, Nathan Henderson, a school resource officer, Dr. James Jones, the
Polk County School Superintendent, Kelly Kimsey, Treva Hyatt, the Polk County School System
Finance Director, and Polk County Board of Education, individually and/or conspired, in
combination and/or concert, with each other and possibly others by spreading false and malicious
rumors in and around the school system and the Polk County and surrounding community by
accusing the Plaintiffs of stealing and embezzling money allegedly belonging to the Copper Basin
1
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 1 of 15 PageID #: 1
Elementary School (“CBES”) and deprived the Plaintiffs of their teaching and administrative
positions at CBES. It was the Defendants’ illegal, conspiratorial, malicious, intentional, outrageous
and depraved actions that tarnished the personal and professional reputations of the Plaintiffs in
the community and the school system where Mrs. Rollins has been employed for the past 17 years
and Mrs. Franklin has been employed for the past four (4).
Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin’s procedural and substantive due process right in accordance with
the United States Constitution, Amendment XIV and Tennessee Code Annotated § 49-5-501 et
seq. The Defendants, collectively and/or individually, wrongfully terminated Ms. Rollins and Ms.
Franklin and have prejudged and tainted any due process hearing such that any hearing would be
3. This is a civil rights action pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 seeking compensatory and
punitive damages against the Defendants, individually and/or collectively or in combination, for
committing acts under color of law, and depriving Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin of rights secured
by the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution, as well as the state
4. Venue is appropriate in this Court because the parties and the acts alleged occurred
within Polk County, Tennessee, which is within this Court’s judicial district.
II. JURISDICTION
5. Jurisdiction is founded upon 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1343 and 1983. The Plaintiffs
request that this Court exercise its supplemental jurisdiction over the transactional state claims
2
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 2 of 15 PageID #: 2
III. PARTIES
6. The Plaintiff, AMANDA ROLLINS, at all times relevant is a citizen and resident
of 489 Campbell Cove Road, Turtletown, Polk County, Tennessee 37391. Amanda Rollins has
been employed by the Polk County Board of Education for 17 years and is a tenured teacher at the
Copper Basin Elementary School. At the times relevant to the allegations in this Complaint, Ms.
Rollins was a kindergarten teacher at Copper Basin Elementary School. Ms. Rollins is a member
7. The Plaintiff, JILL FRANKLIN, at all times relevant is a citizen and resident of
Tellico Plains, Monroe County, Tennessee. Jill Franklin has been employed by the Polk County
Board of Education as the tenured Principal of Copper Basin Elementary School for four (4) years.
At the times relevant to the allegations in this Complaint, Ms. Franklin was the tenured Principal
at Copper Basin Elementary School. Ms. Franklin is a member of the Professional Educators of
Tennessee, which has entered into a Memorandum of Understanding with the Polk County Board
8. The Defendant, ROBBIE COLE, at all times relevant is a citizen and resident of
Polk County, Tennessee. Defendant, Robbie Cole, is employed with the Polk County Sheriff’s
Department and is a School Resource Officer at Copper Basin High School. The Defendant,
Robbie Cole, is a duly elected member of the Polk County Board of Education as was an elected
member at all times relevant herein. Mr. Cole is being sued individually and in his official
capacities as an officer with the Polk County Sheriff’s Department and a duly elected member of
the Polk County Board of Education. Defendant, Robbie Cole, was at all times relevant acting
under color of law and under the customs and usages of the State of Tennessee. Defendant Cole
3
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 3 of 15 PageID #: 3
was at all times relevant a private citizen who acted in concert and combination with Defendants
Hyatt, Jones, Kimsey, Henderson and the School Board in conspiring to and effectuating the
violation of Plaintiffs Fourteenth Amendment rights, as well as her rights secured by Tennessee
Code Annotated and other state law causes of action set out herein.
resident of Polk County, Tennessee. Defendant, Nathan Henderson, is employed with the Polk
County Sheriff’s Department and was the School Resource Officer for the Copper Basin
Elementary School at all times relevant. Mr. Henderson is being sued individually and in his
official capacity as an officer with the Polk County Sheriff’s Department. Defendant, Nathan
Henderson, was at all times relevant acting under color of law and under the customs and usages
of the State of Tennessee. Defendant Henderson was at all times relevant a private citizen who
acted in concert and combination with Defendants Hyatt, Jones, Cole, Kimsey and the School
Board in conspiring to and effectuating the violation of Plaintiffs Fourteenth Amendment rights,
as well as her rights secured by Tennessee Code Annotated and other state law causes of action set
out herein.
10. The Defendant, KELLY KIMSEY, at all times relevant is a citizen and resident of
Polk County, Tennessee. Defendant Kimsey was at all times relevant a private citizen who acted
in concert and combination with Defendants Hyatt, Jones, Cole, Henderson and the School Board
in conspiring to and effectuating the violation of Plaintiffs Fourteenth Amendment rights, as well
as her rights secured by Tennessee Code Annotated and other state law causes of action set out
herein.
11. The Defendant, TREVA HYATT, at all times relevant is a citizen and resident of
Polk County, Tennessee. The Defendant, Treva Hyatt, is employed by the Polk County School
4
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 4 of 15 PageID #: 4
system and works in the central office. Ms. Hyatt is the Polk County School System Finance
Director. Defendant Hyatt was at all times relevant a private citizen who acted in concert and
combination with Defendants Kimsey, Jones, Cole, Henderson and the School Board in conspiring
to and effectuating the violation of Plaintiffs Fourteenth Amendment rights, as well as her rights
secured by Tennessee Code Annotated and other state law causes of action set out herein.
12. The Defendant, DR. JAMES JONES, at all times relevant is a citizen and resident
of Polk County, Tennessee. Defendant, Dr. James Jones is the Director of Schools for the Polk
County School System. Dr. Jones is being sued in his individual capacity and his official capacity
as the Director of Schools for the Polk County School System. Defendant, Dr. James Jones, was
at all times relevant acting under color of law and under the customs and usages of the State of
Tennessee. Defendant Jones was at all times relevant acted in concert and combination with
Defendants Hyatt, Kimsey, Cole, Henderson and the School Board in conspiring to and
effectuating the violation of Plaintiffs Fourteenth Amendment rights, as well as her rights secured
by Tennessee Code Annotated and other state law causes of action set out herein.
Board”) is a political subdivision of the State of Tennessee and responsible for providing education
to the children within its jurisdiction and for administering the laws and policies that govern the
public schools within its jurisdiction, which includes the Polk County School System. Its principal
address is 131 Stephens Street, Benton, Tennessee 37307. Its registered agent is Dr. James Jones,
the Director of the Polk County School District, and the registered agent’s address is 131 Stephens
5
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 5 of 15 PageID #: 5
Complaint as if fully set forth herein.
15. In September 2018, the School Board approved for Copper Basin Elementary
School (the “CBES”) to take the students on a field trip to Nashville, Tennessee and to Savannah,
Georgia. During the 2018-2019 school year, the parents of the children had several fundraising
events such as, Fried Green Tomato Festival, Dances, Bake Sales, Raffles, and Cougar Cards to
16. In the previous year, CBES took a field trip to Washington D.C. and money was
raised by the students’ parents in the similar manner, including a donation matching program. The
School Board gave its approval and Defendants Jones, Cole and the School Board had knowledge
of how the parents were raising money for their children to go on that field trip.
17. On or about April 20, 2019, Defendant Jones received a call from Defendant Cole
about an incident he needed to discuss with him in person. Upon information and belief, Defendant
Jones met with Defendants Cole and Henderson and discussed the CBES field trip fundraising,
including a Whirlpool donation matching program. Upon information and belief, Defendants Cole,
Jones and Henderson discussed among themselves the field trip fund raising activities and accused
Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin of embezzlement, stealing money and fraud.
18. Upon information and belief, the Defendants, collectively and individually, had
received a complaint or complaints from parents of students at CBES about the parents fundraising
activities and their child being upset because he/she did not have money to purchase a snack or
other item.
19. On or about April 20, 2019, Defendant Jones demanded to immediately meet with
Ms. Rollins, Ms. Franklin and Melissa Lance at CBES. Ms. Rollins was in the middle of
6
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 6 of 15 PageID #: 6
inconsistency of the TCAP test. Ms. Lance was a bookkeeper at CBES and was responsible for
properly recording and accounting for any funds received at CBES. The only people in this meeting
was Defendant Jones and Ms. Rollins, Ms. Franklin and Ms. Lance.
20. At that meeting, Defendant Jones immediately suspended, without pay, Ms.
Franklin and Ms. Rollins. Defendant Jones told Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin they have committed
a criminal offense and they would probably be arrested, charged with theft and go to prison.
Defendant Jones also immediately fired Ms. Lance. Upon information and belief, Melissa Lance’s
21. The day after Ms. Franklin was suspended, Defendant Cole told Beth Dlugokinski,
who became the interim principal at CBES, that Amanda Rollins must be embezzling money from
CBES because she would not be driving a Lexis and living in a house on the lake otherwise.
22. Also, on or about April 25, 2019, Defendant Cole told the sheriff that Ms. Rollins
and Ms. Franklin were stealing money and wanted the sheriff to take action against them. In late
May, Defendant Cole said to Lavonne Collins that the Rollins/Franklin matter was another “Mark
Stone case” and they were stealing money. Mark Stone was a former football/softball coach at
Copper Basin High School who misused and misappropriated equipment and funds. From the
investigation into Coach Stone, money was determined to be missing and unaccounted for.
23. Students at CBES have told Ms. Rollins daughter that she was arrested because she
was stealing from CBES and giving the money to kids at other schools. Ms. Franklin’s nieces and
nephews were also told that Ms. Franklin was escorted out of the CBES building in handcuffs and
criminally charged. Several other students have said that Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin were fired
24. In fact, Defendant Henderson’s daughter is one of the primary instigators and told
7
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 7 of 15 PageID #: 7
Ms. Rollins daughter that her dad arrested Ms. Rollins and took her to jail for stealing money.
Other citizens in the community have told Ms. Rollins that it is being told that Defendant
Henderson arrested Ms. Rollins for theft. Clearly these children, especially Defendant Henderson’s
daughter, are hearing the slanderous statements from their parents, relatives, friends and others
25. On or about May 10, 2019, Ms. Rollins was told to leave the school property while
she was watching her son’s football scrimmage game from administration. Ms. Rollins was afraid
that she would be escorted off the property by the police if she did not immediately leave. Ms.
Rollins missed her son’s football scrimmage game and was humiliated.
26. On or about July 12, 2019, it was learned that Janees Nipper was the new
elementary principal and that Ms. Rollins kindergarten position was on job postings and that Ms.
Rollins and Ms. Franklin were being replaced. In fact, Ms. Nipper, the new CBES principal who
27. On or about July 16, 2019, Mrs. Nipper sent Amanda Rollins a message asking her
when she could get her things out of the class and told her that she had been fired.
28. On or about July 18, 2019, Dr. James Jones sent Amanda Rollins a message on
phone stating, “as you have been told by the principal, you will not be working for us in the
upcoming school year. I will be sending you a certified letter stating such tomorrow. . . .” However,
29. On or about August 3, 2018, the Polk County School System Internal School Funds
Annual Financial Report for the year ended June 30, 2018 (the “2018 Audit”) was released. From
the 2018 Audit, Defendant Jones and the School Board were under a Corrective Action Plan, which
was a result of improper fundraising collection and booking actions. According to the Corrective
8
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 8 of 15 PageID #: 8
Action Plan “two schools did not properly follow cash collection procedures for fundraisers . . . .”
30. Upon information and belief, the two (2) schools were Benton Elementary and
Chilhowee Middle School. The Corrective Action Plan further stated that “[t]he fundraiser
collection procedure errors have been specifically addressed with the principals and bookkeepers
31. Upon information and belief, the principals, teachers or bookkeepers at the two (2)
schools who were not following the proper fundraiser collections procedure were not suspended,
without pay, or terminated and did not get accused of theft, fraud or money laundering.
32. In fact, only the “Internal school fund bookkeepers [were] required to attend
training on procedures required for collection of money and fundraiser documentation.” Upon
information and belief, the principals nor the teachers had any required training obligations and
the 2018 Audit merely states that the “fundraiser collection procedure errors have been specifically
33. On or about June 18, 2019, Defendant Jones addressed the school board concerning
the status of Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin. Defendant Jones stated that it is very unlikely that arrest
warrants would be issued against Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin. However, the Defendants Jones,
Cole, Henderson and the School Board continued to assert and represent to the public that Ms.
Rollins and Ms. Franklin had committed fraud, theft and/or money laundering because they had
not followed the proper due process and statutory procedures afforded to teachers.
34. It is clear that Defendant Jones, who has actually said it, and the School Board never
had the intentions of allowing Ms. Rollins or Ms. Franklin to continue their employment with Polk
County School System. In fact, the actions of the Defendants Jones, Cole and School Board
indicate that they have prejudged this issue and have effectively fired Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin
9
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 9 of 15 PageID #: 9
and have not gave them due process of law or afforded them the statutory processes under the
Tennessee Code Annotated or the Memorandum of Understanding entered into between the School
35. Upon information and belief, Defendant Hyatt, among others, does not like Ms.
Franklin because Ms. Franklin fired Defendant Kimsey for falsifying her timecard. It was no secret
that Defendant Kimsey did not like Ms. Franklin, in fact hated her, after Defendant Kimsey was
fired, and she believed Ms. Franklin was evil and was looking for ways to “expose her” and get
vengeance. Defendant Kimsey and Defendant Hyatt are close friends and Defendant Hyatt and
Defendant Kimsey have been looking for opportunities to get Ms. Franklin back and get
vengeance.
36. In July 2019, someone contacted Whirlpool and accused Tony Rollins, Ms. Rollins
husband, of fraud and other criminal acts associated with the donation matching program. Tony
Rollins works for Whirlpool and has for several years. Upon information and belief, the caller was
37. On or about July 30, 2019, Tony Rollins was questioned by a Whirlpool lawyer
about the person’s allegation that made in the phone call and accusing Mr. and Ms. Rollins and
38. To this date, Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin have not received any due process
hearing or been afforded any rights as tenured teachers nor have they been afforded any right to
39. The Defendants have purposefully classified any audit and investigation into the
field trip fundraising accounting issue as criminal to effectively deprive Ms. Rollins and Ms.
Franklin of their procedural and substantive due process rights. Defendant Cole has repeatedly
10
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 10 of 15 PageID #: 10
asserted that Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin will be prosecuted for theft.
40. Defendants Jones, Cole, Hyatt and the School Board know that the Tennessee Code
Annotated, Polk County Board of Education policies and procedures and the MOU would require
due process hearings and a completion of any investigation within 90 days of the suspension when
there is no criminal investigation. Defendant Jones specifically told the School Board that it is not
expected that criminal warrants would be issued against Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin on or about
41. It has been almost six (6) months since Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin have been
initially suspended and approximately three (3) months since Defendant Jones made his assertion
42. Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin have made demands to Defendants Jones and the
School Board to have their due process hearing and attempt to clear their name.
43. Upon information and belief, Defendant Jones, Cole, Hyatt and the School Board
did not reprimand, suspend, terminate or take any negative employment action against the
principals or teachers of the other schools within the school system for accounting irregularities
combination, Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin has suffered damages, financially, emotionally,
45. The Defendants, acting solely and/or in concert and in combination, was reckless,
malicious, willful, intentional, oppressive and taken with a motive to intentionally harm Ms.
Rollins and Ms. Franklin and/or violate their clearly established constitutional rights and
Tennessee statutory and common law rights and/or with such reckless disregard of those clearly
11
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 11 of 15 PageID #: 11
established rights so as to render these Defendants liable to Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin for
punitive damages.
V. CAUSES OF ACTION
Count A – Tennessee Defamation/False Light/Conspiracy to Defame
combination, made and published vicious, patently false and misleading facts about Ms. Rollins
and Ms. Franklin. The Defendants acted intentionally to spread the defamatory statements, or in
the alternative, they acted with reckless disregard of the truth in derogation of the common law of
48. As described above, the Defendants’ actions have painted Ms. Rollins and Ms.
Franklin in a false light before the public. The Defendants were negligent and/or reckless in failing
to ascertain the truth or falsity of the allegations and statements that they published and made
throughout the community. Alternatively, the Defendants acted with actual malice and/or
49. As a result of the Defendants defamatory, slanderous, and libelous actions and
statements, which were done, individually and/or collectively and in combination, Ms. Rollins and
harmed and caused damage to Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin physically, emotionally, financially
12
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 12 of 15 PageID #: 12
Complaint as if fully set forth herein.
52. As described above, the Defendants’ conduct, individually and/or collectively and
in combination, constituted a breach of Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklins actual and/or implied
teaching contract.
53. The Defendants’ actions were taken individually and/or in concert and in
combination, was reckless, malicious, willful, intentional, oppressive and taken with a motive to
intentionally harm Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin and/or with such reckless disregard of those
clearly established rights and protections so as to render these Defendants liable to Ms. Rollins
harmed and caused damage to Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin physically, emotionally, financially
combination, deprived Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin of their rights to procedural and substantive
due process secured by the Polk County Board of Education Policies and Procedures, the MOU,
Tennessee Code Annotated § 49-5-501 et seq. and the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States
Constitution, respectively, while acting under color of state law, in violation of § 1983 and the
Fourteenth Amendment.
undertaken with malice or reckless disregard for or with indifference to Ms. Rollins and Ms.
13
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 13 of 15 PageID #: 13
Franklin’s federally protected rights.
58. The Defendants’ actions were taken individually and/or in concert and in
combination, was reckless, malicious, willful, intentional, oppressive and taken with a motive to
intentionally harm Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin and/or violate their clearly established
constitutional rights and/or with such reckless disregard of those clearly established rights so as to
render these Defendants liable to Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin for punitive damages.
harmed and caused damage to Ms. Rollins and Ms. Franklin physically, emotionally, financially
FRANKLIN, would respectfully requests from this Court the following relief:
1. That the Plaintiff, JILL FRANKLIN, be reinstated to her tenured principal position
at Copper Basin Elementary School and grant her a permanent injunction enjoining Defendants,
their officers, successors, assigns, and all persons acting in concert with them from further
violating § 1983, the U.S. Constitution Amendment XIV, Tenn. Code Ann. § 49-5-501 et seq. and
Tennessee law;
position at Copper Basin Elementary School and grant her a permanent injunction enjoining
Defendants, their officers, successors, assigns, and all persons acting in concert with them from
further violating § 1983, the U.S. Constitution Amendment XIV, Tenn. Code Ann. § 49-5-501 et
3. That this Court enter a judgment for the Plaintiffs awarding them compensatory
14
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 14 of 15 PageID #: 14
and/or punitive damages;
4. That the Defendants, individually and/or collectively, are ordered to make the
Plaintiffs whole and award them all legal and equitable relief available for the unlawful conduct
described in their Complaint, including: (a) back pay and damages for lost benefits; (b)
reinstatement with restoration of all benefits and seniority or alternatively, front pay and damages
for lost benefits; (c) compensatory damages for embarrassment, humiliation, emotional distress
and anxiety, inconvenience, damage to reputation and loss of enjoyment of life; (d) punitive
damages against the individual defendants under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and Tennessee common law;
(e) attorney’s fees, costs and litigation expenses; and (f) prejudgment interest and, if applicable,
post-judgment interest;
5. The Plaintiffs demand a trial by jury of all issues triable of right by a jury;
6. That the Court exercise its supplemental jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1367
7. That this Court award the Plaintiffs their reasonable attorney’s fees and costs
8. That they be awarded such other and further legal or equitable relief to which they
may be entitled.
15
Case 1:19-cv-00282-PLR-CHS Document 1 Filed 10/05/19 Page 15 of 15 PageID #: 15