Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Pranab Saha et al
SAE International Technical Quality Response Team (TQRT)
Helpful for experienced and new authors, the purpose of this paper is to provide guidance for the
preparation of content of an SAE International technical paper. Guidance on each technical paper element
has been placed in the appropriate section as much as possible.
A technical paper is a fact-based document used to close a project or a piece of work. Papers are written in
an objective, formal, impersonal, third-person style.
SAE International does not restrict the number of pages for a technical paper, although the recommended
length is 9-12 pages in a 2-column format.
Standard rules for written English should be followed in the text The paper should not have any plagiarism. Plagiarism is
of the paper. U.S. or UK rules are acceptable, but either must committed when an author purposely uses someone else’s
be applied consistently, not mixed. Standard grammar will work, language, thoughts, or ideas without acknowledging the
ensure that the paper is easily understood by a wide audience original source or getting proper approval from the original
including those not using English as a primary language. source. Therefore, it is extremely important to cite and
reference others who have worked in the field in order to avoid
Spell-check and grammar-check software can be used to plagiarism. SAE International defines plagiarism as “the use or
inspect the written text, but should not be a substitute for a presentation of the ideas or words of another person from an
thorough personal review. A review by non-authors fluent in existing source without appropriate acknowledgement to that
English is one way to check grammar, but must be completed source.” For more information, see the How to Cite
prior to the SAE International peer-review process. (Official References section.
reviewers and organizers do not provide this service.) The
complexity of the technical subject or an author’s difficulty with Examples of Unacceptable Text
technical writing are never excuses to avoid following these
guidelines. A person unfamiliar with the topic should be able to A few examples of unacceptable text are:
read the paper and understand the general theme.
Editorial comments, such as: “The jet aircraft costs $5,500,000.
Many companies provide substantive editing via the Web, This is a substantial sum of money despite the casualness with
including: which million-dollar sums are bandied about these days.”
• The Charlesworth Group
(http://www.charlesworthauthorservices.com/) Personal history, such as: “The first military pre-stressing
• American Journal Experts problem that came to my desk was in 1938 in connection with
(http://www.journalexperts.com/) a request from the Army that we increase the displacement of
• Editage its truck engines.”
(http://www.editage.com/)
Page 2 of 8
Unsubstantiated sweeping statements, such as: “I believe I can The paper should not list the equipment used as it may be
safely say that practically every failure of a new or retreaded jet listed in a laboratory report unless some specific equipment
tire, where the cause could be ascertained, has proved to be needs to be described to understand the work.
the result of a manufacturing error.”
For simulation and analytical work, the system model needs to
Units of Measure be described clearly. This includes identifying any
commercially available software that may have been used to
do the study. If proprietary software or special software has
The long-term goal for SAE is international communication with
been developed, then the fundamental equations that are
minimal effort and confusion. Therefore, the use of S.I. units in
involved need to be discussed and identified so the credibility
all technical publications and presentations is preferred. SAE
of the work is substantiated. However, the author has to be
International will strive toward universal usage of S.I. units and
careful so there is no commercialism or commercial overtone.
will encourage their use whenever appropriate.
Information on various quality metrics, such as mesh
geometry, justification of mesh sizes, and/or nodal boundary
However, SAE International also recognizes that sectors of the conditions needs to be provided.
mobility market do not yet use S.I. units because of tradition,
regulatory language, or other reasons. Mandating the use of
S.I. units in these cases will impede, rather than facilitate Analysis
technical communication. Therefore, it is the policy to allow
non-S.I. units and dual dimensioning where communication will Analysis could be of two types, qualitative and quantitative.
be enhanced. This shall not be viewed as an avenue to Qualitative means obtaining an in-depth understanding of
circumvent the long-term goal of 100% S.I. usage. properties of the product or the solution obtained. Quantitative
means obtaining numerical values of the product or the
Examples of Units solution obtained and thereby determining the performance
metric of the product and/or the solution. These should be
The general rule for capitalization is based on whether the unit clearly discussed and explained for the long term value of the
was based on a proper noun, e.g., Newton. A few examples of work. In discussing the analysis process, tables, graphs, and
units are shown here: photographs should be used to help visualize and explain the
results of the analysis. The tables, graphs, and photographs
need to be explained clearly in order to convey what they
• Hz mean/stand for as opposed to just mentioning that the results
• dB are shown in the figure. Wherever possible, comparison
• km results should be provided in graphical forms rather than
• Nm tabular forms.
• kPa
• kHz Examples of Various Illustrations
Methodology This section provides examples of various illustrations that may
be used to prepare a quality paper.
While writing a technical paper, it is very important to clearly
state everything that is necessary in setting up the work. This Examples of Equations
may include a description of any hypotheses, all implicit and
explicit assumptions, equations, boundary conditions, different
Three examples of equations are shown here. All equations
analysis techniques for solving analytical problems, equation
wider than 3.5 inches must be wrapped to the next line as
verification, measurement setup, and all other pertinent items
shown in Equations 1 and 2. Variables used in equations need
that make this paper a quality paper. Also, it is important to
to be defined in a Nomenclature section at the end of the paper
use correct and consistent terminology used in the discipline.
or following the actual equation as shown in Equation 3.
Addressing these elements properly is not only important for
the credibility of the author and the paper, but also for
successive researchers to classify the work and also to
duplicate the study should that be required.
⎡�1 + 161 � 𝑥𝑥+ � − 12 �1 + 161 �𝑥𝑥𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝
2 2
+ � −1
⎤
A few specific thoughts for preparing a paper based on 𝑑𝑑𝑑𝑑 𝑥𝑥 𝑥𝑥
=⎢ − ⎥×
experimental work would include the following: 𝑑𝑑𝑑𝑑 ⎢ 2(𝐴𝐴⁄𝐹𝐹 )𝑠𝑠𝑠𝑠 2(𝐴𝐴⁄𝐹𝐹 )𝑠𝑠𝑠𝑠 ⎥
• a description of the work and method used; ⎣ ⎦
• a description of the measurement setup such that
the experiment can be reproduced by others; and 12
(1 − 𝐵𝐵𝐵𝐵𝐹𝐹𝑠𝑠𝑠𝑠 ) ∙ (1)
�t−tprev�
• a discussion of the basis of the measuring
principle/comments on the accuracy, precautions,
and limitations on the measurement technique in
general.
Page 3 of 8
When plotting data in a graphical form, all the axes should be
labeled with the proper units. If for proprietary reasons the
1 ∂K f actual data cannot be shared, the data should be non-
ΔK aero _ f (0) = − Laero _ f +
2 ∂W f dimensionalized, normalized, or provide relative data for
presentation purposes. The axes information, including the
1 ∂Faero _ y ∂M aero _ z l f l numerical values of the tick marks, should be legible if printed
lr + − K f (2)
2l ∂β ∂β lr K r mV 2 on an 8.5”x11” or A4 size paper.
100
90
80
60
Where, 50
N = number of possible designs
40
L = number of levels for each factor
m = number of factors 30
20
10
25 mm fiberglass tested at 13 facilities
0
Examples of Figures 250 1000 4000
1/3 Octave Band Center Frequency [Hz]
Figure 3. An example of a figure used for data presentation with a
Three examples of figures are shown here:
reference to related work [5]
1. Photograph
2. A schematic or qualitative data
3. Graphical presentation of data Example of a Table
Page 5 of 8
4. Kook, S., Bae, C., Miles, P., Choi, D. et al., “The Effect 18. Acoustics Testing Laboratory of the NASA Glenn
of Swirl Ratio and Fuel Injection Parameters on CO Research Center (Distributor), Auditory Demonstrations
Emission and Fuel Conversion Efficiency for High- II: Challenges in Speech Communication and Music
Dilution, Low-Temperature Combustion in an Listening, Available from the NASA Glenn Research
Automotive Diesel Engine,” SAE Technical Paper 2006- Center Acoustical Testing Laboratory 04 from
01-0197, 2006, doi:10.4271/2006-01-0197. http://acousticaltest.grc.nasa.gov, Dec 2003.
5. Saha, P., Pan, J., and Veen, J., “Thoughts behind 19. SAE International, “How Does SAE World Congress
Developing a Small Reverberation Room-Based Sound Enable Industry Networking and Relationship-Building?”
Absorption Test Method for the Automotive Industry,” SAE Video 10943, uploaded Nov. 11, 2011.
Presented at NOISE-CON 2008, USA, July 28-31,
2008.
6. Yokosawa H., Fujita, H., Hirota, M., and Iwata S., Nomenclature
“Measurement of Turbulent Flow in a Square Duct with
Roughened Walls on Two Opposite Sides,” Int. J. Heat Theoretical papers are likely to have multiple equations.
and Fluid Flow 10:125-130, 1989. Various terminologies used in these equations should be
7. Antanaitis, D., Monsere, P., and Riefe, M., “Brake identified in a section entitled Nomenclature. Terminologies
System and Subsystem Design Considerations for can also be listed following each respective equation.
Race Track and High Energy Usage Based on Fade
Limits,” SAE Int. J. Passeng. Cars - Mech. Syst. Contact Information
1(1):689-708, 2008, doi:10.4271/2008-01-0817.
8. Veen, J., Pan, J., and Saha, P., “Standardized Test This is where the main author information (author name,
Procedures for Small Reverberation Room,” Sound and phone, and email address) is listed. If desired, the author can
include background, education, and web address details. This
Vibration: 18-20, December 2005.
is an optional section.
9. The International Organization for Standardization
(ISO), “Acoustics – Measurement of Sound Absorption Example:
in a Reverberation Room,” ISO 354, May 2003. Pranab Saha, Ph.D., P.E., INCE Board Certified
10. SAE International Surface Vehicle Recommended Work phone: (248) 674-4100
Practice, “Laboratory Measurement of the Composite e-mail: prsaha@kandse.com
Vibration Damping Properties of Material on a
Supporting Steel Bar,” SAE Standard J1637, Rev. Aug. Acknowledgments
2007.
11. Larsen, R. and Marx, M., “Statistics,” Prentice-Hall, This is an optional section to acknowledge a person or an
Saddle River, ISBN 0-13-844085-9, 1990. organization assisting to make the paper possible.
12. Richards, P., “Automotive Fuels Reference Book, Third
Example:
Edition,” SAE International, Warrendale, ISBN 978-0-
Thanks to the SAE International TQRT (Technical Quality
7680-0638-4, 2014, doi:10.4271/R-297. Response Team) members and the associated SAE Staff
13. Smith, R., “On the Development of Green Energy,” members for making this paper possible.
Private Communication, Feb. 2007.
14. Wilkinson, J., “Nonlinear Resonant Circuit Devices,” Author Affiliation
U.S. Patent 3,624,124, July 16, 1990.
15. Paulson, J., Menzefricke, K., and Gurtoo, P., “Technical The author/co-author information should credit their respective
Insights Lightweight Material Technology Analysis: Fuel affiliations at the time the paper was written. Should the
Efficiency Stimulates Use of Lightweight Materials in affiliations change prior to publication, the current
Automobile Industry,” company(ies) can be acknowledged in the Acknowledgements
section of the paper.
http://www.scienceblog.com/community/older/2004/8/20
047474.shtml, June 2004.
16. Mathuria, P., “Transfer Path Analysis of Diesel Engine Definitions, Acronyms, Abbreviations
Noise Using Statistical Energy Analysis,” Ph.D. thesis,
This is an optional section. The following is an example:
Mechanical Engineering Department, Indian Institute of
Technology, Bombay, 2000.
barrier A barrier is a material that causes
17. Miller, M., The Interactive Tester (Version 4.0), the sound wave to lose energy as
Computer Software, Psytek Services, Westminster, CA, the wave is transmitted through the
1993. material and propagates from one
region to the other.
Page 6 of 8
SA Sample Abbreviations
Page 7 of 8
APPENDIX
Any bulk of information that interrupts the flow of thought in the paper should be placed in an appendix. Examples include large tables,
large images, or long mathematical derivations. Examples:
2
P ωCosθ Bω 2
4 PsωCosθ
2
Bω 2 Sin 4θ
STL = 10 log10 1 + η s Sin θ + 1 − (4)
2ρc 2 ρ c
4
Ps c Ps c 4
Frequency Range Frequency (Hz) General System Influence of different factors (%)
Behavior
Ratio of wear to Mass-filled layer
mass filled layer Decoupler density
thickness
density
Double Wall
Range 2 400 to 1000 Resonance 1 3 96
Effects
Double Wall
Range 4 4000 to 8000 7 7 77
Decoupled Region
Page 8 of 8