Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

HOURLY NEWS
NPR 24 Hour Program Stream
LISTEN On
LIVE
Air Now
PLAYLIST

DONATE

Tiny Desk All Songs Considered Music News New Music Live Sessions

Deceptive Cadence

DECEPTIVE CADENCE

Women Are Great Composers Too, Why

Aren't They Being Heard?
An appalling recent statistic: only 1.8 percent of music programmed by
major U.S. orchestras was written by women

May 1, 2017 · 8:00 AM ET

MOHAMMED FAIROUZ

Missing from the music stands across top U.S. orchestras: music written by women.
Maxcam2008/Getty Images/iStockphoto

1 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

As a composer, I entered a profession in which I knew I could actively alter our

fractious present using the incomparable tools of art. After all, the intellectually
curious and essentially progressive landscapes of our concert halls and opera houses
seem like the perfect arenas in which to harness momentum for change and, through
the aspirational craft of music, feel the resurrection of hope in the midst of despair
and apathy.

Composers should be leading these conversations. We're not. The symphonic halls in
which I work have singularly distinguished themselves among the humanities as the
forum that takes the least account of the shape and form of humanity itself.

Women make up over half the world's population. But you still won't find their
creative voices in the concert hall.

DECEPTIVE CADENCE
Looking For Women's Music At The Symphony? Good Luck!

When it comes to concert music, we may be engaging with the only profession that
actively discriminates against the living in favor of the dead. But even within that
living minority, the numbers from a 2014-15 orchestral survey are a devastating
embarrassment by any stretch of the imagination.

The artistic leadership of the 21 largest American orchestras have collectively

programmed their seasons in such a way that women composers accounted for 1.8
percent of the overall season.

Just 1.8 percent... I'd like to understand the underlying conscious or unconscious
motivation that has led us to this situation.

Many of these organizations are led by artistic and executive directors who are
intelligent, sensitive and thoughtful people. And yet our concert halls are doing worse
than even Congress in terms of female representation. To put it in perspective, 27
percent of the Trump administration's appointees so far are women. (To be clear,
nobody should hold that number as a standard for female empowerment.)

2 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

Article continues after sponsor message

In an interview on CNN marking International Women's Day, the United Arab

Emirates (U.A.E.)'s ambassador to the United Nations, Lana Nusseibeh, commented
that the day should not be viewed as a simple occasion for celebration. It could better
be viewed as an opportunity to remind ourselves of the urgent need to redouble our
efforts towards closing the chasm of opportunity and representation that separates
women from men. Nusseibeh also cites World Economic Forum data projecting that
we would not close the gender gap until the year 2186 should we continue at our
current rate of progress.

What year would it be for classical music to close its gender gap?

Only 18 of the 193 nations who are U.N. member states currently have female heads
of state leading them. That's less than 10 percent. This stark disparity of
representation means that global leadership, by and large, does not reflect the way
that the societies of our world actually look. That is an inorganic, counterproductive,
self-defeating misrepresentation: a social lie of massive proportions.

And on top of all this, a disastrous message is being telegraphed to half of the human
race, discouraging their aspirations to reach the top roles of leadership and visibility.
Disinvesting from half of the population of the world is existentially untenable.

I'd like to gently suggest to those men and women in positions of artistic leadership:

3 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

the next time you bristle when women are abused, attacked or demeaned, please
consider the power that you have to counteract this sort of toxic objectification.

Rather than engage in yet another discussion with friends over the unchanging
behavior of our proven public misogynists, discover and fall in love with a new score
by a female composer. Program one of the many, many powerful works by one of my
female colleagues. Realize that your concert halls are training grounds for empathy.
The more that their music is allowed to speak to an audience, the harder it is for
people to objectify or dehumanize the creators of the works that speak to their hearts.

I remember those music history courses back in conservatory. Not only did the old
Norton anthologies of Western music casually brush aside the musical traditions held
dear by the vast majority of cultures on our planet, they led me to constantly wonder
how much raw human talent was just wasted in the 18th and 19th centuries.
Beethoven is great but, taking these courses, one could easily imagine that there was
not a single woman on the European continent for century after century.

To the orchestral deciders: I understand the reason why Mozart and Beethoven
dominate your symphonic cycles. You want to program something great, and
something that you know will bring in audiences. And then you program it again, and
again, and again. Next season, instead of making your concert hall great again, look
into the incredibly diverse musical communities that surround you (especially if
you're at the helm of any of the United States' 21 biggest orchestras) and listen to the
sounds that they are enamored with.

Much of my work as a composer and writer continues to focus on breaking through

the clouds of misperception that bedevil communication between the Middle East
and the Western world. After my most recent visit to the U.A.E., I noted that the
statistics there tell a story very similar to — and sometimes much better than — the
West. Emirati women make up more than 25 percent of cabinet-level ministers in the
U.A.E. About 50 percent of employees in the U.A.E.'s space program are women, and
46 percent of the country's graduates in STEM subjects are female. By comparison,
about 20 percent of U.S. Congresspeople are women.

In the world today, those are our "good numbers."

4 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

Ambassador Nusseibeh was right. It's not time to celebrate yet. Anyone can see that,
in a world where over half of humanity is female, numbers that live between 20 and
25 percent simply prove that our "good" statistics need a lot of work.

“
"Realize that your concert halls are training grounds for
empathy."

And here I have to come back to the orchestral circuit and our own shocking number:
1.8 percent of music programmed in concert halls by the 21 largest American
orchestras, in 2014-15, was by female composers. That is an appalling statistic. This is
a problem that must be viewed within a wider issue of diversification in concert
music. As a man, I contend that men need to play our part to fix this, and we need to
do so out of self-interest rather than any sense of false "charity."

Leave the moral dimension of equality aside. A strategic waste of potential on this
scale will lead to a debilitation of the entire human enterprise. We're all in this
together. And I'm pretty sure that if women could solve the problems of equality and
representation themselves, then they would've done it by now. We made this mess
and now we need to help clean it up.

For my part, I will say this: If you are programming a show and my music appeals to
you as much as the music of one of my colleagues who happens to be a women, then
please practice positive discrimination and pick my colleague over me.

In a September 2016 article in which I discussed programming diversity at the then-

newly minted Dubai Opera, I also wrote about how a venue needs to mirror its
audiences:

"In July, the speaker of the United States House of Representatives, Paul Ryan, posted
a selfie with a group of Capitol Hill interns that immediately sparked comments on the
lack of diversity in the photo. In response, Eddie Bernice Johnson, a Democrat from
Texas, posted a photo showing a significantly more diverse group of Democratic
interns. The two images are not only a commentary on disparity in diversity, they
speak to one of the choices of our time: clinging to the sequestered past or moving
forward towards an inevitably integrated future.

5 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

All institutions that want to thrive today must acknowledge and reflect what the world
looks like today. Great artists have constantly cut to the core of the human experience
in profound ways. So perhaps art has to reflect the way that humanity actually looks to
survive."

If we are to survive, we need to start by reversing policies that silence the voices of
half of humanity.

As President Kennedy said in one of his most touching speeches: "If sometimes our
great artists have been the most critical of our society, it is because their sensitivity
and their concern for justice, which must motivate any true artist, makes him aware
that our Nation falls short of its highest potential. I see little of more importance to
the future of our country and our civilization than full recognition of the place of the
artist."

Of course, JFK assumed in 1961 that the artist was a "him." But we cannot forgive
ourselves if we continue on that path, a path that deprives the justice of equality from
half of our society. We have no business illuminating the areas in which our society
falls short of its highest potential if we ourselves are falling short of even basic
standards. If we do not correct our path to a more inclusive one, we will mortally
diminish the importance of our art form to the future of civilization and human
discourse.

Mohammed Fairouz is a composer whose operas and symphonies have been

performed at Carnegie Hall, Lincoln Center and the Kennedy Center and
internationally at venues such as the Dutch National Opera, Dubai Opera and the
Barbican in London. His writings on the arts and foreign policy have appeared in
The New York Times, Foreign Policy, The National (U.A.E.), The Independent, Open
Democracy and The Huffington Post.

Sign Up For The NPR Music Newsletter

6 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

Listen to new music, watch the latest Tiny Desk concerts and more, sent
weekly.

What's your email?

SUBSCRIBE

By subscribing, you agree to NPR's terms of use and privacy policy.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More Stories From NPR

MUSIC
Baltimore Symphony Orchestra And Musicians End Contentious Contract
Dispute

7 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

MUSIC
Remembering The 'Fast And Furious' Music Of Christopher Rouse

Popular on NPR.org

MUSIC FEATURES
'We Live In The Time Of Joni Mitchell': Brandi Carlile Turns 'Blue' Into
Repertoire

8 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

BOOK REVIEWS
Prince Memoir, 'The Beautiful Ones,' Brings To Life A Vision In One's Mind

MUSIC INTERVIEWS
King Princess On 'Cheap Queen'

NEW MUSIC
Listen: Kanye West Finally Drops 'Jesus Is King'

9 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

NPR Editors' Picks

NEW MUSIC
Lizzo Enlists Ariana Grande For 'Good As Hell' Remix

MUSIC
Andy Bey At 80: A Love Letter To A Jazz Legend

10 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

MUSIC
Rio Mira: Tiny Desk Concert

NEW MUSIC
New Music Friday: Our Top 8 Albums Out On Oct. 25

Deceptive Cadence

11 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm
Women Are Great Composers Too, Why Aren't They Being Heard... https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2017/05/01/5259...

READ & LISTEN CONNECT

Home Newsletters

News Facebook

Arts & Life Twitter

Music Instagram

Podcasts Contact

Programs Help

ABOUT NPR GET INVOLVED

Overview Support Public Radio

Finances Sponsor NPR

People NPR Careers

Press NPR Shop

Public Editor NPR Events

Corrections Visit NPR

terms of use

privacy

your privacy choices

text only

© 2019 npr

12 of 12 28/10/19, 3:58 pm