Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
O
ver the past few decades, tourism has grown by leaps and bounds
worldwide, especially so in India, contributing to a substantial
increase in revenue, capital investment and job opportunities,
mainly in the Hospitality and Tourism Industries. This has been given
impetus by the emergence of many niche tourism products like MICE, i.e.
the segments covering medical, sports, wellness, eco-tourism, adventure
etc. As per the Travel and Tourism Council, tourism generated $121
billion i.e. 6.4% of India’s GDP in 2011. According to an analysis done by
IBEF (India Brand Equity Foundation), the Tourism Industry contributed
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
©2018 by Vedatya Institute. All Rights Reserved.
140 Hospitality Management Institutes
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
141 Jaykumar
followed suit, the Government giving due support and thrust to hospitality
and related industries observed Honey & Gilpin (2009). All these efforts
fructified, when more and more aspirants joined institutes which offered
programmes in hospitality, tourism etc., to learn the trade and make it their
profession.
The purpose of this paper is to track the growth in the Hospitality
Industry over the past decade or two in India, understand the industry’s
requirement for skilled and qualified manpower and the eventual shift in
its expectations from the hospitality management graduates entering the
industry at various levels. This paper will also endeavor to look at the
curriculum of hospitality education meted out by government and private
institutes alike, to gain an understanding of the objectives fulfilled, skills
taught and knowledge imparted by them to make the students tailor-ready
for the industry. Taking this forward, an attempt would be ensued to rec-
ognize the glaring and obvious skills gap prevalent in fresh hospitality
management graduates today; i.e. between the skills and the knowledge he
is groomed with by the institute and the skill sets he is expected to possess
by the industry he is entering into. The study also would seek opinions
from faculty members and alumni about their views and suggestions on
the above issues. Though this shift in the expected skill sets by the indus-
try would be the core of this paper, other limitations and complications in
relation to hospitality education would also be looked at; so that ways and
means of dealing with them could be sought and confirmed.
Obviously, these changes need to be made at a micro level i.e. by the
institutes at the designing of curricula & skill development level and the
Hospitality Industryat the recruiting and training level. The information
gathered and suggestions received would enable us to look forward to a
future, where the skills gap would be negligible and all the stakeholdersthe
students, institutes and the hospitality partners benefit from this
concentrated effort.
Literature Review
Hospitality Industry in India: The Hospitality and Tourism Industry
has come to the fore as one of the major driving forces in the growth
and development of the Indian economy. The continuous growth in the
inflow of foreign tourists, not to undermine the huge number of domestic
travelers, have given a major boost to the Hospitality Industry and placed
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
142 Hospitality Management Institutes
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
143 Jaykumar
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
144 Hospitality Management Institutes
from the hotel management institutes does not meet the expectations
of potential recruiters. Skills gap is defined as “ the difference between
the markets need (demand) and the current skills supplied by the local
education institutes (supply)” observed Alsafadi & Abunafesa, (2012).
Ideally, hospitality programmes are designed to groom the students with
skills that would prepare them for the competitive world of hospitality.
These skills ensure that the students are able to deal with the rapidly
changing demands of the professional arena, observed Asirifi et al (2013).
Huge gaps have been found between the formal classroom training and
industry expectations in the hotel industry. Johnstone (1994) states, that
hospitality management programmes should concentrate on those skills
hard and soft, which are deemed essential and imperative for the graduates
to be adept in. Yet these programmes ignore many of these skills in their
modules being taught. As a result, the employers found the new recruits
lacking in some of the crucial skills they expected hospitality graduates
to possess. Goodman & Sprague (1991) suggest, that it is imperative that
hospitality education programmes be continuously upgraded to meet the
changing demands of the hospitality industry; which in turn depends
on changing consumer trends. Hence, hospitality programmes must be
attuned with adapting to this shift, responding with educational content
backed by practical inputs so that the graduates are groomed with strong
skill sets ready for the competitive professional world when they enter it ,
opined Asirifi et. Al. (2013) .
What resulted from such a skill gap is, that the graduates from the
hotel management institutes found themselves without lucrative job offers
from the reputed hotel brands and the percentage of unemployed hotel
management graduated began to increase to a worrisome level. According
to the National Employability Report (2012) for hotel management gradu-
ates by Aspiring Mind, only 6% to 18% of these graduates are fit to work
in the industry, and 19% - 43% candidates were unemployed due to poor
communication skills observed Singh & Jaykumar (2017).
Hard Skills Vs Soft Skills
Skills refer to the level of performance of an individual on a particular task
or capability to perform a job well, defined Noe, Hollenbeck & Gerhar,
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
145 Jaykumar
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
146 Hospitality Management Institutes
acquirement and job sustainability and lack of which has created the
skills gap in the professional arena, particularly the Hospitality Industry;
the next step would be to impart the necessary training to the students
while they are in colleges and institutes getting ready to embark into the
professional world.
The aim of a soft skills training programme would be to make the in-
dividuals aware of their hidden skills or capabilities, refine and hone these
skills to culminate in overall development; which in turn would boost their
confidence and worth in the employment market and ultimately result in
success in their chosen profession. It is imperative to align employability
with academic values by linking the institute’s curriculum and employ-
ability, remarked Saunders and Zuzel (2010). Soft skills training should
be incorporated into the Higher Education curriculum, and integrated with
technical training advised by theInternational Youth Foundation(2013).
This would be the much required link between universities and industry
needs bridging the gap between both, to create employability opportuni-
ties for candidates at the entry-level, observed Singh & Jaykumar (2017).
Academic researchers have agreed that the primary reason for such a huge
skill gap is the lack of parallel trainings in institutes and skill application
in the workplace, observed Chung-Herrera et. al., (2003).
Methodology
The above discussion highlights the skill gaps caused due to the candidate’s
inadequacy in employability skills expected by the hospitality industry.
To investigate and understand the perceptions of faculty and alumni
students, on the importance of various soft skills for employability in
the hotel industry; a semi-structured interview was conducted with few
of them. Also taken into the purview of this research is the information
accumulated from quite an exhaustive review of literature.
Results & Analysis: Many soft skills were presented before both the
groups of people (faculty and students) like oral &written communication
skills, honesty, teamwork, collaboration skills, critical thinking, work
ethics, dependability, self-motivation, initiative, risk taking skills,
flexibility, adaptability, leadership quality, interpersonal skills, creativity,
research skills, computer skills and time management skills etc.
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
147 Jaykumar
From the above table, we can see few similarities and some differences
in the perceptions of the faculty members and the alumni students. Both
groups of people felt that communication skills oral and written, were the
most important soft skills one should possess in the hospitality industry.
Where the students felt that adaptability to new technology, team work and
computer knowledge were extremely essential, the faculty members gave
more importance to interpersonal skills, customer care & satisfaction.
Both students & faculty members emphasized that they realized the
value of critical & analytical thinking, but it featured last amongst the
list of soft skills highlighted. The students voted professionalism and self-
management as essential skills to possess, only second to communication
skills in importance.
Conclusions and Suggestions
This paper analyses the various core soft skills perceived as vital or crucial
for employability; and means and methods of integrating them into the
curriculum of hotel management institutes. The aim of this endeavor is to
ensure, that students are adept in these generic skills too, along with tech-
nical or hard skills. In addition to it, the much talked about and worrying
skills gap should also be bridged, resulting in more and more employment
opportunities generated in the long run.
Hospitality subjects like effective communication and personality de-
velopment, hospitality service excellence, word processing & spreadsheet
skills, concentrate solely on communication skills, customer service and
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
148 Hospitality Management Institutes
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
149 Jaykumar
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
150 Hospitality Management Institutes
take a more active and cohesive participation with the training of college
interns. The industry representatives would guide the institutes on current
trends and expectations of the concerned industry. The institutes would
also need to keep them in mind while designing the curriculum, syllabus
and module structures. Soft skills need to be given a more prominent place
in the curriculum in the times to come. Various pedagogies could be used
to ensure that these skills are also embedded in the institute’s curriculum.
Only when all the above issues are taken into consideration immediately
and steps are taken to resolve them at the earliest, can we have more & more
hotel management graduates groomed, trained and confident, making their
mark in the high profile & fast changing world of the Hospitality Industry.
REFERENCES
Asafadi, L. & Abunafesa, R. (2012) ICT Skills Gap Analysis of the Saudi Market (Online).
Sited on 16.11.2018, Available from: http://www.iaeng.org/publication/WCECS2012/
WCECS2012_pp284-289.pdf.
Asirifi, H.G., Doku, V., Morrison, S & Sackey, S.A. (2013) The Gap between Hospitality
Education and the Hospitality Industry, Journal of Education and Practice, 4:24.
Chung Harrera. B.G. (2003) Grooming Future Hospitality Leaders: A Competencies
Model(Online), Cited on 10.11.2018.Available from: https://scholarship.sha.cornell.
edu/articles/366/.
Crockett, Lori L.(2002) Real-World Training to Meet a Growing Demand, Techniques, Vol
77:4, pp18.
Goodman, R.J. & Sprague, L.G. (1991) The Future of Hospitality Education; Meeting The
Industry’s Needs. The Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 32:2,
pp. 66-69.
Honey, M. & Gilpin, R. (2009) Tourism In The Developing Countries-Promoting Peace &
Reducing Poverty, Special Report No. 233, US Institute of Peace.
International Youth Foundation (2013) Getting Youth In The Door: Defining Soft Skills
Requirements for Entry-level Service Sector Jobs, (online) (cited on 20.08.2017)
Available at https://www.iyfnet.org/sites/.../Getting_Youth_In_The_Door_Soft_
Skills_Report.pdf.
John, J. (2009) Study On The Nature of Impact of Soft Skill Training Programme on The
Soft Skills Development of Management Students (Online), Cited on 10.11.2018,
Available from:https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1591331
Johnstone, D. (1994) College at Work: Partnerships and Rebuilding of American
Competence, Journal of Higher Education, 65:2, pp168-181.
Kennedy, J. (2016) Hard Skills, Soft Skills Important To Career Success.(Online),Cited
on 12.11.2018. Available at: http://www.chicago tribune.com/classified/sns-
201512021000-tms-careersntp-h-bb20151209-20151209-column.html
Kumar. A. (2018) Hospitality Education in India: Issues & Challenges. (Online) Cited on
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
151 Jaykumar
Journal of Services Research, Volume 18, Number 2 (October 2018 - March 2019)
Copyright of Journal of Services Research is the property of Vedatya Institute and its content
may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright
holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.