Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Bridge Strikes
from Road
Vehicles or
Waterborne
Vessels
Synopsis
This document mandates
requirements for the management of
the risks to the operational railway
from road vehicles or waterborne
vessels striking bridges.
Submitted by
Published by:
Railway Safety
Evergreen House
160 Euston Road
London NW1 2DX
Brian Alston
Controller, Railway Group Standards © Copyright 2002 Railway Safety
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Contents
Section Description Page
Part A
A1 Issue record 3
A2 Implementation of this document 3
A3 Scope of Railway Group Standards 3
A4 Responsibilities 4
A5 Health and safety responsibilities 4
A6 Technical content 4
A7 Supply 4
Part B
B1 Purpose 5
B2 Application of this document 5
B3 Definitions 6
B4 Principles 7
RAILWAY SAFETY 1
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Appendices
1 Required factors for the risk based prioritisation of bridges - Mandatory 22
2 Damage limits within which a bridge strike nominee (Grade 1) is permitted to
authorise the movement of trains - Mandatory 24
3 Requirements for classification of bridge strikes – Mandatory 26
4 Requirements for training and assessment of competence for bridge strike
nominees - Mandatory 27
5 Recommended factors for local operations instructions - Advisory 29
References 30
2 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Part A
A1 Issue record
Issue Date Comments
One June 1995 Original Document
One B December 1995 Emergency Issue
Two January 1996 Supersedes Issue One and Issue One B
Three August 2001 Supersedes Issue Two
Four October 2002 Supersedes Issue Three
The text of this document has been subject to extensive re-writing and re-
ordering and therefore no amendment bars have been inserted.
A2 Implementation of
this document
The publication date of this document is 5 October 2002.
A3 Scope of Railway
Group Standards
The overall scope of Railway Group Standards is set out in Appendix 1 of
GA/RT6001. The specific scope of this document is set out in Part B2.
RAILWAY SAFETY 3
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
A4 Responsibilities
Railway Group Standards are mandatory on all members of the Railway Group*
and apply to all relevant activities that fall into the scope of each individual’s
Railway Safety Case. If any of those activities are performed by a contractor, the
contractor’s obligation in respect of Railway Group Standards is determined by
the terms of the contract between the respective parties. Where a contractor is
a duty holder of a Railway Safety Case then Railway Group Standards apply
directly to the activities described in the Safety Case.
* The Railway Group comprises Railtrack PLC, Railway Safety, and the train
and station operators who hold railway safety cases for operation on or related to
infrastructure controlled by Railtrack PLC.
A6 Technical content
The technical content of this document has been approved by:
A7 Supply
Controlled and uncontrolled copies of this document may be obtained from the
Industry Safety Liaison Dept, Railway Safety, Evergreen House,
160 Euston Road, London NW1 2DX.
4 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Part B
B1 Purpose
This document mandates requirements for the management of the risks to the
operational railway from road vehicles or waterborne vessels striking bridges.
B2 Application of this
document
B2.1 To whom the requirements apply
This document contains requirements that are applicable to duty holders of the
infrastructure controller category of Railway Safety Case.
a) all underline bridges spanning over roads or under which vehicular traffic
may reasonably be expected to pass
This document applies to both permanent and temporary bridges (or temporary
supports to bridges) in the categories listed above.
Specific requirements for structures owned by outside parties are set out in
section C5.
Partial compliance with section C1.1 (Identification and listing of bridges likely to
be subject to bridge strikes), taking into account the history of bridge strikes only,
is required by 7 December 2002. Full compliance with section C1.1, taking into
account the other factors listed in section C1.1 is required by April 2004.
Compliance with section C2.1 (Measures to reduce the risk at individual bridges)
is required by April 2004.
RAILWAY SAFETY 5
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
After the compliance dates, or after the date by which compliance is achieved (if
earlier), Railway Group members shall not deviate from the requirements set out
in this document.
General requirements for the design of bridges and other structures are set out
in GC/RT5110 (see section C4).
Requirements for the production of local operations instructions are set out in
GE/RT8004 (see section D8).
Requirements for the reporting of safety related information are set out in
GE/RT8047 (see section D10).
B3 Definitions
Bridge
A structure of one or more spans whose prime purpose is to carry traffic or
services over an obstruction or gap, but excludes culverts. A culvert is defined in
GC/RT5100.
Bridge strike
An incident in which a road vehicle or its load, or a waterborne vessel or its load,
impacts with the fabric of a bridge.
6 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Documented arrangements
The conditions applicable and the procedures to be followed by a Bridge Strike
Nominee Grade 2 authorising trains to pass over or under a bridge without a
speed restriction being imposed (other than existing speeds restrictions imposed
for other reasons), following a bridge strike.
Outside party
Any person or organisation other than a Railway Group Member. An outside
party also includes a Railway Group member acting outside the scope of its
Railway Safety Case.
B4 Principles
The requirements set out in this document are based on the following principles:
a) The risks to the operational railway from bridge strikes are to be reduced as
far as is reasonably practicable by assessing the safety risks at each bridge
and implementing appropriate mitigating measures (see Part C).
b) The risks to persons (railway passengers, staff and the public) following a
bridge strike are to be minimised by taking appropriate action including
prohibiting the passage of rail traffic or restricting the speed of rail traffic
over or under the bridge (see Part D).
c) People responsible for taking appropriate action following a bridge strike are
to be competent (see Part E).
RAILWAY SAFETY 7
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Part C
Reducing the risk from bridge strikes
C1 Identification, listing
and prioritisation of
bridges subject to bridge
strikes
C1.1 Identification and listing of bridges likely to be subject to bridge
strikes
The infrastructure controller shall identify and list in a register (but not
necessarily in a single register) all bridges likely to be subject to bridge strikes,
taking into account:
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
a) all bridges for which a bridge strike nominee (Grade 2) is authorised to act
(see section D6)
b) all underline bridges over which all normal rail traffic is permitted to pass
without prior inspection following a bridge strike in accordance with a local
operations instruction (see section D8)
8 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
c) all underline bridges over which specified rail traffic is permitted to pass
without a prior inspection following a bridge strike in accordance with a local
operations instruction (see section D8)
d) any other bridge to which a local operations instruction applies (see section
D8).
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
C2 Measures to reduce
the risk from bridge
strikes
C2.1 Measures to reduce the risk from bridge strikes at individual bridges
The infrastructure controller shall have a procedure in place requiring measures
to be implemented to reduce the risk from bridge strikes at bridges listed in the
register compiled in accordance with section C1.1.
In determining the measures to reduce the risk from bridge strikes, the
procedure shall require the following to be taken into account:
a) the factors taken into account in the risk based prioritisation of the bridge (in
accordance with section C1.2)
b) site-specific circumstances.
The measures to be considered shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
ix) painting the outside of underline bridges to make them more conspicuous
RAILWAY SAFETY 9
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2
a) appraise the relevant authority of the risks to the safe operation of the
railway due to bridge strikes and provide advice as to the appropriate
measures that are considered necessary to reduce the risk to the safe
operation of the railway at the particular location
c) liaison with vehicle operators, highway authorities and outside party bridge
owners to highlight the risks from bridge strikes
a) measures that have been considered to reduce the risk from bridge strikes
b) measures that have been implemented to reduce the risk from bridge
strikes.
C3 Provision of
identification plates
The infrastructure controller shall prepare and implement a programme to
provide identification plates for the use of the public at bridges that are at risk
from bridge strikes, prioritised in accordance with section C1.2.
Specific requirements for bridges owned by outside parties are set out in section
C5.2 c).
b) show a telephone number for the relevant signalling control centre or railway
operations control office giving 24-hour availability, for use by the public,
drivers or others in reporting a bridge strike.
10 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
The infrastructure controller shall ensure that the identification plates are
adequately maintained.
GC/RT5100 sets out general requirements for identification of bridges, both for
record purposes and for identification on site.
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2
C4 Design of new
structures and
structures subject to
alteration
GC/RT5110 sets out general requirements for the design of bridges and other
structures, including requirements in respect of:
C5 Bridges owned by
outside parties
C5.1 General requirements for bridges owned by outside parties
GC/RT5100 sets out the general requirements for the safe management of
structures owned by outside parties.
a) appraise the relevant outside party bridge owner of the risks to the safe
operation of the railway due to bridge strikes with respect to each outside
party bridge
c) liaise with the outside party bridge owner and endeavour to obtain their
agreement to implement measures to reduce the risk to the safe operation
of the railway, including provision of identification plates in accordance with
section C3
RAILWAY SAFETY 11
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
e) record details of those measures that are not implemented by the outside
party bridge owner.
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
Where the requirements are not met, this shall be recorded by the infrastructure
controller, together with the reasons why the requirements have not been met.
12 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Part D
Managing bridge strike incidents
D1 Procedures in the
event of a reported
bridge strike
The infrastructure controller shall have procedures in place to ensure that, in the
event of a reported bridge strike the subsequent risks to persons and property
are minimised.
D2 Action to be taken
when a bridge strike is
reported
When a bridge strike is reported, movement of trains over or under the bridge
shall not be permitted until the bridge has been examined by a bridge strike
examiner to make sure it remains safe for trains to pass.
Conditions under which bridge strike examiners are permitted to act are set out
in section D4. Conditions under which bridge strike nominees (Grade 1) are
permitted to act are set out in section D5. Conditions under which bridge strike
nominees (Grade 2) are permitted to act are set out in section D6.
Section D8 permits actions other than those set out above to be taken when a
bridge strike is reported, provided these are set out in local operations
instructions.
D4 Conditions under
which bridge strike
examiners are permitted
to act
It is permissible for a bridge strike examiner to determine the speed, up to the
permissible speed (or enhanced permissible speed where applicable), at which
the movement of trains can be resumed. In determining the speed, the bridge
strike examiner shall take into consideration the damage to the bridge caused by
the bridge strike.
RAILWAY SAFETY 13
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
D5 Conditions under
which bridge strike
nominees (Grade 1) are
permitted to act
It is permissible for a bridge strike nominee (Grade 1) to authorise the movement
of trains at 5 mph at underline bridges and 20 mph at overline bridges provided
the damage to a bridge following a bridge strike is within the limits set out in
Appendix 2.
D6 Conditions under
which bridge strike
nominees (Grade 2) are
permitted to act
It is permissible for a bridge strike nominee (Grade 2) to authorise the movement
of trains, without a speed restriction being imposed (other than existing speeds
restrictions imposed for other reasons), over or under specified bridges in
accordance with documented arrangements issued by the infrastructure
controller.
At other bridges where documented arrangements have not been issued, the
requirements applicable to a bridge strike nominee (Grade 1) apply to a bridge
strike nominee (Grade 2).
a) The infrastructure controller has identified and recorded the specific bridges,
either by reference to individual bridges or by reference to a geographical
area (including, where appropriate, any excluded bridges).
c) The specific arrangements for each bridge (taking into account the damage
criteria permitted by (b) of this section) have been documented for use on
site.
D7 Actions of bridge
strike nominees after
allowing trains to pass
Until a bridge strike examiner authorises otherwise, the bridge strike nominee
who is authorising trains to pass following a reported bridge strike shall:
a) remain on site
b) keep the bridge under observation to check that there is no worsening in the
condition of the bridge.
If the condition of the bridge worsens, the bridge strike nominee shall instruct the
signaller to stop the movement of trains until a bridge strike examiner has
examined the bridge.
14 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
D8 Local operations
instructions for use by
signallers
D8.1 Issuing local operations instructions
It is permissible for the infrastructure controller to formulate and issue local
operations instructions for use by signallers for managing the risk from bridge
strikes.
In the case of late reported bridge strikes, it is permissible for the criteria for rail
traffic to be permitted to pass over or under the specified bridges to vary
depending on the number and type of trains that have passed over the bridge
since the reported time of the bridge strike. The infrastructure controller shall
demonstrate that, in applying such varying criteria, the incremental risk is
negligible.
a) accurately identify the bridges (and, where applicable, the spans of the
bridges) to which the local operations instruction applies
c) identify the action to be taken by the signaller before trains are authorised to
pass over or under the bridge
d) clearly identify the type and speed of rail traffic permitted to pass under or
over the bridge following the bridge strike.
RAILWAY SAFETY 15
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
b) The infrastructure controller has recorded the justification for issuing the
local operations instruction.
Where the local operations instructions relate only to late reported bridge strikes,
it is permissible to issue the instructions without identification plates being in
place.
The infrastructure controller shall also define the arrangements for the
subsequent examination of the bridge following a bridge strike including the
timescales for such an examination.
D9 Additional structural
examination following a
reported bridge strike
Following all reported bridge strike incidents, the infrastructure controller shall
arrange an additional structural examination of the bridge by a competent person
(for example a bridge strike examiner) to:
D10 Classification,
recording and reporting
of bridge strikes
D10.1 Classification of bridge strikes
The infrastructure controller shall classify every reported bridge strike as
‘serious’, ‘potentially serious’ or ‘not serious’, in accordance with the criteria set
out in Appendix 3.
16 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
RAILWAY SAFETY 17
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Part E
Training, competence and certification
E1 Application of
Railways (Safety Critical
Work) Regulations
GO/RT3260 states that the assessment of a bridge (for example by a bridge
strike nominee or a bridge strike examiner) following a bridge strike is
considered safety critical under the Railways (Safety Critical Work) Regulations
and defines requirements for systems to manage the competence and fitness of
persons required to undertake such work.
E2 General competence
requirements
The infrastructure controller shall have in place procedures that ensure that only
competent persons:
b) consider measures to reduce the risk from bridge strikes in accordance with
section C2
d) establish, in accordance with section D6, the bridges where a bridge strike
nominee (Grade 2) is authorised to act
E3 Certification of
bridge strike nominees
E3.1 Certification of bridge strike nominees (Grade 1)
The infrastructure controller shall have procedures in place to ensure that all
persons acting as a bridge strike nominee (Grade 1) are issued with a certificate
of authority before acting in this capacity.
In the case of initial certification, such a certificate shall only be issued if the
person has attended and successfully completed a suitable training course (see
section E6) and this fact is acknowledged through a statement signed by the
trainer.
In the case of re-certification, such a certificate shall only be issued if the person
is currently in possession of a valid certificate to act as a bridge strike nominee
(Grade 1) and has successfully attended a refresher course or has been
reassessed as competent and this fact is acknowledged through a statement
signed by the trainer or assessor as appropriate.
Records that demonstrate that these conditions have been satisfied shall be
retained for as long as the certificate remains valid.
The certificate shall show the expiry date of the authority to act in the capacity of
a bridge strike nominee (Grade 1).
18 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
In the case of initial certification, such a certificate shall only be issued if:
Records that demonstrate that these conditions have been satisfied shall be
retained for as long as the certificate remains valid.
The certificate shall show the expiry date of the authority to act in the capacity of
a bridge strike nominee (Grade 2).
E4 Expiry date of
certificates for bridge
strike nominees
E4.1 Requirements for expiry dates
For initial certification, the expiry date shall not be more than two years after the
date on which the person completed the training course.
For re-certification the date shall not be more than two years after the expiry date
previously recorded on the certificate.
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
RAILWAY SAFETY 19
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
E5 Register of bridge
strike nominees
The infrastructure controller shall compile and maintain a register (but not
necessarily a single register) that includes names of all persons who hold valid
certificates to act as bridge strike nominee (Grades 1 and 2).
The register shall also include the expiry date of each person’s certificate.
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
E6 Training and
assessment of
competence for bridge
strike nominees
The infrastructure controller shall ensure that the method and components of the
training and assessment of competence of bridge strike nominees (Grades 1
and 2) accords with the requirements for such training and assessment of
competence in Appendix 4.
E7 Competence of
trainers for bridge strike
nominees
The infrastructure controller shall have procedures in place to ensure that
persons responsible for training and/or assessing of competence of bridge strike
nominees (Grade 1) and/or bridge strike nominees (Grade 2):
c) have expertise relevant to managing the risks from bridge strikes to the
satisfaction of the infrastructure controller.
E8 Certification of
bridge strike examiners
The infrastructure controller shall have procedures in place to ensure that all
persons acting as bridge strike examiner are issued with a valid certificate.
Such a certificate shall be valid only if all the following conditions are satisfied:
The certificate shall show the expiry date of the authority to act in the capacity of
bridge strike examiner.
20 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
E9 Expiry date of
certificates for bridge
strike examiners
The expiry date shall be as determined by the infrastructure controller for both
initial certification and for any subsequent re-certification but shall not be more
than five years after the person has been authorised or re-authorised to act in
the capacity of a bridge strike examiner.
b) the person is qualified and experienced to examine and report upon the
condition of structures in accordance with GC/RT5100
c) the person can demonstrate at least five years practical experience in bridge
maintenance, examination or assessment.
E11 Assessment of
competence for bridge
strike examiners
The assessment of competence of a bridge strike examiner shall be either of the
following:
The register shall also include the expiry date of each person’s certificate.
There are special compliance requirements associated with this section - see
section B2.2.
RAILWAY SAFETY 21
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Appendix 1 - Mandatory
Required factors for the risk based prioritisation of
bridges
1.1 Underline bridges
spanning over roads
The factors to be taken into account in the risk based prioritisation of underline
bridges spanning over a road (or bridges under which vehicular traffic may
reasonably be expected to pass) in accordance with section C1.2 shall include,
but not be limited to, the following:
b) headroom
f) existing measures to reduce the risk (for example, signing and markings at
the bridge and on its approaches)
c) type, density and speed of waterborne traffic (taking into account water
currents and tides)
f) existing measures to reduce the risk (for example, signing and markings at
the bridge and on its approaches, protection to bridge piers)
22 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
c) type, density and speed of road traffic (including level of abnormal road
traffic)
f) existing measures to reduce the risk (for example, signing and markings at
the bridge and on its approaches)
RAILWAY SAFETY 23
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Appendix 2 - Mandatory
Damage limits within which a bridge strike nominee
(Grade 1) is permitted to authorise the movement of
trains
2.1 Underline bridge
(rail over road)
Type of Damage limits
bridge
structure
(including
walls and
columns)
All bridges The vertical and horizontal alignment of the track appears
normal. There is no loss of ballast under any sleeper and there
is no gap between sleeper ends and the ballast. The railhead
is undamaged.
In addition:
Metal bridge The bridge is not deformed or displaced and there is no other
damage (except for paint damage).
Metal Column If there is any reason to suspect that a metal column has been
struck, the bridge strike nominee (Grade 1) is not permitted to
authorise the movement of trains.
Masonry Arch Any displaced material:
a) is not more that 150 mm in depth, and
b) does not cover a total area of more than one square metre.
Brick Arch Any displaced material:
a) is not more that one brick in depth, and
b) does not cover a total area of more than one square metre.
Concrete If exposed by the damage, the internal reinforcing bars are not
bridge cut or damaged.
Table 1: Underline bridge damage limits
a) the part of the parapet wall which is immediately over the track has not been
cracked or displaced, either horizontally or vertically
b) any debris from a damaged parapet or wall that has already fallen or could
fall, will only fall into the embankment clear of the track and there is no risk
of any debris falling on or near the line.
24 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
during the examination of the bridge that an independent structure(s) has not
been either:
a) struck, or
RAILWAY SAFETY 25
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Appendix 3 - Mandatory
Requirements for classification of bridge strikes
3.1 ‘Serious’
classification
A bridge strike shall be classified as ‘serious’ if any of the following situations
results:
b) an arch or spandrel wall is damaged to the extent that its stability is not
immediately affected but any further significant damage would require part
of the arch or spandrel wall to be replaced
c) fallen debris (for example, from the parapet of an overline bridge) is lying on
a cutting slope or on the track but does not infringe the loading gauge
26 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Appendix 4 - Mandatory
Requirements for training and assessment of
competence for bridge strike nominees
4.1 Training for bridge
strike nominee (Grade 1)
4.1.1 Training objectives for bridge strike nominee (Grade 1)
The training shall ensure that the bridge strike nominee acquires the skills and
knowledge to be able to:
b) assess whether the damage to the bridge, the track and the track geometry
is within the criteria set out in Appendix 2
c) understand the speed limits that are required before trains are permitted to
pass over or under the bridge, as set out in section D5
d) authorise trains to pass over or under the bridge at the speed set out in
section D5 when the damage is within the criteria set out in Appendix 2.
a) all the elements set out in section 4.1.2 for bridge strike nominee (Grade 1)
RAILWAY SAFETY 27
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
4.3 Assessment of
competence
The assessment of competence following training shall be by the performance of
the candidate in a written test.
28 RAILWAY SAFETY
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
Appendix 5 - Advisory
Recommended factors for local operations
instructions
In accordance with section D8.4, the factors that should be taken into account by
the infrastructure controller prior to the issue of local operations instructions in
respect of a bridge should include, but not be limited to, the following:
g) existing measures to reduce the risk (for example, signing and markings at
the bridge and on its approaches)
RAILWAY SAFETY 29
Uncontrolled copy from the catalogue dated August 2004
References
Railway Group Standards and other Railway Group Documents
GA/RT6001 Railway Group Standards Change Procedures
GA/RT6004 Temporary Non-Compliance with Railway Group Standards
GA/RT6006 Derogations from Railway Group Standards
GC/RC5510 Recommendations for the Design of Bridges
GC/RT5100 Safe Management of Structures
GC/RT5110 Design Requirements for Structures
GC/RT5022 Rails and Rail Joints
GE/RT8004 Local Operations Instructions
GE/RT8047 Reporting of Safety-Related Information
GO/RT3000 Rule Book
GO/RT3260 Competence Management for Safety-Critical Work
GO/RT3062 Regulations for Train Signalling
Other documents
Railways (Safety Critical Work) Regulations 1994
BD65/97 Design Criteria for Collision Protection Beams (part of Highways
Agency’s Design Manual for Roads and Bridges)
The Catalogue of Railway Group Standards and the Railway Group Standards
CD-ROM give the current issue number and status of documents published by
Railway Safety.
30 RAILWAY SAFETY