Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Postage PAID
1st CLASS
U.S. MAIL
The Nation’s Oldest Continuously Published College Weekly Friday, November 22, 2019 Volume 149, Number 11 bowdoinorient.com
N NO PARKING F RAISING AWARENESS A ART AND INDIGENEITY S MAKING A RUCK-US O WHO LET THE DOGS OUT?
Brunswick Town Council unanimously DASA and BSG prepare for International Peruvian dancer Vania Ibarguen visits Women’s rugby captures first-ever NIRA Professor Robert Sobak responds to critcism
passes new parking ordinance. Page 3. Day of Persons with Disabilities. Page 5. campus to perform. Page 7. national title. Page 10. of his op-ed about sophistry. Page 15.
2 Friday, November 22, 2019
2 PAGE TWO
SECURITY REPORT
11/14 to 11/21 STUDENT SPEAK:
What is your most memorable Thanksgiving?
Thursday, November 14 Sunday, November 17
• A group of students was playing soccer in • A fire alarm at Mayflower Apartments was
Sargent Gymnasium when a kicked ball caused by smoke from sizzling bacon. Christian Gostout ’20
struck and smashed a lighted exit sign. A • Two damaged wooden chairs were found
student took responsibility for the errant
kick.
outside Brunswick Apartments.
• Officers came to the aid of a despondent
"Post-dinner drag racing in a desert salt
Friday, November 15
student.
• A student creating a microwave brown-
flat."
• As two students were roughhousing inside ie-in-a-mug activated a smoke alarm in
Smith Union, one of them was pushed into Howard Hall. Officers opened windows and
a wall, causing a large hole. Both students used fans to clear smoke from the room to
will be charged for the repair. prevent the entire building from going into
• A student reported finding their passen- alarm.
ger-side car window smashed as the vehicle
was parked on Park Row in front of Bruns- Monday, November 18
wick Apartments. Nothing was missing • A student received a nose laceration while Andrew Treat ’22
from the interior. playing basketball at Morrell Gymnasium.
• An athlete was transported to Mid Coast "Our green beans were set aflame and
Hospital for an ice hockey related neck Tuesday, November 19
injury- • An officer assisted a student who fainted almost burned down our kitchen."
• An intoxicated student was transported while attending an event at Main Lounge,
from Maine Hall to Mid Coast Hospital. Moulton Union.
• An officer spoke with a student about com-
Saturday, November 16 plaints received about the smell of cigarette
• An officer checked on the wellbeing of a smoke coming from his room.
student on the Osher Quad who had been
drinking. Wednesday, November 20
• Excessively loud music was reported on the • A dirty stove top in Stowe Inn was a con- Yasmeen Wirth ’22
fourth floor of Coles Tower. The volume tributing factor in the activation of a smoke
was reduced.
• An officer conducted a wellness check for
alarm. "My sister fell off a trapeze and busted
an intoxicated student at Winthrop Hall.
• A minor student was found in possession
Thursday, November 21
• There was an excessive noise complaint and
open her lip, so we spent the night in
of two fraudulent driver’s licenses.
• A complaint of marijuana smoke in Coles
an alcohol policy violation on the seventh
floor of Coles Tower.
the ER feeding her smoothies."
Tower led to two students who had been
smoking earlier.
KODIE GARZA
• A student who reported experiencing chest
pain was transported to Mid Coast Hospi-
tal.
• Security officers and police responded to Arein Nguyen ’21
Ladd House for a report of a large crowd
with fights in progress at a registered event. "I came home to surprise my grandma,
Ali Ahmed Ali, 19, of Portland was arrest-
ed and charged with disorderly conduct/ and she was like ‘why are you here’ with
fighting, refusing to submit to arrest or
detention and minor consuming liquor. Ali a straight face."
was also served with a criminal trespass
warning barring him from campus. The COMPILED BY HAVANA CASO-DOSEMBET
incident remains under investigation.
last fall because it fit my schedule, even though I’m not going to be an
ES major, and it completely changed the way I view the climate crisis.”
requested for spring ARCH
ARTH
0%
0%
ASNS 13.3%
Other suggestions for the climate action plan included expanding BIOL 30%
by Gwen Davidson and Drew CHEM 21.4%
sustainability education by teaching students what can and cannot be Macdonald
recycled, switching to more hybridized vehicles, considering more ef- CHIN 0%
Orient Staff CINE 25%
ficient lighting on campus, expanding the Yellow Bike Club, increasing CLAS 33%
censored light motors and encouraging public transportation usage by The first round of course reg- CSCI 66.7%
providing vouchers for the Metro BREEZ bus and Amtrak. istration for the spring semester DNCE 33.3%
“This is something we think about: how do we meet the needs of closed on Monday. DCS 57.2%
EOS 9.1%
the present without compromising the ability of future generations to Computer Science filled the ECON 27.2%
meet their needs,” said Payson. most classes of any department, EDUC 0%
The assembly later entered a closed-door executive session to ad- with 66.7 percent of classes at ENGL 28%
dress indigenous land acknowledgements. full capacity or higher. Next ENVS 23.1%
FRS 0%
were Visual Arts (58.3 percent), 10.5%
GSWS
Neuroscience (42.9 percent) GER 12.5%
SHOOTING CLIMATE and Dance (33.3 percent).
Of the 42 listed depart-
GOV
GRK 0%
29.3%
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 5.9%
ments, 12 failed to completely HISP
HIST 23.8%
nity about the shooting because view with the Orient. “Bruns- fill a single class, including 0%ITAL
police determined that there wick in general is doing pretty Art History, Education and JPN 25%
was no threat to campus or to well with regards to combating Physics. 0%
LATN
Brunswick, said Randy Nichols, climate change, but the hope There were over 500 cours- LAS 10.5%
executive director of Safety and is to keep pushing, because it’s es offered for the spring 2020 MATH 21.7%
MUS 10.3%
Security. kind of life or death.” semester. Two courses were NEUR 42.9%
A woman and her child were Brunswick councilors seemed requested at three times their PHIL 11.1%
staying in the apartment where open to the resolution. capacity: Introductory Fiction 0%
PHYS
the shooting took place, Tedford “I want to thank you all for Workshop and Introduction to PSYC 37.5%
0% REL
Housing’s Executive Director coming, for waiting for so long Modern Dance. There were 12 0% RUS
Craig Phillips told the Times and [for] beautifully articulat- classes which were requested at SOC 36.4%
Record. No children were in ing the emergency that we find least two times their capacity THTR 11.1%
the apartment at the time of the ourselves in,” said Dan An- and 72 which reached or ex- VART 58.3%
shooting. Neither man involved keles, councilor at large. “I’m ceeded their capacity. 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
was staying at the shelter, and sorry that your generation is
neither should have been there the one that’s going to have to
at the time, said Phillips. clean up the mess that those of Top Twelve Most Overrequested Classes
“We are saddened and heart- us who came before you made
broken by the incident that … I hope that the town of ENGL 1228 - Intro Fiction Workshop 38 reg. for 12 slots
occurred at Tedford Housing’s Brunswick can adopt this in a DANC 1211 - Intro to Modern Dance 44 reg. for 14 slots
family shelter last night,” read a future meeting.” VART 1601 - Sculpture I 37 reg. for 14 slots
release from the shelter published The Council will vote on the
Tuesday morning. “The two men resolution at their next meet- MUS 1451 - Intro to Audio Recording Techniques 47 reg. for 18 slots
involved were not guests of the ing on December 2. Four days CLAS 1101 - Classical Mythology 123 reg. for 50 slots
shelter and, unfortunately, both later, BCA will host a rally in
HIST 2019 - The Transatlantic Sixties & Seventies 85 reg. for 35 slots
had guns, which are not allowed conjunction with a national
on Tedford Housing property.” climate strike organized by BIOL 1066 - The Molecules of Life 120 reg. for 50 slots
Phillips told the Times Re- the Sunrise Movement. The CSCI 3420 - Optimization & Uncertainty 38 reg. for 16 slots
cord the shelter may consider rally will begin at 11:45 a.m. at
increasing security measures the steps of the Bowdoin Col- VART 1201 - Printmaking I 33 reg. for 14 slots
after looking at its procedures lege Museum of Art and will VART 1101 - Drawing I 40 reg. for 18 slots
and rules. conclude with speakers and a
DANC 1101 - Making Dances 35 reg. for 16 slots
Editor’s Note: A version of this celebration at the gazebo on
article originally appeared online the Brunswick Mall. Milliken CSCI 3715 - Human-Computer Interaction 32 reg. for 16 slots
on Tuesday, November 19. It has encouraged students, town 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% 250% 300% 350%
been updated to include newly councilors and all Brunswick
released details. residents to join. Percentage Overrequested SOURCE: POLARIS
4 NEWS Friday, November 22, 2019
F FEATURES
Fort Andross luthier Joel Amsden strikes a chord
electric guitar on the floor by
by Reuben Schafir the row of cases containing
Orient Staff
guitars worth several thousand
“We fix catastrophic mis- dollars each, Amsden said,
takes,” Joel Amsden said, pull- “We’ll work on anything.”
ing a replica of a 1959 Gibson Amsden explained that as
Les Paul electric guitar out of an authorized service center
its case. The neck was unfin- for many of the top guitar
ished and barren. The guitar, manufacturers, such as Martin,
worth around $5,000 according Taylor and Fender, about 20
to Amsden’s off-the-cuff esti- percent of the shop’s workload
mate, needed extensive repair. is warranty-related. Though
Its owner had attempted to re- warranty repair costs are regu-
shape the neck himself, but he lated by the manufacturer and
carved off too much material, don’t pay as well, Amsden said
exposing the truss rod (a steel it brings visibility to the shop
bar running down the length on a national level, as manufac-
of the neck for stability and turers who don’t have their own
playability). Amsden filled the shops in the area refer custom-
old truss rod channel, routed a ers to Kennebec Instrument &
new one and is currently in the Amplifier.
process of refinishing the neck. In order to further increase
Amsden specializes in exten- visibility, one of the employees
sive guitar repair. He opened maintains a robust social media
Kennebec Instrument & Ampli- presence for the shop as well as
fier in Augusta, Maine over 10 a blog titled “On the Bench,”
years ago, and he moved to the where they post detailed ac-
Fort Andross Mill Complex in counts of their work. Most of
August. He now has three part- the guitars that end up on the
time employees. blog are owned by high-profile
The shop’s most popular ser- customers, like Bob Thompson,
vice is fret replacement—it does who are popular in Maine and
about 100 per year—which re- whose fans might be inclined
quires a luthier to remove the to bring their own work to the REUBEN SCHAFIR, THE BOWDOIN ORIENT
worn-out frets from an instru- shop. TIME FOR A TUNE UP: (TOP): Joel Amsden and Pete Risano at Kenne-
ment’s fingerboard, resurface These days Amsden seems beck Instrument & Amplifier specialize in extensive guitar repair. The shop is
the fingerboard, then trim, as busy as ever and is looking located in the Fort Andross Mill Complex. (RIGHT): Joel Amsden plays the
set and dress new frets. This to expand. He hired two of his Soma version of a 1959 Gibson Les Paul electric guitar.
labor-intensive work must be employees at the time of the
done perfectly in order for the move, and he will move the going to make [Soma] more of guitar that’s perfect in every
guitar to play correctly. shop again next week to a larger a priority,” Amsden said. He way,” Amsden said. “We have to
“It’s something I feel we do at space across the hall from his is hoping to produce a couple be comfortable with an instru-
a world-class level,” Amsden said. current location. dozen guitars next year. ment to get the most out of it.”
The walls of Amsden’s shop Amsden began as a musician Amsden showed me one of Amsden takes as much pride
are lined with amplifiers and and gradually spent more time his interpretations of a Gibson in building his own guitars as he
guitar cases. One contains a repairing his own equipment 1959 Les Paul Special. The gui- does fixing those of other brands.
Gibson ES 335—a semi-acous- and then his friends’. Soon, he tar has an aged yellowed finish, “It’s very important to me
tic archtop guitar—which began rejecting gigs so he could black racing stripes down the that people have a good ex-
hasn’t been touched since it was spend more time on repair. center of the body and chips perience here and get exactly
made in the late 1960s and now Now, Amsden will train one along the edges; a section of the what they want and then some.
needs extensive fretwork. An of his employees to build gui- wooden body is polished and There’s a lot to be said for that,
original 1950s Gibson archtop tars under his own brand name, exposed where the player’s arm and that’s how I’ve run the busi-
sits against the wall. Amsden Soma. Soma has grown gradu- would rub against it. All these ness since day one,” he said.
seemed unphased by the large ally, from building amplifiers details, Amsden told me, are “It can be difficult because I
crack running down the back to electric guitars as well and intentional. take a big hit sometimes both
of its body, “We should get to makes 10 custom-ordered gui- “When you pick up a really in repairs and guitar building
that sooner rather than later,” tars in a good year. 2020, how- expensive guitar that’s perfect because if I’m not totally happy
he commented. ever, will be different. in every way, you handle it as with it, I can’t live with it. I gotta
Gesturing to a low-quality “For the first time ever, I’m though it’s a really expensive do it again.”
all-time lows. I was there grown with, come to love and idence, not my home. I was beauty and individuality of Until recently, I truly be-
TO BE AT HOME when Barack Obama ran for cherish like an old friend, sud- unable to cultivate the same communities such as Vinal- lieved that my acceptance to
My family moved to Maine president. I found a particular denly felt useless. sense of belonging among the haven. The foreignness of a Bowdoin meant Maine had
the summer before I started pride in surrendering myself As I fluttered through high rolling hills and quiet nights fishing community with just chosen me. It was a way for my
high school. I had spent most to Chicago—the very things school, I was forced to con- of rural Maine that I associat- over 1,000 residents struck state to validate my residency,
of life among the skyscrapers associated with Chicago were front the parts of myself that ed with the hectic city streets. me. The island came to repre- an attempt to make me hang
of Chicago, where anonymi- folded into my own identity were rooted in the city of my I felt like a person caught be- sent the epitome of loveliness, around. Yet, I have come to
ty was expected in the bustle over the course of a decade. childhood, the place I had tween two worlds, neither of something previously a mere realize that when I made the
of city crowds. Yet I felt very Yet, as we packed the car and long called home. My identity which I could fully understand figment of my desires. And decision to attend Bowdoin,
connected to my city. I was drove east that summer day, adapted as I became interest- anymore. in this dream world, all the Maine did not pick me—I
there when the Sears Tower reality turned to memory and ed in the mannerisms of my When it came time for me locals had some connection picked Maine.
was rebranded as the Willis the skyline merely a reflection peers, yet part of me always to apply to college, my heart to my hometown a few hours I was driving back to Wa-
Tower and when crime rates in the rearview mirror. Those felt estranged from Maine. was set on the idea of escaping. inland, a shared experience terville to see my family.
reached all-time highs and parts of my identity I had The state was my place of res- I wanted to go somewhere and that immediately linked us Summer had faded and fall
make it mine. I felt a profound despite being strangers. I felt was once again a familiar
desire to cultivate an emotion- known and understood, as friend. The leaves were slowly
al connection to a place, to feel though my experiences were changing, a subtle coolness
a sense of pride for my home valid. On the ferry ride back infecting the warm air. The
once again. Yet, there was an to Rockland, it felt as though sky exuded a pure, golden,
indescribable force keeping something inside of me had untouched glow. As I pulled
me from leaving. When I was switched. Those few days on on to Maine Street, I felt a
admitted into Bowdoin, it was the island helped a lost sense smooth breeze through the
as though Maine had chosen of pride blossom within me. window, filling my lungs with
me, pleading me not to cross At Bowdoin, being from fresh air. I felt a rush of luck,
its borders into unfamiliarity. Maine is central to my iden- to be in this place with these
For the first time, my heart tity. It is a point of intrigue, people. The Androscoggin
didn’t feel as though it was something that people respect rushed under the bridge to
being pulled in a multitude of and appreciate. Here, I don’t Topsham, and Brunswick
directions. have to come from generations took the stage in my rearview
I can still remember viv- of Maine residents to be con- mirror. I continued forward,
idly the emotions I encoun- sidered a “Mainer”—the social no longer with the pressing
tered during my Orientation rules of belonging don’t apply. desire to feel the comfort of
Trip. My world had become I am part of the community, home—I had been home all
LILY FU focused on the small towns and the community is a part along.
LLAM of central Maine—I had nev- of me. There is nothing fancy Nora Greene is a member of
er before experienced the to it. the Class of 2022.
TALK TO US.
Ranging from lighthearted moments to serious reflections about life at and beyond Bowdoin, Talks of
the Quad feature the Bowdoin community’s best short-form writing. They are published every other
week and can be written by any member of the Bowdoin community. Generally 700-1,000 words.
EMAIL ORIENT@BOWDOIN.EDU
Friday, November 22, 2019 7
Just beyond Maine Street: the invisibility of the opioid crisis at Bowdoin
safety and invincibility can be bubble, some students do have “All walks of life. All,” said ernor Janet Mills is earmarking The ARC at Midcoast Hospi-
by Brianna Cunliffe dangerous, and mind-altering personal connections to the Brunswick Police Department significant funds to expand its tal is the exception to this rule.
Orient Staff substances should never be un- opioid crisis. (BPD) Commander of Patrol availability. Bauer directs an innovative
Maine loses nearly a person derestimated, explained Ring. Patrick Blosainz ’22, grew up Tom Garrepy. Students and politicians alike group-based recovery initiative
per day to opioids. But on cam- “‘We’re all smart, high-ac- in New Hampshire next to a city Opioid substance abuse dis- clash over strategies for en- that allows patients to be seen
pus, students are largely insu- complishing, high-achieving nicknamed “Heroin Hollis.” order and its consequences im- forcement and treatment. Some just a matter of days after check-
lated from the crisis, which hits people [here at Bowdoin]. So “A lot of people dealt with pact everyone from the wealth- claim solutions, such as the in- ing into the system. One of their
Maine’s aging populations and that will protect us from these addiction,” he said. “I had a lot iest members of the community most prominent programs uses
74 overdoses
manual laborers especially hard. drugs,’” said Ring. “The drugs of friends from school who had to its most vulnerable, including Buprenorphine, more widely
In Cumberland County, have no idea who you are. that problem.” the homeless individuals served known as Suboxone, to chemi-
there were 74 overdoses during They’re indifferent to your so- Motivated by this connec- by Tedford Housing, a Bruns- during cally assist recovery.
the first quarter of 2019, down cioeconomic background, your tion, Blosainz spent last sum- wick organization providing ARC was the first hospital
from the previous quarter’s 86. IQ. Addiction is a disease of the mer as a research consultant housing and homelessness pre- the first quarter in Maine to integrate Suboxone
Decreased death tolls are good brain, a neurological hijacking.” looking into the effectiveness vention services. of 2019 in into the ER, beginning the pro-
news, but a greater percentage Looking to learn more about of various community efforts Fourteen percent of Tedford cess of recovery immediately
of these deaths are caused by the impact of the opioid crisis, attempting to address the opi- Housing patrons self-report Cumberland after an individual suffers from
fentanyl, a dangerous substance
which is infiltrating the region
Annie Rose ’20 and Nina Al-
varado-Silverman ’19 designed
oid epidemic. His findings
echo the plea of professionals,
that they are also struggling
with substance abuse disorder.
County an overdose.
But even assisted by a pow-
at an alarming rate, explained an Alternative Winter Break from law enforcement to social Tedford Housing Director of erful tool like Suboxone, recov-
Leah Bauer, medical director (AWB) trip last year that cen- service providers, who work Operations Giff Jamison said creased availability of Narcan, ery is an individualized process
and psychiatrist at the Addic- tered on addiction and recovery. with these issues firsthand: a that this is likely a significant enable users and preclude re- with no guaranteed success.
tion Resource Center (ARC) at Participants visited local orga- bottom-up, community-inte- underestimate, as individuals covery; others believe they save Addiction is often compound-
Midcoast Hospital. For many, nizations that address addiction grated and holistic game plan who admit addiction often fear lives and mitigate risk. Bauer ed by mental illness and so-
addiction starts with a prescrip- in their communities, from the is necessary. they will be denied essential sees every dose of Narcan in the cio-economic vulnerability,
tion written by a doctor but ARC to Portland’s Preble Street “If you work from the top services and face scorn and community as one more tool making it nearly impossible to
spirals out of control, leading to Resource Center. down, there’s huge holes in cer- reprimand in the communities against the specter of overdose disentangle the causal mech-
fentanyl, heroin and metham- “I really do think we have a tain policies that people don’t they belong to. and wants “as much of it in the anism from the subsequent
phetamine abuse. responsibility to engage with see,” Blosainz said. “The best ap- The impact of stigma com- community as possible.” impacts. And often, individu-
The nationwide crisis the local community and un- proach to helping someone kick plicates law enforcement and When facing such a com- als must first have their basic
wrought by opioid overpre- community efforts alike. In plex issue, Gareppy believes needs met before they can even
scription has sparked lawsuits “The drugs have no idea who you are. Brunswick, the presence of that stakeholders must work think about getting clean.
against pharmaceutical giants Route 1 and Interstate 295, together. “Housing is a stabilizing
traveling as high as the Supreme
They’re indifferent to your socioeco- highways that serve as major “When I say stakeholder, force for anybody, whether
Court; a bipartisan coalition in nomic background, your IQ.” drug corridors, means the mid- that’s everyone from the hos- they’re experiencing substance
Congress proposed a nation- coast region is hit hard by the pital to the emergency services use disorder or mental illness,”
wide settlement around $48
–Geno Ring, licensced alcohol and drug counselor influx of out-of-state substances to colleges and businesses. We explained Jamison.
billion. and their repercussions. The all have a stake in this because From summer research to
But despite the magnitude of derstand what it is that folks addiction is a holistic approach, solution to mitigating the crisis it could be tomorrow that I find service learning to decades
the crisis and its consequences, have had to overcome,” said meeting their social support is far from simple. out that one of my family mem- of work in these fields, those
opioids have been a predomi- Rose. needs.” “I’d like to say it would just bers has an addiction,” Gareppy working on the opioid crisis in
nantly silent specter in Bruns- Bowdoin students are Bruns- As for what students can do take heavy [police] enforcement said. and around Brunswick all con-
wick since the 1990s. wick citizens, too. For this on campus, Bauer of ARC says on drug traffickers pushing the cur that it begins and ends with
reason, she believes that the that breaking the stigma sur- stuff, but it just seems like a nev- RECOVERY/TREATMENT community. They point to the
CAMPUS ENGAGEMENT often-invisible struggle playing rounding addiction can begin er-ending battle,” said Garrepy. good work happening in our
out in our community should by using correct terminology. “You take one off the street Access to care is a persistent neighborhood—just down the
Some students are prescribed be part of conversations on As she explains, these are peo- and there’s immediately anoth- problem, even for those who road at ARC, and just beyond
Oxycontin when they get their campus. ple with substance abuse disor- er,” said BPD Detective Jared overcome stigma to seek treat- Maine Street.
wisdom teeth removed. Others Tam Phan ’21, who will lead der, not “addicts” or “junkies.” Verod. “I don’t think it’s any one ment. Many recovery programs “The opposite of addiction
manage pain from serious ath- this year’s iteration of the trip “Stigma is multi-layered, specific thing. I think it’s a to- are not covered by insurance isn’t sobriety,” said Rose. “It’s
letic injuries with similar drugs. alongside Biz Sweeney ’21, also multifaceted and certainly per- tality of things. It’s such a broad and many individuals who human connection.”
Geno Ring, a licensed alco- thinks these conversations are vasive in this disorder,” she said. education and enforcement en- are impacted are uninsured. Those struggling with ad-
hol and drug counselor who has important. “It’s good people wanting to deavor.” Recent legislation has worked diction, opioid or otherwise, or
been contracted by the College “Bowdoin produces political have productive lives who have In 2018, BPD officers began to lessen financial barriers to those concerned for a friend can
for 14 years, believes that in leaders and prominent people had their brains hijacked from carrying Narcan, a medication recovery, but the overcrowded reach out to the counseling cen-
Bowdoin’s insulated communi- in medicine. Teaching people them.” used to prevent overdoses. Nar- recovery programs where ap- ter (207-725-3145), or contact
ty, these cases seldom tumble about this, when they’re in po- can has been a bone of political plicants struggle to find a bed Geno Ring to schedule a time to
into serious addictions. Yet for sitions of power, that could be ENFORCEMENT contention in Maine; former or schedule appointments with talk. For Bowdoin students, this
many, this is how a life hijacked really important,” she said. Governor Paul LePage sought to overworked clinicians reflect service is confidential and free
by opioids begins. Feelings of Although surrounded by the Who struggles with addiction? limit access while current Gov- the magnitude of this epidemic. of charge.
10 Friday, November 22, 2019
S SPORTS
HIGHLIGHT
REEL
EAST COAST
SHREDDER DOES IT
BETTER:
John Lane ’21 won the
Lake Atlantic Invitational, a
surfing competition run by
students from the University
of Massachusetts-Amherst,
last weekend. The contest
was held in knee-to-thigh
high waves at Good Harbor
Beach in Gloucester,
Mass.. Two other Bowdoin
students, Rowan Byrne ’21
and Sebastian de Lasa ’22,
competed alongside Lane,
exiting in the semifinals and
first round, respectively.
Lane dominated the ANN BASU, THE BOWDOIN ORIENT
competition, receiving A HEROES’ WELCOME: The women’s rugby team is welcomed back to campus after winning the NIRA Division III national title last Sunday, the first in program history.
the top score in each heat
A CENTURY OF
Women’s and men’s squash start season strong under new head coach to re-energizing the Bowdoin what we’re doing, it’s not easy,”
by Holly Harris squash program, eager to gar- said Woodward. “It’s more, to
Orient Staff
ner publicity and excitement me, about first years develop-
Reflecting on the kick-off from the greater community. ing a good energy, setting high
of the squash season this past Three weeks into the sea- standards and expectations
weekend, captain Drew Clark son, Woodward already has ... and then holding them to
’20 said, “It’s a great time to be a vision for what he wants to those standards.”
a squash player.” shape the program into. After that, Woodward said,
Both the women’s and “It’s all going well, but it’s a “the results will come.”
men’s squash teams hosted lot of change and trying to get This weekend, both teams
two successful home matches the basics right so that we’ve will travel to Wesleyan for
versus Bates (1-1) and Vassar got strong foundations for the matches against Hamilton (0-1
(4-5). The men’s team found future,” said Woodward. “The M, 0-1 W) and Wesleyan (0-1
victory in both matches, beat- main thing we’re trying to do M, 0-1 W). Clark, Leech and
ing Bates (2-0) 5-4 in the first is change the culture.” Shonrock hope to keep the
win over the Bobcats since In addition to a new men’s team’s momentum going
2002. The women’s team also coaching staff, both teams and bring home a 4-0 record.
showed a strong debut despite also welcome a strong group The men’s team hasn’t started
shifts in the ladder due to of first-year recruits. With a season with such a record
injuries, beating Vassar (4-3) nine underclassmen and five since 2001.
6-3 and putting up a strong upperclassmen, men’s team Looking forward, the men’s
fight against Bates in a 2-7 co-captains Clark, Shonrock team anticipates facing tough
loss. and Gannon Leech ’21 view opponents at the NESCAC
“Both teams are definitely the development of these play- tournament, which will be
growing a lot both on and off ers as essential for the future hosted at Bowdoin this year.
the court,” said captain Tyler success of the program. “We hope to keep up our
Shonrock ’20. “The first couple “We really want to devel- momentum and work ethic all
matches speak for themselves, op the leadership and a good the way through,” said Clark,
skill-wise and squad-wise.” team culture, which will give hopeful for the team’s high
The start of the season us the best opportunity to ex- performance at the tourna-
also marks the debut of a new cel in every match that we play ment.
coaching staff. Head Coach and really set the stage for the The opportunity to show-
Theo Woodward, who pre- next two or three years where case the team’s improve-
viously coached at Drexel the future looks really bright,” ment on their home court at
University and Dartmouth said Clark. NESCACs is the first step,
College, brings a competitive Similarly, with six first- said Clark, to “get[ting] the
energy. Ian Squiers ’19 has years on the 13-player wom- squash program back on track
also returned to the program en’s roster, Bersani recognizes to where it was in the early
as an assistant coach after four the new members as crucial 2000s.”
successful years as a starter on in terms of revitalizing the Hannah Reiff ’22, a member
the men’s team. program. of the women’s team, encour-
“[Coach Woodward] con- “I want to make sure that ages people to come out to
ducts practice with a purpose,” [the first-years] feel really wel- the matches throughout the
Clark said. “He’s improved our come and included on the team season to witness the energy,
work ethic and practice, [and] as well as making sure that the which Bersani described as
also brought the community returning players all are on “electric.”
very close together.” their game,” said Bersani. “The space is very small
“It’s been a very welcome Woodward is concerned and we get a lot of rowdy peo-
change for the women’s team,” primarily with the team’s im- ple in there,” Reiff said. “Even
JACK BURNETT, THE BOWDOIN ORIENT said Clio Bersani ’22, one of provement rather than numer- if you don’t understand the
CONTROL THE T: Gretchen Clauss ’23 and Tyler Shonrock ’20 wind up for backhands in last weekend’s set of home matches the women’s captains. ical results this season. sport, there’s people around to
against Vassar and Bates. The two teams went 3-1 combined in a promising first weekend for new Head Coach Theo Woodward. Woodward looks forward “When I really think about help you pick it up fast.”
O OPINION
It’s a beautiful day in
the neighberhood
Take off your parking brakes! Thirty days from now, new parking restric-
tions will take effect on a number of Brunswick streets, including Columbia
Avenue, Belmont Street, Longfellow Avenue, Noble Street, Pine Street and
Union Street.
The restrictions, passed by the Brunswick Town Council at its Novem-
ber 18 meeting, are not unprecedented—the Council placed similar restric-
tions, specifically aimed at Bowdoin students, on Park Row in 2014, and the
College revoked student parking privileges to the lots at the Maine Street
College Houses the same year.
In light of this move, which forces more students to park in the rather
distant Farley/Watson lot, we’re forced to consider what parking rights and
privileges students should have. Maybe far away parking isn’t so bad?
KYRA TAN
Our campus is a relatively compact 207 acres. For comparison, Middle-
bury’s campus is 350 acres, and Wesleyan’s campus is 360 acres. Bowdoin is
easily walkable for many students, and its location near a densely populated
town center makes it unlikely that the College will expand student parking
anytime soon.
But this is understandable. There are 200 more student parking spaces
Corporate welfare is no good
on campus than registered cars, even though most of these spots are located
near Farley Field House. And as Randy Nichols, executive director of Safety
and Security, has said, few are in favor of a campus filled with parking lots.
Of course, we acknowledge that cars on campus provide mobility that
for corporations or for colleges
can be extremely valuable in our relatively small college town. For some, and only lets in the most talented in keeps prices down. Colleges have al-
they are a necessity, whether they allow students to attend medical appoint- by Peter Slovenski our society? Critical thinking would lowed costs to soar more than dou-
Op-Ed Contributor
ments, drive to a job or travel to see family. make us ask if organizations with ble the rate of the Consumer Price
But the College does accomidate students with cars. Bowdoin students I’d like to comment on last week’s narrow admission for talented peo- Index in the past 20 years. Colleges
are guaranteed a spot somewhere on campus, even if its location is some- Orient article about taxes on college ple in academics or sports should re- could try to hold down costs, but
what inconvenient. The price of a parking permit is relatively low as well: endowments. Wealthy non-profit ceive non-profit status. The National they have discovered that no matter
$50 for the year compared to Colby’s $100 and Bates’ $120. Our parking colleges should not oppose efforts to Football League or Major League how much they raise prices, cus-
spaces should not come at the expense of Brunswick residents. collect taxes on their enormous en- Baseball could make a similar bid for tomers still line up to attend Yale
Beyond being good neighbors, these changes, though inconvenient for dowment funds. Colleges like to brag tax exemption because they screen and Princeton. So they raise prices
some, have beneficial impacts on the campus’s car-related culture. that they encourage critical think- for exceptional talent and then they and build ever more luxurious fa-
An eight-minute walk adds comparatively little time to the 35-minute ing. When I apply critical thinking help the exceptionally talented im- cilities for sports, housing, dining
trip to Portland, but it adds significant travel time to your two-minute drive to college finances, it looks to me as prove their skills and contributions and classrooms. They do not need
to Hannaford. The distance to the Farley/Watson lot disincentivizes stu- though non-profit tax exemptions to society. Helping needy students to keep costs low. They also do not
dents from driving short trips that are typically walkable or bikeable. for schools with billion-dollar en- with a lot of talent is a high-minded need tax exemptions.
Minimizing unnecessary driving by carpooling, walking and biking is dowments are just another form of endeavor, but motivated students do I suspect another subtle but dia-
in the interest not only of campus infrastructure and neighborly behavior corporate welfare. pretty well regardless of what college bolical problem with tax exemption
but also sustainability. On a campus highly concerned with its carbon foot- Colleges claim that they need they attend. Society’s most difficult for colleges. Colleges siphon off mil-
print, the Council’s ordinance enables the College to incentivize alternative their tax exemptions so they can help problems require us to help the lions of dollars of charitable giving
forms of transportation. society. Critically thinking, there needy with the least amount of talent with the most amazing fund-rais-
So, no, faraway parking isn’t such a bad thing. are at least four problems with this more than those who are deciding ing campaigns. They vacuum up
argument. First, can’t colleges and between Harvard and Ohio State. A charitable giving dollars that might
This editorial represents the majority view of the Bowdoin Orient’s edi- universities help our government disadvantaged genius who attends otherwise be donated to soup kitch-
torial board, which is composed of Emily Cohen, Brianna Cunliffe, Roither pay for social programs the way Penn State will do well enough with ens, Boys’ & Girls’ Clubs, homeless
Gonzales, Alyce McFadden, Nina McKay, Danielle Quezada, Reuben Schafir the rest of us do? Social science de- the Penn State education. It’s the shelters, hospitals and wildlife hab-
and Jaret Skonieczny. partments in colleges have designed needy who are homeless or jobless itat preservation. No other type of
most of our government programs. or dropping out of school or trapped tax-exempt organization is able to
Faculty experts lobby to begin and in dysfunctional pre-crime careers match the Madison Avenue cali-
then protect social programs. Col- who require more attention and re- ber fundraising power of colleges.
leges should put their money where sources. They are charitable fundraising
their social science departments are Fourth, selective colleges end up juggernauts. A critically minded
ESTABLISHED 1871 and help pay for what they want the receiving hundreds of millions of evaluation of what colleges do could
government to do. dollars in tuition fees and fund-rais- conclude that they do not do the
bowdoinorient.com orient@bowdoin.edu 6200 College Station Brunswick, ME 04011
Second, if wealthy colleges de- ing support from our wealthiest and kind of charity that needs as much
The Bowdoin Orient is a student-run weekly publication dedicated to providing news and information serve tax-exempt privileges, then most talented citizens because those tax-exempt support as organizations
relevant to the Bowdoin community. Editorially independent of the College and its administrators, there are many equally or more de- are the people who receive concen- in the trenches of anti-poverty and
the Orient pursues such content freely and thoroughly, following professional journalistic standards in serving organizations who should trated benefits from colleges. With anti-crime programs. Let colleges
writing and reporting. The Orient is committed to serving as an open forum for thoughtful and diverse qualify for tax exemptions. Wal- the support of America’s wealthiest build ever more impressive build-
discussion and debate on issues of interest to the College community. Mart helps millions of low-income families, colleges do not need the ings, charge ever-higher prices for
families stretch their resources with extra help of tax exemption. tuition, and let them also pay taxes
Editor in Chief Editor in Chief low priced goods. A car wash that Colleges have to watch out for on behemoth endowments. Critical
Emily Cohen Alyce McFadden employs four men with autism is as the bureaucratic trap that has them thinking would persuade them to
deserving of a tax exemption as a speaking one way, and acting in an- pay taxes and give up some of the
Digital Director Managing Editor News Editor non-profit college. other way. If they are for the public corporate welfare we like, but do not
Steven Xu Maia Coleman Andrew Bastone Third, by what logic do we use good, then they should help with need.
Anna Fauver Aura Carlson tax benefits to help any organization public expenses just as Wal-Mart Peter Slovenski is the Director of
Photo Editor Roither Gonzales that has a narrow gate for admission and the local car wash do. Wal-Mart Track & Field at Bowdoin.
Rohini Kurup Features Editor
Ann Basu Emma Sorkin
Mindy Leder Nina McKay
Ian Ward Sports Editor
Layout Editor Dylan Sloan
Emma Bezilla Executive Editor
Jaret Skonieczny
Ian Stewart
Kate Lusignan
Eliana Miller
A&E Editor
Cole van Miltenburg
Opinion Editor
HAVE AN OPINION?
Data Desk Editor
Gwen Davidson
Associate Editor Diego Lasarte Want to share it with the Bowdoin community?
Drew Macdonald Kathryn McGinnis Page 2 Editor
George Grimbilas (asst.) Lucie Nolden Lily Randall
Nimra Siddiqui (asst.) Reuben Schafir
Calendar Editor
Head Illustrator Copy Editor Jane Godiner Submit an Op-Ed or a Letter to the Editor to
Sara Caplan Sebastian de Lasa
Devin McKinney
Senior News Reporter
Horace Wang
orientopinion@bowdoin.edu by 7 p.m. on the
Social Media Manager Danielle Quezada
Ayub Tahlil Katherine Pady Senior Sports Reporter Tuesday of the week of publication. Include your
Sophie Friedman Emily Staten Ella Chaffin
full name and phone number.
The material contained herein is the property of The Bowdoin Orient and appears at the sole discretion of the
editors. The editors reserve the right to edit all material. Other than in regard to the above editorial, the opinions
expressed in the Orient do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors.
14 OPINION Friday, November 22, 2019
Refutation takes time trust. I know Paul. I trust him. questions first. We must scrape
by Robert Sobak We’ve built that relationship down the thorns together be-
Op-Ed Contributor
over time. It has been fash- fore holding opposite sides
Raise your hand if Paul ioned from well over a decade of the stick. This is what it
Franco’s dog has ever eaten of purloined fruit and strong- means to be in a commu-
your breakfast. ly-argued points. So, when nity of learners. We learn
I knew it! I knew I was not Franco hints that there may be through the habits and
alone! something worth considering, practices of community.
One of the great pleasures it is incumbent upon me to We learn even, and often
of a walk across the Bowdoin give him a careful listen. especially, in spaces and
N
quad is a chance meeting with I give Franco due consid- times that are not formally LA
AP
that lovable scamp. For many eration, especially when he marked out for pedagogy. We RAC
SA
years now, on the way to my advances an idea or argument learn through simple conver- speeches
early-morning Greek class, that I initially consider weak sation, through observation and writings.
I have looked forward to the and unsupported, because I and through iteration. For the true
possibility that my linguistic owe it to Franco, not because In response to my last measure of the
preparation will be delayed I owe it to the mere idea of op-ed, Professor Fran- quietly man’s claims must indeed be
in the service of my intellec- argument. Were Franco to co commented that, while Gor- taken.
tual expansion. The fact that propose that we burn the “however much gias prowled But more than anything,
I sometimes have to make a College down and replace it Socrates dis- the stage, engag- he would have relished the
donation in the form of an ap- with a for-profit corporation agreed with the ing in bamboozling opportunity to scrape away
ple stolen out of my hand or a whose curriculum is driven Sophists, he did epideictic? Does such the hours feasting in the Pry-
banana filched from my coat by the whims of the moment, not find it point- an environment offer taneion while arguing with
pocket only adds to my joy. I’d sit down with him under less to engage anybody the chance to members of his own commu-
Watching Professor Franco the nearest tree and give him with them and try submit Gorgias to the Socra- nity. For true intellectual nu-
double over in laughter while as much time and attention to refute them with reason.” hewn and knotty tic elenchus? trition is found in the practice
making vague gestures toward as he needs to make that case. The clear implication is that plank. It is the way Not at all. That carefully of iterative reason-giving. It
canine discipline simply com- Even if that means allowing Socratic disagreement with in which the Greek shoemaker produced format is well-de- marinates over time. It must
pletes the tableau. his dog to eat my shoes. He sophistry must be exercised describes the act of scraping signed to prevent the process be consumed among those
I do not begrudge the dog has earned from me, and from by reasonable refutation. This and softening tough leather. of refutation from even taking with whom one has nurtured
his thievery, for I treasure my many of you, whatever time assertion is true but insuffi- Over time, this term comes to root, let alone flowering. As a the bonds of trust and affec-
conversations with the human and attention he may request. cient. Socrates described his denote the expenditure of time, result, Socrates would proba- tion. It cannot be snatched
he is taking for a walk. Franco But if a relative stranger, or engagement with Sophists, such that it can later be used of bly realize his time was much from the hand of an itinerant
is one of the finest, most gen- a man who has earned my and with everybody else for diners hanging out at a taverna better spent talking to people speechifier and eaten quick-
erous and sharpest interloc- distrust, were to make that that matter, using the lan- all hours of the night. in his community. Perhaps, if ly. Everybody knows that
utors in our community. His same request and argument, guage of hard work. But at root it is all about there had been a newspaper in drive-thru tacos are nothing
beaming smile is outshone it would be incumbent upon One Greek word in the de- effort, and about how real ancient Athens, and if Socra- but sodium and empty cal-
only by his judicious intellect. that man to first prove that I scriptive vocabulary of Socratic effort must always involve tes had developed the habit of ories. Quickly gulped down
And whether it be Hal or the need to give him the time of practice stands out: diatribe- time. Socrates didn’t just in- writing, he might have devoted in their shiny packaging,
much-missed Reggie snaf- day, much less the respect of in. From this word we get the vest a few hours to arguing some of his time to a careful they will soon find them-
fling my vittles while Franco my attention. English term “diatribe.” But its with Sophists, he devoted his examination of how and why selves steaming on the frozen
distracts me with some phil- Productive argument over original and common usage, entire life to the refutation of Gorgias came to Athens, what ground, waiting for some dog
osophical point, the fact that difficult matters cannot thrive skillfully adopted by Socrates, sophistry. So how would he Gorgias hoped to achieve to come along and make a
I chortle and feel not a bit of in the absence of affection. was deployed by the ancient have responded if only given there, and how Athenians breakfast of them.
resentment toward that mug- One does not learn from oth- carpenter conveying what it the opportunity to write down might weigh the present asser- Robert Sobak is an Associ-
ging is strong evidence of ers by taking up the spikiest of takes to sand down a rough- a question in advance and sit tions of Gorgias against his past ate Professor of Classics.
FRIDAY 22
EVENT
Wellness Program Tabling
Kate Nicholson, Bowdoin’s new assistant director of student
wellness programs, will meet students and speak to them
about upcoming wellness programming, as well as take
suggestions from students about future programming.
David Saul Smith Union. 11 a.m.
EVENT
Lunch with Kathryn Olson: On Farms,
Fish, Forests and Climate Change in Maine
Katheryn Olson, a PhD candidate at Boston College who
examines the effects of climate change on farmers, fishers
and foresters in Maine, will speak to Bowdoin students about
her research. Light refreshments will be provided.
Lantern, Roux Center for the Environment. 11:30 a.m.
KATIE BACALL, THE BOWDOIN ORIENT
LECTURE LIVE FROM BRUNSWICK: The Improvabilities, one of Bowdoin’s two improv groups, had its second show of the semester, “Time Travel.” The
“Ramón Novarro en Mexico”: show included improv games and audience participation.
SATURDAY 23 MONDAY 25
Ernesto Chávez, guest lecturer at the University of Texas at
El Paso, will discuss Mexican-born actor Ramón Novarro, and
how his race and nationality influenced his position in the
American film industry.
Torrey Barn, Cram Alumni House. 1 p.m. EVENT EVENT
Stowe Writer’s Retreat Meditation
LECTURE The Stowe Writers Collective will hold writing workshops in Bernie Hershberger, director of counseling and wellness
Gil Vigil: Nationally Recognized Native genres including poetry, fiction, creative nonfiction, writing services, will lead a meditation session.
Tribal Leader with movement and more. Room 302, Buck Center for Health and Fitness. 4:30 p.m.
Former Governor of the Native American Tesuque Pueblo Harriet Beecher Stowe House. 10:30 a.m.
tribe Gil Vigil will discuss the origins of the Pueblo people PERFORMANCE
and the issues that the tribe—as well as the general Native PERFORMANCE Students of Jeff Christmas
American population—faces in the current political climate. “Hark! Now the Bells!” The students of Jeff Christmas, lecturer in the department of
Shannon Room, Hubbard Hall. 3 p.m. The Bowdoin Chorus, under the direction of Anthony Antolini, music, will perform an evening concert.
will perform a concert of Ukrainian and Russian choral, Kresge Auditorium, Visual Arts Center. 7:30 p.m.
DISCUSSION including works by Tchaikovsky, Chesnokov, Rachmaninoff,
Gallery Conversation: Assyria to America Sviridov, Prokhorov, Kalistratov and Leontovich. Performances
Sean P. Burrus, Andrew W. Mellon postdoctoral cultural will be held on Friday and Saturday.
fellow; James Higginbotham, associate curator for the ancient The Chapel. 3 p.m.
TUESDAY 26
collection at the Bowdoin College Museum of Art and Ayub
Tahlil ’22, will examine the history of Bowdoin’s six reliefs from EVENT
ancient Nimrud. Puppies and Polaroids
Museum of Art. 3 p.m. Student Activities will hold an event for Bowdoin students to
play and take polaroids with puppies. FILM SCREENING
EVENT Morrell Lounge, David Saul Smith Union. 7 p.m. “Deconstructing the Beatles’ ‘The
Community Care Night White Album’”
The Office of Gender Violence Prevention and Education Frontier will be screening Scott Freimans’ documentary,
will invite students to make mindfulness glitter jars, decorate “Deconstructing the Beatles’ ‘The White Album,’” which
cookies and engage in reflection on self-care, community gives the viewer insight into the process of creating the
healing and the second year of the #MeToo movement.
Garage, 24 College Street. 4 p.m. SUNDAY 24 Beatles’ best-selling album.
Frontier. 3 p.m.
28 29 30 1 2 3 EVENT 4
Thanksgiving Break Thanksgiving Break Thanksgiving Break International Day
of Persons with
Disabilities