Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ABSTRACT. Background: E-commerce is one of the most dynamic and important sectors of the Polish economy. Its
development is driven by rapidly expanding Internet access. Worldwide e-commerce is dominated by marketplaces with
a great market share. There are both advantages and disadvantages related to the use of marketplaces, for sellers and
buyers alike.
The aims of this paper are to indicate the nature of marketplaces, develop a classification for them, and also to indicate
new challenges related to them and development directions in Poland.
Methods: For the needs of this paper, research was conducted using the methods of direct observation and analysis of
primary and secondary sources. The primary materials included data obtained from companies providing marketplaces in
Poland and abroad, and the secondary ones – reports, studies and Internet sources. In addition, in-depth interviews were
performed with experts on marketplaces.
Results: The article provides a detailed description of marketplaces. The authors describe the division and characteristics
of marketplaces and discussed the potential trends in this field. It presents marketplace-related benefits and
disadvantages, and how the authors classify them.
Conclusions: Marketplaces create new opportunities for expansion on a larger scale for online sellers. Companies do not
need to invest in a sales platform or have knowledge of legal aspects. Moreover, they have access to innovative solutions.
Obviously, there are many disadvantages, such as very strong competition from numerous sellers in one place, becoming
dependent on this sales channel, and neglecting the growth of the seller's own online shop.
In terms of turnover, in 2018, the two For the purpose of this article, the authors
largest marketplaces were the Chinese Taobao conducted research by means of direct
(USD 515 B) and Tmall (USD 432 B), both observation and analysis of secondary sources
owned by the Alibaba Group. These were such as reports, publications, press materials
followed by Amazon (USD 344 B), JD.com and marketplace websites. Additionally, the
(USD 259 B) and eBay (USD 96 B) [Ali article draws on the authors’ expert knowledge
2019]. Alibaba's turnover stems both from the acquired during over a dozen years of market
purchasing power of China and other Asian observations and the previously conducted
states, where the marketplace is active and analyses and reports.
from the amazing popularity of the group's
platforms. 80% of products purchased in China
is sold on these portals. Apart from China, THE NATURE OF MARKETPLACES
marketplaces had over 50% of market share in
just two countries. In Germany, where Amazon Speaking in the most general terms,
had a 55% market share, and in Poland, with a marketplace is a platform that offers products
Allegro registering 50% market share and services of numerous sellers, which can be
[Ecommerce Foundation 2016]. Currently, bought by clients [Tian et al. 2018, Li et al.
Allegro's share in Polish e-commerce stands at 2019]. Most of the products come from
around 40%. external companies, although some platforms
also offer their own products (e.g. Amazon,
Apart from micro and small businesses, Allegro). Other businesses must be able to sell
medium-size and large firms also sell their their products to make the platform
products on marketplaces. Recently, more and a marketplace, otherwise it is just an online
more of the largest businesses have been shop. Sometimes the term “marketplace” is
joining marketplaces. These new forms of wrongly used for online stores with a very
selling have become an important part of both wide selection of products. As previously
e-commerce and the entire economy. This is noted, marketplaces can also offer services for
because marketplaces eliminate entry barriers sale. However, this article focuses on goods,
to new businesses and the expansion of because their turnover is more complex and
existing ones. They also create new solutions requires more attention.
and show new directions in the digital
economy. Amazon, Alibaba and JD.com invest Sellers trade on popular platforms
billions in logistics infrastructure, thus helping frequently visited by users in exchange for
the regions where they operate to grow. a part of their sales profits. Most often, the
marketplace business model is based on
What is the nature of marketplaces and collecting fees for sales made through them.
what marketplaces other than Allegro are These fees differ depending on the platform
available in Poland? What new challenges do and the category of products. Some
marketplaces face and what are their marketplaces collect fees for listing the product
development directions? These are some of the (e.g. Allegro). The sellers agree to such fees,
questions we will try to address in the article. because marketplaces allow them to enter the
market with low financial outlays.
The aims of this paper are to indicate the Consequently, such platforms are key selling
nature of marketplaces, develop an original venues for many sellers.
classification of them, and to indicate new
challenges they face and development Marketplaces offer undeniable advantages,
directions in Poland. such as prompt access to a lot of clients, high
recognizability, first contact venue (many
The paper is divided into three main parts. buyers start looking for products on
The first section discusses the nature of marketplaces), ready technical solutions,
marketplaces, the second presents and a payment system and logistics. They are great
describes the types of marketplaces, and the venues for testing products and new sales
third speaks of the future directions for the markets and for collecting information from
development of marketplaces. clients. A small batch of pilot goods can be
522
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
launched to test demand and get feedback from [Church, Oakley 2018]. They draw on clients’
clients, all without making big investments in emotions and provide them with a product- and
sales and distribution channels. Some of the delivery-related experience. The emotional
limitations are very strong competition (for aspect applies to lifestyle, fashion, trends and
example, 363,000 new sellers offering social affiliation. This reinforces the
identical or very similar products joined relationship between the client and the
Amazon in Europe in 2017), listing systems platform. Mainly due to customization, the
(some online shop suppliers offer integration Internet has made it possible to know clients
and automated listings), communication with better, in particular their shopping experience,
clients from abroad, and fees. and consequently to adapt the offer to their
preferences and to increase their loyalty.
Some marketplaces seek ways of generating Learning the needs of their potential clients
additional revenues other than from sales allows sellers to offer their products more
commission. One such example may be consciously. Add-on sales are used for existing
fulfilment services, consisting in the clients. This may be take the form of cross-
marketplace taking over processes related to selling, where products from other categories
warehouse logistics, i.e. receiving goods, (often of complementary nature) are sold, or
storage, picking, packing, shipping and selling more expensive or more advanced
handling returns [Semeijn et al. 2005]. This is products from the same category (up-selling).
Amazon’s speciality, as they operate numerous
warehouses across the world. The seller is not As shown in the analysis, there are both
obliged to ship their goods to Amazon advantages and disadvantages related to the
warehouses, but this may mean that their use of marketplaces, and both for sellers and
listings are poorly positioned. the buyers. These have been specified in
Tables 1 and 2.
The leading marketplace sellers owe their
success to their unique approach to customers
Table 1. Advantages and disadvantages for sellers
Advantages Disadvantages
• Marketplace brand recognizability • Very strong competition from numerous sellers in one place
• A high number of clients in one place • Becoming dependent on this sales channel and neglecting
• Low entry barrier (no need to invest in a sales platform or to know the growth of the seller's own online shop
legal aspects etc.) • Frequent changes to the sales and fees policy
• Additional channel of sales and a source of revenue • Service costs (subscription or listing fee, promotion fees and
• Ability to reach clients abroad sales commissions)
• Sales and logistics support • Restrictive requirements concerning product descriptions
• Better promotion of products (lower expenses on SEO and and images, customer service
advertising) • Risk of competitors copying ideas or marketplaces / other
• Increased seller credibility sellers offering the popular products
• Access to innovative solutions (new tech, marketing and logistics • Limited possibilities of promoting the seller's own online
solutions used by marketplaces) shop
• Access to analytical and benchmarking data
Source: authors' own analysis
523
,
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
Sales channels Online only – platforms only available in Online and offline – platforms operating in
digital form (pure players) traditional and digital version (bricks and mortar
players)
Type of relation Direct – platforms through which goods can be Indirect – platforms aggregating information from
purchased directly other sellers and directing clients to them (e.g. price
comparison sites)
Reach Domestic – platforms only available in local International – platforms available in many
languages and handling clients from one languages and handling clients from multiple
country only countries
Product presentation Product catalogue – platforms presenting Product list – platforms presenting offers as lists of
offers as catalogued products, to which new products created by individual sellers (the seller is the
sellers attach their listings (the platform is the owner of their listing)
owner of the product description website,
where offers from at least 1 seller) are
available
524
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
525
,
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
526
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
Today, the keys to success in e-commerce own airline, drone delivery system and
are technology and logistics [Bask, Lipponen, numerous patents related to logistics and last-
Tinnilä 2012]. Marketplaces will continue to mile management, which is the most complex
invest in these two fields in the coming years. and costly element of the entire logistics
Experts expect marketplaces to keep growing process in e-commerce. In the USA, Amazon
in the field of artificial intelligence (AI), has its own parcel lockers and courier vehicles,
machine learning and real-time personalization which reduces the number of parcels handled
[Columbus 2018]. With regard to logistics, the by courier operators. Recently, the company
focus will be on making shipments quicker and also launched courier services in Europe,
cheaper, offering warehousing services, namely in France, Germany, GB and Austria.
picking and handling returns. Some related This expansion caused DHL to withdraw their
activities can be seen on Allegro in this regard. operations from Austria and made the Austrian
In March 2019, Francois Nuyts, Allegro’s postal service apprehensive as to their own
CEO, announced several new solutions. Their future in this market [CEP-Research, 2019].
objective is to turn the marketplace into a sort Amazon may repeat these steps when they
of an ecosystem comprised of sellers and launch sales in Poland. Consequently, the
providers of complementary services. One of courier, express and parcel sector should be
the proposals for change will be a tool with ready for this scenario.
which sellers will be able to analyse their own
business against the competition. More When analysing the growth of marketplaces
attention will be paid to evaluating the sellers in Poland, we should also remember about the
in terms of logistics – the time of shipment very dynamic development and growing
and delivery, along with return possibilities popularity of other, foreign platforms in
will be scored. Allegro also wants to Poland. GearBest.com, Wish.com and
implement uniform standards for providers of Banggood.com are some of these.
logistics services with regard to delivery time.
Same-day delivery is to be available in
selected places. Delayed payment for goods SUMMARY
purchased is to be a breakthrough solution.
This way, the client will have 30 days from the This study extends current understanding of
date of delivery to pay for their order. Credit the essence of marketplaces in e-commerce. It
will not only be extended to clients, but also to develops an original approach to marketplace
sellers, e.g. through a working capital facility classification to facilitate a better
and a revolving facility. understanding of their wide range. Moreover, it
indicates their advantages and disadvantages.
The world's biggest shopping platforms,
Alibaba and Amazon, are going one step Thanks to marketplaces, trade in Poland has
further with regard to logistics. Alibaba has become easier and more convenient than ever
already built numerous warehouses where they before. Its beneficiaries are both companies
perform fulfilment services for their sellers, and customers. Almost each firm has the
while continuing to invest in new technologies potential to become a successful trader.
and expand into new markets. The company is Marketplaces create new opportunities for
currently at the acquisition stage and is already existing entities to expand on a larger
broadening its logistics services. Recently, scale and offers prospects for rapid
Alibaba bought 14% of shares in STO Express, development to emerging entities. This is
the fifth largest Chinese carrier. Previously, the possible due to low entry barriers that
company had also bought shares in YTO encourage more and more companies to sell
Express Group, Best Inc. and ZTO Express their products on the Internet. They can offer
[Kapadia 2019]. a wider range of products without great effort.
Companies are able to save on both fixed and
It has been known for quite some time that variable costs, such as rent, labour and other
Amazon is aiming at the position of the leader overheads associated with the presence on their
in logistics services. The evidence for this is own websites. It is particularly important in the
the company's own warehouse, fleet of trucks, case of cross-border trade, because companies
527
,
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
528
Kawa A., Wałęsiak M., 2019. Marketplace as a key actor in e-commerce value networks. LogForum 15 (4), 521-
529. http://doi.org/10.17270/J.LOG.2019.351
Journal, 15(2), 182-194. Tian L., Vakharia A.J., Tan Y., Xu Y., 2018.
http://doi.org/10.1108/09604520510585361 Marketplace, Reseller, or Hybrid: Strategic
Analysis of an Emerging E‐Commerce
Skorupska J., 2017. E-commerce, PWN,
Model. Production and Operations
Warszawa.
Management, 27(8), 1595-1610.
Statista 2019a. Retail e-commerce sales http://doi.org/10.1111/poms.12885.
worldwide from 2014 to 2021 (in billion
Wei K., Li Y., Zha Y., Ma J., 2019. Trust, risk
U.S. dollars),
and transaction intention in consumer-to-
https://www.statista.com/statistics/379046/
consumer e-marketplaces: An empirical
worldwide-retail-e-commerce-sales/
comparison between buyers’ and sellers’
(accessed on 30.05.2019).
perspectives. Industrial Management &
Statista, 2019b. E-commerce share of total Data Systems, 119(2), 331-350.
global retail sales from 2015 to 2021, http://doi.org/10.1108/IMDS-10-2017-
https://www.statista.com/statistics/534123/e 0489.
-commerce-share-of-retail-sales-worldwide/
(accessed on 30.05.2019).
Magdalena Wałęsiak
GS1 Polska, Poznań, Poland
529
Copyright of LogForum is the property of LogForum and its content may not be copied or
emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.